We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.

Contributions 1–187 of 598. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

When the House adjourned last night, I was at the point of concluding with this exhortation. I felt, in respect of the motion before the House governing this Agreement, that it behoved every Deputy to ask himself, on behalf of the constituents of the area which he represents: "Where does the advantage lie for my people?" Whether we come from cities or rural districts we will have to ask: "What advantage is there in this Agreement for the people I represent?" I must certainly say, addressing the question to myself, and I am sure my colleagues from the city of Cork must agree with me, that we see nothing in it. We see a lot of confusion, a lot of apprehension and a lot of unrest. In other words, the industrial workers in the city of Cork are asking themselves: "What am I going to get out of this? Does it mean more security in my job or does it mean there is a very good chance that my job will not be there at all in five or ten years' time?"

I advise my Fianna Fáil colleagues, who represent Cork city, to please stop, think and ask themselves: "What does it mean to the car assembly industry in Cork? What does it mean to the tyre industry in Cork? What does it mean to the boot and shoe industry in Cork?" It may be all very well for other Deputies to say that there is, in the long run, an advantage to the farming community. If that is so, I should like the Minister for Finance, Deputy Healy or Deputy Wyse to go down to the industrial estate in the Marina, to Fords or Dunlops or go up to the Lee Boot and Hanover Shoe Factory and explain that to the workers there. If they think there is no disadvantage to the workers in these industries they should get up and say so now.

Comment on this

I said so.

Comment on this

They should keep on explaining it and not carry on with these promises that in the long run it will be to the advantage of everyone, because the workers in Cork, like the workers throughout the length and breadth of the country, remember the rosy prognostications of the Government Party in the past. They remember them quite well—and I am sure Deputy Healy remembers, because he was one of its greatest advocates— the 100,000 new jobs——

Comment on this

I never said a word about it.

Comment on this

——that were to be created. Obviously Deputy Healy has a very guilty conscience, which I appear to be pricking, because otherwise he would not interrupt me. The people of Cork remember Deputy Healy, the Minister for Finance, and other Fianna Fáil spokesmen, trotting up and down the streets of Cork saying: "In ten years' time, we will have 100,000 new jobs" and those who got their Intermediate and their Leaving Certificates and their degrees from University College, Cork, since then, know where the 100,000 jobs were. They were in Birmingham, Coventry and Dagenham. I say to the House in regard to these rosy promises and prognostications of the good that will flow from this Agreement—we heard it before.

We in the Labour Party, having examined the Agreement dispassionately on behalf of the people we represent, have no hesitation in recommending our amendment to this motion. Our amendment, as everyone knows, is designed to show that having examined the Agreement, we feel the advantage is with Great Britain in the signing of the Agreement, that our negotiators did not get in the Agreement what we feel any reasonable negotiators should get, and that the negotiators on behalf of the United Kingdom successfully negotiated it to their advantage. All that will flow from this in the long-term so far as we are concerned is less employment and more emigration. Because of that the Labour Party are taking the responsible attitude not only of speaking against the Taoiseach's motion but of voting against it as well.

Comment on this

I will be quite brief in this intervention because much of what I wanted to say has been said already. I just wish to refer to two aspects of the Agreement. Before doing so, I should say, of course, that I share the sentiments of my colleagues on the Fine Gael benches in regard to the Government's change of heart on the question of foreign trade. I welcome Fianna Fáil's conversion to an acknowledgment of the importance of foreign trade as much as anyone else. On previous occasions I adverted briefly to an early recollection of mine, on the advent of a Fianna Fáil Government back in 1932, of the closure of Gallaher's tobacco factory on East Wall Road within three months of Fianna Fáil taking office, when 400 people were thrown out of employment because the factory was controlled in Northern Ireland and did not comply with the Fianna Fáil Control of Manufactures Act. It was thrown overboard along with all the rest of the economic doctrines which constituted the Fianna Fáil bible in those days. However, that is past history and we can rejoice in their conversion to a more sane approach to national economics, and try to overlook the high price that has been paid.

The two matters to which I wish to refer are the question of dumping, upon which we are promised early legislation, and also the position of the motor assembly trade about which Deputy Casey spoke. I feel that Government spokesmen are being less than honest with the House in regard to the matter of dumping. Dumping in the old-fashioned sense of the term, the selling of goods at scrap prices on our markets, is a bogey that can be guarded against. The difficulty which will confront Irish industry right from the initial stages after this Agreement comes into operation next July, is not so much crude dumping of the old-fashioned kind, but a more refined form of price cutting, selling at ten per cent or 15 per cent less than the Irish manufacturer's price, or ten per cent or 15 per cent less than the real economic cost. That sort of thing cannot be prevented because it cannot be proved.

We have to admit that quite a lot of the expansion in Irish exports in the past few years has been made possible by this very device. Irish manufacturers who enjoyed a protected home market upon which they were able to recover their manufacturing costs might have a certain slackness in production. Their factories might be kept going catering for the home market for four days a week, and in those circumstances it was quite easy for them to operate on the fifth day and sell their goods abroad. Their overheads having been recovered on the home market, the extra income from the production of the fifth day sold abroad at less than the economic price was so much grist to the mill. If the workers were kicking their heels for four days, and if you kept the factory going for a fifth day, you were not adding substantially to your costs but you were increasing your income. We have to face the fact that quite a lot of our Irish exports were made possible by the use of that device. If the British manufacturers choose to engage in the same procedure, to my mind it will be quite impracticable to try to stop them from doing so. Therefore I suggest that the Minister in his approach is divorced from reality. I suggest that the impact of the Agreement might well be far more serious than the Government spokesmen are prepared to admit.

The Taoiseach was much franker in his statement of the position. It was an amazing thing to sit here the other day and listen to Deputy Seán Lemass speaking of—and I quote his exact words—"high cost, inefficient, obsolescent industries." The Minister for Industry and Commerce indulges in vague generalities and clichés when he says industry must make itself more competitive and that there must be a change in their mental attitude. As many speakers have pointed out, the majority of these small industries have so far shown little indication of any ability to adapt themselves to change. In my view, they are quite unable to do so. I can speak from some personal experience about one case in point, a small factory in the midlands which has a monopoly in the manufacture of a certain commodity widely used in this country. They have a complete monopoly by reason of the fact that there is a prohibitive tariff on the imports of similar goods. I know of a factory owned by their main foreign competitor—they are not really a competitor because they cannot get behind the barrier but they will be able to do so—which is owned by ICI in England. ICI is so diversified that nobody will be able to identify this particular product. In one eight-hour shift this company can produce as much as the small Irish factory can produce in one year. That small Irish factory can never cope with that kind of competition. It will be a damn good job for the Irish consumer when that factory goes out of production because their product, relative to that of ICI, is inferior and far too pricey. It is one of these industries that should not have been created.

It is employing about 40 people and we have to acknowledge that fact and face up to our obligations to these 40 people, most of whom are girls. Perhaps our obligation to them is not as great as it is to the eight or ten male employees but there is an obligation there which I do not think the Government are facing up to. It is true that this Party adopted a far different attitude to the proposal to enter the European Economic Community, by reason of the fact, as Deputy Cosgrave said the other day, there is in the provisions of the Treaty of Rome a stabilisation fund and various compensation measures which would enable displaced workers to be generously compensated. There is no such provision in this Trade Agreement and the Government's failure to face up to this problem so far is something which is causing a lot of worry.

That leads me to the position of the motor assembly trade because it is a typical case in point. It is a trade which directly employs 4,000 people and in the fringe industries employs another 2,000. There are 19 motor assembly plants and of the 4,000 people directly employed, I estimate that about 1,000 are constituents of mine because there are two of these large plants in my constituency. I am personally acquainted with quite a number of these workers, some of them are good friends and supporters of mine. They are very worried indeed. These are semi-skilled men; they are not tradesmen in the conventional old-fashioned sense of the term. They are not members of the craft unions. They are earning a basic wage of about £15 to £16 a week in the Dublin area at present.

The Minister for Industry and Commerce speaking about the motor assembly industry the other day said that the industry had about seven years to adapt itself to the change. It is of course a truism to say that the motor assembly industry "has had it". That is common knowledge. I believe that the Minister in his statement that the industry has seven years to prepare for obsolescence perhaps overstates the position. It is true that the tariffs will not be removed entirely for seven years but I consider that if any one of these assembly plants, say in two years' time, is faced with the introduction of a major change of model in their parent company—say, the Austin people bring in a completely new model—they might well find it quite uneconomic to jig up—that is the term —for the assembly of that model which would remain current for a number of years. It does certainly seem to me that the crisis situation might well be upon us, for individual plants if not for all, much sooner than the Minister calculates.

The Committee of Industrial Organisation made a pretty thorough survey of this trade and it is very clear from skimming through their report that the employers have little or no real incentive to prepare adaptation plans or alternative plans for the carrying on of their factories, by reason of the fact that they will continue to make the same profits as they are earning at present merely by acting as wholesale dealers for their British principals. In fact it might be the case that they will make more profit out of wholesaling their cars under their exclusive agency terms than they are making from assembling them at present. These are tough ruthless business men whose god is profit. They are accustomed to a tradition in this trade of hiring and firing without any regard to humanitarian considerations. The CIO pointed out that rather than work overtime to get out of production crises in the past the custom of the trade has always been to hire men and fire them as soon as they can possibly dispense with them. That is an indication of the tough type of trade it is.

I would go further and say that some of them are people who may well have little or no sense of national responsibility. That is the worrying feature of it. They probably could not care less. Certainly, they have not taken their workers into their confidence. They have made no announcement of their adaptation plans. It is also quite clear they have not taken the Government into their confidence. I believe they have no plans at all for carrying on the employment of their workers. Admittedly, these men are not acknowledged tradesmen or members of a craft union. I have heard it said they will be able to find employment in the expanded set-up which, it is hoped, will develop in the industrial field.

As far as light engineering is concerned—boiler making, plate laying and that sort of thing—I am convinced that much of that type of light engineering work in the new set-up is going to go to Belfast, where they have very big plants and an established tradition in the engineering trade. I feel they are going to knock our light engineering plants for six. Since they are so close at hand, to Dublin at all events, they would be well able to undercut, and I think there will be a general recession in this field.

Therefore, it behoves the Government to step into this situation, to call the employers together and tell them bluntly that they and this House are concerned about the prospects confronting these men. Equally, it behoves the trade union movement to see if it is possible to fit these men into the craft unions. It is amazing the class distinction that exists within the trade union movement and the lack of co-operation which clearly exists between certain types of workers—the snobbish approach the craft unions can adopt towards those with lesser skills. It seems to me that the members of the National Union of Vehicle Builders might well be out on a limb in the situation I have spoken of.

I do not think there is very much more to say on that question of the assembly industry except to appeal to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to come down out of the clouds. I doubt if the Minister, with his admirable traits of character, is tough enough for these types of employers in the motor assembly trade. I think they could pull the wool over his eyes. They are tough and ruthless. Their god is profit. Some of them have no sense of their national obligation. The Lord knows they have made ample profits out of the industry in the past. It is time now to call them to heel.

Comment on this

This debate is continuing in a rather unreal atmosphere. Everybody expected that the Opposition Parties would criticise and find fault with the Agreement. It would have been most unexpected if they had congratulated the Government on their achievement. But they have been continuing for four days repeating themselves over and over without suggesting any real alternatives. I do not think they can say it is not their business to do so. The best they could suggest was that they could have got a better bargain. That is a matter of opinion. But, since they were not the negotiators, surely they should point out where they could have done better?

Opposition speakers have been speaking with divers tongues. On the first day of the debate I heard a member of the Front Bench of the chief Opposition Party make a weighty speech full of wisdom. He said we had got nothing from the British in this so-called bargain, that everything was weighted in favour of Britain and that they had mesmerised the Taoiseach. But almost in the same breath he said Harold Wilson was playing for the Irish vote in his constituency in the general election that would certainly take place in Britain in the next few months. If he were playing for the Irish vote in his constituency, surely he would be trying to please the Irish in Liverpool and he would not do that by driving a hard bargain.

What struck me about the speeches from the Opposition was their note of pessimism about the future of the country. Invariably, things were going to be bad, workers sacked, the British or somebody else would take over our economy, there was no future and nothing would succeed. I was disappointed and rather amazed at the attitude of a Cork Deputy who knows better than to speak here about the future of industry in Cork and paint a gloomy picture about all those who have to emigrate and give up their council houses. It is perfectly obvious to anybody from Cork that there is a tremendous expansion of industry there at present. The industry most in jeopardy, we are told, is the motor industry. Yet the Ford factory in Cork are spending £1,500,000 on a new building, which is two-thirds complete, and Dunlops are spending £1,000,000. Surely nobody will believe they would be so foolish to spend such huge sums of money on an industry whose future is in jeopardy?

I should like to draw the attention of Deputy Casey and other Deputies to the tremendous possibilities there for the other Cork industries. When I say "Cork industries", I do not mean it parochially for Cork. The Sunbeam Wolsey factory, according to today's papers, will spend £800,000 in buying new machinery and they are putting the money into Tullamore and other places far away from Cork. The future, to my mind, was never so bright for the industrial workers of Cork and for the country generally. I think, also, that those who are interested in these matters should have a look at the stock market which is a rather sensitive barometer of what industrialists think of the future of industry in this country. It will be found that, since this Agreement was signed, the stock market has behaved very buoyantly indeed. Therefore, there must be no lack of confidence amongst industrialists as to the future of the country's economy.

I am sorry to have to say that I think some of the Labour speakers I heard are completely out of touch with reality. I heard them speak here about the Act of Union, comparing 1965 with the Act of Union which took place in 1801. There was talk of selling out the country and of making the position worse than it was before 1922. Anybody who would believe in that pessimistic tone is either completely immature or out of touch with reality. At the time of the Act of Union there was no League of Nations, there was no United Nations organisation, there was no GATT and there was no EEC. At the time of the Act of Union there was no co-operation between nations. Each nation depended on itself.

Nowadays, the world is drifting towards a situation where the nations are co-operating. They are behaving as they should behave and are coming into one big organisation or one Parliament. To think that in 1965 any country would behave as it might have seen fit to behave in 1840, for instance, is completely unreal.

There was mention of a change of heart and of the conversion of Fianna Fáil. The Deputy who has just sat down even spoke about Gallaher's factory going away from this part of the country in 1932. He omitted to say that in 1932 Fianna Fáil restored the 1/- that had been taken from the old age pensioners around that time.

In spite of tremendous opposition from the political Parties opposed to Fianna Fáil—the country's industries which were established were sneered at for 20 years afterwards as being backyard industries that could not possibly succeed—it is interesting to note that those industries are now having as defenders the very people who opposed their setting up. Fianna Fáil need make no apologies for protecting those industries until they were able to stand on their feet. They did that very successfully and few fell. In spite of those that may have failed, very many industries were a credit to the country and succeeded against all competition from outside.

I consider that this is a very good Agreement. Far from Mr. Wilson's mesmerising the Taoiseach, I am sure, generally speaking, that the people of the country are in no way influenced by what has been said in this House by certain pessimistic speakers. The vast majority of the people are very well pleased with the Agreement. They are very satisfied also, that, at the last election and at previous elections, they elected men in whom they had confidence. For at least 20 years I have been hearing some opponents of the Government say that Fianna Fáil duped the people, made fools of the people, made false promises to the people. Such remarks are a sad reflection by those who uttered them on the intelligence of the Irish people. It was also foolish to think that they can be fooled all the time.

The fact is, of course, and it is just as well to face up to it, that Fianna Fáil have had the confidence of the people, generally speaking, for the past 30 years. On the two occasions when they gave the others a chance, they had every reason to regret doing so. This time, I think they are satisfied that their negotiators made a good bargain. Many people I know in Cork are looking to see what England has got out of it, because it seems too good to be true. Our negotiators should be congratulated on the work they have done. If we come here in five years or ten years' time, unlike Deputy Casey and other pessimists, I am certain we shall see the country very much more prosperous than it is today and in no small measure that will be due to the Agreement that has just been signed.

Comment on this

No matter what Fianna Fáil speakers may say in this House, or outside the House, the fact is that this Agreement marks a decided and a radical change and departure from Fianna Fáil policy as we have known it for the past 30 years. As far as I am concerned, the Government are welcome to whatever propaganda benefit they can derive from the present Agreement. Let there be no doubt about it, at the present time they need to bolster up their waning fortunes and to keep the people's minds off the real and pressing problems that confront them in Ireland today.

Propaganda has kept Fianna Fáil in office for a long number of years. They must throw dust in the people's eyes. They must pull the wool over the people's eyes. They believe that if the people are promised pie in the sky in the propaganda sheets, in the Irish Press, on the radio and on television they may forget the credit squeeze, the housing shortage and the depression we are experiencing today.

Listening to the Taoiseach speak here on Tuesday last one would think he was elected to power for the first time last April, when, in fact, we all know he has been in office for, I think, 27 of the past 33 years and that he, and he alone, is responsible for the plight of the country today. It is a long time since I first heard the Taoiseach state that we are breasting the hill, that the next year may be difficult but that if the country will give them another year they will be over the hill. We have been listening to that type of thing from the Taoiseach for the past 30 years.

We are entitled to ask what is in this Agreement. It is all right for Deputy Healy to come in here and to talk about deep tones of pessimism and to say that we are pessimistic. In present circumstances optimistic speeches are of no use to the people today: they want a bit of realism. Compare what we read in the Irish Independent of today with the optimistic speech just made by Deputy Healy. Then it will be realised that his approach will be of very little use to the people. Here is what I read in this morning's Irish Independent under the heading “Sharp Rise in Number of Unemployed”:

The total registered unemployed on December 31st was 63,714, which was 7,310 higher than December 17th, was 4,638 above the most comparable date—January 1st, 1965—and 5,101 higher than January 4th, 1964.

What will these people get out of this Trade Agreement? Deputy Healy spoke of the expansion of industry in Cork. The inter-Party Government were responsible for bringing Verolme to Cork, which has brought £12 million into this country. He mentioned that industries were established in the face of fierce opposition from Fine Gael. That is completely untrue because those on this side of the House, the first people to start the Shannon Scheme and the first of our beet factories—although they may have been called white elephants at that time——

Comment on this

At 21/- a week.

Comment on this

I cannot understand Deputy O'Connor's type of nationalism. When he spoke here the other day about the Buy Irish campaign, he should have addressed his remarks, first of all, to the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, or to the Department of Transport and Power. When he stated he could not get Irish socks, he blamed the people for it and then when he purchased a car in Ireland which did not give him the service it should, he said the sooner the people who produced that type of car go to the wall the better.

Comment on this

I do not intend to deny it.

Comment on this

But, at the same time, it was a very funnty type of argument to put up.

Deputy Healy asked: what will England get out of this Agreement? Unfortunately, it would appear they will get a million of our Irish workers, as they have got under Fianna Fáil since 1932. 1,100,000 emigrants were driven from this country. As we have already stated, this Agreement is unbalanced. The concessions are all on one side.

It might be no harm to say, of course, that this Agreement, as far as agriculture is concerned, vindicates those who built up our country and who were condemned so vigorously by the Fianna Fáil Party in the past. They are those on our side of the House who were dubbed as being pro-British because they believed, in the past, in the improvement of the British market. They believed in co-operating with our neighbour and they believed it was the best market. I remember taunts thrown at Deputy Dillon on this side of the House as being Minister for Grass when he dared to say, after the 1948 Agreement, that we must improve the land of this country to increase our exports as we were, to a large extent, dependent on the British market as one of our best markets.

As far as agriculture is concerned, no matter what the Minister for Agriculture may say, we are back to where we were in 1932 but, unfortunately for us, the Six Counties and the rest of the world have made wonderful progress since then because they had sane Governments. Let us remember this— and it is very important to remember it—that up to 1932 exports from Northern Ireland and the Twenty-six Counties increased at much the same rate. What has happened since then? Total exports from the Twenty-six Counties in 1964 were £222 million but the total exports from the Six Counties in 1964 were £425 million, because they adopted the same policy from 1932, the belief that you must live by exports and that you have to live by exports. Six small little counties in the north-east of Ireland are exporting over twice the amount exported by the Twenty-six Counties. Then, we talk about the wonderful progress we are supposed to have made in this country under the Fianna Fáil Government.

We are told, of course, we should not go back to the past, but remember the temptation is bound to be there because, when we talk about this Agreement, the 1938 and the 1948 Agreements, we must remember what was said by Fianna Fáil in the past. They told us, as has been stated here on numerous occasions, that the British market was gone for ever, thanks be to God. This Agreement abandons, I hope, for ever, the isolationist policy of Fianna Fáil and the man who is now traversing the world and will not stay for a week in the small little country he once advocated we should stay in, is telling Vietnam, Russia, China and the rest of the world how they should manage their affairs.

Comment on this

And Germany.

Comment on this

But, in any case, he said if every ship on the sea were sent to the bottom of the sea, we could do without England and the rest of the world. If every ship on the sea had been sent to the bottom of the sea, he could not have his little trips all round the world he is having at the present time.

Comment on this

He travels by plane, which you people scrapped.

Comment on this

Has Deputy Cunningham read today's paper?

Comment on this

The Deputy's Party put them to the bottom of the sea.

Comment on this

Deputy Cunningham's Party are throwing 7,600 more people on the unemployment scrap-heap.

Comment on this

This is a fair day speech.

Comment on this

Now Fianna Fáil are cooking the unemployment figures.

Comment on this

It was interesting to listen to the new convert, the Minister for Agriculture, when he spoke about agriculture. He said that he who knows not and knows that he knows not, could be a wise man. The Minister for Agriculture could even be the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party at some time, but he who knows not and knows not that he knows not is either a fool or a knave. But, at the same time, he is not as well up in agricultural figures as he makes out to be. The Minister for Agriculture came in here and told us we would make £10 million. When he was asked to break that down, he refused to do so and stuck to his script.

I remember the man who is now Uachtarán of this country when he spoke in County Longford——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The President should not be brought into this.

Comment on this

He was an active politician——

Comment on this

He was the Taoiseach at one time. Surely ex-Taoiseachs can be quoted.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

He is being quoted as President.

Comment on this

——a leading light in the Fianna Fáil Party, still very well known and who intends to stay in politics for a number of years still. He stated at one time there was no further use for cattle. He even went so far as to advise the people to keep bees, that he had been told on good authority that Egyptian bees were the best, that we should eat more honey and drink more milk. Now, with our adverse trade balance of £153 million, the realist we have now as Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party would look very well, himself and his Ministers, with a couple of thousand swarms of bees under their arms, trying to do away with our adverse trade balance.

We are told this is a wonderful Agreement and I suppose we will be told, as we were told in the past, that we whipped John Bull, left, right and centre. It might be no harm to quote what the very same man said a few years ago, in Volume 71, Column 45, of the Official Report:

... I wished, like a number of other Irishmen, that Ireland was 500 miles farther out in the Atlantic Ocean or, alternatively, was between Britain and the Continent.

At that time we had no use for Britain and wanted to be far away from her and get markets on the Continent or anywhere else. The wheel has turned full circle.

Comment on this

And the Deputy advocated that nobody should sell land to the Germans but he was the first man to sell it.

Comment on this

Anything I sold, I bought in my day and I often found it hard to pay for it, but I put it all together and I was offered a good price for it. It was sold to an Irish firm. I ask the Deputy to go to the Minister for Justice or the Minister for Lands and find out whether the firm to which I sold the land paid five per cent or 25 per cent stamp duty on it. That is the test.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise on the Free Trade Agreement.

Comment on this

But if somebody makes a personal allegation, I am entitled to reply to it. I broke no law and I did not rob a bank. I bought a farm as good, or even better, thank God.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear it.

Comment on this

It was one of the best things that ever happened. We hear much of Fianna Fáil seeking publicity because of this Trade Agreement. and claiming it is such a good Agreement. If a blackguard stuck a dagger in a girl's breast and later gave her a blood transfusion and later took out the dagger and then appeared before the judge, I wonder what he would get. He would get about two years in jail. The present Government stuck a dagger in the heart of Kathleen Ní Houlihan in 1932. They may have given a blood transfusion with the 1938 Agreement and taken out the dagger with the 1948 Agreement. Then they want us to throw up our eyes to heaven to say what a wonderful Agreement it is.

It must be hard for Fianna Fáil to realise that they have now swallowed every promise they made. If Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Dillon and Deputy Sweetman had gone to London with their colleagues and secured this Agreement, Fianna Fáil would say that we had sold the North, that we had sold our physical freedom, that we had delivered the Irish people into the slavery of the base, bloody and brutal Saxon. We are now back where we were in 1932, with the difference, let it be remembered, that in 1932, we had free entry for goods into the British market, unrestricted by any conditions such as are in a document like this Trade Agreement. The full extent of the restriction is only becoming apparent now.

In that context I want to quote the former Deputy Dr. Ryan as reported at column 253 of volume 71 of the Official Report when he said

The British market was a free and open market up to seven or eight years ago.

He admitted that in 1938. I should perhaps also quote the present Taoiseach as reported at column 166 of volume 71 when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. He said:

Up to 1932 Great Britain was a free trade country. The agricultural produce of all countries had free entry to the British market and, in fact, the greater number of industrial products had similar unrestricted entry into that market.

We cannot say much for this Agreement. Both Dr. Ryan and the Taoiseach admit that there was free entry up to 1932. Why are Fianna Fáil now trying to fool us and tell us that for the first time we have free access to the British market when, according to their own words, we had it up to 1932? We are also told by certain Fianna Fáil speakers that this is the first time we had free access to the British market, but at column 168 of volume 71 of 28th April, 1938, in reference to the Agreement negotiated by Fianna Fáil, the present Taoiseach said:

Articles 1, 2 and 3 of this Trade Agreement secured for our producers again free entry into the British markets.

According to the Government speakers this is a marvellous Agreement and a great advance on anything achieved in the past. We heard the Taoiseach telling us about the great man Mr. Wilson is. The Taoiseach seems to have been mesmerised by Mr. Wilson and he told us he was a very good fellow. I suppose the next time the Taoiseach goes over they will have a party and they will sit together with the Union Jack wrapped around them, or perhaps sing "Rule, Britannia". No doubt Fianna Fáil have changed very much.

There are very doubtful advantages for agriculture in the Trade Agreement but in the case of industry the reverse is true. The Fianna Fáil speakers remind me of lines in a poem by Southey:

But what good came of it at length? Quoth little Peterkin, "Oh, that I cannot tell," said he, "But ' twas a famous victory."

We are opening the entire Irish industrial market after a certain number of years to the full flow of industrial products from the most efficient industrial producer in the world.

Comment on this

Deputy Ryan has no fear for the industries in his constituency.

Comment on this

I only wish you were right. The Taoiseach has said we must put up alternatives. Would there be anything wrong in making a temporary Agreement with the British Government for a definite time? Let us take our trade with Britain in 1964 when we sold them £160 million worth and Britain purchased from us £129,774,000, a difference of £30 million. We are a small nation while Britain is a large and mighty one. Why could our Government not say: "Our adverse trade balance is £30 million and our people cannot afford that; we are prepared to make a barter Agreement with you. We are one of your best customers: purchase another £30 million worth from us in the next few years and we will then go about making a Trade Agreement with you."

Comment on this

The Deputy said that we sold them £160 million worth and that they bought £129 million worth.

Comment on this

We exported to Britain £129,774,000 worth.

Comment on this

That is what you said they bought from us.

Comment on this

We should send Deputy L'Estrange to Britain.

Comment on this

We sold £129,774,000 worth to Britain.

Comment on this

The Deputy has it right now.

Comment on this

I am sorry; I suppose I used the words "import" and "export" wrongly. There is an adverse trade balance as far as we are concerned of £30 million odd. Would it not have been better if we had gone over and made even a barter agreement? Remember that in Volume CXII——

Comment on this

What year is that?

Comment on this

I am not certain. ——Deputy Lemass advocated something similar then. He said that we had an adverse trade balance with Britain at that time and there was no reason why we could not have made in 1948 an Agreement with Britain that she would purchase more from us until we got on level terms and then made a better agreement.

In this Agreement, in certain details, the Government have gone beyond what prudence would dictate. I believe that Fine Gael would not have signed this Agreement. We would have looked for a much better agreement. As many speakers have said, Britain has not been generous. Britain is a business nation. She has driven a hard bargain and in this Agreement Britain has everything to gain and very little to lose, while we have a lot to lose and very little to gain. We have cattle, sheep and meat to sell to Britain that Britain cannot produce at home. Let that be remembered. An industrial country can build huge factories on a small acreage of land and develop industrial production but cannot produce store cattle. Britain was dependent on our store cattle and could not get store cattle from any other country in the world. There is no reason why we could not have struck a much harder bargain. Britain is crying out for store cattle and could not import them from any other part of the world. Britain could not import store cattle from Europe because of foot and mouth disease. She certainly could not import them live from Australia, Canada, New Zealand or the Argentine. The cattle would be dead before they would arrive in Britain. Britain is dependent on our cattle. We could have struck a harder bargain than we did.

We are told that this is a Free Trade Agreement. It is not a Free Trade Agreement as far as butter is concerned. It has been pointed out by previous speakers that in selling butter to John Bull, we have to put a 1/- or ? postal order around each lb. of butter and that it was costing us £112 per ton to subsidise the British people to eat our butter.

Another very bad provision in this Agreement is the fact that we must first send to Britain 638,000 stores, even if continental countries are prepared to pay us much more than Britain is paying us. If the Germans or the French offer us £10 to £15 a head more for our cattle, we must first supply Britain with 638,000. When people speak about the wonderful achievement that is, they should remember that in 1956 we exported 650,000 store cattle and that in 1927, we were exporting over 700,000 store cattle to Britain.

To many people this Agreement looks like a complete and voluntary sell-out of our limited economic independence. We have the situation now where England has all the industry and employment opportunities and Ireland becomes a ranch once again, supplying unprocessed food to Britain. This applies particularly to the cattle trade. This is something which the present Uachtarán would not agree with if he were active in politics. It might be no harm to quote what he said at column 447, volume 71:

I think it would be a disaster—a national disaster—if we were to go back simply to grass, and if I thought—though I think on the whole the Agreement is satisfactory and there are things in it I want— that we were going back again to grass, simply going to be a ranch and maintaining only the people a ranch could maintain under world conditions, then I would prefer to scrap that Agreement and that my name never appeared to it.

No matter what anybody has stated, in this Agreement we are going back simply to grass and are becoming a ranch again to supply cattle and sheep to Britain.

Let us remember that a Trade Agreement with a number of countries, such as would be involved in the Common Market, is one thing and that an arrangement with a country which already dominates us to an undue extent is a completely different thing. In my opinion, it is economic suicide in our present circumstances.

I should like to quote from Dr. Labhras Ó Nualláin, Lecturer in Economics in University College, Dublin. Speaking about free trade, he said:

A proposal of this kind is a confession of defeat and despair. Integration with other countries of Western Europe is one thing, a desirable objective and one which I believe will eventually materialise. Integration with one country, and that country being Britain, in the present state of our economic development might lead to prosperity for a few, perhaps, but also to continued economic stagnation and to a further depopulation of Ireland and the crumbling away of the Irish nation. We could expect from economic integration with Britain alone a further draining away of our resources of capital, labour and enterprise, leaving Ireland a sucked out orange, dry, useless and unattractive.

This Agreement can be described as something that may mean prosperity for a few but any Government should be interested, not in a few, but in all the people of the country.

There is nothing in this Agreement for the small farmer, the backbone of the country, and who, we have been told by Fianna Fáil speakers on numberous occasions, were the people who returned Fianna Fáil to power since 1932. On numerous occasions in the Seanad Dr. Ryan has boasted of the fact that the small farmers of Ireland stood loyally by Fianna Fáil. They have been badly let down in this Agreement. There is nothing for the poultry keeper or egg producer, very little for the pig producer. There may be something in it for the rancher and the large farmer but there is very little in it for the small farmers of Donegal.

Comment on this

There is something in it for them.

Comment on this

I should like to see what it is.

Comment on this

And for the Kerry small farmers.

Comment on this

I cannot see what it is.

Comment on this

That does not prove anything.

Comment on this

The signing of this Agreement shows the full impact of the Fine Gael constructive criticism of the Fianna Fáil Party for the last number of years. Let there be no denying the full flight from their policy of recent years. Fianna Fáil now realise that industries are not white elephants and that calves are not born to be slaughtered. They have been giving a grant of £15 per head to have them reared.

Comment on this

What about old age pensioners?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil now believe in co-operation.

Comment on this

This is a well-worn record.

Comment on this

Will Deputy O'Connor tell me how much better off was the old age pensioner last year, having regard to the depreciation in the value of money, than he was in 1931?

Comment on this

The Deputy should stick to the Trade Agreement. He is good on it.

Comment on this

1/- per week.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of old age pensions does not arise. Deputy L'Estrange should be allowed to speak. The Deputy has already spoken.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil now believe in co-operation, co-operation with the North and with Britain. We are delighted at their conversion, but it has come 30 years too late. It is a pity they did not believe in co-operation years ago. Had they done so many of our young people, who died in the last ten, 12 or 20 years, would be alive today.

We welcome this type of Agreement, or any Agreement which shows that we want to co-operate with our people in the North and with Britain. At the same time, we do not believe in selling our industrialists down the river, as will happen under this Agreement. I believe much better advantages could have been obtained for our industrialists. The Minister for Justice shakes his head. But why not? Last year we purchased £30 million more from Britain than they took from us. Surely, it should have been possible to point out to them that we are a small, depressed nation, that things are not going too well at the present time, that we took £30 million more worth of goods from Britain last year and the least they could do is to purchase £30 million worth of goods more from us this year. Had that been done we should have been in a position to argue on equal terms. The Minister for Finance, and other Fianna Fáil speakers, said they had not gone hat in hand but if they did not, they certainly came back with their tails between their legs and with a very bad Agreement.

It has taken 30 years to teach Fianna Fáil a sane policy, to see the foolishness of their past economic policy and their hair shirt policy of the 30s. They have now been taught political maturity, but, unfortunately, the country has suffered in the process of their learning. Of course, the members of Fianna Fáil and those associated with them did not suffer.

During the general election campaign in 1961, the present Taoiseach said we would go it alone. Now he says he is not prepared to go it alone; we will hang on to Britain's coat tails and, if Britain gets into the EEC, we will go in with her. We remember, too, that the present Uachtarán was against free trade.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think the President should be dragged into the debate.

Comment on this

I will say "A venerable gentleman who is still active in politics and who intends to stay in politics." On one occasion, speaking about free trade, he said the law of the jungle prevailed both within the State, concerning the individuals in the State, and between one State and another. We are the junior partner in this Agreement and I do not think we will come out of it very well if the law of the jungle prevails. He said further——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He was not speaking as President. He made that statement as Taoiseach or as a Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle will not forget that the President was nominated at a Fianna Fáil convention. His nomination to the Presidency of the State was announced at the Fianna Fáil Árd Fheis.

Comment on this

Very bad taste.

Comment on this

And, that being so, he is in politics by his own election.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is entitled to quote him either as Taoiseach or Minister, but not as President.

Comment on this

Has he actually given back his Party membership card?

Comment on this

At any rate, he stated on the same occasion that a free trade policy was one for which we did not stand:

We saw it in operation for the greater part of the nineteenth century and for the beginning of the twentieth. The people revolted against it, and a national policy was set up.

Where is the national policy now? It seems to be dead and buried along with a great many other policies. He further stated:

The people set out not merely to seek political freedom but to get economic freedom.

There is nothing about economic freedom now. It is forgotten. We are tied to the British and the subsidies being paid cannot be dispensed with unless and until there has been consultation with the British Government.

In order to get economic freedom they based their policy mainly on protection, because it was the only policy that would enable them to have any measure of real freedom.

They saw the Free Trade Policy working out in the depopulation of the country, a depopulation that reduced the number of people living in Ireland from eight and a quarter to four and a quarter millions.

They decided that if this nation was to survive we would have to have protection for the industries of our people.

That is what he had to say about free trade. But he was proved wrong in his arguments in relation to that policy when he spoke about depopulation because we all know that, under Fianna Fáil, we now have only 2.8 million people in the country. We know that 1,100,000 emigrated since 1932. However, according to him, we will now have further depopulation. If that is proved to be accurate, our villages and small towns will be wiped out and in a short time the countryside will resemble a desert.

We have always believed in the desirability and the inevitability of a movement towards freer trade. We believe our position and the conditions necessary for economic survival would be bettered by membership of EEC, even by associate membership along the lines being sought by the Austrian Government at the moment. We believe that closer relations with Europe have other attractions and would reduce our over-dependence on one country. We all know there is safety in numbers and, within the EEC, we would enjoy, with other small nations the protection of the Community. We would enjoy, with other small nations, ticularly the benefit of the stabilisation fund which was dealt with earlier to day by another speaker.

This Agreement will simply result in the absorption of our small economy in a larger one. The gentleman to whom I referred earlier said on numerous occasions that political independence without economic independence is an illusion. The Party on the opposite benches have heard that at numerous Fianna Fáil meetings. We regret, as we are entitled to regret, the fact that the Government have made no effort to negotiate an associate agreement with the EEC, an agreement which would and could take account of our special relationship with Britain but, at the same time, opening up new markets to our farmers and industrialists. Instead of doing that the Government have tied themselves hand and foot. We must first sell 638,000 head of store cattle to Britain before we sell to any European country. Fianna Fáil have allowed relations with the EEC to stagnate since the breakdown in the Brussels talks three years ago. They have made no attempt to secure an agreement for Ireland. The Minister for External Affairs, who should be busying himself along these lines, attending to this very important business, is occupied elsewhere.

If the Agreement is so good, why has there to be such an effort made by the Fianna Fáil Party to sell it on radio, television and in Government-sponsored newspapers? They concentrated mostly on the economic aspects of the pact and tend to obscure the wider and more permanent implications.

The emphasis up to the present has been on what we are supposed to get out of the bargain. That is what we are told it is, a bargain, rather than what has been given away in the name of our people by the Fianna Fáil Government and without the people's approval. There was far too much secrecy about this. The Taoiseach admits that three years ago the idea of making a free trade agreement with Britain pending developments in EEC was first put forward to the British Government by us. Did he tell the Irish people that he was putting it forward, the people from whom he has to get a mandate? It must be remembered that he, just as every other politician, is a servant of the Irish people. He also said on the same occasion that he had discussed this question with Mr. Wilson in November, 1964. There was a general election held six months after that. If he thought that free trade would be good for this country, was it not his duty and his responsibility to go before the Irish people and to say to them: "I am negotiating a free trade agreement with Britain. I believe it will be in the interests of the Irish people. I want a mandate from you and I want to put all the facts before you?" He did not do that at that time because we all know that if he did he would have got a different answer.

A tremendous effort has been made to sell this Agreement to the Irish people. Farmers are being dazzled by the prospects of better prices. Even the Minister for Agriculture has told us they are going to get £10 million more. We are told there is a bigger quota for butter. Why call it a Free Trade Agreement? Did anyone ever hear of a Free Trade Agreement with quotas? On examining this Agreement closely we have to say we see nothing in it for the small farmer. We see nothing for the farmer who produces poultry and eggs. We see nothing for the man who produces milk and who is selling it in this country at the lowest price in Europe. We know what the wife of the small farmer who rears turkeys got for them this Christmas. Some people were lucky enough but others, unfortunately, had to sell them at 1/6d or 1/- a lb., or at less than one-third of the cost of production. There is nothing in this Agreement to improve their lot or to help to keep these small farmers on the land of Ireland.

When we speak of Trade Agreements we should give credit where credit is due. If we do that, then we must admit that the 1948 Trade Agreement was the second best agreement ever signed in this country. I have no hesitation in putting the 1921 Treaty first because it was the stepping-stone to all we have in this country today. Deputy Davern condemned us yesterday for not voting against this Agreement. Fianna Fáil did the very same thing in 1948. We are prepared to be national-minded. We know that the country is in the dumps and let us admit that if this Agreement had not been signed, then there would be no agreement when the other one had lapsed. If this was not ratified, we could have chaos in the country and those who are investing money here might be inclined to withdraw it. We do not want to do anything that might interfere with our economy. We do not agree with this pact. We think it is unbalanced but, at the same time, we do not intend to go into the Division Lobbies——

Comment on this

Is your whole argument not against the investment of money? Every industry was going to suffer.

Comment on this

I cannot follow the Deputy's Kerry accent. Let us examine the 1948 Agreement and compare it with this Agreement. We all remember that in 1948 there was the lowest number of cattle, sheep and pigs we ever had in living memory. The people of England were rationed to two ounces of meat per week. When there was a change of Government the then Ministers, Deputy James Dillon, Deputy John A. Costello, ex-Deputy D. Morrissey and the late Deputy William Norton, went over to England and negotiated that Agreement. Having very little underground wealth, coal, steel and ore, as Deputy Dillon has often said, every one of us depends for his prosperity on what our farmers and workers are able to get from the land and export abroad. It is essential to get the money to buy the raw materials to keep the wheels of industry turning and to pay our way. That Agreement was negotiated in 1948 and for the first time in the history of this country we were allowed to get deficiency payments for our cattle that were being brought to the British farmer. There is very little improvement in this with the exception of the payment which may or may not accrue to us on beef and lamb. In the last eight months of 1965 in only one week was the deficiency payment made on beef.

Immediately after that Agreement, what happened? There was such an improvement in agriculture that cows went up from the £1 at which they were being sold in 1947 to as high as £30 each. The price of three-year-old cattle increased from £30 to £60 and £70 in many cases. The people who negotiated that Agreement had the wisdom and the foresight to include in it a clause that every increase the British farmer got for his livestock was passed on to us. There was a differential of 5s per hundredweight but practically every increase they got was passed on to us. Every increase the National Farmers Union fought for and secured for their farmers was passed on to us, and it is on that account——

Comment on this

They threw in the sponge and got out.

Comment on this

Who threw in the sponge?

Comment on this

The Government.

Comment on this

They certainly did not. They got all these advantages for us and they did not sell out industry. The Deputy knows that as well as I do, and he also knows that if farmers are selling cattle at £60 or £70 over the past ten, 15 or 20 years it is because of the Agreement negotiated in 1948. The arch-patriots of the Fianna Fáil Party have always said: "England's difficulty is Ireland's opportunity." England was in difficulties recently because she could not get store cattle. It was our opportunity. Did they make any use of it?

During the war, after the signing of the 1938 Agreement, Britain was in difficulties. Her ships were being sent to the bottom of the ocean, her people were rationed to two ounces of meat a week, yet the arch-patriots of Fianna Fáil, who had then an opportunity of going to Britain and demanding a fair price for our beef and mutton, refused to do so. They gave to a Britain on the verge of starvation our cattle and sheep at give-away prices. It was not until the Agreement of 1948 was signed that the farmers of Ireland got a chance, that they began to have confidence in a Minister for Agriculture.

At that time our farmers, for the first time in many years, had confidence that they could go ahead and plan their economy with the assurance that for their increased production they would have a ready market at a fair return. They have had that fair return in respect of their cattle and sheep from that date. There was nothing in the 1948 Agreement affecting our industries. There was nothing in it that would close down some industries as there is in this Agreement.

Comment on this

Yet the people immediately afterwards threw you out of office.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Ireland has often excommunicated some of those who served her best and crowned those who served her worst. The Minister for Agriculture told us of the wonderful improvements this Agreement would provide for agriculture. He said it was worth at least £10 million a year. We asked him to give us a break down of that but he refused.

Comment on this

It is obvious.

Comment on this

With the exception of the carcase subsidy and the Exchequer relief through the beef subsidy, the Agreement merely continues what we had. Let us find out what the British have to say about it. If any concessions were given to the Irish farmer, the British are the people who would cry loudest and condemn their Government for giving away concessions, just as we are condemning the Government at the moment. Here is what the Chairman of the National Farmers Union in Britain, Sir Harold Woolley, had to say, as reported in the Irish Independent of 17th December last.

After a meeting of his council in London, he said that as a result of representations made by the union during the negotiations, the Irish had merely confirmed their position in the British market for a wider range of commodities.

Note the word "merely". In other words, there was no change from the Agreement negotiated in 1948 by Deputies Dillon, Morrissey and others. The present Agreement merely confirms the 1948 one. That is far from what we are being told by Government Deputies and supporters. The British farmers are affected by this Agreement and if their pockets were hit by it, if the shoe pinched them, the chairman of their organisation would have told all about it.

Comment on this

He would have been fired by his organisation if he had said anything else.

Comment on this

In Ireland you may be in organisations and tell as many lies as you like and you will get away with it. You will never be fired by the Irish people as long as you are able to throw dust in their eyes. We have heard a lot in the last few days about nationality, about the Buy Irish campaign. When this Agreement comes into operation they cannot advocate the buying of Irish.

Comment on this

That is nonsense.

Comment on this

It cannot be advocated by the Government. Perhaps they can get their men to do it down the country, which is another thing altogether. Fianna Fáil Deputies should tell the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Transport and Power to buy Irish. Deputy Ryan and Labour Deputies got information during the year that these Ministers were buying goods from abroad, were placing contracts abroad. That able old warrior, Deputy Corry, the other day showed that out of 26 ships 23 were sent outside the country for repair. That is a scandalous state of affairs. Deputy O'Connor should speak to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and the Minister for Transport and Power and tell them to place their orders for Irish goods. Had they been doing that we might not have had an adverse trade balance with Britain in 1964 of £30 million. It might be no harm here if we try to find out what monopoly of nationalism Fianna Fáil have. They may have had it in the past but they have damn little since the signing of this Agreement. The 1921 Treaty was the best Agreement we had. It was the stepping stone to everything we have got today and Deputy Brian Lenihan——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

The Minister for Justice would not now be sitting where he is if it were not for that Agreement. Neither would An tUachtarán be where he is, in the Park——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have told the Deputy that the President may not be dragged into debates.

Comment on this

At any rate, all those people would not be in their positions today if it were not for the 1921 Agreement. Because of it, the Fianna Fáil Government were able to go to Britain and negotiate this Agreement. Unfortunately, a perverted type of history has been allowed to be taught in the schools and it was not until the death of W.T. Cosgrave that it was brought home to the people that it was not Fianna Fáil but another Party who built up this country. Unprejudiced historians without jaundiced eyes will in future give credit where it is due. Mr. Haughey——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture, addressing the House on the Agreement, said the farming community needed better incomes in the widest possible sense, to be followed by better processing and better marketing. He said it was his intention to provide them with the necessary tools to give them better incomes. What tools has he given to the farmers? He has been Minister for Agriculture for more than a year and he must know that the tool most needed by farmers is credit. Farmers cannot go to the Agricultural Credit Company. Farmers need a fair return for their labour which they are not getting and thus they will not be in a position to use this Agreement as it should be used. Rates, wages, the cost of living and the turnover tax all hit the farmers to the extent of £4 million last year. When the Minister for Agriculture speaks about tools he knows that the price of cattle has fallen by between £8 and £10 per head, that the price of sheep has fallen by between £1 and 30/- per head. Farmers in the west who sold ewes had to do so for £3 per head less than last year.

Where are the tools? The farmers' income last year was down by at least £8 million. During the last fortnight, figures were published showing that the average income of a farmer and his family during 1964 was £7 4s. per week and in the west of Ireland the average income of more than 60 per cent of the farmers was £200 per annum. In the name of God, how could any man keep a wife and rear a family on that amount? The Minister for Agriculture had the audacity to say he had given, is giving and would give them the tools to make full use of this Agreement. The farmers have been in the front line of many wars in this country, national, social and economic, and when the call came, they always answered it. They represent 35 per cent of our people. In 1959, they got 29 per cent of the national income and last year, under Deputy Haughey, the Minister for Agriculture, it is reckoned they got 19 per cent of the national income. They are the people, we are told, who are, have been, and will be given the tools. Why try to fool the people? Would it not be much better to tell them the truth, that they have not got the tools? They have been neglected; they have been let down; they are the Cinderellas, and it is no wonder they are leaving the land.

The Minister for Agriculture also spoke at length on the price advantages in relation to livestock. When discussing the Trade Agreement of 1948, Fianna Fáil did not believe that a better price for cattle would bring prosperity to agriculture. I quote from volume 112, column 2329 what Deputy Allen, the Lord have mercy on him, who was the Fianna Fáil spokesman on agriculture, said:

Getting a better price for cattle is not going to bring great prosperity to agriculture. That is merely a temporary thing. We are getting a good price at the present time because of famine conditions all over the world.

And this despite the fact that prices have doubled since then. He continued:

That is the only reason why we are getting these prices. Coming down to fundamentals, it is tillage done on the small farms which will bring the greatest prosperity and keep agriculture prosperous. Tillage will do more for agriculture than will temporary increased prices.

That is what counts. Let us go back to the policy of the late Deputy Paddy Hogan when he said: "If we want to make a success of this Agreement, we must advocate the policy of one more cow, one more sow and one more acre under the plough." Deputy Dillon has always preached the same policy. We want to improve the land of Ireland. We want to fertilise it and get from it the maximum acreage of wheat, oats and other crops. I am surprised that there are not some Fianna Fáil speakers throwing something they are supposed to have said across at me.

The Minister for Agriculture also said that we want better farming in the wider sense. Unfortunately, we are getting the worst farming, in its narrow sense. We are told about the wonderful opportunities there are for our people, but the people are not here. Let us remember that tillage is more than important. If we are to make proper use of this Agreement, we must grow our own crops instead of having to import them. I notice a young Deputy has just entered the House and he might be interested in tillage figures. It might be no harm if the country took a lesson from this to see what is happening.

In 1954, when Deputy Dillon, who is condemned so often in this House, was Minister for Agriculture, there were 586,368 acres of wheat. How many had we in 1964? We had 188,600. That should be borne in mind when you are talking to the Fianna Fáil cumainn. There was a reduction of 397,768 acres of wheat in 11 years. That is where Fianna Fáil policy is getting us. We had to import £14 million worth of wheat during the past year. Would it not be much better if that money were used to import raw materials for our industries to give employment to the people in their own country? The acreage under wheat is down by 397,768.

Now let us come to oats. In 1955, when Deputy Dillon, who is so often condemned in this House, was in charge of agriculture we had 545,144 acres of oats in this country. That gave employment to farmers, their sons, agricultural labourers, people who owned and sold tractors and the people who had to repair them. It also gave employment to garages selling and repairing tractors. In 1964, under this wonderful Bonnie Prince Charlie, the Minister for Agriculture, the acreage under oats was down to 281,200 acres, a reduction of 363,944.

Now, let us come to potatoes. Pigs are fed on potatoes. Good wheat is used for our own people but bad wheat and potatoes are fed to our pigs and our cattle. Therefore, potatoes are important. In 1955, we had 285,622 acres of potatoes; in 1964, we had 173,700, a reduction of 111,922 acres of potatoes. That is under a Minister who tells us that he is providing our people with the tools to make full use of this Agreement. What an awful prospect in an agricultural country.

In 1954, we grew 74,017 acres of beet; in 1964, we grew 72,000 acres. In 1965, under the leadership of the man who is giving our people the tools, and the capital and gearing them to enter EEC on level terms with Britain and the rest of Europe, this figure is reduced to 66,000, a total reduction of 8,017 acres in relation to beet.

Some Fianna Fáil Deputies have been holding forth on the wonderful Agreement, pointing out that we will export so much sugar in the next few years. As things are, we will not have enough beet to produce sugar for ourselves. We certainly have not enough barley, oats or potatoes to feed our increased livestock. Instead of growing them all on the land, as we should have been doing, we had to add further to the adverse trade balance and import what we should have been growing ourselves. That would have been giving employment to our own people here.

Under Fianna Fáil policy the only role we can play is that of cattle rancher for Britain. There is no question that this Agreement, rightly or wrongly, has caused quite a lot of apprehension and distress amongst our people. They feel there is a sword hanging over their heads. They are like Mahomed's coffin. They are faced with uncertainty. I can tell those people that even on today's paper there is a further increase of 7,000 in the unemployment figure. Those are desperate figures to face.

Industry has got a very bad deal. There has been a complete sell-out. The 1948 Agreement gained us advantages go leor for agriculture but there was no sell out as far as industry was concerned. There are all gains in this Agreement on the one side, and all losses on the other. Northern Ireland and Britain will be the big shots in the future and, unfortunately, we will be the customers. We had tariffs and quotas to protect Irish workers over the years. I sincerely hope that this Agreement will not press unduly on any section of the community but I am afraid it will, especially on those who, during the past 30 years, have put their sweat and money into Irish industrial development.

The Taoiseach has said that the motor industry which employs over 5,000 people is in jeopardy. The aim of Fine Gael is to provide employment for our own people in their own country. The yardstick by which any Government should be judged on this or any other Agreement is the number of men and women living in their own country, earning a decent respectable living in their own country. I believe this Agreement will throw thousands of Irish workers on the dole, and that we will have more emigration added to the 300,000 who emigrated since 1956, and the one million who emigrated since 1932. I believe we should have more factories based on the raw materials we have at home. I believe more cattle and more sheep should be slaughtered at home. We have got a very slight concession in this Agreement, but it is not enough. We should have held out and said to the British: "We will give meat but we want employment for our own people at home in processing cattle and sheep, and we will send the processed meat to you." Even if we did get a small concession, it is too small.

Under the Agreement we get a paltry extra allocation of 1,000 tons of bacon, bringing our quota to 28,000 tons. Denmark, which is not making any move towards a Free Trade Agreement with Britain, has just been given an extra allocation of 11,260 tons, bringing their total quota to 300,000 tons. That country, which is one quarter the size of this country, is exporting over ten times as much bacon as we are exporting to Britain. Denmark now tops the list of exports of bacon to Britain with 300,000 tons; British home suppliers are second with 233,000 tons; Poland is third with 50,000 tons; and we come in a poor fourth with a miserable 28,000 tons. As a matter of fact, we have 4.5 per cent of British imports of bacon and Denmark has 47 per cent. Surely if Denmark could get an extra quota of 11,000 tons, our Government should have done something to get more than an extra 1,000 tons for the Irish farmers who produce bacon.

We all know that our marketing system is antediluvian and will have to be changed. We must have more aggressive salesmen abroad from all our industries to make full use of this or any other Agreement. There is no denying that we should have done much better. We are entitled to much more than one-tenth of the quota of bacon allocated to the Danes. No matter what is said by the Taoiseach, or by the Minister for Agriculture, either he or someone else fell down on the job because the Danes got an extra 11,000 tons under his nose, bringing their quota to 47 per cent of British total imports. The difference is that the Danes have had a businesslike Government since 1932 whose eyes were on business instead of playing politics. They have a good marketing system and the proof is there now. Remember that before the 1938 negotiations took place, we were allowed to export 29,000 tons of bacon to Britain.

No matter what the Taoiseach or the Minister for Agriculture said, this Agreement will not cure all our ills. It will take years to repair the damage that has been done to the farmers of Ireland by the Fianna Fáil policy of high taxation, high rates, and poor prices for agricultural produce. I told the House already that the acreage under tillage has fallen sharply. As yet, the Minister has made no announcement about next year's wheat. Such an announcement should have been made a month or two months ago, so that the farmers could plan ahead. If we are to make full use of this Agreement, the Department of Agriculture should awaken from their slumbers and announce today or tomorrow what the farmers will get for wheat this year. It will be too late to do that in a week or a fortnight's time.

About 200,000 farmers have been driven off the land of Ireland in the past 20 years, and in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, published by Fianna Fáil, it is envisaged that a further 69,000 farmers will be driven off the land of Ireland in the next six years. We were not told yesterday or the day before, by the Taoiseach or the Minister, whether this new Agreement will make any difference. We were not told whether it will be 69,000, 100,000 or only 20,000. We are entitled to be told these facts. It is a well-known fact that unfortunately in Ireland thousands of farmers are not equipped and have not got the money to take advantage of this Agreement. If the Government had done their duty during the past few years, they would be in a position to take full advantage of the Agreement. Active and courageous measures will have to be taken at once to put the agricultural producer in a position to avail in full of whatever benefits there are for our farmers in this Agreement. The benefits are very small for the small farmers, and there are some for the big farmers and the other ranchers. I think we are moving in the wrong direction, because the small farmer, who is supposed to be the backbone of the country, is entitled to justice, and he does not seem to be getting it in this Agreement. I suggest to the Government that one of the first things that should be done, if the small farmer is to be kept on the land, is to have a complete derating of any farm under a value——

Comment on this
Liam Cunningham Acting Chairman (Mr. Cunningham) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is departing from the motion.

Comment on this

Something like that should be done to put them on a par with the farmers of Britain and Northern Ireland, because it is hard to expect us to compete with the farmers of those countries when we have to pay high rates and high taxation. The farmers will have to be properly equipped. The Minister has said that he intends to give them the tools. One of the principal tools that should be given to them is money. They should be given interest-free loans to put them on their feet and enable them to get the maximum advantage out of this Agreement.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

They have not got the money.

Comment on this

According to the Taoiseach, opportunity is knocking at the door and we must go out and welcome it.

Comment on this

Hear, hear!

Comment on this

Unfortunately many of us are not in a position to rise to the occasion, due to Fianna Fáil mismanagement of our affairs. We have an adverse trade balance of £153 million, and we have a deficit in our balance of payments of £50 million, due to bad government. Are we in a position to grasp the opportunities we are told are there? Where are those opportunities for an already overtaxed people who will be paying £225 million in taxes this year, for the ratepayers who will be paying £30 million in rates this year, despite the fact that about the year in which the Minister for Justice was born, they were promised complete derating? Remember that we are talking about opportunities for people who have become like punch-drunk boxers.

Comment on this

That is the way I am.

Comment on this

Due to our high taxation, they are losing initiative and losing confidence in the Government. The nation is bleeding to death. We heard a lot from Deputy Moore and Deputy O'Connor last night about confidence in the future. We all have confidence and we all want to see our country triumph but what the people want are the facts, to be told the truth, and it is time you told them the truth and stopped fooling them. With all the talk about using this Agreement to the full, we should remember that in Ireland today there are 158,100 fewer people in employment than there were in 1952. If any Deputy says that that figure is wrong, I can give him the information given to me one month ago. In 1951, there were at work in Ireland——

Comment on this
Liam Cunningham Acting Chairman (Mr. Cunningham) Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is introducing matters which are more appropriate to Estimates. It is in order to refer to these matters but not in such detail as the Deputy is now doing.

Comment on this

His whole speech is more appropriate to a fair-day meeting.

Comment on this

It is said that opportunity is knocking at our door and we must go out and welcome it, but there are 158,000 fewer employed now than in 1951 and how can we welcome it when we have the lowest population, of 2.8 million people, we ever had? How can we say that the farmers are geared to meet it when there are 200,000 fewer employed on the land today than there were 20 years ago? A Government should be judged by the number of boys and girls working and living at home in their own country. What is in this Agreement for the small farmers in the west? Unfortunately in the west today, the people who had 20 or 30 acres of land, who should be producing and exporting, have turned the key in the door and have gone abroad. That is due to Government policy. Is there anything in this Agreement that will attract them back from England? What we want to see are more people on the land and in industry. We want to see more people on the land, to see smoke swirling out of the chimneys and to hear the patter of little feet and not to see the locked doors we see today.

The opportunity is not there today. I doubt if those who have gone to Britain will throw up their hands and say: "A wonderful Agreement has been signed by the Taoiseach, and we will rush home to take the key out of the door and get wives for ourselves. We will return home and we will increase production on the land". I think we are also entitled to ask the Taoiseach, as free trade will mean lowering taxes and duties, and the lowering of the tariff walls, where he intends to get the extra money. We will be losing £20 million or £30 million and does he intend to increase the turnover tax or income tax? In conclusion, we are starting a new year——

Comment on this

That is the fourth time.

Comment on this

It is not; I never said it before. I defy contradiction on that. Look at the record. I will give £10 to the St. Vincent de Paul Society if I said it before. I want to say that we are starting a new year which is a very important one for us. We have this new Agreement which is very important to this country and I believe that this is the year in which we may sink unless people are controlled and are prepared to work in the interests of the country. This Trade Agreement will not be worth a farthing to us unless we are prepared to put an end to the bickering and to the industrial disputes which strangle the economic life of the country. We require a period of stability, harmony and co-operation at home—we have it abroad now, we are told—to achieve our targets, social as well as economic.

Now that the Taoiseach has embraced Harold, perhaps management and workers could embrace one another and come to a proper agreement. Everybody must work harder in the future if we are to gain any advantages from this Agreement. We must produce a bigger national cake and we must look only for our due share of it, and no more and no less. No group or sector of the economy should be entitled to look for more than its just share. Let us remember that the naked truth is that we are pricing ourselves out of markets and if this policy continues, our own industrialists will not be able to hold even the Irish market when tariffs are reduced or abolished.

It is time that a national campaign to bring this warning home to everybody was launched. We are slowly but surely committing hara-kiri, and it is the Government's duty to give a lead in controlling the economy to balance all factors one against another. They are the people who should know all the facts and it is their duty to help the people to get the full advantages from this Agreement. They must give the lead but the more we look at the sad history of this country for the past few years, the more we realise that the Government are responsible for many of the ills we have today. They are going this way today and that way tomorrow. They have given labour its head——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is now out of order.

Comment on this

I am saying, and it was stated by many others, that if we are to get the full advantages from this Agreement——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Introducing the Agreement after half a dozen sentences does not put it in order.

Comment on this

I want to say, and I think I am entitled to say, that industry must be saved, must be kept viable under this Agreement, and the Government must lead and must, if necessary, force the employers and the unions to accept changes, in their own and in the national interest. It would be a good idea for each and every one of us if they did that immediately.

Comment on this
Patrick J. Lenihan Minister for Justice (Mr. B. Lenihan) Fianna Fáil

I do not intend to follow Deputy L'Estrange down the highways and byways of past Trade Agreements and past emotional upheavals in his life from his earlier days in politics—I have had a certain acquaintance with them over many years—because this debate should be concerned with the very practical business of the Free Trade Agreement which has been concluded by the Government, in what way it benefits us and how we are to make the most out of it as a nation in the years ahead. Too much time, apart from Deputy L'Estrange's speech, has been spent on not alone going back to the Trade Agreements of 1948 and 1938 but back to the Treaty and to the Act of Union and, on one Labour Deputy's part, to the Treaty of Limerick——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Did the Minister hear Deputy Noel Lemass? He went back to the time of Brian Boru.

Comment on this

——which have nothing to do with the facts of life in 1966.

The main theme with which the Government were concerned in initiating these negotiations with the British Government was to take cognisance of the facts of life as this Government saw them last year and to try to achieve some measure of stability by way of a Free Trade Agreement with our largest customer so as to ensure that by so consolidating our position we would have taken the first step, which both the Fine Gael Party and we agree as being the desirable objective, the first step to Europe with the European Economic Community.

There has been a certain amount of pessimism from various Opposition speakers. This is not in accordance with the mood of a country seeking to expand its exports, first to Britain and later to Europe. I am certain that in voicing this attitude of pessimism both Labour Party and Fine Gael speakers are completely out of tune with the country today. As Deputy Healy said, one barometer alone— probably the most important barometer of economic affairs in any country—the Irish stock market proves them to be completely wrong. Since the signing of this Agreement, the stock market has shown itself to be buoyant and we have an appreciation of shares in every sector. Indeed, it appears both in industry and agriculture there is recognition of the fact, as the Taoiseach said, that this Agreement presents an opportunity to us to show our skills on the market adjacent to us and to train ourselves to be so competitive in that market that we can achieve greater progress in the wider market of the EEC. This, of course, is in accordance with the changed population picture at present, which is another barometer of where a country is going. The population increased projection for 1970 is of the order of 100,000. That would provide a bigger home market from which our industries could expand into export fields.

We have here in regard to agriculture for the first time—despite the Treaty, despite the 1938 Agreement and despite the 1948 Agreement— spelled out absolute freedom of access for our agricultural produce on the British market without any hindrance from the British Government. Under previous Agreements the British Government could, when they wished, in the interests of orderly marketing and after consultation with us, impose restrictions on the sale of our agricultural produce on the British market. In fact, since the British Government linked up with EFTA in 1960, our position under these previous Agreements has been completely eroded. First in 1960 and later in 1963 we had our position in regard to bacon and dairy produce whittled away by reason of Britain's action in order to allow Denmark, one of her EFTA partners, a satisfactory price on the British market.

Comment on this

It was because of the Fianna Fáil Government's failure to develop the industry over the years.

Comment on this

Until the signing of this Agreement, there was nothing any Irish Government could do under the 1938 Agreement and the 1948 Agreement to prevent Britain giving special concessions to her partners in EFTA or any other organisation to the detriment of Irish agricultural exports. The fact is that, due to Britain's involvement in EFTA and GATT and the increased subsidisation of her farmers, which commenced during the war years, the total effect of all these various factors has been to whittle away whatever advantage Irish Governments gained in the 1938 Agreement and the 1948 Agreement. We have spelled out in this Agreement absolute freedom of access in regard to beef and lamb, live or in carcase form, to any value and to any quantity, without any hindrance or any imposition from the British Government "in the interests of orderly marketing", which was the phrase used in previous Agreements, or in any other interest.

Much was made of the fact that in regard to butter and bacon there is not absolute free trade, in that quotas still apply. The quota system in regard to butter is precisely what we want. We do not want complete free trade there because it would represent a greater burden on the Irish Exchequer. What we want is diversification of dairy products into chocolate crumb, cheese and cream products. We do not want a larger quota of butter which would have to be sold on the British market at the expense of the Irish Exchequer. We were delighted with the quota of 23,000 tons for the next two years, with a growth factor for increased production in the following years. We do not want abolition of the quota system so long as the quota is of a substantial kind to cater for our planned growth.

The same applies to the bacon quota. It represents what our planned output from pig-curing establishments is likely to be in the coming year and there is also a growth factor. However, in regard to the field of livestock and dead meat there is no limit of any kind. Absolute access is guaranteed to us. This is in accordance with the most important target of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, which is to raise cattle output by over 40 per cent between 1960 and 1970. Substantial progress has been made already in the achievement of this target. The total cattle population, which in 1964 was somewhere under 5,000,000, is now close to 5,400,000— an increase of practically 500,000 in total cattle stocks last year compared with 1964. The carcase meat industry generally is showing similar improvement. This is an industry that was a small one ten years ago and practically non-existent before that. It has grown up in the post-war period to the extent that total processed meat exports last year were in the region of £35 million. Indeed, one single figure emphasises all I am saying in that the total exports of carcase beef and lamb to the United Kingdom market since 1955 have doubled in the past ten years from 15,000 tons to close on 30,000 tons. That is to the British market alone. In respect of the Continental market, what was an unknown market ten years ago has been transformed into a substantial and expanding market.

It is precisely in this field of processed foodstuffs that the greatest expansion for Irish employment lies. Male employment is largely the category which finds work in these meat processing establishments. We have here a direct encouragement to these meat processing establishments to go ahead. For the first time a floor has been put into what was heretofore a rather up and down market, where risk appeared to be an endemic part of the business. We now have, so far as meat processing establishments are concerned, a guarantee that 25,000 tons of beef will benefit from the British deficiency payments system and 5,500 tons of lamb. This will put a floor into the meat processing industry and undoubtedly mean considerable expansion in the industry as well as an expansion in male employment.

That, I feel, entitles the Government to make the claim that the benefits for agriculture in this Agreement are quite substantial. While no detailed figures can be given, the Minister for Agriculture put the figure for increased income at £10 million in respect of agriculture for the coming year. I think that is a conservative figure. If one links up with what I have just stated in regard to the carcase meat industry the fact that Irish stores will now command a much better price by reason of the reduction of the waiting period and the elimination of the differential in regard to store lamb, and associate with it the fact that there has been a substantial build-up in livestock numbers in this country over the past 12 months, I can see in the coming year a considerable rise in exports under these headings. It is my view that the Minister for Agriculture was quite conservative in his figure of £10 million as the increase under this head next year. The figure is quite likely to be more.

Comment on this

Would the Minister state, at this juncture, how he has come to that conclusion?

Comment on this

For the past ten minutes, I have concerned myself with spelling out facts which would indicate to any limited mind that the advantages gained under this Agreement must mean specific benefits to the Irish farmer in the form of increased income. I do not have to spell out the elementary fact that if a certain period in regard to store cattle is reduced from three months to two months, it will mean an immediate advantage in the price of store cattle to the Irish seller on the British market and is bound to reflect itself back to the initial stage of calf production. It is so elementary that I do not think it necessary to explain it.

The other factors I have just mentioned in regard to agricultural gains will bring substantial benefits to the farming community next year and in the years ahead. We have here an Agreement in regard to agriculture that accords one hundred per cent with what we sought and accords with the targets we spelled out before the Trade Agreement in our Second Programme for Economic Expansion. The increased output which we envisage in regard to cattle, sheep and lambs by 1970 and for which we had planned in the form of incentives and aid to our farmers means that this outlet is guaranteed and in some respects a basic minimum sum is to be financed by the British Government. This is precisely what we wanted. This is the first time we have got this absolute guaranteed right of access without any hindering.

Some people seem to think that we always had this right of access in regard to cattle, sheep and lambs. We have been asked in what way this Agreement represents a gain for us in this respect. People who make this remark and who think, in a blind fashion, that we could have gone along forever with our access for cattle, sheep and lambs without any let or hindrance, do not appear to realise that in 1964 the British Government very seriously set about negotiating a multilateral arrangement in regard to cattle, sheep and lambs whereby various other countries would participate in the selling of them on the British market to the detriment of our country which had always got a substantial priority advantage on the British market. A few years earlier, she had done that, to our disadvantage, in regard to pig and dairy products. The British Government did not succeed in 1964 in achieving that situation but the warning light was there for us. The British Government or any other Government do not owe us a living. They do not like us for the colour of our eyes or for whatever virtues we may possess. They could quite easily have concluded a multilateral arrangement in regard to beef and mutton and lamb to our disadvantage because there was not any guarantee. That is no scare; it was an actual cold, calculated effort in 1964 to reduce the dependence of the British on Ireland for their meat products, live and dead, as they had done in regard to dairy and pig products a few years earlier. Prior to the signing of this Agreement, we had no guarantee that our privileged position in regard to cattle, sheep and lambs would continue. We have it now, spelled out in this Agreement, forever, and without any strings attached as far as these particular products are concerned which means that the Irish farmer can produce ahead in the future secure in the knowledge that the market is there.

I mentioned earlier that the important aspect of this Agreement, the basic aspect of it, indeed, is that it represents the first step we have taken into Europe. Some three or four years ago, the Fine Gael Party, in particular, were completely pro-European, backing the Government in their efforts to get into the EEC, indeed, outbidding the Government in their enthusiasm for European unity and for entry into the EEC. Here, we have a deal which, in regard to industry, is much better than any deal we could have got in respect of membership of EEC. If we had secured membership of EEC two years ago, all of our industrial tariffs would have had to be dismantled by 1970. We are now getting an extension to 1975 and, by virtue of this Agreement, we should be able to carry that into arrangements concerning our entry into Europe: that would be our bargaining point. Once we have established that point, until 1975, we should be in a stronger position in regard to whatever arrangement is reached in Europe.

Two years ago, we should have had to have absolute free trade in industrial products by 1970. We have the extension of the ten-year period from 1975 until 1980 in the event of certain difficulties. We have the unilateral protection allowed by an Irish Government where an industry is in difficulty to put on immediate tariffs or quotas for 18 months. We have the exception clause where industries are in difficulties for the next five years of up to three per cent exports to Britain. We have the safeguards where the Government can come to the assistance of an industry which may be hit by unemployment, which were not contemplated when our application was made for membership of EEC.

I come now to something that worried us in our EEC application. The Irish Government can unilaterally take action to prevent dumping on the Irish market of products coming from Britain and we shall have legislation to spell out these anti-dumping provisions shortly. In the Treaty of Rome, there was a very lengthy consultation procedure which had to be followed before the adoption of any anti-dumping provisions. The Irish Government can now, on its own initiative, adopt the necessary anti-dumping provisions where it is satisfied it is threatening an Irish industry.

Therefore, what we have here is a deal with our biggest customer which enables us to equip ourselves for the inevitable entry into the EEC on much better terms than the terms which we were seeking, by joint agreement of the two main Parties of this House and the support of the Irish people some years ago when we were trying to get into Europe. This will enable us to get into Europe in a much better way, by preparing ourselves over a long period and by having a number of safeguards. Above all else, it means that nobody can turn their back on us. If Britain goes into Europe, we must go as well and this is a most important guarantee which would not have been there in the absence of a Free Trade Agreement of this kind.

As I have said before, it is well to bear in mind that the world does not owe us a living and that neither the British nor anybody else love us for the colour of our eyes or for any virtues we may possess. This is a hard business-like world. The prospects cannot be ignored that if we had not concluded this Agreement we might have certain difficulties in getting into Europe at all. Again, that is a fact of life that must be faced up to. In the sort of world in which we live, not alone between individuals but between nations, it is a business rat race. The necessity is to produce competitively and export competitively. This is the type of world in which we live, and it is just on the cards that if we had not concluded a Free Trade Agreement, the British Government could have gone on blithely into Europe and we could have been left behind altogether. This Agreement guarantees that we cannot be left behind. If there is to be a European deal, we cannot be left behind. We must go into Europe if Britain goes in as well.

On the aspect of agricultural policy, some points have been made that the agricultural deal in the Trade Agreement does not represent free trade. Agriculture nowhere is represented by a free trade situation. In every country in the world, agriculture is managed in one way or another. There are no agricultural provisions at all in the EFTA Agreement and, indeed, in the case of EEC, the agricultural provisions have not yet been worked out. Any suggestion that we can have the best of both worlds, by retaining our existing trade advantages with Britain and, at the same time, working out some deal with EEC, is completely illusory.

We are all aware of the European trends in the past few years since the French and British Governments had their differences. We are well aware of the positions of the French and other Governments and it is quite evident that any deal by us in the present climate of the EEC, while at the same time seeking to maintain our status with the British market, is just out of the question and not a realistic situation. We probed that out last year and the year before by diplomatic probings and it was just not on the cards at all. The Taoiseach said the other day there had been some suggestions by some Fine Gael publicists, Senator Garret FitzGerald and others in the House, who sought to say we could have the best of both worlds in some fashion. The vague idea is being thrown out: "Why did the Government not seek to establish some arrangements with EEC and still retain its position on the British market?" It is not for the beauty of our eyes that Agreement was negotiated. There was absolutely no prospect of our keeping our status with Britain and, at the same time, making some deal with Europe. It is completely unrealistic to fool ourselves that we can go around, and by knocking on the door, get such fantastic advantages, retain the British market while, at the same time, getting some concessions under the EEC situation.

Comment on this

What about Austria?

Comment on this

The Austrian situation has not been reached. Over the past three years, anybody who examines developments in Europe can see that EEC has become much more hardheaded about arrangements and the economic advantages which appertain to any particular country.

Viewing the situation in a rational way last year we realised we were in a situation where our agricultural advantages and, indeed, our industrial advantages in regard to whatever industrial exports we made to Britain had been gradually wiped away by Britain's membership of EFTA and GATT. We had to face up to the situation that Britain might make some deal with Europe while we might just be regarded as a poor relation supplying the British market and no more. We were faced with a situation where we could have been left out in the cold. Well, we have got our leg in here on the British market. We have got a guaranteed free trade deal with her and it means that if she goes into Europe, we go in too. That is now spelled out, written down and the lines of policy have been laid out. Above all else, we can say here that, as far as agriculture is concerned, this agricultural policy is precisely along the lines envisaged by us in our Second Programme for Economic Expansion. In any deal, of course, there will be a certain amount of give and take. We have gained on the agricultural front. We have also gained in certain fields of industry.

I am not at all pessimistic about the industry which stands to gain most from this arrangement, that is, the textile industry. According to the CIO Report, and anybody who knows the facts of life in regard to the textile industry in this country knows that this is one industry which has equipped itself for freer trade. It is one industry which is realistic and has, in the past two or three years, formed major organisations within itself and which is participating in strong exporting business to the British market. Those industries who have geared themselves best for a free trade are those who will benefit most from this Agreement because the most limiting factor—certainly in the textile trade—has been the man-made fibre duty imposed over a long number of years, amounting to at least 20 per cent and, in some cases, over 20 per cent, on any articles going into Britain containing a percentage of man-made fibre. This duty now goes from next July so that from then on the Irish textile industry is assured of complete freedom of access, without any duty, quota or restriction, to the British market. The duties which were there and so restrictive in regard to man-made fibre will be removed from next July.

That is an industry about which I am tremendously optimistic. Deputies from Cork will be aware of firms in their own county. I am aware of firms in my own area and other members will be aware of firms who might make substantial progress towards equipping themselves and making themselves more efficient. These are firms who will continue to expand under the elimination of the man-made fibre duty. There are a number in the pipeline already and, if it gives any pleasure to the Fine Gael and Labour Deputies, the Minister for Industry and Commerce will be announcing substantial projects in the months ahead. These are projects which, during the period of uncertainty prior to the signing of the Agreement, were held up. Now, with the absolute right of access guaranteed for every industrial project from next July, a number of these projects will be finalised and will be made public in the course of the months ahead. As I have said, a number of them are already in the pipeline and a number of substantial investors will come here secure in the knowledge—despite what is suggested to the contrary—that our grants and loans are available and will continue to be available for the establishment of such industries.

These people will come in here, secure in the knowledge that the 100 per cent income tax and corporation profits tax exemption incentives are being allowed to continue under this Agreement because legislation has been passed by Dáil Éireann to implement them. Until 1980, the tax incentives will continue in the form of the 100 per cent remission of income tax and the corporation profits tax. A new drive will be initiated by the Industrial Development Authority on the basis that we can guarantee firms anywhere in the world that they can come here and set up their factories, make use of our grants and loans and, from next July on, can be certain that they will have absolute freedom of access to the British market in addition.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say now that the town of Fermoy has a better chance of getting a factory than it had up to now?

Comment on this

I would have every confidence in the future of a town 20 miles from Cork Airport and enjoying a privileged position in that regard. I wish many towns in my constituency were equally privileged.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Yet the Minister would not use Fermoy pencils in his office.

Comment on this

I have them; I can produce them for the Deputy— Faber-Castell, and nothing else.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is a change, like the British market.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

It has been mentioned that in some way Fianna Fáil are departing from their policy of the past in regard to industry and that we are now proposing over the next ten years to move into free trade conditions and that this implies that we are turning our backs on the protectionist policy. Protection was never intended by Fianna Fáil, or by its architect, the present Taoiseach, to be a permanent device in the Irish economy. It has been adopted by every country in the world in its own time. The United States, after declaring independence, adopted protection. The British Government before it achieved its strength in the race was also a highly protectionist economy. Going back to the time of Adam and Eve, protection was adopted at some stage of every nation's development.

We adopted it and we make no apology for it, or for the fact that protection has never been anything more than a temporary device to get industries going. When they are going under protection, industries are expected to make themselves efficient and competitive. This has been the pattern of history for hundreds of years. We needed protection in the 1930s and 1940s but our industries have now reached a stage where the best of them —I do not say all of them—have made themselves efficient, have made use of the grants given and have adapted and equipped themselves properly for the economic race of today. The best of them, nurtured by protection in the early stages, will be well able to survive the removal of protection and make use of the markets now opening up to them.

That has been the pattern of development since 1932 when we initiated the industrial drive and used the device of protection to get it under way at that start. At present it is essential, if we are to expand industry as well as agriculture, to seek a broader base for our markets. It is obvious, and has been for some years, that we have now reached the stage of industrial development when we must seek external markets as our home market of some three million in the 26 counties, even if now enlarged to four million in the 32 counties, would not still be sufficient to absorb the output needed to sustain a growing labour force in industry. We want more jobs, more industrial employment, and this is an elementary follow-on from the fact that there has been less employment on the land. If we are to have more employment in industry, we must seek a broader base for industrial exports. It has become quite evident in recent years that the old policy must be, as it has been, and must be to a greater extent, directed towards achieving a greater volume of exports. We are guaranteed an unlimited export market of some 60 million to 70 million people in Great Britain from next July on without any hindrance.

Comment on this

Is Britain not guaranteed the same thing in our market?

Comment on this

That is something that is to be done gradually over a period of ten years, with a ten per cent reduction each year, whereas we get our benefit immediately from next July.

As regards our position vis-á-vis the British export market, we are being allowed to stagger the reduction of our tariffs over the next ten years with other safeguards I mentioned earlier, but we shall have free access for our industrial products to the British market from next July without tariffs or quotas.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that this will lead to unemployment in Ireland?

Comment on this

My whole argument is based on the fact that this agreement will mean increased employment in industry. Provided the Industrial Development Authority go out in an aggressive drive to attract new industries here, we shall have more industries here after that than those we may lose and I do not commit myself to saying that we are going to lose any. For instance, the system of dealing with textile products will mean that the industry can absorb more. Certain industries will go to the wall but that is one of the facts of life and for every one that does go to the wall, there will be two or three or four or five others that will come in and take advantage of the facilities we offer here in respect of skilled manpower, proximity to the British market, tax incentives and grants and loans.

In the changing field of industrial development, I have no doubt that we shall have not fewer but more people employed in industry in the years ahead. That must be the basis of economic prosperity, to absorb more people in gainful employment in industry because, inevitably, you will have fewer employed on the land. Our target is to expand industrial employment by 86,000 and that target as well as the target for cattle will be achieved by means of the policy I have mentioned.

Comment on this

We sincerely hope you are right.

Comment on this

I am confident I am right. It would be a mistake if the Fine Gael views or the Labour Party views were to command widespread support because the biggest impetus to progress in any community is confidence and optimism. If we go about like Deputy L'Estrange saying "Ochone, it is terrible," lamenting the fate of Cathleen Ní Houlihan, we will not achieve any progress in the years ahead. It is precisely that sort of attitude of mind, and only that, that can bring us down in the years ahead. What we heard from Fine Gael and Labour speakers in this debate showed nothing but pessimism, lack of confidence and faith in the country.

I have every confidence that our farmers will rise to the opportunities here and that most of our industrialists, who were nurtured under protection, will rise to the occasion now that the challenge is thrown down and equip themselves for the market opening to them. I believe that more outside investment will come in, now that the doubts and fears have been removed and investors and entrepreneurs from abroad know where they stand. That, I take it, is also the reason why Fine Gael are not opposing the Agreement. They realise that this Agreement opens the door, clears the decks and makes the picture plain as far as the expansion of agriculture and industry in the future is concerned.

I said earlier that we must be concerned with the facts of life. There is no point in fooling ourselves or thinking that the world owes us a living. It does not. On the facts of life as they present themselves in 1966 or as it appears they will be by any reasonable forecast in the years ahead, this represented the right deal for us in our circumstances—to secure a foothold in the British market and make certain we had that market guaranteed to us. The only thing we yielded on was the gradual elimination of tariffs over the next ten years and hemmed in by a number of safeguards to protect particular industries. That, on balance, represents a favourable Agreement to us as a country.

That has been the view of representative organisations throughout the country. The major national newspapers have backed this Agreement. I do not say it represents the be-all and end-all, or anything of that kind. The major organs of public opinion have backed it in a cautious, guarded fashion. I would suggest that this House should back it in a similar way, recognising that it does not open up any bonanza to us but does spell out the opportunities that lie before us, does spell out in definite form the way in which this country will go ahead in the next few years, so that people can plan ahead for expansion knowing that the facts, as far as they can be forecast, are contained in that document, particularly when taken in conjunction with the Second Programme for Economic Expansion.

The country knows where it is going. The key to prosperity is there, even though it does not guarantee prosperity. It is up to us to make use of the opportunities now being opened up to the country as a whole. I have every confidence that the various sectors in industry and agriculture will make every use of the guarantee we have got of these particular markets.

With the support of the major newspapers and organs of opinion, with the support of all the responsible voluntary organisations, all the business organisations, all the farming organisations, who have also come out and endorsed this Agreement, not as representing the be-all and end-all, but as representing a good deal, a fair deal, a reasonable deal, on balance, the best deal that could have been got, with the support mobilised of the organs of public opinion, of the responsible voluntary groups in industry and agriculture, with the support of the Government, with the grudging support even of the Fine Gael Party, I feel we can carry this through as a national endeavour which must be followed up by every section of our society in the years ahead.

I would agree with what Deputy L'Estrange wound up with. With 95 per cent of what he said, I disagree, but I would agree with the five per cent at the end. I think he is correct that the onus now lies fairly and squarely, not on the British Government or the Irish Government, but on our own people. That includes every one of us—administrators, politicians, leaders in industry and in agriculture, trade unionists, tradesmen, workers of every kind, farmers of every kind, big and small. The onus lies on every one of us to make use of this Agreement and to make sure that sectional strife and arguments about who should get what and who should not get what are futile and can have no place in the years ahead. The sooner we get together as a people in this respect, the better. The sooner there is an attitude of responsibility and the facts of life are known and from top to bottom, from the man running industry to the man on the shop floor, it is realised that the world does not owe us a living and that all we can do is get the prosperity we can get by the sweat of our brow and the skill of our brains, the better. Involved in that must be the recognition that if we do not export more by the sweat of our brow and the skill of our brains there will be less for all of us to pull out of the national cake. This is the essential lesson which is so pertinent to the present week in which we are, having regard to industrial unrest and all the rest of it. This is the message that must be listened to for the years ahead if we are to make use of this Agreement, which we have honourably signed as a sovereign state with another sovereign state, to make more prosperous the country which will increase in population by 1970.

We can only achieve these aims if there is general abjuring of selfish objectives, general recognition that it is not this or that section that counts— trade unionists, farmers, professional people or business people—that it is the whole country that counts and that the less shouting there is for sectional aims and the less attention there is paid by sectional groups to selfish sectional aims the better. The sooner there is recognition of the fact that each of these groups owes not alone a duty to its particular members, but a wider duty to the country as a whole and the sooner that sort of message gets through to every part of the country, the sooner will we have the prosperous country which we all feel we can achieve knowing the facts contained in the Agreement and what we can get as a result of the Second Programme for Economic Expansion now accepted as Government policy.

Comment on this

I do not flatter myself that at this stage of the debate anything I can contribute will add new light to what has already been said but, in order to clarify one or two points and to make clear my personal attitude with regard to this Agreement, I should like to make a short contribution.

I do not disagree with the Trade Agreement in principle. I do, however, take grave exception to the manner in which the Government have conducted the whole negotiations from start to finish. They deliberately waited until this House had recessed for the summer before any mention whatsoever was made that these negotiations were on the way. By their lack of discussion and consultation on such an important question, the Government treated this House and the country at large with contempt and it is because of this that I feel strongly compelled to vote against this Agreement.

Slyness is, unfortunately for Fianna Fáil, no substitute for shrewdness. The Government should have and could have used with advantage all the help, advice and support of all sections of this country. Their actions were unworthy, unnecessary and regrettable.

Nor do I think it is good enough for the Taoiseach to say that they sat down as equals with the British Government in London. Of course, they sat down with the British Government as equals. When the inter-Party Government repealed the External Relations Act, we made them equals. The credit for that lies on this side of the House, not with the Government side. We established a genuine republic and did away with the mythical Fianna Fáil republic and made them equals. They should remember that.

As regards the Agreement itself, to me it is as unpleasant as a visit to the dentist. Unfortunately, it is as inevitable and as necessary. I do not, honestly, see that the Government had much choice in this matter. It is my personal belief that Britain and the EFTA countries will join with the EEC within the next decade, probably before the full period specified in this Agreement is complete. If Britain does decide to join the EEC, our choice is made for us. We too must join. To think otherwise or to try to act differently would be economic suicide. It is because of my belief regarding the inevitability of our joining the EEC that I regard this Agreement as in the long-term interest.

I am well aware of the challenge it presents to our industries, of the difficulties it will create, of the reorganisation that will be necessary and of the general upheaval it will cause to our economy, but this is something we have to face sooner or later. Postponing the evil day when we must face free competition will not make that competition any easier.

I regard this Free Trade Area as a swimming pool. Heretofore we have sat on the edge of the pool, the more daring of our firms dangling their feet in the water. Now all our firms must learn to swim. The water may be cold and many of them will not like the idea but, if we are to survive, learn to swim they must. In this situation surely it is better to go into the shallow end of the pool by joining with Britain now and learning to swim as best we can, than wait to go into the deep end with the EEC countries.

In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, America was being colonised by people from the various countries of Europe. It was a time of upheaval, of expansion, of challenge. Gradually, the various nations were absorbed and consolidated to become the people of a great nation, the United States of America. The only people who were not able to compete were the Red Indians. They opted out of the economic race with sad consequences for themselves. Today, Europe is in a somewhat similar position. The need by large industries for bigger and bigger markets is exerting pressure and the various nationalities are slowly coming together. We are, I believe, and hope, on the threshold of the United States of Europe. Unless we in Ireland wish to become the Red Indians of Europe, we must be prepared to accept the changes necessary to secure our future.

I do not believe that all our industries can survive, nor do I believe that we should rebuke ourselves on this account. Some industries were started in the 1930s in conditions which were far different from those that exist today. Then, in a world in which unemployment and hunger were the public enemies of the day, we were anxious to provide jobs and we started out to secure all the industries we could. Unfortunately, some of them were not soundly established, but they nevertheless provided employment for many of our people. They kept our workers from emigrating. They gave us experience. They gave us the opportunity to find our bearings.

Today, however, it is obvious that the winds of change are blowing over the sort of economic world in which we have lived for the past 40 years. The protective tariffs behind the shelter of which we developed our industries are about to be dismantled and, when they are dismantled, we shall be exposed to the icy blast of free trade. If we hope to survive, let alone expand and prosper, we must change our thinking in many respects. Management can no longer go on thinking in terms of an Irish market but, rather, in terms of a market which will embrace the whole British Isles. Outdated equipment and methods will have to go. Higher productivity and greater efficiency are more essential now than ever before. Labour, for their part, must be mindful of the problems of management and must moderate its demands to those which the traffic will bear. In my view, this is not a time to kill the goose which lays the weekly wage packet. Both sides of industry, labour and management, should be conscious that they are facing the same problem, the problem of keeping our factories operating and our workers gainfully employed.

That word "gainfully" reminds me of part of this Agreement which I do not like. I refer to the export of butter. The export of butter at a subsidy of 1/7½d per lb., so that it may be eaten by the British, does not in my view represent gainful employment. At that rate of subsidy we could export almost anything. It appears to me that the long-term plan should be to produce butter at a lower cost. I should like to hear of some positive approach by the Government to this aspect of the matter. Our Minister for Agriculture is greatly given to speeches and plans. Perhaps in the near future he would give us both. Perhaps he would give us the benefit of his distilled wisdom on this aspect of the Trade Agreement.

Besides protecting our industry, the tariffs also provided revenue. What will the effect of these reductions be on our revenue? Is there an estimate of the amount involved? How much revenue will be lost in the first, second and third years? So far the Government have not seen fit to make any comment on this or give us any guidance whatsoever in relation to this matter. In their handling of this situation, I believe the Government should have been, and could have been, more forthcoming in this House. They come in here and appeal to our patriotism and our loyalty and they ask us to co-operate. Nevertheless, their entire method of conducting the negotiations lay in refusing to give this House any information. I regard that as petty. I think patriotism lies as much in these benches as it does in any other benches.

We are all patriots at heart and the Government would do well to be less shallow and mean in their approach. Without giving away any budgetary secrets, they could have given some details of how our finances will be affected by this Agreement. I object to the cloak-and-dagger attitude of the Government and that is why I shall vote against this Agreement.

Speaking the other night in this House, that gentleman—if I may use the word loosely—Deputy Corry, used the opportunity to once again try to slander his betters who are no longer here to defend themselves. He complained about the sugar agreement. I understand that the provisions of that agreement, which my late father signed when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce, remain in force under this particular Agreement. The provisions which Deputy Corry came in here and attacked have not been changed. It is a pity Deputy Corry did not spend the two hours he spent in the Library looking for slanderous comments to better advantage by reading the Agreement and studying what is in it. Of course, he is now such a megalomaniac that he is not happy unless he insults the Opposition and at least two or three Ministers in any speech he makes in this House. It irritates me that this man should come in here and make these speeches for the benefit of his supporters in Cork, and then go outside sneering in the corridors, glorying in his own cuteness in pulling the wool over the people's eyes. I could go further and say very harsh things about him, but I shall not do so.

In respect of the challenge, which the future undoubtedly holds for all of us, I believe that, if we act as a united team, we will overcome the difficulties confronting us and we will survive. If, however, we dissipate our energies in wrangling among ourselves, then there will be many other wiser people elsewhere only too anxious to take our place. We could do well to remember that.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It is very doubtful if there is anything that can be said now that has not already been said in this debate. However, I want to avail of this opportunity to tender my congratulations where I think congratulations should go. If anybody deserves to be congratulated, it is Mr. Harold Wilson, because the signing of this Trade Agreement with the Irish Government will help considerably, I believe, to ensure his success at the next British general election. Again, congratulations are due to Captain O'Neill because this Agreement will, in in my opinion, be a considerable asset to many of our fellow-Irishmen in the Six Counties. If anybody deserves sympathy, it is the Taoiseach. He deserves sympathy because of his failure as a negotiator. He deserves sympathy because he has seen the build-up of Irish industry here and now he has played a leading part, in my opinion, in accelerating the downfall of that same industry. I sympathise, too, with the industrial workers. The workers engaged in industry here will find that this Agreement will cost thousands of them their jobs and their livelihoods.

This is an important issue. It is an issue which will have very serious consequences on the future of this country. I do not know if any Deputy has already appealed to the Taoiseach to have a general election on this issue and on the merits of this Agreement. If they have not done so, then I do so now. I appeal to him to consult the people. Ours is a democratic government. I appeal to him to consult the farmers as to what they think will be the benefits for them of this Agreement. I appeal to him to consult the workers as to what they think will be the disadvantages to Irish industry. I appeal to him to consult the management of industry here. The most democratic way in which to have that consultation is for the Taoiseach to consult the Irish people. This is the date on which in 1922 the Treaty was passed by Dáil Éireann by seven votes; this is the most important national issue that has come up for discussion in Dáil Éireann since that date. It is as important as the Treaty from the point of view of the people and if the Taoiseach wants to do his duty in a democratic way and if he is anxious to consult the people before the Irish nation is committed completely to this Agreement, he should submit this to the people at a general election.

When I saw the Taoiseach and his Ministers on television returning from London after the signing of this Agreement, I was expecting them to be dressed in sackcloth but there was no evidence of that. I have always admired Fianna Fáil for their high degree of public brazenness. Only they could get away with it. They tell us here, in the words of the Minister for Justice and in the words of the Taoiseach and other Ministers who have spoken over the past three or four days, that the future of this country now depends on Britain and on the British market, notwithstanding that they devoted the best years of their lives to bringing about the destruction of the British market. Ireland today would perhaps be one of the most prosperous countries in the world—certainly I believe that our prosperity in relation to agriculture would be even superior to that of Denmark—if Fianna Fáil had done in 1932 what they are doing now.

When we see the Taoiseach and other Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party parading through the benches of this House and speaking in high and glowing terms about the British market, we cannot help commenting on what a wonderful change has taken place. They must be congratulated on their conversion to the idea of the great value and usefulness of the British market. I am glad this has been the outcome of many long years of experience of that Party. I do not deny and I shall never deny that I am a believer in the British market. I am a believer in close co-operation with Britain. I am not so foolish as not to realise that if another war ever takes place Ireland must look for its security and safety both to the United States and to Britain. Fianna Fáil have educated themselves after a very long period in which they almost plunged Irish agriculture into disaster.

When listening to the speeches on this Agreement my thoughts went back to the late J.H. Thomas. I am sure that when the documents were being signed at No. 10 Downing Street he was doing spring leaps in his grave. We find those men who devoted all their energies towards saying "The British market is gone and gone forever" and "Burn everything British except their coal" now saying that our prosperity depends very largely on trading between this country and Great Britain. I say without the least fear of contradiction that if we never had to have an economic war in this country, if we never had to have tariff barriers between here and Great Britain, that if we always had the closest possible link between Ireland and Great Britain, we would be enjoying a very high degree of prosperity today. We are an agricultural country of three million people within a stone's throw of Britain where there are 53 million people. We have been looked upon as a vegetable garden for feeding the millions of British people. All that was needed for us to reap the benefit of that situation was a little bit of sanity, a high degree of commonsense, and an effort on the part of Fianna Fáil to realise that Britain was our best customer, our nearest neighbour, the best pay and the most convenient market in the world for our exports.

I suppose it is better late than never that Fianna Fáil have been converted to Fine Gael's policy in that regard. I have been waiting all morning to hear some Fianna Fáil Deputy ask why we are not voting against this Agreement —since we criticise it as not being good enough—but it has not been asked. I presume it has been asked within the past three or four days. Fine Gael have always believed in close trading with Britain and in the British market, while Fianna Fáil decried it and tried to ruin it with great effect. Why now should Fine Gael vote against Fianna Fáil simply for the purpose of voting against them when we see that Fianna Fáil have come to our way of thinking in relation to the importance of the British market? Another reason why Fine Gael are not voting against this Agreement is that if we did vote against it we would be standing for its complete rejection.

We know there must be an agreement with Britain in the interests of the farming and industrial communities and of the economy in general, and because we know there must be an Agreement and that any Agreement is an essential part of our economy, we fully agree with the principle of Agreements with Britain but we feel this Trade Agreement is a bad one. Not only is it a bad effort but it is also a very feeble one. We know from experience that Fianna Fáil have never been good negotiators with the British. We can recall the occasion during the past couple of years when Deputy Smith as Minister for Agriculture went over for important trade talks. He came back with less than he had when he went.

Let us recall also the other talks that have taken place between Fianna Fáil Governments and British Ministers and compare them with the talks between Cumann na nGaedheal and inter-Party Government Ministers. I respectfully put it to the House that the Agreement of 1948 has been responsible for putting millions of pounds into the pockets of Irish farmers, that the livestock industry, and the cattle export industry particularly, would now be non-existent were it not for the 1948 Agreement successfully negotiated with the British.

I should like to know under which article of this Agreement will a penny-piece arrive, by what means it will arrive. I shall be most surprised if anybody can tell me how or where. Can anyone estimate the immediate effect this Agreement will have on our efforts to raise the standard of living in rural Ireland? Has anyone in Fianna Fáil been bold enough to tell us that this Agreement will not be responsible for creating unemployment? Can they tell us how, as a result of the Agreement, a single person in this country will be better off in 12 months' time?

This Agreement is a hoax from start to finish and I would welcome an opportunity—the Taoiseach is too cute to give it—of asking the people of Ireland to judge its value in pounds, shillings and pence in a general election. There is nothing in this Agreement not covered in the 1948 document. The Taoiseach has been speaking loudly about free trade and telling the people that for some years past he has been in touch with the British Government on this question. We must bear in mind in this context that last April we had a general election. Why did the Taoiseach not tell the people that if Fianna Fáil were returned to office he would immediately negotiate a Free Trade Agreement with Britain?

I venture to say that in none of the speeches I read by the Taoiseach or his Ministers — most certainly the speeches made in my constituency— did I see a single line attributed to the Taoiseach in which he said there would be free trade arrangements between ourselves and Britain. It is another example of Fianna Fáil's procedure. The moment a general election is over they proceed to plunge the country into some most unexpected problem. We had it in the case of proportional representation and on many other issues.

That is why I submit the Government are not sincere or serious in relation to this Agreement which is now being boosted by the Fianna Fáil Party, by certain sections of the Press, by radio and television in an effort to create the impression that this is an Agreement which will bring benefits to all sections. I should like to hear from the Government what they have done with their policy of isolation which they have been preaching for years. Do they now realise we cannot live alone? In contrast to the speeches made by Fianna Fáil Deputies in the past few days we may recall speeches of the past and let it be borne in mind by the vast majority of our people that we would have been sunk years ago if it were not for Britain.

We can see the vast amount of employment given to workers from practically every family in Ireland in Britain and the amount of money that comes into Irish homes from the wages earned by Irish workers in practically every town and village in Britain. There are many reasons why Ireland and Britain should have the closest trading relations, the first being the natural one, our geographical situation. It suits Britain to trade with us, but in the long run we have nobody else with whom to trade. It is like an individual criticising his neighbour. Our geographical situation dictates that since Britain is our most convenient outlet we must trade with her. To suggest that we in this small island of three million people could exist without Britain is the height of nonsense. We are dependent on England for every move we make in this country. I am very glad to see, even at this late hour, that there are many speakers now from Fianna Fáil, commencing to realise that, and some of them commencing to profess it and to make it known.

I believe that in this Agreement we have lost a wonderful opportunity and a great chance. When those discussions were arranged, our Government should have been better men for bargaining, should have got better concessions, more guarantees and even more security than they have in this Agreement. As a matter of fact, any good agreement is judged by its value in £ s. d. No wonder the British Farmers Association commented favourably on this Agreement. They came best out of it. Let no man in this House think anything else. The big weight of advantage of this Trade Agreement goes to Britain. Does anybody think anything else or is there any reason why he should? Who is the major bargaining power? Was it the small island of 3,000,000 or the great power of Great Britain with its 52,000,000 people?

When the British Ministers met to discuss this Agreement with the Taoiseach and the Irish Ministers, the solution to the whole problem was that we here in this country knew we cannot live or exist without Britain. The Taoiseach and his Ministers went over, their hats in their hands, to collect the crumbs that fell to them from the table and they were glad to take them. I feel that Fine Gael or an inter-Party Government would have made a much better Trade Agreement for the future of this country, based, first, on the principles of 1948 and its successes, and secondly, on the fine tradition of loyalty to the British market that has always been displayed by the Fine Gael Party. Then we find that men like Harold Wilson and the British Minister for Agriculture are no fools in relation to Irish politics because most of those Members of Parliament, when one meets them from time to time, seem to know so much about activities in this country that they would surprise many of us.

They must have known, and still know, that the men who were over sitting around the table with them as bargainers for the Irish people were the very people who sought for decades to destroy the hopes of success in the British market. The Irish delegation were not competent, were not qualified and did not go over realising the historical importance and background associated with the great value and financial benefit which the British market would be to this country and that they took whatever they were offered. They were not in a position to do any better. They have proved bad at bargaining abroad on behalf of our people whilst the very opposite can be said of the Opposition who had the opportunity of negotiating Trade Agreements abroad.

I want to come to what I consider to be a very important part of this Free Trade Agreement. There is no doubt about it but that this trade agreement, in its present form, whilst applauded in Britain, applauded by Fianna Fáil and taken very cautiously in this country by those engaged in agriculture and industry, must mean unemployment. It must mean more emigration and must mean a greater flight from the land. In other words, the main provisions of this Agreement spell economic disaster for this country. I want to make a reference, if I may, to how and why this Agreement will lead to unemployment.

We have industries in this country which will not be able to stand the test, which will not be able to compete and which cannot possibly compete with imports from Britain, imports which will come in in small quantities after 1st July, and in unlimited quantities in ten years' time. Those small industries, of which the present Taoiseach is the father, in my opinion, are all facing a complete wipe-out. I am sorry for that. I have been a believer, and still am a believer, in Irish industry. I like to see Irish industry survive because we must have in many spheres, particularly in textiles, not alone the best that can be produced in these islands, but the very best that can go into any market in the world. That is why I am glad to see that special mention has been made of the textile trade in this country.

I feel that congratulations should go to all those engaged in the textile trade who were fortunate enough to foresee some time ago what now is happening. When you have men of the foresight of Mr. Declan Dwyer and the board of Sunbeam Wolsey, and the board, present and past, of Salts (Ireland) Ltd., of Tullamore, who have geared themselves up to meet any crisis, there is great hope for the textile industry. Every industry in Ireland is not fortunate enough to be blessed with the same type of men as we have engaged in the textile industry. I venture to say that with free trade in the morning, the Irish textile industry can stand on its own feet at any time, not alone in the British market but in the USA. Canada or any other part of the world where Irish textile products are sent. I am convinced there is great hope for us, whilst we can stand on our own feet, as I believe we can, in relation to the textile industry, and that there must be great hope for industries which can stand on their own feet, and which must stand on their own feet. I appeal to the Government, in the case of industries less fortunate than the textile industry, to give them some assistance either by way of technical help or financial assistance to enable them to stand on their own feet like the textile industry.

Some people are now wondering what is likely to happen to all these industries. I am sure there is great anxiety amongst workers, and their wives and children, who are employed in this industry. Some people may be critical of the Industrial Zone set up some years ago at Shannon Airport. I was very glad and happy to read in this week's External Affairs News Letter a reference to the production of one firm at Shannon. This firm are engaged in piano manufacture at Shannon and they export 97 per cent of their output. They now manufacture one out of every four pianos sold in Germany. I have heard the Shannon Industrial Estate criticised in this House from all sides, but I have never criticised it because I have always had faith in it, and belief in it. Great credit is due to those responsible for giving employment in this firm mentioned in the News Letter and supplying to a great country like Germany one out of every four pianos sold there.

When we consider a successful industry such as this and the textile industry, it must follow that there are many other industries that could succeed too. I have faith, and belief, and confidence, in the people engaged in Irish industry. I believe we can compete with the best. I believe that our products will be bought. All our industries need is to be geared up, but the big problem is that they are beginning to be geared up too late, and that is where I fault the Government. They should have been devoting more time to letting the people know that a free trade arrangement between Britain and Ireland was coming. They made prophecies from time to time, but never with any degree of certainty until the announcement of this Trade Agreement.

It must come to pass that under-equipped small industries, with no big sales organisations in Britain and on the Continent, must fall in free trade conditions between ourselves and Britain, and whatever they produce for our own home market, for our own three million people, at the end of a ten-year period I venture to say Britain will be cute enough, and clever enough, and successful enough, to wipe them out completely. These are our people, and I fear for their jobs and for their future.

The Taoiseach or the Minister for Justice did not tell us what employment will be provided at home for all those who will lose their jobs in industries that are not fully geared to meet the very keen competition that will flood in upon us from Britain. It will not do to tell the workers in industries and factories which are closing down that they must be patriotic, and that they must have a sense of duty and pride. That will not do. Nor will it do for the Government to put their thumbs in their teeth when they are asked by the trade unions and the workers what arrangements they have made to put into employment the thousands of workers who, in my opinion, will be displaced as a result of their free trade arrangements for industry.

I see in the papers this week that the unemployment figure has increased by 10,000. What will be the figure in time to come, unless the Government seriously consider all aspects of the employment position? I am convinced that the economic benefits attaching to this Agreement are far greater for Britain than they are for this country. Britain is not concerned with an unemployment problem. Britain is not concerned with obtaining markets at profitable prices for her produce. Britain is not concerned with survival. She has a healthy agricultural and industrial economy, and a population to consume what she produces, as well as her markets abroad. We have nothing. We have not even the population to consume a fraction of what we produce. Our population is diminishing and dwindling. Our marriage rate must be one of the lowest in the world. There seems to be a flight from the land. We seem to have perhaps the most disturbed industrial relations in the world. For some time past the order of industrial activity here seems to have been the use of the strike weapon.

I thought that a trade agreement between ourselves and Britain would give security of employment to our workers, guaranteed markets and prices for farmers, and a general all-round guarantee of profitable markets for every single item we produced. That is not so. Ireland is depending more on Britain every day, and this Agreement, made recently by the Taoiseach and his Ministers, makes our dependence on Britain greater and greater. We heard from the Minister for Justice this morning that if Britain goes into the Common Market, Ireland must follow. We cannot close our eyes to the fact that we are tied tightly to Britain's apron strings and that the knots are now being tied tighter by this Agreement. There are many national-minded people who think this is wrong but I am inclined to disagree with them. I do not profess to condemn Britain, or trading or negotiating with Britain, but I am sure that when the commemoration ceremonies for the 50th Anniversary of 1916 take place, many of those who will be making speeches will be blushing. I believe it is a good thing that we should be tied closely to Britain but that is a personal opinion on my part. The closer we are tied the less chance we have of sinking completely. I am convinced of that, particularly because of the tremendous failures we have had over the past 40 years. As I said, many branches of industry will survive and many will meet with disaster but I ask the Government to assist industries such as the boot and shoe industry. I do not know if any reference has been made to industries which are likely to meet with disaster. The boot and shoe industry is one that is going to be very seriously hampered by this Trade Agreement. I said I was not afraid for the textile industry but I am afraid for this industry. There are a number of footwear factories in my constituency, in Edenderry, Birr and just outside Carlow, which are employing a number of my constituents. I dread to think what is going to happen to the managements and to the workers associated with the footwear industry. I hope before long we will hear something from the Government about the possibility of something being done for such industries. At the end of ten years there can be a flood into this country of boots and shoes made in Britain and I am afraid that appealing to the patriotic feelings of our people will not be enough if they can buy footwear, which has been made in England, cheaper and which they consider to be of a standard equal to that of the home product.

I venture to say that when that day comes, Britain can dump unlimited supplies of footwear into this country and our shoe and boot factories will not have a hope in hell of competing against them. Appealing to people to buy Irish will not be enough because the Irish will buy what they consider is the best at the cheapest possible rate. Without action on the part of the Government, this could result in the closing down of every boot and shoe factory in the country. That is why I appeal to the Government to take the necessary steps under this Agreement, whether after 1st July or at the end of the five year period, or whenever it is, to ensure that there will be employment in the industry. The first industry to be protected and catered for must be the footwear industry. The Government may say that there are other branches of industry which deserve prior attention. That may be so but it is up to every Deputy to speak for his own area. I am convinced that this Trade Agreement spells disaster in capital letters for the entire footwear industry.

Comment on this

What about Article XI?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

That is what I am asking about.

Comment on this

There is provision in that.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I know that nobody is more with me in this than Deputy Lenihan. I have always appreciated, even before he came into this House, his efforts to promote industry. He has done a good job for industry and it is a pity that there have not been more active men in industry, having the same spirit for the promotion of industry, as the Deputy. Industries with which he has been associated from time to time have provided employment for many of my constituents on the Westmeath border. However, it is not that which prompts me to pay him this compliment. A Deputy of his experience could contribute much around the council table and be of immense value in determining what industries deserve a measure of protection under the Article to which I have referred.

Comment on this

Thank you. Timeo Danaos et dona ferentes.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I hope the footwear industry will be one of the first industries to be looked after in this respect. There are other industries which will be seriously affected. There is the motor and vehicle assembly industry which provides considerable employment. We also have such firms as Dunlops and other firms engaged in the tyre and shoe business which give very great employment. We also have industries engaged in leather, pottery, hosiery and a wide variety of engineering goods, I feel that industries of this kind are going to be very seriously hampered by this Agreement. I hope the Department of Industry and Commerce are already taking the necessary steps under the Article in the Agreement to provide support for those industries in order to guarantee against loss of employment.

If I were asked what were the advantages in the Agreement, I would have to say the only advantage I see in it is the one in respect of the textile industry. I am glad of that advantage and welcome it. I am convinced our textile industry can stand on its feet and compete with the best in the world.

A good deal has been said, particularly by my colleague, Deputy L'Estrange, in relation to the benefits under this Agreement to the farmers. I cannot see how there is any benefit to the farmers in this Agreement. They are going to get nothing more than they have — nothing more in £.s.d. Under the Agreement we are guaranteed access to the British market for cattle, sheep and lambs on the hoof. Reference was made to that this morning by the Minister for Justice. Have we not had that position for the past 30 years? Where is there any advantage in repeating what already exists?

On the question of the shortening from three months to two months of the period during which Irish unfattened animals must remain on a farm in the United Kingdom before they qualify to be paid the full regulated price, that will be of no advantage either. It is not worth a twopenny damn to the Irish farmer. Can anybody, from the Taoiseach down to Deputy Corry, tell me how that is going to be of benefit to the Irish farmer? It may or may not be of financial help to those engaged in the shipment of livestock—I do not know —but, as far as £.s.d. into the pockets of the farmers is concerned, I cannot see how it will be of any benefit whatever. Fianna Fáil will have to talk about some benefit better than that one.

Several Deputies referred to the butter quota. I cannot understand the Minister for Justice on this. I cannot understand how you can have free trade and quotas at the same time. The amount of Irish butter which Britain will allow to be sold on her market has been raised from 19,000 tons last year to 23,000 tons this year. What great advantage is there to crow over in that, particularly when it is remembered that the Irish Exchequer must pay a subsidy of 1/6d on every lb of butter exported? The Irish taxpayer has to buy a postal order for 1/6d in which to wrap every lb of butter sent to Britain.

We are making the British housewife a present of that in order to enable her to buy Irish butter at a cheaper rate, while many people at home are unable to buy Irish butter at all. There seems to be an extraordinary blunder here. We are paying the British 1/6 per lb for eating our butter. The butter is being sold at 2/9 per lb in London, Manchester and elsewhere. Yet the same butter costs 4/7 per lb in Ireland. I could never understand that. This Trade Agreement makes that arrangement more secure. Thanks to Fianna Fáil and the Minister for Agriculture, we will still have to pay a subsidy of £112 per ton on butter exported to Britain. The Irish taxpayer will have to write a cheque for £112, with our compliments and good wishes, in respect of every ton of butter we export. I would love to hear them explaining that at the church gates or in the towns and cities. Butter costs 4/7 per lb here. It is sold in Britain at 2/9 per lb. Yet with every pound we export, we send a postal order for 1/6 to the British housewife—good luck to her—in order that she can enjoy the flavour of Irish creamery butter.

Was the Taoiseach at the conference table for that? Was the Minister for Agriculture? Was the Minister for Industry and Commerce there? Was the Minister for Finance there? I am completely alarmed that something has not been done in regard to this butter problem which usually crops up here and the subsidy which the Irish taxpayer must continue to pay.

Having dealt with butter, cattle, sheep and lambs, where are the safeguards? I see no safeguards there. Where are the advantages? I see no advantages there. I see disadvantages. I most certainly see not even the benefit of a threepenny bit to anybody engaged in agriculture.

There is one safeguard in the whole Agreement, that is, the safeguard the Minister for Justice was good enough to direct to my attention. It is a very good safeguard. That safeguard alone must justify those of us in Fine Gael for not voting against this Agreement. But I feel that this safeguard, such as it is, does not go far enough, is not effective enough, is not concrete enough, is not sufficiently explanatory. Before I comment further on it, I should like to hear what the trade union people think of the safeguards in this Agreement. Are they sufficient? Are they strong enough? Have we sufficient liberty to safeguard the employment of workers in Irish industry. I should be very anxious to see what the trade union movement have to say on that. In my opinion, it is something in the right direction but is not sufficiently tight.

I can foresee many industries in different parts of the country having to meet the extraordinary position that goods will be dumped in this country. I can see endless trouble and the Minister going to and coming from London. I can see endless trouble with the trade unions and endless trouble in the homes of the workers when this most unpleasant state of affairs arises.

I do not know if there is anything more in this Agreement than what we have been told. Where there is heavy unemployment, quotas may be imposed on imports for 18 months. If the British Government agree, industries with heavy unemployment may get an extension of the period of tariff reduction for five years but each case must be examined on its merits. I can see trouble in my constituency about this. What will happen if the British Government say they do not agree that a serious unemployment problem exists? Our Minister will go to London and say, in effect: "Here is an industry in which hundreds of workers will be forced out of employment as a result of your dumping in this country." But the Trade Agreement clearly states that, if the British Government agree, industries with heavy unemployment may get an extension of the tariff period. What happens if the British Government do not agree? Surely that is a very great advantage to the British? They have nothing to do except to say: "We do not agree. Go back home, man. We do not agree that our dumping in relation to industry is as serious as you say. Go back home." The Agreement is there and now there is nothing we can do about it. I hope we shall hear more about this. I am sure that every branch of Irish industry is examining this clause at the moment because, as it stands and as I read it, the British Government must agree and must approve of it: otherwise the concession for the extension of the tariffs will not be permitted. I most certainly can see very serious consequences in that regard.

We have often advocated the setting up by the State—and I think very recently we have dealt with it—of industrial areas and industrial zones. I am not satisfied that the Taoiseach or the Minister for Industry and Commerce has given the country sufficient information as to how they stand in relation to the establishment of State or semi-State industries. I venture to say that quite a number of people must be worried about this. If private enterprise has fallen flat in regard to an industry, if we see and know that such an industry is essential from the employment point of view and that raw material in a particular area may be an essential consideration, if we decide to set up a semi-State body and a board to run an industry in this country, I wonder if such is permitted under this Trade Agreement? I should also like to know the position in relation to any further industries which may be set up by a State board or by a semi-State body or even by the board who are so efficiently managing the industries at Shannon Airport. That is a very important matter. It is so important that it deserves the very serious consideration of this House and of the country.

As I said earlier, I have been a believer in the industries that have been set up at Shannon. I continue to be. I have visited the Industrial Zone and I have no reason to have anything but the greatest admiration for the skill, efficiency and, above all, the employment I have seen. If I see men working in a factory, that satisfies me that that, in itself, is serving a useful purpose. I should like to see the Shannon industries develop. I know these industries are all for export but I do feel, as time goes on, there may be other activities to which this board could very usefully devote its energies in relation to the establishment of industries. Some provision should be made to permit State or semi-State companies to enter into the industrial field where private enterprise has failed.

One other point I feel deserves mention here is the Buy Irish campaign. We have conducted a most successful campaign which has had very good results in relation to the buying of Irish goods. Quite an amount of money has been spent on sponsoring and fostering the Buy Irish campaign. When this Agreement is in full swing or when England can dump in here whatever goods she wants, when we have free trade between the two countries, does that mean the end of the Buy Irish campaign? That most certainly means that the amount of money already spent on the organisation at present in existence is also gone under this Agreement. There will be no discrimination, on the ground of country of origin, between Irish and British goods. Does that lead me to believe that when, as a result of this Agreement, British goods come in unlimited quantities into this country, there is to be no discrimination in relation to the origin of the goods and the merchant will no longer be in a position to put up in his window "Buy Irish" in preference to the British goods? According to the Agreement, I understand the origin of the goods cannot be questioned and there is to be no discrimination whatever between them. Therefore when the Irish Ministers went over to Britain, one of their achievements was the making of the coffin for the Buy Irish campaign. Back they came, and the speeches made by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, by the Taoiseach and indeed by all of us who are anxious to promote the buying of Irish goods have fallen completely by the wayside because when this Free Trade Agreement is in operation, according to the arrangement between the two countries, that is the end of our Buy Irish slogan.

I do not know what are the political implications involved in this Agreement. Listening to Deputies speaking of the political implications involved, I should like to know what they really mean. I say—and I say it here exactly as I would in my own constituency— the time has now come when we can no longer be like the robin hopping from branch to branch. If another war comes—God forbid that it should—we have not got any very great choice as to where we shall stand. Our stand, naturally, must be on the side of those who stand for freedom and liberty, as against those who are opposed to those ideals. Therefore, linking ourselves economically with Britain would not have any great political implications on our future because commonsense would tell us that our place, in the event of any world disturbances, would be on the side of Britain and the great United States. We have no other choice.

Comment on this

If France goes to war, what do we do?

Comment on this

Take French leave.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I have always been a great believer in the closest possible links with Britain.

Comment on this

You are not alone there.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

I am now in very good company. I was looking around me here this morning and the two members who sat longest in the House during this debate were Deputy Everett and myself. I was wondering what was crossing Deputy Everett's mind after his long experience as a member of this House because no man has the experience of Deputy Everett, having listened to the debates here since the establishment of the State. No man has heard the British market being murdered a thousand times over more often than Deputy Everett and, indeed, myself, for the past 23 years.

However, it is very refreshing and does one good to see what we could describe as the extraordinary conversion. I am glad I have lived to see the day when Fianna Fáil — and every Fianna Fáil TD without exception because none of them has objected to this Agreement — is now a greater advocate of the British market than any Deputy in Fine Gael ever was. I am glad that has taken place. May I say that the Fine Gael Party have contributed generously to that conversion of Fianna Fáil? I hope the next Fianna Fáil speaker will give us a little credit for what we have achieved by our display here of commonsense and intelligence in that we have brought Fianna Fáil around to our way of thinking, something we thought impossible. I welcome that conversion and I hope the new converts to the British market will give it the respect it deserves.

Looking at the motions set out in the Order Paper reminds me to recommend highly to the House the motion of Fine Gael. This Party, as the motion states, is concerned with the effect of free trading on employment and emigration and it deplores the fact that the Agreement, as negotiated, is unbalanced and that the concessions obtained are small in the immediate future and limited and insecure thereafter. That sums up this Agreement.

Whenever the opportunity arises it will be the duty of Fine Gael to seek immediate consultations with the British Government with a view to putting right the imbalance clearly evident in this Agreement. If anybody is to be congratulated on it, it is the British Government. They have most successfully wiped the eyes of every Minister who was in London. I do not wonder that many British interests are highly pleased by the Agreement, as victory has gone to Mr. Wilson. He will not have the responsibility of dealing with our unemployment situation or of providing the 1/6 per lb for the butter he will be eating. We must pay it. He will not have to deal with the industries that would be seriously affected by British dumping into this country. Mr. Wilson and the British people stand to gain: it is a good Agreement for them but, in my opinion, has no advantages for Ireland. I venture to say that this time next year or in two years or three years— please God we shall all live to see it— nobody in Ireland will be a penny richer as a result of this Agreement which is so loudly acclaimed by Fianna Fáil.

I prophesy this Agreement will bring disaster and destruction to many branches of agriculture and a complete wave of disaster to Irish industry. Whenever the next Government take office they will have a great task in endeavouring to correct the irregularities in this Agreement into which the British have gulled the Taoiseach and his Ministers. It is most inappropriate that in 1966 the Taoiseach should go to England to sell this country completely to the British because this Agreement is a complete sell out, industry, agriculture, exports and way of life. As has been said by every speaker here, the weight of advantages is certainly on the British side. We do not blame them for that. They are hardheaded, experienced, and shrewd businessmen and naturally if they meet a few Irishmen whom they can blindfold, hoodwink and talk into something, disguising their own advantages and mesmerising our representatives, they will do it. That is what happened. I should like to see what would happen in this House if Deputy J.A. Costello as Taoiseach had come back with this Agreement or Deputy Dillon, or Deputy Cosgrave, the present Leader of Fine Gael. I venture to say none of them would be allowed to speak in the House. There would be shouts from everyone: "You sold the country. You are wrapped up in the Union Jack."

I can remember an occasion on which I think the Ceann Comhairle had to call in an usher to restrain Deputy Smith when everybody in the House thought he would have a heart attack because of the violent manner in which he and the Minister for Local Government were screaming at Deputy Costello and Deputy Dillon that they were harming the country, that they were not good Irishmen. Where is the sell out today? Must it not be honestly admitted, as has been said here already, that they have remade the founder of the Party, altered his ideas, trampled on their so-called principles and have now sold out lock, stock and barrel to the British? I should be greatly surprised if an effort is not made to fly the Tricolour with the Union Jack over this House. Why not do it decently? They allowed the British to wipe their eyes but Mr. Wilson would not wipe Deputy Dillon's eyes and the British Premier did not wipe Deputy Costello's eyes in 1948 or Deputy Norton's eyes or Deputy Morrissey's when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce.

Whatever concealed advantages are in this Agreement one advantage that can be seen now and always is the financial benefits that flowed from the 1948 Trade Agreement that put millions into the pockets of Irish farmers.

I make this very genuine appeal to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs who is representing the Government here at this moment to ask the Taoiseach, in the name of democracy, now that he has succeeded in selling us out completely to Mr. Wilson and has been responsible for giving Captain O'Neill in the Six Countries a terrific degree of security and prosperity to tell us on which side of the House the republican Party is. The North stands to gain more than we do out of this Agreement. Maybe that is what was arranged. We do not know. Maybe in the little talks going on between Captain O'Neill and the Taoiseach this sell-out to Britain was discussed. The fact of the matter is that there has been a complete sell-out. We stand to gain nothing; Britain stands to gain all. If anybody can tell me after this Trade Agreement in what part of this House the republican Party is, I should like to know.

Comment on this

Both of you.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

This is an extraordinary somersault on the part of Fianna Fáil. Some members of that Party who would have looked down their noses at the mention of England or anything connected with the Empire are now the key advocates of the closest link, the closest co-operation and the closest possible identity with Britain. I congratulate them. I think they deserve to be congratulated. I welcome all these new converts. While the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture, Mr. Haughey, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Dr. Hillery, and the Minister for Finance, Mr. Lynch, did not return from England in sackcloth, I am sure all the Fianna Fáil Deputies this week-end and next week-end will go down to their constituents and appear before them in sackcloth and will strike their breasts and say, “Mea culpa, mea culpa” and beg the forgiveness of their constituents for all the harmful and rude things they have said about the British market over the past quarter of a century.

I am sure that the loving, warmhearted Irish people will forgive them and will admire and appreciate them for at last taking a leaf out of Fine Gael's book and accepting that the steps that were taken by Cumann na nGaedheal, by Fine Gael and by the inter-Party Government to bring about close co-operation between this country and Britain were wise and good and will believe that in future they are all going to be good boys, that they will be silent so far as the British market is concerned. I am sure these Deputies will ask the people's forgiveness for selling Irish industry, for selling Irish agricultural workers and allowing Mr. Harold Wilson to wipe their eye.

I do not see any benefits accruing to us from this Agreement. I can see that we must have an Agreement, that there must be an Agreement there. This Agreement is a feeble effort. It has been a failure. Sooner or later it will have to be replaced by an Agreement which will give the balance of benefit to this country and will not give the balance of benefit to Britain, as it was given by the Taoiseach and his Ministers last month.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan Minister for Posts and Telegraphs (Mr. J. Brennan) Fianna Fáil

I can assure the House that I shall be very brief because there are many others who wish to speak and I have no intention of going over ground that has been covered very extensively and comprehensively in the past few days. I had no intention of speaking but to sit here and not be provoked to say something is rather difficult. The inconsistencies in all the speeches from the other side of the House would be too numerous to mention. The last speaker, having described the Agreement as a disaster, a complete sell-out, then congratulated the people who made it on their conversion to the same way of thinking as Fine Gael, which would seem to indicate that they wished to sell out and that they would be in favour of it, despite the fact that it is alleged to involve untold disasters for the country. Of course, that will all be taken with a grain of salt.

I, in accord with the farming community of the country and with the well-established industries which Fianna Fáil have set up over the years, feel that this is a good Agreement. It is good for many reasons. Anybody listening to Fine Gael speeches and trying to analyse them must discover that they also say it is a good Agreement, if one applies a little of Euclid to the argument that it is only a continuation of the 1948 Agreement.

Comment on this

As far as agriculture is concerned.

Comment on this

The 1948 Agreement, we are told, is good. Therefore, this Agreement is good. The previous speaker said that the 1948 Agreement put millions of pounds into the pockets of the farmers and in the next breath, said that this Agreement will not mean one single penny to anyone, although, according to him, it is a continuation of the 1948 Agreement. This is absolute nonsense that one hears from people, probably from the lack of something better to say, who are not even opposing the Agreement, who criticise it in the extreme, using superlatives to condemn it but who know perfectly well that it is an Agreement which must be regarded by every economist, examine it as he may, as an Agreement that puts us in an improved position vis-á-vis the British market or any other market that is available to us. It spells out security for the foreseeable future for agriculture and merely does for industry in this country what it inevitably had to face sooner or later and for which it was already being prepared.

The allegation that somebody is converted to something makes me smile. The previous speaker referred to older Deputies who would remember the things that Fianna Fáil used to say about the British market. We all remember what we used to say and had to say at a time when the land annuities were neither legally nor morally due and Fine Gael drove some of their best colleagues to prompt the British to put a tariff on our agricultural exports to Britain in order to recoup themselves for the loss of the annuities that we were withholding at the time and we engaged in an economic war where the survival of the fittest was the rule of the day and where we did have to slaughter calves to keep down the cattle population. All is fair in love and war. It is part of what we had to do. A bishop who said that the land of the O'Donnells would not be the first to surrender knew what we were up against. We had to stand on our own feet, uphold our diginity and the prestige of this country and the very men who fought such fights as that, just like the men of 1916, left us in a position to stand on our own two feet and make such an Agreement as this on equal terms with England or any other country.

I can easily visualise the inferiority complex that affects even the intellect of every individual on the opposite side, who can see nothing but a Lloyd George whenever they go to negotiate something and feel that they must come back hoodwinked and bluffed. We are living in a new atmosphere and in different times. If a country has gained sovereignty, that sovereignty must be expressed in terms of ability freely to negotiate even with people who were our enemy and if the climate of relations has improved it is due to the fact that we paid dearly for putting ourselves in a position where we have the ability and now the prestige and the sovereignty to make agreements.

Who is converted? I remember hearing in this House, and before I came into this House reading reports, of the efforts that were being made at the time when the Taoiseach, Seán Lemass, then Minister for Industry and Commerce, set out to give this country an industrial arm with a foresight, which was not then believed in by a single member of the Opposition. They mocked and jeered at what they described as the "back lane" factories which were given protective tariff walls and bemoaned the lot of the Irish people who were being compelled to buy home-produced goods which, they alleged, were inferior and incapable of competing with the goods imported from the bigger manufacturers abroad.

The same people are now crying out about industry being endangered. I remember Deputy Dillon saying that Fianna Fáil would put Aspros on a string and call that a factory: he was insinuating that it was the duty of the country to produce agricultural goods and not manufactured goods. Those were the days in which Irish industry got its feet firmly on the ground. Any person, no matter how elementary his knowledge of industry may be, must have foreseen that it was inevitable, if we were to continue raising the standard of living to the point at which we could cater for an increasing population, that we would have to export, and exporting means that industries must become efficient and capable of exporting.

Our industries today are not afraid of competition from any quarter, except perhaps those countries in which low wage rates are paid, countries which, if they had free access to our market, could dump goods here at uncompetitive prices. Britain is not paying slave wages in the industrial field. We should be capable of competing with people who are paying wages as high as those we are paying and, in many cases, higher. The only thing we have to ensure is that we are equally efficient and equally competitive. That is a position into which we will have to get sooner or later and now is as good a time as any to prepare for it.

Any person, here or elsewhere, who thinks that Irish industry can continue indefinitely to be sheltered by protection and, at the same time, expand and export to other markets, must either not understand the rudiments of industrial expansion or else pretend he does not understand them. I see nothing to worry about. As has been pointed out here repeatedly, if the rhythm of tariff reductions exposes some of our industries to more serious competition, certain steps will have to be taken to enable those industries to face that competition. Provision is made in this respect. Already we have to do something with regard to exports when we found ourselves faced with the temporary British surcharge. Our manufacturers did not for one moment baulk at the difficulties they had to face when this surcharge was imposed. More power to them.

When the history of this century comes to be written impartially for the benefit of future generations, the one man who will find a proper place in the annals of the industrialisation of this country will be Seán Lemass. He must at times be amused by the criticism of himself for exposing industry to competition, or doing something which, it is alleged, will impede the progress of this country. I commend his foresight in encouraging, fostering and sponsoring industries here of a type which many people, and certainly most of the present main Opposition, said we were not capable of supporting but which ultimately proved to be industries that could succeed, and did succeed. That in itself is ample evidence of the foresight of Seán Lemass. The House owes it to him to pay tribute to the years he devoted and the battles he fought in the interests of establishing, promoting and expanding industry here. I would back his opinion at any time in relation to our future industrial development against that of any other man.

I do not believe that any Deputy, whether he be Labour or Fine Gael, believes for one moment that this is anything but a good Agreement. In it I see long-term security. I predict that those who most vehemently oppose it now will a few years hence say: "Oh, we knew it would work out all right if things went the right way. That is why it has succeeded." There will be few to criticise it. I suppose that is why we have had such a flimsy effort here at opposition. Does anybody believe in the speech we have just heard from Deputy O.J. Flanagan? Does anybody pay serious attention to that kind of thing?

Comment on this

17,000 people in Laois-Offaly.

Comment on this

"We have sold out to the British.""We are faced with disaster.""This spells ruination." An opposition speech, if it is to be constructive and logical, must be serious. Some reason must be introduced into it. I do not think it matters a hoot what Deputy O.J. Flanagan says because no one will take it seriously anyway.

There were many people who did not approve of those who signed the Proclamation in 1916. There were many who did not think much of them. But the signatories of that Proclamation foresaw an Ireland in which we would be free to do what we liked, even in regard to those with whom we were then going into combat. Those who tried to tell us that, because we fought for our independence, we should now refuse, having got a measure of independence, to use that independence as the dignity of that independence permits in order to make agreements are digging with the wrong foot. I see many good features in this Agreement. It is designed to improve our trading relations. I see no dangers in it.

Comment on this

I hope the Minister is right.

Comment on this

That is my candid opinion. Access to the British market is given to us immediately——

Comment on this

We had it already.

Comment on this

—— without let or hindrance, even to the extent of enjoying the price support applied by the British to their own agricultural produce. The rhythm of the imports from Britain here will give us sufficient time to prepare for any impact they may have. We have been permitted to exclude certain goods which we thought could not stand up to free trade. There are no political commitments or ties. We are free to sell in any market we like.

Comment on this

Oh, no.

Comment on this

Not now.

Comment on this

We must first, for example, supply Britain with 636,000 stores.

Comment on this

Those who manufacture goods can compete in any market they wish to supply. Fine Gael hoped this Agreement would give them something to talk about and they suggested we were confining ourselves to some particular market and precluding our entry to others. Ultimately when they discovered these things did not happen, they had a long discussion.

Comment on this

Read the Green Book.

Comment on this

It is wrong for a Minister to make such a comment.

Comment on this

They could not agree to oppose it in the House, and one of the Labour speakers said they had not the guts.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil opposed the 1948 Agreement.

Comment on this

I am talking about this Agreement. They said they could not see any good in it—although privately they did—and they decided to attack it, right, left and centre, in the House. That inconsistency is not easy to explain. One finds a member of the Fine Gael Party standing up in the Front bench and saying that every time we sell a pound of butter we send a postal order for 1/6d with it to the British housewife. That is what they would like the people to believe. The creameries of this country know perfectly well what the position is in relation to butter and nothing Deputies opposite can say to misrepresent the position will change their minds. They know we must subsidise our exports of butter in order to enable the exports to take place, and what is the good in trying to pretend otherwise? It would be just as sensible to talk of the days when the people opposite imported butter when they were the Government.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil imported it in 1946 and 1947, Danish yellow butter.

Comment on this

Dillon's yellow butter. It may be that the circumstances at the time made it necessary for the Deputy's Government to do it, but why should they talk about the subsidisation of dairy products which is necessary in order to ensure that our cattle population will increase? Do they think they will get any support for that argument from the agricultural community?

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange can go up to Donegal and bluff a few people but he will not do it here.

Comment on this

There were 250 active men and women present that night. They see a change. We are proud of that.

Comment on this

The young ones must not have published their names. I read the supplied report.

Comment on this

That is completely wrong. I supplied no report. There were three reporters present.

Comment on this

Give the man a chance. He is the only Minister who did not read his speech.

Comment on this

Every Deputy must have regard to the effect that any action taken by the Government will have on his own constituency. I am very pleased at the improvement which is bound to ensure in the sheep trade as a result of the better conditions for the export of store sheep or carcase lamb. This is very important to the western seaboard, particularly to Donegal. I am very glad also that as the main tweed manufacturing county in Ireland, Donegal is facing a bright future under this Agreement in regard to the textile industry. These are two important factors, apart from anything we may say here for or against the Agreement, about which I am personally happy and which will be of the greatest possible benefit to the people of my county.

I do not think it necessary to emphasise—even some of the Fine Gael people have said this outside the House—that we cannot improve our standards, or support an increasing population without access to foreign markets and without exporting. Exporting our manufacturing goods essentially means getting away from protection on the home market. This is what I did not quite understand in regard to the Labour approach to the Agreement, when they expressed, as the last speaker did, a fear about thousands and thousands being thrown out of employment in industry.

Comment on this

There are 7,700 gone since the day the Agreement was signed, according to today's paper.

Comment on this

The whole question of a better manufacturing industry in this country is bound up with the ability to export. That means that the industry must be efficient and be able to compete with others. We can do it, and industry has spoken and said it is not afraid to do it. What would be the position of industry 30 or 40 years ago? First of all, there was none. Those were the days when Fianna Fáil were accused of establishing backlane industries, protecting inferior industries. Those were the days when industry began in spite of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

There are many things one could talk about that are best forgotten.

Comment on this

We can look back on the past with pride.

Comment on this

We can. The people who have the same attitude towards Britain are the very same people who were shouting the same things in days which will be commemorated this year.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil are starting off well by selling out the country.

Comment on this

It comes ill from that side of the House to be talking about selling the country.

Comment on this

"The British market is gone and gone for ever, thanks be to God."

Comment on this

The days of the "damn good bargain" and the days of submission to threats are gone. We make bargains on the basis of equality with others. We stand on our own feet. We know that we make them for the betterment of the country. We used the dignity of the freedom for which we fought and won to make this Agreement. Nothing that can be said from that side of the House can take from the reputation they have in regard to bargaining which will besmirch their record for future generations. I am annoyed listening to people making silly statements that are not supported by anything that can be reconciled with the past. We have achieved a good Agreement and we have been able to make it on the ground of equality.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil can thank this side of the House for the fact that they are even governing the country today.

Comment on this

We are happy to know that we have gained security for our agricultural produce for the future, that we have put our industry in the position where it is capable of withstanding competition and that we have finally reached the stage, which we inevitably had to reach, of exporting and being able to face competition from imports. These are things in the Agreement which highlight its worth and extol those who negotiated it. They did a good job.

The very word "agreement" means give and take and in this Agreement most of the taking is on our side. We get free access immediately for our agricultural produce and participation in British supports to a valuable extent. On our side, the removal of tariffs has been fixed during a period of ten years, giving us a chance, ample time, to prepare for the competition that will come. We have been allowed to exclude certain items which would not be able to stand up to competition and we are permitted to continue protection for certain items. The national sovereignty is in no way affected. If anything, the climate in the relationship with our fellow Irishmen across the Border has been enhanced and the old bigotry that has done so much harm has been dealt another blow. This has opened a new door to increased and continued development and prosperity in this country. It is a significant Agreement which will be judged better in retrospect, one which will reflect on those who negotiated it the highest possible praise and give to them a reputation in our history as being the team who negotiated a satisfactory Agreement with Britain outside the old Lloyd George climate.

Comment on this

I rise to support the Labour Party amendment, and if I had any doubts on the matter, they were dissolved by the contribution of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, speaking without a brief, because his arguments, or lack of argument, would not convince anybody inside or outside the House that there is any value in the Agreement. He reiterated a number of points which have been coming from Fianna Fáil Ministers, notorious for making statements at election times which subsequently are proved incorrect.

Not so long ago we had, in one of these statements, the promise of 100,000 new jobs. Fianna Fáil claim to have been responsible for the industrialisation of the country and today the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs supported that claim. When he opened the debate, the Taoiseach spoke about lazy industrialists. According to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, it was the Taoiseach who established these industries over the years. The Taoiseach did not think it worthwhile to name the lazy industrialists who were not doing their job. I agree there are many lazy industrialists who are not doing their job, who, behind a barrier of protection for years, have not been doing the job entrusted to them, have not been improving their competitive position or providing decently remunerated, secure employment for their workers, many of them being staunch supporters of Fianna Fáil.

There is one significant feature about the debate and to some extent it may be a welcome factor. Though there have been cracks and repartee across the floor of the House, the debate revealed a union of souls between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, long awaited, long anticipated and, we hope, in this year when we celebrate the 50th anniversary of the Easter Rising, nearly realised. Now and again in moments of heat, the old sores are still opened across the floor of the House but there now seems to be hope that they will be finally healed. While there has been a lot of criticism of the Agreement from the Fine Gael benches, they have made it quite clear they will not vote against its adoption.

The method by which the Agreement reached the House is a matter of interest to us in the Labour Party and to many people throughout the country. During the course of the debate it transpired that Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Government as far back as 1963 had seriously considered the possibility of exploring free trade channels with Britain.

Comment on this

November, 1964.

Comment on this

It was probably being considered before that time. Fianna Fáil are past masters at keeping to themselves information which they do not think the electorate, the ordinary people of the country, should know before an election. We had a general election a few months ago and during the course of that campaign Fianna Fáil gave not the slightest indication that they had started along this road with Great Britain, demonstrating quite clearly that they were afraid to tell the truth to the Irish people. Possibly they feared that the Irish people would not think of discussing the prospect of free trade arrangements with Britain at a time when they had an opportunity of exercising a choice.

This is not the first time Fianna Fáil adopted tactics of that kind and I do not think it will be the last time because here they refer to as a Free Trade Agreement, one which imposes certain restrictions and certain limitations on the agricultural industry, while at the same time exposing the industrial side of our economy to increasing competition. We have been repeatedly told here the number of store cattle which may be exported to Britain. We have been told not only that, but also the number which must be exported. I read in one of the morning newspapers yesterday that Britain was in trouble with Denmark, one of her partners in the EFTA, because Britain was exporting cattle to West Germany. I wonder if Britain is taking advantage of the availability of Irish store cattle and the fact that Ireland must export a certain number every year to Britain to have an advantageous deal with West Germany? Would there have been a possibility, in the absence of the provision in this Agreement for export of Irish cattle, of Irish farmers exporting cattle to West Germany? Certainly they could not do it now unless they first of all supplied Britain with the 634,000 head.

Comment on this

It is 638,000.

Comment on this

Well, I do not think we will quarrel about 4,000. I do not claim to be an agriculturist. Yet, we are told by the experts in agriculture in this House, without this Agreement, in existing circumstances, the farmers could sell 638,000, or, in fact, more, to Great Britain without any difficulty. The Ministers, of course, tell us that the benefit is there and Britain must take them up to that number. That, of course, could be a benefit if and when the situation arose where Britain had a surplus. Is that likely to take place in the circumstances of the development of the British economy? If Britain develops, substanially and successfully, she will probably still need more cattle than she could produce and the farmers might well consider that they would be reasonably secure without this Agreement.

There is another aspect of this matter. Again, without any agricultural knowledge, but with sufficient knowledge gained from listening to the debates in this House from time to time, from the point of view of employment—and that is the aspect of the Agreement with which the Labour Party are concerned—the least rewarding is the store cattle trade. It is also the least rewarding from the point of view of enabling Irishmen to provide for their families and enjoy a decent standard of living.

The store cattle trade is very valuable from the point of view of the balance of payments. We appreciate that in the present difficulties. These difficulties were not mentioned, or even hinted at, six or seven months ago when the Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, and his satellites, were occupying full page advertisements in the newspapers, were appearing on television, were having meetings all over the place, and when everything in the garden was lovely. There was no great indication, at that particular time, that a fall-off, whether temporary or otherwise, in this particular trade, would have such catastrophic effects as it has had in recent months. We will agree, from the point of view of the balance of payments, that any Agreement which provides for some security in that way is valuable but, again, it is not the most rewarding.

The Minister for Agriculture, a very competent Minister in his own view, was unable to boast very loudly about the other aspects of the Agreement under the heading of agriculture. The carcase meat trade shows some improvement. It is certainly not such a marvellous thing and the efforts of the Government and the Ministers negotiating this Agreement are not very rewarding in this regard. I do not think that anyone, in normal circumstances, would feel that the Minister for Agriculture would deserve a medal for his efforts in relation to the export of bacon. We were told both in the Agreement and in the House that the turkey export trade would not only disappear—it has been valuable to small farmers on previous occasions— but that it could, under this particular Agreement, reach a point where consumers in this country would be buying poultry from Great Britain.

Comment on this

They will be doing so very soon.

Comment on this

That is what is conveyed in the Agreement.

Comment on this

I think that is a wonderful thing. Ireland has always prided herself on being able to produce poultry. There are some good spots in this Agreement. Nobody wants to deny those or to take credit from them but the Minister for Agriculture says that as a result of this Agreement we can now buy turkeys from Britain. The Taoiseach used the term "opportunity knocks". He must be a viewer of Ulster Television. They have a programme called "Opportunity Knocks", conducted by Michael Miles, on which people are asked a few simple questions. The announcer always makes sure they have the right answers so that when they have they get a key and can open a box.

Comment on this

That is "Take Your Pick". You have them all mixed up. "Opportunity Knocks" is Hughie Green's programme. You have got to sing a song and you might win.

Comment on this