We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Economic Situation.

Contributions 120–241 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Not at all.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins knows as much about the congested areas as my foot. This is a result of the ill-conceived scheme of the Minister's predecessor in office, Deputy Smith. I know he was doing his best but everything went against him and the weather went against him. The fact that we have had no growth of grass from the end of August to this day has greatly complicated the problem. The small farmers of the west of Ireland have had to face cruel disillusionment and they now have an immensely heavy burden to bear. For some reason that I do not understand, there has been a very heavy fall in the price of bonhams. The increase in the price of meal consequent on the increase in the price of barley given last year has driven a lot of people out of pig rearing. That surprises me.

With the spead of the creamery industry throughout the west, I expected that the availability of milk, plus the availability of meal, would make the feeding of pigs more popular but I saw bonhams sold for £7 a pair a fortnight ago. I have not seen them as cheap as that for a long time. They have been from £10 to £12 a pair. I am speaking now about the ten weeks' old pig and I am repeating these facts so that the House may remember that it is not only the industrial workers and the industrialists who are living in a state of acute anxiety and difficulties. The small farmers are also suffering acutely today.

The question which any man is now entitled to address to Deputy Cosgrave or myself is: "Now that you have told us the story, what do you think we ought to do?" The duty is on me to answer that question to the best of my ability and I want to say, quite honestly and without making a smart answer to anybody, that the only solution is to get rid of the Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

I thought that would be what you would say.

Comment on this

I want to give my reasons for that. No one can prescribe the true remedy for the present economic crisis unless he is in full possession of the facts. As Deputy Sweetman said today, nobody who is not in the Government has access to the true facts. Every public statement made by members of this Government on the economic situation or the economic prospects have been proven in the event to be false. I would not believe the Gospel from their lips today. I believe that on every occasion they will tell us what is not true. I know they did not tell the truth in the past and I have no reason for believing that they will tell it in the future.

I will conclude by telling the people what the remedy is but before I do so, I want to say that I am grateful to Deputy Collins for giving me the opportunity of placing on record this fact: I am speaking from this seat by my own will and desire, by my own irrevocable decision. Some people may think that is right; some may think it is wrong. I am here because, in my judgment, this is the right place for me to be and my colleagues in my Party accepted my judgment on that matter as on many others, and I think they were perfectly right. I think they were fortunate in having at their disposal so able and suitable a successor as Deputy Liam Cosgrave. This is the last time I will advert to that matter in this House.

Comment on this

A mutual admiration society.

Comment on this

My answer to the people's problem is to get rid of Fianna Fáil and we can put our hands to the task without delay. There is available a weapon to wipe them out and it is for us to show whether we are fit to use it. We have the local elections in June and if we can inflict upon them the kind of defeat we ought to be able to inflict upon them, we will have them out before the end of that year and will have Deputy Liam Cosgrave as Taoiseach of a new Government. There is only one remedy for the present situation, that is, to put that gang out and put in a Government of honest men.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about your Ard-Fheis?

Comment on this

Never mind about our Ard-Fheis. Your Ard-Fheis is due next week and if two or three of you do not suffocate from swallowing your own words, it will be the eighth wonder of the world. I do not want to hit that Deputy over there too hard. He is new here and I do not want to hurt his feelings but every time I see him, I am inclined to answer him as if he were an old, hard nail. The only chance this country has is to get a Government of honest men. That Government will be faced with very formidable difficulties that they will inherit from this Government, but by telling the people the truth, and by resolutely undertaking what requires to be done, they can salvage this country from the crisis and the disastrous mess into which it has been led by Fianna Fáil. I wish I could say and believe that I think Fianna Fáil have been honestly doing their best. I am sorry to say I cannot. I believe we are in the mess we are in because of the strange, almost daft, obsession on the part of the Taoiseach to pass on to his son-in-law the post he at present occupies.

Comment on this

You are ruining me.

Comment on this

I would not want to do that. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is a highly intelligent young man. I would not wish to ruin him, but I would wish to reform him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think it arises in this debate.

Comment on this

His interjection made me express solicitude for his future. The difference is that I proclaim it in public and his colleagues do it behind closed doors. Here is the solution, and I know of no other. I have sought faithfully to put myself questions in public which I believe the people want answered, and to give them in public and in the presence of my critics, not at a dinner or a dog fight, my answers to those questions. I challenge a pretty adroit performer, who sometimes I suspect is more adroit than honest, to deploy the best resources he has to answer me if he dares.

Comment on this
Charles J. Haughey Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Haughey) Fianna Fáil

I think we can all agree that that was a magnificent performance, but what connection it had with reality escapes me, at any rate. There is a central riddle, it seems to me, which is emerging.

Comment on this

The Minister is clearing the House.

Comment on this

I know. Burke used to be called the dinner bell of the House of Commons. I must be the tea bell of the Dáil.

Comment on this

It is having the same effect behind the Minister.

Comment on this

The riddle is: was the ninth round wage agreement, the famous 12 per cent agreement, a bargain freely negotiated between the trade union movement and the employers as Deputy Cluskey said, or was it a confidence trick produced by the Fianna Fáil Government as Deputy Dillon suggested?

I submit to the House that it cannot be both. If it was a freely negotiated agreement between those two independent parties, it cannot be a confidence trick by the Government. If the Fianna Fáil Government at that time were so full of chicanery, and so activated by base motives of self-interest, that they were prepared to seek popularity by foisting a wages agreement on the Irish people which they should not have done, could they be the same Government who deliberately went out and sought unpopularity by imposing the turnover tax? This seems to be an extraordinary situation. Here, on the one hand, we have this Government who apparently sought popularity at all costs by, as Deputy Dillon suggested, buying votes through squandering the national resources, and who at the same time went out and brought on themselves a wave of unpopularity such as this country has rarely seen by imposing an iniquitous tax on the people. I wish some speaker who comes after me would solve that riddle for me.

Comment on this

Why did the Minister not mention Paul Singer—another of their friends?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I want to put him on the right track.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce have dealt at some length with the economic and fiscal situation and the plans which this Government have to deal with it. I think, therefore, that my contribution to this debate should be concerned mainly with the two great industries for which I have special responsibility, their present position and prospects, and the part which we hope they will play in our plans for the future. I refer, of course, to the industries of agriculture and fisheries.

While it is true that fairly steady progress has been made in recent years in the development of our sea and inland fisheries, I believe that the full potential of the industry, either from the point of view of production or consumption, has not yet by any means been realised. I think that is particularly true on the sea fisheries side. At present there are some 1,700 men employed in sea fishing in a full time capacity. In addition, there are about 4,000 persons engaged on a part-time basis, most of whom are farmers or members of farm families. The annual value of sea fish landings is somewhere in the region of £1½ million. Exports of all fish, including salmon, are valued at approximately £2 million per annum, a not insubstantial sum.

An Bord Iascaigh Mhara, in collaboration with my Department, have recently been carrying out a detailed study of our sea fishing industry and I have every hope that a more intensive development of the industry along modern lines will be shown in the years ahead and will bring about a marked improvement in terms of increased employment, greater landings, and particularly in a higher level of exports. All of this, we hope, will make a significant contribution to the economic growth especially in localities where other types of economic development present serious problems. It is my intention to press ahead as vigorously as possible with this development programme which will parallel in the fisheries sphere the agricultural expansion programme.

Events, I think, have shown quite clearly the importance of agriculture in general and of our cattle population and cattle products in particular in relation to our balance of payments. Deputies know that what is often referred to as the import content of agricultural exports is low, a factor which increases their impact on our balance of payments. We have a record number of cattle and sheep now on our farms and a record number of breeding stock. The census for June, 1965, showed that cattle numbers had reached a record level of 5.3 million, or 7½ per cent higher than in 1964. Cow numbers increased by 137,000; cattle under one year, by 134,000; cattle over one year, by 106,000. Sheep numbers topped the 5 million mark for the first time.

Comment on this

Deputy Coogan does not want to hear encouraging statistics of this sort.

Comment on this

They are selling at £15 apiece less.

Comment on this

Nonsense. In 1964 the number of cattle exported—and as Deputies know this figure fluctuates from year to year—rose very substantially and prices were much higher than in previous years. In the present year, however, cattle on the average, for a variety of reasons, are of a younger age and including increased retentions for breeding, many more cattle apparently are staying on the farms. The revival in cattle exports which we expected in the second half of this year has not happened, at least it has not happened to the extent we hoped for. However, the cattle are there on the farms and in vastly increased numbers and they will certainly be exported in 1966, if not in this year.

Deputy Dillon mentioned that some of our farmers have been hit by the fall in cattle prices. I agree that that is so and that unfortunately that has happened but we have acted to the best of our ability to help in that situation. As Deputies know, the beef guarantee scheme which we introduced earlier this year to underpin the cattle trade has been extended to June of next year and that should have the effect—we hope it will—of enabling farmers to go ahead this winter and feed cattle secure in the knowledge that they will have a remunerative price for them when they come to dispose of them.

Milk production and income from milk have continued the steady upward trend of recent years and exports continue to expand. Last year deliveries of milk to the creameries was 7.4 per cent higher than the previous year. This year supplies to the creameries are running at nine per cent higher than last year. The value to farmers of milk delivered to the creameries rose from £31½ million in 1963 to £37 million in 1964 and we estimate that it will be at least £40 million this year. It seems clear, therefore, that agriculture is now geared for an expansion of output, exports and income, for the next few years——

Comment on this

Tell us about the tillage position?

Comment on this

——though prices obtainable for our products and access to markets are still a constant source of anxiety to us. We would like, and all Deputies I think will agree with this, to solve our balance of payments problem by increasing exports and by balancing at a higher level of trade. This is clearly the right solution in the long run. Recently, with this end in view, at the request of the Government, I inaugurated a series of meetings with agricultural and fishery organisations and exporters and discussed with them possible ways in which agriculture and fisheries might make some extra contribution towards solving our present difficulties. It was clear from these discussions which I had—and they were on a very broad basis—that there are very real prospects for an expansion but special attention will have to be paid to marketing arrangements at every level. In the tightly controlled world around us, where a variety of protective devices of all sorts exists on every side, we cannot afford to leave anything to chance or be haphazard in our approach. We must make every effort at Government level to protect our legitimate interests and at trade level to exploit in a consistent, determined and scientific fashion every opening available to us.

The decline in tillage has, very serious effects on our balance of payments position. We had a substantial bill to pay for imports of cereals and sugar in 1964. At the beginning of 1965 I increased the price for wheat and barley and the price for sugar beet was also substantially increased. Despite these increases, however, there has been a further drop in the tillage acreage——

Comment on this

Twelve per cent in wheat.

Comment on this

——and also a poor wheat crop. I am afraid we are likely to be faced with an even bigger bill for imports in 1965-66 when we can ill-afford it. This is a very real problem and a very serious one and one to which I have given a great deal of study. It is one which I have discussed time and again with farmers' organisations and representatives and I want to admit frankly that I do not know what the answer is. I will be very happy to accept any constructive suggestion which any Deputy in the House puts forward.

I was told that a very important factor bearing on the decision of farmers whether or not to grow wheat was the question of marketing arrangements. After some considerable trouble we succeeded in devising and putting into operation this year a system of marketing which I think has been generally acceptable. But again this does not seem to have solved the problem and I admit that this question of the decline in tillage is a serious and a worrying one.

Notice taken that 20 Members were

not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

In the expansion of agricultural production, on which we must rely very greatly to achieve an improvement in our balance of payments, the question of agricultural credit is very important. I want to tell the House, in case there is any misapprehension about this matter, that credit for farmers has been expanded very rapidly in recent years. The banks are the main source of short and medium term credit for farmers and the amount outstanding in respect of bank advances to farmers has increased from £33 millions in mid-1960 to over £50 millions in mid-1965. Side by side with that increase in bank lending there has been an enormous expansion of activity by the Agricultural Credit Corporation. During the years 1961 to 1965 the Agricultural Credit Corporation lent a total of £10.3 millions, which was equivalent to the entire amount it had lent in the previous 33 years of its existence.

A good deal of lending recently by the Agricultural Credit Corporation had been for purposes which were not directly productive. There have been some suggestions that the Government put a squeeze on the Corporation's lending. In fact, all the Government have done has been to recognise that some of the purposes for which the Agricultural Credit Corporation was making money available were not directly productive and they have asked the Corporation at this time to confine its resources to immediately productive purposes. I think at any time, but particularly at the present time, that would have been a sensible and reasonable request to make to the Corporation. The Corporation is, in fact, really inhibited only from lending money for two main purposes, the purchase of land and the funding of debts. The truth of the matter is that the Government have made £1 million extra this year to ensure that the Corporation will be in a position to make money available for all the directly productive proposals put to it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree that the Corporation should not lend money for the purchase of land which is a very important function in the western counties where a small farmer wishes to increase his holding?

Comment on this

I would make a distinction there between different types of purchases of land. I could certainly agree that, where you have a farmer with a limited holding, farming it well and with a good sensible development programme, to lend him money to increase his acreage to an economic size would certainly be a productive purpose and, as I understand the situation, the Corporation are still prepared to consider applications of that sort.

Comment on this

It must be within the past fortnight that they are prepared to consider such cases because farmers of that type have got notification from the Corporation that they will not advance money for the purchase of land, irrespective of the merits of the case. I think that is bad.

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows, the Corporation must consider every case on its merits, but my understanding of the position is that the type of case he has mentioned— and I think the Deputy will agree— is the type of case that should be catered for.

Comment on this

But the fact is——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy may not continue these interruptions. Time is running out and a Labour Party Member will be called in 30 minutes.

Comment on this

The increasing willingness of farmers to use credit is I think one of the encouraging features of the situation and in particular it shows they got away from the old fear of debt and borrowing. They are now prepared to show their confidence in the future by borrowing money and investing it in their farms. It will be agreed, I think, that the Government have played a significant part in stimulating development by providing very substantial amounts of capital, many millions annually, by way of grants for farm buildings, land development, livestock and so on, Demand for these schemes has been running at a level even higher than anticipated in the Second Programme. This indicates a very substantial amount of reinvestment by farmers out of income. The farmer is operating in a fluctuating environment both in relation to weather and markets and he cannot be expected to reinvest in his farm unless he has, first of all, reasonable prices and secondly, a reasonable guarantee of stability in the markets. These we have endeavoured to provide by providing price assurances where possible and so far as was in our power to do so, such as the one I have mentioned, the introduction of the beef guarantee scheme.

I want to emphasise that it is our policy to seek to close the gap which exists between farm income and that of other sections of the community. I do not think we can have a balanced, healthy community here if any one large section of it is to be condemned permanently to a state where its income is substantially behind that of most other sections. I want to emphasise that this is not something which can be easily achieved but we intend to do our best and indeed to take this problem into account in all our economic planning. Some progress was undoubtedly made in 1964. It was a good year for farmers. I admit that economists will disagree as to the precise extent of the effect on this relativity but at least there was some improvement.

The agricultural price level is, of course, of primary importance in this problem but there is a great variety of other factors that greatly influence the income of farmers such as land and the amount of capital available and the efficiency with which they are able to use these. We now have in operation a comprehensive structure of schemes and services to help farmers to increase the contributions to the national product and incidentally in so doing, improve their own income position. As Deputies know, these measures include grants for the improvement of lands and buildings, the Calved Heifer Scheme, measures to improve livestock and seeds, expanded educational and advisory facilities, marketing arrangements and the extension of the operations of the Land Commission. As I have said, it is an indication of the healthy state of agriculture and of the confidence which farmers now feel about the future that they are availing of these various improvement schemes to the extent that they are. I would hope, therefore, that in these two great industries, agriculture and fisheries, we have the potential to make a very real contribution towards the solution of the financial and balance of payments difficulties which we are undergoing at present.

Everyone has an interest in preserving stability in the economy and ensuring that increases in income do not outstrip the growth of productivity and are equitably distributed among the various sections of the community, including farmers. Farmers, especially, have a vital interest in the maintaining of a steady and balanced growth in the economy and in seeing to it that increase in gross national product is shared out evenly all round, and they can be relied upon to support any measures necessary to ensure these objectives. I have, therefore, every reason to believe that farmers are fully behind the Government in measures which they have taken to ensure that steady economic progress will not be jeopardised by allowing unhealthy trends which have been appearing in the economy to continue unchecked.

On the broader front, it seems to me that we are now confronted with a new situation in this country, a situation in which we have problems arising out of expansion. Hitherto for decades we have been faced with the difficulty of getting a comparatively inert economy to move forward at all. That problem has now been overcome, the break through has been achieved. Everywhere one goes in the country to-day one sees evidence of progress, development, expansion, improvement. The statistics reflect it clearly also.

The new situation in which we find ourselves has been brought about by this very progress itself. I much prefer to deal with the problem of controlling expansion than the problem of overcrowding stagnation. Our task at this stage is to find enough fuel to keep the fires burning, now that they are well and truly lighted. I want to emphasise that this is a very difficult job that calls for very careful handling. Economic management is a very fine art despite what any Deputy may say. There is always the danger of going too far, of accentuating the very trends one wishes to correct, or of precipitating violent fluctuations and disruptions. These are the sort of considerations that have guided us, and will continue to guide us, in our approach. We have no doubt that we can succeed in our endeavours to steady the economy and set it moving forward to even greater levels of achievement.

I suggest that the Government have not been dilatory and have not been secretive with the country or the Dáil but that we have, honestly and openly at every step of the way, outlined what the situation is, what the difficulties are and what the trends are. As it became necessary to do and in pursuance of our policy of not going too far in any one direction or another, we have brought into operation remedial measures which we believe are adequate to deal with the situation at this moment of time.

Comment on this
Michael Joseph O'Higgins Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins Fine Gael

That the Government find themselves in this mess is no shock to me. In fact, it has been apparent for some time but we were facing a number of byelections and subsequently a general election, and I think the Government did not have the moral courage to tell the people the position they were in. Since the introduction of the turnover tax, prices have been steadily rising. About 18 months ago, I think, I addressed to the Minister for Industry and Commerce a number of questions about the price of various foodstuffs. To each he replied that, though the prices were high, he did not think they were unduly high, so prices went on their merry way. Now they have reached the stage where the average housewife finds it almost impossible to balance her budget.

In July, the Government brought in a prices control order and last week they imposed the levies. By the very imposition of these levies, prices have increased further. There is no good saying that, if you buy things made in this country, you will not be charged the dearer prices. I looked carefully down the list of articles subject to the levy. There is one item which affects me and many other young mothers in the country, that is, baby-clothes. Although a baby is a very small little thing, his clothes are extremely expensive—and baby grows very rapidly! You cannot get in Dublin city—or indeed in my constituency of Galway —good, well-made Irish baby-clothes. You get a very limited range of baby-clothes made in this country and, I regret to say—perhaps it is not popular to do so—they are not of the best quality. A housewife with so many calls on her budget will only be prepared to pay for something that is going to last. She will not buy an article that will be gone in a day or two. I would appeal to the Minister to have another look at the question of baby-clothes and see if there is any way by which they could be exempted from the levy, or else appeal to clothing manufacturers to make a better line of baby-clothes. My remarks do not refer to clothes for children in the four to ten age group. They are well catered for. But infants and toddlers are not well catered for.

To get away from the baby-clothes, I was appalled yesterday to hear the Taoiseach say there would have to be a cutting-back of spending in the Department of Health and the Department of Education.

Comment on this

I did not say that. That is what Deputy Dillon said.

Comment on this

You said your promises made in the election would not be honoured.

Comment on this
Michael Joseph O'Higgins Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins Fine Gael

The situation in regard to the health services in my constituency has sadly deteriorated. About one and a half years ago, a number of dispensary areas were amalgamated and we lost one dispensary doctor. I understand we are going to lose two more, who are coming here to Dublin. I further understand that these dispensaries are not to be filled because, as the Government always seem to be doing, there is to be issued a White Paper or Blue Book on Health. The White Paper or Blue Book will not remedy the appalling dispensary service in my constituency.

Another matter which worries me exceedingly is the County Home, St. Brendan's, in Loughrea. It was to receive a considerable amount of money for extensions. It is said that one can judge one's country by the way it treats its old people. If we judge this country by the way it treats its old people, it must rank as one of the lowest in Europe. St. Brendan's is a very old building. It is absolutely bursting at the seams. They have an excellent staff who take good care of the patients, but it is impossible for them to work and cater for the number they have. This is a matter of absolute urgency. No matter what money is spared by the Minister for Health, I would appeal to him to release whatever money is necessary for this urgent matter.

With regard to education, I had intended saying a lot, but I think another opportunity will arise. I notice the Minister for Education, not so much in the House—he is not given to telling us things in the House—but by letters to certain Bishops in the papers and other remarks, plans to make changes in the school system, whereby some schools will be amalgamated, doing away with the smaller national schools. Anything that would tempt the Minister to do away with the small national schools in my constituency—and we need a number of new ones—would be an absolute disaster. If I lived permanently in the country—I spend half my time there and half in Dublin—I would send my children to a national school. The small national schools with one or two teachers give children an education they never get in the "tonier" schools. I know; I have been to both.

In my constituency—indeed throughout the west of Ireland—education is the only opportunity we have to offer our children. If we cannot give them a sound basic education, we can give them nothing. Unfortunately, half of the boys and girls leaving the national schools, secondary schools and vocational schools in my constituency emigrate. It is vital that every penny be spared for education. It is also vital that the boys who stay at home on the farms get a good education. There is only one way to save the West, that is, to get the men of the West to marry, and the girls will not marry them unless they have a reasonable standard of education. For that reason I implore of the Taoiseach not to curtail in any way the money spent on health services and education.

Comment on this

We should treat this debate as a trial before a jury. The Government stand charged of incompetency and of not being able to see into the future as their position should have enabled them to do. Because of that, the Labour Party amendment has been tabled. We believe the beginning of this crisis was not when a 12 per cent wage increase was granted but when the Government subsequently failed to control prices. The jury in the case are the people of Ireland. It is they who will decide whether or not the Government are guilty of neglect in this case.

Let me say that the Labour Party had no quarrel with the wage increase. At the time many people, whether he claimed it or not, gave credit to the Taoiseach for bringing about that increase. But we knew that, should that increase be followed by a continuous increase in the cost of living, we would lose all that was gained. That proved to be true. There was a continuous spiral of increases in all the necessaries of life, uncontrolled, without any attempt in any way to limit the profits being made by (1) the importers, (2) the manufacturers and (3) the retailers, until the position was reached in which, before the National Wage Agreement period had been exhausted, trade union officials, their committees and their officers, were being pressed by their members to demand a further increase. That that was resisted in so far as it was humanly possible is evidenced by the facts. Only in isolated cases has there been any compensation for the increases in prices which resulted since that agreement was entered into. There were exceptional cases. I think the Dublin Corporation, the ESB and CIE are the outstanding ones.

Prior to the general election, that is, prior to 7th April of this year, we read and saw slogans somewhat on the lines of the Tory Party slogans in Britain: "You never had it so good.""Let Lemass Lead On.""Return Us and Everything Will Be All Right."

Comment on this

"Let Lemass Lead On" was the main slogan at the last election.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Kyne.

Comment on this

Prior to April, and that is not so long ago, the Taoiseach and his advisers must have been aware of the danger, if not the actual fact, of this crisis. Why were the people not told? I will not allege that the Taoiseach kept the information back so that he would be elected. I just do not know why he did it, but I believe he must have known, and I should like him to say why he did not tell the people and let the people judge on the facts, as they were then; apparently we were running into an economic blizzard. None of us, neither those of us in the Labour Party nor those in any other Party, wants Ireland to sink under an economic blizzard, not even for political reasons. I do not want to see a Fianna Fáil Government wrecked and go down with that wreck myself. I do not want to see the people go down with it. I am quite sure that any co-operation the Labour Party can give to this Government, or could give to any Government in power in the same circumstances, will be given willingly but that does not mean that we can be stopped from saying what we think needs to be said. Why were the people not told? I just do not know why they were not told and I suggest to the Taoiseach that, when he comes to reply, he should clear up that point with the public.

On the Fianna Fáil side of the House, we have had one suggestion. We have had two contrary suggestions on the Fine Gael side of the House. On my side of the House, we are anxious to know why the Taoiseach did not, prior to 7th April, during his "Lead on" campaign, indicate to the people that there was a danger of an economic blizzard hitting us within six to eight months.

I come now to the solution devised by the Taoiseach, the 15 per cent on imports. We do not oppose this imposition. Our amendment and the Fine Gael amendment show clearly that we are in agreement that this must be done. We regret the need for it and we allege that the need for having these amendments is the fault of the Government. When the people examine the facts, I think they will be fairly satisfied that that is true.

How will this 15 per cent operate? We heard at the outset that it would not be passed on to the consumer. It has been explained pretty clearly now by Government spokesmen that that is not so. In relation to commodities subject to the 15 per cent levy, the levy will be passed on to the consumer. What will be the result? "Buy Irish" is a fine slogan and all good trade unionists would like to accept that principle, but there are things, manufactured in Ireland, which are not perhaps just what people need. It may be a matter of style; it may be a matter of quality; it may be a matter of price. If a man is working on a tight budget and can find a foreign substitute for an Irish commodity, something he needs urgently, and the price is within the range of his budget, then naturally, very naturally, he will buy what suits his pocket rather than what suits the country. "Buy Irish", by all means, provided Irish is as good and as cheap as the commodity produced by the foreign competitor. We will certainly do that, if it suits us, and any Irish manufacturer who is putting on the market a commodity as good in quality as and in price comparable with that of the foreign competitor, need have no anxiety. Irish people have enough sense and wisdom in them to make the right choice.

If this 15 per cent levy causes a price increase, the effect of that increase will be reflected in organised workers demanding and securing, by organised resistance, a compensatory increase in wages. Where will we go from there? We will have prices rising and wages endeavouring to follow. When we get an increase in wages, there will be a further increase in prices. It is true that we have a price control arrangement. I suggest that that price control arrangement is the very type of machinery which will lead to a further wage demand. I hope not; I sincerely hope not.

Having listened to all sorts of talk about 15 per cent levies, "Buy Irish", and all sorts of recommendations to increase exports and reduce imports, I was rather puzzled to come across a curious position in my constituency only six weeks ago. It was the subject of a Parliamentary Question on 21st October. I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce if he was aware that the National Board and Paper Mills of Waterford were permitted to import pure Kraft paper without any duty, even though, in ordinary circumstances, it is subject to 60 per cent duty. The National Board and Paper Mills were permitted to import over three years more than half a million pounds worth of paper, duty free, with the result that workers who had previously to be compelled to work excess overtime to meet the market now find they are in danger of going on short time. I got the glib answer that the factories say it cannot be done. It was done; it was done for one and a half years. The reason that product did not turn out to be satisfactory was that the firm themselves insisted on adding to the mixture an inferior substitute that proved unreliable in the process. Is it any wonder that this American company should favour taking their surplus from Florida, importing it duty-free and distributing it throughout the paper industry in this country? This represented a loss of employment and of wages for workers in this country and adversely affected our import-export balance by £½ million.

When I endeavoured to secure redress for the workers of the area, I was met in this House with the statement that the Minister was not satisfied, that he had heard the employers' side and would have to secure a lot more proof before he would accede to my request for a meeting between his Department, the employers concerned and the trade unionists so that the trade unionists could explain that, whatever the employers said about inability to manufacture, the workers were prepared to prove that, given the proper machinery, they could do just as good a job as any American firm. In view of the fact that adaptation grants are made available, one would imagine that the Government and, in particular, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, would be anxious to give Irish workers a chance to prove their ability. One would think that he would do that for the sake of encouraging national self-sufficiency and achieving the objective we are now trying to achieve by the imposition of a 15 per cent levy on various commodities. I notice that Kraft paper is not included in the items on which the 15 per cent will be levied. Either through error or by deliberate intent, it has been excluded.

To substantiate what I have said, I shall give figures given in reply to a Parliamentary Question tabled by Deputy Pattison and myself for answer on 21st October. In 1963, the value of paper imported duty free as waste was £239,714; in 1964, it was £186,287 and in 1965, for the first nine months up to August, it was £164,965. That is a total of £590,966, just over £½ million. This is an extraordinary position in the context of our having to impose a levy of 15 per cent on commodities that people believe to be essential in order to redress the import excess.

Another thing I find difficult to understand is the imposition of levies of 15 per cent at a time when we are in the middle of negotiations for free trade. We are endeavouring to negotiate free entry of our goods into Britain and free entry of British goods into this country, subject to certain reservations and certain dates, while, at the same time, we are imposing emergency tariffs of 15 per cent, reducing to ten per cent. Was there ever anything so crazy and so impossible to understand?

I am aware that under the agreement of the House, I must conclude at 8.15. I should like to have had an opportunity of further discussing whether the Fianna Fáil Party and Government were guilty or not guilty. When the people examine the charge that the Labour Party make against Fianna Fáil, that they did not foresee in time the difficulties they are now faced with and did not take adequate steps to protect the interests of the people, the verdict will be "Guilty as charged."

Comment on this

The people have had a rude awakening. Little did they think six months ago when they fell for the sunny and glowing promises of the Fianna Fáil Party that they would find themselves in such a sad predicament today. The veneer of smug complacency has been wiped off and the Government Party have been revealed for what they are and for what they always were, a Party bereft of a policy, bankrupt of ideas and of ideals, and now, it would seem, bankrupt of financial resources.

We were told six months ago that we never had it so good in this country. Having listened to the Taoiseach's speech of gloom and foreboding yesterday. I think it is true to say that we certainly have had it good and proper with a bang on this occasion. The "Lead on" slogan which so many fell for in the last general election and in so many previous elections has led us to the brink of virtual economic disaster. The plans, programmes and policies of this Government, so glibly presented, and which duped and fooled so many in the past, have come to nought and even the most ardent supporters of the Government Party are now stupefied and dumb-struck by the frustration, misery and fear of the future which surround them on every side today.

At a time of unrivalled opportunity in this age of unparalleled progress in human knowledge and scientific development, when all around us in the world today we witness a scientific revolution that is making it physically possible for the first time in human history for Governments to win for their people high standards of life, full employment, the atainment of high cultural values and leisure which formerly were enjoyed only by the privileged minority in society, when countries are moving forward to the prosperity I have referred to, it is difficult in the extreme to reconcile ourselves to the situation that we have to contend with in Ireland.

Our country has not merely not made progress; it has remained constantly underdeveloped and stagnant. Now it seems, despite the high incidence of unemployment and emigration, which is the highest in the western hemisphere, not to mention the social code here in health, education, welfare and housing which is not benefiting any civilised or Christian society, we are now falling back into an abysmal depression which will wreak terrible deprivation, suffering and misery on countless extra thousands of our citizens, as if they had not suffered enough.

Comment on this

This is a sorry dirge.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is responsible for this sorry state of affairs. Any scanty glance at the system of government in any progressive country will reveal that it is not necessary in this atomic age that people should suffer so and it is clearly a question of gross mismanagement and dereliction of duty on the part of a Government who wreak utter misery of this kind on the people. This Government stand clearly indicted for the sorry state of affairs which we in this country have to contend with today. Let it be said they have had more than a fair innings to solve the social and economic ills of the country. They have been in power intermittently for almost 30 years and have had every opportunity of putting into operation their policy for solving the problems of our people. Thirty years is a fair opportunity in that respect and, in this modern day and age, in the affairs of nations, 30 years in government, except in a totalitarian state, could hardly be rivalled.

At the present time, apart from the fact that we have had a chronic problem of unemployment in this country averaging 50,000 and reaching 90,000 at peak periods and the fact that we have had emigration running at between 30,000 and 50,000 a year, certainly under the operation of the First Programme for Economic Expansion from 1958 to 1963, it is on record that 170,000 people have emigrated. Today unemployment is rising. Underemployment and redundancy are rearing their ugly heads now in almost all facets of industry. The building industry—this important industry charged with responsibility for rehousing the thousands who are living in rat-infested houses and insanitary tenement flats— has been the first to be hit by this credit squeeze. It is felt by the unions catering for these men that in the early part of next year unemployment amongst the tradesmen, labourers and craftsmen in the building industry will be widespread. Some firms in the textile industry—an industry which, mind you, was expected to do well, even in face of bad circumstances — have already closed down. Again, in the flour milling industry, firms are closing down. In my own constituency, the town of Cahir has met with economic disaster by the closing of the mill there and I think it is true to say that another mill is about to close in my leader's constituency in Wexford. This has come about, again, as a result of the Government's tendency towards the creation of monopolies.

It is ironical to realise that when I stood for election in 1961, the Fianna Fáil Cumann in Cahir town on the eve of that general election rushed to the printers and issued pamphlets, to the effect that if I were elected to the Dáil as a Labour candidate, or if my Party came to power, the flour milling industry would be nationalised and the workers would all lose their jobs. How happy an event it would be for those unfortunate workers if that flour milling industry had been nationalised, as we have persistently demanded. These workers would be secure, have remunerative employment and their future would be stable. They can blame their own Party for the damage which has befallen them.

Likewise in the motor assembly industry. In today's Irish Times, we read of the fact that the trade union leaders estimated yesterday that about 400 workers have become unemployed as a result of redundancy; 200 workers were laid off at Messrs. Fords of Cork and others have been laid off in some other motor assemblers throughout the country. The workers in that industry are about to march through this city, I understand, on next Saturday, protesting—2,000 strong—against the Government's intention to wipe out that industry by agreeing to free trade with Britain. Is it too late to appeal to the Taoiseach to safeguard the livelihood of all these workers and, in that regard, there are not fewer than 6,500 workers involved? They comprise some 1,000 people engaged in the coachbuilding industry, 4,000 in the assembly of cars and 1,500 in ancillary trades. It seems rather a tragedy that the Taoiseach is hell-bent on free trade, in the clear knowledge that this industry will be wiped out and that misery will be the lot of some thousands of workers in this important business. The wages paid to the operatives involved amounts to some £5½ million a year and it seems the height of economic folly that we should unnecessarily threaten the future of that important industry.

We are not compelled to enter into a free trade agreement with Britain. There is no obligation on us and why any responsible Government should create this sad state of affairs is beyond us. Again, money is drying up for local authorities. Housing, in particular, is badly hit. Money is not available for essential work schemes of water supplies, sewerage and house-building, et cetera. Many local authorities, according to our local papers, are already bankrupt. They cannot find the money from the Local Loans Fund or the Department of Local Government and the banks will not accommodate them. We have grave fears of the curtailment or cancellation of essential services for our people and we are gravely perturbed about the possibility of wholesale unemployment amongst county council workers as well. These people in the building trade, in particular, have been the first to be caught in this credit squeeze. It seems particularly sad that the many thousands of people waiting for homes —8,000 in the queue in the city of Dublin and some 160,000 in the country at large—will be committed to a further long purgatory of waiting, relegated to a limbo of forgotten people to be the first victims of this infamous credit squeeze.

It is to be greatly deplored that many progressive firms in this country and many progressive industries which, conscious of their obligations and the fact that free trade would come some day, had been making realistic efforts to re-adapt themselves, re-organise themselves and revitalise themselves, for that kind of rigorous competition should now be faced by free trade with Britain at a time when clearly they are not fully prepared or equipped to meet that kind of challenge. These industries, the boot and shoe industry and other industries, need more time to perfect their adaptation methods and strengthen themselves for this competition with which they will have to contend in freer trading circumstances. The abandonment of the quota and the introduction of the levies will, in our opinion, have disastrous consequences. Clearly our industrial potential cannot compete with the all-powerful British industry.

However, I want to say a word in connection with another industry which is deeply involved in this matter, an industry for which I have a particular responsibility in this House and from which I derived my livelihood for a long number of years, the boot and shoe industry. This industry provides the requirements for 97 per cent of the home market, employs 6,000 persons and another 2,500 in ancillary industries, so that there are about 8,500 people, or 35,000 families, dependent on this industry. It distributes in wages some £3.5 million a year and exports 27 per cent of its output. That is an indication of the extent to which this industry has developed and we are concerned here, in respect of the recommendations made in the report by the Committee on Industrial Organisation and the reports of the National Industrial Economic Council, that many of the Government agencies, and especially the Industrial Development Authority, would seem to be working at variance with the reports of those bodies as to how best to assist these industries in their system of adaptation.

I want to emphasise that fact by saying that the policy of the concentration of industry is being ignored by Government agencies. This industry is widespread throughout the country and the report of the Committee on Industrial Organisation recommended the centralisation of industry. We have the sad predicament of new industries for the manufacture of boots and shoes being removed altogether from the boot and shoe centres, which is at complete variance with the recommendations to which I have referred. The adaptation council of the industry clearly cannot fulfil its obligation, especially in regard to education in the technology of boot and shoe manufacture, if this continues. The Industrial Development Authority has an obligation to consult with these adaptation councils and to advise them of future developments. New industries should bet set up where industry is in existence at the present time; they should be tied up with the industries which are now operating. This industry is over-producing and this question of centralisation is a matter of dire necessity for them. It is ridiculous to set up new factories in places where a number of factories have closed in recent years.

This Party have been pleading with the Taoiseach to advise us of the terms of the Anglo-Irish agreement which is now nearing completion and the Taoiseach has persistently refused to give us this information. This is in stark contrast with the attitude of the British Government who are advising industry in Britain as to the ramifications of the Irish agreement and as to the repercussive effects it will have on industry in Britain. This is borne out by the fact that the British Board of Trade obviously consulted the British boot and shoe industry and revealed to it the fact that the Industrial Development Authority in Ireland had recommended the removal of the quota and that it should be replaced by an import levy of 30 per cent on imported British footwear. This was the first intimation the Irish industry or the trade unions involved had received of the removal of the quotas. The British Government obviously had advised the industry of this fact.

Comment on this

That arose out of an agreement that has been in existence for 20 years.

Comment on this

Why should you not consult with the industry here?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy trying to say that there was a review of that quota without the industry being consulted?

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

That is not so. The Deputy does not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

The first they knew about it was when they read it in the British Shoe and Leather News. We know of no reason why the Taoiseach should not give to the House and the people concerned the information that is vital to them.

Comment on this

That is an old agreement that the Deputy is talking about.

Comment on this

If free trade is to be the outcome of these talks we in the trade unions and the labour movement know full well what will follow. There will be widespread dislocation of industry, a shocking problem of unemployment and redundancy and even the existence of the best established industries will be threatened, if dumping is permitted. It will be difficult to prevent the dumping and too late to stop it when it has taken place and factories have closed down. The Taoiseach seems to be in the mood to teach Irish industrialists a lesson, to be determined to unwrap the swaddling clothes and to expose them to the stark realities of free trade. He seems to be about to teach them a lesson for some inertia on their part but he would be a foolish man indeed if he did not realise that the great and highly efficient industries of Britain can supply for the 52 weeks of the year the total needs of this country from less than a week's production of their factories. There is no ambiguity in our minds about the fact that if the tariffs and quotas are removed, industrial graveyards will result. There will be widespread unemployment and emigration. That is the price Irish workers are being asked to pay.

The employer in most cases will be able to confer on himself a golden handshake, but the workers with whom we are concerned will be thrown ignominiously on to the unemployment market. They will be helpless and penniless. We know the size of the problem because it is spelled out for us in the report of the CIO. Of the 26 industries on which the CIO reported, employing some 77,000 operatives, they have told us that in freer trading circumstances—and this surely applies to Britain—not fewer than 11,000 Irish workers would lose their jobs, and that if the adaptation measures which the CIO recommended were not adopted, a further 23,000 workers would lose their jobs. That is the kind of great human problem with which we have to contend. Even if agriculture does well out of this free trade agreement, which many of us doubt, it is unlikely to absorb any extra employment on the land, especially when one has regard to the fact that since 1957 over 60,000 workers have left the land for the towns and villages more particularly of Great Britain.

Let me say now that the White Paper on manpower policy which was issued recently by the Government has come to us in the trade union and the labour movement as a deep disappointment. It is a deep disappointment to those of us who worked and agitated for a positive manpower policy designed to achieve an intelligent, organised, planned economic development which would provide jobs quickly, ensure jobs security, raise living standards, give us price stability, and deal effectively with the problems of unemployment and redundancy with which we now know we will have to contend. The proposed manpower policy of this Government is only a pale shadow of what is required by the Irish trade union and labour movement.

I say that primarily because this economic policy programme is being handed over to two Departments of State, the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Social Welfare. It cannot be successful. We resent deeply the fact that the Department of Social Welfare should have been brought into this matter at all. The Labour Party and the trade union movement have called for the establishment of a distinct Ministry of Labour whose responsibility would be to effect this intelligent and organised plan for our society to which I have adverted.

We believe a Ministry of Labour is vitally essential. We think its primary purpose should be to enrich and ennoble labour. We resent the fact that this responsibility has been handed over to the Department of Social Welfare with their archaic, puny, niggardly-minded concepts, their doles, their means tests, and all the red tape that can possibly be conceived by the ultra-conservative bureaucrats in that Department. That Department could never solve the problem of redundancy or unemployment. I realise I have only had half an hour to deal with these important problems.

The Fianna Fáil Government have been in power in this country for nigh on 29 years. They were returned time and time again by a mandate of the Irish people, sometimes with a huge majority. They have had more than their fair innings to resolve the social problems of our country. Seldom in the history of nations have a Government been able to lead a country for so long. It seems to us in the Labour Party that this Government are bereft of any hope of curing our nation of the economic and deep-seated malaise which has clearly set in. They are now about to abandon us and to hand us over to an outside interest, be it Britain, EFTA or the EEC, whatever the humiliating terms or their shattering consequences.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask the Deputy to draw to a close.

Comment on this

Certainly. The Government are clearly prepared to sell out the Irish people. It is obvious that a defeated Government driven by economic failure are prepared now to come to terms with the age old enemy, England, in the hope that the gold may rub off and that some kind of boost may be given to our wilting and decaying economy.

Comment on this

In the past 12 or 18 months we have heard references to inflation. The references made in the past need no longer be a matter for controversy here because in this debate, at this time, at this moment, this country is facing the problem of inflation. The basic cause of that is that the total of domestic expenditure, both current and capital, by public and private sources, has increased at a rate substantially faster than national production. As I say, this is no longer a matter of controversy. It is now one of the facts of life which even Government Ministers have had to concede and deal with in this debate. We in Fine Gael are concerned not so much with establishing a problem which is there, but with considering how it came about, what led to it, what situation brought this calamity upon our people, so that if that can be established steps can be taken to ensure that what has happened will not happen again.

Inflation, as we all know, has certain symptoms while it is taking place. The process may be pleasant initially but there are certain indicators which should be read and seen, particularly by those charged with the responsibility of looking after this economy. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries who said a few words a while ago made a very precious reference to the art of economic management. Let us see how well this art has been exercised by those who have had responsibility in the past 12 or 18 months. One of the first symptoms of an inflationary situation must be and is the creation or development of balance of payments difficulties.

Without going far into the past, it is reasonable to point out that in the first six months of 1965 our imports rose by £13.9 million while at the same time our exports dropped by £9.6 million. That led to an adverse trade balance showing an increase of £23.5 million. That fact was there to be seen, to be observed and to be considered. I wonder was it? Perhaps it was brushed aside by the facile reasoning that this drop was due to a decline in our cattle sales and this would be bound to rectify itself later in the year. It is true that the creation of that trade gap was contributed to by a decline in cattle exports but there were other more ominous factors which should have been observed and understood by a Government knowing their job, confidently doing it and concerned to discharge in a proper way their obligation to the people.

For instance, in that first six months' period there was a decline, and a significant decline, in the quantity of manufactured exports. There was also —probably a more significant factor and more disturbing in view of what took place last year—an increase, and again a somewhat significant increase, in the rate of consumer imports. The total increase in imports in the first quarter of this year was some £5.7 million. In fact, consumer imports represented 37 per cent and in the total amount of imports in the period, the rate of consumer imports advanced significantly.

Now, these facts were there to be seen in the opening months and throughout the first part of this year. They were not the only factors that should have been observed. We have had a situation over a number of years in which there has been a deficit in our balance of payments but in fact that situation was covered and cloaked by a very large inflow of foreign capital into this country. In the last few years the figures have been significant, but significant as they were they contained in them a source of danger, the source of danger being that the size of the capital inflow would create, as I believe it did create, Ministerial complacency in relation to our trading position.

In 1960 the inflow of capital was £0.6 million; in 1961 it had risen to £13.4 million; in 1962 to £23 million; in 1963 to £25 million and last year, in 1964, there was a massive inflow of capital of some £36.6 million. Now, that massive increase of over £11 million should have put the Government, if they knew their job, on their toes to see whether we were not banking too much on an inflow of money upon which we could not rely. We had a deficit in 1964 of £31 million but even so with that inflow of capital our external assets rose by something around £8 million. I want to suggest that with that situation going on last year and the beginning of this year a change took place which should have been apparent to a Government watching their responsibilities. It was a change of a significant kind because the rate of capital inflow into this country began to decline significantly. The Government knew that; the people did not. The Government knew what was taking place but did they understand what was involved? I suggest they did not.

There is ample evidence that in the first months of this year as a result of the fall in the inflow of foreign capital there was a clear economic indication of danger given and that was by the steady and continuous decline in the external assets held by the commercial banks. In fact, the accumulated drop in the first four months of this year was 17½ million and the drop in the external reserves of the commercial banks was from £100 million in January, to, in the month of April— and let Deputies mark well the month —£79 million. I charge this against the Government, that knowing of a situation in which we were increasing our imports, and in which our exports were dropping, knowing of a situation in which the inflow of foreign capital was decreasing and seeing a very perceptible drop in the reserves available to our banking system, any Government knowing their job would have appreciated that the reason for this was something that was happening in the economy itself.

Of course, they would not have far to go. They would only have had to look at the extraordinary amount of expenditure that took place in the year just concluded. There were also other indications available to them. If they cared to consider it there was available, as published subsequently in the Economic Statistics, the fact that industrial production was perceptibly dropping towards the end of 1964. Indeed, in the review which was in course of preparation, and which was subsequently published by the Department of Finance, on the working of the first year of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, attention was drawn to the fact that in the latter half of 1964 the rate of expansion and the volume of production was slowing down.

Shortly following that, the National Industrial Economic Council, in its comments on the Department of Finance review, drew attention in paragraph 4 of its publication to the fact that the development of production was slowing and that there appeared to be grounds for anxiety. It directed the Government's attention to this. All that must have been apparent to the Government in the early months of this year, in January, February and March. We want to know why something was not done about it. Is it because the Government did not recognise the signals or, recognising them, chose not to do anything about them? Was this another exercise in political expediency, in declaring an election before the facts had to be faced? We can remember only too well, as can the people, the last exercise in political expediency by the Taoiseach and leader of Fianna Fáil. Only 12 months before, having published on behalf of the Government a White Paper indicating that a gap between incomes and output would require to be closed, the same Government nine months later, at a time of political embarrassment for them, initiated—I say it deliberately — the ninth round of wage increases.

In the early part of this year, inflation was indicated. Not only had there been a vast increase in expenditure from private sources, a very definite and great increase, but public expenditure had also increased enormously. It appears from some figures recently published that in 1964 there had been a very definite increase in bank lending in the public sector. It was up by some 27 per cent and there had also been a very great increase in lending in the private sector. In any event, in the early part of this year, these figures should have caused concern to any Government concerned with discharging their responsibilities. We do not know whether the Government considered these signs or what was the mind of the Government. We know only what they said, and at the end of the first three months of this year, with our external assets falling in London, the volume of industrial output dropping, the inflow of foreign capital decreasing, with all the economic indicators pointing to danger and these facts known to the Government, we find the Taoiseach saying on March 25th that the years immediately ahead would far surpass all that has yet been accomplished, provided we as a nation followed a consistent and coherent policy under a competent and united Government.

Comment on this

But it is an incompetent Government: that is the point.

Comment on this

Two days later he said: "Rarely before in history were all the circumstances, external and internal, so favourable to Irish economic development."

Comment on this

"Let Lemass lead on."

Comment on this

I want to know how could the leader of a Government knowing his job, concerned with public honesty and with playing fair with the people, or how could any man who was aware of the facts to which I have referred and which are now available in Government statistics, say to the people that "rarely before in history were all the circumstances, external and internal, so favourable to Irish economic development." Either the man did not know his job or he was indulging in an exercise in political chicanery.

It may have been a coincidence that on March 27th, a Saturday night, down in Nenagh, there was the last mustering of Fianna Fáil supporters in that constituency prior to a general election the following week. Possibly that had an effect on the Taoiseach's approach. We are concerned, however, with the fact that the election being over, the situation now having been faced, the people should know what mistakes were made and these mistakes having been discussed, that guarantees will be given that they will not be repeated. We believe that what happened—and I doubt if this will be seriously challenged by anyone—was that there was not on the part of the Government sufficient foresight and planning in relation to the direction in which this country should expand.

They had the Second Programme, and up and down the country Ministers were in the habit, in 1964, of persuading themselves and those who listened to them that the mere fact of printing a Second Programme for Economic Expansion was as good as delivering the goods. In fact, the Second Programme was an exercise in sound economic foresight by a team of civil servants. I do not believe that either the Taoiseach or any member of his Government ever understood what that Programme was designed to achieve. How could they, because no programme for economic expansion can hope to get off the ground, unless it is guaranteed sufficient credit? How could anyone hope to expand an economy like ours without ensuring that there is available for the worker for the doing of the necessary operation sufficient organised and sustained credit?

In the first year of the Second Programme, there was a situation which was described in the Irish Banking Review published last month as follows:

In 1964 the banks extended credit in excess of the growth of their credit balances on current and deposit account.

It goes on to say:

The second feature to be emphasised in relation to the rapid acceleration of bank lending which developed in 1964 and which gained force in the earlier months of the present year is the steep growth in borrowing by the Government and other public authorities.

In fact, in 1964 many a person could walk into his bank and, if he wanted to gamble on the stock exchange, he merely had to ask his bank manager to put him in funds to enable him to do so.

There was no effort by the Government in relation to the Second Programme to make sure that the machine —we will call it a motor car for the moment—had enough fuel to get going. When we in the Fine Gael Party indicated in our Programme for a Just Society our views in relation to how the economy should be planned, we indicated in the section on economic planning certain things which required to be done. Amongst the primary things we put forward was effective co-ordination between economic and monetary policy. That was part of our banking policy. It was immediately impugned by the Taoiseach. He said we were in some way going to make a raid on the people's money. All we were concerned with was that in relation to any economic plan there should be a rationalisation and an organisation in regard to monetary policy to ensure that it would work. The Taoiseach sneered at it. Now, six months later, it is apparent to all that the dissipation of our credit resources which took place last year has prevented and has retarded the economic expansion hoped for in the Second Programme.

In relation to many other matters, a prices and incomes policy and matters of that kind, we also indicated in the early part of the year what should be done. If what we indicated at that time had been done, it would not be necessary in this debate in the autumn of the year, for the Taoiseach to say, as he had to say yesterday, it is too bad but the situation is so grim that we will have to postpone the promised expansion in health services and in education. In my view, the fact that these have been postponed is a tribute and a monument to the imcompetence of Fianna Fáil in the past 18 months.

Comment on this

The same as 1956 and 1957.

Comment on this

That was the time when the widow was so prominent, is it not?

Comment on this

Deputy Burke may take consolation from the fact that, unlike 1956, there is now a responsible Opposition in Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

And nobody from these benches advocated devaluation, as the Minister for Lands did.

Comment on this

Or put up the sign of the pawnbroker around the country.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Now we are living with Lynch.

Comment on this

I want to say a word about free trade. The Minister for Finance in the debate yesterday said—I thought rather naively—that he could not understand the anxiety expressed about the free trade proposal with Britain, that, after all, we had been talking about free trade since the summer of 1961. That is quite true. Ever since 1961, when quite suddenly the Leader of Fianna Fáil and the Government made an application to the EEC for membership, we have been talking about free trade. But it is quite a different thing and it is in no way the same thing as the proposal to have a free trade area agreement with Britain. If the Minister for Finance or the Taoiseach thinks our people understood all the talk for the last four or five years to have been related to free trade with Britain only, then he is very much mistaken indeed.

What attracted the ordinary people in relation to free trade under the Rome Treaty over the past four years was the fact that, if free trade was to come, we would have the benefit of the institutions established under that Treaty. Those institutions were designed particularly to safeguard the interests of weaker economies and smaller countries. They were designed particularly to have regard to the kind of economy, the agricultural and rural economy, in parts of Europe very similar to our own. It was these things that were understood when people talked about free trade in the past four years.

I want to suggest in relation to a free trade agreement with Britain that at no stage ever since the present Taoiseach became the Leader of Fianna Fáil was there the slightest indication or suggestion given by him or any member of his Government that they were proposing or contemplating a free trade area agreement with Britain until he announced it when he came back from London last July. Up to that, there was never any such suggestion, good, bad, or indifferent. It is worth recalling that this announcement was made at a time when, apart from one newspaper, the national press was not available and there was not any possibility of having a general discussion on a matter which was rather in the nature of a political bombshell.

The Minister for Finance said last night that free trade was coming and that there was GATT and all the rest of it. I do not believe GATT offers any justification for this proposal. I believe that, on examination, it will prove to be quite erroneous to say that because of any complications in relation to GATT a step of this kind is necessary. GATT has been there for a long time. There has been more talk about it than evidence of progress. The GATT situation is not a factor that requires to be considered at the moment. But I would like to remind the Taoiseach—I am sure it is not necessary to remind him, but it may be necessary to remind the country— that the proposal to enter into a free trade area agreement with Britain creates, or may create, the very dilemma which Arthur Griffith fought against and foresaw as far as this country was concerned.

Arthur Griffith's whole political and economic philosophy was concerned with trying to correct a situation in which the small Irish economy was face to face in unrestricted competition with a larger and more powerful one. I should imagine it is not necessary to suggest these matters; they should be known to everyone in the House and, most of all, to the Leader of the Government, but we are concerned with the fact that, having made the announcement in July, these has been no further public discussion on behalf of the Government in this country in relation to this matter. It could, however, be mentioned in the Queen's Speech in Westminster yesterday. It could be referred to by the British Prime Minister, who said that he is very pleased with the progress that is being made, and the Minister for Finance could go across to London and, in the presence of Mr. George Browne, talk about the free trade area proposal. But no Irish Minister and no leader of an Irish Government will discuss it here in Ireland's Parliament, and this is where it should be discussed.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

What are we doing now?

Comment on this

What are we doing now? The Taoiseach is not doing it. The British Prime Minister said yesterday that prospects were bright. That is precisely why we fear this. When an Englishman smiles, many an Irishman has learned to shiver. Prospects were bright!

Comment on this

Bright for whom?

Comment on this

What is the justification for this proposal? We either go into Europe or we stay out. We will certainly go into Europe if Britain goes in. If Britain stays out, we shall have to take a decision. If those circumstances arise, we shall either merge ourselves into the British economy or we can seek to continue the existing type of trading arrangement with Britain, while, at the same time, exploring the possibility of accommodation in Europe. Those are the alternatives open to us. The Government have obviously decided that, with Britain out, it is necessary to enter into an economic marriage with Britain.

I should like to know what efforts the Government have made in the past three years to explore the possibility of seeking accommodation under the Rome Treaty. I assert that they have made no effort whatsoever. There has certainly been no diplomatic move in Europe, good, bad, or indifferent, ever since the end of 1961. If this free trade area goes through, we shall have to examine the terms—I assume they will be debated here—if a commitment is entered into. I am assuming for the moment that the treaty will be such as will preserve the economic independence of this country. I am assuming for the moment that the treaty will be such that the balance of advantage will be in our favour. I am assuming that the new arrangement will be along those lines, but I want to ask what then will happen if Britain enters Europe. We will go in, of course, but we will be no longer in charge of the negotiations. Those who will negotiate on our behalf will be the British.

We have problems quite particular to this country. We have the problem west of the Shannon. We have the situation in which there is emigration from the rural areas and the flight from the land. Are we going to allow a British Prime Minister to negotiate these things for us? I assert that this particular piece of folly is being indulged in now by the Leader of a Government bankrupt of ideas, frightened at the effect of their own mishandling and running away from the economic mess created through their own incompetence in the past 18 months.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

People can take some consolation in these times and in these circumstances in the fact that there is now in Dáil Éireann a strong, determined and vigilant Opposition, sure of their policy and knowing precisely what should be done. We gave the lead in relation to proper thinking and proper consideration in regard to economic planning, in regard to the things that might have been done in the past six months, in regard to the free trade area, and all the rest of it. We are concerned with the establishment of a more just society in this country. We have a policy which we believe can achieve these things. Certainly, in present circumstances, we are, I believe, acting properly in the interests of the people. We are not behaving as Oppositions have done in the past, as the Opposition behaved when Deputy Sweetman was Minister for Finance and was doing what required to be done, taking the steps that should be taken, steps which, according to the Minister for Finance yesterday, were too severe in the view of Fianna Fáil in 1956, steps which are now adopted by Fianna Fáil. Unlike the pattern then, there is no destructive Opposition here on these benches now. We recognise that the strength of the Irish economy will withstand the past mismanagement of Fianna Fáil. The economy is sound. It can develop if proper methods and a proper policy are introduced. Sooner or later, I believe we shall be called upon to do just that.

Comment on this

I am not very clear why the Opposition Parties asked for this debate. During the course of it, there was no serious dissent expressed by any spokesman of either Opposition Party to the measures taken by the Government to deal with the present economic situation, which is what we were supposed to be discussing. In the main, the Opposition speakers confined themselves to making some carping and critical remarks about other matters irrelevant in this context. It seems to me the Opposition Parties were seeking to make some small political change; I doubt, however, if they made very much.

In this day and age, political parties and political leaders have to work for public respect rather than for partisan cheers. That, anyway, is my view. I do not want to press it on either of the Parties opposite if they do not like it. I doubt if the interest of the general public in this debate goes deeper than a desire to understand the nature of the difficulties now facing the nation and what is being done about them. I think there is far less concern about how they arose, why they arose, when they arose, and how they are to be cured. When we are considering how these economic difficulties can be overcome, how the country's rate of economic growth can be speeded up again, the public want precision, definite and understandable statements and proposals about measures capable of immediate or early application rather than vague generalities. This is what the Government have given them and the advantage of this debate to the Government is that it afforded us an opportunity of repeating those statements rather than listening to anything that the Opposition Parties have contributed.

I want to make some comment on the opening speech on the other side of the House by the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Cosgrave. In doing so, may I say I recognise at once Deputy Cosgrave's difficulty in speaking as a leader of a Party so divided and confused as Fine Gael seem to be? The leadership of such a Party is a very difficult business, I appreciate, and must necessitate considerable skill in tightrope walking. That probably explains why in his speech Deputy Cosgrave confined himself to the vaguest generalities, avoiding specific commitments of any kind, and suggesting policies rather than advocating them.

He began by repeating his suggestion that the economic difficulties of this day began with the turnover tax imposed in 1963 and, no doubt, this was just his formal acknowledgment of what used to be known as the old Dillon line. I doubt if he really believes it himself. It is, of course, as unfounded now as it ever was. It ignores several things. It ignores the purposes for which that tax was imposed, the purposes for which the revenue raised by that tax was expended, the alternative taxes which would have to be imposed if that revenue was not available, and it ignored particularly the fact that, although that tax came into operation in 1963, 1964 was the best year this country ever had, a year in which production went ahead more strongly in agriculture and industry, in which national income rose more rapidly than before and which was in every way a good year which has given us added strength and resources with which to meet the difficulties of this year.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies allow the Taoiseach to make his speech? This barrage of interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

In fact, the emergence of our present troubles coincided more with the imposition of the British import charge, although they cannot be attributed solely to this cause.

Deputy Cosgrave spoke about a Fine Gael plan. For those of us who are not very familiar with the internal affairs of the Fine Gael Party, perhaps he will at some time say which of the many plans they produce from time to time has now been elevated to this capital letter Fine Gael Plan. If what Deputy Cosgrave said about it is descriptive of it, then it is nothing more than a string of vague generalities which could mean anything or mean nothing.

He said that the purpose of this plan, although he emphasised the word "plan", is not to impose controls of any kind, not to control business or to order individuals around but, he said, to marshal the forces of the nation. I do not know how you marshal forces of any kind without giving them directions or orders or without controlling them. Military metaphors of this kind can sometimes be confusing and perhaps some time or another Deputy Cosgrave will translate what he said about his plan into plain civilian language.

He urged that we should have meaningful targets for agriculture and industry. With all due respect to Deputy Cosgrave, that was not a very meaningful statement. But, apparently, this plan provides for a planning board, a board which is presumably to supersede the Government or to order the Government about, although later in the same speech he made the suggestion, which was repeated by other members of his Party, that the Government are being run by civil servants. It seems to me that if I understood him correctly this is precisely what his Fine Gael plan envisages.

Then he said the public and private sectors of the economy should be properly co-ordinated. Whatever that means as a practical measure, it was a fine phrase, a pretentious phrase, although what it means or does not mean is not very clear.

Comment on this

It means you should not hog all the moneys as you have been doing.

Comment on this

That is one definition. Perhaps some other Deputy of the Fine Gael Party will give us another definition. Then he said we should have an ordered system of capital priorities but made no suggestion that the priorities set out in the White Paper on the Capital Programme should be changed in any way. He complained that there was a sudden and rapid cut back on Government capital spending and bank credit when all the facts disclose that there has been no cut back, sudden or otherwise, and only a restraint on their expansion, as I tried to explain when speaking yesterday.

Comment on this

A distinction without a difference.

Comment on this

Once again, Deputy Cosgrave spoke about a prices and incomes policy. This is a vague phrase which he uses frequently but carefully avoids defining. Later in his speech he spoke about wages being settled in free negotiation and, whatever may be said for that particular method, it seems to me the very opposite to the type of incomes policy that he had in mind and as he wanted us to interpret it.

All these matters, he said, were to be organised on a basis of goodwill and mutual understanding, which sounded to me far more like a prayer than a policy. Then he went on to call for what he called a constructive banking policy with a combined approach of Government, Central Bank and commercial banks—another fine but rather meaningless phrase unaccompanied by any indication of the extent to which present banking policy is defective or requires to be changed.

He spoke, again very pretentiously, of effective co-ordination between the monetary and the economic policies. That, to me, is as fatuous and as meaningless a statement as anything that ever appeared in an Irish Times leading article. The leader of a political Party, any political Party, but, I suppose, very especially, Fine Gael, should be trying all the time to bring all his colleagues up to some level of responsibility. Once he starts allowing himself to fall down to their lowest level of partisan irresponsibility, then he is abandoning the obligations of leadership. I regret that Deputy Cosgrave here, yesterday, decided to revive some of the antiquated political jibes that were at one time Fine Gael's entire stock-in-trade but which we thought he was going to put on the scrapheap as an unwanted legacy from the Dillon days.

Comment on this

So they hurt, did they?

Comment on this

I recognise, of course, that he has got political needs vis-à-vis his own Party and that this is the kind of stuff that members of his Party understand and expect but, if I may say so without offence, I suggest that he should seek to establish his reputation as a Party leader on a sounder basis. He may be fairly sure that, no matter what he says, Deputy L'Estrange will still lead the applause.

Comment on this

One sure sign that the Taoiseach is rattled is when he is offensive.

Comment on this

To get back to the more serious aspects of Deputy Cosgrave's speech, he asked if the Government would give an indication of the likely trend of events in regard to the import levies, to facilitate traders who may wish to place orders for delivery of these goods after next March. Personally, I do not think that the Government should be expected to facilitate operations of that kind. We have announced that the levies are in force until March 31st, next year. I hope it will be possible then to let them lapse but, as I said, it would be irresponsible on our part to make a firm commitment to that effect until all the facts are known.

May I say a few words also about Deputy Corish's speech? First of all, he gave me the impression of making a speech here yesterday because he had to make a speech and not because he had anything new or different or important to say. As I am giving advice on Party management to Fine Gael, I may as well give it to the Labour Party. I think the Labour Party will have to train themselves to look squarely at realities, not just to deplore them or to moan about them but to decide how to deal with them. None of our difficulties, whether they are large or small, will go away just because the Labour Party do not like them. It seems to me that the way to get rid of these difficulties is by plan and action and in these respects Labour Party Deputies have nothing to say or, at any rate, decided that they would not say it on this occasion. If the Labour Party aspire to exercise influence in Irish life, they will have to abandon the role of the Party of discontent and be prepared to commit themselves to some clear ideas and some definite proposals and, perhaps, formulate eventually what could be presented as a comprehensive policy. Jeremiah was never a very popular guy but he had not to go up for election and was not worried about his popularity.

Comment on this

You will not be in the top ten.

Comment on this

A philosophy of defeat and gloom with Deputy Treacy as its high priest will set no bonfires alight. Most Deputies who think about these matters would prefer to have a more constructive role for their Party.

Comment on this

The blowlamps will set fire to us all.

Comment on this

I hope the Deputy will not do anything rash, such as setting fire to himself on Leinster Lawn.

Comment on this

I can understand the Taoiseach's anxiety about the blowlamp.

Comment on this

The Labour Party belief, expressed by Deputy Corish and supported by other members of the Party, that the price increases of the past couple of years could have been prevented by some earlier application of price controls does not stand up to any detailed examination of the price increases of that period as reflected in the consumer price index. I am going to take these price increases, the commodities which have gone up in the price, in the order of their importance in the index. The first was beef. The increase in the price of beef added 2.5 points to the index. That was due to the high prices prevailing in the export markets. No system of price control that we could have applied here could have prevented these higher prices following on the increase in export markets. The only result of any attempt at price control would have been to make it impossible for Irish butchers to purchase Irish cattle and so would have made vegetarians of all of us. There is an inquiry being undertaken at the moment into the whole system of marketing of our meat.

The second group of commodities that added to the consumer price index were those which are affected by increases in taxation, cigarettes, whiskey and stout, and the increase in taxation on these commodities was imposed with the approval of the Labour Party and with the consent of most Deputies in the Dáil, in order to enable us to pay out higher old age pensions and to provide better social service benefits generally.

The next cause of the increase in the consumer price index was the increase in the price of potatoes and this was due to the bad harvest and the shortage of supplies. Whatever the disadvantages to consumers it is at least one consolation to know that the higher prices operated to compensate the producers for the bad yield. Fresh milk was responsible for another increase in the consumer price index and that was due to higher prices which were sanctioned for fresh milk and, to some extent, to higher wages in milk distribution.

The increase in the price of bread was due almost entirely to higher labour costs, although there was an increase in the price of wheat. These items account for about half of the total increase in the consumer price index. Is there any one of these in which Deputy Corish would say we should have controlled the prices?

Comment on this

Tell us about the turnover tax.

Comment on this

The turnover tax raised prices by three per cent. It did what it was intended to do. Of the remaining half of the increases that took place in the two year period, while some were related to increased import prices——

Comment on this

They were infinitesimal.

Comment on this

——higher labour costs accounted for the greater part of the other half. If we had done as Deputy Corish asked, that following the National Wage Agreement we should at that time have imposed price control, it would have meant that most of the workers would not have got the increases and that the rest of them could not have got them until much later.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

When you get down to thinking about these things, you will realise how true that is. If we had said to every employer whose employees were seeking an increase of 12 per cent in wages that they could not increase their prices, how many of the employees would have got the increase? That is what you are saying we should have done.

Comment on this

Deputy Corish misquoted me when he said I was not blaming the British import levies for the falling off in our industrial exports. There has been no falling off in total imports.

Comment on this

That is what I said.

Comment on this

The effect of the British levies was that there was a falling off in industrial exports to Britain but there has been an increase in our industrial exports to other destinations, although the increase in these exports has not been as considerable as we would hope for. I am surprised at Deputy Corish's concern that we should not express criticism of the British Government for imposing this charge. He said that his Party was advocating price control for the past two years but I hope he and his Party will assist us in providing a defence when all the consequences which may flow from this measure of price control begin to emerge. I am sure that not all of them will be welcome.

Comment on this

Then why did you bring in price control at all?

Comment on this

Several Deputies, including Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy O'Higgins, appeared to be of the opinion that the import levies now in force should have been imposed much earlier. If the Government had taken action before it was certain that that action would be required, before it could be demonstrated as necessary, it would have been another story. The Government took action when the situation required it and when most Irish business circles expected that action would be taken.

I mentioned yesterday that some countries had made formal protests about the levies. They were not many, they were not serious and they were not pursued when the circumstances were explained. They would have been much more seriously pursued if the need for the levies could not have been as clearly shown. There was adverse comment in some foreign newspapers. The usual argument advanced by those who made these protests and by these newspapers who did not fully appreciate our circumstances here was that with our reserves standing at over £200 million a deficit in external payments as anticipated by us in this year could have been carried by these reserves without imposing any restrictions on trade.

If this was a temporary situation, one which we could say was now over, or coming to an end, no action would have been required and none would have been taken. Our concern is not with what has happened but with what may happen. We propose to correct the adverse trends which threaten our economic stability before these trends become too strong. Earlier action would have been unjustifiable. It is generally accepted by the Irish business community and abroad that this action was necessary.

Deputy Dillon compared these measures which the Government are now taking with the measures which his Government took in 1956. He says that our measures are inadequate but I will give this assurance to the House and the country, that this Government will not build up a surplus of £12 million in external assets as in 1957 at the cost of one hundred thousand unemployed.

Comment on this

Why did you keep on the levies then?

Comment on this

The Labour and Fine Gael Parties have been talking on this subject of an incomes policy. I have often objected to the use of this phrase in a loose way by people who clearly have no conception of its meaning or regard it as a cure-all. When I use this term "incomes policy", I mean complete and effective arrangements that will ensure that the benefits of rising production and productivity are reflected in higher incomes, including wages and salaries regularly and adequately while at the same time avoiding undue or untimely increases so as to ensure that the benefit of higher incomes in living standards will be as full as possible by minimising adverse effects on the general price level and, with particular regard, to the consequences in respect of the expansion of employment.

It seems to me that an incomes policy must also be capable of serving social purposes, involving some redistribution of the national income for the benefit of the worst off groups of our community and must, therefore, imply a willingness on the part of the better-off groups not to press for increases of equivalent percentage amounts and to accept whatever taxation is required so that those worse off may be assisted, without seeking compensation in their own remuneration.

We are slowly building up to such a conception but it is a very hesitant process. Pitfalls of suspicion and misunderstanding abound. I think it would help to have defined, in as precise a way as possible, what are the components of an incomes policy and what are the social purposes to which it should be directed. I hope that the NIEC may undertake this task.

Comment on this

That is not original from the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave said that I did not admit in the course of my opening statement that the Government had made any mistake in this situation. Looking back now, I can say that if we had started to pull down the level of Government capital expenditure earlier in the year, we would have found it easier to impose limitations, but, now when we are going to do it, Deputies do not seem to be very happy about it and I doubt if they would have been happy about it earlier in the year either.

Deputy Dillon said that I said we are planning to cut back expenditure on health services and education. I said nothing of the kind. I said in my opening statement that we see a necessity to defer expensive improvements in the health and education services until the economic situation improves. I want to make it clear that existing policies will proceed and what I have in mind are significant new developments involving substantial expenditures. So far as the health services are concerned, the Government have comprehensive plans for their development but, with the best will in the world, these developments could not in any event and for practical reasons, have proceeded far in the coming financial year. The present financial difficulties will not stop us developing long plans for the health services. In fact, the Government have recently decided to publish them in a White Paper which I hope will appear before the end of the year, so that there can be full public discussion on them before the final decisions are taken and legislation drafted for their implementation. It is the firm wish of the Government that these and other social services should be developed as the growth of national income makes it possible. The wish is to be in a position to push on steadily and early with our development and that indeed is an important factor influencing the Government in their present steps to strengthen the national economy.

With regard to educational facilities here, we are awaiting the receipt of Commission reports on important aspects. The intention is that development plans will be fully prepared, publicised and implemented as rapidly as our resources permit. We must, however, be realistic in our recognition of the fact that in the circumstances of 1966 if substantial additions to taxation are to be avoided, as we hope, the rate of progress in relation to these or, indeed, any of the State services will be less rapid than we would wish but some progress will be achieved.

Deputies opposite appear very anxious to overlook what has happened in respect of these services and this applies also to misinformed newspaper commentators on these developments. The enormous development which has taken place in our educational services in recent years is, I am sure, well understood by those who are concerned about the educational facilities of the State but they are not likely to be mentioned by Deputies across the way when they are speaking at the crossroads. In the past ten years, these services have been so expanded that Government spending on them has increased from £13.2 million ten years ago in 1955 to £33.7 million in this year. For every four pounds spent on the education of our youth in 1955, there is £10 being spent today.

Comment on this

Even if the Vote for Education next year is no higher than it is this year, it will still be more than 150 per cent higher than it was during that golden era Deputy Dillon was talking about.

Comment on this

The same applies to our health services. The expenditure on our health services, where there has also been a very considerable expansion, has more than doubled over the same period. Total expenditure on health in 1955 was £7.8 million. In this year, including a Supplementary Estimate yet to be submitted, it will amount to £15.8 million. If it can continue to expand at this rate, it will be grand but, if we cannot do it, it will still be a record of achievement which we will be able to present to the people with pride.

There were a few other matters mentioned in the course of this debate to which I should like to refer and which may be less contentious if Deputies will keep quiet. Like Deputies, the Government have been concerned by reason of the placing of orders by Government Departments abroad in the circumstances where the wisdom and sense of these courses appear dubious. In some instances, it is more by reason of the normal operation of standard procedures and after the normal preference has been extended to Irish firms tendering for the contracts. There always has been the need and always will be the need to prevent the taxpayer being mulcted in unreasonable quotations by Irish firms. This will only be done by making it clear that if it does happen the Government will resort to other sources of supply. The Government have now decided that substantial orders should not be placed abroad for goods or equipment capable of being supplied by Irish sources without the specific approval of the Minister concerned and where it is possible, there should be at this time a postponement of other purchases. We expect this practice to be followed by all the State-sponsored bodies.

Deputy Cosgrave referred to what he called the exclusion of agricultural representatives from the National Industrial Economic Council. I have spoken so often on this matter that it is hardly necessary for me to speak on it again but apparently what I did say has not registered. There is no exclusion. If farming organisations are willing to accept responsibility for membership, there is no objection to that course so far as the Government are concerned. There may be some practical difficulties of arranging adequate representation for farming interests within a reasonable number of members, but I feel sure an adjustment of the present balance of representation by the principal interests on the council can be negotiated, if this is regarded as necessary.

Comment on this

That is a change.

Comment on this

It is no change. I said this in a speech I made at the first meeting of the NIEC. Deputies can read it if they are interested.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The allegation that is frequently expressed by Fine Gael Deputies that Government policy is settled by civil servants is an absurdity and can only be put forward by a Party who are mentally reconciled to being permanently in Opposition. We have many highly competent civil servants to whose advice we give full weight, but decisions on policy are made by the Government, and only by the Government. If there were any member of the Government, who in my judgment, was not fully in charge of the policy of his Department, I would regard it as my duty to request his resignation. That has never arisen and I do not expect it will ever arise in this Government. Every decision of the Government is subject to challenge in debate in the Dáil, and is defended here by the man or men who made it. It is my duty to see that policy decisions of Ministers within their own Departments are fully co-ordinated, and kept in line with the overriding policy of the Government as a whole, a policy that has been widely publicised and fully documented to the Dáil.

I will not occupy the hour, but I want to repeat what I said yesterday and, indeed, what the more responsible members of the two Opposition Parties confirmed in their remarks. Nothing has gone fundamentally wrong with the national economy, and it is the determination of the Government to act in good time to prevent anything from going wrong in a fundamental way.

I do not know in what kind of world Deputy Treacy lives. He does not seem to have any understanding at all of the situation prevailing in the country, or pay any attention to the official statistics that are published. Production is rising. We may not in this year achieve the rate of growth in national output for which we hoped and for which we programmed but we will still have growth and it will be at least three times the average rate of growth in all the six Coalition years.

Unemployment is lower. Deputy Corish said unemployment was rising, or perhaps it was Deputy Treacy said that. We send him every week an analysis of the Live Register but this seems to be a waste of time, paper and postage. In the first nine months of this year the average number on the unemployment register expressed as a percentage of the total labour force was the lowest ever recorded since these statistics were prepared. In seven of those months and in the two other months, when the level of unemployment was affected by trade disputes, the percentage on the register was not higher than the lowest previously recorded.

Comment on this

What about the week of 27th October? It showed an increase on last year.

Comment on this

Of a 100 or so, and trade disputes affected that, too.

Comment on this

Here we have a situation in which there is no loss of output. Output is rising. There is no slipping back in the national economy. It is not going ahead as fast as we would wish, but it is still going ahead. There are more people in employment than there were last year. Fewer people are registered as unemployed. When I say that in this year the number registered as unemployed in most of the first nine months of the year as a percentage of our labour force was less than that ever recorded, I hope I will be able to say the same next year. That will depend on the effectiveness of the measures we are taking now and the degree of public co-operation we get in fulfilling them.

Comment on this

Wives, put your husbands to work in Birmingham.

Comment on this

Because of the country's progress in recent years, and particularly because of the exceptional improvement in our position last year, the country is in a much stronger position now to meet the impact of a temporary period of difficulty. In recent years we moved to a higher plateau of activity, and there we intend to stay. We have no intention of allowing the country to slip down from that plateau. We intend to consolidate our gains, our gains in production, our gains in providing employment, our gains in higher living standards, and the object of our policy now is to ensure that these gains will be made permanently safe so that a revival of our nation's progress at a still more rapid pace will be made possible later.

Comment on this

You nearly believe it yourself.

Comment on this

We are confident we can do it and, as the Party responsible for the management of the nation's business, the fact that we have confidence in our capacity to do this is far more important than the despondency of those Deputies who spoke in this debate with the intention of undermining public confidence and adding to a nation's difficulties.

Comment on this

Not a word about anything specific.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment No. 1 put.

Tá 63
·
Níl 69
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Division

Amendment No. 2 put.

Tá 63
·
Níl 69
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?