Committee on Finance. - Transport Bill, 1964—Committee Stage.
Contributions 247–491 of 731. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 4 of 1964 ›
Section 3 is open to discussion, surely. Certain amendments were ruled on, but not the section.
Comment on this
The method of getting the information may not be discussed.
Comment on this
The subject may be discussed. The Bill can be amended to that extent. There are two different things involved.
Comment on this
"The Board shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board."
Comment on this
We are asking the Minister now. Months ago I asked the Minister for information and he refused to give it to me. But he gave it to me yesterday. What was wrong with him yesterday? Was it the power of the Press or the fact that he knew he was coming in here this afternoon? Why could he not give it to me originally with the ordinary decency and courtesy—I give them credit for it— shown by other Ministers on the Fianna Fáil benches; when one puts down a Parliamentary Question, they reply to it. Why does this Minister not do that? How are we to know what is happening? I am not talking about the amendments which were ruled out of order. I am on the section. How are we to know? How will we know in future?
Comment on this
I am not opposing any section. I am asking the Minister a question. I want to know how we will get information about this.
Comment on this
I should like to say a few words on the section. I understand it is the section that is before the House. This section appears to me to be a simple declaration, a very desirable thing in a Bill of this nature, to ensure that a body which is receiving a subsidy does not expend that subsidy and its own resources beyond a certain limit. This is the type of section one would expect in any Bill of this kind. The company will get a large amount of money annually and it would obviously be undesirable that any undertaking, whether CIE or any other, should embark on any speculative development. It is from that point of view, I think, that a section such as this must be imported into a Bill of this character. There is on the other hand a drafting difficulty in providing that the moneys are devoted only to the purposes for which they are in fact voted.
It seems to me that, taking the amendment which, I understand, has already been accepted in relation to this section, and embodying it in the section, we are left with a net statement which will not have very much operative effect. It can be effective only in this way: whatever body controls State expenditure—ultimately, I suppose, the Comptroller and Auditor General——
Comment on this
That is true, but if you read the section, you will find "shall not incur any expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking or——"
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy. It does say the Board is satisfied, if that is the point the Deputy is making. But can one make it otherwise?
Comment on this
Whether it is the Board or anybody else in a section of this nature, can you define capital expenditure so tightly that you will not hamstring the company in its legitimate activity? That is the difficulty.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy read the section this way: "The Board shall not incur any expenditure unless the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of the undertaking"? That would leave it open to us to question whether it is or not.
Comment on this
I agree, if the Board is satisfied, but only in relation to whether this is capital expenditure or not.
Comment on this
That is the first part of the section and the second is whether it is going to be remunerative.
Comment on this
As I read the section, whether it is remunerative or not, it will apply to expenditure of a capital nature only.
Comment on this
Does this House not delegate powers of interpretation quite frequently in a large number of spheres? This is essentially a direction to the Board and, in actual fact, it can have very little operative effect because of the difficulty of distinguishing between capital expenditure, which should not be incurred, and expenditure which might technically be called capital expenditure which may be necessarily incurred for the purposes of the undertaking, and quite legitimately so. I am putting this to the House as an inherent difficulty in drafting a section of this nature and I am attempting to bring the matter back to a discussion of the fundamentals in the section. I do not think the provisions of this section are suitable for raising the matters the Deputies opposite are raising. I do not think they properly arise on this section.
Comment on this
Nothing will arise except what the Board decides. Then you cannot question them. If the Board is satisfied, that finishes the whole thing.
Comment on this
Who is to know whether a section is remunerative or not? I heard Deputy Corry tell us that a line in Kanturk was paying its way and then the Minister told us the opposite. Every stationmaster in Ireland was muzzled. They would not be allowed give us any information. The Minister has been untruthful.
Comment on this
I do not see how this arises. If the Deputies opposite are looking for a free-for-all to have a go at the Minister, there is nothing much I can contribute to it.
Comment on this
Are we to be told whether or not a bus service is remunerative? We put down question after question and we get the same stock reply: that the Minister has no function.
Comment on this
The Deputy's contribution so far is not relevant to this section.
Comment on this
When are we to be told whether any service is remunerative or not? We will not be told it by the Minister. Where are we to find out?
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to make his statement.
Comment on this
Deputies opposite are seeking to make political capital and propaganda out of this. The reason they are doing it is this. I am still waiting for an Opposition Deputy to have sufficient responsibility to accede to my request to read the statements I made at very considerable length and with great care in volume 191, columns 909 to 915 and volume 207, columns 1518 to 1522, in which I explained my attitude and the attitude of the Government to the delegation of authority to the State companies under my supervision. Not one Deputy in the Opposition has had even the decency to examine what I said and to engage in an intelligent, and even, if you like, a destructive discussion, paragraph by paragraph.
This is a most complex subject. It is a subject discussed in every Parliament in every democratic country in the world. Our Government and this House have made very specific decisions. This House, in the case of CIE in previous legislation passed by the Coalition Government, has very definitely delegated authority to CIE in regard to the carrying out of its obligations. Do I need to repeat the clause in the 1950 Act which makes it quite clear that CIE is not even bound to provide me with information about its day-to-day administration? Deputy McGilligan, in connection with a report to the Seanad, has already made it quite clear that you could not have efficiency if there were day-to-day interference by way of Parliamentary Question with the operation of State companies.
Having said that, if the House wants to listen to the whole story all over again, I will give it. I do not care how many hours it will take. I feel very keenly my responsibilities about that. Emotionally, I would like to treble my staff and add hundreds of people to the staffs of all the State companies and answer all the day-to-day questions. I would like to feel I could have myself at any one moment a complete and absolute grasp of the situation. No such thing takes place in any country in the world. Even in the socialist administrations in Northern Europe, no Minister interferes with the day-to-day operations of State companies. It would be my emotional inclination to agree to the whole of this, but it has been decided for a long time in many cases that it is impossible to get commercial efficiency if there is excessive and undue political pressure, which eventually leads to interference with staff and to unnecessary and enormous subsidies by the taxpayer to support State companies, whose directors are unable to carry out their day-to-day activities because of constant Parliamentary interference. This matter has been discussed in exactly the same way in the Labour administrations in Sweden and Denmark. It is not something out of which we can make political capital as people are trying to do here. I have made two very carefully propounded statements and not one Deputy in the Opposition has had the decency to read and criticise them. Apparently, I have to start all over again to deal with the matter.
In order to show the ridiculous character of the opposition by Deputy Lynch to all this business of CIE, I took occasion to go through all the speeches on the Estimates, the speeches I made in regard to the report of CIE when the closing of the lines was being considered and the remarks I made when a private Bill was introduced by Deputy Browne and Deputy McQuillan recently. I do not know whether the House wants me to give a list of all the information I gave of a character sufficiently detailed to enable the House fully to understand the operation of CIE? There are pages and pages of information.
I made it perfectly clear at the time that under the 1958 Act CIE was made responsible by this House for closing uneconomic branch lines and that, according to the 1958 Act, in strict truth, I could sit here in the Dáil and reply to absolutely no observations whatever made by the Opposition or any Deputies. In fact, as an illustration I gave to the House a list of all the lines which were being closed and detailed information of the character of the substitute services. I gave information by illustration of the number of passengers entraining at certain terminals to show the light character of the traffic. I gave detailed information as to the nature of the grants from the Minister for Local Government to provide for the improvement of certain roads affected by the closing of lines. I gave full information on questions arising from changes in the transport of beet. I gave information on the proportion of goods carried on the West Cork Railway on behalf of the industries in west Cork before the closing of the railway line as a comparison with the total tonnage of goods carried for those industries. I gave a great deal of information. I have here four pages of notes. On each page there are about ten or 12 items of information I gave.
I made it clear that when CIE was going through some very drastic change in its organisation, it would be my duty to provide information to the House that would satisfy them as to the nature of that change. I did so. There was very full information provided in regard to the circumstances in which certain railway lines and stations were being closed. I also made it clear that under the relative legislation, it would be quite impossible for me in the ordinary way to reply to questions which involved a fragmented analysis of every section of CIE, that it would simply result in political pressure being exercised by every Deputy or every public representative to extend or maintain a service in one area at the expense of the general efficiency of the system, and I said that, in Pacemaker, the House would find a complete analysis of the CIE position, with very definite detailed figures of the bus services that were losing, the bus services that were paying, figures of analysis for income and expenditure for various sectors of the line, which they could see from a study made at a certain period.
I gave in my Second Reading speech a full statement with regard to the losses of CIE over various periods. In the annual report of CIE, the loss or the profits for the main sectors of the company are indicated. The amount of capital expenditure under main heads is included, including the expenditure on buses in each year. There is a wealth of information provided in this kind of way which should make it possible for any Deputy to understand how CIE is operating, the kind of service it is providing for the public, and I do not think I have in any way refused to give information of a necessary kind on this matter.
Take the question of the Goleen-Schull bus service. The question of that service does not really relate to this Bill at all. Deputy Murphy says that I was misinformed in regard to the cost of it. The information I was given was that the loss to the Board was £10. 14s. a week, excluding overheads, and it was £12, including overheads. I am prepared to believe that CIE tell me the truth. I have full trust and confidence in the Board. That is what I was told. I was also told by them that it was cheaper to provide the average of two persons per journey with a car apiece than to run the service. That is not the point.
Comment on this
The point is that if I started to inquire about the cost of every bus service, the receipts and expenditure for every bus service, it would completely destroy the independence of CIE. It would completely destroy the principle of delegating authority to State companies to carry on and to operate efficiently. The same thing would apply to any other State company. One could ask the ESB to give detailed expenditure in regard to the replacement of generators or transmitter apparatus. It is contrary to the whole principle of operating State companies.
As I have said, I am not trying to shelter behind that because I make it quite clear that I am generally responsible for the supervision of these companies, and if the companies do not operate efficiently or if there are widespread complaints and I am not able to put them right, then I am responsible before this House and the House can take whatever political action they wish.
I do not know whether I need to go into it in very great detail but I have already explained that we have a system of dealing with complaints that come to us in the Department. Deputies write quite frequently. If they are very minor complaints, we send them to the State company concerned and ask them to reply direct. Complaints that look as though they may have a serious character are sent by us to the company concerned and we ask for a copy of their reply to the person. We maintain files of these complaints, which, I am glad to say, are very few, to make quite sure that they are not repetitive and we take the very greatest care to ensure that, in our view, they are providing proper services. For example, if we get particularly any complaints in relation to agricultural services—sometimes there are complaints in regard to the operation of the CIE lorry fleet in relation to cattle marts—we take very great care to have these complaints fully investigated and if the person who makes the complaint is still aggrieved, we ask them to see the CIE area manager about it.
Then another thing arises in this connection, that is, the decentralisation of responsibility in CIE and the appointment of area managers ensures a relationship between the public and CIE which is very excellent and very far-reaching in character. I have never yet had any complaint from any person that he was improperly received by an area manager or any of the officials under him in CIE. It means that the public are acquainted with the character of the CIE service. It means that the public can make complaints when there are deficiencies in the service or when the service is inefficient, on a basis that was not possible before. That is one of the best ways of dealing with the inefficiencies that can arise in a great company.
As I have said, the House knows all this already. The character of the questions answered by my predecessors was exactly the same. There has not been any change in this general refusal to answer questions relating to day-to-day administration and, incidentally, one of my predecessors, the late respected Deputy Norton, when speaking about CIE, expressed the hope that it would pay as a result of the fresh injection of capital. There was nothing new in that as compared with what I said during the passage of the 1958 Act.
I do not know if Deputies want me to go into it any further. If they do, perhaps I should re-read the two lengthy statements I made in detail so that they will fully understand the position, but it is quite impossible for me to diminish general acceptance of the principle of delegation of authority to State companies. I simply am not able to do it and the information I give in the Dáil on the occasion of an Estimate is, in the circumstances, very full indeed. I do my best to satisfy Deputies at the time of an Estimate by giving information which perhaps might normally not be permitted by the Chair in order that everyone can have a full discussion. Unfortunately, there was one occasion on which I was limited to about one and a half hours and I had another three or four pages of notes but the debate lasted so long that I was unable to give replies to very detailed matters.
I like to take a flexible attitude towards this in so far as it is possible but, nevertheless, as I have said, I simply cannot allow the tradition to start whereby information on fragmented sectors of State companies would be perpetually asked for which would inevitably end their independence and result in political pressure of the worst kind being perpetually exercised and get us away from the entire principle of having State companies here.
May I say that we are very lucky in our State companies? Not only in this company, but in my supervision of other State companies, I find the boards which run them are composed of first-class men and the officers and staffs are of the very highest calibre. This would be a completely different debate if we were discussing a company which was suspect by everybody, in which the Board and the high executives were suspect in regard to their honesty, their decency or fundamental efficiency. If we had a debate of that kind on a company, then everything I said could be answered by saying: "We do not trust this company. We do not believe the men are running it properly. We do not believe they are honest. We do not believe they are decent men". That would nullify the whole character of what I have said already. We have a very fine tradition in connection with the operation of State companies which makes it all the more possible to delegate authority in the way I have mentioned.
I have tried to explain it as best I can. I hope the House will understand it and I hope, before we have another discussion on this subject, Deputies will be kind enough to read what was a more carefully reasoned case than I am now making, the quotations from which I have already given.
Comment on this
This long speech is a complete evasion of what has been discussed on section 3. The Minister has dragged in this whole matter of State companies and intervention by this House in the day-to-day business of these companies. Nobody is demanding that right at the moment. I myself set the example with regard to the Electricity Supply Board many years ago but then there was a different conception of what day-to-day administration covered. It is only in these recent years, when the Minister has evaded questions properly addressed to him, not on day-to-day administration, that this House has got to understand the great difficulty this Minister is raising in connection with the running of these State companies.
Nobody wants to poke into day-to-day administration matters but questions were asked about a week ago with regard to the purchase by CIE of nearly £1 million worth of lorries and the Minister did not answer. The answer was dragged from him eventually after a colleague had answered a similar type of question about the purchase price of certain powerful aeroplanes but the Minister's statement was that it was a matter of day-to-day administration. It is because of that bad example which he gave that Deputies are quite concerned. There has not been very much trouble with regard to other members of the Government and other State companies. The Minister has brought this on his own head by the extension of the area of day-to-day administration. Because there is a phrase in an old Act excluding day-to-day administration, the Chair has naturally ruled that questions relating to such matters cannot be asked.
Take this amendment which I have down:
Notwithstanding anything contained in section 16 of the Act of 1950 the Board shall furnish to the Minister such information relating to its activities as may from time to time be required to enable the Minister on request to keep members of either House of the Oireachtas informed as to its said activities.
That was ruled out of order because of the narrow restriction imposed in earlier Acts. Deputies should understand that they may not discuss an amendment which asks the Minister to get from the Board such information as might be required to keep members of either House of the Oireachtas aware of their activities. The field has been narrowed to that. Other boards have been properly managed by other Ministers who have faced up to their responsibilities and they have not narrowed the question down to day-to-day administration. It is not easy to draw the line between what is a day-to-day matter of administration and what is an important matter, but surely the question of £1 million worth of rolling stock could not be called a day-to-day matter? But the Minister thought that it was and the Chair agreed.
Deputy de Valera came into this debate late and his remarks have at least helped to clarify what is at issue, although possibly not in the way he wanted to. Deputy Murphy asked if he wanted to raise the question of the Goleen to Schull service, would he be told that he would not be given a reply because it is a day-to-day matter of administration. Suppose a matter of capital expenditure is involved and I want to inquire about some railway line between two points. Remember the House is being requested to pass a Bill which contains the phrase that the Board "shall not incur expenditure that is properly chargeable to capital unless it is satisfied that the expenditure is essential for the efficient operation of its undertaking and, secondly, is satisfied that the project in relation to which it is proposed to incur the expenditure will be remunerative to the Board". Suppose there were something which the Board decided to count as capital expenditure, but to which there might be another side and if a question is asked about it, hereafter the Minister's easy answer is: "I have no function; the Board are satisfied that it is capital expenditure". If I am interpreting this wrongly, I should like to be corrected.
Then we go to the second part. If the Board are looking for certain capital moneys and if I ask if this is likely to be remunerative, the Minister will tell me: "I have no function." The Board tell him that it will be remunerative and that is the beginning and the end of the matter. Surely that is not what this House should be asked to do? When Deputy de Valera was speaking I said that if the section were drafted in a slightly different way, it would be all right. Supposing it were put in this way: "unless the expenditure was essential"—that does not say that the Board are the judges—and suppose that it also read "unless the project will be remunerative to the Board" and left it open, then it could be the subject of questions here. There may be matters which should properly be brought before the House and we do not want to be faced with the statement that as they are matters of day-to-day administration, they cannot be answered, or that the Board are satisfied and that would be the beginning and end of the whole thing.
Comment on this
I am astonished at the ingenuousness of the Minister talking as a politician to other politicians, as we all are, and taking the extraordinary line that people are putting a point of view forward for political purposes. Of course we are. This is a political assembly and that is our function in life. It is just as if a doctor at a medical meeting were accused, after reading a paper on a subject of interest to the other doctors, of putting forward a point of view for medical reasons. There is no harm in putting forward points of view for political purposes. I have heard this from other Ministers and it seems to me to be a very silly attitude.
On this section, Deputy Colley made a very important point when he interjected "It is the House that makes the law". He was defending the Minister and of course he is correct. The Minister is hedged in and restricted by laws made here and it is for that reason we have to be particularly careful that we do not tie ourselves by sections of this kind passed apparently with our consent and that we do not deny ourselves a right which we believe we have with regard to the ordinary running of State companies. At some later time Deputy Colley can tell us "In section 3 of the Bill which you passed in 1964, you gave this Minister power", and queries can be stopped in that way. It is for that reason that the Opposition are anxious that this question should be seriously considered at this stage when we can change the law and make it more in accordance with our wishes. The Minister must bear with the worries of the Opposition in this regard.
The point made by Deputy McGilligan is of course most important and valid. We are saying: "You may spend your money under two conditions, that it will be remunerative and essential", and then we wash our hands of any responsibility thereafter and of any power thereafter to question whether in fact they have obeyed the law which we are passing here.
I am a socialist and I have a particular vested interest in the activities of these State companies and that they should operate successfully, be respected by the public and be efficient. It is quite wrong to call this a socialist organisation, because it is a State capitalist organisation; it is publicly-owned but not publicly-controlled, and that is the very important difference. The greater the extension of public control which we can inject into legislation of this kind, the more I would like it, and to the extent to which other Deputies want it, I would certainly support them. The issue is not black and white. This is a very complicated question and there cannot be day-to-day investigation into whether a train is late into Kingsbridge or whether it took a train longer to get from one point to another, or into any of these trivialities.
There cannot be questions on that kind of thing, but, at the same time, there must be some access to guiding policies at a particularly difficult period for the transport companies of the world, the transition from steam to oil, from rail to road and the problems created for the public by the Board's decisions which create some conflict of opinion between public representatives and the company. We should have some form of access to the activities which determine the decisions of the company from time to time. The Taoiseach has accepted that there is need for some controlling body and he has thrown it on the Opposition to make suggestions in that regard.
There is validity in many of the objections put forward by the Opposition and there is a responsibility on the Minister to meet the views of the Opposition. The fact that so much animosity has been created in recent years could be due to the fact that the new manager of CIE appears to be an autocrat, or perhaps to the fact that he is facing a period of acute difficulty, but, whatever the cause, the fact remains that there is serious suspicion in the minds of most of us about the apparently autocratic way in which many decisions are taken from time to time by this company and the little power we have over the final outcome of those decisions.
I will go with the Minister in saying that as far as the ordinary member of the public is concerned in his daily relations with CIE, there is good relationship. The ordinary public have a right to go to the company and inquire about various matters and they get reasonably courteous and efficient service. That has been my personal experience. However, as far as public representatives are concerned, we have had a record of bad public relations with this company. My personal experience has been that we cannot get near the controller of this company to ask him any questions. That has not been our experience in regard to any other Minister in any of the Governments we have had. We have always had access to a Minister to discuss matters with him, even if he did nothing about it.
Over recent years, there has been disharmony between this company and public representatives and the Minister must be conscious of that. He must be conscious of the fact that there are a number of semi-State companies in the State which are all subject to the same worry, inquiries and uncertainties. Yet they are free from the same sort of misrepresentation, if you like, or dissatisfaction which we have in relation to CIE. I think it is about time the Minister accepted that fact, the fact that there is something seriously wrong with the public relations of CIE vis-à-vis the members of this House.
We should have the right to question the decisions of CIE to run its affairs strictly on the ground of their remunerative quality or not. We disagree with the general approach which has become more noticeable in recent years in regard to the House, that if a particular service does not pay, it will not be made available to the public. That question arises under this section, the question of the social need as opposed to the economic viability of any particular service. That has been at the bottom of most of the dissatisfaction which has been aroused over the years in all of us. If we accept this section, then we are agreeing to cut ourselves off for all future time from any access to the making of a case or any effort to persuade the controlling Board of CIE that we do not agree with any policy decision they may have taken.
A transport service should be run primarily as a social service. Where you have a transport service with a society such as ours, with a big rural hinterland and a widely scattered population, if you are going to serve the social needs of the people, you will have to run a largely unremunerative service. It is running in complete conflict with the social principles of such a society to curtail and restrict services to the rural population simply because they do not pay. There is an important basic principle enshrined in this section of the Bill and I believe it will be wrong if we give the Minister full power to carry on with the policy which has developed rapidly in recent years and which has created great dissatisfaction throughout the country.
That policy is completely contrary to the principle that if people live in rural areas, they are entitled to the basic services, to the Post Office service, to the telephone service, to an ambulance service, to water and sewerage supplies. Transport is an absolute need for people living in the rural areas and it would be a very wrong principle if the Minister were able to incorporate in this legislation that the service will be supplied only where it pays. The fact that the service is not used to such an extent as would make it pay has nothing to do with what I believe to be the correct social principle of helping people to live in the areas in which they wish to live, to help a predominantly rural society to maintain its characteristic organisation.
It would be wrong if we forced people to leave rural Ireland by insisting on running a purely economic transport system. It would be just the same as if a person had his telephone removed because he did not use it enough; if a Post Office service were cut off because he did not receive enough letters; or if a water supply were cut off because a person did not leave taps running all the time. The whole thing is completely inconsistent and illogical.
It would be most undesirable if the Minister were to get the full powers he is seeking here. I would ask him to give serious consideration to the possibility of achieving a closer link between public representatives and this company, in order, if for no other reason, to save himself the embarrassment to which he is so frequently subjected in this House as a result of the fact that he is tied by provisions of various sections of Acts, as referred to by Deputy Colley, where he simply cannot reply or says himself he cannot reply to questions put to him by Deputies in the legitimate course of carrying out their jobs as politicians.
Comment on this
Deputy Dr. Browne has made a rather logically conceived statement on all this. He raises some of the fundamental issues. CIE is not operating at a profit and I wish Deputies would read the second volume of Pacemaker in which they will see the very large number of road freight, rail freight, railway and bus services that are not paying. They have been losing money and will continue to lose money. The social services given by CIE in the form of losing services are fully indicated in Pacemaker and I gave them in my Second Reading speech. Deputies should know from reading my speech and that report that there is no need for them to have anxiety when they consider asking questions on the day-to-day details of individual bus services. They know from reading Pacemaker the general trend.
Comment on this
They will know from the Pacemaker report the general balance of profitable and losing services of CIE and I am prepared on every Estimate to inform the House as to whether there has been any change in the general policy.
CIE is now subsidised deliberately. No longer is it being asked to pay its way. Deputy Dr. Browne may disagree with me but I consider the subsidy of £2 million in relation to its revenue, to its expenditure, to its capital or to the general economic position of the country, to be sufficient and I am afraid that, in the course of the next five years, I shall not be in a position, by yielding to political pressures in regard to individual bus services, to encourage CIE to increase its losses or its deficit through the provision of more and more services of an uneconomic character.
I take full responsibility for that statement. If the members of the Opposition would prefer to have a six months to six months approach to this question and to have questions answered in the House in a general climate of talk which would, in fact, erode the £2 million subsidy very quickly and which would give rise to all sorts of political pressures whereby the £2 million could very easily become £4 million, the Government are entirely against that, and the Opposition can have recourse at a general election to throwing us out, if they can, for that or for any other reason. However, this Bill clearly indicates that it is a five-year measure and therefore within those five years—I am speaking without any regard to any emergency or special difficulties that may arise—that £2 million must provide the difference between expenditure and receipts.
Capital expenditure is sanctioned in my Department and there are discussions with the Board of CIE at official level and I have discussions with the Chairman of CIE when they come to us for capital. We examine the requirements in a general way. We see how their request for capital relates to the total amount of capital being spent. We see how the capital being invested relates to the general progress of the company. In view of the fact that, particularly in this Bill, the subsidy includes the sinking fund and interest advanced from the Capital Fund, at the end of the year CIE provides the House and the public with a full account of their capital expenditure giving it in sectionalised details as to how much was spent on buses, on wagons, and so forth. They give the profit and losses on the main sectors of the Company's operations.
On the occasion of the Estimate and having regard to all the correspondence that goes on between Estimates, it is possible for me to estimate the volume of complaints on the service and to gather from discussions in the House what the problems are. There is no question, in my view, of my preventing full discussion on the operations of CIE during the Estimate debate. If any responsible member of the House feels that any State company is not operating properly, he can ask to have the company's report discussed as the CIE report was discussed because of the protest over the closing of the railways.
Deputy Dr. Browne put his finger on one thing. I think the fact that there has been so much discussion on CIE and that there are no detailed questions asked of me about the cost of different sectors of the ESB rural electrification, of the cost of providing current in Cahirciveen as compared with Monaghan, is due to the very widespread changes which have taken place in the organisation of CIE.
This House enabled CIE reorganisation to take place. Over 1,600 people have left the service of CIE. People have been moved around. There have been widespread changes and, as Deputy Dr. Browne says, this is a conservative country and it causes agitation. Then, of course, the major agitation that has taken place in relation to questions not being answered is of the closing of railway lines. We could have a controversy that could last right up to 10.30 to-night on the closing of railway lines. I claimed the substitute services that were offered were satisfactory and I have had very few complaints. It is not true that if you look at the whole network of the CIE services, including the rail and bus services, that there has been any noticeable contraction in the past five years. An odd bus service might have been stopped here or stopped there but generally there has been no major change in the scope of the service.
I disagree with many Deputies here and I am quite prepared to back CIE in regard to their policy of having closed minor branch lines. I take full responsibility for it. I could at any time have amended the 1958 Act as an act of emergency if I felt they were abusing the freedom they were given by this House. I did not do so. I made that clear to the House and made myself responsible for the general supervision of CIE in regard to the closing of railway lines.
I have been perfectly honest about that. I have not sheltered behind the Act passed by this House which gives them the sole decision in regard to closing of railway lines, because I have admitted that at any time I could have asked for the suspension of that Act, if I so desired. Therefore, no one can accuse me of sheltering behind the 1958 Act which gives CIE those powers. Most of the controversy that has arisen has been caused by the closing of these railway lines. I maintain that in remote rural areas, to avoid double handling of goods and to provide people with as many stopping places as possible, a bus service is much more suitable. Most of the controversy on CIE has arisen from that fact. I also believe with CIE that rail services should be fast long-haul services of passengers and goods and I am prepared to take the criticism of those members who disagree with that policy.
I should mention that Dr. Andrews and his staff received numerous deputations at the time when railway lines were being closed, and particularly during the period of the secondary closings.
Comment on this
That was on quite a different matter. That was a question of political pressure being exercised in regard to a particular section of the service——
Comment on this
Who was to determine whether it was political pressure? Was it Dr. Andrews who came to that conclusion?
Comment on this
I stand on what is in the Reports of this House and I shall leave it at that. I quite understand Deputies disagreeing with me. I do not want to feel antagonistic about this. I believe that in all the statements I have made in reply to questions and on Estimates, I have gone far beyond the strict conception of not answering on day-to-day matters. I have made very elaborate statements on the Bill, both in the opening and closing speeches on the Second Reading. If Deputies read those statements, they could hardly say that I refused to give proper information to enable them to deal with the various sections of this Bill.
This is a very controversial matter and I should like to answer many more questions than I do answer. I have gone into the whole matter and I am satisfied with the manner in which we are now doing it, in a sort of pragmatic way in which much information is provided during Estimate debates and on Bills, and I do not think members of the Opposition have failed to gain the basic information they require to enable them to deal with this measure.
Comment on this
How can we know whether we can prevent abuses in CIE or not, if we have not got the information? The Minister is still standing on day-to-day administration. I want to put to him again the question put by Deputy Lynch and the question I have repeated several times as to whether the purchase of nearly £1 million worth of rolling stock——
Comment on this
I want to know is it a matter that should be raised in this House. Surely the matter of what lorries were bought, what was paid for them, whether they were greater in their over-all length than what was previously on the road—surely that is not day-to-day administration? The Minister refused to answer those questions.
Comment on this
The Minister at first refused to answer and afterwards sent a press cutting or something of that sort through his private secretary.
Comment on this
The Minister might as well say that the ESB produce an annuual report and that you can get anything there, but there are a number of questions arising on important points of policy.
The second point I want to make is that the Minister is so much under criticism in this House because of the very specific promises that were given when the 1958 Act was passed as to the procedure to be adopted when it was proposed to close down branch lines. This was referred to by Deputy Lynch at column 1796 of the Official Report of 20th May of this year. There was an amendment tabled that there should be consultation with the local authorities concerned and with the trade unions, and the present Taoiseach, who was then piloting the Bill, said that, of course, they would get two months notice and, of course, they would see these people in deputations. The purpose of the requirement to give two months notice was to provide a statutory period during which the inevitable representations could be entertained. We know that despite that very specific and clear promise, branch lines were closed down without giving local representatives a chance to make their case and it is because of that breach of confidence that there is so much agitation about this matter. Coming back to section 3, does the Minister think it proper to fortify himself against other questions in the future by the phrasing of section 3 ? If there is a dispute as to whether or not certain moneys are properly regarded as capital moneys and the Minister is asked a question about that, he is empowered to say, if this legislation goes through as it is: "It is only the Board who have to be satisfied about that. I have nothing to do with it." He might even say: "I do not think myself it is capital money but it is not my business." Also, if he is asked whether certain expenditure will be remunerative, he is again entitled to say: "It is not my business." If Deputy M. P. Murphy comes along, when a complaint arises in a part of his constituency, will the Minister say: "The Board tell me that is not going to be remunerative and that is the end of it"? I do not think that is proper and I think it is particularly improper at a time when we are moving from the idea of an economic concern to what amounts to a social service.
Many people feel, and I partly agree with them, that the railways cannot be ruled by the standard whether their capital is going to be remunerated or not; that there is a necessity to keep certain branch lines open for social purposes, whether they are remunerative or not. The Minister is coming in here at a time when the Board have closed down a number of stations and when the situation for the Board—not for the community—has been considerably eased and the Minister wants to fortify himself by this section so that no question can be put to him as to whether moneys are properly expended or not. The Minister's easy answer is to say: "It is not any of my business." Am I right in that interpretation?
Comment on this
I have to sanction capital expenditure by CIE—and the Minister for Finance must sanction it —and I have to assure myself that it is truly capital expenditure. I have to ensure that the capital sanctioned is properly spent. I have to be assured that CIE is carrying out the instructions given to it in general by this Bill.
Comment on this
Let us deal with section 3. The Minister says he has to get the money from the Minister for Finance when he wants capital moneys. He hands that on to the Board but the expenditure of that money is a matter for the Board and it is then a question of what they consider properly chargeable to capital.
Comment on this
I am inclined to change my views as expressed earlier on the Minister's integrity. I think from the two recent statements he has made that he is not honest in his approach to this measure. He said a while ago that instead of not giving information in the House, he feels he has given too much information——
Comment on this
——and that the 1958 Bill gave him the right of refusing to give any information. That is a clear statement made by the Minister earlier. He listed the type of information he has given in the House. He posed the question: Surely I am not supposed to answer about a particular bus service which operates today or which is likely to operate tomorrow and give particulars of timetables and services? It never happened in this House that the Minister was asked such a question. He was never asked about time schedules. That was a ridiculous assertion on the part of the Minister. It looked as if he were trying to imply that questions of that nature were asked in this House.
Comment on this
The questions asked here are questions such as those listed by Deputy McGilligan, questions of national importance, matters in which large sums of money are involved, for the purchase of rolling stock, for example, running into seven figures. Such a question was ruled out of order.
Comment on this
And various other questions on important issues were ruled out of order. A question was raised here by me this evening, and later taken up by Deputy McGilligan, in relation to this section providing the Minister with a cover where future questions are concerned. So far as representations are concerned, the Minister can hide behind this section in future and tell whoever is seeking information that, unless a particular service is likely to be remunerative, CIE cannot provide it because section 3 precludes them from doing so.
The Minister went into detail on a particular service which was the subject matter of discussion here earlier this evening. He said that the net cost of that service, according to the information supplied to him, was £10 14s weekly and he added for good measure that the overhead charges were £1 6s. I should like to remind the Minister that his case was necessary to provide a sum equivalent to approximately 15/- per head of the population to subsidise CIE. Add a subvention of £2 millions with a writeoff of £1 million liabilities incurred previously by CIE and the net capital charge will be more than 15/- per head. The particular service I was speaking about would not, even on the Minister's inflated figures, measure up to 15/- per head of the population to be serviced. Therefore, what we are asking here is 15/- per head of the population to enable CIE to continue its operations and, at the same time, we are withdrawing an existing bus service, which, on the Minister's own figures, even if they were correct, would mean that the subsidy would not be more than 9/- or 10/- per head and would, in fact, be less. Surely, on that basis alone, the Minister must review his decision. He informed us earlier that it was a decision of his to withdraw that service. I hope now that the Minister will restore this service.
As Deputy Dr. Browne pointed out, it would be just as easy for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs to say: "We are not getting enough remuneration from the services we provide in your parish. We think we should get more and we are now going to withdraw the postal service because it is not remunerative. People are not writing enough letters. The returns from stamps, telegrams and telephones are not sufficient."
The Minister introduced the question of the social need for services. This is a social service. Nevertheless, he has withdrawn this social service completely from one parish. I know the Minister has difficulties where CIE is concerned because the Board created a bad public image. Instead of currying favour with the business community and the travelling public, they have gone out of their way to alienate the affections of the people and to cut the people adrift. We heard Deputy McGilligan quoting a passage this evening from a statement made by the Taoiseach in 1958. He was Minister for Industry and Commerce at the time. He spoke about the deliberations which would be bound to take place between local bodies and CIE when proposals to close a particular transport route arose. We know how that promise of the Taoiseach's was implemented. Deputies of this House, members of the county council, members of the county committee of agriculture and other public bodies in Cork were completely ignored and were given no opportunity of any kind to meet the Board of CIE to discuss matters with them.
The Minister is well aware of that. The Board treated any representations made with gross contempt. It is regrettable that the Board responsible for our public transport should have that dictatorial outlook. That is an attitude Irish people will not tolerate. The Minister must get it into his head that Irish people do not accept dictation and will not accept a dictatorial attitude on the part of the Board of CIE. Surely the people who asked that a deputation be received by the Board were sufficiently representative of Cork to be granted that opportunity? In my opinion, they were more than representative enough to be heard by that autocratic body, the Board of CIE. Had the Board adopted a reasonable attitude and met the representatives with some amicable arrangement, the position today might be very different and the arrangement might have resulted not only in conveniencing the general public but also in financing CIE.
Of course, all CIE has to do when faced with deficits is to come along to the Government and ask for a further measure of assistance from this House. All other companies must stand on their own feet. Deputy Dockrell is a big business man here in Dublin. If he were to adopt the attitude adopted by CIE, if he were to refuse to meet his patrons, his business would not continue very long. Deputy Dockrell is, of course, a wise man. He, and other business men like him, would lose money if customers ceased to present themselves. In that set of circumstances, he could not ask to be subsidised from public funds. But it is all right for CIE to do that. They do not have to watch closely their bookkeeping and ensure a profitable and fair return because they can come along here and we will give them a subsidy.
Deputy Dr. Browne made it quite clear that the Labour Party believe in subsidising public transport. We agree it is impossible to provide transport in uneconomic areas and remote and isolated districts on a remunerative basis. But we ask something in return. We ask for civility and courtesy. We ask those responsible in CIE to meet local deputations with a view to agreeing on the establishment of the most suitable type of transport service for the particular area. CIE will not agree to meet any local deputations. They have, as I said, created a very bad public image. In 1958 it was stated that the measure then before the House would, when it became law, see an end to CIE troubles five years later. That is what we were told. By the end of five years CIE would be standing on its own feet and the Irish taxpayer would no longer be asked to subsidise it. Some of us did not accept that at the time because we considered it too farfetched. I agree that a Board who felt in 1958 that in the relatively short period of five years, CIE would be able to stand on its own feet could not be deemed to be competent. Yet, the same Board are continuing now.
I want to get a clear definition from the Minister on section 3 what this particular phrase means. When we discussed the 1958 Act, we were told that the sections were passed and that the Dáil gave CIE this authority. I am not one anxious to give authority to CIE lightly because of the attitude adopted towards us. This House is right in questioning every comma in this measure. We have to be cautious when dealing with a body such as CIE. I regret very much to have to comment so adversely on our public transport body. The Minister has not helped himself by the attitude he has adopted to Deputies seeking legitimate information on matters of national and local importance. He has told the House on innumerable occasions he is not prepared to give information to the Deputies seeking it.
I said on Second Reading that the Board of CIE should be reconstituted. In 1958 this Board asked for five years to put everything right. They got that blank cheque, and they failed. That being so, I maintain we should look around and see if we could get other people with brains to deal with our transport problems. The Minister apparently feels that within the confines of this State, there are only a limited number of people capable of dealing with our transport problems, and that limited number seems to be confined to the Board of CIE. I do not agree that CIE constitute a monopoly of brains as far as transport is concerned. I do not think it is out of place to refer to the many statements made by the Chairman of CIE in relation to transport problems. He said in 1961 that his mind was in a state of flux in regard to transport problems. He admitted on a number of occasions that, as far as transport problems were concerned, he felt rather at a difficulty in dealing with them. He admitted his incapacity for dealing with complex transport problems. Without any reflection on the personnel of the Board, they have had their chance.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, this is an attack on members of the Board. There is nothing in this section concerning the method of appointment.
Comment on this
There is nothing in the section relating to the composition of the Board. This section relates to finance.
Comment on this
The Minister is accepting responsibility. He is responsible for the composition of the Board. If the Minister advised the Government, they could reconsitute the Board.
Comment on this
That is the Minister's attitude. That is why we want £11 million more in the current five years to subsidise the Board. The Minister is adopting an arrogant attitude, even though I believe he feels at the bottom of his heart that the arguments by the Opposition are entirely correct. Yet he will not give in. He is prepared to allow this Board to travel along the road they have travelled over the years and continue to provide a costly and inefficient transport service.
Let us examine the record of CIE since we gave it all this authority. Not alone has it lost money—its indebtedness is higher than ever—but it has closed miles and miles of railway. It has closed some 700 miles of railway. Now it is turning its attention to road transport and commencing to close routes which it tells us are not economic. Surely a Board with that outlook on transport problems in this relatively small country are not fit to remain in office? The answer to this transport problem is to wipe out the present Board. They had their chance and failed in their undertaking. I believe another Board could be found who would address themselves to our transport problems much more efficiently as far as the common good is concerned.
Comment on this
I have already pointed out to the Deputy that the composition of the Board does not arise on a section which deals with finance.
Comment on this
That is not the point. It does not arise on the section. The Deputy may get an opportunity on another section.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy is out of line. The section relates to expenditure. The composition of the Board does not arise.
Comment on this
The Minister told us he is not going to change the Board. He has got a little rough this evening. He is not going to listen to reason. He is going to hold on adamantly to the views he expressed earlier to-day. Would the Minister be able to tell me: how does it happen a line is closed? Who initiates the procedure for the closing of a line?
Comment on this
I should like to know who is responsible. Is there a particular person in CIE who decides when a line is closed?
Comment on this
Deputy Murphy will have to relate his remarks to the section. He may not wander all over the question of public transport on this section, which relates to expenditure.
Comment on this
I do not mind. This is like an Estimate debate. I am prepared to sit here for hours and hours discussing CIE in general if people want to. It has nothing to do with the Bill.
Comment on this
If section 3 becomes law and if a Deputy asks a question about the provision of a service, is he not likely to be told that under section 3 of the Transport Act of 1964, the Board are precluded from providing that service?
Comment on this
It is the Board will decide, not the House. Section 3 clearly states that it is the Board who will decide whether it is capital expenditure or not. Is it not likely the Minister will make such a reply if a supplementary question is put to him? We have had plenty of experience of that. Is it not likely he will say that section 3 of this Act, approved by the Dáil, gives the Board that authority? This House gives the Board that authority and they are doing nothing more and nothing less than exercising the authority given by this House.
I feel, as has been pointed out by a number of Deputies, that this section is a very dangerous one, having regard to the history of CIE and particularly having regard to the Minister's statement a few minutes ago that he will not reconstitute the Board. Personally, I feel that we should divide the House on this issue and put on record our opposition to this dictatorial line which the Minister has taken. He has again and again been assured by Deputies here and by the House generally that we are all in favour of providing a transport service and we are prepared to dip into our pockets to subsidise that service, but, in return, we expect efficiency and courtesy and do not want this dictatorial attitude of wiping out transport in some part of the country without consulting anybody. We do not want a dictatorial attitude. The Irish people are not prepared to accept a dictatorial attitude. Having regard to all the facts, the House should divide on this section.
Comment on this
I tried to get in immediately after the Minister made his long address in which he said that no Deputy read his closing speech on the Second Reading.
Comment on this
No, not that—two other speeches which I have already mentioned three or four times and asked people to read.
Comment on this
I was present here for the reading of it. I was not well the following Sunday morning when I read it in bed. It kept me in bed for nearly a fortnight.
Comment on this
The Minister is the best man to cover up that I have ever met. He stated here that night that he would answer every question. He did not answer any of the questions that I put down to him. He will have to answer. I asked him was he going to keep his word about maintaining as efficient a service between Waterford and Tramore as was there before he wrecked the railway. I could not get any answer to that question.
Comment on this
Do you hear this man? This man had a whole lot of questions here on the Order Paper yesterday in regard to piers. He had questions down about 37 piers that nobody ever heard of.
Comment on this
What I will keep on saying, until the Minister makes an open confession that his experts were wrong. We will have experts advising this Board and this Board will be there, with their cloaks and daggers, and nobody will know what is happening. We will not have any way of finding out. Some of these experts will tell the Board to do something and the Minister will go off and do it and will make a mess of it, just as the great mistake was made by CIE and by these experts. Many of them fled from CIE afterwards but the Minister stood over it. The king can do no wrong. He was the king in this case, with the idea that it must be done no matter what happened. I have said in this House, and will repeat whenever I get the opportunity, that there were 550,000 people who travelled on that line in its last year.
Comment on this
I am discussing section 3. This Board will incur expenditure of up to £2 million of our money. They will be advised by some of the same experts as closed this line. I ask the Minister to keep his word and to keep the word of his predecessor, the present Taoiseach. They made promises here and they gave their word. If the Minister wants to improve his public relations in my constituency, the only thing for him to do is what is done by everyone in every part of Ireland every day, even by tinkers. They are men of their word. Do not belittle this House by saying one thing and doing the opposite and then remaining mute.
The Minister's advisers advised CIE. We could not find out what was happening at the time. They just went in and smashed everything that was in the Tramore railway station and then sold it to the town commissioners. Now they want the town commissioners to provide a public convenience at the bus stop. They built a bus terminus instead of the railway station.
I intervened when the Minister was closing to ask him to answer questions I had asked the previous night in the House. He did not do it. He sat down. I am glad that I was reported as saying, because I did say it: "The Minister has degraded this Parliament". That is what is happening. We are here as the representatives of the people. We have been endeavouring to get information here since 3.30 this afternoon.
Comment on this
I want to tell Deputy Coughlan that I thought there must have been a change of heart, because, believe it or not, the Minister answered six Parliamentary Questions for me yesterday. I have them here.
Comment on this
I will tell you. We have been here all the evening on this section and we have been asking the Minister about this Board and how Deputies will be able to reach this Board and the Minister has refused pointblank to answer.
Comment on this
The Minister's statements are too elaborate and when a Deputy reads them he finds they amount to nothing at all. Will the Minister get up and say: "I will answer any reasonable question put to me in this House concerning this Board"?
Comment on this
The question of the Dáil getting information does not arise on this section. That question has been dealt with on previous legislation by the House.
Comment on this
How are we to know whether a line is profitable or not? That is mentioned in section 3. I have experience of the West Clare railway dissolution. There was an expenditure of £90,000 on three engines, at £30,000 each, and the engines were not properly run-in when the Minister closed the line and £90,000 worth was sold for scrap. I put down a question and I got no answer. The Minister had no function. Where are we to go? That was the West Clare railway and CIE houses along that line were sold for £30. That cannot be denied.
Comment on this
That is what we want to protect ourselves against. We are entitled to that information but I had to get the information in a roundabout way.
Comment on this
The Minister said that Deputies did not read his statement. I was in the House all the time the Minister was speaking and the Minister knows that. I have a good memory and I will remember what the Minister said all the years of my life. Even at this hour, the Minister should say to us that he will be prepared to meet Deputies if they ask him questions, not about day-to-day administration but questions relating, say, to sums of £50,000 or £100,000, or what was the annual take in regard to a service or in relation to something we know is in his office, which the Pacemaker Report tells us is in his office. The Minister should not be fooling the people and getting it into the national papers that the Deputies did not read the Pacemaker Report. I got a copy of the report in the Library. I asked how many copies were printed and the Minister would not tell me. I asked him if there had even been a dozen printed and the Minister would not say. I believe that if there had been more than one dozen printed, the Minister would have said so. This is an important document and the Minister gets about 12 copies and puts one in the Library of the Dáil, and that is supposed to be publicising it. It is the Minister's way of making it a secret document and adding to his policy of not telling anybody in this House what is happening, how moneys are being spent or how much is being spent——
Comment on this
I had an idea when I was sent into Dáil Éireann that I could ask any Minister a Parliamentary Question and that if it was responsible, the Minister should answer it, and I was under the impression that that was all right because when I came into the House, my Party were over there and I bombarded them with Parliamentary Questions and they replied. When the Fianna Fáil Party went over there, I bombarded them, and I must give the Ministers their due, they answered, with the exception of this Minister. How are we to find out anything about this Board and how they are spending this £2 million?
Comment on this
I was informed by the Minister that subsection (1) of this section had a bearing on this matter of capital expenditure and perhaps the Minister would explain what he meant.
Comment on this
I thought I had already explained that. Under this Bill, my position is actually strenghtened in that I have to be satisfied, before recommending a capital advance to the Minister for Finance, that the expenditure is necessary within the circumstances defined in section 3.
Comment on this
No; the Board require my consent and that of the Minister for Finance for capital advances.
Comment on this
Do the Board decide that the capital expenditure is required for the efficient operation of the company and for purposes that would be remunerative?
Comment on this
The Board have the general responsibility of spending the capital according to the provisions of this and of the 1958 Act, but I can have discussions with the Board when they come to me for the capital to ensure that, in my view, the Act is being properly interpreted.
Comment on this
Has the Minister anything to do with the expenditure being essential and being remunerative? I suggest not.
Comment on this
——from year to year, and quite obviously any Minister who is responsible for examining CIE accounts has to examine the trend of operation every year. If I see that obviously an excessive amount of capital is being spent on, shall we say, running a very profitable sector of the railway, whereas quite evidently some part of the system elsewhere is being allowed to collapse, it would be my duty to say they are not interpreting the general sense of the transport legislation.
Comment on this
Does the Minister mean that hereafter he will answer questions in this House regarding these matters?
Comment on this
I am not talking about questions. I have already spoken at great length about that and what is the use of bringing it up again?
Comment on this
I have already said that I consider the debate on the Estimate, on the CIE report and on Deputy Dr. Browne's motion——
Comment on this
——constitutes a very fair recording of all the facts and the economics in regard to the progress of CIE in the past five years, and I am prepared to stand over that.
Comment on this
The Minister has evaded that. The Minister is suggesting that section 3 might as well be read with "the Minister" instead of "it".
Comment on this
The Minister for Transport and Power and the Minister for Finance, the Government and this House have some part in all this and I have made it clear that I am responsible for seeing that when capital is advanced, it is in general going to be spent for a proper purpose, just as the Auditor General who audits the Company's accounts every year has to be assured that the amounts advanced have been properly put to the capital account, or to the current account, or to the appropriation account, and so forth. I do not know what more information the House wishes to have.
Comment on this
I do not want to appear to be insensitive to the Minister's feelings but he has opened up in this section the question of his duty and functions vis-á-vis the Board regarding questions of expenditure. He has indicated that this section strengthens his position and I gather that the degree of strengthening is only so that he can require discussion, examination and consultation. He has said that he is the person responsible for seeing that anything done is done properly. If that is so, does it not follow from the Minister's claim here that he is being put in a stronger position by this section, that hereafter he can, with a completely clear conscience, answer the questions of Deputies with regard to matters arising from this Bill?
Comment on this
I have already answered a great many questions in this House. We can debate this matter all night and not get any further. It is entirely a question of interpretation. Is the Goleen-Schull bus route in which Deputy Murphy is so deeply interested a question of day-to-day administration? This is a very complex question and Deputies are entitled to discuss it but the trouble is that we never seem to get to the end of it. Much of the discussion in political circles has been based on historical considerations, particularly with regard to the early days of the United States when the operations of the railways were subject to political interference.
The idea mooted here is that we should give fragmentary information from day to day on every day the Dáil sits, that we should give a detailed, constantly repeated review of the operations of a vast service such as that of CIE with an expenditure of about £22 million a year and that we should be constantly holding up the Board about the closing of this or that service or the number of buses run on a particular route. If we do, then we will destroy the efficiency of the Board. That has generally been accepted over the whole of Northern Europe where the ordinary democracies have accepted this general view. Everybody worries about these things because of the fact that these companies have achieved great power to expend vast amounts of capital and people are worried over the extent to which they should continue to receive this freedom. We look at the matter absolutely pragmatically and we think the State companies have operated very efficiently over the years.
If we had a multiplicity of questions, to such an extent that it revealed a general unrest over the operations of the Board, the situation might change. I could have an inquiry into the operations of CIE but these things have not happened in the past. A great deal of this controversy here this evening is again due to the tremendous objections there have been to the closing of railway lines. I am sorry that Deputy Murphy has left the House because I could tell him to look at the debate on the CIE report in which the closing of the West Cork railway was discussed.
Comment on this
My conscience is quite clear that I have given all the information necessary to enable the House to consider the question of whether there was anything wrong, or undesirable, or contrary to the interests of the public in the closing of these railways. If Deputies disagree with me, the result is that we have disagreement in the House about the matter, but I gave all the relevant information at that time.
Now, the major part of the lines to be closed have been closed and I will not curtail the freedom or independence of CIE by asking how much it cost to run the line from Mallow to Cork or what the receipts and expenditure are this year compared with last year. If I did that, it would end the independence of CIE. I have done my best to explain all these points to Deputies.
Comment on this
The Minister has attempted to give the best explanation he could to the House but I also think that he has attempted to oversimplify the matter. The whole trouble here is that if one accepts that there should be no question in this House about the closing down of a railway line or bus route covering ten miles, then there should be no question about the closing down of one which covers 100 miles.
We on this side of the House do not feel that immense sums of money should be passed through the Minister to a group of people who, when they receive that money, claim that they have no responsibility to this House for explaining how it is spent. I have great sympathy with the Minister because I feel he is in an invidious position. He is trying to defend something that is very hard to defend. I would ask him in his own interests to try to appreciate the fact that we believe there should be parliamentary control over the public transport system. We believe that if we think money has been wrongly spent, we have the right to ask why it was spent in that way.
Comment on this
The Minister has made many lengthy interventions, all with the object of evading the real question. Would he forget for the moment about day-to-day administration? Let us take it that matters of day-to-day administration are excluded. Let us also think of a situation in which capital moneys are required and there is no question of these being for capital expenditure. There are certain safeguards looked for with regard to capital moneys. The Board must be of the opinion that they are necessary for the efficient operation of the undertaking and also that the project for which they are needed will be remunerative to the Board.
Who is to judge on these two points in section 3 as to whether the expenditure is required for the efficient operation of the undertaking or whether the project will be remunerative to the Board? The Minister has nothing to say to that under this section. Remember that day-to-day administration is out of it and that there is no question about these being capital moneys. The decision has now to be taken as to how the capital moneys advanced are to be spent and the decision has to be taken as to whether the project is to be remunerative to the Board. The Minister, under this section, has nothing to say to that.
Comment on this
I am building section 3 into section 4 which we are now discussing. The Minister claims that he is being put in a stronger position than ever before. There is now no question of day-to-day administration and there is no question about the money being for capital expenditure. There are two points to be decided, whether the money is for the efficient operation of the undertaking and whether the project will be remunerative to the Board. On that the Minister has nothing to say. If he tells me he has, I will gladly move an amendment on Report Stage to put in the Minister instead of the Board—"but cannot expend these moneys unless the Minister is satisfied". He can always exclude day-to-day expenditure. We do not want to bring that in for the time being. However, the two pivotal questions are not for the Minister's decision but for the Board's decision.
Comment on this
The Minister, when explaining the section to us, said he would consult with the Board in regard to the outlay of the capital moneys, that is, £6 million. What the Minister did not say was, if the Board of CIE consulted with the Minister in regard to, say, the purchase of helicopters or something like that and the Minister said to them: "I do not agree with this" would the Board be said by the Minister? I should like the Minister to answer that. Has the Minister any power to control this Board? I do not think he has.
Comment on this
I thought I had already made this clear. Capital must be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance on my recommendation and I have to be satisfied that the programme of capital financing is generally satisfactory. There would be discussions at official level and I would have discussions with the Chairman and, if necessary, with the Board. We would look at this list of suggested capital expenditure items and if we were satisfied that in general CIE was operating on a sound basis and looking after that part of the service which is remunerative and, at the same time, supplying essential social services, I would then say to the Minister for Finance: "I approve of the issue of capital to CIE", and when the capital was issued to CIE, they would then proceed to spend it.
Comment on this
I hope I have described the position correctly but one has to keep to the law about this.
Comment on this
The question at issue is whether the capital moneys ought to be expended and the test is that these two points are left to the Board, not to the Minister.
Comment on this
The Minister cannot explain it in the face of section 3 which says the opposite to what he is saying.
Comment on this
The Minister has to give sanction for the expenditure of capital. He must, in general, be satisfied that the capital is being spent for the right purpose. I cannot see why there should be any difficulty about understanding that.
Comment on this
The incurring of the expenditure is not for the Minister to decide? Is that not right?
Comment on this
The Minister should read section 3 in which the Board is specified. The Minister does not come into section 3.
Comment on this
Of course, the expenditure of the capital once having been agreed, is a matter for the Board.
Comment on this
If the Board are satisfied about two things. What is the good of trying to argue against the section?
Comment on this
I was asking the Minister, if he was not satisfied, could he prevent the Board going on with capital expenditure. The kind of capital expenditure I have in mind is, perhaps, £1 million. Could the Board go on with that expenditure and take no notice of the Minister's advice in these consultations?
Comment on this
I do not understand the Deputy. I made it absolutely clear. The Board go into the details. They have the responsibility of spending the capital, once it has been advanced to them, and I have responsibility for seeing that the amount of capital they are asking is——
Comment on this
I thought when the consultations were being set up, the Minister's hand was being strengthened.
Comment on this
In practice, there are all sorts of miscellaneous capital items but there would be also important capital items which they would indicate to me.
Comment on this
I am trying to protect the Minister. I am also trying to protect the House and the taxpayer. If CIE were about to spend £1 million on engines which would only go forward—you remember the mistake that was made before in regard to the other engines—could the Minister prevent CIE making that mistake?
Comment on this
The most successful man in that operation was the salesman. We should get his name and address and invite him over here to start a school of salesmanship. This is a very serious business because there is reference here to the advance from time to time to the Board "of such sums not exceeding in the aggregate £6 million". One would think it was buttons. There is a crowd of faceless men in Kingsbridge, as far as we are concerned, and the way this Bill is going, they have no responsibility to the House. It appears the Minister must be the fall guy if anything goes wrong. At the same time, no member of this House, none of the elected representatives of the Irish people, can ask the Minister here what is being done with the £6 million. This has nothing to do with day-to-day expenditure or with small bus lines. There is reference here to £6 million and we would not be doing our duty as public representatives if we did not seek a definite statement from the Minister as to how he stood about this.
Comment on this
That is the kind of question the Minister likes to be answering because it means nothing. Before the expenditure, if the Minister has consultations with the Board and if the Minister decides he does not like the proposition the Board are putting up, can he stop the Board from spending that money?
Comment on this
As they like. I am certainly not going to allow a situation to arise in which the Dáil could step in in the middle of the year and prevent CIE spending capital. That would be exactly the kind of interference that would make the position of the company impossible.
Comment on this
If the Deputy suggests that it would not be a day-to-day matter for me to list capital expenditure envisaged for future spending, he is right. That would be a question that would be answered—how the moneys are allocated. But if he is going to ask me why CIE buy diesels from General Motors instead of from another concern, that is a matter for the company.
Comment on this
I am taking the case of moneys which have been passed on to the Board as capital moneys and the Board propose to spend them in a way of which the Minister does not approve and he cannot stop them.
Comment on this
On 14th April, I got a letter from the Ceann Comhairle disallowing a question of mine regarding a large purchase of buses by CIE.
Comment on this
The Minister refused to answer that question. I asked what the length of the buses was, what was the specification and what was the cost. He refused to answer that question. I put it down again last week and he answered it yesterday. It was only a little matter of £445,000. These buses were 36 feet long, six feet over the maximum allowed for any vehicle travelling on Irish roads. These are things this House should know. I was told about them and I was not sure whether it was right or not. I went to the responsible Minister, the Minister who says he is responsible, and he would not tell me.
Comment on this
As I said, I would not regard it as a matter of day-to-day administration to give to the House details of a substantial capital programme of CIE by simply saying what the division of the money was between the various types of capital expenditure.
Comment on this
Somebody in the Minister's Department woke up about ten days afterwards and wrote me a letter. I have a strong objection to that. I asked the question so that the Minister would answer it here and so that the Irish people would know. I did not want a letter sent to me. This is an old trick of the Minister's. He tells us about the Pacemaker Report. Only 12 copies of it were printed. The Minister will come in and say as he said yesterday: "You will find it in this year's report of CIE." This year's CIE report has not yet been published.
It is not available to anybody in this House.
I wanted the information I was seeking for this debate and for the Estimate. We are entitled to ask these questions and entitled to get answers. We are now dealing with two sections since 3.30 p.m. but the Minister would have had the Bill three hours ago if he had followed the example of his colleagues and answered the Parliamentary Questions.
The Minister says that he can prevent, or object to, CIE taking a certain line of big capital expenditure. We would not expect him to bother with small items which would be merely the day-to-day business that he is always talking about, but when it comes to a big change in policy or a new and expensive step by CIE, I want to know from the Minister, if such a step is being taken and the Deputies become aware of it and want to know if it is a fact, will the Minister answer that question?