Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.
Contributions 103–211 of 211. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
Stitching is one process. Where is the other process? If three yards of Japanese cloth are used to make a dress, the only process involved is cutting out and stitching up. Is that one process and must there be another?
Comment on this
Did the Minister say a limited quantity of these dresses, in which only one process was involved, will be allowed in?
Comment on this
It must be two processes. That has not come to light until this moment. This is very important.
Comment on this
There is, as I said, a certain percentage permitted in outer wear which does not apply to inner wear.
Comment on this
If there is less than a certain percentage non-area material, then it is all right. It is limited in percentage only and, as far as I know, it does not create a problem for manufacturers.
Comment on this
It does not create a problem? Does the Minister think they will be able to send as much as heretofore?
Comment on this
Much more than before. The general achievement is a big improvement. Would the Deputy be confusing the issue with the low cost cotton?
Comment on this
This has nothing to do with the rules of origin. The Deputy has been talking about a different thing from what I was talking about.
Comment on this
What has happened is that Deputy O'Higgins was talking about man-made fibres and Deputy Donegan was talking about cotton. I was dealing mainly with man-made fibres.
Comment on this
May I not make a speech as I intended to do? I would not know the details which manufacturers would know. Any information that is required by manufacturers, exporters or even Deputies will be made available to them in the most detailed way if they can formulate their questions and know what they are talking about.
Comment on this
Is the Minister for Industry and Commerce not entitled to make his speech?
Comment on this
The rules of origin are very complex, and we have had a good example of how confusing they can be for all of us. I do not think that politicians could be expected to know all about cloths and threads of different kinds that even exporters themselves find difficult. I think they would be well advised to consult either the Department of Industry and Commerce or Córas Tráchtála who will give them detailed, specific advice on their own particular problem. I understand that Córas Tráchtála are preparing a leaflet which will be available for exporters in the near future. They hope to have discussions with exporters to explain the rules of origin. Therefore there is nothing to be gained by going through the very complex field of rules of origin and putting them on the records of this House.
Comment on this
In relation to cotton, this is a separate Agreement. Side by side with the Free Trade Agreement, a separate Agreement governing trade in certain cotton textiles has been made. Under this Agreement the Irish Government have undertaken to continue existing control on the exports from this country of cotton yarn for five years. They have also undertaken to restrict the exports of cloth, household textiles and made-up goods manufactured from materials originating in countries whose direct exports to Britain are themselves restricted. The control of exports of these goods will last for five years. The base level of the amount is something to be decided between the two Governments within the next two months. It is expected that the base will be a recent year and that there will be a provision for growth in the controlled exports on a basis equivalent to the rate of growth of the British market for cotton textile products. Cotton products other than those covered by the special Agreement are subject to the ordinary application of the Free Trade Area Agreement rules and are not affected by the restriction now being imposed on low cost cotton.
Comment on this
Yes; that is the Agreement. I have outlined the situation as far as I can. Any information that Deputies or exporters want will be available in the Department of Industry and Commerce. I should like to repeat what I said earlier, that any benefits to be gained or any untoward effects to be avoided will depend mostly on people outside this House. It will depend on the attempts at adaptation made by industry itself. That is why I say I would not like to say anything in this debate which would reduce the feeling of urgency and anxiety which should drive our industrialists into organising their industries and adapting their industries, and guide our workers into winning for themselves a livelihood in this country out of the new opportunities.
My predecessor in office, Deputy Lynch, spent many a long day and night exhorting and almost begging Irish industry to adapt itself. That was eight years ago when the question of a European Free Trade Area was first raised, four years ago when the question of EEC was raised, and since he arranged for the unilateral removal of tariffs. Some firms of honourable mention have responded to this and have made themselves fit for competition. This time, however, I should like to talk about the firms that have not responded and have not seen fit to adapt themselves to the competitive conditions of free trade. I suppose this Agreement seems to give further time for adaptation, but again, as was remarked already, we may have joined a wider trading group which requires a more rapid reduction of our tariffs before the end of the transition period mentioned in this Agreement.
There has never been so much advance warning given of any impending change. Some months ago during a debate on the economic situation, I dealt at length with adaptation, the amount of adaptation that has taken place, and the need for urgently getting down to adaptation by those who had not taken part. Now at this time with my short period of experience in this office, I find myself more concerned with another aspect of adaptation, the mental outlook of management and workers towards their responsibilities and their work in this new situation. I suppose it is inevitable that 30 years of protection should have fostered in management and workers an attitude of mind which would be fatal in an era of free trade. This is the lack of a sense of urgency about which I complained before. This is the lack of response to the exhortations of my predecessor over so many years. I should like to say to them now that if a sense of urgency does not become part of the normal attitude of mind of management and workers, we have very little to look forward to in a free trade area. The managers here must compete with managers in other countries and the workers and trade unions here must contribute every bit as much as the workers and the unions in competing countries.
The rate of productivity which enables a country or an industry to carry on without difficulty behind high tariff walls is not the rate which would enable it to survive in free trade conditions. Much has been done by the Irish Productivity Committee but we would be deluding ourselves if we failed to realise that over a large range of Irish industries there is scope for much further improvement in productivity. Let me repeat, therefore, that while physical adaptation is of primary importance in meeting free trade conditions, and is of the greatest urgency, it is not of itself sufficient if we are to achieve what we desire—to put it bluntly, nothing more or less than industrial survival. Physical adaptation must be accompanied by a radical change in outlook, in practice, in trends of thought, much more so than was necessary during a prolonged period of high protections. That type of outlook must disappear.
The time for physical adaptation is running out, now that the terms of this Free Trade Agreement are known. The uncertainty of our future trading relations has now been removed and people cannot any longer blame uncertainty as a cause for inhibiting final decisions in relation to adaptation. To assist these firms who have not already taken the necessary adaptation measures, the Government have decided to extend the provisions of the legislation in relation to adaptation grants to enable such grants to be approved up to 31st December, 1967, provided application is made by 30th September, 1967 to An Foras Tionscal. This gives industry an extra 18 months in which to formulate extra plans for adaptation, if these plans are to be grant-aided. I hope this last opportunity will be availed of to the fullest. I should like to draw attention here to the fact that applications for adaptation grants lodged after 31st March, 1966, will be confined to expenditure in the future and such grants may not be applied retrospectively as at present. This should encourage firms not already undertaking adaptation measures, or who have but have not yet applied for grants, to get down to it before 31st March next.
Many calls were made to industry by the Government to create circumstances that would insure against the worst effects foreseen by the more pessimistic members of the community. I should like to repeat that the outcome in 1970 and 1975 depends to a great extent not on what the Government do but on the action of the various parts of industry. I have already mentioned that productivity of course would be largely determined by improved skills and more scientific means of production, of work study and the use of more up to date machinery. We must also look for more co-operation and understanding between workers and management. This will become increasingly important. I am sure that in this respect the community look for an enlightened spirit of trade union leadership. Trade unions have worked hard and have participated in the various organisations concerned with industrial efficiency and increased productivity. This, of course, is for the direct benefit of their members as well as for the common national good. They are now participating in various councils of State. I should like to be able to remove any doubt people may have that they are adequately organised to get the fullest possible support from their own members.
On this question of efficiency, it is not in ten years' time, when all the tariffs are gone, but in five or six years when half the protective level will be removed, that the first real wind of competition will be felt. Even in five years' time we will not just be starting to become competitive and if what we do in 1966 is against the economy, if it is wrong for the economy, then what we do this year will not be undone by 1970. If we continue to award ourselves pay increases without corresponding productivity increases this year and next year, we will very likely have priced ourselves out of competition by 1970.
There have been great changes in the employment pattern in Ireland during the past ten years and I foresee even greater changes during the next ten years. There are areas in the country which will suffer reductions in employment and other areas where there will be increased employment opportunities. These changes are inevitable. They happen in every country which is developing and making progress. It is the price of progress. Other countries have had to face up to it and so must we. Many people are reluctant to face this inevitable change in employment opportunities and incidence. They are naturally afraid their jobs will be jeopardised or that their patterns of life will be upset.
We must overcome this fear of change or the fear will overcome us. The main aim of the Government's manpower policy and the various explanations we have published of it is to minimise the need for workers to feel apprehensive about changes which are about to come. We must try to look into the future and forecast these changes so that they will not prevent workers from earning a decent standard of living in their own country. We have decided on a number of measures to make it easier for workers to change from one type of employment to another and to protect the worker from fear at the disappearance of one type of work by gearing him for another type.
The White Paper was published by the Government to explain this manpower policy, and I am happy to be in a position to inform the House that substantial progress has been achieved by the Parliamentary Secretary in this, one of the most important of our works for the near future. Since the publication of the White Paper, a manpower advisory committee consisting of representatives of the Federated Union of Employers and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, under the chairmanship of an official of the Department of Industry and Commerce, was set up last month to assist the manpower agency in its work. An Industrial Training Bill which proposes the establishment of a number of authorities with wider powers in regard to industrial training and re-training was introduced on 14th December, and it is hoped to circulate this Bill at a early date. A draft scheme for redundancy payments and re-settlement allowances has been prepared. This draft scheme, together with the initial development proposals and placement functions which have been agreed upon, has been submitted to the manpower advisory committee which meets in a couple of days' time. Arrangements for recruitment of staff for the manpower forecasting unit and careers information service are in hand and every effort will be made to have this functioning as soon as possible.
In relation to the motor car industry, I should explain that quota restrictions on vehicles are required under the Agreement to be abolished on 1st July. On the removal of the quotas, a shadow duty of 75 per cent flat will come into operation. This duty contains a revenue element and the protective part will be reduced. We have the alternative of reducing it in the normal ten year ten per cent rhythm or, if we wish, to have it removed altogether by 1971.
Comment on this
Of 75 per cent or of 100 per cent? Is it 58 per cent of the 75 per cent or 58 per cent of the value of the goods?
Comment on this
The Committee on Industrial Organisation which examined various aspects of Irish industry when the prospect of joining the EEC was first alive felt that this assembly industry would not survive in free trade. Since then people who are familiar with the industry, and others longer associated with the administrative side of the industry in this country, have come to regard the CIO estimation as somewhat pessimistic. Whatever the outcome, the next six or seven years should see little change and in that time it will be our duty as the Government to seek to make arrangements — and also it should be the duty of the owners of these assembly plants and industries — to make provision against future losses of employment by their workers. I have already mentioned in former debates the efforts which have been made to encourage assemblers to transfer their management and work force to other manufacturing activities. This together with what the Government agencies can do, plus the activities of the manpower agency having regard to new industrial development, will do much to allay the anxieties of the workers in the motor assembly industry.
Someone seemed to think we would not have all that industrial development which the Taoiseach spoke of, but my experience in the past few weeks since the Agreement, since the establishment of a secure and wider trading area, has been that there is a livelier interest here in Ireland on the part of prospective promoters of new industries for exporting. The lack of security which existed during the negotiations on EFTA and the EEC and especially in the past couple of years, inhibited the interests which people might normally have had. I can say that since the signing of the Agreement, since it has become a fact, and since the wider area of trade has become a fact, people who before this were holding back have come very much more actively into negotiations about industries which I would regard as very important additions to our employment opportunities and export trade.
In this regard I suppose I should point out one of the gains which we do not underline as a gain, that is, the right of this country to continue with export tax concessions for the life of legislation which we have provided. As Deputies know, these concessions are available to industries setting up in any part of the country up to 1980, and in the Shannon Free Airport area up to 1983.
Much of the statement by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions on the Free Trade Area Agreement is clearly dealt with in the book which has been presented to all Deputies — the White Paper on the Agreement. They deal with all the things the Government have taken into account, and exhort the Government to do things which the Government have already decided to take into account. One thing which is clear from Congress's reaction is that they have had the same healthy reaction to the Agreement as the Federation of Irish Industries. They accept that this is a new situation, that this is a fact, that this is a trading arrangement, and they ask: "What do we do about it?" The fact that both sides of industry are starting the first year of the new Agreement with this attitude is something that augurs well.
My intention in intervening in this debate was to inform. I know it would not be possible for any one person to carry the detailed provisions of a Trade Agreement in his head, or even in a brief. Again, I invite those who need information to seek it in my Department where every assistance will be given to the exporter, the industrialist, or the Deputy, who wants to have clearer information on the implications of the Free Trade Area Agreement. I would say nothing to deny the right of industrialists to feel anxiety. Anxiety, worry and insecurity are the lot of industrialists in every part of the world. It is the milieu in which this breed of man finds his métier and his success and I do not know any reason why our industrialists should live in a different position from that of industrialists elsewhere. I am quite convinced that our managements and our workers can, given the proper attitude of mind, by adapting their mental attitude compete with workers and management anywhere in the world and it will be the job of my Department to give them every assistance to do that.
Comment on this
A day, or a couple of days after the documents which this House is asked to approve were signed in London by the British Prime Minister and the Taoiseach, The Times of London appeared with a story about the Agreement and referred to it as being the end of the philosophy of Sinn Féin. I do not know whether the writer of that article knew the coin he was using so far as his country was concerned, because for us Sinn Féin has meant the coming of a change, which made it possible for an Irish Government to go to London and there freely to treat with the Government of Britain. Sinn Féin for us has meant the development in our own way of our own resources and the expression of our determination to make of ourselves a nation in the world. If the writer of this article in The Times meant to convey that our people or any Irish Government had lost or were losing the determination to fight or maintain for this country our position in the world by a reliance upon our own resources, then we reject without question that suggestion.
We have little doubt that whatever is involved in this Agreement, whether it is a good one or a bad one, whether it is the right thing to do, or the right time to do it, certainly the philosophy of Sinn Féin and what it meant and means for our people will not be forgotten. Indeed, we may have to call more upon it in the times that lie ahead and in relation to the challenge that lies ahead. We may have to realise that the competition in a narrowing world may demand from us a far greater display of national determination and a resolution to depend on our own resources than we had ever had to face in the past. For that reason I have little doubt that any English writer who thinks that the conclusion of this Agreement means the end of the philosophy of Sinn Féin requires to think again.
If, on the other hand, the writer of this article meant that the signing of this Agreement means the ending of a philosophy which believes in indiscriminate tariff protection, the end of the philosophy which believed that by keeping out competitors, you could strengthen your economic position, then, while it is not historically accurate to attribute that philosophy to Sinn Féin, he may be right, because I do not believe that from now on, certainly in the present situation, and in the immediate future, any country in Western Europe can rely on indiscriminate protection by tariffs to promote or sustain a national economy. The explosion that has taken place following the end of the last war has changed, probably permanently, thinking on these lines. From the efforts to reconstruct Europe following the carnage of the last war, there has been a trend which gradually has grown stronger and has now become a pretty irresistible force, a trend towards the liberalisation of trade, the removal of tariff barriers of one kind or another all over Europe.
That is a situation which exists; it is a fact that we have got to realise and it is in the context of that view and of that understanding that we have to consider this Agreement and what has been done on our behalf by the Government. If we do not approach this Agreement in the realisation of these matters, we may very easily come to faulty conclusions. This Agreement is in its terms irrevocable. The Taoiseach today reminded the House of that fact. It is well that we should realise the significance of that. To the extent that agreements between nations are honoured by nations, this Free Trade Agreement ties this country permanently to the economy of Britain. Whether the Agreement be good or bad, for better or for worse, under the terms of the Agreement, there can be no stepping back.
The mere statement of that fact five years ago—certainly ten years ago— in this House by any member of the Government would have aroused the most incredulous cries of protest because it would have been true then, and I think it is true today, that normally and ordinarily it would be unthinkable for this country so to tie itself to Britain — unthinkable for a country such as ours that spent so much of its efforts and of its resources on the philosophy of Sinn Féin in ending the free trade area that existed all over these islands and in securing for ourselves the right to decide our own economic and national policies. It would be unthinkable in normal circumstances for a country with that background and position, with the fears and susceptibilities we have had for very good reason, to turn back the pages of history and to make ourselves, as we had been, the larder of England. It is therefore tempting in a debate of this kind to speak immediately from an understandable reaction to an agreement which is so out of tune and so out of context with our recent national history. But we have got to remember that these are not ordinary times and that this Agreement cannot and should not—and I fear the Labour Party have made a fundamental error in this matter — be considered as an agreement concluded in normal circumstances with Britain.
That is not the fact. There is in the background the imponderable factor of Europe, imponderable because there is none of us can state with any assurance or certainty how great, how small, how real or how unreal a factor in the present situation is the possibility of European union. But it is true to say this: if the Rome Treaty is to be expanded and if it is to cast its net over the entire of Western Europe, then neither we nor, any more than us, the British can henceforth consider merely our two countries. We will cease to have either that obligation or pleasure and we will be concerned merely by the position of our people and of our countries in a very much larger sphere of influence. It is because of the background of Europe to this discussion today that we have got to stand back from it and consider it not merely as an Agreement concluded between ourselves and the United Kingdom but as an Agreement that has been concluded by two countries that may in the near future be swallowed up in the greater Europe that many people believe is coming.
Having said that, it is unnecessary for me to say that whatever the future may be from Europe, whatever the developments may be, they have not happened yet. In fact, there is no certainty that they will happen, although the possibility is, I suppose, that they will. But the developments have not yet taken place. The justification for this Agreement and the only justification that can be made for it has to be based on the assumption that Britain and this country will both be in Europe by 1970. It is on that assumption and in that belief that the Agreement we are debating provides for the disposition on the British home market of a possible and expected growth in our production up to 1970. It is because of that assumption that we are going to be in Europe that the entire nature of this Agreement is moulded on the basis of the targets set out in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion.
All that is understandable. If by 1970 we are in Europe, if by 1970 the basis for this assumption has been realised, then everything in the garden will be rosy. We will then have to meet within the framework of the European Economic Community the challenge there involved and to arrange for the sale of our products in a wider market, including of course the British market. But if by 1970 neither we nor Britain are in Europe, if by 1970 the Rome Treaty for one reason or another has not been expanded, if by then there are still two trading camps in Europe and the bridge between them has not been built or travelled, then we shall find that we have cut a stick to beat ourselves.
It is for that reason that we in Fine Gael have very anxiously considered our position in relation to this Agreement. We look on it as a gamble, and frankly a gamble we doubt the Government are entitled to take. We look on it as a gamble, a gamble by the Government in the sense that they have chosen to say: "Our bet is that both Britain and ourselves will be in Europe in the next four years." On that assumption, betting in that sense, we conclude this Free Trade Area Agreement with the British because the exercise will work out as a preparation for Europe. That is a gamble from which, if it succeeds, no harm will come; but if it does not come off and we do not get into Europe, then this Agreement will work untold damage to the Irish economy. From 1970 on, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce indicated, it will cause increasing harm and damage to Irish industry. If it continues after 1970, and if we are not in Europe, it will cause the transformation of Irish agriculture back to the situation in which a man and a dog looked after large areas of ranch land and, from 1970 on, we shall very quickly be turned back into the situation in which we are the supplier of cheap beef for the British market. Our people will have lost and will lose, without doubt, any opportunity for expansion of employment and, from 1970 on, we must face the certainty that employment will recede and emigration will increase.
These are serious thoughts and those who may be affected, four years hence, could not have a say in the matter, anyway. However, the responsibility is ours here today to decide something which affects them and to hope that we do it rightly and in their interests. The first thing we have to say, whether the Government are proved right in this matter or not, is that we doubt their right to gamble in this matter. We doubt that it is justifiable that so large a risk be taken which can have such a far-reaching effect on this country but the fact is that this risk has been taken. This Agreement has been signed by an Irish Government expressly in the interest of freedom of trade, in the interest of the development of European economic co-operation, in the interest of all these other matters set out in the Preamble. In these circumstances, it appears well nigh impossible for any Member of this House who believes in the development of Europe to deny approval to an Agreement of this kind. I do not see how we can do it. We might doubt the wisdom or the right to take the gamble, but, it having been done, it is very difficult to say that approval should not be given. If this Dáil failed to approve this Agreement, we should be declaring, certainly to the British and I believe also to the Europeans, that we are not interested in the development of European economic co-operation and that, I believe, would not be in the long-term national interest.
We have also to say that while we regard this as a gamble, we also desire to know the circumstances in which the decision to venture this step was first taken. Today, the Taoiseach said it was his idea, not that of the British Prime Minister. He said it was an idea which he first put forward to the Conservative Prime Minister, Mr. Harold Macmillan, and, it not being acceptable then, he put it forward again in November of 1963. If that is so, we have witnessed a very strange exercise on the part of the head of a democratic Government. If, in fact, it has been the settled intention of the Fianna Fáil Government, over the past 18 months or so, to enter into precisely this Agreement, an Agreement based on the principle of free trade between this country and Britain, and if the only difficulty in their way was that of getting an amenable British Prime Minister to listen to them, why, in the name of everything that we regard as sacred in this country, have the Irish people not been told of it? Why was this particular settled intention not disclosed at an earlier date to our people so that they could pass judgment on whether or not this gamble was justified?
I think it right that I should remind the House, through the Chair, that the first time the term "Free Trade Area Agreement" was used was when the Taoiseach came back from London last July. However, we now know that it was not then that he had first thought of it but that throughout all the earlier months — in March, he says, of 1965 — his officials were as busy as bees working on this proposal.
Comment on this
It is well to mention that he used the words "March, 1965". May be he was busy at that time because the sovereign people of Ireland were being asked to elect a new Government. It might have been of passing interest to them to know that, behind the scenes, going on all the time, was the forging of this Agreement but nobody thought well of letting the people know so that the people could pass judgment on these rather grave matters. There are people who write articles in the newspapers, who pass judgment on Deputies for not controlling the power of bureaucracy. These scribes who write in that way might well think of what is involved in a matter of this kind. Here is the most far-reaching Agreement since the Treaty that established this State. Here is an Agreement that —unless it is stopped, as I hope it will be—by European development will have far-reaching effects on the future of our people. Yet the Taoiseach, the leader of a democratic Irish Government, tells us here today that this is not something that suddenly emerged last July but is something that was his settled intention and something which he had discussed with his colleagues, who were unanimous about it, a long, long time before. Nevertheless, not one of them thought it well to let the Irish people know what was in their minds. I regard that as outrageous and as quite contrary to any democratic principles which people talk about so glibly but obviously find so difficult to practise.
Why did the Taoiseach not disclose at the general election that he contemplated this agreement with the British—or was he afraid people might say it was an unwise thing to do? Why did the Taoiseach not tell the Irish people that he proposed to take this chance in the faith and conviction that it would be all right — that, in four years' time, we should all be in Europe? Was the Taoiseach afraid the people would say: "That is a chance you may not take. You may gamble with other things but you may not gamble with the future of this country"? Was he afraid that if he made that disclosure, he and his Party might lose the general election? Certainly, it appears to me that when he comes in today and says that was always his policy, he is either being untrue to the principles of democracy or is not being truthful in what he says to the House here today.
The Taoiseach also today taunted the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party on what were the alternatives. That is a very old political device and is a manner of thinking which is particularly familiar in the case of the Fianna Fáil Party. When a change of Government had taken place, one can remember the abolition of food subsidies and then the propaganda all over the country: "We had to do it, the others left us in debt and we had to do it". Here now the Taoiseach says: "Tell me the alternative; we have to do this". I want to challenge that. To me it is unthinkable that the Leader of an Irish Government could, for the 18 months before last July, have always looked and wished for a Free Trade Area Agreement with the British. I do not believe that. The British get so much out of this Agreement. They get twice as much as we do. The British will earn up to £75 million a year from Irish business. The increased business we can expect to get will be something of the order of £25 million a year.
I do not believe for one moment that the Taoiseach could have had a settled, firm determination to enter into an Agreement of this kind. I believe that other things must have been considered. I believe there must have been a consideration of an Agreement which would involve the partial freedom of industrial trade in return for certain agricultural benefits. I believe there must have been a consideration of all these matters. If my belief is correct, why could there not be a greater display of frankness in this matter? Why cannot we be told what alternative arrangements and conditions with the British were, in fact, considered? Are we to assume that nothing else but a Free Trade Agreement was considered the whole time? That is what the Taoiseach says. I cannot accept that that is so.
What about Europe? I listened carefully to the Taoiseach speaking about the possibility of development of opportunity in Europe since the breakdown of the British negotiations in January, 1963 and I have heard the Taoiseach speak in this House many times over the past 20 years. For those who may not have listened to and heard him as often as that, here is a tip: whenever you hear the Taoiseach getting indignant, vehement, annoyed and cross, be certain he is on weak grounds. Be certain he is on weak grounds and it is right that he should have been vehement, cross and that he should have protested in the strident way he did about Deputy Cosgrave's suggestion that more attention should have been paid to Europe, because there is the Taoiseach's Achilles heel. Make no mistake about it.
I want to assert that since General de Gaulle put the British out of Europe in January, 1963, and, with them, us, not one single thing has been done on the diplomatic front to investigate or endeavour to find out what our prospects have been in Europe. Nothing has been done over that period. We, as a small country, are absolutely involved in Europe, which means the possibility of expansion or extinction for our people. When we should have regarded this matter in that serious light, we had our Minister for External Affairs trotting over to the United Nations Organisation proposing Resolutions of interest to Timbuctoo and everywhere else in the Far East but he never darkened Europe with his footsteps. These are serious matters. What have the Government been doing for the past two years? They have allowed our situation in Europe to stagnate and I say it not merely in the form of guessing. I have gone to the trouble of going to Brussels to find out. I assert, without doubt, that apart from an effort which was made in relation to certain beef exports in the last three years, no effort, good, bad or indifferent, has been made by our Government to investigate the possibilities of getting into Europe.
The Taoiseach was indignant about it today: "Foolish to make such a suggestion," he says; "Anyone who could believe that that was possible would be native." There was, he said, the common custom tariff and the only thing the authorities in Brussels would consider would be adherence to that common tariff. If the Taoiseach believes that, I suppose this Government cannot do anything about it. We have to put up for the time being with the Taoiseach we have. He has been a very native man indeed himself because in the last three years the Austrians, who have strong ties with the Communist world, who are bound in economic ties for marketing with the Communists, have been able to convince the authorities in Brussels that they could enter Europe and be associated with Europe as an exception to the common custom tariff and still retain their markets in Eastern Europe. That has been accepted in the case of Austria. It is also accepted in the case of West Germany who have retained a situation in which they also have certain connections with the East. It has been accepted in the case of Portugal, Greece and many other countries. Why does the Taoiseach think it would be unthinkable? I assert he says that because it was not thought of at all. Instead of having the Minister for External Affairs cavorting around the place as a candidate for the Nobel Prize, he might have been in Brussels winning some prizes for our people and he would have been doing better business and better work.
I shall suggest there have been times in the past 18 months, in Europe particularly, when a certain statesman in France would have been very glad indeed to use the Irish as a pawn, if necessary, in a game of chess with the British. We, as a small country, still have our uses. Remember, the fact has been that on the Continent of Europe —I doubt what the situation now is— there was a very favourable climate for a young, sturdy, courageous, little country to join other countries in EEC. We have allowed that opportunity to go by and I fear that in doing so and in taking this gamble, we have very much queered our own pitch in Europe. I do not believe it is possible now, no matter what happened to this Agreement, to develop any independent policy in Europe. We have finished that once and for all. I think it is a tragedy to have done so. Let me recall that the Leader of the Government who did it is the same man who three years ago, puffed up with insistence on national independence, never kow-towing to the British or anybody else, declared that so far as he was concerned he was prepared to go into Europe, whether the British did so or not.
Comment on this
He did not mean it, but that was the sentiment of the Leader of the Government who today thinks it foolish for anybody to suggest the possibility that we could have explored entry into Europe in the past three years, foolish and naive. This is the same man who was prepared, if his words mean anything, to go into Europe, whether the British came in or not. He would have looked a very sorry sight, but that was his sentiment and those were his views. I suggest there has been a very serious dereliction of duty on the part of the Government by their inaction in relation to Europe in the past three years. We do not know and cannot know what could have been possible but we do know that there was goodwill available to us in Europe. We know that a small country particularly was always welcome in Europe and that countries with particular problems were never disregarded merely because they had problems and we know that one small country mounted a diplomatic offensive over the past 18 months which is now paying off and we know that Austria looks like concluding an agreement with the Common Market authorities which will give her a bit of the best of two worlds. What Austria could do we could have done if we were not so obsessed with settling the affairs of the globe and forgetting about our own people and problems.
Having said that, I want to come to the Agreement which we have. I suggest, however it happened — why it happened, I do not know—that there have been some very unfortunate claims made for this Agreement by a too-enthusiastic Minister. The most vocal in that regard has been the Minister for Agriculture. In the two or three days before Deputies and political Parties were able to see what was signed on their behalf, we had Press interviews and statements issued by the Minister for Agriculture with, I think, the result that every farmer in the country thought there was going to be a perpetual harvest moon and that the land was going to flow with milk and honey. It was only after this nonsense had been issued and finished with that eventually—I do not know the number of typists available to the Government — two or three days later, we were able to get these documents. Then there was difficulty about getting the copies. It was only then we were able to read in cold print the exact terms of this Agreement and assess for ourselves the possible benefits. It has been a very depressing bit of reading.
There is a Preamble to the Agreement and I feel those who concluded the Agreement were, if not trying to fool themselves, trying to fool other people, because the Preamble is an example of a failure to face facts. It speaks of "the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom, bearing in mind the close economic links long existing between the two countries and the special trading relationship which has developed under the Trade Agreements concluded in 1938, 1948 and 1960, and the substantial measure of interdependence of the economies of the two countries, determined to expand mutual trade and to that end to eliminate duties and other restrictive regulations of commerce on substantially all that trade...." That is a very fine sentence. This is a Preamble and one could imagine any Irish farmer quickly turning over the pages to find out how many restrictive regulations on agriculture had been removed. What does he find? Practically no change. There is a new thing called "guaranteed access" for store cattle, sheep and lambs. These are just to go in in the same way as they had been going in before but they are now guaranteed. But for butter there is a quota, for bacon a quota, for cereals a quota, and poultry, turkeys and broilers cannot go in or, at least if they do, we have to allow the British back and on everything else there is a restriction of one kind or another and some are very serious, as I shall show in a moment or two.
What, therefore, is the meaning of the phrase in the Preamble "and to that end to eliminate duties and other restrictive regulations of commerce on substantially all that trade"? Of course there has been a removal of restrictions on industry promised in this Agreement. Of that there is no doubt. Under this Agreement an industrial free trade area has been created between this country and Britain. That is to Britain's advantage, but in agriculture our farmers have been let down and our people have been let down by the man who spoke too soon and too big and who has not been sitting in for this debate at all today. Restrictions on agriculture have been retained and copper-fastened in many ways. In this Agreement we have thrown our domestic industrial market open to the British and we have had nothing substantial in return.
Again, the Preamble goes on:
Resolved to establish between their two countries a Free Trade Area, on a basis of fair reciprocity and having regard to the provisions of Article XXIV of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, with a view to the sustained development of all sectors of the economies of the two countries on terms of fair competition and to the promotion of increased productivity, the rational use of resources, full employment...
Again, I want to know why was "full employment" inserted into that Preamble? I do not think there is anyone who could believe other than that full employment of our people at home under this Agreement would be utterly impossible. Still, "full employment" is included in the Preamble. I do not believe it could mislead any Irish Minister or, indeed, any British Minister, but why is it inserted in the Preamble? Is it to create the impression that if it is in the Preamble to an Agreement of this kind, it will mean something to the people? Of course, it does not. A spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down. There it is.
I could discuss the actual details of the Agreement at some length but I do not want unduly to trespass on the indulgence of the House but there are one or two details of the Agreement I want to refer to. I have said that, in relation to agriculture, this Agreement just does not stand examination. We have had a change, if you like, to guarantees of access for store animals. That is a very welcome change in verbiage but it does not make a thraneen of difference to the substantial trade in live animals being carried on between this country and Britain for many years back. There never has been a restriction, in the interests of organised marketing or for any other reason, apart from a certain unhappy situation that once developed when we had to cut the throats of all our calves, but, apart from those days, there never has been any difficulty in our selling to the British our store animals. It may be a consoling thing to know that there is guaranteed right of access but I cannot think that it will make the slightest difference to my constituents around Graiguenamanagh, Rathdowney and such places. I do not believe that they feel any more confident. I think they will still raise about the same number of cattle as they usually raise and will do the same things with them, but, apparently, the Government feel that these people should feel a little happier about it and a little more confident in relation to doing what they always do. I do not believe there will be any difference.
Then there is the next gain that we are supposed to have got, the reduction of the waiting period from three months to two months. That period was increased to three months after the 1948 Trade Agreement, by the British. I think Fianna Fáil were in office at the time, when they lost us a month.
Comment on this
It does not matter. I think the conclusion will be the same. Whatever was feared in the extension of the period from two months to three months in relation to the cattle trade, it did not happen; it made absolutely no difference. So I cannot believe that the winning back of the month will make any difference but, if it does, it must have a very infinitesimal effect.
Then we have the deficiency payments for 25,000 tons of carcase beef and five and a half thousand tons of lamb; and there it is. These are the concessions which are supposed to transform Irish agriculture. It has been estimated, very optimistically, that these particular gains will mean something about £3¾ million a year to Irish farmers and that has been estimated at something equivalent to an increase of 1½ per cent in the farmers' income, something less than 6d in the £. This is the wonderful douche of prosperity which Irish farmers will get under this Agreement.
That is on the credit side. Under this Agreement that is supposed to remove restrictive regulations of commerce on substantially all the trade between the two countries, there still is retained the restriction on the export of sugar, control of sugar, under the existing sugar agreements. We still have specifically under this agreement the right of the British to control exports of Irish potatoes, of new potatoes, seed potatoes and sweet potatoes, and we still have under this agreement the continuation of the situation which has caused considerable imbalance in our economy over the years, the retention of the quota system for butter, bacon and cereals.
It does not matter that there is a slight increase in the permitted quota for butter. That is not important. What is important is that in this Agreement, which is paraded as the freeing, substantially, of all our commerce with Britain, Britain reserves the right to control the commerce produced from Irish butter. That is the fact that causes difficulty here. We are supposed to be expanding our cattle population. Fianna Fáil may be able to produce one but up to this I have never heard of a cow that did not produce milk at one stage or another. We cannot increase our cattle population without increasing the amount of milk and, consequently, the amount of butter that will be available for distribution and for sale.
It is quite absurd to call this a Free Trade Area so far as agriculture is concerned when the quota system is retained for butter, and retained it is. There is a guarantee of 23,000 tons up to March of 1967, in accordance with the terms of Mr. Bottomley's letter, but from that on—and again it is on agriculture that this Agreement appears to be falling down very badly — according to the Bottomley letter, it seems very doubtful as to what is likely to happen to our butter export quota after 31st March, 1967. The only provision in this letter is an undertaking to aim in the consultations to provide reasonable opportunity, in the light of the total imports authorised into the United Kingdom each year and equitable claims of other suppliers, for growth in the basic quota for the import of butter from Ireland into the United Kingdom.
That means we have an increase for the next 15 months in the amount of butter we can sell to the British, at a loss to ourselves, mark you, and it is well that people outside should realise that every lb of butter we sell to the British costs us money. But we have to dispose of it. Under this wonderful Agreement we have been given now a right by the British to sell at a loss another 4,000 tons of butter over the next 15 months on the British market. They do not know whether they will permit us to continue to do that after March, 1967, but they will aim at allowing us to continue provided they are not unfair to their other suppliers. That is the position in relation to butter and that is supposed to be a freeing of agricultural trade.
In relation to bacon and cereals there is again a reduction of the quota system. In relation to bacon, as Deputy Corish has pointed out, there is the particularly unfortunate result that, once a quota system operates, any expansion in our production can be forced into pork and pig meat, possibly to our considerable disadvantage. The British have retained the right to control our trade in that regard. They have done the same in relation to cereals and other commodities.
I question whether it is possible to describe this Agreement, particularly in relation to our main industry, agriculture, as an Agreement for free trade. It certainly is not that in my opinion. From the point of view of Irish agriculture — I am glad the Minister for Agriculture is in the House — it is a very bad Agreement indeed. But it does not end there. In Article VIII of the Agreement there are provisions which may cause further dangers to our Irish farmer in the years ahead.
In Article VIII provision is made for arrangements in relation to imports of agricultural products and it is provided that either party may regulate from the territory of the other any agricultural products other than store cattle, sheep and lambs, in pursuance of an obligation under an intergovernmental commodity agreement. It also provides for the implementation of any other arrangement for the purpose of orderly marketing, which in either case involves both a restriction on the domestic production or marketing of an agricultural product and the regulation of imports from all other substantial sources of supply of such products.
In other words, the right is given to the British to regulate any agricultural product, other than store cattle, sheep and lambs, if they do it in pursuance of a commodity agreement or some other arrangement for orderly marketing. We give them the right to regulate our exports in all agricultural products except store animals if they have a commodity agreement or some other arrangement for orderly marketing. We give them that right expressly. We give it to them in relation to pig meat, pork and a variety of agricultural products that we might be able to develop on the export market.
In paragraph (2) of Article VIII there is provision which means, in effect, that if the British decide to enter into a commodity agreement or to make an arrangement for orderly marketing they must consult with us and the purpose of the consultation would obviously be to endeavour to ensure that harm would not be done to our trade. Then, in paragraph (3) there is a provision the meaning of which I want to know. The paragraph says:
In the event of the Government of the United Kingdom invoking the provisions of paragraph (1) of this Article, it would be their intention to take account of the special relationship created by this Agreement, to provide full opportunity for imports of the product from Ireland at a level not less than that achieved during a recent representative period prior to the introduction of the arrangement in question,
This does not refer to a commodity agreement; it says "prior to the introduction of the arrangement in question".
and to afford opportunities for the growth of such imports from Ireland which would be proportionately not less favourable than are allowed under the arrangement for supplies to the United Kingdom market from any source, including producers in the United Kingdom, covered by the arrangement.
The Taoiseach said today that no one could suggest in relation to any of the Articles of this Agreement anything that the Government had not already considered. We must take it, therefore, that everything said in these Articles and the words used have been said and used delibarately. I want to know why in paragraph (3) of Article VIII "commodity agreement" has been dropped. Does that mean that it is only where the United Kingdom Government propose an arrangement for the purpose of orderly marketing that they shall have regard to the expected growth of the product being exported from Ireland? If they enter into a commodity agreement they are not bound to have regard to growth from our side. I mention that because Article VIII is vague enough in many respects. This is dealt with further in the Record of Understandings. In paragraph (16) of the Record of Understandings it is expressly provided that an intergovernmental commodity agreement might not require the restrictions of the domestic production or marketing of agricultural products. In other words, despite what is said in the opening of Article VIII, in paragraph (16) of the Record of Understandings it is envisaged that the British can make a commodity agreement which will not restrict the production of their own farmers and which, because it is not an arrangement for orderly marketing, will not require regard to the growth of exports of the products from the Irish market. That seems to me to require very careful watching. In addition to the vagueness of Article VIII and paragraph (16) of the Record of Understandings we have the letter from the Minister for Agriculture which seems to worsen the situation because in the letter of the Minister for Agriculture signed Charles J. Haughey, of the same date as the Agreement, there is this undertaking given apparently gratuitously to the British, since it is after the conclusion of the Agreement:
Having regard to the provisions of those Articles—
The Articles in question are VII and IX of the Agreement.
—the Government of Ireland undertake that, in the event of the Government of the United Kingdom, after the consultation referred to in paragraph (2) of Article VIII or in paragraph (4) of Article IX—
—which apply to bacon, butter and cereals—
—wishing to implement an arrangement of the sort referred to in paragraph (1) of Article VIII—
—that is for a commodity agreement or an arrangement for the regulation of marketing—
—which involves the regulation of imports of an agricultural product by means of a minimum import price system enforced by levies, they—
—that is, we.
—will be prepared to waive their right under Article I of that Agreement to duty-free access to the United Kingdom for the agricultural product in question, provided that Ireland is accorded no less favourable treatment than that accorded to any other country enjoying a right of duty-free access for the product to the United Kingdom, due account being taken of the different grades, qualities and price levels of that product.
I want to know what that letter means in relation to Article VIII. It seems to mean this—I should be glad if I could be told that this is not right— that the British can at any stage decide to enter into a commodity agreement or to enter into some other arrangement which they style as being for the purpose of orderly marketing. Having done that, they can impose a nominal restriction on domestic production, a restriction equal to ten times known domestic production. They then can fix a minimum price for the Irish product coming in at which we have to sell, and they can give a concession to their own producer which will put us outside the levies looking in and put us in a situation in relation to the British market that we are at a disadvantage compared with the British domestic producer.
In those circumstances it is very little use saying to us: "You will be no worse off than the Dane or the New Zealander." If in fact under Article VIII and the Haughey letter the British are given the right to give an advantage to their own producer, then the idea of calling this a free trade area so far as agriculture is concerned is complete rubbish. The most extraordinary aspect of this Agreement is the care which the British Government have taken to protect the British farmer. He is protected by quotas. He is protected by a variety of restrictions and under this letter he is given the added guarantee that if he develops a trade, for instance, in pig meat or pork or something of that kind there is a guarantee that a minimum price system can be built up which will keep all competitors at a disadvantage to him in the home market. And this is called removing all restrictions on a substantial portion of the commerce between the two countries.
There are other parts of the Agreement to which I could refer but I do not intend to do it. I should just like to mention in passing that there has not been the extension of deficiency payments on butter and other agricultural products of that kind. There has been a continuance of what was there before along that line. A little bit of "give" here by the British has involved giving a great deal more on our part.
The Taoiseach says: "We got everything we asked for." I hope again that that is merely a way of clinching an argument in a debate. I would long dislike to believe that any government asked for this and was given it on a plate. That surely could not be so. It surely could not be that the Taoiseach and his Ministers went across and said: "You may continue to restrict our exports of bacon. You may force us into pig meat and pork, and we will give you the right, if we develop a trade on that line, to enforce import levies to protect your own producers." Surely the Taoiseach and his Ministers did not say: "Restrict us in our exports of butter and cereals, and if we develop a trade in broilers or turkeys we will throw open the Irish market so that you may come in, too." Surely the Taoiseach was just exercising a way of speaking when he said: "We got everything we asked for." I am certain that that was not so. It could not be so.
As I said at the beginning, this Agreement, for good or ill, has been signed by the Government of this country. It has been signed in the sense that it is a gamble worth risking. It is a chance worth taking that in the next four years, by 1970, we shall be in Europe. This Agreement is permanent and cannot be revoked but there is this to be said about it that not only the Taoiseach but also the British side have accepted that this Agreement has been entered into by us in the imminence of entry into Europe, in the sense that in the near future we shall be within Europe. That possibility is impliedly if not expressly referred to in the Preamble. Therefore, I regard this Agreement as depending for its validity as an agreement between Britain and Ireland on the fact that we are going to be in Europe in 1970. I believe that is the basis upon which it was negotiated, that that was the spirit of the negotiations. I believe neither side is in any doubt in that regard. If it happens that in fact by 1970 Europe is no longer a possibility for us, if it happens by 1970 that the idea of the dream of a greater Europe will have receded and we are left with an agreement of this kind, which in those circumstances we would never have negotiated or signed, we on this side of the House, in those circumstances, if we have responsibility certainly will have no hesitation in telling the British that we are going to end it.
Comment on this
I rise to second the amendment in the name of Deputy Corish of the Labour Party that: "This Agreement represents a balance of advantage to the United Kingdom in that it does not provide adequately for agriculture and will lead to a reduction in industrial employment and an increase in emigration." This is the confirmed opinion of the Labour Party who deplored the irresponsible attitude of the Government in precipitating this country into a Free Trade Agreement with the gigantic forces of Britain at a time when all the evidence is that we were completely unprepared for such a battle, at a time when the resources of this country were at their lowest ebb.
Many of us felt that free trade was inevitable, that it was something we would have to face in the immediate years ahead, particularly if and when Britain entered the Common Market. However, there was no good reason why we should have free trade at this time of economic depression, with acute shortage of capital and credit for economic and social advancement at home. It must be clear that the Government in these circumstances were themselves incapable of taking the necessary steps to cushion the impact of such an Agreement on the thousands of people in all facets of our economy who would be effected.
Instead of equipping our economy and gearing us in our industrial and commercial fibre, it is now a fait accompli: we are now, willy-nilly, at the worst possible time, going into free trade with Britain, at a time when our national resources are at their weakest and most vulnerable point. The economic battle which we are being asked to engage in is between a pigmy and a giant. The workers of this country in particular will suffer as a result. The workers will take a terrible beating in this battle.
The full impact will not be felt for some time. It is only when the tariff and quota protection which we enjoyed for so long is whittled away during the next five or ten years that the real effects of this Agreement will be felt and I assert that there will not be many small towns in Ireland which will not be littered with industrial graveyards where once many thousands of Irish men and women found secure and remunerative employment.
The Labour Party feel that the outcome will be that big business will be the order of the day—the ring, the cartel, the monopoly will gradually take over in this small economy of ours, squeezing out the small factory, the small businessman, the private trader. Foreign super-salesmanship will certainly make a mockery of our Buy Irish campaign and the extension of supermarkets and chain stores will close up many small grocers' stores. Moreover, it may well transpire that out entire distributive trade will fall into the hands of foreigners. Supranationalism will be the order of the day and our Irish nationalism will become something of a nasty word, for such it is in the context of the Treaty of Rome, in the views of all those in Europe whom we have met in recent times.
The Taoiseach has asserted there are no political implications in the Agreement. That assertion was an insult to the intelligence of the Irish people. Economic dependence, of necessity, means political dependence. We will in the long run see a shedding of our national autonomy and independence. It is a pre-requisite today to entry into the EEC, and vis-à-vis our position with Britain in this Free Trade Agreement, the lot of the Republic of Ireland is one of subservience and dependence on that country and that subservience and dependence will become more pronounced as we move closer to a European alliance.
Indeed, any initiative or independence which this country enjoyed in our negotiations for admission to the EEC now seem to be lost. We are being looked at through the eyes of Europe as an integral part of Britain, a shire of England, a nonentity not to be recognised. We have thereby lost an effective, independent voice in the policy-making decisions of Europe and in world affairs generally. It was, therefore, audacious to imply that there are no political connotations in this Agreement. Very largely, as will be seen in the future, this nation has now been taken out of the hands of an Irish Government and in future we sink or swim with Britain. It is ironical that this should come about on the 50th anniversary of 1916!
Comment on this
It is ironical that it should have been brought about by a Party purported to be Republican, who purported to have a separatist tradition, the tradition of Tone, of Emmet, Mitchel, Pearse—aye, and of Eamon de Valera—whose philosophy it was to break the connection with England, the never failing source of all our economic and social evils. That is a quotation from Tone, the founder of Irish republicanism. This was the Party of Sinn Féin, the protector Party, the Party who would win for us real independence, the Party who claimed to embody all the finest traditions of nationhood involving the maintenance of our own culture, our distinct way of life and the revival of the Irish language at all costs.
Now, by a stroke of the pen, I assert that the Fianna Fáil Party, the soldiers of destiny, have reneged on those proud principles and aspirations and have perpetrated an act of union with Britain more final, binding and irrevocable than the Charter of Henry II or the Act of Union of Grattan's Parliament. This Agreement means integration with Britain and let there be no doubt or ambiguity about it. The soldiers of destiny have become the Queen's men and they have now turned their backs on all they pledged and fought for.
These are some of the political implications of this Agreement as we see it. We are wondering therefore how this Government can go on to celebrate 1916 and the 50th anniversary of the Rising with any degree of sincerity. We must pose the question: was it for such as this that these men died?
Comment on this
It would be more fitting for this Government to let the dead men rest in peace. To extol their ideas would be to make a mockery of their lives, their sufferings and their deaths.
It is ironic that this Government, forced by economic failure—let us admit it—and the utter collapse of their policies, should feel so utterly helpless that they sold this country back to Britain, in a last desperate hope and expectation that the gold would rub off, and that some kind of a boost would be given to this wilting economy of ours. What if the gold turns to tinsel? We little thought in this generation, steeped in history as we are, that we would live to see the day again, as historians told us happened in the past, when we would find a set of Irishmen, purporting to be idealists, selling their souls for penny rolls, for soup and hairy bacon.
Many people in this country do not as yet realise the full implications of this Free Trade Agreement. I said earlier that it will be some years before its full impact is felt. Many people seem to forget that we have enjoyed free trade with Britain for a long number of years. There was no blowing of trumpets about it, but it is a fact that we enjoyed a free trade with Britain for a long number of years and, at the same time, maintained a protectionist policy for our industries at home and we had full access for our agricultural and industrial produce to the British market. That situation has been condoned, approved and ratified by successive Irish Governments as being the most desirable, the most necessary, and the most satisfactory kind of agreement with Britain down through the years. We virtually had complete access to her markets to which we exported some 80 per cent of our products, and we maintained protection at home for our own industry.
In that type of situation, we feel there was no really worthwhile reason why we should depart from that procedure. There was no particular reason why we should have free trade at this juncture, no reason why we should cast aside protection and deliberately expose our industrialists to the competition with which many of them clearly cannot contend. While most of us expected that some day free trade would come—and the Government had been admonishing industrialists and others to that effect—we are now being precipitated into this Free Trade Agreement at a time when we are least prepared for it and, further, at a time when all the advantage would seem to be on the side of Britain.
Before committing us to this kind of agreement, the Government had a bounden responsibility to assess the economic growth of this country, to aid, to stimulate and to co-ordinate the efforts of local industry, to gear them for this occasion, and to help them to re-adapt themselves to meet the rigorous competition with which we now know they will have to contend. Above all else, the Government should have taken particular cognisance of the vulnerability of our industry and the plight of the workers who will become redundant and unemployed as a result. While we have heard all this talk of free trade through the years, it was always in the context of free trade with Europe, with the countries of EEC. It is rather understandable that the re-adaptation measures which industries were adopting were waning in recent years, because our chances of getting into that Community were receding rather than improving, by reason of the attitude of President de Gaulle. There was never any question or talk of free trade with Britain. This is something which the Taoiseach and the Government have sprung upon the Irish people. Our eyes may have been looking towards Europe, but this free trade with Britain is something new and it has caused shock and dismay in many quarters of this country.
We are not aware of any demand by the Irish people for such an Agreement. We have heard no clamour for such an Agreement and, indeed, the Government received no mandate from the Irish people to negotiate such an Agreement. Neither was this Agreement an issue in the general election a few months ago. There was not a tittle about it. Neither do we sense much jubilation in many parts of the country as a result of this Agreement.
The most worrying aspect of the issue now before this House is that this Agreement was cloaked in secrecy and implemented in most indecent haste. The speed with which it was done savours of thoughtlessness, irresponsibility and panic. The speed with which it was done indicates clearly that it was ill-conceived, hasty and reckless. It was slipped across the Irish people under a cloak of secrecy and deceit. Such an action was most assuredly the action of a bankrupt Government who had nothing else to fall back on and who wanted to abandon their responsibility to some outside force of any kind.
I believe that when the full impact of this Agreement is felt, the Irish people will rebel against it. It is perhaps in ten years' time that the real impact will be felt and by that time only the strongest of our industries will have survived. The weakest will have gone to the wall, and with them will have gone many thousands of Irish workers. We in the Labour Party pose a question: what are the Government doing to provide alternative work for the workers we now know are going to be affected? I will be saying something later on about the Government's proposed manpower policy which has not yet come before us. An Agreement has been signed and this Government have been tinkering with the idea of joining in a Common Market with Europe for some years, yet there is no evidence of any legislation which would provide any compensation for the workers who will become redundant as a result of such action. This is irresponsibility on the part of the Government. There is a danger that by reason of this precipitate act, and the shock and dismay which it has caused, especially in industrial quarters, many industrialists may decide quickly to get out and there is evidence of that happening already. We will then have an immediate problem of redundancy on our hands. Most industrialists, having read this Agreement, are re-appraising their position and are coming to quick decisions as to whether they can continue in business or not. We cannot expect them to be over patriotic or too humanitarian in coming to a decision. They will do this on the basis of whether or not it is now profitable to stay in business in the light of the Agreement and they will make their decision accordingly.
These employers may well be in the happy position to confer on themselves a golden handshake but the unfortunate workers concerned are being thrown ignominiously on to the unemployment scrapheap with no legislation in this House yet to provide for severance pay or schemes for the retraining or the re-absorption of these people in alternative employment. It is not good enough for the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy S. Flanagan, to talk about his scheme. We want to see this scheme in the House and we want to see it improved out of all recognition because the manpower policy which we have seen up to this is only a pale shadow of that required by the trade union movement and by this Party.
Comment on this
It falls far short of what is required in a positive manpower policy. If the Government are sincere about it a manpower policy should mean the creation of a distinct Ministry of Labour the task of which would be to provide for full employment and security of employment, and rising standards of living, and it should take care of the problem of redundancy. We reject a manpower policy which has inherent in it the idea of dividing responsibility between two Departments, the Department of Industry and Commerce and the Department of Social Welfare. We object also to the aspects of the redundancy scheme contained in that manpower policy which make it obligatory on the workers to contribute towards it. The workers who gave to industry their ability, their brains and brawn, should be cared for properly when it comes to the time when they must retire or the day when they have to be dispensed with and it should not be obligatory on the workers to contribute to this scheme at a time when they are in fact paying social welfare contributions.
I have said that the Government knew that we were moving towards freer trade and that barriers were coming down, and at the same time they did nothing to accelerate economic growth within the State. They have been depending solely on foreign capital, technical skill and know-how to build up our industrial arm. We all know that private enterprise, despite its best endeavours and despite all the State aid which it has been given, some of it very lavishly, has been unable or unwilling to provide for the employment of all our people. Despite all that State aid we still have a standing army of some 50,000 unemployed and a very high incidence of emigration. Protection is now being dispensed with and we are taking on a battle with a vast industrial giant, Great Britain, the pioneer of the industrial revolution. Labour believes with regret that the people who will suffer most will be the working classes.
We would again exhort the Government to embark on an upsurge of State enterprise. Where private enterprise has failed there is a moral and a bounden obligation on the Government to establish industry to utilise the nation's resources and wealth and to put people into productive work. We in the Labour Party have always complimented this Government for what they did in that respect. We are proud of such State enterprises as the ESB, Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann, Irish Shipping and Bord na Móna, which are all of great consequence to us, and which have upon them the badge of permanence and security of employment for those engaged in them. Every other country embarks on expenditure for the creation of industry where they have people unemployed. Our people must surely be our most cherished asset and where private enterprise fails the Government must step in. Labour will support and applaud any effort which the Government make in that direction. The Government's lack of initiative in this direction is to be greatly deplored. We wonder whether they are handing over the economy altogether to monopoly capitalism for the exploitation of our people.
State aid of this kind would be far more beneficial than much of the money expended by the Industrial Development Authority and An Foras Tionscal for the establishment of new industries here. Many of them, although opened by the Taoiseach or some of his Ministers with a flourish of trumpets, and which were supposed to employ many hundreds of our people, quickly closed up leaving the workers concerned in idle bewilderment. Once again the people were outraged by the action of fly-by-night, speculating gangsters in our society. We believe where public money of this kind is to be expended on Irish industry, the State should have a say in the control of that industry. Too many slick operators with foreign accents have already sold too many dummies to the Industrial Development Authority and An Foras Tionscal.
Looking at this Agreement, the Labour Party welcome the marginal benefits which accrue to agriculture. While the inference is given that this is a free trade agreement, it is not free trade as far as agriculture is concerned. Previous speakers have dwelt at length on that aspect and I do not want to belabour the point. Quotas are still involved. Some of them, such as the bacon quota, we are unlikely to fulfil. We will fulfil the butter quota, regretfully, at a great loss to the Irish consumer. In so far as butter is concerned, it is to be regretted that our negotiators were not able to secure an agreement whereby we would get an economic price for that commodity. We should not have to continue to export butter to Britain at a loss of over a shilling per pound. We are still paying the British housewife that to eat Irish butter. It must be taken into account that on the increased quota we have secured there will be a recurring loss. We might say that every pound of butter we send out will be wrapped up in an Irish postal order for 1/- or 1/6 to the British housewife. That kind of economic agreement is unsatisfactory from any standpoint. We would have hoped for an economic price for butter also because it would give the small farmer—who is getting very little out of the Agreement, especially the small dairy farmer—a better deal. Had we secured a decent price for butter we would have been able to give the dairy farmer a better price for his milk, thereby doing something to improve the sorry standard of living these people have at present.
While there may be advantages for agriculture—we sincerely hope there are, because it is still our most effective economic arm—the Labour Party are concerned about what are the employment opportunities as a result of increased opportunities for the farming community. All the evidence is— this is also the view of the Congress of Irish Unions—that if this improvement takes place in the incomes of our farmers as a result of this Agreement, it will not provide much more additional employment on the land. As Deputy T.F. O'Higgins said earlier, if our industrial arm is to be virtually destroyed in this economic battle, there are no compensations from the agricultural employment standpoint.
We have lost some 50,000 from the land in five years. We will be going back to the era of the rancher in this country, of the bullock, the stick and the dog. The Labour Party do not want this country to be merely a cattle ranch for John Bull or a cabbage garden either. We do not want to see a situation whereby if employment is to be given as a result of this kind of agreement, it will be provided not on the Liffey, the Lee, the Suir or the Shannon, but on the Thames, the Humber and, perhaps, the Seine, the Tiber and the Rhine. We want Ireland to remain for the Irish. Those of us who remember our history books will realise the terrible beating this country took in the nineteenth century when we had a free trade area with England and when our industries were destroyed. That is, in fact, what came about. We became merely John Bull's other island to supply food and fodder in times of war.
We would have hoped that this movement towards freer trade would have been a gradual one and that the full repercussions would have been assessed by a responsible Government. The Labour Party are shocked at the precipitate action which has taken place. Many industries are vulnerable to imports from Britain. They find it difficult enough to survive at present. According as the quotas are removed and the barriers of protection lowered, these industries will find it more and more difficult to continue to manufacture their different products. Many of them have been mentioned here and they must be mentioned again. The Minister for Industry and Commerce who spoke before me sought to give some kind of solace to the motor assembly industry. I sincerely hope what the Taoiseach said on television and what the Minister said this evening will bear fruit and that this industry, which employs 6,500 people, will not be destroyed.
We are concerned, too, about the footwear industry. Here again, the vulnerability of this industry to exports from England was graphically revealed by the Taoiseach in 1947 when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce and when, for a period, he lowered the then protection; the reasons are best known to himself. However, within a short period of months, over 1,000,000 pairs of footwear were dumped in this country. Dislocation of the industry became evident and thousands of workers in many parts of the country walked the streets in idleness for some months until a new Government took over and the new Minister for Industry and Commerce, Mr. Daniel Morrissey, put back the protection, thereby saving that industry from virtual extinction at that time.
I appeal to the Taoiseach and to his Minister for Industry and Commerce to have particular regard to the welfare of the footwear industry. I appeal to them to see to it that it is given breathing space to re-equip, re-adapt and re-energise itself for the competition ahead and to ensure that there will be no loss of employment as a result of the decision contained in this Agreement. I was disturbed to learn here this evening that one well-known boot and shoe factory, renowned for the quality of its product and for the fact that it was one of the best exporting footwear factories in the country, is now in some difficulty and that there has been a lay-off of workers in this city. I sincerely hope that that is not a portent of things to come. I appeal to the Minister to take immediate steps to see to it that no disaster befalls this important industry and that it is given all the let-outs in this Agreement, where an industry is threatened—that the quota will not be abolished too rapidly and that the extension may go to 15 years instead of to 10 years.
We have the reports of the CIO, to which Deputy Corish referred this afternoon. I believe that these reports are as true in respect of free trade with Britain as they were in respect of impending free trade with the countries of the EEC about which the committee were perhaps then thinking. The CIO have spelled out for us the repercussions which could arise in Irish industry in freer trading conditions. Of the 26 industries they surveyed, comprising some 77,000 workers, the CIO declared that in freer trading circumstances of any kind, some 11,000 workers would lose their jobs and that, if the adaptation measures which the Committee recommended should be taken in each particular industry were not speedily adopted, a further 23,000 persons would lose their jobs.
We know the industries which are most vulnerable. It is amazing that the Taoiseach, at his recent television interview, when asked what industries are likely to be affected, said it was difficult to know. Surely any analysis of the situation would pinpoint the weaknesses in Irish industry? Have we not had the reports of the National Industrial and Economic Council to tell us where the defects lie? Had we not the reports of the CIO to indicate the weakest sections? Surely it is irresponsible and unfair of the Taoiseach to infer that he did not know what industries would be affected? This is the size of the problem for our workers—with no hope of alternative employment in agriculture. There is, then, the real risk of a shocking unemployment problem in the next few years and an exodus by way of emigration. Because of the high cost of living in this country today, I think it is impossible for a responsible unemployed man, especially a man with family commitments, to remain idle for longer than a few weeks. He must go or become a pauper—destitute—and he would go to England. Our country would be denuded of its population, our most cherished asset. It is a terrible indictment of this Government, who have been in office for 28 years, that, while countries in Europe laid waste by two great wars, one of recent origin, can provide full employment for their people and even experience an acute shortage of labour and are drafting in labour from other nations, we have never been able to come anywhere near full employment, despite the grandiose statements contained in the various Programmes for Economic Expansion and the talk, again, of full employment contained in this Agreement.
This Government have never shown that respect and regard for Irish men and women that they are entitled to in this country, namely, the right to work in productive employment in their own land. In that connection, we have won for ourselves the name of a vanishing race. I do not wonder at the Government's selling out and abandoning their responsibilities to Britain at the present time. It is ironical in the extreme to realise that, after 40 years of native Government, we are now, in this Agreement, handing back this country to Great Britain more underdeveloped and underemployed than ever before and certainly with fewer people than ever before in our history. No doubt Mother England will take good care of us: she has always cherished us, as we know, in the past.
In conclusion, I want to say that the Labour Party have tabled this amendment to expose the incompetence of this Government and previous Governments in their economic failure and to condemn them for bringing us into this alliance with Great Britain, primarily because they have failed to deal with the economic ills of our community and because they have a balance of payments problem with which they cannot seemingly effectively grapple. We are going in at the worst possible time and the people in the forefront of this battle are the Irish working classes who will take a terrible beating. I would not wish anyone to construe from what I have said that we, in the Labour Party, are against free trade as such or that we are opposed to the European economic movement. We, in the Labour Party, are no Luddites seeking to put back the clock. We are not blinding our eyes to the happenings around us in the world today.
Comment on this
You were the Republican Party who were purporting to be the heirs to the traditions of Tone and Emmet. You go annually to Bodenstown and you are the Republican Party in brackets.
Our opposition to this Agreement is not based on any sectarianism or even class or nationalism because, as far as we in the Labour Party are concerned, we are not merely national in outlook but we are international as well. For us, as Labour men the world over, poverty and insecurity anywhere in the world are a threat to freedom and prosperity. We welcome the day when we can join with the nations of Europe in the European movement as equal partners when the prudent time comes; but we deplore being precipitated into it at a time of underdevelopment, depression and unpreparedness. We will work with any Party for the happy day when we can take our place in the community of European nations but we must be prepared for going in there. We must have an independent voice in the decision making of that community. We must not be in a secondary capacity to anyone because we know in the final analysis the hopes of our people must, of necessity, lie with the prosperity which abounds in Europe. We know too that in these European nations people are well cared for. There is full employment, rising standards of living and, above all else, security in sickness, infirmity and old age. These are things which we, in the Labour movement, cherish the world over and there is kinship between us the world over in that regard.
I have said sufficient to demonstrate the reasons why the Labour Party are opposed to this Agreement and the fears we have of the repercussions which may arise therefrom. It is the responsibility of this Government to take all such necessary steps as will cushion that impact. On them lies the responsibility for signing this Agreement and on them lies the responsibility for the evils which will very likely arise therefrom.
Comment on this
When this Agreement was first mooted, I travelled around my own constituency to find out what industries would be closed down according to the prophets here. I could find none. I travelled round Rushbrooke, Blarney, Midleton, Youghal and many other places and I did not find any industrialists there afraid of their lives of this Agreement. It seems rather peculiar now that this Agreement has to be defended today by the man who, after all, every Deputy and every individual throughout this nation admits, was the architect of our industrial arm in this country, that is, Seán Lemass. He is the man now, according to the gentlemen here, who will close down all the industries and throw thousands of men out of employment.
I have heard complaints here about agreements and about the time they should be discussed or not discussed. I went down to the Library to have a look at all the other Agreements which were made in the past with Britain. I never accused the Labour Party of being unpatriotic because their Minister for Industry and Commerce went over and made an Agreement with Britain. I speak of a particular Agreement and I am hanged if I could find it. It took me two hours of research in the Library before I hit on the fact that it was not exactly a full Trade Agreement. It was a sugar Agreement but that sugar Agreement never came into this House for discussion and was never discussed here until 1958, when I raised it here in the way of a question. While on 30th November, 1956 we were paying 5/8d a cwt. duty on our sugar going into Britain, after the late Deputy Norton signed this Agreement on 1st December, 1956, we paid 22/-, in other words, 16/4d more on every cwt. of sugar sent into Britain under that Agreement. In the year 1959, according to the figures I have here which were given to me by the Minister for Industry and Commerce at that time, in order to get our sugar into Britain, we paid a duty of £857,000 and that was under an Agreement. When we talk of Agreements here and people becoming unemployed on account of them, I should say that was an Agreement made and agreed to by Britain. My only worry about this Agreement is that I do not believe Britain ever honoured any Agreement or will ever honour any Agreement. That is my honest opinion of it. That opinion is borne out by Deputy Barry's leader. That is what he said.
Comment on this
If I had thought I would be speaking here this evening I should have brought in a baby's bottle for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon was speaking in regard to an Agreement signed by the late Deputy Norton when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce in 1956 which clapped £16 on every ton of sugar we exported to Britain.
Comment on this
I shall make my own speech if the Deputy will keep quiet. Mr. Dillon, as reported at column 1411 of the Official Report of 12th July, 1960, said:
I want to raise a specific matter which affects the problem of beet farmers who are supplying beet to the sugar factories, and also other products which are produced from Irish sugar, which is raw material produced in this country. In 1948, we negotiated a Trade Agreement, Article V of which reads as follows:
The Government of the United Kingdom undertake that where goods, the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland, are dutiable at preferential rates of duty, they will not vary the existing preferential treatment of these goods in such a way as to put any class of goods, the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland, at a disadvantage in relation to goods of that class from other sources enjoying preferential treatment.
Now, that is a pretty comprehensive Article and yet with that Article in existence I understand that goods containing Irish sugar are being subjected to a very formidable levy, the proceeds of which are devoted to the subsidisation of goods of similar quality containing sugar derived from Crown colonies of the British Crown. I am told, I think, by some of the Minister's colleagues, that when Deputy Norton was Minister for Industry and Commerce, this matter arose and that he did not consider it desirable to press the interpretation of Article V which would give us the right to claim exemption from that levy. I do not know what the position is in regard to that——
This was the Minister for Agriculture in the mixum-gatherum Government——
—I have no recollection of hearing the matter discussed when I was a member of the inter-Party Government, although it could have happened and passed out of my memory, but I do not remember it and I have not discussed the matter with Deputy Norton...as I see it now—
Jack-out-of-office—
—it appears that that Article is wide enough and comprehensive enough to cover the present procedure under which I believe that goods which are the growth, produce or manufacture of Ireland are being put at a disadvantage in relation to goods of that class from other sources....
That was a breach of the Agreement made in 1948. Another Agreement was made in 1956 which completely wiped out Article V of the 1948 Agreement and under it the Minister for Agriculture at that time, who was supposed to be acting in the interests of the Irish people, allowed a levy of over £800,000 to be collected from the beet growers of this country on sugar. I admit that even my own colleagues could not believe this could happen. The only one I got to believe it was my old comrade, Deputy Smith——
Comment on this
He set to work in his own northern way and went to London without any flourish of trumpets and here is the result of his work.
Comment on this
Deputy Smith hammered out a new Agreement on sugar and that is why Deputy O'Higgins was remarking that there was no new arrangement on sugar. Under the arrangement made by Deputy Smith in regard to sugar, we got a guaranteed quota of 10,000 tons of Irish sugar at the British price, which this season is £60 per ton. They further accepted that this 10,000 tons of sugar would be supplied here to chocolate crumb and sweet factories for export at a price of £32 per ton, the difference being paid by the British who under the Agreement have paid the Irish Sugar Company this year £260,000. There was an agreement made by Deputy Harte's colleagues under which we were mulcted in £850,000 a year and a man of common sense went to Britain and converted that Agreement and that loss to an income of £260,000 a year for the Irish farmers and the Sugar Company.
Comment on this
Those are solid facts. That is how we do business. That is why I have no fear of any clause in this Agreement. I admit the beggars will break it some time. They have broken one before and they will break another, but when we have a Minister who is capable of going there and bringing back an Agreement——
Comment on this
I have Official Report after Official Report here dealing with the sugar question from the first time I asked a question in this House about it until I got the final result in the action of Deputy Smith when he was Minister for Agriculture.
Comment on this
I did not fix it up with anybody. I speak for myself. If there are any constituents of Deputy Harte in the Gallery, they will put him out the next time and I shall be looking at another vacant seat. Mark you, I have looked at many of them.
Comment on this
The Deputy might listen to the Chair. This matter does not arise on the discussion before the House. It is a matter for an Estimate.
Comment on this
I have asked the Minister to obtain the opinions of the captains of industry that he appointed as to the prospects for these industries. I have given specific instances. Over £200,000 left this country during the last 12 months that could have been spent here and could have provided employment for 100 extra men. These are the things that I want attended to. I do not care about Ministers or anybody else. I am here as Deputy Martin Corry for as long as I want to stay here. I would ask the people of the country to have sufficient patriotism to insist that State subsidised companies be required to use Irish manufactured goods and Irish labour in connection with any work they want carried out. That obligation is carried out by the Department of Local Government and by the Department of Agriculture. If a Cork farmer built a haybarn and used two sheets of British corrugated iron in the construction he would lose the £60 grant. The same laws should apply to State-sponsored bodies. I have given the facts to the Minister.
Comment on this
If he will not listen to me one way, I have another way of making him listen. I do not want to be dragging up the question of the sugar agreement.
Comment on this
The only way the Deputy can make speeches is by slandering his betters who are not here to defend themselves.
Comment on this
I have discussed the Trade Agreement and I could go back and discuss the 1938, the 1948 and all the other Agreements.
Comment on this
I will discuss the Agreement that was made in Ottawa when you were hitting John Buli in his pride and in his pocket. The Deputy's natural home is on the other side of the Border and he will find himself there soon enough.
Comment on this
Before I call on Deputy Lindsay, the Minister for Industry and Commerce has an announcement to make.
Comment on this
The Dáil is adjourning tonight at 10.30 and meeting at 10.30 a.m. tomorrow. The Dáil will adjourn at 5 p.m. tomorrow.
Comment on this
That does not complete the debate. The debate will not be completed tomorrow. That should be made clear.
Comment on this
The debate will be resumed when the Dáil meets again?
Comment on this
I want to make a few observations on this Agreement and on the motion before the House that Dáil Éireann approve of it. Let me say at the very beginning that agreements are rarely binding unless there is incorporated within them that necessary element of contract by which they can be enforced and an agreement is less binding when one finds that one contracting party is powerful and the other is very much weaker. That is the position that we find in this Agreement and the results achieved by it. A great deal of the Taoiseach's brashness here this afternoon, his truculence, his intolerance of any other views are in themselves an indication that this Agreement is not even to his liking and does not satisfy even him. I am not surprised at that because on a simple analysis of this or any other Agreement the fundamental question to be asked and to be answered is, what are we getting for what we are giving?
If we approach this Agreement applying that test, we will discover very early on that what we are giving is much more than what we are getting or what we are likely to get even if we ever get all that we are supposed to get under this Agreement.
Deputy Cosgrave mentioned this afternoon that Mr. Harold Wilson appears to have mesmerised the House of Commons and the British electorate and has now given all the appearance of having mesmerised the Taoiseach and the Ministers who accompanied him to London. I am under no illusion whatsoever about the apparent friendship and goodwill on the part of Mr. Harold Wilson. He represents a constituency in Great Britain in which there is a very strong Irish vote. He controls the House of Commons by such a slender majority that in the general election about to take place in Great Britain within the next couple of months, he hopes that, as a result of the apparent goodness he has shown to us through the medium of this Agreement, he will capture the Irish vote in Britain. Indeed, it is as a result of the policies pursued over the years by the people who concluded this very Agreement we are discussing here this evening that these Irish voters are in such numbers in Great Britain today.
The very first thing that makes me curious about this Agreement is the date selected, 1st July, 1966. By then the local government elections and the presidential election will be over and the people will not have had any sample experience of the implementation of this Agreement and they can accordingly still be caioled into believing there are great things ahead. One's curiosity might even reach as far as suspicion when we think of the wonderful things that were promised from a Health Act in 1947 prior to the general election. Suspicion might even be surpassed when we think of the general election of 1944 fought on the issue of Córas Iompair Éireann. Who could have gathered from the words of joy in those days that we would see the chaos in which the company is today?
The last time there was a free trade area as between this country and Great Britain was as a result of the Act of Union. This matter has already been touched on by Deputy Treacy. At that time there were roughly 45,000 Irish people engaged in the textile trade over the whole of this country. Allowing for the wars in Europe to settle down, and allowing for that 20 years, in 1820 the number employed in the textile trade in this country had dropped from 45,000 to roughly 13,000. It is in that situation I see the greatest difficulty arising from this Agreement. The greater the unit, the greater the production and the lower the cost; the smaller the unit, the less the production and the greater the overall cost. You will have the powerful producer in the textile industry in Great Britain producing against the small, almost pioneering, people in this part of Ireland. I hope it will not come to pass. Nobody wants to see redundancy. Nobody wants to see unemployment. Nobody wants to see the home broken up through emigration. But these are the kind of things I fear from this and these are the kind of things that are not adequately, in my view, guarded against.
The Taoiseach told us that this Agreement is the result of a long, hard process of negotiation. It was long; it may have been hard; but the result brings to mind the old adage, Parturiunt montes, nascetur ridiculus mus— the mountains have been in labour and a little mouse is born. It has been suggested before today in statements by Ministers that this is a step to Europe. Such statements are fraudulent in conception and a great deceit to practise upon the people. This may be an exercise in preparation for Europe. If it is, it will be a costly exercise. That is as far as I am prepared to go with it. It is not a step to Europe and let nobody say, because he cannot say it with any conviction, that this Agreement is in any way related to further active steps towards Europe. It is a simple Agreement made between Great Britain and the Republic of Ireland. The European background may have been in mind and may have been discussed but it nevertheless does not further this country's application by one inch beyond what it was when we went with great song and dance to Brussels, handed in our application, and came home.
The Taoiseach seems to think it is a great thing that this Agreement is permanent, that it contains no provision for its termination. The Agreement that does not contain any time limit or does not contain any provision for termination is, in my opinion, an agreement particularly fraught with danger for the smaller partner to it. I do not regard the absence of such a provision as one of any great merit.
The Taoiseach told us an extraordinary thing today. He told us that these talks were initiated in November, 1963, beginning with a move made further back in 1960. Now I acknowledge the right of the elected Government of this country to legislate as they see fit for the community over which they govern in between elections. I acknowledge the right of the Government to negotiate internationally in between general elections. But, once the Dáil is dissolved, I believe the people should be told everything. In the course of the last general election, we did not hear a single word from Government speakers at that time about this Agreement or the terms they were seeking. Neither did we hear anything about the results they hoped to achieve from such negotiations. That was, I think, a bad thing. It was a serious breach of faith with our people. It might well have been something that would have had a great bearing on the results of the election.
Would, for instance, the industrialists of this country have supported the Government Party, as is and was their wont, if they had known that their protection was to be dismantled in the manner envisaged in this Agreement? I have marvelled at many things in my time but the one thing I would marvel at now, if I could see it, would be the bank balance of the Fianna Fáil Party seeing they no longer want the support of the industrialists of this country. I sympathise with the Taoiseach in that he will not be able on the occasion of the next general election to send out the customary letter to the industrialists telling them that they have emerged out of the swaddling clothes with which he provided them to become the great captains of industry, and remind them there is a general election in the offing and that funds are required.
Comment on this
I have not got it here. I do not make a practice of carrying around letters of that kind. I am sure the Minister for Industry and Commerce or the Minister for Justice would oblige.
The very first thing we must examine in any document is the title. Indeed at certain times during the progress of a Bill through this House or through the Seanad, it is the custom that the presiding chairman rises in his seat to announce the title of the Bill. The title is regarded with such deference and respect that the chairman rises to it. Here is the title of this Agreement: "Agreement between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom establishing a Free Trade Area." That, to say the least of it, is not accurate. It forms a free trade area for manufactured goods, but agriculture and all its ancillaries are out of it. They are the subject matter of most polite letters passing between various Ministers and appended to the Agreement. First of all, the title of this Agreement is not accurate because it does not establish a free trade area. I want to venture a definition of a free trade area as follows: A free trade area is an area within which the Governments of the respective countries do not discriminate against imports in favour of national products or interfere with exports in order to favour consumers in the home market. Within a free trade area control and taxation are not used to protect the home producer against competition from fellow members of the area or to favour the home against the others. Surely in the whole field of agriculture that definition does not apply. If we examine this Agreement in the light of that definition we find we are confined to manufacturing-process articles.
In order to ascertain what the Agreement does or is likely to do one must examine the position obtaining prior to the Agreement. As far as I have been able to get it down into definite categories, I find it as follows, and if I am wrong no doubt I will be corrected in the course of this debate. First, since the establishment of this State there has been free movement of labour and capital as between Ireland and the United Kingdom. In Ireland and the United Kingdom, therefore, there has been one market for labour and capital. Nobody, I think can gainsay that. Secondly, as a result of past trade agreements Ireland has had:
(a) free entry into the British market for industrial products with few exceptions, mainly manmade fibres;
(b) Ireland has had a protected home market for industrial products though the United Kingdom products were subject to less duty than those of any other countries;
(c) Irish agriculture had duty-free access to the British market. It could be controlled quantitatively though the British guarantee payments for Irish stores fattened in Britain.
We must ask then how does the present Agreement expand and/or improve former ones. I might pause at this stage and say I think that whatever has been done in relation to agriculture as contained in this Agreement could have been done by itself without any reference to the industrial side. If we are so keen on talking about entering into the Common Market, it would have been a very good thing if this Agreement had been confined to the agricultural side, so that when we came to bargain for entry into the Common Market we would have that bargaining power to offer, namely, the dismantling of protection. If entry into the Common Market does not come before 1975 we may as the Taoiseach hopes, be geared, but we shall certainly have no bargaining power. We shall have to go without any protection so what then would be the point? By that time it will have to be considered whether we shall seek entry into the European Economic Community either by ourselves as a free negotiating nation or whether we shall go and be regarded as a satellite of Great Britain under conditions not unlike those that obtained subsequent to the Act of Union in 1800.
I do not say, and I do not want any member of Fianna Fáil to think that I am alleging or insinuating, that an Irish Government composed of the Fianna Fáil Party or any other party would have gone to London or anywhere else to sell us down the drain. That would be a wrong view. It would be a hopelessly unpatriotic view and it would be damaging not to the persons against whom it would be alleged but to the person who would allege it. I believe these men, our Ministers, did their best but their best is simply not enough, having regard to the circumstances and the power with which they could bargain.
The Taoiseach told us that the Minister for Agriculture fought tenaciously. I can well understand that, but if I fight tenaciously for something and I succeed in getting it, I like it to be regarded as a prize worth fighting tenaciously for. When one examines what has been procured on the agricultural side of the Agreement, one does not know what the tenacity was necessary for. Article 1 of the Agreement removes the few remaining restrictions on the export to Britain of goods originating in Ireland and provides for a dismantling of the protection heretofore provided for Irish industry. There is a distinction to be made in the agreement as between what has happened in relation to industry and to agriculture.
The dismantling of protection by a certain percentage year by year is a positive and irreversible act so that when we have reached the end of the dismantling stage in the Agreement which, according to the Taoiseach, contains no provision for termination, it will be positive and irreversible in relation to industry. The position is not so in relation to agriculture because we still have got all of the powers in the Agreement with the British, as with ourselves, to engage in consultations. Basically, of course, the duties have been removed from man-made fibres and from little else. The whole dismantling of the tariff wall is over a period of ten years. That ends it as far as industry is concerned, and whatever industry remains after ten years is something about which I would hate even to hazard a guess. Lip service is given in the agreement to quantitative restrictions on imports and exports.
In my view, Article 6 rules out free trade in agriculture and Appendix II lays down the terms of agreement regarding store cattle. Article 9 excludes bacon and cereals from the Agreement. Butter is to be specifically dealt with by the quota system. At this stage, I should like to put a pertinent question to the Minister for Industry and Commerce who is responsible for the administration of the Industrial Development Authority and An Foras Tionscal. What will happen to the undeveloped areas which are supposed to benefit from the funds at the disposal of both An Foras Tionscal and the Industrial Development Authority? As I see it, the undeveloped areas are now thrown to the winds. Can you, under this Agreement, give £50,000 or £100,000 or £150,000 to build a factory in the west and will you do it if you can?
Comment on this
Possibly you could get the British to transfer portions of their industrial arm to areas where there is no employment. With all due respect to the manpower policy which the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us was progressing because some committee had been set up——
Comment on this
Not just the setting up of a committee. A great deal of work has been done and the Parliamentary Secretary will make a statement on it.
Comment on this
I hope he will tell us he has done more than set up a committee. I take it the Minister for Agriculture will speak and I wish to refer him, without quoting him, to his blueprint for the west as printed in the Western People in March last. I should like to know what is in this Agreement to the benefit of the small farmers in the west. I want to know if it will lessen in any way the number who each year at a certain time have to migrate in order to supplement the small incomes from the small holdings. I want to know if this will assist in keeping at home a number of the young people who leave this country every year, at any time of the year they are able to go. I want to know if the Government have any positive plans or have made any evaluation on specific industries which might be affected by the agreement. I want to know by how much they think the people of the west will be affected and if they have any plans to re-establish these people in employment elsewhere.
At one time, even though there was mass migration from the west, from west Donegal right down to west Cork, there was the consolation that some of the people were absorbed en route, principally in Dublin and other big centres through which they had to pass. I fear that consolation will be taken away from them on the implementation of this Agreement— that now their journey must be completed, that they must join their kin in Birmingham, Manchester, London. I want somebody in the Government to explain Article 18 which expressly provides that either party may, consistent with its international obligations, introduce quantitative restrictions on imports for the purpose of safeguarding its balance of payments.
That is not as simple as it sounds. First of all, it can be done—quantitative restrictions may be introduced by one side and the other side need not be told until it has happened. If possible, the other side will be notified. Can one imagine the Board of Trade telling Dublin: "We shall do it tomorrow or next week." That is where the kernel of our motion comes in. We talk about imbalance. When we get into balance of payments difficulties, it is because of trade. If Britain gets into balance of payments trouble, it emanates not from trade only but from sterling manipulation and money market conditions. The Agreement refers to international obligations. Our obligations internationally are small by comparison with Britain's and here is the whole kernel of the problem. Sterling is one of the world's trading currencies and it is obvious that from time to time Britain will run into balance of payments problems that will necessitate the action envisaged in Article 20 of the Agreement. We can take these measures in order to assist us trade-wise. Britain can take them for any reason whatsoever that interferes with her balance of payments, and they are not all trade, as I have explained.
From what I have said, and so far as my examination of this Agreement goes, it must be clear that there is no appreciable improvement in access to the British market for the products of industry, except in the textile field. How we are going to manage in relation to the big units across the Channel and our own smaller ones, I simply do not know, nor do I think the Government know. They are taking a chance. I will not go so far as to use the word used by Deputy O'Higgins— the word "gamble"—but I think they are taking a chance. They are hoping everything will go right or at least that a substantial part will go right. For the sake of the country, I hope that the chance they are taking will come off. There will be a great problem, so far as I can make out, from the dismantling of the tariff barriers. The capacity to export will be weakened and, of course, it will cost more to service the home market.
Comment on this
This is my own brief We are on holidays at the moment from the Law Library so we are in full attendance here, and no one is complaining. Since I got this document, I have given it a fair amount of study. The Minister for Justice will agree with me when I say that I would hate to get a brief from an economist because I would not understand it. He probably sympathises with me in that view.
As I said, stripped of economists' verbiage, all this means is: what are we getting for what we are giving? If we could bring it down to that I would be satisfied with the application of that test, and I would not be as fearful of the future as I am at the moment. Admittedly, this creates a free trade area for industry but the difficulties for industrialists will be very great. We must create the best possible working conditions. Labour will have to take a very firm hand in this, too. Employer-labour relations will have to be sorted out with great speed if this is to survive. I say that in a constructive spirit. In discussing this Agreement, I do not want to tear it down for the sake of tearing it down.
I think I heard on the news this evening that the Minister for Industry and Commerce is taking some steps to help labour relations. I may be wrong, but I think I heard something like that. If I only dreamed it, I hope my dream comes true. I hope the Minister will take active and immediate steps to try to bring together the employers and the representatives of the workers, to hammer out an agreement as soon as possible, based on how much we are prepared to offer, and how much the employers can afford to give. We must get the whole thing straightened out because this country must be looked at askance at the moment by almost everyone who cares to look at the chaos which exists between employers and workers. I am not putting the blame on one side or the other. There must be faults on both sides but I do not think the problems are insurmountable. Unless they are cleared up, this Agreement has as much chance as a snowball in hell. The employers and workers must come together and decide to work for the common good.
Let me turn now to agriculture. I already mentioned that agriculture forms a separate part of this document. It is not part of the document that forms the free trade area. That is purely industrial, and no more. Agriculture is still subject to quantitative restrictions, and quotas and all the things we had before. A great deal of credit is being claimed for the negotiations in relation to store cattle, but that is a question of demand in the United Kingdom. They want a faster growth of the Irish animal population. A supply of store cattle is an integral part of the British economy, and getting them from Ireland saves payment to the Argentine, for instance, in hard currency. That is the advantage of getting them from here. Of course it also gives them material for ancillary industries such as hides and horns. Some one said it was of fundamental importance that we should get that concession in the British market. I think it is the other way round. It is of fundamental importance that Britain should have the necessary supply of stores. Their only alternative is the importation of South American beef which involves the loss of the value added and also hard currency. We must produce more and more stores, and if we increase our cattle population, naturally we will increase our butter output. Britain has increased the butter quota. They will take all we can produce. Indeed, the city of Manchester could take all our butter exports. That is the situation as I see it.
Let us take this Agreement vis-à-vis agriculture in relation to the small farmer on the west coast, which does not exclude the constituency of the Minister for Industry and Commerce. There is only one way in which you can increase your cattle herd. You must have capital, or you must be prepared to wait for the natural growth. You must have extra tyings to keep your extra cows and you must have extra stabling for your extra tyings. To do that you must get a grant from the Department of Local Government. That is the situation as I see it. That will take a considerable time. Capital is the problem.
I do not think there is anything here for the small man. His situation is as bad as it was before. This Agreement does not create for him any opportunities for employment. His necessity to emigrate, and migration for the heads of certain households, will still be the pattern on the west coast. I would have hoped that any Agreement of this kind would have done something to assist those people rather than the people on the better land of the country. It all forces me to the belief that the Government, whatever they are, are always influenced by the economics of the good land.