Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1963—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–155 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
I received a notification from the Chair, as did some other Deputies who had their names to amendments, that my amendment was ruled out of order because it would impose a charge on State funds. I respectfully suggest a mistake has been made in this case because the acquisition of land is not a direct charge on State funds. Perhaps the Ceann Comhairle would have another look at the matter? It is very serious in relation to this Bill. It is financed in a certain way and not directly out of State funds.
Comment on this
There is the point about the amount of money available in land bonds. The House is asked to increase that amount from £15 million to £20 million and it is out of that that the money comes for the acquisition of land.
Comment on this
Surely the loan the Government get by way of land bonds is State funds? There can be no question about that.
Comment on this
If the additions Deputies seek are imposed, it would involve an increase in the charge.
Comment on this
We do not want to make a big point about this. Surely the section is merely permissive—the Land Commission may acquire if they so desire?
Comment on this
There may be a technical way out of it. The Land Commission can do only a certain amount of work. If they do the work suggested in the amendment, it will not be any extra charge because the other work they do will take place the following year.
Comment on this
I cannot go into all these technicalities. There is no doubt whatever that some of the amendments, if adopted, would impose a charge.
Comment on this
The Chair ruled amendment No. 12 standing in my name out of order. It is to the effect that the Land Commission shall provide in every year not fewer than 50 farms. I had intended that they would be given to people at an economic rent so that they would be paying for them themselves.
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled. Is it the last word or may we make submissions when the Chair rules out an amendment—
Comment on this
I am ruling that that money comes out of State funds and no Deputy may move that, except a Minister of State.
Comment on this
This is rather an extraordinary position. The Ceann Comhairle having ruled on this matter, that appears to be the end of it. I have great respect for the Ceann Comhairle but he could have made a mistake. An error could have been made. We have discussed this among ourselves and while we have not as much experience as the Ceann Comhairle, we think a genuine error has been made. We feel that the desire that the Land Commission would have the right to acquire, if they thought fit, lands which——
Comment on this
That is not making a case against my ruling. It is making a case against a provision in a Standing Order which makes me rule them out.
Comment on this
I am making the case that this does not say that it will cost the State money. That being so, I cannot see how it can be ruled that it is a charge on State funds.
Comment on this
I have endeavoured to explain the position to the Deputy. I have written to him and said it is liable to impose a charge on public funds and therefore I cannot allow it.
Comment on this
My experience of the Ceann Comhairle for over 20 years is that I have never seen him make a mistake.
Comment on this
The rulings of the Chair have always been in accordance with fact. However, one of the amendments is in fact relieving the State of an obligation to incur the charges. My amendment reads:
Before section 6 to insert a new section as follows:
"The Land Commission shall provide in every year not fewer than fifty farms for the purpose of letting them to such young farmers as the Land Commission may decide for a period of not less than ten years."
I had intended, in respect of those farms, that the tenant would pay the full economic rent, thus relieving the State of the obligation of payment.
Comment on this
Would it be in order to ask for the numbers of the amendments that have been ruled out of order?
Comment on this
On amendment No. 12, I appreciate the position—that a Deputy on this side of the House, or indeed any Deputy other than a Minister, cannot move an amendment which will result in a charge being imposed on public funds — but in relation to Deputy Flanagan's amendment No. 12, with all respect, I do not see how it can be ruled out on that basis without allowing discussion on it, because whether or not a charge would arise on foot of this amendment depends entirely on the arguments in support of the amendment.
Comment on this
We are saying to the Minister that the land already acquired be used to provide those farms. It would mean, in fact, that the Exchequer would be relieved because the lands would be let at economic rents.
Comment on this
That is so. The Ceann Comhairle is aware, as every Deputy is, that the Land Commission acquire land and that for years, sometimes, that land is not divided.
Comment on this
The point that weighed with the Chair was that the amendment seeks to provide 500 farms and therefore these farms must be acquired by money out of public funds.
Comment on this
Perhaps that is where the Chair went wrong. If we knew where the Chair got the 500 farms from——
Comment on this
I should like to deal with amendment No. 32 and refer the Chair to section 26 which states that the Land Bond Act is amended by the substitution of £20 million for £15 million. When that section is passed, the money is available and what we are asking in amendment No. 32 will not mean any increase in the demand on State funds.
Comment on this
Even if the money were paid immediately afterwards, State funds had to be used to acquire the land.
Comment on this
Is it not a matter of opinion as to who says priority should be established for certain lands? The reason we are so anxious about it is that even the Minister has said there is power to acquire land retrospectively.
Comment on this
The Land Commission must use State money. That is the only thing they can use to acquire land.
Comment on this
We are not asking for extra money. We are asking for money that will have been voted under section 26.
Comment on this
If that amendment were carried, State money would have to be used to carry out the work.
Comment on this
An ordinary Deputy is not entitled to move an amendment which would involve an extra charge on public funds. Deputy McQuillan is advocating something which would impose an extra charge. I am sorry, but I cannot allow discussion on it.
Comment on this
It seems an extraordinary thing that to suggest to the Minister he should use lands already acquired——
Comment on this
Supposing there was a proposal to the effect that a register of aliens who purchased land be compiled, would that not mean an extra charge?
Comment on this
That would be purely departmental administration. Amendment No. 32 would be a new provision altogether. It has to go into the legislation. I am afraid I must rule it out.
Comment on this
I do not know whether there is any appeal against this ruling of the Chair. Anyhow, it will not be reached this evening.
Comment on this
Everybody knows the Ceann Comhairle is a very reasonable man, a man of great commonsense and intelligence. The problem here involves his opinion and the opinion of Deputies. The only problem is a difference of opinion.
Comment on this
This is not something that arose today or yesterday. It has been arising while I have been in the House. It has been arising during the past 25 years.
Comment on this
Relating my remarks again for a moment to amendment No. 12, if the Minister agreed with the Deputies' interpretation of the effects of the amendment that it would not impose any charge other than that already in existence, would that not influence the Chair to some extent?
Comment on this
For what my opinion is worth, I do not see how the Ceann Comhairle could rule otherwise than the way he has ruled. Without going into the merits or demerits of the amendment, it would be disastrous for a congest if the amendment went in because it would mean that half the land acquired by the Land Commission would go to those people at the expense of the congests. If 50 farms are to be given, the land must be bought and the money provided out of public funds.
Comment on this
Irrespective of the merits or demerits of the amendment, I do not see how the Ceann Comhairle could rule otherwise.
Comment on this
If the Minister's argument is correct, then he should accept amendment No. 32 because we are telling him in it how he can get land.
Comment on this
If the Deputies object to my ruling, they have a perfectly legitimate way of testing it. I shall not feel a bit annoyed about it. Deputies are quite within their rights. That is the only method by which the ruling of the Chair can be tested.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, lines 19 and 20, after "a holding" to insert "or land".
I think, Sir, amendments Nos. 1 and 2 could be discussed together. They are associated principally with section 14 and deal with Land Commission nominees. My purpose is to ensure that the provisions of that section are flexible enough to apply them to any holding of land or part or parcel of land or incorporeal hereditament. The matter will be dealt with when we come to discuss section 14. I ask the House to accept these amendments as textual improvements. They are designed to make section 14 more flexible and not to tie the hands of the Land Commission in dealing with section 14.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 3, line 21, after "an incorporeal hereditament" to insert "in whole or in part".
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us what difference there is between the new congested areas envisaged and the old conception of the congested areas under the Congested Districts Board?
Comment on this
Under this Bill, the congested areas are those already prescribed by law. The Deputy will find them in the Second Schedule to the Bill. They comprise: Donegal, Galway, Kerry, Leitrim, Mayo, Roscommon and Sligo; the portion of the county of Clare comprising the former rural districts of Ballyvaughan, Ennistymon, Kilrush, Scariff, Tulla and Killadysert; and the portion of West Cork comprising the former rural districts of Bantry, Castletown, Schull and Skibbereen. These were laid down under the 1909 Land Act. As the Deputy appreciates, there is a section enabling the Minister to bring in, in addition to these already defined congested areas, a declaration that any part of the country is a congested area.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister will agree that, apart from the districts to which he has referred, there are other great pockets of congestion which are equally as congested as those defined?
Comment on this
That is the very reason for another section in the Bill to enable the Minister to bring in any portion as a congested area. For the first time, that is being written into our law. We felt that, outside the existing congested districts as defined, there are pockets of congestion in different parts of the country. That is why we have this section giving power to the Minister from time to time to schedule any further pocket of congestion outside the areas set out in the Schedule.
Comment on this
Does the Minister see any danger in this definition that the provisions of the Bill and of the Land Acts generally will be directed towards the acquisition of land in the congested areas as such rather than in the areas outside the congested areas where the land is really available? I think the present method whereby the Minister is enabled to define what a congested area is and has discretion as regards the type of land is a most unsatisfactory method of dealing with the definition of congestion. That should be widened to include the congested areas in every county and it should be decided at a certain stage what a congested area is. Let every county where there is congestion be so described.
Comment on this
Section 4, subsection (2), sets out more or less, but in a very loose way, how the Minister will define a congested area. The Minister is going to take into account the size of holding and the type of farming to be carried on. What would be the Minister's reaction to an area which was once an area of smallholdings— and, in fact, still is—but where the majority of the smallholders have now vacated their houses and locked them up? Should the Minister not take that fact into account—that the majority of holdings in an area are either derelict or vacant because they are too small to keep a family or the owners are in England or America, some of them perhaps hoping to come back and resettle after they have earned some money? I do not think it is sufficient to take into account the size of the holding only. That could be very misleading. An area could be called a deserted area when, in fact, it is not.
Comment on this
What will the Minister require before him to make an order declaring a new congested area? From my experience, there are pockets of great congestion in every county, even in Meath. On what information will the Minister make an order declaring a congested area? Will he give us some more information in relation to that?
Comment on this
It is quite true, as Deputy Flanagan has suggested, that there are probably congested areas to be found in every county in Ireland. I have no doubt that if one went into the highways and byways, one could get the odd village or area in which there is congestion. But there must be an order of priority; first things must come first. That is why I adopted the definition of congested areas from the 1909 Act to start off with. These are the areas of the most intense congestion we have, the areas which were down through the years regarded by all and sundry, even in the old Congested Districts Board days, as being the areas of most intense congestion and the areas that should first be dealt with from the point of view of giving relief to those who live there.
As far as the counties outside those specified here are concerned, I have no doubt that when this section comes to be discussed I shall have many Deputies from different parts of the House asking that their counties be included. It is as well for me to anticipate this argument by giving the reasoning I am giving now. Under this Bill, many things will happen which did not happen previously. We have the new type of holding to which we aspire, the new type of division, the new provision in respect of pockets of congestion enabling people to solve their own congestion and so forth. It is only in the working out of this Bill that the Land Commission officials will get the necessary experience to enable them to advise the Minister as to what areas must be brought in step by step. It will take some time, for instance, to build up the necessary organisation and staff to deal with the provisions I am asking the House to enable the Land Commission to bring into force under this Bill.
I thought that the best way of dealing with this matter—and certainly it is quite obvious to the Deputies who are familiar with this problem—was to start with the areas where we know there is intense congestion, the areas that always were regarded as the congested areas, and, from time to time, as the Land Commission get geared for the job to enable them to advise the Minister, to bring in another pocket of congestion in any particular county in accordance with the experience that they may derive.
The point was raised by Deputy Blowick about deserted houses on holdings that the Land Commission have already dealt with. The answer is that any holding that is not up to the new standard, whether they got additions before from the Land Commission or not or whether they were re-arranged before by the Land Commission or not, will come in under this Bill and if these people are within the distance qualification of land to be divided they are entitled to get an addition or to be considered for an addition.
In many cases, particularly a number of years ago, the Land Commission, depending upon what land was available, were bringing people up to perhaps £4 or £5 valuation and then vesting the holdings and writing them off and, as Deputy Blowick well knows, once they were vested and once there had been a re-arrangement scheme you had no business coming to the Land Commission for improvement works or anything else. They regarded themselves as having finished with that area, townland or village.
In many of these cases, by present day standards, those units are completely uneconomic. It is true that in respect of some of them the people have gone. One of the purposes of this Bill is to stabilise the rural population that is on the land and in the congested areas where there are these deserted or vacant holdings—there are other sections of this Bill that deal with this very point—they are going to be taken over to try to build up the land structure for the people left in these congested areas. Whether, as I have said, they had already got Land Commission additions or not, the aim is, in so far as the land that is available goes, to bring them up to the new concept of a family farm in this day and age.
Comment on this
I want to ask only one question. In the definitions section for the definition of "congested area" one is referred to section 4 and the Minister has told us that the Second Schedule contains the congested areas —Donegal, Galway, Kerry, Leitrim, Mayo, Roscommon, Sligo, parts of Clare and parts of West Cork. I am informed by the Minister that these were scheduled as congested areas in 1909. Does the Minister see any case, or has he any evidence before him to show, that any of these places need not now be deemed to be a congested area?
Comment on this
Sligo and Roscommon, yes. I gather that areas that are in congested areas have preference in the allocation of land. Surely if there were a congested area in, say, Offaly or Meath or some place like that it would be unfair that somebody in part of, say, Mayo, in what is now not considered a congested area, would get preference over somebody living in a congested area in Laois, Offaly or Meath?
Comment on this
If Deputy Corish will consider the vast section of our seaboard that is comprised in this Schedule I think he will do some rethinking on this question. There is the whole of Donegal, the whole of Galway, the whole of Kerry, the whole of Leitrim, Mayo, Roscommon and the whole of Sligo as well as portions of Clare and portions of West Cork. That comprises a very big stretch of our country and these are the areas in which the intense congestion is.
One of the main purposes of these sections is to give priority to these counties on the question of migration because in many of these counties you still have the hard core of intense congestion that the Land Commission or even their predecessors, the Congested Districts Board, failed to solve. The easier jobs have been dealt with. The estates that were easier of re-arrangement have been dealt with. As I have been pointing out, most of those that were easily solved have already been dealt with and in the main the rundale estates that are left in these congested counties are the hard core of the congestion. There are cases which have proved, in fact, to be insoluble up to the moment for one reason or another mainly, perhaps, because the people either would not agree to a scheme or would not agree to migrate out of these areas, and so on.
There are some powers being taken in this Bill by way of inducement to try to solve this hard core of rundale estates and it is only in the counties mentioned in the Schedule to this Bill, as far as my knowledge goes, that there are rundale estates left in this country, only in these intensely congested counties, and I am sure if Deputies think about this matter they will agree that in the order of priority of things these must be dealt with first.
There is power being taken for the first time here to schedule congested areas in any part of the country and it is the intention, at all events, of the Land Commission that immediately they get near to the job their officials will report to them, no matter in what county they are working, if there is a pocket of congestion. They will report to them to have it scheduled and they propose to bring this in or advise the Minister to bring this in.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Corish's point was that even in the listed congested counties in the Second Schedule there would be areas, some large, some small, that are comfortable or well off and, even though in a congested county, could scarcely be described as congested areas. Such areas do exist and Deputy Corish's fear was that simply because a county was listed as a congested county these comfortable or well off areas, whatever you like to call them, within the congested counties, would get preference or priority and still another slice of the cake, regardless of congestion in non-listed counties. Is that the point? I think the Minister missed Deputy Corish's point. I put it that it is a very cogent one, in this connection at any rate.
Comment on this
I was anxious to hear from the Minister. He did tell us that these congested districts were defined in 1909. Does it not speak badly for the Land Commission that the same congestion exists in these areas in 1964 as existed in 1909? Further, is it not possible that the Government of the time may have had reasons for leaving out certain areas which were congested areas but in respect of which there was sufficient pull at the time to bring them out of the scope of congested areas? Further, the Minister must agree that in parts of Wicklow, parts of Monaghan and parts of Laois, as well as other areas, there is equally as great congestion as exists in the counties outlined in the Second Schedule.
That is why I feel that the time has come for complete reconsideration of the congested areas. There are many districts which can be described as congested areas. Steps should be taken to see that they are given the same treatment under this Bill as will be given to the areas already defined as congested areas.
Comment on this
There is something which I think could have been done in the Bill and perhaps the Minister could consider it. Deputy Corish pointed out that whole counties put down here are described as being congested districts. It is true that many portions of these counties are not congested. As a matter of fact, we find areas in East Donegal with land as good as, if not better, than we find in County Meath, and the same applies to other counties — perhaps, Galway and Mayo. Should opportunity not have been taken to do what has been done here with Clare and West Cork, to put down portions of these counties rather than have the whole county designated? In Meath, for instance, we have Meath Hill, Drumconrath, Newcastle, Oldcastle — the Minister knows that area — where many farmers are trying to exist on very small farms. All the land they have is an acre here and two acres somewhere else. It is scattered all over the place. That would be comparable with the position in the real congested areas. Occasionally, the Department take the people out and give them a transfer holding somewhere else. I think an attempt should be made by the Land Commission to designate all congested areas in the country, and take out of the congested districts the areas not so congested.
That is one point, but there is a second point, and I wonder has the Minister given any consideration to it. As we all know, hundreds of people have been brought from outside the county into County Meath. The first group of people who came, actually the first 200 or 300, came to farms of around 15 to 20 acres, some of which is pretty bad land. Where do they stand in relation to congests in the areas they came from? They have now neighbouring farms of 40 to 45 acres.
Comment on this
It would be hard to designate them as congests because Meath is not included in the Bill. It is a dangerous situation and I think the Minister should take cognisance of it. The position is that we have the local smallholders who were there when those people were brought in first and who did not get any additional holding. There is a feeling of unrest among those people and the Minister might as well know that, in Meath, the ideal holding is one of 40 to 45 acres. Endeavours should be made to achieve this whenever land becomes available in the area. The early migrants and the smallholders, who were there at the time, instead of getting an increased viable holding, might now find that further congests might be brought to that area. I think that is the main objection to the Bill. The result will be that those people will still be left in a semi-congested condition. I do not know whether the Minister can do anything about this, but I seriously suggest that he should look at it. If something is not done about it, the last situation could be much worse than the first.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to say if there is any objection from this point of view to dealing with the matter on the basis suggested by Deputy Tully. That was the suggestion I was about to make to the Minister. I think the Minister might take it for granted that there is no Deputy on any side of the House who wants to see any of those old-time congested districts, if you like to call them that, taken out of the legislation. I think everyone recognises that in all of these old-time congested districts congestion still exists. The Minister indicated, in reply to Deputy Corish, that in some of them the congestion is now appreciably less than it was and it would seem to me, if you like, a more modern approach to this question, if the Minister were not simply to accept the 1909 definition but if he were to look at the matter from the point of view of the realities of the situation as in 1964. I think he would be doing a good day's work to come into the House with a new list of scheduled areas which would be realistic, having regard to the 1964 situation.
The point which was first put by Deputy Corish, and then by Deputy Blowick, is, I think, the fear that exists under the definition as it stands at the moment. Anyone in the areas set out in the Second Schedule would, prima facie, seem to be entitled to more favourable consideration, to put it that way, no matter in what part of a particular county he lives, as against a person living in another county which is not in the scheduled list. It may be that the Minister's reply to that will be that it is not scheduled now, but under paragraph (b) of section 4, he has power to add it. Most Deputies would feel happier if the Minister's approach were to try to give us in this Bill a 1964 definition of congested districts, basing it more or less on the last two portions of the Second Schedule.
Mr. Rooney rose.
Comment on this
I should like to support what has been said in relation to the definition of congested areas. I take a very poor view of this Bill. From my point of view, it is a completely biassed Bill. Apparently the Minister could not find any congests in the whole Twenty-Six Counties, except in the counties which have a shore along the Atlantic.
Comment on this
I shall just look down this list quickly. Apparently the Minister in this Bill has only found congests in places like Donegal, Galway, Kerry, Leitrim, Mayo, Roscommon, Sligo, a portion of County Clare and a portion of West Cork. The rest of the country is completely disregarded and no proper recognition is given to the fact that there are many congested areas throughout the Twenty-Six Counties apart from the places mentioned. It is very painful for a number of small farmers in County Dublin or, indeed, in many other places when they see a large estate taken over by the Irish Land Commission and when the question of distributing that land is being considered the congests are selected from the areas specified in the Bill. They are given special priorities.
There is a remarkable difference in the conditions available to persons removed from any of the specified places when it comes to the payment of rents and the conditions under which they hold their farms. The other congests will be at a very great disadvantage if they do not come from some of these places. Presumably the cost of purchasing the holdings into which these people are put is met by the taxpayers generally in every county but when it comes to the question of equal rights, only a specified number of citizens will get the privileges available under this Bill as listed in the Second Schedule.
That is why I think the Minister, when considering amendments, should bring in one to ensure that smallholders, wherever they reside, will have equal rights regarding the distribution of holdings. I have seen holdings taken over in County Dublin and given to migrants, while at the same time small farmers who know how to use the land in that area and know the conditions there, did not get any relief or assistance, although they were convenient to these large estates which were being divided by the Land Commission and could have used them to great advantage. If a privilege is being given to people who are not resident within a short distance of these estates, at least a proportion of the estate should be made available to small farmers residing near them.
Comment on this
Judging by the numbers in the Opposition benches tonight, it is perfectly obvious they are now properly under the Whip after the "walloping" they got——
Comment on this
It arises in that after getting the kick they got, I do not think the Minister should take them very seriously. Whatever he might do or has done, at least his actions are to be much preferred to those of the Opposition who did nothing when they had a chance to do something. Down in front of me is the former Minister for Lands, Deputy Blowick. I do not want to say anything dirty about him. I shall let him go. He never did anything when he was Minister. I hope the present Minister, who comes from within a few miles of Deputy Blowick's native place, will long continue on the course he has now charted for himself. If he does, he will do something worthwhile, not only for the West of Ireland but for the country in general.
If anybody is to improve the land position, he must take drastic steps. The situation is completely unnatural. It is none of our making. A situation was created years ago by foreign tyrants which we must undo. They took drastic measures to chase us out of the midlands. I do not happen to be one of those who came from the midlands. I came from the north to fight against the British, unlike some of those who ran away from the midlands. If we are to rectify the position, we must send back to the midlands those who were chased out of it, whether we or they like it. We must restore the balance. We have a very low population in the midlands where there is the best land not only in Ireland but probably in the world. It is rather amazing to hear somebody speak of Roscommon as a county which should be classified as a place where there is congestion. Many of the people in Roscommon have three holdings and are making no use of them and the sooner they are taken from them, the better.
It is not true that Roscommon is a congested area and neither is it true that only the Atlantic areas are congested. There are other areas just as much entitled to consideration as areas in Mayo, Galway and Kerry. Very serious opposition has been met by people who have come from the west into the midlands but if you go into any town there and ask any trader who is his best customer, you will find it is the man who came in from the west. I often go out of my way to see these people and I have yet to find one man who has come up from the west and has failed. Those who try to denigrate the people from the west are not honest or fair. As a matter of fact, those who come from the west are, and always have been, an example to the midland people and it is a pity the midland people would not follow their example. If they did, they would soon become prosperous.
We know what goes on. Those people have land and by all kind of stratagems have succeeded in holding it. That is not fair. Any man who has 200 acres at present deserves to be dealt with. I would allow a lazy midland man to have 200 acres but after that it is time to deal with him. Those people do nothing with their land but spend their time at race meetings, weddings probably, funerals, dog-tracks and so on. They have the effrontery to look down on the people from the west. I say to the Minister the more people he will take from the west and the quicker he takes them, the better for the country generally.
Comment on this
I do not want to be technical about this Bill but I suggest that many of the arguments or points that have been made could more suitably be discussed on sections 4, 5 and 12 rather than at this stage.
As Deputy Blowick said, I did misunderstand Deputy Corish. There is no question in this Bill of people in the congested areas having such a priority as would affect the Land Commission's work in non-congested areas. The purpose of section 4 is to define the areas to which section 5 relates. That is the loan scheme to help people to solve their own congestion problems. Section 7 is also relevant because that is the section under which future annuitants, outside the congested areas, will not get the benefit of the 50 per cent reduction. But the ordinary Land Commission work in the non-congested counties will still continue.
There is no intention, as some Deputies would appear to think, that the work of the Land Commission should close down or be confined to the congested areas. What Deputy Rooney states, that migrants are brought in and local congests ignored, is news to me. From my experience as Minister for Lands, I cannot accept that it is so. All local congests within the distance limits laid down are considered before any migrants are brought in. In the division of an estate, the general rule is that, first, all old employees who are displaced must be dealt with; then the immediate congests within the distance limits are dealt with; and then, if any land is left over, the migrants are brought in.
Standards have changed. I found one rule in the Land Commission relating to the west of Ireland that when anyone acquired a valuation of £10, he was regarded as having an economic holding. That day is now gone. The standard practice of the Land Commission is the practice to which I have referred, that within the limit distance laid down, within a mile today—in former years, it went further—and according to the standards laid down for what was then called an uneconomic holding, suitable local congests are satisfied before bringing in migrants.
Deputies will appreciate that you can find a very wide difference in the type of people living around an estate. Some of them may have a small piece of land and others have avocations or jobs. It may well be that one applicant within the limit distance laid down is known to the Land Commission as an unsuitable person to whom to give land but, by and large, the practice which still obtains is that migrants are brought into these counties only after the needs of the local congests have been dealt with.
Comment on this
That does not apply where a man has eight or nine acres and has to take a job to keep his family from starving. He is ruled out.
Comment on this
On further sections of this Bill, Deputy Tully and others will be arguing as to what is an uneconomic holding. Deputy Tully feels that people who have got an allotment of land with a labourer's cottage should get some land. He would be happy with that if they got it at the expense of people from my part of the country. Deputy Flanagan would go further and give land to all the landless men in the country, to all the deserving applicants.
Comment on this
If we had enough land to go around, every Deputy would be glad to give land to everybody who deserves it, but our land is a limited quantity and we must have some system of priority as to those to whom we shall give it. What I want to emphasise it that the purpose of section 4 is to define the areas to which section 5 applies. This is a new enabling power under which the Land Commission can make a loan to a man so that he can solve his own congestion problem. That does not only apply to people in the congested areas. My reply to Deputy Tully is that in due course we shall come to a section enabling the Minister to schedule any place as a congested area and once that is done, all these powers will apply to the new congested areas.
That is a fair enough answer to the comments that have been made. When I come to these sections, this matter will be debated at much greater length, but, as far as Land Commission intentions are concerned, the same work for the relief of congestion in the counties not scheduled under this Bill or the 1909 Act will go on. They will deal with the congestion they find there, with the exception of the provisions of sections 4 and 5 of the Bill now before the House.
The whole point of this Bill is to try to relieve congestion in the seaboard counties which, as Deputy Leneghan points out, is partly due to our history, to the Cromwellian dictum of: "To Hell or to Connacht", and partly to the imbalance of population in our country. Primarily, there is the question of rearranging our land structure to enable our people competitively to produce on the land in this day and age. That is the primary objective of this Bill. In places where there is rundale, two or three people may have to be taken out of it because that is the only way in which viable holdings can be arranged.
Comment on this
When does the Minister hope to be in a position to give us a comprehensive 1964 picture of the congested areas? The Schedule mentioned refers to the congested areas declared in 1909. I presume the Bill will be passed between now and summer and does the Minister hope to be in a position to give the House and the country a complete picture of the new areas which he proposes to declare congested districts? We all agree that there are parts of Monaghan, Wicklow, Laois and Carlow in which there is as great congestion as in any place defined in the 1909 Act. Can the Minister assure us that before the end of the present year, the Land Commission will be able to present us, with some degree of accuracy, with an up-to-date picture of the situation?
Comment on this
Before the Minister replies to that, some other Deputy asked him if he could possibly define the considerations which would influence decisions in regard to what is a congested area. There appears to be an unexpressed feeling among certain Deputies that there is a possibility, when the Minister has this power, that political influence might enter into the question of deciding what is or is not a congested area. Deputy Leneghan seems to be very interested in this side of the House.
Comment on this
He disappeared for so long from the House that most of us thought he would not come back.
Comment on this
A number of places are mentioned here, such as Donegal, Galway, Laois and Mayo. Everybody knows that Galway has very many large estates and farms but apparently every part of the county, whether it is the congested districts or the areas in which there are large estates, will have smallholders who will be entitled to get the advantage of this arrangement of paying only 50 per cent compared with those who must pay 100 per cent of the rent. If we are to live up to the purpose of this Bill, congested areas should be defined and we should not just include a whole county like Galway, which is the third or fourth largest county in Ireland, and say that anybody who comes out of that county will have an advantage over the smallholders of, say, North County Dublin. There are scores of small farmers in Rush, County Dublin, living on six acres of land given to them by the Land Commission and when one sees these other people being given up to 45 acres, one wonders why a start should not be made in north County Dublin to relieve congestion. We should be more specific in our definition of congested areas. There are districts in Galway and in Mayo which are congested but in the Schedule the whole county is included and the advantages are available to anybody resident in any part of the whole county.
Comment on this
The purpose of this Bill is to deal with the congestion problem. To my mind, this problem has become aggravated very much and is now less easy of solution, due to modern decisions. About 12 years ago there was an estimate of the maximum acreage of land which at any time could become available for the relief of congestion. Side by side with that was the figure for congests. There was not a hope even then of ever arriving at the stage at which we could relieve congestion 100 per cent. While the number of congests may have gone down, the decision now is to increase the allocation of land in order to make an economic holding and instead of bringing these congests up to 20 acres, it is now intended to have a 40 to 50 acre holding, if possible. That means that the holdings which would be available for the relief of congestion and the number of congests remains static. That is a problem I see.
The Minister said that the easiest type of congestion has been solved; in other words, those who are prepared to move have moved and those who want to stay where they are for various reasons have been left. I think that we should have another look at this. If those people want to stay where they are, that is a problem in itself. Their reasons for wanting to stay are many and varied. They have the benefits of the social welfare code; they have the benefits of living along the coast and of the fishing industry; and they have the benefit of turbary, of lower rating and of lower valuation, all of which they are not prepared to sacrifice by going to other parts of the country where many of these benefits are not available. In that event and having the overall picture of more production from our land, and better land usage, should we not consider local people around the estates which are to be divided? Some people call these landless men; some call them conacre farmers; while I would call them the local users of land and whether they have small bits of their own or not they should be considered. It is wrong to view this problem of congestion in the same way as it was viewed 15 or 20 years ago, and especially as it was viewed in 1909.
Comment on this
The discussion on this section seems to be rather like the case of the father of the heroine in My Fair Lady who made the point that the undeserving hungry may be just as hungry as the deserving poor. We are creating two different classes of people who get land, those in the congested areas and those outside. The Minister is now going to define the areas. It must have been a very difficult position at all times because we all know that seeking land by land division is like taking a ticket in the Sweep because there is just not enough to go round. If we are to create a first-class and a second-class ticket at the whim and will of the Minister, I have the feeling that we shall be creating a political situation. We may as well face the fact that political branches or cumainn do agitate to get land divided.
Comment on this
——say which is a congested area and which is not a congested area, he creates a first-class ticket and a second-class ticket and pressure can be exerted on him to declare or not to declare, by one of his cumainn or, if one of our side were Minister, by one of our branches. I think this is a wrong departure.
Comment on this
Then I shall pass from it. The other point is that there are pockets of congestion in the middle of County Meath or County Kildare and in places where one would imagine there would be no such areas as congested areas. There are tiny pockets in townlands where congestion is very severe. Because of the local economy that builds up, there is not the practice, when one needs help, as there is elsewhere of, say, going to work for the county council, even if one has a small farm as in the west, or it is not, shall we say, condoned here by the powers-that-be, apart from the farmers themselves.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I am surprised by some aspects of this discussion. The Minister directs us to a definition at the beginning of the Bill and, when we look at that definition, we find it is a global, geographical list, drawn up in 1909, embracing, as it must, of necessity, congested and non-congested areas. It looks as if the Minister purposely, or otherwise, did not do his homework. Surely it should be an easy matter for him to provide the House with a list of congested areas all over the country? They are available in the Land Commission. They are available parish by parish. It should be a simple matter for the Minister to give a list for the whole country instead of taking unto himself the power of scheduling an area, for reasons which he, and he alone, may know.
It appears now that if people in the congested areas will have two advantages over those outside them. First, they will have financial advantages and, secondly, the reduction in the annuities. I gather from the Minister that they will have no specific advantages over the congests in the nonscheduled areas from the point of view of priority in the allocation of land. If they had, it would be highly objectionable. In my constituency, we have quite an amount of congestion. That may not appear to be the position to the average Dubliner or the person from the midlands who regards Tipperary as a very good county. It has its good areas but all around Thurles, parts of North Tipperary, certain areas in Waterford, the Nire Valley, the Glen of Aherlow, we have large areas of congestion. I should not like to think this Bill was framed in such fashion as to ensure a species of partition for the purpose of giving some preferential treatment to those west of the Shannon as against those living under equally difficult conditions in my county and other counties.
I should like the Minister to give me an assurance, at any rate, that he is not attempting to solve the congestion on the western seaboard at the expense of congests all over the rest of the country. I have every sympathy with the people along the western seaboard but my first loyalty is to my own constituents. There must be some measure of justice in this. Because the Minister comes from the west, I trust he does not feel that that gives him the right to solve the problems in his own and neighbouring counties at the expense of the midlands, the eastern part of the country and the south.
Comment on this
Deputy Donegan very clearly brought out the issue here in relation to congests when he spoke of the deserving poor and the undeserving poor. As a result of this legislation, we shall establish here deserving congests, who will be listed, and undeserving congests who will have to pay double the rent——