We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.

Contributions 133–286 of 425. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

I was listening to him as well and I was paying attention to the expressions on the face of Fianna Fáil Deputies when he was speaking, and if the gloom on their faces was any reflection of their thoughts——

Comment on this

The Deputy is being a psychologist now.

Comment on this

You would not need to be a psychologist. I do not want to be uncharitable to Deputy Crowley and I hope he has an idea of what I am referring to, but if he pursues this line of attack, I will not refrain from answering him. I will be charitable at this stage.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy, on the motion.

Comment on this

Exactly, and time it was said.

Comment on this

Last night I had a discussion with a doctor friend who told me that he knew the Taoiseach exceptionally well. I do not know what the gentleman's politics are, but, having discussed this Agreement into the early hours of this morning, I was left with the opinion that if we could know the innermost thoughts of the Taoiseach, he would freely admit that he was misled by another person who is in a higher position in this country today. What does this Agreement mean? What is in this Agreement for our people? Is it the free trade that has been commonly referred to as such by Fianna Fáil speakers? Is it really free trade? Deputy Andrews nods his head in assent. Does Deputy Andrews agree that the British industries have complete access to Irish markets?

Comment on this

The Deputy is speaking and I have no intention of subjecting myself to a cross-examination by him. I do not wish to interrupt him.

Comment on this

Silence is golden.

Comment on this

That is what I am doing, I am remaining silent.

Comment on this

I will answer the questions for the Deputy. In a few months' time British industry will have three million more customers. Irish agriculture has not got the same advantage on the British market and agriculture, whether the Fianna Fáil Party like it or not, is the first and the only industry this country has got or will ever have. We hear glorious speeches such as that made by Deputy Moore about getting our feet on the ground and making our nation's economic standards equal to or better than those of other nations in Western Europe but Deputy Moore needs to be more realistic. We are a poor nation and will always be a poor nation. The only way in which we might improve our position is to get rid of a Fianna Fáil Government which has been on the wrong path for the past thirty-five years.

Let us examine the position that existed in this country before 1932. I was in conversation with a Northern Unionist about a month ago—in actual fact, on the day the Taoiseach signed this Agreement in London—and he asked me what I thought about this new Agreement which was then being referred to as free trade. My reply was that he must know as much about it as I did because he got his information from the same source as I did, and he probably read more newspapers than I did. This was a secret Agreement up to last weekend. The only people who talked about it in any great detail were Fianna Fáil Ministers who were trying to put a facade on it which has been described as the nearest thing to a word which is unParliamentary.

Let us return to 1932 and examine the Trade Agreement in the light of the situation which existed prior to the Economic War. When the late W.T. Cosgrave set up Government, we had full access to the British market and when the spokesmen of that Government and their supporters talked commonsense, we know the co-operation they got from the predecessors of the people sitting opposite to me today. We know what answer they got. It was not co-operation, Deputy Moore.

Comment on this

This is 1966, not 1932.

Comment on this

Yes, it is, but do not forget the past. Your heritage is in it——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

May I point out to the Deputy that there is no reason for singling out any particular Deputy and addressing remarks to him? The Deputy should address the Chair.

Comment on this

I submit to your ruling, Sir, but I would like to point out that it has not been the practice in this debate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has never been the practice to address any particular Deputy in the House, but the Chair.

Comment on this

Well, I will continue. When Éamon de Valera took over the reins of office, the first major issue which he tackled—and I will admit freely that possibly he was right in his thoughts but very immature in his timing—was to refuse to pay the land annuities to Great Britain. At the time Deputy Lemass said they would not pay the land annuities because by law and by right they were entitled to withhold them. I will give the reference to that if anyone wants it. The British Government retaliated and put an embargo on Irish livestock which represented 75 per cent of our agricultural exports to Great Britain. In other words, 75 per cent of 80 per cent of our total exports. What happened then? Deputy Lemass said: "Fair enough; you put an embargo on livestock and we will put a tariff barrier on your imports". The saviour who used be but is seemingly forgotten about today by the backbenchers—and the wonder is that someone has come along to take his place—announced that from then on foreign industries in this country would have to have 51 per cent Irish capital.

We were then in isolation and for the first time in this State, from 1922, we had established beyond doubt an economic border between the Six Counties and the Twenty-six Counties and I defy contradiction on that. The Party who took over the reins of office on the promise that they would unite the country had then established beyond all doubt that between the Six Counties and the Twenty-six Counties we had an economic border for the first time. Deputies can deny that if they wish and any Deputy who has not yet spoken can take a note of it and reply to it. I was born within a half a mile of that Border and that Border I am told, because the position existed before my birth, was, between 1922 and 1932, nothing but a political inconvenience to both Nationalists and Unionists. But your Chief, the man who blew the trumpet, beat the drum and waved the flag whenever this Party were realistically evaluating the British market, appealed to the loyalties of the Irish people who were still suffering from the hangover of a battle with Great Britain. Throughout our history one phrase recurs: "a stepping stone." When I use that phrase, there is not a Deputy but does not know to whom I am referring. No leader of this Assembly ever took greater advantage of that stepping stone than its present leader, Deputy Seán Lemass.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is still addressing the opposite side of the House. It is quite irregular.

Comment on this

It may not be in order, Sir, but it seems to be the habit of the House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is incorrect again. The Deputy is challenging my ruling. It is not the habit of the House.

Comment on this

I submit to your ruling, Sir. This Agreement vindicates the wisdom and foresight of the leaders of the Provisional Government of this country. Last Saturday night the Fine Gael Party honoured four great statesmen who played their part in the building of this nation. They honoured Dick Mulcahy because he kept law and order in this country when it had to be kept. They honoured Paddy McGilligan because he built industry and established the foundation for industry here. The previous speaker said there was one man who had put industry here into swaddling clothes. We had industry here before Fianna Fáil was ever heard of. The sooner we get rid of them, the sooner we will have good, healthy industry here again. We honoured Michael Hayes for making parliament parliament in the days when the Deputies now sitting in the Government benches were, in the words of Deputy Ryan, "afraid to come into this House in case they might dirty the seats of their pants". When parliament ceases to be parliament, democracy ceases to be democracy.

Comment on this

On what section of the Agreement is that?

Comment on this

I relate this to the Agreement in the same manner as the Taoiseach and Deputy Moore related their remarks to the Agreement. We also honoured General Seán MacEoin for his part in Irish history. But we could accord them no honour greater than that accorded them by the signing of this Agreement. The Taoiseach says this must be a good Agreement because it takes us out of isolation and prepares us for entry into EEC or EFTA or a combination of both. He tells us that, if we did not do this now, we would be too late. The Labour Party rightly point out that we are being rushed and that Irish industry has not sufficient time to adjust itself to the outside world.

If this Agreement is good in 1966, surely it was much better in 1922, 1932, and 1938? If the men who tried to adopt that viewpoint democratically had been allowed to build up this nation, what kind of nation would we have here to-day? Would we have to listen to the previous speaker appealing to Irish industry to get its feet on the ground and build up this nation into one economically as good as any other in Western Europe? In 1922 the plenipotentiaries returned and said: "We wanted more, but this is all we could get." Were they not in the same position then as the Government are in today when the Taoiseach comes back and says: "We might have got more, but they would not give us more? This is the best we could get."

Fianna Fáil ask us why we do not vote against the Agreement. Is it not much easier for us to vote with the Agreement than for the Minister for External Affairs to vote with it—the man who is on record as saying: "The British market is gone and gone forever, thank God"? I do not wish to be political, but I cannot help it. Some time ago a pal of mine told me he had read a pamphlet concerning Tammany Hall in America. It is noticeable that most of the hierarchy of the Tammany Hall Committee were Irish. The nearest comparison the writer of the pamphlet could get to it was the Fianna Fáil Government in Ireland.

Comment on this

What is the name of the pamphlet?

Comment on this

I do not remember it offhand, but I will get it for any Deputy who wants it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest the pamphlets before the House should become the subject of the debate.

Comment on this

I have read this Agreement. I do not propose to discuss industry, because industry does not affect a Donegal Deputy. However, I propose to refer to agriculture. The Minister for Agriculture told us he now has an agreement which allows 638,000 store cattle into Great Britain. In reply to a question, in volume 53, column 1021 of the Official Report Deputy Dr. Ryan stated that the number of cattle exported to Great Britain prior to 1932 was 750,000. That is 112,000 more than the Minister for Agriculture has got in this Agreement. After 35 years we are told we have a guaranteed market for 638,000 cattle, despite the fact that in the year 1931 we exported 750,000 cattle. Is it not ludicrous to think we are now exporting fewer cattle to Great Britain than 35 years ago?

Is it not ridiculous that before the main Opposition Parties had an opportunity to examine this Agreement, when all sorts of issues were being put forward by civil servants who were forced into that position by Government policy, excuses were given to members of this Party and, I expect, to members of the Labour Party, when they were asked for a copy of this Agreement, that, because of printing difficulties, they could not get it out. The British newspapers had it a fortnight before members of this Assembly had it. Is that democracy? Did that give the Irish people or the main Opposition Parties an opportunity to examine and discuss it among themselves or in their own groups? I venture to say that, in all probability, certain prominent members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are not Ministers or Parliamentary Secretaries got advance briefings of it. But this I am certain of, that the Taoiseach, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture painted a very rosy picture of what it is all about.

The first time, as far as I recall, the Minister for Agriculture spoke on the Agreement he said that store cattle would increase by as much as £7 per head. I know as much about store cattle as the Minister for Agriculture. If the price of store cattle in the months of November and December would increase by only £5 or £6 per head in the month of April then there would be very few people buying store cattle in the month of November. This is a seasonal drop in the price of livestock and the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Haughey, has codded nobody when he tells us that the price of store cattle will increase, due to this Agreement, by £5 or £6. Such tactics reflect his anxiety to project a better image of the Agreement which they thought they got and which now appears, on second thoughts and on second reading, to be a shambles of the 1938 and 1948 Agreements put together.

If any Deputy wishes to look back over the records of this House and to examine the trading figures with Great Britain prior to the Economic War he will note that they were more advantageous to this country then than they are at the present moment—and then we see the naked truth; then we see what this Agreement will do for Irish industry and Irish agriculture. I venture to say that even members of the back bench of Fianna Fáil are at this stage wondering what happened to the glossy picture which the Minister for Agriculture, in particular, painted of the new Agreement when he first came back and told us that the agricultural community would benefit by £10 million per annum. Where will this £10 million come from? Has anybody ever told us how he arrived at a figure of £10 million? Nobody in the Fianna Fáil benches has told us, but we would dare to guess that he had the same calculation as the Taoiseach, Deputy Seán Lemass, had when he announced in Clery's Ballroom in 1957—100,000 New Jobs; Get Your Husband back to Work; Bring Your Sons and Daughters back from England—and, before the 1965 General Election, we heard— Prosperity is Here; Do Not Change Horses in Mid-Stream: Let Lemass Lead On. Lead on where? Lead into a situation where we now find ourselves overnight in a credit squeeze? Lead us into a situation where, if any small businessman in rural Ireland wishes to have increased accommodation through his local bank, the bank manager refuses to give it to him, not because he distrusts him but because he has not the capital to give to him—why? Because the Government tell the banks to lend no more money—why? Because the Government want the money themselves—for what? To pay for their own mistakes, the blunders and bribery of the 1963 by-elections in Cork and Kildare.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling very far from the Agreement. Does the Deputy admit that he has travelled very far?

Comment on this

I do not wish to dispute the ruling of the Chair but I would respectfully point out that yesterday the Taoiseach's son took us back and gave us a lecture on sixteenth century history.

Comment on this

He does not know anything about the twentieth century.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Harte considers that a bad lead. Deputy Harte does not wish to follow a bad lead.

Comment on this

It was you who said it, not I. However, I submit to the ruling of the Chair. In any case, as a Party, we have examined this Agreement and we can truthfully, and individually and collectively say that it is not a good Agreement. We can also state, as a Party, that our heritage, our tradition, is free trade with Great Britain to a very large degree. Therefore, on that basis, we do not propose to vote against the Government's Agreement other than to vote for our own amendment.

Certain Deputies may try to distort or confuse the situation which the Fine Gael Party are in at the moment. Let me remind Deputies on the Government Benches that no Party have been more consistent in thought or in deed in this Parliament since the foundation of the State, politically speaking and economically speaking, than the Fine Gael Party. We may have told our political lies; we may have coasted out of individual difficulties but no Deputy opposite can look up the record of any major debate which took place in this Parliament and point out to this House that any prominent member of the Fine Gael Party ever advocated any other way of trading with Great Britain, any other basis for a sound economy for this country, any other political relationship with Great Britain, than the right to be free, the right to control our own destinies while, at the same time, being friendly with what was then described as "our old enemy."

In the past five or six years, beginning with a promise of 100,000 new jobs, we have had different agreements, Bills, one thing and another proposed by this Fianna Fáil Government Party. We had the Five Year Plan which was changed to the First Programme for Economic Expansion and then dropped like a hot cake prior to the 1961 general election and re-introduced, painted with all the cosmetics that go with political public relations, and called the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. We have had a new system of taxation, the turnover tax, which was introduced in this House and described by the Ministers proposing its adoption as being a system of taxation which the people would not have to pay, that industry would carry it, that business premises would not pass it on to the consumer, and we know the result. We know the difficulties the Government then found themselves in. We know they found themselves in a position that they must contest two by-elections. We knew, the people knew but, best of all, Fianna Fáil knew, that after they contested those two by-elections around or about the date the Labour Party moved the writ to fight the by-election in the city of Cork, their political destiny had reached the end, that they had had it.

The Taoiseach then announced, or jumped on the bandwagon, and announced the ninth round increase—"stand back lads, share the cake of prosperity, go off on a honeymoon." Those were the expressions used by Fianna Fáil speakers only four years ago. Then the Ministers for Justice came into this House and gave an increase of £1,500 a year to the judiciary who were then in receipt of £4,500. I am not against the judiciary or anybody else getting an increase but I am against getting an increase the Government cannot afford.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

What has an increase to the judiciary to do with this debate?

Comment on this

I submit I am still in order. We now find that all the schemes put forward by the present Taoiseach who has lost the mythical figure, the long, dark shadow, and who beat the drums to get his supporters to back him, the man who said——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is travelling very far from this debate. If the Deputy intends to introduce any names into this House, I will see that he travels very carefully.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has made so many excuses for the loss which I have just tried to explain and found myself using unparliamentary language. To try to overcome these failings he has brought in more Acts to this House, telling us that prosperity is just around the corner. They have all failed and this new Agreement is nothing more than a blind across all his failures to try to keep the people talking of the economic difficulties in this country at the moment. It is not a free trade. It is a plain Agreement with Great Britain, an Agreement which is only a wind down over ten years to the situation which existed prior to the economic war.

We have been living in this country, or rather the Government have been making us believe we have been living like the Beverly Hill Billies. That comes to an end like every good thing that may last a long time but will not stay for ever.

The Fine Gael Party are married to the idea of free trade with Great Britain. At long last we rejoice in the fact that Fianna Fáil have, at long last, reached political maturity. We could rub in salt to the wounds and if we were in Government, we could expect nothing better than the Fianna Fáil Party to rub salt into our wounds, if we had wounds to rub salt into. But, whether it is an opportunity for a Deputy on this side of the House to speak on a certain line of thought, whether it is an opportunity for a member on this side of the House to speak on a different line of thought, the fact still remains that Fianna Fáil have changed so much in the last 45 years that the only two cogs left in the full wheel of circle for Seán Lemass to employ—and I say this lest, perhaps, future generations of this country may be misled as has the generation to which I belong—are, No. 1, he should now appoint a committee to examine who was right and who was wrong, politically and economically, since we gained our independence. Having done that his final one is to abolish the Fianna Fáil Party because they are nothing now like what they were when they were first created. That would be an expression used by that mythical gentleman I referred to earlier.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I fail to see what all this has to do with the motion before the House. I shall have to ask the Deputy to resume his seat.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, when speaking yesterday, said: "We see this as a definite advancement towards economic and industrial expansion and it must be good for the country". Surely it would not be impertinent for me to say if it was good for the country in 1966, it must have been a lot better for the country in 1922.

The Minister for Finance said this morning "Free Trade is imminent and we could be late if we delayed". How long have we delayed? Is it not true that we have delayed for the last 45 years but Fianna Fáil are only now seeing the forest for the trees.

In Volume 53 of the Dáil Debates, at column 2108, a Deputy, who is still a member of the Fianna Fáil Party and whom I shall not name but for any person who wishes to find his name, I have given the reference, said:

The idiot of a farmer who stuck to it——

(meaning the production of beef for the British market)

——is in a bad way now.

He continued, at column 2109 and said:

The sooner the farmers in this country realise those matters the better.

Those are the words of a Fianna Fáil back bench member who purports to have an interest in the agricultural field. While they are stupid remarks they typify the thinking then, the present view points to the Fianna Fáil Party who believe in nothing else but Fianna Fáil and who have also put Fianna Fáil in front of national interests——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is not a word about Fianna Fáil in the motion.

Comment on this

Well, the Government. I shall conclude by quoting Mr. Lemass.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Taoiseach is the proper reference.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, said in volume 53 at column 2536:

What good are British pound notes to us? We will teach our people the lesson that there is no security based on an export market.

Surely that is now ironical.

Comment on this

This Agreement under discussion at the moment is a Government Agreement which was negotiated by the Government and signed by them before it was presented to the House. One wonders what purpose this debate serves. We are now committed to the terms of this Agreement, good or ill, but we in the Labour Party feel it is essential for the workings of democracy that the people should fully realise what the implications of the Agreement are and will be for them. The Government, having negotiated this Agreement, now ask all Deputies to endorse their action. I can assure the Government that it is not the intention of the Labour Party to give them the green light to close down industries on which millions have been spent in order to establish them as a matter of Fianna Fáil policy. It has not been denied, but rather admitted openly by the Taoiseach, that this Agreement will result in a considerable loss of employment. We realise that, nobody knows, or seems to know, how many industries will be affected or how many workers will be put on the emigrant ship or on the employment exchange as a result of it. We have no accurate or even approximate estimate of the number of livelihoods this will affect.

In a television interview, the Taoiseach said he could not say how many industries or how many workers would be affected by the Agreement. On the other hand, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and his Parliamentary Secretary are not able to tell us, although this Agreement has been in the process of negotiation for a considerable time, when redundancy payments will be introduced or how far we have gone with the so-called manpower policy. That is to be expected from a Government that so blatantly misled the people in the past when they invited them back from England and elsewhere to take up the mythical 100,000 jobs. We have some slight indication —although I doubt the accuracy of it—in the White Paper on the Free Trade Agreement which, on page 49 paragraph 153, states:

The Committee on Industrial Organisation, in its final report, stated that it could be expected that the total reduction in employment in existing manufacturing industries in the transition to free trade in the context of EEC membership would be about 10,000...

That is approximately seven per cent. Turning over the page, in paragraph 158, one finds it stated that:

It is questionable, therefore, whether a free trade area relationship with Britain will involve consequences for Irish industry different from the earlier expectation of complete free trade by 1970 in an enlarged EEC.

We can at least anticipate that 10,000 will be affected and I think that is a very conservative estimate. When you add that to the shortage in the projected number of new jobs offered in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, to the shortage of 87,000, not only have we not got the 100,000 new jobs but it is likely we shall not have the 100,000 old ones. That will be one of the offsprings of this Agreement which was signed, sealed and delivered before it was placed before this Assembly. Yet, the Government expect responsible Deputies to endorse their action.

We know from what I have said the grave hardships that this Agreement will impose on a number of people but I see nothing being done by the Government to offset these hardships. All we have is a vague— they specialise in being vague; there is no doubt about that—reference by the Taoiseach that for every industry that goes, four or five will spring up. Four or five what? And where, And when? And how?

Under the Agreement I believe the position is, that if a foreign industrialist comes here to establish an industry, the Government are prohibited by the terms of the Agreement from giving any financial assistance to that industrialist to establish a factory here, but there is nothing to debar the Six-County Government from giving financial assistance by way of grants-in-aid to such an industrialist. I should like some Government spokesman to deal with that matter. This is another offspring of the Agreement that the four gallant Fianna Fáil men brought back with a fanfare of trumpets— probably obtained from the Garda Band—to tell the workers that prosperity was now here and that we had no further ills.

As the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce asked yesterday, what if some workers go to the wall? If some 10,000 go to the emigrant ship or the employment exchange, what did it matter? This is the kind of thing we are getting from Government spokesmen, people charged with responsibility for the welfare of the citizens. Yet Fianna Fáil and the Government expect that members of the Labour Party would endorse their action in this House.

We are told at this stage that there was no alternative to this Agreement, that this was the only possible thing to do and that this is where the prosperity and the welfare of the Irish people lie. It may be true that there was no alternative. As a result of the policy that had been pursued by the Fianna Fáil Government, that brought this country to the brink of bankruptcy, a situation now exists where a few short weeks ago the Taoiseach announced in this House that it was necessary to withdraw money that they had anticipated spending on education and health. Possibly this Agreement represents another hairshirt that the Irish people are asked to wear because of the policy pursued by Fianna Fáil Governments. Possibly that is the reason why they could see no alternative. They had got so far into the mess that they had to find something to distract the attention of the people away from the sorry plight in which they now find themselves. If it entailed the sacrifice of a few thousand workers here or there, what did it matter?

We in the Labour Party have many doubts as to the wisdom of entering into this Agreement. We are responsible for this debate being held so as to ensure that there is not another sleight of hand trick played on the people, that the people will get some chance to realise what is involved in the action of the Government trotting over to London and coming back with an Agreement, signed, sealed and delivered, which can have very serious consequences for the ordinary people of the country.

We hear a great deal of talk about industries that will boom and prosper. Some industries will undoubtedly prosper. The Minister for Agriculture and his colleagues maintain that agriculture will benefit by £10 million per annum under this Agreement. The Minister is rather vague as to where the £10 million will come from, just as Fianna Fáil and the Government are very often vague about things that are to come but which never arrive, such as the 100,000 new jobs.

I am not very familiar with agriculture. I am city born and bred. A great deal of play is being made about store cattle and about the dead meat trade. I wonder if there are not a few flaws in that part of the Agreement which is being heralded as one of the greatest achievements of the Agreement. What will be the effect on the dead meat trade when store cattle are being exported in unprecedented numbers on the hoof? What quantity will be available for those engaged in the meat trade for slaughtering and export as carcase meat?

There is another question in regard to the dead meat industry to which we should get an answer. What will happen the markets that have been built up in European countries other than Great Britain over the last number of years? I am in a position to know that approximately 60 per cent of the product of some of our largest dead meat factories goes to European countries other than Great Britain. These factories have spent a considerable amount of time and money in building up these markets. In very recent years they have begun to make an impression. What now? That goes. All the eggs are in Britannia's basket. This is the type of thing that the Government have the audacity to ask Deputies to endorse.

This Agreement is, as I have said, a Fianna Fáil Agreement. They made it. They negotiated it. They are now, prematurely, trying to take credit for the pseudo benefits that will flow from it. We want it to be made known and we want to impress on the people's minds that this is a Fianna Fáil Agreement and that they must accept, for once, the responsibility for what will flow from the Agreement. We are determined in the course of this debate to pin that responsibility very definitely on Fianna Fáil and on the Government. It is your Agreement. You made it. You must accept responsibility for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I had nothing to do with it. The Deputy said I had.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy made it very clear that it was Fianna Fáil who made it.

Comment on this

There is one comment that should be made. We in the Labour Party have made our attitude very clear by our amendment to the motion moved by the Taoiseach and by our contributions to the debate. There is nothing ambiguous about it. It is consistent with the policy of our Party. It is regrettable—I think this should be said—that the members of the Fine Gael Party who made so many excellent contributions to the debate and pointed out in no uncertain manner the flaws in the Agreement did not have the conviction to vote against it and let the Government accept, as they should accept, the full responsibility for making it.

Comment on this

If I were asked what was the most pertinent question posed by the Taoiseach to the Opposition Parties, I would unhesitatingly say that it was the question asking them what alternatives they could put forward, if they did not approve of this Agreement. This Trade Agreement was freely and independently negotiated with the British Government. It was skilfully and adroitly brought to a conclusion by the pragmatic ability of the Taoiseach to see things as they really are, instead of living in the clouds, and to assess accurately the existing economic situation.

For the past three days I have sat here listening in vain for alternative suggestions from the Opposition Parties, the alternative suggestions they propose in our present economic circumstances. Like my colleagues in Fianna Fáil, I came prepared to listen diligently and patiently to concrete proposals put forward by the Opposition. Perhaps I was a little naive in thinking the Opposition would have concrete proposals to make. I have listened for so long now that I have reached the stage of feeling tired of the spurious promises and the Utopian schemes for the furtherance of our country's economic growth. Again, perhaps naively, I was hoping for too much.

Deputy Corish said that this Agreement is one of the most vital things that have been done and one of the most vital decisions with which this country has been confronted since its emergence as a nation. Having heard that statement, I anticipated at least that the nucleus of some original and objective proposals would be given birth to during this debate. I hoped in vain. It is no part of my function to point out to Opposition Deputies the harsh economic and political set-up in Europe, a Europe which is rapidly and aggressively moving towards an integrated bloc, a bloc which has no notion of waiting for either Fine Gael or Labour to make up their minds as to what is possible and what is feasible in this integrated European bloc. In the meantime, of course, neither Fine Gael nor Labour can stem the rapidly with which Europe, and, indeed, other countries outside Europe, are charting their economic course towards this particular form of integration.

Let me put it in a slightly different way. In my opinion it is the duty of the Opposition, an Opposition which may have ambitions to lead the country some day, to put lucidly and authoritatively, and without any contradictions, a positive, practical and realisable alternative policy. What do we get? We get a suggestion of some form of association with EEC, which the Taoiseach, with complete justification, described as a foolish proposal. We search in vain for some concrete and objective proposals for the implementation of such an association. So far, I have heard no suggestion with regard to implementation put forward by any of the Opposition speakers. It is irresponsible and politically immature to carry on as the Opposition Parties have been carrying on, especially the Fine Gael Party. Their attitude shows the utter vacuity of policy existing in the Fine Gael Party at the moment.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy comment now on the 100,000 jobs?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

I wish they would for our edification indicate how they propose to implement this proposal of associate membership with the EEC. It was, I think, Deputy T.F. O'Higgins who referred to the case of Austria. He rightly stressed that Austria is at the moment strenuously seeking associate membership with the European Economic Community.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What about the time the Deputy was seeking active membership of Fine Gael?

Comment on this

We will leave Lord Carbury now on his own side.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is not answering the question.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question does not arise.

Comment on this

Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, and the economists who presume to advise him, should be aware of the very rough passage Austria is getting at the hand of the EEC countries. Austria is receiving very, very scant regard from these EEC countries. Furthermore, I believe that, if Austria could now withdraw with some dignity, she would not hesitate to do so.

It is clear that Deputies on the Opposition benches have no clear concept of what associate membership of EEC entails and Deputy Cosgrave is to be indicted as leader of what should be a responsible political Party for showing no clear appreciation of what the realities of associate membership of EEC mean. Every responsible and informed Deputy is fully aware that full membership of EEC is not easily achievable. My own observations lead me to believe that, while the French Government continue to reject this supranational structure, which is inherent in and intimately part of the Rome Treaty, no negotiation based on quick integration is possible for quite some time. The view has been put forward that President de Gaulle's eclipse in the French Presidential election——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I thought he won it.

Comment on this

——would perhaps hasten the French commitment to what the architect of the Rome Treaty, Jang Monet, held to be its most vital clause. I do not wish to detain the House by discussing the merits or demerits of this opinion, but I hold it is a valid conclusion that any eventual agreement between the EEC partners will not be quickly achieved. It is, therefore, also valid to conclude that the Opposition Parties here show a surprising ignorance of the situation as it exists.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think we shall get in by 1970?

Comment on this

The Labour Party have their own economists to enlighten them.

Comment on this

We have not 30,000 of them. Will the Deputy give us his opinion?

Comment on this

I shall give it to the Deputy if he listens.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy think we will get in by 1970?

Comment on this

Will the Deputy listen?

Comment on this

I thought he was getting away from the subject. That is why I asked him.

Comment on this

One can understand the anxiety and dismay of many of the supporters of the Fine Gael Party who cannot find it in their hearts to believe that Fine Gael would come out so strongly and vehemently against this Agreement and then suddenly decide to vote with the Government on it.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

We did not.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not presume so far.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party are not opposing it. Obviously you have not got control over what your speakers are saying because the last two speakers I heard from the Fine Gael benches explicitly said they do not intend to oppose this Agreement.

Comment on this

That is a different thing from voting for it.

Comment on this

It is a negative vote for it. I would go so far as to say that the Fine Gael Party, despite all the pious supplications and what I would call hypocritical statements cannot cloak the fact that they are politically bankrupt and bereft of any concrete proposals as an alternative policy to this trade agreement.

Comment on this

"Bankrupt" is a dangerous word to use nowadays.

Comment on this

I wish to quote from that very responsible business magazine, to which I see this month Deputy Sweetman is a contributor, Business and Finance, whose political correspondent says with much more wisdom than members of the Fine Gael Party:

This is a good agreement from the Irish point of view. It is an agreement of opportunity, and the people will become more and more aware of this as the ten years of movement from partial free trade evolve.

He goes on to say in what I consider to be a very balanced assessment of the trade agreement:

The British Farmers Union were in little doubt about it. The Agreement is a stinker as far as they are concerned.

That is the greatest compliment that can be paid, that the British farmer sees the advantages that the Irish negotiators have gained on behalf of the Irish farmers. Deputy Corish had previously informed us his Party would take no responsibility for the signing of this trade pact. I should like to ask Deputy Corish for what will his Party take responsibility?

Comment on this

Quite a lot of things, but not for that.

Comment on this

They have not given us one little germ or glimmer of an alternative to the proposal. Opposition without responsibility is the slogan of the Labour Party, and we can say that no Party exploits it more irresponsibly or more ruthlessly than they. All the well-worn clichés and shibboleths that are the Labour Party's stock-in-trade have been politically bounced here in this debate.

Comment on this

The Deputy wore his out.

Comment on this

To sum up, both from the Fine Gael side and the Labour side, what alternative proposals have we got? I would say the answer is "None". For the first time in this House I am provoked into rejecting vehemently and trenchantly and with all the words that I can command Deputy Treacy's damaging offensive against the Irish workers. He paints a picture of us as a nation of industrial workers utterly incompetent, so completely unskilled as to be incapable of competing with our counterparts under free trade conditions.

Comment on this

Is that a quotation?

Comment on this

Roughly. Not alone that, but he indicted Irish industrialists and salesmen as people of little or no initiative and, to quote, he said that British supersalesmanship would bury us, that we would have throughout the country industrial graveyards for our workers. If that is Deputy Treacy's attitude towards the Irish workers——

Comment on this

It is not towards the Irish workers.

Comment on this

The industrial graveyard in this country?

Comment on this

As a result of this Agreement.

Comment on this

I am confident in the Irish workers' ability to rise to the occasion and to overcome any disadvantages which Deputy Treacy put forward. I have complete confidence in them and I would say that the only tombstone to be erected in this industrial graveyard may be Deputy Treacy's own tombstone as a result of his assessment of the Irish worker.

Comment on this

We shall see at the next general election.

Comment on this

I should like to put forward to the Minister for Industry and Commerce the idea which I mooted when speaking on the Taoiseach's Estimate of appointing a professional sales force possibly under Córas Tráchtála to go into the British and world markets——

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

To sell our products.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

What are salesmen for?

Comment on this

If this Agreement is all right they do not want them.

Comment on this

The Deputy was criticising Deputy Treacy because he said we did not have what the Deputy is proposing now.

Comment on this

I said the policy is there.

Comment on this

Deputy Treacy said it was not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputies allow Deputy Crowley to make his speech?

Comment on this

We need a sales force to go out into these world markets to ensure that Irish goods are presented and marketed in the proper way. I am sure there would be substantial increases in Irish exports if we had this type of dynamic sales force.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

From all the discussions I have had with people in my constituency, industrialists, workers and farmers, they are all delighted at this stage that they did "Let Lemass Lead On".

Comment on this

I should like to draw the last speaker's attention to the terms of the motion before the House to which two amendments have been moved. It is in the light of these amendments that we are conducting this discussion this evening. Since the debate opened, we have been concerned with the factual situation that an Agreement has been signed on behalf of this country and the amendments do not allow of anything else beyond expressing our disappointment with the Agreement which has been negotiated. Our amendment is:

To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and to insert the following:

", while approving the Agreements, Exchanges of Letters and Understandings between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom which were signed in London on the 14th day of December, 1965, and copies of which have been laid before Dáil Éireann, is concerned with the inevitable effect of the freeing of trade on employment and emigration and deplores the fact that the Agreement as negotiated is unbalanced and that the concessions obtained are small in the immediate future and limited and insecure thereafter."

As already expressed by other speakers on this side of the House, this Agreement recognises a fact which has been there for a long time as part of the history and the Taoiseach came into the House and related the background against which he negotiated this Agreement. It surely is not the duty of Fine Gael, as an Opposition, to suggest any alternative to a fact which has always been the keystone of thought in this country—that our geographical nearness to Britain has always made Britain our best market. It is something that neither history nor geography will change.

The Taoiseach referred in his opening statement to the conditions in which he decided to negotiate this Agreement and gave reasons which took him back to 1963. I suggest that the background to the negotiations culminating in this Agreement can be found in the situation which existed in this country at that time. The negotiations were born of necessity because of the imposition of the British levies which created difficulties for this country—a danger of unemployment, a danger to our financial stability, a danger to the progress of the programmes the Government wish to see implemented. The fact that our trade relations with our largest market were being interrupted was the dominant consideration which sent the Taoiseach to London in an attempt to deal with the situation.

When the Taoiseach was speaking of the dangers and the lost opportunities for this country either by way of delay in implementing the Agreement or in the negotiations leading up to it, one could not help thinking of the great pity it is that the recognition of that fact has had to wait for so long. We could have over the years accepted the situation we are now prepared to accept and which is now put before the House as something with which everyone should agree—that access to the British market must be the dominant consideration in this country in the future. Access to that market has been available to us throughout the whole period of which the Taoiseach spoke, the great pity being the years we wasted and the opportunities we lost. Otherwise, our economy might now be in a better position to face the challenges which the 60s are bringing and which the 70s will bring to this country. Of that there is no doubt.

Britain is now being recognised as our largest export market. As Deputy Dockrell said, here we have proposed an economic union which gives to a nation of more than 50 million people —with long traditions in the manufacturing industry, with a large and valuable supply of native materials, with the techniques that have been built up and directed towards the world markets which she controls — open access to this small market but which to her is a very valuable one. The year 1966 has not changed the geographical facts in relation to these two countries. What has changed is the philosophy of the Government Party. I can do no better than read from the White Paper, at page 56:

Britain will continue to be the principal outlet for most agricultural exports in which Ireland has an interest. It follows that a primary objective of Irish external trade policy must be to secure satisfactory access for Irish agricultural exports to the British market.

Comment on this

They talk about getting into the EEC.

Comment on this

I should like at this stage to say in regard to this document, its various annexes and the pages with which it is prefaced, that it is the Government's presentation of the answers in regard to all these problems. It is a political painting of the advantages they believe to be available from this Agreement. Nobody will find fault with the Government colouring their presentation of the Agreement in the most favourable light in which they can colour it. It is something with which we do not disagree because, as Deputy Dillon said today, this is a valuable document for our agricultural community in the sense that it continues agreements negotiated previously which have provided outlets for our agricultural produce to our nearest neighbour. That is one of the main reasons why we do not advocate complete rejection of this Agreement.

In speeches here we have pointed out the weaknesses which we believe are inherent in the Agreement. I think it was the Minister for Agriculture and the Taoiseach who referred to this Agreement as being a lasting Agreement, in so far as trade between the two countries is concerned. It is no more lasting and final in this respect than any of the Agreements which have ever been concluded between countries negotiating trade matters. It is no more lasting and final than the discussions which have taken place in the EEC area, the EFTA area or any other trade groups and blocs throughout the world. I am as sure as this Dáil is debating this Agreement here today that in future times an Irish Parliament will still continue to debate Agreements which it may enter into, freely, with other trading partners in the European bloc or any other bloc with which it may be associated.

It was mentioned here this morning that it would repay one to read the debate which preceded the Union in this country in 1800. When one reads that debate even at the present time, one sees in it sentiment expressed which might be held at the present time to be even patriotic. There was placed, equally so, before that Parliament at that time the advantages which it was held out would accrue to the Irish nation by integration of its economy with the economy of the dominant party. Just as equally as that Agreement was not the final one and as people are constantly reminded in this city by that statue up in Parnell Square that: "No man may set bounds to the onward march of a nation," neither will this be a final boundary in so far as the country is concerned.

One thing we have learned quite recently, and learned to our cost, is the fact that Agreements are not sacrosanct. When it suited Britain she very easily cast aside in her difficulties Agreements which were voluntarily entered into. It would be foolish on our part to think that if the same happened again this Government now in office in Britain, or any other, would not just as easily use the opportunity, if it so suited them, to serve the interests of their own people first.

This is one of the probabilities and possibilities which must always be remembered in regard to these Agreements. Even the Minister for Agriculture spoke of the possibilities that might arise in regard to the exclusion, for instance, of store cattle. Of course there could be that possibility. Nobody can ever exclude possibilities arising, but the probabilities of the case, I am afraid, would rule out the British being so foolish as not to require, for instance, the importation of our store cattle to supply their needs. There is no nearer source of supply to them from which they can draw adequately their needs in this respect.

The previous speaker referred to a Fine Gael absence of constructive policy or alternative policy in regard to this Agreement. As I have stated in so far as this Agreement is concerned, there is a recognition that there is no question of any alternative inasmuch as it is and always has been a keystone of the policy of this side of the House. The Government Party and Government speakers, rather than present a political picture of how well this Agreement looks in their eyes, might have dealt with this on a factual basis, and we might have heard from them some of the advantages, and, equally, the disadvantages which there are without trying to colour them with political tint. If they feel criticism of this Agreement is imposing an obligation on them to make this type of speech here, then the only thing one can conclude about it is it is not as good as they feel it to be.

I think that has been admitted by the Taoiseach, the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Finance. We readily concede that the Irish team of Ministers and officials who went to negotiate this Agreement did the very best they could, that they obtained what they were able to obtain from a team of negotiators who have a long tradition in this matter. I believe they sought, and I give credit to the team for seeking, so far as they could, any advantages for this country that it was possible to obtain but, again, we must recognise here that we were seeking an Agreement from need and Britain was negotiating an Agreement by choice.

In this matter of assumptions, one wonders how it comes about that in this White Paper certain assumptions are accepted by the Government and certain other assumptions are rejected. In paragraph 156 on page 50 of the White Paper, the quotation occurs: "While certainty is impossible in this regard,"—that is in regard to Ireland and the EEC—"the balance of probability on the available evidence is that in the post-1970 period membership of the Community will have been achieved." I presume that this was not inserted in this document without some thought and that it has a factual basis. One would ask, at this stage, what "post-1970" is in this respect? How long after 1970 is it thought Ireland may get into the EEC? The previous speaker gave it as his opinion that conditions for getting into EEC are difficult to fulfil and membership is not easy to obtain. Surely the Government in presenting this White Paper must have some indication. Reading this document, I believe it is deliberately left vague because there is no question of taking it any further than 1970. If you like after 1970—and that can run for many many long years.

Again, in paragraph 157 we have the extraordinary statement, to my mind, that:

It has been represented that in a Free Trade Area there will be more severe competition from imports from Britain particularly after 1970 than would be the case in an enlarged EEC including that country.

It goes on to say:

...views have been expressed that the home market and exports would grow more slowly after 1970, that the previous rate of growth of manufacturing industry would not be maintained between 1970 and 1975 and that the growth of employment in manufacturing industry would be halted and might even fall slightly after 1970.

I presume that if these views were found worthy of inclusion in a White Paper issued by the Government it means that an appraisal of that situation was made by some responsible authority to merit Government attention. We heard nothing about them here but the opening sentence of paragraph 158—a short sentence— reads:

The Government reject these conclusions.

How is it that the Government on the one hand can make their own assumptions and on the other hand reject assumptions made by some other independent person with whom they evidently do not agree? The Government, as stated in paragraph 159 accept:

...that there are adequate grounds for the views that (i) the home market will grow more slowly after 1970 than in the period 1960-70 and (ii) the rate of growth of exports will be lower after 1970...

Again, in this instance in this document the Government might have justified their reasons for such thinking. If this White Paper is to be of benefit to Deputies who have been trying to debate this intricate document here for the past couple of days, and will continue to debate it, as the country will continue to debate it, we are entitled to know the basis on which the Government made that statement.

Paragraph 160 is more favourable inasmuch as it states:

Recent population projections which forecast, on certain assumptions as to emigration, a population growth of 100,000 in the period 1966-71 and 180,000 in the period 1971-76, point to a growing home market in this period, which will gain added buoyancy from rising agricultural income.

Here, again, in this document the Government find solace and comfort in the projections which seem to favour their case. I do not find fault with that but I believe it is a political presentation of views which Ministers wish the people to believe are founded on fact.

In paragraph 162 the Government refer to industries that will be attracted by adequate supplies of manpower. This has been referred to by various speakers already. One does not want to be too pessimistic in regard to this position but where are the adequate supplies of manpower to come from? Will they come from unemployment in other industries which will suffer as a result of the blitz which may hit them? Are those adequate supplies of manpower to be available from this projection of population increases coming in the decade 1970-80?

In the next paragraph reference is made to the fact that account must be taken also of the contribution made by agriculture-based industries. Again, in a debate such as this Government spokesmen have an obligation to tell the House what agriculture-based industries they will employ these people in who are displaced in industry. An old canard that used to be hurled at this Party in the past was that we supported an improvement in relation to the British market, that we were in favour of the ranchers and the bullocks. If that is to be the result of this Agreement one fails to see where these agriculture-based industries will arise.

Undoubtedly it would be a good thing for this country if more industries based on our basic raw materials produced by agriculture, which is our main industry, were to be used and if there were more processing of them here rather than to export beef on the hoof. There might then be some hope for that type of employment. More should also be based on fisheries on the western and southern seaboards or on vegetable production, and even such a cinderella as the apple industry and we might look forward, perhaps, to some employment for more people. I shall return to that matter later.

I notice that in the introductory part of the White Paper, in the presentation of the Government's case, there is a new philosophy for the Government Party, a philosophy born of necessity and not of expediency, I take it. In paragraph 176 the Government state:

The Government are alive also to the possible effects of a free trade area arrangement on the employment of workers in the weaker areas of industry.

They go on to state that special measures are being taken to retrain these people for employment in expanding industries, to make special payments to workers who have to seek alternative employment and, finally, to minimise the difficulties which individual workers may encounter. The final portion of that statement is significant: "changes which are inevitable and which are necessary for economic progress."

This is a realistic appraisal by the Government as to what is liable to happen. One may praise them for being realistic in respect to it and for being realistic in setting it out here, but certainly so far as the Government Party are concerned, it is a philosophy to which they will have to become accustomed, in the sense that the change for them must surely be something that is new and I am sure, to a large number of Deputies, unwelcome. Of course, the fact that it is unwelcome would not make it more unpalatable. We must face this fact in the future, and it is just as well the Government say so boldly now, that there will be this upset in employment and we will have to take steps to deal with it, that workers' lives will be upset and that the community must be prepared to make some provision for dealing with the type of situation which is likely to arise.

On this matter Deputy Dillon referred today to the people who have made an investment of capital in industry. The State may do something to compensate them but for those who have worked for years in industry and who now have commitments, family commitments or otherwise, the prospects must be much harsher. In this connection, the outlook in regard to re-training should certainly have been given much more prominence in this debate. I hope that we will have some indication from the Minister for Education before this debate concludes, in view of the publication of "Investment in Education," what projects he has in mind for younger workers, not to mind the older workers. Younger people will have to face a different type of era and a different climate from that to which their fathers turned their minds some 30 or 35 years ago.

Some of the traditional industries to which their parents turned will undoubtedly have vanished and one would like to think that the type of training which we should be able to give young people in the future would fit them to work as a skilled force for the type of industry that might be attracted here, and equally that we would have young people of such a calibre that having been suitably trained, they would be capable of the highest degree of management and be able to initiate for themselves or others schemes for industry which would provide not alone a return for themselves but remunerative sources of employment for some of our own people.

At this stage I should like to refer to my own constituency, West Limerick, a constituency of small farmers. I should like to have heard from the Minister for Agriculture what benefits small farmers in my constituency will get from this Agreement. There is not much point in telling us about this question of store cattle, and the opportunities, because the small farmer with 12, or 35 or 40 acres, or the man who is able to carry ten, 15 or 20 cows is going to be concerned with the old tradition and what was always the basic industry of the area, the dairying industry. When he has calves, he has not got the land on which to keep them and he has to dispose of them. He does try to make a living from dairying and by rearing pigs, and latterly we have had this question of broilers and poultry generally. I have not heard anything which would lead me to think, for instance, that the farmers are going to get anything extra for milk. Indeed, in the exchange of letters on this Agreement in regard to butter, it is very noticeable that while there was in other portions of the Agreement the question of subsidisation or a link price being obtained by British farmers for stock, there was no question of any link price so far as dairying products were concerned. The extraordinary thing is that the Minister for Agriculture did secure the right to pay a subsidy here on the export of dairying products. The dairy farmer will continue to provide one-third of that subsidy and the taxpayers will provide the further two-thirds in order to ensure that butter will continue to be available on the British market.

I understand from reading the Agreement that consultations will take place in regard to butter quotas in the future. One thing in it at the moment is a quota which takes us up to 1967, but does not pass it. When the Minister for Agriculture was speaking yesterday and when he referred to the benefits in the Agreement, for instance, in regard to the increased quota for butter, he might have referred to the connotation in this Agreement in regard to the targets being set in regard to the dairying industry in the future and the projections which are being made. The country would have appreciated the fact that he had referred to the dairying industry and his plans for the industry and this question of rationalisation and what it means for the dairying industry and also what it means for the co-operative dairy societies which represent the farmers' interests in the dairying counties at present.

A new philosophy in regard to larger units seems to be growing up. This is not alone in regard to land—one Minister of State has often given voice to it in this House and outside, that the more viable unit of agricultural economy is the larger farm, but it seems now to have moved into the various State Departments. We seem to think that the future salvation of our economy whether industrially or economically is to be found in larger units. I wonder is this an indication of Government thinking as far as the countryside is concerned? Are we projecting our minds so far ahead that we are inclined to think the countryside may become denuded of its population, or are we prepared to consider that we ought still to encourage our people to maintain themselves on the land as the true vocation of an agricultural people? I would have liked to have heard the Minister for Agriculture on this matter. The basic fact will always remain that you cannot have exports of stores and beef from this country if you have not a thriving dairying industry as well. That is a basic fact of our agricultural life with which we will always have to live.

In the exchanges and understandings which are portion of this Agreement, the question of subsidy being paid on exports is one that may be the subject of consultation by the Parties to the Agreement. I want to know if I am correct in that interpretation. Can there be interference with our butter quota, for instance, if it is regarded as being a subsidised export to the British market?

I would also refer to another fact that the Minister for Agriculture yesterday dismissed very lightly indeed, that in regard to the payments to be made for our agricultural products, the link price obtainable by British farmers is to be the subject of consultation with the British Government. The Minister posed possibilities yesterday. I can pose a possibility which is perhaps even more fundamental in regard to store cattle. Could it be that the British Government want to be able to tell the Irish Government how they feel these subsidies should be used in order to promote the type of growth of agricultural produce which they think would be best for the British market? Surely that is one of the matters that must have been given thought to? The House is entitled to learn whether that means anything that might be in any way detrimental to our freedom of action in regard to the utilisation of such payments as we might obtain.

The majority of our farmers are small farmers. They will not be concerned with the mechanics of large numbers of store cattle. They will be concerned with the smaller numbers they can keep for a short time on their small holdings. The Minister for Agriculture made an assessment of the benefit in money values this Agreement would bring to agriculture. Is it beyond possibility that the Minister, or some other Minister on his behalf, would be able to say how much of this £10 million he alleges will be available will find its way directly into the pockets of the small farmers and not into the pockets of those with large amounts of land who can afford to keep for a period a large number of cattle for export to Britain? These are some of the things the Minister for Agriculture should tell the people in regard to this Agreement.

There is one other point in regard to this question of store cattle. The Government have committed themselves to ensuring as far as they can that 638,000 head of store cattle will find their way into the British market. Is this irrespective of the price of cattle on other markets with which we sometimes trade? Are we committed to supplying cattle to the British market as a first priority, or may our farmers send, through traditional channels, their cattle to other markets if a higher price is obtainable for them there? Again, that is a very pertinent question and one about which I think the Government should inform dairying and cattle interests.

The question of support prices has already been mentioned, and I do not want to labour it. The fact, apparently, is that support prices were payable during only one or two weeks of the past seven months. We will have to look elsewhere for this valuable increase in agricultural income with which the Minister for Agriculture was concerned when he spoke. Is there an outlet for agricultural produce by way of processing? If so, are the Minister and the Government prepared to assist industry here to enter into that type of activity in the future, seeing that it will be necessary to provide outlets for industry, other than those they have been used to? Will there be grants available to the agricultural community to engage in that type of promotion such as those made available to manufacturing industry over the years? This is something that might prove valuable to the rural community, particularly those who live on small holdings. They could, through co-operative movements, obtain for themselves a better livelihood than they have today.

In that connection I might refer to the recent speech of the general manager of the Sugar Company in West Cork where he praised the co-operative efforts of the farming community there in providing for themselves an outlet for crops they can produce as well as providing employment for a number of young people in their home area. It is not beyond the bounds of all possibilities that these are matters to which we could successfully turn our attention and that we could provide ourselves with a useful outlet for production on the farms and a useful, even if a small, outlet for our younger labour force coming along.

I confess that one of the things that surprise me in this Agreement is the import of tomatoes. Not that we are able to supply our own needs in that respect but I am surprised because since I came into this House I have taken some interest in the Gaeltacht areas. We have given some aid to the Gaeltacht to erect glasshouses for the production of tomatoes. I am surprised that even such a small amount as 850 tons of tomatoes can be imported into this country during the control period and that, at other times of the year, tomatoes can come in here freely. I was surprised because the growing of tomatoes was an outlet which we felt ought to be encouraged amongst our people, particularly in those areas where the land is not so good and where opportunity is not so vast.

Equally, as was mentioned by Deputy M.P. Murphy and Deputy Mrs. Desmond, there is the question of the importation of fish. One of our problems in regard to the Gaeltacht, and a shrinking Gaeltacht, is the fact that the life of the people there, in rather harsh surroundings, is one of few industries and that their opportunity for earning a living there is rather confined. In our climate, tomatoes do not ripen early. They would be of late vintage, in any case. With our home industry competing with imported tomatoes, it is rather expecting too much that, small as it is, it might even survive. Equally so in regard to this question of fish.

Attempts were being made, and I think successfully made, although perhaps not as fast as we would have liked, to encourage the growth of the fishing industry and our people's undertaking this type of vocation. There were schemes of training for young men and incentive schemes for trawler-owners. It is rather a pity, in the light of the improved attempts to encourage this industry and particularly in so far as the areas where this industry is located are concerned, that there should be any such thing as an importation of what I would regard as rather large amounts of fish. It is not the amount, perhaps, but we shall be competing against people who have been canning fish over a long period and who will perhaps be better able to present it in competition with our people. For that reason, I am sorry to see in the Agreement that this type of import is being allowed.

We have been trying to encourage people to lay down orchards. I know, and very many other Deputies know— certainly Dublin Deputies know—that there are only a number of areas in this country where apple-growing can successfully be undertaken. Our climate does not help us in this matter and, in other cases, our soil does not help us. However, where it does, and where the industry has been engaged in, the importation of quantities of British apples at the periods when they will be imported will not be conducive to any further expansion in so far as trying to encourage people to lay down orchards is concerned. These are only minor matters in a large economy but they are very important matters to the small-holder. They are very important factors in so far as the economy of the small man is concerned who engages in such sidelines to help his ordinary economy.

Before I leave the subject of fruit, I want to mention sugar. The Deputy for South-east Cork, Deputy Corry, has taken time off here in each debate to point to the sins of the inter-Party Government in regard to an import levy which the British imposed on sugar. I do not know whether he read this Agreement fully but he might read paragraph 29, page 217, in regard to sugar:

The provisions of the Free Trade Area Agreement do not affect the United Kingdom sugar surcharge levied under the United Kingdom Sugar Act, 1956, which may continue to be applied to imports from Ireland.

I just mention it because at this stage he might perhaps forget to ride his favourite hobbyhorse and find on this occasion that he can transfer his attentions to his own Ministers who, with all their good intent—and I do not doubt it—were not able to get rid of that imposition.

I want to summarise by saying that this Agreement is accepted by us for what it is, namely, an international instrument that has been signed by an Irish Government and brought home and put before the people. We accept it as being not more than it is. We do not accept all the rosy pictures that are painted of it. We believe it has got its weaknesses. We believe these weaknesses will be capable of remedy in future stages. We do not believe it to be final until the last word is spoken in regard to negotiations so far as the interests of this country are concerned. Opportunities will present themselves to the legislators in this House, if not in the immediate future, at some later stage to be responsible for the conduct of affairs here, and again have to negotiate in regard to our trading arrangements with partners abroad.

One of the important things is that we should recognise the area of difficulty which will be presented to the country in regard to the implementation of this Agreement, a factual type of disadvantage, in so far as the employment of people in certain industries is concerned. It was politically courageous of the Minister for Industry and Commerce to say here in this House that areas of employment would shrink in parts of the country and grow in others. How large the shrinkage and how large the growth? Only time can dictate that. But in the Ireland of the 70s and 80s and, particularly between 1970 and 1980, there will be presented to the younger people, who will have had time to forget the type of volte face which has now occurred on the part of the Government Party, a complete turnabout whereby the Taoiseach, in what I might call his last political testament, recognises the facts of life, as he said, and has been participated in here by the Minister for Agriculture as well, the facts of life, the geographical hard facts that we are not 500 miles out in the Atlantic Ocean, that we live here on the western fringe of Britain and that the British market is now being recognised for what it is. There is also the hard fact that we have lost out over 30 years when we could have used our endeavours to perfect our economy and improve our agricultural industry. The fact is that the Government could have initiated a better economy in so far as this country is concerned, which would have provided better opportunities for the education of young people.

Those are the kind of thoughts the Government must concern themselves with. It is not enough to come in with this Agreement at this stage but, having presented it here, as it has been presented politically—and I do not in any way find fault with the Government for doing so—this should be matched equally with the type of determination that the disadvantages which will certainly accrue from it are not laid aside easily, that we cannot afford to gloss them over, that this debate will end but, in so far as the country is concerned, we will have to live with this Agreement. The people will have to live with it until something better can be negotiated. In that type of approach lies a more sure salvation as far as the country is concerned.

There is not much use in harping backwards and forwards in regard to the matter now. It is an accomplished fact. From it surely we have a lesson to learn. We have a lesson to learn that nothing is sacrosanct. Nothing remains, everything changes as we move ahead into the future. I might recount here this evening that the Fianna Fáil Government have, by the very terms of this Agreement, now acknowledged the fact that they were politically wrong for so long and acclaim the benches opposite for speaking in favour of it. They were wrong previously and may be wrong again in regard to it.

We should not try to appraise it for more than it is. Certainly, we on this side of the House do not appraise it for less than it is but rather as a continuance of the opportunities we felt were always available in these markets. We will live with it and we will work with it. We tried in this debate to point out its weaknesses so that, if possible, it might be improved in any negotiations which might take place subsequently. We have pledged ourselves that if the Irish people allow us we certainly will not write it down as the last word in Anglo-Irish relations.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lalor Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Lalor) Fianna Fáil

Quite honestly, I must confess that I have had a certain amount of sympathy over the last few days with the Deputies on the other side of the House who have been endeavouring, in a futile way, to belittle this Agreement. Indeed, their efforts could scarcely have been more futile in view of the outstanding value of this Agreement, especially for the agricultural community.

Deputy Jones asked the rather amazing question as to why the Government speakers did not seem to go out of their way to specify and spell out what the individual advantages were. I feel the Government speakers have been so doing but the efforts on the other side of the House in endeavouring to downgrade or to belittle those particular advantages, apparently, have had that effect. Deputy Jones dealt with a particular area in his own constituency—the west Limerick area—as if it were an area comparable with the whole western region, for which I have certain direct responsibilities. He asked in what way this particular Agreement could be of benefit to the small farmers and instanced the case where any benefits which could accrue to the store cattle trade would not be of any great benefit to the small farmer.

The very same accusation was made in connection with the heifer scheme, in so far as that was a scheme which was to benefit the big fellow only. It was alleged that the small farmer, who would appear to be carrying as many cows as he could, could not possibly benefit but we saw how it did over the past couple of years in relation to the increased prices for dropped calves and young heifers. In the very same way, the increase in store cattle prices automatically means benefits all round and, in actual fact, with special reference to the small farmers. Up to this, Irish farmers have had to operate their farms and plan their production under the shadow of insufficient export markets. As much as one half of the production of all our farms must be exported and so the agricultural industry has been particularly dependent on export outlets.

That is one of the problems that have been faced by the Department and the Government for quite a long time. The implementation of the expansion plans for agriculture under the Second Programme for Economic Expansion could be assured only if an adequate and secure export outlet was available. The increased benefits of the Free Trade Area Agreement provide us with this increased outlet. This outlet is now available for the small farmer and the man engaged in horticulture and for the fisherman and they can all go ahead now and increase their output in the knowledge that the market outlet is available.

The assurance of unrestricted access for our store cattle, sheep and lambs and the effect of the reduction from three to two months in the waiting period they must spend on English farms, must be of the greatest benefit. It means better selling prices for Irish farmers. The average store bullock will put on an average of about a half-cwt. in the extra month and this means that half-cwt. can be put on the beast on this side and, at current prices, it is fair to say that the value of the beast can be assessed as from £3 10s. to £4 10s. higher than at present.

Comment on this

That is a very serious reduction. The Minister for Agriculture said £5 to £7.

Comment on this

I am talking about the average beast. It is quite possible that it will be £5 to £7 on a good beast.

Comment on this

I am sure he was taking an average also.

Comment on this

In the case of sheep and lambs the reduction of one month here represents a greater proportion of the animal's life and should give a tremendous fillip to store sheep and lambs. The extra weight that a store lamb can put on in a month could reasonably be expected to increase the total weight of the animal to the extent of an average of about £1 per lamb.

Comment on this

They are down £1 this year.

Comment on this

Our proposal is to get up the lamb prices by £1. The extension of the deficiency payment scheme to the 25,000 tons of Irish carcase beef and 5,500 tons of carcase lamb is certainly a major development. In view of my special concern for the western area I am particularly gratified by this extension of the deficiency payments scheme to carcase lambs. The quantity of 5,500 tons represents close on a quarter of a million lambs and obviously that is a very substantial amount. The other day Deputy Lindsay wondered if the Agreement would be of any great benefit to the western region. I make the point that this benefit in the carcase lamb trade means quite an appreciable gain in view of the fact that the general overall increase in sheep numbers in an area which contains half of the sheep population of the country, namely in the 12 western counties, must bring great benefit to the western area.

Comment on this

It is an area very hungry for lime and phosphate.

Comment on this

We are endeavouring to help small farmers in that area as much as we can under the advisory services and we are trying to get a marked improvement in that connection. Coupled with the improvements secured for store sheep—the reduction in the waiting period and abolition of the ¾d. per pound differential in favour of the British home bred sheep -this should make quite an appreciable difference and benefit the sheep farmers to a greater extent in its own way in that particular part of the country where it is most needed than it would benefit the cattle man. There is no need to labour the point that the store trade in cattle, sheep and lambs is the backbone of our export trade.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

That is generally accepted. In 1964 it represented £43 million of our total exports to all destinations which were valued at £217 million. The improvements now secured for the store trade must accordingly be of fundamental importance not only to the farming community but to the national economy generally. If we see such a high proportion of the trade being carried on in this way and if we visualise two-thirds of the whole export trade in agriculture being concerned the Agreement must be of tremendous benefit to the economy of the State.

As a result of the Agreement there is no doubt that farmers can look forward to an ever-increasing demand for stores. The reduction in the waiting period enables British farmers to have a greater turnover of stock thereby improving the demand and actually helping the British feeder to step up his turnover in turn. In that way it will put a greater proportion of the subsidy into the pockets of the Irish farmers and provide for greater flexibility in business between those engaged in the trade on both sides of the Irish Sea. In general, therefore, it can be said that it will have a great effect in strengthening the store market in this country.

I should like to refer to one further matter in connection with the store trade. Yesterday, Deputy Sweetman made an effort to cover up what can only be described as the appalling ignorance of the arrangements applying to the store trade disclosed in the statement issued by Fine Gael on 20th December last. He made a rather feeble effort to maintain that the waiting period of two months had first been secured by the inter-Party Government in 1958.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): 1948.

Comment on this

1948. In fact, the position is that that two months waiting period had first been secured by a Fianna Fáil Government in 1941 and that was seven years before the 1948 Trade Agreement was negotiated. He also argued that the 1960 Trade Agreement was the first Agreement to refer to the waiting period of three months. This is just another quibble. The fact of the matter is that the waiting period was increased with effect from 28th March, 1956. It was increased under the inter-Party Government. Nothing that Deputy Sweetman can say can change that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And confirmed in a negotiated Agreement in 1960.

Comment on this

It was increased in 1956 and it has been claimed by the Fine Gael Party that it was introduced and was first mentioned in 1960.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): But confirmed in a solemn and formally negotiated Agreement in 1960.

Comment on this

The follow-up of Deputy Sweetman's claim was the further claim that it had not any effect. There is no doubt that this arrangement of 28th March, 1956, was the subject of an exchange of letters and I have seen copies of these letters between the British Minister for Food, Mr. Amery, and the Irish Ambassador in London acting on the instructions and at the dictate of the Minister for Agriculture at the time, Deputy Dillon. It is wrong that Deputy Sweetman should endeavour to confuse the position in that regard. There is no doubt at all about the basic and important fact that 28th March, 1956, was the date on which the waiting period was increased from two months to three months and that it was done by a Fine Gael Minister for Agriculture.

I should like to inform the House of what happened to cattle prices after this unfortunate arrangement which was entered into in 1956. In the six months, April to September, 1955, the average price of store bullocks in Dublin was 140/- per cwt. Then the British guaranteed price was increased by 12/4 d per cwt in March, 1956, and it would be normal to assume that we would be able to command a price of 150/- per cwt in the following six months. This did not happen. As a result of the giving away of what we had at that time by the then Minister for Agriculture, the average price of store bullocks in Dublin in the six months April to September, 1956, was only 111/- per cwt, a price which proved to be in the region of 40/- less than the market price we would have expected at that time. How, then, can Fine Gael maintain that the increase in the waiting period at that time had no effect on store cattle prices?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why did not you get it back in 1960?

Comment on this

Why, then, now when we have got it back, do Fine Gael endeavour to say that the decrease in the three months to two months will be of no significant advantage? Efforts of this nature should not be made in this House to downgrade and belittle what has been done.

Deputy Dillon seems to contend that the 1948 Agreement gave us as much as we now have got in the Free Trade Area Agreement. Nothing could be further from the truth. Agricultural products were dealt with only in the Annex to the 1948 Agreement, which was expressed to operate for a four year period and related entirely to bulk purchase by the British Ministry of Food, which ceased to function before many years had elapsed. No assurance whatever was included about long-term access to the British market and even the price-link between our stores and British beef cattle, of which Deputy Dillon boasts so much, was expressed in loose terms which gave Britain the legal right to increase the price differential provided only the increase was not "excessive". These may seem strong words but they must be said at this time.

Deputy Dillon attempts to explain this away by referring to what the late Sir Stafford Cripps may have said or done subsequently but the fact remains that the provisions of the Annex to the 1948 Agreement remained unamended during the four years for which that Annex lasted. Indeed, it was not until 1953, under a Fianna Fáil Government, that an Agreement was made with the British Government which not only removed any possibility of an increase in the differential but, in fact, reduced it to 4/6 per cwt.

It would be wrong for me, and I am not endeavouring to do so, to belittle the 1948 Agreement, which was probably as good as the then Government could have got at that time. However, it should be clearly understood that the Agreement made no provision for trade under normal conditions when bulk purchasing which was in operation at that time had ended.

Deputy Jones spoke about butter. The basic quota has been increased from 12,905 tons to 23,000 tons. While we had been getting some supplementary allocations from Britain on top of our basic quota, we had no legal or other right to those allocations. If at any stage Britain had too much butter, we would be placed in an impossible position if our butter exports to Britain were confined to that basic figure. The situation would have been disastrous for our dairy industry. This weakness in our position has now been completely eliminated.

Comment on this

For how long?— until 1967.

Comment on this

The point is that we have been given this assurance and there is no reason to believe that the assurance does not last on a permanent basis.

Comment on this

There is no assurance in the Agreement.

Comment on this

It is written into the Agreement——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Until March, 1967.

Comment on this

——that the basic quota is 23,000 tons, with the prospect of having that basic quota increased after a period.

Comment on this

Or reduced.

Comment on this

There is no mention of a reduction.

Comment on this

There is no mention of an increase either.

Comment on this

In relation to our increased output, provision is made for increasing the basic quota.

The improvements in regard to the butter quota and the general assurances with regard to access which, of course, apply to other dairy products such as cheese, milk powder, cream, condensed milk and chocolate crumb, are of the greatest importance and value. They affect an export trade which was worth over £15 million in 1964 and which can be expected to expand substantially in the years ahead. We are fully appreciative of the fact that small farmers are greatly dependent on the monthly milk cheque. They now have a new degree of security as a result of the Agreement and there is every reason to believe that the increased scope for expansion of this vital industry will be of tremendous benefit to the nation.

Before I leave the subject of dairying, I should like to refer to some other remarks made yesterday by Deputy Sweetman. Having been caught out in connection with the inaccuracy about the waiting period in his Party's press statement, one would have expected that Deputy Sweetman would have taken the trouble to check his facts on other matters. Yet, we find him making equally inaccurate statements when speaking yesterday in regard to dairy products. He said that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries had claimed to have got exactly what he had asked for in the case of the butter quota. The Minister was referring to the butter quota for 1966/67 and what he claimed was perfectly correct. He asked for 23,000 tons and he got it.

Comment on this

Until 31st March, 1967.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. The Parliamentary Secretary should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I come now to Deputy Sweetman's big blunder. He went on to talk about the cost of the support on exports of dairy products and he maintained that the crucial thing was that the Government should have insisted on the British deficiency payments being applied to our exports of dairy products. All our problems in relation to dairy products would be solved, in Deputy Sweetman's opinion, if only we got the British deficiency payments. I am afraid that, despite what Deputy Sweetman thinks, the matter is not so simple as that and cannot be solved as easily as he suggests. Even if we were to get the British to agree to apply, as Deputy Sweetman suggests, their deficiency payments to all our exports of dairy produce, we would be no better off, because there are no deficiency payments on dairy products in Britain.

Comment on this

There are no deficiency payments in Britain on dairy products.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It would have been good business to try to get some.

Comment on this

Deputy Sweetman's statement goes to show the Deputy's knowledge, or lack of it, of the conditions under which our dairy produce has to be sold in Britain. And the Deputy's knowledge seems to equal that of his colleagues, incidentally.

Comment on this

They know as much as the Parliamentary Secretary does.

Comment on this

This monopoly of knowledge is interesting.

Comment on this

With regard then to our exports of fish to Britain, so far from our exports of fish to Britain being restricted in the interests of orderly marketing, the position in future will be that there will be no import restrictions at all on our fish into Britain. Deputy Jones dealt with this matter when he was speaking. Not alone will there be no import restrictions under the Agreement but there will not be any restrictions either in the context of an international commodity agreement or in any other context. As well as that, we have reserved the rights to protect our fishing industry.

Comment on this

Before the Parliamentary Secretary finishes with dairy products, would he tell us what the increased quota will cost the Irish taxpayer?

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

£2 million.

Comment on this

Would the Minister for Agriculture care to laugh now?

Comment on this

We do not have to sell elsewhere.

Comment on this

That may be so, but what is the figure? It must be a simple calculation.

Comment on this

It is £2½ million.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies had better make their calculations by way of speech rather than by way of interruption.

Comment on this

Not one of the Deputies opposite knew there were no deficiency payments on dairy products. Do not try to bluff. The Deputies opposite thought there were deficiency payments on dairy products in Britain and there are not. Admit it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order! The Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

There is a figure and the Minister must know what the figure is.

Comment on this

Have you stopped beating your wife yet?

Comment on this

Do not be so childish.

Comment on this

When I hear that expression by the Minister, I can understand why the Minister was clattered with a placard in London.

Comment on this

The Deputy was clattered himself once.

Comment on this

But not by the Minister.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must insist on the Parliamentary Secretary being allowed to speak. Interruptions are disorderly, no matter where they come from.

Comment on this

The question asked by the Leader of the Labour Party is naturally a difficult one to answer. The point is that, if we did not have this access in Britain for increased butter, we would have to try to find an outlet in some other market.

Comment on this

I understand that.

Comment on this