We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Transport Bill, 1964—Committee Stage.

Contributions 492–731 of 731. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Transport Bill, 1964
Enacted

No. 4 of 1964 ›

The Minister has not, but that is what he constantly says. He had the audacity to say in the House to-day that he had answered every question I had asked him on the Second Stage of this Bill. I had the Dáil Debates in front of me and I had to protest that he was not answering the questions I had put to him, although he had a fortnight, between the time I spoke and when he replied to the debate, to enable him to get the information. I have no doubt his officials supplied it to him.

Comment on this

I shall not attempt to satisfy the Deputy in regard to that. He is being utterly unreasonable and, so far as that is concerned, it is a matter that is closed with me.

Comment on this

I shall be far more unreasonable because I am dealing with an unreasonable Minister who never showed reason in regard to anything asked on this side of the House or on his own side of the House in regard to his Department. He brushed everybody aside. I am still asking if Deputies ask Parliamentary Questions regarding an important step that CIE might be about to take involving big capital expenditure, possibly up to £6 million, would the Minister answer them. Are we entitled to know?

Comment on this

I have already made it clear to the Deputy that he could have a list of capital expenditure and I want to make absolutely clear that agitation in this House will not stop any State company under my supervision from carrying out any programme during the year, if I approve of it. Agitation here will not influence any State company under my supervision as regards the carrying out of its annual programme, the general character of which has been debated here and which has been made perfectly clear to the public. The House has no power to interrupt programmes of that kind. I shall be responsible for any ill results that come and, on the next occasion when the Estimates come before the House, I shall be answerable for any mistakes made by the company in general.

Comment on this

That is the trouble —the Minister is not answerable.

Comment on this

The Deputy who says that is utterly unreasonable.

Comment on this

Earlier, the Minister spoke about people making political capital. Now he says that agitation here will have no influence. But for agitation, the Minister would not be here or any of us.

Comment on this

There is going to be delegation of full authority to State companies. The Government stand by that and the Deputy may object to it, but that is the fact. There will be full delegation with relevance to the Acts.

Comment on this

This is something we should be very careful about. We have had these experts from CIE advising Ministers and advising this Minister before and he came here with their recommendations and forced them upon the House. These recommendations were to be carried out in spite of the fact that even from his own benches he was told he was wrong.

He was wrong, and he was proved wrong. Time proved him wrong. And these experts can be wrong again.

I do not want to clog up the wheels of CIE. I do not want to see any more railway lines dug up. When we are asked, however, to give our assent here to handing the Minister a sum of £18 million over a period of years we have a right to say something about the expenditure of this sum. We have a right to say in what circumstances we will vote this money. We have the right at any time to come into this House and oppose or support any matter. I pointed out earlier the danger of not being allowed to do that.

There was a public company of which another Minister was practically in charge. No Parliamentary Questions were allowed. They were all brushed aside. Grave mistakes were made by that company. It is now in liquidation. A few Parliamentary Questions might have saved that company. The Minister wants to put CIE into an impregnable position. They will get this money. They can take a chance. They can go in for large capital expenditure. If they lose, what about it? Who cares? Nobody can ask questions. Write off the losses. If the Board of CIE knew that, if they made blunders, they just could not go blundering on because they would be brought to book in the Parliament of the country, that would save the situation.

I do not agree with the Minister that he should give all power to these people. This is the Parliament of Ireland. We were sent here by the people of Ireland as custodians of the public weal. The people of Ireland are our masters and we should be the masters of any public company we set up. When I say "we," I mean this entire Assembly. I have given the Minister about five chances on this. I ask him once more will he give us an undertaking—he need only say "Yes" and I will take a chance; I will take his word for it—that, if Deputies ask questions relating to CIE, or to any State companies and these questions are in respect of very large sums of money and large expenditure, those questions will be answered?

Will the Minister also give us an undertaking to explain to us what the difference is when I put down a question about the price of a fleet of buses and he refuses to tell me, while another Deputy, on the same day, asks the price of three or four very high priced aeroplanes, running into £2 or £3 millions, and the Minister answers the question. In the past four years Deputy after Deputy has asked questions about CIE and the Minister has just brushed them aside. I have my latest addition here:

Dear Deputy,

I regret I had to disallow two questions addressed by you to the Minister for Transport and Power—

(a) regarding the erection of a public convenience at Tramore bus terminus and

(b) ——

Comment on this

On a point of order, these questions are decided by the Ceann Comhairle and I have no obligation to defend the action of the Ceann Comhairle in refusing questions.

Comment on this

Why not just subside?

Comment on this
Seán MacCarthy Acting Chairman (Mr. MacCarthy) Fianna Fáil

It is the duty of the Chair to give every possible facility to members to make their points. Members are entitled to quote particular instances, not ruled on, in support of their contentions, but, at the same time, I feel there is a good deal of useless repetition in this debate and that points have been made and quoted over and over again. I would ask members, in the interests of proceeding normally with the business of the House, to be reasonable.

Comment on this

The Minister got up immediately I started to read this letter from the Ceann Comhairle. This was no repetition and, as far as I am concerned, it was not necessary for the Minister to defend the Ceann Comhairle. I accept the Ceann Comhairle's ruling and yours, with all respect. As far as repetition is concerned, we have to be forgiven if we repeat ourselves a little——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

I got another letter today which informed me that two amendments tabled in my name Nos. 5 and 25, were ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I have no responsibility for that.

Comment on this

The Minister has no function in the matter.

Comment on this

It was the Ceann Comhairle who decided that; it has nothing to do with me.

Comment on this

It is always a good thing to gallop a horse for his wind.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I think there is a great deal of it here just now.

Comment on this

I galloped a horse. I got one of these letters. This is what I am coming to. I deeply resent Deputy Moher coming in on this because he did enough screaming about his own line down in Youghal.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I think the standards of the House ought to be maintained. Deputies should speak responsibly when dealing with a matter such as this. Interjections across the floor of the House are not orderly and certainly not helpful.

Comment on this

This is a performance.

Comment on this

If anyone is lowering the standards of the House, it is the Minister. We have a Minister for State, who is being asked to adopt a certain course in relation to a very important State company, and who has refused to give any information or any idea as to what he will do in future. At the same time, he asks us to vote him £18 millions here. I want to put myself on record here so that I may have the satisfaction in two or three years' time, please God, of saying I did make a stand against this. I was here when the Transport Bill of 1958 was passed. The Minister's predecessor, Deputy Lemass, gave an undertaking which he never carried out.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

This does not arise on the section.

Comment on this

Will the Minister answer questions with regard to the capital outlay of the Board of CIE in future?

Comment on this

That has been asked and answered ten times.

Comment on this

It has not.

Comment on this

I want to put this case to the Minister. The Minister has stated that he is quite prepared to answer any questions listing the capital expenditure of the Board. A case has been put to him by Deputy T. Lynch with regard to the purchase of buses. A question was asked about that purchase and I understand it was not answered. I understand also from Deputy Lynch's remark that the cost involved was of the order of £400,000 or £450,000 and that the buses at the time exceeded the legal length for such vehicles. I think the regulations in that respect were altered so as to provide for a variation in order to bring the buses within them.

The question I want to put to the Minister arises out of that. Assume for a moment there is agreement between the Minister and the Board that a certain number of buses will be purchased as part of a capital programme of the Board. I take it without question that if the Minister gives sanction for the purchase of buses, he would intend that the buses being purchased would comply in all respects with the law of this land, and if it came to the Minister's notice before the buses were purchased that in fact they were not going to comply with road traffic regulations, there should be some power in the Minister to stop that transaction and there should be some power in the House to raise that kind of question with the Minister, to bring it to his attention and to insist as far as possible that the Minister take action in the matter.

That is what is at issue arising out of the matter raised by Deputy Lynch. I should like to know what is the Minister's attitude there. Apparently, his attitude within the past fortnight was that he had no function in that matter and that he was not going to reply to the question. I want to know when this Bill goes through, when this section goes through, will the Minister's attitude be the same. It is a question of capital expenditure. It is a question of agreement between himself and the Board. Surely it is not sufficient for the Minister to say: "Once I have given my consent and given the money, there is nothing more for me to do and I am not going to put up with agitation by Deputies on this." As far as I and other Deputies on these benches are concerned, the Minister will put up with agitation unless he is prepared to meet this House fairly and squarely and give us the fullest information on all of these questions.

Comment on this

The Minister is making the case that he provides reasonable information on all questions of a basic and fundamental nature which do not impinge on the day-to-day operations and practice. That is not the case. Deputy Lynch has given numerous examples of questions to which it was not possible to obtain a reply. I have had similar experience. On at least two occasions, I have tabled a question to inquire as to the profit earned by CIE on the operation of the Dublin city services. That basic fundamental information, without which one cannot appraise the functions of CIE, has been withheld from me and from this House. The Chairman of CIE has admitted to me that that information is available. That is a preposterous state of affairs.

Comment on this

The Deputy has the information.

Comment on this

I have it now for the year to March, 1962. What about the previous years in respect of which it was denied to me?

Comment on this

That is all the Deputy is going to get, to be quite frank.

Comment on this

Surely that is contempt for Parliament? Surely the public are entitled to this basic fundamental information, without which no one can evaluate the service rendered by CIE? The citizens of Dublin have a chip on their shoulders. They believe CIE are making extravagant profits on the Dublin city services. Surely, if for no other reason than to disillusion us if we are wrong, it would be in the Minister's interest that we be provided with that information, not for one year but for every year?

Comment on this

The Deputy has raised a perfect example. I was trying to think of one. Periodically, we have had these reviews of CIE. In the Pacemaker Report, it was clearly indicated that the surplus on the Dublin bus service was £380,000 and that the loss on the Dublin suburban railway service was £160,000. It was clearly indicated, therefore, that the total surplus on Dublin transport, taken as a whole, was £220,000. It was clearly indicated that a very considerable proportion of the total overhead expenditure of CIE was attributable to work and employment in Dublin. It was clearly indicated that the actual surplus on the city bus account was equivalent to .37 of a 1d per journey. If you work out what it would cost for 12 journeys a week, it would not amount to a frightening sum of money. All that information was given.

Comment on this

For one year.

Comment on this

That is not likely to change very much. There is not going to be any extreme or violent change in the profitability of the Dublin bus services. The idea of cross-subsidisation within CIE is entirely permissible. I do not intend to encourage agitation as between cross-subsidisation from one service to another by suggesting to CIE they should sectionalise their accounts in the way suggested by the Deputy.

This is a matter of controversy. The Deputy has his point of view. He is entitled to it. There are other intelligent people who might argue with the Deputy. I am not prepared to say that I am standing here as a person who is so inevitably right that I am certain the Deputy is absolutely wrong. It is a controversial matter. It is different in the case of different State companies. There are some State Companies where very sectionalised accounts might have no adverse affect and it is just my view, supported by the Government, that I do not want to have, every year and every month, discussions in the Dáil by way of questions that involve the principle of attacking the cross-subsidisation of accounts as between the different sections of CIE.

The Deputy knows the total net profit of the Dublin transport service is nothing that could cause a scandal. It is not excessive. It amounts to .37 of 1d per journey. We have had that discussion. It is ended. That review is being undertaken and, in my view, for the next four or five years, until we have another complete review of CIE, if we need one—we may not need one—it is unreasonable to ask CIE to sectionalise the accounts. It is wrong in the interests of the public as a whole and such sectionalising is not conducive to efficient service.

Comment on this

The Minister is completely begging the question. This information is revealed in the Pacemaker Report, of which 12 copies were printed. It is revealed in respect of the year to the 31st March, 1962, that there was a profit on the Dublin services of £380,000. We are not here at this stage going to discuss Dublin city transport.

Comment on this

The profit is going down.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is being discussed.

Comment on this

It is not. I am going on the point of principle. This basic fundamental information has been available to the Minister and CIE year after year, and it is deliberately being withheld from this House. That is gravely wrong. That is a travesty of democracy. It is true that in the year in question, 1962, it has been revealed that the profit was £380,000. All the indications are that in several of the years prior to 1962 the profit on the Dublin city services was in the order of £1 million. Since 31st March, 1962, there have been two increases in fares and, for all I know, the profit on Dublin city services for the year ended 31st March, 1964, could have been £1 million. For all this House knows, it could have been £10 million or there could have been a loss. Whatever the result was, we should know what it was because it is basic fundamental information without which we cannot evaluate CIE.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

If we continue to discuss sectional issues such as this, which, to my mind, are more appropriate to the Estimates, we will not make progress with the section under discussion.

Comment on this

It might be no harm to carry over the section, Sir.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is the section agreed?

Comment on this

No. I do not know whether the Minister, in my absence, has replied to the questions I have put.

Comment on this

I have said everything that can be said on the subject.

Comment on this

I want to speak on section 4. I have put to the Minister a proposition. Think in terms of something that is beyond day-to-day administration. Think, also, in terms of some moneys which are clearly capital moneys and not to exceed £6 million in a particular period. The Minister says he is getting great control here because he and the Minister for Finance must agree to expenditure of a capital nature. Let me take up the position where these two points are clear: capital expenditure without a doubt and not day-to-day administration. The Minister then, with the collaboration of his colleague, passes over a certain sum of money inside the £6 million to this Board. It comes to the question of its expenditure.

I have put to the Minister that under the section we have already passed— section 3—he has nothing to say to the two points that then arise for determination: (1) Is the money required for the efficient operation of the undertaking; and (2) Will the project for which the expenditure is proposed be remunerative? I have asked the Minister to agree with me that on those two points he has nothing to say. Supposing he notifies the Board who are to expend the money of his view that the expenditure was not required for the efficient operation of the undertaking or that it was not going to be a remunerative project, I suggest the Minister can be rebuffed by the Board. The Board can simply tell him to take a jump at himself. Am I right about that as the Bill goes? I am not talking about what may happen behind the scenes—persuasive powers and all the rest of it. I am taking the case where the Board are satisfied that the expenditure is properly required and will be remunerative. Can the Minister interfere? He says, of course, there can be consultation. There is nothing about consultation in what we are passing.

I am going to propose on Report Stage, when we come back to section 3, that the authority to be satisfied will not be the Board but will be the Minister, or the Minister after consultation with the Board. As the matter stands at the moment, the Board can cock a snook at the Minister when he tries to interfere in these two points.

Comment on this

I have already made that point clear.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain section 5?

Comment on this

The section empowers the Board to borrow moneys from the Minister for Finance who in turn is empowered by section 4 to make advances to the Board and to defray capital expenditure. Under section 3 of the Bill, the Board must be satisfied that any such expenditure is incurred only when it is essential——

Comment on this

And the Board decide that.

Comment on this

——for the operation of the Board's undertaking or on projects which will be remunerative. That is the explanation.

Comment on this

It brings us back to section 3, does it not?

Comment on this

And the Board have complete control there?

Comment on this

I have to be generally satisfied, too. The Deputy can argue this all night.

Comment on this

Where is the Minister in this?

Comment on this

The Minister exercises general supervision over CIE.

Comment on this

Is the Minister mentioned in section 3?

Comment on this

I have got to the end of arguing in detail about this.

Comment on this

Has the Minister come to the end of the line?

Comment on this

I have got to the end of the line of arguing points about CIE that have no bearing on the general effects of this matter. I give approval for a broad programme of capital expenditure. I have said that.

Comment on this

Is it agreed that section 3 does not mention the Minister?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

There are two amendments to section 6—amendments Nos. 7 and 8—and I understand that it has been agreed that they may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:—

In page 3, to delete subsection (5) and to substitute the following subsection:

"(5) Where an order is proposed to be made under this section, a draft of the order shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and the order shall not be made until a resolution approving of the draft has been passed by each such House."

This is the question of how the arrangements for a variation in the amount of the annual subsidy is to be debated in this House and, as the Deputy will see, I have conceded the principle which he put forward. The only difference is that I understand that it is not appropriate for the Oireachtas to amend a Ministerial order. That can only be done by me as Minister. That is the only difference between my amendment and that of Deputy McGilligan. Deputy McGilligan felt that there should be a more specific discussion in the House when we get to the end of the five-year period rather than the form suggested in the Bill. I am quite prepared to agree to that, that there be a specific discussion.

Comment on this

There is a difference between the two amendments. I tried to have it as "the draft shall be open to amendment". The Minister does not say anything about that.

Comment on this

I would not accept that.

Comment on this

Therefore, we are back again to the old situation. Parliamentary procedure here has developed two lines of approach to these orders. One is the type of order that is made and becomes operative unless it is negatived and the other is the type of order that is put into the House and does not come into operation until it is approved.

In connection with both types of order there is a further distinction, that Ministers have got into the habit of coming into the House with orders and saying. "Take it or leave it. We propose to do such and such a thing and if you do not like that, then we will just not do anything." Whereas, I want to have a full discussion and have leave to amend an order. That is important.

This is a very important order under section 6. We have to deal with the annual grant and the annual grant is generally to be £2 million a year and that £2 million is to be the expenditure year after year for five years and then, by part of a section, that amount may be varied but the variation is only to take effect if it is approved by the House.

I do not want the Minister to come in here with a draft order saying: "Instead of paying £2 million in one year, we are to pay £3 million," and I will agree to pay £2½ million and I want to amend to that point, but, if the Minister's proposal is carried, he can come in with an order saying: "Change the £2 million to £3 million and, if you do not like that, we will not change it at all." Why should we have that position? If the House is to have cognisance of an order at all and to be allowed to approve or reject, surely it ought to be allowed to amend? There are plenty of precedents. The State Guarantees Act, 1954, has a section which deals with a draft order. The Social Welfare Act of 1952 has the same and the Restrictive Trade Practices Act, 1953, the same. I think it is essential that we should retain control and be able to amend draft orders——

Comment on this

I understand that the amendment is put in exactly the same form as it appears in the State Guarantees Act.

Comment on this

Perhaps, but is it possible to amend a draft order under the Minister's amendment?

Comment on this

No, not technically.

Comment on this

You take either what the Minister offers or you do not take it at all?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

I object to that. We are now voting £2 million for five years and power might be taken to spend £4 million in one year. If we did not agree to the £4 million, then you go back to the original £2 million, but the House might be disposed to pay £3 million but not £4 million. What is the reason for not taking this?

Comment on this

I could amend the order in order to give effect to the wishes of the House, if I felt it right to do so.

Comment on this

The Minister wants to take away more of our powers in the House. This kind of niggling legislation is taking away powers from this House and we will be just like county councillors. Ministers will not even be in a position of being like the county managers, but we will have people in Government Departments running the whole show.

Comment on this

I understand that this is a technical matter. The Ministerial order can be framed only in this way.

Comment on this

Who told the Minister that?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Draftsman has so informed me.

Comment on this

He is our employee and is not here to dictate to us.

Comment on this

The order is in the same form as for the Estimates for the Departments.

Comment on this

Why has this House no control over a variation order?

Comment on this

The Estimate for the Department is rather the same, is it not? It can be referred back but I do not know of any amendment suggesting that the Vote for the Department be cut in half.

Comment on this

There might arise a situation in which the Minister might be persuaded to amend his own order but the House cannot do it. That is outrageous.

Comment on this

In subsection (1), the Minister has specified that £2 million will be paid to the Board each year until 1969. From my reading of the section, it seems the Minister has in mind not to change the provisions until 1969 and that it is unlikely that there will be need for a change in that period.

Comment on this

We have gone through that.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

We are considering two amendments, an amendment by the Minister and an amendment by Deputy McGilligan which are being debated together.

Comment on this

We will have it on the section.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I find myself compelled to support Deputy McGilligan on this matter. If this House has any function, it must be to amend, where it thinks fit, either legislation or draft orders. To say that this House will deny itself that right in legislation is to say that we deny our rights to represent the people and that we are denying the right to the people to amend any draft order put before the House by a Minister, an order drafted by the Civil Service and by the draftsmen who are now telling the Minister that we have no right to amend or qualify any draft order the Minister may put before the House. We know well what the attitude would be—"You must take this draft order or I will accuse you of denying to CIE £2 million and its employees will have you to thank if they do not get a pay cheque next week". That is the type of thing that is put before the House when you try to put an argument in a democratic manner. It is time that this House recognised its own rights and if it means that we have to take up the matter of not having any right to qualify Ministerial draft orders elsewhere, we will certainly do it.

We certainly do not accept the Minister's amendment. Deputy McGilligan is accepted as one of the leading parliamentarians in this country and in this century, and the House should be guided by what he suggests. His amendment is a very worthy one. The Minister has accepted it in principle and it may well be that he would like to go all the way with Deputy McGilligan.

Comment on this

If the House should decide, by refusing to agree to this motion, to suggest an alternative sum, it would be up to the Minister of the day to decide whether he would submit a new draft order for that sum or the alternative would be a Government crisis, the defeat of the Government in the House on an important matter. The Deputy knows that just as well as I do and there is no question of there not being a democratic procedure if an order is defeated.

Comment on this

What is wrong in saying "amend the £2 million to £2½ million but not to £3 million"?

Comment on this

It would be very difficult in connection with CIE——

Comment on this

No; the Minister has brought in an order and we say, instead of giving them £3 million, give them £2½ million. What is wrong with that?

Comment on this

It is very difficult to decide on a basis of calculation.

Comment on this

If the Minister cannot produce arguments that £3 million is not necessary——

Comment on this

If the House were to decide that £2½ million should be given instead of £3 million, I would then have to reconsider the matter. The Government would have to consider it and the Minister for Finance, and if we agreed, we would come back with a new order.

Comment on this

That is the way it should be.

Comment on this

But I am afraid that in the form of these Ministerial orders, it is not possible——

Comment on this

I never heard of this precedent.

Comment on this

I have not got the background.

Comment on this

It is a pity on an important matter such as this that the Minister did not get the background.

Comment on this

I still think the alternative is just as satisfactory.

Comment on this

The only difference is that under my amendment the draft would be open to amendment.

Comment on this

I think the alternative is just as satisfactory.

Comment on this

Leave this over to the next Stage when perhaps the Minister will be better briefed.

Comment on this

I do not think that will get us anywhere. I do not think there should be established a principle in the case of State companies that subsidies proposed can be varied. The Minister has to make up his mind on the order and listen to what the Opposition say and, if he felt they were right, he could come back and suggest a different amount but in the ordinary way this question is decided in advance by the Government.

Comment on this

Is this not a deliberative assembly where we are supposed to be persuaded by argument?

Comment on this

If the Government were defeated, the House would have prevailed by argument.

Comment on this

As Deputy Ryan said, if CIE were prevented from getting the money, the blame would be put on us.

Comment on this

That applies to other——

Comment on this

If you could give me any reason for this, I would not mind.

Comment on this

I cannot see any objection to this.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 8 may not be moved since amendment No. 7 has been carried.

Comment on this

It only adds to amendment No. 7 that the draft should be open to recommendation. The difference is "open to amendment". It is really an amendment to amendment No. 7.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 7 meets amendment No. 8 to a certain extent.

Comment on this

With the exception of the important words "open to amendment". Why not put my amendment and have it defeated?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy can put down his amendment for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have been made an offer which I accept.

Comment on this

I agree with the Deputy that I should know more about the background.

Comment on this

To give the Minister a chance of explaining it, I will put down the amendment for Report Stage.

Comment on this

I think that is reasonable.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 9 in the name of Deputy M. P. Murphy is out of order for reasons given.

Comment on this

This section grants a subsidy of £2 million to CIE each year for the next five years. I want to know why this sum of £2 million has been arrived at. Who is to say that £2 million is sufficient to subsidise CIE? Who is to say that it is not too much? I should be grateful if the Minister would enlighten us on that point and tell us what contribution to the CIE pool he expects the Dublin city services to provide. Is this sum of £2 million based on a scientific calculation? I suspect it is based on some sort of a forecast for the coming years.

If so, does that forecast provide for a cross-subsidy, to use the Minister's term, from the Dublin city passenger services to CIE in the order of £250,000, £500,000, or a £1 million, or does it presuppose a loss on the Dublin city services? These are points we ought to know in order to assess the merits of this provision. If the sum of £2 million anticipates a cross-subsidy of the amounts I have mentioned from the Dublin city services, I want to protest. In this Bill we are bringing in a new principle for the first time, the principle that transport has to be subsidised. It is a radical turn about in our transport policy to admit that a State subsidy is necessary.

If we admit that principle, we must be consistent and logical in our application of it and we must cast aside the basis upon which transport policy has been founded for the past number of years. It was wrong from the start to expect the Dublin city services to contribute a large subsidy to the operations of CIE. It is going to be much more grievously wrong in the future because of this new principle of subsidy. It was wrong in the past because the people who are creating this subsidy, the Dublin workers, are being badly treated by CIE for the reason they are being provided with inadequate services for which they have to pay outrageously high prices.

As a Dublin Deputy, I feel somewhat guilty. I have listened here to Deputies from rural parts fighting their corner and making their case strongly for various rural services. I feel that Dublin Deputies on all sides of the House have failed adequately to impress upon the Minister what a damn bad service the people of Dublin are getting from CIE, how unfairly and inequitably they are being treated.

I do not wish to avail of this section to make a protracted speech on the operations of CIE in Dublin. The Minister knows my views on that matter. I have previously indicated the inadequacies in considerable detail —the lack of shelters, the outrageously high fares, the manner in which the stages are fiddled by CIE to ensure that people who are taking the most commonly availed of services will pay the maximum fare.

The Dublin workers from the dormitory housing estates, from Ballyfermot, Cabra and Coolock, people of very modest incomes, have to travel to their work and home again at a cost of from 30/- to £2 a week. They are the people who are creating this pool of profit from which we are to expect CIE to draw. The Minister has the audacity to defend that practice as a legitimate device, to defend this cross-subsidy, as he calls it, and to quote statistics of mileage rates and profit per journey. The people who are using the CIE Dublin city services are people living on modest means. Some of them are badly off. There are young girls in housing schemes travelling considerable distances and paying 10d bus fares to get to their work for which their remuneration is £4 or £4 5s per week. Thirty shillings per week taken out of that modest wage packet is a very considerable sum.

The burden of CIE fares is creating hardship for some parents, particularly for parents of large families whose children have to travel a distance to school. The concession fare provided for schoolchildren, as the Minister is aware, is only available to children going to school in the morning and coming back in the evening. It is not available for travelling at lunch time. Rural Deputies are not aware of the way of life of our Dublin people who have to travel considerable distances and whose children have to travel distances to school. Parents may be making considerable sacrifices to send their children to a secondary school and this added burden of transport fares is the last straw that makes their goal unattainable.

I want to protest against the situation and I shall protest at every opportunity which presents itself, no matter how angry the Minister becomes. The Minister says he does not intend to leave the door open to agitators to exploit a situation such as this. The use of that very phrase illustrates very clearly what contempt the Minister has for Parliament. In making these complaints, we are availing of our democratic right to discharge our duty as legislators.

I spoke here a few moments ago about the profit on the Dublin services and on the refusal of CIE to disclose what profit was being made over the years. The Minister condones that. He admits they have that figure. That fundamental piece of information is available to the directors of CIE, is probably available to the Minister, but is withheld from the public and from their representatives. That is an appalling state of affairs that would not be condoned in any Parliament where the basic principles of democracy are respected.

The harsh glare of publicity is the best safeguard to ensure the fair and efficient operation of our State companies, including CIE. The accounts furnished by CIE do not give anything like adequate information to those of us who wish to appraise the workings of that company. However, I do not propose to become involved in that. I merely wish to avail of this opportunity to inquire from the Minister, who has decided that £2 million is the subsidy which CIE will require per year for each of the coming five years, if this sum is based on a scientifically calculated budget. If so, what contribution is going into that budget from the operation of the Dublin city services? Is it £500,000? Is it £1 million? Whatever it is, we should know.

I would urge the Minister to take into account the basic considerations of equity, to consider that these Dublin workers who are contributing very handsomely to the CIE pool are a section of the community who are most savagely taxed by our taxation code of indirect taxes, together with PAYE, a system of tax applied to wage and salary earners, the only section of the community who have no way out of the tax net. It is, in these circumstances, quite wrong and unjust to expect them to pay an added tax every time they make a journey on a CIE bus.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Byrne, I should like to know how the Minister arrived at this figure of £2 million, what kind of system he applied to ascertain that £2 million was the figure required.

Comment on this

I have already explained it on the Second Stage.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not know the history of subsidies to CIE since 1958? Does he not remember the many statements he made, even since 1958 and as late as 1963, that he has retracted in the course of the Second Reading debate? Does he not realise he has made at least five public statements since 1958, the last one in 1963, to the effect that he did not believe in subsidising transport, that he would get rid of that system from our legislation, that there was no justification for spending public funds on subsidising transport. Is the Minister not making changed statements on transport since he was appointed to his office? I shall agree he did not anticipate as late as 1963, less than 12 months ago to be exact, that he would, in the summer of 1964, be asking the Dáil to approve of a sum of £2 million annually for CIE for five years.

We give the £2 million to CIE and, as we have already mentioned in the House several times, we are unlikely to get any more information as to how this money is to be expended. Supposing a number of services are withdrawn. Even though the Minister has indicated in the course of the Second Reading that it is unlikely that services will be withdrawn, all the Minister's statements are suspect. When the Minister put forward a case proposing the closure of the West Cork, West Clare and Tramore railway lines, he made it quite clear that until 31st March, 1964, there would be no question of closing any further lines, that the closure of those lines would be sufficient to balance CIE finances, that there would be no need to make any further changes and that people who were fearful lest their transport system would be withdrawn need have no fear. Within a few months of the Minister making that statement, there was notification of further closures. A number of lines were closed within a matter of months.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The closure of lines does not arise on section 6, which deals with the annual grant to the Board. The Deputy has discussed this point on other sections.

Comment on this

We are now having nothing but repetitions.

Comment on this

If the Minister is not careful, I shall go back even further to remind the Minister of statements he has made. I have gone back only as far as the 1958 Transport Act. I wish to quote subsection (1) of this section:

Subject to subsection (2) of this section, the Minister shall in the financial year of the Board beginning on the 1st day of April, 1964, and in each subsequent financial year of the Board make to the Board, out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas, a grant of two million pounds.

This clearly indicates there will be no change until 1969, until which time the flat rate of £2 million a year is being given. Supposing services which are deemed to be uneconomical are withdrawn in a number of areas. I am not speaking now of rail services; I am speaking of rail and bus services generally. The Minister has now commenced to remove the bus services and possibly he may remove other bus services——

Comment on this

I dealt with all that before. The Deputy is merely repeating himself.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not mentioned this before and it is relevant to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Deputy has mentioned it before.

Comment on this

The Minister need not feel irritated because time and again he has irritated Deputies on this side of the House who were trying to get information from him. Naturally, we are very slow to pass any section of the Bill without the closest examination. We know what happened when we tried to get information before. Did the Minister not tell us that in 1958 the House passed the Transport Act which gave CIE power to do this and that and that we were not entitled to get information. He said CIE were acting in accordance with powers they got from the House. That being so, having regard to the treatment we got from the Minister and from CIE, we must be very diligent in our examination of every word and line of this measure.

Subsection (1) of the section gives CIE £2 million per year. We asked, as did the previous speaker, Deputy Byrne, how that figure was reached. At the time of the closure of the railways I have mentioned, it was implied in the Minister's statement that there was a likelihood that CIE would break even, when they would be rid of these uneconomic lines. At that time, they had a good year. I think the deficit was not much more than £250,000. It jumped in the next year to, I think, more than £1,700,000. That was a big jump, despite the fact that the Minister had wiped out a number of lines.

I feel that the State as a whole must contribute this money. No areas are excluded from the obligation to contribute, although areas are excluded from the right of participation in the services provided. Removal of a service from an area does not remove the obligation from the people there to continue subsidising CIE. I am making the case that if, as is not unlikely, in 1966 or 1967, the Minister decides to close the 750 miles of railway which he states are uneconomic and if he decides to close the bus services which he earlier mentioned as being entirely uneconomic, and if he gets back to the opinions he held up to 1963 that CIE should not be subsidised, how would this section work? Whether the Minister likes it or not—unless there is new legislation—this legislation gives CIE a flat sum of £2 million per year.

It is not true that CIE are in the most favourable position as a public company. I have frequently mentioned the obligations of CIE and my belief in their right to subsidisation to provide services in uneconomic districts. Possibly we would not have the discussions we have had on this Bill were it not for the attitude adopted by the Minister and CIE.

If CIE decides, after getting this £2 million to close ten uneconomic routes or any routes it declares to be uneconomic, what will happen? The subsidy will continue. The people affected by the closure of the routes will get no satisfaction from CIE. There is no question of their being told in advance of the proposal to close the transport service. On the 1958 Act, the Taoiseach said that two months notice would be given of the withdrawal of rail services and it was generally assumed that the same would apply to bus services. We then found that the two months notice, although given, was of no avail to the affected areas because the Minister and the Board refused to meet or discuss closures with any responsible authorities locally.

I now find no notice is given to an area when a bus service is withdrawn: the notice does not apply to road transport. The first an area affected knows about services being withdrawn is when they find buses no longer passing through their district. From past experience, that is likely to arise. In the light of experience since 1958, it is most likely to arise and still the subsidy will continue.

I see in this Bill that the Minister is getting something similar to what he got before but we did not have the experience in 1958 we now have. He is getting, or endeavouring to get, a blank cheque from the House for £2 million annually for CIE and approval for wiping out some liabilities which already exist and also approval for amending the figure, if he so wishes, in years to come. In return, he has told the House that he is not prepared to answer any questions that may arise on this matter. He has already indicated that he feels he has given too much information to the House about CIE affairs.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of Ministerial replies does not arise on this section. It has already been debated and the Deputy has mentioned it on more than one occasion. The Deputy is repeating himself for the third or fourth time.

Comment on this

We have to be very careful, and I have mentioned that on a number of occasions, but I think, with due respect, the question of Ministerial answers is relevant to every section of the Bill.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair feels otherwise, and it is the decision of the Chair in these matters that counts and not what the Deputy thinks.

Comment on this

We cannot repeat too often that the Minister's record in answering questions tabled here is not good. I am not speaking of small items. Earlier, Deputy McGilligan told us that when he tried to get information on a transaction running into more than £1 million, he was told that as it was a day-to-day transaction of the Board, he was not entitled to the information.

Comment on this

To a copy of it.

Comment on this

I do not want to delay the House unduly but at the same time I am in no great hurry to facilitate the Minister. I think his attitude here this evening has changed. In the earlier part of the day, I felt obliged—and I thought it was warranted—to pay him some compliments. Even though his remarks were incorrect and unsoundly based, I gave him credit for being sincere. I withdraw that now. The Minister has grown rather arrogant, if I may use that term. He is impatient. He is trying to ignore the House. That is the attitude adopted not only by the Minister but also by the Government. That is the attitude adopted by the Board of CIE in relation to many matters. The attitude is: "Give us the money", followed by a refusal to give the representatives of the people here information to which they are lawfully entitled.

I want to know from the Minister now, if services are withdrawn from a district, what will happen? Will the people get advance notice? Will they get any assurances? It is proposed to give CIE £2 millions annually for a certain period. I do not see anything in the section to suggest that the Board of CIE will meet people affected by the withdrawal of either road or rail services in order to discuss their problems.

Comment on this

There is nothing in section 6 about withdrawing services at all.

Comment on this

But that is likely to happen. As Deputy Colley knows, section 6 is one of the most important sections in the Bill, because under subsection (1), £2 millions annually will be handed over to CIE. The Minister is trying to get that money from this House. In return, there is no assurance that relevant queries in relation to the expenditure of that money will be answered.

Comment on this

There is nothing in the section about withdrawing services.

Comment on this

In the year in which the services were withdrawn from west Cork, west Clare and Tramore—and Deputy Colley knows this—the Minister made a statement here that no further services would be withdrawn until we had this Bill. Within a few months of making that statement, further services were withdrawn. The Minister has established a record since he took office of wiping out 750 miles of railway line.

Comment on this

They did not pay.

Comment on this

No one would travel on them.

Comment on this

Not even the Deputy.

Comment on this

We were told in 1958 by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the present Taoiseach, that, if the 1958 Bill were passed, there were sufficient brains on the Board of CIE to develop our transport in such manner as to make it capable of standing on its own feet in a period of five years.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach did not commit himself.

Comment on this

We would all have liked to see that prophecy fulfilled. Unfortunately, it was not fulfilled, and that is why we are addressing ourselves now to these questions. The main theme in relation to the 1958 Bill was that, given the Bill, in five years, the likelihood was that CIE would be able to stand on its own feet. The then Minister, in his opening statement, said that, if the Bill were approved by the House, the anticipation was that CIE would be able to break even in five years. The plea was to give them unfettered power and authority, to leave them to themselves, not to bother them with questions here, and, in five years, everything would be all right. I am sure the Minister will admit he believed that statement because he has committed himself on several occasions in his argument that transport should not be subsidised.

The Labour Party believe in subsidisation of transport. We are not against giving the money but we believe that the money should be used to the best advantage. We believe, too, that members of the Oireachtas are entitled to know how the moneys they vote are employed, whether they are gainfully employed or otherwise. We feel that CIE is not utilising these voted moneys to the best advantage. We feel they are too dictatorial. We believe they should be more approachable. We believe they should treat their potential customers with civility and consideration. Instead of that, CIE alienate people by their dictatorial attitude. Now, whether or not the CIE balance sheet balances at the end of the financial year, it will have £2 millions to cover any deficit. If all private companies adopted the attitude CIE adopts, I wonder what the state of our economy would be.

We heard earlier today about two Dublin Deputies who asked the Board of CIE to discuss a particular matter relating to Dublin. The Board would not trouble to meet them. The Minister should have a word with the Board. He has refused my request to reconstitute the Board. He has told us in a very arrogant manner that he has no intention of reconstituting the Board. He firmly believes they are as good as any board that might replace them. He must tell them, however, to be more courteous and more civil.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The composition of the Board of CIE does not arise on this section. I think the Deputy discussed it already on earlier sections.

Comment on this

I think it does arise, but I shall not continue on that line. It is regrettable that we should have to comment adversely on our public transport system. The criticisms offered by this side of the House have been constructive criticisms. We should not be honouring the trust reposed in us if we did not point out deficiencies, in the hope that notice will be taken of them and they will be rectified. We hope that in the not too distant future there will be a different approach by the Board to the public generally. If that happens, there is bound to be an improvement in the Board's finances and the result of that will be a reduction in the subsidy they require.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I join with Deputy Byrne and my Fine Gael colleagues representing Dublin in asking the Minister to state what contribution will be made towards the finances of CIE by the Dublin city services over the next five years during which the Minister proposes to make this sum of £2 millions available annually to CIE. On the Second Stage, the Minister said this figure had been assessed by the experts of CIE as being the probable loss which will be suffered over the next five years. In arriving at that figure, some estimate must have been made of the contribution from the Dublin city services. As these are one of the principal revenue earners of CIE, we think detailed particulars should be given of the receipts from the Dublin city services. The figures in the 1962 and 1963 reports show that the Dublin city services produced two-thirds of the road passenger revenue of CIE, much more than the total rail services of CIE. Yet the Minister persistently refuses to give us figures showing the breakdown of the principal revenue earner of CIE. We do not think that is good enough.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps the Deputy would relate his remarks now to the section, which provides for an annual grant to the Board. The question of receipts from road services in any part of the State does not arise.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

With respect, this section deals with a grant of £2 millions, based, we assume, on some facts. We want to know what the facts are. We are entitled to get them before we either approve or disapprove of this section. The Minister refuses to give them. He weighed down the postman this morning sending around a 30-page document giving details of the operation of his Department and the activities his Department superintends. There is not one figure in that document to show what the revenue is from the Dublin city services. We are given figures for the net losses but there is no breakdown at all to show what contributed to those losses and what contributed to profits. There is no breakdown of road passenger services to show how much is earned on the Dublin city services and how much elsewhere. We are entitled to make that point and submit it as a reason why the Minister should give us the information for which we ask.

From the figures which CIE invariably give us after the Estimate is discussed—therefore, they are of little moment by the time the Estimate comes round the following year—we know that per mile travelled, CIE make more on the Dublin city bus services than on the provincial services. The figure in the 1963 report indicates that on the Dublin city services, there was a profit of 3/1¾ per passenger mile.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is a matter for the Estimate, not for the Bill.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

We are dealing with an estimate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with the annual grant to the Board.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Based on an estimate of the revenue and losses of CIE over the years. I know this is far above the intelligence and ability of the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil, but we assume the Minister has some understanding of the fact that there must be an assessment of the profit and loss on all sections of CIE. We are entitled to know that, before we give a blanket £2 million to CIE in any year. In the course of his Second Reading speech the Minister presumed to give figures about the Dublin bus routes. As we know, CIE has given misleading figures before. Selected figures have been given. CIE has engaged in special pleading before and has not told the full truth. We cannot accept any figures the Minister and CIE give us.

Comment on this

That ends it then?

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Until such time as the Minister names, terminus by terminus, each route supposed to be making a profit or loss, we cannot accept figures from CIE. The Minister gave this House to understand, and CIE gave the country to understand a couple of years ago, that the Dublin suburban train services were losing a colossal amount of money. This fiction is still being recited. The Minister said that of the 1,400 miles of railway track in this country, something like half were making a profit. He presumed to distinguish between profitability and marginal profitability. Frankly, I think we have reached the stage where we do not intend to make a profit for wealthy elements in the community, or for the Government, on any particular tracks. That should not be the test. If it is marginally profitable, it ought to be entirely acceptable.

The Minister told us that 700 of the 1,400 miles were paying a profit. He said it did not call for any great intelligence to know that those tracks were situated in the most densely populated part of the country, the eastern seaboard, in particular. Is there a part of the country more densely populated than the Dublin suburbs? What part of the whole rail system is more likely to pay than the part which, according to the Minister, is situated in the part of the country most densely populated? Yet what did CIE do? It loaded those few miles of track with the capital expenditure and maintenance of Amiens Street, Kingsbridge and Westland Row stations, serving the length and breadth of the country. All this was loaded on to the Dublin surburban services so as to give false figures. CIE has not given a breakdown of those figures.

How can we act responsibly in accepting the blanket estimates given when the Minister and CIE persistently refuse to give us the breakdown to which we are entitled for the Dublin services? If they do pretend to give any breakdown, it is based on figures which, on the Minister's admission, cannot be accepted because of the principle he sets out as being incapable of contradiction—the principle that a railway line will pay as long as it is situated in an area with a high density of population.

These matters are fundamental. If the Minister is not prepared to give us this detailed information, if not on this occasion, then on some other occasion, we Dublin Deputies cannot accept that the Dublin services should still continue to help run the services in the rest of the country. The only figure which we know is of any value is now two years old. It was given for a year which was not a particularly good one in transport finances. We are entitled to get the figures for 1963-64. The Minister has not given them in this 30-page document he circulated for our guidance, although I have not found any fact in it of any assistance in discussing either this Bill or the Estimate for his Department.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister will reply to the statements made?

Comment on this

We have plenty of time. I have no objection to replying but it would not be of much use to give any figures because the figures of CIE are no longer trusted. If Deputies do not accept them, there is not much use at this stage going into figures to any great extent.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The more figures, the more we can check.

Comment on this

The Opposition say they believe the figures of CIE are faked, so there is not much use giving them. The question of this subsidy is arranged in this way. Taking into account all the factors which are reasonably foreseeable, CIE estimate the deficit that will arise on their combined operations, including the securing of loans on capital advances from the Exchequer, over each of the next five years. These have formed the basis, taking one year with another, of the average annual subsidy needed to break even. The projection does envisage a contribution from the Dublin bus services of the present proportion.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this

I could not give the House the detailed breakdown of the figures for the next five years. I have already indicated to Deputy Byrne the figure indicated in Pacemaker. I have told him it represents .37 of a penny per passenger journey, which he does not believe. I have already told him that amounts to some 4d per week for 12 journeys for the average passenger and that I did not consider it excessive. I have already told him — the repetition in this debate is fantastic —that, if you relate the loss on the Dublin rail services to the profit on the Dublin bus services, the total surplus in relation to the total revenue and expenditure of CIE could not constitute an excessive cross-subsidisation. But the Deputy does not believe the figures. I have already said all these things. Now, I shall say to Deputy Ryan that even though he does not believe the figures——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Minister must not misquote me. I said nothing about believing or not believing.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputy's pardon, Deputy Ryan said it. Deputy Ryan has not read Pacemaker, apparently. He has not realised in connection with the Dublin rail services, when I said there was a loss of £160,000, assuming that the rest of the service was closed down, under the new calculation headquarters costs and administration of CIE, and everything that would relate to a great deal of the headquarters expenditure, are allocated to the different sectors of CIE operations throughout the country in a proportionate manner. In saying that the Dublin rail services lose, CIE has not fraudulently put on other expenditure, including a whole lot of headquarters costs which do not really apply. Perhaps that would satisfy the House in regard to that? The reason the Dublin rail services are losing is the same as that in connection with many other commuter services, which have two very high peaks in the morning and evening. Unless there are unusual conditions where people are travelling constantly during the day in enormous numbers a short haul service of that kind is never a paying proposition and there are endless commuter services that lose money. Some of the more favourable kind of services make money. That is why the Dublin suburban railway service loses money and I do not think the net surplus of the whole system is anything that Deputy Byrne need be worried about.

Comment on this

The Minister has very little regard for our Dublin workers who are being so badly served by CIE.

Comment on this

In regard to that matter also I made a full statement today and on the Second Stage.

Comment on this

Tell us when they are going to get shelters to protect them from the elements.

Comment on this

I gave full details to the Deputy of the plans of CIE to try to improve the service, in relation to the congestion of traffic in the centre of the city, which is the main cause of the complaints, that people have to queue at certain times of the day. I explained that at great length. I indicated the plans to the House in my Second Reading speech.

Deputy Murphy asked me some questions about the position in relation to the closing of services. Yes, it is a fact that CIE has the power to close bus services without any notice of a statutory kind as provided in the 1958 Act in relation to the closing of railway services. That is a fact. Deputy Murphy is correct. Again, the whole question of the maintenance of a bus service network throughout the country is something which can be discussed on the Estimate, something for which I am responsible and which cannot be judged by action taken in regard to small individual services; it should be judged by the general character of the services offered by CIE.

In regard to railway services, CIE, under the 1958 Act, still has the power to close a railway service without there being any recourse to the House and without my having to give my consent. That clause in the 1958 Act still stands.

Comment on this

Was there not to be consultation with the local authorities?

Comment on this

I should add that if the Deputies read the text of my speech on the Second Reading they will find the Government clearly desire and intend to maintain the major arterial railways of this country and the lines that are left, where there might be some concentration or reorganisation, are very small in number. Deputies have only to look at the map and to note the existing railway system to realise that the lines that could be closed are not extensive in character. The Government have agreed to maintain the major arterial railway service. I think I have answered all the questions on this point.

Comment on this

There is another point. The Minister will appreciate that it was not written into the Act of 1958 that CIE should meet deputations. The then Minister mentioned that it was superfluous to have a provision such as that in the Bill because he felt there would be no difficulty whatever, that there would be too much notice given, that CIE would meet all the interested parties.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of receiving deputations does not arise.

Comment on this

It does not arise on this at all.

Comment on this

If you will excuse me. The Minister will appreciate that CIE dishonoured the assurance given to the House and which was responsible to a large extent for the passage of that measure without the opposition that it would have got were it not for that assurance. That assurance facilitated the smooth passage of the measure through the House. We were told subsequently that what the Minister said in the course of the discussion had nothing to do with the Bill, that what was in the Bill was what CIE had to do. CIE dishonoured the assurance given by the then Minister, the present Taoiseach. That assurance was given in no uncertain terms. It has been quoted time and again in debates in this House on public transport.

I should like to know from the Minister whether the Minister or the Government took any disciplinary action, if that would be the correct term, in relation to the dishonouring of the assurance given by the responsible Minister to the House. The dishonouring of that assurance led to a world of trouble.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question does not arise.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

The Minister has taken umbrage because I am challenging figures. We will leave the millions aside for the moment. If I understood the Minister correctly he said the average contribution by Dublin passengers was .37 of 1d per trip and that on the basis of an average passenger travelling 12 times a week the person would be contributing about 8d a week towards the general profit.

Comment on this

Twelve times .37d. obviously.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Obviously, the Minister and myself are not ad idem on this. If I multiply .37 by 12, I get 4.44.

Comment on this

It is roughly 4½d.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

That is not very like 8d, which is what I understood the Minister to say before. If the Minister said 4.44 that is all right, but that is not what I thought he said earlier. In any event, if we accept even the Minister's figure, the figure ought to be much nearer 8d or 9d if the Minister now says 4½d on the basis of 12 journeys. The ordinary working person in Dublin who uses public transport for going to and from work will in the course of a week make 24 journeys, taking even six days of the week during which he may travel to and from town. If he comes home for lunch the average contribution will be about 8d or 9d. In many cases, not only the breadwinner of the family, but other members of the household— children going to school—will also have to pay a considerable amount in bus fares and in any household far distant from the centre of town this means a colossal imposition on the family. Of course, the person who travels a longer distance to the more remote suburbs pays more per mile than his fellow citizen nearer to the centre of the city is paying. A person contributing 2d or 3d per journey to and from work is paying 8d per day towards the general profit of CIE. We do not think that that is a fair imposition to continue on the working people of Dublin and we make no apology here or anywhere else for saying so and for saying that we cannot accept the Minister's figures. There are details that we want and which we are entitled to get. Just as members of any company or of any concern or society who are contributing towards the expense of it are entitled to get it, we are entitled to get this detailed information and until such time as we get it we cannot accept the Minister's figures and he cannot blame us.

Comment on this

There is no use in arguing this question. If the surplus on the Dublin bus service is eliminated then either the general subsidy goes up, the taxpayer has to pay more money or some other people down in West Cork—Deputy Murphy's area —will have to pay extra fare. You can go on arguing this ad infinitum.

I feel that a reasonable element of cross-subsidisation in regard to the Dublin service is quite acceptable having regard to the enormous expenditure by CIE in the Dublin area, not only on the bus services, but the general headquarters. I grant that this is an arguable matter but I am prepared to leave the present situation as it is. I also indicated earlier—we seem to have endless repetition—that if Deputies study the increase in bus fares over the past four or five years, the increase in the earnings of workers, and the increase in social welfare levels, they will find that the increased bus fares bear some relation. I have not got the figures with me, but if Deputies work it out, they will find they bear some relation, so that it cannot be said that the increases are pressing hard on the people in Dublin.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

May I say that the battle has been worthwhile? The Minister has conceded that the Dublin bus fares are making a magnificent contribution——

Comment on this

A contribution.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

——to CIE so that it can be felt in the sinews of the company in West Cork and every other sinew. That is an immense concession from the Minister.

Comment on this

With regard to the policy of closing lines and curtailing bus services, and where such services have been terminated, has the Minister any power to reconsider the reopening of such lines or services where it can be proved that their closure was to the disadvantage of the community from a social, business and economic point of view? If CIE takes a decision to close a railway line or terminate a bus service is that final and irrevocable?

Comment on this

I already dealt with that matter but possibly not quite in the form in which the Deputy has put it. I admitted that during the operation of the 1958 Act and up to the present Bill I would have the power to amend the Act whereby CIE can close lines without recourse to the Minister but I did not do it because I was satisfied with the general manner in which CIE was acting, and that is perfectly true now. If I had felt that the policy was having serious effects, I would have gone to the Government to say that there must be an emergency amendment of the Act with regard to certain powers. The Board of CIE have my confidence; if I felt they no longer had my confidence, I could request their resignations. So far as I am aware from all the information made available to me, the substitute services provided are satisfactory and I have heard a great deal of praise of the substitute services in certain areas. I believe the general policy of CIE in regard to the closing of railways was intelligent and in line with what was done in other countries.

Comment on this

My concern is that a decision to close a line was implemented by CIE with indecent haste. There was a particular line running from Waterford to Tramore which was the subject of great controversy in this House, in Waterford city and Tramore generally and in south Tipperary and Waterford. CIE knocked down bridges and tore up railway lines within a matter of hours after a decision had been made in this House to close the line. That does not give me the impression that there is any hope of reconsidering the reopening of such services when CIE is permitted to act in such a manner.

Comment on this

The question has been asked of the Minister over the past five or six hours whether or not he has any function in the closing of a railway line and the Minister has been talking about trends in transport in Great Britain and other countries and has probably spoken about trends in transport legislation. The Minister is well aware that in Great Britain, despite the powers which Dr. Beeching appears to have, he has not the last word in the matter of closing railway lines. It will be recollected that within the past 18 months, Dr. Beeching made certain proposals for the closing of railway stations and lines in Great Britain but many of these were vetoed by the Minister of Transport, Mr. Marples. He has the power to veto proposals for closing railway lines and stations.

I should like to know whether the Minister has ever considered taking such a power to himself by way of legislation. After all, he is the custodian of the public welfare in this. As far as the Board of CIE are concerned, whilst they may be charged with acting in accordance with the general interest of the people, they also had the superhuman task of making CIE break even within a period of five years. There has to be a balance between making a service as economic as it can be made and the public welfare in the matter of transport. In Britain, the Minister is the arbitrator, so to speak, in that.

On the section, the Minister will forgive me if I ask him will £2 million be sufficient or will it be eaten up by operating costs? In deciding on an annual grant of £2 million, does the Minister think it will be sufficient to pay for the redundancy that will undoubtedly come about, in view of his statement regarding the building of buses? I am not convinced that it will be enough. There will, of necessity, be increases in wages during the next five years and it appears that this sum will not be adequate.

Comment on this

In reply to the Deputy, we have left in the clause in the 1958 Act which gives power to CIE to close branch lines where the Board consider them to be uneconomic. We have not changed that clause and the section of the Act remains. Secondly, I hope the subsidy will be sufficient. It has been carefully calculated and it includes an element of redundancy compensation measured against economies effected. It is also based on the assumption that there will be increases in wages in the next five years, consonant with the growth in national productivity on the basis of what we hope will be an intelligent calculation.

Comment on this

Did the Minister ever consider or would he care to give an expression of his view with regard to the transport legislation in Britain, whereby the Minister of Transport has power to veto proposals with regard to the closing down of railway lines or railway stations?

Comment on this

I did not suggest to the Government that they should alter the Act. One can look at it quite objectively and one can see that no railway line would ever be closed, if the views of local representatives were to be entertained. There were 528 miles of railways closed down before the 1958 Act ever came into operation. Since then, 620 miles of railway have been closed down, and the main protests against this action in almost every case were made by people who never used the railway lines and never intended to use them. I did not consider there was any point in changing the terms of the 1958 Act for the reason that I approved of what happened between 1958 and 1964.

Comment on this

On the question posed by Deputy Treacy, who asked whether, once an order had been made to close a route, it could be revoked, we all know that when an order is made to close a railway line, it cannot be revoked because the rails are taken up immediately; but so far as a bus route is concerned, it does not entail any capital cost to revoke the order and reopen the route. Do I understand that the Minister will not revoke any decision made by CIE to close a bus route or that CIE will not reconsider the reopening of a closed route? If that is so, then it is useless to make representations to CIE because the decision will not be changed, and the Minister will not interfere.

I think the Minister should consider applications for the reopening of bus routes that have been closed. I agree that CIE acted with indecent haste in taking up railway lines, but so far as the bus routes are concerned, there is no expenditure involved, and I am surprised that the Minister and CIE are not prepared to consider the reopening of bus routes which have been closed.

Comment on this

I have already dealt with this matter at immense length. I have made it clear that I would like to review the whole question of CIE services as a whole over a period of time and in a limited way from year to year, but a transport service could not be operated efficiently if a Minister could stop bus services from closing or if the pressure of views of public representatives could alter a decision of the Board. You cannot run a transport service in that manner. I like to look at the general situation as a whole. There is nothing to stop CIE reopening a bus service which has been closed, if circumstances change.

I have heard nothing here today during the whole of this debate but criticism of the closing of one country bus service. None of the Deputies who have spoken has given credit to CIE for the splendid work they have done in reorganising the bus services throughout the country. There have been no complaints in the areas where the services have been reorganised as a result of intensive market research carried out by CIE. All day there has been nothing but complaints about the closing of the Schull-Goleen service. Whenever a bus service is changed, somebody is going to suffer. You may benefit four people and two people may be aggrieved. I prefer to regard the question in general rather than have CIE administration interfered with week after week and month after month.

Comment on this

Surely it would not be undue interference with the Board of CIE on the part of the Minister if he had the right to approve or disapprove of the discontinuance of a bus service or the closing down of a railway line?

Comment on this

I think the suggestion is hopeless.

Comment on this

The suggestion is not hopeless. Some hundreds of miles of railway line have been taken up over the past five years. The Minister has shown that he is able to take criticism and that he is able to resist the pressure of big deputations. The Minister has responsibility for the provision of transport services and for seeing that CIE provides such services. These are services that have been enjoyed by people over a long number of years. It is not possible that every single railway line or bus route will in itself be an economic venture for CIE, but, as far as we are concerned, we regard it as the function of CIE to provide a public transport service. It is a serious matter for Waterford and Tramore, or for Schull and Goleen, or for County Monaghan when a railway service is discontinued.

Why does the Minister, who has been quoting to us trends of transport all over the world, including Great Britain, not give himself the power to approve or disapprove what appears to be drastic action to the people affected by the closing down of a railway line or the discontinuance of a bus service? He has said that he would not do that because of what is tantamount to his fear of pressure from the public and of criticism by the Dáil. Every Minister is subject to that. Whether they are Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael, they have at times to resist criticism and the pressure of deputations. We agree that the Minister should not engage in undue interference in the day-to-day administration of CIE, or even in minor policy decisions, but it is no minor policy decision when a railway line that has been running between Waterford and Tramore for years is scrapped by what now appears to be an anonymous body, an anonymous body not responsible to anybody.

If John Doe is sacked from CIE, we do not expect the Minister to defend the action of CIE in sacking him. If CIE want to change the colour of the cushions in their carriages, we do not want the Minister to defend that action here, but when 25 miles of railway track which have been used for years and have been giving good service are taken up, it is a serious matter. With all due respect to those who are on the board of CIE, particularly their Chairman, and having regard to their ability as experts in transport, I do not think it should be left merely to their decision. The Minister should have some function in this and should not appear to be— I do not say he is—hiding behind the Board of CIE.

Comment on this

I want to intervene again on this because the Minister spoke about people putting pressure on him, pressure groups, deputations. Deputy Corish may not be aware of this but the Minister for Transport and Power, in his own inimitable fashion, when the Tramore railway was being put on the block refused to receive any deputation.

Comment on this

Tramore railway cannot be closed again.

Comment on this

The Minister made sure it could be neither closed nor opened. There was a right butchering job done by the Minister 24 hours after it closed.

Comment on this

There was enough trouble when it was closed once. The Deputy should not try to close it again.

Comment on this

The Minister will not admit it was the greatest mistake he ever made, and he has made many. This was not a railway that was not used. It was used by 550,000 people in the last year of its existence, seven miles of railway with no intermediate stations and involving very little expenditure. The figures we got at that time from the Minister were not the correct figures. The whole business was done with indecent haste. The Minister has been asked a question now by Deputy Treacy and Deputy Corish and he will not face up to it. He cannot face up to being the protector of the people of Ireland, to being their representative in Dáil Éireann. We had a faceless man again. We do not know who made out this report.

Why should it be left to the decision of a group of men in Dublin that a public amenity railway down the country is to be destroyed? This public amenity from the city I represent to Tramore was destroyed. It was a great loss to the ordinary working class people, to their wives and children. They do not travel on the miserable bus service with which the Minister replaced it. The Minister gave an undertaking here and his predecessor gave an undertaking when the 1958 Act was going through that any service they would destroy—and I use the word "destroy" deliberately — they would replace with an equal service. The Minister knows he has not done that. I want to lay at the door of the faceless men in Kingsbridge the disgraceful vandalism they carried out there. They went into the station house in Tramore and smashed the public convenience. This was not done by juvenile delinquents. It was smashed up by CIE. At great public expense, they made a bus terminus and there was no public convenience there. Then they said to the town commissioners in Tramore that it was their business to provide that. They wanted to have it charged to the ratepayers.

I warned this House when we were trying to reach the Minister that if they destroyed this railway, the Irish taxpayers would be mulcted in large sums of money out of the Road Fund. We were told the Tramore railway was losing £3,000 or so a year. A sum of £52,000 has been spent already in Road Fund grants to make up for the depredation of the Minister for Transport and Power. I know in the Minister's county there is £75,000 a year. That is a figure alone but it does show how the taxpayer is being mulcted in other ways. It is not true that the Minister had to suffer any pressure about the railways. He refused to receive a deputation. I think in the end the Corkmen overpowered him and, when it came to Youghal railway, he received a deputation.

Comment on this

The Deputy ought not to mention anything about a deputation in connection with the Youghal railway. It could be embarrassing.

Comment on this

I know what happened there. He received a deputation and I can assure the Minister that, if he had received a deputation from my constituency, he would not have been embarrassed as much because we are reasonable people.

Comment on this

I never received a deputation.

Comment on this

In any case the Minister did not tear up the railway line from Cork to Youghal, and as long as I am coming into this House, I shall throw that at the Minister. He has not the decency to say that he, with the faceless men, made a mistake.

Comment on this

To suggest that Dr. Andrews has not got a face is going a bit far.

Comment on this

He has not a face as far as I am concerned.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Acting Chairman (Mr. P. O'Donnell) Fine Gael

Personalities should be left out of this debate.

Comment on this

I did not mention the name.

Comment on this

I merely mentioned it in the most humorous way in order to lighten the tenor of the debate.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The facial expressions of Dr. Andrews are not relevant.

Comment on this

I did not intend to say anything about Dr. Andrews. As far as Dr. Andrews and Tramore railway are concerned, he did not receive the deputation, which was eventually received by officers in Kingsbridge. In my opinion, the officers there were in outer space as far as the Tramore railway was concerned. I have been putting down questions to the Minister as to what was the profit or loss on the bus service to Tramore, and he refused to answer me. I know from the Pacemaker Report that he has that figure but he refuses to give it. He is losing far more on the bus service to Tramore than the railway company was losing. If he had been influenced by the local people who knew their business, it could have been made pay in a year. We were very reasonable about that. We put that proposition to the people in Kingsbridge, that some of the old policies of the Tramore railway should be continued for one year and if it did not pay, they could dig up the railway. They closed it the following Saturday and paid men overtime on Monday to dig it up in the rain. Every time I get an opportunity I shall keep on saying that to the Minister.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Perhaps the Deputy will get an opportunity on another occasion.

Comment on this

Will the Minister explain the liabilities which section 7 covers?

Comment on this

This section writes off the advances made to CIE which represent, generally speaking, the difference between the annual fixed subsidy they were given each year and the actual expenditure.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say if compensation to employees who are redundant will be provided out of that £1 million?

Comment on this

No. The compensation for redundancy was treated under a separate heading in the Department's Estimate.

Comment on this

When did the Minister learn that it was essential to give this money to CIE or that this particular liability must be written off? When did this come to his notice or when was the decision made?

Comment on this

It came to my notice in connection with the working out of the CIE accounts over the five years. They were granted £1,175,000 in each of five years and in addition, they required £1 million to carry on the undertaking.

Comment on this

This did not arise from the payment of redundancy compensation?

Comment on this

No. They borrowed this money from the Minister for Finance and now it is written off as a non-returnable grant. It did not include an element of redundancy.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would explain the section?

Comment on this

In future CIE is being financed for capital services by advances from the Central Fund made in accordance with section 4 of the Bill. They had power to issue stock which would have to be approved by the Minister for Finance and guaranteed by him up to the value of £15 million. We have now reduced that figure to £12 million because they will not need that money and they will get their capital in future by way of advances from the Central Fund. They will not need power to issue stock to the value of £15 million.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Amendments Nos. 10 and 11 appear to be related to amendment No. 15 and it may, therefore, be appropriate to take amendments Nos. 10, 11 and 15 together.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 4, line 15, after "waterway" to insert "or by road".

I take it that amendment No. 15 is for the purpose of bringing road employees within the ambit of the redundancy compensation provision and that is the object of the amendments in the names of Deputy Byrne and myself. The Bill, as submitted by the Minister, would allow compensation for employees of CIE who lose their employment or who are disturbed by reason of any withdrawal of transport services by rail or inland waterways or having substituted diesel for steam traction or of the making of an order under section 9 of the Act of 1958 in relation to a specified level-crossing.

What we seek to do here is to have these redundancy provisions applicable to CIE employees engaged on road services. The kind of case we have in mind is likely to arise where road services are discontinued or are reduced, and from what we have heard in the past few hours, apparently this is occurring in different parts of the country. We are also aware of the great difficulty which may yet arise with the introduction of the one-man buses. Men who entered into employment in CIE with a reasonable expectation of remaining as conductors for 30 or 40 years may find themselves withdrawn from a particular service because it is converted to one-man bus operation and being asked to move to an entirely different part of the country for the purpose of taking up alternative employment.

A case which has come to my notice in the last few years concerns a man from County Leitrim transferred to Dublin. While in Leitrim, this man was fortunate enough to have a comfortable house and a garden for a rent of £12 per year. That unfortunate man, since he moved to Dublin with his three children, has to pay £3 10s. for a one-room flat and he has no expectation of getting housing accommodation from Dublin Corporation within the next few years. We are asked to believe he has not had his conditions of service worsened. Previously this man paid less than 5/-a week for his accommodation. Now he is removed from his house and the garden in which he grew his vegetables, transported to Dublin where he has to pay £3 10s. and has no garden or facilities for growing his vegetables. That man has been seriously worsened in his employment. He has been very seriously punished. We believe it would not be unreasonable to provide that such an employee would have the right to elect for the compensation under this Bill or transfer to Dublin because, clearly, the hardship which is now imposed on him and the opportunities which he had in the past and has now forfeited amount to a serious worsening of the man's working conditions.

Another problem we have in mind and which arises from the operation of one-man buses relates to men who for several years have been engaged as conductors on provincial bus services. It is not unfair to say that work as a conductor on a provincial bus service with a limited number of stops is not comparable with work on a double-decker bus in Dublin where the demands on a man's stamina, energy and patience for several hours of the day can be really colossal. Whatever about the chances of a man who enters the conducting service in Dublin on double-decker buses when he is young maintaining sufficient vigour and stamina and thereby being able to operate on such a bus without undue hardship right through to his pensionable age, it is an entirely different problem for a man who has operated on the relatively quiet provincial bus service and then finds himself transferred from that work and put on a double-decker bus in Dublin.

This problem arises in particular for a number of men who for several years were working in Broadstone and whose duties in the summer months were on additional bus services put on during the tourist and holiday season. Their duties during the remainder of the year were to provide relief services for provincial buses, many of which would travel only part of the journey, then turn round, leaving one or two buses to complete the full journey.

Several of these men were asked, on the introduction of one-man buses, to go on double-deck buses in Dublin. They were told they would have no right to elect out of this entirely different type of work or retire with a suitable pension. It may well be that one would not want to leave this election open to all employees, to those who are still vigorous and those who could undertake the new duties without undue hardship. It might be fair to say they should not be allowed the benefit of these compensation provisions but, in the case of a person of mature years, who has cast upon him an additional burden, serious consideration should be given to allowing such a person to avail of the redundancy provisions. That is why we insert here after the sections which allow compensation to be paid to certain employees the words "or by road" or, if any reduction takes place in the services or personnel, compensation may be provided. In case there is any doubt we spell out in greater detail "or having withdrawn conductors from any omnibus service". The purpose of that is to provide for one-man buses, to which I have already referred.

I do not know whether the Minister is in a position to give any figures here—he may well have them but will not give them—but I understand there is an increasing number of heart conditions amongst bus employees. That is definitely so in the case of drivers. Many men who enjoyed good health on the Dublin tramway service find that, operating the double-deck buses, they have developed heart conditions at a relatively early age. From my own experience of the Dublin tramway service, which was terminated, I think, twelve and fifteen years ago respectively, many of these men deteriorated in health when they went on the buses. Men of fine physique and stamina, with pleasant personalities, when operating the trams, developed all kinds of physical complaints and became quite irritable as a result of operating buses. In these circumstances I do not think it is unreasonable that, since we are providing compensation for certain employees, some choice should be given to these men who find themselves in their maturer years with the threat of dismissal hanging over them, without compensation, or else undertaking duties for which they are not suited.

Comment on this

I think I made quite clear our reasons for excluding certain categories of workers from compensation on redundancy on the Second Stage. It was made quite clear by the Taoiseach on the 1958 Transport Bill that the redundancy provisions were to be regarded as purely temporary. They were designed for a five-year period only. They were put into the Bill in order to enable CIE to carry out its first programme of reorganisation quickly and to the satisfaction of the workers concerned. The rates of compensation by any standard, at home or abroad, were extremely generous, and the House knows that.

We felt we should continue the redundancy and compensation provisions in so far as CIE are concerned by specifying the amounts on the same basis as the 1958 Act, with one or two minor changes but that, in connection with road services, in view of the general buoyant character of the road services of CIE, there should be no specific provision for compensation and CIE would negotiate with the trade unions whatever kind of agreement they could secure. That seems to me to be quite reasonable. CIE have an agreement with the union in regard to the one-man buses and part of that agreement includes a section which stipulates that no man in regular employment will be required to transfer outside his depot area in consequence of the introduction of one-man bus operation. That is a specific answer to many of the observations of Deputy Ryan. CIE cannot break that agreement with the union unless they negotiate changes of terms. It is up to the union to deal with this matter.

Comment on this

Did that compensation arrangement not cease as from 31st March last?

Comment on this

What the provision said was that, after expiry of the compensation provisions of the 1958 Transport Act on 31st March, 1964, no driver or conductor in regular employment, as defined in paragraph (1), will be disemployed in the road passenger section as a result of one-man bus operation, nor will such driver or conductor be required to transfer outside of his depot area or to work in any alternative post outside the road passenger section. If new statutory compensation provisions are introduced after 31st March, 1964, they will apply to staff declared redundant in consequence of the further extension of one-man bus operation. That is the position. It is quite clear.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

Why did we not provide that in the Bill?

Comment on this

Because the Government felt that the character of the employment in relation to road services was not the same as the character of the employment in relation to rail services. Road services were tending to expand rather than contract. CIE are constantly taking on new conductors and drivers and the Government felt it should be possible for CIE to re-negotiate terms for severance payment and conditions of transfer. It is a matter for CIE and the trade union.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I can readily appreciate the desirability of leaving all these matters for negotiation between the company and the trade unions, but there are many problems which arise which just do not permit of things being left on that type of indefinite footing. The Minister has put in obligatory statutory provisions here in relation to some employees. I cannot understand why he should discriminate as between different types of employees. It would be much better, I think, to put them all in. There are some anachronisms which do not readily appear. I have dealt with the problem of the man who had been working for years on a provincial bus service operating out of Dublin, living in Dublin and based on the Broadstone Depot. To transfer that man from a long route provincial bus service down to some Dublin garage, out of which double-deck buses operate from six in the morning until after midnight, is to change his occupation entirely.

Comment on this

No such transfer has taken place. The Deputy must be misinformed.

Comment on this
Mr. Ryan

I shall be only too glad to discuss the matter with the men in the Broadstone. I have some information, and I do not disbelieve them. If that has not taken place, then it must have been threatened.

There are other problems. Seniority rights may be jeopardised. My information is that the Broadstone provincial bus depot has its own seniority list over the years. The Dublin city bus services have a separate seniority list. Men leaving the Broadstone and going to the Dublin garages forfeit their right of seniority. There are apparently all kinds of perquisites attached to seniority and it could be a serious reduction in a man's status to have such a change imposed on him. My information is—if it is wrong, I shall be glad to have it corrected—that there are certain fringe benefits sometimes attached to the provincial bus services, particularly in relation to the summer tourist traffic, which obviously would not be available in the bustle and tumble of the daily services in Dublin.

All these are matters the men would have a right to decide on. I am forestalled to some extent by the fact that members of the Labour Party, some of whom are trade union officers, have tabled a Bill which to some extent incorporates the same idea. This does not spell out in the same way as the rail provisions do all the benefits to be available for these workers. We should not have the matter in doubt, as it would be even during trade union negotiations with CIE.

Comment on this

I am not quite clear what the Minister has been trying to convey to the House. We put down this amendment to try to ensure that those who may be rendered redundant will be looked after. As far as I am aware, redundancy compensation ceased after 31st March this year for all but railway men. Even in respect of the railway men, redundancy compensation is limited to a case of the withdrawal of a service or where dieselisation is introduced. I am not quite clear from the Minister's reply on the position with regard to the redundancy compensation provision in respect of the operation of the one-man bus service. There was an agreement between CIE and the unions regarding this service, but two-thirds of the provincial routes have yet to go over to one-man operation. I am not satisfied from what the Minister said, and from this section, that there is to be compensation for those who will be rendered redundant by reason of the introduction of one-man buses on the remaining two-thirds of the provincial routes.

The 1958 Act had a section which provided that the Government would supply the money for schemes of redundancy compensation in respect of the CIE workers. There is no such provision in this Bill. I suppose it is safe to assume, therefore, that CIE, with the resources it has, is expected to pay compensation to the limited number defined in this section—the railwaymen rendered redundant by the closing of a service or the introduction of diesel trains. There is no guarantee in this section either that there will be compensation for those engaged in the road passenger service and engaged in the maintenance of road transport. There is no redundancy compensation provision for the clerical workers in road transport. There is no mention of the redundancy that might arise out of a scheme of reorganisation other than what is set out in the Bill. No redundancy compensation is provided for any changes that may be made in workshops by reason of the introduction of work study and all the other new methods being employed not alone in CIE but in other places as well.

The Minister said these were matters to be negotiated by the trade unions with CIE. I have a copy of the agreement made between the trade unions and CIE during the dispute in connection with the one-man buses. I am not satisfied from it, and from the Minister's remarks, that this agreement will be applied to the type of worker I have mentioned. The 1958 Act includes compensation provisions for many types of workers. For that reason, this amendment was tabled by members of the Labour Party to ensure that all those rendered redundant will be compensated in some measure.

CIE never seem to have regard to compensation. They seem to be very indifferent with regard to those who suffer domestic upset. I have known many cases of people who worked in a railway station that was closed being told they could go to some town 25 miles away where there would be a job for them. That may be all right for CIE, but for the man rendered redundant, it is not so easy to resettle his family in a place 20 or 25 miles away. May I give the Minister an example of two men near New Ross town in a district where the railway was closed completely? They sought redundancy compensation but were told they were not entitled to it because there was an offer of employment with CIE in Waterford city. I am sure the Waterford Deputies know the position with regard to housing in Waterford city. I am sure it is hard enough for Waterford people to get houses, but I do not think anybody from the rural area of Wexford seeking a house in Waterford would be welcomed by the Corporation or the city manager.

There have been scores of cases like this all over the country. Those who cannot live 25 miles from their work because they cannot get a house discover they must give up their job altogether. They should be compensated in some way. I do not suggest we should give them a pension on which they might live for the rest of their lives. Such men have been deprived of a job in which they have been for the past 20 years, perhaps. It is difficult for them to take up some other job.

The Minister has said that compensation provisions agreed between CIE and the unions are pretty good. I will not say they are excellent, but in respect of the limited number of compensation provisions made, they appear to be generous. However, there are many cases of redundancy that have not been dealt with at all. It is for that reason we think the Minister should include in the Bill some provision which will require the Board of CIE to compensate workers who have been rendered redundant by reason of the policy operated by the Board of CIE.

Comment on this