Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 14—General (Resumed).
Contributions 321–473 of 473. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
Deputy O'Connor should be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman said noise was no substitute for intelligence. He has plenty of noise behind him over there. I hope that will sink in, if The Kerryman does not. Our people are definitely on the forward march. They have a feeling of hope, of going places. They need all the encouragement and help they can get from the intelligent members of this House. Since time immemorial, the forces of the invader have been attacking the institutions of this country and saying we are not capable of doing this or that. Unfortunately, they have left their mark and I suppose a bit of this will go on until the end of time.
Yesterday, Deputy Clinton made the statement that the Budget represented an imposition of from £8 to £12 10s., on the agricultural labourer. To impose a tax of £8 on an agricultural labourer, his wage would have to be £450 a year or £8 a week. To realise a tax of £12 10s., his wage would have to be £650 a year or £12 a week.
Comment on this
The Deputy should be allowed to make his speech.
Comment on this
The agricultural wage in the Dublin area is £6 15s. a week; £6 7s. in Limerick and Cork, and in all other areas £6. Assuming that £5 of the £6 is taxable, the agricultural labourer would have to pay 2/6d. a week tax. If he is a married man with one child, he will get 10/- a month, which wipes out the tax he would have to pay. If he is a married man with three children, he will get 14/6d. per month—4/6d. over and above what he will have to pay in tax. If he has four children, he will get 19/- —9/- over and above what he will have to pay in tax. If he has five children, he will get 23/6d., an increase of 21/- over and above the tax. If he has six children, he will get 28/—25/6d. over and above the tax. Deputy Clinton's statement that this agricultural labourer will have to pay from £8 to £12 10s. is indicative of the figures the Opposition are attempting to put up—figures which cannot stand up to examination. That is the mentality behind the speeches by the Opposition on the Budget.
Various references were made to the 300,000 people alleged to have left the country between 1956 and 1962. I shall not argue because I do not know what number has gone. I do not know whether there are any substantial figures to back up those statements. But, even allowing they have gone, from 1956 our national income has increased from £456,600,000 to £632 million in 1962, an increase of 38 per cent. It is noticeable that we had that increase after, as is alleged, 300,000 left the country. Our gross national product at current prices in 1956 was £560,400,000, and in 1962 it was £764 million, an increase of 36 per cent. The increase in actual money at current prices was £203,600,000. That again came after, as the Opposition claim, 300,000 people had left the country. The actual increase in gross national product at constant prices between 1956 and 1962 was £78,800,000. Those are the figures issued by the central authority, which are substantiated and which must have a bearing on our position. If we can increase our productivity and output with 300,000 fewer people, it must mean we have reached a very high standard of efficiency. It is a pity the Opposition would not devote their efforts to finding ways and means of keeping those people at home. In that way, we could increase our output still further.
On previous occasions here, I suggested there was a major problem facing our nation. The people are looking for leadership. They are prepared to put their energy and intelligence—of which they have plenty— into an effort to put this country on the plane on which it could be. All right thinking people in this Dáil should try to get together to find a way of stopping emigration. We have a very low output from our land. I was amazed at a function recently to hear Mr. Leydon, one of the directors of the Central Bank, say that the gross average output of land in this country was £15 per acre, whereas in Denmark it was up to £160 per acre and in Germany, it topped the £200 mark. That shows how far behind we are in agricultural output.
I have my finger on the public pulse in Kerry and I know our people are going ahead. They have increased milk production from 40,000,000 gallons two years ago to 50,000,000 gallons. They have increased the numbers of cattle, pigs and sheep. The tourist industry is growing and an effort is being made to bring fishing into a productive state. We hear a lot about people leaving the western counties, but the census figures do not bear that out. Leitrim is especially high, but Kerry, Clare and Galway are all around the 15 per cent mark. Places such as Meath and even Wexford are as high as 12 per cent. Therefore, it is not just the western counties that are losing their population. The figures I have quoted will stand up to any examination any Opposition Deputy cares to make of them.
I would earnestly urge them to bend their energy towards devising a policy in Opposition which will help the people to redirect their efforts into channels that will increase our production to the levels needed to give us a strong economy. Deputies were elected here as leaders of the people. They should behave as such and advise the people to direct their energies in the right direction. There is too much of this policy of fence sitting in the Opposition, of saying: "If we were over there, things would be different."
Deputy Sweetman this afternoon held out the carrot that if his Party were elected to office, they would drop the turnover tax and the increase in the corporation profits tax. He would have a retrenchment policy and that would bring us back to the position we were in in 1956. There is no other answer. I do not think anyone, even those in Opposition, desire that. Deputy Sweetman also referred to what he called the Lemass era of the thirties. Surely any right-thinking Deputy in the Opposition must agree that the thanks of the nation are due to the Taoiseach for his efforts in the 1930's—for having set up such industries as Bord na Móna and for his wheat growing policy.
Comment on this
A terrible lot of Irishmen ate it and the person who says we could not eat it is not a very good Irishman.
Comment on this
You have to have a bit of Irish blood in you to be an Irishman. It came very badly from Deputy Sweetman to attempt to criticise the activities of the Taoiseach at that time. The suggestion was that he built a wall around our industrial effort so that nothing could be brought in. There were forces in this country from the very start who were nothing more than a bridgehead to attack our industries. They are in our ports and their aim is to maintain the tradition of foreign firms based on our soil. Perhaps a lot of our industries run by Irishmen have not come up to scratch but many such industries did good work and if they survive in the future they deserve a lot of credit for it. I mentioned here already that another Deputy and I went into a shop in this city and could not get a pair of Irish-made socks.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not a fact that since then, both Deputies have got presents of hundreds of pairs of socks?
Comment on this
Here is one Deputy who got no presents, who does not need them. It is a terrible state of affairs when a firm based in this country should admit that they could not provide an Irish-made article. Surely the trade unions whose members work in such firms could do something about it? I do not wish to take up any more of the time of the House because I know other Deputies are anxious to get in, but I would point out that even supporters of Fine Gael at the moment are saying we are lucky to have the Taoiseach at the head of affairs. Instead of making the sort of criticisms they have made during this debate, Opposition Deputies would be much better employed in advising our people on ways and means of getting our production up. This would ensure a sufficiency in this country which would in turn eliminate emigration.
Comment on this
I have listened to some Deputies from the Government benches during this debate and might I remark at the outset that the contributions made by most of them have not done anything to substantiate a case in favour of this Budget? They have mainly indulged in comparisons with the past. Deputy Nicholas Egan said that when Cumann na nGaedheal took 1/- off old age pensions, it was their downfall. As a young man in politics, I sincerely agree, but I will go further and say that this 2½ per cent turnover tax will be the downfall of the Fianna Fáil Government, and the sooner the better.
The last speaker, Deputy O'Connor from Kerry, quoted an article from The Kerryman. As a Donegal man, I have very little interest in The Kerryman—the paper, not the man. Having quoted part of that article, he should have completed his reading. Right beside the statement he quoted is the editorial which says:
At the present time the Government is not a popular Government, and we would say deservedly so.
The article Deputy O'Connor quoted was written by a Mr. Seán Mitchell and expressed the opinions only of Mr. Seán Mitchell. The editorial, on the other hand, stated the views of the newspaper. I cannot form an honest opinion of any of the statements made by Fianna Fáil Deputies, and that includes members of the Cabinet. Either they are out of touch with the state of the country or they will not tell the truth.
Deputy Timmons was so optimistic about this country that I fully believe he thinks that Dublin ends on a sixpenny bus ride from Nelson Pillar— that of course, is when the buses are running. He went on to talk about the progress this country has made and boasted about the ESB and the sugar company. Surely that is the biggest fallacy that ever came from the Fianna Fáil benches because when Deputy McGilligan and members of Cumann na nGaedheal, in the late 1920s, were trying to set up the ESB, they were going around calling it a white elephant. Surely it is a damnable thing when 30 years later a Deputy comes in here and compliments the people of that time for starting schemes like the ESB and the sugar company in the mistaken belief that it was his own Party who started them? These things are history now and I do not propose to go into them.
The biggest controversy about this Budget is the turnover tax. This is designed, in my opinion, to suit the higher executives and the big business men and not to meet the requirements of the more needy. I would say that the people who matter do not care and the people who care do not matter. That is my opinion of the mentality of the present Government. They say that the tax is evenly divided and distributed over the country, but how can they explain that 18 months ago we had members of the Front Bench justifying an increase of £1,500 a year to certain members of the judiciary and now they turn around and say that they had to pay and they must share in the cake of prosperity? Surely there has been a big change in the past 18 months.
Since I came into this House two years ago, we have had the Government giving increases to certain sections of the community. We had the eighth round increases—16 per cent to people earning £2,500 a year; 16 per cent to people earning £1,500 a year and 16 per cent to people earning £2,000 a year. This was in order that they could share in the cake of prosperity. We had the Minister for Justice, a man for whom I have the highest admiration, being put in the position that he had to argue on behalf of the Government and convince the people that it was right to give the judiciary an increase from £4,500 to £6,000 odd. It was the mistakes of that time which left the Minister for Finance with a debit balance in his Budget.
The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance spoke this evening and while he was most entertaining, and while on many occasions I have heard him make a good contribution to a debate, I do not think there has ever been a more ridiculous speech in this House. He would not promise that inspectors would not be sent around to inspect premises in relation to the turnover tax. Perhaps his Department might explain why there are advertisements in the national newspapers asking for applicants for administrative purposes. They just cannot organise this turnover tax without having manpower and I suspect, in view of the happenings in my constituency and throughout the country, that when it comes to the appointment of these inspectors, they will have to be secretaries of Fianna Fáil cumainn or their fathers will have to be secretaries of them.
The Taoiseach mentioned that he was prepared to meet any people aggrieved by this Budget. I take it that he meant trade unions and organised business associations but perhaps he overlooked the people of the country. There is no doubt that this Budget is the most controversial Budget ever introduced in a Parliament in Western Europe. It is designed so that it can be "hooked and crooked" by any person who wishes to take advantage of it, by any person mean enough to do so. I have heard it said that Jesse James and the Dalton Brothers would have nothing on this Budget. If the Taoiseach is prepared to meet any aggrieved persons, he will have ample opportunity in the immediate future and he can put it on record for the people of Dublin North-East that the result of the by-election will determine the future of the Government, and I have no doubt what the answer will be.
As some of my colleagues are anxious to get in before the Minister speaks at 9 o'clock, I will cut short my contribution. Bearing in mind that I am no financial wizard, I would ask the Minister who gave him this figure of £10½ million as a year's income from the 2½ per cent turnover tax? I am informed that £17 million is collected by way of revenue in this State per annum from income tax on profits. I have compiled a few figures and where nine people are concerned at the moment who pay £310 15s. per year income tax, on the turnover tax, they will pay £2,184 10s. This may not be an accurate assessment. It may be no guide whatever to the £10½ million but I am convinced that the man who said that the figure would be £10½ million either did not know what he was talking about or did not want to tell the truth, did not want to create alarm in the country.
If these figures, however, are to be taken as a guide, that £10½ million could turn out to be £30 million, £40 million or £50 million. Who is to decide that it will not? If it does, you can call it one per cent, two per cent, 2½ per cent, three per cent or five per cent—any percentage you like—but the fact remains that £30 million, or £40 million, or £50 million will be collected to help this Government get the money they have squandered since they came into office. Who will pay that £30 million or £40 million or £50 million?
We heard the Minister for Social Welfare saying that as the shopkeepers are honest-to-goodness shopkeepers, they will put it on luxuries, that they will not put it on foodstuffs. Surely that is passing the buck? Surely that would have been the decent thing for the Government to do or had they not the courage to do it?
I should like to refer, with the permission of the Chair, to a matter that happened in this House last Wednesday week when Deputy Briscoe and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands misunderstood a remark I passed. As the Official Report of the Dáil shows, Deputy Briscoe was wrong. Now, Deputy Briscoe is a man of advanced age. His hearing may be failing him. I accept that he probably misunderstood me. However, the Parliamentary Secretary heard exactly what I said but he thought he would create a scene. I have often heard that the Parliamentary Secretary was a chancer: I am fully convinced of it now.
I should like to thank Deputy Carter, who was sitting on the back bench of the Fianna Fáil benches, for getting up and, in spite of the fact that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands was trying to make a field day out of it, admitting that he heard me say what I did say, namely, to give everyman his due. Deputy Briscoe may have misunderstood me but the Parliamentary Secretary did not misunderstand me. He tried to make a field day out of it. If he is man enough, I hope he will come into the House and withdraw his remarks.
Comment on this
I shall not be long in my contribution to this debate tonight. I come from one of the poorest areas in Ireland. If we do not get money the schemes we have in hands cannot be carried out. I draw the attention of the House to the following schemes.
Next Wednesday, we are asked to open a generating station in Bellacorick. It has cost millions. Fianna Fáil are responsible for its promotion. Fianna Fáil are willing to pay for it. The money must come from the people.
Bord na Móna are operating in that area. Bord na Móna are spending thousands and thousands on reclaiming land there. They are making milled peat available for the generating station and they provide employment for a number of men.
In Geesala we have the Grass Meal Company. That company are doing great work there. They are showing the people of North Mayo that we can convert bogland into good land. They are showing them that we can grow good grass there and make the land valuable for the nation.
In Geesala, we have the Peatland Experimental Station. It is a credit to the area and, in addition, it gives employment.
I mention now the drainage of the Moy. That has been discussed for I do not know how many years. It is now being carried out by Fianna Fáil. It certainly will be a great asset to the people of my area in North Mayo and it is giving employment.
We have started a new factory in Ballina. To a certain extent, the money for this factory is being provided by the Government.
I have mentioned six projects which provide employment in North Mayo. If the people of North Mayo are asked to pay a little extra, such as 6d. in the £, I am certain that no one there will object to doing so. We must bear in mind that we shall get back an increase in the social benefit which will outweigh the extra amount the imposition in this Budget will entail.
I speak now for the people of my area. If we had not a Fianna Fáil Government in office there would be nothing doing in North Mayo. When the Coalition Government were in office in 1957 we could not get a housing grant or anything else in North Mayo. The people there have faith in this Government who are taking positive action and spending money on projects which will benefit the area and provide employment. They realise that that position would not obtain if Fianna Fáil were not in office.
I recollect that the work in the Bellacorick area in connection with Bord na Móna and the generating station was closed down when the Coalition Government was in office. I recollect making a special plea in 1956 or probably 1957 to maintain at least 10 or 12 people at work in Bellacorick. That was my desire so that the drains that were opened in the area would not be allowed to close in. I felt that if the drains were closed in the Coalition would not see to it that the work would be started.
I am glad I have lived to see that work started. I take a certain amount of credit for having done my best to get that work started in North Mayo. It is a very good thing that Fianna Fáil have seen to it that that work is being carried out there. I do not mind the small extra sum which we in North Mayo will have to pay for it. We are willing to do so because we realise the Government must get money to pay for the work. If they are providing employment in an area, as is certainly the case in North Mayo, the people will have no objection to paying a little extra, That is something of which I am certain. The question of having to pay something extra such as 6d. in the £ will easily be outbalanced by the increase in the social benefits which will be something more than what this extra amount will account for.
I am very pleased to stand up in this House and to say that our Fianna Fáil Government have done something for North Mayo and given employment in that area. Otherwise, North Mayo would be in a poor condition. I realise that our present number of unemployed is a bit high. It must be pointed out that because of the frost and snow over a prolonged period in Britain thousands of single people came back to North Mayo. As we all know, North Mayo sends out many people every year to Britain for agricultural work. North Mayo got an awful setback in the weather. If we had not these schemes in operation in North Mayo, the position there would be very bad. The people there will have no objection to paying 6d. extra in the £: I see Deputy Browne smiling.
Comment on this
Who knows better than Deputy Browne the position in North Mayo to-day, a position which is far more favourable than that which obtained under the Coalition Governments? He should be the last man to object in this instance. In his day, he saw his home town of Crossmolina a deserted village but now it has been transformed into a hive of industry. I say definitely that he cannot deny it.
Comment on this
Crossmolina would be a washout, only for Bord na Móna and the Bellacorick peat station.
Comment on this
Did you check the Fianna Fáil vote in Crossmolina in the last election?
Comment on this
I have no objection to doing it ever. I beat Deputy Browne hands down in Crossmolina. The Fianna Fáil vote in Crossmolina for the first or second time ever was definitely in excess of Fine Gael. I am definitely certain of that and I am making that statement openly and publicly. We in North Mayo are proud of Fianna Fáil. Only for Fianna Fáil, North Mayo would be a washout. Deputy Browne may check and go back. He may say what he wants and I will not object.
Comment on this
Deputy Browne should not interrupt when I am stating facts. Deputy Browne will be able to tell the people if I am making any wrong statement. Do not be whispering behind. I am going to say to you that nobody knows better than Deputy Browne what good and what benefits Fianna Fáil conferred on North Mayo. As I told you, all six major schemes in North Mayo were given by Fianna Fáil and I defy Deputy Browne to tell us what good ever was done for North Mayo by a Fine Gael or Coalition Government. I know North Mayo.
Comment on this
I have been in politics in North Mayo since 1918 and I certainly know what the opinion of North Mayo is. They thank the Fianna Fáil Government. They definitely thank them and are proud of them. They do not object to paying 6d. in the £ extra for goods when they have an increase in social benefits which will mean more for the people in North Mayo than the extra expenditure which the Budget will occasion. We in North Mayo are people who have large families and these people will get the extra money from the increased social benefits. We are proud of Fianna Fáil and happy that they will be able to carry on those works.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Deputy Calleary is not in a position to say that Deputy Browne is thankful to the Fianna Fáil Government.
Comment on this
If Deputy Browne thinks I have made any false statements, he has plenty of room to object.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil have done a lot for the people of North Mayo and as this tax is something small we do not worry because we will be able to pay it. This is a different time from 1957. We are going to have the money and can take steps to get that money. What harm, so long as we are doing the work and developing North Mayo. What harm as long as we in North Mayo get a certain amount of employment. Definitely, 500 to 600 men have been employed as a result of those schemes and that is the end of my story.
Comment on this
Most of the Deputies on the far side of the House, even the last speaker, have tried to convince us here that this is a good Budget, but Lord bless us, there is not a bit of point in it. It is a waste of time, at that. If they want to convince anybody that it is a good Budget, let the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Lands who spoke in my adopted constituency some three or four weeks ago tell us why the Government changed their mind. He told a Fianna Fáil cumann there that the forthcoming Budget was going to put a tax on luxuries, on fur coats, jewellery and cosmetics, but either he must have changed completely or else the attitude of the Government has changed.
I got a telegram from a colleague of mine, Deputy MacEoin, and I think Fianna Fáil speakers should go down to Athlone and try to convince the people there. The telegram is addressed to "General Seán MacEoin, TD, Dáil Éireann, Dublin" and says: "Traders of Athlone and district at public meeting held tonight unanimously resolved to oppose turnover tax and refuse to implement it." If you want to convince anybody, convince the people of Boyle and Athlone. We will register our votes against it but, unfortunately, you have a majority to carry it.
Let us examine for one moment what the Budget is going to do to the people, particularly the people involved in business, and the hardships that will be created for them by this turnover tax. Also, I would like the Government Party to keep in mind the hardships already created by the Government for these people.
Deputy Sweetman told us today that business in rural Ireland and small towns is usually a mixed type of business with grocery, bar, hardware and sometimes drapery and boots. People involved in that type of business over the past number of years have had to get some type of transport. Some have got small pick-up trucks while others have got station wagons or other means of transport. They got them for the haulage and delivery of their own goods because the Government of the day have closed the railways that heretofore took the goods to these people. Only a couple of years ago, they got a substantial increase in road tax. Every year, including this year, the price of petrol has gone up. Insurance has gone up. Everywhere that a penny could be squeezed out of the medium or small business fellow, it has been squeezed out.
Take the price of social welfare stamps. Only two years ago, the price of a stamp for a man employed in a business house was 5/6. Then it went up to 9/- and since the first of January this year, it has been 10/6. The price of a woman's stamp was 4/1, then 7/7 and since the 1st of January, it has moved up to 9/1. The employer has to pay his portion of this stamp while at the same time he never can hope to get any benefit out of it. Not only that but many business houses with one or two staff employed have been appointed collectors of tax under PAYE a few years ago, as they must collect the tax from the staff and send it to the Minister for Finance.
Every year, the business man is paying a substantial increase in his rates and at the same time the population of my adopted constituency, Roscommon, is dropping and this means that there are fewer people left to buy the goods offered for sale by these small and medium people. I honestly think that the hardship that has been created for them is desperate. Take, for instance, the statement made in the Minister's speech on page 51. I will not read it as time is running out and there are others who wish to speak, but he clearly indicated that the intention was to charge a flat rate of 5/- on the first £50 of monthly turnover and 3d in the £ on the next £50.
If we take the average small businessman, his sales are usually made up of bread, butter, tobacco, cigarettes and a few other commodities. Take bread, the one that is most profitable for him to sell. He has to sell 750 loaves before he can take in £50. On that, he has a profit of £3 2. 6 and the Minister immediately claims 5/- out of it, leaving him with £2 17. 6. on his investment of £50, and his income tax has to come out of it as well. The only answer the Minister or any Government speaker gave to that point is that competition will look after it. Let me warn people on that side of the House that you can ride that horse too far. He could be a very dangerous horse to ride.
I would also like to point out what competition is doing at the moment. The 1b. of sugar costs the retailer 7d. and he sells it at 8d. and if he has to pay turnover tax, it means that he has a halfpenny less profit. A 1b. loaf, the price of which to the trader is 1/3d. he retails at 1/4d. He has a profit of 1d. but if he has to pay a turnover tax, again it reduces his profit to a halfpenny a loaf. Take the 1b. of butter which costs the retailer 4/3¼.—I stress this for the information of people on the opposite side because they seem to forget it—he retails it at 4/6d. giving him a profit of 2¾d. If he has to pay a turnover tax out of that, his profit is reduced to 1¼d. per 1b. on his investment of 4/3¼d. I do not think that is going to happen.
The higher it gets, the worse it gets. Take a cwt. of flour which costs the trader 53/9¾d. He retails it at 55/6 so his profit is 1/8¼d. If he has to pay turnover tax, it will be 1/4 which leaves him with a profit of 4¼d. on a cwt. on which he invested 53/9¾d. We are told by the Minister that competition will look after that, but there is no place in the world for competition there. I honestly think that speakers on the other side will have an awful job to convince their supporters on this.
The net result of this Budget is simply this—that the price of bread will go up by a penny a loaf, the 1b. of butter will go up by a halfpenny, the cwt. of flour will go up 1/6d., ten cigarettes will go up a penny, a 1b. of sugar will go up a halfpenny, a glass of whiskey a penny and stout a penny per pint. There is no doubt in the world that this is the only result of the Budget, and anyone who tries to say anything else is living in a fool's paradise.
Comment on this
This whole debate reminded me very much of what happened after the 1952 Budget introduced by Fianna Fáil. Very shortly after that, there were three by-elections and my colleague, Deputy Calleary, was one of those returned to the House for the first time in those by-elections. What happened was that the Fine Gael propaganda machine had not an opportunity to get moving properly. The people of Ireland at that time accepted that the economic situation of this State was such that the measures taken were desirable and necessary, even though they were not very palatable. The Fine Gael machine ground relentlessly on with the same type of propaganda as we have just been listening to from Deputy Reynolds and others ad nauseam for the past three weeks. Time will tell whether or not the propaganda Fine Gael have been spouting out for the past three weeks is justified. I am willing to abide by the verdict of time on the proposals introduced here.
I think that Fine Gael have seriously miscalculated the position in directing their attack on the 2½ per cent turnover tax. I think that they have misunderstood it. I do concede that there is room for misunderstanding as to its application. In the introduction of any new system of taxation which is unfamiliar to the people, there is bound to be speculation and doubt as to how it will actually operate in practice.
Deputy Harte seems to think that this new 2½ per cent tax will be administered by Fianna Fáil cumainn. He is very much misguided indeed. I understand that this tax will be operated through the existing machinery of the offices of the inspectors of taxes. We are told that it will not cost more than one per cent of the amount collected. That is something I must ask the Minister for Finance to watch and guard zealously on behalf of the people. It is most desirable that the administration of this should not exceed the figure mentioned by the Minister. I feel that it will be possible to keep it within that, if the necessary vigilance is exercised by the Minister in the years ahead.
There are one or two aspects of the Budget about which I have misgivings. I would ask the Minister to have a second look at the proposal to make retrospective any of the provisions in the Finance Bill. I hope that he will be in a position to say this evening that he will take a second look at the proposal to date back to 1962 the provision regarding corporation profits tax. I think he would be wise to do so.
As far as the 2½ per cent tax is concerned, I should like to draw the attention of some speakers who have been most vocal about its being imposed on tea, sugar and the necessaries of life, that this is not a fact when all of its provisions are taken into consideration. In this connection, I should mention to Deputy Calleary that the people with large families are not altogether in North Mayo. There are some in South Mayo also. As a result of this, I and all those others who have six children will qualify for 28/- extra children's allowances alone, representing £56 in purchasing power or 56 sixpences per month, representing £672 purchasing power per annum. It must be understood that the shopkeeper is also the father of a family and will also get the benefit by way of 10/- for the first child and additional benefits for the others thereafter. In that way, if he is the father of six children, he will be able to have an additional £672 in purchasing power. That is a substantial amount of money to lay aside for any purchases of necessaries and clothing for his family. I do not pretend to say whether or not it is enough, but having regard to the average income of people, it seems to be adequate and in fact to be more than a person would normally spend on those items in a year. Therefore the person in that situation is at least no worse off.
The person who will admittedly be worse off and contribute more to the Exchequer is the person whose expenditure is in the higher brackets. This Budget was designed in such a way that the burden would fall least on those who could bear it least and most on those who spend most. I do not see any inequity in that. On the contrary, it is by far the most equitable system that could have been introduced. It applies not merely to the individual but to the trader also and, as I said, where necessary, to other items, and time will tell.
In the meantime, the people will note the attitude of Fine Gael throughout this whole debate. It has been negative, unproductive, unhelpful. Fine Gael saw the opportunity then to castigate the Government. They saw the same opportunity in 1954. They were ready and willing to take it but they were not ready to offer alternative and practical suggestions for making the necessary revenue available. They were prepared to shove it down the throats of the people that Fianna Fáil were a cold political Party who cared nothing for the people but who had a sadistic desire to take every penny they could from them. They made that lesson stick in 1954, but, if they did, the Irish people found that there was something more involved in the responsibility of Government than putting up a placard comparing the price of tea, butter and sugar between 1952 and 1954. This told in favour of Fianna Fáil and the people have not forgotten the negative and unproductive attitude of the Opposition on that occasion.
As far as the main provisions of the Budget are concerned, the constituency I represent has benefited and will benefit still more in the coming year by the increased expenditure, particularly the increased expenditure by the Land Commission in the acquisition of land and forestry development in South Mayo. In my constituency we have not got the potential of North Mayo for industrial development and the emphasis must be laid on the other aspects of development. The promise made by the Government to provide economic holdings, which will be implemented in a Land Bill shortly to be introduced, and to provide work on forestry in my constituency, is being redeemed. The amount of money to be spent there in 1963 will again, for the third successive year, set an all-time record.
Somebody has to pay; somebody has to find the necessary money for these works. If, as happened before, a Fine Gael dominated Government were to get back in office, they would find themselves in the same position as they did in 1954, that they could not redeem their propaganda, they could not run the country without money, that they could not, at the one time, retrench and develop. Fianna Fáil do not go in for any restrictive retrenchment. They go in for development and the money necessary for that development has to be found. Admittedly, this hits certain sections of the community but in the process, it hits least those who can bear it least and it gives most back to them.
Comment on this
I am not surprised that the previous speaker should be annoyed with Deputies on this side of the House when they referred to the increase in taxation on the ordinary foodstuffs of life. This Budget was so framed as to put across to the people this 2½ per cent turnover tax. Quite a lot of the people did not realise that it was going to mean an increase in the price of bread, sugar, butter and all the necessaries of life. What annoys me most is that in the past few weeks speakers for the Government party have tried to put it across that this tax may be met by the shopkeepers. I should like the Minister for Finance to show me any shopkeeper, small or large, who can afford to pay this tax himself.
There is something else that has not been brought to the attention of the public, that is, that this tax also covers drugs and medicines, so that automatically, due to this increase of 2½ per cent, rates must increase. Every county council supplies drugs, medicines, and foodstuffs to the institutions for which they cater. In the face of that, I cannot understand how any speaker can say that it hits only those who can afford it. It is going to hit everybody.
I am not against the giving of grants by the Government but we must realise that this Government are giving grants for the building of luxury hotels. I am not against the building of luxury hotels but I am against overdoing it at the expense of people who, due to overspending by the Government, are now being taxed to the hilt by this 2½ per cent. The Minister for Finance is making civil servants out of the shopkeepers. In my constituency, every shopkeeper is puzzled and worried as to how he is to work this tax.
There is one question I should like to ask the Minister: Is this 2½ per cent turnover tax a tax on credit sales? If a person gives out credit to the amount of £200 in a particular month, must he pay the tax price in the following month, even if he has not collected the money?
The corporation profits tax which was 10 per cent is now being increased to 15 per cent and the former exemption up to £2,500 is no longer included. The completely unfair part of this taxation is that the Minister has made it retrospective. There are firms in this country who have closed their books for that year, who have paid their dividends, who have probably made plans for the future regarding development and who now find that the Minister for Finance can increase this tax retrospectively. No provision has been made for it by these companies and it may have the effect of retarding development and the installation of modern machinery. I would ask the Minister to think again, and if he finds that he cannot reduce the amount to the original figure, he should at least get away from the element of retrospection.
Comment on this
The Deputy appreciates that the Minister will be called upon to conclude at 9 o'clock. It is now 9 o'clock.
Comment on this
Those are the few points to which I wanted to draw the Minister's attention. This tax is cloaked, to my mind, because the people do not realise its effects. It has been brought in by a Minister of a Government who have not got an overall majority. It is our duty as the Opposition to bring to the notice of the people that the Government, without an overall majority, are putting such a burden on the people of the country. I should hate to see what they would have brought in, if they had been given an overall majority by the people of Ireland.
Comment on this
Before the Minister starts to reply, may I ask if it is democratic procedure to close an important debate such as this without allowing every Deputy who offered an opportunity to speak?
Comment on this
This motion was put to the House earlier and the House agreed that the Minister should be called upon to conclude at 9 o'clock.
Comment on this
Nothing could be more democratic than that, even though we have not got an overall majority. First of all, I should like to point out that there was extra expenditure to be met this year under three or four headings. Service of debt accounted for about £4 million; social services and social welfare £2.67 million, education £.94 million, health, £5 million—that is another £4 million—economic services: agriculture, £2.4 million, industry, £.7 million, transport £.5 million; and forestry and fisheries £.1 million. That is another £3.8 million. General services account for another £1 million or so, so we had to cover expenditure of an extra £13 million. No speaker from Fine Gael or Labour objected in any way to any of this extra expenditure. In fact, they all tried to give the impression to the people that they also would give those social services, that they would give the services for agriculture, for education and so on; but, of course, they would not pay for them. That is the difference between Fine Gael and ourselves.
Fine Gael, and Labour also, give the impression that they agreed with all that expenditure, but they found fault with every single tax that is put on. They had some fault to find with every single tax. I want, therefore, to deal with some of the points raised. A few Deputies suggested that we need not have tried to cover all the expenditure—in other words, that we could budget for a deficit—while, at the same time, drawing attention to our very high adverse trade balance. A Budget deficit will add to an adverse trade balance because the effect of a Budget deficit is to distribute more money for spending and that, in itself, will create a balance of payments deficit, and make the case worse than it was before.
Some Deputies also said that there are no incentives for development and enterprise in this Budget. Of course, that is a very irresponsible criticism to make. It is painful, if you like, to have to draw to the attention of Deputies the amounts provided for development under the various heads. Even in the Budget Statement, I drew attention to the amount being provided for the development of agriculture, which runs to almost £40 million. The amount that is being spent on agriculture does not, as one Deputy tried to contend, cover the administrative staff of the Department of Agriculture. It is provided for the development of agriculture under the various heads.
First of all, we encourage the farmer to drain his land by providing money for drainage. Money is provided for land reclamation and improvement, and so on. Money is provided to improve his buildings and for his water supply. Money is also provided for the scheme which is operating at the moment, and which we all hope will come to an end, that is, the eradication of bovine tuberculosis. There is also expenditure on advisory services and direct subsidies.
On the industrial side, in the same way, large sums are spent on the development of various objectives. Some members of Fine Gael in their usual demagogic way tried to draw attention to the amount spent on luxury hotels. We have a Tourist Development Association here and a Tourist Board. Both said that tourism could be built up very much more, if we had more hotels. It was necessary to give grants for the building of hotels in tourist resorts. Under that scheme, grants were given for some luxury hotels which Fine Gael, in their demagogic way point out to what they call the starving people of Ireland. We will not get much progress while we have such people in the House. While some people are interested in trying to get a few votes from the few envious people, we are not likely to make very much progress. Those are some examples of what is being provided by way of incentives to development and enterprise. I should say that on the agricultural side, if one looks at the Book of Estimates, one will see that there is a big increase in the amount provided for agriculture in 1963-64 as compared with the last year of Coalition Government.
Total capital expenditure has increased from £26.7 million in 1955-56, to £79.6 million for the coming year. Deputy Sweetman suggested that we tried to cut capital expenditure when we came into office in 1957. I do not know if that is true until I look up the figures. I must accept Deputy Sweetman's assertion until I verify the figures. If we did, at least we made amends, because now it is three times as high as it was in 1955-56.
Before I go any further, I want to correct a matter which was raised by Deputy Dillon. He referred to a publication called Economic Development. As the person who produced it is not in a position to defend himself here, I must point out that Deputy Dillon said we were departing from what was stated in that document: while there had been a big increase in taxation between 1950-51 and 1957-58, “the increase in incomes which would cause a natural buoyancy in revenue has been largely wanting.” It was for that reason it was stated in that book that a sales tax or a purchase tax would not be suitable. But the position has completely changed since then. Taxation has not been increased in recent years in rate, taking it all around and, at the same time, incomes have increased very much. Therefore, the change in circumstances would warrant the consideration of whether it should be a purchase tax or a sales tax at present.
Speaking on this point, Deputy Dillon also said we had condemned this type of taxation in our first White Paper. I think that at the end we expressed the view that a sales tax, as such, would not be inappropriate to the circumstances of this country. We certainly did not turn it down completely at that time.
A good many Deputies condemned my action in the Budget of asking for returns of the amount of interest received on deposits by people who had deposits in the banks. It was pointed out by some Deputies that this was going to have a very serious influence on the amount of money left on deposit here. Some scaremongering was done and one would be afraid it might have a bad effect on people and might frighten them into taking their money out and trying to place it elsewhere. In answer to this criticism that it would result in substantial withdrawal of money, I must say I received no representations from the banks that there had been any such withdrawals.
There is no good reason why there should be. After all, most people with money placed in that way know a thing or two. They know what is going to happen. They know that in the Budget I said the Revenue Commissioners would have power, where they thought it necessary, to inquire from the banks the income of a particular person in the year 1962-63. Taking out the money now, therefore, will not save them. In addition, if a person takes it out, what will he do with it? If he wants to use it, he will have to bring it back some time. I do not see there is anything to fear. The existing relief from income tax on the first £25 of bank interest, whether in a savings bank, the Post Office Savings Bank or an ordinary joint stock bank, will still remain. The first £25 of interest will still be free of tax. I do not think we need bother further about that.
I should like also to refer to the fact that one of our daily papers contributed to a bit of mischief-making in this instance. What strikes me as very peculiar about that paper is that they have been so consistently unsympathetic with an Irish Government, no matter what Irish Government. At the same time, they have been always so understanding of any action taken by a British Government. Lest you might think I am being sectarian in this, I want to say one of our weekly Catholic papers is just about as bad— and I am not referring to The Standard.
Comment on this
I have not referred to it because I have not read it lately. There are two attacks made in respect of corporation profits tax. One is that it is retrospective and the other is that it is hard on the small company. First, I shall deal with the question of retrospection. I explained in my Budget that I wanted a certain amount of money. I tried to get money every way I could. I took credit for the balance in the Exchequer. I also took credit for errors in estimation—that we might have estimated expenditure too high or revenue too low. I took £2 million there. Even after that, we had to find a great deal of money by taxation.
I thought it would be fair to divide it, putting half on what you might call the better off people with money invested, and the other half on the entire population. In order to get that half, we had to get about £3 million from corporation profits tax and the money held by depositors in banks or rents from property. On investigation, I found that corporation profits tax is always put on from 1st January. There was never any departure from that. In many cases, concessions were given in corporation profits tax by way of lowering the amount to which the tax applied. They were also given from 1st January. That has been the practice at all times. I must say it suited me that that was the practice because it meant we could get this £3 million.
Comment on this
It was the same in 1932. Whenever we put these increases on, it is always to do something good, like increasing social services, which the Coalition Government never did. It is only fair to make all companies liable from the same date, because you will have inequities, if you do not do so. That is a reason for making it 1st January, 1962, in all cases.
I want to make this point with regard to retrospection. If we had put a 1/- on the income tax, there is no doubt it would be retrospective; it always is. If we had put a 1/- on income tax, it would be taken off the last accounting period before 31st March, 1963. That might be 30th June, 1962. Therefore, we would be taking income tax off from 1st July, 1961, to 30th June, 1962, which would be far more retrospective, but there would be no objection. Of course, there might be, because Fine Gael would conjure up some objection merely because Fianna Fáil had done it.
Comment on this
The Minister will remember that the objection in regard to retrospection I made was as between 1st January and 5th April, 1962. You never go back to that period for income tax?
Comment on this
I want to correct the Deputy on this. If we had put a 1/- on company income tax, it would be taken off the last accounting period before 31st March, 1963. The Deputy knows that is true.
Comment on this
Income tax is dealt with on financial years; corporation profits tax on accounting years.
Comment on this
No. The Deputy will not get away with that at all. The Deputy knows very well and that is why I am surprised at the Deputy saying it. I did not think he would do that sort of thing. It is the last accounting period that is taken for income tax. We were told about the hardship on the small companies. Here we have brought in a five per cent tax on all companies which make a profit of less than £2,500. Although they paid income tax, heretofore these companies were exempt from the corporation profits tax and we have brought in this five per cent tax on these people. In all fairness, surely even small companies should be content to contribute something, when we are, at the same time and in the same Budget, introducing a turnover tax which may—which will, I would say myself, even though others say not— increase the cost of living of everybody in the country, whether rich or poor.
That was the reason we thought it right to apply this five per cent tax to the small company as well as the big one. We reckon that 1/- in the £ on income tax would bring in about the same amount — perhaps a little less. There might have been a small difference in it. There would not have been any great crib about that: there might have been a bit of an objection from Fine Gael and maybe even from Labour, but the objection would be because we were doing it and not for any other reason.
I have examined this question of the small company in relation to the corporation profits tax, as I have examined all the arguments put up to me by Deputies up to today, to see if any changes should be made, if any concessions should be given, and I think that in this case, it is right we should make some concession. I am therefore providing in the Finance Bill that there will be a relief of 50 per cent of this tax on the small companies for the first two years; in other words, until they get down to it.
Comment on this
There was a lot of talk about how it would affect different companies and Deputy Governey gave the most heartrending description of the man making up his accounts. Let us take a man who makes £1,000 profit. I am taking that figure because it is easy to calculate and we will all understand it. I do not want to make the sum too big. The man has £1,000 profit. He has paid out, perhaps, a certain amount in dividends, but he is asked to give only £50, or five per cent, of that £1,000. We are now bringing it down to £25 and I do not think that will upset any man in business. I think we can leave it at that.
I was asked to consider what the effect of the corporation profits tax would be on the various companies. I asked my Department to get the Stock Exchange returns before and after the Budget, and I find from the lists made out for me that, in respect of about 90 per cent of the quotations of public companies before the Budget and after the Budget, the shares were higher after the Budget. In three or four cases, they are lower and in all other cases they remain the same. Therefore, as far as the investing public are concerned, they have no fear that any company will be worse off as a result of this Budget. We can take the investing public as a neutral group of people, even though some of them may be Fine Gael and some Fianna Fáil. They will not put in money for the sake of Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael, but because they think it will pay. Their opinion of these companies at the moment is good. They do not believe that this Budget has affected them in any way. In fact, they have paid more for shares than before the Budget.
I come now to the question of rates on residential property. The widow, of course, was brought up. Nobody would ever think of saying that the poor fellow going around in a Buick might have to give up his Buick and go back to a Ford. You see, they want to draw tears from my eyes over the widow. This widow has property and if it is office property, she would have to pay income tax on it, in the same way as I am now proposing for residential property. She was paying income tax on five-fourths of the valuation and when that was added up, she knew what it came to. I cannot see any good reason why people who have an income from rents should be treated differently from anybody else. Why should such a person not pay on his income the same as any other man?
Let us go back to the widow. If she pays rates, repairs or other expenses, and if she is an invalid widow, she may have to employ an agent to collect a rent, she will be allowed all these expenses and then, on her net income, she gets the widow's allowance of £259. If it is a controlled property, the assessable amount is written down by 40 per cent; if it is not a controlled property, it is written down by 20 per cent. Then she pays her income tax. How can we say that that widow will be badly off? She will have a fair amount to live on, very much more than the Fine Gael Deputies gave us to believe the people of this country are living on at the present time. If we listened to those Deputies, we would think the people are half starved, every one of them.
Going back to this widow, if she is over 65 years of age, she gets an age allowance of another £86 or more. If she has children—one of the cases mentioned by a Fine Gael Deputy involved three children—she is allowed £120 more for each child—another £360. A widow with three children has close on £1,000 net income before she pays any income tax at all. Let us leave the widow now, having seen if she deserves our sympathy.
Comment on this
Do you remember the time she had only oats? Deputy Burke should remember that.
Comment on this
Deputy Sweetman asks why we call this a turnover tax. Various descriptions were put to me in the beginning. I thought we could not call it a retail tax because we were including services. I cannot for the life of me see anything political in this description: why would we be more likely to get off better politically by calling it a turnover tax? I do not see that at all. A retail sales tax brings to my mind what I have seen in America and in one country on the Continent, where each article has a tag on it. For instance, a handkerchief may have two shillings on its tag which also has marked down 2d. tax That tag is on everything that is sold, and I presume the duplicate goes back to the Revenue Commissioners.
That is the sales tax idea. I think a sales tax would also give the impression that you must put on your 2½ per cent on everything. I would say to Deputy Reynolds that if a shopkeeper must put a halfpenny on the loaf of bread, he should not do it on the lb. of sugar—the one halfpenny should be enough for him. I am not suggesting the shopkeeper should cut his profits, but if he finds it necessary to put a halfpenny on a loaf, which is a matter of a halfpenny in the 1/-, he should not have a halfpenny from the lb. of sugar which would be a halfpenny on eightpence. It would be wrong to call it a retail sales tax because it is not.
We come to the question of whether there will be an increase on every article sold. There will not, I suggest, be a halfpenny put on the box of matches, or hardly will there be a halfpenny put on a needle. I do not know what a needle costs now but we used to get them three for a penny. A box of tacks would surely not be raised a halfpenny. There is almost exactly the same tax in Sweden and Norway. It is higher, of course. As far as my recollection goes, it is six per cent in one and ten per cent in the other. It is there referred to as a turnover task. Surely the name does not matter.
Comment on this
I do not know. I mean, it is difficult to know what you must call it. It is really a turnover tax, not a retail tax. Some Deputies expressed the opinion that with very keen competition, the tax will not be passed on to the consumer. That, of course, is an optimistic opinion. On the other hand, some say that it will not be passed on to the consumer and that the shopkeeper will be ruined. These are the pessimists. That is the curious thing about this. The Fianna Fáil people say that the shopkeeper will bear it and they are optimists, and the Fine Gael speakers say that they will have to bear it and they are the pessimists. Although both have the same idea, everything on that side is pessimistic and everything on this side is optimistic. I do not think either of them is right. I think the shopkeeper will put up his price on certain articles, not on everything, and that he will end up in about the same way as he is at the moment.
Comment on this
On that basis, I was asked a question yesterday and I got this answer from the Statistics Department. I notice that Deputies on the opposite side never stop quoting figures that suit them but they never quote those which do not suit them; they always say that they are not very reliable. I will take them as being reliable in all cases. The statistics people say if it is put on exactly on all articles the cost of living will go up by two and a quarter per cent. That is their verdict and we leave it at that. We have to omit this absurdity about putting a halfpenny on a box of matches and a halfpenny on a newspaper. I will come back to newspapers again. There are compensatory measures for a big part of the population and Deputies would be surprised to know what the figure is. In fact, I would say that Fine Gael Deputies will be very disappointed to hear it. The percentage of the population which will be compensated for this increase is 47½ per cent; in fact they will be more than compensated for this increase. The other 52½ per cent are the better off people who will bear the tax.
Deputy Sweetman said that the proper way to draw up a Budget is to fit the tax to the well-off people and not be so hard on the less well-off people. Is that not exactly what we have done? We have put on this tax and we made the case that we must compensate all these people on the lower scale and see that they are not asked to bear the brunt of this tax. Old age pensioners, contributory and non-contributory, all widows, the unemployed, both insured and assisted persons, disability benefit recipients and all children as well as most State and local authority pensioners, are compensated. The total number of people to come into these categories— you may make a note of it for yourselves—is 1,300,000 so that actually what we are doing in this Budget is we are putting on this turnover tax but we are compensating almost half the population—1,300,000 people out of 2,800,000 people—and giving them sufficient to more than cover the increase in many cases and at least cover it in all cases. That is the position and because I know that when Fine Gael Deputies go down the country they like to tell the truth, I want them to keep that figure in mind.
To give the Government fair play, you can start off your speech: "They are going to compensate 1,300,000 by giving them extra payments in their allowances, whatever they may be, and they are going to get the other 1,500,000 to pay the taxes." If you say that, I am quite sure a lot of people will say that it is damn well good enough to make 1,500,000 people pay it.
Comment on this
I know that, because the Fine Gael Deputies themselves do not believe it. The total money provided in a year is £4¼ million. Deputy Nicholas Egan made this point today, and it is a very good point: if you take that amount and see how many pounds would that provide sixpences for, it consists of £130 million. Out of the amount spent in this country that is a fair amount of money. It is probably about 20 per cent. Some Deputies would give us the impression that the old age pensioner, if he gets an increase of 2/6d., will be worse off on account of this tax. After all, he is getting 32/6d. and if he has to pay an extra 6d. in the £ after November 1st, that means 10d. more. That is 10d. more than he is paying at present and if he gets 2/6d. and he has to pay 10d. for the increase he is better off than he was before. I do not think we need go any further into that.
Take the 1/- for the children. A person might say that 1/- will not cover them. Well, now, 1/- will cover an expenditure of £2 in the week. We hear people talking about the poor man earning £10 a week and having four children. Will any Deputy say that he is spending more than £2 a week on each child? He would have nothing left. It is obvious that he does not spend more than £2 any week on any child. Therefore, he will have ample compensation for any increase after November 1st. In the same way you can go through all these increases and you will find that everybody is more than compensated, everybody I mean within this category of 1,300,000 people. Therefore, the man with the big family does not suffer; the man on unemployment whether insurance or sickness benefit, the sick man, the old person, the State pensioner, the local authority pensioner, all get their compensation and they will all be better off than they were before when November 1st comes along. That is why—if I might digress for a moment —Fine Gael discussed among themselves when they would have the byelection. Some people said to have it in November and some said have it now, that the shopkeepers might have made up their minds about this tax by November. Therefore, they decided it would be better to go ahead now before the people understood it.
Comment on this
I was told that. I do not know whether it is true or not. Nearly all the Opposition speakers said that it was going to cost more than two and a half per cent. That was the general opinion amongst Fine Gael because they like to have it appear like that. In fact, I think they would not object if it worked out like that because it would suit them. They all argued that it would involve more than 2½ per cent for the consumers and at the same time there were some Fine Gael speakers who said the shopkeepers would be losing. How can it happen to both sides? You cannot have it both ways but Fine Gael will have it both ways and the result is that they are not going to let themselves down on either side because they want the votes from both sides, the consumers and the shopkeepers. I have never seen a Party so greedy for votes and like every other greedy person they never get all they want.
Comment on this
Another point is that every Deputy who is against this takes the man with £8. There is no man who can spend £8, at least I do not know how he could. I do not think any man could spend all his earnings in such a way as to be liable for this tax. Many a man has to pay rent and rates. Maybe in the city he pays some of his income on bus fares.
I remember what happened in this House last year when bus fares went up. One would imagine from the attitude of the Labour men and the Fine Gael men last year when the bus fares went up that the ordinary man spent half his income on bus fares. They spoke about a man who had to work in one part of the city, whose daughter had to go to work in Drumcondra and whose other children had to go to school in Marlborough Street. The bus fares were deemed to cost half that man's income and it was said he could not bear the increase. A man may have to pay insurance or hire purchase. He is probably contributing a little to some charity or religious object.
Another thing we were told last year when the Budget came in was that all these working people spent an awful lot of money on stamps for the letters they were writing to their relatives in England—all the people who, Deputy Dillon told us, were over in London. The stamps will not go up under this. A fellow may lose a bob on a horse. He may be paying for a radio or television.
Comment on this
We may take it, anyway, that the man who is earning £8 or £10 or £20 a week will not have the whole of his earnings subject to this particular tax.
Next we come to the inspectors. The inspectors are a terrible bogey always with the Opposition. Maybe we had that to some extent ourselves when we were in Opposition: I do not remember. The Revenue Commissioners told me they are already dealing with 90 per cent of the retail trade in volume—not in numbers. There are already inspectors so that, as far as inspection goes, we are now coming down to the other ten per cent.
We are told that the retailers will become tax gatherers. Take these men who are paying their income tax. Are they tax gatherers? I do not know. They have to pay it, anyway. I do not think they are called tax gatherers at all.
The next thing we hear from many Opposition speakers is that we shall get a whole lot more money than we think. They appear to think I had some sinister motive in bringing in this tax. I could not get it imposed before 1st November. I tried hard—even for 1st October—but the Revenue Commissioners said no, they could not do it. If I could have done it much earlier I would have done it and in that case maybe it would not have been as high. However, it cannot be helped now.
Why would any Minister for Finance have a motive of that kind in imposing a tax for £3 million in order to get a big slice out of it next year? In my opinion, it will bring in £10½ million next year. Many Deputies on the other side say it will bring in a lot more than that. If it does, it means that speakers on the other side are putting the national income much higher than I expect it to be next year. I am putting it at a certain figure next year and on that basis I say £10½ million. If Deputies opposite prove right, and the national income proves greater than I think it will be, that is the only way in which we can get more. That will mean we shall have £7 million more on the credit side of the Exchequer next year than we have this year out of the sales tax.
Everybody knows, I am quite sure, that the service of debt will go up about £3.5 million and social welfare about £2.5 million, which is already promised and for which legislation will be introduced. We took £2 million out of the Exchequer balance: we cannot do it again—that is certain— so that cannot be done next year. If you add these up, you will get the difference between £3½ million and £10½ million. Therefore, all the money will be required, and perhaps more. I am mentioning only a few instances there where extra money will be required.
I was asked questions. Take, for instance, auctions. I was asked if goods sold by auction were liable to tax. The answer is no. I said in my Budget speech very specifically that a person selling an article of his own would not be liable to this tax. An auction would be regarded as a person selling his own goods, whether through himself or his agent. Therefore, auctioned goods will be exempt from this tax.
I was asked about the newsboy. The newsboy is not likely to register as a retailer. There will be many like him. I remember long ago—I think they have practically disappeared— pedlars, and so on. They have nearly all gone. People like that will buy from a retailer and sell. They do not come in at all. They are completely exempt. If they buy from the newspaper office itself they will be treated as retailers in that case but the newspaper boy will not be subject, as far as he is concerned, to this tax. He will get his papers at a certain price and sell them at a certain figure— whatever the newspaper may decide.
That principle, I should say also, of allowing the newsboy or pedlar or anybody like that to buy goods from a retailer and to sell without the tax could apply to the very, very small trader. I did know—perhaps they are there still—people who did very little business, maybe only £3 or £4 a week after Mass on a Sunday. That type of person could be treated in the same way.
We are told that the retailer will be compelled to keep accounts. Deputy Coogan talked about the 2,000 inspectors who will be sent down on top of the poor salesmen in respect of keeping their accounts. All they are asked to do is this. Any retailer, I am quite sure, without being asked at all, jots down at the end of the day how much he made. If he has not a till he can put his hand in his pocket, take out the money, see how much he made in the day and mark it down and, at the end of the month, add it up. He will have a form. He can fill in that amount and send on the money. That is the end of it as far as he is concerned. He will not be asked to pay on his credit business and therefore he will not be asked to pay on bad debts. It is a cash transaction. He will be asked to make up only in a very simple way the amount of money he takes in for the month, to pay whatever amount is due on that and to send it along at the end of the month.
Comment on this
When the money comes in—yes: he pays on the money received. There are no unnecessary forms. It is the simplest tax imaginable. As far as administration is concerned, it is the simplest tax imaginable. I repeat what I said on the Budget that it will cost less than one per cent to administer.
A Deputy complained last night about the computer, saying that it would do a lot of people out of a job. That is a very primitive idea, I think, and I need not deal with it further.
If the Revenue Commissioners have a suspicion—I do not think it is likely to occur in many cases—they may possibly send an inspector round. But why do Fine Gael object? Why do Fine Gael always want to shelter the man who evades taxes?
Comment on this
They do not want the banks to give information either. Votes again—and the vote of a rogue is just as good as another as far as Fine Gael are concerned.
Comment on this
The farmers: how do they stand with regard to this tax, our project being that farmers' raw materials for agricultural purposes will be relieved of tax? Also of course plant, machinery, seeds, farm feeding stuffs and so on will be relieved. That will have to be put down in black and white because, as Deputies will understand, we cannot very well ask a man with a general business, not dealing very much perhaps with farm requisites, to keep a separate account if he sells a fork or a billhook and these are all he sells for a week. There will have to be regulations to see that it will operate smoothly.
Comment on this
Before the Bill, we will have to see how this will be done. There is also the question of diesel oil and electricity for power. I do not know whether they can be included or not but we are talking about that with the people concerned.
Comment on this
We are seeing what can be done.
We are also condemned on another ground. I explained on the Budget that in many cases where a man is making a fair amount of money apparently, runs a motor car, is able to dine out in the evening and dine well with his friends, he says that he has made no profit from his business. This is hard to understand but he says that he has a farm, that he made a lot of money on the farm and that is the money he is spending. He points out that on the farm he has claimed, as he is entitled to do, to be assessed under Schedule B. Now where the man has another business as well as land we are making him come under Schedule D and adding the profits of the farm and business together and making him pay up. Fine Gael do not like that.
Comment on this
Fine Gael would like a man to be allowed to continue that type of fraud.
About co-operation: co-operative societies will be exempt from income tax and corporation profits tax on profits arising from the purchase of fish or farm produce for the purpose of the co-operative and also on the sale of some raw materials required by farmers in their business. That should be plain enough for anybody and I do not see why Deputy Dillon in spite of explanations should talk about the threat to every co-operative society in the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy never read it until he saw it before him and he never read the White Paper which was issued three days before that either, though I thought Deputy Sweetman would be very interested in it. I thought he would be very interested in the report from the Income Tax Commission but he did not read it.
Comment on this
I am going on to agriculture as there seems to be some doubt about what we are doing for agriculture. In a country where agricultural production is not more than what can be consumed by the people of the country, there is no great trouble. All you have to do is to fix a decent price and see that the farmers get a decent price, but in a country like this, where there is a surplus, we must find a market and usually when you find a market, the price is not as good as it should be to remunerate the farmer.
What has been done? We have tried to cut the farmers' costs of production by rate reliefs, by improving the land, by drainage, reclamation, liming and manuring, by improving farm buildings, by subsidy on artificial fertilisers, by grants for the installation of water and by educational services. These cost a lot of money. These are measures, some of which were carried out by the Government before us on a smaller scale, which we have pursued in order to give the farmer a chance of cutting his costs so as to enable him to compete. In addition, we have to give direct subsidies on goods going out so as to raise prices to the farmers and that is costing £9 million this year. The total cost under all these headings in the present year is something over £39 million.
Comment on this
They vote in such a way that we cannot get money out of them.
There has been a reduction in the rural population for years back. I am not prepared to go into all the reasons but there has been a reduction in the rural population in Ireland and in order to meet that, we have increased expenditure on uneconomic holdings from £1.9 million to £2.7 million. We have expanded the forestry programme in order to give more employment in country areas from £1.2 million to £3.1 million. We have expanded turf production—I have not got the cost of that, I think—in order to give increased employment. We increased arterial drainage in order to improve the people's land and at the same time, give some employment in rural areas. Recently, very recently, if you like, the Government have been encouraging the Irish Sugar Company to engage in processing fruit and vegetables. Since the Bill was passed in the Dáil before Christmas, we have paid over £3 million to the sugar company for these purposes. The Agricultural Credit Company has been reorganised and is proceeding now at a very much faster pace than formerly. In the past five years, it has paid out £5 million and in the 25 years before that the figure was £7½ million. They are now moving at a faster rate and that in spite of the reduction in the rural population.
We have heard a lot of criticism, but not a single suggestion from any Fine Gael Deputy, not a single one on anything so far today. They criticise everything but we have not heard a single suggestion as to what is to be done. In fact, Deputy Dillon said when he was making his speech, that he was prepared to take over right away. He knew he could put things right. Deputy Sweetman said he could bring in a Budget that would be far better for the country than this one. But nobody told us what is to be done.
Comment on this
They are going to solve the problem, but they know very well that they have not a chance of coming in for years and they are going to withhold that remedy from the farmers of the country. They will not tell us what it is. Is that fair to the people or to the farmers of the country? Deputy Sweetman knows what is to be done but he will not tell us.
Comment on this
Do they think the people of the country are going to support them on such a plea: we know how things ought to be done but you are not to know?
Comment on this
You cannot blame Fianna Fáil either, and what I want to know is if they can tell us how we will be able to stop it but nobody has been able to tell us. You cannot blame people if they say that what we are doing is wrong, but when we try to get them to make some practical suggestion of their own about what should be done, they will not tell anybody what they think ought to be done. That is going too far. In the past ten years, the output of agriculture has gone up by 17 per cent although the population has gone back almost 20 per cent, so that there is one thing certain anyway, that even if the population has gone down, work has gone up, and it is easy to see that the people who were there then were in fact under-employed. I remember myself, and of course Fine Gael Deputies if they were honest enough would admit it, that ten or 15 years ago if I were looking for a man for threshing, I would have about 20 waiting for the job but in the past two years I could not get one.
Comment on this
I was just going to make the point that the farmers all over the country cannot get casual labour now because the people in this country in the past seven or eight years have made up their minds that they are not going to live on casual labour and they have gone to England if they could not get work anywhere else, because they would not have that kind of life any more. It is a pretty precarious life. But those remaining behind have done more work and their income is 40 per cent higher per person as a result of that exodus from the country.
In those economic statistics cited, there was a mistake made. I do not know where it was made and I am not going to say how it was made but it is obvious that it did go on more than in the last year. They could pass the whole thing back and in fact could go back far enough to have some other Governments bear some of the blame too.
One thing should be noted, that in these statistics every year you will see the number of people "employed in industry" and "engaged in agriculture", because the people in statistics recognised that the people who were in the rural areas should be said to be engaged in agriculture, not employed, because a lot of them were only casuals, getting odd days now and again and trying to make a very precarious living. We will leave that until the figures are corrected and we know exactly where we stand.
Comment on this
The Deputy was prepared to take a bet of £5 to a penny that he was right. I would take that bet myself.
Comment on this
The Deputy spoke for two hours and ten minutes and he ought to let me to speak for 15 minutes. In spite of all these items we hear about, the national income since 1957 has gone up from £438 million to £632 million, and exports from £114 million to £174 million. Who are doing the exports? We hear in every speech from Fine Gael that employment has gone down in the past ten years by 60,000 people or whatever figure came into their heads. How could that be when exports went up from £114 million to £174 million and the national income from £438 million to £632 million? That is an extraordinary thing. We must be becoming very competent people if we have 60,000 gone out of employment and have almost twice as much national income as we had ten years ago.
Another thing—you might say that perhaps the national production figures are cooked, but you cannot cook the exports and you cannot cook the income tax, which has doubled practically in the past 15 years. People do not pay income tax unless they have the income. Their incomes must be up if they are paying double the tax, because the rate has been brought down from 7/6 to 6/4 during that time. If it were 7/6 still, we would be getting a whole lot more from income tax.
So everything points to more production, greater work being done, exports up, more taxes collected and so on. But still we have this ullogoning of Fine Gael that employment has gone down by 60,000, that unemployment is going up, but they forget that when we took over the figure was 95,000. It was never like that since then. Emigration is going up, they say. It is now 12,000 but when we took over it was 65,000, so there you are. All these things we have been listening to in the interests of democracy. I agree, of course, that the Government should make proposals and the Opposition have a right to oppose, but really they should not be obstructive. I would like also to say that I have been at this job now for over six years and I can truthfully say that during those six years I never heard a constructive suggestion from Fine Gael. Did anyone ever hear one? They did not. It is all right to oppose but you are expected to make some constructive suggestion now and again. Why do you not do it?
Comment on this
After listening to this debate by the two Parties, both Fine Gael and Labour, I have no hesitation in agreeing with what Deputy Burke said here, that it is just hypocrisy.
Comment on this
If we increase the social welfare benefits or the payments to agriculture, we must get the money for it.
Comment on this
Not a single Deputy, either Labour or Fine Gael, made any suggestions about how to get the money. Last year when we asked for extra taxes, they voted against them, and now they vote against everything this year. It is all very well for Deputy Norton to make a joke of it, but we cannot give these increases unless we get the money. We could, as was done in the past, either cut social welfare or give no increases in social welfare, or cut the price of milk. Then we would not want the money at all but we are increasing those things and so we want the money.
I think it is time for me to come to a conclusion now. Fine Gael want a showdown on this thing. They want Fianna Fáil put out and Fine Gael put in but they do not tell us what they would do if they were put in. They say that is what they want but is that really what they mean? Do they really want a general election?
Comment on this
When an election comes, we will go up as Fianna Fáil with our record behind us. What will Fine Gael do? They have been talking about the benefits of Coalition Government but apparently they are not going forward for Coalition Government. Why? Is it because it was not a success?
Comment on this
If it was not a success, why do they not say so? Why do they leave it to me to say it? They are now going up for a single Party Government. In 1954 and 1957, they said that we were despots because we went up as a single Party Government and they even said that Coalition Government was not democratic enough for them. It had to be an inter-Party Government. That is all past and gone now. They are going up now as a single Party Government. At least that is what they are telling the people.
Comment on this
They sold the North and they would sell their souls to get into power but they are not going to get away with it.
Comment on this
Some of the Labour speakers and Deputy McQuillan said that we should coalesce with Fine Gael. Why should the Labour Party and Deputy McQuillan, who did coalesce with Fine Gael, want to give us a chance at that? If it had been a pleasant experience for them, they would not let us in for it. I am not at all thankful to them for the suggestion and I can tell them that we have no intention of doing it. We will let Fine Gael go ahead on the single Party issue and we will go as Fianna Fáil with our record behind us.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?