Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.
Contributions 188–388 of 598. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
My apologies. The same principle is involved. Somebody is being persuaded he is getting something for nothing.
Comment on this
There is no doubt that the master of gambling in this House and in the Government for many years back has been the Taoiseach. He has been lucky on many occasions but sometimes he has been unlucky. I do not think he knows whether, in the years ahead, his gamble will come off. That is one of the matters about which we are particularly concerned. We admit from these benches that there is some improvement from the point of view of agriculture, but speakers who are better acquainted with the subject than I am have pointed out that the improvement under that heading is not as great as it should have been, certainly not as great as it could have been if our negotiators had not been mesmerised by their opposite numbers.
We in the Labour Party are concerned about the general development of the economy, both in agriculture and in industry. We are concerned about the position of the agricultural community and those who make up the agricultural community, whether they be medium sized or small farmers. We are primarily concerned with those who draw their normal week's wages from agriculture or rely on the production of the small farms to provide them with a reasonable living. The numbers of such persons are declining each year. They are declining by some thousands each year. We have to look at the opposite side of this coin to see whether the gain in this Agreement will maintain in agricultural employment the number of people who are at present employed in it.
I do not think that even Fianna Fáil spokesmen have advanced the thesis that the number of people at present engaged in agriculture will continue at that level even with the agreed improvements so far as agriculture is concerned. Even Fianna Fáil spokesmen, I think, have admitted that there will be a decline year by year, so the gain in trading conditions for the agricultural community will be shared by a smaller number of people. Fianna Fáil may have quite a number of large-scale ranchers supporting them and any immediate gain in that sector will go to a great extent to the ranchers who support Fianna Fáil. The Government are very conscious of agreements that affect the people who at least temporarily support them.
So, we have in agriculture an admitted gain, but I do not think that in a general way it will help in our balance of payments problem. We have, at the same time, the problem that there is a decline in the number of people engaged in agriculture. The Taoiseach said that this Agreement is a prelude to our going into the EEC. Our application has been made, and it has been stated that if and when Britain's application is accepted, because of our proximity to Britain, Ireland will continue to have a large trading agreement with Britain, and willy-nilly will go into the EEC with Britain. The Taoiseach referred to that circumstance in his opening address, but we are dealing with the Agreement. What does the Agreement provide, not just for industry, but for those who make their livelihood in industry?
So far as one can judge there are a number of industries that are bound to be affected in the years that lie ahead by a reduction of the tariff walls. A number of those industries will be affected and the employment of the workers in them will also be affected. It might be no harm just for a moment to think of one or two industries that are likely to be affected. The boot and shoe industry is likely to be very seriously affected, and employment in that industry is likely to be affected, by this Agreement and the reduction of the tariffs. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs told us about the wonderful things in store for industries using man-made fibres and those engaged in tweed weaving. He did not mention the workers engaged in the woollen and worsted industry. Perhaps they slipped his mind, because it is anticipated that a reduction in tariffs will have a very serious effect in the years that lie ahead on the workers in it.
There is also the motor assembly industry. I do not think even Fianna Fáil were quite clear on that matter because the CIO report indicated that for the next three or four years, unless there is a catastrophic change, there may be some increase in that industry arising from an estimated increase in the number of motor cars on the Irish roads. Of course the number of motor cars on the Irish roads may not increase to the figure estimated unless the economy of the country recovers from its present difficult situation. Leaving aside the present financial difficulties which have been referred to in this House on more than one occasion, it was estimated that the number of motor cars on the Irish roads would increase from 46,000 at present to about 60,000 in 1970, and that the number of workers in that period would show some increase, but after that period even though the number of cars might continue to increase at the same ratio, it was estimated that because of the effects of this Agreement, and the reduction of tariffs by ten per cent per year, the number of workers in that industry would be reduced: that whereas the numbers might go from 5,000 to 7,000 at first, after that they would come down. It is estimated, fairly reliably because it is based on costs, that the number will go down below the number at present employed in that industry to around 3,000. I think this industry was established by Fianna Fáil and it has given quite a lot of employment.
There are also the industries like those engaged in food processing and in the manufacturing and processing of chocolate, sugar, confectionery, etc. Again, we are primarily concerned with the workers in this industry and while the prognostication is that they may continue providing around the same level of employment in the years that lie ahead they will still be open, as the tariff barriers come down, to the type of competition referred to in one or two Articles of the Agreement, competition from larger undertakings in Britain. I am not referring to the question of dumping of low cost goods, nor even to goods which would be subsidised or have price supports, but to goods of the same nature and size as those from similar undertakings in Britain. The workers in this industry and in other industries could be faced with the situation that the unit cost of production in Britain would be lower and, therefore, goods could come in and be sold on the Irish market at prices lower even than those at which the very efficient factories here can produce them, because of the relatively small size of those undertakings.
There is also the problem arising from dumping and our fear is that the Agreement has no great safeguards about dumping. In Article XI which is headed "Dumped and Subsidised Imports", section (1) reads:
Nothing in this Agreement shall prevent either party from taking action against dumped or subsidised imports consistently with its other international obligations.
These obligations are contained in the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. Deputy Tully will probably be dealing with this. Having read them, I may say that I am fairly satisfied that they do not give the type of protection that workers affected by dumping would require. Section (3) of the same Article says:
If any industry in the territory of either party is suffering or is threatened with material injury as a result of the importation of dumped or subsidised products into the territory of the other, the latter shall, at the request of the former, examine the possibility of taking such action as is consistent with its international obligations to remedy the danger or prevent the threatened injury.
Most people engaged in trade, like most people engaged in industry, are not in it for their health, whatever lofty sentiments they may express from time to time. They are in it for the profit they will make and if an importer finds it possible to import a considerable quantity of cheap goods, put them in a warehouse, and then sell them to retailers and these goods eventually appear at dumped prices, that importer will do it. There is nothing in this Article that makes provision for controlling imports in such a way as to prevent that happening. We know that in past years on more than one occasion goods appeared in the shop windows in this country at half or one-third the price those goods could be manufactured for even by efficient industry in this country. By the time the complicated administrative machinery was set in operation hundreds of workers were out of employment. This Article provides that you can utilise the machinery under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade and if you are threatened, the procedure, as I understand it, is that the Minister for Industry and Commerce of the day will start to collect information and will make representations to his opposite number in Britain. I am no great critic of the Civil Service and I think there are very many excellent people in that service, but the Civil Service machinery for this type of thing would inevitably be slow, burdensome and complicated.
The effect would be that by the time workers could make their complaints regarding their employment being affected by dumped goods they would find that they were joining the ranks of the unemployed even before an investigation was carried out on this side, leaving aside the question of discussions on the other side. This is the type of problem with which the Labour Party are concerned. It may not concern Fine Gael very much; they may talk about it but they are not prepared to make an issue of it and show their disapproval by voting against the Agreement and in order to demonstrate that they very much care about people affected in this way. I know that many of their members would be concerned but the Party has spoken.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave devoted a considerable amount of his speech to the question of dumping.
Comment on this
With all respect to your Leader, Deputy Cosgrave did devote a considerable amount of his speech to dumping but he read that Article and other Articles. I am not criticising Deputy Cosgrave personally but I am saying that the Fine Gael Party read that Article and they have no motion down disapproving of the Agreement. There is another problem in relation to Article I, which is headed "Import Duty", section (1) of which reads:
On and after 1 July, 1966 the Government of the United Kingdom shall not apply any import duty to goods, which in accordance with Article II, are regarded as originating in, and are consigned from, Ireland.
Section (2) goes on to refer to the periodic reductions of the tariffs, ten per cent in July 1966, and so on.
Paragraph (5) of Article I is worth reading. It states:
During the year beginning 1 July 1970 the Government of Ireland may conduct a review on the question whether any difficulties analogous to those specified in paragraph (1) of Article XIX, but of a more permanent character, have been caused or are threatened as a result of the operation of this Article, Article IV or Article VI. If the Government of Ireland are satisfied in this review that such difficulties exist or are threatened, the parties shall jointly consider whether they can be dealt with by action in accordance with paragraph (3) of Article XIX. If the Government of Ireland then conclude the goods in respect of which ceptional that they cannot be dealt with by such action, they may exclude the goods in respect of whchi the difficulties exist or are threatened from the application of this Article, Article IV or Article VI, provided that the number of goods so excluded shall be few and shall not account for more than 3 per cent. by value of total imports into Ireland from the United Kingdom in the immediately preceding year.
That looks very nice on the face of it. But this review is to take place in 1970. What will happen to the workers put out of employment by the tariff reduction of 30 per cent by 1968? There is no review there. There is no use saying to them there will be a review in 1970. That will not be much comfort to their wives and families. These workers may be employed in a factory owned by one of the lazy industrialists to whom the Taoiseach referred, or else in a small factory genuinely doing its best but located in one of our small towns and affected by transport costs to the east and south coasts. The review in 1970 will not be much good for those industries. By then they will be gone.
Those are the problems the Labour Party had in mind when they put down the amendment. They felt the Government had not taken sufficient action in advance to safeguard workers' employment to the extent necessary. It is estimated that between 1965 and 1970 there will be an increase of about 18,000 in industrial employment, a decrease of about 3,000, leaving a net increase of 15,000 to offset the reduction in agricultural employment of thousands every year. The Taoiseach should have brought in plans to provide employment for the 100,000 he spoke about some years ago. As far as I can see, he has no plans to provide employment for the workers who may be affected by this Agreement. He has talked about how necessary it is for employers to do this and that. In nearly every industry surveyed during the course of the last year, there has been a substantial increase in productivity by the workers and, goodness knows, little enough many of them got for it. The increase in productivity in the farming community has been phenomenal as far as the workers are concerned. What have they got? The members of the Agricultural Wages Board should be ashamed to expect workers to rear families on the wages provided. Will the remaining workers in that industry benefit to any substantial extent from this Agreement?
We are told there will be a reduction in employment unless something is done. I hope we will do better than in the current year. At 3rd December, 1965, the total number on the live register was 54,816 as against 54,182 in 1964 and 50,465 in 1963. That is not a good augury for this Agreement. We have the same story on 10th December and 17th December. The latest figure, for 31st December, 1965, is 63,714 as against 59,076 for 1964 and 58,613 for 1963.
In the years ahead the industries employing many of our people will be faced with substantial tariff reductions likely to cause further unemployment. One of the problems of discussing this Agreement is that we are discussing something already signed and that will come into operation. All we can do is express our views on it and enjoin on the Government that, as the authors of this Agreement, they have a responsibility to ensure that steps are taken to provide that the workers will not suffer as a result of it.
If there is any benefit at all to be derived from the Agreement, I am sure the Government will extract every ounce of credit for it. They are masters at it. We just want to put them on notice that aside from their preaching —and they have been joined to some extent by some of the members on the Fine Gael benches—at the workers of this country, it is their job to start to do the job they were elected to do, and so far, they are falling down pretty miserably on it. It is a good thing to see spokesmen of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael agreeing basically on a number of matters. From a broad number of aspects of this matter which have been discussed, it would appear that there may be some hope for a different atmosphere between these sections of the movement. I do not propose to talk in terms of betrayal of this, that or the other. This country has been notorious down the centuries for the flaunting of accusations of betrayal of this person, that cause and anything else—people, Parties and individuals.
This is a Free Trade Agreement, with restrictions. Possibly, it has certain political implications, too, in a broad way, in so far as it has been made by the Government with a view to participation, if and when they can, in the EEC. As everybody in this House knows, membership of the Common Market is not confined solely to an economic agreement. There is a much wider and much deeper significance to it. Whether this Agreement will continue to exist in the years that lie ahead, whether circumstances will, at some stage, alter this Agreement which has now been signed as forever, thus making it operative for only a temporary period, we can only speculate at this stage. The Government who signed this Agreement have committed the workers of this country engaged in agriculture and in industry to certain future risks and possibilities. The Government have a responsibility to ensure that all possible steps will be taken to prevent any harmful effect to the workers and to ensure that, where workers become redundant, adequate provision will be made for them.
In that connection, I want to make this remark. There has been a lot of talk about the re-equipment of industries, the re-training of workers, and so on. There is one basic fact which we must all take into account. We may talk about the re-training of workers after displacement but we must bear in mind that the workers are not mere ciphers. Many of them are fathers of families and almost all of the remainder are members of a family. They have established social and family connections in the place where they are living.
It would be unrealistic to think that workers would readily agree to be transferred from one part of the country to another if work locally folded up and there was an opportunity in another part of the country. It was found in the past, in the case of the linen and cotton textile industry, that workers employed in Cork would prefer to work in the same industry in Britain than to work in the industry in Drogheda or Dublin and that the workers in the midland countries would rather do the same thing. The human factor, the social factor, has to be taken into account. Whenever it may be desired to transfer workers from one place to another, it must be remembered that they cannot be treated like cattle. You can transfer a heifer from one field to another and, provided the grass is all right, there will be no more about it.
Comment on this
All they are worrying about is how much per lb they will get when she is sold on the market. The people will eventually be the judges of the benefits or otherwise in this Agreement for the ordinary working people of this country. Since this Government came back into office, they appear not to have done very much for the workers. Deputy J. Lynch is now Minister for Finance and has moved into a rarefied atmosphere and his colleagues find it very difficult to get any money from him for work that is urgent and necessary. In the course of his speech, he said that we, in the Labour Party, feel that the Irish workers are not capable of competing with their opposite numbers in other countries and that the Fianna Fáil Party feel that that derives from some inferiority complex on the part of the Labour Party in respect of the Irish worker. Let there be no misunderstanding about it. The Labour Party are quite convinced that the Irish worker, given the education and training, is second to none in any part of the known world. By and large, however, our workers, in too many of the industries we are concerned with, start off with too many handicaps—an inadequate, insufficient education and no desire on the part of their employer to give them an adequate opportunity of training when they go in as young boys and young girls.
There are thousands of youths and girls going to work in factories in various parts of the country and even though, in some cases, the employers are required, under joint labour committee legislation, to train the workers, it happens in many cases if the employers get them to do a job to their satisfaction, they leave them at that particular job and will not bother to train them any further—and this is not just a statement from the Labour Party. Anyone who has had any experience will testify to the ability of the young men and women of this country to do a good job, given the proper training, the proper opportunities and the proper conditions of work. Whether the people be British—and I do not know where many of the industries in Britain would be today without Irish workers — Germans or Americans — and, God knows, the United States of America owes enough to the ability of the Irish race—they all recognise the ability of Irish workers. Possibly the Minister for Finance was suffering from one of the delusions that Ministers for Finance frequently suffer from — the delusion not too many months ago that everything in the garden was lovely but, a few months later, everything was the other way around. I am sure that, on reflection—because it was not his attitude when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce—he will once again agree that they are not his views and that they do not represent the views of his Party.
I shall conclude by indicating again that, for the reasons advanced by my colleagues, and in a small way by myself, the Labour Party are supporting the amendment in the name of Deputy Corish.
Comment on this
I intend to make my comments very brief because I have no intention of retracing the ground already covered here during the past two or three days. I rise to speak of my great interest in one of the major industries in this country, agriculture. I have not heard from any Government speaker here within the past few days anything in connection with what I could describe as the dying dairying industry. At the present time there is great unrest amongst dairying farmers. I have before me a report on a pilot area in my own county. This is after an extensive survey of a portion of the constituency I represent here in Dáil Éireann and I should like to inform the Minister for Agriculture of its contents. I am sorry he is not in the House now to listen to this report.
The main lines of farming in this district which have been the subject of a survey by his Department's officers are dairying and pig keeping. In this pilot area there are 375 farms and the average size of farm is 50 statute acres. I find it alarming, in this year of 1966, that the average income from a 50 acre dairying farm in this district is £320 per annum. Surely this must be of interest to the Minister and to the Parliamentary Secretary who spoke here yesterday and who said he was responsible for and interested in the farmers along the western and southern coasts.
What I find still more alarming is the classification of farmers by age in this district. Under 20 years of age, there is 0.5 per cent engaged in agriculture in this district. From 20 to 30 years of age, there is 10 per cent; from 30 to 40 years, there is 17.5 per cent; from 40 to 50, 20 per cent and so on; and over 70, there is 7 per cent. That document alone is a clear indication of the fading out of this industry.
During the discussion on this Free Trade Agreement, I have heard quite a lot of capital being made from the opposite benches of the fact that they have a market for 638,000 store cattle in Britain. I should like to inform the Minister for Agriculture that the store cattle trade in this country depends largely on the dairying industry because, if the dairying industry does not flourish, store cattle cannot be provided.
I present this document—which was to have come before us at a county agricultural meeting to be held today, at which, were it not for this debate, we would have been present—to the Minister for his examination. I cannot see, for the life of me, that an income of £320 per annum from a 50 acre farm is an inducement to any young farmer in that district to get married and bring up a family.
Deputy Larkin touched on a very important subject, that is, the poultry industry. During the Mid-Cork by-election, and the general election which followed, we heard a lot of talk in my constituency of Mid-Cork about a broiler industry which was supposed to be built up in Bandon. Deputy Crowley spoke here yesterday and I am sorry I was not in the House at the time because, during the by-election to which I have referred, he made quite a lot of capital out of this broiler industry. That is over 12 months ago and, since then, we have heard nothing whatsoever about it.
I am conversant with the problems confronting the dairy farmers because I have the practical experience in that I am a farmer myself. In the past we had a situation where dairy farming was substituted by pig rearing, poultry keeping, the broiler industry and so on. I would not say the poultry industry is dying; I would say it is completely dead. As Deputy Larkin has said, it is quite possible we could have English turkeys in our ovens next Christmas. That is what it looks like to me.
If I may refer back to the £320 income I have mentioned, it is quite possible that a holding of that size, 50 acres, would be subject to a rate of anything between £50 and £60, depending, of course on the valuation. Unless something is done, and done immediately, this industry will die out completely. We all know the small farmers of this country are the backbone of the country.
I feel it important that we should examine the conditions obtaining at the time this Agreement was negotiated. To be frank about it, I feel the conditions and circumstances prevailing at that time were very favourable to our negotiators because I notice that in the debate on the Queen's speech in the House of Commons recently a prominent member of the Labour Party in England stated openly in the form of an appeal to Mr. Wilson, to stop using Ireland as a reservoir of cheap food and cheap labour and that this had been the position for too long. He appealed to Mr. Wilson, his boss, to drop this attitude and to come to a permanent trading agreement between the two countries. That was widely published in the papers and every Deputy here should be aware of it. It is a terrible situation when a prominent member of the British Labour Party appeals to his Prime Minister to stop using this country as a reservoir of cheap food and labour. I feel that in a situation where the Labour Party in England, with a very slender majority, now faces a general election within the next three or four months and with Irish emigrants forming a large part of the British electorate, there should be a great advantage to our negotiators, sad though it may be that so many of our people are over there due to Fianna Fáil Governments down the years.
Apart from the advantages or disadvantages of the Agreement, we in Fine Gael have made our position quite clear. We have always advocated trade with Britain because of our close proximity to Britain. We have pointed out in this debate the portions of the Agreement we do not agree with. On the opposite side, it has been said that the pessimistic view we have taken and our expressed anxiety for industrial workers are unwarranted. We have cause for anxiety in that connection. In a television interview, the Taoiseach said that even if some industries went to the wall, where one would go five would spring up. I listened very carefully to the Minister for Justice and he had not the same "neck" as the Taoiseach. He began by saying two industries would replace the one that goes. He managed to stretch that out to five later when reminded of what the Taoiseach said.
Whom does the Taoiseach think he is codding? Are we to accept that in the same spirit as the 100,000 new jobs offered in the 1961 general election or in the same spirit as we were asked to accept in the last general election the slogan: "Let Lemass Lead On" and "Do not change horses in midstream"? Lemass has led on and the country has faced a very serious financial and economic situation. As a member of a local authority, I find that about 100 workers on our cottage repair gang are now idle as a result of the shortage of money, strange as that may seem, after an election in which we were told everything was rosy. We could not get the money to provide work for these men in Cork County Council. That is a very serious situation. We have enough redundant workers without the effects of the Free Trade Agreement being added on.
Our attitude to trade with Britain is well known to members of this House and to the people. I welcome the change of heart in Fianna Fáil even at this late stage and even though for the past 30 years, they could not see eye to eye with this Party and realise that our best customers were the British consumers. I heard much from the Government side about the advantages of this Agreement but I should like to know from the Minister for Agriculture what is in this Agreement over and above what was in the 1948 Agreement. I heard about the extra quota for butter but I seriously think we shall not need that if our dairying industry is allowed to die as it is dying. The extra quota is no advantage to us in view of the heavy subsidy which the Exchequer must provide to the English consumer.
The Minister for Agriculture said this was the best Agreement for this country ever reached. In the same breath he said he hoped it could be a good deal better. I should like that to be further clarified. He said they got what they asked for and yet hoped it could be better. If British manufactured goods have unrestricted entry to our country, those goods will reach the retail counters and it will not be sufficient to appeal to our people to buy Irish because our manufactured goods will not be in a position to compete with them. In the constituency of Mid-Cork my greatest problem is to find alternative employment for small shopkeepers and business people deprived of their living because of supermarkets in small towns and villages. That is a detrimental development. The livelihood of people who lived out of small businesses is gone and without taking into account the results of this Trade Agreement it is a problem to find work for those people.
I have said all I intended to say. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary here will note what I said about the dairying industry and that whoever replies on behalf of the Government will deal with that point. The dairying industry is in dire need of immediate attention and if it does not get that attention it will die just as the poultry industry died. I hope that there will be some concessions given to the dairying industry, on which, as I have said, the store cattle trade depends.
Comment on this
I intend to be very brief because I think the debate has been dragged out far too long already, due, no doubt, in large part to the unnecessarily long speeches of many Deputies.
The most outstanding feature of this Agreement is that it has been accepted and approved generally by the people of the country. The farmers have acclaimed, accepted and approved it as an instrument which will give them great opportunities for expansion and prosperity. Industrialists have accepted it. Despite what many Deputies on the Opposition benches have said, they have largely accepted and approved it, first, because it has abolished the British imposts and will give free entry to the British market for all our manufactured goods and, secondly, because Irish industrialists recognise that the free trade idea is spreading rapidly and, if it has not already been established, it is only a matter of a very short number of years before it will spread through the whole of western Europe.
As a farmer, I should like to deal briefly with some of the beneficial provisions for agriculture contained in the Agreement. The reduction from three months to two months in the waiting period in Britain for store cattle, sheep and lambs in order to qualify for the fat stock payments will undoubtedly give a great impetus to the production of store cattle, sheep and lambs here. It does not take much of a farmer to appreciate the difference in the cost of feeding store cattle, sheep and lambs for two months instead of three months. I was amazed to hear people, who I thought had a good knowledge of agriculture, saying that this does not matter twopence. Any man who ever owned or fed cattle knows there is a great deal of difference between having to feed them for three months instead of for two months.
Comment on this
They would, but they would have to be fed and a farmer could have other cattle putting on weight in their place and could be selling them every two months instead of three months. This will undoubtedly prove a tremendous attraction to the British store feeder. It will accelerate the sale and export of store cattle from this country by over 30 per cent. That is simple mathematics. Anyone who cares to carry out that simple exercise will see that it will increase the price of store cattle here by reason of the fact that British feeders will have to keep them for only two months instead of three. That is a very simple fact and a very simple figure.
Comment on this
This arrangement is bound to have a far-reaching and beneficial effect on the production of store livestock here and on the price. There is no doubt at all about that. All the farmers know that. Every dealer and exporter in the country knows it.
The extension of the British deficiency payments to 25,000 tons of carcase beef and 5,500 tons of lamb is an entirely new departure which is very welcome to us. It is bound to give a tremendous impetus to the dead meat industry here, an industry which, apart from being of tremendous benefit to the farmers, has a very high labour content as I am sure members of the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party appreciate.
I am not a dairy man; I am a midlander. However, the dairying industry has been spreading rapidly throughout Laois-Offaly in the past five or six years. I realise and appreciate that the increase in the butter quota to 23,000 tons will be a boon to the dairying industry. Why should it not be? The dairying industry is a most important sector of agriculture.
I think it was Deputy Flanagan who ridiculed the idea of the increase in the butter quota and went on to make the fantastic statement that a 1/6 postal order was enclosed with every lb of butter exported from this country to England in order to give a present to the English housewife and encourage her and her family to eat it. That is utter nonsense. Anyone who knows anything about the dairying industry and about butter exports knows that it is necessary for the State here to subsidise butter exports in order to help the dairying industry and in order to ensure the sale of our butter on the British market in competition with Danish butter, which can be sold there at a lower price than ours. Although the Danish butter is not directly subsidised, the Danish farmers are able to supply butter at a lower price to the British market because indirectly they are very much heavily subsidised and supported by what might be called invisible supports and invisible subsidies, which put them in a position to supply butter at a lower price than ours. What is wrong with our subsidising our dairying industry, directly, more openhandedly and more frankly, in order to enable our surplus butter to be sold on the British market? Are we to let it all go down the Suir or the Shannon, or what are we to do with it?
The same Deputy went on to compare the price of Irish butter in England and the price generally of butter here and across the Border and suggested that our price should be reduced to the British price. Is he suggesting that we should also reduce the price of milk? I do not believe any other Deputy in the Fine Gael benches would subscribe to that. Do any of them suggest we should reduce the price of milk? Is that not what it would mean? Deputy Clinton knows that quite well. He would be a foolish man, indeed, who would make such a foolish suggestion. As everyone knows, the price of butter here is based, and rightly so, on the economic price for milk to the dairy farmer. If the price of butter is reduced then one must also reduce the price of milk to the dairy farmer. I trust the Corkmen, the Tipperarymen and the Limerickmen will take special note of that.
So far as agriculture is concerned, this Agreement, in my opinion and in the opinion, I think, of 95 per cent of our farmers, and not just the ranching farmers, as stated here by some Deputies, will lead to great benefits for Irish agriculture. Time will prove the truth of that. Is it any wonder then that it has been acclaimed enthusiastically by the farmers and the farmers' organisations—the NFA and the ICMSA?
As far as industry is concerned, surely we have to face facts here. Free trade is coming all over Western Europe. It is only a matter of time until the whole of Western Europe will be a free trade area. Surely it is only commonsense that we should prepare ourselves and our industries to meet that situation. Is it suggested we should wait? Some Labour Deputy asked what the hurry is. Some Opposition Deputies went so far as to admit that free trade is coming and we would have to face up to it sooner or later. When should we face up to it? Is not now the time? Should we wait until we are presented with a fait accompli at which stage we could easily be wiped out altogether without ever having got properly started, perhaps, because everyone else would have started the race before us. Surely it is only commonsense and economic wisdom, when we know that it is inevitable, to prepare for this free trade situation.
During the last few days, I have listened to a great many pessimistic speeches from the Opposition benches, speeches which stressed and emphasised what they alleged would be the detrimental effects of this Agreement on Irish industry and Irish employment. Surely, and I put this particularly to the Labour Deputies, we are not now losing faith at last in the capacity and ability of the Irish worker and Irish management to face up to competition from other countries. Surely we have sufficient faith in our Irish workers, in Irish management and in Irish industry generally to believe that they will put articles on the market here as cheap as, or cheaper than, similar articles coming in from countries from which we are divided by the seas. Surely we still have faith in the patriotism of our people, that patriotism which will urge them to support Irish industry, Irish management and the Irish worker. Surely we have not lost that faith. Surely the Irish people are as patriotic today as ever they were. Surely, when they are confronted with a situation in a particular industry which may spell danger for Irish workers and Irish industry, they will face up to that challenge and that patriotic instinct the Irish people have always had will surely assert itself again.
Comment on this
We must face the fact now of free trade in Europe and, in facing up to that situation, we must find some way in which to end this epidemic of strikes which has plagued us here in recent times and which, if continued, will ruin our industry and, indeed, the whole economy of the country. Let us be men enough in every Party to acknowledge that.
I said I would be brief. In relation to strikes, I want to congratulate the NFA on their patriotic attitude in abandoning their campaign to withhold the rates.
Comment on this
I want to congratulate the leaders at the top, the leaders at county level and the members of the organisation generally on the fine example they have set. It is an example that could and should be followed by other organisations and unions in the country. I hope it will.
Comment on this
I desire to register my opposition to this Agreement. In my 43 years in this House, I think this is the most serious motion that has ever come before the House. I realise that the Taoiseach, after 30 years of trying to build up a tariff wall to protect Irish industries so that they might provide employment, has now, by a single stroke of the pen, decided with a British Labour Government to deprive many Irish industries of the tariff protection they enjoyed for the past 30 years. I am sorry the Taoiseach is responsible for that. I am satisfied that he, more than any other member of this House, recognises that this Agreement is not all that the Fianna Fáil Party say it is. I admit there will be a benefit to the ranchers and, in the years to come, when I shall be no longer here, I prophesy that this country will see once more a repetition of the nineties when the unemployed, the landless men and the small farmers will do what they did before, insist that the land is for the people and the bullock for the road.
I am surprised that the Minister for Justice today made an argument for this Agreement on the basis that the British Government would get into the Common Market. There is no guarantee that Britain will get into the Common Market. Surely the Minister must know that members of the Common Market have publicly stated that if Ireland is granted any concessions, it will only be as an associate member. Notwithstanding that, we have the Minister for Agriculture, an infant in politics, praising Mr. Wilson and talking about the great regard Mr. Wilson and his wife had for the Republic of Ireland. Does he remember that it was the Wilsons, the Attlees, the Callaghans and the Brownes who imposed the Government of Ireland Act on us and denied us the right to have a Parliament for the whole country? Does he forget that the same gentleman, when it suited him, broke a previous Agreement and imposed a 15 per cent levy upon exports from this country?
We are told the wonderful fact that farmers will be able to export so many extra tons of butter. In our day we were always told that charity begins at home. I would prefer to see that butter going to the widows, orphans and old age pensioners here. We often come across advertisements in the newspapers and on the radio: "You do not know the taste" and "You cannot tell the difference". There are thousands and thousands of the children of lower paid workers who eat margarine, who do not know the taste of butter because it is so dear. We prefer to send it at a cheap rate to workers in England earning £20 and £30 a week.
There was a flourish of trumpets when Mr. Wilson, with all sympathy, sent us back what were supposed to be the remains of the Irish patriot, Roger Casement. There are a large number of my former constituents who are now living in Wilson's constituency in Liverpool and he did not carry the support he expected from them, so he comes along and pretends to be sympathetic to Ireland by making this Agreement. Unfortunately, the Government have accepted the terms dictated by these people who have no love for Ireland. I have had contact with the Callaghans, the Morrisons and the Attlees and I know they have no love for southern Ireland, even the late Herbert Morrison with whom I had an interview when he was over here. I am surprised that some of the old stagers in the Fianna Fáil Party should accept this compromise merely for the sake of achieving associate membership of the Common Market.
There has been talk about protection. I am concerned with a very important industry in my constituency, the Arklow pottery. Dumping has gone on quite recently, but what will be the position when British monopolies are allowed to dump here? The Arklow industry has defeated the British in their own market by supplying a superior article at a cheaper price, but when these monopolies get the right to dump here, I am satisfied that in 12 months' time a large number of men in that industry will lose their employment.
When the Taoiseach was asked if he thought England would maintain the Agreement in the event of an emergency, he said he thought they would. We must judge by our past experience. I believe this Agreement will knock hundreds of men out of employment while it will be of no great benefit to the small farmer who will have to bear the burden when creameries will not give him an increase in the price of his milk. The Ministers opposite then hope that this Party or some other Party will not play politics in this regard. We know that the Fianna Fáil Party will take advantage of any situation that suits them. I do not make a charge against any member of the Government in regard to these negotiations. They did their best but it would have been better if before signing that Agreement, they came back here and got the authority of the people to accept it. They had no authority from the people to sign this Agreement. I only hope that I shall prove to be a false prophet, that people in industry will not lose their employment, that ranchers will not be the only people to get any benefit from these provisions, and that the rural areas will not be further depopulated. The position will be more serious. I hope it will not happen but I have to say that I regret very much, in the evening of my political life, to have to come in here and oppose an Agreement of this kind because I am satisfied it will bring misery, hardship and insecurity to a very large section of the people of this country.
Comment on this
The truth can never catch up with a lie well told and often enough. That must have been in the mind of every Fianna Fáil Minister, from the Taoiseach down, who was interviewed on television, radio or who gave a statement to the newspapers on the effects of this Agreement. They felt that if they could convince the people of the country this was a good Agreement, the truth would never catch up on it. I believe that is the reason why we have been here since Tuesday discussing the Agreement, why, for the first time since I became a Member and probably for the first time in the memory of many Deputies, we had to sit on a holiday of obligation. In spite of what we say from these benches or of what is said from the Labour benches, the Agreement is signed, sealed and delivered and we must accept it and work within it.
One would be inclined to say it is therefore pure waste of time discussing it, other than to register our protest as a Party and our individual protests as Deputies. I do not think we were treated very fairly by the Government in this matter. The Agreement was signed on 14th December last. It is issued in a document of 270 pages. We received it a week later and began to debate it on 4th January. That gave us a mere 14 or 15 days to examine it. Christmas intervened and, boiling it all down, we had an unbelievably short time in which to examine it, to take the "whens", the "wheres", the "whys" and the "hows" out of it. When we do that, there is damn all in it but it takes a considerable length of time to digest.
Having read it and listened to the speeches from Ministers and Deputies on the Government side, I asked myself what is in it for the people of my constituency. I rather doubt if there is anything in it. Some days prior to his speech during this debate, the Minister for Agriculture issued a statement to the Irish Times saying that the two to three months waiting period in respect of store cattle would mean £3 million to £5 million extra for the people producing stores. That would be equivalent to between £5 and £7 per head. In the Sunday Independent the next day, he stated that the stores would only gain £5 or £6 per head. When he spoke here during this debate he made no reference to it. Therefore, one is entitled to doubt all of the Minister's statements.
Taking his figure of an appreciation in value of £5 or £6 per head, would the Minister for Agriculture then tell us what he is basing this increase on? Is it on the price received for cattle last April, May or June or on the price of cattle at the end of the year, in October, November and December when the bottom fell out of cattle prices? If he is basing it on the former, we shall be all glad. If, however, he is not basing it on the prices paid last spring, the cattle trade will go up the spout and we will go up after it.
Let us now take the question of butter. There has been a tremendous amount of loose talk about the price of butter. In the 1948 Agreement, negotiated by the inter-Party Government under the leadership of Deputy John A. Costello, ably assisted by Deputy Dillon, we could sell to the British market 19,000 tons of butter per year or more if they required it. Under the present Agreement we can sell 23,000 tons, an increase of 4,000 tons per year. The negotiators of the 1948 Agreement had an entirely different outlook from that of today's negotiators for the reason that until 1946 the people of this country were allowed a ration of only two ounces of butter per week and that was after 14 successive years of Fianna Fáil Government. If I were on the Fianna Fáil benches, I should feel ashamed to speak about agriculture.
I was highly interested today to hear the contribution of the Minister for Justice who represents the same constituency as I represent. He preached about the facts of life but we on this side were only interested in the facts of this Agreement. It made one recall a booklet issued some time ago in this country, disseminated outside, which was called Facts about Ireland. It was an incomplete document but no more incomplete than the speech today of the Minister for Justice. He said their reason for not looking for a greater quota of butter was that the Exchequer would have to subsidise it by 1/- to 1/6d. per lb. He went on in the very glib way of which he is capable, being a lawyer, and made a damn good job of it but he missed a few points.
He told us the Agreement provided for an increased market for cheese and chocolate crumb. He did not say these commodities would not be subsidised but neither did he say they would. Let us examine the situation. We are losing substantially on exports of cream, cheese, chocolate crumb and the other commodities sent out by An Bord Bainne. Six million gallons of our milk are exported in the form of cream at a subsidy of 3d a gallon; 25,000 gallons of milk are exported in the form of cheese which demands a subsidy of 5d to 6d a gallon. That is the amount we are paying to the people of England to buy our cheese. In the form of chocolate crumb, 30,000 gallons of milk are exported annually carrying a subsidy of between 4d and 6d a gallon. Powdered milk carries the greatest subsidy of all. In that form we export 20,000 gallons at a subsidy of 6d a gallon. Those are the facts and, in my opinion, it was a pity the Minister for Justice did not go the whole hog and tell the whole story. I should like it to go on the records of this House as having been completed by me, a Deputy representing the same constituency.
The Agreement of 1948 gave us a quota of 27,000 tons or more of bacon. The Agreement of 1965 gives us an increase of 1,000 tons, which puts the figure at 28,000 tons per year. Our negotiators in 1948 had the difficulty that up to 1946 if an Irish man or woman wanted to buy a lb of bacon in this country, they had to take their place in a queue outside the grocer's shop. That was after 16 successive years of Fianna Fáil Government. When our people negotiated for 27,000 tons, they were quite satisfied that the producers in this country would not be able to supply it when the home market was supplied. There is one little point which I consider worth mentioning here. From memory, in the 1948 Agreement, the price per cwt was 225/-. I do not think there is any mention of price in this Agreement. If there is any mention of it, I have failed to find it in this document. If there is anything about price in this, I do not think it would be a wrong calculation, on my part, to suggest that that price, if it were to keep at par with the 1948 figure of 225/- should run to a figure of 400/- per cwt.
Deputy Larkin pointed out today that it is embodied in this green book we got, to which I must refer, that we are in a position to import turkeys from England. Do we not in all honesty and justice say to ourselves: "Is that not putting our whole agricultural system in reverse gear?" There are a number of small farmers in the constituency I represent, Roscommon and South Leitrim, who were dependent, up to a few years ago, on the sale of poultry, eggs and turkeys at Christmas. Those people today no longer have any market for their poultry, eggs or turkeys. I should love some Government speaker, who comes after me, to tell me what is to become of those people? What is their future except emigration? Emigration has hit that area very hard and from memory, I think Leitrim has the highest percentage rate of emigration in the last census, followed closely by Mayo and next by Roscommon. I can see no future there except that the percentage of emigration will be still higher. I do not want anybody to misunderstand this statement. More people will not leave because if they did there would be nobody left but the percentage rate will be higher in the next five years than it was in the past five years. That is not a very great achievement for any Government Party.
There has been a tremendous amount of loose talk and the phrase "swaddling clothes" was used. It was used with reference to industry. It was first used in the debate by the Taoiseach; it was mentioned a few times from these benches; and it has been mentioned since a few times from the Government benches. If there are industries in this country that are wearing swaddling clothes, surely there is nobody to blame for that but the Fianna Fáil Party. Mind you, some of them are wearing damn good swaddling clothes and the people who are paying the piper for them are the consumers of this country.
I was highly amused by the intervention of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. He came in here and anybody listening to him from those benches would think that we did not contribute anything to the industrial section of this community. I want to say this. Long before Fianna Fáil ever existed, there were boots manufactured in Ireland, there were woollen textiles manufactured in Ireland, there was beer made in Ireland, there was whiskey made in Ireland and there were biscuits made in Ireland. The sugar factories were also functioning in Ireland. Mind you, when we started their operation from this side of the House, in my late father's time, in the late W.T. Cosgrave's time and that of other members of the old Cumann na nGaedheal Party, the reference made from that side of the House was that the Deputies representing the then Government Party were trying to sweeten their own constituencies. Those debates are available in the Library and I suggest that some of the younger members of the Fianna Fáil Party might read them.
Hosiery was manufactured in Ireland in those days. The Electricity Supply Board had begun to function and I do not think it necessary for me to restate the reference to it made by the then Opposition, the Fianna Fáil Party. It is no harm to refresh the minds of the younger members of the Fianna Fáil Party on these matters. The Taoiseach said—not, I think, in this House but somewhere else because I remember reading it—for every one industry that closed, five would open. Mind you, he made sure not to say which would close or which would open. I am strongly of the opinion—I hope I am wrong but I rather doubt it—that every one that closes will continue closed. I rather doubt if there is anything in this Agreement to open them.
The representatives of a number of towns in my constituency, Mohill, Boyle, Strokestown and Elphin, have been hammering at and battering on the door of the Department of Industry and Commerce for the past number of years in an effort to get some type of industry for them. Would any Government speaker who follows me tell me what hope is there now under this Agreement of those towns ever getting any type of industry? Certainly, from my simple analysis of the Agreement, my view is that their hopes are completely finished. I will admit that one town in my constituency, Carrick-on-Shannon, has two small industries. I may say here and now that were it not for the introduction of the Undeveloped Areas Act by the inter-Party Government, they never would have had any industry.
We also have a problem in that constituency in relation to Arigna coal. For a long time we have been trying to get the Department of Transport and Power to erect another power station in Arigna. From 1st January, the price of Arigna coal delivered to Cement Ltd. has dropped by 8/- a ton. It is highly amusing when one looks at the papers and sees the profits made in the current year by Cement Ltd. Their increased profit over last year is £246,705, and they still have to reduce the price of Arigna coal by 8/- per ton. One is inclined to ask: why was it reduced? It was reduced because the British market is dumping coal at a cheaper rate than we can produce it in Ireland, and our seams are not as thick as theirs. I can see the same thing happening in other industries, and it will happen much faster and sooner than we think.
One thing that strikes me as rather peculiar about this Agreement is that it comes into operation in July, 1966. Is it not rather peculiar that we will have local elections in June and that we will have a Presidential election in June? Will we not have every Fianna Fáil man, woman and child on all the butter boxes available at every church gate in June telling the people about the advantages of this Agreement? Is that not the reason why the Agreement is coming into operation in July, so that the Fianna Fáil Party can cod— or try to cod—the electorate again? I honestly think they have done that too often.
One cannot help recalling what was said by that Party in the 1920s when they failed to take their seats in this House. Their attitude was: "No, we will not associate with Cumann na nGaedheal; they are a tainted Party." In the 1930s they told us to burn everything English except coal. One also cannot help recalling that in the 1940s, they told us they were giving a monopoly to CIE. That issue was lost in this House by one vote but it was an issue in the general election. We voted against a monopoly then and today we see in the papers: "Grim warning for CIE: No more money from the State."
Comment on this
I do not think there is any other issue I want to raise. We find again from today's papers that there is a sharp rise in the number of unemployed. The total on December 31st was 63,714 which was 7,310 higher than on December 17th, and 4,638 above the figure for January 1st, 1965, and 5,101 higher than the figure for 4th January, 1964. If that is what this Agreement gives us. I believe the Fianna Fáil Party should examine their conscience again.
Comment on this
I feel like the labourer at the eleventh hour. The attack on this Agreement has been individual and varied. It reminds me very much of guerilla bands attacking a sound and well-held position. In this apparently leaderless attack, there were two leitmotifs and two running themes right through. There was a great endeavour to show that all the shining virtues were on the other side: patriotism undefiled, flowing from the fount of Tone and watered by the Fenian springs. There was purity of intention with no sectional interests to overcome the common good—virtue shining through: angel choirs and vestal virgins. Despite all that, they were the strong, hard businessmen, well able to make a bargain and knowing the right time to make a bargain. They were strong and tough. They were the better negotiators than we were. They knew when to hit. You got the whiff of grapeshot and a sight of Cromwell's Ironsides. They had a tender care for the aged, the poor and the infirm and a burning desire to lead us into Europe like Don Quixote charging against the windmills in Spain. They had the courageous leadership. They had all the virtues. They were like the boy in Longfellow's poem who was attracted by the mountain shine—not the moonshine—and carried a banner with a strange device, Excelsior.
Comment on this
That is that side and this is the other side. We on this side had no virtues at all.
Comment on this
We were the super-optimists, the chancers, the gamblers. We knew absolutely nothing and we had no sense of timing. That is why over there was heaven and this was hell.
Comment on this
This side is in the darkness and on the other side is shining a beautiful, heavenly effulgence.
Comment on this
What are the facts about this Agreement? The existing Trade Agreements did not adequately secure our position because on the agricultural side, our market sharing arrangements were gradually weakening our position. They could be 20,000 tons this year and 18,000 tons next year. On the industrial side, our preference position in the British market being eroded, because of England's commitments to EFTA and to GATT, with the result that possibly by 1967 we would find ourselves without our preferential position, the necessity for making the Agreement arose now.
In regard to the Agreement, as far as the agricultural side is concerned, I do not propose to say anything, as enough has been said about it already. All I can say is that whatever we have got is plus. Even though it may have regularised the existing position, it has done that which I hold existing Agreements did not do and that is protect us. On the industrial side, where we were negotiating with a stronger force, what we naturally looked for in the Agreement were some forms of protection for those industries which are not strong enough to face competition. We will get immediate entry for our goods into Britain—that is included in Appendix XI—and quite a substantial amount of goods which had not got this entry before will now have free entry into Britain from July 1st. All this is simply a negative approach to the industrial position. An important point to remember is that Britain is already importing 70 per cent of her goods free of duty into Ireland. The other 30 per cent will be gradually phased over the next few years.
As regards protection, the biggest need is to protect industries in regard to dumping and that is well spelled out in the Agreement. The only thing we have to watch is that when we come to provide the necessary legislation we must make sure that we cover it there. There are plenty of examples to guide us in this such as the Canadian Acts. Article XVIII deals with the balance of payments difficulties and Article XIX deals with difficulties in particular sectors. The positive approach to all this is to make Irish industry competitive. The Government have played their part in the last few years to do this. You have the CIO reports, the Adaptation Councils, grants for modernisation and technical assistance grants. There are industries, and everybody knows them, which, by availing of these grants, by mergers, by consolidation and by making common market arrangements and common market research, have succeeded in bringing themselves into a competitive position. They are quite capable of standing on their own feet by 1970 and there will be several other industries which will have availed of these grants and arrangements by then. It is up to others to do the same by way of physically adapting their plant and, as the Minister for Industry and Commerce said, by adapting their mental approach to the fact that they have to be really competitive by 1970.
It is quite clear that we are not sufficiently cost conscious. We have got to be cost conscious and once we have got that into our minds our industrial relations might improve. I am not blaming this on one side or the other. Management and workers must become far more sophisticated and have a far more adult approach to labour relations and they must be able to sit around a conference table and argue what increases there should be arising from the increase in the gross national product.
We have been hearing about the industrial colossus which will invade Ireland and fears have been expressed that our industrialists might not be able to meet this colossus but the colossus might meet a Finn Mac Cumhaill sucking his thumb and get a great disappointment. Another point is that not alone will we be ready to meet competition by 1970, I hope, but while the British have access to a market of 3,000,000 people we will have access to a market of 60,000,000 from July 1st, 1966 and it really amounts to good factory management and hard selling. Let us stop looking at the negative aspects and look at the positive ones. You may produce goods if you like but you have to sell them and with hard work and good selling you will get there. We will win on that. That is the way we should think instead of adopting a wailing, Cassandra-like attitude to this Agreement. This Agreement was designed to make Irish industry more efficient and ready by 1970 and gives us the opportunity of a bigger market.
Another point is that there are many industries negotiating at present to start in Ireland. I have not got this information officially but I know it for a fact. They were held up pending the outcome of these negotiations but they are carrying on. Any industry that comes in after the signing of this Agreement will be a thoroughly competitive and viable one. It will have to be, because the people know what is in front of them. These people are not fools and if they are going to invest money in industry they know it will have to be completely efficient. That will be the proof of the pudding. There is no point in hiding the fact that some industries will go but then for every one that goes you might have two or three more.
Comment on this
I do not know the number but there are industries in the pipe-line. The point I want to make is that any industrialists that come in after this Agreement will be coming in with their eyes open.
Comment on this
It simply gives security to producers and investors and they will know where they are going. It is simply a signpost.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not drag me into a discussion on agriculture. I am dealing with a subject about which I know something.
Comment on this
In a country such as ours we must aim to reach price level stability by 1970. If you have stable prices you will be able to have an increase in wages. This is a most important thing. You will also have a stable cost of living, an increase in the variety of goods, and life will be richer and better. Provided we are able to grasp our share of the English market to which we are entitled——
Comment on this
If I were a salesman with a good product and with a good range of samples, I would not mind tackling the British market. The Deputy should read Appendix XII. By 1970 we should be ready for the Common Market and I hope that we grasp the full implications of that. We will then have to submerge our sovereignty to some extent. Deputy Ryan was very hot on this subject. We have certain rights now in regard to dumping and that is a mark of sovereignty.
Comment on this
I may have quoted Appendix XI. Our Labour Party will be happier, I am sure, with the European Social Democrats than with Harold Wilson's Labour Party.
Comment on this
You tried to make out that he wanted to get the Irish vote. If he drove a hard bargain, would he get the Irish vote?
Comment on this
The other side did. This is not the first time we were in a common market. I hope EEC and EFTA will become one and that we will get into it. It would provide a bastion for the preservation of our European cultural heritage. Let us cast our minds back. We were there a thousand years ago. We were there at the Court of Charlemagne, in Bavaria and in Lombardy. When we come back there again I hope we will give a good account of ourselves. I should like to finish on that note. We can look backward as well as forward. Sin deireadh an chláir.
Comment on this
In discussing this Agreement, we are told by one side it is heaven and by the other it is hell. Where do we stand here? People I have met in this city during the past few days are asking why the Tánaiste and Minister for External Affairs, Deputy Aiken, has not taken part in this debate. People tell me there is some split in the Fianna Fáil Party at the moment over this Agreement.
Comment on this
This is an important debate and the Minister for External Affairs should take part in it. It is commonly rumoured in the corridors of this House that there is some left wing in the Fianna Fáil Party and the Minister for External Affairs is going a different way from the Taoiseach and his Ministers.
Comment on this
I have heard it said in the House that the members of the Fianna Fáil Party have been very quiet for the past few days.
Comment on this
Long before you, and I did not get in by the back door either. I am here since 1943. I came in before you were in Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
I think of the good old days when all of us were supporting Fianna Fáil. We heard the war cries from a person now occupying a high office in this country who came down to Kerry when I was a young lad and, addressing the people of Tralee, said: "Give me Republican Kerry and Republican Galway. If I had a few more counties like them, I need never address a public meeting before any election." That was back in 1927, 1928 and 1932. At that time Fianna Fáil won three seats out of four in North Kerry and two seats out three in South Kerry. Therefore, Fianna Fáil had five seats out of seven there from 1926 until a few of us entered the field in 1943. Now in Kerry they have only three seats out of six and, by all accounts, they were damn lucky to get the second seat in South Kerry on the last occasion. It was a photo finish. That is an indication that the Republican Party, as Fianna Fáil were then, have now lost the confidence of the people of my county.
We heard the old slogans, which I probably believed myself, "Thank God the British market is gone forever" and "Burn everything British but their coal." During this debate we had a Deputy from my county lecturing us that we should advise trade union members that they could play a very important part in saving the present situation by buying Irish-produced goods. This individual played an important part in turf production during the emergency. By all accounts, he appointed himself an organiser to try to get increased prices for the turf producers and distributors. While he was doing that, he arranged to bring in a cargo of coal to the nearest port to his home town.
Comment on this
It is no harm to say that people should be consistent. You cannot start giving lectures to those in a position to reply. The first thing you should do is put your own house in order.
We have to consider this Agreement on its merits. We have to consider all the statements made by different politicians over the past 40 years. I do not want to dig them up. However, if you read them, you will find some of them have not been a bit consistent.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, Sir, the rules of order of this House were not drafted for the convenience of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Deputies have produced the Official Report and quoted speeches by some of the present Ministers in 1932, 1933, 1936 and 1937. Not so long ago they were making the same statements: they were the Republican Party and the salvation of the country was in their hands.
We have to assess this Agreement on its merits. We know ourselves that industries have been built up since we got native government and have been protected by tariffs, and so on. Are we prepared to meet the consequences of British goods coming into this country? We may not feel their impact this year or next year but, from the fourth year onwards, we shall feel their impact and that is what worries me. Only for the protection that some of our industries received over the years, they could not compete with goods from a highly in-have survived. Now we ask them to dustrialised country. It is stating the obvious to say that our country is not industrialised and that our chief industry is agriculture. I hope that what I say will not happen but when we reach the third or the fourth year after this Agreement becomes effective, I fear that our workers will suffer.
The previous speaker said that we have certain proposals and that our industrialists will fare far better under the Agreement than the farmers. Might I ask what will happen when the ten-year period expires? Surely there is a big danger to our economy when British-produced goods will flow freely into the country? Then we shall be right in the midst of trouble. Under the Agreement, we have a guaranteed market for a certain amount of our goods and produce but as soon as we reach the tenth year, I would say we are heading for very poor times and I hope that my prediction is not correct. For the past 25 years, there has always been a market in Britain for all the cattle we could produce.
Comment on this
Many years ago, at a meeting in my county. I proposed that a subsidy should be provided in respect of our heifer calves and I was laughed at. We were told that the only alternative was to increase the cattle population. What is the position now? Over 80 per cent of the farming community in my county are small farmers. It is surely a poor outlook for the small farmers of my county, and those of other western seaboard counties, when, in the past few days, we had the spectacle of the small farmers in my county queueing up to sign for the dole. That is an indication that very little prosperity lies ahead. Thirty-three years after the introduction of the dole to this country, we are now proposing to give it to our small farmers, which indicates that they are finished. The Government are doing it to help the small farmers to support themselves and their wives and to rear their families. It is a shocking and disgraceful thing——
Comment on this
——that our small farmers in certain counties are asked to demoralise themselves by signing on for the new dole. That is the most disgraceful thing ever introduced in this country—and then the Government will tell us that the farmers were never better off. These were the cries we heard prior to 4th April last——
Comment on this
"Let Lemass lead for one more term." Who will lead afterwards? Will it be the Minister for External Affairs or the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries?
Comment on this
That is probably what is wrong in the Fianna Fáil Party at the moment. There is probably a difference in thinking and who knows who will lead the Party in the future.
Comment on this
We are told that our farmers were never better off and yet, in my county, farmers with valuations of £10, £15 and £20 are queueing up at the employment exchanges to know if they would qualify for unemployment assistance. It would be far better if the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries would give some guarantee to our farmers in relation to prices and thus enable them to support themselves, their wives and families on their holdings rather than to demoralise them in this way.
Comment on this
The whole danger I see in this Agreement is that it may cause the disemployment of a large number of our people. Our neighbours in the Six Counties had access to the British market all the time—one could actually call it free trade—and yet there is more unemployment in the Six Counties than in any other six counties in this country. What will happen to us after next July when we enter free trade? Irrespective of what Government are in office in England, they are Englishmen and they will negotiate to the best of their ability to the benefit of their country. We in the Labour Party think Britain has got the best of this bargain and that is why we oppose the Agreement.
Comment on this
This Agreement has been discussed since Tuesday last and it was introduced and praised very enthusiastically by the leaders and members of the Fianna Fáil Party. It has been lauded very highly for the benefits it will confer on the country, especially on agriculture.
We had Agreements with Britain before—the 1948 and previous Agreements—which were satisfactory, without selling or giving away anything of our nationality or freedom. This Agreement is vastly different because we have finished up by giving the advantage to Britain in a very big way and, even if all those big advantages were to accrue to agriculture, which unfortunately is not true, the agricultural community would be fully entitled to them because agriculture has been in the front line trenches, not alone now but in the years gone past, through the mismanagement of the Fianna Fáil Party, whose policy it was to keep them there because they were going to industrialise our country. However, if it were a fact, it would be high time that agriculture got a little compensation—and we might call it restitution—for what it went through over the years, due to Fianna Fáil policy.
This Agreement is supposed to increase cattle exports to 638,000 head, increase our carcase meat trade to 25,000 tons and lamb to 5,500 tons. These quantities would be entitled if the occasion arose, to deficiency payments which, as a maximum, would be something like £1¼ million. It will not happen, of course; but, if it did, that amount could not be expended by our Government here without the prior permission of the British Government. It is an extraordinary state of affairs that, in 1966, John Bull has to be considered before that deficiency payment of £1¼ million is disbursed.
In agricultural industry, however, there is more than cattle. This has been referred to already by my colleague, Deputy Creed, and other speakers here. There is the dairying industry in which we, in the south, are very interested. My own constituency is mostly a dairying and tillage area and milk is produced there to provide a living for most of the people but, unfortunately, the price received by the producer at the moment is practically the lowest in Europe. Last year, in order to encourage the production of high quality milk, the Minister for Agriculture granted a payment of one penny as an incentive. Unfortunately not everyone was capable of getting the benefit of that penny. The highly-geared farmer with capital was in a position to equip himself so that he could get this increased payment, but, the small farmers—and we must remember there are more small than big farmers—have not the necessary capital to gear themselves to the point at which they will have higher production and better quality milk. Most of the milk is produced by family cheap labour.
In a recent survey, the national average income of those engaged in agriculture was something like £7 4s per week, which is subject to correction. I was rather amazed to find, on looking through the document my colleague, Deputy Creed referred to earlier—a survey carried out by officials of the Minister for Agriculture —that the income is as low as £2 a week. It is no wonder farm labourers are leaving the land. Unfortunately, many of them have already gone because agriculture is not in a position to pay them the wage to which they are entitled. The point is now being made that this Agreement will put farmers in a position to improve their business and their workers. Of course, there is not a word of truth in that. It is a case of "Live horse and you will get grass"—something might turn up.
There is also another category of farming, tillage, which meant a lot to our economy over the years. The returns from the Statistics Office for the acreage of tillage under dry crops was down by 40,000, which included wheat, and this showed the biggest decrease of 12 per cent. There was also a drop in the acreage of barley and oats. Of course, as we know, the biggest drop of all was in sugar beet which was such a help to our economy. Furthermore, there was a substantial drop in the potato acreage of something like 10,000 acres, again subject to correction. It is a rather extraordinary state of affairs that there seems to be no relief provision for any of those crops under this new Agreement. They must struggle on and do their best.
In support of that, I shall quote the Irish Farmers' Journal of October 16th, under the heading “Forecast of Further Drop in Tillage Acreage”.
The only thing that can hold up the acreage of cereals and beet this year is the credit squeeze. It makes it too difficult for farmers to switch quickly to cows or dry stock. This comment came from Bernie O'Neill, chairman of the Beet Growers' Association, when he told their annual general meeting that it had been a disastrous year for tillage men in general and wheat growers in particular.
He said that we could look to further reductions in tillage acreage in the future, as no man could plough back into the land what he hadn't taken out of it.
Comment on this
No, but I daresay he was present. That was a rather significant statement from the chairman, Mr. O'Neill, of the Beet Growers' Association. He was stating the truth.
Comment on this
I suppose that will come later. The substance of the speech was that tillage counties or parts of counties interested in tillage will be getting out of it because there is not an economic price for their produce. This is aggravated by the inclemency of the so-called summer and harvest weather. I believe this was a significant statement about a matter that will undoubtedly affect our economy because if we cannot produce cereals, sugar beet and potatoes at home, it will, I suppose, turn out like the case of the turkeys; they will come over from England and consequently there will be more unemployment in agriculture. More people will have to go into the towns where unfortunately they do not readily get employment now and the next thing will be that they will go to Birmingham.
This Agreement does not confer any benefits on the farmers. To believe otherwise is wishful thinking. Things must improve very much before the farmers can get anything extra from the national cake. Deputy Corry, one of my colleagues in the constituency, said earlier in the week that he had made a survey of the industries in his constituency and he was glad to find they would not be affected.
Comment on this
It was a rather extraordinary statement and the Deputy should have given it more thought and consideration before he made it. He need not go very much farther than the steel industry which is very near him where we had 180 disemployed prior to Christmas. He referred to that himself in the papers as meaning a very bleak Christmas and he connected that with the Buy Irish campaign in which seemingly all the patriotism should come from individuals and households, while the State and semi-State companies could go over to John Bull and buy corrugated iron which was manufactured beside them. That is what is causing the unemployment.
I agree with him to that extent but I do not agree that the industries in the constituency will not be affected. Of course they will. While in this House we must be concerned with the over-all national picture, as Deputies we must be concerned primarily with what happens in our own constituencies. In my own home town, there is a family hosiery business built up over the years on the people's initiative and undoubtedly, not alone in ten years but in three or four or five years, that little industry will feel the full blast of hosiery imports from England and there will be unemployment as a result. Deputy Corry did not discuss the matter with those people. It is wishful thinking on his part to say that industries will not be affected.
Of course we will be consoled, I presume, by the statement of the Taoiseach and others that where one industry closes down or collapses, five more will spring up like mushrooms. We all know very well that will not happen. I am terribly concerned about those industries. In latter years we were all concerned in rural Ireland especially when we had to go looking for industries. At one time we sent a team to Germany from our own town and district to investigate the possibility of inducing manufacturing concerns, preferably some heavy industry for male employment, to come to our town where they would have a free site and other necessary facilities. While they got all the promises in the world from some and others said they would review the position and that we would hear from them later, nothing has materialised.
My point is that if under this Agreement an existing family industry is going to fall by the wayside, how can we induce anybody else to come into rural Ireland?
Comment on this
Despite all that has been said here about the benefit this Agreement will confer on Ireland, I predict a very bleak time ahead for rural towns.
Comment on this
Under this Agreement, vested interests with bigger supermarkets than we have already will take over the country, to the detriment of family businesses and local traders. Again as a result of the Agreement, local traders will have to face higher taxation. The duties which will be taken off after July will have to be made up and the obvious way is by increased taxation. The people in small towns will be running out of them because there will not be a living to be got in them.
On one occasion my colleague, Deputy Barry, and I asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce, by way of Parliamentary Question, if he would state the opinion of the Government in relation to supermarkets. Speaking subject to correction, I think the answer was, substantially, that they were good for business.
Comment on this
That is what the reply amounted to. They might be good for vested interests but, unfortunately they are not good for the people who were born and bred in small towns and developed businesses which, while they might not be very big, provided a livelihood. These people will be deprived of that livelihood and they will take to the emigrant ship.
Fine Gael have always favoured freer trade relations or closer trade relations with Britain, with the overriding consideration that they reserved the right to investigate the possibility of getting better markets than the British market in continental Europe. Unfortunately, under this Agreement. that opportunity will no longer be available.
Comment on this
I shall be brief but I should like to join with Deputy Burton in expressing in a few words our great regret for the fact that our fellow Deputy from Cork-East mentioned certain industries in that constituency in respect of which he had a guarantee from the managements that they would not be interfered with and were in no danger under the Agreement. I should like to ask this question: What will become of the industries Deputy Corry referred to here? We should like an answer on this. We are chiefly interested in the towns of Cobh, Midleton, Youghal, Fermoy, Mallow, Kanturk, Charleville and many other towns where small industries have existed and have tried to survive over a long number of years. Some of us are led to believe by the managements of the industries concerned that, despite Deputy Corry's claim, these industries will be seriously affected as a result of this Free Trade Agreement.
That will represent a loss in itself. The proof is that at the moment, as the previous speaker pointed out, there are roughly 200 men unemployed in the town of Cobh who were laid off by Irish Steel during the past three months. Deputy Corry, a member of the Government Party, knows that. I am fully convinced that Deputy Corry came in here and made that statement for one purpose only, that was, to try to convince the people of Cork that everything was rosy in the garden. We know that he is a bit of a disturber in his own Party at times. I have in my possession a copy of the Cork Examiner dated back to 1926, when Deputy Corry was a problem at the time Fianna Fáil entered the House.
Comment on this
What Deputy Corry did in 1926 does not seem to have any relevance to the Free Trade Agreement.
Comment on this
Deputy Corry made a statement that as far as industries in Cork were concerned, they were quite safe under this Agreement.
Comment on this
He never consulted the management of any of them, and as far as we are concerned, as Deputies for that constituency, it is our job and our duty to point out to the people the danger of this Agreement and what will happen as far as industries are concerned. I make that point now.
Comment on this
Deputy Spring made one very important point, that is, that despite everything that is being said at the present moment about the prosperity of the small farmer, the clearest indication that the Government now realise that the small farmer is fast disappearing, due to the fact that his income is practically nil, is the introduction of a special system of unemployment assistance for small farmers on the western seaboard and covering portion of Cork county. That is a clear admission by the Government that they realise the position in which the small farmer is placed and the difficulty he experiences in trying to exist on a small holding at present. As years go on, the position of the small farmer will become even worse.
We should like to have a guarantee from the Government as to what is to happen the small farmers and also as to what is to happen the business people in many towns in rural Ireland. The Government have completely forgotten the old slogan of the Republican movement under the leadership of certain people. I want to quote and put on the records of the House what I think is the greatest statement ever made, which was made by a good Corkman and a good Irishman, the late Terence MacSwiney, when he addressed a Sinn Féin conference in Cork in 1919. I quote:
We in the Republican movement expect to do great things for the Irish people but I will give you no guarantee whatsoever as to the use that will be made of that freedom by those who come after us.
Freedom is misused at the present time. It was misused by those who went out under the banner of republicanism and completely forgot that policy in a very short time.
Comment on this
The spirit of republicanism and nationalism has fast disappeared from Fianna Fáil. They have failed the people of those days 30-odd years ago. The younger generation are more enlightened than the people were 30 years ago, and if and when the opportunity arises, Fianna Fáil will get their answer from the Irish people as far as this Trade Agreement is concerned.
Comment on this
I was very glad to hear the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs saying here today that he saw no reason, when we had gained our independence and established our sovereignty, for refusing to trade with our former enemy. We on this side of the House could not agree more with him. We welcome this change but we regret that it is so belated because this is the policy the Fine Gael Party have advocated for many years and which was denounced and rejected by the present Government Party.
I shall not attempt to discuss the position of agriculture under this Agreement because, first of all, I am not competent to do so and, secondly, because it has already been dealt with by many other speakers on this side of the House and on the Government side of the House. However, from the little knowledge I have of agriculture, it is obvious to me that even the Government Party Deputies did not rejoice over this Agreement; as far as I could gather from their remarks, the Agreement will mean a very small gain.
I am mainly concerned with the consequences of this Agreement on industry because the constituency I represent is, in the main, a working-class constituency. I am wondering how many of our industries will be able to stand up to the competition from their British counterparts. If they are not able to stand up to that competition, then they will inevitably fold up, with consequential unemployment for many of our people.
One industry about which I know something is the liquor business. There is one company in Britain with a capital of no less than £350 million with, perhaps, an equal sum in reserve. Our distillers would not have more than about £5 million. If they are to try to compete against the British distillers it will be a very uphill fight. Guinness, the major brewery here—not in their stout trade but in their other trades—will face competition ten times their size. It will be very severe and very keen competition.
In Dublin, the building industry is one of the main industries. Most of the accessories, such as locks, nails, door furnishings and fittings, are turned out in greater numbers in Britain than they are here. I am apprehensive as to how we will compete against the British when they have free access to our market. For us to catch up with the British in this field and to carry the wide range they carry there would need to be a huge injection of capital to enable us to compete successfully against them.
Another industry, which has been mentioned several times and which, we are given to understand is in a serious position is the motor assembly industry. That industry gives good employment in Dublin. If it were to fold up there would be serious repercussions. I think it was Deputy Reynolds who said that, within a fortnight of this Agreement being signed, there was an increase of 7,000 in unemployment. Judging by today's papers 2,000 more in the building maintenance trade are under notice. It is said that eventually 100,000 may be affected. If the figures revealed in the last fortnight are any indication of the trend of events, then I do not think any Deputy could feel otherwise than apprehensive about the implications on industry of this Trade Agreement.
Comment on this
I believe that the Taoiseach and his Party should have told the people on the occasion of the last general election that it was their intention to sign a trade agreement with the British. That was their duty. They did not do so and I believe they did not do so because they were afraid. The very least one would have expected is that the Taoiseach would have consulted the people when he had the opportunity to do so. It is quite plain to me now that, because of the record behind him and his predecessor, a record of going around the country for more than 30 years denouncing everything British and deploring the fact that the people on this side of the House always advocated an increased outlet on the British market for our agricultural produce, he was afraid to take the rightabout turn before the people; he knew that, if he did, it would be too much for his own supporters to swallow. At the moment there are only two Fianna Fáil Deputies in the House, one of them being a Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
The Minister for External Affairs has been conspicuous by his absence. Indeed, when he was listening to the Taoiseach the other day, I thought he looked as if he needed a tonic. Rumour has it that the Fianna Fáil Party are split and, judging by the empty benches opposite, it would look as if the rumour is not without foundation. I cannot understand the attitude of the Government Party in not coming in here to discuss this Agreement.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach told us a few days ago that it was his intention in 1963 to go ahead with this Agreement, but he never mentioned it at election time. He could not go around the country and say, as he said a few days ago: "This British market is a wonderful market", because he had been saying the reverse of that all his life. It would be too much of a pill for the people to swallow in one gulp and he was afraid of his life to tell them.
Subsequently when he did go across to England he had behind him the ghost of a £50 million trade deficit. That was a very embarrassing position to be in and a very bad bargaining ground on which his Ministers and himself found themselves. Apart from the balance of payments problem there were all the other problems that are still around us, strikes and one thing and another in the various Departments of State, including Local Government. Even the Parliamentary Secretary's Department sent out a circular letter telling Deputies and Senators not to submit new proposals as there was no more money to spend on them. I got such a letter and I am sure other Members of the Oireachtas got it, too.
Comment on this
There was no money to pay housing grants and a thousand other things. There was also the fact that our Minister for finanace and some of his advisers went to New York and to several other parts of the world to borrow money which, as far as I know, they have not got yet. It was with that ghost also at his heels the Taoiseach went over to London to sign the Trade Agreement. Those were the circumstances in which these documents were signed, documents that have been circulated with all the ballyhoo of which Fianna Fáil are capable in order to try to smother the fact that there is nothing extraordinary in this Agreement.
Certainly there is nothing extraordinary in these provisions for the hard-pressed people that I and other Deputies from the west of Ireland represent. The Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Faulkner, stated here yesterday evening that it would be of great benefit to the sheep and lamb industry. We cannot press buttons and produce sheep and lambs in a matter of months. It will take quite a long time to get increased production of sheep and lambs. This is the Fianna Fáil policy: live horse and you will get grass.
Comment on this
I travel very frequently, in the course of my business, not only around my own county but all over the western counties, and I know how things are. There are hundreds of closed homes as a result of the policy of Fianna Fáil and I do not think this new Trade Agreement will bring the people racing back across the water to enjoy this alleged prosperity. Of course, we had to listen to some wild tales from the former Taoiseach. We were going to import Egyptian bees for the production of some extraordinarily rare type of honey. He said we had the milk and all we needed was the Egyptian bees to provide the honey. I do not think the Egyptian bees ever came into the country but certainly we were stung from somewhere and I think it was from the far side of the House.
One would have thought that the main objective of the delegation that went to London would have been to refer to this 15 per cent levy, five per cent of which was removed some time ago, but we hardly heard a word about it. All the people here were shocked. Industry was shaken to the very foundation and the agricultural community were also shocked when this levy was imposed. The Taoiseach himself was so shocked that I believe he got on the phone to London. He used strong language at the time about not being able to depend on arrangements that one might make with the British. That is my recollection of what happened.
The Taoiseach and his Ministers were very strong in their criticism of the British and went so far as to say that they could not be relied upon. In the space of a few months, the Taoiseach has changed. The Taoiseach and his Ministers are now prepared to come into this House and pledge their word here to us and to the Irish people that these gentlemen who broke their word before are now jolly good fellows. I have some experience not of the British politician but of the British businessman. My late father and I sent hundreds of thousands of pounds across the water to the principal cities of Great Britain. When one is reared in that tradition and when one knows these people as I do, one is in a better position to speak about them here than others, and particularly those who have spoken from the opposite side.
I can say of English and Scottish businessmen that I have found no more honest people, no more honest traders, than I found across the water. Their word is their bond and their cheque is as sound as the name of the bank it is drawn on. My experience and that of my late father, before the Fianna Fáil take-over of office, was that we were able in the west of Ireland to buy from our neighbours eggs, poultry, including turkeys, potatoes and other things and export them across the water. In this respect, I should like to tell this story about when Fianna Fáil took over office, and if there is anybody on the other side from the Department of Agriculture, he can look up reference No. W. 194.
Comment on this
The Deputy is being irrelevant. This has nothing to do with the Free Trade Agreement.
Comment on this
During the debate we have heard nothing about eggs or turkeys. That market was wrecked by Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
The matter referred to by the Deputy is irrelevant. We are discussing the Free Trade Agreement.
Comment on this
In which there is no reference to eggs or poultry. The Minister for Agriculture kept very close on that subject. We have better knowledge of these things than the Minister has.
Comment on this
I was very interested in the transactions with Britain to which Deputy O'Hara was referring.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Hara then will get an appropriate opportunity to tell the Deputy all about it.
Comment on this
I am afraid that under this Agreement you will not see any mile-long queues of lorries from all parts of the country at the North Wall, laden with turkeys, eggs and other farm produce bound for England. Fianna Fáil have thrown away that business and they should be ashamed of it. It is surprising they did not take the Minister for External Affairs with them to London. Of course he was the man who said he would like to see sunk every ship that went across the ocean. They would have been ashamed to take him with them. I am not surprised he did not go.
Comment on this
It must be borne in mind that quite a number of people will suffer as a result of this nonsense. I will suffer very seriously. Deputy McAuliffe had similar things to say about the people of West Cork. He said that as a result of the Agreement, the small farmers in the south-west and the west will suffer, despite all the assurances of the Minister for Agriculture who comes down from time to time to tell us of the prosperity we can look forward to. I am very pessimistic when I think of the other promises of Fianna Fáil, including the 100,000 new jobs we were told about.
I am not concerned about new industries in the west because none was established there. We were promised great things under the Undeveloped Areas Act. The man responsible for it was the present Minister for Finance, then Parliamentary Secretary, who I have always found to be honest and sincere in his intentions, anxious to do everything he possibly could. Unfortunately we had not, as a result of his honest efforts, any great success as far as industries in the west are concerned. Ballaghaderreen, Charlestown, Swinford got none; there was a little in Kiltimagh; and Ballina got an industry which may go to the wall. Of course we are not allowed to discuss these things. In the field of industry, we do not have a lot to lose in the west.
What worries me in this respect is the possible loss of our old-established industries, many of them in existence long before we achieved native government. I am thinking of one in my own town of Foxford and there are others, probably smaller, in other towns in the county. I have been told by senior staff members of the woollen mills in Foxford that they are very worried about their ability to compete against the big combines. If that industry does not not only survive but thrive, it will be a sad day for the people of that town. We had an old-established industry in Ballina which had to close down. In the flour-milling industry there, quite a number of people were employed. Those people were, for economic reasons, forced out of business as a result of mismanagement, in my opinion, on the part of the Government and dwindling population. They have gone out of business and their workers have cleared off. The majority of those workers have gone over to England with consequent serious loss to the town and the district. It is a hard thing for those workers to pull up their roots, pack their bags, break up their homes and bring their wives and families over to Birmingham. They have to try to get a flat somewhere. They are perhaps 40 to 50 years of age and they find it hard to pack up and leave the country. I do not think Fianna Fáil are a bit concerned about those people at all. My attention has been drawn to the fact that there is only one Fianna Fáil Deputy in the House, apart from the Parliamentary Secretary.
Comment on this
They are all looking for the Minister for External Affairs. He was last heard of playing a tambourine in Barcelona.
Comment on this
I could not help noting that the people opposite have been asking us on this side of the House not to be digging up the past. There is a certain amount of temptation to do so because so much deceit and fraud was practised by the people opposite in the past that it is necessary, in my opinion, to bring it to the notice of the people outside. I got the impression, prior to the signing of this Agreement, that some people, quite innocently through reading the Irish Press, thought the Agreement to be all right. I believe that if this Dáil meeting of the past few days has done nothing more than to bring both points of view to the notice of the people, it has done a good day's work. I am very convinced that when the Party opposite come before the people at the local elections during the year, it will be all waiting for them. We will not be afraid to tell it, please God, if we live till then. The people will know a little more then about Fianna Fáil than they did in the past.
There is one matter I regret I have to refer to, that is, the attitude of the Labour Party here. Some of their speakers have been critical of our action. I can safely say some of my best friends in this House are in the Labour Party. They are very close friends of mine and I do not really like to say anything to hurt their feelings. They are quite naturally at the present time very perturbed and worried about the position of the motor car industry and they are worried, and naturally so, about certain other industries in this city and out of it. The majority of the Deputies in the Labour Party are from the eastern and southern counties and are very decent men. Indeed, taking them, by and large, from their leader right down, I have nothing but the greatest respect and admiration for them.
They seem to be trying to take a different line, or trying to put us in a spot, in connection with the attitude of the leader of our Party and the attitude of all Deputies here on this side of the House in connection with this Trade Agreement. We have talked over all this; we have made up our minds in our own way; we have discussed the Trade Agreement and we have taken our stand on that. The Labour Party, for the time being, seem to be very bitter and very hard on Fine Gael in their criticism. I think one of the best speeches I heard was that of Deputy Everett. I was delighted to hear him as he is one of our senior Members. He related some of the old things that happened. I was delighted to see him in such good health and in such good form. I feel bound to say this. I do not think Fianna Fáil would be sitting on the far side of the House but for the statement made by Deputy Corish before the general election.
Comment on this
He said he would have nothing to do with another Coalition or inter-Party Government. That is something that caused a lot of unease in the country at the time.
Comment on this
It has nothing at all to do with the debate on the Trade Agreement before the House.
Comment on this
I was just saying if there was anything wrong about the Agreement now, that statement helped it.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish said what he said with the full approval of the Labour Party, and no regrets.
Comment on this
I want to say this much. If they want to put us in a spot, they are in a worse spot in regard to that statement. I know this has been a pretty dragged out debate. I am sure it is wearying for the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, the Ceann Comhairle and for all Deputies, listening to us so long. It is very hard for Deputies to be relevant in their remarks at this stage.
Comment on this
I have no doubt, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, you will be quite pleased, and so will every Deputy in the House, the people in the officials' benches, the people in the press gallery and the Distinguished Strangers' Gallery to hear from me that I propose to finish in five minutes. I just want to say that the discussion which has been going on for the past few days—it started at 3 o'clock on Tuesday and it is now almost ten to seven on Friday —has been enlightening in the extreme. If I were at home in Cork, I would have in front of me, not the Irish Independent, but the Cork Examiner. I have the Irish Independent in front of me now of today's date, 7th January, 1966, and written across the front of it there is a heading “2,000 to get sack”. Is that more important to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, all the Deputies here and all the people in the different galleries, than telling us that we have got the best of this Trade Agreement that was signed by the Taoiseach in our name in December, 1965?
In my opinion, any Trade Agreement, no matter who it is signed by, or what the contents of the clauses in it are, if it does not give some better opportunity to the people on whose behalf it is signed, is a bad agreement. If we consider this in a calm and cool way, however, I think most Deputies will agree that this is not a good Agreement. I want to say that I consider there are in the Fianna Fáil Party and the Labour Party quite decent, respectable and intelligent Deputies. I have no doubt that all the Deputies in the Fine Gael Party are responsible people. What is the purpose of this debate which has been going on for two days longer than anticipated? The Irish Independent gave us the answer today. If you read the second heading of that paper you will find it says: “Decision may affect 100,000”. The 100,000 is rather significant. This means 100,000 out of employment. It is not many years ago that the leader of the Fianna Fáil Party said that the policy he was proposing would give 100,000 more people jobs. It is nostalgic to look back to just a few years ago. One hundred thousand more jobs! It does not do me any good to stand here in Leinster House, as a representative of the Irish people, and say that in a boastful fashion. It is a pity.
Deputy Corry is a colleague of mine and I have great respect for him. On Tuesday night I listened to him talking about the benefits in this Trade Agreement for the people in the North-East Cork constituency. He said he had consulted all the industrialists in Midleton, Youghal, Fermoy, Cobh, Mallow and Kanturk, but the truth is he did not consult anyone. What he said was recorded here and published in the papers the following day. He said that in his opinion, having consulted these industrialists, there would be 5,000 more people in employment in North-East Cork as a result of this Trade Agreement of 1965. It is a pity that any Deputy who represents the people of this country should come in here and make such a statement to mislead his people. Even though Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party may have their shortcomings, at least when we speak in this House in the name of the people, we should be straight and honest.
The plain fact of the matter is that in the North-East Cork constituency, as I find it now—including the towns of Youghal, Cobh, Midleton, Charleville and Kanturk—as Deputy Burton said, there will be 5,000 fewer people employed. Where do we go from there? I said I would not delay the House more than five or six minutes, but I feel I have a duty to the people I represent to say I hope Deputy Corry is right, but I feel he is wrong. I am an auctioneer in a small way, among other things, and I think it right to say— and it does not give me any pleasure to say it—that this country is not on the verge of bankruptcy but is, in fact, bankrupt. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle looks at me as if to indicate that that is irrelevant to the motion dealing with the Agreement, but I have said I am an auctioneer in a small way and if, as an auctioneer, I were instructed tomorrow by the Taoiseach to sell this country, I do not think I could. If I advertised it for weeks on end, and if I were to pay for those advertisements, I think I would be bankrupt.
Those are the simple facts of the case and here we find ourselves now, with a Free Trade Agreement that has been hailed by all the papers, daily, weekly and monthly, as being the best thing since the Treaty. We see a headline in the Irish Independent:“2,000 to get the sack”. I honestly believe and accept that the Taoiseach in his own way is honest in his view of this Agreement. So are the Ministers who went with him: the Minister for Finance, his son-in-law, the Minister for Agriculture, and the others. What really happened was that when they were talking to Mr. Wilson and his colleagues in London, they thought they had a mandate from the Irish people to sign what they liked.
Before Christmas here in the Dáil, many questions were asked to try to get some indication of the terms of this Trade Agreement. No matter how the questions and supplementary questions were couched, they failed to elicit any information on what was happening in London at the time. Now we see in the papers: "2,000 to get the sack." When the Minister for Justice was talking earlier today, I asked him—in a rather rude way perhaps; by way of interjection in any case—how he concluded that the Irish farmers will get an extra £10 million this year. His answer was that if I had been listening to him for the previous ten minutes I would have understood. I did listen to him, and I want to assert now in a most emphatic and categorical way that in my view— and I think this should be said, and made very clear—in the next 12 months the Irish farmers will not get £1 more in their income, never mind the £10 million that has been mentioned.
If, as the Taoiseach and the Minister for Agriculture said, the Irish farmers will benefit from this Agreement, it should be stated how that money will get into the Irish farmers' pockets. I hope the Minister for Agriculture is right; I hope the Minister for Justice was right today; but I still think they were talking in mythical terms. Let us get finished with it. So fas as I am concerned, this is rather tragic and nostalgic. This is the 7th January, 1966. The Agreement was signed on 14th December, 1965. We see a national daily paper today with the headline: "2,000 to get the sack. Decision may affect 100,000 people." Where are we going from there? Are we going to be honest with ourselves and say we are not fit to govern the country? I am going to make a bet with you, Sir, that in six months there will be a general election and a change of faces here.
Comment on this
: In my constituency the small farmers who mainly comprise it have gained practically nothing as a result of Fianna Fáil administration during their term of office. After a close examination of the Free Trade Agreement, we discover that it embodies nothing new, that it merely embodies what was in the 1948 Trade Agreement. I wonder what are all the headlines and blowing of bugles about, or what are we to boast about in regard to this Agreement. We are obliged to supply 638,000 cattle to England but we did that in 1964, and we also did it in 1948. What is there to boast about as far as those figures are concerned? Today in my part of the country, the cattle trade is poor due to the credit squeeze and because the banks have refused to put money into circulation which would be used by enterprising people to buy and sell cattle. The terms of this Agreement do not mean any immediate relief for those people.
The poultry industry, for instance, is not mentioned in this Agreement. In times gone by, the housewife was able to pay for her housekeeping from the poultry kept on the small farms in my constituency. That meant money going to the shopkeeper and it meant employment for other people, because, as Deputy O'Hara said, you had a fleet of lorries travelling to the city on various mornings of the week. That business has gone; yet Fianna Fáil will tell us about the great prosperity that is about to come our way as a result of this Agreement. In 1948 we exported 20,000 tons of butter to England but in 1967 23,000 tons will have to be sent. Year in year out, we have been stressing the necessity for manuring land, the necessity for improving our herds, and the other factors which contribute to increased milk production, and it is surprising to think that we will be sending only 3,000 tons of butter more in 1967 than we sent in 1948. That is not something which warrants boasting.
We must also remember that the British can either increase or reduce that if they wish. At the same time 1/9½d. is given by the producer to England to supply a lb of butter to the English housewife. In view of what the farmers have gone through, it is a sad case that in 1967 we have to subsidise butter to this tune in order to get rid of it. It would be a difficult thing to explain to people producing milk and having large supplies of butter in the creameries why we have to give 1/9½d. to England to have a lb of our butter sold in England. Our own hardworking people have to pay 4/9d. a lb. When we have to do that, there is nothing to boast about.
As far as the ordinary person can see, industry is not in for a good time. In the past we have been struggling to have industries set up in the constituency from which I come by sending deputations to Departments or anywhere else that we thought would be of use. Recently we were with the Forestry Division and met officials from that section and other officials, but no encouragement was given to us to set up an industry, despite the fact that we are providing thousands of acres for forestry. Yet when an industry is to be established, it is to be established perhaps 100 miles away from County Sligo or County Leitrim. That is the picture as we see it.
Every day of the week, you will meet young men at the local railway station going to England. We who travel to Dublin discover often that we are in the company of a husband and wife and their children who are going off to England because there is no employment here. By the look of things, there will be even less employment and more homes will be closed. Unless a watchful eye is kept on this problem the position will worsen. We should also bear in mind that the people about whom I am speaking are paying highly for the concessions they are getting. The few small industries in my constituency have been employing girls at a small wage and when they have paid for their clothing and so on, there is not much left.
Sligo is on the main route to the North, but it has got very little in the way of industry. A few small industries were established, and one of them closed up a few years ago. In 1951, we had 1,217,100 employed, and in 1964, the figure was 1,059,000 a drop of about 158,000 people. What will happen if further industries have to close? Where will our boys and girls go to work except in the English cities? Fianna Fáil boast about our prosperity. Were it not for the money coming home from our boys and girls in England, more homes would be closed. We hear a lot of talk about tourism and the money it is bringing to this country. It is coming in the pockets of boys and girls who would come home if there was never a word about tourism. The big hotels may get the people they are after, but the boys and girls about whom I am talking would come home if there was never a line in the papers about tourism, because they love their homes. We should provide employment for them at home instead of forcing them off. I meet them when they are home and they ask me if there is a chance of a job in this country. I tell them we would be delighted to have them if employment could be provided for them.
I could go on talking for a long time about this Agreement, but I would be only repeating what has been said by other speakers. I could deal with bacon and poultry. One statement rather surprised me. That was the statement that for every industry which closed down, five would spring up in its place. They have been very slow to spring up in the past. As I mentioned, we have been seeking industry for years and the devil a one has sprung up. Saying that five industries will spring up for every one closed is a very rosy prospect, but I doubt it very much.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
It was around this time last evening that I heard Deputy M.J. O'Higgins say that at that stage it was not possible to break new ground in this debate. If that was true yesterday evening, it should be doubly true this evening. Nevertheless, before the debate concludes, it is only right that most Deputies should express an opinion on this Agreement. It is an extremely important Agreement for the country, and the people should know where their public representatives stand on it.
Many things have been said about this Agreement, and that is only right. Most of us would go so far as to say that a comprehensive review of the trading arrangements between this country and Great Britain was long overdue. But, now that that review has taken place and an Agreement negotiated and signed, I believe there is widespread disappointment, dissatisfaction and even apprehension at its outcome and effects on certain sectors of the economy.
I am puzzled to understand how the Taoiseach could sit down with his opposite number in the British Government and negotiate an Agreement such as this—urgent as that was— without insisting, as a prior condition to the discussions, that the existing British levy, which was imposed in absolute violation and breach of existing trading arrangements, be first removed. That should be insisted on as an earnest of the intention of the British Government to keep whatever new Agreement might be negotiated. However, there appears to be no suggestion that the British Government were asked to remove this levy before negotiations started. That was starting on a very bad foot. It is remarkable that throughout this debate not one Government Deputy has referred to this British levy. Many speakers from those benches stated that from now on our industrial products would have free access to the British market without restriction or imposition of any kind. Of course, that is not true. Unless the British Government decide to remove this levy before July next —and there does not seem to be any indication that is going to happen— our industrial products will still carry that ten per cent.
We have been asked what better we could have done. We have said, and given it as the opinion of this Party, that it should have been possible, as one alternative, to get some sort of a limited trading arrangement with the EEC. That suggestion was scoffed at by the Taoiseach and various other speakers from the Government benches. It has been scoffed at without producing any evidence whatever that a real effort was made to do this. At least, we produced the evidence that Greece succeeded and Austria now look like succeeding in getting some such agreement. But we have no evidence from the Government benches, except hearsay or an expression of opinion, that that was not possible.
Some of us also felt it should have been possible to get a more limited agreement with the British to give us greater access for our agricultural produce while, at the same time, not throwing the Irish market wide open to British industrial competition. It is remoured that, at one stage, the Taoiseach was on the point of returning home without signing the Agreement. It is a great pity he did not do that. It is a great pity he did not come back here and come into this House and tell the people he could not see his way to sign this Agreement. He could then have the situation debated and he could perhaps point out where the shortcomings were, and perhaps be helped by the Deputies in this House. I believe he would shortly be recalled and offered an Agreement much more advantageous to this country. But he made that decision and that Agreement is signed and we now have to make the best of it.
I do not want to be put on record as saying that I see no advantages in this Agreement. There are certain limited advantages. The only reason I could find even partial pardon for the Taoiseach for signing this Agreement is becasue of his apparent conviction that this country will gain membership of the EEC before 1970. If we do not get into the EEC before 1970, this will then be a very unfacourably balanced Agreement. The entire balance will go over in favour of Britain after that time.
In the short term, I see certain advantages in this Agreement. The disadvantages will not appear immediately. What were we setting out to solve and what are our difficulties? What are the difficulties confronting us at the moment? I think our greatest concern should be for the large number of people we have unemployed and the large number of people emigrating. There are many other things for which we want to find money as well—housing, schools, health services, and so on. However, I think first of the unemployed and those who have to emigrate.
At the present time, we have nearly 64,000 people unemployed and we have approximately 25,000 people emigrating annually. That figure has perhaps gone up. Anyhow, altogether, we have in the region of 100,000 people in this country at the present time for whom the economy is not able to cater. If we are making an Agreement and trying to ensure that such an Agreement will help to solve our problems, surely that is the first problem that should concern us.
I want to say quite frankly that I see nothing whatever in this Agreement that will either solve the unemployment problem that we have or provide additional employment opportunities for our people. The Taoiseach gave it as his opinion that opportunity now knocks. The Minister for Industry and Commerce also expressed the view here yesterday that he could now expect and see that we would have industrial establishment here at an accelerated pace. How he works that out, beats me. He says we have got a much wider market for our industrial products and that this, in itself, will be an attraction to people who come here and set up industry.
We have guaranteed access. I want to know what the difference is between the access that we had up to the present and what is described as guaranteed access.
Comment on this
The only limitation I am aware of was a limitation that the Government of the time allowed to be written into the 1938 Agreement and that was this limitation in relation to goods containing man-made fibres. That has been removed and it is estimated that after the lapse of a period of some years, it may be worth £10 million to this country. What is the estimate of the loss that this country will suffer, first of all, in import duties on British goods—what is the estimate of the loss in cash and in employment?
I was on the subject of the establishment of industry and I do not want to leave it. This agreement to open our industrial market to British competition is absolutely and entirely premature. The Taoiseach said yesterday that valuable years had been wasted— those were his words—through this system of protecting industries for too long. That, my view, is an expression of failure. It is an expression of failure that we have not got down to the job of attracting and establishing sufficient industry here to provide employment for the people who have been leaving the land in such numbers.
It was said in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion that we would provide 8,000 new jobs each year in industry for people leaving the land. Since 1951, I estimate that we have provided in industry approximately 3,500 new jobs per annum. That is a statistic that proves failure because I do not see where else the people will be employed if they are not employed in industry. We have at the present time—the last year for which we have statistics, 1964—158,100 fewer people at work than we had in 1951. That is a shocking state of affairs. It is with that situation in mind that any Agreement should be decided upon with any outside power.
I know, from my experience of trying to help people to come in here to establish industry, what a job it was to get through the Industrial Development Authority and An Foras Tionscal. We should have done what they did in the North of Ireland. We should have built the factories and leased them. We put every obstacle in their way and we have failed completely. I know that many of the smaller industries, when confronted with the mammoth, long-established British industries, will be wiped out.
People talked today and yesterday evening about patriotism and the grit and the guts of our people. Government speakers would not be talking like that, were it not that they are perfectly aware that these people will be called upon to face hardship and to overcome an ordeal. We had other Deputies from the opposite side talking about buying Irish as one great way out of this difficulty. Everybody knows it is written into this Agreement that we can no longer operate this Buy Irish campaign. Only for a limited period will we be able to give the proposers of industry here anything like tax concessions, grants, etc. After that, British industry takes over here in a big way. British industry is so big, so specialised and has such an enormous home market that there is no doubt they will come in here and wipe us out in many cases. There is, perhaps, some little significance in the fact that two Fianna Fáil Deputies have not yet spoken. One is Deputy Booth and the other is Deputy Gallagher. They are both people in business here who probably know the way in which their own industries are likely to be affected by this Agreement.
I had a number of people in with me a couple of days ago, people who live in my constituency and who are working in the car assembly business. I do not want to give the impression that it is the car assembly people only who will suffer—because I can foresee many similar industries going under—but the view the people in the car assembly business expressed to me was that no Government have the right to make a decision that tells them "you will lose your job." No Government have the right to commit an act of that sort unless they are able to say: "We are putting you out of a job today but we have this to offer you tomorrow." These people are very upset. They have family responsibilities. The statement has been made and admitted here in this House that those people will lose their employment. But have any Government agency gone into those industries since that announcement was first made and said: "Look, do not worry; we will provide you with alternative employment; we will train you for alternative employment and, if you are not capable of being trained for alternative employment, we will compensate you"? Those people are entitled to receive that sort of assurance. I do not think an Agreement such as this should have been concluded until we were in a position to tell those people, who will inevitably lose their employment, how they will be treated afterwards.
I should like whatever Government speakers there are still to contribute to indicate to me what will induce additional industry into this country at the present time, what new market have we got and what new facilities have we got? Is it because people might come in here, knowing they were able to wipe out our own small industries because they had a bigger arm somewhere else? I see a much greater danger of industries here, with a British base already, deciding to close down the unit here and supply from Britain. We will reach the point very soon where we will have no attraction to offer in this country for people proposing to establish industry here, except a pool of labour and that, unless there are big changes, will be a pool of unskilled labour, a pool of labour which will not be fitted to take its place in industry as it should. The only advantage in this Agreement from the industrial point of view—and it has many disadvantages—is contained in the portion of it relating to man-made fibres.
We pass then to the other side of this Agreement, which has been described by every Government spokesman as the greatest thing that ever happened and, that is, the agricultural aspect of it. What have we got in agriculture and how does it compare with what we got in 1948? I hold there is very little difference in what we got in 1948 and what has been received under this Agreement in Irish agriculture. The only additional benefit really one can see is that we now participate in the deficiency payments, when they are paid, on store cattle, store lambs and on a limited quantity of carcase beef and lamb. If I may make a correction there—we had store cattle, but the waiting period has been reduced. Now a figure has been put on the value of that waiting period by the Minister for Agriculture. He says, as a result of the reduction in this waiting period, store cattle will improve by £5 to £6 per head. That is making a very extravagant claim for the reduction in this waiting period. My own feeling is that it will make little or no difference. We have and had, in my opinion, free access to the British market for store cattle, sheep and lambs always. There has never been any restriction in operation. Apparently the power is there under the 1948 Agreement, for the purpose of orderly marketing, that this restriction could have been imposed.
I say the British still can impose anything they like. When the Taoiseach was trying to explain and apologise for the shortcomings of this Agreement he said they were confronted in these negotiations by a highly skilled, highly experienced team of negotiators from the British side. He described their ability in making this type of Agreement and I think he could just as well have referred to their ability at breaking such Agreements. The British people will adhere to this Agreement as long as it suits them, as long as it is expedient for them to do so and they have agreed to guarantee us, as they say, free access for store cattle, sheep and lambs because it suits them to do so, because there is no place in the world at the present time where they can get store cattle of the quality and as disease-free as they can from here. It is simply because the British farmers and feeders want our stores and not that the British Government were giving us anything on a plate.
It has been said that because of this guaranteed access, the whole outlook of Irish farmers regarding cattle production will change. I do not think it makes any difference to the Irish farmer that we will now be able to participate in the deficiency payments on beef. We have been getting these deficiency payments when they had to be paid over the past 18 months or so and it is something much smaller than it sounds. Only in two very short periods in the past 12 months were any deficiency payments in Britain. The expectation is, with the shortage of cattle on the Continent and elsewhere, that in the coming year there will be probably little or no deficiency payments.
In 1948 the butter quota was 20,000 tons and more, if more was available. We have now secured a quota of 23,000 tons which, in my view means no change because 20,000 tons and more, if available, is at least equal to 23,000 tons now. Somebody seems to be amused at that statement; I see nothing amusing in it; it is a fact. Since 1948 through the failure of the Government to exploit the opportunities and advantages of that Trade Agreement we lost our place as suppliers in the British market because the Government had no interest or confidence in agriculture.
Comment on this
Sir, some noise is being made by people who are not in the benches—I think they have gone now.
Comment on this
We lost our place in the British market as suppliers of butter and we were down to 12,500 or 13,000 tons but, because of the scarcity on the British market, we were offered extra and in the past year we supplied 19,000 tons of butter. Where is the advantage here that we should shout about? It is a question of whether we should not have got some assistance because of the fact that we have to pay at least 1/-a lb. on the butter we export. I admit this is not an easy problem because the British can buy butter at this sort of competitive price from other sources and that is the result of highly subsidised agriculture elsewhere. I think it was the Minister for Agriculture who said there was no support for butter in the British economy or for milk. That is quite wrong; perhaps he may have said that there was no deficiency payment and that is true. There is no direct deficiency payment but the price for liquid milk is much better there than it is here and they have many other built-in supports by way of greater grants for farm buildings, grants for silage, calf subsidies, ploughing up subsidies and so many agricultural subsidies that one can never say that there is no support for milk or butter in England. The British people are not interested in the British farmers in regard to butter because they make practically no butter and their milk supply goes into cheese and chocolate crumb.
The Minister for Justice today said that in negotiating this Agreement they had got one hundred per cent of what they sought for Irish agriculture. Obviously, we did not seek enough. Negotiations of this kind are hard bargaining and we made a bad bargain. He said they got all they looked for. Were they afraid that if they got a greater quota of butter the subsidy would be more than they could pay? Had they the same consideration in mind when negotiating the bacon quota? In 1948 we got a bacon quota of 27,000 tons and more if available; we have now got 28,000 tons and that represents all we looked for. I know that in the present state of pig production here we will find it difficult to supply these quantities and again that is a reflection of the Government's interest in agricultural production over the years. It is undeniable that in the west of Ireland, we are producing half as many pigs as in 1929. That is the progress that has been made.
The question of broilers was raised and the Minister for Agriculture, to my amazement, said there was no limitation on the development opportunities we now had for broilers and also for turkeys, while, of course, it is written into the Agreement that this cannot happen. Immediately any significant development takes place in the broiler industry, we must consult with the British and give them free access for their broilers. In my view the broiler and poultry industry is killed forever and any possibility of any significant development in this sector of agriculture is gone. Let us not try to cod the people. The British have safeguarded themselves in this matter. They have ensured that no development regarding broilers such as that envisaged some time ago in the Bandon area of County Cork will ever take place here. It is well known that about four broiler-producing units in England will produce about 60 per cent of British needs in broilers and we can easily see what is awaiting us if we develop our broiler industry.
Another matter that the Minister for Agriculture proudly boasted about was the opportunity we had for the development of the fishing industry. That is another of these chancy, semi-dishonest statements. Everybody knows that we were not short of a market for fish. I know, and most Deputies know, that no less than 22 countries were looking for Irish fish but we failed to produce it. We failed to develop a fishing industry that would supply these markets.
The Second Programme for Economic Expansion estimated that landings of fish would be doubled in the decade from 1960 to 1970. The records for the first four years of that period show that landings declined. It is a dishonest claim to make for this Agreement that we have got the new market that we required before we could develop our fishing industry.
Personally, I am sorry the Taoiseach, when he had more or less decided to come home without signing an agreement, did not do so. Today we have a situation where there are 100,000 people not catered for. The front page of today's paper has a banner headline "2,000 to get sack". At the bottom of the page, there is a report headed "Inquiry into Shoe Factory Dismissals".
Comment on this
The Irish Independent. I am sure it is in the Irish Press as well. The report says:
A Board of Inquiry is sitting at the Edenderry Shoe Co. premises today to discuss the decision of the factory management to dismiss 59 workers. The factory, which specialises in women's fashion shoes, exports most of the products.
The workers, 43 women and 16 men, are under dismissal notices since before Christmas. The decision to dismiss them is linked with the Free Trade Agreement and a recent statement of a reduction in the factory output.
That is just another example of the type of business that will suffer when we open our market here to British industry.
Since 19th December, there has been an increase of 7,000 in the number unemployed and it is obvious that that is not unconnected with the signing of this Agreement. Every page of today's paper contains reports of strikes, lock-outs, disputes and loss of employment. This helps to indicate the present state of the economy. It indicates the failure of the Government over the years to set up some sort of decent labour relations. If this continues we will have chaos. It is the responsibility of everyone who speaks in public to refer to this matter.
Various wage agreements were negotiated and it is obvious that these wage agreements and the things that followed them have been so hopeless in their effects that there is industrial chaos at the present time. There is nothing in this Agreement that I can see that will relieve that situation. My colleague in County Dublin, Deputy Burke, said yesterday that he cannot see anything in this Agreement that will do harm to the people in his constituency. I hope he is right. Already, people who are affected and who are likely to be affected in the near future are coming, knocking at my door, and asking what will be done about it.
Deputy P.J. Lenihan said today that we were free to send our cattle, our livestock, our industrial products, to any part of the world. He did not seem to know that we were first obliged to supply to the British market a minimum of 638,000 store cattle and 25,000 tons of carcase beef and that it was only if we had quantities surplus to those amounts that we could explore other markets. If the statistics are right, we will have surpluses of cattle and beef over these amounts and can continue to develop markets other than the British market. It is more and more important that we should try as far as possible to reduce our dependence on this single market. We have tied our economy to the British economy at the present time. Undoubtedly, Britain is our biggest and best market and we should do everything we can to improve our position in the British market but we should not lose sight of any opportunity to expand in other markets.
The Taoiseach said that he saw this Agreement as the only way in which we might eventually gain entry to the EEC. That represents an extraordinary change since the time we were told in this House that if Britain did not get into the EEC, we would go it alone. The Taoiseach has changed his mind since then and now says that there is no possibility of our ever getting into the EEC unless through our association with Great Britain. He hinted that perhaps we would now proceed to try to get into EFTA but I think we are going to do that only if and when the talks which have been initiated by the British Premier between the countries look like succeeding and look like bringing about an association between those two blocs. He said it then might become a matter of urgency for us to gain entry into EFTA.
It is not quite clear to me as to whether, if and when we get into EFTA, this Agreement that has now been made with Britain completely falls and whether all our obligations and Britain's obligations disappear because of our gaining entry to EFTA, but the impression I get is that it does. I sincerely hope that the Taoiseach's forecast that we will gain entry to the EEC by 1970 proves to be correct. If that gamble comes off, and I describe it as a gamble, it will deliver us from the worst effects of this Agreement. It may be that the Taoiseach does not himself look upon it as a gamble and that he would describe it as a calculated risk worth taking.
In the short term, this Agreement has certain advantages for this country. In the long term, we will lose out heavily on it. These are the assessments. They are not my assessments. They are the assessments of people better qualified to assess the situation. The assessment of the situation is that this deal with Great Britain will be worth to Britain anything in the region of £60 million to £100 million at the end of ten years and that this country will not gain a fraction of that amount but it does appear to give us an opportunity to develop with a greater degree of confidence the agricultural sector of our economy. I only hope that the new quotas, which are little, if any, better than those we secured under the 1948 Agreement, will not be lost again through neglect of the industry and through failure on the part of the Government to take sufficient interest in the industry to get the required production.
On the question of participation in the deficiency payments, it is not clear, apparently, to everybody what will happen to these deficiency payments if, and when, we get them. The British Government will have their say in how this money will be spent. No Government speaker so far has given us his impression as to how the money resulting from participation in the deficiency payments will in fact be spent. Will it be given back to the dairy farmers in an increased price in their milk? In what way is it intended to support and stimulate production? We are not on level terms with the British agricultural producer. It is one of the great pities from the point of view of this Agreement that more was not done to put us on a level with the British producer. Their farmers are supported by a large industrial empire and, with that well-established industrial empire behind them, they will be allowed to come in here and compete against our weak and unprepared industries. I believe the Irish economy will suffer. As I said, I hope we will be delivered from the worst rigours of this Agreement by succeeding in getting into the EEC before we realise how unbalanced this Agreement really is and before our people are asked to suffer the worst rigours of it.
Comment on this
This debate has been long and protracted but it has certainly been well worthwhile. This Agreement is very important and will be for many years to come. It has been said that it is the most important measure since the Treaty. I agree. The Agreement has been assessed by various speakers, for and against. Is it as good as could have been got or is it as good as the Fianna Fáil Party try to make out? With the other speakers on this side of the House, I believe it is not as good as it could be and not as good as it should be. However, nothing can be done about that at the moment. It is signed, sealed and delivered. All we can do now is talk about the lost chances, if chances were lost. We believe they were.
There is nothing in this Agreement that will help any small farmer, whether west of the Shannon, or anywhere else, to stay a day longer on his holding or to produce more—nothing whatever. Some of the ghosts that haunt the rafters of this Chamber must be smiling, some of them sardonically, when they remember the things that were said on the Fianna Fáil benches in the past about the British market. Many of the people down the country must be smiling ruefully, the people who went through the rigours of past years and who saw the chances that are now being availed of lost and chances missed of building for ourselves a place in the British market, a place that was allowed to go to other people in Europe and elsewhere.
There is no satisfaction in saying these things, but it is only right that, in a debate of this kind, the truth should be told. Thirty years late it is seen that the British market is our best market, and will be for some years our only market. It is no great satisfaction now to remember the wasted years. What was the rush recently? Why the degree of haste in negotiating this Agreement at this moment? I agree with other speakers that the untold millions we are supposed to gain under this Agreement in this or any other year are mythical millions. Even though there may be a rise in stock prices in the immediate future, the Minister for Agriculture must realise that the only reason for that rise will be the scarcity of good cattle in the country. Good cattle are scarce and will remain scarce for some time.
It must be borne in mind that the heifer scheme, designed to increase the cattle population, has resulted in a number of stock being of a far lower standard than we were breeding heretofore. Everybody knows that every kind of heifer was used for breeding. Indeed, some of the bulls used were open to question too. The result will be a smaller number of good cattle coming on the market in the spring and early summer. That will mean that our balance of payments will continue to be unsatisfactory for a much longer period than even the Government anticipated. In regard to the credit squeeze, and all the other squeezes resulting from it, the sooner the balance of payments situation rights itself the better it will be for the nation. I fear the improvement will be slow because I fear that some of the other mistakes made by the Government in the past will cause a little more travail and a little more confusion.
The other day a man, who seemed to know what he was talking about, told me that one of the reasons for the speed with which the Government entered into these negotiations was that they found themselves in a cleft stick as a result of their policy of supporting industries here, with the help of the taxpayers' money, which were not proving economic, that they found themselves in the position in which they had not money to pay any more of these people anxious to establish industries. But, even if they had the money, the industries would not prove worthwhile.
That is the picture I have been given and it seems reasonable enough. Today the longest train that ever came from Westport came up the line crowded with emigrants from the west going across to Britain where they had to make their own trade agreement long before the Taoiseach or anybody else ever thought about it. To survive they had to make an agreement, whether they liked it or not. This country had to make this Trade Agreement signed by Fianna Fáil in order to survive and, I suppose, there was no alternative.
I can only hope that the Agreements can give results that will be to the betterment of every farmer, small or large. I also hope that the fears in the minds of other Deputies here that there will be widespread unemployment in industry are groundless. If at the end of a year the Dáil discusses this again, we shall be able to assess whether the negotiators made a good bargain or whether they were capable of undoing the damage that was caused by their mistakes in the past.
Comment on this
I do not intend to delay the House too long. The previous speaker says this debate has gone on longer than that on the Treaty and that it was as significant and as important as that debate. The Treaty debate lasted only two days and this has now gone into its fourth day. Therefore, I shall make just a short contribution to the debate.
I do not know why this discussion has lasted four days because from my excursions through my own constituency and from listening to the opinion of the man-in-the-street on this Agreement, I would say they all seem to be satisfied that it is a good Agreement, both for agriculture and for industry. Some speakers have said that the Common Market would be a still better arrangement, but the ten-year transitional period of this Agreement will possibly help us to get into the Common Market quicker than might otherwise be the case.
Any Deputy who goes down to the Dáil Library and reads the editorials in the provincial papers—I have read some of them—will see that there has been full agreement among these provincial papers that this is a good Agreement as far as we are concerned. Opposition speakers have said there is nothing in this for agriculture. Why are the Northern Ireland farmers, the Scottish farmers and the British farmers so perturbed, as is evident from the pronouncements they have made, if there is not something good in this for us?
Apart from the agricultural, industrial and economic advantages which this Agreement is to bring to the Irish nation, the most important and significant advantage—and I say that future generations will thank the Taoiseach and the Ministers who made this Agreement for us—is in the political field. This was not a secret Agreement such as was signed in 1925 when the Six Counties was sold away. It was an agreement made in the full light of day. I believe this agreement will hasten the day—and I think all right-thinking people will agree with me—of the reunification of our country. If there is free movement of peope and goods across the two divided parts of our nation, the Border can be only an imaginary line. We have made great strides to reunify our country. It was not the fault of my Party that it was divided.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the Ceann Comhairle. We are celebrating this year the fiftieth anniversary of the Rising of 1916. I believe it is a good thing that this debate has gone on till the eleventh hour and we shall stay here and debate it with the Opposition Deputies for as long as they like. I believe future generations will thank the Taoiseach and his Ministers for having signed this Agreement. It is something that will help us to achieve a reunited nation with the Tricolour flying over the whole Thirty-two Counties.
Comment on this
It has a great deal to do with the Agreement. Agriculture, industry and economics are in this but there is also the political idea in it. Everybody knows that if there is free movement of people and goods all over the country, it is a stepping-stone——
Comment on this
That is the word the Deputy wanted to use. Forty-five years too late they are using the stepping-stone.
Comment on this
I am glad I have got the Opposition Deputies going. This is the stepping-stone we have to put back to undo the wrong that the Deputy's colleagues did in 1925——
Comment on this
I shall have to use the powers vested in me if Deputies will not conduct themselves.
Comment on this
This stepping-stone has been put back now by the Taoiseach and by our Ministers. I hope we shall all settle down now in this New Year, the fiftieth anniversary of the Rising, and work in peace and harmony so that we can achieve the reunification of our country.
Comment on this
I intend to be very brief, but I wish to make reference to a few of the remarks made by the last speaker. He said this Agreement will be of political significance to them. That is the general idea of it, that it will be of political significance to Fianna Fáil, that it will keep them in power for a few more years. At the beginning, the Taoiseach set the headline and the 70 odd Deputies behind him——
Comment on this
They said the Agreement would benefit both the agricultural and industrial spheres. Those fellows who sit over there, or who should sit over there, spend half the time asleep and the others who do not sit over there fall asleep outside the door. Deputies represent both the agricultural and the industrial fronts here and I, therefore, do not see why the 72 Deputies over there should fall into step behind their Taoiseach on this Agreement.
Comment on this
Deputy Molloy is inclined to interrupt me. I did not hear him make a contribution so far. There have been five speakers from this side of the House and only Deputy Kitt from the Government side. Have they run out of wind?
Comment on this
I have. I do not think the Deputy will ever have as much. When the Agreement was signed in London last month, we were led to believe it would help agriculture and that it would do no harm to industry. The first announcement we had of the fact that the Agreement had been signed was when Mr. Lemass was interviewed——