We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1963—Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 363–559 of 559. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1963
Enacted

No. 14 of 1963 ›

Can the amendment not be withdrawn? Amendments have been withdrawn before.

Comment on this

Nos. 25 and 28 will have to be amended.

Comment on this

It is very difficult to see any difference between Nos. 23 and 24.

Comment on this

The difference between £250 and £750.

Comment on this

No. 23 refers to page 31, line 13, where the figure £500 occurs. The Minister says £500 should be deleted and substituted by £250. Deputies Leneghan and Sherwin propose, in line 13, page 31, to delete £500 and to make it £750. Surely they are two amendments directly opposed to each other?

Comment on this

No, they are not. Fine Gael laugh because they are incapable of understanding a thing like this. They do not try, perhaps. But they ought to try to take these things seriously or, if not, they should go away and allow someone else to carry on. I shall explain the position again. Perhaps the Labour Party are serious about this and will listen to me: Fine Gael will not. No. 23 refers to people who are getting their goods from untaxed sources and therefore they must be brought down to £250, in my opinion.

Comment on this

So would No. 24.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It refers to the same line.

Comment on this

It still remains the position that if you accept amendment No. 23, you are taking out of the list certain small shopkeepers with a turnover between £250 and £500 and you are increasing the number who, themselves, have to be responsible for turnover tax by accepting amendment No. 23.

Comment on this

They are two direct opposites. How can the Minister say he can alter this in any way? He refers to the one set of figures—£500 down to £250 or £500 up to £750. It is on exactly the same lines.

Comment on this

Does this amendment not mean that shopkeepers with a turnover of more than £3,000 must now be registered and be responsible for the collection of the taxes on retail sales? The opposite amendment means that shopkeepers with a turnover of less than £9,000 will be exempted from registration and will not be responsible for the collection of tax at retail level. Is that not the difference—that one amendment states that shopkeepers having less than £3,000 are exempted from collecting the tax on retail sales? The alternative amendment suggests that the figure £3,000 should be £9,000. Does this not involve a big number of shopkeepers—all those within the £3,000 to £9,000 turnover bracket?

Does it not include all those shopkeepers? Is that right or wrong?

Comment on this

It is wrong.

Comment on this

May be Deputy Leneghan could explain.

Comment on this

Nobody could explain to you.

Comment on this

Let us have it out, then.

Comment on this

Deputy Leneghan has put the Minister in an awful quandary.

Comment on this

Mind he does not put himself in a worse one.

Comment on this

A member of the House has asked the Minister to define the section. I have given him the definition. I would just ask him to say whether or not my definition is correct. The Minister should oblige a Deputy who asks him directly, through the Chair, to say whether or not that is the position. I shall repeat this. The Minister's amendment proposed to reduce those who will be exempted from registration and exempted from collecting the tax at retail level on a turnover of £6,000 annually to a turnover of £3,000 or less annually and the alternative amendment, if approved by the House, would exempt all those with a turnover of less than £9,000 annually. Is that the net position so far as the two amendments are concerned?

Comment on this

I have explained this more than once. The effect of my amendments, Nos. 23 and 25, taken together—the rest are consequential— is that a trader who buys his goods from a non-registered person, for example, from a farmer, where no tax is paid, can sell only up to £250 per month without registering himself. On the other hand, take a person who buys from a wholesaler who pays the tax— which would refer to the great majority of shops, grocers, drapers, and so on. As my amendments go, they can go up to £500 a month without registering. Now, Deputy Leneghan proposes that that go up to £750. I have no great objection to it.

Comment on this

You have.

Comment on this

But I have to insist on the £250 for those who are buying untaxed goods.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Does the line in the section show that distinction?

Comment on this

If the Minister wants to carry that point, he will have to withdraw No. 23 in order to get Nos. 24 and 25 carried, but he cannot have Nos. 23 and 24 together.

Comment on this

No. My suggestion is to agree to No. 23 and to withdraw No. 24 to the Report Stage.

Comment on this

Is No. 24 withdrawn?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has not been moved at all yet.

Comment on this

What is in the Bill is what will become law. We had enough about assurances when we had the Taoiseach telling us on 9th May, 1959, when discussing the Transport Bill, that there was no need to embody them in the Bill. He put that across at that time and subsequently dishonoured his assurances and obligations. Now the Minister for Finance wants us to accept a similar proposal from him that there is no need to embody this in the section. I believe he should withdraw this amendment and make it quite clear on Report Stage by redrafting the section. We will not accept these assurances any more, since the assurance we got from the Taoiseach was subsequently dishonoured.

Comment on this

If amendment No. 23 is out, amendment No. 24 may not be moved?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is so. Amendment put and declared carried.

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 71
·
Níl 68
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 24 not moved.

Comment on this

Why, sir?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It cannot be moved now. The House has taken a decision on the matter.

Comment on this

I understood that the proposer of this amendment voted for the decision which the House has just taken.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have nothing to say to that.

Comment on this

I want an explanation. I understand your ruling to be that Deputy Leneghan's and Deputy Sherwin's amendment cannot be moved because they voted for amendment No. 23.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I did not say that.

Comment on this

I want to know if that is so.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The matter has already been decided by the House.

Comment on this

Am I to understand that amendment No. 24 cannot be moved because the House has accepted amendment No. 23?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is right.

Comment on this

That is the amendment for which I understand the proposer and seconder of amendment No. 24 have just voted. I was wondering whether the two Deputies had passed through the Lobby standing on their heads.

Comment on this

This is a separate matter.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 25 is consequential on No. 23.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In subsection (3), to insert the following new paragraph before paragraph (b):

"(b) (i) Subject to subparagraph (ii) of this paragraph, a person who sells goods in the course of business, other than a person to whom paragraph (a) of this subsection applies, may at his discretion elect to be accountable for tax on the moneys received by him in relation to the activities in which he engages in a case in which those moneys have not in any month exceeded, and are not likely in any month to exceed, £500, and unless he so elects and subject to paragraph (d) of this subsection, tax shall not be chargeable and he shall not be accountable for tax on those moneys.

(ii) Subparagraph (i) of this paragraph shall apply if, but only if, not less than 90 per cent of the moneys received are received in respect of the sale of goods which have been procured by the seller from a person accountable for tax in respect of his sale of those goods."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In subsection (3), page 31, line 21, to insert "or paragraph (b)" after "paragraph (a)".

This is also consequential.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In subsection (3) page 31, line 33, to delete "£500" and substitute "£250".

Comment on this

I am sure the noblest Romans of them all will wish to contribute to a discussion on this amendment.

Comment on this

That is for the Chair. You get back to your circus.

Comment on this

We are listening with bated breath to hear what Deputies Sherwin and Leneghan have to say.

Comment on this

You are not ringmaster in a circus.

Comment on this

I am inviting Deputy Sherwin and Deputy Leneghan to give us their views.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 27.

Comment on this
Deputies

Chair.

Comment on this

The Chair knows his business.

Comment on this

Tell the people how you codded them about the fur coats.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 71
·
Níl 68
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 28 is consequential on amendment No. 27.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 28:

In subsection (3), to insert the following new paragraph before paragraph (d):

"(d) Where a person has not been accountable for tax by virtue of paragraph (b) of this subsection and the moneys received by him in relation to the activities in which he engages exceed £500 in each of two successive months, he shall become accountable for tax immediately on the expiration of the second month."

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would explain this amendment?

Comment on this

The effect will be that, if a person exceeds £500 in a month, then there will be no offence, but if he exceeds £500 in two successive months, then he must register.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to understand the purpose of inserting this amendment. Does the Minister propose to amend this amendment later?

Comment on this

Yes, it would be amended.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell us how this register of persons requirement will be compiled with? Will people have to submit their names or will the names be collected by the Revenue Commissioners?

Comment on this

They will have to apply for registration.

Comment on this

There will be a notice to that effect?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

What will the Minister do if they do not apply?

Comment on this

There is a penalty for non-registration.

Comment on this
Mr. Donnellan

What will the Minister do if they do not apply?

Comment on this

If the trader has a turnover of more than £500 for two successive months, he will be prosecuted if he does not apply for registration.

Comment on this

Will he be prosecuted on two counts—non-registration and non-payment of the tax?

Comment on this

He will be prosecuted for not registering and there is, of course, a penalty for not paying the tax.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps amendments Nos. 29 and 30 could be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In subsection (1), page 32 to insert "or hired" in line 21 after "sold", to delete "seller or provider" in line 26 and substitute "person from whom the goods were bought or hired or by whom the services were provided" and to insert "or hire" in line 29 after "sale".

The Bill mentions the hire as well as the purchase of goods. This is to ensure that registered persons will be entitled to have goods hired to them free of tax in the same way as they are entitled to have goods and services free of tax. This is for people who are below the tax limit. Within the limit, they will be entitled to hire goods as well as buy them.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 30:

In subsection (2), page 32, to insert "or hired" in line 43 after "sold" and to delete in line 47 "the seller or provider" and substitute "that person".

Comment on this

What exactly does this mean?

Comment on this

It is designed to secure that goods withdrawn from stock will have to pay the tax. For instance, a grocer taking goods for his own household, or a man with a furniture shop taking furniture for his own household, will have to pay tax.

Comment on this

Is it suggested that a small shopkeeper in rural Ireland who takes half an ounce of snuff out of a tin for an elderly person living with him in his own home will be liable to tax on that pinch of snuff?

Comment on this

The Deputy is citing an extreme case.

Comment on this

I admit that.

Comment on this

A small shopkeeper is not likely to be registered and it will not apply, but if he is a large shopkeeper and if he does nothing more than take a pinch of snuff, I think we will let him go.

Comment on this

If a grocer takes groceries, does he pay the 2½ per cent on the wholesale price?

Comment on this

The retail price.

Comment on this

That seems to be unfair in view of the fact that the wholesale price was more or less the purchase price for his use. But it is the retail price in fact?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

It will have to be.

Comment on this

He is not going to charge himself a profit.

Comment on this

There must be some limit to the degree in which we are prepared to legislate for the impossible. A grocer standing behind his counter can fix the retail selling price of his goods. The whole basis of the Minister's case is that a grocer can charge the turnover tax on any commodity in his stock on which he chooses to charge it but he need not charge it on some other commodity. There is nothing in this Bill, nor in the laws of the land that I know of, to restrict a grocer from selling tea at 4/6d. per lb. and then selling it to the next customer who comes in at 4/- a lb. Is there any limit or restriction or legal obligation on a shopkeeper to charge his customers any particular margin of profit on any particular item of goods? Is there not a legal practice in the large discount houses of selling goods below cost price for the purpose of inducing custom? If a self-service store in Dublin is seeking to knock out the small shopkeeper, it sells certain goods below cost. I understand that they will be asked under this law to pay turnover tax on the price they actually charge. I think I am right in that?

Comment on this

Yes, the current retail price.

Comment on this

Now we are legislating to say that if somebody sets up a self-service shop in any particular part of Dublin and for the purpose of wiping out all the local small shopkeepers and creating a monopoly of trade in a particular area, he is entitled to sell any commodity in his shop at any price he arbitrarily chooses to charge for it. However, if a grocer in Ballaghaderreen, or in Baltinglass, or Wexford, or Limerick, or even in Belmullet, chooses to charge himself the wholesale price for a commodity which he proposes to take from his own store for use in his own home, he is committing an offence punishable by imprisonment under this Bill. Surely that is carrying legislation for the impossible beyond the limits of sanity.

Does any Deputy desire to legislate that a shopkeeper in any part of Ireland who bona fide draws goods from his own shop for use in his home shall be liable to penalties which are not operative against a cut-price self-service store which is selling the goods next door to him, not at wholesale prices but substantially below wholesale prices, to his customers? That seems to me to be so flagrant an absurdity to enact that I urge the Minister not to persist in it.

Comment on this

I do not see any good argument for putting the 2½ per cent on the retail price. I assume that the turnover is based on the income from the retail sales. The shopkeeper buys goods at wholesale prices. I do not think we could stretch our imagination to the extent that we could imagine the shopkeeper actually selling goods to himself. He has paid the wholesale price and surely it should be sufficient to charge the 2½ per cent on that, where he takes goods for his own use. There has been, in fact, no retail sale. It would be as if he went to the other side of the counter and asked his wife, or the assistant, to pass him the money to make it a retail sale.

Comment on this

Deputies will have to agree that if you want to get this tax to work fairly, the person will have to account for any goods taken for his own consumption. If we were to say: "You can take all you like free of tax for your own house", there would be a great danger that he might be kind to his friends as well in regard to giving them goods and in his returns he might set out "so much supplied to my own household". We would have to stop that type of evasion. When you come to stop it, how can you deal with it? His customers are paying the retail price and the tax, to be fair, should be on the retail price as well. It would be difficult to have two prices, the wholesale for him and the retail for the others. In practice, of course, there will be an agreement. Any reasonable shopkeeper would have an agreement with the Revenue representative in regard to however it may work out. There might be £6 or £7 worth of goods supplied each week to the house and that will be the end of it.

Comment on this

It just occurs to me that it does not make much difference in any case. If I am in the furnishing business and I want to take a table out of stock for my own use and the wholesale price is £20, would it not be possible for me to say that the retail price is going to be the wholesale price? It is up to me to determine the price so that in respect of all items the shopkeeper is entitled to fix his own price and deem it to be the actual wholesale price.

Comment on this

As the Minister knows, there are throughout the country a number of small grocers— who are probably of sufficient size to come in under this tax—who sell their own produce from an orchard or a garden in their shops. There are the nurserymen who take flowers or shrubs for their own use. I am not sure whether both of these would come in under this category of exemptions applying to sales by farmers of their own produce. The Minister will appreciate, particularly in relation to the type of shop I am speaking of, that in the summer, the shopkeeper will sell appeals, or pears, or lettuce, or scallions in his shop. Is the position of that proprietor that, provided he takes them direct from his garden to the house, it is all right, but if he passes them through the shops and they are brought into stock for a period and then consumed in the house, they are in, but otherwise they are out?

Comment on this

I imagine that in such a case, where a shopkeeper has a farm or garden of his own, vegetables for his own house would be free. That type of case is better dealt with under amendments Nos. 23 to 28 which we have just passed. If a person is getting most of his goods from a farm and, say, is in the poultry or egg business, he would only be free of tax up to the £250 a month, not up to £500. I know there are shopkeepers in the country who sell one specific article from their own farms, say, butter, or milk, or cabbage, and it is not necessary to penalise these people so much. If they do not exceed 10 per cent of their sales from their farms, they could go up to £500.

Comment on this

Would the Minister deal with the point I raised?

Comment on this

Of course, in the case of articles such as a table or a piano, he could fix his own retail price.

Comment on this

It is also quite possible to get articles in the same category selling at varying prices in the same town.

Comment on this

As this section stands at present, a shopkeeper can send his wife outside the counter of his shop or commission her to act as a customer and I know of no provision in the law of this land that prevents a grocer or draper or furniture dealer putting any retail price he likes to the customer at the other side of the counter. There is no reason under the existing law why the proprietor of a cut-price shop in Dublin, desiring to attract to himself a particular customer whom he knows can give him a big amount of business, cannot say to that customer that he will quote him any price he likes in order to attract him. How do you then effectively legislate in the terms of Section 50 if you cannot prevent a shopkeeper from telling a customer that he will sell him a parcel of goods for 6d.? So far as I know, the shopkeeper is entitled to sell those goods at 6d. if he wants to do so.

There is no statutory definition of a retail price and there is no obligation on anyone to sell goods at a profit. I suggest to the Minister that Section 50 is unenforceable and that any attempt to enforce it would be unjust. You cannot say to a grocer that he must sell goods to his wife or to anyone else at a price that would make him a profit. We all know that there are retail distributors selling goods at prices substantially below cost. How can the Minister say that the shopkeeper who sells to the public below the retail price is breaking the law? It is fantastic to pass laws in this House which have no meaning. Anyone with any experience of the retail trade knows that Section 50 has no meaning.

Comment on this

What about the publican who drinks whiskey out of his own bottle?

Comment on this

We all know the price of whiskey.

Comment on this

But how do we know how much he drinks?

Comment on this

May I suggest to the Minister that he is cutting across the established procedure of the Revenue Commissioners in their dealings with retail traders who are accustomed to keep accounts of goods drawn from their own stocks for their own use which are accounted to them at cost price. You cannot make a profit out of yourself. You are asking these people to pay a retail tax on goods sold to themselves.

Comment on this

Possibly the grocery trade is not the best example. I do not know a lot about the purchase of groceries but I do appreciate that in respect of many of the articles bought by the ordinary housewife, tea, sugar, butter, jams and jellies, there is some regularity in the price. I do not think it is fair that the owner should have to pay the tax on the retail price of goods used by himself but it is fair that he should pay it on the wholesale price. As I said, the grocery trade is not the best example but there is great variation in price in the hardware trade and in the drapery trade. I suggest that the Revenue Commissioners are going to have a difficult time if they try to establish the retail price for all the commodities in a hardware shop or a drapery shop. You cannot say that such-and-such is the retail price of any article in a small town.

If this tax is to be collected every month, the inspectors will have to determine, for the purpose of a proprietor taking goods from stock for the use of his family, what is to be the retail price of hundreds of articles in a hardware or drapery shop. I think the Revenue Commissioners' job could be done much more easily if the tax in respect of these people were related to the wholesale rather than to the retail prices.

Comment on this

Related to the cost price.

Comment on this

Yes, to the cost price.

Comment on this

This is a retail tax and, therefore, it would appear illogical not to take that tax at the retail price. It can be taken at the current retail price and I do not think there will be any great difficulty at arriving at what is the current retail price. I agree with Deputy Dillon that a man can sell his goods at any price he likes. A man can sell tea at one shilling a lb, if he wants to, but if he starts that, his business would become so big that he could not deal with it. The Revenue Commissioners hope that this will work out by coming to an arrangement with the persons concerned. They can agree to take the figure of £6 or £7 a week and that will be the end of it.

Comment on this

The Minister will find it very hard to get any agreement with the business people of this country after the introduction of this tax.

Comment on this

Is the Minister not creating a very dangerous precedent? The Revenue Commissioners can say to me: "We will settle with you for £5 a week". But they do not like Sweetman——

Comment on this

It is quite possible.

Comment on this

——and they say to him: "We will charge you £7". Where exactly are we to stop at that sort of game? The importance of any law is that everyone is equal before it.

Comment on this

Some more equal than others.

Comment on this

Unfortunately, that has been the truth throughout the country. The Constitution lays down that everybody is equal before the law but we are creating a contrary situation here. When the Minister says that the pinch of snuff is an extreme case, I should like to draw his attention to the case of the publican who has a shaky hand on the morning after the night before. He wants to take a half-one out of a bottle and he lets the darn bottle drop and spills the lot. Has he to pay tax on that?

Comment on this

No, he has not got cash for it.

Comment on this

Are we now creating a law which will bring the entire legal system into ridicule? I am afraid we are.

Comment on this

I am afraid Deputy MacEoin has turned his point in the wrong direction. We are legislating here to levy a tax on the whole community. Is there any reason why any one of them should be put in a more sheltered position than the other by being able to evade that tax? The man who sells goods must also pay the tax on commodities he uses in his own household. Surely that is equality before the law.

Comment on this

Our difficulty will be to administer it.

Comment on this

Let us take a suit of clothes, for example. In the centre of Dublin, in four different shops, you could have four different prices for the same suit. If a shopkeeper wants to withdraw a suit for his own use, which of the four prices will he charge?

Comment on this

His own, of course.

Comment on this

Every time he wanted to withdraw something, he could declare a five minute sale.

Comment on this

It is making the law silly.

Comment on this

Paragraph 10 of our little pamphlet on the proposals says:

Reasonable estimates of withdrawals for personal use will be accepted.

Comment on this

Does that not cover the whole thing?

Comment on this

Deputy MacEoin says it might be £7 in one place and £8 in another. Of course that would depend to a great extent on the size of the family and the living standards.

Comment on this

This is legislation. We are legislating that certain goods shall be charged at the retail price current at the time of the withdrawal. I suggest there is no such thing known to the law as the retail price current at the time of the withdrawal. As far as I know the law, the retail price of a commodity is the price at which the merchant sells it.

Comment on this

What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

The merchant's wife comes to the counter and wants the groceries for their common house. Is she not her husband's customer? If so, is he not entitled to charge her any price he likes for the goods he gives her?

Comment on this

That is too academic.

Comment on this

It is extremely practical. I want to know what does the law require a law-abiding citizen to do. I am informed by this section that he is required to charge the current retail price for the goods withdrawn for his own or his family's use. I suggest we are legislating for the impossible here. The Minister says the Revenue Commissioners are prepared to take a reasonable estimate. But is not any taxpayer entitled to say he does not agree on an estimate? I submit the Revenue Commissioners have no right under existing law to challenge that election on the part of any law-abiding citizen, and having made that election not to make any estimate in respect of weekly withdrawals, I submit that in accordance with the law he is entitled to give goods to his wife and family at a nominal figure.

Comment on this

Or to anybody.

Comment on this

Or to anybody. The fact is it is common knowledge to anybody reading the Garda Review that a list of shops is given to members of the Garda Síochána in which a specified discount is given. The INTO publication gives a similar list of shops where members of that organisation are given a specified discount. It appears to me that under Section 50 the shopkeeper will find himself in the astonishing position that while he is entitled to sell goods to members of those organisations, he is not entitled to assess the value of the goods at the same rate in respect of his own family. There are well-established trade practices through which a shopkeeper's staff buy goods at a marked down price of five or ten per cent below retail prices. Is it seriously argued that a shopkeeper serving his own family is not permitted to allow goods to them at the same prices as he sells to members of his staff?

While I condemn this tax unreservedly, if it is to be enacted into law, let us make it a thing that law-abiding citizens in this country can observe. That being so, I suggest Section 50 be omitted from the Bill. To suggest that we in Dáil Éireann deny to a shopkeeper the right to charge his own family the lowest price at which he has sold to anybody coming into his shop is fantastic. It is utterly wrong to place such an obligation on a body of people who are, after all, self-respecting, decent, law-abiding, whose rights should be regarded with some respect by this Legislature.

Comment on this

The Minister quoted paragraph 10 of the pamphlet to the effect that reasonable estimates of withdrawals will be accepted. It has already been pointed out, and I think it must be emphasised again, that neither what is in the pamphlet nor what the Minister says is the law. What will be the law is what is in Section 50 of the Bill when it becomes an Act, not what is in the pamphlet. Irrespective of what is in the pamphlet or of what the Minister may say, it is open to the Revenue Commissioners or any other authority concerned to say in later years: "The law is what is set out in Section 50 and that is the only law that will be applied in this respect. No longer will we do business on the basis of estimates, however reasonable they may be".

It is necessary the House should understand that clearly. I accept the proposal that it should be accepted on the basis of the shopkeeper's estimate, but we must understand that that may not continue to be so. Assuming the Minister is able to satisfy the House on the question of a definition, if that is possible, of the retail price current at the time of the withdrawal, the other consequences of which I speak may occur later and this idea of agreeing on an estimate may go by the board.

Secondly, I want to get clarification from the Minister on this point. Section 50 deals not only with the withdrawal by a person for his own use but with the withdrawal by a person of goods from stock for his own use or for the use of any other person. The Minister must know that very frequently in this country where sales, bazaars or functions of one sort or another are run in aid of charities, it is quite a common custom for businessmen to give gifts out of stock. We do it by way of food for consumption at a function or flowers for decorating a church, or so on. I should like to know from the Minister if those will be chargeable now with tax as withdrawals from stock, even though they are not for the person's own use and are intended purely for charitable purposes of that sort.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

This is the longest lasting stock that I can remember.

Comment on this

I have listened with great interest to what has been said from the opposite benches. I can understand their difficulty. I see Deputy A. Barry laughing: he is probably laughing at what he is hearing. A shopkeeper does not have to go through the performance described by Deputy Dillon of calling his wife down from upstairs and saying to her: "You need porridge for tomorrow's breakfast. Go out there and buy it." It is all nonsense. The purpose of this section is to cover whatever the shopkeeper uses, whether he pays or not. As a matter of fact, the turnover tax does not specifically say cash sales only. It includes also credit sales.

The purpose of this section is that the shopkeeper, at whatever price he sells his goods, will pay the 2½ per cent —if he does not come to an agreement with the Revenue Commissioners —on the consumption by himself and his family of those goods.

Comment on this

How is the price arrived at?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins seems to think that everybody is naive. He brings up the instance of the shopkeeper who gives a present of something from his shop on a charitable occasion and asks if he is to pay 2½ per cent turnover tax on that. Surely Deputy O'Higgins is wise enough to know that if he or I—as we often do— give subscriptions to charity, we are not allowed any relief in income tax in respect of our gift. He knows that.

Comment on this

What is the relevancy?

Comment on this

It is that if the shopkeeper wants to be charitable, it is out of his own pocket the charity comes and not from the State.

Comment on this

But does he pay the tax? That is the question.

Comment on this

Of course he will.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong.

Comment on this

He is taking it himself for the purpose of giving it as his gift for this charitable occasion. Therefore, he is liable to pay the 2½ per cent on the value of his gift, whatever it may be.

Comment on this

He does pay: is that the answer to the question?

Comment on this

I am trying to be polite. The answer is that when you or I, as we often do, give a subscription in cash to charity, it is out of our net income and we get no income tax allowance for that gift.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

In the same way, if I choose, instead of cash, to give something in kind, I am taking it from my stocks for my own purposes. Therefore, I am liable for the 2½ per cent tax.

Comment on this

So the answer is yes?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

You are quite wrong.

Comment on this

I am not. If I use it for my own purpose, in my own home, it is no different from taking it and giving it as a gift. It is my gift. Therefore, I am liable for whatever taxation there is on it, and the cost of it is out of my own pocket.

Deputy Dillon talked about a shop. Deputy A. Barry was talking about shops and Deputy MacEoin talked about the poor publican who was so bad in the morning that he could not pour himself a drink without dropping the bottle, and so on. These are all fantastic suggestions in relation to this matter. First of all, the poor shopkeeper is not involved. Only when he gets to a certain turnover per month does he become involved. He is liable to pay the turnover tax on his retail sale price—not the retail sale price of his neighbour or somebody in another city. We know all about these sales to which Deputy Dillon——

Comment on this

So Deputy Dillon is right.

Comment on this

He is not right. This is no shop price. It is on his own sales price that he pays the tax.

Comment on this

It may vary.

Comment on this

A shopkeeper can have an annual sale and can advertise goods that were sold at £5 and that can now be bought for 39/11d. He will pay the turnover tax on the 39/11d, which is now the retail price.

Comment on this

How often can he have a sale?

Comment on this

Weekly.

Comment on this

Every night at 9 o'clock. He will not get anybody except his own family.

Comment on this

How long will he last in business? Is it not nonsense to think that any man has his own shop for the purpose of obliging his friends?

Comment on this

No, his family.

Comment on this

Is there not a well-known saying in all trades that when you want to get something wholesale, you pay more than you would if you bought it retail? Those are the friends you have who give you wholesale. It is all nonsense that you are talking. This is the only equitable way it can be worked.

Comment on this

We are not all talking the same language.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in business himself and he knows. He can make any blend of tea he likes to sell at any price he likes. As the Minister said, if he is going to have a retail shop to sell tea at 1/- a lb., he will not be able to deal with the trade and how long can he last if he pays his wholesaler the price for the tea and sells it at about a quarter of its cost? Is that not all nonsense? Deputy O'Higgins is a professional man and I can understand his having some difficulty until he studies the matter a bit more. But the arguments used, in my opinion, are just nonsense.

Comment on this

May I take it that a shopkeeper who buys an article at a certain price and then sells retail at a profit must put himself in the position of a customer coming into his shop or does it mean that he must pay tax on what the article cost him as a shopkeeper?

Comment on this

On his retail price.

Mr. Donegan rose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would point out that the House has agreed to dispose of all sections up to and including Section 65, with their amendments, by 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

No, no—at 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this

A distinction without a difference.

Comment on this

No. You have to go on consecutively until 10.30 p.m.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There can be no discussion——

Comment on this

We can have it where we like. If we like to have it on this, that is our affair.

Comment on this

What is the Minister's opinion of this situation? In the window of a self-service store the other day, I saw butter advertised at 4/- per lb. It was being deliberately sold at less than cost in order to attract people to buy other goods. If this tax becomes law, the shopper will have to pay 2½ per cent, including the butter at 4/- per lb, at the exit. If I withdraw from my own shop a pound of butter for my family and charge myself 4/- for it, according to this I will be expected to give 2½ per cent to the Revenue on the current retail price.

Comment on this

Charges like this have been going on in income tax here for a long time.

Comment on this

Always at cost.

Comment on this

At cost, I admit. There is no difficulty about this matter.

Comment on this

There is no difficulty about determining costs.

Comment on this

How are you going to get the retail price?

Comment on this

We say at current prices in the shop.

Comment on this

Any court could drive six horses and carts through that definition.

Comment on this

It may be so. We have to lay down some rule. I do not think it will cause any great difficulty at all. There is no great difficulty about the amount or quantity being used, taking the wholesale price and making up what it all amounts to. In this particular case, they agree on the quantity that may be used. They say the current retail price is so and so and come to an agreement. I do not see why there should be so much difficulty put in the way of this section.

Comment on this

Supposing the retail price of the domestic article amounts to £20. That price includes, perhaps, £4 profit. In other words, to that man the actual cost was £16. But 2½ per cent on the current retail price of £20 would be 10/- whereas in fact the cost of the article to him was £16, on which the tax would be 8/-. He is therefore charged 2/- in respect of a profit he never made.

Comment on this

I dealt already with the point made by Deputy Dillon when speaking on the Budget. I know shopkeepers in Cork selling butter at 3/11 a lb., for which they paid 4/4, in order that the customer coming in may be got to buy a pair of nylons or some other drapery goods on which there is a profit of 50 per cent if they are Irish goods and 63 per cent if they are English goods. Those are the people who are saying they will have to close their doors if they have to pay this 2½ per cent.

Comment on this

That is a ridiculous assertion. Everybody knows that in the drapery trade there is a mark-up on goods of from 20 to 25 per cent. Deputy Corry's assertion does not do himself or anybody else any good. We have the Minister admitting that six horses and carts could be driven through a section of this Bill.

Comment on this

I did not admit that.

Comment on this

You said "perhaps" in reply.

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree with the point made by Deputy Rooney that the position under this is that a proprietor of a shop is now being charged what to him is an artificially high price on which tax will be levied? The position is at the moment that, if he withdraws goods from his own shop for his own use, he does not charge a profit against himself. It does not seem reasonable if this law is to be operated that he will have to regard himself as paying himself a profit and then charge himself tax on the profit as well.

Comment on this

In regard to my amendment No. 31, I assume the Minister is not going to do this and therefore I am not moving my amendment. He is not going to breach the privilege of the client?

Comment on this

I do not see how it could be done.

Comment on this

I am advised it could be done, but I am assuming that is not the intent.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 32:

Before subsection (3), to insert the following new subsection:

"(3) Where it is shown to the satisfaction of the Revenue Commissioners that—

(a) any part of the taxable turnover of an accountable person in any month consisted of moneys paid under a contract entered into before the 1st day of August, 1963, which provides for the sale or hire of goods or the provision of services at prices or charges fixed before that day, or

(b) any part of the taxable turnover of an accountable person in the month of November, 1963, or any of the four months next following that month consisted of moneys received in respect of goods sold or hired or services provided before the 1st day of August, 1963, the Revenue Commissioners may repay the tax paid on that part or, at their discretion, allow it to be set off against the tax payable in any month."

The points arising on this amendment have already been discussed and I do not think there is any necessity to discuss them again.

Comment on this

I move my amendment to amendment No. 32:

To delete "1st day of August, 1963" where these words twice occur and substitute "1st day of November, 1963".

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted from amendment No. 32 stand".

Tá 71
·
Níl 0
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 33:

To add to the section the following new subsection:

"(5) Where an order which was made before the passing of this Act under Section 12 of the Court Officers Act, 1945, contains a reference to levy under a certificate issued under Section 7 of the Finance Act, 1923, that reference shall be construed as including a reference to levy under a certificate issued under the said Section 7 as extended by this section."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 34:

In subsection (2), page 35, line 45, to delete "or (4)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 35:

In subsection (5), page 36, line 10, to delete "or (4)".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 36:

In subsection (3), page 37, line 14, to insert "document," before "record".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 37:

To add to subsection (2), the following new paragraph:

"(f) any article which is declared by the Minister for Finance by order to be an article not chargeable with tax on being imported into the State."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 38:

To add to subsection (2):

"but no order shall be made under that Act for the purpose of increasing the rate of the tax or extending the classes of activities or goods in respect of which tax is for the time being chargeable."

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 39:

To add to the section the following new subsection:

"(3) Section 39 of the Inland Revenue Regulation Act, 1890, is hereby amended by the insertion of `turnover tax,' before `stamp duties'."

Comment on this