Committee on Finance. - Transport Bill, 1964—Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–246 of 731. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 4 of 1964 ›
This is the first information I have received that amendment No. 1 has been ruled out of order. I cannot see how many amendment making provision about the disposition of the funds received by CIE could possibly be ruled out of order, particularly when a provision which allegedly has to do with the revival of the Irish language is considered to be of relevance to the Transport Bill while a provision which will affect some 600,000 people using the Dublin bus services is ruled out of order. The House is entitled to an explanation as to why it has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
It is not true that the Deputy has not been informed that his amendment is out of order. A letter has been sent to the Deputy by the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
The Deputy has not yet received it, and he was in the House all day yesterday and all day today. In any event, the House is entitled to an explanation as to why an amendment asking that the profits of the Dublin Transport services be used for the benefit of the users of those services was ruled out of order.
Comment on this
The letter sent to the Deputy informed him that it is long established practice that an amendment to an amending Bill such as this must be relevant to some provision in the Bill as read a Second Time. The amendment tabled by the Deputy did not satisfy those requirements and was accordingly ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I got this communication from the Chair only ten minutes ago. It informs me that amendments Nos. 5 and 25 in my name have been ruled out of order. With respect, Sir, I should like an explanation as to why these amendments have been ruled out of order. Amendment No. 5 is a simple amendment asking that the Board shall furnish to the Minister such information as he may from time to time require regarding matters which relate to its activities. It would be a great help to the Minister. From what we know of him in the House, the Minister is not apparently able to get any information from the Board.
Comment on this
Again, the Deputy was informed that it is long established practice in this House that an amendment to an amending Bill such as this must be relevant to some provision in the Bill as read a Second Time. I would point out to the Deputy that the Bill does not open up for amendment the existing position of CIE vis-à-vis the Oireachtas in relation to the conduct of its undertaking.
Comment on this
This amendment was put in last week. I was in the House all day yesterday until 10.30 p.m., and I got this letter only today —just now as I was coming into this House. That does not appear to be fair to me at all. I consider that amendment No. 5 should be allowed to stand. Section 3 states:
The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board.
In view of that, I think my amendment is a fair one.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment was very carefully considered and ruled out of order on the ground I have stated. I should also point out that the Bill deals with the financing of Córas Iompair Éireann, redundancy compensation, entry to the clerical grade of CIE, development of property by the Board and some other minor matters.
Comment on this
Surely Deputies are entitled to ask the Minister for Transport and Power questions regarding large outlays of finance by CIE from time to time? Surely we must try to protect the rights of the people by putting down serious amendments such as this?
Comment on this
I would point out to the Deputy that the Bill before the House is an amending Bill of a very restricted nature. The Bill in no way opens up for review all the powers and obligations of CIE.
Comment on this
The only restriction I can see is that CIE are now reduced to squandering £2 million.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I may be a bit more fortunate than the others who have raised this matter of the exclusion of these amendments. I was informed about an hour ago of this. I want to say, within the rules of order, to you that I think it is reasonable that we who are the victims of this continuous campaign of being ruled out of order, particularly in reference to this Minister and this Department, so far as amendments and questions are concerned, should have a public explanation in the House for the benefit of the people outside the House. I cannot circularise everybody in my constituency, nor can I afford the time or the money to do it, to let them know what has happened to my particular amendment which reads:
Córas Iompair Éireann shall institute a system of reduced morning and evening fares for persons going to or returning from their places of employment.
That is a vital matter which the public would expect would be discussed on this Bill. I am privately informed, an hour before this debate, that discussion will not be allowed upon that amendment. How am I to convey that to the electorate? There should be a public statement in the House in regard to these amendments and, with all due respect, Sir, I do not think that the explanation given by the Chair fits the situation.
I may say, with all due respect to you and to the Chair, that we are being asked to provide a colossal sum —£2 million—which must surely affect every aspect of the running of CIE and here we are being denied an opportunity to talk about this industry which is vital to the nation. We are being denied once again the chance to say what is in the minds of the people outside.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment has been rejected because it was not relevant to any provision in the Bill as read a Second Time. The Chair has no option but to rule it out of order.
Comment on this
On a point of order, this Bill is not described as an amendment Bill. I respectfully submit that a Bill cannot be considered an amendment Bill unless the word "amendment" appears in the title thereof. This Bill is described as "an Act to make further provision in relation to transport". I respectfully say the amendments to which Deputies T. Lynch and S. Dunne have referred and the amendments in the names of Deputy Byrne, Deputy Reynolds and myself—the one dealing with the Dublin services and the one which says that it shall be the duty of the Board to convey old age pensioners on scheduled passenger transport services of the Board free of charge—are matters which relate to the making of further provision in relation to transport. We are pressing this point and I am sure I am speaking for certain of my colleagues when I say that if you rule against us in this matter, the Committee Stage will proceed under protest and the Minister will have to await the further Stages of this Bill until such time as another tribunal, a proper tribunal, has determined whether or not the Chair's ruling in this matter is right.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment has also been ruled out of order because it is not relevant to any provision of the Bill as read a Second Time.
Comment on this
Was there any amount stated as being covered by the Money Resolution? For a concern that is to pay its way next year, we are voting, apparently, about £16 million plus something.
Comment on this
There is £16 million odd for a concern that was to pay its way next year—is that not right?
Comment on this
Surely it is six million pounds in the first paragraph and then two million pounds a year for five years. That is £16 million in my count and there is an extra £1 million, which makes £17 million, and then there is whatever is covered by paragraph (5). Is that not right?
Comment on this
I am raising this point because I want to know if the House is not to be allowed to discuss the expenditure, or potential expenditure, of £17 million plus, in relation to a concern which we were told is to pay its way this year or next year.
Comment on this
I am coming to section 3 in a moment. I want to know what is covered. My calculation is £17 million with whatever is the undetermined expenditure covered by paragraph (5), that is, the payment out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas of the expenses incurred in the administration of the Act. Certainly there is £17 million clear covered.
In those circumstances, I, with other Deputies, thought we had better have a new orientation towards the Minister in respect of the expenditure of these moneys, and I put down an amendment which you ruled out of order, that is, amendment No. 4, to the effect that the House should be informed from time to time on such matters as the Minister would require information on in order to keep Deputies informed and, through Deputies, to keep the public informed.
Under section 3, the Board is not to incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital. How are we to investigate that? If we ask questions, we will be told certain things are day-to-day administration and will not be permitted for discussion. As Deputy Ryan has pointed out, this is an Act to make further provision in relation to transport and one of the prohibitions now is that the Board is not to charge expenditure to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is required for the efficient operation of the undertaking or else that the expenditure will be remunerative. Again, how are we to know that? If questions are asked here with regard to expenditure, say, on a big number of lorries, and a refusal is given in the House to an application for information on that matter, how are we to know whether the judgment of the Board is to be accepted as to whether it is remunerative or not, unless we can ask these questions?
It is for that reason that I put down this amendment that we should have such information from the Minister as might be required to keep members of either House informed of the activities of the Board; in other words, to inquire whether it is properly chargeable to capital and whether it is remunerative.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment was ruled out of order because it was not relevant to any provision in the Bill as read a Second Time.
Comment on this
Anything that is covered by section 3 is relevant and capital expenditure is one thing which is covered, and, secondly, the question as to whether expenditure will be remunerative or not is covered. Surely, one is entitled to ask under that as to the administration of the Board in relation to capital expenditure and in relation to ordinary expenditure. I am making these points in order to ask you to withdraw the ruling that my amendment, No. 4, is out of order.
Comment on this
In order to get the debate back into order, I would ask the Minister to move amendment No. 6 to section 3.
Comment on this
Before you pass from this crucial issue, may I ask the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, without casting aspersions on the impartiality of the Chair, to indicate to me, whether or not the Ceann Comhairle consults with the Minister for Transport and Power or any member of his Department in considering questions and matters put to him by members of this House appertaining to the functions of the Minister for Transport and Power? Does the Chair act of its own volition or in consultation with the Minister's Department?
Comment on this
The Chair does not consult with any Minister or any Department. He rules according to the Standing Orders of this House.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not a fact that, if the Minister says he has no function in the matter, that finishes it as far as the Chair is concerned?
Comment on this
No. It is a matter for the Chair to decide whether the Minister has a function or not.
Comment on this
Could we deal with the Ministerial amendment to section 3 and the Deputy can then proceed to discuss his point on section 3. Amendment No. 6—the Minister.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 2, line 24, after "undertaking" to insert "or to enable it to carry out the general duty imposed on it by subsection (1) of section 7 of the Act of 1958".
In the course of the Second Stage debate in Dáil Éireann, Deputy Casey suggested that the provisions of section 3 might be interpreted to prohibit capital expenditure by the Board on the restoration and maintenance of long stretches of permanent way, sections of the railway which are not making a profit, or on the provision of better office accommodation and facilities for the staff, and similar views were expressed by Deputy Corish and Deputy Mullen. I also met the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on this matter and they were worried about the actual statement in the section and so I am moving this amendment so that it relates section 3 to subsection (1) of section 7 of the 1958 Act which reads:—
It shall be the general duty of the Board to provide reasonable, efficient and economical transport services with due regard to safety of operation, the encouragement of national economic development and the maintenance of reasonable conditions of employment for its employees.
The amendment therefore relates the general purpose of the section to that subsection of the 1958 Act and thus ensures that the capital can be spent when required for the proper maintenance of the system, for the restoration of the system, and that capital can be provided, if necessary, for social purposes within CIE for the improvement of social conditions within CIE.
Comment on this
The amendment goes some way to meet some of the objections made by Deputies of this Party. I note that the Minister referred to section 7 of the 1958 Act and said that CIE were charged with promoting general economic development in the country. I think I heard the Minister correctly in that.
Comment on this
The encouragement of national economic development and the maintenance of reasonable conditions of employment for its employees.
Comment on this
That satisfies me. I am sure that in this whole matter the Minister is concerned with maintaining employment as far as he can in, for example, the workshops of CIE, and I would say therefore that under section 7 of the 1958 Act, CIE must have regard to the value of employment in the workshops. The Minister, however, is aware that CIE have told the trade unions recently that from September next until January, 1966, they propose to construct 255 single-deck buses but that the parts for the construction of these will be in an imported condition — I understand the term is a "completely knocked down condition"—and that from the latter part of 1965 to March, 1967, the company propose to construct 120 double-deck buses and the material for these will also be in a completely knocked down condition. The Minister must also be aware of CIE's responsibility for maintaining employment and the desirability of doing all the work that can be done in their own workshops in this particular regard.
I am informed that CIE have told the trade unions that between 50 and 100 operatives will be dismissed by reason of this action by CIE. I know the Minister has been made aware of this and I should like the Minister's observations about the desirability of assembling and constructing buses and importing parts from abroad concurrent with the proposed dismissal of some 50 to 100 men. The Minister and CIE have a responsibility in this matter to maintain employment where it is possible to do this work in this country.
Comment on this
This matter will really arise more appropriately on the sections relating to redundancy but, if Deputy Corish would like me to deal with it now, I will. The decision to import the bus bodies in a completely knocked down condition is a departure from previous practice but it is only as regards the main framing of the bus body and the introduction of a quantity of fibre-glass into the design, and the outer panelling and inner trimming and finishing of the bodies will be carried out in the usual way as before. I gather that this is the result of worldwide changes in the techniques of bus design and manufacture and will enable CIE to incorporate up-to-date design and methods without being involved in prohibitive re-tooling costs. It is one of these inevitable productivity operations which are taking place in all parts of industry. In so far as redundancy may take place within the staff, there naturally will be negotiations between the trade unions and CIE. I would hope that we have reached the stage now where it may be possible for some of these men to be transferred to other parts of CIE and that re-training can be arranged for them. As the Deputy knows, the Minister for Industry and Commerce has already received a report from the CIO about re-training in industry consequent on new productivity methods. I think this comes within the ambit of those matters. In any event, CIE will certainly be negotiating with the trade unions with regard to the matter.
Comment on this
That is not entirely satisfactory from my point of view. The Minister says that the modern trend is to engage in a different type of construction and introduce fibre-glass into certain parts of the bus bodies and that we have to do this in the name of progress. Is it absolutely necessary to do all these things when it means the disemployment of anything up to 100 people? I do not know what reply the Minister will give us on the section dealing with redundancy but it was pointed out on the Second Stage that there was no suggestion—and I do not think there was any suggestion in the Minister's reply, either—that there would be redundancy compensation where men were displaced from workshops. It is not set out specifically in the Bill. It does not appear to us that there is any redundancy compensation in a matter such as that. These workers in the CIE workshops who have been engaged in the construction of buses, especially in the Spa Road workshops, have been complimented on their high degree of workmanship. I do not think the Minister should condone, or appear to condone, the disemployment of so many workers in the name of what is to me in any case doubtful progress.
The buses plying around the country seem to be satisfactory and are most attractive and mechanically they seem to be pretty good. Why we should in our present stage of development try to ape or copy the buses plying in the USA, Germany, France or Great Britain I cannot imagine. One of the fundamentals at present is to ensure that men will not be disemployed. I am not impressed either by the Minister's assurance that his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, has proposals for re-training and compensating and all that sort of thing. He, too, has been questioned about his proposals in regard to workers who will be rendered redundant by reason of anything the Government may do in preparation for our entry into the European Economic Community but he has not been specific.
I believe that we should not allow this sort of thing to happen, no matter what the results may be. We should not be importing buses in any condition at all. We have too many unemployed in this country and there has been serious redundancy in CIE. If the Minister can give me an assurance that these men will be placed in other sections of CIE, I will be satisfied but he has not given us any such assurance.
Comment on this
I have already given Deputies full information on this subject. I would say that the buses which we have in this country need replacement badly and I would also say that we need the most modern type of bus that can be found at whatever cost is reasonable. The competition between buses and people travelling together in motor cars is going to become more intense and unless we have buses produced by the most economic means and in the most up-to-date manner we can get, the only result will be a decline in the numbers travelling by bus. You may have possible reduction in employment for drivers, conductors and maintenance men on the one hand, and the possibility of some reduction in assembly, on the other. This is something that is going on all over the world. The more rapid the growth in the economy, the more substantial are the changes in techniques in industry.
CIE have agreed to enter into discussions with the trade unions as to what steps will be taken in the event of redundancy but it is impossible for me to say what arrangements for transfer will be made and also, if the economy advances, what demand there will be for people trained as fitters and vehicle builders. The Deputy has referred to extensive unemployment but I would argue that there is no very extensive unemployment among skilled workers in Dublin. In some sectors of industry in Dublin, there is good employment; in others, there may be occasional unemployment; but the Deputy has only to look at the figures given each month by the Central Statistics Office to see that the situation has changed very much for the better as compared with five or ten years ago. I do not think we need be unduly alarmed about this matter while the workers have the right to negotiate with CIE about the position.
I could not restrict the advance of modern design in bus building. I feel it is absolutely essential for CIE to have the most modern and up-to-date buses that can be obtained at a reasonable cost and I know that the new buses coming from CIE are much more advanced that those of previous years.
Comment on this
The Minister has said it is necessary for him to use new techniques in order to save money. Does the Minister mean that the new techniques should enable him to introduce buses that are too long? CIE bought buses that were 36 feet long while all the time 30 feet was the legal length of the buses allowed to travel the roads of this country. The Minister's colleague in the Department of Local Government made an order legalising that purchase. I put down a question to the Minister about the matter and he would not answer it. Now he is getting the result of that.
Comment on this
That is an old Tammany trick. When Jim Fisk was going to do something illegal, he first brought it to the Legislature and had it made legal.
Comment on this
Why do we have to import buses even partially assembled, as appears to be the case? What is the meaning of the term: "completely knocked down"? Why could we not import the material and build the buses from the ground up? I assume the new buses to be acquired will be something of the type we have brought over from England and which have been travelling around the roads in the south county for the past month or so. If that is so, there appears to be some doubt as to whether these will carry baby-carriages and prams. It is said that they are incapable of this. This may seem to be a light matter for some people here but it is not a light matter for the people of Ballyfermot where, thank God, they have the largest baby population in the country. I would like an assurance that these people's prams and baby-carriages can be carried on the new buses.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Dunne when he speaks about the problem of conveying prams and baby-carriages but I consider it equally important that we should provide for the carriage of elderly people with or without wheel chairs. What arrangements are being made by CIE and the Minister to see that these people are carried?
Comment on this
I am afraid I could not give any information as to the extent to which prams can be carried but CIE do their best to carry mothers and childern. I do not believe that any change in the type of bus will alter the extent to which these people can be facilitated. In regard to the question of assembly, this is a result of a worldwide change in the technique of bus design and it enables CIE to keep up with this design without having to undergo an extensive re-tooling process the cost of which would be very high. I could not give the cost of any particular type of bus but Deputies will be well aware of the enormous cost of a re-tooling process.
Comment on this
The Minister has said that CIE will do its best. Many years ago it was said that CIE would do its best to make the undertaking pay. Now we are being asked for £17 million for CIE. That is what CIE means by doing its best. There was a limit imposed, I expect, after consideration of safety on the roads, on the length of buses to be allowed. CIE apparently bought buses longer than the maximum length allowed and an amendment had to be made on an order by the Minister for Local Government in respect of that. Previously, as we know from questions to the Minister here which were not replied to, CIE bought engines which would only run backwards. All information on these matters was refused, the Minister saying this was day-to-day administration. The Minister has introduced an amendment which brings into the section that the Board is still under obligation to run an economic and efficient system. How would we know that? How would we know what capital expenditure is properly incurred? How would we know what capital expenditure is likely to be remunerative to the Board unless we are entitled to ask questions on that matter? Is the Minister now opening the door to us in that respect, so that when questions are put here, after section 3 and particularly after the amendment is carried, he will indicate why it is properly incurred capital expenditure and why the capital expenditure is likely to be remunerative?
The Minister said that there is no shortage of employment for skilled workers. Are we getting back to the old days when, if I remember them, railway employment was so secure that railway employees were not asked to subscribe to unemployment insurance? Their occupation was regarded as so good that they would never get any benefit from unemployment insurance. Does the Minister state we are getting back to that stage? Will he tell me, when he said the other day that 900 people have been declared redundant in CIE, whether they are people he would regard as being unskilled?
Comment on this
The Deputy will not trip me up on this. I have not made any statement precisely as to what will happen in connection with the future of CIE. I merely indicated general economic trends. I have no idea what the final negotiations will be between CIE and the trade unions in regard to the men who are affected by these changes in assembly. I was merely indicating that, by and large, CIE has been successful in negotiating with the trade unions in regard to these important matters and I hope, as a result of the improvement in relations that has taken place recently and the improvement in the method of negotiation, they will have further success. I am not committing myself to making any specific statement in regard to any particular group of men who may be found redundant in CIE in the future. I was just giving the general trend.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would confirm or deny the figures I gave him. Is it a fact that from September next until about January, 1966, CIE will import, in a completely knocked-down condition, of course, 255 single-deck buses and, from the latter part of 1965 to March, 1967, 120 double-deck buses? Will the Minister tell me what replacement period would be represented by the importation of 255 single-deck buses and 120 double-deck buses?
Comment on this
It is very important because I asked the Minister whether or not we are discontinuing the industry of bus building in this country.
Comment on this
I want to know what will be the effect on employment in the industry of the CIE proposal to import in a knocked-down condition 255 single-deck buses and 120 double-deck buses? If that is the replacement for five years, it means there will not be employment for five years. Will it always be the policy of CIE to import buses in a knocked-down condition rather than have them completely constructed here?
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is under an illusion about this. As the Deputy knows, there are quota restrictions in regard to motor assembly. CIE will be bound by the quota restrictions and import duties which apply to the whole of the motor car industry. They will be no different from the other assembly plants. They are putting themselves in line with that. They are merely taking the advantage of whatever degree of importation is permitted for the general motor car industry. They are not seeking to assemble here and there is no alteration in the general quota system or in the general import duty system. They will be in exactly the same position as other motor car assemblers.
Comment on this
The Minister said that any men who would be declared redundant would be looked after by CIE and alternative employment would be found for them. There were many men declared redundant by CIE in the past few years. They were offered jobs but the jobs they were offered were perhaps 70 or 80 miles away from where they were living.
Comment on this
If we do not say it now to the Minister, we shall never be allowed to say it. We shall never be ruled out of order. Now is the time to say it.
Comment on this
The Deputy could not be ruled out of order on section 9 when it is relevant. He can be ruled out of order at the moment.
Comment on this
The Minister has been asked whether the death-knell has been sounded for coach building in Inchicore. He told me yesterday 42 buses were brought into service at 31st March, 1964, at a cost of £455,000. It took three months to get that information from the Minister. What I want the Minister to tell me now is whether the figure that appeared in the Evening Herald two weeks ago of £900,000 for the purchase of buses in the past 12 months was correct or not. If we are to continue purchasing these buses from the Leyland Company, the Leyland Leopard and the Worldmaster, why should they not be brought in here in a knocked-condition to be assembled?
Comment on this
The Minister has not answered the question. He has only half answered the question. He said the bodies were brought in, glass fibre and so on. I am talking about the actual chassis. The Minister gave us no information about that. Is it a fact that they were brought in, ready to go without needing anything to be done to them? Believe it or not, I can give credit to the Minister and CIE in one respect. The Minister's area manager invited me and some other people last Monday to see some new coaches at Waterford railway station. They were magnificent and I was delighted to hear they were built entirely in Inchicore. This is what I want to know. If they are still able to build five coaches in Inchicore, why is the Minister bringing in these buses with the coachwork almost finished? These men only screw it together. Could the Minister not make a recommendation to CIE, as he has told us he is responsible for CIE, that in future the designers and the fine coachbuilders at Inchicore be given a chance of building the bodies for the buses entirely in the works?
Comment on this
It appears from the Minister's statement on this section that CIE intend to modernise their bus fleet and everybody agrees that is a good policy, even though it may be very costly. We should have first-class buses are not constructed in this country. It is a reflection on Irish industrial development that we must import these buses in a knocked-down condition. The Minister should again consult the Board of CIE with a view to getting these buses constructed in toto here. Otherwise, it is a reflection, as it suggests we cannot do that work. I am sure there are men capable of building these buses here.
I agree with modernising the bus fleet but I want to know from the Minister, if this section is approved, will we have an opportunity of discussing the purchase of these buses in the House subsequently, or will we be told by the Minister that he has no function in the matter? The Minister may not know that he has another name—the Minister without functions. I think he should indicate here whether or not he will answer Deputies' questions on the modernisation of the bus fleet.
Comment on this
The matter of answering questions put down by Deputies could arise on any section of the Bill. The Minister has made a number of statements here and has indicated that CIE is to modernise its bus fleet, purchasing a number of buses abroad. I want to know will the Minister be in a position to answer questions relating to these buses, asked in the House, or will he adopt the attitude that he has previously adopted of refusing to answer such questions. It is peculiar that some questions relating to the business of CIE, where the answer is likely to be favourable, can be answered.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting away from the amendment, which has nothing to do with answering questions.
Comment on this
I respectfully suggest that the matter of the answering of questions, whether the Minister will answer questions or not in this House, could arise on any section of, or amendment to, the Bill, because, as I said on Second Reading, this is one of the main grievances of the Opposition Benches. Several Deputies who spoke on the Labour and Fine Gael benches referred to this grievance which is an all-round one.
Comment on this
It does not arise on the amendment and, if the Deputy persists in discussing the particular point, I shall ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister if he would repeat for my benefit section 7 of the 1958 Act?
Comment on this
Would the Chair permit the Minister to say whether or not he intends answering questions on matters in connection with this section if they are asked at a future date in this House?
Comment on this
I did not wish to make any comment but merely to ask the Minister if he would read out for my benefit subsection (1) of section 7 of the 1958 Act.
Comment on this
The section reads:
It shall be the general duty of the Board to provide reasonable, efficient and economical transport services with due regard to safety of operation, the encouragement of national economic development and the maintenance of reasonable conditions of employment for its employees.
Comment on this
Would one not consider that CIE were not considering the safety of the public when they lengthened the buses from 30 feet to 36 feet?
Comment on this
The amendment was put and I interrupted to ask the Minister about the section of the 1958 Act.
Comment on this
The section reads:
The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board.
This has been amended by amendment No. 6 to this extent:
... after "undertaking" to insert "or to enable it to carry out the general duty imposed on it by subsection (1) of section 7 of the Act of 1958".
Herein is contained, I submit, the fundamental philosophy which has motivated every action of the Government towards CIE. The sole yardstick, as far as I can judge, the Government ever applied to the operation of CIE is one of economic profitability. This is where we in the Labour Party disagree with the Government's attitude towards public transport. It is not good enough that CIE should be regarded in the same light as that in which one would regard a private company operating in a commercial fashion with the principal motive of acquiring as much profit as it can for its owners and shareholders.
CIE is the property of the nation and its first function is to serve the nation by providing a transport system. If that can be done economically, well and good. If it can be done through the medium of trying to balance the budget, well and good. But, if we are to sacrifice the public good purely for the sake of being able to say we have narrowed the gap so far as deficit is concerned, while, at the same time, depriving the people of transport, that is no good whatsoever to the people. Not alone that but it is in direct conflict with all progressive thought in the matter of transport and in the matter of public services.
The Minister is very fond of referring to trends abroad in the world and to what is happening in other countries. Very often many of these references on his part have no relevance whatsoever to this country. The sectors of our economy, to use the abominable modern phrase now universally accepted, which compare with those of other countries are few and far between. We have a very different proposition here from what they have across the water, on the continent, or elsewhere. Leaving that aside for the moment, there is no country in the world in which it has been found possible to make transport pay, to my knowledge anyway, and we can hardly be expected to do it here. Inherent in this section, however, is the proposition that the Board must so operate that every act it does must be governed by the question of cost and the public good is not mentioned at all except in a general, meaningless way in a reference to previous Acts. When I refer to the public good, I refer to the possibility, for instance, that there may come to the Board of Córas Iompair Éireann at some time in the future, perhaps with a change of Minister, perhaps with a change of administrators in CIE, the notion that the people of Dublin deserve justice in the matter of fares. It must eventually dawn upon some Minister for Transport——
Comment on this
Oh, surely it does. I am giving the reasons why we are opposing this section, and these are the reasons——
Comment on this
I am about to indicate the faults we see in the section and the way in which we differ from the Minister and the Government in their attitude towards public transport. This section states that the main purpose of CIE is, in simple language, to make a profit. We disagree with that.
Comment on this
The Deputy's amendment has been ruled out of order. The Deputy has been informed why and he may not now raise the subject matter of the amendment in another way on the section.
Comment on this
I assure you I am not trying to do that. If I use words which have been used in the amendment, it is not with any ill-intention, such as trying to circumvent the ruling of the Chair, or anything like that.
Comment on this
Surely we are entitled on a Transport Bill to talk about things which concern our constituents. If we are not, then we are not a Parliament at all.
Comment on this
We will do our best, the Deputy and I, to ensure this will remain a Parliament. But the trend seems to be the other way. As I say, we in the Labour Party feel strongly that the Board of CIE should have as its prime consideration the provision of a transport service and the question of whether or not it can be made a profitable one is of secondary importance. The people of this city are long overdue a fair deal in this matter. I shall not push it further than that, except to say that it would be wrong for us in the Labour Party to let the section go without a protest against it, because, at some stage, the Minister, or some of his aides, will be sufficiently active to discover that we have no such intention. We will watch this Bill and every act of the Minister to ensure that we express, in so far as we are allowed to do so, the views of the Labour Party and the views of the ordinary people who have to put up with a great deal from CIE.
Comment on this
This section is a very wide one and I should like to ask the Minister now whether questions arising from the operation of the section will in future be answered in this House.
Comment on this
I am basing this on the section, as amended, and, since it deals with expenditure properly chargeable to capital, will questions on such expenditure be answerable in this House? With respect to you, Sir, I think that question arises directly on this section.
Comment on this
May I ask a further question? I understand it is intended that CIE provide a national service. Deputy Dunne spoke about CIE making transport pay. Am I to assume that in particular areas where transport does not pay services will be withdrawn, as they were withdrawn in the Schull-Goleen area? We are asked here to provide money to the tune of £2 millions to subsidise CIE. That £2 millions will be drawn from the people of the country as a whole. Everyone is asked to pay his or her share of taxation to meet the CIE demands on the Exchequer, but, in some section, where the Minister indicates that a loss is shown on the operation of CIE services, those services will be withdrawn. I am not now dealing with rail services. They have been dealt with here in great detail already. I am dealing with bus services. The service from the town in which I live to the adjoining town of Goleen has been withdrawn.
Comment on this
This is an amending Bill of a restrictive character and these questions of detail do not, therefore, arise.
Comment on this
It is not so described. It is a Bill to make further provision in relation to transport.
Comment on this
Might I point out that it does not open up a debate on the transport code of the whole country?
Comment on this
Am I right in asking whether this Bill is so restricted that we cannot address ourselves to the question as to whether or not CIE intends in future to restrict services in areas which are not showing a profit?
Comment on this
The Deputy may raise the matter on an Estimate, but it is not relevant on section 3, as amended.
Comment on this
Is it in order then to raise a matter of legislation on an Estimate? We are stymied every way, no matter how we try to raise it.
Comment on this
You will agree, Sir, that it was only today you sent me a letter refusing an amendment. I had a letter from our esteemed Ceann Comhairle on 10th June refusing a question.
Comment on this
Now, on a debate on transport, we are told to sit down and that we may not address ourselves to several questions which are of interest to the people and of interest, in particular, to the people we represent here.
Comment on this
So far as transport is concerned, an attempt is made to stifle any discussion. That is an unfortunate outlook.
Comment on this
I want to object to this section. First of all, this is very narrowly restricted, we are told. It is an amending Bill to amend an already restricted piece of legislation. In fact, it is not so at all. The Long Title is "to make further provision in relation to transport". Part of the further provision is apparently contained in section 3, apart from the amendment, which I shall deal with particularly. Apart from the amendment, which has, apparently, been accepted, two points arise on the section. One is whether certain expenditure is, first of all, chargeable to capital or whether it is essential for the efficient operation of the undertaking and, the second, whether the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure is remunerative.
On the question of being remunerative, amendments have been mentioned calling for the institution of a system of reduced morning and evening fares for persons going to or returning from their places of employment. Surely that arises from the matter of remuneration? It is well known that both Aer Lingus and Aerlínte offer seats at very reduced rates to certain special passengers. Those passengers may not take up the seats unless there are no other occupants for them. In other words, Aer Lingus and Aerlínte believe it to be remunerative to carry certain people at one-tenth of the ordinary charge if certain conditions prevail. Is that the sort of thing CIE would ever bring under consideration, that they might have empty buses at certain non-peak hours and it might be possible for them to get passengers at reduced rates—people going to or from their work? Surely that would come under the heading of whether or not the expenditure is remunerative?
The second matter that arises on this—possibly it could be dealt with by way of question—is whether expenditure chargeable to capital is required for the efficient operation of the undertaking. Surely, on that, it would be possible for Deputies to make inquiries as to what the expenditure is likely to be in amount and how far it will be remunerative and whether it is required for the efficient running of the undertaking?
I did not know until I heard it from Deputies that certain buses are so constructed that there is no room in them for prams and for the carriages used for the conveyance of small children. Surely that is a matter that should be inquired into? Would it not help the efficiency of the undertaking that places be provided in buses for prams and a baby carriages? Would not one be entitled to query whether capital expenditure on a bus without such accommodation for children was a proper capital charge and whether it would assist the efficiency of the undertaking?
I hold these things are open to examination. Even though an amendment has been ruled out of order asking that a system of reduced morning and evening fares for persons going to or from work be instituted, it seems to be quite open, after this section is passed in its restricted form, to query what public services CIE might be asked to run for special people at special hours and, secondly, whether or not they should be asked to see their buses will give the accommodation that might be required for children in thickly populated areas.
In any event, the whole situation has changed as between this Bill and the 1950 Act, and even since the 1958 Act. Up to 1958 there was the pretence, maintained by the Minister's refusal to answer questions, that CIE was going to meet its obligations without any subvention from the taxpayer. We have abandoned all that. CIE is now carrying on what amounts to a social welfare service. It is no longer an economic transport undertaking. It is dependent on the taxpayer. By this very big enlargement of the restricted Transports Acts up to this, I suggest Deputies have an enlarged area of inquiry as to what CIE is doing under social welfare conditions.
Comment on this
The section, as amended, imposes an obligation on the Board to consider the encouragement of national economic development. Therefore, it seems proper to us in Fine Gael to allow the House to consider a number of aspects of public transport and the manner in which they affect economic development. One of the greatest problems affecting about 300,000 people who want to avail of the facilities offered by CIE is the lack of facilities provided for those people. I am concerned particularly with people within a radius of two or three miles of Dublin city centre and taking a radius of about five miles. There is a wheel around Dublin city about two miles in width in which people find it extremely difficult to board buses going to or from their work. This is keeping many working people late for their daily employment and is thus having a grave effect on the economic development of Dublin. CIE and the Minister have consistently refused to tackle this matter and give it serious consideration. The continued growth of Dublin, with consequential extension of routes of up to eight miles from the city centre, has meant that people who reside halfway on those routes find it extremely difficult to board buses. Indeed, the extension of the 5-day week and the increase in the number of people commencing work daily at 9 a.m. and completing work at 5.30 p.m. will multiply that difficulty in the years immediately ahead.
It seems to us in Fine Gael and to all Dublin Deputies that CIE has failed entirely to consider this problem and to attempt to solve it. It will have to acquire additional vehicles for its transport fleet if this difficulty is to be overcome. Even though that may mean there will be a large number of vehicles lying idle for the remainder of the day, if we are to move with the times and meet the needs of these people, we will have to accept the additional capital liability, particularly when we have increased the peak and valley periods. That is what we are doing by allowing the extension of uniform hours of working from 9 a.m. to 5.30 p.m.
The difficulty we have in giving powers like this to CIE is that CIE may interpret them in an extremely narrow sense. It is because it has done so that the transport facilities the people have a right to expect are not being provided. It is important that the difficulties people experience in relation to public transport should be voiced in this House so that the Board will appreciate how they are failing in the duty which we, as legislators, have imposed on them.
It seems most undesirable that we should be taking away work from the Dublin coachbuilders. There is a long and honourable tradition of coachbuilding in Dublin. We have been among some of the best coachbuilders in the world. The coachbuilding works at Spa Road has built up its own tradition over its half-century of experience. I do not believe it is beyond the capacity of the engineers, coachbuilders and designers of Dublin to devise some means of producing reasonably cheap, safe and efficient coach work. I do not at all accept the Minister's contention that it is necessary to import so many of these vehicles in an almost completed state. There are many ways in which coaches and buses can be built and there is no necessity for this country to follow slavishly whatever practice may exist elsewhere. We ought to endeavour to use our own equipment and our own talents. This is part of the duty which the Board should try to discharge under their obligation to encourage national economic development.
The question of the facilities which are to be offered to the people who want to travel by CIE also comes within the general description of national economic development. It is surely a part of national economic development that we should try to extend public transport services to all sections of the community.
Deputy McGilligan has referred to the practice which apparently has been accepted as being respectable in air transport of offering cheaper fares at off periods. To some extent, this principle has been accepted in Dublin by having a cheaper rate of a twopenny trip during the valley periods. It would appear to be equally arguable that CIE ought to have cheaper facilities for all persons offering during valley periods, but, if CIE think that is going too far, we feel that certainly CIE should have cheaper fares or no fares at all for old age pensioners who would travel during the valley periods. This would not be imposing any additional strain on CIE finances because, as things are at the moment, the cost of public transport is so great that it discourages and prevents old people from travelling at all.
Comment on this
On a point of order, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle has already ruled out discussion on all these matters because they are all referred to in certain amendments. I want to know whether I am to be allowed to reply to them. When the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was in the House, he ruled discussion out of order on the amendment put forward about reduced morning and evening fares for persons going to or returning from their places of employment. He ruled out a number of amendments. Now they are being discussed in general on the section. I am quite willing to answer them if I have your permission. I want to know if I am to prepare notes in advance in order to answer them.
Comment on this
The Minister can be assured that he will be allowed to answer any questions raised in the Dáil.
Comment on this
We are trying to get the Minister to answer questions. That is the main reason for this debate —to try to get him to answer.
Comment on this
We will have an allnight sitting if the Minister needs it to reply to all the questions, now that we find that it is the Minister who is anxious.
Comment on this
I have already answered all the Deputy's questions on the Second Stage—every single one. The Deputy wants to repeat them for the sake of getting publicity.
Comment on this
The Minister did not answer any questions I asked. There were five questions of mine which he did not answer.
Comment on this
Would Deputy Lynch allow Deputy Ryan to continue?
Comment on this
A good thing cannot be repeated too often and, if repetition embarrasses the Minister, then he will either have to suffer or give up the portfolio. I do not think transport would suffer if he did hand it in tomorrow. It would become more efficient. We accept the pattern of general economic development when we extend public services to all sections of the community and, if we accept that as a valid principle, as we do here, then the provision of transport for all sections of the community falls within the ambit of the obligation which lies on the Board. If this House is indicating that this obligation must be carried out in a generous way and if the Board do not carry it out in a generous way, it will be the Minister, and the Minister alone, who prevents CIE from carrying out the wishes of this House and the Minister will have to accept responsibility for that and will have to submit to continued questions and criticisms by Deputies if he is the person who continually holds back the Board from carrying out the wishes of the people.
Comment on this
Could this section be interpreted later on by the Board as precluding them from providing services which they would deem uneconomic? For instance, the Board may say that under section 3 of this Bill, they are not allowed to invest capital in providing a service which, in their opinion, would not show a profit. We know from our experience of the 1958 Act the type of interpretation that CIE may be likely to give to sections of this Bill, so we must be very cautious in our approach in this House. Could CIE use this section in reply to representations that may be made? If I or interested parties in west Cork were to make representations to the Board subsequent to this section becoming law for resumption of a bus service which existed up to a short time ago on the Schull-Goleen route, could CIE say that under section 3 of the Transport Bill, 1964, it was precluded from providing capital towards that service, that the Act specifically precluded it from doing so?
I have criticised the Minister for Transport and Power on a number of occasions. At the same time, I have a certain admiration for him. I felt that even though his statements might have been unfounded, the Minister believed in his statements. I was surprised that in his reply to assertions made by me on the Second Reading of this Bill the Minister was untruthful. I will not say that he was deliberately untruthful, because I feel that he was not, but I must say that so far as this particular route is concerned, which is of great significance to the part of the country from which I come, and to which the Minister addressed himself on Second Reading, he indicated a weekly loss of £12. That figure is far in excess of the figure I gave in this House and which I and my colleagues got officially from CIE. We were told that the loss on this route was up to £8 weekly. It is the general belief that the loss was not even £8 weekly. When the Minister came to reply in the House he used the figure £12 weekly. I am not saying that the Minister intended to be untruthful but I wonder did CIE, in order to support his argument against providing a service on this route, deliberately inflate the figure and hand the Minister his brief setting down a figure of £12 weekly. If so, they are not a company which could command our respect if, in support of their attitude in the withdrawal of the services on this route, they told the Minister a deliberate untruth and thereby led the Minister into making an untruthful statement in this House, a statement which is contrary to the official information which the three members of the Dáil from Cork South-West got officially from CIE.
I should like the Minister to review this matter. I should like, in particular, him to answer the question I posed at the outset as to whether or not anything contained in section 3 of this Bill could be used subsequently by CIE as an argument against providing a service which in its opinion may not be economic.
Comment on this
In regard to the character of the Dublin bus services, I have already dealt with that in detail on the Second Stage of the Bill. I pointed out that congestion in the Dublin bus services relates to a number of factors. If Deputies will read the Pacemaker Report, Volume 2, they will see an analysis of the time lag for buses passing during peak hours at various points in Dublin at different hours in the day. They will note that, although it is true that the present changes in the use of the roads in Dublin have improved the position, if the number of buses was very largely increased during peak hours, it might not have any effect in regard to solving the position of people waiting for buses. I said that, and I also pointed out that CIE is now engaging in the process of reorganising its Dublin bus services. It is establishing a traffic control centre in O'Connell Street and decentralising traffic inspectors, putting in more time clocks to control the movements of buses and generally undertaking a reorganisation of the service. Naturally when traffic rules in regard to one-way streets are altered, the whole pattern of bus services has to be re-examined and CIE has this question of congestion constantly in mind.
Another question that was raised was about bus fares. It would be quite impracticable to offer reduced fares to workers going to and from their place of employment and to identify them would be difficult. Where this practice has been tried out, the position now is they are trying to get rid of it. It is far better to establish a sound economy and to have such a level of wages that people can afford to travel to work by bus or in whatever vehicle is appropriate.
I do not need to give again the figures in relation to increased bus fares, increased social service levels, the increase in the cost of living and the increase in workers' earnings over the past five or six years. If Deputies go back to a previous Estimate speech, they will find the relationship of these various things to one another and which have a very human significance. It can be said in general that the prosperity of the people is growing and that to try to arrange special fares for special sections is not the best way to do it; the way to do it is to have bus services as efficient as possible, to provide fares for school children and to provide valley fares at particular times. That seems to be the simplest way of dealing with the matter in general.
Deputy Murphy raised the question of the Goleen and Schull bus services. I am afraid it would be quite impossible if we were to have continuous debates on the existence or closing of every individual bus service in the country. You could take up the whole time of the House if you had questions like that discussed. It is my responsibility and I am prepared to take full responsibility to see that CIE which is now subsidised by the State relates social needs to economic services in a proper manner. I am not going to judge the issue by individual isolated complaints which are made. I have to judge the issue as a whole, of how far the rest of the people can be asked to pay a tax in order to support any bus service. This is a question of watching a general trend, seeing whether complaints multiply, whether there is a great volume of complaint in a particular area. It is my job to exercise a general supervision in that matter. I take full responsibility in this House for any deficiencies in the services of CIE which are the result of my failing to hold a general supervisory position over the provision of services by CIE.
Having said that, there obviously must be some limit to the number of bus services provided. It is quite obvious that CIE could double its services all over the country and you could find one or two or three people going into a bus and the bill before this House would be absolutely enormous. I and my Department have studied the report of CIE on this matter and in relation to the provincial road passenger services, of which there are 234, two-thirds yield an annual revenue of less than £5,000 and account for only 15 per cent of the total revenue in this section. Of this figure, 73 services are wholly profitable, nine are marginally profitable and the remaining 152 are unprofitable. Generally the short distance services are the least profitable.
Taking it large and wide, if that statement is studied, it will be seen that the social need with regard to the provincial bus services is not being ignored. I do not think the existence or the non-existence of a particular country bus service can be looked at in isolation from the general pattern or from the volume of private transport which is constantly growing. I do not believe the bus services are second-class. Taking it large and wide again, the pattern of bus services in the cities and the country is fairly satisfactory in so far as we can compare it with other countries. I have examined map routes of buses in other countries; I have examined the bus structure in rural areas of Scotland; and I have had talks with the head of the Highland Bus Company in order to get some comparative idea of the extent to which social need is satisfied. I believe it is satisfied fairly well by the present bus service. In so far as my responsibility in this House is concerned, as I said before, if I started to get a great many complaints from people and on examining these complaints found that the social needs were not being provided for adequately, I would have to see CIE and discuss the matter. That seems to me to be a reasonable statement.
There is one further point. I note that there is now a definite cleavage of opinion between Deputies of the Labour Party and of Fine Gael. The members of Fine Gael are very much alarmed at the total provision of capital and subsidies to the tune of £17 million, whereas Deputy Dunne implied that even though we are providing £2 million a year, CIE, and I as Minister supervising this expenditure, still have the idea that CIE should pay its way. I do not see how CIE can pay its way if it is subsidised to the tune of £2 million but I know that £2 million is a considerable impost on the taxpayer, and I should like very much when any proposals for great reductions in the fares are made by Deputies that they would vote for the increased money involved. As I indicated, we can examine the level of the subsidies later. It is impossible to make an absolute comparison of subsidies for transport services, but so far as we can get an approximate comparison we find that the subsidy afforded to CIE comes within the higher echelons of subsidies to transport companies in Europe. In other words, by any method of comparison, it is a fairly high subsidy.
Comment on this
The Minister says that he takes full responsibility in this House for CIE but the test of responsibility is the capacity to be questioned and to give satisfactory answers. The Minister has had that responsibility for years and the way he has evaded it is by getting the aid of the Chair and the House to base its rulings on the phrase "day-to-day administration is to be excluded". If the Minister will answer questions for the future, very well.
The Minister tells us that CIE has to be made remunerative. This Bill is a confession that it cannot be made remunerative. There is at least £2 million lacking in what would be necessary to make it remunerative. The Minister has failed to answer Deputy Murphy's very particular question as to whether it will be possible hereafter for the Minister to say that a service is not remunerative. I think it is quite clear that in the future the Minister will not be able to say that a service is not remunerative. It is not he that will say whether it is remunerative or not but the Board of CIE. The Bill says that the Board shall not incur expenditure properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that it is essential to efficient operation or that the project will be remunerative to the Board.
That means that we are putting this whole question outside the control of the House. Whenever a question is raised, the ruling of the Chair will be that the Minister has no function in the matter. The Chair will rule under this section that the Board must be satisfied that the expenditure is essential to efficient operation or that the project will be remunerative. How does the Minister propose to get between the Board and this House? He has evaded responsibility all along the line and this section provides him with a better opportunity than ever to evade responsibility still further.
Comment on this
The Minister has not answered my question on section 3. I must confess that I was under a complete misapprehension as far as the proposal to close the Schull-Goleen section is concerned. I will never have an opportunity of saying this again and for that reason I propose to address myself briefly to it. I understood that it was CIE closed this bus route but I now interpret the Minister as saying that it was he closed it.
Comment on this
You said you took full responsibility for it. So far as the Minister is concerned, there is no social need for this bus service to Goleen. It does not earn a profit. But it would be difficult for it to be profitable because no parish in Ireland has suffered more from emigration. Within the past ten years, more than 600 people left that parish for England and even more will leave if things go on as they are. It is completely out of place for the national transport body of this country to remove this bus service from the most extreme parish in this country. As a Dáil representative for the area and as a person living within a few miles of Goleen, I want to protest vehemently against the Minister's attitude in this matter.
On the Second Stage of the Bill, I appealed to the Minister to review the position and I told him on that occasion that it was not constitutionally right to deny to these people services that are provided from the national funds. They are as much entitled to retain this service as are any of the people living on the 152 other mainly unprofitable routes the Minister mentioned here. He said that there were 152 other mainly unprofitable routes. Why should Goleen be picked out and the other 73 left in? If one were to judge impartially, it would be all right to say that we cannot continue to pay a subsidy to CIE and that so we must wipe out the unprofitable routes but a large number of these are to be retained. That is what this Bill is for.
If CIE were a paying concern, there would be no need for the Board to come along here and ask for a subvention amounting to £33 million as between 1958 and 1968. As things are going, they may have to increase on that. I am making the case that it is not constitutional for CIE to withdraw a service from a parish such as Goleen which has enjoyed that service up to the present. At the same time, the people of that parish must contribute their share of that £2 million annually, plus the million pounds being written off under this Bill. I am appealing to the Minister to address himself to the question of the closure of the bus service to the parish of Goleen. It may be a short route and it may not be used extensively but, from every point of view, the parish of Goleen is entitled to have its bus service restored.
Comment on this
The Minister made an untruthful statement in the House. When I referred to that, I said that it was not a deliberate untruth as I felt he would not be guilty of telling a deliberate untruth. I assume the information he got was misleading and was different from the information supplied to the public representatives of west Cork. The Minister deliberately availed of that in order to make a good case in the House but his statements were untruthful and I hope he was not responsible for that himself.
Comment on this
The Minister told us that about a fortnight ago, and when I asked where he got these figures, he said that they were broken down in the Pacemaker Report. I asked him for particulars regarding one particular service and he refused pointblank to give them to me. How can we ever get these particulars?
Comment on this
We have no objection to keeping CIE going but we are entitled to question the Minister.
Comment on this
I have explained it all at great length and, if the Deputy wishes, I will do so again.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Lynch could be allowed to make his contribution.
Comment on this
I am extremely grateful to you, Sir. The Minister is coming before the House to get £2 million a year for CIE and he says that we are not in favour of that. We know that the railways have to be kept going and we have said that all along. We did not say that they could make a profit but we are entitled to ask about the services provided and we are entitled to an answer from the Minister. The Minister is like people who, years ago, used to be found mute of malice.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Coughlan. The Minister has belittled the House. We come in here as responsible representatives of our constituents. We come in here to pass a vote of £2 million a year for CIE. Of course the Minister considers that £75,000 is only small beer. We come here to ask him to break his silence. He is like a fortress there. He will not allow us to ask any questions about anything. This is a very serious matter. If Deputies are to be stopped from asking Ministers questions about companies for which they are responsible or in which the Ministers are share-holders——
Comment on this
This section does not deal with Ministers' questions.
Comment on this
If you bear with me a little while, I shall explain. We had the example some time ago of a company in which a Minister was a big shareholder and practically had a responsibility, and nobody could ask a question about it in the House. Terrible things were happening inside that company, so much so that a brave servant of that company had to sacrifice himself——
Comment on this
May I point out that this has nothing to do with the section?
Comment on this
It has something to do with this section, which reads:
The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board.
We can never find out anything about that and, that being so, the same thing can happen. This is the most serious thing that has happened since I came into this House ten years ago. The Minister is standing over that. I make no accusations against the officials in Kingsbridge. However, it is possible for the same thing to happen there as happened in respect of the company I have mentioned. It should not be expected that some brave public servant will have to sacrifice himself, lose his job, in order to let the people outside know what is happening.
We do not intend to ask questions about small matters of day-to-day administration but we are entitled to ask questions about the expenditure of £900,000. We are entitled to ask questions as to whether a bus service is paying or not when we know the Minister has the information. The Minister will get his Bill more quickly than he ever thought if he will say he is prepared for the future to meet Deputies by answering reasonable Parliamentary Questions in relation to the running of CIE.
Comment on this
The Minister said he would listen to representations on bus services, and so on. I want to put before him the case of a bus service in the suburbs of Dublin city. I might say, in passing, in regard to his reference to CIE delivering the goods as well as any bus service in any other country, that may be, but I have seen with alarm down through the years the growing queues for buses in my constituency and in every other constituency in Dublin. I am sure it is a matter of concern to the Minister and CIE officials. I can remember the days of the trams and, while I do not necessarily want to see the trams back again, I never saw in those days queues 30 or 40 yards long at 5.30 in the evening in the centre of the city as I see every evening now.
Comment on this
The Minister said he was prepared to listen to representations, and representations have been made to the company again and again.
Comment on this
It arises on the question of expenditure. The claim has been made that it will cost money to extend the services but I believe that if an extension were made to the service in Mount Merrion, it could be made more profitable. I should be obliged if the Minister would take that up with the company. Deputy Murphy referred to a bus service in County Cork so I felt I should refer to one in the suburbs of Dublin.
Comment on this
The section relates to capital expenditure.
Comment on this
It is an opportunity to place seriously before the Minister the general dissatisfaction which exists in regard to bus services at peak hours in Dublin. I refer particularly to the area of Roebuck, the No. 11 bus service, an area in which there is an old folks' home with 300 or 400 old people in it, where houses are being built every other day, an area which contains huge schools and where people have to walk long distances——
Comment on this
I have pointed out that this line of discussion is not in order.
Comment on this
I shall accept your ruling. On the section, I want to draw to the Minister's attention the fact that there is general dissatisfaction in that respect on the part of the citizens of Dublin.
Comment on this
This is a capital expenditure section. It is worth remarking that the control of public expenditure, capital or revenue, is a fundamental function of every democratic Parliament. The Minister is bringing the institutions of parliamentary representation and parliamentary government into complete contempt and disrespect by reason of the policy which he is adopting in regard to these matters raised here this afternoon. It is a very serious development and a very grave reflection on the Minister's respect for the fundamental principles of democracy that he condones the action of CIE in refusing fully to account to the public for their stewardship through this Parliament and through him. It is a very salutary thing that there has been such a to-do——
Comment on this
The Leas-Cheann Comhairle has alredy refused to allow an amendment to appear on this subject.
Comment on this
I am taking the same line as has been taken by other speakers during the past hour and I am as much entitled to do so as they were.
Comment on this
If that line relates to amendments up to No. 5, they have been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I am not dealing with any amendment; I am dealing with section 3. I shall read it:
The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board.
A previous speaker has pointed out that the criterion upon which this section is based is that of efficiency and has suggested there is a case for applying other criteria to CIE.
Comment on this
The section has been amended, and I shall read for Deputy Colley's elucidation the section, as amended.
3. —The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or to enable it to carry out the general duty imposed on it by subsection (1) of section 7 of the Act of 1958.
Comment on this
The Minister is showing absolute contempt for the democratic process and that is a very grave matter for the country.
Comment on this
Whether the discussion has been in order, I am not quite sure, but in view of the fact that Deputy Byrne has been allowed to make the case he has made, I presume the Chair will allow me to make the case in reply. It seems to me completely wrong for Deputies to come into the House and speak as Deputy Byrne has spoken about the Minister for Transport and Power showing complete contempt for Parliament. The fact is that Parliament has laid down the way in which we are to treat not only CIE but other State bodies.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy must keep to section 3.
Comment on this
It appears it has been deemed that under section 3 one may suggest that the House is entitled to obtain details of any expenditure. It will be remembered that the argument was not confined merely to capital expenditure. As I said already, I was somewhat doubtful whether that was in order, but, as it has been allowed, I was endeavouring to answer the general case that has been made and to suggest that Deputies who are trying to make this case are not on the right lines, in my opinion. I shall support them on the general principle and there might be many people, perhaps including the Minister—I do not know: I am speaking personally and I have not discussed it with him, but knowing the Minister I feel he might be concerned about this problem—who will be concerned for this principle. But the manner in which it is being approached here is, I suggest with due deference to the Deputies who have spoken, merely wasting time.
Surely what is involved is the general principle applying to all State companies, and if we want to deal with this, what we should be devoting ourselves to is the principle of providing them with Parliamentary control and at the same time allowing these bodies to operate as commercial organisations rather than Civil Service organisations. There are many ideas I could put forward on this subject but I do not propose to do so now. I suggest that this is a general problem which is becoming more and more acute in all countries, not only in this country, and to get up and attack the Minister as to why he is trying to do this is merely wasting the time of the House.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 4 was specifically ruled out.
Comment on this
The Minister has been wasting the time of the House over the past two years—and the public's money. The Minister for Justice got his Estimate——
Comment on this
That is out of order, and the Deputy knows it.
Comment on this
Every other Fianna Fáil Minister will give us information and we are entitled to get it.
Comment on this
If the Deputy proposes to discuss getting information, I must point out that amendment No. 4 which deals with that has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
Is there no section in this Bill on which we can ask the Minister to give this House some information relative to the duties of CIE and where it will be in order to do so?
Comment on this
At the moment we are dealing with section 3, as amended.
Comment on this
And on that section the Minister said he took full responsibility for CIE. How do we find out how he discharges his responsibility?
Comment on this
The Minister has been wasting the time of this House since he became Minister for Transport and Power. He knows that himself and every member of his Party knows it.
Comment on this
The Oireachtas has the right to ask questions and the Minister has denied us the right to get answers to any questions about CIE. This is an important matter when the Minister wants £2 million from the House.
Comment on this
That amendment has been ruled out and I cannot allow a discussion on it. The Deputy must cease discussing it.
Comment on this
The Deputy is discussing the subject matter of that amendment.
Comment on this
An amendment to section 3 has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
I am quite well aware of that. I got about five minutes notice of it, coming into the House this afternoon. With no other Minister does the like of this happen. It is a long time since anybody's amendments were ruled out of order in this House.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I must have this matter adjudicated on by the Chair. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle who was here earlier said very clearly that the Department of Transport and Power played absolutely no part whatever in ruling these amendments out of order. Does the Chair confirm that?
Comment on this
The Department had absolutely no hand in it whatever, directly or indirectly, or by any kind of communication.
Comment on this
The Minister says he did not do it. The Deputy must accept the Minister's statement.
Comment on this
That is not the question. It is a question that the Leas-Cheann Comhairle said there had been no communication with the Department or myself. It was the Leas-Cheann Comhairle who said it, not I.
Comment on this
The Minister pointed out that during the Committee Stage the matter I am dealing with now was dealt with at length. If it was in order to talk about it then, why is it not in order now? This is a very important issue before the House with regard to CIE. We are to give them £2 millions. They will get it. We know that CIE must be kept going and we have always said so. It was the Minister, or his predecessor, who said he would make a profit out of it. What I want to know from the Minister is how we are ever to get information from the Minister after the Minister leaves this House with this Bill in his pocket.
Comment on this
That does not arise on section 3, and that has been the ruling all day.