Committee on Finance. - Transport Bill, 1964—Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–162 of 332. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 4 of 1964 ›
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 4, line 17, after "crossing" to insert "or having withdrawn conductors from any omnibus service".
Comment on this
I want to say a word about this matter. It came to my attention only this morning when I received a telephone message about people becoming redundant and being transferred.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 11, having been discussed with amendment No. 10, the Deputy may not speak on it now.
Comment on this
The Minister has nothing to do with it. It is a matter for the Chair and the Chair understands that amendments Nos. 10, 11 and 15, being related, were discussed together.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 10 has been defeated and amendment No. 11 may not be discussed because the three were debated together.
Comment on this
Do we take it then that the Minister has no comment to make on the remarks of the Leader of the Labour Party?
Comment on this
Deputy Corish was speaking last night when the House adjourned. How could the Minister make any comment on what he said unless he had read Deputy Corish's mind?
Comment on this
We can discuss it on the section. If the Minister wants the debate held up, we do not mind.
Comment on this
I thought that amendments Nos. 10, 11 and 15 were taken together so that it must have been moved.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants a decision, I can put the question now but there can be no further debate.
Comment on this
I would ask that the question be put so that there will be no doubt that the amendment was moved.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 4, subsection (4), lines 34 to 36, to delete", in the case of a person transferred or seconded under section 14 of the said Great Northern Railway Act, 1958,".
The effect of this amendment is to extend to all CIE employees concerned the provisions of section 17 (3) of the Great Northern Railways Act Which enables the superannuation of employees to be increased where they enter the service after the normal age of entry. It is a corrective arrangement to ensure that all these people will be treated in the same way.
Comment on this
That is what I am afraid of, that the Minister will treat them all in the same way. Some of them are offered jobs 70, 80 and 90 miles away from home. When they went there, they could not get the kind of accommodation they wanted and they had to give up hope of continuing their employment with CIE. It is ridiculous for the Minister to bring men from outlying counties, where they have good cottages and a reasonable standard of living, into Dublin where they have to pay very high rents for flats. According to the information I have, they have to pay up to £4 per week for one room and the use of a kitchenette. It is all right for the Minister to say he wants to treat everybody alike.
Comment on this
I have been listening to the Minister for nearly two years and I cannot break through at all. The Minister never gives an explanation regarding anything, either on the Order Paper or in a question. He never gives a proper answer, never answers what he is asked. He answers another question and goes off on another line.
Comment on this
I should like to hear from the Minister what steps CIE, or the Minister, propose to take to ensure that, when these men become redundant and are transferred, these transfers will be reasonable, and they will not be living 70 and 80 miles away from their place of employment.
Comment on this
The position is that the matter to which the Deputy refers does not arise at all. It has always been a condition of service of CIE on the rail side that men can be transferred from any part of the country to the other. This is the position and it is accepted by the trade unions and the Board of CIE. There has never been any change.
In connection with reorganisation which took place during the past five years, and before that, it should be pointed out that reorganisation takes place at all times at different levels. It has always been clearly understood that employees of CIE are provided with transport from one region to another. Redundancy compensation entered into the picture where, for example, a person is transferred from one area to the other when his position alters. To give an example, if a person were a head ganger in Cork and was transferred to Ballybrophy and there was no position open to him except that of a minor ganger, and he lost certain provisions relating to travel allowance or other perquisities, or fringe benefits, he would be entitled then to compensation in cash. That is a matter which is regulated between the trade unions and the Board. I have no control over it. It would be very wrong for any Minister to enter into such matters. If the person is aggrieved, he goes to the arbitrator appointed under the Act.
Comment on this
I should like to refer to this as it arises frequently in my own constituency. We are all familiar with the problems arising from redundancy. These are very largely human problems. You have a man who is working and living in Clones or Castleblaney. The tradition was that there was no more stable employment in the country than railway employment. Then there came this upheaval of redundancy. Frequently, one finds cases where men in a certain grade had a right to free travel. They had the right to travel on the train to and from their place of work. In the new situation, they find themselves transferred to some other centre of employment and discover that that concession is now withdrawn and they are expected to pay for their tickets.
You have to get the picture in your mind as to what the situation is. From the point of view of an arbitrator, when a man is transferred from Castleblaney to Dundalk, the arbitrator is inclined to ask: "Why do you not go and live in Dundalk?" He is quite oblivious of the fact that a man in middle age to have to transfer his family from Castleblaney to Dundalk means the disruption of the whole pattern of his life. He has no guarantee if he makes that radical change that he will live the rest of his days in Dundalk.
Over and above that, it is a very common thing to find that when a railway worker resides in a small town, or in a town even like Clones or Castleblaney, he has a little shop in which he sells papers, sweets, and so on. If the family home is moved from the centre where the family have built up a business, where their friends and neighbours live and where their children are at school, their whole life is disrupted. When an individual gets caught in the huge machinery of arbitration and the general principles that have been laid down, you find cases where men have got all they are entitled to under the general scheme but where grave hardship remains.
It has often occurred to me that in this process of adjustments which have been rendered necessary by this redundancy situation, it would be a human and rational thing to say, where people in the past had the right to free travel by rail to and from their place of work, that right should remain to them on whatever form of passenger transport CIE is now operating in the area. In Monaghan, there is the extraordinary situation in which all the railways have been torn up. There are no railways there now and nothing but road transport in the whole county. Yet, men are being asked to go from Castleblaney, or from Carrickmacross, to Dundalk to do their day's work. In theory, they could move their home and their family to live in Dundalk; in practice, it is a very great hardship to impose on them.
I wonder if it would not be reasonable and possible to say, even though it is not provided for in the general scheme, that a principle might be accepted whereunder, if people have to travel substantial distances to their day's work, CIE might make available to them transport facilities which, after all, cost the company nothing— the buses are running and are rarely so packed that there is no room for one more man to sit into them—instead of requiring them to pay the return fare every day. I think that if that arrangement were made, a good deal of the hardships that at present afflict individuals could be remedied. But, so long as that amenity is denied, there will be individual cases of hardship throughout the country.
It is difficult to realise, when dealing with a broad question, how heavy a burden these hardships are in individual cases. This is a situation which calls for a human approach. It may not be possible to incorporate into a broad agreement with the trade union movement a scheme which will provide for every human contingency that can arise, but it would be a prudent thing if the Minister would recommend to the Board that wherever difficulties of this character arise they should lean heavily towards conceding this amenity to persons who find themselves in this difficulty, more especially in that it involves no charge on the Board's funds but is merely a permit to use accommodation in a bus that otherwise would be empty.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would be good enough to answer a question I should like to put to him on his amendment. Due to a misunderstanding on my part, I did not get an opportunity of putting the question. Alternative employment was found in two companies in Dundalk for approximately 180 workshop members in 1958.
These people were covered by the previous Act in case redundancy occurred in the two firms they went into. Will they still continue to be covered under the present Act?
Comment on this
I understand that this is a matter for the standing arbitrator. We are not changing the legislation. All the legislation covered by the 1950 and 1958 Acts is being repeated. There are only very small changes.
Comment on this
This is an immensely complex piece of legislation. I understand that what the Deputy asks about is sub judice with the standing arbitrator. He is considering this particular group of cases at the moment.
Comment on this
Will the fact that this Bill goes through, without anything being done, affect the cases?
Comment on this
No, not at all. The arbitrator has the duty of interpreting the Act in respect of these particular persons. The matter is being considered by him at present. There are very considerable delays in regard to his decisions. He found the position extremely complex. He made a lot of decisions recently in regard to employees.
Comment on this
The Minister will say, maybe later on, that he answered the questions he was asked here. But, in his own inimitable style, he is able to distort things so much. He got up there and gently said that employees of CIE were always liable to be transferred. That is, we will say, a kind of a fact. We will regard it as a kind of a half-truth and maybe not even a half-truth. The majority of the people who were transferred in, say, the good days of CIE were transferred on promotion. They were transferred to better conditions, to better pay and to better housing or they would not accept the promotion. There may have been the one or two cases where a man, for disciplinary reasons, was sent to a bog station. Now the Minister is faced with the position that men who have served CIE well, who have good records and who should be in line, maybe, for promotion, are declared redundant and are sent to bog stations, or are told they are to go to bog stations and they surrender and walk out and the Minister, like Pontius Pilate, can wash his hands and say: "I am finished with them, anyway."
In the matter of free transport for the company's employees, I had a famous case that I brought before the Minister. I shall remind him of it again because he forgets very quickly. A man living in Tramore was working in CIE in Waterford. He had a privilege ticket on the Tramore railway for about only 11/- a month. This man did not take home £7 a week at that time. He had not a great job with CIE in Waterford. In spite of the fact that the Minister's predecessor guaranteed that the alternative service would be equal to the one he was doing away with, this man then found that he had to travel by bus to Waterford North, in from Tramore, and that it was costing him three times as much.
These are the kinds of things we have to come up to the House with. When the Minister brings in a Bill, these are the kinds of things we must take the opportunity to speak about here. These are the kinds of things the Minister and his colleagues would criticise and say: "Look at what they are bringing up on a Bill here—this small item of one man." But it is the Minister's fault and I charge him with it. If he had answered the Parliamentary Questions put down to him at that time——
Comment on this
I just said that if the Minister had answered the questions, he would not be sitting here now: he would have his Bill. We must take advantage of occasions such as this to voice these grievances and to point out that there are small people in CIE and in the services over which the Minister has control who have had to suffer much at his hands and who have had to suffer much by reason of the action of his Board and who have had to suffer much because of the Minister's inaction. He did not answer me on this question I asked him.
I asked the Minister what steps he was taking to ensure that persons declared redundant would get jobs equally as good as, or maybe a little better than, the jobs they had. As a matter of fact, the position they should be offered should be a little bit better to compensate for disturbance. I also ask the Minister if he will see to it that men are not offered jobs 70, 80 and 90 miles away — I am repeating this because the Minister did not answer the last question — from where they are based at present.
Comment on this
The Minister did not answer. He told me CIE had the right to transfer any man, but the only people they transferred were transferred on promotion. Usually a man joins as a railway porter in a country station. He might become a signalman and spend the rest of his life there. Those are the people who are liable to be disturbed now. Again the Minister did not answer.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 14 is consequential on amendment No. 13 and perhaps they can be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 4, subsection (6), line 51, to delete "reference in paragraph 4" and to insert "references in paragraph 4 (as amended by this Act)".
These are purely drafting amendments to clarify the intention in the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 4, subsection (6), lines 52 and 53, to delete "a reference" and to substitute "references".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
To add to the section a new subsection as follows:
"The Board or the Company shall extend the provisions of this section to any case in which the services of an officer or servant are dispensed with or he is transferred to another position because of redundancy arising from any scheme for the reorganisation and more economical operation of any department of the undertaking affecting any section or category of workers."
Comment on this
On the question of compensation for those who are redundant, I am concerned with the problem which affects people who are transferred from rural areas to Dublin. The problem is illustrated by the case of a man down the country who has a house and a garden at a rent of £12 a year. He is transferred to Dublin and the only accommodation available to him is a flat at a rent of £3.10, £4 or £5 a week, with no garden, and perhaps only one or two rooms for himself, his wife and two or three children. Quite clearly, if such a man is at an identical point on the wage scale, he suffers a colossal reduction in his living standard if he is removed from a house and garden for which he pays 5/- a week, to a one-roomed flat in Dublin at a rent of £3.10, £3.15 or £4. I am drawing the attention of the Minister to this matter, and I want him to endeavour to persuade the Board of CIE to do the right thing.
My information is that in Inchicore where there is a considerable estate of railway houses, built in the last century — good, solid, stone houses — a number of those houses have been lying idle. Some time ago I was told that five houses were lying idle for a considerable time. It seems outrageous that railway houses should be lying idle when CIE employees are compelled to pay £3.10 or £4 for flats in parts of Dublin when they are transferred from the country.
There was an enlightened social policy in the 19th century when houses were built for railway employees and let on reasonable terms. Perhaps CIE propose to sell them. Whatever their policy is, in the frightful housing situation in Dublin today, they should facilitate their employees and make these houses available by letting them or by selling them. If a man had to borrow 100 per cent of the capital to buy a house, he would pay less in mortgage repayments than he would have to pay for a one-roomed flat. This is a very serious and grievous matter, and the Minister should use whatever influence he has with the Board to see that these vacant houses are made available immediately.
Comment on this
What I have done in this connection is to encourage all State companies to have the most up-to-date and perfect communications for their workers, not only in the form of the usual trade union relationship, but through the trade union relationship to have matters of human and technical interest discussed at all levels. I pointed out the very urgent necessity, even though it may take some considerable time, of breaking down the sort of invisible wall that exists because of historic circumstances in that regard. CIE has established a great number of social industrial councils throughout the country which meet at regular intervals, at which workers can bring before the management side not only such matters as upgrading or down-grading, rosters of work during different periods of the day, matters relating to the progress of CIE, and productivity, but also human conditions. The question raised by Deputy Ryan could probably be dealt with by the joint industrial councils. The less I, or any Minister in charge, intervene while this process is continuing the better. Of course, if I felt it was a matter of general interest, in the sense that the trade unions were failing fundamentally in some aspect, I would reconsider the matter, but I have no information which would lead me to believe that the trade union organisations in CIE are not capable of dealing with such matters.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say how it is that five houses have been lying idle? To my knowledge, one house has been lying idle for a couple of years and my information is that five have been lying idle. Whatever the reason may be, it is quite clear that the proper steps are not being taken to make them available. I do not think this is a trivial or a light matter. I agree with the Minister that it would be better to have the negotiations outside the parliamentary or the executive level. It is a crime against humanity to have houses lying idle in Dublin, and the crime becomes grievous when CIE will not make its houses available to its employees on transfer from the country.
Comment on this
The Deputy has raised a matter of interest and I shall have it inquired into. I am certain there must be an explanation. I find it hard to believe that there were not special reasons why these houses are not occupied. No organisation is perfect. I am certain there must be a reason. I will find out about these houses and communicate with the Deputy.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 5, line 4, after "arrangement" to insert "the whole or part of".
This again is purely a drafting amendment to make quite sure that there is consistency in the approach to redundancy compensation.
Comment on this
The section deals with the development of land by the Board. This section is the cause of and to the whole CIE setup. It says that the Board may retain any part of their land. I have no objection to the Board taking steps to develop any land they own or to the Board acquiring land in the discharge of their proper duties. The point I am interested in is how Deputies are to know about these things. They could not be defined as day-to-day administration. For instance, CIE owns land in Dublin. That land is valuable and CIE might decide to use it for purposes to which people would of necessity object. In Dún Laoghaire, CIE went into the East Pier.
Comment on this
The Board of Works are responsible for Dún Laoghaire Pier. The question has nothing to do with this Bill.
Comment on this
There are large strips of land, once used for railway purposes, running through this city. The disposal of this land could not be regarded as a matter of day-to-day administration. It might be year-to-year administration and we should have some method of ascertaining in advance what CIE intends doing with it. What usually happens is that we read in the morning papers about protests by large numbers of citizens in Dublin, Cork, Limerick, Waterford or some other built-up area where these lands would be very valuable. This brings us back to the old bone of contention: how are Deputies to know? Would the Minister again promise us he will be prepared to give us information if we ask him for it, or is this to be another blank cheque to CIE?
Comment on this
That depends on the attitude of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in relation to legislation. I am willing, and it will be my duty, to give to the House a description of what the general policy of CIE is in relation to land disposition. There is nothing contentious in it at all. Under existing legislation, when CIE abandon railway land, they can dispose of it by private treaty to adjoining land owners. That is purely a private matter between CIE and land owners concerned, and unless there is multiple abuse of a national character, it would be a delegated power to CIE.
CIE may dispose of land to local authorities, public utility undertakings or any tenant on either side of the line, or by private treaty to the Commissioners of Public Works or the Land Commission. Any other land they have to dispose of must be put up for public auction. There are regulations in regard to the abandonment of a railway and the disposal of the land and any effect it may have on the maintenance of drainage or fencing. I have answered questions on this matter in the Dáil and if Deputies want the information, they can examine the Dáil reports.
In connection with land in Dublin, Dublin Corporation would be interested, I feel certain, in relation, particularly, to the Planning Act of 1963. Obviously CIE could not auction land publicly, or would they undertake any private transaction in regard to the sale of valuable extensive lands in Dublin where it would have such a vital bearing on town planning without consulting the planning authority. Deputies can be convinced that under the new or even the old Planning Act, there would be a very definite interest in the user of any such land.
Comment on this
The Minister has given one of the answers I wanted. What about development CIE might decide to do themselves? CIE could decide to put up some objectionable structure in Dublin.
Comment on this
When the Planning Act was going through the House, objections were made here by Deputies because State companies were exempted in many cases.
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy will realise that town planning does not come within the ambit of this Bill. The question of whether the 1963 Planning Act is defective does not come within the ambit of this legislation.
Comment on this
I agree, but does the Minister not see the danger? All I am seeking is an assurance that information will be made available to us.
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that if CIE decide to build a monument to him on the Waterford Tramore railway line, I shall let him know in good time.
Comment on this
Or build a scaffold and hang from it an effigy of the Minister for Transport and Power.
Comment on this
The Minister brought it up himself. It must be very much on his conscience. If the Minister had been a little more tolerant, if he had made available information sought by Deputies in the past, much of the taxpayers' money would have been saved and there would have been better relations between CIE and the public.
Comment on this
The Deputy is getting away from the section. It deals solely with the development of land by the Board.
Comment on this
Is that not what I am talking about? If the Board here in Dublin decide to build some sort of structure at the back of a number of valuable houses, how are we to learn about it and what can we do about it if people approach us? It will be noticed that I spoke of "proposed development". We are never able to get any information until we read about things in the newspapers and then the matter is a fait accompli. This subsection states:
(2) The Board may, in particular—
(a) retain any part of its land which is not required by it for the discharge of its duties and develop it for use by other persons, and
(b) where the use of its land for the discharge of its duties can be combined with its use for other purposes, develop the land by constructing or adapting buildings for use wholly or partly by other persons,
with a view to selling, letting or otherwise disposing of any right or interest in the land or any part of the land after the development is carried out.
Comment on this
The Deputy is merely holding up the business of the House. I made it perfectly clear to him that all this is provided for in the Planning Act of 1963. Whatever powers State companies may have, they will certainly have to have regard to what the planning authority says. I do not propose to alter the pattern of this Bill in regard to that matter. I believe CIE to be a responsible body. I doubt if it would erect some monstrosity in the middle of a residential area. I think that argument is patently absurd.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks CIE would not be capable of doing it. They are only human. CIE made mistakes before and could make mistakes again. The purpose of this House is to keep it on its own rails, if we can.
Comment on this
If it will satisfy the Deputy, I can say that in relation to anything in the nature of a scandalous act that came to the notice of the Deputy, and was the subject of a Parliamentary Question, that question would, of course, be answered, and I have made that clear.
Comment on this
If I put down a simple query, asking the Minister is it the intention of CIE to do such and such a thing with such lands——
Comment on this
We went over all that last night for seven hours. If the Deputy reads the script, he will get, I think, the fourth complete description of my position in regard to this matter. The Deputy just disagrees with me.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not convert me, though he talk from now until two o'clock. What I said stands and, no matter what the Deputy says today, I will not change my opinion.
Comment on this
Now, is that not extraordinary? I was reading a poem last night and this came into it: "A sermon on hell's pains may start him; you may convince but not convert him". I think the Minister's attitude is most unreasonable. I put a reasonable request to him: if valuable land belonging to CIE is to be developed— the proposed development might only come to my ears or to the ears of some other Deputy by accident; the development might be and probably would be perfectly all right—why should we not be told? Why should it be kept a secret?
Comment on this
The Deputy has said that on at least three occasions. He must cease repeating himself.
Comment on this
I am informed now— I was not absolutely certain earlier— that CIE definitely come within the ambit of the 1963 Act. CIE is not a State Department and it is therefore under the control of the 1963 Planning Act. As far as I am concerned, there is no more to be said about it.
Comment on this
In answer to Deputy Kyne, the Minister sent him to arbitration. In answer to Deputy Ryan, he sent him to some other body. Now he is sending me to the planning authority. All I am saying to the Minister is—it is perfectly reasonable —that, if any Deputy is informed that CIE is about to do some kind of development on land in the centre of the city, and nobody knows what kind the development will be——
Comment on this
As I said, it will probably be the right kind of development, but why should we not know? Why should there be such a secret about it? Would it not be better for the Minister to say in such a case that he is prepared to tell the House what CIE intends to do. Down through the years, the selling and letting of lands and property held by CIE has always been done by public auction. Sometimes, of course, CIE uses its powers to put on a squeeze. I have in mind a man who disposed of a good deal of property for CIE over the years, a man who acted as their estate agent over a big area, settling many of their claims, and settling them well. In a case where a man claimed £200 for the loss of hay which, he alleged, had been destoyed by sparks from the engine, the claim was settled for £10.
Comment on this
What does arise is the fact that CIE will put on the squeeze where development and the disposing of their lands are concerned. I have just said that a man was engaged in disposing of land for them for years over a large area. I was the man. I got the squeeze. They can keep their agency. They thought that by taking it from me they could muzzle me. Is that the proper line for a State body to take? Maybe the Minister will stand over his Board. From the day I started objecting here to the action of CIE in relation to certain matters in my constituency, I was cut off. I heard an official of CIE say at a function—I did not want to take advantage of it at the time because there were quite a few people around—"Well, of course you said such a thing about the Board and the company." That shows the advantages the Minister's officers can take. That is the advantage they will have in the development or sale of their lands. They can indulge in Tammany Hall tactics. They can put on the squeeze on anybody they have in their employment or on anyone they may employ as their agent.
For the last time, if it becomes known in this city, for instance, or in any built up area in which CIE hold valuable pieces of land, that development is about to take place on that land—I do not say it would not be the right kind of development—will it be possible for Deputies to get information from the Minister with regard to that proposed development? There is the question I am asking the Minister. Will the Minister answer that question?
Comment on this
A specific question was asked. If the Board of CIE contemplate the development of a parcel of land——
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister has misunderstood the question. As I understand the query, it is this. If it comes to the knowledge of the public or of a public representative that development of a parcel of land in the ownership of CIE is contemplated, is this a matter on which a question can be addressed to the Minister for Transport and Power in this House, on the understanding that the information will be forthcoming by way of question and answer? The Minister may say no, that that is a matter for the Board to which the Deputy should address himself, or the Minister may say yes. But surely it is a legitimate question and one to which we are entitled to expect a categorical answer. It is a very simple one.
Comment on this
I already made quite clear yesterday, in the course of a lengthy debate, the general attitude I hold in regard to the delegation of authority to CIE. Deputies will be able to read my observations and also two very complete statements I made on previous occasions. The answer to the Deputy is covered by those statements.
Comment on this
If it is covered, is it not the very quintessence of Committee debate that, if there is any ambiguity in any Deputy's mind and he formulates a categorical question in respect of a restricted matter which may have been covered by the wide statement of the Minister and says in regard to this restricted matter that this is a Parliamentary Question being addressed to the Minister, as distinct from the Board, we can look forward to a reply? The Minister may say: "In my statement yesterday and on previous occasions, I made it clear this is not a matter on which the Minister would be prepared to give the information wanted". Is it not, however, reasonable to ask for that information? Parliamentary debate becomes extremely difficult if the Minister simply says: "I have said all I intend to say and I will not answer your question".
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister this? As I know the position, it is freely admitted that CIE is losing money and is likely to continue to do so. If CIE decides to develop a certain area and I get representations from people in which it is pointed out to me that it is an uneconomical proposition, or I get further representation from people who say the structure they are going to erect will be a public nuisance to the residents in the area, my only function as a parliamentary representative is to come into Dáil Éireann and place those facts before the Minister. I am citing those as two particular instances in the abstract of what might occur.
What is my position then? Am I to put down a question telling the Minister I consider CIE are developing such-and-such an area and I am informed they are creating a public nuisance by so doing, or can I say from what I have been told I consider what they are doing is an uneconomical proposition and that they will lose more money for the State? I conceive our duty as parliamentary representatives is to see that public money is expended to the best purpose. Those are two clear-cut cases in which I might come to Dáil Éireann and feel constrained to ask those questions, not only on behalf of my constituents but in the national interest.
Would the Minister kindly indicate if he would answer those questions or refer me back to the Board? If I am referred back to the Board and if the Board have taken a decision to do whatever it is, they are not likely to take the slightest notice of me. That is an accepted fact. If the Board make up their minds to do something, they will do it. The only "comeback" there is for a public representative is to ask a question. It seems to me to be eminently reasonable that the Minister should accept such a question and answer it. That would hardly be day-to-day administration, but would seem to be an overall policy decision by the company subject to parliamentary endorsement.
Comment on this
It is a most complicated question to answer. I have already answered it in great detail. The question of whether questions are to be answered is a matter for the Ceann Comhairle. It is impossible to answer a hypothetical question of this kind. In regard to this piece of hypothetical land the Deputy speaks of, the edifice on it might be ugly and undesirable. In that case he should go to the Wexford County Council under the Planning Act, 1963. In so far as he believes that CIE, by developing a piece of land, is further increasing its losses, if he asks a question and the Ceann Comhairle feels it is quite clearly a matter of day-to-day administration, it would still lie within my responsibility to find out for myself whether such an accusation was true.
I indicated clearly and at great length how we deal with complaints coming to us, not only from questions that may be ruled out of order as matters of day-to-day administration, but letters that come to the office in regard to CIE and other companies. If it is an entirely trivial matter, we send a letter to the State company involved and simply ask them to reply directly. If it is a matter that seems of more importance, we ask the State company for their reply to the question. We keep files of these letters to see if there is any trend in regard to matters which, individually, might not be of any importance but which, collectively, would be of importance in so far as the proper running of the company was concerned, for example, if we had a great number of complaints about overbooking on Aer Lingus planes over a short period, or if we had a number of complaints of the kind mentioned by the Deputy, where people seem to think that all over the country CIE were planning development of a kind that simply could not be economic.
I have to look at this thing pragmatically. It has been looked at pragmatically by successive Governments. It is impossible to make absolute rules. I think I can satisfy the Deputy in this way. If I felt on the face of it that this looked like something which required investigation, I would certainly investigate. I think I made a perfectly fair statement anybody in the House could understand.
Comment on this
The Minister has still not answered the question I put to him. What I asked him was: if a Deputy were approached and told that CIE was about to develop lands—I have not said whether this development was a wrong kind of development that could be stopped by the Planning Act of 1963—have we any right or any way of getting information regarding that land? Can we come into this House and ask the Minister if it is the intention of CIE to develop the land in such a place or to develop the land behind such a street? That is not a matter of day-to-day administration. There are sections of land in the centre of this city which are owned by CIE and they should be worth £100,000 or £200,000. This would be a matter where a decision has to be made by the Board. CIE might not have any intention of doing anything about the land. Have we any way of finding out what the Board are about to do?
Comment on this
The Minister comes in here asking us to vote money for CIE and we are entitled to know what CIE intends to do about some lands which it owns. I do not intend to let the Minister go lightly out of the House today and go off to Kingsbridge with £2 million in his pocket. He could come in next month and we would be ruled out of order if we asked a question and told it is not the Minister's function. This is a very simple thing. If a Deputy asks a question about whether CIE intend to develop land in such a place, he should get an answer.
Comment on this
We are innocent people and we do not know what day-to-day administration is. I asked the Minister a question some time ago about buses—it was a matter of about £900,000—and I was told it was day-to-day administration and the question was disallowed.
Comment on this
It is a very strange thing that it is only in the Minister's Department that this happens. I do not know whether the Ceann Comhairle consults with the Minister's officers or the Minister but if we ask any other Minister a question like this, we can be told the answer. The Minister has just said if he considers it is not a day-to-day matter, he will answer the question. If any Deputy asks him a question about whether there will be development on land owned by CIE in Dublin which may be worth £50,000, £60,000, £100,000 or £200,000, will he get an answer?
Comment on this
The Deputy should know there are all sorts of difficult problems in regard to property disposal. The answer to the question is that some people might make very large profits if they knew that adjoining land in their area was to be developed. I cannot answer a Parliamentary Question about something like this when arrangements have not been completed. I could be making a fortune for a lot of people out of their property. The Deputy would be the first person to say I was acting in an improper manner or making profit for those people. The Deputy knows all about leases of property. I would lack all reasonable propriety if I disclosed information before final arrangements had been made. The Deputy must leave it to my commonsense and the decision of the Ceann Comhairle on questions of this sort.
Comment on this
The Minister wants to keep secret what this development might be so that nobody in the area would be able to make anything out of their own property. Would it not be better to let people living on land in the area know about it rather than to have some slickers getting information and making a profit out of it? That is the danger in this. The property owners around an area which is to be developed should be able to make money out of their own property instead of letting the slickers come in and do so. The Minister should not be allowed to go on in this cloak and dagger fashion. We know all about the ruling of the Chair. If there is to be a development here in Dublin on CIE land, there is only one way to do it. If CIE want to purchase another piece of land alongside it, let them do it but it should be possible then, and it would be to the Minister's advantage, for any Deputy to come in here to the House and ask the Minister if there is any intention to develop this land. The Minister could get up and say that there was going to be development in that area and the people whose property had appreciated by the fact that the development was going to take place would know where they stood.
The Minister wants to keep us in the dark. I do not say a leakage would occur through the Minister because I do not think he is that kind of man, but the leakage could occur and some slicker could come in and get the land. It would be better for the Minister to say here and now if there is any question regarding development by CIE and what the development will be.
Comment on this
I am not a lawyer. If it will satisfy the Deputy and he allows this Bill to proceed, when we come to Report Stage I shall ascertain what is the proper course in this matter particularly from the legal standpoint. The Deputy has raised a very important question. Under the Town Planning Act when developments on land are to take place, the plans must be deposited with the local authority. My belief at the moment is that it would be most improper for me to disclose any intention of CIE regarding the development of land. It would not be proper for me to do so unless I had no confidence in the Board regarding this matter. As I said, when we come to Report Stage, I shall make references regarding the dispositions of CIE property. I shall let the Deputies know what would be the right and proper thing on Report Stage regarding this question.
Deputy Dillon rose.
Comment on this
This is Committee Stage and we have had very wide scope for debate, but I think it is in the interest of the House that the Chair should see to it that progress is made. If progress is being impeded by needless repetition, it is the function and the privilege of the Chair to say so.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the Deputy. I am referring to the general debate on section 11. I am quite confident there is needless repetition.
Comment on this
It is not necessary that I should name anybody. It is a general trend and that is the impression I have got in the Chair. I am only anxious that the business of the House should proceed and in that regard I have pointed out that there is too much repetition, that repetition is disorderly and that it is the function of the Chair to say so. I am not referring to the Deputy.
Comment on this
It would be an astonishing proposition if the Chair ended a debate in Committee just because he got tired of it.
Comment on this
This particular problem really stems from the difficulty that exists because of the want of satisfactory machinery for review by the Oireachtas of the activities of publicly-owned companies.
Comment on this
Surely the purpose of a Committee debate is to review so predominantly important a question. If we had machinery such as an ordinary commercial company has which would provide an annual review by the shareholders or their representatives, at which the directors of a public company can be called on to account for their stewardship, many of these problems about getting information would not arise. Public representatives would be content to raise these matters at the annual review and to discuss them there. We do that in respect of every Department of State. We delegate to the Public Accounts Committee the responsibility of calling on the accounting officer of each Department and we get from him all the information we want. That Committee have power to send for people and documents and it is noticeable that the Chairman of that Committee is always a member of the Opposition.
No analogous machinery exists with regard to public companies. When we reach the stage at which we are being asked to vote a very large sum of money annually for the next five years and find that we are asked to agree to this provision:
The Board shall have power to develop its land either alone or in conjunction with another person in such a manner as it may think fit,
it is necessary for the House to insist that this power which it is proposed to give to the Board be controlled by the ordinary parliamentary machinery of question and answer.
I freely concede that this problem of providing machinery for control of public companies has been considered by previous Fianna Fáil Governments, by the inter-party Governments, probably by the present Fianna Fáil Government, by the British Government and by the Governments of various other countries. Nobody has found an entirely satisfactory solution to it and this is a dilemma with which we are not alone in wrestling. I suggest to the Minister that the objectionable and evil words in this section are "in such manner as it may think fit". Those words mean a declaration on behalf of the Oireachtas that we withdraw from Dáil Éireann any power of interrogation in regard to matters that fall within this section. It would then fall for the Minister to say that this was a matter to be determined by the Ceann Comhairle. The Ceann Comhairle looks at the terms of the statutes passed by this Oireachtas and he determines in the light of those and in the light of Standing Orders what is relevant and what is irrelevant.
I suggest that the words in line 29 "in such manner as it may think fit" are a virtual declaration by the Oireachtas that this is a matter absolutely in the discretion of the Board and therefore would not be open to parliamentary debate and that out of those words the ruling would come from the Ceann Comhairle that questions arising in relation to matters in section 11 of the Transport Act of 1963 were specifically excluded from the discretion of the Ministers and therefore were not to be the subject of question and reply in Parliament.
The Minister says he will examine the whole matter of answering questions in regard to the development of land. What I suggest to him is that when he is making that examination, he might consider the appropriateness of deleting from subsection (1) of section 11 the words "in such manner as it may think fit". If he does that it will operate to bring matters relative to the development of the land, either alone or in conjunction with another person, within the ambit of a Parliamentary Question and it would meet the point raised by Deputy Lynch.
The Minister is mistaken if he does not realise that there is a growing atmosphere of public uneasiness about the difficulty of getting information in regard to public companies. I think an analogy can be drawn. I do not think I have ever heard a question addressed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce when he was responsible for the ESB that was not answered. The Minister frequently went through the form of saying "I have inquired from the ESB and they have given me the following information", but I do not ever remember him saying that this is a matter within the discretion of the ESB and therefore I decline to answer the question.
I put this question to the Minister: Does he ever recollect answering a question here in regard to the ESB in the same terms as he feels it incumbent upon him to answer a variety of questions in regard to the public transport company? I suggest to him if he will make a comparison, he will realise how legitimately concerned we are about the apparent reluctance of the Minister to furnish information in regard to the public transport company.
I believe if the Minister became less sensitive on this score and more communicative to the House, he would very readily find that if Deputies habitually addressed inappropriate questions to him as to why one of the servants of the company was transferred from one station to another, the feeling of the House would quickly correct that. Instead of finding a constant atmosphere of irritation and frustration, he would discover that Deputies, who abused the right to raise matters appropriate to Parliamentary Questions and Answer, and that Deputies who continued to raise matters which are manifestly inappropriate to this form of inquiry, would lose the sympathy of the House and the Minister would find the House would swing to his side and support him in all rational attitudes. There is no doubt that he has allowed the situation in regard to the affairs of CIE to grow on him which has created a particularly undesirable atmosphere.
There are many decisions by the Board of CIE with which I disagree. As I have said on a previous occasion, I regard the Chairman of CIE as a man who threw up a relatively easy job to take up a very difficult one, whether I agree or not with him. I have no doubt he is doing his best according to his own lights. I have no reason to believe that the Minister and the Board of CIE are not doing their best according to their own lights. I am fairly certain if the Minister became less sensitive in this matter and took us more into his confidence, he would find the whole problem greatly simplified. I suggest he might consider taking the first step to that end between now and Report Stage by deleting the words "as it may think fit", and thereafter the rulings of the Chair as covered by section 11 would approximate very closely to what all Deputies desire.
The Minister would find himself under no greater difficulty in answering questions about CIE than he, or his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, have found themselves in answering questions relative to the ESB. That would be a development which would be eminently desirable and which would greatly expedite the dispatch of public business in this House, if it came about.
Comment on this
The Deputy did nothing whatever about this when he was Minister.
Comment on this
I should like to think that Deputy Ó Briain would greatly stimulate the debate. When I was in office, complaints of this kind did not arise. In fact, if Deputy Ó Briain will examine the record, I doubt that he will find a single place in which questions were asked relative to the affairs of CIE that were not fully answered at that time. This is an entirely new development.
Comment on this
I should like to say that is not so. I have not consciously altered the pattern of answering questions or the general trend in regard to answering questions since I took over my office in the Department of Transport and Power. There has been no change and the attitude of the Chair has not changed. Naturally, more interest is taken now in the affairs of the company over which I have general supervision because supervision is now the responsibility of a separate Department. Previously it was merged with the Department of Industry and Commerce. I have not changed in regard to this matter.
In reply to Deputy Dillon, I should like to say he has put the whole case in regard to State companies very succinctly and I agree with him there has always been controversy over this. At this stage, I would simply say that I think he should read what I have already said about this matter. It would be unnecessary for me to repeat what I have spoken of in great detail.
In regard to this section, I do not believe the alterations suggested by the Deputy would make any difference. I think the matter of answering questions under this section would be covered by the general provisions of section 16 of the 1950 Act. As I have already said in regard to this section, I shall say more about it on Report Stage and about the very great difficulty that would attend the giving of information ad interim in regard to the use of property by State companies. I might add there are other companies besides CIE that have power to dispose of land and development. I shall speak about that on Report Stage because it goes beyond the question of what is a day-to-day matter. I have already indicated some of the difficulties.
Comment on this
Before we leave this section, I should like to refer to the Minister's remark that he has not changed anything in regard to the information he gives this House.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned it and I want to say it is not true. The Minister answered questions in regard to Aer Lingus on 14th April on the price and specification of aircraft and he refused to answer questions in regard to the price and specification of CIE coaches. You mentioned here, Sir, that you were anxious that the business of the House should proceed. You have accused Deputies here of repetition. I feel guilty of repetition. I had to repeat myself and had to do so continually so that the Minister would get the information and bring it to me on Report Stage. It is the Minister's fault, Sir. We are asking the Minister to do reasonable things. If he would only answer questions and in a simple form instead of going into Acts or referring us to arbitration or conciliation, or referring to the Act of 1963 and if he would say that he would be prepared to answer questions, that would be something.
As far as repetition is concerned, Sir, I am sorry to say that if we get more of the grunts and more of the interruptions we have been getting from the far side, we might take a little longer over this Bill.
Comment on this
It is nice to hear the Deputy over there grunting anyhow, even though we seldom see him.
Comment on this
There is an amendment in the names of Deputies Casey, Corish and other members of the Labour Party. What is involved in this connection also arises on amendments Nos. 21, 23 and 24. A suggestion has been made and I hope it will be agreed that Nos. 17, 21, 23 and 24 be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No.17:
Before section 12 to insert a new section as follows:
"Section 35 of the Act of 1950 is hereby amended by the substitution for subsection (2) of the following subsection:
‘(2) (a) Subject to the provisions of this subsection, entry to the clerical grades of the service of the Board shall be by means of open competitive examinations in accordance with rules made by the Board.
(b) Every open competitive examination held in pursuance of this subsection shall, subject to paragraph (f) of this subsection, be open to all persons who are ordinarily resident in the State or who are Irish citizens or the children of Irish citizens and who pay the fees (if any) and possess the qualifications (if any) as to age, health, character and education prescribed by the rules relating to the examination.
(c) The Board may by special rules provide that such proportion as may be approved by the Minister of the vacancies in the clerical grades of its service shall be filled by means of limited competitive examinations, and where an examination is so limited only persons in or who have been in the employment of a dissolved company within the meaning of the Act of 1944, a dissolved undertaker, the Board or any other transport undertaker whose undertaking has been vested in the Board under this Act or any subsequent Act or the children of such persons shall be admitted thereto.
(d) An open competitive examination shall consist of the following types of test namely:
(i) a written examination;
(ii) an oral examination.
(e) Irish shall be a compulsory subject at every competitive examination under this subsection.
(f) The foregoing provisions of this subsection shall not apply in relation to the entry of staff, for employment in a temporary capacity, to the clerical grades of the service of the Board.
For the purposes of this subsection "temporary" means employment in the nature of holiday or casual relief.'"
This is an amendment the acceptance of which will delete section 12 of the Bill. It can be described as a section which we are asking the House to accept in substitution for the one proposed in the Bill.
This section contains what we regard as a highly objectionable and undesirable innovation in a matter of staff recruitment, in as much as it opens the door quite obviously to all kinds of possibilities in regard to the appointment of staff and the handing out of jobs in CIE. It has long been accepted in this House and in the country generally that the fairest method which can be adopted in recruitment for any position is that of open competitive examination. It is a method which, while not absolutely perfect, at the same time approximates to fairness in so far as it affords the various applicants, no matter from what area of the country they may come, no matter what their background, regardless of whether or not they are related to anybody, an opportunity to enter the competition and if they have the ability and brains, to secure the vacancies. That has always been accepted as the proper way to fill positions, particularly clerical positions, in public companies. Here we have initiated the proposition that this must be changed.
If Deputies will look at subparagraph (d) of section 12, they will see that it reads as follows:
A competition shall consist of such one or more of the following types of test as the Board may specify in the rules relating to the competition, namely:
(i) a written examination;
(ii) an oral examination;
(iii) an interview;
(iv) any other test or tests that the Board considers to be appropriate.
There are a lot of consequential qualifications as well, such as that Irish shall be compulsory, and so on.
I, and those associated with me in the Labour Party whose names are appended to this amendment, wish to bring the attention of the House very forcibly to the fact that here we have for the first time to my knowledge, a provision written into the law to enable a public company to appoint people to clerical positions purely as a result of an interview. It is stated specifically here.
The purpose of our amendment is to safeguard the existing method, which has been accepted over a long period of time, of filling vacancies by open competitive examination. The Minister was at pains here yesterday to suggest the awful and dire consequences which might flow if members of this House are enabled to ask questions which might relate to the day-to-day administration of CIE. It is evident sometimes when he is talking on these matters that he considers that — in the main, at any rate, and certainly in so far as the Opposition are concerned — this House consists of venal people.
Comment on this
I am drawing attention now to the possibilities of venality there are in this proposal by the Minister. It does not require much imagination for us to think of what can happen when public funds are at the disposal of a Board which has the right to fill well-paid jobs — as clerical posts are in CIE — purely as a result of an interview.
We have seen in other public companies the results of such activities. People find themselves in positions, although they are not fit for them, purely by virtue of their association with a political Party or, it may very well be, by virtue of their blood relationship with a politician or a member of the Board. These things have happened and do happen and they are a subject of public comment daily throughout this country.
We know very well that nepotism is rampant in some of these institutions. Here we have a proposal which will open that undesirable avenue much wider than it is at present. The people expect, when we are disposing of public funds, that Members of the House will do all in their power to ensure that these funds will be employed for the good of the entire community and that if there are positions for the payment of which these funds will be used, then that such positions should be on offer to all the citizens of this country on an open competitive basis.
It appears that the principle that entry into clerical posts in the national transport company was written into the 1924 Railways Act. Here, we are going back and undoing the work and experience of the past 50 years by including this provision. It is perhaps the most undesirable aspect of this Bill. We want to know why it is there. What is its purpose in being there? Who suggested that it should be there? Is it the Minister's idea? It would seem to me to be highly doubtful that it is.
Where did the suggestion come from that this provision should be put in the Bill and what does it mean? It means simply—from what I can read into it —that CIE wish to be put into the position that they can appoint whomsoever they like without applying any test save that of an interview. That is something we shall not accept and it is something we shall put to the issue in this House. We want to label it for what it is. If it were allowed to slip through, it would be a very serious mistake. God knows, the Board of CIE are already sufficiently intoxicated with authoritarianism. If they were to get this as well, as a present, how do we know the manner in which they would employ it and how do we know what the end result would be? The House should seriously consider the matter and the Minister should eliminate this undesirable provision from the Bill.
Comment on this
In actual fact, the section of this Bill follows in all its essential features the arrangements for competitions by the Civil Service in section 15 of the Civil Service Commissioners Act, 1956. So, civil servants of this type—clerical officers—can already be appointed with one or more of the following tests, namely, a written examination, an oral examination, an interview, a practical examination and any other test or tests considered by the Commissioners to be appropriate. The section provides that where a competition consists of more than one of the types of tests specified in subsection (3)—which I have already read out—not more than one of the tests need be competitive.
There is plenty of precedent for this within the Civil Service. No other State body coming within my control has any statutory restrictions in regard to the recruitment of clerical staff. I might have recommended the complete annulment of the section and it would still place CIE only in line with other State companies. In fact, we are still maintaining rules and regulations in regard to the competition which are not in any other statute governing State companies under my supervision.
In the case of Bord na Móna, the clerical staff are appointed on the basis of qualification, on leaving certificate or intermediate certificate and an interview. The same applies to the ESB, Bord Fáilte and Aer Lingus. For the superior scale, the higher grade of clerical officer, leaving certificate with honours is required, and after that there are intelligence and aptitude tests and an interview.
Comment on this
I am quoting from information. In fact, CIE are finding it difficult to compete with other State-sponsored bodies in the recruitment of clerical staff of a certain kind. The reason for the amendment of the law is the use of office machines of all kinds. In fact, a written examination given to a candidate who already has an educational qualification is not the modern way of assessing aptitude. It is not done in a great many companies. There are aptitude tests and interviews.
If you have five or six candidates for the position of clerical officer— and I might add that it is getting more and more difficult to get them—they might all have the leaving certificate qualification, and only one might know how to use the machine to which he would be appointed. He would be the person to be chosen, and there would be an oral interview to see whether he was satisfactory, having got references from his previous employment, or from the priest, the clergyman or the manager of the school. We are modernising the practice. I will not yield one single inch on this section which puts CIE nearly on a level with other State companies.
Comment on this
Did the Minister say this is based on a section of the 1956 Civil Service Act?
Comment on this
No; I said the Civil Service Commissioners Act provides the same type of examination regulations for persons entering as clerical officers as are now provided in this section. I think it is reasonable. I do not think it can be said there is any sinister objective on the part of CIE if they virtually copy a section of the Civil Service Act.
Comment on this
There is not anything sinister in the Labour Party amendment. What the Minister has said is a reflection on our system of education. In the main, the amendment proposes that there should be a written and an oral examination. It is all very well to talk about the practice in other semi-State and State bodies. It is all very well to talk about what happens in the Civil Service. The Minister must remember—and this has been running through the debate since it started yesterday afternoon—that while the Dáil does not appear to have any worthwhile control over the policies pursued by CIE, the Dáil has control over the activities of civil servants.
In this amendment, Deputy Dunne is trying to ensure that there will be equal opportunity for every boy and girl when they come to the age at which they might qualify for a job as clerical officers in CIE, or any State institution. The Minister talked about the difficulty of recruiting staff able to operate the complicated computing machines. There is nothing in this amendment which would hinder the Board of CIE in recruiting whatever staff they want. Surely it is not unreasonable to expect CIE to recruit staff, and clerical staff in particular, by way of written examination? Are we to discard the importance in which the intermediate certificate and the leaving certificate are held? Surely they must be of some significance. They are the certificates which every boy and girl seek to obtain. They are the badge of a certain standard of education, academic at least.
Deputy Dunne did not suggest that the person who came first in the written examination should get the first appointment. This amendment also includes an oral examination. If the Minister wants to ensure that people are competent in the use of the machines to which he referred, that could be discovered by way of oral examination. It is not appropriate to make vague or wild allegations of favouritism or influence in obtaining posts with CIE, the ESB, Telefís Éireann, or any State or semi-State body, but so long as there is a suspicion in the minds of the public that influence will get one a job in any State company, I do not think the Minister is doing himself justice, or is being fair to the country. Boys, girls and their parents should know that merit, and merit alone, will get a job. For that reason the amendment suggests that there should be a written examination, and those who qualify can be interviewed on their aptitude and ability. Let that be tested by oral examination.
I think the Minister suggested the Civil Service had power to appoint staff without written examination. I do not know whether that is a regulation, but everyone knows there is an open competitive examination for posts as clerical officers and junior executives. It is also true that there is an interview and an oral Irish examination. To suggest, as the Minister has suggested that CIE, which is subsidised by the taxpayer, should employ any method it wants to recruit staff is something we cannot swallow.
Paragraph (d) of section 12 provides that:
A competition shall consist of such one or more of the following types of test as the Board may specify in the rules relating to the competition, namely: (i) a written examination;
(ii) an oral examination;
(iii) an interview;
(iv) any other test or tests that the Board considers to be appropriate.
Subparagraph (iv) is the worst: "Any other test or tests that the Board considers to be appropriate." That could mean anything.
Comment on this
We could think of many examples of what it could mean. By accepting this amendment, the Minister should indicate to the country that so far as State and semi-State bodies are concerned, everything is open and above board in the recruitment of staff, and that merit and merit alone gets the job. I do not suggest that there are unscrupulous members on the Board at present, but if there were such an unscrupulous member, he could use paragraph (d) (iv) to do whatever he liked.
Children now studying for the intermediate and leaving certificate honestly believe that to get positions in these semi-State bodies it is necessary for them to qualify by way of written examination, accepting, of course, that it will be necessary for them to attend an interview and to pass an oral Irish test. What ambition can they have to a post as clerical officer in any semi-State body if they do not know what recruitment method will be employed—if they do not know whether it will be by way of interview or whether they will be subjected to a test to determine what political Party or sporting organisation they belong to?
There have been abuses in the past and the Minister knows of the criticism levelled at the method of recruitment to a recently established State body, Telefís Éireann. I hope we are not to have the repetition of that. I trust the Minister will insist that as far as the CIE Board are concerned, the only qualification will be a demonstration of a certain standard of education by passing a written examination. It is too thick to propose to give to CIE the right to conduct any kind of examination or interview they like, which is what this subsection proposes.
Comment on this
The whole thing is exaggerated. I do not see how this section proposes any change——
Comment on this
——from the system in operation. I have seen advertisements for posts and one of the items at the bottom of such notices is that canvassing will disqualify. I have seen that put into operation. It is not long since the Leader of the Fine Gael Party raised the matter in reference to an Aer Lingus appointment. On one occasion years ago, a member of this Party wrote a letter in respect of a person applying for a post in Aer Lingus and that person was disqualified. When a condition like that in respect of canvassing is inserted in the conditions of application for appointment, it is not put in for fun. I do not see any danger in the system the Minister proposes to adopt. It is no different from the system in operation.
Comment on this
The Deputy is wrong. It was written into the Railways Act of 1934 that there should be an examination.
Comment on this
It is, in certain instances.