We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.

Contributions 1–132 of 425. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Last night when speaking on this motion and the amendments to it, and its effects on Irish industry and agriculture, I said that, if I were asked to sum up my opinion of this very highly complicated and technical Agreement, I would say that we—"we" being the Irish Government—had handed over the Irish industrial market freely to British industrialists and had not got in return completely free access for our Irish farmers to the British market. Our Irish farmers have not been put on parity with the British farmer——

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

——whilst the British manufacturer has been put on parity with the Irish manufacturer. That, to my mind, is the essential weakness of this Agreement.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

We can talk about the details and we can talk about the interpretation of this Agreement, but the one fact emerges that this is an economic Act of Union. I know, as we all know, the tragic history of the 19th century; the Act of Union which started at the beginning of that century, with such high hopes, went out in the 1920s unwept, unhonoured and unsung.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Remember, it was started at the beginning of the 19th century on the part of many sincere Irish people who believed that unrestricted access to British markets would be to the benefit of the Irish manufacturer and who believed that, on balance, Irish agriculturists would make up for whatever possible losses might be incurred on the industrial front. In fact, we know that the industrial front was swept away, barring the linen trade, and a few other trades which, for various historical reasons, managed to survive and thrive.

Maybe in this case we will find, in relation to the man-made fibres mentioned in the Agreement, a big industry built up in them—I hope, indeed, that we shall—and an increase in our existing industry by many, many times. However, the question I ask myself is what is to prevent the British manufacturer doing the very same thing in Britain? Is this just something that has been handed out by the Government as a sop to us? Is it a case of: "Well, you have got these wonderful opportunities with the man-made fibres"; but, as far as I can see, so have the British manufacturers?

Good luck to our manufacturers in the struggle that obviously lies ahead in the field of textiles. I hope they will do very well in their exports, but they will want to do mighty well to make up for the losses we will sustain in other sectors.

We, as a Party, followed a policy of what I would describe as modified protection. We did not give indiscriminate protection to every little industry which sought it. The Fianna Fáil Government did the latter and now, after 30 odd years of that, there are many industries —this has been referred to by other speakers, but it cannot be emphasised too often or too strongly—which started up from not very auspicious beginnings, perhaps, but which for 30 odd years now have given employment. I am concerned in certain cases with the actual losses which will be sustained not by the manufacturers in those industries—some of them have made their money and very good money, too —but by employees by reason of the unemployment that will result therefrom and the general weakening of the whole body politic. We cannot afford to have thousands of people thrown out of work. Our social services will be hit. The contributions which would have come from those who are gainfully employed and increasingly gainfully employed have been counted on to enable us to give the necessary benefits for all our social service schemes such as they are. Will we be able to maintain those in the future?

These are all problems which this Agreement has thrown up to us. We on this side of the House feel that this thing has been rushed. We have not had time either as a Party or as a country to study the effects which will flow from this disastrous document, and I believe it is a disastrous document.

There has been a lot of talk, and rightly so, about the motor trade and the effect this Agreement will have on the future of the car assembly business in Ireland. There are a number of other trades which will be equally badly hit. I could name some of them but I think it would be very wrong for me to mention the types of trades. However, I can say that from a lifetime spent in the building supply trade, I can think of many firms who manufacture for the building trade who will be gravely affected. One of the difficulties of eventual unrestricted competition with very powerful manufacturers is that the smaller firms, even apart from the price, cannot carry the range that a vast manufacturing country like England can carry. Make no mistake, in spite of the fact that in our lifetime England has turned from being a first-class power to something less than that, nevertheless she is still one of the most powerful, if not the most powerful single power in Europe. There are only the United States and Soviet Russia at the moment who I would say are more powerful than Britain. That vast industrial capacity, not only potential but actual, is now to be put in full and unrestricted competition with our industries.

I know the Government are in a dilemma in regard to the EEC and EFTA and all that might come from association with either or both of those bodies or a mingling of those bodies. We understand that as a Party. That is why we have not given a categorical "no" to the idea of this Agreement, but we believe this Agreement has been far too hastily entered into and far too ineptly handled at Government level.

As I said last night, the British are amongst the most skilled horse traders in the world. They have been a great trading nation for many centuries, following, perhaps, in the tradition of another very skilful trading nation, the Venetian Republic, which enlarged itself by trade and almost by trade alone. The British have done that. There are no more skilled traders and entrepreneurs in the world. This is one of thousands of trade agreements they have made down through the centuries. Every paragraph of every agreement they have ever made is stored in what I might call the racial memory of English higher civil servants and the ministers of that country. Skilled as our own civil servants are, it is difficult for them to deal with people who have centuries of experience behind them, and it is still more difficult to deal with a great trading nation when we are not a great trading nation ourselves. That is the position the Irish Government were in at this juncture.

On this side of the House, we have always felt that the unrestricted protection which was afforded was not always the wisest course to follow. Now the wheel has come full circle and those in the Government benches are now going back in policy—not in words, but it is action and policy that count, and not words—on what they have done for 30 years and what, shall I say without being unduly political, they criticised us very severely for proposing. We have not the exhibition of the poacher turned gamekeeper but of the gamekeeper turned poacher which is a still more extraordinary spectacle to behold.

Practically everything that one can say at this stage of the debate has already been touched on in some way or other by another speaker. We have been told there is no politics in this. Of course there is politics in it—there is nothing else but politics in it. As Deputy Seán Dunne said, economics and politics are inextricably bound together and the Irish people have always known that politics and economics were bound together. Hence the dream of Irish patriots long dead that the factories and wheels would turn in Ireland only when we had our own Government.

I am afraid that as a result of what I might call the political aspects of this Agreement, as a result of the unemployment, the unrest, the disappointment which will be felt by many of our people, the feeling will become widespread that the Irish Government have let the people down and the people will turn to more violent measures than just opening their mouths to speak against the Government or of voting against the Government or passing resolutions. We have a long and tragic history of that sort of thing in Ireland and I am somewhat nervous of the future in that respect. However, I do not wish to dwell on the unhappy political aspects of the Agreement, though they are there. They are inherent in the Agreement and eventually they may emerge. Please God, they will not.

What can we do to help remedy the situation? There is not much that individuals can do. The full impact of this Agreement will not be felt for four or five years but then it will come suddenly as, in many industries, the point will be reached when it will be cheaper to import than to manufacture here. We must remember that many of our industries are affiliated with their counterparts across the water. As we already know, it will be cheaper, unfortunately, to bring in motor cars already manufactured in Birmingham or Wolverhampton or wherever it may be. That will apply to a large number of other industries which have connections with English businesses. Unfortunately those industries eventually will tend to close down.

I do not know what we can do. We can hope to develop certain industries and thus take up some of the slack which will be caused in employment because of weaker industries going to the wall. The workers' problem will be the same whether they are in a good thriving industry or in one which will not be able to stand up to competition. It is not defeatism to say that. With Britain's industrial size and strength, individual firms can employ first-class designers for packaging. They can employ the very best people to design their products and the British Government can maintain big design centres through which manufacturers can, if they avail themselves of the opportunities, get the very best technical advice. We have a certain amount of that in Ireland but it will be very difficult for us and will become increasingly so as the facilities we have lessen because, as some of our manufactures close down, there will not be the same work for design experts here as on the other side and accordingly many of these experts will leave.

Before I close, I should like to reiterate that we are bound to be very gravely affected by this Agreement and in their efforts to hide the facts from the people the Government have not been honest. It is not honest to present a measure of this importance to the House and try to pretend to the House, and through us to the people, that it is just an ordinary trade agreement which will be to our advantage. It is not to our advantage and it cannot be to our advantage. It will take all the skill, all the courage of our people to surmount the very great difficulties that lie ahead. This is one of the biggest decisions that have been made in this country during the past 160 years. We had the Act of Union, the Treaty and now we have this economic Act of Union. That is what it is and make no mistake about it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

It might as well be called that. It will close down factories. Even in today's paper—it may not have anything to do with this—we see a report of a situation in Wicklow, the effect of rationalisation. There has been hasty establishment of factories, the building up of hopes of employment in districts and then the rationalisation and closing down. That is a pattern which we shall get increasingly in the future. It is for those reasons that we tabled the amendment to the Government's motion of approval of the Agreement. The Agreement is unbalanced because we have not got the concessions in the agricultural sphere to make up for vital losses on the industrial front.

Comment on this
John Lynch Minister for Finance (Mr. J. Lynch) Fianna Fáil

I should like to begin by assuring Deputy Dockrell that when we went to London—when I say "we", I mean the Ministers and officials of our Government—we did not go with any inferiority complex, despite the Deputy's eulogies of the calibre, quality and skill of the British Ministers and civil servants. We had no air of inferiority going there and, having gone there, we knew that, man for man, whether at ministerial or official level, we were as good as any of the British negotiators and, from my observations later, many of ours were better. Let us not delude ourselves that we went hat in hand, taking whatever crumbs would come off the table of those skilled negotiators.

I cannot understand the attitude of Fine Gael. In the words of the last speaker, this is a disastrous Agreement—it will bring disaster to our economy, closure on our industrial front. If they feel that way, then why do they not come outright and vote against the Agreement——

Comment on this

Exactly—the man in the middle.

Comment on this

——rather than the shilly-shally way they are approaching the matter.

Comment on this

We have not been shilly-shallying.

Comment on this

There is an air of unreality in the contributions of many Deputies to this debate. Many of the Deputies who have spoken already have approached this debate as if we were still living in the economy of the 1930s, as if we were still living without any idea of free trade being, not only on the horizon, but immediately imminent. It must be realised that the policies of the 1930s and even of the 1940s must now change, having regard to the fact that all around us the nations with which we trade are rapidly approaching free trade in the blocs of which they are members. It must not be suggested that we are going to stand aside and leave ourselves in economic isolation and in economic desolation, without doing something about it.

Before I come to the more general criticisms of the Agreement, I might first refer to some important details of the Agreement that have not been adverted to so far by my colleagues. These are, to some extent, in the fiscal and monetary field. Article IV deals with fiscal charges. The essential purpose of this Article is to bring about the elimination of any protection on home-produced goods contained in fiscal charges. Fiscal charges as such are defined in paragraph (6) of Article IV. In addition to customs duties, they cover also other forms of taxation such as excise duties. An example of protection under Irish fiscal duties is the difference in the rate of excise duty on Irish whiskey and customs duty on Scotch whisky. Discrimination on home-produced goods can also arise, for example, where rebates of duty are available to home producers but not to importers. The United Kingdom have undertaken to abolish such discrimination and protective elements in fiscal charges by 1st July, 1968, the delay being for the purpose of enabling amending legislation to be introduced.

Comment on this

Does that include subsidisation of transport for export? There is a petrol rebate tax in Britain for export. Would that be included under this Article?

Comment on this

These are matters that are capable of being discussed under the Articles provided for consultation between the two Governments.

Comment on this

I would have thought it would have been an obvious one to have discussed when you were there.

Comment on this

We have agreed on our part to take similar action, either by one or more steps, between July, 1966 and July, 1971 or by ten equal deductions corresponding to the tariff reduction rhythm which has been agreed already.

Comment on this

Do you have to give notice of what you are doing?

Comment on this

Again, consultation will be necessary in these cases.

Another Article, Article XIII, deals with Government aids. This is one of the very important elements of the Agreement to which, I think, reference has already been made. Under Article XIII, we here are expressly permitted to continue the present Irish tax reliefs up to 1980, in the case of the country generally, and to 1983 in the case of Shannon, with tapering off periods. It is important to note, in this respect, that the EFTA Agreement negotiated by Britain some years ago with her other EFTA partners contains no corresponding provisions. In fact, corresponding provisions in the EFTA Agreement expressly prohibited this type of aid to exports.

Article XIV refers to public undertakings and, in particular, to the practices of such undertakings, and of central and local authorities, in favouring home-produced goods in placing orders for such goods. As the House is aware, there is a system extant in this country whereby certain preferences are given as matters of practice. Any such arrangements will have to be eliminated by the respective Governments, by the United Kingdom before 1st January, 1967, and we have undertaken to do likewise by the end of the transitional period in 1975. That, of course, is not, as some Deputies suggested, abandoning the Buy Irish campaign. There will, of course, be a patriotic duty on individuals and organisations to give their usual patriotic preference to goods of home origin.

Article XVI, on the question of establishment does not prohibit the maintenance or restriction of the rights of establishment but rather records that it is the general policy of both Governments not to impose such a restriction in such a way as to frustrate the benefits expected to flow from a Free Trade Area Agreement. Paragraph (2) of the Article provides for consultations to be held in seeking equitable and mutually satisfactory solutions to any complaint that a measure in force in either country was not in keeping with this general policy. The only measure of this nature in force in this country is the Control of Manufactures Act, which, as the House is aware, has already been repealed, with effect from 1st January, 1968. I might mention, in this regard, that the restrictions imposed on the purchase of agricultural land in the Land Act, 1965, are not affected by this Article.

Comment on this

Does this Article bring the repeal of the Control of Manufactures Act into any earlier operation?

Comment on this

No. The other Article of a fiscal and monetary nature to which I think I ought to refer is Article XVIII which deals with balance of payments difficulties. Under this Article, it will not be permissible in future to impose levies for the purpose of meeting balance of payments problems but quantitative restrictions, having regard to each country's other international obligations, will be permissible. There is a specific waiver in respect of the import surcharge and the import levies the British and we have recently introduced.

Some reference was made to the absence of a social fund as in the case of EEC. I think it was unrealistic to suggest that such a fund is proper to a Free Trade Area Agreement. In fact, there is no such fund under the EFTA Agreement. Such a fund, is, of course, proper to a Common Market because in the Common Market that exists, there is power to rationalise and regionalise production of certain commodities. This EEC Agreement envisages that in such rationalisation of production, the manufacture or growing of certain commodities, industrial or agricultural, as the case may be, can be done in different regions and, indeed, in different member countries, therefore, involving in such cases, migration of workers. It was for such purposes as this that the European Social Fund was established in the first instance.

When we applied for membership of the EEC, we had studies undertaken as to how we could participate in this Fund. When our application for membership was suspended that study was continued by an inter-departmental committee on the basis of preparing outlines or recommendations for legislation to deal with the situation we are now about to face. These studies have led to the redundancy and resettlement schemes, the details of which are now being discussed with management and trade unions, preparatory to the introduction of legislation.

In the debate on the Free Trade Area Agreement, Fine Gael have nailed their colours, to the exclusion of everything else, to the EEC mast. They have based their assumptions on premises which I think are not valid. I should first like to refer to the allegations that have been made that no attempts were made to make contact with the EEC to see whether some workable arrangements which would be of advantage to us could be come to with the EEC countries. There was a series of meetings, as the Taoiseach mentioned, in 1963 and 1964, at both ministerial and official level. On 29th November, 1963, the Minister for External Affairs, with a full official team, met members of the Commission of the European Community and discussed in great detail just the type of things Fine Gael suggested should have been discussed and were not discussed. On 1st December, 1963, there was a meeting at official level.

Comment on this

Was that not while the discussions were current, and you have done nothing since?

Comment on this

I am telling the House what has been done.

Comment on this

Perhaps I had better listen and I might learn that the Minister is making a liar of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

I am recording the facts.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach gave different facts.

Comment on this

I have sat here for several hours without interrupting any Deputy. The debate so far has been conducted in a reasonable fashion but, for some reason, whenever I get up to speak, there is a barrage of interruptions. I try not to be offensive, but to be as factual as I can.

Comment on this

The Minister is never offensive.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is the practice that every Deputy is entitled to speak without interruption. The Minister is a Deputy and he is entitled to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

Very often interruptions are useful to the speaker.

Comment on this

Sometimes they are useful to break the sequence which the speaker is trying to follow. Therefore I will have to delay the House that much longer by going back to the beginning of the sequence. I have referred to the meeting on 29th November, 1963, at which the Minister for External Affairs was accompanied by a full team of top officials. I have also referred to the meeting on 1st December, 1963, at official level. There was another meeting on 13th March, 1964, with the Commission, at official level with top officials. There was a meeting on 26th January, 1965, at which the Minister for Agriculture attended with senior officials. There was another meeting on 27th January, 1965. I mention them in passing because of the allegations made in the House by Fine Gael spokesmen, and outside in articles which categorically stated that there were no ministerial meetings at all to explore what alternative there might be to full membership of EEC which would still be of advantage to us.

In his press conference on 20th December, 1965, Deputy Cosgrave said:

Before attempting to negotiate an Agreement that will tie us more closely to Britain, on whom we are already excessively dependent, the Government should at least have explored the possibility of an arrangement with the EEC under which we might have secured new outlets in that market without losing access for key products to the UK market. This the Government made no attempt to do, preferring instead the easier task of negotiating an Agreement with Britain on terms that are markedly to Britain's advantage.

Admittedly, the White Paper which dealt with the contacts that were made with the EEC was published on the same afternoon as Deputy Cosgrave's press conference, but nevertheless Deputy Cosgrave and other members of his Party have repeated that point of view—notwithstanding the categorical statement made by the Taoiseach to the contrary when he opened this debate.

I do not think it necessary for me to repeat the points made in the White Paper in this respect, nor what the Taoiseach said, but I may be able to amplify these matters to some extent. The main obstacles to our securing new outlets in the EEC are threefold: (1) the common external tariff with which the tariffs of the individual member countries are in process of being aligned; (2) the protective effect of the measures, principally variable import levies, built into the common agricultural policy arrangements which cover most agricultural products in which we have an interest; and (3) so far as products not covered by the common agricultural policy arrangements are concerned—mutton and lamb being a case in point—the national import regimes applied by individual member countries in which quota restrictions figure prominently.

Since the effect of the suspension of consideration of our application of July 1961, for entry to the Community was to exclude us temporarily, at any rate, from membership, any interim link with the Community would have had to take the form of association which, in the wording of the Rome Treaty would consist of an "agreement creating an association embodying reciprocal rights and obligations." To overcome the obstacle presented by the common external tariff, association would have had to be based on participation in the Community's customs union, as in the case of Greece.

Deputies are all aware of what the customs union means. In any association we would join, we would have the same customs regime as member countries of that association. This would involve commitments on our part to abolish over a fixed period our tariffs on Community goods, that is, tariffs on goods exported from the EEC, and at the same time, to align gradually our tariffs on imports from third countries with the common external tariff. In other words, instead of maintaining the preferential tariff we had as against Britain, we would have had to apply to goods entering this country from Britain the common external tariff which British goods entering the Common Market face at the present time. Both of these commitments would have conflicted with our obligations under the Anglo-Irish Trade Agreements under which we are obliged to accord to British goods free entry in certain cases and preference where duties are chargeable.

The assumption underlying the case made by Fine Gael seems to be that there is, or was, some possibility of negotiating some arrangement with the EEC in relation to the common external tariff which would have permitted of the maintenance of some at least of Britain's preferential rights in the Irish market and in return we would have been able to preserve access to the British market for our "key products," to use Deputy Cosgrave's term.

Of course, Deputy Cosgrave is repeating words used in newspaper articles submitted by a Fine Gael Senator last year. In one of these articles, it was stated that "there was at least a remote chance of some kind of arrangement with the EEC similar to that which Austria is currently attempting to negotiate, under which we could be associated with the Community while retaining our special relationship with Britain". I will deal in a few minutes with the suggestion that we could have done something on the same lines as Austria. In fact, since I have mentioned it now, I might as well deal with it now.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

You must not say even that.

Comment on this

I am glad that I evoked a "hear, hear" from Deputy Dillon. Fine Gael have been parading Austria both inside and outside the House as an example of what we ought to have done in relation to forming some kind of association with the European Economic Community. They must know that there is very little in common between our position and the case of Austria vis-à-vis the Community. Austria, as we know, is a country surrounded on all sides, with the exception of its boundaries on the south-west, by Communist bloc countries, and naturally has a substantial volume of trade with these countries and at the same time has a peace treaty with the Soviet Republic. Austria, however, is very much a western country ideologically and politically, and is a Christian country, and it is only natural that the EEC countries would wish to have her remain so.

On that basis alone, comparing the position of Ireland and Austria, can anyone seriously suggest that we would have as strong a case in going to the EEC for some form of association, as Austria has? Austria wants association with the Community that would permit it to maintain free entry for certain products from eastern countries so as to hold on to her trade outlets in the Communist countries. The suggestion, apparently, is that we should have sought association with the EEC on similar lines on a basis which would permit us to maintain, to use a Fine Gael expression, "in some degree our special trading relationship with Britain", and, again to use a Fine Gael expression, "to give us a degree of access to the EEC and UK markets simultaneously". Even if we could ignore the political and ideological considerations to which I have already referred, I do not think there would be much prospect on those grounds alone.

Let us examine what the economic considerations are vis-à-vis ourselves and Austria. Ireland imports 16 per cent of her requirements from the EEC; Austria imports nearly 60 per cent. Remember, too, the disparity in population which will increase considerably the volume represented by these percentages. Ireland's exports to the EEC represent 11 per cent of her total exports, whereas Austria's exports represent 46 per cent of her total. It is clear, therefore, on economic grounds alone, that Austria can make a much stronger case for special treatment by the EEC. Nevertheless, the fact is that Austria is still seeking special treatment and, so far, there is every indication that any association which Austria will be able to arrange with the Community will have to be based on the acceptance of the Community's common external tariff. The experience of Austria confirms what was stated in paragraph 128 of the White Paper, the paragraph dealing with the consideration of the alternatives suggested by the EEC. In this paragraph, on page 41 of the White Paper, it is stated that:

there was no possibility of a bilateral exchange of preferences, except within the framework of the Community's customs union, participation in which would involve the application of the Community's common external tariff to imports from third countries.

These third countries would include Britain.

It might be noted also that the relief that Austria is seeking from the need to apply the EEC common external tariff to third countries is a limited relief. It is most unlikely that Austria will succeed in having her trade with her EFTA partners exempted. This represents only about one-third of Austria's total trade as compared with three-fifths for Ireland's trade with Britain, that is of her total trade. If Austria secured relief in respect of all imports from Europe it would account for about 10 per cent of her trade and we need only contrast this with, say, a percentage of about 50 per cent of the trade for which we would be seeking exemption if Britain's imports to Ireland were to be given special treatment. Can there be any reasonable grounds for believing that the EEC, which is already enjoying a preferential trade balance with this country, would value so highly an arrangement with us which would still preserve substantial privileges for Britain, and would go out of its way to negotiate such an arrangement with us and, therefore, give us attractive advantages in return and, into the bargain, give Britain advantages in what would be part of the Community's markets?

Some Fine Gael speakers appeared to suggest that Austria was now home and dried as far as negotiating this special relationship with the EEC was concerned. In fact, the latest report available to us from Europe Agency, which is the authoritative source for information in these matters, is:

The negotiations are in fact at a point of deadlock for all these matters.

"These matters" are tariffs, trade and agricultural questions.

Comment on this

Everything else is at deadlock, too, so long as the General stays at home.

Comment on this

The Austrian negotiations have been conducted continuously, notwithstanding the situation between the Five and France and, notwithstanding that, this is the latest report available.

Deputy T.F. O'Higgins talked of the relationship between Eastern and Western Germany as an example of what we might have done. How naive can one get in this debate? Everyone knows there was a special let-out written into the protocol of the Rome Treaty in the first instance, which was a sine qua non as far as Western Germany was concerned, to allow her trade with Eastern Germany to continue. It would be foolish in the extreme to assume that the German arrangement, for which there were very compelling political reasons, would have in any way influenced the Community's view towards an application for some association by this country, especially having regard to our trade with Britain which would have obviously created serious problems for the Community.

I do not think I need go into any more detail about these matters. It is obvious the examples quoted are not real examples and are not capable of being followed up by us. I could sum up by saying that the answer to this suggestion by Fine Gael, and particularly the point made by Deputy Cosgrave, is that the Government have in fact explored the possibilities of an arrangement with EEC and have found no worthwhile trading advantage of negotiability which would at the same time permit of the preservation of our access to the British market.

One of the next points made by the Fine Gael speakers, and indeed in the press statement issued by Fine Gael following their press conference on 20th December, was that the safeguard clauses in the Free Trade Area Agreement we negotiated were not as good as the corresponding clauses in the EEC Treaty. I should like to quote the Fine Gael statement, which is to this effect:

Fine Gael had called for provisions in the Agreement similar to the EEC Rome Treaty which would enable the Irish Government to reduce the threat to industry and employment resulting from the freeing of trade. The clauses in the Agreement purporting to provide such safeguards after 1970 were quite inadequate.

I need not quote any more. I should like to compare specifically what is provided in this respect in the Rome Treaty with what is provided for in the Free Trade Area Agreement. In the first place, I might mention that the specific provisions in this respect in the Rome Treaty are contained in Article 226. It is not a long Article but it is not necessary for me to quote it except to say that the safeguards which may be employed can be employed only during the transitional period and that they must be such as are approved in advance by the Commission of the Community. In other words, no member country can take unilateral action until such time as the Community has examined its application and determined the extent of the action which may be taken. Then it permits action only for a limited period. What is more important—again contrasting with the provisions in our Agreement to which I shall refer in a minute—there is no provision in the Rome Treaty for extending the application of these safeguards beyond the transitional period. In our Agreement there is provision for the unilateral imposition of safeguard measures for a period of 18 months; in other words, without any consultation. There is no corresponding provision in the Rome Treaty.

The Treaty does not provide or contemplate the permanent exclusion of any products from free trade between member states. We have very reasonable provision for such exclusion. The Rome Treaty contains no provision for safeguard measures after the transitional period, while the Free Trade Area Agreement provides specifically for the possibility of such measures. So much for that part of the Fine Gael criticism based not on the White Paper but on knowledge of what was contained in the Agreement and what was contained in the Rome Treaty.

I should like to come now to the criticism that the balance of the Agreement is in favour of Britain. On the agricultural side, many of the existing uncertainties for outlets of our produce have been removed. We are guaranteed under the Agreement unlimited access to the British market in some cases for agricultural products and in others, where other traditional suppliers to Britain, including Commonwealth countries, have to be taken into account, we are guaranteed access on terms equal to the best available even to British farmers themselves.

On the industrial side, the principal advantage is that all remaining United Kingdom protection against us is now being removed and at once, on 1st July, with the single exception of cotton, for which a separate agreement was being negotiated in any event without reference to the Free Trade Area Agreement. Even that separate Agreement improves the terms on which our cotton exports can enter the British market at present. The removal of these United Kingdom duties will undoubtedly facilitate the export of new industrial products, exports which hitherto have been discouraged by the existence of these remaining tariff obstacles.

I might say in passing that it is not generally realised that already and for many years past up to 70 per cent of our industrial imports from the United Kingdom come in free of any tariff or quota restriction whatever. That is something which ought to be taken into account in considering this Free Trade Area Agreement.

Having mentioned the advantages on the agricultural and industrial side, I should like to refer briefly to the corresponding obligations we have undertaken on the industrial side. These have been spelled out so often it is hardly necessary for me to repeat them again: (1) the removal of restrictions over a nine-year period with a right of review on 1st July, 1970, for any sensitive sectors of our industry; (2) the complete exclusion from the obligations of the Agreement of a wide range of goods including industrial goods processed from fruit, milk, vegetables and fruit; (3) the extension of the transitional period of five years for some categories of goods and then the further exclusion from free trade of a quantity of goods in value not in excess of three per cent of goods imported from Britain in the year preceding review—so that, again, will embrace quite a wide range of Irish manufactured goods which would be free of the obligations of this Agreement. How, therefore, can anybody seriously suggest that the balance of advantage, even on this basis, lies with Britain?

Other positive advantages for industry are the removal of uncertainty surrounding our external trading arrangements which has inhibited the forward planning of investment and production over the past few years. This advantage is expected to be reflected particularly in the establishment of new industries, some of which, no doubt, have been held back pending clarification of trading arrangements with our principal export market. Indeed, I am personally aware of a number of these particular industries.

When assessing the balance of the Agreement, I think it is necessary that we should look at its provisions in terms of trade both ways. The resultant growth of trade will be the measure of the value of the Agreement to both countries but the expansion of British exports to Ireland will depend on our capacity to import them or, in other words, will depend on the additional income generated by the Agreement in Ireland.

It is estimated that for every £1 million worth of exports, there is generated in Ireland about £1? million of additional income within the economy. This relationship demonstrates the extent to which the trading advantages which Britain will gain from the Agreement are directly dependent on counterbalancing benefits that will accrue to the Irish economy. Clearly, therefore, far from the suggestion of Opposition speakers that Britain will gobble us up, even in a negative way, is it not in Britain's own interest that any trading arrangement between the two countries should be reasonably balanced and such as will afford a reasonable prospect of growth in the Irish economy and so a reasonable prospect of growth of British goods on the Irish market and vice versa?

Any serious criticism of the Agreement must also take into account the consequences of not concluding it or any Agreement and that means allowing Anglo-Irish trading relations to continue to be governed by the Trade Agreements of 1938, 1948 and 1960. This would simply be a matter of the status quo, involving no new obligations but nevertheless involving also the continued erosion of what advantages our agricultural exports enjoy.

The advantages of a new Agreement would clearly be denied to us but, at the same time, not only would they be denied to us if we did not make this Agreement but we would not avoid the obligation to continue with the reduction of protection. Again coming to the point I made earlier on about the unreal air of some of the contributions made, this is an obligation which the external trading environment in which we live imposes on us, whether or not we join any association, of continuing to reduce our tariffs and making ourselves more efficient.

Incidentally, Deputy Corish said in his speech two days ago that nothing was heard about tariff reductions, about freeing of trade, until 1960 and, even after 1960, nothing was done about taking steps towards a lowering of tariffs, notwithstanding that the 1960 Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement contained specific provision to that effect. I immediately challenged him but he continued his assertion that nothing was done. Since then, I took the trouble to check how many reviews of tariffs were undertaken by the Industrial Development Authority as a result of the provision in the 1960 Agreement. I find that there were no fewer than 19 such reviews—in many cases, of important commodities. Let me take some examples—leather, breakfast foods, bread, textile floor coverings, wooden furniture, and so on. Of these 19 reviews, ten resulted in the reduction of tariffs already in existence. No change was recommended in two cases. A reduction recommended in one case was not implemented because it coincided with the imposition of the British 15 per cent surcharge. In another case, the replacement of a quota by a duty was recommended. One case was withdrawn by the British Board of Trade. So much for Deputy Corish's assertion that nothing was done from 1960, when the 1960 Agreement was implemented, about tariff reductions.

Coming to the balance of the Agreement again, the outstanding fact in our external trading environment is that countries to which we sell over 80 per cent of our exports are rapidly completing free trading arrangements between themselves—the six Common Market countries, within their own community, and the EFTA countries, within their Free Trade Area Agreement. Therefore, it is an illusion to think that merely by standing aside, we can preserve the status quo.

The principal factors that force us to participate in this movement of freeing of trade, whether unilaterally or as part of a free trade group, may be summarised in this way: (1) a satisfactory rate of growth in the economy, with all that implies in the way of raising living standards and increasing employment depends largely on the expansion of the industrial sector; (2) because of the conditions of competition we have to meet in our principal export markets which will reach free trade by 1967, we cannot expect to achieve the necessary expansion in industry unless our exports are fully competitive; (3) we cannot expect to bring about the necessary degree of competitiveness without a substantial further lowering of protection in the period up to 1970 and the choice has been to do this either unilaterally or as part of a free trade area arrangement where we could get reciprocal advantages; and (4)—and perhaps more important—if we did not face up to this challenge, in addition to incurring the penalty of economic stagnation we should expose ourselves to having to face much graver burdens at a much quicker tempo whenever the opportunity would present itself to us of joining the wider EEC.

The real comparison, therefore, is not between the advantages we obtain and the obligations we assume under the Agreement. A substantial proportion of these obligations in the way of tariff dismantlement would, in any event, have to be undertaken unilaterally. The real balance is between the advantages we have gained—and which are immediately operative as of 1st July—and the obligations which will remain, say, after 1970 and which are likely—and I repeat this—very likely to be absorbed in the more extensive obligations we shall have to take on as a member of an enlarged European community.

I should like to refer here to the gloomy forebodings of the Labour Party that this Agreement would cause widespread unemployment and create industrial graveyards, to use the words of one of their Deputies, throughout the towns of this country. I wonder why the Labour Party, who pride themselves on being more akin than any of us to the working man, of having his interests more at heart, and who say they know more about the potential capacity of Irish labour, should write those people off as a bunch of ne'er-do-wells and nincompoops. Irish labour and Irish management can do as well as their counterparts anywhere else. To be more specific, as the House is aware there has been an annual review of the progress made under the First and Second Programmes for Economic Expansion, particularly the annual review of the targets set out in the Second Programme for industrial output and industrial employment. A Labour Deputy asked me a question in the House on 16th December last as to what the revised estimates were, particularly in view of the Free Trade Area Agreement coming into force. The review which was conducted recently in association with management and the trade unions— and which incidentally has not yet been commented upon by the NIEC—indicates that, far from there being reduced employment, the figures for both industrial production and industrial employment in transportable goods have had to be revised upwards.

As I said at the beginning, the debate ought to be conducted in the atmosphere of the reality of the conditions in which we live. The Agreement must be debated against the background of our possible membership of a wider economic community or, at any event, in the certain knowledge that free trade is coming, that tariffs are being reduced all round us, not only by our trading partners in Europe but in the United States and in other parts of the world. These tariffs will be, as between EFTA and EEC countries, at nil in 12 months, and then there follows fast on the heels of that the Kennedy round which will seek to reduce tariffs between the EFTA and EEC blocs and the rest of the world by 50 per cent. Surely we cannot live in a cloud cuckoo land and ignore these trends all around us. I do not think we should stand aside and ignore what has happened, dig our heads in the sand and let our industries be wiped out and our economy submerged. I say that our industries would be wiped out even if we maintained our high protective tariff element in this country because, as between Britain and her EFTA partners, with tariffs being reduced, there is inevitably the urge to become more and more competitive in order that the industries in their respective countries can hold their own with their competitors in the same trading blocs. The more competition there is and the more efficient these industries become the better they will be in a position to export to countries like ours which might continue to be protected by high tariffs and, therefore, effectively eradicate the far-fetched idea that protection is an answer to everything.

It is obvious we would have had to continue the reduction of our tariffs at some level in any event. We had undertaken this, I think, with the approval of the House and the country, as an exercise to ensure our economic survival, apart altogether from the immediate objective of preparing ourselves for membership of the EEC. Now we are getting reciprocal advantages for the exercise we had already undertaken.

I do not want to go into any detailed comment about complaints that this Agreement was conducted without full disclosure, as we went along, to the Dáil. As Deputies opposite are well aware, no negotiations could be conducted with any country except on the basis of complete confidence and it is ridiculous and illusory to suggest that we should have kept the House informed as we went along and, particularly, that we should have had a full debate here before the Agreement was finally negotiated. It is obvious that that would have weakened our hands considerably at the negotiating table when the crunch points would have to be met.

Deputy Cosgrave referred in particular to a speech I made in London when I was invited by the Corkmen's Association to address them and when I referred to the Agreement in certain terms. What I said then was I thought that the conclusion of this Agreement would give us greater economic freedom than we now enjoy and in particular would enable us, with a freer hand, to negotiate trading arrangements with other countries. That is, in fact, so. I made that assertion in reply to allegations made by no less a person than the Fine Gael Senator, Senator Garret FitzGerald, when he spoke in the Seanad in July during the course of the Finance Bill just after our return from London from the second round of ministerial talks. Senator FitzGerald said we were tying ourselves to the sick man of Europe. I said then that the successful conclusion of the Agreement would give us greater freedom than we now have, and that is a fact. It is very funny to contrast the suggestion of Senator FitzGerald that we were tying ourselves to the sick man of Europe with that of Deputy Dockrell who has just said that Britain is now the most economically powerful country in Europe. Sick or powerful I do not know which—it is up to Fine Gael to decide.

We still have people, of course, talking about selling our sovereignty but the hard working farmers, the great bulk of our industrial workers, exporters and manufacturers, who have invested their money in this country, have welcomed this Agreement. The great majority of our people have welcomed it and I think those Irishmen and women are as good as those who bleat about sovereignty. All these people have welcomed the Agreement as an opportunity and a challenge. I believe if we, as a Government, had not taken the initiative we did, then we could have been accused of prejudicing our political and economic sovereignty. This Agreement is now effective and when the debate is over, I hope it will cease to be a political plaything and that we will get on with the job. I think the great majority of our people will no longer tolerate dilatory or obstructive tactics in economic matters generally or in industrial relations in particular. We have always claimed that the Irish nation, given an opportunity, can work as hard and as well as any in the world. I think this Agreement gives us the opportunity and the challenge. Now is the time for us to prove our claim.

Comment on this

During this debate there was an obvious desire by a few Deputies to represent the action of the Labour Party in opposing this Agreement as the action of an irresponsible Opposition Party never likely to assume the position where it would have to operate its own policy or, shall we say, provide an alternative. We are represented as a Party bent at all costs on the political game and anxious to put ourselves in the position in which we could come along some time in the future and, speaking as ordinary Deputies, tell our constituents: "There is the Free Trade Agreement for you. We told you so."

That is not the case. We in the Labour Party examined this Free Trade Agreement as fully as possible in the short time at our disposal to see, first of all, if the balance of advantage, or a fair proportion of the advantage, was in favour of the Irish people and, unlike the Minister for Finance, we decided conclusively that it was not. We also examined it from the point of view of what it would mean to Irish people in terms of employment and emigration, in terms of a more equitable distribution of the nation's wealth among all our people, which is one of the primary objectives of our Party, and we found this Agreement was a positive hindrance to the achievement of these objectives. We found it would result in increased unemployment, not, as the Minister for Finance has said, because of the feeling that the Irish worker was not competent, given a fair opportunity, to compete with his counterparts elsewhere. Our precise case is that he is not getting a fair opportunity under this Agreement. We decided the price we are paying is far too high in view of the few concessions we are getting and we felt obliged to oppose the Agreement and vote against it in this House.

This Agreement was negotiated and signed on the assumption that it would be absorbed by our becoming members of EEC or EFTA or, as the Taoiseach said, a combination of both in the next two or three or four years before the hardships that will ultimately result from it for the people of this country become evident, before its shortcomings appear. In the past few years, the Taoiseach has repeatedly forecast the probable date on which we will become members of one or other of the trading communities that exist in Europe. He has done this with such monotonous regularity and misguided optimism that we can be pardoned for not being swayed by any of his forecasts. We accept that free trade is very likely, if not inevitable, in the not too distant future and that preparations must be made if we are to survive under its conditions as members of any of these associations. In recommending the Agreement to the House, the Taoiseach said much valuable time had been lost and that we must lose no more time in getting on with the job. If time has been lost, that is the fault of the Taoiseach himself and if we must no longer continue to foster, to use his own words, high-cost, inefficient and obsolescent industries, such industries exist only because they were fostered and nurtured by the Taoiseach as Minister for Industry and Commerce down through the years.

The Taoiseach now seems to have embarked on some sort of panic preparations for entry into EEC but surely he cannot expect us, nor can the Minister for Finance, despite what he said just now, to accept irrevocably that we had no choice other than to negotiate the Agreement that has been made. The Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture went to great lengths to tell the House that this Agreement is binding and permanent with our highly industrialised neighbour across the Irish Sea. The Taoiseach says his Government sat down as equals with the British Government and he was at great pains to impress us that this was so. Of course they sat down as equals and I think any man in the street could sit down as an equal with any Minister in the Fianna Fáil Cabinet. There was no need for them to feel inferior but in any Agreement such as this where the balance might be in favour of one side or the other, we can very easily estimate in whose favour it is. We do not believe that Britain acts charitably towards this country. All the safeguards for the British economy are enshrined in this Agreement and no safeguards for us.

Perhaps we are all inclined to make sweeping statements—indeed, they have been made ad nauseam in this debate—but in the very short time at our disposal there was not much else we could do. There was no opportunity to go into great detail but in any case the aspects of the Agreement that have been discussed are its most important assets. We are guaranteed a market for 638,000 head of store cattle in Britain each year. Our case— and it has been said before—is that this market was already there, even if the Minister for Agriculture never had any consultations with his British counterpart. The only snag is that in making this permanent Agreement if prices paid by other countries exceed the prices we obtain in Britain at any time, we are tied and committed to export this quantity of store cattle to Britain at the market prices obtaining in Britain at that time. However, being charitable, we place this on the credit side.

The shortening of the waiting period for cattle exported to Britain to enable them to qualify for deficiency payments is certainly an improvement and must result in higher prices for cattle for a percentage of Irish farmers and also in a greater turnover in cattle. We may put this on the credit side also. Similarly, we regard the guaranteed minimum payments for 25,000 tons of carcase beef and 5,000 tons of carcase lamb as on the credit side, although in this case the 25,000 tons represents only half what the Taoiseach estimates Irish farmers will have to sell by 1970. The sting in this Agreement, and we cannot overlook it, despite the Taoiseach's protestations about sovereignty, is that when these deficiency payments become operative, the British can tell us what to do with them. The Labour Party cannot stand by the British dictating to us in any way.

This is the kernel of our case—it is not likely that any of these benefits will accrue to the small farmer of this country. That is reminiscent of Fianna Fáil policy towards the farmers down the years. Any benefits that have been provided have gone to the bigger farmers. The big farmers have got more. The small farmers have got little. Bacon, butter, sugar, dead meat in excess of 25,000 tons of carcase beef and 5,500 tons of lamb are all subject to restrictions. There is no free trade so far as the products of the small farmer are concerned and on which the small farmer depends for his livelihood.

Another point on which we do not agree is with regard to the broiler industry. The difficulty is that if we increase our exports of broilers significantly and increase our export of turkeys beyond a figure of 3,000 tons, we must consult with Britain with a view to allowing imports of these products from Britain. I am hoping that that will not dampen our hopes of securing broiler industries in various places throughout the country. We had hoped to get a broiler industry in a town in Cork in the near future. I hope this will materialise.

In terms of pounds, shillings and pence, there is another matter which we cannot afford to overlook. The view has been expressed by Professor Dovring, Professor of Agriculture in Illinois University, in a report entitled "Problems of Manpower in Agriculture", to the OECD, that in relation to farm incomes a decline is evident in agricultural prices relative to other prices; that a trend in this direction has been evident in the United States and other highly developed countries for a number of years and is expected to become more general in Western Europe, including Britain, during the 1960s. In view of the fact that any gain which we may get from this Agreement is on the agricultural side, that is something we cannot forget. I hope the estimate made by the Minister for Agriculture of a £10 million gain for agriculture materialises.

Another matter in connection with this Agreement which strikes me as peculiar is that we feel free to guarantee to Britain a market for a total of 38,000 tons of fish per annum. That seems ridiculous in a country whose fisheries are not nearly developed to the full. Instead of guaranteeing Britain a market for 38,000 tons of fish, we should have been expanding our own fishing industry, safeguarding the home market and developing exports.

The benefits accruing to this country from this Agreement are few. It is the big cattle rancher who will benefit On the whole, we feel that the benefits to be derived are totally insufficient and inadequate recompense for the general upheaval that must take place in industry. Despite the complacency displayed by various Ministers, that upheaval in industry is inevitable in the next four or five years, particularly if the Taoiseach's forecast that we will be in one of the western European trading groups within that number of years is correct. All our industries will be exposed gradually, but very surely, to the full blast of competition from industries which enjoy a home market of over 50,000,000 people. Any Irish industrialist will tell you that in order to expand exports at the present stage of development a fairly good guarantee of a home market must be in existence as a base. Without that, industry cannot hope to survive. These are the words of the management of an Irish industry to whom I have been speaking recently.

Irish industrialists find that they cannot compete on the home market with industries which the Government have helped to set up by grants, exemption from corporation profits tax, income tax and rates, established primarily for export but allowed to sell their products on the home market. The escape clauses with which the Agreement is adorned will be freely availed of. It is extraordinary that the Government should have so much confidence in Britain honouring the Agreement. What will happen if one of the negotiations which inevitably will take place results in Britain not settling even for the fall back positions of which the Taoiseach spoke? I am surprised at the Government expecting Britain to honour this Agreement in view of the history of Britain as to the honouring of Agreements and in view of the Government's failure to honour agreements made in respect of Irish industry. In 1960, a firm manufacturing pottery was set up in Kilrush, Clare, primarily for export. An agreement was made involving that firm and Carrigaline Pottery, to the effect that 100 per cent of the products of the Kilrush firm would be for export for a period of three years, and after three years, consultation would take place in order to explore the possibility of allowing five per cent of its goods into the Irish market. No such consultation took place. Early last year, before the Trade Agreement was negotiated, the Carrigaline Pottery had letters from Ceramics Ltd. and from An Foras Tionscal informing them that £45,000 worth of the products of Ceramics Ltd. would be launched on the Irish market annually and that, in addition, accumulated stock valued at £50,000 would be sold this year. That agreement was not honoured. An agreement negotiated between the IDA and Carrigaline Pottery was not honoured. Naively, the Government accept that the Agreement now made with Britain will be honoured by Britain.

We can envisage this Agreement resulting in mass unemployment. We are very dubious about the three per cent escape clause, the fact that we can exclude from the operation of the Agreement for all time a quantity of goods in value not in excess of three per cent of goods imported from Britain in the preceding year. We feel that that is not adequate. I envisage considerable difficulty in selecting the industries from which the goods of a value not exceeding three per cent will be drawn. I can envisage—I hope I am wrong—industrial unrest as a result of it.

We are not suggesting that the Irish worker is in any way inferior to his counterpart abroad. We are suggesting that he is not getting equal opportunities with his counterpart abroad. I have no doubt that this Agreement will result in wholesale uprooting of Irish workers, and uprooting nowadays is not a pleasant thing for anybody. We have been told that the Government have a manpower policy, have arranged for redundancy payments and will provide a system of retraining. Retraining for whom? That will not be enough to compensate the displaced Irish worker. That will not solve anything for him.

We all know Irish workers in industries throughout the country who are carrying huge mortgages on their houses. Indeed, some have built houses and cannot now get loans sanctioned to pay for these houses. There have been no loans available over the past six months. What happens if these workers cannot sell these houses? The Taoiseach and other Fianna Fáil speakers have agreed that there will be unemployment in some areas; they say that the loss of that employment will be compensated for in other areas. What will happen if there are no opportunities for employment in particular areas? What will happen if the Irish worker is saddled with a home of which he cannot get rid? These questions have not been answered at all. There are others we could ask had we had more time in which to examine all this. Our fear is that there will be no employment forthcoming for the Irish worker and the only future for him will lie in Britain.

Despite all the Taoiseach's blowing about this Agreement, he admits that the problems of industry cannot be foreseen and estimated. On the other hand, Deputy Corry has told us that he examined all the industries in his constituency and found that none of them will be hurt. It is a pity, I think, that the Taoiseach, before signing this Agreement, did not give Deputy Corry the job of examining every industry in the country; he would then have been in a position to come in here and tell us that none of them needs to worry.

We have, of course, made up our minds in relation to these matters and we are not likely to be misled by what Deputy Corry and the Government Party say about this Agreement. We have made up our minds. It is our considered opinion that this Agreement will result in mass unemployment, consequent emigration, and a more inequitable distribution still of the wealth of the country among our people. We have, therefore, no hesitation in opposing this Agreement and we have no apology to make to anybody for walking into the Division Lobby to vote against it.

Deputies Dillon and P.J. Burke rose.

Comment on this
James Tully Acting Chairman Labour Party

Deputy Dillon.

Comment on this

This is two to one.

Comment on this

I have been waiting here since 12 o'clock.

Comment on this

I waited seven hours yesterday and three the day before.

Comment on this

The Deputy is good-looking and we like looking at him.

Comment on this

I will not stand in Deputy Dillon's way.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, the same order has been followed throughout the debate. There has been no change.

Comment on this

That is what is wrong with it. It is two to one.

Comment on this

"The British market is gone forever, thanks be to God". The Leader of the Opposition said here very aptly that the zeal of the convert is often embarrassing. I have been watching the faces of the Fianna Fáil Deputies as their leaders have passed through their transports of joy over the achievement of free trade and unlimited access to the British market and the only thing that I could think of was the faces of the Muslim supporters of the Mad Mullah, had he announced his intention of joining the Jehovah Witnesses. But it would be a strange thing, indeed, if the observers of the political scene in Ireland, who regard themselves as so sophisticated, should have had it to tell that, because Fianna Fáil have come to their senses, this Party should be expected to vote for a reimposition of their insanity. We are delighted they have come to their senses, but, in their release from the insane asylum in which they have dwelt so comfortably for the past quarter of a century, we do not want them to go berserk altogether. Surely it is in order, and not contrary to public policy, that, in welcoming them home from their protracted sojourn in an economic mental hospital, we should exercise some restraint upon them by telling them that, in the initial stages of their freedom. It is customary to be in before 12 o'clock at night and that alcohol is still intoxicating.

I was listening to the Taoiseach on Tuesday. He wound up his speech, in all modesty of course, by speaking of the swaddling clothes that he had provided for Irish industry. His biblical description of his own functions in the public life of Ireland, I thought, reflected credit on his modesty and humility. He never seemed to have heard that, before his name or that of his Party had ever been heard of in Ireland, there were boots made in Ireland; there were woollen textiles made in Ireland; there was beer made in Ireland; there was whiskey made in Ireland; there were biscuits made in Ireland. There were sugar factories functioning in Ireland. There was milling proceeding. There were clothing industries operating. The name of Balbriggan was not unknown in the hosiery industry. The Electricity Supply Board had begun to function on the Shannon, though we did not think much of it then.

I readily concede that the Taoiseach provided what he calls swaddling clothes for some of the industrialists but, to me, they looked more like mink bikinis. The difference is, of course, that the cost of the mink bikinis has long since been written off by those who wear them, but the working man, who went in to furnish the mink bikini when he was young and vigorous and ready to be trained to any art or craft to which he was called to earn his living, is now 45 or 50 years of age; he has no mink bikini and he is a bit too old for swaddling clothes. He is told, in the poetic words of Deputy Seán Dunne, that he will be invited to retrain himself. Some of them are inclined to ask, and with reason: "For what? Is it to milk cows when I am 50 years of age?"

Does anyone doubt in this House that one of the consequences of this Trade Agreement will be that there will be a number of middle-aged men with families, perhaps at the most expensive ages, left unemployed? Does anyone doubt that the provision we have at present made for them is inadequate? What reassurance have we that there will be effective provision made for them? What certainty have we that it is surely possible to make effective provision for them? I remember ex-Deputy McGilligan of this House once saying— I am glad to be able to put it on record that he had two great qualities, one, perhaps one of the finest brains in Europe and, two, an intense and deep compassion for the circumstances of the working man——

Comment on this

He said he was not concerned with the unemployed of this country. That is on the record.

Comment on this

Do not speak untruths.

Comment on this

That is on the record.

Comment on this

It is not on the record. The Deputy should tell the truth.

Comment on this

One million people have emigrated since 1932.

Comment on this

Surely Deputies will let me deal with Deputy Paddy Burke. If I cannot deal with Deputy Burke at this time of my life I shall never be able to do so. I want to say that if Deputy Burke made that statement advisedly, he is displaying a reckless indifference to the truth which would reflect discredit upon a liar.

Comment on this

I shall bring in the record.

Comment on this

The Deputy can parse that observation and when he is finished reading it, he may understand what it means. The statement which Deputy Burke credited to Deputy McGilligan was never made and the records of this House are there to prove it. That man to whom I have referred had, in addition to this distinguished quality of mind, an intense compassion for the working man. I remember his saying here in Dáil Éireann that he would never again consent to a scheme which imposed on people in middle age the obligation to retrain for different employment from that in which they had spent the best years of their lives acquiring a skill. If the national interest demands that their lives be disrupted, then the national interest must be prepared to bear the burden of carrying them at their full wages for the rest of their days, if they so desire. That we shall be faced with a substantial burden of that character as a result of this Trade Agreement there can be very little doubt.

I want to speak a word of reason to both sides of the House. I do not believe that the Government of Ireland drawn from any Party in this House went to London for the purpose of selling this country to the British Government. I do not doubt that the Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government did their best in London, but it was a very bad best. That is exactly what I would expect from them. If I thought they were capable of doing a good best, I would have supported Fianna Fáil. It is because I think they are incompetent, because I do not think they understand the vital interests of this country, and because their own history demonstrates those facts that I have consistently opposed them.

On the other hand, let us not get this whole problem out of perspective. Our Government did not go to London to dictate armistice terms to a conquered nation. The process of negotiation of a Trade Agreement is that if you want to take, you have got to give. This is an agreement, not an ultimatum. I would describe the whole of the Government publicity relating to this Agreement as an obscene fraud. It is the exaggerated claims and the brouhaha that have gone on about this Agreement which justify the description of an obscene fraud.

The Minister for Agriculture came in here yesterday with a carefully prepared brief which he intended to read for our edification and which he attempted to read. If he read it, he would have made the good speech I expected from him, because he is no daw. However, as we all know, he made the worst speech he has ever made since he came into Dáil Éireann because when he departed from the brief so carefully prepared for him by the extremely able assistants that he has—and I speak from personal experience—he floundered into admissions and concessions which reveal the fact that what Sir Harold Woolley said is perfectly true, that when you come to read and study the agricultural sections of this Trade Agreement, they amount in substance to a confirmation and a codification of the Irish position in the British market for certain Irish agricultural products as it at present exists.

What have we got for agriculture under this Agreement? Some very valuable things which were secured in the 1948 Trade Agreement and, do not let us underestimate it, we have the precious link between the price paid for Irish store cattle resident in England for two months and the British-bred cattle at the point of slaughter. That was first conceded in in the 1948 Trade Agreement and it is now confirmed. However, the Minister for Agriculture says that over and above this we now have unlimited access to the British market for Irish store cattle. Did you ever hear such tripe from a rational man? In the name of commonsense, for what do we want unlimited access to the British market for store cattle if not to sell them to the British farmer? Is it to race them at Aintree or to send them round the course at Epsom? We have access to the British market for as many store cattle as the British farmer will buy. What is important is that when he comes to the Dublin market to buy them and reckons up: "What profit can I make on them?" he says to himself: "If I keep these cattle two months in England I will get as much for them as if they were bred in Westmorland or Dorset, Scotland or Wales." Do not let us underestimate the value of that concession; do not let us decry the fact that that concession we secured in 1948 is continuing. But do not let us vitiate it by fraudulent claims for this document that cannot now or ever be justified.

It is monstrous for a responsible Minister for Agriculture to get up in this House or tell the Sunday Independent that this will mean an appreciation of £6 per head for store cattle when everyone who has any knowledge of rural Ireland knows that the price of cattle fell in the past ten months by £10 a head. If they do not come back £6 on what they were last December, we might as well fold up altogether. I have told the House there were people paying for conacre throughout the country who had bought cattle in the spring and sold them in November, for the want of grass, at less than they had paid for them, and they still had to pay the conacre rent. If the price of store cattle has not gone up by £6 by next spring without any Trade Agreement, the cattle will go up the spout and all the farmers in the country will go up after them.

I was looking at pictures of the effects of drought in Bechuanaland, in parts of Rhodesia and other regions of Africa, of cattle dying of starvation by the roadsides. If we could not depend on a good spring coming round here, we also could see pictures of cattle dying of starvation after they had finished eating the bushes. I do not apprehend that happening, but it is obscene fraud for the Minister for Agriculture to pretend that things are attributable to this document which in fact never were.

This has been a very remarkable debate and some of the finest speeches I have listened to in Dáil Éireann in a long time have been made in the course of it. I do not deny that the Taoiseach, in introducing his case for this Agreement, had prepared a skilful document and he read it skilfully, making out the best case that could be made for the Agreement that he commended to us. I do not think any side of the House will challenge me when I say the Leader of the Opposition spoke better than ever before in his criticism of it. I hope Deputy Corish will not think it amiss if I pass over his contribution to speak of the contribution made by Deputy Seán Dunne. I have been 34 years a Member of the Dáil and it is not easy to impress me or to move me by political oratory, but when a man of Deputy Seán Dunne's bulk can address this House in a monotone for 20 minutes and say all he managed to say as he said it, I shall not forget it all the rest of my life.

This morning when our proceedings were resumed, Deputy Dockrell made a very remarkable speech, in the course of which he said this is an economic Act of Union. He recalled that 160 years ago the Act of Union was enacted in this city and there were lots of well-intentioned men who believed it would serve the interests of our people. In the subsequent 160 years, we have learned what a fearful delusion these men laboured under and how aptly did Grattan and Flood criticise it and how they were vindicated by its results. Deputy Dockrell said that three great events happened in the past 160 years —the Act of Union, the Treaty and now this Agreement. There was a lot of truth in what Deputy Dockrell said but I shall go further. There were five great events—the Act of Union; the Land War and its victory; the concession by the British Government in the Home Rule Act, of the recognition of the right of the Irish people to govern their own country; the Treaty and the Agreement we now have under consideration.

I wonder if Deputies feel the presence of the ghost of Castlereagh. He would not have been welcomed in this House when he was fit to come himself. It is an odd thing that his ghost should walk here, smiling sardonically and contemptuously, at the invitation of Fianna Fáil. This is not a free trade Agreement. It is not a free trade Agreement for the reason Deputy Dockrell gave today. With extraordinary penetration, he put his finger on the heart of this matter when he said this Agreement gives the British industrialist equality in Ireland with the Irish industrialist. Who will claim that this Agreement gives the Irish farmer equality with the British farmer in Great Britain? I make no concealment of the fact—I am freer to speak, now that I have shed some of my responsibilities—that the land and those who live on it have always been closest to my heart.

If this Agreement gave the farmers of Ireland access to the whole system of price supports and to the enduring and unrestrained affluence of the farmers of Britain, I would have found it hard to utter words of criticism in this house and I believe Irish industry would have discovered that the fastly expanding market that would have been available on the home front through giving our farmers the affluence that such equality would have brought would have amply compensated them for any challenge British industry in Ireland would have involved them in. But this Agreement does not give that kind of free trade and it never will give that kind of free trade.

The Minister for Finance today got quite indignant when he recalled that Deputy Dockrell had said: "Beware when negotiating with Great Britain". The British are at it as long as the Venetian Republic and their ability is still beyond belief. The Minister for Finance took that as a reflection on his intelligence and on that of those who went with him. It was nothing of the kind. I shall remind the House that when Sonny Liston entered the ring with Cassius Clay and confidently predicted he would have Clay eliminated in the twinkling of an eye, it was Sonny Liston who was carried from the ring. When Gene Tunney challenged Jack Dempsey, he did it with trepidation, vigilance and circumspection and it was Jack Dempsey who was carried from the ring. It is those who go swaggering into the presence of the old hand, confident of their ability to meet and master him, who get carried from the ring.

Would that our Prime Minister had the guile and wisdom of the Prime Minister of France. He did not exclude England from the Common Market because he was afraid of that combination. He did not exclude England from the Common Market because they were an island. He did not exclude England from the Common Market because they were Anglo-Saxon. He excluded England from the Common Market because, for the first time, the French civil servants met in Brussels the British civil servants and they said to themselves, and rightly so: "Up to now we are the masters of the situation. If those bucks get in God knows who will come out on top." Should we not admire them.

I remember speaking to my own Taoiseach, when I was negotiating in 1948, on behalf of agriculture, and saying: "We have an old warrior in here and he is like the Rock of Gibraltar. You could not knock a chip off him." He was advising the British Minister for Agriculture. As Deputy John A. Costello will remember, we had to invoke the aid of Sir Stafford Cripps before we could shift this old warrior. We never underestimated and we never flagged in our admiration of his loyalty, tenacity and devotion to the Minister and the Government he served.

I think it was the Minister for Agriculture, yesterday, who spoke of some ambiguity and uncertainty relating to the 5/- differential that was in the 1948 trade agreement. Let us just put this on the record. Yes, in the text there is an ambiguity but the then Taoiseach, Deputy Costello, when we were negotiating, will remember me asking Sir Stafford Cripps: "Does that mean 5/- a cwt differential or not?""Yes", he said, "that is what it means". It is perfectly true and if the Minister for Agriculture asks his officials, if he has not already asked them, he will discover that within one month of our coming home from London I got a letter from a high British civil servant saying that he proposed to interpret the matter in this way—that the extra 5/- awarded would be 8/-. I said: "Let there be no comment made on that letter. Send it to Mr. John Dulanty in London and ask him to go down to the Treasury and show it to the Chancellor and ask him whether that is a true record of our agreement." The Chancellor's answer was to tear the letter up, throw it in the wastepaper basket with a request to Mr. Dulanty to tell Mr. Dillon to regard the letter as never having been written because we knew when we made the Agreement that we were dealing with a man whose word was better than his bond. Mind you there were good negotiators then.

I believe the British Government are friendly to this country but I do not believe they carry that friendship to the point of betraying the interests of their own people. I think they fought hard in this context to defend their own people's interests and they have admirably succeeded. Let it be truly said here today that it is nonsense to pretend our Government had not difficulties to grapple with. They certainly had and if they had come home and told us frankly that they did the best they could in all the circumstances, I think they could have averted a good deal of the criticism they have drawn on themselves.

It is true that we have a quota for bacon but it is also true that in Annex F of the Trade Agreement of 1948 we had unlimited access to the British market for bacon, fixed at a price of 225/-. Let us reckon what that price means, in terms of money, in 1966. It is 409/- per hundredweight. Now, I know that the conditions are not the same. I know that the British Government were buying bacon then they are not buying now. I know that there was a subsequent pigs and bacon agreement made in 1951 because I made it. It lasted until 1956. Times change, circumstances change and we must change with them. If we are to make comparisons let them be true comparisons. Then, we can judge the facts on their merits and not on fraud.

It is true that we have got a licence to supply the British with an extra quantity of butter. The figure mentioned in the 1948 Trade Agreement was 20,000 tons but there was an important additional phrase "or more if available". It is true, when I made that Agreement in 1948, I could have got for that butter the equivalent of about 550/- per hundredweight but our Government decided it was proper to give our own people unlimited supplies before we sold any of it at all. It is true, in that context, I said to the farmers of this country: "You are now getting ½ to ¼ per gallon for milk. Drop the guarantee for milk and we will give you the current milk price with the assurance that you will never get less than a 1/- in terms of 1948 prices. You will get anything over and above that which the market gives." Do you understand what that means in 1966 prices? That was a guarantee of a minimum of 1/10 a gallon but in the meantime the farmers of this country could have got in the days of scarcity that then obtained the equivalent of 2/9 or 3/- per gallon for their milk. That is ancient history. What is the use of going into all those questions now?

We have got an increase in the quota for butter. If they had come back and said to us, honestly and truly, that this makes no difference to the dairy farmers of Ireland but that the burden of the dairy subsidy on the Irish Exchequer would be substantially lightened I would have said: "That is an honest and true statement and I am glad they were able to get that relief for the Exchequer but it does not matter a damn for the farmers of Ireland."

The farmers of Ireland get a guaranteed price for milk and Bord Bainne has to sell butter anywhere it can. If they sell it in England the burden is lighter on the Exchequer. If they sell it in Persia or Peru, where we can sell all the butter we can produce, the price is lower. It is true that one-third export subsidy is levied on the price of milk. I doubt if that levy can long continue. In fact, the benefit of this increased export quota to the British market is in relief of the Irish Exchequer just as when we come to this sensational undertaking by the British Government to pay a non-existent support price for carcase beef exported. There was no support price paid in the past seven months because the world price was higher than the support price fixed. During the last weekly or fortnightly period there was a support price paid of .408 pence per lb. When you come to measure that today what does that mean to the Irish farmers? It means a substantial relief to the Irish Exchequer even when meat becomes cheaper again. In so far as it relieves the Irish Exchequer, I am glad to know it, but let us tell the farmers the truth. Do not let us attempt to sell them this Trade Agreement by fraud.

People will say to me: why then do not Fine Gael vote against this Agreement? I asked myself that question, as every responsible Deputy must ask himself that question. What if we did? The 1948 Trade Agreement and the 1938 Trade Agreement have been abandoned; they are gone. This is the substitute. It is incorporated in this Agreement with the British Government that the other two are gone. In the 1938 and the 1948 Trade Agreements, we had the right to fix notice on the British Government of six months that we intended to abrogate those Agreements, and at any stage the British Government could have said to us: "This day six months the 1948 Trade Agreement ceases to function." We had a corresponding right with them.

We must have some Trade Agreement and this Trade Agreement includes the precious asset of the link between Irish cattle and the guaranteed price in Great Britain. Frankly, I am too long absent from the Department of Agriculture to give the House any serious appraisal of the value of the concession in regard to carcase mutton and lamb. When I was there, the French market for lamb was sufficient to stabilise the price of carcase lamb but I do not know whether that is true any more. It is certainly true that the 1948 Agreement stipulated a period of residence of two months for Irish store cattle before they qualified for the price support. I remember when the British Government unilaterally pressed upon us an increase to three months and I think there was some trifling reduction in the differential. I was full of apprehension that this would make some vital difference to the value of store cattle, but I never could discern that it made the slightest difference at all.

The plain fact is that store cattle were never higher than they were last May and June. I am sure it is a welcome fact that the period of residence is reduced from three months to two but if you ask me, I do not think it matters a damn. I often used to ask myself how in the name of God they ever enforced this regulation. I believe it was made originally to ensure that Irish store cattle were bought by British farmers and transferred to their land, and not bought by a butcher and brought from the sales ring to the butcher's shop. It was meant to ensure that after the British farmer bought the cattle in an English sales ring they were brought to a British farm. I could never make out how they enforced that regulation. When it was three months it never made any difference and I do not believe the reduction will do so either.

I want to put this consideration to the House. Are we seriously proceeding to examine this Trade Agreement—and to consider whether we will approve or reject it—in vacuo? Because if we are, we are all cracked. This Trade Agreement is a very small item in a very large picture which constitutes the economic future and hopes of our people. If anyone imagines that the approval of this Trade Agreement will open out the broad high road to prosperity for our people, they are insane. A sword of Damocles is hanging over the heads of our people today.

"Cybernetics" is a new word that has been coined to cover the whole field of thought, at the core of which stands automation. We are a very, very, very small political and economic unit in the world. As certainly as we are in this House today cybernetics and automation are going to wipe out in the world in which we live employment for the unskilled man. In ten years' time, an unskilled man and woman in the markets of the world will be no more able to earn their living than a stray dog. That is a terrible thing to say. When I was young, I knew men and women who could neither read nor write and they were greater ladies and gentlemen, and more highly educated citizens, than hundreds of the skilled operatives who are earning £30 and £40 a week in Birmingham today but they had no skill for modern civilisation. They had the culture, the distinction and the charm of a highly civilised people. They could not survive in ten years' time.

I may survive the next ten years, but I will not survive many decades, and cybernetics will have damn little effect on me but they will affect my son and to a far greater degree if, under God's Providence, he should be blessed with a family, they will affect them, unless we provide out of our own resources, in this country, not skyscrapers with Chinese hats, not elaborate office buildings with wall to wall carpeting, not luxury flats set at £120 per week, or hotels to accommodate those who can afford to pay £50 a day, but schools and the personnel to man the schools, and the equipment to enable that personnel to spread their knowledge and impart it to the rising generation, and homes to keep the families together to correct the loathsome and detestable centrifugal tendencies of the society in which we live today which have shattered homes and scattered families. Unless we can provide the means for them to attain their health and strength and to develop their qualities, we are condemning our people not to be the hewers of wood and drawers of water — there will be no wood to be hewn and no water to be drawn—but to be the stray dogs of the world, unable to make and hold their place either at home or abroad in the world in which they have to live.

It is because I see in the Government a complete obliviousness to these facts that I am filled with apprehension when I hear of Trade Agreements being the solution to all our difficulties. I know our Ministers come in here and say: "We have approved more schools, more houses, more work of this kind than any other Government". I am not looking for the approval of plans; approvals are very easy to issue as long as you have paper and ink in the Department to issue them.

What is the use in telling the Christian Brothers in Monaghan that they have the approval of the Minister for Education to erect a new secondary school if the bank manager says: "We have not got a penny to lend you wherewith to build it"? And when they say: "You have not got a penny to lend us who have dealt with you for a hundred years, with whom we have had one thousand debts when we were poorer and our people were poorer, and never defaulted on a penny?", he answers: "We have not got it because the Government have it. Whatever we had to lend the Government have borrowed." Why do you think we have suddenly seen the sale of lumps of an Irish bank to a British consortium and the withdrawal of the Irish banks into the exclusive sphere of Irish bank circles? Ask yourself some time has it anything to do with the maintenance of the lending ratio prescribed in London as compared with the lending ratio accepted in Ireland today. We are turning our eyes away from the things that really matter. We have got an adverse trade balance for the 12 months ended 30th November of £153 million. We are going to have an adverse balance of payments this year of £50 million sterling. The banks in this country are now being required to channel all the available credit that they can mobilise into the hands of the Government who cannot meet their bills from any other source.

Let us pause here for a moment. Now is the time and this is the occasion on which to examine these fundamentals. It is all cod to be talking about the joint stock banks lending their customers money. That is all blah. The joint stock banks are the machinery devised by society for the administration of the credit of the Irish community. That is their function and the only reason it is left in the hands of the joint stock banks is that empirically in a free society we have learned that that is the best way it works. Theoretically, you can argue that they all should be made subject to the Government. Anyone who has tried that has lived to regret it. The credit of this community is being sucked off by the Government to the detriment of the essential services to which I made reference earlier on.

Some of the more foolish supporters of the Government are dazzled by the fact that the First National City Bank of New York is going to set up offices here, that the Bank of Newfoundland is going to set up offices and that the Bank of San Francisco is going to set up offices here. Go and ask the First National City Bank why. You will not have too long to wait because they are go-ahead, energetic, tough operators. They facilitate land speculation and they will facilitate anything that returns a fast "buck" and they will tell you: "If there is anything going in this way we want to share it," but I wonder if the Christian Brothers go in to borrow money for 30 years to build a school to educate poor children, will the red carpet be put out in the Bank of San Francisco for them. We will be told by the Government that there is foreign capital flowing into the country. It is flowing into the country to buy out the ground from under our feet; flowing into the country to do with gold what fire and steel failed for seven centuries to do. We used to talk about beating swords into ploughshares but there is a new modern development which we had not heard about until Fianna Fáil facilitated its discovery in this country that is beating currency into swords and achieving with gold, or even with silver, and now with promissory notes, what steel had failed to achieve before.

It is a strange, strange world in which we live if we are fated to see a generation conquered with paper and silver when hunger and starvation and fire and sword had failed to beat their fathers down. This Trade Agreement is going to destroy a great many of the mink bikini industries. I am not worried about the gentlemen wearing mink bikinis but I am worried about the people who work for them. I am proud to remember that it was at a Fine Gael Árd Fheis three years ago that we first raised this issue and said that there is no programme of economic expansion, first or second, any good to us that does not show us where provision is to be made for the redundant workmen or the man who loses his job. The boys in the mink bikinis will look after themselves—they have it salted away—but it is the men who work for them whom we must consider.

Now I am going to say something that will shock my colleagues, but they are not responsible for me any more. What maddens me is that it will bring some comfort to the Deputies who sit opposite and will enrage those sitting on my right. The fact is that one of the greatest threats afflicting this country at present is the reputation it is acquiring for labour relations. There was a recent survey made by OECD, and I know unfortunately it coincided with our transport dispute and our building dispute, but in the statistics which it threw up, it showed Ireland as having the worst labour relations in Europe. I have employed men all my life, either personally or as a Minister of State. I have dealt with the leaders of the Irish trade union movement. I have dealt with some of the toughest. The tougher they were, the easier they were to deal with. It took you time to make the agreement. Here is something a great many employers in this country forget. They had to say to you: "Do not forget we are working for the men. We are not their bosses. We think the draft agreement we have negotiated is a good one, but they have got to agree with us." Here is something vital to what I am going to say. I have known cases in which trade union men have come back to me and said: "We think this is right and you think this is right, but the men will not take it. If we go back and tell them they must take it the only result will be that we will get the sack and they will send you somebody else." Too many employers forget that. But when there comes a time that there is an agreement and it is approved and the trade unions go berserk and repudiate the agreement, it is time for labour to examine its conscience.

I am going to prescribe the remedy. I do it with full respect. There are too many trade union leaders in this country who have not taken example by me. Europe is littered with old warriors who believe themselves to be indispensable, with tragic consequences for Europe. The trade union movement of this country is getting littered with good, decent men who are living in the 19th century.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not like interrupting the Deputy but he seems to be widening the scope of the debate somewhat.

Comment on this

A Trade Agreement affecting the whole future economy of this country? This was injected into this discussion by the Leader of the Government, who said that labour relations were at the heart of the whole problem. However, I only want to make this point. I know distinguished leaders of the trade union movement who are so far living in the 19th century that, when their union wanted to give them a salary which was not a quarter of what their responsibility would entitle them to, they protested on the grounds that it was monstrously excessive compensation. The trade union had to say to them: "Go out of the room and we will fix your salary. Come back and take it. Be glad to get it and say nothing more about it."

The evil of that is this. This old-fashioned man has the idea that no man is worth more than £1,000 a year, pace a certain distinguished gentleman now in residence in another place, and not at £1,000 a year either. He gets that into his head and applies it to himself. When he has a district organiser—a man in a most responsible position, who ought to be educated, able and in a position to command and direct—he applies it to him and says “If the boss has only £1,000 a year, £600 is too much for him.” What is the result? Half the trade unions in this country are trying to live on slave labour. American trade unions and British trade unions are wakening up to it. Trade unions all over the world are recognising that their organisations must be brought up to date. The only men to do it are men who are born into this century and who understand the complications of labour relations today. It is true that a great deal of the responsibility for bad labour relations devolves on the employers of this country. But you cannot make labour relations good with trade union men who themselves are living in a century in which nobody else except themselves is living at present.

Let us not delude ourselves. This Trade Agreement is substantially what Sir Harold Woolley described it to be so far as it affects agriculture. It is going to cause a great deal of unemployment and economic dislocation. It will wipe out a lot of the mink bikini boys and wreak considerable hardship on many working men who trusted Fianna Fáil when these industries were started. This Trade Agreement and its authors are not the fount of Irish industry and never were. Irish industry— and the kind of Irish industry that is going to survive—was here before Fianna Fáil was ever thought of.

This Trade Agreement will not resolve all our problems. I have tried to indicate what it can do. As far as it preserves the precious asset of the agricultural community of this country, we could not in conscience vote against it. It is fraud to call it a free trade agreement. There is no equality because the British industrialist is free to function here on terms of equality with our industrialists but the Irish farmer is not so free to compete with the British farmer in Great Britain. No matter how this Trade Agreement turns out, it is not going to open up the highways to progress and prosperity this Government would seek to persuade us it will, unless we have a better Government than Fianna Fáil are ever likely to provide and unless the trade union movement undertakes to reform itself and to shoulder the burden consciously of educating Victorian employers in this country into a realisation that they must bring themselves up to date.

Comment on this

I have been listening to the negative approach of Opposition speakers to this debate for the past few days. Apparently, they do not want any agreement at all. They are not concerned with the workers of this country or our survival as a nation. I listened to Deputy Dillon, the man who had such little faith in Irish industry and who would not be seen dead in a field of wheat or beet.

Comment on this

Just as the British market is gone forever. There is very little wheat or beet being grown now.

Comment on this

That was the attitude. The people who are criticising us for——

Comment on this

——selling the country to Britain——

Comment on this

——selling the country to Britain, and all their other allegations, are the very people who sold our transatlantic jets when we had an opportunity of developing that project. Furthermore, while they were in office from 1948 to 1951 and from 1954 to 1957, they permitted the importation of goods with a view to reducing the cost of living, so much so that I had to send telegrams to the then Minister for Industry and Commerce asking if he was dumping British goods on the Irish market and pointing out the plight of hundreds of workers who became unemployed in Lucan and in other parts of County Dublin.

Comment on this

You will keep the Post Office busy, so.

Comment on this

I shall sit down and listen patiently to Deputy L'Estrange if he will make a speech. He is like a corncrake squeaking there all the morning. These people tell us they are interested in the Irish worker and in what the Irish worker stands for. When the Irish workers had to leave this country in their hundreds in 1956 and 1957——

Comment on this

They are going in their thousands now.

Comment on this

——and when this country was at its lowest ebb, the then Government, instead of trying to do something or to bring about an agreement to save our workers, left this nation with an unbalanced Budget and cleared out. It irks me to have to listen to the rot I have been listening to from some Deputies opposite for the past three days. Our Taoiseach was the first man to raise the standard of living of our workers by his industrial policy when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. He created employment for our workers and is responsible for the better conditions they enjoy today. We are suffering from a recession at the moment but it is a fact that while the Taoiseach was Minister for Industry and Commerce he succeeded in doing more to uplift the Irish worker than any workers' leader ever did.

Comment on this

What about the late James Larkin?

Comment on this

We heard some Labour Deputies speak yesterday and the day before that. They try to give the impression that nobody is concerned at all with our workers, good, bad or indifferent, except the workers' representatives. We are a Party concerned with the well-being of every section of our people, irrespective of class or creed, and we owe no apology to anybody for it. We will not sabotage the interest of the Irish people and sell them down the Swanee for any Agreement. For at least the past 22 years, I have been concerned to protect the interests of our workers and of our people as a whole. If, by any chance, especially in the motor trade, there is redundancy, I, as a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, shall strive with my other Parliamentary colleagues in the county to secure that alternative employment will be given to the people involved or at least that compensation worthy of their years of service will be given to them.

No Bill ever went through this House that was perfect. We have had to amend Bills time out of number. If, in the course of time, we find that the terms of this Agreement are not what we anticipated, not one of us will stand for anything except what we believe to be in the interest of our people. This is 1966, not 1920 or 1922. We were anxious to get into the Common Market and were disappointed that our application did not succeed. There is a different outlook in the world today. Nations are trying to co-operate with each other. Six countries in Europe have succeeded in coming together in the common interest. That is a new political and economic trend in the world. If we do not wish to accept these trends in Europe is it our desire to be left isolated?

Last night, I listened to Deputy O'Connell speak for one hour and during all that time he made no constructive criticism in relation to the Agreement. Every country is anxious to have a Trade Agreement. I do not want to mention the names of the countries but it is a fact that all the countries want to trade with one another and it is the ordinary civilised practice in the world today. However, to judge by what we heard yesterday evening, one would think that nobody in this country was concerned about anybody except the saviours of the workers over there. Then we heard Deputy Dillon tell us today what he would do. He spoke about the poor farmers of Ireland and the poor workers of Ireland and the workers in ten years' time and what will become of them. We have tried to educate our people and we are spending money to that end. I assure the House that if this nation could afford it I would agree to the expenditure of three times as much money on the education of our people and on fitting them to face the world.

Comment on this

There is not the price of a bag of cement now.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy think that up himself?

Comment on this

Is the corncrake at it again?

Comment on this

For Deputy Foley's benefit, Deputy L'Estrange did not get it from anybody.

Comment on this

Steady up there, lad.

Comment on this

Some very flowery speeches were made and they were all speeches consisting of destructive criticism. There was nothing constructive about them: we were selling out to Britain, we were doing this, that and the other. I would ask the Deputies who criticised the Government in relation to this Agreement if they want Ireland to be cut adrift economically from every other country.

Comment on this

No—Fianna Fáil wanted that for 30 years.

Comment on this

It would seem that Fine Gael and Labour wanted to achieve the complete isolation of this country when they sold our transatlantic jets. I know the policies of both of those Parties because they are against the national interest.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

What about Deputy Aiken?

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Deputy O'Connell last night, although it is true that I thought he might have sent a telegram at the time the conference was proceeding: it would have been a great help had he done so.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

We are up against dishonest criticism. Fianna Fáil will always put the interest of this nation before anything else. That is what we have done and what we shall continue to do. In 1955, 1956 and 1957 there was no such thing as an effort to bring about a Trade Agreement when the trade balances were on the wrong side, as they are now, too, and I am not denying it.

Comment on this

They are £50 million worse now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange has no licence to interrupt every Deputy who gets up to speak.

Comment on this

The leaders of the Fianna Fáil Party have done their very best to bring about a situation whereby our adverse balance of payments position will be rectified. Even if our balance of payments position continues on the wrong side, the speeches of hypocrisy made on the other side of the House will be of very little good to the man in the streets of Dublin, of County Dublin, or even of the towns in every other Deputy's constituency.

We must consider what are the best improvements we can bring about. What are the best means we can consider, from the national point of view, to bring about a proper balance of payments and not an adverse one such as we have at the present time and such as we had in 1955, 1956 and 1957? We know it took us about four years to get it back in 1957, when there was hardly a bob stirring when we took office. It took us until about 1960 to get things any way reasonable at all and we do not want that to occur again.

If there was one Deputy, even Deputy Dillon—who I admit is a wonderful orator and can speak with dramatic effect—who made one constructive contribution to this debate, I would have said "hear, hear" but, unfortunately, it was all idle criticism. It is easy enough to criticise and be destructive about it; it is easy enough to say somebody has done something he should not have done, and criticise him for it, but it is another thing to advance some alternative for the benefit of the Irish people whom we represent here in this sovereign Parliament. From that point of view, it was a completely negative approach from the word "go". None of us says it is a be-all and end-all Agreement. No Agreement can be perfect; there is nothing perfect in this world. We are not supernatural beings who can produce perfection. Human beings may err unwittingly but, at least, they will make amends afterwards.

If this Agreement about which there is so much talk is not to our satisfaction, it is not beyond the bounds of possibility that we may go along and ask for amendments. That is only natural and every country in the world has done it. Britain came along, while we were doing reasonably well on the British market, and imposed a 15 per cent levy on us and other countries because of her economic situation——

Comment on this

And she would again.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy O'Hara, but, if she can do that and if we are in the same free position here as a free country able to do anything we think for the benefit of our people, we should be able to do likewise. As the Agreement stands, what I have read about it and even taking into account the criticism I have heard of it, I believe it a very good one. If, in the course of five or six years time, we enter into the Common Market, it is still a very good thing to have secured this Agreement with our nearest neighbour because, had we been accepted for membership of the Common Market a few years ago, we would have had to do these things.

We have industries which are able to sell to all countries throughout the world. Some of those are industries which were started only a few years ago. There are industries in my constituency, which is also Deputy Clinton's and Deputy Foley's constituency, exporting all over the world and competing internationally.

Deputy Dillon spoke about the Act of Union. What brought about the Act of Union was the jealousy of the then British Prime Minister and Government. They were jealous of the position which existed here, even with their own people within the Parliament of the day, because Irish industrialists were competing internationally and beating British products all over the world. I have enough faith in the Irish people to know that, even in adversity, they were always all right.

I remember listening to my grandfather relating a story about the position during the Famine when they were refused food in the West of Ireland, from where I came. Evidently when an English Protestant came along and was distributing Indian corn, he told my grandfather's mother she could not have it unless she changed her religion. She went home and the family started eating raw turnips before she could boil them. That generation survived such adversity. I have sufficient faith in our Irish industrialists and workers to realise that, given a chance here, we could become the greatest country in Europe.

We are up against one problem at the moment, that is, that our trade balance is on the wrong side and we have taken steps to rectify this situation. If it is a mortal sin, according to the Labour and Fine Gael people, if it is wrong for our Government to try to rectify our adverse trade balance, then I plead guilty, but I plead guilty on behalf of the Irish people. One thing concerns me here and it is this. Will the Deputies consider seriously the position of this nation, or are they more concerned with political kudos for their own Party? It is a serious position that while dealing with an Agreement of this kind, people get up here to make cheap jibes. I was never concerned during my time in this House with making cheap jibes or attacking anybody personally. I never believed in it. This practice of making cheap jibes in all the speeches from one side of the House to the other amounted to one thing: "We do not want anything; we do not want an Agreement; we do not want aeroplanes; we do not want airlines; we do not want any coalmines; we are able to look after the Irish workers and we do not want anybody else to come in."

Prior to the 1948 election, when we were trying to encourage the tourist industry to help us with our balance of payments at that time, a member of the Labour Party told us we were creating white elephants in that we were encouraging foreigners to come in here and eat the food we should give to our own workers. We were defeated in 1948 and, of course, the misrepresentation was shocking during that period when the other Parties told a lot of untruths and when their propaganda machinery was extra good. One of the men concerned became a Minister and went down to open Butlin's Camp. Butlin's Camp had already been under way when the inter-Party Government came into office. The man who made the statement in the benches here went down to Butlin's as Minister, opened the camp and said the tourist industry was wonderful, that it was worth £27 million to the country at that time. Two months earlier he did not want foreigners in here eating our food. How can one expect progress when people say——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is getting away from the Trade Agreement.

Comment on this

I crave your indulgence; I am replying to criticism made about the Trade Agreement and discussing the inconsistencies of the Opposition. If they discussed the Agreement and said they did not believe in this part or in that, that they could have done better here or there, I would clap them on the back. I would almost award them medals because that would be something new —to get constructive criticism.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy plenty of medals?

Comment on this

I shall give you one when I get one. I do not want to delay the House and on some other occasion I shall give the exact quotation of a previous Minister for Industry and Commerce on his attitude towards the unemployed. Deputy Dillon spoke about labour relations but nobody went as far to meet the workers of this country and establish good employer-labour relations than the present Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I have been associated with labour relations for nearly 30 years. Sometimes we succeed and sometimes we fail. I was associated with the introduction of the Industrial Relations Act and anxious that it should ensure as much freedom of negotiation as possible so that the workers and employers could meet and evolve good relations gradually. One cannot expect miracles overnight. It is only natural when the standard of living is going up that John Jones will want as much money as Paddy Murphy. That applies all over the world. While statistics may be true, sometimes facts are different. The good relationship that exists between the trade unions and many employers is something to be proud of. In certain areas relations between workers and employers are bad but the responsibility is not all on the one side. In my dealings with people for a long number of years, I have discovered that it takes two to make a row. It is the present Taoiseach who laid the foundations for the development of good industrial relations as Minister for Industry and Commerce. When disputes arose, he even intervened himself or, later, got his Ministers or Deputies to do so. Deputy Dillon, it seems, was going to be the saviour of industrial relations. He is entitled to his opinions; I would die to defend his right to say anything he likes. That is democracy. I can criticise him and that is also democracy.

We are not anti-anybody. We are national, first, last and all the time. We are only concerned to do anything we can in our time to better the position of our people. We may have another opportunity of going into the details of this Agreement and should any hardship arise as a result of it for the people I have the honour to represent in County Dublin, I shall stand up here to defend them. That is what I am here for and that is why the people have trusted me for so long. We are doing what we believe to be the right thing, notwithstanding the pressure groups that have come to us concerned about their own petty affairs, underestimating the intelligence of the people they approach and thinking that we are not concerned with anything but our own political views. This is our own country and anything we can do to make it better will be done.

This is a good Agreement. It is an Agreement that is going on for quite a long time——

Comment on this

Since 1948.

Comment on this

Anything that has been done by the Taoiseach and his Ministers has been done on behalf of the Irish people and any possible gains have been secured so that we may have a better nation in the future and so that we may successfully deal with a very vital problem and one that is of vital concern to Britain also, the problem of the balance of payments.

Comment on this

I have sat through most of this debate and listened to the various speakers and I have no doubt whatever now that the Fine Gael attitude to this Agreement is both logical and realistic. As a Party who always recognised the economic interdependence of the United Kingdom and this country, we decided not to vote against the Agreement, but, as a responsible Opposition Party, we deemed it our duty to examine the Agreement in detail and make a critical appraisal of it. It is regrettable that the Taoiseach and his Ministers have endeavoured to mislead the people into believing that the Agreement is the most wonderful thing that has ever happened and that as a result of it all our economic social problems will vanish almost overnight. This type of batantly dishonest propaganda will serve no useful purpose.

I think the television interview given by the Minister for Agriculture on his return from London was the worst possible thing that could have happened because now that the Agreement has been discussed in detail, the original assessment of it by the Minister for Agriculture has been proved to be completely exaggerated. The Minister, deliberately or otherwise, tried to convey the impression that this Agreement means unrestricted entry for all our agricultural exports and a great increase in prosperity. Of course, we now know that that is not the case at all.

Looking at the actual details of the Agreement, particularly those which, perhaps, affect my constituency, we find that it offers no security of access to the United Kingdom for agricultural products, other than store cattle and lambs. In so far as bacon is concerned, the position remains unaltered. In so far as the dairying industry is concerned, which is the most important arm of our agricultural industry, the concessions gained are very small indeed. We find that the British Government have undertaken to increase the quota for Irish butter from 12,900 tons to 23,000 tons. In fact, in 1965, we exported approximately 19,000 tons of butter to Britain, so the net effect of this new Agreement will be to increase our exports of butter to Britain by approximately 4,000 tons.

I observe from paragraph 45, page 20, of the Government publication on the Free Trade Area Agreement that this quota is for the year 1966-67. It does not mean that the quota of 23,000 tons will operate for an indefinite period. It means just for one year. So that the uncertainty which has always surrounded the export market for butter in the United Kingdom still remains. It is stated in paragraph 45:

If imports of butter into Britain continue to be subject to quantitative restriction in subsequent years, there will be annual consultations between the two Governments and the British Government will aim to provide reasonable opportunity for growth in the new basic quota and to take into account the Irish plans for increased output of dairy produce under the Second Programme.

That is all very vague and gives rise to further uncertainty regarding the future of our butter exports to Britain.

It is stated in paragraph 46 that the British Government will hold prior consultations with the Irish Government for the purpose of reaching agreement on the character and substance of any such arrangement. The paragraph goes on to say:

This will have to provide opportunity for imports into Britain no less favourable than those under the existing arrangements.

I cannot understand why, instead of being developed into two full paragraphs, there was not a simple statement to the effect that a quota of a minimum of 23,000 tons over the next five years would be accepted. If that had been done, it would have been a step in the right direction.

When the concession in respect of butter is analysed against the background of the recent developments in the dairying industry, it is quickly realised that this concession will not have any very big effect on the dairying industry. All the emphasis in the dairying industry, all the talk about rationalisation of the creamery industry, has been aimed at diversifying milk into products other than butter. This increase of 4,000 tons in the quota for next year will not put one penny into the pockets of the dairy farmers and will not provide employment for one more worker in the dairying industry. As representing a constituency where the main industry is dairying, I want to express my disappointment in so far as this Agreement relates to that industry.

The reduction in the waiting period for store cattle from three months to two months will make very little difference and is not of very great advantage. As has been shown, when the period was increased on a former occasion from two months to three months, it did not alter the situation very much.

In so far as agriculture is concerned, this new Agreement does not contain any revolutionary proposals. It will not release any new dynamic leading to a new era of expansion in our major national industry. As has been mentioned by other speakers, Sir Harold Woolley, of the British Farmers Union, correctly summed up this Agreement when he said that it merely confirms our existing arrangement and, perhaps, effects some minor improvement.

In so far as the industrial implications are concerned, the Minister for Industry and Commerce said yesterday that it was not possible at the moment to state with any degree of certainty what industries would expand and what industries would be adversely affected. Until such time as proper examination has been made of our various industries, it is difficult to estimate the effects of this Agreement on our industrial arm with any degree of accuracy.

What is most important now and what is most urgent is that no time should be lost in introducing whatever measures may be necessary to offset the disadvantages to our industry which may come from the freeing of trade. In particular, we have to make sure that safeguards will be introduced against dumping and that provision will be made for redundancy and to enable our industries to gear themselves for greater competition—all those measures which were suggested by the Leader of this Party, Deputy Cosgrave, on Tuesday, such as tax concessions, and so on, which will enable our industrialists to accept and to tackle this new challenge of competition.

This debate has been marked by gross exaggeration on the part of the Government and Fianna Fáil speakers and exaggeration in the other extreme on the part of some speakers from the Labour Party. Quite honestly, I do not think this Agreement will open up a new era of expansion. Neither do I think that this Agreement will lead to mass unemployment and emigration. In fact, I think that if the Agreement is approached objectively, it will be found that there are certain minor advantages for us in it; I am of the opinion that the advantages are outweighed by the disadvantages. In the interests of national unity, however, the Fine Gael Party will not vote against the Agreement. Indeed, it behoves all Parties in the House to pull together to make the best maximum use of whatever advantages the Agreement may have in order to offset the disadvantages.

Comment on this

I intend breaking with the debating traditions of this House by being brief.

Comment on this

On a point of order, are the Labour Party not being considered for a further speaker?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I should like to point out to the Deputy that the Labour Party are certainly being considered and they have had a bigger proportion of both speakers and time so far than any other Party. For that reason I am now calling on the main Party whose contributions have not been in the same proportion as those of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

I am not challenging the action of the Chair, but I just want to make it clear for the record that the Labour Party are the main opposition to this and the Party have been passed over twice. Fine Gael speakers have been called twice in preference to a Labour Deputy. I have nothing against Deputy Andrews.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I might point out to the Deputy that eight Labour Deputies have intervened in the debate, ten Fianna Fáil and ten Fine Gael. I cannot see how Labour can complain.

Comment on this

They are a separate Party and they are entitled to a separate voice—eight against ten.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They have had a higher proportion of speakers so far than any other Party.

Comment on this

Proportions do not count.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They do, and the time factor has also to be considered.

Comment on this

We will have to take the matter up elsewhere. I have no objection to Deputy Andrews and I am sorry for interrupting him.

Comment on this

As I said, I intend breaking with the debating traditions of the House by being brief. In that context I should like to pay tribute to Deputy Mrs. Desmond. I thought her speech succinct and pithy and to the point. I do not agree with what she said, but I liked the way she said it.

The Labour Party amendment comes as no great surprise to me, with all its vagueness and generalisations. The Government would, of course, prefer to get better terms than they have got in this Agreement for agriculture, and still better terms for industry. Remember, however, that there are two sides to every bargain and, in all the circumstances, the Agreement has done very well for our country. Incidentally, it is worth nothing that Labour in our country show very little solidarity with their British counterparts in their assessment of the present Pact.

Before this Agreement was finally concluded, many people, including Republicans and Republicans of the Old Guard, feared we were selling out on our national identity and that our independence would be in some way compromised. They feared this House would become something resembling a provincial parliament rather than a sovereign assembly. It is quite clear now from the Agreement that these fears are totally unfounded. This is a reasonable business deal. No business deal is of any value unless both sides to the bargain get something out of it. An Opposition Deputy mentioned that any international agreement involves a lessening of the liberty of the countries concerned. May I suggest to the Deputy that he is confusing liberty with licence. Parties to an agreement have the liberty to negotiate an agreement that gives them the licence to deal with one another in a particular manner. That, I think, is the point the Deputy missed.

There are tremendous tasks facing our country at this juncture and, in my view, the Labour Party could make a useful and substantial contribution in helping to bring these tasks to a successful conclusion if, instead of tabling this type of amendment, they applied their minds, in the light of their professed philosophy, as inheritors of the traditions and teaching of the great James Connolly, to a critical examination of the way in which we on this side of the House are carrying out our tasks. We, in Fianna Fáil, are the inheritors of the republican tradition. What does the Labour Party inherit? Right now it is becoming more and more difficult for anyone to answer that question.

Another very important aspect of this Agreement, and in relation to future agreements, is the present condition of our industrial relations. Why can the Labour Party, whose clear function it is, not devote themselves to some solution of the trade union problem in this country? Nobody believes that these unions act through malice; they are the inheritors of out-of-date practices, out of date laws. I believe deeply in unions, but they must be responsible unions. Could the Labour Party not devise some parliamentary measure to remedy the present situation? Could they not propose to the Government that, if necessary, the Constitution should be amended to enable just one union in State or semi-State bodies instead of the multiplicity of unions that we have at present which, by their very multiplicity, cause nothing but confusion? I have said they are not motivated by malice—they are the victims of circumstances.

Now, if the Labour Party do not want to go as far as I have suggested, could they not propose legislation to remedy what is becoming an intolerable and disastrous situation? Do they, or anybody else, think we can avail of whatever advantages there are in this Agreement by fostering the miserable reputation we have among the other nations of the world as a nation of strikers? How can we hope to attract foreign capital to our country while the present situation continues?

I should like the House to accept the latter part of my contribution in a spirit of constructive rather than destructive criticism. I am making a plea for all-round co-operation. Such co-operation will make it much easier for the Government to take whatever rational actions are necessary. The assurance of such co-operation from all sectors, but more particularly from the Labour Party, will ensure the success of this Agreement. Indeed, it would be an excellent thing if special actions could be taken as a result of initiative on the part of the Labour Party.

One finds it difficult to analyse the Fine Gael attitude. They have condemned the Agreement out of hand. Simultaneously they have indicated that they are willing to vote for it. It is difficult to rationalise their point of view. This much, at least, can be said for the Labour Party; they have come out clearly against the Agreement.

As one of the so-called younger generation in political life, this Agreement represents to me a great and substantial challenge to our country leading to ultimate entry into Europe. Are we to be excluded in the future from any share in a market of 180 million people? These are the figures in the last census in 1963 for the EEC group. Are we to be excluded from the EFTA market of many more millions? Is Ireland to remain in isolation outside Europe? The answer to these questions is clear.

The Agreement has also another very important function in that it allows us time in which to test the efficiency of both our industrial and our agricultural sectors. Indeed, it allows us time to make these sectors more efficient. In the last analysis it will test our capacity for hard work within the present limited market, before we finally enter into the greater entity.

There is one matter to which I should like to draw the attention of the Minister for Industry and Commerce in relation to Article XV of the Agreement. This Article deals with restrictive trade practices. In this respect I am rather concerned that with the gradual reduction in Irish tariffs, larger British manufacturing plants with their bigger production capacity and with the attendant lower cost unit of manufacture may overshadow and curtail their Irish subsidiaries. In the constituency which I represent there are a number of firms whose backs may go to the wall. I do not suggest that they will become defunct but I should like the Minister and his civil servants to keep this matter under constant review.

It has already been stated that the officials who drafted this Agreement did a first-class job. I agree with this point of view. Finally, in keeping with what I have said in relation to brevity, I should like to say how pleased I am at the prolongation of this debate. There was a lot of public criticism on the Prices Bill that back bench Deputies did not speak. This extended debate, however, has performed a valuable function in that it has enabled us to express our point of view.

Comment on this

The two previous Fianna Fáil speakers, Deputy Burke and Deputy Andrews, have dealt with the present labour unrest in the country, and Deputy Burke, in particular, showered praise and blessings on the Taoiseach for the great part played by him in the promotion of labour relations. I should like to remind the House that the Taoiseach has done more in his time to jeopardise labour relations and to promote labour unrest than any other person by virtue of the policies which he and his Government have pursued. I need not go as far back as the wages standstill orders, the White Papers and the various other proposals by the Fianna Fáil Government to control wages. We in the Labour Party, three or four years ago, forecast this position, this unrest which would come about as a result of policies pursued by the Government at that time. In regard to the introduction of the turnover tax, for instance, every speaker from these benches said at that time that that would lead to large-scale labour unrest as a result of a steep rise in the cost of living. We told them then and we repeat here today that those policies are the chief cause of the present unsatisfactory position.

That labour unrest exists also because people cannot be guaranteed constant and continued employment. If they are in employment and they cannot be guaranteed that employment for any period of time, they are inclined to get as much out of it as they can while they are working in order to save up for days of unemployment or in order to save up for the emigrant ship to take their wives and families across to England. The workers are also in a state of unrest if they cannot look forward to an adequate pension or adequate benefits while out ill. Those are the primary causes of labour unrest. If they cannot provide adequately for the future, and indeed for the present, there will be, as there is at the moment, labour unrest.

It is the duty of the Government to put these things right. This country enjoyed comparative quietness on the labour front up to a few years ago when the spark was set off. The turnover tax was the spark which led to this state of affairs over the last number of years. It is now incumbent on the Government to initiate policies which will put these things right.

We have now almost completed the third day of this debate. Like Deputy Andrews, I am pleased that the debate should go on this length of time. The Agreement before the House requires detailed and close examination and criticism, especially when we consider the reasons for its introduction. It is a panic measure taken by the Government to get out of the difficulties in which they found themselves earlier in the year. Therefore, it requires very careful and critical examination. It has been quite definitely established by speakers from every side of the House that the Agreement will lead to unemployment. There are some safeguards against unemployment in the Agreement but we on this side of the House feel they are too few and totally inadequate. I believe also that were it not for the action of the Labour Party in speaking against this Agreement before it was signed, even these few small safeguards would not have been embodied in the Agreement.

It would help us in the consideration of this Agreement if we had fuller details of the manpower policy. We have just a broad outline of what is proposed and in this debate that leaves us at a disadvantage because we need more detailed knowledge of the proposals.

The unemployment which will inevitably be caused by the Agreement will be of a gradual nature. That kind of unemployment is more deadly than sudden large-scale unemployment. There could be a gradual process in which three men are let off this month, three more in six months, half a dozen six months afterwards—a kind of creeping unemployment which is more dangerous because when it is happening, it is too small to take action about but when, at the end of a period, it is found that 200 or 300 men have lost their jobs, it is too late to do anything about it.

The proposals in regard to manpower have, like this Agreement, been made in a hurry by the Government. That is another reason why there will need to be very careful examination of the proposals when submitted. In my opinion, the Government were depending on getting into the EEC and having available to them the fund in that Community provided to deal with manpower troubles. Having found they could not get into the EEC for the time being and that therefore this fund would not be available to them, they had to take hurried action to create a manpower authority to deal with the problem of unemployment and consequent emigration.

There has been gradual rationalisation of industry within the country but in the future we can expect British industry to figure in the rationalisation process. One example would be the flour milling industry. We had quite a number of small mills closing down and production being concentrated in the bigger mills. Rationalisation of that industry within the Agreement might mean that smaller units would close down or be gradually taken over in take-over bids even to the extent of their ultimate absorption in bigger units of the industry in Britain. That is the kind of rationalisation I fear. Is there anything in the Agreement at all to stop the drift of agricultural labourers from the land? If we could only prevent this drain, we would be accomplishing something but I am afraid the Agreement will serve only to accelerate the flight of agricultural labourers.

We oppose this Agreement because we feel the Government have not created the environment necessary for free trade. All we have here is an environment for protected trade. The environment necessary for free trade does not mean only modern factories and working conditions. It means a lot more than that. I give the Government credit for the various inducements they have offered to industrialists to gear themselves for freer trade by way of technical assistance, adaptation grants, tax remissions and other benefits, including the Design Centre at Kilkenny. Unfortunately, I fear our industrialists have yet to be educated to avail themselves of all the inducements the Government have offered. I have spoken to quite a number of major industrialists throughout the country about the Kilkenny Design Centre and the cynical opinion of many of them on this project surprised me. I urge the Government to point out to such people the importance of such a centre. It can be of incalculable benefit to our own distinctive design of our own goods. Our workers can produce the goods and this centre can produce the designs but we must get our industrialists to avail of the service.

While these measures ought to go a long way in creating an environment for free trade, they do not go far enough. There is a particular sphere which has not been considered by the Government. I pose the question of how a worker is supposed to give of his best if he is compelled, with his wife and family, to live in one or two rooms in an attic, to prepare meals there, to eat there, sleep there and live there. How can he give of his best in his working hours? How can he produce as much as a worker in England, who has probably a modern home and adequate housing facilities? How can a worker, who has to live in a condemned house, give as much in his work as a worker who has the fortune to have adequate housing facilities? The Government must tackle this problem of housing immediately. It will more especially be felt if the manpower policy is all we hope it will be. Housing will be a big factor in the administration of that policy.

The same can be said in regard to the health services. How can a worker who is not adequately provided for in regard to health services give of his best as against a worker in Great Britain who has adequate facilities and a good health scheme? Only last week a worker came to me and complained that he had been out sick. He was a key man in the factory in which he worked. He got flu and he was out from work for a number of weeks. He had a medical card and he went to his doctor. The doctor gave him a bottle of something which the man told me was coloured water—I do not know very much about that. He was out for nearly two weeks taking this bottle and he had to go to a private doctor then. The private doctor prescribed a very expensive drug for him which he had to buy. That expensive drug cured him overnight and he was back at work the next day.

I do not blame the dispensary doctors. Those people are forced to keep prices down and not to have expensive medicines in their clinics. They must get the cheapest kind of medicine and anything will do. The whole thing is to keep down the cost of the health services. There are to be no expensive drugs and no expensive medicines. If we want to prepare our workers for freer trade and to compete on a level with workers in Great Britain, we must provide good and adequate health services and give them all the treatment, specialist if necessary, they require, not alone for themselves but for their families.

The same can be said of the field of education. The argument for improvement in education is quite obvious here. Our producers in this country, the workers who will produce the wealth of this country, must have adequate facilities to improve themselves. Here again is where the manpower authority will be tripped up if this facility is not provided. There are long waiting lists in schools of technology and even the rural vocational schools find it hard to accommodate all the pupils who are coming to them. The Government, under those three headings of housing, health and education, must provide immediate and effective remedies. I feel that if we had this environment in this country, we could confidently face the hazards of this Agreement but because we have not the environment, and the Government have neglected to create that environment, we are opposing this Agreement.

Comment on this

I shall be very brief on this matter but as a new Deputy, I should like to say that I was astounded by the attitude of the Fine Gael Party to this Agreement. They have come in here and have spoken during the last two days on this Agreement. They have all described the Agreement as something evil but even so they are quite prepared to compromise with evil by voting for it. The Labour Party were perhaps much more honest about it. They made it clear they had not enough time to study the agreement. I would say their speeches have borne that out. At the same time, they were a bit more direct about this. They were against this and they were going to vote against it. It almost seems there is some filibustering on the part of Fine Gael to drag out this debate as if they changed their minds after having seen the action of the Labour Party.

There is just one other matter I want to refer to on the Fine Gael attitude, that is, some magic figures which have been mentioned. One man shouts 1922 and another says 1948 and then Deputy L'Estrange says "hear, hear". That is the total contribution. We know and every serious-minded member knows that the winds of change have been blowing almost at gale force, and unless we want to go on always regarding ourselves as the poor relation of Europe, we have got to stand on our own two feet and put things in order as the Taoiseach has planned. We have been hearing the Jeremiahs wailing that many workers will lose their jobs but here is a man, the architect of our industrial revival, who planned since 1932 that we should have a strong industrial arm to the economy, despite the opposition, very often, of Fine Gael. I made a resolution not to go back any further——

Comment on this

It would be advisable not to.

Comment on this

——but I hold the Fine Gael record up for consideration. Deputy Harte says it is advisable not to. I am tempted now to refer to one thing, that is that when Seán Lemass tried to establish a good air service for the State, the Fine Gael Government knocked it down. I knew a man who worked in the airlines. He did not want much from life but just to live here and rear his family. As a result of their action, he was forced to emigrate and his bones now lie in Pakistan. This was done through the conniving of the Labour Party. I will not go back any further because it is tomorrow we have got to pin our hopes on and to think of. We have got to think of the youth of this country. We do not regard our youth as being in any way inferior to British youth, Swedish youth or Danish youth because we believe, under the leadership of Seán Lemass, we can build this country up so that we can go in and become as great as Denmark, a much smaller country than we are, or Holland. We have to try to get Fine Gael and the Labour Party to throw off this terrible inferiority complex that we Irish are doomed and that our workers are doomed because we cannot stand up to competition.

The last Labour Party Deputy who spoke said the English workers had the advantage because they were so much better housed. Does he realise what he was saying? Does he realise the gigantic problem of housing they have in England? He said the man in England was better able to work because he was better housed. Their housing situation is no better than ours. It is probably very much worse.

Comment on this

They have an increasing population but we have a decreasing one.

Comment on this

We also have an increasing population. The Deputy does not need to take my word on this. He can get the official statistics. It has been said that the Taoiseach threw this suddenly on us, that it was kept secret and all that kind of thing. If they take the trouble to read any of the speeches made before this Agreement, they will find the Taoiseach warned us we could not go on for ever sheltering behind tariff walls and that we had got to face the cold winds of reality, go out there and build our country the same as anyone else. He offered at one time to pay the cost—the offer is still open— to any firm who wanted to have an investigation of its costings. The Government would pay part of this expense. Adaptation grants are available. The Institute for Industrial Research is there for firms who want to have their goods tested. These are the things the Taoiseach and the Fianna Fáil Government have brought into being. They have given back faith to the people.

I believe in this Agreement. It does not give everything, but no Agreement could give everything. This Agreement paves the way for us to go into Europe. Everyone knows we are going into Europe. About 200 years ago, John Donne said "No man is an island," and a political entity cannot remain as an island. Even the United States dropped their isolationist policy long ago because they knew the world had shrunk and that we have to live together. We must build up our economy to keep our people at home, and stupid suggestions that the Fianna Fáil Government have signed an Agreement which means mass emigration are absolutely ridiculous when regard is had to the record of the Government.

When this Agreement comes into operation, there will be difficulties, but it is the task of the Government to see that no worker is displaced because of it. We in Fianna Fáil believe that the State has a duty to make sure that no man will suffer. The whole resources of the State must be availed of to ensure that not by any action of the Fianna Fáil Government will one man be forced to emigrate. The Agreement also applies to education because, if we are to meet the challenge of Europe, we must ensure that our artisans are as well trained, at least, as their counterparts. I hope that in the next Budget there will be a lot more money for vocational education.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

The suggestion which has been made that this will lead to mass closure of existing industries is absolute piffle. The Taoiseach has said that no existing industry, no matter how small or inefficient it may now seem to be, will be written off before in each case the possibility of its reorganisation has been examined. The fears of many workers are being played on by Opposition speakers and by outside pressure groups who have been holding meetings, circulating pamphlets, and coming to the House to interview us and point out the terrible thing that will happen because of this Agreement. I met one pressure group last night and I asked them had they read the Agreement. They admitted that they had not read it. It is not a very easy Agreement to digest at one go but if these people were sincere, they would at least take the trouble to read it.

Most speakers have mentioned the great need there is for an improvement in industrial relations. I am at one with Deputy Cosgrave in this regard, and with Deputy Andrews and other speakers who mentioned it, because we can no longer afford the luxury of having the worst industrial relations in the world. Labour speakers blamed this on the Government, but it is a fact that in recent times there have been several big strikes, not against the Government, whatever Government were in office, but against the trade union authority. One of our biggest transport strikes had nothing to do with the Government. It was against the trade union movement and it resulted in the formation of a breakaway union. It was a row amongst the unions. I am not gloating over this fact, but if we are to have proper industrial relations, we must examine the cause. I am glad to see that even in the past few days, black as they looked, the trade union movement have realised that there must be an improvement in our industrial relations.

Comment on this

Tell us about it. What would you do? What is your answer?

Comment on this

I am trying to give the answer.

Comment on this

I am waiting for it.

Comment on this

Legislate, is the answer.

Comment on this

I will quote Deputy Cosgrave who said we should sink our sectional interests and think of the common good.

Comment on this

When Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil join together, we will expand.

Comment on this

You join with them.

Comment on this

You are quoting Deputy Cosgrave. Who else are you quoting?

Comment on this

Harold Wilson.

Comment on this

Brother Harold Wilson.

Comment on this

Comrade Harold Wilson.

Comment on this

Education will play a bigger part in our developing economy, and as I said before, I hope that in the next Budget we will see——

Comment on this

The turnover tax increased.

Comment on this

——ample accommodation made for big expenditure on vocational education and the public library service. Unless we get the know-how for our young apprentices and tradesmen, we cannot face the future and compete with European nations. Our craftsmen must be at least as good as their counterparts in the other nations. About two years ago, there was an international conference of trade apprentices and the Irish boys did very well indeed in the more traditional lines, such as bricklaying and carpentry, but we noticed that the Japanese and Germans were better equipped than our boys in the more mechanical lines.

Deputy Cosgrave mentioned the great need for industrial development to be given a very high priority in town planning legislation. In parts of the country it is very frustrating because when industrialists want to establish a factory, they find objection at local level and the factory is held up. Very often they go elsewhere. This may sound as if it is a small point but it is terribly important. When this Agreement comes into operation, we will have an all-out drive to put this country on a level with its European counterparts, and I believe that under the leadership of the Taoiseach, we will accomplish this.

Comment on this

I listened with great interest to Deputy Moore. I do not like to take up something a Deputy said and throw it back in his face when he has not an opportunity of denying it. Deputy Moore apparently is of the opinion that most Opposition Deputies who have spoken have not taken the time to read this Agreement and the views of outside authorities as well. If he were on this side of the House listening to some of the speeches, not alone of the backbenchers of the Fianna Fáil Party but even of Ministers, he would be more convinced that they did not take time to read it. Even the Minister for Finance was asked questions this morning about certain detailed matters affecting the Agreement and he could not answer them. I do not wish to reflect on the integrity of the Minister for Finance and I feel it is only right that I should say that the most constructive and detailed speech made from the Government benches was made by the Minister for Finance and the only Minister who dealt with the Agreement and with the Agreement only was the Minister for Finance. Even the Taoiseach went rambling from EFTA to EEC and he never at any stage discussed in detail the Agreement which this House has been discussing for the past three days.

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this

Read his speech.

Comment on this

I listened to him.

Comment on this