Economic Situation.
Contributions 1–119 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Last night I was dealing with the allegations made and the demands made for a discussion on the free trade agreement with Britain. I was giving instances of what happened in a previous British Agreement and I was quoting the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, on it. On 12th July, 1960, Deputy Dillon said in the House that he had no knowledge of an Agreement made with Britain in 1956 and had no knowledge of a levy of £16 per ton put on Irish sugar exported to Britain under that Agreement. I do not know how much faith can be put in Britain's word in view of the fact that Deputy Dillon, who has always been a believer in the good faith of both parties to these Agreements, stated publicly in the House that portion of the Agreement with Britain in 1956 was a direct violation of an Article of an Agreement made with Britain in 1948.
At column 1411 of volume 183 of the Official Report, Deputy Dillon said:
In 1948, we negotiated a Trade Agreement, Article V of which read as follows: The Government of the United Kingdom undertake that where goods, the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland, are dutiable at preferential rates of duty they will not vary the existing preferential treatment of these goods in such a way as to put any class of goods, the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland, at a disadvantage in relation to goods of that class from other sources enjoying preferential treatment.
That is Article V of the 1948 Agreement. Deputy Dillon continued:
That is a pretty comprehensive Article and yet with that Article in existence, I understand that goods containing Irish sugar are being subjected to a very formidable levy, the proceeds of which are devoted to the subsidisation of goods of similar quality containing sugar derived from the Crown Colonies of the British Crown. I am told, I think, by some of the Minister's colleagues, that when Deputy Norton was Minister for Industry and Commerce this matter arose, and that he did not consider it desirable to press the implementation of Article V which would give us the right to claim exemption from that levy.
Deputy Dillon went further and said:
I do not know what the position is in regard to that. I have no recollection of hearing the matter discussed when I was a member of the inter-Party Government.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the demand made here by Deputy O'Leary, Deputy O'Higgins and others that there should be a discussion on the proposed free trade agreement with Britain.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the manner in which those people, when they were a mixum-gatherum Government, dealt with agreements.
Comment on this
Surely it does not take all that to make the argument the Deputy is seeking to make?
Comment on this
The Deputy has said that, but does he find it necessary to read all that long quotation to indicate what the attitude of the Government was?
Comment on this
I have read it in order to prove that sections of that Agreement of 1956 were made without even the knowledge of a member of their own Cabinet, Deputy Dillon. He denied it here. I do not want to read anything unnecessary here. He said:
I have no recollection of hearing the matter discussed when I was a member of the inter-Party Government. It could have happened and passed out of my memory.
Under that section of that Agreement made in 1956, this country had to pay over £2 million in two years on sugar and chocolate crumb exports to Britain. Nobody knew of that Agreement in this House until we started exporting sugar and I put down questions to find out the reason for this levy.
Comment on this
Why did we not have a discussion on that Agreement? Deputy L'Estrange is the gentleman who asked why there had been a reduction of 10,000 acres in sugar beet last year.
Comment on this
The farm Deputy L'Estrange got rid of when he put on nice shoes and the collar and tie to come in here would grow a lot of beet.
Comment on this
I shall have to ask Deputy L'Estrange to leave the House, if he will not conduct himself. He and Deputy Harte are constantly interrupting.
Comment on this
I do not think they are up to anyone here, Sir. What I have read is a complete answer to those who are now demanding that the Free Trade Agreement should be discussed here. I have shown the manner in which that Agreement was made and in which the knowledge of it was not conveyed even to Cabinet Ministers of their own Government.
If we had a little more patriotism in this country, there would be no need for talk of a credit squeeze or anything else. I have looked at the shops in Cork city and in my own rural towns and in every case Irish goods are prominently displayed in the windows of the drapery shops there. But you come to Dublin and walk the principal streets, as I did yesterday and the evening before, and you will see no Irish goods displayed in their shop windows.
Comment on this
I stated publicly here before that I went into one of the largest drapery shops in this country looking for a pair of Irish socks.
Comment on this
That was the same gentleman who closed down Lyons and Company in Cork and put 300 men out of employment last week—the fellow who was kicked out of the Seanad. There are 200 or 300 workers walking the streets of Cork because he decided to leave Dublin and come down to Cork to carry on his iniquities there. Let us have a little more patriotism in that line and let us at least help out our own workers by buying goods of Irish workmanship. I suggested to the Minister for Industry and Commerce previously that, if the shopkeepers of this city will not stock Irish goods in their windows, they should be made display in their windows a sign saying "No Irish goods stocked here." Then let the public deal with them. There is too much of this going on.
My fault with the steps taken by the Government are that they are not severe enough. Some nine months ago when speaking in this House, I dealt with the question of certain goods that had been imported here. We are an agricultural community. The bulk of our exports is agricultural produce— good beef, good mutton, eggs, butter and everything else. To a large extent this is what you might call a deal in kind, where we send something over to Britain and get something back in return. I said then, and I repeat now, that the farmers who produce the goods for export so that imports can be brought in are feeling sore, and very sore, and if any Deputy over there goes to the trouble of reading——
Comment on this
On a point of order, are you, Sir, going to allow that as a parliamentary expression? May I call anyone an idiot as often as I like?
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that he should read the speeches made during the Economic War.
Comment on this
I have here the imports into this country during the last 12 months and, amongst them, is an item of £1 million worth of musical instruments. I have a very definite objection to a good hundredweight of butter, a good bullock, or a good sheep going over to Britain to pay for the tambourines and the pop singers' flutes.
Comment on this
May I raise a point of order? This is intended to be a serious debate on a serious subject. I do not think it does the House or the country any good to have this sort of pseudo-comical speech.
Comment on this
I have here an official document with particulars of the imports of certain items into this country. On behalf of the taxpayers and of the workers, I ask that these be prohibited, not tariffed. There is a limit to everything. Can anybody justify the present barter system under which we send over good food to Britain and get back tambourines?
Comment on this
This document gives the imports from January to December, 1964. There is an item here of £3½ million for imported periodicals, novels and printed tickets. I have always believed we had enough printers in this country to produce what we require. I cannot understand our having Britain print tickets for us—perhaps they are soup tickets. These are the things to which I object and that is why I say I am not satisfied with the action taken by the Government. The time has come when we must have prohibition of certain luxury goods and articles coming into this country. The figures I have read out here I read out here some six months ago.
Comment on this
I saw many like Deputy Harte come in here and, the Lord save us, when I look over there now, I wonder where they are.
Comment on this
I suggest the Department of Finance should go through this book and pick out the articles that do the country harm instead of good, and prohibit their import. I could go on reading this book until it is time for the Taoiseach to conclude tonight, but I do not want to delay the House. I suggest Deputies take the trouble to examine this book for themselves. It is disgraceful that at a time when the agricultural community are trying to increase production in order to have more for export, we should have these articles being imported. I object to exporting good food in order to import tambourines. It is time this sort of thing stopped.
The agricultural community have done their part. Only yesterday I concluded an agreement with the General Manager of Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann under which our little processing factory in Midleton will increase its acreage of produce three times, from 600 acres to 1,850 in the coming year. The acreage producing vegetables for processed foods will be increased by 100 per cent. That is the proper way to meet a situation such as the situation we find ourselves in now. But I strenuously object to exporting good food so that trash and tripe costing millions of pounds can be imported.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce and I agree on one thing, and that is that this is a serious debate and the type of pseudocomic tambourine to which we have unfortunately had to listen does not do the Dáil, or the country, or the Party to which the Deputy belongs, any good.
Comment on this
It would be very easy for me to take this motion, and the documents behind it, introduced by the Taoiseach yesterday and use the opportunity solely for the purpose of ramming down the neck of the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Party the untrue attacks that were made some nine years ago, attacks in which I was the target. I do not propose to regale myself with that pleasure. I am perfectly satisfied that in due process of time, history will write the correct tale and the judgement then, in history, on the actions of the Government of which I had the honour to be a member, will be that we took the right steps at the right time, and that the mistake that was made then was perhaps that at Christmas of that year we did not lighten up just before the general election and the mistake that was made by the Fianna Fáil Government who succeeded us was that they, deliberately, for their own ends, accentuated the trough of depression and deliberately, for their own ends, made certain that we would get into the depression from which the country suffered until 1958.
Any observer impartial in any respect who goes back and looks at what happened then will see without question that, apart from the catastrophic breach in confidence caused by the Fianna Fáil Party tactics in the general election of 1957, the salient point is that the Government of that day retained the levies and in certain cases built them permanently into our whole customs structure. It would be easy for me to go back to that time to contrast the speeches that were made by the Taoiseach with the speech he made in July last and with the speech of the present Minister for Industry and Commerce made in July last, which I did not have the opportunity of reading then but which I have since read.
In 1956, the whole cry of Fianna Fáil was: "Too little and too late", that the Government of that day had not imposed a serious enough deterrent. When speaking here at the close of the debate last July, the Taoiseach, at column 1549, expressed the view that the Coalition Government of the day did too much too soon.
I am not interested in endeavouring to see what was said then and what is said now for the purpose of justifying the action that was taken at that time. I am interested solely in examining what transpired for the purpose of seeing how it can be applied to the present situation. As I have said already, I am quite satisfied that the verdict of history will be that the action taken then by the Government of which I had the honour to be a member was the right action at the right time and in the right degree and that the verdict will be favourable. I am equally certain that the verdict on the Fianna Fáil Party of that day will be as unfavourable in history as the verdict that will be placed by history on their leader of that time who is interested only in his own personal aggrandisement and the aggrandisement of the Party, instead of considering the national interest, even right down to the time when he denied his own shadow Minister, Deputy MacEntee, who came to see me in reference to the arrangements for the debate of that date.
We face a position today in which the Government have taken certain steps. The Government announced that they would take certain steps in July. With the remarks of the Taoiseach on that occasion I shall deal later but we are discussing today primarily the levies, the 125 new taxes, the Government introduced, not in a Budget speech—because they were afraid to come in here and introduce these levies in a Budget speech, as we introduced them to the House. They had to do it by mere Government Information Bureau statement outside in respect of which they could not be criticised or challenged. They have brought in these 125 levies and they have done it because they say the situation requires them to do something.
I want to brand 1965, not as the Taoiseach said last July when he was referring to another observation, as the Zulu War or the night of the big wind, but as the year that will go down in history as the year of the great deceit, the year in which Fianna Fáil fraudulently deceived the people in the spring, before the general election, and the year in which, since the general election, they have been so incredibly incompetent as a Government that anyone in business would be ashamed of his life if he had carried on in the way in which they have carried on, never knowing from day to day what they wanted to do, shilly-shallying, wobbling, announcing one thing and changing it the next minute, as I shall show in a few minutes, and, above all, hiding from the people the true state of the economy as they knew it, or should have known it if they were competent to know their job.
Yesterday, the Taoiseach said in the House that the Government had no knowledge of any circumstance other than knowledge that was available to the ordinary people. I want to brand that as an untruth, saying so with all the knowledge that was available to me as Minister for Finance when I was over there, and to say categorically that any Minister has available to him, and the Taoiseach more than any has available to him, advance information in relation to statistical trends the ordinary public has not got. I want to go further and say that the members of the Government have also available to them skilled economists to portray, to decipher, to gauge and to determine the strength of the economic statistics available to the Government and not available to the ordinary person.
I shall give certain specific factors and I challenge the Minister for Industry and Commerce who, I presume will speak in this debate, and I challenge the Taoiseach when he is concluding the debate, to deny that these specific factors were known to the members of the Government and were not known to the public and that they were either fraudulently concealed from the public so that the Fianna Fáil Party might get a verdict in the general election or else that the Government did not know and are too incompetent to care what was happening in relation to the national economy.
I think I am right in saying that the general election took place on 7th April. Last March, a foreign body, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, printed from Paris an economic survey on Ireland. The Minister for Industry and Commerce may not know but his colleague, the Minister for Finance, will tell him that before that survey is printed a draft of the survey is discussed with the officials of the Department of Finance and that the officials of the Department of Finance were aware of the facts that would be commented on in the publication of March. I am certain that those officials brought their knowledge to the notice of the Minister at that time.
On page 23 of that report, it is made clear that the inflow of capital in 1965 was bound not to be as great as it was in 1964 and yet the Fianna Fáil Government and the Fianna Fáil Party went out to the country saying that they would spend more and more capital in 1965, though they had that special knowledge that the ordinary people of the country had not got.
On page 14 of the report it was stated:
The net capital inflow in 1964 was exceptionally high and may have included some short-term funds.
We were saying at that time, without the knowledge that was in that report, then secret and not available to the ordinary people, that it was certain that there had been some short-term transfer of funds from Britain and elsewhere to here that was masking the position in relation to our current deficit in the balance of payments. We said it again and again but the proof of it had not come to our notice and, had not become available to the public but it was available, not perhaps to Deputy Hillery because he was considering Education at the time, not Industry and Commerce, but to the Government as a whole and, above all, it was available to the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance.
The second item of which the Taoiseach knew and of which he would not tell the country was the drop in the external assets of the banking system. Before I give the exact figures in respect of that drop, let me draw the attention of the House to a revealing question I asked here in June last. It was always considered in earlier years that the important ratio of our external assets was the ratio of net external assets to imports, so as to ensure that we would, come what may, have sufficient external assets to be able to carry our imports for a substantial time. In the year ending 30th April, 1956, our net external assets were 91 per cent of our annual import bill. In the year ending 30th April, 1957 they were 106 per cent and year after year since that they have dropped, so that, in the year to 30th April last, the percentage of 91 per cent has dropped to 58.2 per cent. The figures in relation to that were not completely known to everyone until I asked for them in a question in the House, when they were made known and if the members of the Government had wanted to take the trouble to inquire and did not want to deceive the public, they could have done so.
Let us look at the figures for the net external assets which, with the exception of June and December, are made up to mid-month in every month and are on the table of the Minister for Finance, as well as I can remember, on the last day of that month or the first day of the succeeding month. I am certain the practice in existence when I was Minister for Finance of those figures being made available to the Minister for Finance has not been discontinued or, if it has been discontinued, why? Was the Minister for Finance not interested? But as far as I know, those figures would be there on the last day of every month.
What was the position in January 1965 or, mid-January? In 15 days approximately, 15 or 16 days, according as how the week ended, there had been a drop of £5 million in our external assets, double the situation of the preceding year. In mid-February there had been a drop of £5,700,000 in these external assets, in March a further drop of £3,100,000, compared in the previous year with a rise of £7 million in March. These figures were available to the Taoiseach, these figures were available to the Minister for Finance, showing a serious trend, a trend that had to be considered. Yet the Minister and the Taoiseach decided they would not disclose them to the public but they would go ahead lest it might interfere with their chances in the general election.
Then we come to the next point mentioned by the Taoiseach in July, which is hire purchase. The increase —and the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be able to verify this from his own Department—in the March to December figure was virtually double what it had been in the March to December period of the previous year. Again, there was no mur-mur about that, or about the import excess trade figures for any month which are available by the middle of the following month. I agree, of course, everybody knows the trade figures when they are published but only the Government know, only the Government have an assessment, until the full quarterly returns come in, as to how that trade figure has been made up. It is only the Government who can tell whether it is a consumption increase, whether it is an increase of producers capital goods or whether it is an increase of materials for further production. They know because they are given an assessment. At least, I was given an assessment and I am certain the Minister for Finance of the day is given an assessment in the same way. It is not the flat knowledge of an import excess that matters but the knowledge of how that import excess can be segregated, is distributed and can, therefore, be construed.
In February of this year the import excess was £15 million against £8,700,000 in February of 1964. In March it was £18 million against £12 million the March before. In April it was £20 million against £14 million the April before and, in May, it was £17,850,000 against £9,730,000 the May before. It was double—as near as makes no difference—but was there any effort by anybody, knowing this trend was coming along, to say a word to the public before the 7th April? The public were deceived and the Government kept concealed from the public the information it was the public's right to know.
Worse than that, once the election had come and gone, the Government, by their handling of the matter, showed themselves utterly incompetent to deal with the situation. It was bound to come. We have been saying this for some time, that it was bound to come, and the boys over there have been jeering at us. How could it be otherwise?
We had a deficit in our balance of payments in 1962 of £13,500,000 and in 1963 of £22 million. The deficit in 1964 was £31 million. How did we meet them? We met them by borrowing from other people who are bringing their money in—capital inflow. Was it not bound to happen that that would one day stop? Was it not bound to happen, as OECD agreed, that the amount of capital which would come in in anticipation of the formation of a Labour Government in Britain would go back once the British Labour Party had given its indication of the pattern of Labour taxation in England? We built up by depending on other people's capital to finance Fianna Fáil's current deficits and anyone could see that was not likely to be an unending situation. It is a glorious thing to go on drawing from the bank as long as the bank manager allows you to go on drawing, never asks you to pay back and never asks you not to go further. That was what Fianna Fáil were doing in relation to our general account and now nemesis has overtaken them and they are a bit surprised.
If we look at page 4 of the June trade statistics we will see there that one of the things happening was that we were getting in a substantially increased amount of consumption goods in the first six months of this year, a preview of which must have been available, by way of assessment, to the Government, which should have acted as a warning light: £3,500,000 in those six months alone purely on consumption goods. There were also increased many of those items such as that we heard today in relation to Ballymun that could have been mentioned here but nobody was bothering to do so. Had not "Buy Irish" meant "Buy Irish" for everyone other than the members of the Government, as was proved by the Minister for Local Government today?
The fact remains and cannot be gainsaid that in relation to every economic index of which the Government had knowledge and on which the Government should have acted, it was certain that this was going to come at the time of the general election. I charge the Taoiseach with deliberately concealing from the Irish people the true facts in relation to our economic position. I charge him with having sent out his boys, his Ministers, for the purpose of painting a picture which he must have known in his heart and soul was not a true picture, the picture that we were to have more and more and to pay less and less for it.
Let us look, for example, at that expert in extravaganza, the Minister for Agriculture. He said. "We intend to continue our policy of economic planning for the future, to expand the incomes already achieved until we reach a level of prosperity equal to that of the most advanced country in Europe." How? With levies, with a credit squeeze, with restricted hire purchase? I have plenty of quotations from the Golden Boy, as somebody calls him. In the final rally in Dublin, he said: "Our simple purpose is to do everything better in the next five years." How? Better with levies, better with hire purchase restrictions, better with a credit squeeze?
He has done better in one respect. He has done better in respect of the manner in which imports of cereals are coming into the country. I concede that perhaps because of the harvest weather, wheat imports will have to be higher. They are going to be 5,100,000 cwts. this year. But barley was a good crop and yet, apparently, we are to import 1,625,000 cwts. this year, although we have never imported that amount since 1950. And then we are told: "Buy Irish, grow Irish." This is the Golden Boy. In regard to maize, we find it is not possible to give particulars of maize alone because there is maize, milo maize or seed wheat. Even now we are in a situation that we are to import 1,700,000 tons in the remainder of this year, although we have already imported 1,500,000 tons. Again, with one exception, this is the greatest amount imported in any single year of the past ten years. And we are told to grow more Irish. In that respect, at any rate, he is planning better than he did last year.
It is not, perhaps, fair to pick on him. He was just carrying out the instructions of the Taoiseach, the instructions of the Government who told him that there was nothing to worry about, and perhaps they gave him an order that this disturbing economic phenomenon was not to be circulated to Fianna Fáil speakers in case some whisper of it might get to the people. Yesterday the Taoiseach referred to these things and to speeches he made in January and February last warning the people that there were dangers. He made speeches in January and February but the moment he decided to declare the general election, he stopped those speeches. It is now quite certain that the reason the Taoiseach decided, when Deputy Mrs. Desmond won mid-Cork, to declare a general election was that he knew the pattern of these economic trends, knew what was going to happen and decided that he had better get his election over before the cat was out of the bag.
There was no other reason for it, and it must now be obvious, even to the Deputy from mid-Cork who was then the Fianna Fáil candidate in the by-election. I know his name. I was one of the people he came to when he wanted to join Fine Gael. But it was not as a member of Fine Gael he wanted to join. It was like the recruit going to join the Guards who, when asked why he wanted to join, said it was not the Guards he wanted to join, that it was the superintendents he wanted to join. And the portfolio of Finance was the one in which he was interested.
Now let us come from the general election to the present time. The general election was on 7th April, Again I do not know the reason—it may have been that knowing that they had deceived the people in the general election, the Government in office were afraid to let the cat out of the bag any sooner—the Budget came in on 11th May and what did we discover yesterday? We discovered something about which there was not a word in the Budget. This was kept secret until yesterday when the Minister for Finance acknowledged that the day before the Budget was introduced, the banks were told to clamp down on credit and reserve it for certain purposes.
Is there a word in the Budget about that? If the Minister for Industry and Commerce has not a copy of the Budget speech before him when he rises to speak on this motion, I will lend him mine. There is not a word of that in the Budget speech. Either the right hand did not know what the left hand was doing or else it was not disclosed for the reason that if it was disclosed, then it would look as if they had failed to tell the people the true situation during the general election. Nothwithstanding the fact that they had before them the OECD Report, they put out a plethora of documents, including a statement on the capital programme. I do not object to a plethora of documents but when they push out all these figures in the course of one week, it is impossible for anyone to assimilate them in the days immediately before the Budget.
One of the things mentioned in the statement on the capital Budget was that there was £7,700,000 which was classified as capital services and which should properly be met out of current revenue or out of borrowing. With all the trends there—trends the Government now have to acknowledge—what did they do? They deliberately poured petrol on the flames by injecting that £4 million additionally into the economy to make for further inflation.
They also went on to say they had made certain changes in relation to some items. Did they give any indication that they were making those changes because of any dangerous trend in the economy? Oh, no. They said they were doing it because time had made closer examination possible. I wonder was that true? Looking back, I wonder was it not the beginning of the cut in the capital programme they were trying to hide, by pretending it was merely a later examination, a later estimate? Or was it that they were so incompetent that they did not know what they were talking about, just as in relation to capital expenditure by the Government the Taoiseach has shown himself utterly incompetent within the course of a few months?
When replying to the debate at the end of the last session, the Taoiseach made it very clear—I shall turn up the quotation in a second—that the Government were going to ensure that the capital programme was not in excess of the programme as outlined in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. As Deputies will see if they look at page 270 of the larger blue volume, the Second Programme for Economic Expansion provided £95,570,000 for public capital programme. The Budget estimate published on 11th May was £103,720,000, an increase of £8,150,000. On 11th May, the Minister for Finance told us that the appropriate figure for this year was not £95,570,000 but £103,720,000 and on 13th July, as reported at column 1094 of the Official Report, the Taoiseach said:
To summarise therefore the immediate measures the Government consider applicable to this economic situation, they are: first, the reorganisation of the Government's capital programme for this year to keep the total outlay on capital account within the forecast in the Second Economic Development Programme.
"To keep the total outlay on capital account within the forecast" in the Blue Book. We now come to the White Paper published in October—August, September, October, three months afterwards—and what do we find? A White Paper published with an entirely different figure again. I thought perhaps it was "laid by the Minister for Finance" and that the Minister was ignoring what the Taoiseach said, but it was "laid by the Government". Instead of being within the amount laid down to make for expansion within the Second Programme, it was to be £5 million in excess.
When will the Government make up their minds as to what they are going to do, or is it that they do not know, that they are incompetent, that they are afraid of taking the appropriate steps? Why did the Taoiseach come in here in July before the House broke up for the recess, and make the solemn assertion that he, as head of the Government, was going to see that the capital programme was kept within that figure? Then, before the House resumed we had another White Paper denying the Taoiseach's words. Had they changed their minds again, or was the Taoiseach chancing his arm when he spoke here in July, or had they not got down to the question at all?
During the course of the general election, we heard statements by the Minister for Local Government in particular, that if only Fianna Fáil were returned to office, there would be a rising bounding building programme of a kind never seen before. I invite the attention of Deputies to paragraph 23, page 9, of the White Paper on Government Capital Expenditure which makes a liar of the Minister for Local Government, because it says that even if balance of payments difficulties had not arisen, the recent rate of expansion could not have been maintained. It seems very hard to see where they are going when they do not know from one day to another themselves.
We now have 125 new taxes imposed by—is it the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Government?—Government order, I think. Included in that is a licensing provision. I think the effect of that licensing provision will be that people will tend to look for raw materials outside the country, even though those raw materials may be available within the country. I have in front of me one comment by a business man who knows what he is talking about. He said business had been anticipating that the levies would be introduced and accordingly would be pre-stocking to beat those levies and that, in addition, designers and buyers tend to order from their traditional sources of supply. That is natural, and the very fact that there is this licensing provision will mean that they will more and more go to that traditional source rather than see for themselves whether it is not possible to improvise in relation to what we need.
I want to know from the Minister for Industry and Commerce what he proposes to do to ensure that we get out of this economic difficulty, crisis, phase, depression, whatever word one likes to use. What does he propose to do in relation to industry? We know that so far as the Minister for Finance is concerned on the day he brought in his Budget, there was not one single incentive of any sort, kind or description introduced for the purpose of industry, for the purpose of agriculture, for the purpose of saving. Then suddenly about a month afterwards, when we came to the Committee Stage of the Finance Bill, he got a brainwave and decided that it was terrible that there was not a single incentive and that he had better put one in on that Stage. He decided to increase the incentive I gave for small savings in relation to deposit interest. After nine years, he just increased one figure. That is all the Government were able to think of. They are barren of ideas. They show that they do not really know where they are going by changing from day to day or else are deliberately deceiving the people. I will leave it to them to explain which it is.
We have to ensure that there is greater agricultural production at home; we have to ensure that those imports to which I have referred are not going to be continued. We have to ensure that we get for our exports proper markets and proper terms. In relation to the free trade area, let me say that I want to be satisfied in any discussions or in any agreement that is made on the free trade area that we get worthwhile concessions for agriculture. Paper concessions are not worth a curse. A reduction, for example, in the period for which our cattle have to be in England before they qualify for the British subsidy is not worth anything. Unless we can get clear, full and unrestricted access for cattle, sheep, lambs, butter, pigs, pork and bacon it is not going to be worthwhile giving up what we have to give up on the other front.
It is because rumour has it that the Government have failed in that respect that we take the critical attitude we do take in relation to that failure. It has got to be done if we are to succeed and the Minister for Industry and Commerce has to do some new thinking in relation to industry. He must take other steps, other leaves out of our book, as the Government have done in relation to certain aspects of our incomes policy. Speaking as far back as February 1964 in this House, I made it clear that I felt that one of the things necessary was an incomes policy to ensure that we would be able to get that orderly marketing, that orderly prices regulation, that orderly paying out of the increases in national production that all of us would desire. Even as late as the general election six months ago, the Taoiseach said he was against it. I welcome the conversion, welcome it wholeheartedly. The only thing about that is that in other respects where Fianna Fáil have taken over Fine Gael policy they were usually too incompetent to carry it out properly.
I want to make sure, too, that in these difficulties the truth is told to the people. What is the use in the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Finance saying outside that these levies will be on for a period of six months, to the end of March, 1966, when the Minister for Finance comes in here, as he did yesterday, and says solemnly that he does not think we are going to get out of the difficulties before March, 1967? How can we reconcile the two things? Is this another indication of the deceit of the Government in their desire to fool the people?
I do not think that even Fianna Fáil could have the local elections before March, 1966 and get away with it. Certainly from what I have heard people are beginning to see through their deceit. This was bound to come because, for one reason, three consecutive years of Budget deficits by Fianna Fáil, over £4 million in 1963, £2,219,000 in 1964 and £4,069,000, in 1965, or £11 million of accumulated Budget deficits in three years, have added fuel to the flames and more fuel was added in the seven months of this financial year.
In the first seven months of this year, up to 31st October, expenditure rose by £15 million over last year and receipts rose by £12 million. We have gone £3 million further in the red in the first seven months as a result of Government action, of Government incompetence at a time when they are pretending they are trying to rectify the situation. Anyone who wants to see these figures can see them in Iris Oifigiúil for 2nd October —receipts up by £12 million and expenditure by £15 million. At the same time, the Government have injected £9½ million extra into the economy in below-the-line issues in that period.
There is a striking indication in another place of the manner in which the Government are causing difficulties for the commercial community, because as we can see on page 13 of the July Central Bank Bulletin, in mid-July, total bills, loans and advances at £329.9 million were 14.5 per cent above the level of 12 months earlier. Borrowing by the Government and local authorities showed an increase of 36.1 per cent over mid-July of 1964. Borrowing by the Government was up by one-third on the previous year. How could there be enough money for the private sector when the Government were taking it all? How could the ordinary farmer looking for credit, the ordinary businessman, the person trying to buy his house, hope to get money when the Government were, in plain, if rather vulgar language, hogging it all? That is what it amounts to.
We have heard from the Taoiseach some comment on the free trade proposals. I want to be perfectly clear, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce has come back again, and to say that we want to be sure that these proposals will give to us unlimited duty-free access and unlimited access as to quantity without quota into the British market for all our agricultural products. Without that, we will consider the Government have failed in their task in negotiating a proper trade agreement. As regards the interim, let the Government act as a Government. Let them make up their minds about what should be done and keep to it and not have the shilly-shallying or the wobbling or the deceit or the change of direction there was between July and October in relation to the Government capital programme.
Let the Government stand up to their responsibilities even—and I can say this—if in doing so it makes one temporarily unpopular. The permanent record of history is worth far more. This country is sound and can be saved in spite of Fianna Fáil. Our economic problems can be solved and we can do it provided there is a proper lead. A Government can be certain that they will not get from this side of the House, the suggestions, the under-currents, the sabotage with which they were so glib when they were over here. I want to make it quite clear, as did Deputy Cosgrave, Leader of my Party, that we believe without question that these problems can be solved and we refuse to see any question of devaluation arising. There will be no suggestion by us as there was in 1956 by members of Fianna Fáil that devaluation was on the way. Devaluation is not on the way and must be rejected and if the Government are not capable of rejecting it, they should get out and make way for a Government who are.
Comment on this
In case Deputy Sweetman's strong assertion about devaluation should again raise the hare, I should say that the Taoiseach has made it clear that there is no question whatever of devaluation of the Irish currency.
Comment on this
The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption as the previous speaker was allowed to do.
Comment on this
We have listened to vague, swollen generalities and then to pious assumption of responsibility by people who would not like to rock the boat and then to the outright pillorying of members of the Government by Deputy Sweetman. In an earlier debate we heard Deputy Dillon say that we kept the knowledge from the people but we hoped to be beaten in the election. Now we hear Deputy Sweetman say that we kept the knowledge from the people because we hoped to win the election——
Comment on this
If I were to accept Deputy Sweetman's challenge and the others that were flung out, I should need to be like Cuchulainn catching all the darts in one shield. I do not feel I am up to Cuchulainn's standards and in any case I have some points to make, not alone for the House, but for the public also. We have heard the Opposition here speaking with hind-sight and many blind spots and I was tempted last night when Deputy M.J. O'Higgins was taunting us with the call "Let Lemass lead" to say: "Surely politics is a matter of alternatives, particularly at election time, and if you want to argue on that basis what was your alternative and what did you do with the alternatives afterwards"? I do not want to follow that line. I want to take up, as we intended in July, a line of seeking public co-operation and of minimum interference by the Government in the normal domestic processes while at the same time taking enough action to protect the developing and expanding economy. I do not see any sign of the disasters Deputy Sweetman seems to see.
Comment on this
The amendments to the Taoiseach's motion seem not to be at issue with the measures we have taken but rather tend to say that we have taken these measures too late. There is some element in the speeches of "too little" also.
Comment on this
My answer to that would be the same answer as that I gave in July which Deputy Sweetman missed but read afterwards. I believe that in their period of office the Opposition, in dealing with perhaps a similar situation, reacted too quickly, almost abruptly, and too much and, in justifying the naturally unwelcome aspects of their policy, created an atmosphere the consequences of which were worse, I think, than the effects of the economic situation they set out to cure.
Earlier this year when we saw the development of unwelcome trends and at the beginning of the year, before the election, the Taoiseach gave it as his view of the economic situation to the people in public that this was going to be a difficult year. There is some implication in what Deputy Sweetman says that if the people thought they were facing trouble they would not have elected this Government but would have opted for another. I cannot see any sense in that: I do not think the Deputy really believes it himself, but when we saw the trends developing we set out to let the public know that if these unwelcome trends went unchanged—increasing imports, slowing of exports, spiralling of incomes and prices, and industrial unrest, a serious situation could develop.
That serious situation could still develop but as a first step we decided that what was to be done was to alert the nation to the possibility of this occurring and to take certain measures, some very moderate which could be described as mild, on the part of the Government. These measures were in relation to hire purchase, taking powers more actively to control prices, cutting down Government expenditure and a real attempt to put whatever capital was available into productive use and reduce the spending of useful capital on unnecessary consumer material. These measures were, in a way, restrictive and much of the debate has centred on this type of measure or curb. My thinking at that time was, and still is, how positively to bring our productivity up to the level at which it could support the developments which are and have been going on in our economy. For this we need strong voluntary co-operation from the general public and from organised sectors as well as certain Government incentives.
I would like to repeat I am still convinced that the Opposition, who are now saying we are acting too late, in their time abruptly over-acted and created a chain reaction of damaging consequences. I am confident—and I think we are all agreed— that, with a fundamentally sound economy, what we need is a gradual adjustment back to the trends we can support. I am sure most people are aware that other nations with developing and developed economies are subject from time to time to the various ills of such economies and have to take such action as they think fit to protect themselves. There is no running away from responsibility, nor would I at any time claim from the Irish people that the only right we have to be in Government is that everything would go well. We are fully aware of our responsibilities. We stand to be judged not alone on how we manage our affairs in good times but how we manage them when, for various reasons, things become a bit more difficult.
The co-operation of the general public of which I spoke was mainly aimed at restraint in spending, and perhaps a diversion of spending as much as possible away from imported consumer goods. The Buy Irish campaign, which has recently become active again, is calculated to divert much of the consumer spending from imported goods to goods the manufacture of which gives employment here at home. If, by putting on the levies or taking other actions, we seem to be disappointed at the result of our call for voluntary co-operation, that is not to say we are turning away from seeking the public co-operation, as we did in July, and depending entirely on our own measures. Now, more than ever, we hope that the interest of the general public in our economic health will bring the co-operation that is so necessary.
I would not wish, by having this debate or by the imposition of recent measures, to set the stage for a situation where the individual and the State seem to be in opposition and where various individuals would try to escape with whatever they could get away with. We are a community, all dependent one upon the other. In recent years, as economic life has become more complex, the different sectors of the community have become more dependent on each other. The State is the instrument of the nation in seeking to combine all forces for the common good.
Having said that, I should like to return to the Buy Irish campaign. I am happy to see that the formers of public opinion see, as I see, the imposition of the levies not as an alternative to the Buy Irish campaign but as a new springboard for greater public response to it. In a question in the House today I was asked about the statement of a prominent man who said that the Buy Irish campaign was contrary to our movements towards competitiveness. I would like to make it clear that this is not a campaign to try to sell the goods of Irish manufacturers who are not endeavouring to be competitive. It is a campaign to promote the sale of Irish goods of equal value, competitive in price and of as good quality as the foreign article.
Comment on this
There is a consumer complaint service which is widely availed of Several hundred complaints have been handled since its inception. Apart from constituting an outlet for dissatisfaction by the consumer, it is having a salutary effect on keeping the Irish manufacturers alert to the need for maintaining quality and presenting their products in a way which can compete with international standards. It is important in relation to this campaign, and in relation to everything we do, that no short-term measure would militate against us in the long run by reducing the competitiveness of our manufacturers. They must be prepared to go out to seek markets. We depend on them. We must expect them to win markets, and that includes the home market. Many countries more powerful than we are have constant campaigns for the home product, because an exporter needs the sound basis of a home market from which to work. If other stronger countries do this to support their manufacturers, we should do the same in Ireland.
The positive side of our policy in dealing with the economic situation does not change. Much of what is good in good times is a protection in bad times. If I talk a great deal now about exports, it is because there is a more urgent need for us to export and to earn our own money. Nobody owes us a living. It is not a good idea to over-simplify economic matters. However, I see the position myself as a matter of how we earn, how we pay for what we earn and how we spend. I believe the way out of our difficulty is hard work, and perhaps more important than hard work is work to better effect. A call for hard work is never welcome, especially to people who think they are working hard enough already; but work to better effect, through better management, better equipment and better organisation, is within our reach and can raise our productivity. I think it was Swift, an Irishman, who said that the man who could raise two ears of corn and two blades of grass on the spot where only one grew before——
Comment on this
(Cavan): That sounds like one more sow, one more cow and one more acre under the plough.
Comment on this
——would deserve more from humanity and be doing more for his country than all the generations of politicians. I should like to add to Swift's definition the products of our factories, to bring him up to date, and, having done that, I would say that he has a very good definition of productivity. It is one of the troubles of our time that you find a word which explains something so adequately that it fails to sink in, but we have to get down to realising that, if we are to get more money, we will have to produce more wealth ourselves. For too long too many people have felt that the way to get more money is by charging more for what they are doing. If a commodity or a service costs, say, £1, then the way to make more money, or to earn more money, it to produce more commodities and not to charge £2 for what should cost £1. The way to production is to produce two commodities where one was produced before. Then we shall be on our way. The way of productivity is the way towards economic success and out of economic difficulties. But it is not the way that has attracted most people because it is not the way of least resistance. Up to recently people have found the way of least resistance to be the passing on of the price to the consumer. If we continue to do that, we shall price ourselves very easily out of export markets and, indeed, out of the home market, too. There is very little hope of further industrial expansion based on our small home protected market. We will have to go out and find new markets and stimulate the industrialisation process which has been going on by offering it the prospect of wider markets.
In relation to exports, I should like to say that recent years have seen a good start made by Irish manufacturers in exporting. If I, from time to time, express dissatisfaction, it is because most of our exports are done by a small number of manufacturers and a big number of manufacturers are still content with what they can do in a sheltered, protected market. These manufacturers must be made to get out of their offices and out of their businesses and go out and find markets abroad. As I say, we saw a good start in recent years. In 1964 the export of industrial manufactured goods had a value of £54 million, that is, about five times the value ten years earlier. In the first seven months of this year, exports of manufactured goods had a value of £32 million, representing an increase of £1.5 million over the corresponding period in 1964. Our industrial exports have continued to rise. What has happened now is that the pace at which they were rising has slowed down. There is a slackening in the momentum of the increase attained in recent years. The main cause of this was, I think, that £50 million worth of our exports were hit by the British temporary surcharge of 15 per cent, imposed in October last year and reduced to ten per cent in April of this year.
Government action, when this levy was imposed, and when this threat to our exports appeared, was a prompt decision to give market development grants to help to meet a proportion of the lossess incurred by our exporters. Government action at that time also involved various measures to assist diversion of exports to other markets. I think it might fairly be said now that prompt Government action at that time helped our manufacturers by enabling them to turn a difficult corner in relation to their exports. Of interest, and a welcome feature that has been referred to already, is the fact that in the first seven months of this year, while exports of manufactured goods to Britain and the Six Counties fell by £1.3 million, a six per cent drop as compared with the same period in 1964, exports of the same type of goods to other countries rose by £2.8 million, an increase of 33? per cent as compared with the first seven months in 1964.
The Dáil will remember that, to give an added incentive to the export drive in July last, which is regarded as an essential action in relation to curing our economic trends, the Government announced that firms whose total exports for the second half of this year are greater than they were in the corresponding six months of 1964 will qualify for increased market development grants in respect of their exports to Britain. It is hoped that a substantial increase in exports will result from this. I have no estimate as yet as to the probable effect of it, but I should like to announce that we have taken a decision that the increased grants will apply also where exports for the first half of 1966 exceed exports for the first half of 1965. These are the new incentives to our exporters. Once more, I should like to refer to the need for a sound base in the home market for our manufacturers so that they can face export markets with confidence.
I know it is not easy for manufacturers to win new markets, but I also know that it is not impossible. What some manufacturers can do, others can do. Since our economic survival depends on them, I am sure our manufacturers will rise to the task. There are many State encouragements which compare favourably with the aids their competitors from other countries have. I do not know if it is necessary to remind the House that the profits from increased exports are relieved from both income tax and corporation profits tax and that there is a wide variety of services provided by my Department and by Córas Tráchtála to help manufacturers find export markets. They can be helped in financing visits to new markets, in financing design programmes, consultations, participation in trade affairs, and in a big number of other ways.
The funds with which Córas Tráchtála are provided in the form of grants-in-aid from my Department have been increased from £145,000 in 1959-60 to £450,000 in the current financial year. These funds are for the purpose of helping our manufacturers to export. The growing output from our industries, both the newly-established industries and the old, the various incentives, tax and otherwise, which I have mentioned, the increased investment in advertising and sales promotion abroad, the continued improvement in products and package design are all reasons why we can be optimistic about the future of our exports of manufactured goods.
Earlier I mentioned productivity. While many of the new industries which are being set up are being set up for the export market and are geared to compete on that market, I should like to say that we must not lose sight of the fact that the main contribution to an increase in our exports must come from the old-established firms and that, to be able to compete, these firms will have to increase their efficiency and productivity. The easiest way to judge the increase in productivity is by measurement of the steps taken by firms to replace and improve their equipment. The provision of new and extended premises, new and better machinery and facilities is essential to competition in the export market. As measured by applications for grants and loans—because there are Government grants and loans towards adaptation for the purpose of this stronger competition—more than 500 industrial undertakings have embarked on adaptation programmes, involving capital expenditure of about £50 million. The State contribution towards this in respect of grants and loans approved up to 30th September of this year is about £7½ million.
The overall picture is one of widespread capital investment which I am certain will leave industry in a strong position as far as the economics of production are concerned. It is clear from the information available to me that many firms are regarding adaptation, not as a protective measure but as a way to increase their output and as a springboard for expansion in foreign markets. They take the view, and they are right, that a firm that does not go forward will ultimately decline. Many of these firms are foreign-controlled and it is encouraging to see that they are demonstrating their confidence in the future of Ireland's economy by investing considerable amounts of money in expansion and modernisation. These firms which are foreign-controlled have set a headline to our own Irish industrialists which they could emulate with advantage.
The degree of participation by firms with external associations varies from industry to industry. In some, such as the chocolate and sugar confectionery, footwear, fertiliser and electrical goods industries, firms with external associations have a dominant position while in others, such as the cotton, linen, wearing apparel, glassware, iron and steel industries, the degree of foreign participation is not significant.
In the course of their normal activity, members of the Industrial Reorganisation Branch of my Department have discussed with firms their future plans and in the case of industries where externally controlled firms hold a dominant position, most of the major companies have indicated their intention of maintaining their production here, no matter what the outcome of free trade negotiations will be and many of them have plans for expansion in circumstances of free trade.
There are indications also that several single-firm industries with external association will continue production here in the event of free trade. It is inevitable that some foreign-dominated or controlled firms would find it in such circumstances more economic to cease production here but it is reasonably certain that the most of the large firms will continue their manufacturing activities here in the event of free trade, in view of the size of the capital investment already made, the availability of labour, tax incentives and the difficulty often experienced of expanding in their own countries. I gather that the subsidiary industries or firms least likely to continue here are of the medium to small size type and do not constitute a significant proportion of the employment or output potential of our industry.
Adaptation is not, of course, a matter for individual firms taking individual action. The Committee on Industrial Organisation urged that organisations be set up called adaptation councils to sponsor the measures needed on a collective basis by different sectors of industry. These councils are State-aided by a 50 per cent grant of their administrative costs for a limited period. Similar scale grants are available to trade union advisory bodies established to facilitate consultation within the councils and the trade unions. In all, 22 adaptation councils have been established. Some of the 26 sectors of Irish industry examined were satisfied and satisfied my Department that a council would in their case serve no useful purpose.
The position about adaptation councils generally is reasonably satisfactory but their effectiveness has varied somewhat. Some have given striking evidence of what can be achieved by co-operation and others have not up to now made the progress which might have been expected. Those which have not up to now made progress will have to get down to it. Nobody can say from now on that they did not have sufficient warning or that there had been a lack of financial encouragement by the State. I should like to tell these people now that time is running out and that further delay could be fatal to their individual industries.
The imposition of the levies announced by the Minister for Finance may in the minds of some firms constitute a breathing spell or may be used as an excuse for more delay in facing up to their responsibilities to prepare for freer trade and keener competition. This is a foolish attitude and a firm that adopts it will almost certainly find itself in real trouble when these protective duties are removed. The trouble is that these firms are not alone endangering themselves but they are threatening the livelihood of their employees by their dilatory procedures and I would say to them again now to adapt before it is too late. The firms which have been taking effective measures to adapt themselves to free trade are firms which will survive and will thrive in the context of keener competition, but to them, too, I should say that they cannot afford to slacken in any way. Some firms will not survive in free trade.
We had some discussion here yesterday during Question Time about what would happen. The CIO Report on the probability—as far as it could be calculated—of the outcome of trade in relation to membership of EEC suggested that certain of our industries would not survive and that those would represent, perhaps, an employment figure of 10,000. The estimate of the same group for the new employment possibilities in the same period was 86,000, so this is the position which workers and management should prepare for. This is the position we are preparing for by developing a manpower policy. The first part of our manpower policy, or the first essential of a manpower policy, is to create new employments.
Our industrialisation is going ahead as it was in the past number of years. In the first six months of 1965, 16 new firms and extensions to existing undertakings went into production. The capital investment was not less than £10,000 in each case and the aggregate investment amounted to £6,900,000, with an employment potential rising from an initial 1,300 to 2,900 at full production. At the end of June, 1965, 47 new factories and extensions to existing ones were in course of construction. The capital investment in these new enterprises is expected to amount to £30,700,000 and the employment potential to rise from an initial 3,000 to 5,350. Many of the undertakings and extensions which went into production in the first six months of this year will make a valuable contribution soon to our economy.
A number of proposals for new projects are at present under consideration. I should like to say that the number under consideration is up to the level of any other year. A number of these relate to production for export markets. It is in the context of a continuation of this industrial development and the creation of new industrial employment that we think on our manpower policy. I think it was Deputy Cosgrave who criticised our decision not to have a Department of Labour. The imminence of freeing of trade and the immediate effects on certain industries—such as the one we discussed yesterday—make it necessary to have our manpower policy in operation as quickly as possible. The quickest way to implement it was to have an agency set up in my Department and there the Parliamentary Secretary is responsible for the development of the various types of legislation and administrative arrangements for implementing a manpower policy.
Comment on this
I did not criticise that. What I said was that the NIEC recommendation should have been adopted in preference to the inter-departmental committee one.
Comment on this
We studied both and, again, felt that this was the quickest way to deal with the problem.
Comment on this
There are so many activities which really belong to different departments. For instance, Education in the retraining of people, Social Welfare in the placing of them and Industry and Commerce in another way. There are several departments and to attempt to build all your administration in the first instance would only create delays which would be unforgivable in view of the urgency of arrangements to meet the many rapid changes which must come within the next ten or 15 years.
I would say that the development has increased with that which needed to be done and, as further staff is needed, that section of the Department of Industry and Commerce will widen. As further responsibility is taken on by that section, there could be a gradual evolution towards a separate Department of Labour. But the way we are doing it now is the quickest way to meet the needs which we foresee.
Speaking from memory, I had a question in relation to the car assembly industry yesterday and somebody across the way shouted that 20,000 people will be put out of employment. I do not know how you handle this type of shout. There are 3,600 wage earners in the car assembly industry and about 700 on the administration side—say 4,300 people in all. Some of the firms assembling are quite certain they will survive any changes which might arise out of a free trade agreement. For my part, those who will not survive I would urge to turn their factories to other uses now and I will give them any help and any facilities in respect of their present mode of living which would encourage this. I do not think there is any need for the workers to feel insecure in this industry because the projection is that new employment positions will be available. We will have a training body, training courses, retraining courses and redundancy schemes in operation so that workers will easily transfer from one employment to another in the event of their present employment being unable to survive in competition.
Comment on this
You could hardly say they were held up to exepctations as forecast in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion.
Comment on this
I do not want to get into a discussion on that now but I do not agree. I think it is essential to our industrial development, and to the establishment of new industries.
Comment on this
The Minister should be permitted to make his speech. This cross-examination is not in order.
Comment on this
I was going to talk about prices. It was our policy that in normal circumstances prices are best controlled by the free movement of commodities and we always regarded as undesirable any intervention except in very exceptional circumstances. Indeed we did not provide for such intervention until last July when we thought an economic situation might develop which would warrant intervention in this field of prices.
I would like to do a small analysis of prices, if not for the benefit of the House, at least to clear our heads as to the way the price of an article goes. I have not got any figures for our own country but I have a document from which I can make an estimate of the component parts of the prices of commodities and services. This document is an English one and in that country prices fall into three parts: money incomes, 74 per cent; imports, 16 per cent; and taxation on expenditure, ten per cent. We probably have to import more of our raw materials but if you allow ten per cent off money incomes and on to imports, you could say that 60 to 65 per cent of the cost of commodities would relate to money incomes, wages, salaries, profits, and fringe benefits, 25 to 30 per cent would be imports and ten per cent would be taxation.
If the money income percentage of prices goes up, it being the biggest component part, it will put up the price proportionately more than a percentage increase of import costs or taxation. The line of least resistance is one of the laws of human nature and up to now there has been a tendency to follow the line of least resistance when costs go up. The line of least resistance was to pass on the costs of new money incomes, fringe benefits, wages and salaries to the consumer. The consumer, finding prices dearer, in his own turn sought increased income and so whatever services and commodities were involved on his part were also increased in price. A spiral resulted. It is possible that if an article contained a sum of £10 in the income part of its components and the people making it want to get more out of it, they can do so by producing two articles. Up to now they have been doing it by charging twice the price for the one article. It is possible to improve our methods of work and our equipment so that we can have better output. Passing the increase on to the consumer is not the way to do it. That is the basis of our decision to attempt to control prices.
As well as that, there is also the competitiveness that arises if the money income is increased. Other sections of the community immediately have an expectation of an increase in their own incomes. When the Government made the order on 7th October considering that the economic situation required it, giving me certain powers for the control of prices, I set about making a Ministerial order and publishing a notice on 27th October requiring three months' advance notice by manufacturers wishing to increase their prices as well as importers and wholesalers who wish to increase their margins. These goods covered a wide range and the intention was that as far as these goods are concerned, only justifiable increases will be allowed to be passed on to the consumer.
When the levies were announced, an interpretation of them was made by the people in the trade that their margins could not be increased and, to make the matter clear, I announced that the cost of the levy would be passed on but the people passing it on such as wholesalers and retailers should not take any margin increase for themselves. I could see no justification for not passing them on because the purpose of the levy is to make the foreign-finished article more expensive here. I could see no justification for holding down the prices of foreign-finished articles. Nor could I see anybody basing a claim for an increase in salary or wages on the increased costs of non-essential foreign-finished goods.
I told Deputy O'Higgins yesterday that I had about 30 applications since the publication of that notice from various manufacturers and importers, covering a range of goods which would affect many of us in our ordinary lives. Every one of these has been held up until it is investigated. I had a great deal of departmental investigation carried out before that and applications for price increases have been refused in almost all cases. Price advisory bodies have been set up to inquire into the cost of meat and potatoes respectively and they are to report on 30th November and at the moment I am about to set up a price advisory body to hold a public inquiry into fertiliser prices.
Comment on this
While it is understood that the trader can pass on the levy, is it the case that he cannot take an extra margin? Does it follow that if he is liable for increased turnover tax on the increased price, he is entitled to offset that increase by increasing the price?
Comment on this
I will have that point cleared up. I should like to say in relation to prices that I will not hesitate to use what powers I have, and make full use of those powers, to attain price stability. Too much is at stake for us not to go at this task with every weapon we have. It is vital to our situation at present that we have price stability. I should also like to say that I would hope—and I think we could expect—to have the full co-operation of every responsible citizen in this matter.
I am sure the House would like to have information about the effect of the hire purchase curbs, the restrictions which we put on in July, but there is no real evidence yet of their effect. Other factors, particularly the request to have capital used for productive purposes, are having an effect in this market, and it is not as yet, at any rate, possible to say what effect the hire purchase restrictions we put on are having.
I set out to deal with what actions the Government have taken to deal with our economic situation, and I hope I have succeeded in taking people's minds away somewhat from solely restrictive actions, because I am very convinced that if we are to see our way through these difficulties and build on them in sounder times, it will be through work, through productivity, and through the promotion of exports. While the curbs may be necessary to reduce unnecessary spending on imports and divert capital to productive activities, they are only half the picture.
Again, when the Opposition say we acted too late, my answer is that when faced with a similar or a corresponding situation they overacted and acted too suddenly, and in justifying themselves they created an atmosphere, the consequences of which outlasted the difficulties they set out to cure.
Comment on this
The atmosphere was well created before the election in which you blamed us for creating it. I should like to refer back to the variety of voices with which Fine Gael speak, the vague generalities, the pious responsibility, the pillorying of Ministers. They spoke with many voices, but I think the public have a right to expect at election times, and other times, that they should produce an alternative. It is not enough to say we did not do something in time. They should produce some alternative which would appear more attractive and more effective than what we are doing.
Comment on this
Yesterday in his speech to the House the Taoiseach said that the amendments put down by the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party were purely politics, plain politics, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce has said more or less the same thing here this evening. We in the Labour Party make no apology for putting down the following amendment:
After the word "situation" to add the following:
"but considers that such emergency economic measures were rendered necessary mainly by the Government's previous inadequacies and failures in economic policy, particularly in the field of price control."
We think the criticism included in that amendment is very much justified. We say so, and we can substantiate it by looking back not as far as 1956—a year which has been bandied about for the past two days—but over the past two years. Let us look back at the National Wage Agreement which was negotiated—and I emphasise the word "negotiated"—and not given out by Fianna Fáil as they tried to insinuate.
Comment on this
Twelve per cent was negotiated for a period of 2½ years, and since that time—and the agreement has not yet expired—the Government have allowed prices to rise by 11 per cent. Then, some 18 months after the National Wage Agreement was concluded, they introduced price control which they stated and reiterated in the past was a heresy. They introduced it when it was too late. They introduced it when the damage was done.
In the period we are now reviewing, industrial production went up last year by some ten per cent and in the first half of this year it went up by 4½ per cent, but where did it go? Where have the fruits gone? We do not know. The workers in the factories, the shops, and elsewhere, do not know, but they want to know, and are entitled to know, and are entitled to be told by the Government who brought about the situation which now confronts us, and which we are now discussing. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions want to know. They are at the moment carrying on discussions which were found necessary in view of the situation which was allowed by the Government to develop by their refusal to introduce price control at a time when it could have been effective, could have done some good, and could have saved us from the situation in which we now find ourselves.
One wonders what is the motivation for the Government's action? One wonders are they trying to sabotage the talks going on at the moment between employer and labour representatives? I do not think the political acrobatics in which Government spokesmen have been indulging recently will deter the ordinary workers from seeking their just rights. I do not think, if it is the intention of the Government to sabotage these talks, that they will be successful and that the workers are just going to sit back and do nothing after waiting for approximately two and a half years with their 12 per cent.
During this debate several speakers have referred to an incomes policy. We in the Labour Party have always accepted the need for and the desirability of an incomes policy. This is not something to which we have been lately converted and it is not—and I think this should be said—something that was thought up by Fine Gael, although they are claiming it now as if it were their brainchild. This is something that has been advocated by Labour representatives for a long time. When we hear new converts talking about an incomes policy, we wonder just how sincere they are and just what do they mean. Do they mean all incomes? We are inclined to doubt it. If an incomes policy were devised and put before this House, we would be very interested to see just where the support would come from for such a policy if it were to affect, as it would have to affect if it were an incomes policy, not only wages and salaries but profits, dividends, professional earnings and so on. We are inclined to think Fine Gael are perhaps talking with their tongue in their cheek to some extent when they talk about an incomes policy. If we are wrong, we are glad that we have managed to convert other Parties to the desirability of an incomes policy.
Before the last general election, everything was beautiful, according to Fianna Fáil spokesmen. There was no need for the country to worry; there was no sign of the country being in the situation in which we now find ourselves, just six months later. It has been stated by the Minister for Industry and Commerce that Deputy Dillon made one statement about what motivated the Government's silence and that Deputy Sweetman made another statement, but I do not think it is hard to see at this stage what motivated them. They were not quite sure whether they would get back into power, and if they did not get back into power, was this not a lovely situation to hand over to someone?
Comment on this
And if they did, as they hoped to, it would not have been very profitable to tell the people what the indications so far as——
Comment on this
They are saying now that we did not even see the indications, did not foresee the situation in March.
Comment on this
If you won, this had only happened and if you lost, then somebody else could clean up the mess. That is my interpretation of the situation. The facts were, and must have been, known to the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Government as a whole.
To go back for a moment to the question of an incomes policy, I have said that the labour movement, both the political labour movement and the industrial labour movement, would support and accept a true incomes policy but it is only fair to say that they will not accept an incomes policy imposed on them by this or any other Government, or accept any policy that will interfere with the free, collective bargaining system we have.
We all know the record of Fianna Fáil in regard to standstill orders. We can look back to the war years and at the other attempt made in 1947. There was another "go" when we had Closing the Gap and then more recently we have had this suggestion about setting up the tribunal in relation to civil servants and semi-State workers. We all know Fianna Fáil's attitude in regard to free, collective bargaining and we know that if they think they can get away with it, they will impose another standstill. However, even at this stage I think they realise that it would not be too easy to get away with it, although very obviously they are chopping around the edges. I doubt if they would be foolish enough to make a real attempt because I can tell them it would not be accepted by the ordinary workers.
When the Minister for Industry and Commerce was speaking, he referred to the Buy Irish campaign and said we should all encourage people to buy home-produced products. We agree, and every Party in this House has lent support in every way possible to that campaign, but one wonders what the Government are at when one discovers that over the past two weeks members of the Government replying to Parliamentary Questions have had to state that post boxes, mail bags, baths and pipes, to mention but a few items which were bought by Government Departments, were bought outside the country, despite the fact that they were obtainable here and that Irish firms tendered for their supply to the Departments. One wonders how serious are the Government.
The Minister mentioned manpower policy and said that one of the first things that must be done is to find new jobs. He went on to say that workers who might be affected by the advent of free trade need not feel at all insecure, that they had nothing to worry about as the Government had this position under review and were instituting all sorts of schemes to provide alternative new employment, with particular reference to the people in the car industry. It is not too reassuring for Irish workers, faced with redundancy through the direct action of this Government, to look over the record and see how far short the Government have fallen of their Second Programme for Economic Expansion in the provision of new employment. It is not too reassuring to go back and find that each year over the past four or five years only 1,000 new jobs have been provided and it is necessary, in order to reach the Government's target, to provide 15,000 jobs per year from now until 1970. Does the Taoiseach at this stage really believe this can be achieved? Yet, Irish workers are supposed to be assured and not feel the least insecurity because the Government have taken action.
On the question of grants being paid to people coming in here to establish new industries, I understand that the amounts of these grants are related to some extent to the amount of employment these firms will provide. I do not think it is news to anybody that the experience in regard to employment by new industries has been anything but satisfactory. They expected to do this and that, but the fact remains that in the vast majority of cases, if not in all, the employment they proposed to give when seeking the grant and getting it, never materialised. This has been going on wholesale for many years and that is another reason, I suppose, why Irish workers facing redundancy should not feel insecure: the Government will look after them.
We now have a situation in which negotiations for free trade between Great Britain and ourselves are taking place and nobody in the House, except a chosen few members of the Government, knows what is going on in the negotiations or what will be the result of what we are seeking in regard to free trade between ourselves and Britain. The Government do not see fit to take the House into its confidence and inform them, as they are entitled to be informed, about negotiations that could, and will have very far-reaching effects on every man, woman and child in the country. There is speculation by the ordinary people, by Deputies, by organisations of farmers and workers and by all sorts of organisations in regard to what the outcome will be and what the Government are at, but we are not told. One speculation is that while it would appear reasonably sure that the agricultural community will be looked after, the industrial section will pay the price. I do not think an agreement having that effect, if it has that effect, would be acceptable. I can assure the House it would not be acceptable to members of the Labour Party. If the Government think they can sacrifice one section of the community for the betterment of others, they have another think coming. They will be bitterly opposed by the Labour Deputies.
At this stage everyone is being urged to pull his weight. The country is in a bad way and everyone must now rally round the flag. We agree. It is our intention as it always has been —and our record shows that—to do what is necessary or to support the Government in any action they consider necessary to try to rectify this situation. We are prepared to do that but we say: Fianna Fáil brought about this mess. They alone are responsible as the Government, and must accept responsibility for our present situation. They know they can appeal to the patriotism and sense of responsibility of Deputies in Opposition and they will undoubtedly get support for whatever measures are necessary to rectify the position but they are still answerable to the people of the country for the situation they have brought about, and that is something they cannot escape.
Comment on this
It would be wholly wrong for anyone to minimise the economic crisis in which the country now finds itself. I emphatically endorse the words of the Taoiseach which he has used on two separate occasions here warning the people that we are involved in an economic crisis of the first magnitude. On both occasions, he has taken the precaution of sending in the Minister for Industry and Commerce on the following day to apply soothing syrup and that Minister, by his own claim, is a past master of that art. But the Taoiseach is the person who counts in this Government and his estimate of the situation is correct. We are faced with the gravest economic crisis the country has faced since the Economic War, but there is this difference: we entered on the trial of the Economic War sustained by the reserves so prudently marshalled by the Cosgrave administration: we enter this crisis on bare boards and let the House recall that for the first time in our history we have mobilised the last reserves of the Central Bank. That has never happened before.
The less experienced Members of this House and of the public may not realise that the forced loan on the joint stock banks negotiated by the Government some months ago of the order of £20 million was in fact the mobilisation of the free reserves of the Central Bank, because we had nowhere else to turn for the money required to insulate the economy from imminent collapse. Since then, we have had recourse to borrowing abroad £7 million sterling to meet a deficit in our balance of payments of £50 million sterling. Let us not underestimate the quality or magnitude of the economic crisis which confronts our people at present.
The people are going to ask these questions: first, how did this economic crisis come upon us? Secondly, why did this economic crisis come upon us? Thirdly, what will it involve for us all? Fourthly, what should be done now? I speak only for myself but I am going to try to answer those questions as honestly as I can.
I can charge myself with no responsibility for leaving the people unprepared as to the inevitable results of what this Government were doing for the past 18 months. I think I can claim, as Leader of the Opposition over the past few years, that beginning in Naas Town Hall on 9th January, 1964, in the course of the Kildare by-election; in my own constituency; at the Árd Fheis; in the Roscommon by-election, and in the general election culminating on 25th March last, on 15 occasions I warned the people that Fianna Fáil were marching them into the ground and that, if their policies continued, we would be faced with an acute economic crisis which would strike at the livelihood of every employed man and woman in this country.
Now, I propose to recapitulate the answer to the question: how did it happen? What brought this about? The people are entitled to know. I say this was brought about by the thrice-accursed decision of the Fianna Fáil Government to enact the turnover tax. I told them in the Dublin by-election that, if that tax were enacted, there would flow from it consequences disastrous for this country. The people of North-East Dublin accepted that estimate, emphatically rejected the tax and returned Deputy Belton to this House in a constituency represented by the present Minister for Agriculture and the Minister for Education, which boasted of having the best Fianna Fáil organisation in the country.
Then we had the Kildare by-election. It is a grave charge to make —I make it deliberately—I say in the Kildare and Cork by-elections the present Taoiseach made up his mind it was requisite to save his political fortunes to practise a confidence trick on the electorate of this country. I concede that, in spite of my warnings throughout these by-elections, his confidence trick succeeded admirably and he won them both by fraud. Let us say what we like, Deputy Cluskey rightly says that the 12 per cent increase in wages was the result of negotiations between the trade union and employer organisations, but the Fianna Fáil Party made the case in the country that it was a benefaction from their hands. I heard the case made in the Kildare by-election: who would vote for Norton? Is it not Lemass is splashing the money around? You may regard that as clever and cute. I suppose it is. But it degrades the standards of public life of this country.
Comment on this
I am saying Fianna Fáil made a fraudulent claim that they were the dispensers of this benefaction. Listen, I will make my speech here, whether the Minister for Agriculture interrupts me or not. I will say what I intend to say.
That fraud came off, but the truth remains that, so long as you were faced with the combination of rising prices, a rise in the adverse trade balance and a rise in the adverse balance of payments, we had before us evidence as clear as crystal that we were in an inflationary spiral and that there was imminent danger not only to the economic but to the political survival of this country as an independent entity. Do not forget, and some of the less sophisticated members of the Fianna Fáil Party ought not to forget, that General de Gaulle perceives what the natural consequences of the EEC are. Certain degrees of economic integration carry with them political over-tones. It is one thing to become a member of a united Europe with a large quasi-federal body of equal partners. Think what it means establishing a Common Market between partners who have no pretensions to equality at all.
I want to answer the question, if my diagnosis of how this came about is right, why did it come about? Why did Fianna Fáil plunge down the precipice of inflation and land us where we are today? It is a reasonable question for any ordinary man or woman up and down the country to ask and to expect an answer from those they trust. To those who trust me—and they are not an inconsiderable number—I want to provide an answer and, to my mind, it is a shocking answer. It is an answer I am ashamed of.
It was with deliberation that I described this Government as a gambler's Government led by a gambler. Any of us with experience of life know that there is some element of romance about a gambler, always provided he gambles with his own money. But when a trustee begins to use the funds of which he is the trustee to gamble at the expense of those who trust him and loses, he is ordinarily described as an embezzler. I charge this Government with gambling with the fundamental interests of the Irish people and, having lost, they are deserving of the same fate as any other trustee who betrays his trust, that of the embezzler. It is a beastly thing to see a Government in whom the people have placed their confidence betray them, for any reason. I charge this Government, deliberately and publicly, with betraying them for the basest reason of all.
Deputy Sweetman may have his views and Deputy Cluskey may have his. I will give mine. I believe that the present leader of this Government came to the conclusion, after the Roscommon and Galway by-elections, that his confidence trick on Kildare and Cork could not be repeated. He judged that he was going to be beaten in the general election which could not long be postponed. He spent everything he could lay his hands on; he borrowed wherever he could borrow; he entered into commitments of a gargantuan kind, manifestly beyond his capacity to meet, and he entered the general election, believing he would be beaten and his place taken by an inter-Party Government. In that belief he was right until Deputy Corish spoke at Tullamore. That ended that and threw the victory back into the Taoiseach's hands. His purpose was to go out of office and leave us to deal with the mess he now faces so inevitably, which was there and concealed by him from our people. The purpose was to return to office and, in the credit that he had falsely claimed, to pass on the office he now occupies to his son-in-law, the Minister for Agriculture. That is true: crudely put, but true.
Comment on this
That is true, crudely put. I said, Sir, when I commenced, that the people of this country were entitled to ask: How did it happen? Why did it happen? I am answering these queries——
Comment on this
——and they do not like to hear it. And I do not like to say it because, whatever the truth is, the Taoiseach is the head of an Irish Government. It is our Government. It is the Government our people chose. They are ruling this country by the authority of God. It is something we ought to be proud of; and what revolts me is that I have to make such an indictment in public of our own Government. It is something of which I am ashamed. It is something of which I think everybody in this country has every right to be ashamed. When I see the situation into which we have now drifted, and when I hear the Taoiseach of this State tell us that our economic plight is such that we must cut back, I am ashamed. Cut back on what? We must cut back on education. We must cut back on health. We know by our own experience that we are cutting back on housing because the man who wants to borrow the money to buy or build his house today cannot get it.
Comment on this
Wait a minute. I want to ask the House, and the Taoiseach, and the Minister for Agriculture if this be true: does this not represent a nation eating its own seed corn without regard to the harvest of the future? If we are to deny our people education, if we are to deny our people the essential health services we are all agreed they ought to have, if we deprive them of the housing that we believe distinguishes a decent society from a deprived society, are we not creating a future for our people which can only be described as that of a nation gone mad enough to eat its seed corn? Remember, this is certain. In the world into which we are passing, nolens volens, there is no room anywhere for an unskilled labouring man. Whether or not Fianna Fáil intend to drive another quarter of a million of our people abroad, can anyone believe them to be so cynical and so ruthless as to resolve that those people are going to be driven out, uneducated, as unskilled labourers into a labour market where they cannot even command the lowest living wage?
I am ashamed to have to say these things in an Irish Parliament. I am ashamed that the world should see us reduced to such a level. But these facts are true, and they are shocking facts. Deputy Cluskey is shocked that we should compare today with 1956. Only a fool does not learn by experience. We did run into difficulties in 1956. Why? Because we had a good Minister for Local Government in the late Deputy Michael Keyes. I glory that he ran us into difficulties. He built too many houses, and he went on building, and there were many of us in the Government, Deputy Sweetman included, who said that was the cause, but we would not withhold money from it. We spent too much and we built too many houses. We did get into difficulties and, to the eternal credit of those splendid colleagues, when they saw the danger that now confronts at this hour threatening the working man of this country, they said: "Whatever the unpopularity, we will never face the danger of mass unemployment. We will stand up to whatever steps are necessary to restore equilibrium in the balance of payments because we know we have colleagues who will stand by us until the ship is back on an even keel".
Just as the Labour Government in Great Britain at the present time, inheriting from the Tories a storm-tossed ship, shaken to its foundations, turned to their supporters and asked for their confidence to get the ship back on an even keel so that they can sail on to the objectives they have before them, so we asked our colleagues in the inter-Party Government to judge us by our performance as their colleagues. They trusted us, and they were right, because within one 12 months we produced out of our difficulties in 1956 the first favourable balance of payments of £12 million, the first recorded since the State was founded. I know what we had to do was harsh. I know it was stiff. I know it was resolute, but it meant that we had then the resources to resume the expansion we had engaged on. Remember, too, that in our first Government we were putting men into employment at the rate of 1,000 men a month.
Comment on this
When I hear people allege that the late Deputy Norton, or the late Deputy Keyes, or the late Deputy Tim Murphy failed in their trust, I look back with pride on men who were faithful to their trust and compare them with—I used the word; was it too strong?—the rabble who bear a similar burden today and who so shamelessly betrayed the people who trusted them. I am proud of the things we did and, having swung back resolutely, as we did, we handed over to the present Taoiseach, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce——
Comment on this
We handed over a State where we had kept the people at home, where the people trusted us that we would find employment for them again as we had done before at the rate of 1,000 per month. Fianna Fáil came in and solved the problem. They shipped 300,000 abroad. If we had done that, we would have had no 97,000 unemployed. We would have had a shortage of 200,000. They stayed at home. In 1957, 1958 and 1959, they went away.
Let us not forget the lessons we learned. I agree that it is the future that matters but only a fool faces the future indifferent to the past. We should learn from the past, not only by the wisdom that is there available but by the mistakes that were then made. We made a mistake but I say quite openly it is a mistake that I am proud of. We built too many houses and, as the Taoiseach told us, when he came into office and sent for Dublin Corporation and asked them what was their housing programme, they said they had too many houses, 1,500 houses with no one to go into them.
Comment on this
Listen to them. We had 1,500 houses with no one to go into them. If that was the cause of our difficulties, I glory in it because, added to that, we had the complications of Suez and the complications of other international events. I do not deny that the Taoiseach has had to face the problems of the post-Tory period in England, with England trying to redress her balance of payments. He has the problem of the post-election situation in the United States of America where they are trying to redress their balance of payments. That is impinging on us. But do Deputies not remember that in this House, speaking from that Front Bench, I said to him: "Remember, at the present moment in England there is inflation going on with the Tories trying to win the election and to persuade the people to reject the Labour Party," that I said to him: "Do you not realise there is inflation going on in the United States of America with the Democratic Party seeking to secure the suffrage of the American people? Do you not realise that there is going to be a situation immediately after these two countries have passed the elections in which there will be retrenchment to the left of us and retrenchment to the right of us? What plans have we to meet that situation?" and the answer was that he did not believe me? I do not deny that he has that difficulty to handle. I do not deny that that has exacerbated the difficulties with which he is at present struggling but I do charge him that he concealed it from the people for the base ulterior motive I have described and, worst of all, that when he finds himself confronted with the situation, we have the degrading spectacle of his not knowing from hour to hour or from day to day what he ought to do.
Comment on this
I want to point out to the Taoiseach the deplorable effect it creates upon the morale of the people when his Government declare on a Monday that the 15 per cent levies are not to be passed on and on Wednesday issue a statement that, of course, they are to be passed on. I can imagine that kind of lack of co-ordination existing between Departments but I want to warn him that that kind of lack of co-ordination and atmosphere of confusion in the central Government is calculated to persuade the people of what I am desperately afraid may be true, that you do not know what you are doing, that you are staggering about from one frantic effort to another.
I want to warn the House again that the 15 per cent levy with the ten per cent preferential rate is not going to correct the balance of payments problem with which we are at present confronted. It is a nice choice whether when you deal with a situation of this kind, you grasp the nettle firmly, do what has to be done and have done with it, or whether you keep piling Pelion upon Ossa until the people abandon all hope of finality of disruption of their daily lives. I think we will find by experience that the business of loading one fatuous remedy on top of another does infinitely more damage than a resolute approach and a frank admission of the gravity of the situation with which we have to deal. I am certain of this: you may deceive some of the more unsophisticated members of the Taoiseach's Party but you do not deceive those who look at this country from abroad.
Comment on this
You do not deceive those on whose judgment this country now for the first time has so heavily to depend. I am 30 years a Member of this House, in Government and out of Government. I have never known any period during that 30 years or, indeed, watching politics during the ten years that went before that, when this country was not in a position to say that they did not give a damn what the bankers in Zurich thought of Ireland, we could do as we pleased here and we had the means to say to anybody: "If you want to speculate against our currency, go and speculate." We could beat the wealthiest consortium of bankers in the world and, signs on it, down through these 40 years the British currency was speculated against, the French currency was speculated against, the currency of practically every great nation in the world was speculated against, but at no time did any Government of this country have to feel the apprehension that our esteem would decline in the eyes of international bankers anywhere. Can we say that now? When we go borrowing, whether it is in New York or in Zurich, what sort of questions do we have to answer?
I was present at a meeting of FAO to which Mr. Eugene Black, President of the World Bank, expounded the doctrine on which the World Bank was founded. His explanation of it involved this peroration: he said "Our purpose is to help; we want to help everyone but of course I want to make this clear—we are a responsible body and we are not going into any country to offer them help unless they give us an adequate undertaking to use that help as we think it can best be used." I remember a great many agricultural Ministers there applauding Mr. Black and thanking Mr. Black and saying what a benediction Mr. Black and his bank were, and then I struck a discordant note. I said: "Mr. Black, are you seriously proposing to me that the Irish Government should express its indebtedness to you for offering to buy from us with your loans what seven centuries of fire and sword would never make us concede to the British Government? Because, if these are the terms on which your loans are to be made, I want to tell you that decisions on our social policy and our economic policy are made in Oireachtas Éireann and we do not give two god-damns what Mr. Black thinks." I was thought to be a very unruly citizen. Was I right?
Comment on this
I represented a sovereign Government and I recognised the right of no external power, whether it was based in London, Paris, New York or Zurich, to come in and tell us how we should run our own country. Remember that when I spoke, I spoke in the full knowledge that I had behind me the resources so to say to Mr. Black. Can we say the same today?
Comment on this
To give every man his due, we survived five years of Economic War on the resources of Mr. Cosgrave, the present Party Leader's father. We then accumulated great reserves during the war and I do not deny that we came into office in 1948 at a time when expansion and development were relatively easy. All I am saying is this: I was in a position to take up that attitude ten short years ago. Can we say the same today? If we cannot, is it not time we pulled up our socks and began to consider our situation?
I remember a great deal more of that period, in which we were able to improve social services, reduce taxes and develop industry, but I agree with Deputy Cluskey that to go into the past in too great detail is a fruitless exercise. At the same time, I think there were lessons to be learned and, so long as I am here, they are lessons I glory in recapitulating and none more glorious than that we ran ourselves into difficultes building too many houses.
I want to ask the House have they considered this question because the people will ask it. When we have answered the question of how, when we have answered the question of why, the people will then ask us: "What do you mean when you talk of the country being faced with an economic catastrophe?" We have all heard this question: "What do you mean when you say the country is going bust? The country is always going bust and yet nothing seems to be happening." I want to tell them, and I want to tell them on the authority of the Taoiseach, the Head of the present Government, that this is what "going bust" means. I think the Taoiseach speaks truly, and I endorse his remarks when he says that any rumours current elsewhere that the currency of this country was to be devalued were groundless and false. I know this Party and, I believe, the Labour Party—unless they have taken leave of their senses—will throw themselves a hundred per cent behind any Irish Government in resolving the position, albeit, the steps they have already taken seem to me to be inadequate, but, as the situation evolves, they will take further steps and then the currency will come through unscathed and intact.
But I say you are moving this country into a situation which I call "going bust", which means either devaluation or the physical control of imports. Now the Taoiseach goes on to say—rightly, in my judgment —"I rule out devaluation; now we must turn to the control of imports". Right—in that he is perfectly right— but he goes further. He says: "That is not enough; that is only a curing symptom, holding the line until the real remedial measures have time to operate". That means cutting down on capital outlay and postponing—now that is a nice long word—"postponing"—certain things we hoped to do in the spheres of education and health. That is what "going bust" means. Do not let us laugh at it because, remember, when you go slow and postpone education, remember what that means. It means to say to one generation of children, one group of youngsters who are now 15 and, in three years' time, will be 18: "You are going to go for the rest of your lives of three score and ten without the education you ought to have had". They will never get it. Do not let us forget that. Each one of them will go through life without the education he ought to have had. Do not forget, in the world in which we live at the present time, what that means to each of them. Take any one of us who is sending his children to secondary schools because we have the means to send them. Imagine if you took your own child from school at 14 and gave him no secondary education at all, closed the door to university and told him that he would have to make a way as best he could. That is what we are saying to thousands of our neighbours up and down the country and it is a horrible thing. There are thousands of people in this country who will now have to take the decision that their children will never get the secondary education or the vocational education which will equip them to develop to the full the gifts God gave them. That is one of the consequences of "going bust".
We will postpone the health services. There is none of us here in this House who, if he is ill, cannot go and get the remedy and pay for it—not one of us. But there are people in the next three years who will become crippled for the rest of their lives because we have decided it is necessary to postpone certain medical facilities we had hoped to make available. That is what "going bust" means.
Comment on this
It does not mean the country stops; it does not mean that Ireland sinks into the sea. It means that thousands of our neighbours will suffer irreparable harm and, at the end of their lives, they will feel the consequences of this Government having brought us where we are. They should be ashamed to admit that to the nation, if they know what shame means.
The Minister for Agriculture is here. I do not quite know the reason for the collapse in cattle prices at the present time but this debate has so far proceeded almost on the assumption that our society consists exclusively of industrialists and industrial workers. The industry which employs most people in this country is agriculture. In the past three months the small farmers of Monaghan, Cavan, Donegal and the west of Ireland have lost in the price of cattle more than they collected in the heifer subsidy. That is a shocking thing to realise. Farming on the small farms of Ireland is hard work and very few Dublin Deputies believe or understand that farming on the small farms in rural Ireland means not a four-day week, or a five-day week or even a six-day week but a seven-day week, day in, day out, year after year. If you keep pigs or cows that have to be milked seven days a week twice a day, there is no escape from it for yourself or any member of your family who is grown up enough to do the work. I want to remind the Minister for Agriculture, and I live among the farmers and I represent them, that the wave of disillusionment that has swept over the congested areas of Ireland in the past six months appals me. And the burden has fallen most heavily on the small farmers who produce cattle and sell them young.
I know dozens of farmers who bought cattle last April and May, who took land and paid too much for it, and who with the failure of the grass before the autumn have had to sell those cattle and take £5 a head less for them than they paid. And then they have to pay the rent.