We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - Succession Bill, 1964: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 124–256 of 256. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Succession Bill 1964
Lapsed

No. 17 of 1964 ›

It is not codology.

Comment on this

Why go on pretending that the Succession Bill you introduced is in principle the Succession Bill you want the House to pass? It is not.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this

All the fundamental parts are gone. The machinery sections, which are not controversial, remain, but Parts IX and X of the Bill are blown out of the ground. It has now been announced that the important section dealing with the making of wills is to be dropped. The Parliamentary Secretary came in here and he did not know the Minister's proposals; he has now dropped the practice which has been in operation for years in this country in which a small estate could be administered by a customs officer.

Comment on this

The non-existent customs officer.

Comment on this

We had one in Ballaghaderreen until they took him away. In some parts of the country, they are more accessible than in others. That system was in operation for years, although in some places people did not avail of it very much. However, it was availed of in the case of some small estates. The Minister has now introduced a new principle, that is, to introduce local probate registries approximately on a county basis and the county registrars will have a wide discretion to help and guide persons in this procedure. But that is not in the Bill. It was announced so casually that the Parliamentary Secretary, who was so anxious to help, told the Minister that this was something that ought to be looked into, only to be told that it was no longer proposed. I like the Parliamentary Secretary. I think he is a good Deputy and all of us in the early stages of our official careers have put a foot wrong but it is not right that we should find two members of the one Government contradicting each other on the Front Bench. That is the fault of the Minister for Justice in trying to push through the House a Bill in such a complex manner. If we take the original Bill and superimpose on it the White Paper, the Minister's speech today and the amendments he has indicated he intends to make, you may get some kind of mosaic of what may be in the Minister's mind but that is not the Bill.

I think Parliament is a system which works well, a system to which Governments, Ministers and Deputies should show deference and I do not think that Parliament will be promoted in the eyes of the people as a reasonable and sensible legislative system as a result of the manner in which this Bill has been presented.

Comment on this

We will have full discussion on it on Committee Stage.

Comment on this

That is all cod. It may be good enough to fool some of those who sit behind the Minister but it is not good enough to fool those of us who have some regard for parliamentary procedure.

Comment on this

Parliamentary procedure is not as inflexible as all that.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy remember when he brought in 100 amendments on the Committee Stage of a Bill?

Comment on this

That is all very well but what the Minister has done is to alter the principle underlying the Bill. He has boasted of that. When you bring before the House any Bill, the sensible procedure is to amend that Bill in the Committee Stage, if it can be amended.

Comment on this

That is what I am doing.

Comment on this

It is not right to announce in advance that you have abandoned the principles of the Bill but you do not propose to withdraw it. You should submit it to the House in some form which the House can read and understand. The Minister knows that just as well as I do. I will record then a very emphatic proposal against this House being asked to discuss the principles of a Bill which is in substance withdrawn. I agree with Deputy Colley, the Parliamentary Secretary. I agree that the proposal to abolish the ceremonial procedure in the making of wills is a retrograde and an improvident proposal.

There are very many wills of a fraudulent character but not all wills are so. There is no doubt whatever that the solemn procedure of a testator signing his will in the presence of two witnesses who sign it in the presence of each other does lend a certain solemnity to the procedure which removes or, certainly, mitigates, the temptation to people, actuated by avarice, to make false wills or to falsify them.

I can see the argument proceeding on both sides of this case but as yet I have not been able to think of any persuasive argument which could be advanced for abolishing the old system and substituting the relatively easy procedure which was envisaged in the first draft of this Bill. I believe the Minister himself now recognises that in seeking to honour the principle of protecting widows and dependent children from capricious wills he has gone too far. He would like to lay down a whole set of rigid rules controlling the disposition of property. It is quite intolerable in a way in our social circumstances but that does not close the eyes of many of us to the fact that capricious wills can be a real and tragic disaster for a family.

I remember in my own personal experience a perfectly rational man, whom I could not imagine making the type of will he made, in which he left all his property to his children and nothing to his wife at all. She was confident that she had the wherewithal to rear her family but suddenly found she had not the price of a postage stamp. All her property was in trust for the benefit of the children. I do not know whether that was due to the incompetence of a solicitor or to the man himself. That is something which is hard to understand.

We all know of cases in which a man takes up with a woman and leaves his property to her. He leaves his wife and children unprovided for. Those are very rare cases but they are sufficiently frequent, I think, to require provision to be made to prevent their recurrence. I believe the Minister for Justice should not have gone to the extreme which is proposed in Part IV of this Bill. Mind you, the Fianna Fáil Party are very ready to pour buckets of whitewash over themselves and weep crocodile tears for what they have done. The statement of the Minister for Justice, prior to his migration to the Department of Agriculture, gave us to understand that he seemed to be pretty rigid in his view that this was a great thing he was going to leave to posterity whereby to judge him. It is gratifying that the attitude excited in the country amongst responsible people everywhere has been responsible for the attitude which the present Minister for Justice is now adopting.

I want to make this matter clear. There is a tendency developing in this House to assume that this is a lawyers' Bill. It is not a lawyers' Bill. It is a Bill which affects the daily life of individual citizens, great and small, rich and poor. I am not really deeply interested in the convenience of the solicitors. They are well paid to take the necessary steps to carry out their clients' instructions. Mind you, I hope the Labour Party will not fall into the error of saying this is a lawyers' Bill and that we should send it to a Special Committee.

Comment on this

It is not the lawyers who do the work of the Special Committee.

Comment on this

If there is a Special Committee of this House set up to consider this Bill, it is the lawyers' voice which will be heard the loudest. That is a very natural thing.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is right. This is the place to have a discussion on this Bill.

Comment on this

It is a very dangerous proposal to send this Bill upstairs to a Special Committee because it is not an easy Bill to evaluate. It is a Bill in which technicians can very quickly make their views prevail if there are not sufficient ordinary men and women to say: "We do not give a fiddle-de-dee for these doctrines which you declare sacrosanct. We think it is bad to do this and we do not want to have it done." Therefore, I cannot share the views of the Leader of the Labour Party that this is a Bill eminently suited for a Special Committee. It is quite true there are a number of technical Bills dealing with drainage, local government and other technical matters of that nature which can very often, with advantage, be sent to a Special Committee. This is a Bill relating to the making of wills in which the least important party involved is the lawyer who drafts the wills. The testators and beneficiaries are much more important and their voices ought to be heard with respect when we come to consider the details of this Bill.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am sorry Deputy Colley, the Parliamentary Secretary, has gone because he had fears for the justification and evaluation of the distinction between realty and personalty. He told us a story of a man who bought his holding on a fee simple and found half his kitchen went to his legal heirs and the other half was distributed, as to one-third to the widow and two-thirds to the remaining children. That reminds me of when the Government bought a site in Nigeria for £65,000 and then discovered it was on shifting sand and you could not build anything. The dilemma of that gentleman was due to the fact that he did not have his solicitor draw up the will in a proper manner and not have one-third fee simple, one-third leasehold. I have known of a case in which people thought they were buying fee simple and discovered there were intolerable leases. Those cases take place in the best regulated households but they do not represent the law. People should know what they want to buy and should buy what they intend to buy. If they build a house they are not building a house with theories attaching thereto nor should they build a house on shifting sand. Only Fianna Fáil Governments and improvident testators do that kind of thing.

In regard to section 84, I want to invite the House to consider what I have been describing before as Chesterton's law. I do not know the origin of the theory that if you make a will and subsequently get married, the solicitor must chase you on your honeymoon all over the country to sign your will again before he lets you out of his sight. It has happened to one or other of us. There is always something grisly in seeing an unfortunate bridegroom re-executing his will after having signed the marriage register.

I do not know the history of that. I do not know how it grew up but before we casually abolish it by a short section of the Will Act as it is, I would like to hear that history. G.K. Chesterton once said our society is full of strange archaic observances which one is tempted at first glance to sweep away as being incompetent, but never yield to that temptation, he said, until you first find out what made our forefathers ask for that observance. It was because they were not fools, and they erected that observance for allaying some evil. They recognised the evil that then existed. They erected the observance to allay it and the observance has been so successful that we have forgotten what the evil was. Have we any reason to be assured that, if we sweep away what looks like an archaic observance, this evil will not re-manifest itself and we may not have the intelligence our grandfathers and great-grandfathers had to devise the appropriate remedy?

I would gladly concede that in the Statute Book there are archaicisms which might with advantage be removed today but somebody for some reason must have made this odd provision that a will made prior to marriage ceases to be vaid after marriage. It is hard to see the obvious explanation of it. Since it was done, there must be some reason for it. Some abuse must have existed which this was designed to correct. If we know the abuse and if we are now satisfied that that abuse could no longer arise in the society in which we live, with superior methods of communication and superior methods of recording and so on, well and good, we could sweep it away. But I should like to be told why it was first instituted, and why should it now be decided to sweep it away before accepting blindly that it should be so disposed of.

I should like to be in a position to discuss this Bill constructively, make suggestions and ask and raise queries without trying to obstruct the progress of the Bill through the House.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Naturally that is the rational approach of any rational Deputy to legislation of this kind. The Minister's whole attitude to this business has made that approach as difficult as it is humanly possible to make it.

Comment on this

If the Deputy did his homework, he would know it cannot be done.

Comment on this

I have done my homework but I do not propose to do the Minister's homework. He is paid £4,500 a year for it.

Comment on this

I have done it. We can have a sensible discussion on it.

Comment on this

Neither the Minister's predecessor nor himself has done it and it is a pure combination of laziness and a desire to preserve political face that induces the Minister to ask the House to consider the principles of a Bill which he himself and his colleagues are repudiating. If we had before us a new Bill, we could deal with this in a rational way. What will happen is that when the Committee Stage comes, all the Minister's amendments will be inserted into the Bill. Then it will be re-printed and re-distributed and then we will proceed to re-commit, I suppose.

Comment on this

We will have another stage for discussion. Then we will have a Report Stage. We are just introducing an extra Stage. Why? To preserve the pretence that the Minister and his predecessor have done their job. However, let them not say to me: "Do your own homework".

Comment on this

We can have a discussion on my amendments on Committee Stage. Ministerial amendments are a well-known feature of the Parliamentary process.

Comment on this

I do not know that it is expedient to pursue some of the topics raised by Deputy Colley but he did elect to go through one or two sections of the Bill. Section 89 says:

Extrinsic evidence shall be admissible to assist in the construction of, or to explain any contradiction in, a will.

That would seem superficially a most reasonable proposal. Ninety-nine per cent of average men would say that this is a most laudable reform and is long overdue. I would ask them to pause and consider. There has grown up over the years a pretty comprehensive rule of interpretation applicable to wills, one being that they are taken to speak from the date of the testator's death. There are a variety of other technical rules, all well known to competent lawyers. The average testator goes in to a competent lawyer and he explains what he wants done. This is cast by a competent lawyer into the language long accepted in the interpretation of wills.

That competent lawyer proceeds to give expression to the testator's intention in the language which has been repeatedly tested in court. Take any member of this House who sits down with a sheet of notepaper and writes on that sheet of notepaper in language he believes to be as clear as crystal what he wants done and let him get it witnessed. The correct procedure is adopted to make it a valid will but God knows what a High Court judge will declare that to mean by the time he has had access to extrinsic evidence.

That is not all. We know, as regards probate, any High Court judge in this country can set himself the task of determining by the examination of extrinsic evidence what a testator meant. I venture to say if you took the whole High Court bench of this country, you would not find two judges of that bench who would give the same meaning to the same will after they heard extrinsic evidence. I think that in matters of this kind the nearer you can get to certainty and to uniformity the better: the nearer we can reach the point of saying that no matter what judge is sitting on what bench the meaning of the words used in this instrument has long been interpreted on good advice, the better. Here is something full of danger.

I am open to conviction. Maybe I am wrong, but I sound this note of warning. Most ordinary, rational people say this is a most obvious reform. We have heard of the most extraordinary interpretations being given to wills and of wills which appear to us perfectly clearly to say one thing being held by the courts to say another. We have to bear in mind that if the testator is made to say in the language of wills something other than he meant, that is due to the incompetence of the solicitor he had and not to the form of the language to which the courts have attached certain specific meanings.

If we once depart from that—there are as many interpretations of wills as there are judges on the Bench—it will create a queer situation. You can find two wills in virtual identical terminology. In Court No. 1 the judge declares it to mean one thing and in Court No. 4 the judge declares it the direct opposite. Both have found themselves entitled to have acceptance of evidence. I think I can sum it up by saying that the main dictum in the matter of wills is to approach as nearly as possible to objective truth.

Any more approximation to the objective truth than the evidence of human beings I think it would be hard to find. It is the truth as the witness saw it and we can all see a different truth, honestly, on the same set of facts. In regard to section 89, I would enter a caveat: come as near to objective truth as possible. Extrinsic evidence can lead us down the strangest paths. Deputy Colley, the Parliamentary Secretary, turned to section 103 which deals with the making of wills on board ships or aircraft. Every time I hear the Minister for Justice having the impudence to tell me to do my home work! I have done my home work.

Comment on this

He thinks.

Comment on this

I must say I have not done as much as I should have liked because I have been too busy. Deputy M.J. O'Higgins has quite a knowledge of the Department of Justice and of his competence I have not the slightest doubt.

Comment on this

He displayed great competence today.

Comment on this

He would make a good Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy believe in the competence of the Irish people?

Comment on this

I still believe the Irish people have the ability to make mistakes, and so long as they go on electing Fianna Fáil, apparently they have that right. I have confidence that they will not only continue to have that right but that they will exercise it as well. Let us turn to section 103. It says:

A testamentary disposition made on board a vessel or aircraft shall also be valid as regards form if its form complies with the internal law of the place with which, having regard to its registration (if any) and any other relevant circumstances, the vessel or aircraft may be taken to have had the most real connexion.

What do you make of that? What the heck does that mean?

Comment on this

What it says.

Comment on this

I should like the Deputy to parse it. What do you understand by "any other relevant circumstances, the vessel or aircraft may be taken to have had the most real connexion."? What test do you apply—whence the vessel sailed, the nationality of the master, the ownership, the residence of the owners of the vessel? If you once depart from the principle of recognising a vessel by its place of registration and the flag it flies and substitute for it "the place with which, having regard to its registration (if any) and any other relevant circumstances"——

Comment on this

It is a legal phrase.

Comment on this

I do not know whether it is a legal phrase or not. Can the Minister not imagine that giving rise to a tumult of legislation?

Comment on this

Not really.

Comment on this

There is a simple test. If people want to make wills on ships —God only knows why they should— can they not go down to the rear of the ship, pick up the flag and say: "Do I want my will to be interpreted according to the laws of Liberia or Panama, or, if I do not, shall I wait until I get home to Cobh?"

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Or Greece, or anywhere else, with no reference to nationality.

Comment on this

The Minister may have some explanation. It is not a very unlikely contingency. It seems a queer provision when the object of this legislation is simply to find a law relating to wills. Is it not perfectly simple, or is there an implied injustice in saying: "If you want to make a will on board ship go down to the stern and look at the flag and if you do not like its design, wait until you reach terra firma”?

Comment on this

It might be a flag of convenience.

Comment on this

Suppose it is Liberian, a fellow says: "That is a ship Liberia borrowed the money from the Irish Government to buy from a Dutchman". Is it a Dutch, an Irish or a Liberian ship?

Comment on this

That is the purpose of the phrase "real connexion".

Comment on this

There is a ship cruising across the Atlantic. It was built in Cobh by a Dutch company which was paid £350,000 for building it, though it only got £150,000 for building it. It is registered in Liberia. The Liberians borrowed some millions from us to buy from us the ship we paid the Dutchman £150,000 for building, and part of the ship is now owned by the Dutchman, who does not own the company which built the ship—it only bears his name—and part of the ship is owned by the Liberian Government. Neither of them paid a penny for it.

Comment on this

Whom will you will it to?

Comment on this

"... and any other relevant circumstances, the vessel or aircraft may be taken to have had the most real connexion". I am damned if I know whether that ship has the most connection with the wholly-owned subsidiary of the Industrial Credit Company. Mind you, the Industrial Credit Company did not provide the money, but a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Industrial Credit Company did and the Industrial Credit Company presumably got the money from the Irish Government. So you have the Liberian, the Dutchman, the Dutch company, the wholly-owned subsidiary of the Industrial Credit Company, the Industrial Credit Company and the Liberian flag to consider.

Comment on this

Now you know why that phrase has to be used.

Comment on this

I suggest that if—and this is highly probable—by this time the ship is flying the Panamanian flag, instead of going into this elaborate inquisition as to what happened, how it was built, how it was financed, who bought it and so on, the simple thing is to say to the intending testator: "Look, under our law, if you want to make a will, look at the stern of the ship and if it is flying the flag of Panama, then it will be determined under the law as Panamanian." Whatever flag it is flying indicates its port of registration and for the purpose of this section the nationality is so determined.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Surely it would be easier to say the man is an Irishman?

Comment on this

That is in the previous section.

Comment on this

The thing to do is to send it to Bord na gCon and find out the pedigree.

Comment on this

This is a matter for consideration if we intend a simplification of the law.

Comment on this

It must be read in conjunction with the previous section.

Comment on this

We should bear in mind that the purpose is the simplification of the law in addition to its codification and do not let us ramble into the unnecessary thickets of legal terminology if that can be avoided by a simple expedient which imposes no material hardship on any intending testator.

I deprecate most strongly the procedure adopted in relation to this Bill. I still cherish the hope that the Minister may see the force of the contention I have advanced. The proper course is to produce a new Bill. If he does, I agree with other Deputies that there should not arise in connection with the consideration of such a Bill any matter about which there would be any political contention. I recognise what I imagine Deputies on all sides recognise, that there is scope for honest difference of opinion as to what is the best machinery to provide against the rare capricious will which would do cruel injustice to a widow or dependent children. I believe between our joint wisdom we can find a workable and equitable solution to that.

Some people will favour strongly the British device which appears to have worked well, that is if the will appears to be capricious, it can be referred by the widow and the children to the High Court for determination as to what would be equitable and just. Others will take the view that there should be, in the event of a will being deemed to be capricious, some automatic fractionation of the estate, each fraction appropriated to a different section of the family. That is a matter we could argue rationally and intelligently.

Frankly, I have found myself in complete sympathy with both sides. In theory, I would favour the reference to the High Court judge but when you come to examine that in practice and realise that you may get seven different interpretations from seven different judges——

Comment on this

That is what happened in Britain.

Comment on this

——you may find yourself in a very embarrassing situation. I do not know that the law of testacy has not operated fairly equitably. There has been the one-third to the widow and two-thirds to the children but I think it is far too rigid when you are dealing with the general testamentary capacity of a rational testator. What I am groping towards is some standard which would declare a will to be capricious whereupon some mandatory minimal provision would become operative for the spouse and the dependent children. But I want to sound one note of warning. Take the case of the parent who is deliberately deciding not to make provision for a particular child. Now, he may have made ample provision during his life and made up his mind that, having done the best he could for that child, the child, the boy or girl, is incorrigible and he intends to do no more. Having given most careful thought to the whole business, he has resolved to declare that he is cutting the child off with a shilling. He may have said to his wife: "you will have to provide for this boy now and see that he does not meet with disaster as he is being bereft of property; I am not going to give him any property because it will be dissipated." We are asking that he state in the will the grounds——

Comment on this

Not in the amendments.

Comment on this

I have studied the amendments——

Comment on this

That is out; that has been dealt with.

Comment on this

That is one of the difficulties in which I find myself. Some amendments may have escaped my notice. Originally when I read the Bill we were asking the testator to declare as a matter of public record whatever family misfortune——

Comment on this

That is gone.

Comment on this

That is a very proper reform and it is evidence of the grave lack of thought on the part of a responsible Minister ever to have allowed it to be incorporated in the Bill. It is his job. It is the Minister's job to comb out the suggestions submitted by the civil servants attached to his Department who do their part of the job which is to put up ideas to him. It is his duty as political head of the Department to interpret what is good and to accept or reject and then inform the Government that he was urged by his experts to put this view forward but he decided not to bring it to the Government because he did not approve of it. This amendment is desirable but the fact that the proposal was first made without thinking and that the situation was created for a parent who, because of the failure of his child, cuts him off, that he was required to proclaim the reasons before the world is evidence of the very careless drafting of the Succession Bill as we first received it.

We will put our amendment to the House because we think the process of legislating this legislation can best be served by a new Bill which can then be calmly considered in Committee, if necessary re-committed, and treated as it ought to be treated, as a wholly noncontroversial piece of legislation. In its present form it certainly is not that. It is not only controversial but incomprehensible. It reflects gravely——

Comment on this

Not if the Deputy read the explanatory memorandum. The Deputy has not done his homework.

Comment on this

——gravely on the diligence and competence of the ex-Minister for Justice. I pass no immediate stricture on the present Minister for Justice but he should be warned by the fact that his own junior colleague whom, I think, he will agree with me is an honest man, and a diligent Deputy, found himself, in discussing the Bill, in a dilemma not of his making but of the Minister's. It is a dilemma in which every Deputy who takes an intelligent interest in this Bill will find himself unless the Minister presents a new Bill. The end result may be the same but if the procedure which the Minister, in this exercise of face-saving, wishes to pursue for his Government, if we have a Committee Stage in which the Ministerial amendments are incorporated, then we ought thereafter to have a Recommittal and a Report Stage.

Comment on this

Yes; we will have the full picture on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

Then we want to re-commit it, that is, a discussion on the Committee Stage and on what is ordinarily the Report Stage and then thereafter the Report Stage—a Recommittal. Is that possible, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle? I think it is.

Comment on this

I think we should go through the fullest possible parliamentary procedure.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has been done.

Comment on this

If we take that course, some of the damage can be repaired but let us all be resolved that this silly mess will not be taken as a precedent.

Comment on this

Why a Recommittal?

Comment on this

To get us out of the mess in which we now are.

Comment on this

Have we reached a Committee Stage?

Comment on this

Poor Deputy Tully does not know where we are.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon and Deputy de Valera are discussing the sections of the Bill across the floor of the House.

Comment on this

They are.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The Minister said it is a Committee Stage Bill. That does not mean it could be discussed——

Comment on this

The proposal is that this Bill that nobody wants, either the Minister or anybody else, and which is the bane of us so that we have to go through the farce of taking a decision on the Second Stage, will then go into Committee——

Comment on this

With the Ministerial amendments.

Comment on this

No. The Ministerial amendments will then be inserted in this Bill in Committee.

Comment on this

Can we not short-circuit it?

Comment on this

I have been trying to persuade the Minister to do that. Now he has Deputy de Valera addled. We should throw this Bill on the waste heap and bring in a new Bill.

Comment on this

No. Can we not take the Ministerial amendments quickly into the Bill, get the thing complete and then have the real Committee?

Comment on this

You must have a Report Stage afterwards. You must have two Committee Stages and a Report Stage. This is all to save the face of the Minister for Justice. All that could be avoided——

Comment on this

It does not require any magnificent exercise of comprehension to read the Ministerial amendments side by side with the Bill.

Comment on this

You have Deputy de Valera, Deputy Tully, Deputy Coughlan and me addled—the four of us have been members of this House for quite some time—and we are sustained by Deputy M.E. Dockrell. I do not know if he is any clearer than we are on this matter.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

He is not addled but he is not as clear on the matter as he would like to be.

Comment on this

This procedure reflects badly on the Minister and on his supporters. We will put our amendment to the House. If the Minister wants to persist, he has the majority for the time being to do so. But, in fact, he cannot initiate a proper discussion of this Bill until a farcical Committee Stage which the Minister thrusts upon us has been put through. It is only when we go out of that Committee Stage that we can start a proper examination of the Bill.

Comment on this

A very constructive——

Comment on this

Putting in the Ministerial amendments——

Comment on this

And a discussion on them.

Comment on this

It is on the recommittal that we discuss them and further amendments will have to be presented on the Report Stage. However, we shall deal with that situation and extricate the Minister from his own mess as best we can. So long as that document constitutes the basis of our discussions, we shall be in a continual sea of mystification and frustration. If the Minister really wanted a constructive approach to law reform, he would have a new Bill. He could have avoided all this to-do today if he had come in at 3 o'clock and said: "We might as well withdraw the Bill. If the House will indulge me, I will present a new Bill on Tuesday next," and we would have got on with the job.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not read a single memorandum circulated with the Bill, obviously. The whole thing is quite plain. Even the members of his own Front Bench demonstrated that today by making most constructive speeches on the Bill.

Comment on this

It is as plain as a pikestaff that this is a futile attempt to cover up the incompetence and the lack of duty of the present Minister's predecessor. He was too lazy to do his work. That is why we are faced with the situation we are confronted with today. I hope that in his new sphere of activity he will show a higher diligence and not leave it to the Raheny hens to salvage him by laying golden eggs.

Comment on this

It is rather a pity, for a different reason from that which Deputy Dillon puts forward, that the Bill was not introduced next week rather than today because I have a feeling that the battle which is being fought in Galway is having its echoes in this House.

Comment on this

None whatever.

Comment on this

For that reason an approach is being made to the Bill from both sides of the House which causes me to think that it would be much better if the discussion did not take place today.

Comment on this

Not by me.

Comment on this

Forty pages are a bit much, I think the Minister will agree.

Comment on this

Most reasonable.

Comment on this

The whole question of whether or not the Bill is the type of Bill which should have been introduced is one which will be debated on the Committee Stage. Again, it is rather a pity that the Bill, the second long Bill introduced in a short time in this House, was one which, no sooner had it been introduced, than Ministerial amendments started to pour in. I grant that there has been a change of Ministers and that, I suppose, has produced a change of attitude to the Bill. However, we have had the Land Bill here for months on end. Eventually we got through the Committee Stage but at the last minute there came the really important motion in relation to the Land Bill in the form of an amendment. Will the same happen now in six months' time? When this Bill has almost completed the Committee Stage, will the Minister get a brainwave and introduce something which will change the whole complexion of the Bill?

As everybody seems to be agreed that this Bill is one which should have no political implications, is it not a pity that everybody here will approach it from a political point of view? Therefore we echo what Deputy Corish said earlier. Why can the Bill not be submitted to a Select Committee— because eventually it will come back here? I do not agree with the suggestion that the lawyers in the various Parties will be shouting in the Committee——

Comment on this

They will talk the leg off the Deputy and vote him down.

Comment on this

According to what Deputy Dillon said tonight——

Comment on this

He is right, for once, on this.

Comment on this

——it is the interpretation of the sections of the Bill that will count. Apparently the lawyers will give the correct interpretation of it——

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

It was said that they must have a legal interpretation which will give the true meaning of the Bill. If that is so, surely the lawyers who happen to be members of this House should be able to give a lot of assistance in passing, including Deputy Dillon himself?

Comment on this

A Bill that will keep them idle?

Comment on this

I am sorry to see that Deputy Corry has rested from the battle tonight. Otherwise we should not have the pleasure of hearing his sweet voice. Quite a number of sections in the Bill commend themselves to everybody but there are a number which at present seem to be incomprehensible to most people. People will agree that the law in this country which allows any person to disown, as far as the division of his estate is concerned, the closest members of his family—maybe for a good reason or maybe for no reason at all—should be amended. Most civilised countries have done this years ago. That portion of the Bill seems to be quite good. How the division is to take place is something we should be able to debate on Committee Stage and reach a final conclusion on.

I hope the Minister does not retain the section which proposes that the £500 be raised to £2,000 in the case of small estates which can be administered without going to law. At present that administration is carried out by Customs and Exise officers, but it is almost non-existent because it is hard to find them. I hope the Minister will appoint somebody who can be approached more easily for the purpose of having this done.

Comment on this

We will have no limit now. If he wants to, he can go in himself to the county registrar.

Comment on this

That is not in the Bill.

Comment on this

That is what is going to be in it.

Comment on this

That is a doublecross. That is really to take the whole benefit away from the small estates.

Comment on this

We will have to discuss that on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this

I am afraid the lawyers will have a lot to say on this section of the Bill.

Comment on this

Watch the lawyers on that and see if you want to send it to a Special Committee. The Minister is thinking of the day he will be a lawyer again.

Comment on this

The Minister has quoted the figures. He says the present system is not being used. The reason it is not being used is that it is not possible to get the Customs and Excise officers. I know people who travelled long distances to meet these people and found that the officers were gone when they arrived. All those complications can arise. The Minister intends to have local officers available and, in addition, I hope it will be possible to do it with a central office in Dublin. Many people down the country can more easily get to Dublin than to some of these country towns. That may not be appreciated by the lawyers but I think it will be appreciated generally. Whether or not it is right to bring up the limit I do not know, but it can be discussed.

The original Bill suggested that a farm could be divided up into numerous small sections. I think that is something the Minister for Lands would not agree to. I think he would be perfectly right because that would not work. The Minister for Justice was right in attempting to have it changed. The member of the family who has been settled, who has already left the household and who has got either some money or kind from the family when leaving, who has made himself independent by his own efforts, need not be included. I think that is a good idea.

I honestly believe that if this Bill is to do any good, the Minister will have to ensure we do not have a repetition of the Land Bill. There are 129 sections in this Bill at present. I would like the Minister to assure us we will not find 129 Ministerial amendments before the Bill is finished. It is pretty complicated as it stands. There are some sections which do not seem to make any sense. In his desire to improve the Bill as it goes along, the Minister could find himself in the situation in which his colleague, the Minister for Lands, found himself a few weeks ago—that he had so many Ministerial amendments, not to talk of amendments put in by other Deputies, that it was hard to recognise the Bill as the Bill originally introduced.

Comment on this

Surely that is good democracy? Is this not what Parliament is for?

Comment on this

No. Parliament is for introduction of the Bill considered by the Government, the final product coming from the Minister having been approved by the Government, being as near possible to perfect as they can make it.

Comment on this

Then Parliament is only a rubber stamp?

Comment on this

Parliament then have the right to introduce amendments. It is not right that the Government should, after the introduction of an important Bill, change the whole kernel of that Bill by Ministerial amendments. That is what happened on the Land Bill and it may happen on this one, too.

Comment on this

There will be a number of Ministerial amendments.

Comment on this

I am aware of that.

Comment on this

Then what are you making all the noise about?

Comment on this

The Bill was never brought before your Party.

Comment on this

If the two silent Deputies in Fianna Fáil, who certainly do not speak too often, want to say something, they will have the whole day after the Protection of Animals Bill tomorrow and they can talk as much as they like.

Comment on this

You know a lot about the Protection of Animals Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Fanning might know a lot about animals——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Perhaps Deputies will allow Deputy Tully to speak? There are only a few minutes left.

Comment on this

The Bill was introduced as a result of a discussion in the House that something should be done to deal with the position of people dispossessed. Most of us were delighted when it was originally introduced but, when we saw the form of it, we felt it did not meet all we wanted. The amendments the Minister proposes to introduce will bring it much nearer what we hoped it would be. The Minister announced four amendments, then two more and now a further one. If this is only the start, we will see the amendments piling up until eventually we will have the same situation as the possessed. Most of us were delighted Land Bill; it will be hard to recognise this Bill as the Bill originally introduced.

Comment on this