We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).

Contributions 1–165 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

When I moved to report progress last night, I had just said that 2½ per cent turnover tax, plus the extra five per cent on corporation profits tax, would yield the £6¼ million required to close the gap. Frankly, I am surprised that there was any substantial opposition in this House to that extra tax on big business profits. I had thought we had reached the stage of maturity here at which we would have a proper sense of fair play as between the big fellow and the small fellow, the strong and the weak. That does not seem to be the case. I feel sure that no Deputy in the Labour Party is opposing this increase in tax on big business profits.

I cannot understand how any Deputy claiming to have sympathy with the weaker sections, with the poor, with the unemployed, with the social welfare recipient, can justify opposition to this increased tax. It was said on a famous occasion, and very well said, that property has its duties as well as it rights. Well, it can be said now with equal truth and equal force that big business has its duties as well as its rights—its duties to the poor, to the aged, to the workless, to the workers and to the sick. If this debate proves nothing else, it proves where the friends of the big business tycoons are in this House——

Comment on this

Hear, hear! A finance committee.

Comment on this

I shall pass now to the turnover tax. It is a new tax, a new departure here, but it is not new on the Continent. It has been in operation there for years in several countries, in one form or another, and it has worked with outstanding success. The proof that it has been successful is that it has been kept on by these countries. They have not given it up. It has become a permanent feature of their budgetary structure. It is also in operation in such socialist countries as Denmark, Sweden and Norway but to a greater extent, up to ten per cent in fact. You can call it what you like; it is the same system.

Surely its successful operation in these countries is a recommendation to operate it here in the financial circumstances in which we find ourselves at the moment? It is not a big tax, this 2½ per cent, or 6d. in the £. It will be chargeable in proportion to what is taken in by the shopkeepers. If the shopkeeper's income goes down, the amount of the tax to be collected will go down and vice versa. It is far and away different from the position the farmers so bitterly complain about— that when their income falls, their rates and general costs keep rising. At the same time, the majority of speakers from the Opposition benches, including Labour Deputies, claim that the entire 2½ per cent will be passed on to the customers. That has been said over and over again by Fine Gael, Labour, some of the Independent Deputies and by the National Progressive Democrats.

Comment on this

What about RGDATA?

Comment on this

If that is true, then the shopkeepers have very little to complain of. They will pay nothing at all. Surely a Deputy must come down on one side or the other? Is he to claim that the shopkeepers will pay this tax or that the customer will pay it, or will he compromise?

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

Who will pay it? The consumer, of course

Comment on this

Even if the entire amount of the 2½ per cent tax is passed on—and mind you, many Deputies on the Fine Gael benches, as well as my friends, Deputy Tully and Deputy Norton, say more than 2½ per cent will be passed on——

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I heard speaker after speaker claim that. They made a claim tantamount to an assertion that all the business people, the shopkeepers of this country, are dishonest. What else does such a claim mean? If a person who has to pay a 2½ per cent tax—let us admit he is morally right in collecting that tax—passes on three per cent to the customer, he is dishonest. This claim is tantamount to a suggestion that the shopkeepers will exploit the situation to get more out of the customers, that the shopkeepers are skinflints who will exploit a budgetary situation or a new tax to get more than they are entitled to out of the customers. That is a disgraceful accusation to make against the business people of the country. I do not believe they will do it. I know as many shopkeepers throughout the country as any Deputy and from my experience of them, I can assure the House that not one per cent of them will do this.

Of course, you might get some politically-minded shopkeeper, a shopkeeper suffering from an excessive zeal for Fine Gael, who might put a little extra on an article so as to be able to say to a customer: "That is what Dr. Ryan did for you; that is what Lemass did for you; that is what Fianna Fáil did for you. "I can assure the House he will do it only for a very short time because the shopkeeper next door will not be talking about Dr. Ryan or Deputy Lemass. He will be a man of business acumen who will treat his customers justly. I do not want to be hard on anyone. I am talking straight and plain.

Comment on this

I love to hear the Deputy annoying them over there.

Comment on this

We have all this wailing about this heavy burden but on whom will the burden be?

Comment on this

Everyone.

Comment on this

Let us take an old age pensioner. He will get an increase of 2/6d. a week from next November. He will have to spend over £5 a week before this tax will even begin to worsen his position.

Comment on this

Let us assume that he has a family, will they not pay it?

Comment on this

When he will have spent the whole 32/6 which he is getting at present and have paid the full 2½ per cent—if the shopkeepers are so hardhearted and so harsh as some Opposition Deputies would have us believe—he will still be 1/8¼ to the good. I know the sneers expressed by Fine Gael about halfpennies and farthings and I also heard Deputy Norton speaking. I was surprised that he was in such a frivolous mood. Since I came into this House, I have seldom heard him treat matters lightly. I was always able to follow his speech and he was always crystal clear. By and large, he always treated his subject fairly but on this Budget he was in a frivolous mood and adopted the same attitude as Deputy O'Sullivan about halfpennies and pence and made statements that were tantamount to accusing the shopkeepers of being dishonest, saying if it were a matter of 7½d., the shopkeeper would make it 8d. Would the shopkeeper not take the generous view and say: "I will charge 7d.?" Of course that is what the shopkeeper always does.

To return to the old age pensioner, he will be saving 1/8¼d. I am not ashamed to mention the farthing because it is the truth. To look at it in a simpler way, he is getting an increase of more than 1/6d. Some of the mathematicians in Fine Gael can check that and they will find that it is right. They will find that it is a fraction over 1/6d. Therefore, even if he paid the full 6d. in the £, he would still be 1/- to the good. Let us go on to another person the Fine Gael members would have us believe will also be burdened.

Let us take the working man with a family, say, a family of nine children under 16. At present that man is getting £8 9s. 6d. a month. Get out your notebooks and check that. You can have a wager with me if you want to bet that I am wrong. As from November 1st next, he will be getting £10 11s. per month.

Comment on this
Mr. Browne

You may not be there to give it to them in November.

Comment on this

Why do you not contradict me?

Comment on this

We are enjoying it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I am glad to be able to entertain you. This will be an increase of £2 1s. 6d. per month and that man would have to spend over £83 per month before the turnover tax would even begin to worsen his spending position. Of course, we know that he would not spend anything like it. He would not have it to spend but let us give him a liberal sum to spend. Let us say he spends £40 in the month, from November 1st, and he will still be £1 to the good because he is getting almost 25 per cent increase. Therefore the tax is not going to weigh very heavily on him. This Budget, while keeping the national finances in a sound position and providing for and encouraging the continuance of the expansion and development of our economy, has, at the same time, protected the poorer sections, the old people, the man with the big family and the widows against whatever increase in taxation they will have to pay.

Comment on this

There is a man in the public gallery who does not agree with that.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He was in it—he is not there now.

Comment on this

That has been the Fianna Fáil policy down the years and that is the big difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. When the Government realised that they had to get £6¼ million, they faced up to the problem even though they knew they could not get it from the traditional sources of revenue. They did not take a step backwards or say: "We will cut down on this or on that; we will let someone go without; we will not give the recipients of social welfare benefits any increase; we will let this development slow down or we will let the other development stop". They did not do that. They had courage enough to introduce a system which works well in other countries.

Comment on this

On a point of explanation——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There can be no point of explanation. Deputy Egan is in possession. The Deputy will get an opportunity of making his own speech.

Comment on this

They have also been able to increase the old pensions by nearly eight per cent. and to give increases to all the other recipients of social welfare benefits. Some years ago, when Fine Gael were in power under a different name, when they came up against an awkward budgetary situation, they resolved their difficulties, partly in any case, by reducing the old age pensions by ten per cent.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

You did not recount all the difficulties. Your brother is more familiar with them.

Comment on this

You took one shilling off the old age pensions.

Comment on this

His brother is more familiar——

Comment on this

We are all familiar with them. No one is more familiar with them than I am.

Comment on this

I knew that would come back. If I met the Deputy in a place where we could discuss these things, I would give him enough of it.

Comment on this

This is the place to discuss things.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Egan should be allowed to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

I am making the assertion that the Fine Gael Government, when faced with budgetary difficulties, resolved those difficulties by cutting old age pensions by ten per cent.

Comment on this

They were faced with other problems at the same time.

Comment on this

They could resolve the problems by methods other than leaning on the most defenceless section of the community. They did not allow their friends to go without anything even when faced with these difficulties. They took damn good care that their friends were well looked after.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be unwise to follow that line because I can talk about Fianna Fáil doing well by their friends also.

Comment on this

The Deputy has always skeletons in his cupboard. Some day we will explore his cupboard.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Egan should be allowed to make his own speech and the interruptions should cease.

Comment on this

Is it a speech? I thought it was a diatribe.

Comment on this

That is the great difference between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, their respective attitudes to the poorer and weaker sections, to the workers and towards social welfare generally.

I welcome the very substantial sum provided in this Budget for the farmers, almost £40 million. This is something the farmers will understand, something concrete. Fine Gael have nothing to offer the farmers but advice, filling every townland with instructors and advisers. If you have a good farmer and give him a chance to make good with subsidies on fertilisers and other helps and if that man does make good, he is better than having a whole battalion of instructors and advisers because in farming, as in other walks of life, example is better than precept.

Comment on this

Tell that to the Minister for Agriculture. He would have whole fields full of inspectors.

Comment on this

I welcome the increase in old age pensions and in all the social welfare allowances and the increase for the man with the big family. I also welcome the provision and encouragement in the Budget for the continued development of our economy. This is a very sound Budget and a very fair one. The burden is spread equitably over all sections, having due regard to protection for the weaker and poorer sections. Anywhere there is weight to be borne it is placed on backs fit for the burden. I congratulate the Minister on a job well done and I believe that when the next Budget comes around, his courage and wisdom and foresight in this Budget will be appreciated by the people and that they will not be slow to say so.

Comment on this

Why not let the people say it now?

Comment on this

So much has been said already about this Budget in the House, and outside it, so much has been said and written, that it is very difficult to avoid repetition. However, there are some things that cannot be repeated too often. I hope to avoid repetition as far as possible. I think no Budget in the history of the State has provoked so much adverse comment. Certainly, no Budget has aroused such widespread condemnation as the Budget we are now discussing. The fact that the Government have had to resort to the most unpopular forms of taxation conceivable has been interpreted rightly as an indication of the mess in which this country finds itself after six years of Fianna Fáil rule.

No amount of bluff and propaganda can succeed in presenting this Budget other than as a drastic remedy for a desperate situation. The Taoiseach, in his speech, tried to sound convincing. He made a valiant effort when he spoke enthusiastically about the new five year plan and about the need to finance economic and social progress through increased Government spending. He tried to sweeten the pill of increased taxation by painting rosy pictures of future gain but no amount of windowdressing can hide the fact that the Budget is necessary because of the complete failure of the economic policy pursued by the Government since 1957.

In my opinion, the Budget is an admission of failure and the Taoiseach and other Government speakers were unsuccessful in their attempt to cover up that failure. They must think the people are simpletons to fall for glib talk about a new five year plan which is to bring increased employment, better social services and a higher standard of living. The people will not easily forget the promises made six years ago, the 100,000 new jobs, the economies to be effected in Government administration and so on. I believe if we look at this Budget in its true setting, we can only see it against the background of the record of the Government since 1957.

What is that record? I could use the word "record" in another context because the Government have undoubtedly created several records. For the first time, we have an adverse trade balance of over £100 million; our National Debt now exceeds £500 million; Government expenditure has reached an all-time high level of £167 million and last year £23 million were raised through local authority rates. Certainly, when it comes to raising and spending money, this Government have created records. What have we got in return? Have we the increased employment and lower emigration that we were promised? Have we better housing and social services? Have we increased production from our greatest natural resource, our land?

It is easy to find the answer to these questions. I shall take unemployment and emigration first because it was on a categorical assurance that they would solve these twin problems that Fianna Fáil were returned to power in 1957. The Taoiseach made this quite clear when he spoke in the Dáil on 14th May, 1957. I quote from column 44 of the Official Report. This passage has been quoted before but it could not be repeated too often. The Taoiseach said:

I and my colleagues have no doubt in our minds that we became the Government because the people expected us to work determinedly and intelligently to bring about a situation in which employment would expand, in which the twin problems of unemployment and emigration would be vigorously tackled.

What has happened since then? How did the Government fare in their attempts to tackle these twin problems of unemployment and emigration? Again, the facts speak for themselves. Although there has been a certain amount of controversy about the exact figure, it is a fair estimate that roughly 250,000 people have left this country since 1957. So much for emigration.

With regard to unemployment, we remember the 100,000 new jobs which were promised and we find that in the past five years, taking 1961 as against 1957, there have been something like 14,500 fewer people in employment. We see, then, the net results of the Government's efforts over the past six years have been that 250,000 persons have had to leave this country in search of employment while there are 14,500 fewer persons in employment here.

What about the social services? What about the so-called Fianna Fáil priority housing? How much of this colossal amount of money that has been raised over the past six years has been spent on housing? I have some figures here for expenditure on local authority housing. In 1957, the figure was £10,814,000; in 1958 £7,068,000; in 1959, £5,961,000; in 1960, £6,061,000 and in 1961, £6,389,000. By a process of simple arithmetic, I have got a comparison here. I find that in the three years of inter-Party Government a total of £35,651,000 was spent on housing, which is an average of £12 million per annum, whereas in the four years from 1957 to 1961, a total of only £25,479,000 was spent, which is an average of just over £6 million, which means that the expenditure on housing has been reduced to half.

Comment on this

Why was that?

Comment on this

That is what I am trying to find out.

Comment on this

I will tell you in a minute.

Comment on this

All right. Take the numbers employed in local authority housing. From 1954 to 1957, a total of 15,623 persons were employed on local authority housing. That is an average of 5,207 persons per annum, whereas in the four years 1957 to 1961, a total of 6,495 persons were employed, which is an average of 1,624. That is 1,624 for the four years 1957 to 1961 as against 5,207 in the preceding three years.

I have some figures for houses built by private individuals. From 1954 to 1957, a total of 16,089 houses were built, whereas in the four year period from 1957 to 1961, 14,009 houses were built. So that we can see there has been a considerable reduction in the number of houses built and the amount of money spent on housing.

We see there the record of the Government in the matter of employment, in the matter of emigration and in regard to housing. We now come to agriculture.

I believe that Fianna Fáil never had a policy for agriculture and never will have a policy. In 1962, almost 20,000 people left the land. Farmers, particularly the dairy farmers, until the recent penny was granted, which has now been negatived to a large extent by the increase in the levy, have had no increase in their income but their costs have risen by 30 per cent. Thousands of acres of the best land of this country have been sold to aliens and we have had the extraordinary situation of the Minister for Agriculture trying to justify the wholesale selling of land to aliens. He tried to justify that during his recent speech at Mullingar.

Looking back over the past six years and particularly looking back over the period of the first five year plan for economic development, which is now drawing to a close, we find that the Government have raised more money and spent more money than any other Government. They are now looking for more. Despite all the money which the Government have had at their disposal over the past six or seven years, 250,000 persons have had to leave this country in search of employment; house building had come almost to a standstill; agricultural production for the most part has remained static; the cost of living has risen by several points.

One question more than any other is being asked at the moment by the man in the street. It is not so much how will the money be raised by the new methods of taxation that have been introduced but what, in heaven's name, did the Government do with all the money they have put through their hands in the last few years. It is a very intelligent question and it is the question which the man in the street is asking.

I am not a financial expert and I shall be looking forward to my colleague, the Parliamentary Secretary, telling me what has happened but I shall just make a few shots at answering the question, what have the Government done with all this money? Of course, a considerable amount of it has gone to meet the ever-increasing cost of public administration. The cost of Government in this small country, with its now all-time low record of achievement, must be higher than in any other country in the world. Over the past few years, particularly over the past year and a half or so, Government spokesmen have been exhorting business firms and industrialists to modernise their methods and to cut costs through greater efficiency.

I should like to ask if any effort has been made to overhaul working methods in public administration. As far as I can see, the Government are just handing on the increased costs of administration to the taxpayer. I remember in 1957 promises of huge economies in administration. Those promises, of course, like all the other promises, are just so much hot air and bluff. I believe a considerable amount of money spent over the past two years has gone in meeting the ever-increasing costs of public administration. A good deal of the remainder has been squandered on a mad economic policy. Instead of developing our natural resources and establishing industries based on those resources, the Government have concentrated on grandiose, crackpot schemes, massive public buildings, tourist roadways. These are the things which seem to appeal to the Government. That is where the money goes and pop goes the taxpayer.

Coming from the general to the particular, let us look at the results of the five-year Programme for Economic Development. Let us look at the results in my constituency. Taking emigration first, there is the report of a survey carried out by the Limerick Junior Chamber of Commerce. In passing, I should mention that this is the group before whom the Taoiseach made his momentous announcement some weeks ago in relation to the introduction of a sales tax; on a later occasion, he referred to this group as being the same thing as a Fianna Fáil cumann. This body has published a report of the survey they carried out and the report states that between 1956 and 1961, 22,000 people emigrated from the Limerick area.

Let us look now at employment in my constituency. Except for a few minor industries, no major industry of any significance has been established in either Limerick city or county and in some of the old established industries, there has been a reduction in employment. I have here some official figures got over the past six or eight months in reply to questions here in this House. In Limerick locomotive works on 1st January, 1958, there were 305 people employed; on 21st November, 1962, the number had fallen to 243. At Lansdowne in the Dairy Disposal Company milk-processing plant, situated in the heart of the Golden Vale, in the finest milk producing region in Europe, there were 209 people in permanent employment in 1957; in 1962, that figure had fallen to 187. In afforestation, there were 82 people employed in 1957; in 1961-62, the figure had been reduced to 70. These are the results of the five-year Programme for Economic Development. That is what the programme has achieved for Limerick.

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

I thought the Board of Works were operating down there.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not mention it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is getting the works now.

Comment on this

Earlier I gave figures for housing. How much money has been spent on housing in Limerick in the past six or seven years? We have in the city of Limerick, and the Minister for Local Government must be thanked for having courageously adverted to the situation and made a public pronouncement on it, a desperate, deplorable, shocking housing situation.

Comment on this

It was I who said that.

Comment on this

The first time any real pronouncement was made on the housing situation in the city of Limerick was the occasion on which the Minister for Local Government prior to his departure for America last August, publicly commented on it. It was that more than anything else that focussed attention on the situation.

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

Someone must have told him.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Taking the six year period 1956-1962, in 1956-57, 200 houses were built. In 1957-58, 159 were built. In 1958-59 no houses were built.

Comment on this

Tell us why.

Comment on this

In 1959-60, 175 houses were built; in 1960-61, 108 houses were built; in 1961-62, no houses were built; in the last financial year—I have not got the official figure —I understand something in the region of 67 houses were built.

Comment on this

The Deputy understands wrongly.

Comment on this

There are 1,500 families in the city of Limerick at the present time living in the most deplorable conditions, conditions to which I would not subject the humblest animal on my farm. This is the result of the famous economic policy. This is the result of all the bluff over the past five or six years. I have done a little research in my constituency.

Comment on this

Our constituency.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Donnell

The results of my research are significant. There are 2,000 people in Limerick city and county in receipt of home assistance. There is no need for me to emphasise the type of existence they have on the miserable pittance they receive.

With regard to educational facilities, there is a good deal of talk now about the new college of technology.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree with it?

Comment on this

I agree with anything which will improve the educational facilities of Limerick and bring them more into line with Dublin and Cork.

Comment on this

And Galway.

Comment on this

I am referring to the five-year plan for economic development and the tremendous results that plan has produced in Limerick city and county. Our educational facilities in Limerick are much poorer than are the facilities available in Dublin, Cork and Galway. Wherever the money comes from, whether it be £2 million or £10 million, I will not crib at it, provided its purpose is to give us improved educational facilities and a college of technology as well.

Comment on this

God knows, we would need a university down there.

Comment on this

We need a great many things down there.

Comment on this

Graduates could do with post-graduate courses.

Comment on this

One could say the Parliamentary Secretary is beyond educating.

Comment on this

Taking Limerick into consideration, taking into account the fact that we have the finest agricultural hinterland in Europe, transport facilities in the port of Limerick and nearby Shannon Airport, taking all these natural advantages of the Limerick region into account and looking at the results of the five-year Programme for Economic Expansion, I say without fear of contradiction that we have in the Limerick region the worst case of underdevelopment in Europe. Therefore, the colossal amount of money spent over the past six or seven years has not gone in solving the unemployment problem or the emigration problem. It has not gone in providing more housing. Very little was spent in my constituency. It has gone on all types of foolish schemes.

Comment on this

Such as?

Comment on this

Swimming pools, skating rinks, luxury hotels.

Comment on this

The Deputy is against those?

Comment on this

Civic centres.

Comment on this

The Deputy is against the swimming pools and the new hotels? That is interesting. It is on record.

Comment on this

Maybe the Parliamentary Secretary would allow the Deputy to make his own speech?

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Palatial embassies. As I say, the money is gone and we are looking for more.

Although everything that could be said about the Budget has been said, it might be no harm to say a few words about the turnover tax. A great deal has been said about it but nobody seems to know how it will work out. The Taoiseach said he hopes the force of competition will prevent the charge being passed on to the consumer. If that is so, it will mean the extermination of the small shopkeeper because the average family grocer is working on a very narrow margin. As far as I can ascertain, the average margin is ten per cent to 12 per cent and a 2½ per cent tax on a ten per cent profit is equivalent to a 25 per cent tax on profits. I believe this turnover tax must be passed on to the consumer if the small shopkeeper is to survive. If it is not passed on to the consumer and the force of competition keeps prices down, we shall see the complete clearing out of the small shopkeepers and an increase in the number of supermarkets.

In regard to the increase in corporation profits tax, it is a bad thing because so many industries and large businesses have, particularly over the past year or two, responded to the Government's call for greater efficiency and modernisation of methods. If this increase in corporation profits tax is to mean a lower amount of profit available for ploughing back into the business, it will have disastrous results.

Out of all the controversy and all the confusion which has been created by this Budget, one significant fact emerges: the way in which people have reacted to the Budget demonstrates very clearly the political maturity of our people. It shows the ability of the ordinary voter to penetrate the veneer of bluff and propaganda and to make a critical appraisal in the light of hard facts and practical results. This is a sobering thought for this or any future Government. It means that henceforth the performance of any Government will be judged on the results and not on promises. I welcome that prospect and I also look forward to seeing this political maturity very forcibly demonstrated in the forthcoming by-election.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Donnellan.

Comment on this

Since when does the Parliamentary Secretary direct you whom to call on?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary did not direct me. When the Deputy who has just spoken sat down, I looked at the Government benches and as nobody offered, I called on Deputy Donnellan.

Comment on this

Why is that?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It would not be normal to call the Deputy immediately after a Fine Gael speaker.

Comment on this

That is all right. The Parliamentary Secretary tried to direct you, all the same.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary did not.

Comment on this

Why did he point at Deputy Donnellan?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It does not matter whom he pointed at. The Parliamentary Secretary did not offer and I called on Deputy Donnellan, a Fine Gael Deputy having spoken.

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

I thank the Parliamentary Secretary for allowing me in. It is no harm to leave Limerick for a little while and go across the Shannon to Galway. I am glad the Minister is in the House because I wish to refer to the turnover tax. This tax was certainly a brainwave on the part of whatever civil servants got the idea because the Minister for Finance and the Parliamentary Secretary beside him do not know how this tax will work or how it will be collected. Some Deputies over there say the consumer will pay it; others say the shopkeeper will pay it. The Parliamentary Secretary last week said it would not be paid by anybody. Therefore I should like to know from the Minister who exactly will pay it.

As regards the small businessman in the town, for every pound's worth he sells must he collect sixpence, keep an account of it and give it back to the Government? If the consumer buys 10/- worth of goods, will he be charged an extra 3d.? Will he be charged an extra three farthings to buy his 5/- worth? Will he be charged an extra halfpenny to buy half-acrown's worth? May I refer to the farthing, as Deputy Egan did? Will he be charged three farthings on it? That is what I want to know.

Is it the consumer who must pay this tax or must the small businessman make a tax gatherer of himself? Will he collect it or will he pay it himself? Certainly, the Minister has not made it clear whether it is the consumer or whether it is the businessman who will pay the tax or collect it. As far as I am concerned, it is ridiculous to ask either one or the other to do so. The simple reason is that it cannot definitely be collected on the amounts of money. Say a man buys 2/6d. worth of stuff. Has he to pay a halfpenny or three farthings or has he not, or does the businessman keep an account of it and pay it himself? I want to know which of them is to do it. I regret that either of them have to do it.

I am sorry Deputy Kitt, my sparring partner down in East Galway, is not in the House at the moment. I wonder if Deputy Kitt thinks of the business people of Dunmore, Milltown, Mountbellew, Tuam, Glenamaddy or Ballygar? Does Deputy Kitt think that each and every one of them—small business people as they are now; I regret to say quite a lot of them nearly on the way out—should become unpaid tax gatherers for the Government or does he think that the consumers should pay? Personally, I do not think they should.

The self-same thing applies to Deputy Millar's area, which is my own as well. Take the people of Ballinasloe, the people of Ahascragh, the people of Athenry. I wonder if Deputy Millar believes they should pay this tax? The self-same thing applies to my good friend, Deputy Carty. Does he think the business people of Loughrea, Clarenbridge, Gort, should become tax gatherers for this Government or that the consumers should be forced to pay this 2½ per cent tax? The Minister himself does not know. He has not committed himself, mind you, on whether it should be the consumers or the business people.

I regret very much that this tax was ever brought into this House. I say it was a brainwave of some civil servant who did not know what he was doing and cared a damn sight less about what he was doing. He had no interest in the rural areas when he suggested putting on a tax of that description. I am quite sure that the Minister and his Parliamentary Secretary beside him, will fully agree with me that the small business people in the small towns are at their wits' end to make ends meet and by putting on this tax, probably the big business man can wipe them out. Probably he will be in the position that he can pay this tax himself. If he does that, as he probably will, will he not wipe out these small people?

Comment on this

What will the weekly or monthly turnover of these small people the Deputy is talking about be?

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

Well, I would not know exactly.

Comment on this

Roughly?

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

Say a turnover of £500 a year—the worst of them. The smallest of them would have a turnover of £500 a year. Is it fair that they should be taxed? I do not think it is. It is unreasonable that it should happen. My point is that the bigger businessman will probably pay this 2½ per cent himself. He will not do it for the good of the people generally but, by so doing, he will put the smaller man out of business completely. I would ask the Minister to reconsider this 2½ per cent tax. If the Minister arranged that it should be put on the wholesaler, it would be much easier for the Government to collect it. The Government will get roughly £10½ million out of it.

I believe the idea of the Government in doing this is that next year they will have a surplus. This is my view about it. I may be wrong. They will have a surplus. They can give certain concessions and then it will give them a good opportunity to go to the country. I would ask them not to adopt that attitude but to be fair and honest with the people. Therefore, I urge the Minister to consider withdrawing this 2½ per cent tax or else to tell us straight who will be responsible for the collecting and payment of it.

Comment on this
Donogh O'Malley Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance (Mr. O'Malley) Fianna Fáil

There is one thing evident from the debate on this Budget. It has shown in no uncertain fashion that particularly the main Opposition Party here, Fine Gael, are completely bereft of any ideas, plans or constructive criticism and in fact are devoid of any programme for the future of the country in the position they occupy at the present time. Ninety-five per cent of the Opposition speakers in this debate, which is now drawing to a close, dealt solely with the effects of the turnover tax. Surely it is an extraordinary reflection on the so-called political maturity which my colleague in Limerick, Deputy T. O'Donnell, suggests exists now in this country, that some members of this House are so devoid of ideas and so unable to express themselves on any facet of the whole economic programme of the Government that the only matter to which they can devote their attention is the turnover tax?

On the turnover tax itself, has there ever been a greater campaign of misrepresentation throughout the country —all aimed, of course, at the coming by-election in Dublin North-East? To come out in the open, as the Minister says, when you have this tax of 2½ per cent, someone will have to pay. That is quite obvious. The money will have to be got somewhere. The source is 2½ per cent on established turnover and it is estimated that in a full financial year, it will yield a little more than £10 million. It is completely dishonest in the first instance for these speakers to suggest that this turnover tax will sound the death knell of the small shopkeepers. Perhaps the Fine Gael Party and some members of the Labour Party may succeed for a short while in causing utter confusion in the minds of the small shopkeepers throughout the country. There is no question of doubt about it: these shopkeepers as a result of this campaign of misrepresentation are worried and certainly they have every reason to be worried when they see the Opposition papers in particular quoting in extenso the speeches of leaders of the Opposition Parties.

No one has any desire to go over these matters in detail again. When I asked Deputy Donnellan what he considered to be a small shopkeeper in his constituency of East Galway, the rough figure he suggested was a turnover of £500 per annum. If my memory serves me correctly, the Minister in the Budget Statement specifically cited the case of a small shopkeeper with £100 per month or £1,200 per annum turnover and said that in fact he would be liable only for a tax of 17/6d. per month and thereafter 3d. per pound on the next £50. This Budget does not in any way sound the death knell of the small shopkeeper. Comparatively speaking, this Budget does not in any way injure the small shopkeeper. In fact, it is my personal opinion, from making a study of the position, that the smaller shopkeeper, due to the small tax which he or she will contribute, will in fact be in a definitely advantageous position because with a very slight tax, there will be no question of passing on anything to his or her customers. That is a fact.

One of the choices facing the Government in framing this Budget was to allow things to stand as they are at present. Another was to advance under all headings of national endeavour. That was the choice with which the Government were faced.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister did not say it was going to enter the capital development fund.

Comment on this

It is quite obvious that the Deputy does not understand the point I am making.

Comment on this

Explain it and maybe I will understand it better.

Comment on this

Are there some among us—evidently there are—who do not want to step up further and increase the tempo of our economic development and our economic advancement? If there are—and by their speeches they exist on the Opposition benches of this House —it is an extraordinary frame of mind but it is an attitude which they are entitled to adopt: "Preserve the status quo; let us stand as we are.” They say the Budget deficit was something under £5 million but remember that the Coalition deficit in their last year of office was more than £6 million. The Minister for Finance could have preserved that status quo but that is not the policy of this Govvernment or of the Fianna Fáil Party. To illustrate that perhaps a little better, I will answer what I might have considered a hypothetical question when Deputy O'Donnell asked where all the money has gone since 1957.

Comment on this

Singer took it.

Comment on this

That is typical.

Comment on this

You let him out. He gave a good subscription to the fund and you cannot deny it.

Comment on this

This position is far too serious——

Comment on this

It is serious for a lot of people.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Parliamentary Secretary should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

But I am putting him right.

Comment on this

The people of the country with the political maturity that was mentioned by Deputy O'Donnell expect more from the speeches of the Opposition than what we have heard so far.

Comment on this

They want the brains trust.

Comment on this

No doubt Deputy Sweetman who will be speaking shortly will make clear the Fine Gael viewpoint which we have not heard up to now.

Harking back to the fact that we could have stayed as we were, the buoyancy of the revenue might have made sure that we would not have a deficit in the coming year and taxation would more or less remain lower than the figure we are seeking. But look at the position regarding social welfare, for example. Back in 1957, current Government expenditure on social welfare was in the order of £25 million and in the financial year 1963-64, the Estimate has risen to £28 million. Is it suggested by the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party——

Comment on this

The purchasing power of the £ has gone down since then.

Comment on this

It has not gone down that much. Is it suggested by Fine Gael and the Labour Party that we should not have increased those benefits by this £3 million? Another important point to remember is that of the estimated yield of £10 million from the turnover tax, approximately £4½ million goes in social welfare increases for old age pensioners, children's allowances and other benefits. Nearly 50 per cent of the total £10 million goes in social welfare payments. I have pointed out that we have raised the cost of social welfare services from the 1957 figure of £25 million to £28 million, and we are not ashamed of it.

Perhaps the Opposition want us to leave the education provision alone. Do they object to our increasing it from £13 million in the 1957 Estimate to nearly £20 million? If they want us not to spend that extra £6 million, will they say so? At least they would be honest if they did. That is not the policy of the Government.

We realise that one of the major problems, as has been more than hinted at by the Taoiseach and the Minister for Education, is the absolute necessity for a revolution in the education system whereby as quickly as possible in the future every child will at least be given a means of livelihood which will remove him from the category of a serf or a slave by post-primary education, by easier access to secondary education and in certain instances to university education, and particularly by the advancement of what I think the House will agree is far too slow, vocational education and higher technological education generally. We make no apology for showing where portion of this tax will go.

We point out, then, that the health services have gone up from 1957 by another £3 million. There have been certain advances with regard to the health services. A Committee of the House is sitting to examine the entire ramifications of the Health Act, and I sincerely trust that the day is not so far off when its report and recommendation will be given to the House.

The provisions made for agriculture, industry, transport, forestry, fisheries, the Post Office and pensions for the public services have all increased. The difference between ourselves and Fine Gael is this: Fine Gael says that there is no future in Ireland. They have no confidence in Ireland, and consider that as far as this country is concerned all is lost and that nothing possible to keep on to our goals could be done by any Government.

When one is talking about proposals by Governments, it is reasonable for each and every one of us to keep away from too much detail on finance. What is life, one should ask oneself. What do we want here in Ireland? What is the Ireland we seek to achieve? The ambition of each and every member of this House is to have our 32 counties as one entity under one flag, but apart from that, the Ireland we are aiming for, surely, we must get into its proper perspective. Do we want work for all our citizens? The unemployment problem is not solved by any means, though it certainly is a far cry from the figure of 97,000 people in 1957 when we took over. Admittedly we want work for our people, but do we want the country crawling with Dagenhams? The position could get out of hand if that proper perspective I speak of is not secured.

It may sound a long way off the Budget, but I think it will be agreed that under the provisions in the Estimates, I am entitled to refer to one of the most important Bills going through the House—the Town Planning Bill. The Ireland I would like to see will have industrialisation in the proper place with the preservation, above all, of the amenities of our country in the realisation that the be-all and end-all of life here and the absolute goal is not solely money. We are still in a position to have an appreciation of things beautiful, of the arts, culture, drama and so on. That is the Ireland we all should aim for, and that is why I am so enthusiastic about this Vote for Education being so substantially increased. I sincerely trust that in years to come successive Governments and successive Ministers for Finance will ensure that our three priorities will continue to be attacked more vigorously down the years.

First of those is education. I am not going to boast, but we have increased the output of school buildings. Nevertheless, children in certain instances throughout Ireland are being reared and educated in hovels. There is no point in hiding our heads in the sand and denying that. There is a tremendous programme there. I do not think that this is controversial, for everyone will agree on it.

As regards housing, it is quite true that, as Deputy O'Donnell said, not only in Limerick city but in Dublin and other areas, people are living in overcrowded conditions and nearslums. The Minister for Local Government was perfectly right last August before he went to America. Of course there are slums and overcrowded conditions in Limerick and Dublin. I only hope that measures to deal with that problem will be stepped up.

Above all, the amount given in social welfare benefits is not at all adequate. I sincerely trust that with increased prosperity and increased productivity and the raising of the standard of living, the old age pensioners, the widows and unemployment assistance beneficiaries will get substantial rises, and not the annual increases, which have been the pattern up to now, of a shilling or two. They each got half-a-crown on this occasion, plus the increases in children's allowances.

I should like to see the amount paid in social welfare benefits tied to some wage rate. We have all heard the cliché particularly coming up to Christmas time, that if you offer these people a day's work, they will not take it, that all they want to do is stand around and hold up the bookmaker's office. I remember, when I was Mayor of Limerick, meeting five to six hundred people who were looking for work and on no occasion did I come across people who would not take work if you offered it to them. People called to me time and time again seeking work.

The first duty of the Government is, and it is the Government's responsibility, to do all in their power to provide work but, if they do not achieve the aim of full employment or an approach to full employment, then the less well-off members of the community must be catered for in a more realistic and more generous manner than we are doing at the present time with the limited resources at our disposal.

My colleague in Limerick, Deputy O'Donnell, referred to the housing position. I do not want to weary the House with details and statistics but he quoted the figures for Limerick in 1956 and 1957 and the same pattern would be typical of the country as a whole. We had the figures for 1956 all right and then the graph went down at the end of 1957. It continued to go down in 1958 and in 1959, it went up again and is still at an increasingly high level. I do not want to labour the point but I hope that Deputy Sweetman will refer to this important social matter in his speech. There were 8,000 skilled tradesmen who fled from this country between 1957 and 1959. The figures I am quoting here are not my own. They are obtainable in the Statistical Abstract under the different categories, carpenters, bricklayers, masons and plasterers. They went, and unfortunately they have not come back.

Comment on this

To what would they come back?

Comment on this

That is what you are up against. We are trying to ensure that we will get them back again.

Comment on this

If you could stop their brothers going, you would do well. There are 40,000 of them going every year.

Comment on this

I wonder what a young person of 22 or 23 years of age who comes up to the public gallery thinks when he hears this kind of thing.

Comment on this

Facts are facts and you cannot escape them.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Acting Chairman (Mr. P. O'Donnell) Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary is in possession.

Comment on this

I will give way to the Deputy if he will quote the figures.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy will have an opportunity of replying if he has not already spoken.

Comment on this

Deputy Coogan has alleged that the latest emigration figure is 40,000. If he wants to quote these figures, I will give him an opportunity.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary is going to sit down, I will stand up.

Comment on this

I will give way to Deputy Coogan to give him an opportunity to quote the figures.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Parliamentary Secretary is in possession and the Deputy will have an opportunity of replying later.

Comment on this

Over the 12 months ended 28th February, 1963, the emigration figures, at 12,200, were the lowest since the war. I am sure that a mistake of 27,800 would not unduly worry Deputy Coogan.

Comment on this

It would not worry you.

Comment on this

I would like to briefly dispose of the housing position. Deputy Sweetman, when Minister for Finance and when a crisis arose, called all the county managers together and told them the position.

Comment on this

And I told them what they could rely on for the following year. Will the Parliamentary Secretary get the minute in that regard from his colleague and put it on the Table of the House? I told them that they could rely on more money than they actually spent.

Comment on this

Suppose I am told that I can rely on £10,000 and when I go to look for it, it is not there, what am I to do?

Comment on this

It was there and it was paid out. In some cases, they did not spend it at all.

Comment on this

The Deputy referred to the financial year 1957-58 when we had taken over office.

Comment on this

That meeting was held in January or February of 1957— I do not remember which.

Comment on this

This Government took office in March 1957 and supplied the money. The position was that a financial crisis arose. I am not going into the reasons for it, the Suez crisis and other matters alleged by Deputy Sweetman. The position was that as a result of that county managers' conference, planning for the future came to a standstill. In housing schemes, to bring to a standstill the acquisition of land and development of sewerage schemes and water supplies, the planning of the houses themselves, the surveys of the land, can result in a delay of anything from 18 to 30 months in getting things moving again. That is what happened. You cannot just press a button when the planning has ended and start off again. You must start again from scratch. That is the trouble. Some 8,000 building operatives left the country according to the Statistical Abstract between 1957 and 1959. That is one of the reasons why things are only coming back to normal at present. The position would not have arisen at all and it would not have been necessary for Deputy Sweetman to call this conference of county and city managers in January, 1957, had he taken note of the warnings issued to him by the present Minister for Finance and the present Tánaiste.

Comment on this

What was the meeting called for?

Comment on this

To tell the county managers what the position was.

Comment on this

And what they could expect to receive in the following year.

Comment on this

Yes. I am speaking of my own local authority only and our city manager in Limerick reported back to us that he would have to cut substantially the programme envisaged by perhaps the more enthusiastic members of the council. Whatever the Minister for Finance told him, the position was that there was no money there. Deputy Sweetman may shake his head and deny that but I know what I am talking about.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should know but does not.

Comment on this

The building industry then was in a critical position. Things were so bad that Deputy Sweetman, as Minister for Finance, had to allow Dublin and Cork Corporations access to the Local Loans Fund for the first time.

Comment on this

Dublin and Cork Corporations will be interested to know that the Parliamentary Secretary criticises that position because they wanted it for a long time and it had always been refused by my predecessors.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

That is true. Ask the Minister and his advisers will tell him the position.

Comment on this

His advisers will tell him no such thing because it was not so.

Comment on this

His advisers will tell him the truth.

Comment on this

Yesterday a figure was given by an Opposition Deputy for large issues from the Local Loans Fund. Heretofore, access had not been given to Cork and Dublin Corporations to this Fund and the reason why Deputy Sweetman, as Minister, had to allow them in was that they were unable and would have been unable to raise the money by public issue as had hitherto been done. That is what increased issues from the Local Loans Fund at that time.

Comment on this

Deputy Timmons knows about Dublin Corporation. Do not embarrass him.

Comment on this

We could not get the money.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Sweetman would tell us why things were so bad in regard to the administration of the Small Dwellings Acquisition Act, 1898, that not alone was there no money but in desperation— I am in a difficult position, a Cheann Chomhairle, because due to the position you occupy at present, I cannot refer to you——

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Acting Chairman (Mr. P. O'Donnell) Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary may not refer to the Chair.

Comment on this

"The then Minister for Local Government" is the phrase the Parliamentary Secretary wants.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair has no objection to the then Minister for Local Government being criticised by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The then Minister for Local Government was willing and keen to do his best but he had to take his riding instructions from the then Minister for Finance and he did not come under starter's orders because, not only was there no money—and Deputy Sweetman will have to refer to this—but the suggestion or the great masterplan of Fine Gael who occupied the key posts in the Coalition Government, was a system of guarantees with the building societies. They forgot that the building societies had no money, either. At any rate, it did not work. This is not a debate on the Estimate for Local Government and I just wanted to clear those points and have them on record in regard to housing generally.

I want to point out to Deputy Sweetman that the criticisms made by the present Taoiseach, by the Minister for Finance and by the Tánaiste of the imposition by Deputy Sweetman of the levies in 1956 arose not from the fact that the levies were imposed. They were bad enough and brought heavy unemployment as a result, but it was the failure of the Minister, Deputy Sweetman, in allowing matters to drift and not taking remedial measures earlier that provoked the criticism. We had taken over from one Coalition Government in 1951 when a balance of payments crisis existed of £61.6 million and in 1955, the balance of payments after the Coalition had been just one year in office, was £35.5 million which ran on in 1956 to £14 million.

When Fianna Fáil came up against such crises they took immediate measures. They put the serious position before the people and relied on the understanding of the people to appreciate the necessity for the measures that had to be taken. To my colleague and to other members of Fine Gael generally, I would say: Is there any chance they might lose their pessimism and see some bit of blue appearing through the so-called dark economic clouds? Are all their skies grey? Is there nothing in the future—

Comment on this

The North Dublin by-election.

Comment on this

—to give confidence and hope? I do not know if Deputy O'Donnell from my constituency is typical of the attitude and mentality generally of Fine Gael but if he is, we do not have an Opposition Party any longer. He criticised the building of so-called luxury hotels. I am interested to have on record that Deputy O'Donnell is against the building of these hotels in Limerick.

Comment on this

It is a matter of priority. I would be more interested in the building of houses in Limerick than in the building of luxury hotels.

Comment on this

That was flogged to death long ago. They are two different things. In a speech recently, Deputy O'Donnell also criticised the building of the luxury hotel in Limerick by Intercontinental Hotels. One hotel is being built in Cork, one in Dublin, one in Limerick. I do not want to boast but it is thanks to me that the hotel was built there. There will be more about that at a more appropriate time.

Comment on this

Of course, it happens to be untrue—the selection of Limerick as one of the sites.

Comment on this

What is untrue?

Comment on this

That the Parliamentary Secretary was responsible.

Comment on this

Without any shadow of doubt, yes.

Comment on this

I happen to know something about that.

Comment on this

I do not want to be betting fivers here every week. I could not afford it.

Comment on this

No, not at the rate at which you lose them.

Comment on this

Let us leave it at this—I was responsible.

Comment on this