We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).

Contributions 166–320 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Acting Chairman

Perhaps it could be decided on another occasion and the Parliamentary Secretary would get back to the Budget?

Comment on this

Everyone in Limerick knows who brought the hotel there. Furthermore, I remember reading anonymous letters—always written by Fine Gael—to the effect that this so-called hotel of Deputy O'Malley's was a white elephant. The same letter suggested that Bord na gCon's coming to Limerick, which we got, too, was another white elephant.

Comment on this

I know nothing about Bord na gCon but I do know about the hotel.

Comment on this

We will leave that aside and Deputy Sweetman will tell us about it in his speech and tell us who brought it to Limerick.

Comment on this

No, he will not, but he will contradict the Parliamentary Secretary when he is not telling the truth.

Comment on this

That will make interesting reading. Let us leave it at that. Possibly Deputy Sweetman thinks he is correct and that I am wrong. So be it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary, I imagine, knows why I think it.

Comment on this

I do not.

Comment on this

I know who handled the matter.

Comment on this

For Intercontinental?

Comment on this

I will tell you afterwards.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps we could get back to the Budget?

Comment on this

I was dealing with the mentality of Deputy O'Donnell. He deprecates the building of this luxury hotel now and he says there are other hotels in Limerick that have spent a lot of money doing up their premises and asks why should the State contribute towards the cost. Does he not appreciate that the estimated increased injection to the turnover of the economy in Limerick will be of the order of £500,000 per annum of new business and does he appreciate that according to statements made by the directors of these hotels, business coming in will be entirely new business and will not cut across in any way the amount enjoyed or earned by the existing hoteliers?

Surely Deputy O'Donnell is not critical of the hundreds of people who will directly benefit from the construction of this £¾ million hotel? Surely he will appreciate the fact that benefits will accrue to the former through the sale of produce to the hotel? Surely Deputy O'Donnell will understand that it is not alone this new hotel that received a subsidy from State funds or semiState bodies from voted money from this House but that every other hotel that spent money on new bedrooms also enjoyed this subsidy? Let us be fair about the matter. I want to know why Deputy O'Donnell also objects to the spending of money on a swimming pool. Perhaps he will say that this is not the time to embark on the construction of a £110,000 swimming pool. I am sorry Deputy O'Donnell is against the swimming pool project.

Comment on this

I am against luxury hotels, palatial buildings, while the housing situation in Limerick is as it is. There is a shortage of tradesmen.

Comment on this

If everything is to close down until we solve our housing programme, that would bring business to a standstill. I can assure Deputy O'Donnell that in Limerick, Dublin and other cities, and particularly in some inland towns, the young people are crying out for swimming pools. A swimming pool is a great advantage. The provision of swimming pools is encouraged, logically, by the Minister for Health. The matter is administered by Local Government and encouraged by the Department of Health, for obvious reasons.

Comment on this

The swimming pool will be of great benefit to the young fellow and his wife who want a house.

Comment on this

To the families living in one room.

Comment on this

The rules of the House would not allow me to describe in adequate fashion the suggestion——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Neither do they entitle speakers to go into detail that would be much more appropriate to the Estimate for Local Government.

Comment on this

I would point out, with respect, that my colleague, Deputy O'Donnell, not only gave statistics from 1955 to the latest date for which figures are available in respect of housing in the State generally but went into great detail in respect of the number of houses built and the number of men employed in Limerick city.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Of course, the trouble is that two wrongs do not make a right. We had better get back to the Budget.

Comment on this

I do not want the broth spoiled by too many wrong cooks. I want to get the facts on the records of the House. However, I bow to your ruling on the matter.

Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins spoke here yesterday. Her speech was typical Fine Gael propaganda, but it was interesting for all that and was delivered in an excellent and lucid manner. She made one statement which set a kind of headline for many Fine Gael speakers. I refer to the suggestion that, due to the Minister's acceptance of a recommendation made by the Commission of Inquiry into Income Tax in relation to the letting of land, houses, flats or rooms, a widow, Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins said, with three or four children would now find herself in a serious plight because her financial circumstances would be drastically worsened. Deputy Sweetman appreciates, of course, that that will not be the position.

Comment on this

I am still trying to get some information from the Minister about how the tax will work. He could not explain it the other day.

Comment on this

I will tell the Deputy now.

Comment on this

I should prefer the Minister to give the information rather than the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The Minister will deal with the point when he comes to reply.

Comment on this

I wonder.

Comment on this

I am talking about the unfortunate widow with the three or four children.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary must not edge in on Deputy Paddy Burke's preserve.

Comment on this

It was made clear by the Minister that Deputies are wrong in saying this tax is an imposition on a person such as the unfortunate widow to whom Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins referred. If this tax were to be applied in the way suggested, I should be the first to criticise it, because I know that a large percentage of widows and elderly people, depend for a livelihood on the letting of accommodation. This suggestion is but another misconception which has gone abroad because of the unfortunately dishonest propaganda of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

We must be very powerful.

Comment on this

The Deputy has a great many papers and the people read them. You would be surprised at the unfortunate people who believe what some Fine Gael speakers say.

Comment on this

A great many people believe what they read in the Irish Press unfortunately, too.

Comment on this

As the Minister has pointed out, unless the person in question is subject to tax, this new proposal will not affect him or her in any way.

I was amazed when, after the Minister's opening statement and after Deputy Sweetman had replied, Deputy Norton spoke for the Labour Party and dealt with nothing except the turnover tax. There was no suggestion that he welcomed the £10 million expected yield in a full year from this tax. There was no suggestion that he welcomed the fact that £4½ million of this yield would go to social welfare beneficiaries. He never adverted to the fact that there will be a yield of £3½ million from the corporation profits tax. No one on the Opposition benches lauded the Minister, not even Deputy T. O'Donnell, who represents a predominantly rural constituency, for putting an end to the racket whereby professional and business people took land as a sideline to their business or profession in order to evade paying tax.

The fact that an end is put to this practice now is, I think, a good thing for the country generally. It should be welcomed by the farming community, by the young farmers, by the very loquacious farming associations. Deputy Sweetman makes a very good attempt at times, not quite successfully perhaps, at being factual. I trust he will not permit the present propaganda trend to continue. Fine Gael speakers misrepresent the facts because they have been given a political pep talk by Deputy Dillon and Deputy Sweetman. I do not think any of them has read this Budget. Had they read it, had they listened to the Minister—that may have been difficult because of the appalling acoustics——

Comment on this

"I want money," he said.

Comment on this

I want money, too, to correct the acoustics here.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary could teach the Minister not to mumble, that would be better than improving the acoustics.

Comment on this

It was not a question of mumbling. We will be improving the acoustics here.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary will disimprove them.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon and Deputy Sweetman gave a pep talk to their backbenchers, with Dublin North-East on the horizon.

Comment on this

I explained, of course, what the Budget meant to my colleagues as I am sure Fianna Fáil would explain it to their Party. I wonder did the Minister explain it to the Fianna Fáil Party down in the Party Room.

Comment on this

The position is we know Deputy Sweetman gave a biassed——

Comment on this

Factual.

Comment on this

——account of this Budget and told the backbenchers certain points to stress. If Deputy Sweetman is responsible for some of the economic theories expounded by Deputy Rooney last night, he has a good deal to answer for. As far as Fine Gael speakers generally are concerned, they have really no proper conception of this Budget and I sincerely hope that, when the Minister concludes tonight, they will listen to him and then rectify the misrepresentation of which they have been guilty.

Deputy Barrett talked about the turnover tax affecting newsboys.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister said himself. He said the newspapers would inform the Government how many newspapers they gave to the newsboys and it was no concern of the Minister's how the newsboys collected the tax. That is in the Official Report of 23rd April.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say that at all.

Comment on this

He did say it. I will go out and bring in the Official Report and quote.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I will bring in the debate and quote it.

Comment on this

I should be glad if the Deputy would.

Comment on this

It is ridiculous to talk about newsboys paying a turnover tax.

Comment on this

Better leave that statement alone now. It was a bad one.

Comment on this

Deputy T. O'Donnell comes from my own constituency. He criticised the proposed civic centre in Limerick. I did not think that would occasion any controversy. The Taoiseach said recently that many of our city and town centres are in an appalling condition and require rebuilding. There is a social problem there in that there is no point in denuding the centre of these cities and having the shops and shopkeepers losing quite a source of revenue. It is a problem that will have to be tackled in Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Galway and elsewhere.

I wish to refer to the cost of the provision of swimming pools and other public projects in the past. In 1926, according to the local papers in Limerick, a local association member said: We cannot bear any further impost" and in 1928: "This would mean the end of the shopping community generally." This is the trend down the years. No matter what constructive projects are put up, there will always be a certain section of the community, particularly, I am sorry to say, those who with the increased productivity and growth of the country generally benefit substantially, are not prepared to share a penny with the less well-off members of the community.

Another cliché expressed by Fine Gael speakers has been the ever-increasing cost of administration of the Civil Service. What Deputy O'Donnell must bear in mind is that any increases are the result of the increase in the number of new proposals by the Government. Naturally, it was necessary that extra staff be employed to run these new boards or new sections of Departments. It must not be forgotten that civil servants have to live, too, and that they are workers just the same as everyone else who is classified as such. I am satisfied that when Deputy O'Donnell looks into the background of the increased number of employees and the increased cost of administration, he will admit that not only is a tight rein on recruitment increase being held but the increases are most reasonable.

I should like to say a little word to my friends on the Labour benches. Sometimes they look astounded on the Government benches and they say: "How is it we got only one seat in Dublin? How is it that the Irish people, the working man, all sections of the community, are represented by the Fianna Fáil Party. The good sense, the common sense and the logic of the man in the street——

Comment on this

The nonsense.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that the voter is incompetent or incapable of making up his mind? The reason for our success in the political life of this country is that, Fianna Fáil can, at Government level and at Party level, represent every section of the community, the small farmer, the big farmer, the tradesman, the professional man and the business man. That is the beauty of it. Then of course with such interests represented and having a Government with such an appreciation of equality, particularly, the greatest advantage of such a Party is the stability in the value of the £. To bring it to its logical and ridiculous conclusion, there is no point in increasing wages by £80 or £100 a week.

The Minister's summary of the Budget in his opening statement and the recent pronouncements by the Taoiseach indicate that our whole policy is one of continuing advancement. The only trouble is that we are not advancing as quickly as we would like. However, there again the difference between ourselves and Fine Gael is that at least we aim at the stars. Fine Gael still wail at the weeping wall, are still the Jeremiahs, who see no future in Ireland and suggest to the younger people: "Let us get out of here; there is no future in Ireland."

Deputy Dillon when making his major contribution to the Budget debate made an extraordinary statement. In so far as he is Leader of the main Opposition Party, one would have thought he would have made a statesmanlike speech or one worthy of the Leader of the main Opposition Party. He candidly confessed that he would welcome and be glad of the opportunity to take over the leadership of the Government, were it entrusted to him. I do not know how he would achieve that. Perhaps Deputy Sweetman would enlighten us as to the political alignment for which he hopes. Labour, evidently, will never again join a Coalition, or will they? Fine Gael will have no truck with Labour, Clan na Talmhan or any other Party. We know how we stand. We are not dictated to by anybody. We are a Party and will continue to be a single Party but surely for the new voters, the young people, it is a reasonable question.

Comment on this

There are none of them left. They have flown out of the country.

Comment on this

It is a reasonable request to make. I want to refer to one paragraph of Deputy Dillon's speech on this Budget. At columns 268 and 269 of the Official Report, he said:

The deficit on the current Budget is £4,857,000—

It was over £6,000,000 in his last period.

Comment on this

I should also compare like with like, if I were you.

Comment on this

What is the "like with like?"

Comment on this

Think about it and look at the figures.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon continued:

—and that is all in the context of the fact that our imports are steadily rising and our exports are declining.

This is the point I want to come to, to show again the pessimistic mentality of Fine Gael:

Not only is that true but the rate of increase in the gross national product at constant market prices is steadily declining.

Deputy Sweetman nods his head. To prove it is steadily declining, these figures are taken from the Economic Statistics.

Comment on this

Table 12 B.

Comment on this

I shall give the Deputy the page, not the Table itself.

Comment on this

Page 31. I have it here.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon said:

Not only is that true but the rate of increase in the gross national product at constant market prices is steadily declining.

Deputy Sweetman nods in agreement. Then the figures given are:

The increase in 1959 was 4.9;— I presume, per cent.

—in 1960, it was 5.9; in 1961, it was 3.8; and in 1962, it has declined to 2.5.

How much can people attempt to twist the truth? Is it not, in fact, evident, even from his own figures, without his observations, that the gross national product at constant market prices is annually increasing?

Comment on this

And the trend is decreasing.

Comment on this

And the trend is decreasing? I think that this is an excellent example of Fine Gael thinking. In 1959, the increase over the previous year was 4.9 per cent. In 1960, it was 5.9 per cent over the previous year, plus the 4.9. Coming back to last year, 1962, the increase was 2.5 over all these percentages "plus," from 1959 onwards. So much for that.

I did mention Deputy Sweetman's pep talk to Deputy Rooney and others and the play that has been made on this alleged retrospective punitive legislation in the corporation profits tax. Fine Gael speakers have mentioned the word "unconstitutional": that the tax was most unjust; the like of it has never happened before. It does not make sense to think that a Minister would propose in this House an unconstitutional measure whereby the Revenue Commissioners would be empowered to go back over a period of 12 months or more—I think to 1st January, 1962. Does every man, woman and child not know that if you or I pay income tax, it is assessed on what has been earned over the previous 12 months, and longer in some cases? This is another example of the misrepresentation of which I speak.

These little interesting observations and asides of mine will, I think, show what we have to put up with. The serious point is that if the Fine Gael Party themselves do not understand this Budget and have not gone to the trouble of reading it——

Comment on this

The Minister does not understand it.

Comment on this

Well, they do not understand it and it is very serious to allow them to make speeches directed towards the unfortunate people of the country, particularly the small shopkeepers——

Comment on this

You did not say one thing about the Budget.

Comment on this

——to upset them and to suggest to them that it is the end of their source of livelihood. That is not fair; it is not reasonable. It is ridiculous to suggest that it will be like the Bovine Tuberculosis Eradication Scheme or the warble fly inspectors and that you will have a horde of inspectors visiting every shop in the country. That is not correct.

Comment on this

Can the Parliamentary Secretary say how many would be visiting the shops?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary will tell the Deputy this much. This is the most economic and simplest form of tax that could be, and has ever been, collected. What is more, to answer Deputy Harte's question, it may well be that no inspector at all might call or need call.

Comment on this

Is that a guarantee?

Comment on this

I am giving you the guarantee of what I say here now to be true. It may well be——

Comment on this

Ah—"may well be".

Comment on this

I did not change my phraseology.

Comment on this

You twisted it.

Comment on this

I did not twist it.

Comment on this

You can do the Madison next.

Comment on this

I know who can twist and he is on that side of the House. It may well be that there are businesses where no inspector might ever call.

Comment on this

"May well be"—"might".

Comment on this

There might be no inspector. It is so simple. Take the small shopkeeper. He adds up what he takes in cash and, at the end of the month, if he takes in £100 turnover, this is what he does. He fills up a line, one line, and he posts it off to the Revenue Commissioners with 17/6d.

Comment on this

Does the Parliamentary Secretary really mean that it is as simple as that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And where does the small shopkeeper get the money to recoup himself for writing the line?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy accept that it is as simple as that?

Comment on this

I do not know, but you cannot get over the second leg of it.

Comment on this

I am stressing the fact that these are unjustifiable and unreasonable Fine Gael calculations which have upset everyone, including the small shopkeepers. I am telling you what the facts are. There will be no hordes of inspectors; there will be no hounding by inspectors. The inspector will appear only if it is suspected that anyone is acting "hooky". Surely Deputy Harte or any other Deputy would not condone some people getting away with tax evasion and others not. That is the only time you will have inspectors appearing on the horizon. It could well be that you could go through your business for many months, if not for a year or more, before you would see one of them. I am glad I am making an impression on Deputies.

Comment on this

You are not—you overestimate yourself.

Comment on this

As an entertainer, you are.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman has given a pep talk on the Budget.

Comment on this

You would want one and a couple of pep pills, too.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy Rooney when coming in here is told he will deal with such and such a point but he has to deal with everything. I am told that Deputy O'Donnell will deal with housing——

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary will let me, I will repeat it now.

Comment on this

What?

Comment on this

What I said to my Party.

Comment on this

In a few minutes, you can say it. There has been so much misrepresentation over the past weeks about this it has evidently caused such a furore among Fine Gael Deputies that it is as well that we should look at this in a dispassionate manner and understand the simplicity of the proposition and the ease of collecting the tax. There will be no hounding of individuals, no inspectors breathing down their necks, and mark you, there will be no detailed forms, no complicated forms, to be filled in.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Will the computer do it?

Comment on this

It will do a lot of the work.

Comment on this

How many extra inspectors did PAYE bring in? Two thousand. Is that not a fact? You cannot deny it?—2,000 with their staffs.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy not be talking?

Comment on this

I am talking of what is on the record of this House and you cannot deny it. You would like to deny it.

Comment on this

You are about 1,000 out.

Comment on this

No, and we will rub your nose in that.

Comment on this

You will not.

Comment on this

We will rub your nose in it.

Comment on this

I will not take any impudence from you.

Comment on this

You are only a Deputy here.

Comment on this

Another source of misrepresentation is in the speeches made, in the provincial papers in particular detail, by Fine Gael supporters about the order—perhaps stricture as Deputy Sweetman would suggest—to the banks to disclose information. The Deputy was appalled by this, as his followers suggested they were, but remember where the recommendation came from. Do not forget either who set up the Commission.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Parliamentary Secretary would do me the honour of reading my remarks on this on the Vote on Account this year.

Comment on this

I read them. I was on this question of the edict or the fact that the Government proposed to take the necessary measures to ascertain certain facts about deposits in banks. Perhaps you will allow me to recall that in his Budget Statement the Minister said that this section was to be included in the Finance Bill following this recommendation by the Income Tax Commission which would require banks and other financial institutions to make returns in relation to deposits held by Irish residents. The return, except for current account, will be one in respect of interest accruing rather than amounts on deposit—and these are the important words—and will be sought only where interest exceeds £15 a year. At one per cent, that would require £1,500 to be deposited.

Comment on this

I must congratulate the Parliamentary Secretary on his arithmetic.

Comment on this

Thank you. Surely that is not unreasonable. I myself can see let-out clauses and I have no doubt the Revenue Commissioners will tighten up on those let-out clauses. Again in equity, in the approach to equity, if you like, in which this Government framed their Budget, why should any section of the community get away with anything which the rest of us would not? In actual fact, what is this so-called mandate to the banks but a reasonable inquiry in certain circumstances?

Comment on this

I wonder would the Parliamentary Secretary mind if I intervened for a second? You were in the chair, Sir, when the incident happened and before you leave, I should like to say that the Parliamentary Secretary alleged at one stage that I misrepresented the Minister about the tax being levied on newspapers. May I be permitted to get the reference for the Minister and the Parliamentary Secretary? I am sorry that the Minister has gone. I quote column 191 of Volume 2022:

Mr. Barrett: I was wondering, if this tax is to apply to the sale of newspapers on street corners, how it is to be levied?

and at column 192, the Minister said:

There are certain difficulties. Deputy Barrett raised the question of the newspaper boy. He gets his newspapers from the newspaper office and whatever they charge him, he knows what to charge his customers. That does not concern us.

The Parliamentary Secretary said it was not true for me to say in the House what I said in respect to newspapers: that this was going to be levied and that the Minister said it did not concern the Government how it would be levied. I think the Parliamentary Secretary might at this stage apologise for his misrepresentation. At column 191, my question was:

I was wondering, if this tax is to apply to the sale of newspapers on street corners, how it is to be levied.

and at column 192, the Minister said:

"Yes, it is to be levied but it does not concern us how.

Comment on this

I do not see why I should apologise. I do not see in fact that my statement is incorrect but in the light of what the Deputy has read—I would hesitate to suggest that he is generally in the right—I would tender my apology if my interpretation was not correct.

Comment on this

And the Minister said he did not say it.

Comment on this

To be fair to the Minister, the quotation now read to the House by Deputy Barrett is entirely different from the allegation I respectfully submit, made in his reference to the Minister.

Comment on this

Not according to my recollection.

Comment on this

I exactly stated it as in the report.

Comment on this

I understand that Deputy Sweetman with an eye on Dublin North-East, will go so far as to inform the House and the public as to what Fine Gael would do, were they in our position, with regard to the method of taxation. That will be a very interesting proposition to listen to. I sincerely trust that he will give us that indication. It is natural and reasonable to criticise this Budget constructively and if you wish, destructively. We have no objection to that. We criticised when we were on those benches. But surely we could ask, and I even appeal to the Deputy and members of the Fine Gael Party to let us know, if in fact Fine Gael have any policy. We know that they have no policy with regard to industry. With regard to agriculture, the only thing talked from one end of Ireland to the other is the £1,000 which Deputy MacEoin spoke about the other day—the £1,000 interest-free loan to the farmer. That is the be-all and end-all of the Fine Gael agricultural policy.

Comment on this

No, no. You do not begrudge that to the farmer, surely?

Comment on this

Someone has to pay for that interest-free loan. Would the corollary not be that housing should be interest-free also because it is an important social adjunct? Why not extend the proposition generally? When they hold up this bait of a £1,000 interest-free loan, where would the money come from, how is it to be funded, who is to pay for it?

As I said, schools, drainage, agriculture, housing, industrial developments —all these require further capital and further assistance to make a major impact on the economy. If Fine Gael have no faith in the future of Ireland, then all the good works we contemplate are wasted as far as they are concerned.

Comment on this

Faith without good works will not work. You will not provide the work.

Comment on this

Deputy Coogan should have faith in his politics as well as in his Bible.

Comment on this

You would want to learn both.

Comment on this

I try to learn and I have to learn a little every day. I sincerely trust that the Fine Gael backbenchers, many of whom are reasonable men, now understand the misrepresentations of the campaign which has been waged. I did not go into the question of housing in detail, or the misrepresentations under the first Coalition. We are looking to the future and trying to learn from the wisdom of age, to be cheered by the sallies of youth. A publication brought out by the first Coalition Ireland is Building, spoke about the men Ireland needs and the wages she pays in industry, and it called on them “to come back to Erin.” They were gone again in four months when everything closed down.

We should also see if we could raise the tenor of these debates in the Dáil. The young people growing up nowadays are anxious to hear constructive speeches.

Comment on this

Why do you not talk about the Budget, instead of this ráiméis?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Coogan should allow the Parliamentary Secretary to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The Deputy can make his own brilliant contribution in due course. I sincerely trust that in future the debates in this House will reach a higher standard and that we will not spend our time in recriminations about what happened at such and such a time. It is a difficult thing for supporters of the Government to carry that policy into full effect when the main Opposition Party will not contribute in any way to anything of a forward-looking proposition. All the time we have this wailing, and that is one of the reasons why Fine Gael can never in the foreseeable future attain the position of being a oneparty Government.

I should like in conclusion to refer to the reference made by the Leader of the Opposition to the Minister for Finance in a most hurtful manner. Perhaps it read a lot worse than it sounded. I do not know whether this suggestion that this is the Minister's last Budget is true or not. I have no knowledge of these things, but I do know this—there was no better Minister for Finance in the history of this State since it was founded.

Comment on this

That shows all you know.

Comment on this

I had admiration for Deputy Sweetman when he was Minister for Finance for lots of reasons, and so had others on my side of the House. We had our criticisms of him, too. Having had personal experience, I know of no finer Minister or member of this House than the present holder of the post of Minister for Finance, Deputy Dr. Ryan. I have no inside information on these things, but I do know that it will be a sad day for Ireland should he go, whenever he goes. I wonder whether the young people coming up nowadays, like some of us even on this side of the House, will be able to discharge, or even come near discharging the responsibilities which these men who have gone before us carried.

I want to pay that tribute to a man without whose efforts, and the efforts of others here present, the Tricolour would not be flying so proudly over our public buildings.

Comment on this

Only for Collins.

Comment on this

In conclusion, I sincerely trust that Deputy Sweetman in his contribution will try to deal in a factual way with the points so much misrepresented by his followers.

Comment on this

I have heard Deputy O'Malley speaking as Deputy O'Malley and as Parliamentary Secretary making some good convincing speeches, but never on all the occasions I have heard him speak in this House did I hear him so unhappy, so obviously distressed and so obviously unconvinced of the truth of what he was trying to say. In fact, I could not help feeling very sorry indeed for him, in having, out of loyalty to his Minister, to get up and make a speech defending something he knew was quite indefensible. I will say this, however, for it—it was much more pleasant to listen to than the other speech from his side of the House we heard earlier to-day, when the gentleman, who, I think, is chairman of the Party, seemed to imagine that noise was a substitute for intelligence. At least, the Parliamentary Secretary spoke in restrained and dulcet tones, because that was really all that was pleasing about his speech.

This Budget and, indeed, any Budget should be judged on whether it is going to promote economic growth, whether it is going to provide an opportunity for our people to obtain a permanently better standard of living. That is not merely the test on which this Budget should be judged; it is the test on which any Budget should be judged. On that test, no matter how it is applied, this Budget will be found to be defective. It is a bad Budget, a Budget that does not take proper account of the needs of the time, of our economic position. It is a Budget that does not, in the incidence of its taxation, provide for a fair and just distribution, a Budget that does not in the manner in which it was presented make for that certainty which is obviously one of the requisites for economic growth and progress. It is not going to achieve progress but rather to retard it.

I want to state categorically and, in case the Parliamentary Secretary might misunderstand it, I want to say that this is a political observation, that no Minister for Finance has ever introduced a Budget in this House and shown at the end of that Budget how little the implications and effects of his proposals are really understood. It is extraordinary that, at the end of the Budget, the Minister was able in so small a degree to explain the implications of the proposals he had just announced.

I want to be perfectly clear in stating that we regard this Budget as a bad Budget, not designed at all to meet the needs of the moment. Furthermore, speaking on behalf of Fine Gael and speaking with some responsibility and a little experience in these matters, I would say that this is a Budget we would ask the people to reject and we would ask the Government to give the people an opportunity to reject, in an immediate general election. We ask the people in Dublin North-East to give strength to that call for a general election by their vote in the by-election and we believe that if there were a general election at the moment, the effect of it would be to remove Fianna Fáil from office and to give to Fine Gael the task of forming a Government.

If the people are given the opportunity of having that general election now and if we are given from that general election the task of forming a Government before this Budget goes to its full implementation on 1st November, I want to say clearly on behalf of Fine Gael that we will introduce a different type of Budget, that we will not adopt the Budget introduced by the Minister for Finance on behalf of Fianna Fáil. I am saying that with full deliberation and with complete knowledge of what might be involved, with full appreciation of the difficulties there might be in the introduction of a different Budget in which will not be included retrospective taxation, a Budget which will not include the turnover tax announced by the Minister for Finance to come into operation on 1st November next.

I will come to the reasons why we make that declaration later on but I want it to be clear that I am saying that, with the knowledge I have, another Budget can be brought forward by us if we are given the opportunity now of doing so. It would be a Budget that would provide assistance for our economic growth, one that would ensure that the primary and fundamental principles of taxation were observed, that whatever has to be raised will be taken fairly and evenly from all sections of the people. I am asking, on behalf of Fine Gael, that the people be given the opportunity to judge now and if they are given that opportunity, we will abide by their judgment. If they give us that task, we will carry it out in that way for the reasons I am going to indicate now.

Any Budget should be judged, not on whether it is soft or tough, not on whether it is bad or good in the ordinary popular sense but on whether it is bad or good in the sense of whether it is going to promote economic growth and improve permanently the standard of living of our people. Everybody in this House, every member of Fianna Fáil, every member of Fine Gael and everybody else, would like to increase at once to the maximum degree the amount of assistance that can be given to the weaker sections of the community; but the only reason anybody stands back from immediately doing that, be it Dr. Ryan or anybody else, is that he knows that if more is done at any particular time than the country's economic growth can stand, the effect is not going to be to improve the lot of the weaker sections of the community but rather to ensure that the weaker sections, instead of benefiting, will suffer.

I want to make it clear, having regard to some of the things I heard earlier to-day, that I do not consider that anxiety to promote the welfare of the weaker sections of the community as the prerogative of any one Party in this House. We are all anxious to do it but the various Parties differ as to the way in which it can be done. The aims of most of the Parties are exactly the same but the policies by which those aims may be achieved differ and it is the difference in policy that makes the difference between Parties, not the difference in aims. We all have the same aim, to endeavour to ensure that we will permanently improve the lot of all our people here. When we turn to what occurred in 1962, we must therefore consider it against that background. The first thing in relation to the year 1962 we must look at is the outturn of the current Budget introduced by the Minister last year, an outturn that showed he had a deficit of just under £5 million, a deficit that means that everyone in the country must contribute towards paying for the next 20 years an annual sum of about £240,000 to make it up. Clearly, the Minister was right in assuming that he could not continue with an increased deficit this year. The Taoiseach spoke about deficit financing but the fact is that Budgets have been brought in on a deficit basis in Ireland for the past ten or 12 years, if one considers the method of computation adopted in England.

That is not the point at issue here; it is whether the Minister was wrong last year in having that deficit. He was. It arose not because of failure in revenue, as revenue on the whole was more buoyant last year than he expected, but because he failed to control expenditure last year. It is a fact—an unpleasant one, perhaps, for those interested in the office of Minister for Finance—that it is the task of the Minister to control expenditure to ensure that it stays within the capacity of the nation's purse. The Minister failed last year in that respect. The buoyancy in revenue this year provided, in the ordinary course of events according to the estimates made by the Revenue Commissioners, without the Minister doing anything about it, sufficient, and more than sufficient, to make up that deficit, but it would be in certain circumstances permissible to increase a deficit. In certain other circumstances, a deficit should be wiped out and, indeed, some of what is now used as below-the-line expenditure, be it for capital services or otherwise, should be taken in. This year, it is perfectly clear, in view of the balance of payments position, that the Minister should not look to the Budget for a continuance of the miscalculation he made last year.

National production last year showed a decelerating trend of increase. It showed that the impetus that had been created in earlier years was tapering off and wearing out. Gross national product at constant prices was not showing anything like the increase that earlier years promised. The table included at No. 12 (b) of the Pink Book showed an indication that the curve of economic growth was flattening and that it was not rising as we would all wish. The trade figures we have seen, as indicated by the Minister himself in his Budget speech, show a serious deficit on our balance of trade, offset to some extent by invisible exports but at the same time—and this is the serious point about it—a trend of an adverse balance of payments that is steadily rising quarter by quarter.

If one takes the 12 months up to March 1962, the 12 months to June, 1962, to September 1962 and so on, all the way along in each quarter, we find that the balance of trade figures are steadily rising against us. Nobody minds a short hump of an adverse balance of trade. Even of the order that existed in the last calendar year, it would not make the slightest difference if it were clear that it was a temporary hump but the serious feature of it is that it is rising quarter by quarter. If you take the 12 months to March 1962, the adverse balance of trade was £82 million; to June 1962, it was £85 million; to September it was £90 million; to December, it was £99 million and to March 1963, it was £102.3 million. When you have an ascending adverse balance of that sort, coupled with decending exports, it is clear that a Budget is called for which will help to rectify that position. I see little evidence of that in the Minister's Budget.

We had an increased national income last year also and the Statistics Office itself says the greater part of the increase was due to a change in money values. We know, as the Parliamentary Secretary said a few minutes ago, there is no use in increasing money incomes if they cannot buy more and yet in relation to the Minister's national housekeeping last year, the Central Statistics Office says that the greater part of the increase is due to changes in money values.

For the first time this year, we had a separate publication by the Minister in relation to the capital Budget. I am, and always was, sorry that the Minister was constrained by political difficulties to do in 1957 what I had announced I would do, that is, introduce to the House the capital Budget at a different time from the current Budget. It is natural and inevitable that if you introduce the capital and current Budgets together, people will give more thought and attention to the current Budget and the capital Budget proposals tend to be overwhelmed and not to receive the publicity they should get. Publication of the booklet Capital Budget, 1963 this year goes part of the way towards what was suggested. I welcome that advance but I am sorry we are not going the whole way so that we could have a discussion on the capital Budget alone, unhindered by considerations of current budgetary problems.

I made it clear long ago, speaking authoritatively on behalf of this Party, that we believe that the proper basis for a capital Budget is that it should be the highest possible productive capital Budget that the country and the people could support. My quarrel with the Minister for Finance in relation to his capital Budget provisions, not merely this year but over the past years, is not on the amounts, although I think he made a grave error in 1957-58 and 1958-59 in unduly depressing the capital Budget figures of those years below the amounts I had indicated were going to be put forward. My quarrel with him is not about the amounts of the capital Budget but about the fact that it is apparent from the figures with which we are faced this year that the capital Budget has over the years not been expended in such a way as to produce an adequate return, either direct or indirect.

Only a Government are in the position of having the confidential information, having the confidential assessments before them, of various capital requirements, capital schemes. An Opposition cannot, of necessity, know many of the confidential matters that are known to the Government and to the Ministers concerned about the proposals made in relation to the expenditure of substantial sums of capital. We had an example of that recently in connection with the fertiliser factory. The Minister for Industry and Commerce came in here and told the House that he had information on which he was able to assess the value of the scheme but that the information was confidential and could not be given. Ministers came in here before in relation to the guarantee to be given of State money, taxpayers' money, to the Avoca mines. They said that they had confidential trade information that they could not give to the public at large or to the House. They had to accept the Ministers' judgment. An Opposition, no matter how much it may dislike it, in the absence of that confidential information, cannot always arrive at the position of being able to examine as it would wish proposals for the expenditure of substantial capital sums.

I am certain, for example, that if one had available all the information I have now in relation to the expenditure of vast sums in Dundalk, at the time the money was being voted, we would have raised very arched eyebrows about the foolhardiness of going so inefficiently about the job of trying to protect and preserve the employment of the people in the Great Northern Railway Works in Dundalk. It was right that steps should be taken to try to do everything possible to protect their employment but we know now that what happened was that it was not protected, that instead, a great deal of money was lost that should have been put to proper productive use. It is examples like that, and the failure of the Minister to put the money to productive use, that have made his capital Budgets over the years fail to provide the buoyancy and the direct returns that could be shown in this year's account, and so avoid some of the problems with which he is faced.

The Minister in his Financial Statement naturally and properly went on to talk about employment, unemployment and emigration. In the few remarks I am going to make, I am quite deliberately following the pattern of the various sectors of the economy that he took in his Financial Statement, doing it in that way for his convenience, so that he will have an opportunity of dealing with it and of assessing my comments against his own.

In relation to employment, we have a situation which is difficult to understand, a situation described not, I hasten to remind the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, by Fine Gael propagandists, but by the Central Statistics Office when they said that there has been a gradual but cumulative over-estimation of the total number of persons at work throughout the intercensal period. "Gradual and cumulative over-estimation of the number of persons at work." Yet, when we study what is published in these Tables in regard to employment, we find that the numbers engaged in all transportable goods, industries in 1962 went up by only 3,600, that the number of males engaged in farmwork, as permanent paid employees, came down by 3,500 and, in relation to temporary employment, came down by 1,700.

What do those figures mean? Leaving out the number of families at work on farms, what do they mean? They mean that if you take Tables 7 and 8 together of Economic Statistics, there are declared by the Central Statistics Office of the Government to be fewer persons in paid employment in Ireland in 1962 than there were in 1961. Leaving out family labour altogether, taking purely paid labour on the land, on the one hand, and in transportable goods industries, on the other, the figures show that the number in transportable goods industries is up by 3,600 and the number of permanent agricultural employees is down by 3,500—a difference of 100 in permanent employees and, as I have said, there are 1,700 fewer paid temporary employees on the land.

We all know in relation to farm labour that wherever you go, to whatever county you go in Ireland, there were fewer people at work on the land last year than there were the year before and the year before that and the year before that again. The Taoiseach has made the point here again and again, in an effort to explain away these figures, that he does not consider the criterion of family labour worth considering. We do. But, even without going into that at all, there were fewer paid employees in agriculture in 1962 as compared with 1961, on the one hand, and transportable goods industries, on the other.

Again, if we turn to the booklet Economic Statistics, we find that agricultural output is virtually steady— no increase—and that the increase on the industrial front is on a decelerating scale. It is natural therefore—I hope to take other opportunities of reminding the Taoiseach of this—that we should feel, and the country should feel, that this is a far cry from the 100,000 jobs promised in Clery's Restaurant in November, 1955. The people were told at that time that this was a coherent plan and scheme, that there was nothing airy-fairy about it, that there would be so many jobs the first year, so many jobs the second year and so many jobs the third year. They were to be divided out. So we were told in that famous, or should I say, infamous, speech made in Clery's Restaurant for the purpose of duping the electorate at that time. When I heard the Taoiseach speaking the other day of a new plan, I wondered how many of the promises in that new plan would go the way of the promises made in Clery's Restaurant some seven and a half or eight years ago.

I will not go through the list of increases in prices. The Minister himself in his Budget Statement admitted and acknowledged that consumer prices were up last year. By the look of them this year, from what we see in the Economic Survey published by the Institute, there is a prospect now of their increasing still further. I shall not tantalise the Minister because it does apparently tantalise Fianna Fáil to be told about the cost of living and the increase in the price of individual items, but the fact is that, however much it may tantalise the Minister here, it tantalises the housewife far more when she goes into the shops to buy that which she has to buy.

As I said, agricultural output is virtually static; in fact, net output this year is shown in Table 6 to be slightly down on last year. Is it not a strange commentary on the boasts that this Government have made as to the efficacy of the way in which they have helped agriculture so much that net output in 1962 was less than in 1961? It is no use taking gross output because we want to ensure that the land is farmed and not mined. Net output shows that.

Let us hark back now to economic development and to the basis of economic development in relation to agriculture. It was stated that we must take proper and adequate steps to ensure that we would increase our cattle population. The objective of policy, it was stated, and this was repeated in the Government's policy statement, would be to increase cow numbers progressively to at least 1,500,000 by 1964. If that were the objective of policy, is it not pretty obvious now in 1963 that that policy has completely failed and that the Minister and his Government have been failures in getting anywhere near that objective? Is that not one of the reasons why we have a static net agricultural output?

The Government have completely failed to provide the 50,000 a year extra breeding stock they set out as the foundation of a proper agricultural policy. It is no good saying that the reason for the failure is the necessity for implementing the scheme for the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. They knew the bovine tuberculosis scheme had to be put into effect at the time they were setting out this objective and telling us their policy was going to achieve that result. The fact is, of course, that it did not achieve it and I cannot see anything in this Budget designed to improve our chances now of reaching that objective by this time next year.

If we read the figures sent out by the Economic Institute, we find that to-day, in this year of 1963, there will be a reduction of some two per cent as compared with last year in industrial exports. I freely admit that it is quite impossible to be accurate at this time of the year to within one or two per cent, but the fact is that our imports are increasing and the balance of trade is rising steadily against us. We know, therefore, that if we are to have at best a static figure for exports, the effect will be far from encouraging on our whole balance of payments position. The latest estimate—it is, of course, only an estimate—is for a six per cent increase in home production. If there is a decrease of two per cent in exports, not merely have we got to have that two per cent decrease in exports wiped out but we have got to ensure a substantial increase in industrial exports this year if we are to be able to meet, and survive, the increasing imports month after month.

I see no sign whatever in this Budget of anything that will help to promote the growth of exports to meet that situation. In fact, I think it is true to say that this Government have done nothing in relation to exports other than to increase the incentive that we provided for exports in 1956. We were suffering then and we are suffering now—and only gradually getting over it—from the effect of the Lemass policy of the thirties, which was to concentrate public attention on trying to build an island wall and trying to ensure that we would not be an outward-looking people in relation to our production but an inward-looking one. Naturally, the difficulty of changing people's outlook on that is one that took and is taking a considerable time to overcome, but it is true to say that it was the Lemass inward-looking view, so often expressed all through those years in the thirties, that was responsible for the export troubles in which we have found ourselves in the post-war era.

If we are adequately and permanently to increase our standard of living, we must increase our exports substantially. We must do it on both the agricultural and the industrial fronts. Industry needs more help than mere financing. While we want to get the technical know-how as far as we possibly can from people outside the country, at the same time, we want to get psychologically the belief among our own people that they will have every bit as good a chance of improving their production as the foreigner coming in. There is undoubtedly abroad at present the feeling that if you want to get assistance towards the expansion of an industry, you have a better chance of getting it if you are a foreigner. That must be killed. We must go on making it clear again and again to our own people that it is on them the results depend and that though we want to get all the technical know-how and skill we can from people outside, we shall provide for our own factory owners and workers, for our own businesses, the means and the ability adequately to expand and to modernise.

Does this Budget do that? On the contrary, this is one of the three aspects in relation in which I venture to say this Budget will be known as the rob-the-till Budget. The only way existing industry can modernise and expand is out of the profits it earns. It must do that and the imposition of this retrospective corporation profits tax is a blow at modernisation, at productivity and at increased employment. It is easy for people like Deputy Nicholas Egan to say that it is taking something from rich profits. If it were desirable and necessary to tax profits, there was a proper way to do it, but this does not hit the profits that are being taken out of industry. It hits the profits that are being left in industry for the purpose of creating greater employment in future.

It would have been a perfectly simple matter for the Minister to provide a type of tax, differentiating, on the one hand, between profits distributed and taken out for spending and, on the other, profits retained in business and ploughed back for the purpose of modernisation. Corporation profits tax does not do that. Corporation profits tax strikes at the root of the funds necessary and available for expansion of employment, for increased productivity, for bettering the standards of the workers working on these machines, for the provision of a better chance of competitive export. Modernisation and productivity could bring down prices. Far from this Budget doing anything to assist industry in that respect, it has done exactly the reverse. It has hit it a body blow which will be felt not by the people who are drawing their profits out of industry but by the whole community because the hope of the increased employment, increased production, increased productivity and increased modernisation that those moneys could have provided is now gone as the result of this stipulation by the Minister.

Other improvements could be made in relation to the assistance necessary for industry to increase exports. Technical assistance grants, by their nature, are limited and though I believe that a development bank, such as operates in other countries for industry, should be operated by private hands, it should be assisted and promoted by the State. A development bank, which has been a great success in other countries, would assist in the provision of finance, as the Industrial Credit Company does and, I think, does adequately—if we can get over the feeling our own people have that it is only for foreigners, with which I do not agree —and could have governmental financial support. There could be some form of subsidy to the development bank which could provide the technical advisory functions utilised in other countries and could operate a wider type of technical assistance scheme. That would be a worthwhile scheme.

Training of management personnel is something that has been tackled by the Management Institute but it must be tackled in a much wider sphere, if we are to get that outward and forward-looking approach to our industrial export problems. Again, I see no sign of any such constructive proposition. I think I am right in saying that the World Bank provides special facilities for that type of exchange cost of consultant. I wonder whether it would be possible to stimulate here something of the American concept of the independent consulting engineer, which has broadened during the past two decades or so into the management-cum-engineering consultant firms, and have it accepted on a wide basis throughout the country. We must show some imagination and some belief in the practical manner in which we can assist those in industry and those in agriculture to meet the problems with which they are faced.

The survey given by the Minister of the economic position failed to indicate any positive increased constructive approach. It failed to indicate any positive increased hope of substantial growth. The Taoiseach, when he spoke on the Budget of veering to the left, was, I think, only playing with a political catchcry. Nobody could suggest that he gave any concrete evidence of what he had in his mind except another fake Clery's employment plan.

Against that picture and pattern, what has the Minister done in this Budget? He found, and I agree with him, that tobacco was unlikely to provide substantial additional tax revenue, that the consumption of tobacco in pounds weight was down on that of the year before. Spirits, as the result of the blow he dealt it last year, was not merely down on home consumption but the base for exports was also down. He said he could not turn to these as the two main normal sources of indirect taxation. However, he did, all the same, turn to them and included them in his other proposals. The tax he announced and with which I shall deal later was in fact the equivalent of 1d. on the packet of cigarettes and 1d. on the glass of whiskey, though he said himself he did not think they would take it. It looks at least possible, therefore, that the effect of his imposition in that respect may slow down and may harm the goose that has laid the golden egg.

The Minister started off, when looking for his money, by taking balance out of revenue. Surely the Minister for Finance will not seriously tell the House that to balance this year's Budget by taking £2 million from the revenue balances is an honest transaction when he had a Budget deficit of £4,857,000? He must have known in March whether he would safely be able to do without that revenue balance. If he is able safely to do without it—he is or he is not—he must have know in March; nothing has happened since. PAYE is providing the flow of revenue to which he refers. He must have known in March he would impose one or other type of sales tax which in the future would provide an even flow.

If the Minister knew and thought then—and he should have known then, if he thought about the matter—that that £2 million revenue balance was not required, the honest thing to do with it was to pay it into the Exchequer account before 31st March so as to reduce last year's deficit by £2 million. Instead, what he did was to take it out. It is what I would term a fake accounting transaction for this year— robbing the till. I am not the person who coined that phrase in this respect. The person who coined the phrase "robbing the till" is no less a person than the Tánaiste. When the suggestion was made that the revenue balances need not be kept quite so high —not that they should all be taken away but that they need not be kept quite so high—he said that would be robbing the till.

The Minister for Finance is already robbing the till in the corporation profits tax of the money that would be there for modernisation and increased employment. He is now robbing the till in relation to this revenue balance. Further, on his own saying in relation to the turnover tax, he will rob the till of every shopkeeper in Ireland, if he does not want them to pass on the tax that is being imposed. These are three ways in which I think this Budget will become known as the "Rob the Till Budget".

Naturally enough, there have been a great many different viewpoints on the manner of operation of this so-called turnover tax. I use the words "so-called turnover tax" quite deliberately. This is not a turnover tax as known by any economist, nor is it a turnover tax as known by the Fianna Fáil Government themselves. For the purpose of pulling a trick of the loop on the people, they have changed the name. This is a retail sales tax. Lest anyone should wonder why I think so, I would refer them to the Government White Paper on Direct Taxation published on 19th April, 1961. In Chapter III there, they deal with the turnover tax proper; with the value added tax; with a retail tax, a manufacturers' tax, a wholesale tax and a purchase tax.

The Minister for Finance, when explaining on Budget Day what this is, made clear that this is a tax which will operate exactly as the tax operates in Norway and in Sweden. I cannot remember whether or not he mentioned America. However, he said it works successfully in Norway and Sweden and that the tax he was proposing was exactly the same tax as was in operation in Norway and Sweden. Here is what the Government said, two years ago:

The retail tax; this is a single-stage tax levied at the retail level.

It is widely used as a source of state (as distinct from federal) revenue in the USA and as a local tax in the Canadian provinces. It was employed in Sweden in the period 1940-48 and was re-introduced there recently. It is also in use in Norway.

I want the Minister for Finance to tell the country simply, quietly and categorically why he changed the name of the tax he has now introduced from the name he gave it in the Government White Paper published in April, 1961.

A turnover tax is a multistage tax. The French system to which, I think, the Minister also referred, is not a retail sales tax of this sort. It is turnover tax and the value is added back by each retailer and by each wholesaler as the goods pass through the chain of distribution. The French system is a tax on the amount the particular person in the chain and industry believes should be added back before he passes on his goods to the next stage in the distributive chain. That is generally accepted as being a type of turnover tax and indeed the White Paper in paragraph 34 refers to the turnover tax as a general cumulative tax or multistage tax applying to sales in all stages in productive and distribution channels covering all goods and services.

I want to know what good and valid reason the Minister can give for changing the name, other than that he was trying to cod the people as to the manner in which this tax is to work. I want to ask him in what other countries specifically is this type of tax operated as he intends it to operate in Ireland. Let me say at once that I agree with him on one thing and one thing only: a single stage tax is preferable to a multistage tax. I want to ask why it is that he announced in his Budget Statement and in relation to the Resolutions passed on that day, that it was going to be possible to take out of the orbit or ambit of this tax certain raw materials but not possible to take out necessaries of life like bread, butter, flour, tea or sugar. Perhaps I was wrong and that he intended to tax fertilisers, for example, for the farmers, but he indicated that he did not want to tax raw materials. If a hardware shop in the country has a grocery in one section, hardware in another and sells fertilisers to the farmers in a third section, why will it be possible to extricate from the turnover of that shop the money that comes into the till for fertilisers, while it will not be possible to extricate and take out of the ambit of the tax the money paid for bread and other necessaries of life? What can be done for one could be done for the other.

It seems to me quite indefensible that any Minister for Finance should impose a tax on every type of retail sale which meant that the same rate of tax was paid on the necessaries of life as on the luxuries of life. No Minister for Finance likes imposing taxation. I do not believe that even Dr. Ryan as Minister for Finance likes it, although I think this has been imposed this year for a particular purpose to which I will advert in a minute. No Minister likes imposing taxation. I did not like having to do it. I did not like having to do it in 1956 for the purpose of getting a more solid framework on which it would be possible to get economic growth, but when I did do it, I made very sure that I placed a higher tax on luxuries than on necessaries. I made very sure that the ordinary necessaries of life were not taxed at the same rate as luxuries which people could, if necessary, do without.

The fundamental objection to this tax is that it imposes exactly the same rate on the loaf of bread as on the fur coat, to take two extremes of the scale. It imposes exactly the same rate of tax on food of all necessary descriptions as it does on food of exotic descriptions. It imposes exactly the same rate of tax on necessary articles of clothing as it does on those that may be pleasant for those who have sufficient income to buy them but which are definitely luxuries and not part of the necessaries of everyday life.

That infringes the cardinal principle of taxation that taxation must bear fairly on those who must pay it. This tax does not and it is primarily because of that that I made it very clear in the beginning that if the Government now give the people the opportunity they want to test this Budget by a general election, we will ask the people for a mandate to enable Fine Gael to form a Government, in the knowledge that we will bring in a different type of Budget, a Budget designed to meet the economic needs of the moment and to ensure that this type of tax hitting the necessaries of life just as hard as the luxuries will not come into force next November. That will give a better chance and opportunity for those in agriculture and those in industry not merely of increasing production but of increasing the exports we must have if the country is to survive.

Comment on this

Like most Deputies, I have listened to the various speeches and I think the most amusing speech I have listened to from the Opposition was the speech delivered by Deputy Sweetman who has projected Fine Gael policy for the by-election in the hope that the result would induce a general election. During his remarks, I could not help thinking how foolish his speech was, when one related it to Deputy Sweetman's performance when he had the opportunity of trying to form a Government during certain periods in the past ten years. The general mishandling of the financial situation produced a crisis in 1956 which the Fianna Fáil Government had to redress.

I was also amused at his crocodile tears for the social welfare classes. From my younger days, I can well remember that the Party of which he is a member reduced the old age pensioners by a shilling a week. He consistently complains of the inadequacy of the social welfare allowances. We all agree that they are inadequate, but the policy the Fianna Fáil Government have pursued during the past six years and in the previous 15 or 20 years has produced conditions which have bettered the position of the social welfare classes.

I do not think that what Deputy Sweetman has said here tonight will convince anybody in North-East Dublin or any citizen or voter in the country. He has told the people that he proposes to introduce a Budget, provided Fine Gael get a majority. No sane person, having regard to the record of Fine Gael in the past and to the fact that they subordinated the policy they had and joined with the Labour Party, with the help of certain Independents, will attempt to return Fine Gael to office. That is my view, and I do not believe that Deputy Sweetman's speech will have any influence in Dublin North-East or anywhere else.

He has told us that Fine Gael propose to introduce a further Budget, should they by any mischance or miracle ever be returned to power, but neither he nor any other member of the Opposition has indicated in what way they will impose the taxation necessary to meet the current expenditure the Government propose for the coming year. I have listened to numerous speeches in this debate, which has been protracted deliberately because there is a by-election in North-East Dublin, and I venture to suggest that if the shadow of that by-election were not over this House, this discussion would have ended last week. Certainly it would not have dragged on interminably as it has.

I view this Budget as setting the pattern for a lean forward for further economic expansion in spite of the gloomy speeches made by Opposition speakers. It is easy to come in here and refer to figures, but my yardstick is the progress that has been made. The emigration figures have gone down and employment has gone up.

Comment on this

Emigration, you mean. You are mixing your figures.

Comment on this

In the past few weeks, the Dáil was told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that Dublin city alone was to have 28 or 30 projects from which we will get additional employment opportunities.

Comment on this

Blueprints.

Comment on this

The Budget provides further expansion of existing services. We know, for instance, that in housing, there is a problem in Dublin. Additional sums of money are earmarked for that social work. While I do not wish to go into the details of the housing position within the ambit of a debate of this nature, I do wish to refer to one aspect in it, to contradict certain statements made about the lack of employment opportunities in our country. Within recent weeks, the Dáil was told that 1,400 families returned from England to avail of employment opportunities afforded by the policy the Fianna Fáil Government pursue. Of those 1,400 families, 549 had to be housed by Dublin Corporation. On their waiting list today, included in the 4,000 urgent cases, there are 800 other families. These are realities that I am concerned with in my approach to the question of providing the additional taxation necessary to develop this country. The whole basis of the Budget is to protect, to continue and to expand activities, whether at Governmental level or at the level of private enterprise.

Reference has been made to the agricultural industry. As a Dublin Deputy I have an appreciation of the agricultural industry's problems. I know that it represents 30 per cent of the livelihood of our people. I am glad to see that in this Budget there are further aids to agriculture, and further help to get rid of that scourge which has plagued that industry for so many years in the bovine tuberculosis eradication scheme. That particular industry will benefit when that scheme has reached finality.

I have referred to housing. There is that problem in Dublin, with the additional employment opportunities created. There is that problem facing even urban centres adjacent to provincial cities and towns. The development of new factories has brought an influx of people. Deputies have referred to that problem on certain Estimates. Limerick city, though efforts have been made to denigrate it by a Limerick Fine Gael Deputy, has that problem of housing, and in County Dublin, there is the same problem. New factories built in Clondalkin—the new aircraft factory and other associated services—are presenting Dublin County Council with a housing problem. All these are facts and are evidence of an upsurge in the country, despite what Opposition speakers have stated.

As the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance has said, our school building programme is going ahead. In Dublin city, we have a school building problem related to the great expansion of our suburban districts. The new housing areas that have arisen within the past four or five years require new schools, and plans are being perfected by the authorities for their building, while others have been completed. There is a real problem also facing the city in regard to vocational education. We are all of one mind in saying that this service should be expanded, and there is a demand in certain areas of this city for additional vocational education facilities. If these aims are to be achieved, additional moneys must be found.

Deputy Sweetman in his reference to the mythical or ghost Budget he proposes to bring in if Fine Gael should have the misfortune to be returned, has not told the electorate or the people of the country what taxation he is going to impose to provide for the extension of these vital services for our community. We have the road replacement schemes developed, and we know that one thing that has struck visitors and people generally in this country is the wonderful improvement in our roads. That is capable of further development, and this Budget provides for a continuation of that policy. We have a very urgent traffic problem in Dublin which can be solved only by the provision of additional money. In this Budget, generous financial assistance is provided to enable the Department of Local Government to solve the problem.

There are two matters relating to the country generally to which I wish to refer. These are the progress of the arterial drainage schemes and the provision of water supplies. These schemes are beneficial to the country but they need financial assistance from the Government and impetus from the Government Departments. Fianna Fáil have provided that assistance and that impetus and will continue to do so, despite the criticism from the benches opposite.

Reference has been made to the decline in our exports. It is true that they went down by some percentage last year, that they were not as good as the record achieved in 1961, but they were much higher than they were in previous years and far in advance of what they were when the Coalition Government were in office. The national debt was referred to by Opposition speakers. It is my view that it is reasonable that a young country such as ours should have a national debt but its existence is being offset by capital investment and by the physical assets produced by the policy of this Government.

These assets include the development of rural electrification, the operations of the sugar company and of the air services. These are physical assets which will benefit the country in the future and help to provide employment for our young people at home. There has been criticism of the method of raising the money. That is the only difference that exists between the Parties. I believe that the imposition of this new tax will not create the hardship suggested by Opposition speakers. I envisage that in a progressive country, a country building up its economy, this tax may yet result in a replacement of the outmoded tax systems we have.

I think the Minister had a difficult job in framing the Budget and he is to be congratulated on his courage in introducing it. It reflects the fact that Fianna Fáil policy is always based on realities, and that we never run away from our responsibilities. When they appreciate the implications of this Budget, the people will understand that services provided must be paid for and that money must be found from taxation for the ultimate benefit of the community at large.

Comment on this

This Budget cannot be described as anything but an amazing Budget, amazing in the fact that the Minister, when questioned about it in the House, knew nothing about the points raised. On each occasion on which he was questioned, he had to turn to the officers of his Department for his replies. One can only describe the Budget as a Budget of the bureaucrats of the Minister's Department and the Department in Dublin Castle. It is rather strange that my two colleagues, the Minister for Defence and Deputy Geoghegan, have not even offered to support it. The Minister is quoted on the records of the House as having said: "I want money". That was all there was to it.

It has been said that the new tax is only 6d. in the £ but if the Minister wants money, we are entitled to know what he wants it for. Is it for a continuation of the policy of squandermania, the policy of unemployment, of an increased cost of living and of emigration at the highest figures for years? We are entitled to ask these questions and to get replies to them, instead of all the talk we have had from Ministers in after-dinner speeches. Where is all the economic progress we have heard about? Where is the great expansion in our economy? The people are fed up. They have been led up the garden path long enough and now they are not prepared to go any further. They have turned back and the first of them to turn back are the members of the chambers of commerce who have passed a vote of no confidence in the future of the country.

There is a lack of confidence in the future. It is that lack of confidence that has brought on the CIE strike. The real cause of that strike is the insecurity of the members of the different unions. There is a lot of mumbling and grumbling about the Government throughout the country. We have heard a lot about the five year plan: we hear the bees but we never see the honey. We now find ourselves confronted with a financial crisis promoted by Fianna Fáil because of their lack of policy to meet the situation created by our failure in regard to the Common Market.

We find that the banks now have to give an account of their stewardship. It is no wonder that millions of pounds have already been transferred across the Border to Northern banks. Is that not something that is of grave concern to the country? Another after-dinner speech by the Minister for Lands contained a promise to give 45 additional acres to small holders. I have my pockets laden with letters from people looking for transfers. Whom does the Minister think he is fooling with all this talk of 45 extra acres? Some of the people fell for it and Fianna Fáil are always willing to promise something the people will fall for, but the people are beginning to sit up and see for themselves. They have taken this with a pinch of salt. The Minister should not continue insulting the intelligence of the people of west Galway whom I represent with this glib promise of 45 acres, when for years they have known that they have not been considered for five acres outside their own holdings.

Speaking on this Budget, which is the largest ever put on the backs of the people, I want to ask the Minister why we have such an increase in the number of unemployed in my constituency. The Minister for Defence cannot deny that. I have the figures—I got them in this House—despite all the talk of the increased number of factories in the area. We got a report recently in my town about the numbers coming on the labour market each year. The report was drafted by an interested group. They were not a political group and they were interested in the people as a whole. They include those coming from national and vocational schools. I do not propose to quote the figures, but I can assure the House they are very frightening, and are a matter of grave concern to the parents of the children coming on the labour market year in and year out. I suggest the Minister should arm himself with that information.

I further suggest to the Minister that he should do something with the millions of the people's money which he and other Ministers are gambling. If the Minister's policy is continued, we will eventually be left with only the very young and the very old. We will have to face increasing Budgets, and we will have a decreasing population because of increases in rates and taxes as a result of an ineffectual Fianna Fáil policy.

To collect this turnover tax, the shop counters will be lined with inspectors. At one time, the Minister for Agriculture promised to line the ditches with inspectors. We have seen an increase of 2,000 civil servants since PAYE came into operation. That has made a nice little nest-egg for Fianna Fáil. It will work out at anything up to £15 million. Where is the money to come from? Is it to come from the purse of the housewife, and the till of the shopkeeper?

The blister of this Budget will be felt by all sections of the public. The people are not yet aware of its full implications. The Minister said: "I want money". He and his Party are now demanding information from the banks. Is it to be a bank hold-up? It would not be the first time the banks were held up by members on that side of the House.

Comment on this
Seán MacCarthy Acting Chairman (Mr. MacCarthy) Fianna Fáil

That should be left out of the debate.

Comment on this

The Minister is not using a gun, but a fountain pen, but the power of the gun is behind the fountain pen. The position at the moment is that there is utter confusion and a lack of confidence amongst the people. Because of Fianna Fáil's lack of policy, the people cherish the hope of getting a chance of replacing the Government and they are looking forward to doing so at the first available moment. It is about time for the Minister to draw up a Budget himself and not leave it to the officers of his Department. He should come to the House prepared to stand up and tell us what the Budget means. We were able to find out only gradually what this Budget means, and some of the Minister's Party have not yet learned its full implications.

Comment on this

Listening to the speeches from the other side of the House, and reading in the Official Report the speeches we did not hear, it is amazing to realise the attempt that has been made by the Opposition to try to convince the people that an air of despair permeates the land. I cannot understand why members of the Opposition should adopt that attitude. Are they completely blind or are their heads completely buried in the sand?

During the course of their speeches, some Deputies from the Opposition side of the House referred to extracts from The Kerryman. I wonder if they read last week's issue of The Kerryman, the issue of 4th May. That paper is famous for being anti-Fianna Fáil and famous for expressing the views of the people it represents. I will read this extract for the people on the opposite side of the House. There is a black heading: “The People are Sick to Death of Dáil Cant and Hypocrisy: Opposition failure has contributed to”——

Comment on this

What is the paper?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

What is the date?

Comment on this

4th May. I think this issue was submitted to every Deputy. I quote: "Opposition failure has contributed to desperate political situation that could mean a dangerous future for all of us: James Dillon is the man primarily responsible for deflated balloon which passes as an Opposition."

Comment on this

Would the Deputy read the other paragraph now?

Comment on this

Read it all.

Comment on this

We have all read it.

Comment on this

I am reading extracts.

Comment on this

Read the editorial.

Comment on this

The spicy parts.

Comment on this

I am not holding this out as being right or wrong. I am trying to convey to the opposite side of the House what the people think. A newspaper is supposed to represent the point of view of the people. It is supposed to know what the people are thinking.

Comment on this

I am trying to convey to the Opposition that the people are sick of Dáil cant and hypocrisy.

Comment on this