Finance Bill, 1963—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 173–362 of 559. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 14 of 1963 ›
All we are asking the four Independents to do is give themselves a little walk into the country and then we will abide by the decision. It is a slight exercise and it will do the Deputies good.
It has been said of the British Prime Minister by his Labour opponents that, as a result of certain things that have happened over there, he is what they now call a man on a ticket of leave. That describes the present Taoiseach. He is on a ticket of leave and I do not know whether he will be proud to find that the ticket is signed by Deputy Leneghan and Deputy Sherwin.
Comment on this
Great play has been made with the result of the Dublin North-East by-election. In the final analysis, Deputy Belton secured victory by some 5,500 votes. I should like to feel that as in the case of a previous by-election in Dublin North-East, his victory represents a gesture of respect and goodwill by the electorate for the services of his brother in the past. In the previous by-election in Dublin North-East, Deputy Paddy Byrne succeeded his father. The majority at that time was some 4,400 votes.
Comment on this
But despite that victory, Fianna Fáil got an absolute overall majority within 12 months. So much for the feelings of the people.
Deputy Tully got entangled in a discussion today with Deputy Colley. He could not understand why, if the tax was put on at the source, it would mean a higher cost to the consumer. I do not know to what Labour group Deputy Tully belongs, but he apparently does not have to attend wage increase discussions. Indeed, sometimes I wonder what sections of Labour some of these members represent and how they came to be chosen to represent Labour instead of the FUE. Deputy Tully knows that when increased wages lead to increased costs the mark-up at the wholesale and retail level multiples the original increase as far as the consumers are concerned and that has been used by trade union negotiators to justify a larger increase than the manufacturer perhaps wants to grant so that the worker will be better off in real spending power and increase his income to a greater extent than the increase in the price of the commodities affected.
I did not intend to speak on this section but Deputy Dillon, the Leader of the Opposition, made today a low, personal attack on the Minister and, not satisfied with that, also on my children and my nephews and nieces. Deputy McGilligan asked us to look at history repeating itself. I think it is time I gave a bit of history here. The most outstanding feature of the developments in the last few weeks has been the organised attempts to intimidate Deputies to vote against their consciences. These attempts may have persuaded one to change his mind but I think those Deputies who vote in accordance with their consciences are to be congratulated for resisting these foul attacks. We are told that, so long as these Deputies vote for Fianna Fáil, that is an end of democracy. I maintain that, if they are subjected to voting against their consciences by pressure groups, that is the defeat of democracy, the defeat which General O'Duffy, Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Higgins wanted.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins came in here today and expressed pride in his association with the Blueshirt movement. Deputy Dillon did the same thing a few weeks ago.
Comment on this
I should like to point out that the Leader of the Opposition is described as Deputy James M. Dillon. I suggest that in 1933 the "M" stood for Mussolini; in 1963, it stands for Mosley. Fascism started in March, 1919. It was started with the assistance of wealthy traders.
Comment on this
They achieved their objective by creating what might be described as social unrest by the sort of tactics we have been watching on the far side in this debate, threats of kidnapping, bullets——
Comment on this
That is the Fascist approach. Deputy Dillon believes that, if he can defeat this section, not only will he become Prime Minister but he will become the great dictator and he is such a vain man that he believes he would fill the bill.
It would be a good thing for traders to look back at the record. Once Mussolini achieved power, he attacked the very people who financed him and made it possible for him to gain power.
Comment on this
Let RGDATA realise by what manner of man they are being led. When my wife saw a RGDATA poster on the shop where she deals, she said "I am sorry; I will take my business elsewhere". I hope that other housewives who are in favour of continued expansion, more employment, better wages and better conditions will do the same thing. If they do, the posters will quickly disappear out of the windows. The surprising thing is that most of those who display them are amongst the exempted groups.
I do not know whether traders believe the repeated allegation by Fine Gael that small traders will be pushed out of business because they will not be able to compete. It will be the supermarkets, and Mr. Quinn, and all the other people who led them through the streets. Who are trying to get monopolies? Who are trying to open supermarkets? Are the Government trying to take them over with the 2½ per cent tax? If anybody puts them out of business, it will be the large combine very often financed from outside the State.
I was surprised to see the Labour Party lining up with big business in this matter but as their former leader would only be eligible to be a member of the Federated Union of Employers, it is perhaps not so surprising.
Mr. Wilson, the leader of the British Labour Party, on July 8th last speaking to the Transport and General Workers Union, advocated a pay pause and an economic policy based on expansion. That is what we are doing here. It is on that policy that we should get the support of Labour.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon has come in here and attacked the Independents. I wonder does he remember that he was at one time an Independent Deputy supporting a minority Fianna Fáil Government? There was nothing wrong with doing that. I am quite sure there were no pressure groups when he decided to vote for some tariff legislation. In Volume 41, column 1269 referring to a tariff on clothing he said:
I do not propose to vote against them——
that was the Government
——because their defeat would hopelessly and unnecessarily embarrass the Government... . I do say this, that this tariff above all others is going to hit the poor and nobody but the poor.
Then he marched into the lobby with Fianna Fáil. If another Deputy is going to do that today, it is not right. Deputies realise that this legislation is not going to hit the poor so that their actions are far less blameless than Deputy Dillon's.
I have many more quotations from this illustrious Leader of the Fine Gael Party from time to time but to quote them all would be ridiculous. For instance, he came in at that time as an Independent fighting against these tariffs on clothing and at column 383, Volume 41 he said:
Let him put back the tax on tea. Tea never did anybody any good. It is purely a luxury, and if they drank less tea they would be a great deal better off. Those who cannot resist this stimulating draught, let them pay for their stimulation.
At column 2037, in Volume 42 he said:
Any person who feels that the 4d. tax will place a strain on their resources can, without depriving themselves of a luxury, arrange that their children will not have tea.
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Leader of the Fine Gael Party has the same views today. Tea was one of the commodities to which he did not refer on Committee Stage. He did refer to it on the earlier Stages. Does he still consider that this is a stimulant——
Comment on this
But I know my history, and the history of the O'Higgins family, if it comes to that.
Comment on this
I have read the life story of the Leader of the Opposition as reported in the Dáil Debates. He has a solution to this problem and the solution he advocated year after year was: why not throw up our sovereignty and let England come in and clean up the mess? Is that his solution today? We must remember that the last Government were thrown violently out of office as a result of their inability and lack of courage to impose taxation when it was required. On 8th May, 1957, when the Minister for Finance. Dr. Ryan, was introducing his Budget, he said:
The deficiency in public savings last year was made up in two ways. Approximately £9.3 million was obtained from the banks and over £10,000,000 from departmental funds, partly from investment income but mainly from sales of securities.
Is that the way to do it? In spite of that, there was still a deficiency of £9 million which had to be met. At that time, and I said this before and I have been told that I am completely out of order in saying it, and Deputy Dillon becomes very cross when I say it, neither private business nor the bankers would advance money to the Government or accept their security as good security and I have evidence of that.
Comment on this
No matter how often you say it, it is still not true. I defy the Deputy to produce any evidence.
Comment on this
I will produce the evidence. It is contained in a report of the minutes of the Municipal Council for the City of Dublin, 1956. It is a letter from the City Managers to the Lord Mayor, Aldermen and Councillors and is dated June 11, 1956. It reads as follows:
On April 16th the City Council were informed of a letter from An Taoiseach regarding the financing of the Corporation capital works for 1956-57 which indicated that if the Corporation were unable to raise the full £3,000,000 required, the Government would make good the deficiency by advances from public funds. In the light of An Taoiseach's letter, An Coiste Airgeadais authorised me—
that is, the City Manager—
—to communicate with the Bank of Ireland with a view to securing overdraft accommodation from the bank for capital purposes pending the availability of money guaranteed by the Government. The bank, on the 7th instant, stated that they were not in a position to assist the Corporation in financing its capital requirements.
They would not give us one penny.
Comment on this
Deputy McGilligan went back to 1946 and if I had known he intended to do that, I would have done the same.
Comment on this
The Government gave Dublin Corporation the money and you deliberately sabotaged the building of houses.
Comment on this
We did not get the money just then. The Government, faced with this difficult situation, brought in a guaranteed purchase scheme. I do not think Deputy Sweetman has yet inspected these documents, although I have offered them to him. Every building society in the country refused to lend money on the guaranteed Government scheme. The Government's guarantee was no use to them.
Comment on this
The debate would improve if we got back to Section 46.
Comment on this
The debate has become a little quieter since the scurrility of Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Higgins——
Comment on this
If we want to talk about scurrility, we can talk about this Deputy and certain quotas.
Comment on this
Having got that off my chest, I will go on to say that some of the present taxes are 2/6d. on 20 cigarettes, 2/9¼ on a gallon of petrol, 3¾d. on a pint of beer and 2/1d. on a glass of whiskey. Fine Gael will agree that these taxes are high enough. In 1946-47, we had it from Deputy McGilligan, Deputy O'Higgins, Deputy Dillon and practically every Fine Gael Deputy that some taxes were unnecessary, that they would cut down, that they would close the vehicle factory at Inchicore and go back to retrenchment. We in Fianna Fáil are only interested in economic expansion and in bettering the conditions of the workers. We want harmony between employers and employees. We want the people to realise what we are doing. We publish our programmes in advance; we report on them every year so that nothing is hidden. The thing we have to decide to-day is whether expansion or retrenchment is to be the policy. I am surprised that the Labour Party have not come in with us on that issue because anyone who comes in with us on it is doing the right thing in the interests of the nation.
Comment on this
I met a friend today at an old comrade's funeral and he said to me: "I never heard so much about nothing". He was referring to the campaign against this Bill. If one examines that campaign closely, one finds that people are making a mountain out of a molehill. Two groups are interested in the defeat of this Bill. One is the political Opposition because for the first time they have managed to get support that they could never hope to get again. They have got support from certain small groups and from Independents who are frightened out of their lives because it would appear that public opinion is against this Bill. The question of right or wrong does not enter into it at all. It is only a question of whether it is popular to be against the Bill.
Not only have the political groups who aspire to Government got the support of the smaller groups and Independents but they have managed to get the monied group as represented by RGDATA behind them also. About a week ago, we saw these monied people representing, from £80 million to £100 million, in this city. They were allegedly concerned with the poor but that is a lie because a document issued to Deputies today has not a single reference to the public or to the exemption of food from these proposals.
Comment on this
The Opposition have aligned themselves with this monied group who hope to save themselves from any close examination by the Revenue authorities that might disclose something they do not wish to have disclosed. So we have two parties very anxious to defeat this Bill. We have the Opposition who, for once in a lifetime, have found such support that they are satisfied that if they could defeat the Bill, they would be in power for the next five years and we have the monied crowd who hope to save big money as a result of its defeat. It should be obvious to anyone that if the monied crowd are to save money, the people in need must necessarily lose.
Simple people believe that if this Bill were defeated, it would mean the end of taxation. They forget that we would have just as much taxation if there was a change of Government, whether it be by turnover tax, sales tax or any other form of tax. There would still have to be £11 million collected from the public. It is the consumer who pays and who always pays but this turnover tax gets at a lot of people whom a sales tax would not get at. A sales tax would mean that the Government would put so much on certain goods but the monied crowd would put it on to the public and a little more along with it. It would still have to come from the people. This tax gets at profits, at deposits in the banks, at gambling, at entertainment and all sorts of other services. Little or nothing escapes this tax and, because a certain amount of competition between the business community will be caused, it is held that the competition will force them to lose.
If we are to get a substantial amount of money from the monied crowd, someone must gain. The public must gain. It is elementary commonsense that the public must gain. A sales tax could not be less than 1/- in the £ because this tax embraces so many things that if the same amount of money were to be obtained from a single sales tax, it would have to be increased or doubled to get it. It is quite easy to explain it. If ten people booked a room for a meeting and the cost of that room was 10/-, they would be expected to pay 1/each but if twenty people booked the room, it would only cost them 6d. each. When a thing is as all-embracing as this tax, we can afford to leave it as low as 6d. in the £ but if it were a sales tax, it would probably have to be 1/- in the £, with a probable increase in income tax in order to get the same amount of money.
One has to have something within in order to have faith. One cannot withstand the barrage of bribes and threats unless one believes. I believe that the Minister will get the money he requires and if he does not, the poor will be the poorer and, instead of giving the social services needed, the Government will only be able to give out buttons. I believe that at the end of a full year the Minister will be able to give many benefits to people in need and that is the reason why nothing will shift me from my stand. There was a grand alliance to defeat the Bill. The monied crowd thought this was a grand chance, a chance that would never come again. The extraordinary thing is that the rank and file of the Opposition prayed that the Government would win. My attitude is clear.
Comment on this
Never mind. I am always in the corner of the fellow on the floor. All my life I have been trying and winning. There have been five reductions in differential rents in Dublin in ten years and I got the five of them. In the past two years, through my agitation, I have got the cripples an extra half-crown. Do not worry. I shall always be in the corner looking for a little more, but I will not do anything silly if I do not succeed. I can always wait and get more in my own time.
What was the RGDATA solution to this problem? I have looked it over. It does not contain a suggestion that there should not be a tax on food. They suggest a sales tax on all goods. They are the crowd who helped to win Dublin North-East. The alliance is cracking up now. It is each one for himself from now on and here you have a last minute effort by this monied crowd, hoping that the Government may change their minds and have an all-embracing sales tax. They are not worrying what people will have to pay for food. In the latter part of their circular, they talk about half the traders being exempt from registration, meaning that in their case the suppliers would have paid the tax. They are concerned, first of all, about a sales tax on all goods, but if there is to be a turnover tax, that they be exempt from the necessity to divulge information. In other words, their whole concern is for themselves all the time.
I wonder what the Opposition's solution is? If in Government, what would they do about the RGDATA proposals? They will not repudiate them now. There may be another election and they want those people on their side. They are gravely mistaken. Once this becomes law, the alliance is finished. I am prepared to admit this form of taxation is a bit of a nuisance but, in my opinion, it must right itself. It always does.
I would suggest to the Minister that he should have a smaller coinage. I do not know whether this is possible or not, but I am told that if enough farthings were put on the market, it would ease things considerably. This RGDATA circular says that the big stores will charge nothing extra for foodstuffs, that they will put it all on the larger articles. What they are saying is that the working classes will benefit by increased social allowances but will pay no extra tax under this Bill. Actually, these increased benefits this year were intended only to cover the cost of the turnover tax to individual householders in the poorer sections of the community. No one could expect an increase in benefits in a year when we were facing a deficit of between £6 million and £7 million, so any increased social benefits given were aimed at covering this tax. I believe there will be a further increase in the benefits next year and I do not think there will be any increased taxation. I believe this tax will bring in a lot more money than the Minister expects because a lot of people will be found out in the same way as people were found out when PAYE was introduced.
RGDATA say that the people will be charged nothing extra in the big stores, but they then go on to weep for the little shopkeeper. All this talk sounds very phoney to me. Why all those tears for the ordinary people if they are to get foodstuffs without extra tax and at the same time, increased social benefits? How are the people to suffer if that is so, as RGDATA says it is? Supposing the shopkeeper does suffer, why should the people worry? Was this an idea to excite the people to march? I say the Dublin North-East by-election was won by fraud. You had one man in the Opposition telling the man in the street how much the turnover tax would cost him and you had RGDATA saying the big stores would not show the tax at all.
Comment on this
My election was won by a personal effort. I had no organisation, little or no money, no one with me but a wife and a few kids, so the Deputy can shut up.
Comment on this
The people are gradually waking up. When that RGDATA thing is brought home to them, as it will be by me during the next week, they will wake up. I do not mind a tax.
Comment on this
I am no greenhorn, in case you think I am. When the majority of Opposition Deputies feared there would be a general election, they were crestfallen. They cheered up a bit when they realised the Government would win, when they saw my friend, Deputy Leneghan and I were here and that everything was all right. What is the money from this tax required for? We want money and that is that. I listened to Deputy McGilligan this afternoon. Of course he is a lawyer. Without meaning anything personal, lawyers can split hairs and can tell every lie in the calendar. It is their job. He said this turnover tax will mean an increase in the cost of living. What kind of tax would his Party impose, or have they any plan at all?
Comment on this
RGDATA say this proposal will not mean an increase in the cost of living. Now, we are not chumps.
Comment on this
Sometimes what Deputies say here is not intended for here: it is for consumption by people who take a very small view of things, who have not the experience to see overall implications. That is why Deputy McGilligan spoke as he did today about the increased cost of living. It might be a minor increase but what about his plan? At least RGDATA, to give them their due, were prepared to be satisfied with money. But they are not politicians. They only want money. They do not want votes. So they can afford a little honesty at this stage. But the Opposition want votes: that is different. The crowd would get wise. This is not the time to talk about what they put on. Still, we have Deputy McGilligan saying that this could be an increase in the cost of living. What about his figures? I am trying to find out about them. I asked to have it explained to me but I got no explanation.
Still, you are asking me to turn against the Government—I who have enough "savvy" to understand all these arguments and who am convinced of the need for revenue. Do not forget all the Private Members' motions for increased pensions for retired Gardaí, retired teachers, State pensioners, Army pensioners, and so on. The money sought now is to help to meet people whom you have been promising to assist. If there is money there, those people may be met but if money is not there, they cannot be met. We must keep all the people on social services in mind. We must keep in mind an enormous number of people who cannot get what they want until the revenue is there to give it to them.
You are trying to put it over on the simple folk that if you get into office, they will not have to pay any taxes, that some crowd known as the higher-luxury group will pay it. How many of them are there? I have heard it suggested that it should be imposed on fur coats. How many fur coats are sold in the year?
Comment on this
You should know— not my associates, anyway. This is a ridiculous sort of suggestion. Of course, it is not broken down. It is the usual stuff you get from politicians for the simple folk who do not think in that overall sense in which we fellows think because we have to think that way. Yesterday, Deputy Dillon talked about housing. We are not supposed to talk about housing but I shall say a few words on it. I found out this about Deputy Dillon. He can get away with murder. He can ramble and tell us about the past and the future, crack jokes, and so on. But, if we try it, we are often told we are out of order. Yesterday, Deputy Dillon spoke about housing. He referred to the buildings falling in the city. I am the only representative in Dublin who gave evidence at that inquiry. Why? Because I know all about it. I have spoken about this before. The majority of Deputy Dillon's representatives know very little about it. Do not forget that the evidence I gave was in front of all the corporation officials who could contradict me. I said I brought 500 people out of dangerous buildings. In the allocations section last year, I brought out 2,000 altogether.
Deputy Sweetman wants to know what I do or do not do. I am telling him what I do. I could spend all day and night telling him. That is why, if you examine this whole question, I can see the wood from the trees and, with no feasible alternative by the Opposition, I had no alternative but to vote for the Bill. I am prepared to admit that there is a certain amount of nuisance involved but it will be surmounted. If there are very serious defects, the people concerned will meet the Minister and I believe they will be ironed out.
The fact is that we want the revenue. There will be further need of revenue in the future because there will be greater demands on it. We were told the money we formerly got on imports will gradually decline, so, whether or not we like it, we need some form of taxation to meet the demands. It has been brought home to us that as far as certain goods such as beer, cigarettes, and so on, are concerned, we have reached the limit.
If I try to get something and do not succeed, I try again. If you want me to tell you a lot more about what I have done for those people, I shall tell you but you had better be careful. I am a fellow who has to work hard because I am on my Pat Malone. I work all day, Sunday, Saturday and so on. You do not. None of your crowd does it much, either. I do not earn one penny outside this House because I gave it all up for full-time work here. You would not do that. I am damn certain you would not.
I have a letter here from Limerick— not from one of my constituents. He tells me he has been informed, in regard to bread, that shopkeepers will not put any money on batch bread, that they will put a little on fancy bread, so that bread will be just the same in price. He went on to say that he is aware that the RGDATA crowd, especially the Fine Gael side of it, paid some of their workers to come up to Dublin and gave them a free tricket—£2 each —and in many cases they raised their goods by five per cent to pay for it.
You are not talking about the business people—profits up by 58 per cent last year. I was looking at the paper the other day. Despite Unidare's profits in Finglas, there is cribbing over 2½ per cent. But they will not have to pay. Maybe it is that the other fellows are not so honest about this big percentage of profits and that that is why they are objecting. I am very suspicious about all this business.
I shall not detain the House. I know Deputy Dillon is anxious to come in and have a go at me while I am sitting down. If he does, I shall get up and have a go at him. I want the Opposition to know this much. If, at the next election, whenever it is, the Opposition are returned to power, I can assure them that if I think they can function as a Government, they will get my vote. There is one for you.
Comment on this
Do not worry. I am damn well certain. It has been said among some of the Opposition group that, if they were in the Government's position, they would rather Sherwin a thousand times than some of the other Independents, because he would not rat on them easily.
Comment on this
I do not want to exaggerate the importance of Deputy Sherwin in any way. I think it is a most unfortunate set of circumstances that has catapulted himself and his colleague behind him into the particularly unique position they occupy here this evening.
Comment on this
We invite him and the Taoiseach to give the people an opportunity tomorrow of deciding what catapulting they will do. I do not believe this Government have any right in these circumstances to endeavour to push this tax down the throats of the people. Surely it is not right, when the House is exactly evenly divided on a drastic new tax measure such as this, that, because Fianna Fáil have acquired and continued to get the support of two Independent Deputies, they should endeavour to force this through? Even with the votes of those Deputies, they can secure the support of only one-half of the membership of this House. Is it right in those circumstances that any Government should try to change so drastically the entire tax system and framework of this country?
It is at least open to doubt whether this Government, under the Constitution, are entitled to remain in office to-day. It is laid down in the Constitution that when the Taoiseach fails to retain the support of a majority in this House, he should resign. On a vote that it was agreed was tantamount to a vote of no confidence on the Second Reading of this Bill, the Taoiseach did not get the support of a majority of Deputies. He got the support of half the Deputies, which is not a majority of the House.
Comment on this
We heard that kind of speech from Deputy Noel Lemass, and to the eternal credit of the Minister for Finance, let it be said he went out while Deputy Lemass was making it. Of course, he cannot go out while his second-in-command is sitting beside him to make the same type of speech. At least it is open to doubt whether this Government are entitled to remain in office in view of the vote taken on the Second Reading of this Bill. It certainly is questionable whether any Government in any country are entitled with the support of only half the full representation of Parliament drastically to change the tax system. It is admitted on all sides —even by Deputy Sherwin, who is described in one of today's papers as the lynchpin of Fianna Fáil—that public opinion is against this tax and that the people do not want it.
Surely one of the basic essentials of any democratic system of Government is that the voice of the people will be heard in the Parliament of the people? Is the voice of the people being heard in this Parliament today? If it is being raised, is it being listened to? Do Deputy Leneghan and Deputy Sherwin not know that the vast majority of the people are against these Government proposals? Is it not manifest in the only constituency in which the people had an opportunity of passing judgment on these Government proposals, Dublin North-East, that the people voted against them and, without reflecting in any way on the individual candidate, that the Government sustained as humiliating a defeat as any Government in office sustained at a by-election? Is it any wonder, in face of that, we have the kind of bad-tempered speech we heard this evening from Deputy Noel Lemass?
Comment on this
If the last two speeches are to be taken as samples of the arguments put forward in favour of these proposals, it is an excellent demonstration of how completely bankrupt the Government are of arguments in favour of them. I want to make it quite clear—and I think in view of what Deputy Sherwin said it is necessary to do so—that neither I nor any of my colleagues in these benches hold any brief for any trade organisation. But we recognise the right of RGDATA or any other trade organisation under the Constitution to make known their views on Government policy, legislation and proposals. We are entitled to defend their right to assemble peacefully for the purpose of protesting against these Government proposals. They are entitled to do that without being threatened, as they were threatened by the Taoiseach, with bloody noses if they voice their opposition to Fianna Fáil.
Deputy Sherwin quoted their proposals. I do not care what their proposals were. At least they did make proposals. They had a solution. Deputy Sherwin had a solution also and on the White Paper issued to Deputies that solution was made known to us—an amendment to challenge the Government to exclude batch bread from these proposals. Where is that amendment now?
Comment on this
He will get his opportunity in a few moments to vote to exclude batch bread from the provisions of this Bill. It is at least good to know that he—described to-day as the lynch-pin of the Fianna Fáil Party—accepts in public that public opinion is against these proposals of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
This is the third time in the last 12 years that Fianna Fáil have deliberately increased the price of food. If Deputy Sherwin was asked by any voter in his constituency at the last election was he going to vote for a tax on food, for a tax on bread, for a tax on coal, for a tax on clothes, I am sure Deputy Sherwin would be honest enough to stand up here and say he would have told the questioner he had not the slightest intention of voting for a tax on food, fuel and clothes. If the Tánaiste or any other member of Fianna Fáil were asked at the last election if they were re-elected as a Government would they by positive Government budgetary action tax food, fuel and clothes, is there any of them who would have stated on a public platform in the last election that they were seeking a mandate from the people for the purpose of taxing the basic essentials of life, for the purpose of taxing food, fuel and clothes?
Comment on this
Do they claim today that is the mandate they got at the last election? I do not think any of them do. In the present circumstances when, even with the assistance of Deputy Leneghan and Deputy Sherwin, they are able to secure only half the votes in a full House, with the knowledge that the people are against these proposals, with the knowledge that no Fianna Fáil spokesman at the last election sought a mandate from the people for this tax or for any tax on the basic essentials of life, would not the decent thing to do be to go to the country now and to submit this issue to the people at a general election?
If the Government are as confident as they pretend to be, if Deputy Sherwin feels the Government are entitled to be confident that the people would back these proposals, what are they afraid of? I understood from some remarks made by the Taoiseach some time ago that he is all out for the excitement of a general election. Why does he not indulge his propensity for that excitement now and let the people decide?
Comment on this
In the daily newspapers of the 13th of last month, the Taoiseach was reported as saying that he believed the Irish people had developed in political maturity and want to be treated as responsible men and women capable of exercising intelligent judgment on political questions.
Comment on this
Might I remind the Deputy that this is not the Second Reading but a debate on the section.
Comment on this
The Chair can hardly be unaware of the fact that Deputies on the opposite side quoted reports from as far back as 1932. I am referring to a speech of the Taoiseach last month. The Taoiseach was reported as saying that he believed that the Irish people had developed political maturity. He said he was willing to stake the political future of the Government and of his Party on their judgment and did not think he was taking any risk whatever. I invite the Taoiseach to allow the people to exercise their intelligent judgment on this political question of the turnover tax in this Finance Bill. Of course, as long as he retains the support of two Independents which enables him to secure the votes of half the House, he will not do that. He will not stake the future of his Party or of the Government on the intelligent judgment of the Irish people on this political question.
We are dealing with a section of the Finance Bill relating to the turnover tax. The first point I want to repeat, for the benefit of the last speaker in particular, is that the turnover tax will increase the cost of living. If allowed to go into operation, it will increase by 2½ per cent the prices of all goods and all services coming within its scope. It will do that without making the slightest differentiation between luxury goods and Deputy Sherwin's batch bread. It will not make the slightest differentiation between the person who at the end of the week, must spend all his weekly income on domestic needs and the person who is able to put away three-quarters of his weekly income in savings or spend it on luxury goods requiring only a quarter of it for domestic needs.
This tax will mean that 2½ per cent more must be paid for the basic essentials of food, fuel and clothes and on the Minister's own calculation, of the £11 million he hopes to raise from this tax, about £7 million will be taken from the people buying these items. The operation of the tax will be complicated. Many think it will be unworkable. All those considerations are relevant to the section we are discussing. Deputy Sherwin has followed faithfully in the footsteps of the directive apparently issued to the Fianna Fáil Party at their recent meeting that a good argument whenever a Fine Gael speaker refers to the turnover tax is to ask: "What are you going to do instead?"
Comment on this
Deputy Sherwin should remember that in 1947 the Party he is keeping in Government at the cost of the turnover tax introduced a Supplementary Budget in which they put savage impositions on a number of commodities. Fine Gael, in common with other Parties, opposed them and they were told in effect by Fianna Fáil that the money had to be found, that the country was facing a crucial period and that money was needed to keep the ship of State on an even keel and that if there was a change of Government and if a new Government dared to abolish the taxes Fianna Fáil had put on in their Supplementary Budget in 1947, the country would have to face vast new taxation and the Government would have to put up income tax by 2/6 in the £.
Deputy Sherwin describes himself as a veteran and I am sure he remembers this as well as I do. The change of Government came about and inside a fortnight, I think, the inter-Party Government, under Deputy John A. Costello, remitted all those taxes imposed by Fianna Fáil in 1947. They gave social welfare benefits also.
Comment on this
At the end of 12 months, they had given either in benefits or in remission of Fianna Fáil penal taxes £13.5 million without putting on a penny extra taxation.
Comment on this
There was a general election and Fianna Fáil got back to office and introduced a Budget in 1952 in which their first effort was to wipe out half of the food subsidies. That was the first time in recent years that Fianna Fáil deliberately increased the price of food. Would the Tánaiste ask me what happened in 1957? I am going to tell him in any case. In 1957, they again got back to office and their first action in their first Budget was to remove the remainder of the food subsidies to save the Exchequer £9 million which the previous Government had kept there to protect the weakest section of the community against food increases.
Now, would Deputy Sherwin oblige by asking what happened in 1963? With the assistance of Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Leneghan, a Fianna Fáil minority Government, unable to attract the support of the majority of the House, again proposed by deliberate positive Government action to increase the price of food, fuel and clothing and a host of other commodities also.
Comment on this
We shall put the present Government out of office at the earliest opportunity and do it with the support and goodwill of the people of the country.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins spoke about the mandate the people gave us. The mandate the people gave us was to rule this country, as my colleague, the Parliamentary Secretary said, but I remember the mandate they gave us in 1957. I have a very clear recollection of the mandate they gave us at that time: "Do what you like, but for goodness sake, do not let that Coalition back," and we are determined to keep that promise we gave the people at that time that they would never come back again.
Most of the Fine Gael speakers say that the people generally are against this tax. Why, therefore, do Fine Gael think we are going on with it? Can they suggest any reason whatever if the people are against us, and they say we know they are against us? If that is true, what reason can they give for this tax being put on? Is it not obvious the only reason they can give is that we think it is for the good of the country that it should be done? There could be no other reason and I defy any Deputy on the Fine Gael or Labour side to suggest any other reason why we are going ahead with this tax.
We do not believe there is this great feeling against the tax at all. There are a lot of vocal protestations but we will not be intimidated by any organised opposition to this tax. I think we are to be congratulated because we are going to fight this intimidation from the point of view of principle and, to use Deputy Dillon's words, it is a much more pleasant feeling to fight a thing like that than to be selling our souls for penny rolls——
Comment on this
Deputy T.F. O'Higgins made a long speech against this tax generally but he did not like to end his speech without throwing a sop to RGDATA. He went on to say that if this tax must be imposed, it would be better to impose it at the wholesale level. I should have imagined that speakers from Fine Gael and Labour would not consider any modification of this tax, that they considered it was wrong and that was the end of it. However, the attitude of the fine Gael Party is that whatever your principles may be said to be, at the same time, do not lose a friend. They do not want to lose their friends in RGDATA so they put their point of view forward before this debate ends.
I want to say a few words about this proposition put up by Deputy O'Higgins on behalf of RGDATA that the tax should be put on at wholesale level. Everybody knows enough about trade to realise that if the tax were put on at the manufacturer level, it would have to be made very much higher to get the same yield. If the manufacturer's price is so much, there is a margin added on by the wholesaler and a margin added on again by the retailer. It is obvious there must be a higher tax at the manufacturer level than at the retail level.
Comment on this
There is also the point that you cannot apply tax uniformly at the manufacturer level. It would be necessary to put on a tax of four to five per cent at the manufacturer level to give the same yield. That four or five per cent added on will itself be increased at the wholesale level and again at the retail level so that the consumer, as the Parliamentary Secretary said quite rightly, would be paying about six or seven per cent more than he would at the retail level. At the retail level, he will not pay more than 2½ per cent if the retailer sees that the consumer pays the tax. At the manufacturer level, the consumer would have to pay about three or four per cent more for his goods and the revenue would get no more. Fine Gael, not wanting to lose the support of RGDATA, are in alliance with them in this regard, so let me say it would be a very bad bargain to impose a tax at the manufacturer level from the point of view of the revenue and, at the same time, the consumer would be paying more.
Deputy Dillon and Deputy O'Higgins tried to misrepresent speakers on this side of the House as sometimes saying the consumer must pay and sometimes saying the shopkeeper must pay. Of course, the Deputy has a right to express his opinion but I have been the principal spokesman for this tax all through and at every opportunity I said I was assuming that the consumer would pay this tax. In the Budget, I made that point and I said I wanted to compensate the social welfare recipients for the increase in the cost of living which would be imposed on them as a result of this tax. It would not have been necessary for me, as Deputy Sherwin pointed out, to increase the social welfare benefits if I did not believe that this tax was going to be passed on. In fact, I agree with Deputy Sherwin that practically any tax goes on to the consumer sometime or other, if it does not go on immediately.
Deputy Tully spoke about the increase this tax would impose on the old age pensioner and other people of a similar class. Deputy Tully must be very uninterested in matters in this House if he does not remember that in the Budget speech, I provided for an increase in the old age pension and for all other social welfare recipients so as to compensate them.
Comment on this
The Minister is talking a lot of nonsense. He is giving a half-crown and there will be about four shillings taken off, and he knows it.
Comment on this
That is the greatest nonsense I have heard for a long time. Deputy Tully knows the old age pensioner has about 32/6d. Sixpence in the pound is about tenpence on that amount.
Comment on this
The increase is about tenpence on his expenditure, whatever it may be. In fact, it would be somewhat less, because, as I pointed out in the Budget speech, the whole of his earnings will not be subject to tax. There will be certain things on which he will spend money and which will not be subject to tax, for instance, if he has to pay rent, rates or bus fares. Therefore, the whole income will not be subject to tax, but if it were, the tax would not be more than tenpence, and we are giving him a halfcrown. Deputy Tully is not interested in what people are getting; he is more interested in politics. If he were interested, he would be more solicitous as to how we are to raise this money to give to the social welfare recipients.
Comment on this
I am more interested than the Minister. The Minister was never in an old age pensioner's house in his life.
Comment on this
We gave them 11/- over a period while the Deputy's colleague gave them 2/6d. when he was minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Last night we gave you £4 million for social welfare. We will vote for more than you want to give.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 23:
In subsection (3), page 31, to delete "£500" in line 13 and substitute "£250".
Amendments Nos. 23, 25, 26, 27 and 28 might be taken together because they all have the one purpose.
Comment on this
That remains to be seen. The purpose of these five amendments is to amend subsection (3) of Section 47 to allow those who are taking goods from a registered person to opt out to extent of £500——
Comment on this
On a point of order I am completely at sea. As I understand it, the Minister is moving amendment No. 23 which deals with line 13 of page 31. I may be wrong but I thought that amendment No. 24 also deals with line 13 of page 31.
Comment on this
The Minister said it was a different thing. I want to know what amendments we are dealing with and then we will know where we stand.
Comment on this
There is still some ambiguity. The figure must be wrong. Which figure does Deputy Leneghan's amendment No. 24 relate to?
Comment on this
The effect of the five amendments in my name is that persons dealing in goods will not be able to "opt out" of the tax on turnover up to £500 a month unless they have procured their stock in trade from a taxpaying source, that is, from a supplier who is accountable for tax. Where, however, the retailer gets his goods from a person who is accountable for tax, he can go to the limit of £500. For persons providing services, the option limit remains at £100 a month. If he is giving a service, he need not register up to £100 a month. If he is selling goods which he has bought from a registered person, he can go up to £500 per month but if he has not bought them from a registered person, he can only go up to £250 a month.
Comment on this
The meaning of the amendments which the Minister is now moving is to remove from the list of those who need not be themselves liable to the operations of turnover tax certain small concerns between £250 and £500 a month. The effect of these amendments is that certain persons who, as the Bill is drafted, were not themselves responsible for the operation of the turnover tax are now, as a result of this batch of amendments, being made so liable to come in that category. These are ones with a turnover of between £250 and £500 a month. Is that not the correct meaning of those amendments?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not move it now. There may not be two amendments before the House at the same time. The Deputy may discuss his amendment.
Comment on this
The position is that if the figure of £500 a month is brought up to £750 a month, it would eliminate a great many of the difficulties for the shopkeepers throughout the country. We all know from the ordinary public that there is no real objection to the 2½ per cent turnover tax and those people who came along and tried to bribe and intimidate myself and Deputy Sherwin were not the ordinary workers. They were people who were organised by politicians.
My amendments is not designed to help out these people but I do realise that there are many people who have a much higher turnover than they are believed to have. Many of these people have not got the means of collecting this tax. They are one-or two-men businesses, or perhaps a business run by a man and his wife, or perhaps a man and his sister. They have no method of calculating the tax and of dealing with it. I feel that if the figure were raised to £750, it would smooth out the grievances of many of these people and I hope the Minister will agree to it.
Comment on this
If Fine Gael are so pleased and excited about having lost the last division, they should contain themselves. The House is still in session and up to Section 65 of the Bill will have to be dealt with tonight. I should like to support Deputy Leneghan on this amendment. A number of people have misgivings about this matter, for the reason that they are afraid of having to keep books and of having to do complicated returns in order to pay the tax. I should imagine that over 80 per cent of the businesses in the average small town would be covered by this amendment, that is, businesses with a turnover of £9,000 a year or less. It would give them the opportunity to opt out and thereby divest themselves of all trouble in connection with the tax.
For reasons that I can appreciate, this would mean putting additional work on the wholesaler but it is, perhaps, not unfair to say that the wholesaler is well equipped to look after book-keeping matters. It is only a matter of channelling some additional material into a machine or of having it otherwise recorded. It cannot be said that a shopkeeper with a turnover of £9,000 or less is altogether a small trader. I would regard him as having a reasonably sound business because he would have a profit of anything from £1,000 to £2,500.
Comment on this
Any business with a profit of £1,100 a year upwards is a reasonably-sized business and it would allay the fears of a lot of people if they were allowed to opt out if they did not have a turnover of more than £9,000.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance proposes that the exemption of traders be reduced from £500 to £250 a month. Deputy Leneghan proposes that the exemption be raised from £500 to £750 and Deputy Flanagan supports Deputy Leneghan. I understand that Deputy Sherwin is associated with Deputy Leneghan's amendment. So we have the fifth and sixth wheels of the Government wagon now proposing a direct negative to the proposals of the Minister for Finance. The Minister is proposing to reduce the exemption from the level of £500 to £250 and Deputies Leneghan and Sherwin are proposing to raise it from £500 to £750. Let us put this to the issue now so as to determine how honest they are. They will get a chance in the Lobby of demonstrating not only their honesty but their independence——
Comment on this
As I put down an amendment similar to that of Deputy Leneghan, I take it I will be permitted to discuss this. One of the arguments used by the shopkeepers was that they did not want this accounting. They said it would entail extra staff. They would prefer that this tax was deducted at source. A shop with a turnover of between £600 and £700 a month is not a very big business and a lot of those people do not have all that much money. Many of them who drink and gamble a little, live from week to week. They do not want the responsibility of holding on to the money. They find it itchy. They would like this money taken away in dribs and drabs. We know that before the introduction of PAYE many people found it imposible to hold on to money with which to pay their income tax. Now they have no difficulty. The same would apply to small shopkeepers, and it is in their interest that I would ask the Minister to accept this.
Comment on this
I would support Deputies Leneghan and Sherwin in asking the Minister to accept this amendment. Nobody could describe a man with £750 a month turnover as a big shopkeeper. It is doubtful, in fact, if the business would be worth all the trouble of keeping accounts. I believe, speaking generally, that this turnover tax will be most popular throughout the country. The Opposition, of course, disagree, but they had a different story to tell when PAYE was being introduced. I should add that I speak on behalf of far more shopkeepers than does Deputy Sweetman.
Comment on this
Would the last Deputy or Deputy Seán Flanagan ever suggest to the Minister that he should have put down this amendment?
Comment on this
There is no conflict between my amendment and that of Deputies Leneghan and Sherwin. My amendment was aimed at ensuring that a person who was not required to register would not be in unfair competition with a person in the same trade. Take, for example, a butcher who buys his cattle direct from the farmer. He might be in competition with a man who did not. The same applies to milk. It would be unfair. It is a type of competition that could go on between a person who got his goods untaxed and a person who got them taxed. For that reason, I wanted to bring the limit down to £250. The amount in the Bill is £500 and in principle, I have no great objection to raising that. It makes very little difference to revenue because a smaller man registering is allowed a low rate on the first £50 and a reduced rate on the next £50. If you take him against the person who is taking all his goods from a registered person and where they are taxed at wholesale rates, I am advised it would make very little difference. The figure of £750 is not too high, but if it were very much higher it would mean there would be a loss to revenue.
Comment on this
We were told there was a matter of simple mathematics involved in computing the profits and that every little added something to the tax if the person is taxed at the first stage. Then you come back to the second stage to the extent of 80 per cent, according to Deputy Seán Flanagan.
Comment on this
I think it is the other way round. The Deputy is talking about wholesale prices. The wholesaler is taxed and he passes it on to the retailer. If the retailer bought at wholesale prices he would pay the tax but he would pay it at a low rate on the first and second £50. The revenue would be better from the wholesale point of view so long as the exemption is low. If the exemption reaches a certain figure, we begin to lose.
Comment on this
The Minister misunderstands me. If what he says is so, why cannot he put the entire tax back to the beginning of the transaction and follow it down with each article? Then the public would not pay any more than the 2½ per cent ultimately.
Comment on this
To put the whole levy on the wholesale end would obviously mean we would be collecting only 80 per cent.
Comment on this
Deputy Seán Flanagan said that was the percentage of the trade represented by the small shopkeepers.
Comment on this
It is possible it would cover 75 or 80 per cent of them but only 15 to 20 per cent of the business done.
Comment on this
Could we get a direction about the amendment? The amendment we have before us is amendment No. 23. If amendment No. 24 is to be kept alive, and if Deputies want to speak in support of it, amendment No. 23 must be defeated. What I mean to convey is that if amendment No. 23 is carried, the other falls?
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept the figure of £750 and is he consequently withdrawing No. 23, his own amendment?
Comment on this
No. I said I had no great objection to the figure £750 in this case but if we are to accept it, I think the only way we can do it properly as regards drafting is to take No. 23, my amendment, and to let me bring in a similar amendment to No. 24 on Report Stage. My amendments will have to be re-amended before——
Comment on this
I should like to see somebody read out what the section would be like with the two amendments in it.
Comment on this
The Minister should explain himself. I am assuming he is forced to accept No. 24 and he is trying to withdraw his own amendment in a subtle kind of way. He has indicated he may change it for Report Stage. I am assuming he is doing that because possibly he is afraid to face the division lobby on his own amendment now. He cannot afford to face it in view of the viewpoints expressed by his supporters. The Minister should clarify the point. Is he withdrawing the amendment reducing £500 to £250 and accepting the alternative amendment to delete £500 and substitute £750?
Comment on this
I want to get my own amendment agreed to — bringing it down to £250. The only way I can achieve that is to ask the House to pass the amendments I have put down and, on Report Stage, to bring Deputy Leneghan's idea into it. It cannot be done at this stage. Deputy M.P. Murphy should not accuse me of being afraid. I think I have shown some courage up to this.