Committee on Finance. - Land Bill, 1963—Committee Stage.
Contributions 156–301 of 301. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 25 of 1963 ›
It is now quite clear to me how wise I was in lifting the definition of congested areas out of the 1909 Act. It is quite obvious from some of the comments by Deputies on the opposite benches that they are quite prepared to attribute some fantastic and political motives to the provision of some of the sections in this Bill. Had I not taken the definition in the 1909 Act, had I tried to define such areas myself, I can well imagine the arguments I should have heard here and the points raised by the Deputies opposite.
Deputy O.J. Flanagan asked me if I could define congested areas in a year's time, or two years' time, or when, in point of time. I could give the Deputy a legal definition right here and now. I can lift it from the Constitution: I would say the whole of Ireland, its islands and territorial waters. I am sure there is some congestion somewhere in every single county. The point is that the intensely congested counties that are scheduled under this Bill are the areas which the people who examined this problem down through the years have agreed should be dealt with first in order of national priority. From my own knowledge of the counties set out in the Schedule, I have no doubt at all that there is a much more intense congestion problem in these counties than there is in any other part of Ireland. I have no doubt at all about that.
It is only in these counties we have a rundale problem, a type of congestion created by intermixed holdings with different people owning every second or third field. These conditions do not obtain in other counties. The scheduling of a congested area under this Bill, which will be done by ministerial order—we shall be asking the House to give us that power—will be done on the report of the Land Commission inspectors. This is a matter with which the inspectors are competent to deal. They make these reports about congestion regularly in the ordinary course of their work. There is not a county in which the Land Commission are not doing work of one kind or another. I could not, and neither could my officials, determine these congested areas in vacuo, just picking out at random a number of congested areas.
This is a job that will have to be done very carefully and meticulously. It will have to be related to up-to-date conditions. As I pointed out, there were particular standards, 30, 40 and 50 years ago, with regard to what comprised an economic holding. Today, there are different standards; we are aiming now at what we call the family farm. In many cases in which schemes of rearrangement took place in the past, the units are, by modern standards, unrealistic. Times have changed and this is a matter that must be assessed in the light of conditions existing from 1964 onwards.
There is also the question of getting the Land Commission geared to put into force the new powers for which we are asking in this Bill, both in and outside the congested areas. That will take some time but they will get instructions and they will go ahead and compile in each county the areas they consider should be scheduled as a congested pocket under this Bill. Once they have done that, the Minister, whoever he may be, will undoubtedly exercise the power I am taking under this Bill to schedule the congested area. Then the people of that area, be it large or small, will be entitled to the benefit of this Bill, just as if that portion of their county were going into this Schedule.
The main difference between the counties outside the Schedule of this Bill and the congested counties is the application of sections 4 and 5 of this Bill, the sections that deal with a loan of money that is here provided for the man who solves his own congestion problem by migrating. Apart from these two sections of the Bill, the people outside the congested counties will be entitled to the same help from the Land Commission as they are already getting. There is no order of priority being established. The Land Commission, as they are in a position to do so, will be compiling these registers of areas that should be scheduled under this Bill. This is the first time that such a power was taken in any Land Bill brought before this House.
I foresaw that somebody would allege that this power might be used for political purposes by some Minister. Notwithstanding that, I felt that if I did not propose that such a power should be there for a Minister for Lands to schedule a particular area, I would be faced probably with amendments from many Deputies asking that their county be included in the Schedule to this Bill as a congested area. It would be impracticable to do so because I am satisfied, as I have already said, that there are pockets in many counties on the east coast as well as on the west coast in which there are congests. From a practical point of view, thinking of the necessary increase of staff in order to operate this Bill and thinking of how much they can take on at a time, I believe the only solution is to take the power here and let the Minister be advised, as the Land Commission officials in their operations throughout the country are able to decide and advise, that a particular townland, parish or other portion of any county should be scheduled.
Some Deputies raised the point as to how we would define an area to which this section would be applied so as to include it with the congested districts. It is a very simple matter where there is in any townland or in any county a pocket of congestion. Where the land units do not measure up to the family farm we now envisage, and where there are a number of landowners, these smaller units would, I am sure, be suggested to the Minister for inclusion under this section as a congested area.
I can well visualise that in different counties as the work proceeds, it will take a considerable time for the divisional inspector and the inspector in charge of the local men to make up their minds as to whether certain townlands in their county should be scheduled as a congested area. On the other hand, I believe that within the next 18 months, once this Bill becomes law, I shall have some recommendations that different counties be scheduled and I can assure the House that where such a recommendation comes, if it can be implemented, it will give me great personal pleasure to schedule those areas recommended as coming within the four walls of this Bill.
However, scheduling a townland or a congested area outside of what is in this Bill entails further planning on the part of the Land Commission. It may well be that in regard to some areas that are scheduled, it will be necessary to move tenants out of that area. Again we are up against the question of priority. There are only a limited number of migrant holdings available. I would say that taking good years with bad, it works out at an average of about 100 migrants a year throughout the country and, of course, the more areas that are scheduled, the greater will be the demand on the pool of land available for migration. However, immediately the Land Commission are in a position to do so, they will get instructions as soon as may be to notify the Minister if there are portions in their bailiwicks they would suggest should be scheduled under the Bill. In so far as we can do so and have the staff to do it, the Land Commission will take all these areas in the different counties outside the areas that are included in this Bill.
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Minister but I put a question to him about certain areas that are absolutely dotted with small registered holdings but which are not inhabited. I take it what the Minister will do is to ask inspectors to report on certain areas or consider representations by Deputies, county councillors and others who suggest that a certain area is, in their opinion, congested and should be scheduled. Subsection (2) of section 4 says:
When making an order under subsection (1) of this section, the Minister shall have regard to the size of the holdings, the quality of the land and the type or types of farming carried on in the area to be declared a congested area.
There is no word there of whether the area is thickly populated or sparsely populated. What happens in the case of an area with many holdings?
Comment on this
You cannot generalise about the size of holdings per se. It depends very largely on the type and quality of the land and the location of the land. Deputy Rooney rather amused me by his talk about the terrible plight of small farmers on six acres of land in County Dublin. I assume he has in mind some of what I call the merchant prince farmers of Rush, Lusk and so on——
Comment on this
——who are sitting on goldmines right beside a very lucrative market in Dublin city. Four, five, six or eight acres of land there would be as good as and possibly better than 150 acres of land in the part of the country from which I come. One cannot generalise on acreage per se, without taking into consideration the type of land and its location in relation to a market. What would be an economic unit, say, in Lusk or Rush would certainly be anything but an economic unit on the island of Achill, in Ballycroy, or some of those remote places in the west.
Deputy Blowick spoke about the definition in section 4 (2). The size of the holding, the quality of the land and the type or types of farming carried out are what are in mind. I do not know what Deputy Blowick has in mind when he mentions vacated holdings.
Comment on this
My worry is that you might get a Land Commission inspector wasting his time on an area where land division would produce very little good effect. Take, for instance, a thinly populated area in relation to which, on paper, he could show he was justified simply because the area was full of small but vacated holdings. I think the Minister knows the type of area I am referring to.
Comment on this
I understand now. That is primarily a matter of administration. If I were Minister and got reports of this kind and saw that some inspector was engaged in the type of work mentioned by Deputy Blowick, I should certainly ask the Land Commission to put a stop to it quickly and lively. Under the new and additional work and worry the Land Commission staff will have as a result of this Bill, I suppose that to say they will have a full-time job is the understatement of the year. If they are fully to exercise the powers given here to try to induce the recalcitrant landholders who hold up division schemes and to try to induce the old people to take pensions and give up their holdings in order to put through the rearrangement schemes contemplated, they will have plenty to do without wasting their time in the way Deputy Blowick suggests.
That brings up a matter that will no doubt be argued again on another section of this Bill. To anticipate this, because I have no doubt I shall have it from many sides of the House before the Committee Stage is finished, the order of priority of the division of land and who will get land is a matter of administration. The classes who will get land are neither being widened nor contracted in any way under the provisions of this Bill. I know from experience that there is a special problem in Donegal. Indeed, Donegal people are unique by virtue of the fact that you will not get people from West Donegal to migrate to East Donegal and they generally take a very poor view of asking them to migrate out of Donegal at all. That is their privilege.
There is also a system in Donegal, as Deputy P. O'Donnell knows, under which, by tradition, many people down through the years take lettings of land, maybe an acre or two, for the purpose of producing seed potatoes. Indeed, down through the years there, even young fellows, I understand, for pocket money, take an acre or two by way of letting to produce seed potatoes or some other crop. There is a position in Donegal that does not obtain, I think, in most other counties but at the same time you will find some deserving landless men in every part of this country.
The very same case has been made to me by Deputies representing dairying counties where men with no land take land and milk a number of cows and have farm machinery. Perhaps there are not so many of that type outside Donegal who make their livelihood in this way. There is a special problem in this way. Once the Land Commission extend their practice of the order of priorities which already exists, once we widen that and bring in landless men—they are quite entitled under the existing law to give land to these people — we can give landless men land and, in fact, have done so but they must necessarily come down to the bottom of the list.
The very first purpose of the Congested Districts Board and the Land Commission was the relief of congestion, that is, the relief of the people in the land slums of this country, people on uneconomic units of land, and that must continue to be so. Reasonable Deputies will still see the wisdom of the policy that while we have all these congests in the country, they must, in so far as is possible, be dealt with first and they must have what I would call the first priority on the land pool that is available.
If I may anticipate the argument just touched on by Deputy Blowick—I have no doubt other Deputies representing other parts of the country will make the same case, that landless men should be considered—the short answer is that there is nothing in this Bill to prevent landless men from getting land if it is there for them. That is purely a matter of administration, a matter of the priorities established by the Land Commission.
Whenever the Estimate for the Department of Lands comes before the House, Deputies can make their case and can argue to extend or to change the order of priorities that now exists and to change the practice that now exists. This Bill does not affect the position, one way or the other, as to who will be given land. I would ask Deputies not to waste the time of the House in arguing something which is not in the Bill and does not arise at all.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister a question in relation to the peculiar type of land user that has been going on and has become known as the Lagan Valley system? Does the Minister envisage that any part of the Bill will change or upset that system, or does he consider it desirable to do so? The Minister knows the system I refer to and which Deputy Cunningham referred to—conacring under a system that is not employed in any other part of the country. When I was Minister for Lands I made the experiment of taking up some of the land that had been conacred in that valley for years and years to find that those who had been conacring it and were willing to pay high prices for it would not take a present of the land from the Land Commission. I must say it dumb-founded me.
Comment on this
I know we have this Lagan Valley system, and I might say the system in Donegal has given me considerable worry because I have found that where the Land Commission have taken land, they had, in fact, to provide for people who were traditionally taking lettings and there was no place for these people to find land, once the Land Commission had moved in. This is the problem peculiar to Donegal; in fact, it is widespread in Donegal.
There is no other county in Ireland that has produced the same type of problem. I do not see any easy answer to it for the reasons I have given. Again, it is a question of internal policy for the Land Commission whether or not they should try to devise some special set of rules to meet the circumstances thrown up by the Donegal people. I have given the matter some thought but have not yet got anybody in my Department who has been able to come up with what I would call a satisfactory solution to the particular problem we have in Donegal. Generally speaking, I do not think we have what has been termed the Lagan Valley problem in any other part of the country.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is aware that in every county there are cases of people who have been taking small portions of estates for tillage and for the grazing of a cow or a few cattle for upwards of 20 years who have been dispossessed by the Land Commission, their stock turned out on the road and given no land whatever. Surely that situation is widespread.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister and the ex-Minister are ad idem as far as Donegal is concerned. I would make an appeal on behalf of those conacre landless men. The Minister has put his finger on it, as has Deputy Blowick. There are probably no better citizens in this country——
Comment on this
——than those landless men who take conacre in the Finn and the Lagan Valleys. They are, if I may say so, a law unto themselves. They mostly live in labourers' cottages and you will find as many as three or four members of a family taking plots. In the old days, it was for flax; now it is for seed potatoes, and sometimes ware potatoes and seed oats. I would be sorry to see these men victimised by this Bill and I am glad to see the Minister is conscious of their position. It would be a tragedy were he not, because those people might become dispossessed of the lands they have been taking on conacre under the 11-month system.
What happens is that farmers in Donegal let out portions of their farms for rotation tilling. A farmer who traditionally produces root crops and who is himself not anxious to go into seed or grain crops, will let out portions of his farm, not simply to procure money from the letting but in order that the land may be rotated. He does not do it himself—the conacre men do it for him.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will excuse my intervention, could we not suitably leave this over for section 4?
Comment on this
I would not have mentioned it if section I did not refer to section 4 by way of definition.
Comment on this
If I could be guaranteed that this discussion on section 1 would save, to some extent, a discussion on section 4, I should be inclined to suggest that we leave over this discussion to the later section. My worry is that there may be a repetition of this discussion on section 4.
Comment on this
My intervention in the debate has been very brief. I agree that possibly the matters we are now discussing would be more relevant on section 4, but the Minister did mention the content of section 4 in discussing this section.
Comment on this
No. Section 4 can be discussed fully. Discussion of it is being attempted now on section 1.
Comment on this
While there would not be limitation of discussion as such, I am very worried about section 1 and the powers it confers on the Minister.
Comment on this
I should like to tell Deputy O'Sullivan what I am worried about. If he can guarantee me that we will get section 4 passed without discussion, I shall allow the discussion to proceed on section 1.
Comment on this
Perhaps we could continue the discussion on this section and then, when we come to section 4——
Comment on this
This involves a very important principle. As the Minister says, it is the first time these powers are being sought. The Minister is asking the House to confer powers on him as Minister that have never before been sought by any Minister. We know what has been going on in the country; we know the type of misinformation that has been circulated in regard to the Land Commission and it is only rarely that a breath of fresh air——
Comment on this
You can come out the back and I shall discuss hire purchase or any other purchase with you.
Comment on this
The problem we are discussing now is that the Minister is seeking powers that were formerly the preserve of the Land Commission. I am not alleging the Minister has cloven hoofs, but neither is he sprouting wings. He is not legislating merely in regard to his own intentions. He is asking the House to enact legislation that will be there until it is reversed. Giving the Minister the benefit of the best intentions in the world, he is asking for powers to be conferred on the office he holds that could lead to immense abuses.
The fact is that there is prevalent in this country ideas regarding the influences that might be brought to bear relative to land which may be available for division and the subsequent dividing of it. It is only rarely do the occasions arise in which some frank, honest statement is made relative to the operation of the Land Commission. I can recall with pleasure the occasion on which Deputy Gerald Boland, having retired from the office of Minister for Lands, made clear in this House how he regarded that position. He felt it was due to the country as a whole to realise the impartiality of the Land Commission and their staff. Here we are giving powers to the Minister which, if not abused, nevertheless, can create and will create an impression in the minds of gullible people that there are influences that can be brought to bear politically on the political head of the Ministry the Minister now occupies.
This is a very serious departure. No matter how it may be presented as being a logical way of dealing with this problem, nevertheless, there is no doubt that the opinion will be held, and held strongly, by numerous people in a weak position that there can be influence brought to bear, because section 4 provides that the Minister may from time to time make an order declaring such an area to be a congested area. Who are the people who will assist the Minister in determining the areas to be scheduled? What process will be followed? By whose recommendation will the Minister be influenced on the decision he will ultimately take?
The Minister referred by intervention to the fact that he was conscious of the limitation on the pool of land available to those seeking allotment. It is rather belated for him to express concern at the limitation on the pool of land available. Much water has flowed under the bridge since it was first brought to his notice that the pool of land available was being rapidly reduced by the purchase of land by foreigners. For a long time a very deaf ear was turned to the demands of the people up and down the country who wanted to have some control over the position that land, which could have been made available to the congests about whom we are expressing so much sympathy, was no longer available. The people view with alarm the amount of land not alone passing out of the hands of the Land Commission but out of the hands of Irish nationals.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt any Deputy, but I feel we are going to have a rehash of what Deputy O'Sullivan said when we come to deal with the relevant sections. We are dealing now with the definition section. It does not give any power to the Minister for Lands at all. It only assigns certain meanings to certain words. I would suggest Deputy O'Sullivan is getting on to a line of country completely irrelevant as far as this section is concerned.
Comment on this
I can distinctly recall the Minister referring to the limitation imposed on him by the non-availability of a sufficient pool of land.
Comment on this
I asked the House to take this section and decide on it. The very matter the Deputy is now raising could be raised entirely relevantly on section 4.
Comment on this
Very good, Sir. Concluding, I want to express my complete dissatisfaction at the proposal in this section to confer powers on the Minister that could be abused or could be implied to be abused.
Comment on this
The Second Schedule to the Bill defines what are the congested areas. I mentioned several of the counties already. I was glad to hear from the Minister that he is now prepared to make a list and a map of congested areas all over the country, so that the people resident in those areas may be considered congests within a limited meaning and not within the meaning of the Second Schedule. In the Second Schedule the Minister mentioned portion of County Clare. He was able to pick out portion of Clare instead of putting down the whole county. Possibly, that is the kind of district he will pick out in the various congested areas throughout the country. Similarly, instead of putting down the whole of County Cork, or even the western portion of it, he selected certain districts there. There, again, is an example of where he has put the microscope on areas that were to get special facilities.
Comment on this
This is duplicating discussion. Section 1 says that "congested" has the meaning assigned to it in section 4.
Comment on this
I am discussing it exactly as it is there. It says that "congested area" has the meaning assigned to it by subsection (1) of section 4. The words "congested area", as defined, are what I am arguing about.
Comment on this
This is a definition section. It says that the words "congested area" have the meaning assigned to them by section 4. That will arise on section 4. I do not see any reason to discuss it on the two sections.
Comment on this
Section 4 will come before the House in the ordinary way and the Deputy can have his fling at it then.
Comment on this
The only difficulty is that, if we agree to the definition of "congested area" in section 1 and then go on to section 4, we will find ourselves tongue-tied and in the position that we have already accepted section 1.
Comment on this
I do not think the Deputy will find himself tongue-tied at all. I suggest what he is discussing here is relevant to section 4. I rule that.
Comment on this
On your ruling, Sir, Deputies are asked to take "congested areas" and wait until section 4 before we can decide whether there is an agreement with the Minister or not. In other words, we are asked to buy a pig in a poke?
Comment on this
It seems to me we cannot be expected to accept this until after we have discussed section 4.
Comment on this
May I intervene to shorten matters, in answer to Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Rooney? The main complaint would appear to be that there is this enabling section for the Minister for Lands to bring in a new congested area. I am quite sure that if this section were not in the Bill Deputy O'Sullivan and a number of his colleagues would insist on a section like it going into the Bill to enable the congestion problem in any particular county or area to be brought in and, conversely, I am quite sure that if Deputy O'Sullivan put down an amendment to take away this power from the Minister for Lands he would not get a dozen Deputies to support him.
Comment on this
An example was given this afternoon by a colleague of the Minister where he emphasised in relation to industrial grants the advisability of vesting in the Industrial Development Authority decisions relative to the location of industry and gave full explanation and full reason as to why it was advisable in 1956 to give these powers to a body outside the Minister and remote from the Minister and without being directed or controlled by the Minister. If that applies in relation to the location of industry, surely the same principle applies in relation to operations of the Land Commission vis-à-vis the political head of the Department of Lands?
Comment on this
No; the Chair is making no such suggestion. I am suggesting that section 1 is before the House and what the Deputy is endeavouring to discuss is not relevant to section 1 but is relevant to section 4.
Comment on this
Is it clear that if we let section 1 go, there can be complete discussion on the definition on section 4?
Comment on this
The definition of "congested area" is tied in with subsection (1) of section 4. So, when we come to subsection (1) of section 4, can we have an assurance that we can discuss the question of congested area under that section?
Comment on this
What is relevant to section 4 can be discussed on section 4 and "congested area" is mentioned in section 1 and referred to section 4.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister what objection he has to the laying of the rules and regulations made under this section before each House of the Oireachtas? I feel that a matter of such great importance as, say, the making of an order declaring any particular district to be a congested area or, indeed, any order made under this Bill should be placed before each House of the Oireachtas. The House would be interested to know what objection the Minister might have to that course. I strongly recommend that the Minister should consider placing these rules and regulations before each House of the Oireachtas.
The Minister is aware that section 3 of the Land Act, 1933, empowers the Minister for Lands with the concurrence of a Committee consisting of the Judicial Commissioner, the Secretary of the Land Commission and a Lay Commissioner, after consultation with the President of the Incorporated Law Society, to make rules. There is no provision in the 1933 Act for the laying of these rules when made before the Houses of the Oireachtas nor is there any provision in this Bill for the laying of such rules before the Houses of the Oireachtas.
The Minister is also aware that section 3 of the 1933 Land Act provides that the Secretary of the Department of Lands, as having a special position distinct from the other Commissioners on the Rules Committee, represents the Civil Service side and a Civil Service outlook and that section 3 of the 1933 Act emphasises the undesirability of having the Secretary as a Commissioner, as he is intended to hold a view different from the rest of his fellow Commissioners.
That is why I feel that in this Bill there should be provision for the laying of the various rules and regulations by the Minister before the Houses of the Oireachtas for the purpose of giving Deputies notice and information which is very often difficult to obtain when these rules and regulations are not laid before both Houses of the Oireachtas.
I highly recommend to the Minister that in an effort to secure speedy passage of the Bill and co-operation from all sides he might meet us on some point. Our request that the rules he makes be laid before each House of the Oireachtas is, indeed, a very reasonable one and I, therefore, recommend it to the Minister.
Comment on this
I am sorry I cannot accede in this instance to the Deputy's request although I can assure him that any submission or argument that is made in the course of the debate on this Bill that I consider would improve the Bill or would be workable will get my wholehearted consideration.
In certain statutes powers are taken to create rules that need not be laid on the Table of the House. As I am sure the Deputy is well aware, the only effect of laying rules on the Table of the House, as we call it here, is to enable Deputies to put down a motion within 21 days. The only practical effect of providing that any statutory rules be laid on the Table of both Houses, as I have explained to the House, is this procedural motion that Deputies can table to amend or annul within 21 days, or whatever the specified time is, under our rules of procedure here.
Now the very same procedure is available, in a different way, to Deputies by way of motion where the particular statute does not prescribe that they must be laid on the Table of the House. Under this section, Deputies can put down a motion criticising the rule or calling for its revocation or amendment. Deputies will have that right under the ordinary rules of debate in this House. The only real argument, I suppose, that would be suggested by some Deputies is that rules might be made and, because they are not laid on the Table of the House, may be in existence for some time, without coming to the notice of Deputies. If there is anything wrong with the rules, knowing how close Deputies are in touch with their Dáil work and their constituents, which will be made and which will affect a constituent in a local area, I am quite sure we shall hear about it quick and lively from the Deputy concerned.
There are some rules—for instance, the Land Bond Order—which must be laid on the Table of the House. It is envisaged that these regulations will be on questions of procedure, on technical matters of finance that must be dealt with inter-Departmentally by the Land Commission and the Minister for Finance. With regard to the particular rule, to which Deputy Flanagan referred under the 1933 Act, questions of procedure and the rule-making authority, I can assure Deputies that it is a very good job it has not been laid on the Table of the House.
I have been, and my people have been, quite a long time trying to hammer out new legal machinery for the Land Commission. I had to negotiate with the Incorporated Law Society and we had several meetings to try to hammer out a workable procedure, a procedure that would be acceptable to them on behalf of the legal profession. It went on for a very long time. We have, in fact, achieved agreement. Some new rules have been made in agreement with them and with those others concerned, including the rule-making authority itself. If I have to come back in here, and Deputies knock this down, agreement having been reached, I am afraid we will never reach finality on that point at all.
What is contemplated here are rules of procedure, not technical matters or finance, and these may have to change from time to time, depending on different circumstances, maybe until money is available for a particular job, and so on. I think it would be a cumbersome procedure, for what is envisaged here, if we had to come to the House and lay the rules on the Table of the House. I think the real answer to what Deputy Flanagan has in mind is that we have a satisfactory procedure in regard to rules which may be made under this section in that Deputies have a right to put down a motion to amend, annul or criticise them.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree to circulate to Deputies and Senators the rules, when they become law and when they are available, as an ordinary matter?
Comment on this
The Deputy's suggestion appeals to me but he will appreciate that I do not want to give an undertaking to the House on the spur of the moment, without looking into the matter. I assure the Deputy I shall look into the suggestion and I shall come back to it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister said if the document went before the House, it might be knocked by the House and all his trouble would have gone for nothing. Surely that is suggesting that the agreement reached is one which would not be accepted by the House and the only way to get away with it is to let nobody know about it? I am afraid I have to agree with Deputy Flanagan that it is a rather peculiar thing that the documents are not laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. There is no point in the Minister saying that Deputies can put down a motion objecting to them. How will any of us know that those rules have been brought in, in order to bring in a motion within the statutory period? While people down the country, whom we represent, would very soon, when they hear about them, bring them to our notice, if we do not hear of them, how will the people down the country hear of them within 21 days?
Comment on this
I would ask the Minister, even if it does mean extra inconvenience to the Land Commission, to place those documents before the Houses, so that Deputies, who are supposed to be making laws, will know what is in them, and, if necessary, can object to them. The Minister, having the power of the Government behind him, might have very little fear about having them knocked down.
Comment on this
I am surprised at Deputy Tully's argument. What he is trying to do is to knock the Incorporated Law Society, the trade union of the legal profession. As the Deputy knows, it is one thing to desire to put something into operation, but, unless those concerned, are prepared to cooperate and work to achieve that end, I would be wasting my time trying to put it over on them without having their agreement to operate it. The quick answer to the Deputy, and indeed to Deputy Blowick, is that these statutory rules must be published in Iris Oifigiúil. They are there for anybody desiring to see them. Any Deputy who is interested enough is entitled to get a copy of them. The real test is that if these rules, in any way, affect Deputies' constituents, and it is given as a reason that under the rule or under the law, this or that cannot be done, I am quite sure that, quick and lively, we should have a Motion in this House to knock the particular rule or to amend it.
The position is that these rules are published and are available for those who want them. In so far as it might be desirable to have them circulated to Deputies, the suggestion appeals to me but I should not like to give an undertaking to the House, without considering the implications of it. I have given an undertaking to look into the matter between now and Report Stage.
Comment on this
The Minister said he was surprised I said what I did. In trade union matters, the official must go back to the members with his proposals. The Minister is trying to get through his trade union without letting its members know what has been done.
Comment on this
I should like to make this point to the Minister. If the circulation of the rules to Deputies and Senators is difficult, surely it would not be too much to ask that Deputies and Senators get a note in the ordinary way saying that rules are being made under section 3 of the Land Act, 1964, and that they were available in the Government Publication Sales Office? The Minister mentioned that the rules are published in Iris Oifigiúil but how many Deputies and Senators bother their head reading it? Special application has to be made to get it.
Comment on this
I have a suggestion I should like to make to the Minister. The Minister is aware of the existence of the Seanad Select Committee on Statutory Instruments and if the rules and regulations were placed before that Committee, they could, at least, be examined by them for the limited purposes for which such a Committee is set up.
Comment on this
If these rules are subjected to the same examination as under the 1933 Act, there would not be any danger. That Committee, which is a Select Committee of the Seanad, would, at least, be given an opportunity of examining all the rules and regulations.
I am afraid the Minister's suggestion that a motion should be put down here for the purpose of annulling or amending any Order would not be practicable. First, it would be very difficult for a Deputy or a Party to put down a motion, if unaware that such a rule or regulation existed. The Seanad Select Committee on Statutory Instruments should at least be given an opportunity of examining all these regulations under this Bill when it becomes an Act.
Comment on this
This is legislation by reference and if the Deputy reads section 2, he will see that it refers back in the same way to the procedure under section 3 of the 1933 Act which means that they are subject to the same scrutiny by the committee set out in that section. Regarding Deputy Blowick's point, Deputies will appreciate that there is another Minister and another Department concerned under subsection (2) of this section and I could not, here and now, without considering the implication of having these things circulated, give an undertaking that they will be circulated. But I repeat that I shall look into the point and see, after consideration, if it is feasible.
Comment on this
If the rules have been agreed on between the authorities and have become law and are available for sale in the Government Publications Sales Office, surely two lines on an ordinary slip of paper to be distributed to Deputies in the ordinary way with their post, would meet the case?
Comment on this
Personally, I think that would be desirable, just to bring the matter to the notice of Deputies, but if any of these rules affected an individual in any part of the country and particularly affected a constituent of Deputy Flanagan, I can visualise the Order Paper we would have here from the question point of view, leaving out motions.
Comment on this
It is not the case that every Deputy would want to put down a motion, or indeed any Deputy, to annul or alter a rule because I think such a thing has never happened in the history of this House and would be most unlikely to happen in this case. I am simply talking for the purpose of trying to ensure that Deputies who are desirous of getting such information should get it.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I take it that when these regulations have been published in Iris Oifigiúil, what will appear will merely be a notice that they have been made and that a Deputy may apply to the General Office and get a copy. Submission of a notice of motion in regard to these rules and regulations would seem a very dilatory method of handling the matter. A notice of motion may be on the Order Paper for months and in the meantime the grievance will continue. Would it not be more expeditious if, as Deputy Flanagan suggested, an order were laid before the House that would come under the 21 days' clause?
Comment on this
Not for internal reasons, as I said. I have pointed out there are two Ministers concerned and in these rules we are dealing with a situation that may change very frequently. Changes may have to be made between the Department of Finance and the Department of Lands, and it would be cumbersome and would slow things up if they had to come here every time some slight change was being made and put it before the House. I am pointing out that there is this procedure whereby Deputies can put down a motion to annul, amend or revoke the rules made. The only effect of providing that the rules should be laid on the Table is, as I have said, that it brings the fact of making the rules to the Deputies' attention. I may be able to adopt the suggestion by Deputy Blowick that Deputies be notified when these rules are made. I think that meets many of the fears or criticisms voiced by Deputy Flanagan.
Comment on this
We have an undertaking from the Minister that at least the Seanad Committee on Statutory Instruments will have an opportunity of examining all these?
Comment on this
Since it has now become perfectly evident that the Opposition will be trying to sabotage this Bill at all costs, may I suggest to the Minister it would be much more effective just to force the Bill through without discussing——
Comment on this
What is the Minister's objection to the rule or regulation being placed on the Table of the House, so that the 21 days' provision may operate? All the Minister has said is that it is a matter for two Departments and that everything that comes before the House has to be subject to annulment under the 21 days' regulation. But that is not the case at all. Deputies will not come in and annul everything put before them but at least they want an opportunity of debating the matter, something that Deputy Leneghan does not believe in. That shows his mentality; we might as well stay away as be here if that were the situation. Otherwise, it seems the only opportunity the House would have of debating something that many Deputies would disagree with, might be lost. The Minister says we can put down a motion. He knows perfectly well that if you try to get something annulled under the 21 days' clause, you get priority and you get an opportunity of debating it, whereas a motion may be two or three years before it comes up. To my knowledge there is a motion down for Private Members' Time about whiskey distilleries which is three years there now. It is only nonsense for the Minister to tell us that it is perfectly easy to deal with in the way he suggests. That is untrue.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): The Minister made a point that he has to consider another Department and that is a difficult thing in laying these rules before the House. Surely that applies to many Bills where it is accepted that the rules and the regulations made under them are laid before the House?
Comment on this
The matters to be dealt with in these rules are solely to prescribe matters of form, in the main, and as far as I know, this type of rule was never made the subject of the provision of being compulsorily laid on the Table of the House, as it is called. These rules will prescribe certain forms and regulations under this Bill after consultation with the Department of Finance and the Department of Lands and their respective Ministers from time to time. These matters must change occasionally and it would be impracticable for every change required in one of these rules, after the discussions have concluded between the Departments, to have to come and lay them on the Table of the House.
I gave an instance a few moments ago to Deputy Tully where, under one rule-making authority, certain rules and the existing law that we had prescribed were changed and it was only possible to do that after very considerable negotiation and getting agreement with outside people. Perhaps I gave a rather extreme instance. It may be unwise to assume that the House would "knock" a sensible agreement but that could happen if it had to come here. Deputies would not be as familiar with the matters involved in this case as I would be, or with the reasons for having to go a certain distance to achieve a measure of agreement and co-operation between these people.
It is for the very same reason that I am convinced it is desirable to have this section in this particular way. At the moment I cannot see any real objection to the suggestion made by Deputy Blowick that Deputies should be notified when rules are made under this section but I want to think about it and examine the implications of it before making the promise firmly to the House. However, unless I find something to the contrary, I would give an undertaking on the Report Stage to adopt this suggestion.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): One would think the Minister was giving something away to Deputy Blowick but we all know that we can get these rules and regulations by writing to the General Office. In this Bill the Minister is taking powers greater than the powers taken by any of his predecessors and, therefore, we feel obliged to exercise as much control and restraint on these powers as we can. For that reason, and in the spirit of good democracy, we are anxious that any rules and regulations made under this section should be laid on the Table of the House so that every Deputy may see them. Surely the Minister is not being reasonable when he half infers that somebody will rush in to try to block these rules and regulations. Most Deputies are reasonable people and are as anxious as the Minister is to make this a good Bill. It is in that spirit of making it a good Bill that we are anxious that the rules and regulations made under it will be available to every Deputy. That is good practice and the coy way in which the Minister tried to get away with the idea that he is giving away something when we could get these rules and regulations by writing into the General Office is no good.
Comment on this
I am not here for the purpose of throwing out any giveaways. I am here to try to do a practical job. Part of the Bill is designed to cut away the red tape that we have under the existing law and Deputy Hogan, by his suggestion here, would simply be adding more red tape that could well clog the machine. This section is nothing new. It is nothing new to have a section that does not provide for laying the rules under it on the Table of the House. There are several statutes that contain sections in the same form as this where the rules, for particular reasons, are designed for domestic consumption, for prescribing certain procedures and forms.
In fact, this very section refers to section 3 of the 1933 Land Act and rules made under that section have not to be laid on the Table of the House. There is no innovation in the bringing in of a section prescribing the making of rules without having them laid on the Table of the House. While I can think over the matter between this and the Report Stage, I do not see what difficulty any reasonable Deputy could have about letting the section go through.
Comment on this
Of course, this is an innovation. The Minister had already said that this is the first time a Minister has taken such powers. It is quite understandable, where certain powers are delegated to the Land Commission, that there would be agreement in the House not to have every decision placed before the House. However, here the Minister is asking for political responsibility relative to administration and he wants these powers without being required to give to Deputies the information which is so necessary to ensure that the Minister or his successors will not abuse the powers he is now asking the House to confer upon him. This cannot be compared to any of the previous Land Acts because this is the first time the House is being asked to confer such powers upon the political head of the Department.
Comment on this
What I said in my Second Reading speech, as the Deputy well knows, is that for the first time we are writing into the law that the congested areas can be extended by order of the Minister for Lands. However, this section has nothing whatever to do with the Minister. It is a section by reference to section 3 of the Land Act of 1933 and the rules to be made under this section are subject to the same scrutiny by the same statutory authority as provided by law under section 3 of the 1933 Act. This section gives me no more power one way or the other than was given to any other Minister for Lands in this country.
Comment on this
I do not agree with the Minister when he declares so vehemently that there is nothing new in the decision with regard to regulations he makes under this Bill. The 1933 Act is there and the Minister is continuing what is in that Act, as far as the submission of rules and regulations are concerned. As far as any democratic institution is concerned, the statement by the Minister should be a reflection on the people who sat in the House when the 1933 Act was going through because they did not do their job.
This House goes to a great deal of trouble in examining and dealing with the measures that come before it. Every Deputy gives the benefit of his advice and knowledge to the Minister and his Department and then the Minister and his officials come along and decide that where the technical and legal machinery which are necessary to implement the wishes of the House are concerned, that machinery and the necessary rules and regulations will not be disclosed to the people who passed the legislation. To me, that is nonsensical.
I think the Minister is in favour of seeing that this House is made aware of any changes that may be made and that he is in a bit of a spot as far as his colleague, the Minister for Finance, is concerned. I can appreciate the difficulty that he cannot speak for him but let us face it: the real reason why this information regarding the rules, etc., has not been made available is that the faceless bureaucrats in the background do not want to be bothered or worried or annoyed by Deputies. That is it in a nutshell. I know, and other Deputies who take an interest in legislation which affects their constituencies know, that it is hard enough to deal with your normal work, without having to go searching and probing for information that should be laid on the Table of the House. It is an insult to the people who elected Deputies to have them told that they will not be given the rules of procedure, that this is something in the background for the legal fraternity, or the Incorporated Law Society, to work out between them. If a Deputy asks is it to be handed out in this House, he is told it cannot be done.
The Minister should not tolerate that kind of advice. I think he does take the view that rules and regulations, arising from an enactment of this House, should automatically be made available to Deputies. I should also like to ask the Minister where his colleague, the Minister for Finance, comes in. Subsection (1) of section 2, states in brackets "other than provisions relating to land purchase finance". Is the Minister for Finance given power in this to strangle—I will put it that way—provisions of this Bill when it is passed? Is there any great significance in the fact that the Minister for Finance appears in the background so early on as a restraining influence on the Minister for Lands who is anxious to do his job as far as the land problem is concerned?
Comment on this
Is there not such a thing as collective responsibility? Surely if the Minister for Lands speaks, the Minister for Finance may be taken as being in full agreement with what he says? That is the way it was when we were in Government. I do not know whether it has changed.
Comment on this
I would advise the Deputy to keep away from that line of country. Above all else, he should keep away from that.
Comment on this
I have not got such a short memory as the Deputy thinks. Do not provoke me into giving chapter and verse. No Minister of State can give any undertaking on behalf of a colleague without consulting him. It may well be that having examined this matter, I shall find there is no real objection to meeting the wishes of the House. I am much more concerned with another aspect. I am much more concerned with making and having a flexible legal machine when we have finished with this Bill in this House. I am far more concerned with every section we have here and many of them have been deliberately drafted for the purpose of giving us flexibility. I should like Deputies to appreciate how impossible it is if the Land Commission and the Minister for Lands are put in a legal straitjacket when dealing with the congestion problem or dealing with the multitudinous duties the Land Commission are supposed to carry out if they are to be effective.
Comment on this
Does the Minister agree that the first one to put him into a straitjacket will be the Minister for Finance?
Comment on this
I shall deal with the references to the Department of Finance in a moment. Let me say, in reply to those Deputies who are arguing that this proposal is a matter of principle, and that the rules should be laid on the Table of the House, that I am far more concerned, whatever the practical difficulties may be as between the Department of Lands and the Department of Finance, with finding this proposition a clog on the machine I am trying to devise. As Deputies who have had ministerial experience know, if you are going to have a series of consultations between the civil servants in the different Departments and the matter has then to be laid on the Table of the House, you must have a Government meeting and the matter must be decided on at a Government meeting. With all that red tape if things are to be held up and there are to be delays and if every time a line of that must be changed we have to start off again with consultations between the Departments and have to go through what I call red tape——
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs needs no recommendation from Deputy O'Sullivan or any other Deputy. I would be far more concerned with that aspect of this matter than I would be with renewing any undertaking to Deputy Blowick or going the whole hog and amending this section in the way suggested. However, as I say, I shall go into that aspect.
Coming to that part of subsection (1) to which Deputy McQuillan referred —"other than provisions relating to land purchase finance"—that is the regular provision in regard to all Departments. Outside of coming to this House to provide the £5 million in land bonds, that is where every Minister for Lands is dependent on and must be dependent on the Minister for Finance and his Government colleagues at Budget time in regard to the amount of money to be made available to his Department. Indeed, I could remind the House how, at a certain stage in the history of this country, the Land Commission became starved under certain sections of even the existing law, in particular in regard to the 1950 Act which enabled the Land Commission, in certain limited circumstances, to purchase land by public auction, and how when the war came along they were provided for a while with some ridiculous sum— speaking from recollection, I think it was something under £20,000—which was wiped out altogether when the financial shoe started to pinch those concerned with the Land Commission.
It is true to state that as far as cash purchases and other finances outside the land bonds are concerned—and of course we have to have consultation about the issue of land bonds but we are taking power to raise the ceiling to enable us to create these—and the money provided for the other Land Commission development works, including a very big part of my annual Estimate for Land Commission improvement of estates—which costs a lot of money—it depends in all instances on what the Minister for Lands is able to persuade the Minister for Finance and his colleagues to provide at Budget time.
That limitation was always there. It must be there because, whatever Government may be in office, they must have regard to a certain order of priorities and to making provision from taxation for those priorities. Control by the Department of Finance must be there for every State Department. This will not, as Deputy McQuillan implied, limit the Land Commission in any way. The new provisions in this Bill for such things as self-migration, pensions, and so forth, will cost money and operations by the Land Commission will, therefore, cost much more in the future than they have done in the past.
Comment on this
The Minister said that if these orders were to be placed before the Houses of the Oireachtas a great deal of red or green tape would be involved. The orders would have to go before the Government, and so on. Are we to take it that, if an order does not come before the Houses of the Oireachtas, then, by implication, the matter can be dealt with by one of the Minister's officials sanctioning the making of an order, and the whole matter will be finalised without being scrutinised by anybody?
That seems to have been the general theme of the Minister's statements. Perhaps I am reading more into the Minister's remarks than he actually meant but, on two occasions, at least, the Minister stressed the need for— will he forgive me using this word?— secrecy in dealing with these matters, because otherwise the cat would be out of the bag, and something would go wrong. I know I am mixing my metaphors, but I am sure the Minister understands what I mean. If the matter is put before the Houses of the Oireachtas, then everybody who is entitled to know about it will know about it. If it is not put before the Houses of the Oireachtas, then everything will be very much easier and we are to assume that it can be dealt with in some way which is not, in fact, the right way. If I have taken the Minister up wrong, perhaps he will put me right, but that is the idea I got from his statement.
Comment on this
I should like to clarify my mind on this matter before we leave this section. I understood the Minister to say he would consult the Minister for Finance to see if it is possible for these regulations to be laid before the House, or is it on something else he will consult with him? I could not follow the Minister. It seemed to me he was explaining to the House the many difficulties the Government face among themselves, which, of course, we appreciate.
Comment on this
I thought there was no one left in this country with a Hans Andersen imagination, but we still have Deputy Esmonde, even after the results of the recent by-elections.
Comment on this
Will the Minister ask the Minister for Finance if he will agree to that? I think it is the only fair and equitable thing to do. The Oireachtas should know what regulations are being made. I agree with what Deputy Hogan said. Whatever about the 1933 Act, or any other Act, the Minister will get more power under this Act than any Minister for Lands has had in the past. That may be right or it may be wrong but, right or wrong, the root of the matter is that the elected representatives should have the right to challenge. I could not agree more with Deputy McQuillan. It should not be decisions by officials behind the scene. I appreciate officials take a great many decisions in this country but it should be possible for elected representatives to challenge these decisions if we think they are wrong. To say we will obstruct and hold up for purely frivolous reasons is just so much nonsense. Unless the Minister can assure the House that he will suggest to the Minister for Finance that these regulations should be placed before Dáil Éireann I personally could not subscribe to this provision. The correct, proper and democratic procedure must be carried out.
Comment on this
In case Deputy Esmonde would not sleep peacefully tonight, I want to assure him that there is, in fact, no disagreement between members of the Government. Further, I can assure him there was no queue of Fianna Fáil Deputies' cars outside my house during the last three weeks to knife the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I just want to put Deputy Esmonde's mind at rest. The Government are not at loggerheads. Let me quote once more section 3 of the Land Act of 1933:
The Minister may, with the concurrence of a majority of a committee consisting of the Judicial Commissioner, the Secretary of the Land Commission, and a Lay Commissioner appointed for the purpose by the Minister and after consultation with the President of the Incorporated Law Society, make rules for carrying into effect the provisions (other than provisions relating to land purchase finance) of the Land Purchase Acts including this Act (except Part II thereof) and in this Act the word "prescribed" means prescribed by such rules.
Now, let me quote once more subsection (1) of section 2:
The power of making rules conferred by subsections (1) and (2) of section 3 of the Land Act, 1933, shall extend to and be exercisable for making rules for carrying into effect the provisions (other than provisions relating to land purchase finance) of this Act.
The rules made under this section must go through the procedure prescribed by section 3 of the 1933 Land Act. Far from these rules being something that nobody knows anything about, they must be examined by and have the concurrence of the Judicial Commissioner, who is a judge of the High Court, the Secretary of the Land Commission, and a Lay Commissioner appointed for that purpose by the Minister, and the President of the Incorporated Law Society must also be consulted. It should be clear to Deputies that this is nothing new or revolutionary. This is the procedure laid down by this House, in its wisdom, way back in 1933; it is being continued in operation in this Bill. There is also a provision that the rules must be published in Iris Oifigiúil. In my experience over 25 years, the only effect I ever noticed of this provision governing the laying of rules on the Table of the House was that it brought the matter to the attention of Deputies. I did not undertake to Deputy Blowick, as Deputy Esmonde suggested, that I would accept an amendment for the purpose of providing that these rules should be laid on the Table of the House. What I did say was that I would examine the matter, and if I saw no objection in principle to the suggestion, that when we made rules under this section, in addition to publishing these rules in Iris Oifigiúil, a notice would go to Deputies notifying them that such rules were being made. I know quite well, as do other Deputies, that if some rule is made here that in any way affects a constituent of any Deputy, the Minister for Lands, whoever he may be, will very quickly be questioned about it in the House and under our procedure here, if it is something the Deputy considers serious, he will table a motion to annul or amend the rule.
Comment on this
It would all depend on the Minister, on the view taken in the House and on what case was to be made for the complaint.
Comment on this
It is a question of what we might be preventing. What I might want to ensure would happen the Deputy might want to prevent. We will always have these disagreements and differences of opinion. I would be far more inclined to resist the suggestions made here because I can visualise that procedure acting as a delaying factor or brake on the work than for any of the reasons given here. I see no reason not to meet Deputy Blowick's suggestions but while I cannot state this authoritatively at this stage, I have a recollection that I had decided that it would be a delaying factor having to go through the procedure of having these rules laid on the Table of the House.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): On a point of information, the Minister has told us that the rules and regulations will be considered by the judicial commissioner of the Land Commission, a lay commissioner, the Secretary of the Land Commission and the President of the Incorporated Law Society, four very esteemed men, I am sure, although I do not know any of them. He has also told us that laying these regulations before the House will involve a lot of what he calls green tape. Will he tell the green Deputy what this green tape involves?
Comment on this
I do not know that there is anything further I can usefully add to what I have already said. I can assure Deputies that I have a genuine fear that by amending this section we might be running into a procedure that would delay the work of my Department. I have already undertaken that I shall look into the suggestion made by Deputy Blowick and, if I see nothing against it, on the Report Stage I shall give an undertaking to the House that Deputies will be notified as to the making of any rules under this section.
Comment on this
Again in regard to interference by the Minister for Finance, the Minister rightly pointed out on the previous section that the final decision in regard to the amount of money being made available to the Minister for Lands will be made by his colleagues, and particularly by the Minister for Finance. That power is simply a decision of policy as to whether a certain sum of money should or should not be made available to the Minister. What I want to establish now is how far into the workings of the Land Commission the hand of the Department of Finance penetrates. If it is on this question of the amount of money to be made available it is quite understandable that the Department of Finance would have some kind of rein but it would be disastrous to have further penetration by the Minister for Finance into the Department of Lands as a restraining influence on a section that has already held itself under severe restraint as far as expenditure and work are concerned.
I should like the Minister also to clarify for the House whether it is a fact that the Land Commission cannot now be blamed for the large amount of congestion existing in the country today. Whatever Governments have been in power have failed to make the money available; in other words, according to this Minister, the different Ministers for Finance have had the decision all through the years as to what money the Land Commission could spend.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that section 3 deals with money for administrative expenses.
Comment on this
Section 3 refers to the "payments made and expenses incurred by the Minister and by the Land Commission in giving effect to this Act". Apart from expenses, it refers to the payments made by the Minister. It goes on to say:
and in the administration thereof shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.
In other words the Minister for Finance can say to the Minister for Lands on this question of the relief of congestion: "Do nothing about it" and immediately the Land Commission become the cockshot in the public eye, and everybody outside says the Land Commission are doing nothing. The Minister would be doing a good day's work by explaining quite clearly that the Government and all Governments we have had since I came into the House, since 1948, must now bear the responsibility for the small amount of work done towards solving the problem in the areas in the Schedule to this Bill, namely, the congested areas. In other words, if there were a Government with the interest of congests at heart who made the money available, this Bill might not be necessary at all.
Comment on this
This is the usual section that goes into every Bill passing through this House to make financial provision for its implementation. It is true to say that any Minister for Lands or for that matter, any Minister for anything in this State, is depending upon his colleagues in the Government and the Minister for Finance to provide him with the necessary money to run his Department. As Deputies will know, each Minister must present his proposals to the Minister for Finance before Budget time and have agreement reached on the programme and on the amount of money it is estimated will be needed to give effect to it. There is nobody naïve enough in this day and age to believe that any Government or any Minister, and particularly the Minister for Lands, has some kind of Santa Claus over in Merrion Street who provides him with money any time he wants it.
The amount of money that will be provided for under this Bill and to give effect to it must be agreed upon by the Minister for Finance of the day and by the Government of the day. The Minister for Finance must know and have agreement among his colleagues on the amount to be allowed for the running of the Land Commission under the different heads set out in the Book of Estimates so that he can come along to this House with his Budget and the Book of Estimates and the provisions for the taxation that is necessary to meet that demand.
While no doubt we shall have Deputies such as Deputy McQuillan to preach the doctrine that an unlimited amount of money should be provided for this purpose under this section, the Deputy is not the first to go into the division lobbies to vote against taxation if he thinks it is popular with his constituents in Roscommon. It is the easiest thing in the world to preach here the wisdom of providing unlimited money for the purpose of the relief of congestion and at the same time to go back to the boys and to say in effect: "I voted against the 2d. on the cigarettes or the 1d. on the pint."
Each Government, considering their financial position with their Minister for Finance in any year, must decide as a Government—and this is where the collective responsibility referred to tonight comes in—what should be available in the order of priority of things for the land congestion problem and for any of the other problems which different Ministers of State have. In so far as our recent Budgets and Estimates in this House have been going, a very substantial amount of money has been provided year by year, and debated by the House, for the purpose of dealing with this problem.
There is also a limiting factor inasmuch as the Land Commission themselves must be geared to deal with an expansion of their activities in different areas.
To give a specific instance, we find now, in this particular year, that there are many migrants' holdings which will not be ready because the Land Commission have not been able to have the necessary buildings completed in time. You have all this—the amount of work that must be gone through and the amount of investigation that must be gone through by the outdoor staff of the Land Commission inspectorate— and that puts a limit on the amount of money that is capable of being expended in any particular year.
I am sure Deputies will complain on other sections about my proposal to take a short-cut towards the acquisition of land. Some of these provisions I know will probably be strongly debated in this House but, on the intake side of the Land Commission machine, there are tons and tons of green tape that must be eliminated if we are to get on with the job in a fairly reasonable time and there is not all that amount of land on the market in any specific year in respect of the amount of money that the Land Commission might have available for that purpose.
In many of these cases it takes, under existing procedure, maybe three, four or five years through the different processes of law that are there from the point at which the Land Commission start towards the acquisition of an estate until the job is finally finished before Judge Teevan and the Appeal Tribunal. It is not so simple as Deputy McQuillan would suggest that some Minister for Lands, having been given unlimited money, could go out and acquire all the land in just one year.
In my experience as Minister for Lands, there has been a constant and steady intake of land under the existing machinery and sufficient money has been provided for it under the provisions for the relief of congestion. Under this Bill, there are a number of sections which Deputies will well appreciate will involve the Land Commission in very high expenditure in addition to their existing programme. The amount to be made available must depend in any year on what the Government of the day decide they can afford to devote to this problem. The Government have authorised the introduction of this Bill and, accordingly, Deputies must assume that it is the Government's intention to implement the provisions in the different sections and to provide the money.
Comment on this
Would the Minister for Lands be at liberty to make use of the money provided in this section to increase the scale of farmyard enterprise in an uneconomic holding by providing up-to-date and adequate buildings and in this way make an uneconomic holding a viable holding? So far, apparently the Government and the Land Commission have appeared to think that the only way to make an economic holding is to give the holder an extra amount of land or money to buy additional land. It is felt that the problem of uneconomic holdings could be solved in another way in many cases. Could this money, therefore, be used for that purpose?
Comment on this
I am a little confused. I could not follow the Minister's line of reasoning. He said the Land Commission were not able to get enough land because the pool of land was getting smaller and it was more difficult to acquire land and he said that in any case the Land Commission were not able to relieve the congestion as fast as they would like because they had not the money to erect the buildings. These statements appear to be contradictory.
Comment on this
We shall have to wait until the Official Report comes out when we shall have another look at it. Perhaps then we shall be able to decide whether my interpretation of what the Minister said or what he actually said——
Comment on this
I said our migration programme this year was slowed down because we could not get houses built —not because of lack of money but because there is such a building boom in the country that we find it difficult to get contractors to build the houses which we require.
Comment on this
I have agreed with an awful lot of what the Minister said but that is an extraordinary statement and the Minister should know as well as I do that it is an awful lot of cod. Every time we run into trouble about not carrying out a task we always say there is a shortage of labour. If it is not a shortage of money it is a shortage of labour. The Minister has built a number of houses in County Meath and he knows he can get as many as he wants built there over the next twelve months. All he has to do is to provide the money. Furthermore, perhaps the Minister would tell us when he resumes the reason why estates have been held for up to seven or eight years. Are we now getting the correct reason—that either you cannot get men to build the houses or you have not the money to pay them, anyway?