We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agreements between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom.

Contributions 389–598 of 598. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

It is only a technical error.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy had better not answer back to instructions from the Chair.

Comment on this

And that includes the front bench.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I wish the front bench would conduct itself. There has been a constant stream of interruptions.

Comment on this

The first we heard of it was when the Taoiseach was interviewed by a Telefís Éireann reporter in London. The Taoiseach was explaining the Agreement and all of a sudden the camera was taken off his face and put on the smiling countenance of the man who was interviewing him as if he were representing the Irishman in London and showing how happy we were because this Agreement would make us all rich. However, this has been debated at length. I should like to point out that between the signing of the Agreement and the beginning of the debate here we were given very little time to read the document and find out what it was all about. I am sure Deputies on the Government benches must admit the Agreement does not mean plain sailing. I do not say it is a bad Agreement in all aspects. There is a certain number of good points, just as everybody has his virtues, even those on the opposite side of the House.

Fianna Fáil Deputies have been telling us the Agreement will benefit both agriculture and industry. I am sure that Mr. Wilson, Mr. Peart, Mr. Jay and the other British negotiators have not changed very much from the Englishmen we knew, as our oppressors in the past and whom Fianna Fáil Deputies now claim to have oppressed in turn. We have been led to believe that those who negotiated on behalf of the Irish Government got the better of their English counterparts. If they did, and I know they did not, it was the first time in their lives they did. The only reason they got what they did was that the British wanted our store cattle.

The Minister for Justice today said that the negotiations were so successful because the Irish deputation were so good looking and smiled so much. He said that was very strongly in favour of the Irish people and Government. I say that by signing this Agreement the Fianna Fáil Government and Party have gone completely against their past principles. Their idea in the past was to foster small industries. If one factory closed down, their policy was to open five. In my constituency and throughout Connacht there are many more factories closing down than opening. When Deputy Kitt spoke it is a wonder he did not refer to the Tuam beet factory and to the letter published in the local newspaper recently telling the farmers in the Tuam area how to grow beet. As I have said, it has been the policy of Fianna Fáil to foster small industries and they have had limited success. By signing this Agreement they have sounded the death knell of most of these industries. There will be wholesale dumping which will wipe out the chances of all our small industries and Deputies on the other side know that very well.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy not vote against it?

Comment on this

You never know what I might do. Though the Taoiseach, according to himself, has been negotiating for a Free Trade Area with Britain since 1963, since then there have been five by-elections and one general election——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I do not see what that has got to do with the motion before the House.

Comment on this

If Fianna Fáil had not been returned, we would not have this Agreement.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It has not the slightest thing to do with the motion.

Comment on this

Surely it is relevant for a Deputy to make the case that if the Government had been negotiating for two years and had faced five by-elections and one general election in the meantime, it would have been reasonable to tell the people about it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy possibly misunderstands the line Deputy Donnellan was taking.

Comment on this

Possibly the Chair does not understand it.

Comment on this

During the last general election and the five by-elections, the Government did not at any time indicate that they were negotiating a free trade agreement with Britain. Therefore, they have not only deceived the people but their own supporters. All their lives they have been told lies by Fianna Fáil. Fianna Fáil policy, if there was such a thing in the last general election, did not mention anything about a Free Trade Area. They painted a rosy picture in preparation for those elections, of the industrial and agricultural growth under Fianna Fáil administration. I wonder when the next election comes, whenever it may be, what will be the picture proof of their progress, and I mean picture proof. I would also suggest another idea to them: instead of using the Tricolour as a background on their literature, they should use the Union Jack.

Comment on this

It would mean the same thing to the Fianna Fáil Deputies.

Comment on this

He beat you before and he will do it again. He gave you a shaking in December, 1964.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The negotiations with regard to this Trade Agreement, over the past few years, were shrouded in secrecy. The first we heard about the Trade Agreement was last July or August when we were in recess, when they would not have to face the wrath, I presume, of the Labour Party, and certainly the Fine Gael Party. My personal opinion is that all sections of the community should have been notified or should have got some indication that this was happening. The trade unions, the NFA, all business organisations and all Parties in this House could have helped and I am sure, with the co-operation of all, we would have had drawn up an Agreement which would have been much more beneficial to all sections of the community rather than this makeshift one.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Government are elected representatives of the people. They have been elected to govern the country, not to sell it, and quite a bit of what many Irishmen fought hard to achieve has been signed away by this Trade Agreement. As far as agriculture is concerned we are led to believe that the fact that the retention period for Irish cattle has been reduced from three months to two months will be highly beneficial to the Irish farmers.

Comment on this

So it is.

Comment on this

Maybe it is. Tell us how.

Comment on this

In 1948 when the other Trade Agreement was signed, the retention period was also two months and it was not changed to three months until 1955.

Comment on this
Deputies

Who was in power?

Comment on this

There was no food subsidy at the time.

Comment on this

There is no difference in the Trade Agreement as far as cattle are concerned. The important thing, which was started in the 1948 Cattle Trade Agreement, was the price link between the British farmers and the Irish farmers. There is not much point in our selling one million store cattle in England in the coming year if the price is down. We all know that the price of cattle has dropped by approximately £10 per head in one year. Any Deputies who are farmers, or any Deputies who know anything about farming will only have to go out to a fair, or the new cattle marts, to find that out. I speak for the farmers of the west of Ireland. When the farmer had to pay his rates, he sold a beast or two to do so. He will find he has to sell more this year to pay the same amount of rates or, may I say, slightly increased rates.

We hope that this lamb carcase allocation to us will improve the sheep trade. May I say this? We got the same price ten years ago, and 12 years ago, for our sheep as we are getting today—exactly the same price. I do not want to keep this going on all night. As a matter of fact, I do not think I could because I have not got the——

Comment on this

The Deputy has not got the message.

Comment on this

In conclusion, I think this Trade Agreement is of more political significance to the Deputies over there than it is in hard cash to the business people, the farmers, the labourers and the workers of this country. There is another thing about this. This Agreement was made at the most opportune time in the world. It will help them to forget the credit squeeze.

Comment on this
Deputies

That is good.

Comment on this

I am afraid my standing up here is not actually an answer to the challenge of the previous speaker, Deputy Donnellan. I am disobeying the orders of the Whips of my Party.

Comment on this

Do not admit that.

Comment on this

They will expel the Deputy if he does.

Comment on this

I shall not delay the House very long with my contribution. There were so many speakers on the Fianna Fáil side of the House waiting for hours to get in that, as Deputy Kitt has said, we could keep the debate here all night and all night tomorrow night, if necessary.

Comment on this

That is what the Deputy is paid for.

Comment on this

Several references have been made here, with regard to this Trade Agreement, to the statement by the leader on this side of the House, at one time: "Burn everything British except their coal." An awful lot was made of this by the Opposition speakers. During the Thirties, we had a very sensible leader who set up a protection barrier to help the little industry we had in this country. He did this to give us a mantle under which we could build up our existing industries and start new industries and we now have a large number of good industries in this country. It would be a great mistake to continue working behind those barriers and not to let our industries stand on their own feet. Economists for two hundred or three hundred years have been arguing this question of protection as against free trade. We have very little choice in this country today because free trade is accepted by all our traditional markets. They are all moving towards free trade. We had to do something about it to make sure that we do not lose our traditional markets. We hope our industries will continue to expand in the years that lie ahead. There is no use going back to 1922. Indeed Deputy Dockrell went back as far as 1880.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Deputy Noel Lemass went back to the sixteenth century.

Comment on this

This Government are legislating for the future. I stand here as an elected Deputy and I have every confidence in the Taoiseach and the Ministers who signed this Agreement. I come from the west of Ireland, from the same county as Deputy Donnellan. I am behind this Agreement and I feel the future of the country lies in it.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell that to the factory workers in Galway?

Comment on this

I live in my constituency.

Comment on this

I hope all the factory workers, who are living in the Deputy's constituency, will continue to live there.

Comment on this

There is one aspect of the agricultural side of this Agreement to which I should like to refer. Some Deputies mentioned there was no benefit in this reduction of the waiting period by one month. If you take one store bullock—and I would ask the farmers on the other side of the House——

Comment on this

You would not recognise one.

Comment on this

I stood in the fair-green in Galway selling bullocks when you were a young lad trotting down to the little national school. A store bullock will put on, on average, a half cwt in one month.

Comment on this

Where were you grazing him?

Comment on this

This reduction to two months gives the farmer a chance to leave his bullocks for another month's feeding.

Comment on this

In this extra month's feeding these bullocks will gain a half cwt, on average, per animal, and bring in an extra £3 10s. or £4 per animal, which I reckon would bring in £2½ million straight away. I am sure the farmers on the other side of the House will not object if I read an entract from a statement made by the President of the National Farmers Union in England. He said:

...that the Union deplores the provision which put Irish farmers on a par with British if market sharing agreements were concluded. The Union has always opposed the idea that overseas suppliers should be given a predetermined share of the British market over a long period.

He also stated that British farmers were not at all happy about the extension of the British deficiency payments to Irish carcase beef and he described the new arrangement "as a dangerous precedent".

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Donnellan wishes to remain in the House, he must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

It is very hard to listen to that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputies cannot listen they have a remedy.

Comment on this

Surely this is proof that this Agreement must have some advantage for agriculture if the British farmers do not like it.

Comment on this

What is the advantage?

Comment on this

Reference was made to the fact that a hosiery factory in Cork will close down because this Agreement was signed. The Deputy did not give the name of the factory. He mentioned it without referring to anything specific. He talked vaguely about the factory closing down and causing unemployment. The hosiery business is one industry that will benefit 200 per cent from this Agreement. This country has always depended on agriculture and the woollen industry, and anyone who has read economic history knows that the woollen industry has been a major industry in Ireland for the past hundreds of years.

We now have an Agreement, signed by Irishmen, elected by the Irish people—a hell of a difference from the treatment which Irish industry got when this country was governed by Westminster.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Is the Deputy mixing up man-made fibres with woollens?

Comment on this

If the Deputy has any knowledge of the textile industry, he should know.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

A damn sight more than you.

Comment on this

The woollen industry of years ago is the man-made fibre industry of today.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Our textile goods went into England despite the duty on our goods going into that country. We now have free access to the British market.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

I said I would be brief and I will be brief. I should like to add my voice to the voices of Deputies on all sides of the House who appealed for industrial peace.

Comment on this

For the benefit of all Deputies in the House, I should like to remind them that the young Deputy who has just spoken comes from the same constituency as I do, the city of Galway. He talked about bullocks. I do not know where he sees bullocks except at a fair on a fair day. He talked about a hosiery business in Cork, but he avoided what is most important so far as his constituency is concerned—the three factories that have been closed down in our town, and I will name them: Potez, Lydon's woollen mills and the Galway Foundry. I am surprised the Deputy did not touch on the Lydon woollen mills since he is in that business.

Fifty years ago a group of young men went out on the streets of this city to fight for an Irish Republic, to fight for freedom, and to fight for fair play for our citizens. Within a few years we had a Treaty. God bless those who gave us the freedom we have to stand up here tonight, the Collins's and those whom we can hold in great reverence.

During the past few weeks the Taoiseach and his Party accompanied by mass television went over to Britain. We had it for breakfast, dinner and tea; the Taoiseach going up the gangway of the plane, coming down on the other side, going into Downing Street and coming out smiling. The people were saying he went on a mystery tour. They are as wise now as they were when he went. They say it was a joyride. He came back with 95 pages of "yes" and "no". There is a lot of legal jargon which states "whereas", "we may", and "we may not". Not all Deputies may be able to explain all this to the people down the country. I do not blame Fianna Fáil Deputies for having sat down and not had a good word to say. I congratulate Deputy Molloy on having had the courage to stand up, but at the same time he surprised me because he did not refer to the things that are nearest to the bone of his constituency.

In this Agreement we get little or nothing. If we do get a little, we will not oppose the little. Let me remind the House that trotting out the word "treaty", since this is only an Agreement, is just trying to confuse the people. They should not think that the people will swallow that. So far as I can see, the delegation that went not only missed the bus but came back as they went, hat in hand. We are entitled to assess the merits and demerits of this Agreement. I see that we are to export thousands of lbs of butter and pay John Bull £50 a ton to eat it, while on our television we are urged to "eat more margarine". Would it not be more sensible to give a lot of that butter to the old people instead of filling John Bull, the man you hated for so long? Of course Fianna Fáil would not tell the people they would do that. If we had an increase of £10 a head in the price of cattle tomorrow, Fianna Fáil would be claiming that they got it but surely we would only be back to the price we got in the last Agreement.

This is only a continuation of Agreements already entered into. It is the same as we got in 1948 and nothing more. I discussed this Agreement with some businessmen and some industrialists in my town—not that we have a lot of them—and they expressed grave concern over the fact that the big English cartels will be flooding the market here with goods merely for the purpose of pushing out any little industry we have. Once that is the position, we will be John Bull's best customer, John Bull's other island, and we will be officially described as the "British Isles". Already we have cross-Channel supermarkets coming in and as a result small shopkeepers are going out. Now we have the Scottish banks taking over the country. Where is it going to end? It is being said in the country that Fianna Fáil have sold us out, hook, line and sinker. If Fianna Fáil were over here, they would be saying that, if we were in the same position. We have seen the hasps being put on the doors of many houses in my constituency where men and their families have gone to Birmingham or Coventry. Are we going to see the same in relation to the few industries that are left?

In the next few months we are to have the 1916 Commemoration celebrations throughout the country and we are entitled to ask ourselves whether the sacrifices made by these young men at that time were in vain. I am afraid the Party opposite will hang their heads in shame and they should do so because the people are realising that the purpose of this is to try to build up a tottering Party. Throughout this debate, we have had not one mention of Partition and I challenge any Fianna Fáil Deputy to contradict that. Has it become a dirty word among you or are you afraid to mention it? Then you have the cheek to talk about the Treaty. As far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, not only have they betrayed the living but they have also betrayed the dead, but that is all that could be expected from them.

Comment on this

It has never been my form since I came into this House to deal with any question except in an objective way so far as my constituency is concerned. I might be pardoned if I depart from that practice tonight. Deputy Molloy referred to the alteration in the waiting period for store cattle. It is unfortunate that he is a western Deputy because we in the west are, in effect, losing £7 per each beast we export, due to inefficient handling and transport delays. We made a great effort to get a cattle boat from Sligo port to Glasgow and to Birkenhead and the people concerned put down some thousands of pounds but the Government would not give a grant. Due to delays and the time lost through sending cattle through Dublin port, it has been estimated that we lost £7 per beast. As I say, we have made every effort to get facilities and a grant. We were told to form an association and an association was formed which collected sufficient money but then the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries said they could not give a grant.

A colleague and friend of mine on the opposite side referred to an Agreement in 1925 and I felt prompted to ask where were the opposite side in 1925, or what effort were they making then to get this country on to a solid basis? We were trying to build a country from the ashes created by the side who are now Government. The Taoiseach said that we would want to face realities but it is a pity that realities were not faced in 1922. If they had been faced then, we would be in a better position today. The people who went to Britain recently to negotiate this Agreement got the opportunity to do so because of Fine Gael and because Fine Gael alone were responsible for putting them into that position. Apart from the fact that we built up the country from the ruins created by the opposite Party, the next biggest thing the Fine Gael Party did was to make Fianna Fáil a responsible Opposition and later the Government, that is, from the democratic point of view, and the establishment of democracy in this country.

The average farmer in my constituency has from 20 to 30 acres. Every farmer there is wondering what this Agreement will mean for him. The benefits to be derived from it— an Agreement heralded with a fanfare of trumpets—are now being assessed in a logical and mature way. The benefits that first appeared on the surface are now not so evident at all. It would now appear that the Agreement falls short of the essential requirements of the west and north-west in both the agricultural and industrial fields.

As far as we are concerned, the export of store cattle has always been, and always will be, the chief source of revenue of our people, especially the small farmers. Indeed, it is responsible for the main economy of the small farmer there. We are very apprehensive about this Agreement. I do not say it is a bad one, but I would not like to say it is a good one. Personally, I believe our negotiators made the best of a bad bargain, but we are still apprehensive about it.

We are told there is a guarantee for an export of 630,000 store cattle, but in 1957, when the inter-Party Government left office, the export of store cattle was in the region of 700,000. There is no benefit there. To be fair, the 1948 Trade Agreement could be terminated on six months' notice. Under this Agreement the six months' notice has gone. We have a guarantee of numbers, but we have no guarantee of price. I established long ago that we in Sligo have lost about £1 million per year because of disagreement over the provision of drainage and the failure of the Government to recognise our difficulties. I estimate we are going to lose a further £140,000 because they will not give us a grant for a boat for the export of cattle from Sligo.

We in the north-west are apprehensive about the carcase beef trade. We have always exported our store cattle to England on hoof. We do not see any future in the north-west for carcase beef. Processing of carcase beef may provide increased employment, but there will be loss of other employment to offset that. The cattle industry is the only industry that can stand on its own feet without subsidy. It has done so all down the years in the west and north-west. It is an industry which should be carefully nurtured and not interfered with. Store cattle from the west can compete with the produce of any other country in the world on the British market if left alone.

I shall not refer to butter because that has been already dealt with. If we have an increased tonnage of butter for export, it is the Irish taxpayer who will have to pay for it.

I should like to refer briefly to industry, in respect of which the provisions of the Agreement would require detailed study before I could pronounce judgement on them. However, it is clear that the reduction of protection will involve for our industry the loss of the home market to foreign competitors. I see no additional opportunities for industry in the north-west. In fact, in recent years, ever since the Undeveloped Areas Act was enacted, we have lost three of our main industries, with consequent unemployment of about 1,000 workers. Some of those people, especially in Sligo town, married, set up homes and had families. They thought they had secure employment, but they found themselves out of work overnight. There was no chance of retraining them as we are proposing today.

The industries in my constituency will hardly measure up to the standard required without protection. I hope what I am saying is not true and that they will measure up. A couple of years ago, when the differential in the grant between the undeveloped areas and the rest of the country was removed, I forecast it spelled doom for industry in the west. I am still of that opinion. I am of the opinion now that this Agreement is going to finish any possible development of industry in the west.

I am not a doleful Willy, crying about the west of Ireland, but I can see what is happening and it would be only right for me, as a Deputy, to point it out. I hope our industries will be able to measure up to competition but I fear for them. I think this Agreement will have very serious consequences for us. I have heard and listened too often to prophecies from the present Government. I have heard them project images all over the country, especially in respect of the west of Ireland, but they were all pious platitudes. Nothing came as a result of them. Actually, when they came up to the edge of reality, so far as I know, the images broke down every time and it is no wonder, therefore, that I or any Deputy from the west of Ireland must be at least sceptical about this Trade Agreement. I hope it will be a success. I believe our negotiators did the best they could. I shall not criticise but I think the Agreement has fallen a bit short of what we should like to see in the west of Ireland and, in so saying, I sincerely hope that time will tell that I am wrong. However, I must say I cannot see it doing any good for agriculture in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

In the course of his remarks, Deputy Kitt commented on the fact that this debate has gone on for four days, much longer than any previous debate in this House. If the debate had not continued for the past four days the people of the country would know very little about the Agreement because, as far as I know, this Treaty was born in secrecy. The most remarkable thing about it—when the talks were first initiated by our officials and, lastly, by the Taoiseach, the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture —was the curtain of secrecy that enveloped the whole operation. In the Sunday Times of 12th December, 1965, there is this comment:

The most remarkable thing about the Treaty to date is the secrecy which has surrounded the talks. Few people in Britain are expecting it, and few people in Ireland know what to expect of it. The cordon surrounding officials has produced strange plot theories on both sides, amounting, in the end, to much the same suspicion; that birthright is being wilfully sold.

The pattern emerging from the negotiations is a straight interest-swap: Irish agriculture for British industry. It is, however, somewhat difficult to understand how the Irish farmer, whose products already have free entry into Britain, could benefit from a free trade area. The anomaly stems from the 1938 trade Treaty in which the Irish had their cake and ate it: agricultural products had free entry into Britain, but sections of Irish industry remained protected.

We want to analyse this Treaty and to clarify the situation to see if the birthright of Irish industry and Irish agriculture is being sold or has been sold. We can do absolutely nothing at all about it now because this Treaty has been signed, sealed and delivered by the Fianna Fáil Government. Now, if benefits accrue from this, they will reflect benefit on the Fianna Fáil Government for having implemented this Treaty. But, if benefits do not accrue from it, they will say that the people in Ireland were a party to it. I do not think that anybody is a party to this Treaty, for good or ill, except the Fianna Fáil Government.

Nobody will know, until ten years' hence, whether this sell-out of Irish industry which has been mentioned will or will not happen but in my opinion it is a sell-out of Irish industry on the 10-years' instalment plan and henceforward, every year that passes from 1965 to 1975, we shall lose through industry. Unemployment will mount. Today, on the front page of the Irish Independent, we read the headline: “2,000 More to get the Sack” and the dismissal of these people will affect 100,000 more. If we start off on the very first day with 2,000 sacked, what will the rate be in ten years' time? Nobody will know that until the ten years have passed but in my opinion we are in for a state of chaos in employment.

If the debate had not lasted for these four days, the people of the country would not know the full position. Each section of the Agreement has been examined. Every clause and section has been gone into and that will all be published in every paper and the people will know what is in the Agreement. I do not think we were wrong to have this debate for as long as four days. Everything has been clarified but nobody knows now what the result will ultimately be. Usually, when Fianna Fáil negotiate treaties, they make a hue and cry, a song and dance about the benefits. As far as can be realised, this Treaty, for agriculture, is just a re-writing of the 1948 Anglo-Irish Trade Agreement. England wanted our store cattle and now they have got a definite number. What will be the result if the price of cattle should rise on the international markets? First of all, we must supply the quota to Britain. If we have not that quota, we must get it and, until it is filled we cannot benefit from possible increased prices in other markets.

Coming, as I do, from Castlebar where there is an old-established industry, the bacon factory, I would point out that this Treaty does not benefit that industry in any way more than it benefited under the 1948 Agreement. The Minister for Agriculture made a great song and dance about the bacon quota which is now fixed at 28,000 tons. The position already was that in 1948 the Government of the United Kingdom undertook to import bacon from Ireland at an annual pre-war rate of 27,000 tons, or more. The Minister for Agriculture takes it upon himself to shout about 1,000 extra tons. If he had gone to the trouble of looking at the 1948 Agreement he would notice that the Government of the United Kingdom undertook to import bacon from Ireland at the annual pre-war quota of 27,000 tons, or more if it was available. Without this Agreement at all, we could export more than 27,000 tons of bacon to Britain if we had it available. I do not think it will ever be available.

We can ask ourselves, also, whether or how this Treaty will benefit the small landholders in the west of Ireland. I do not think it will benefit them at all. As a matter of fact, on 3rd January of this year, a new introductory unemployment assistance payment was brought in for the smallholders in Mayo, Sligo, Donegal and all the rest of the counties along the western seaboard. Remarkably and significantly enough, the numbers of those people who now draw the dole will not be in the statistics of unemployed. How would they be described? Are they unemployed? Are they only getting this help from the Government so that they will exist? That is an indication that the small farmers of the west will have no employment and that those small industries now in some of the western counties will go by the board.

The Minister for Agriculture stated there would be an increase of from £6 to £10 per head in the price of store cattle. It is easy to increase prices now because the prices of cattle have dropped to such an extent that most farmers who had store cattle were ruined over the last summer. From what period or from what price will this increase be based? Will it be the price of last July, when the prices of cattle were high, or will it be an increase of £10 on the present reduced price? It is very ambiguous and if the people who rear store cattle do not get an increased price on last July's figure, then they will go to the wall, too. Remember, money is not available now. Those unfortunate people who have bought grazing land have gone to the bank for the money to purchase cattle and they will go to the wall, too, if something positive is not done.

The benefits in this treaty have been exaggerated by the Fianna Fáil speakers. There can be no doubt about that. Our industrial products will have free access to the 60 million people in the British market but their products will come in here to swamp our three million. Nobody can suggest that the Irish industrialist will be able to cope with an industrial giant like England. What is the picture? What will happen industry here? One or two old established industries will survive and the rest will go to the wall. The picture we now have of unemployment here will be much greater in the succeeding years. Let me say, before I conclude, that this Agreement shows that the Government have forsaken every principle they had. We have mentioned this before. When they came before the people in the Thirties, they mentioned the usual slogan, that they could do without the English market. Now they have completely reversed their principles and say that this is the best Agreement ever signed by an Irish Government.

Comment on this

By a Republican Party.

Comment on this

That is a forsaking of all their ideals. They have completely let down their supporters. They have completely let down their former leader who now has a position superior to none in this country of ours. Nobody will know how this Agreement will go but we can have our opinions and, from the opinions expressed here today and over the past three days by speakers on the Government side, it will be a wonderful test and interesting to see are they exaggerated, are they false or will this Agreement prove to be beneficial to the country.

Comment on this

There has been some applause but the points to which I have listened are a lot of tripe. The previous speaker talked about the price of cattle being low. Cattle prices are as good as they were three months ago——

Comment on this

Six months ago. Is it not a seasonal increase? I bought more cattle than you have ever seen.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would remind Deputy Harte that I will have to ask him to leave unless he cease interrupting.

Comment on this

There has been a lot of talk that this Agreement is no good, that it is not a good one for the farmers. Only last Monday I was at a mart selling cattle and there were some Fine Gael people there, all smiles and saying this is a good thing at last.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That was last Monday.

Comment on this

It is wrong for any young man to stand up here and go back to 1932 and indeed before that. When you founded the State, it was a sad situation that the only people well off in the country were the old age pensioners, and you had to take a shilling from them. I will go back as far as you want to go back—they were the rich people, the old age pensioners. You said that would put the country right.

Comment on this

What about all the lads you executed?

Comment on this

We heard a lot about the slaughter of calves. To my mind the 77 executed were a greater loss than all the calves ever slaughtered. If you want it now, you can have it. We say some of the replacements over there are a far cry from their predecessors, and they were the worst offenders in this House during this debate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies might allow Deputy Fanning to make his speech.

Comment on this

We have heard a lot of talk here about the dairy farmers. If there is a relief, it is a relief for the store cattle trade and, as far as I know, every cow which calves will be a store beast in two years' time. Will that be a help? Here we have an official cry from Fine Gael. I admire Labour because they will vote against it but they do not seem to have much faith in the industrial workers. To my mind, the workers are good but industries will have to improve and it is about time they did. It is about time protection was called off.

Comment on this

That is a change.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that our workers are as good as anybody and produce as good an article as anybody. We in the farming community have had to improve in the past five or six years. We had to improve on the qualities of our milking machines to produce good, clean milk so that the product going on the market would be first-class. I remember as a young fellow at the fair in Thurles during the Second World War, when a second election was called and I heard farmers there saying: "We will still vote Fianna Fáil."

Comment on this

They are the type of people who support you.

Comment on this

They will want IRA pensions.

Comment on this

Now the Government speakers are wrapping the Union Jack around them.

Comment on this

People of the Deputy's name were more associated with these things——

Comment on this

Nobody belonging to me was ever associated with them.

Comment on this
Liam Cunningham Acting Chairman (Mr. Cunningham) Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy confine himself to the Trade Agreement?

Comment on this

Instead of the fair at Thurles.

Comment on this

It is very hard to do so when for the past four days speakers did not confine themselves to it. As far as I see it, the big worry Fine Gael have is that if we produced, we could not sell. Now we can produce as much as we like because we have a market for it.

Comment on this

We always had it.

Comment on this

I have heard the question asked: "Why did we not look for markets elsewhere," but the former leader of Fine Gael at one time, when the Germans and Belgians came over to buy our cattle when we could not sell them in Britain, said we had fly-by-nights coming over.

Comment on this

That was at the time of the Broy Harriers.

Comment on this

I suppose any man is entitled to make a mistake or a wrong statement——

Comment on this

But he should be man enough to admit it.

Comment on this

Have we not admitted it? I heard a Deputy on the opposite side speaking about the egg industry and saying it was lost, but if you could carry this country on the sale of eggs, it would be a poor day. It could not be done. He also criticised us on the ground that there was no price for agricultural produce but I remember when Fianna Fáil came in in 1932 we were hawking samples of barley and offering it at 10/- a barrel and could not get a buyer. Who made the change?—Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Now you have gone back to where we were.

Comment on this

We advocated the growing of wheat and beet and Deputy Dillon said he would not be found dead in a field of wheat or beet.

Comment on this

I would support that yet.

Comment on this

Would you?

Comment on this

Would you say we should grow wheat?

Comment on this

Would the Acting Chairman ask Deputy Harte to restrain himself?

Comment on this

The Opposition now say this Agreement is a bad one, that it is the same as the 1948 Agreement. If this is a bad one, then so was the 1948 Agreement. They must decide one way or another; they cannot be on both sides of the fence.

Comment on this

After four days of debate, I do not want to delay the House but certain points have arisen regarding this Trade Agreement on which I should like a little information when the Taoiseach is replying. In particular, in regard to housing grants, we have a clause about the use of Irish materials——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am afraid this does not arise. These are matters which would be relevant to the debate on the Estimate for Local Government. We cannot go into such details on this occasion.

Comment on this

If the Chair will pardon me, will this Agreement not be contravened where people at present getting grants are encouraged to use Irish material for building and reconstruction of houses? I should like to know how this condition will operate in the Free Trade Area?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

There is nothing in this Agreement for or against——

Comment on this

There is something in the Agreement.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

A detailed discussion on that matter is out of order.

Comment on this

The Deputy can ask the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

So long as I get an answer, I do not mind. Taking Irish goods in general, will manufacturers of these goods who are supplying materials for building purposes not be affected by the Trade Agreement? In that case will this clause have to be withdrawn? Article IV of the Agreement on page 67 says:

Neither party shall—

(a) apply directly or indirectly to imported goods any fiscal charges in excess of those applied directly or indirectly to like domestic goods, or otherwise apply such charges so as to afford effective protection to like domestic goods;

I should like clarification on that point. No matter what we say here and no matter what has been said in the past four days, this Agreement has been signed on behalf of the Irish people and I want to add my voice to the voices of others who have spoken. When the Taoiseach was asked by the leader of our Party to recall the House to discuss the Agreement, he refused to do so and we were left completely in the dark practically until the Agreement was signed. This Agreement may affect the livelihood of many of our people, and especially our industrial workers in the future.

I am not yet convinced, and I have as high a regard for Irish industry as anybody, that there are not industries which, when the tariffs are completely withdrawn and they come up against the highly organised competition of British industries will—I fear I would not be truthful if I did not say this— certainly go by the board. For years it has been the policy of the Government to protect these industries but I do not believe that even some of those that have got protection will stand up to the competition of the giant industrial concerns of Britain. Regardless of what may happen I hope our people will give preference to Irish goods, no matter what the Agreement holds, in the interests of our own economy.

Take, for instance, the motor assembly industry. What will become of the numbers who will be thrown out of employment? I know I will be told that they will have to be looked after, that we have a manpower policy. It was rather late in the day for a Government of a Party that had ruled this country in practically unbroken succession since 1932 to decide to do something about a manpower policy within the year preceding the signing of the Agreement with Great Britain. I hope that even at this late stage the Parliamentary Secretary will be successful in regard to this project. Having regard to the limitation of the period and what has happened within that 12 months, I would not wish to have the task that he has on his hands.

Article XI of the Agreement deals with dumped and subsidised imports. I wonder if there is sufficient protection in that Article to safeguard Irish manufacturers against imported goods being dumped on this market. If some big industrialist should take the opportunity of dumping inferior goods on the Irish market, by the time the proper authorities here had got notice, by the time the Department and the Ministers became aware of the fact, the damage would be done and hundreds of people might be put out of employment. I should like to be assured that there is sufficient safeguard in the Article. Personally, I do not believe that the Article provides a complete safeguard and I am of the opinion that dumping may occur and it will be too late to take action when the damage has been done.

The Government have handed over an open market here to British industrialists and the British market is open to us. I hope and trust that we here will be able to compete in that market.

A great deal has been said in this debate about the farming community. Irrespective of what we have heard in this House from the Minister for Agriculture as to the increases that farmers will get for cattle as a result of this Agreement, I am not convinced. One would gather from the speech we heard that every farmer will be disappointed if he is not a millionaire by the end of 1966. The farmers have not got free access to the British market whereas the British industrialists have free access to the Irish market. That is one instance in regard to which the Agreement is unbalanced.

Irish agriculture has not had the advantage that British farmers have had. There is a quota for cattle, carcase meat and dressed beef. Therefore, irrespective of what the Minister for Agriculture may have said in this House, I am still not convinced that the Irish farmers are getting the great deal from this Agreement that the Fianna Fáil Party are telling the country and the House that they are getting. I hope I am wrong. I hope the farmers will benefit by the Agreement.

I could go on but I do not want to delay the House. In conclusion, I want to say that I should like to be convinced that Irish industrialists are safeguarded against dumping. I should like also to be convinced that the farmers are getting the deal that we have been given to understand by the Minister for Agriculture they are getting.

While being critical of certain parts of the Agreement, I feel that the Taoiseach and his Ministers tried to do the best they could. I find it very difficult to resume my seat without reminding the Party opposite—and I do not like going back on what they have been reminded of already—that in days gone by they thanked God that the British market was gone and gone forever. We have the British market and are glad to have it now. One cannot live without one's neighbours. At the same time I hope that our Buy Irish campaign will be successful and that the people of this country will, first and last, give preference to goods manufactured here.

Comment on this
Thomas Dunne Mr. T. Dunne Fine Gael

I do not propose to detain the House very long. In my view we have not gained anything in this Trade Agreement which will benefit agriculture. This Trade Agreement contains nothing that was not already incorporated in the 1948 Agreement. Take, for instance, butter. In the 1948 Agreement this country was allocated a quota of 20,000 tons of butter per year, or more if it was available. Under this Agreement, the allocation is 23,000 tons, subject to review.

A great deal has been said about the great British market for store cattle and that prices are already rising. I should like to remind the House that this Agreement does not come into effect until July, 1966 and that there is at the moment a seasonal increase in the price of cattle which is only natural at this time of the year.

I am glad to see that Fianna Fáil have now changed their mind about the British market. It is not so many years ago that they thanked God that the British market was gone and gone forever.

The Irish market has been thrown open to British industrialists who will certainly avail of the opportunities thus presented to them. I find it hard to believe that many of our industries will survive. I would be fearful about factories such as Erin Foods in my constituency. In today's Irish Independent there is a report the heading to which is “Enquiry into shoe factory dismissals,” which states that 43 women and 16 men are under dismissal notices since before Christmas and that the decision to dismiss them is linked with the Free Trade Agreement and a recent statement of a reduction in the factory output. That is an instance of an industry already affected. How many industries will be affected after July 1966?

I was glad to hear Deputy Fanning stating that the people of this country returned Fianna Fáil to government even during the economic war, even when the price of cattle was bad, but I should like to remind Deputy Fanning that it was not because of the price of cattle but because of the free beef which was obtained from the calves whose throats were cut.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Tully, concluding on the Labour amendment.

Comment on this

Sir, this debate has gone on now for four days. The first or second day it appeared as if certain members of this House, particularly members of the present Government, were very anxious that the debate should finish on the second day and an ultimatum was issued that, if we were not prepared to agree to conclude the debate at a reasonable time on Wednesday evening, it would be adjourned until after the 25th of the month, not to the 25th, when the Dáil would re-assemble. We made it very clear that we wanted to have the debate fully concluded even if that meant carrying it over until after the 25th. Eventually the Taoiseach, I think with the idea in his mind that the offer would not be accepted, said he would be prepared to agree that we should do something unprecedented almost in this House, namely, sit on a Church Holiday and, if necessary, sit again today. I am very glad that not only did we sit yesterday, even if it was a Church Holiday, but that we also sat today and used all the time available.

The debate on the so-called Free Trade Agreement has done more, I think, to show the people what, in fact, the Fianna Fáil Government bought for them in London before Christmas better than anything else could do. Certainly, in the years to come, they may be called a lot of things but no one will ever accuse them of being Santa Claus.

We, in the Labour Party, put down a motion expressing dissatisfaction with the bargain. We also expressed our intention of voting against the Agreement. We did this because we believe that the debate on this Agreement is almost as important as the debate which ended on this night 44 years ago. I believe, and my Party believe, that it is necessary not only to express in this House our opinion that the Agreement is a bad one but also necessary to express, by way of vote, our disapproval as a Party of the Agreement.

Frankly, I am amazed at the attitude of Fine Gael. I want to make it very clear that Fine Gael are perfectly entitled to make their own decision, as they did, on this matter. In passing, I should like to point out that it has become the habit of certain people, including both members of the Government and members of the Press, to refer to the leader of Fine Gael as the Leader of the Opposition. There are two Opposition Parties in the House, Fine Gael and Labour. Deputy Brendan Corish is the leader of the Labour Party. In view of the fact that the Labour Party are the Party challenging this Agreement I claim that, in this debate, Deputy Brendan Corish is the Leader of the Opposition and I should be very grateful if those referring to this matter in future would remember that calling the——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The point the Deputy is discussing now is not in order. A dispute as to who is Leader of the Opposition should not enter into a discussion on the Free Trade Agreement.

Comment on this

I do not wish to challenge your ruling, but I should like to point out that I am replying for my Party to the debate which has taken place here over the last four days and I consider it a little harsh of the Chair to start picking on points before I have made the actual point I want to make.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy has talked for some minutes about this and the Chair is pointing out that he is not in order.

Comment on this

The position is that we, as an independent Party of which Deputy Corish is the leader, are challenging the Government on this decision. During the earlier part of the debate I was amazed to find certain ulterior motives given by Deputy Ryan as to the reason why we had taken this particular decision. I want to make it quite clear to everyone that we are voting against this Agreement for one reason, and one reason only, and that is because we think the Agreement is a bad one. When we talk about this Agreement vis-à-vis previous Agreements people tend to try to argue that, if this Agreement is a bad one, then the 1948 Agreement was also a bad one. At least one member of the Fianna Fáil Party made that point tonight. I should like to point out that this Agreement, as far as we can read it, simply repeats, as far as agriculture is concerned, almost the entire 1948 Agreement; but, in addition, it gives away under the heading of “Industry” quite a substantial amount which continued to be protected under the 1948 Agreement.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

That is, I think, a very important difference and anybody who tries to compare and argue that, because we consider this Agreement a bad one then the earlier Agreement was also a bad one, just does not know what he is talking about. The extraordinary feature of the earlier part of the debate here was the number of people prepared to give free advice on the economic state of the country and who tried to infer, in particular, that the economic state of the country now and inside the next few months was not and would not be as a result of this Agreement but because the trade unions and trade unionists were not pulling their weight. Anybody who suggests that has a colossal cheek. They are suggesting, in fact, that all the employers in the country are fair, reasonable people, who never make a mistake or never do anything wrong. I would be the first to admit that the trade unions and trade unionists have made mistakes from time to time. We must remember, however, that if a row takes place, and if we have people unemployed and out of work, and if we have, as a Minister said yesterday, the danger of industries closing down, it is not because trade unions and trade unionists are unreasonable; it is simply because there must be a damn good reason why the row has been kicked up.

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Seán Flanagan, repeated something the Taoiseach said in his TV appearance the Thursday before Christmas. He said that certain industries would, of course, close down. He was quite honest about it. But he went much further than the Taoiseach because he went on to say that, if they were closed down, that was something we just could not avoid; if they were to be closed down then they were going to close down and, after all, he and the Government would eventually get round to a manpower policy and the people affected would be retrained. For what? Where is the alternative industry being provided? By what stretch of the imagination does the Parliamentary Secretary think that we can, at the present time, set up in this country further industries which will immediately absorb the unfortunate people who will lose their jobs because of the fact that we have now got what the Government choose to call a Free Trade Agreement with Britain?

I should like to make this final point in regard to that particular aspect. Deputy Flanagan, fortunately for himself, never had the necessity to go to his employers at six o'clock in the evening and receive his card telling him his job had terminated. If he were a person with five or six or maybe more children and a wife to support and got his card with no prospect of further employment, he would then know what it meant to find himself out of a job whether it was the Government or the employer who had blundered.

We know, of course, that the Parliamentary Secretary has great plans for setting up industries. He said that people may have to move from place to place, that they should have no objection to that. It reminded me of a few weeks ago out in Brussels when a spokesman for the EEC pointed out to a delegation from this country that, of course, there was no unemployment in the EEC because a person, say from Berlin, who would be out of a job could get a job in Brussels, Paris or somewhere else. The Parliamentary Secretary's approach was exactly the same: "What have these fellows to complain about? After all, there may be a job one hundred miles away." The fact that these people have built a home for themselves, are trying to pay for it, and are up to their necks in debt trying to keep their home together, did not seem to enter into Deputy Flanagan's mind. There was a job somewhere else for them. Like the snail they can get into their box and move off. It is about time the people who are taking on the responsibility of looking after the manpower of this country who will become redundant realised, first and foremost, that these people are human beings, that they have dignity, that they have rights and that they are entitled to be treated as human beings.

The one thing that really surprised me about this whole Agreement is the number of extraordinary statements made by Government spokesmen. First of all, there was the statement made by the Taoiseach—he did explain it afterwards and maybe it is unfair to quote it here—that for every one factory that closed five more would spring up. I think he explained afterwards that he was just joking. He must have been joking. However, the Minister for Justice today said it would be two for every one. Subsequently when he was challenged and told the Taoiseach had mentioned five, he said: "Yes, five for every one." Whom do they think they are codding? Do they imagine the ordinary people, who are aware of the desperate efforts that have been made over the years to keep industry going against foreign competition, even with the protection of tariffs, will be able to survive and that new factories will be able to start and survive on what will soon be a completely free trade basis? The one thing the people are entitled to in these circumstances is honesty. They should be told the truth. It is most unfair that they should try to describe through rose-coloured glasses what is going to happen.

The Minister for Agriculture, I understand, was originally talking about an increase of £35 million in agricultural income for the next year, He toned that down a bit. He is now down to only £10 million, and maybe with a little bit of encouragement he will start going up again. The Taoiseach, when he was opening this debate, paid tribute to the Ministers who were with him in London and said the Minister for Agriculture had fought tenaciously. I have no doubt at all the Minister for Agriculture did, but he did not get very much for his fight in this case because it appears that what he has got is almost a replica of what was in the 1948 Agreement with this exception which the Fianna Fáil Government are claiming as being something wonderful, that after a hard battle they won from the British Government the right to put 638,000 store cattle into Britain every year which is, in fact, a promise from this Government and from this country that they would not go under 638,000.

Again, are we supposed to be fools and are we supposed to accept this thing and not be able to read into it that instead of getting a concession, as the Government say, we are giving the solemn guarantee that no matter who is prepared to pay a higher price for our store cattle we will not sell them? We must give them to England. I would be the first to admit that the British market has been of invaluable assistance to this country down through the years. Whether we have quarrelled with Britain or not, no matter what way we look at it, Britain has been our best customer. We have not been a bad customer for her either. Despite the fact that we had a tariff barrier, she sent a substantial quantity of goods in here. Go around anywhere there is a supermarket, particularly the British-based ones, and you will find that wherever possible they will plug the British article. What will happen now? Will we not find that these stores and many others like them will be absolutely swamped with British-produced goods? Do not let anybody tell us we are still going to be patriotic, that we are still going to wrap the green flag around us and everything will be all right. That was not true of Government Departments, one of which sent across to Scotland at the height of the Buy Irish campaign and brought back materials to this country to the detriment of Irish workers. I will say this for the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, that when it was brought to his notice very forcibly in this House, he changed the situation and bought Irish-made materials which his predecessor had been importing for over 12 months from a British manufacturer. There are a number of other Departments that could be quoted in this connection. There was the extraordinary situation, of which Deputy Ryan had to complain, that Galway County Council had bought concrete lamp posts in England, despite the fact that it is laid down in the regulations that a preference must be given by local authorities to Irish materials. The Minister for Local Government said that the material produced here was not the right type, that they were getting a better type in England.

Under this Agreement—and if anybody wishes I can quote chapter and verse—arrangements are made that in future, from a certain date there will be no right for local authorities or any other such people to give preference to Irish manufacturers. It will be a crime against the Agreement if they do. They can be hauled up and asked why they did it. Is that not a nice state of affairs in an underdeveloped economy such as this? We have seen the disgraceful situation that despite the fact that we are not able to have full employment, have never gone near it and in the last couple of months have had a steadily climbing unemployment figure— there was a figure of 67,000 in one week—we are told that they are going to take away the little protection we had. Even if it only gave employment to a couple of hundred people, at least it kept that number of people at home.

It is not fair to say that our Ministers went to Britain deliberately to sell out the Irish nation. I do not think they did. I am quite positive that according to their lights they did the best they could but they were just not good enough. The British Government had too many heavy guns for them and the result is the puny effort we have before us now which offers us the bare scrapings as far as agriculture is concerned and under which we lose everything in industry.

Some Deputies have said that Irish industries cannot survive the terms of this Agreement and others, including Deputy Corry who could survive anything, that they will. I do not believe that industries which have been in operation for some time and have been exporting and have not had to get an injection of capital from the Government in the past couple of years will be too badly affected. As a matter of fact, it is my opinion that many of them will hold their own. But industries that have been operating behind the tariff wall and those that have been getting subsidies, whether they were tariff protected or whether the subsidy was direct, cannot survive under conditions of free trade for industrial goods between this country and Britain.

My opinion in that respect is based on two reasons. One is that at the present time such industries are getting it hard enough to exist. Secondly, when the great British manufacturers who have been so long established in industry get their sights on what to them might be considered a small target of three million people, they will be able to outsell our industries on their own doorstep. Do not let us believe that dumping will not be permitted in accordance with the terms of this Agreement. Article VI of the GATT Agreement defines dumping and says that the products of one country introduced into the commerce of another country at less than their normal value and which constitute a threat to the industry of the receiving country can be stopped or slowed up by putting on a tariff.

In our case this cannot be done until we have reached a situation in which there is serious loss of employment, the danger of a closedown and this, of course, cannot happen until quite a substantial amount of this type of goods has, in fact, got into the country and, by the time the Government get around to discussing the situation with the Government of Britain, I feel sure the same thing will have happened as happened some years ago in the case of a certain garment when a firm, supporters of the Government, were allowed to buy up a considerable quantity of the commodity and then a tariff was put on to stop more of the material coming in.

That situation can happen all over the country because of the fact that the arrangement under the Agreement is so long and so detailed it will be impossible to stop the situation occurring until it has gone too far and harm has been done. The result will be that thousands of workers may be out of their jobs before those steps can be taken. The loss of employment which can thus be caused to a small country like this is most serious under a number of headings. First of all, the person who loses a job will be entitled to unemployment benefit for six months. That will fall directly on the State. The loss of his stamps for that period will fall on the State. The loss of the income tax which so many workers are contributing so unfairly under PAYE will fall on the State.

No matter how one looks at it, if there is substantial unemployment, more than there is at the moment, it will leave the Department of Social Welfare and the Department of Finance in a perilous state. Before putting their signature to this Agreement, therefore, the Government should have considered all those factors. It appears to me amazing that sensible men such as they are, particularly the Taoiseach, who was the architect or the chief mover in giving protection to industries, should take this step which now, according to the Government and Fine Gael, cannot be backed down from.

The cost to the State of what will happen as a result of this Agreement is something which everyone of us will have to worry about. That is why the Labour Party have put down the amendment. I do not agree that because the Agreement has been signed it is the end of the world. We in the Labour Party do not agree that if it were defeated in the House it would mean the end of the world. The change does not take place before 1st July next. To my mind, it would be a good thing if the Government were shown here tonight that the people of the country did not want what they signed for, that they want the Government to go back and have another go or, alternatively, have somebody else replace the Government who would go and try to make a better bargain.

What surprises me most of all is the phrase which allows the subsidies on carcase meat. It allows the Irish Government to spend that money only after consultation with the British Government. I think it is scandalous to include any such condition in any Agreement between this country and Britain. I can see no reason why a country with autonomy, including fiscal autonomy, would allow another nation to say how money given in that way should be spent in the way the other country said it should be spent. Somebody mentioned Marshall Aid. Marshall Aid was a handout and this, on the other hand, is something we are earning. It is something we hope to get in respect of stock we shall supply to the British market and it appears to me as if the Government have taken leave of their senses to allow the British Government to say how this money would be spent. It might be that the Government here would not apply it in the ways which the people of this country would like. The Government can say: "Do not blame us. The British Government would not let us do it". It is just too bad it should be allowed.

While on that point I should like to deal with the question of the reduction from three to two months in the waiting period in respect of store cattle. Here we do not seem to have got the right end of the stick. This may have a slight effect on the price of store cattle. It may be true that because they will be held here for one month longer, we should be entitled to a higher price, but as Deputy Dillon said, it is quite true that in view of the low price operating for store cattle for some time the price must go up. When the time was increased from two months to three months, I honestly believe the effect was slight. I believe the effect of the change back to two months again will be very slight.

There is another thing that surprises me. It often makes me wonder when I think that the price of cattle on the British market decides whether our balance of payments is on one side or the other. Is it not extraordinary that with all our talk we are still depending on that one item and that the balance of payments, which this year has turned out to be so adverse, is mainly because of the price of store cattle on the British market? Is this, then, a means to get a few bob extra or are we about to sell down the river practically all our industries for the purpose of getting a few shillings extra on store cattle to try to help our balance of payments?

We have heard a lot about this being a preparation for membership of the EEC. The Taoiseach stated that this idea was in his mind since 1963. In fact, the discussions were going on since November, 1964. Despite the fact that he did not remember it in the by-elections or the general election and not one mention of it was made to anybody or any Deputy in this House, I am convinced the main reason why there was indecent haste to have this Agreement signed was that the Taoiseach realised the people of this country were getting sick to the teeth of him, his Government and their credit squeeze.

I spoke to a number of farmers in my constituency. A substantial number of my supporters are members of the farming community. Their first comment, when the Free Trade Agreement was mentioned was: "Would there be any possibility of having some arrangement made whereby we could get a few pounds with which to carry on? We have not got the money now. We cannot get it from the bank or the Agricultural Credit Corporation. We are living from hand to mouth." Would it not be a good idea if an effort were made to try to put some money into their pockets? Do not let anybody get the idea, if there are a few shillings to be got for store cattle, that that will mean a lot more for the majority of the farmers in this country.

Mind you, the farmers of this country were not reared on £10, £15 or £20. It appears some members of the Government think that if they are able to put something like that into their hands they will go cheering and shouting around the place. They will not. Because of the hard work and the difficulty of making ends meet they want something more than that. I cannot understand why an attempt was not made to get some kind of deficiency payment from the British Government on butter and bacon. That is the way money could have been put into the pockets of the small farmers. Let nobody tell me that the British Government do not pay deficiency payments. Of course, they do not but they subsidise every step of the way. The result is that the British farmers are much better off as a result of the subsidies they get.

It would not have been amiss for our negotiators to ask for some money on our bacon and butter exports. It rankles when you get people in this country, as Deputy Everett said, who as a result of advertising, do not know the difference between butter and margarine. Of course, they do not because they never eat butter. They never had the price of a pound of butter. Would it not be a better idea if something could be done to help the small farmers? Would it not be something to tell those people who have to struggle on with their bread and spread that we were not wrapping up our butter in postal orders and sending it across to Britain?

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said that this was an exercise for preparation for entry into the EEC. He said the EEC membership was coming at any rate. I cannot understand that. The EEC have no application before them from this country nor have they for some time. The EEC have made it plain that they would not consider an application for membership, or association, from this or any other country in Europe at the present time. They allowed Greece in. Austria are having quite a lot of trouble because they are not getting the concessions they were looking for. No other country will be considered as far as membership is concerned. The EEC have made that quite plain. If they have not made it plain to the Taoiseach they have made it plain to members of this House, who were in Brussels, that Ireland on her own would not be welcome. I know the Taoiseach has been shouting around Europe that we were prepared to go it alone. Mind you, that tune has changed.

Now we are trying to get close enough to Britain so that if Britain is finally accepted we will ride on her piggy-back into the EEC. That is the only way we can get in. I cannot understand why the Taoiseach insists that Britain is on the point of going into the Common Market and that as a result Ireland will go in. That is not correct because there are so many eventualities. First of all, General de Gaulle must be satisfied. General de Gaulle is no fool and I consider he is perfectly right in his stand. First, France is not prepared to supply cheap agricultural produce to the Common Market countries and, secondly, General de Gaulle does not believe, as do some people in this country, that we should hand over our nationalism, that we should forget all about it and anything else, except the fact that we are Europeans. If General de Gaulle allows Britain in, there is no guarantee that they will be satisfied with the conditions offered to them.

We are dismantling our protection and preparing to remove all tariffs in the hope that Britain will get into the Common Market and that we will get a piggy-back ride in with her. Deputy Corry commented on a previous Trade Agreement. He tried to suggest that Deputy Dillon knew nothing about it. He blamed the late Deputy Norton for certain things that happened. God bless Deputy Norton, he was an excellent member of this House and he did a great deal of good. Deputy Corry seems to think, when he is dead, it is good enough to have a dig at him. I would not mind if there was any foundation for this. If Deputy Corry took the trouble of looking up that Agreement he would find, on page 217, paragraph 29 of the Agreement that the reference in it is still carried forward in the present Agreement. Therefore, it appears as if Deputy Corry wanted to have a go at somebody who was not here to answer him. Unfortunately, Deputy Corry is not here tonight. I have no doubt that he had important things to do in Cork.

Comment on this

He is never here when something unpleasant is said about him.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He is in some hole or catacomb.

Comment on this

His absence is welcome in any circumstances.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He will be here when the bell rings.

Comment on this

He is a great old warrior all the same.

Comment on this

I would not condemn everything Deputy Corry says but when he makes a charge against a colleague of mine who is no longer with us, I feel, when I know the circumstances, I should not let the opportunity pass without giving the full facts. I should like the Taoiseach, when he is replying, to comment on this, if he has time.

Comment on this

It will be "if."

Comment on this

I am very glad that is the situation. Is it correct that there can be an objection by the British Government if we assist foreigners in this country to start industries? If that is so, can the same objection be made if Northern Ireland or the Six Counties assist the same foreigners or similar foreigners to start industries?

Comment on this

That is utter nonsense. There is nothing about that in the Agreement.

Comment on this

I should be very glad if that went on the record of the House. I am quite sure the Taoiseach knows what he is talking about but, just in case he does not, I should be very glad to have it on record. I was surprised by the fact that there is a guarantee in this Agreement with regard to the right of the British Government to export to this country certain products which we should be able to produce ourselves. After all, if our industries were being dismantled there was no reason why we should not make an effort to try to hold on to something with which we should be able, and could be able to compete. I refer particularly to fish imports. The facilities are being left there and they will be entitled to send to this country the same amount as they always sent.

I refer to the latter part of the Agreement as the give-away section. For instance, Appendix III, Article 2 says.

If at any time Ireland develops a significant export trade in broiler chickens...to the United Kingdom, the Government of Ireland shall consult with the Government of the United Kingdom with a view to providing for the import of such chickens into Ireland from the United Kingdom.

I do not know where the Minister for Transport and Power is. I missed him during the debate. I hope he is not unwell.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He is hanging around tonight.

Comment on this

He is at the door. I am glad to see him. I do not know if he has looked at this part of the Agreement, because Monaghan in particular, Cavan, and parts of Meath, have gone into the broiler chicken industry in a big way, and they will not be glad to know that if they expand their industry in the British market the English Government can reverse the proceedings. The same thing applies to turkeys. Article 3 states:

If at any time exports of turkeys ...from Ireland to the United Kingdom—

(a) in the case of dead birds which are ovenready, develop to a significant extent; or

(b) in the case of dead birds increase significantly above the level of 3,000 tons a year;

then in either case the Government of Ireland shall consult with the Government of the United Kingdom with a view to providing facilities for the import of dead turkeys into Ireland from the United Kingdom.

Comment on this

They need not worry about the turkeys. They are wiped out already.

Comment on this

They will be wiped out now after this comes into operation. I am amazed to find an Irish Government handing out the fringe benefits which have been attached to agriculture for so many years. If the amount exceeds a certain figure the British can send their exports here, but there is not any provision for a change. If, for example, in one year it happens that the British Government have cause to complain under this heading then, as long as Ireland is Ireland, and Britain is Britain, they can send as many turkeys and broiler chickens here as they like, and there is nothing we can do about it.

Comment on this

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy but will he ask the Taoiseach what became of the broiler factory in Bandon.

Comment on this

I will let him answer that himself.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That by-election is over.

Comment on this

The position is the same in regard to fish. Article 4 states:

The Government of Ireland shall as a minimum maintain opportunities for the import each year into Ireland of 11,000 hundredweights of fish, fresh (live or dead) chilled or frozen...of United Kingdom origin.

Article 5 states:

The Government of Ireland shall as a minimum maintain opportunities for the import each year into Ireland of 27,000 hundredweights of filleted fish and pieces thereof, smoked... of United Kingdom origin at a rate of import duty not exceeding 2d per pound.

Article 6 states:

The Government of Ireland shall as a minimum maintain opportunities for the import each year into Ireland during the control period 7 May to 31 October of 850 tons of tomatoes... of United Kingdom origin. The pattern of licensing for such imports shall follow that which has operated in recent years. Imports during the period 7 May to 31 May shall be free of import duty and the rate of import duty chargeable during the period 1 June to 31 October shall not exceed 4d per pound.

It is the same in the case of apples. At least in the case of apples no one can be tipped off to rush apples in quickly and get away with it, as appears to have happened recently. Article 7 states:

The Government of Ireland shall allow imports of apples... of United Kingdom origin—

(a) free of quantitative restrictions;

(b) during the months March to July inclusive free of import duty; and

(c) during the months August to February inclusive—

(i) as to 3,000 tons of such apples, at a rate of import duty not exceeding 1d per pound; and

(ii) as to any further imports of such apples at a rate not exceeding 2d per pound.

The same thing applies to cereals. Article 8 (2) states:

If the demand for cereal seed in Ireland declines, for example on account of a fall in cereal acreage——

We have got that——

——it may be necessary, in the consultation provided for in Article XII of the Free Trade Area Agreements, to consider the question of reducing opportunities for the import of such seed of United Kingdom origin into Ireland in proportion to the decline in demand.

That is one little safeguard for us which the Minister for Agriculture must have got when he was fighting tenaciously. Perhaps he knew that the growing of cereal was at such a rate that he had to do something about it. The same thing applies in regard to other things: 6,000 tons of malt is the minimum, and 3,000 cwts of perennial and Italian ryegrass certified seed. Again the Minister for Transport and Power will have something to say about this. Article 11 states:

The Government of Ireland shall as a minimum maintain opportunities for the import each year into Ireland of fishcakes, fish sausages, prepared meals containing fish and other prepared or preserved fish and fish products of a similar nature of United Kingdom origin to a value of £6,000 c.i.f. at a rate of import duty not exceeding 1d per pound.

We go on, and on, and on. This is the give-away section. These are the things we are giving to John Bull in case their economy may be affected by what we are doing.

I did not notice it, but the Taoiseach and his friends going to Britain, must have been wearing long beards and red cloaks. The big problem about all this is that the Taoiseach and his Ministers went to Britain having prepared over a long period what he calls a free trade agreement but which, is fact, certainly does not give free trade in agriculture, and gives one-way free trade in industry. We fear that there will be widespread unemployment. If the Taoiseach and his Ministers had made any effort to ensure that some little reciprocal agreement would be given that might protect us, I am sure when that was explained the Taoiseach would have had the sympathy of the House, but in view of the fact that the traffic seems to be all one-way, we feel that the Agreement should not get the approval of Dáil Éireann.

For that reason, we in the Labour Party are voting against the Agreement, and we make no apology to anyone for doing so. We feel that when the Agreement has been fully considered, fully inspected, and fully read by those outside the House, the same decision will be reached. While some people, when the announcement was made, felt that they were getting something, the number of such people is getting fewer and fewer. I was surprised to hear Deputy Fanning say that he met some people at a fair who said: "Now we are getting something. This is something for us." Obviously they were not very bright, but, of course, he explained that was a few weeks ago. If he talks to them next Monday I am sure he will get a different answer.

I suggest to the Taoiseach that this Agreement should not have been signed. Not only does it tie this Government, but it ties the Governments of this country in perpetuity. That is an action which should not have been taken. Therefore, we in the Labour Party believe that the only sane decision the public representatives in this House can take is to vote against the Agreement in this House, and we are voting against it.

Comment on this

Handicapped as we are by the Minister for External Affairs who busies himself with the Afro-Asian groups, and with affairs that always seem to be 5,000 miles away, Fine Gael have been campaigning for at least three years for an international agreement to protect our trade and see that we are kept "with it" in this situation where the freeing of trade is progressing all over Europe. We have the EEC and EFTA and now Britain is moving closer to Europe. Therefore, my Party, while feeling that the Agreement was not everything that could have been got, and feeling that the Government had not done as good a job as the people would wish, are not voting against this Agreement. At the same time, we are ready to point out the deficiencies in the Agreement, the things that should have been secured and have not been, and the mistakes that have been made. We feel that if we had had the opportunity to negotiate such an Agreement we would have done a better job. I propose to try to tell the House why such is the case.

We have been regaled by statements from the Minister for Agriculture and these have been so extravagant and so impossible that there is only one question before us, whether or not the Minister for Agriculture is a genius, who deserves the best of every Irish man and woman, or a political bombast and a fraud. That is the choice because his statements have been so extravagant that we must accept that if they are true then he is a genius and has exceeded all the things we would expect from a man in his position.

I should like to deal with the claim by the Taoiseach that this is a permanent Agreement. There is no such thing as a permanent Agreement in international law and there is no penalty for infringing an Agreement. The only penalty there can be is force. Everybody knows that because of the size of our economy we can never use force. In the 1930s there was such an idea but surely that idea has passed and people realise now that there can be no question of force. This Agreement is not a permanent one. It can be infringed by Britain any time they decide to do so. Let us remember that the 15 per cent levy, which was reduced to 10 per cent and is now continued, was applied to us in direct contravention of the 1948 Agreement. When Britain placed a quota on us, recommended by GATT, she again infringed the 1948 Agreement. There was no penalty except the use of force and the only force Ireland could use would be an atomic bomb and, thank God, we have not got that.

There is no need for a breach in the future because written into the Agreement there is power for Britain to impose levies in its balance of payments difficulties. The effect of such levies imposed bilaterally would have, as it were, 40 times the effect on our economy as they would on the British economy. Why should this tiny economy have to give the power to Britain to impose levies on us, as they have already done? Why did we not succeed in having ourselves excluded from this? I think we could have so succeeded. If we had succeeded, it would have been an inducement for industrialists to come here from abroad. I believe that this levy, serious as it is in its financial implications, difficult as it is for exporters, is far more difficult inasmuch as it implies to industrialists wishing to come here and export to England that the levy can be applied. There is provision for its application. This is one of the most serious factors preventing industries from coming here.

Let us consider the claims of the Minister for Agriculture that this Agreement will be worth £10 million for the Irish farmers in the first year. I would have wished that the Minister for Agriculture or the Taoiseach had been more particular on this matter. I should like to know where the money is coming from. If a Minister makes such a statement, the House is entitled to have that information, to know that there will be so many millions from one item and so many from another. It is not sufficient to say that this is worth £10 million.

The Minister boasted about the relatively small quantity of beef and lamb for which there will be an Exchequer payment from Britain to the Irish Government. Deputy Tully mentioned that there is now to be consultation about how this money will be spent. The British Government will ensure that it is not spent in any way that will affect their trade. It can operate to ensure that the beef factories here will not get the full benefit of this money and to see that the farmers do not get the full benefit. Last year there was a heavy export of beef on the hoof to Britain. The people who bought it were in a position to pay 2d or 3d deadweight more than the Irish factories. This was because of the disposal of the offals and the multitudinous uses that can be made of them in a huge economy such as that of Britain and because of the factories set up near the main factory. This money may be used to help the Irish factories but it will never reach the Irish farmer. We must face that fact and also the fact that the payments for last year in respect of deficiency, or subsidies, were, for one fortnight, .4 of 1d. in the pound.

If Britain is moving nearer to GATT, it will be incumbent on her to dismantle deficiency payments. If we get any of these payments in the short term, certainly in the long term we will get none of them. When Britain abolishes these deficiency payments they will not be there for us, yet this is based on the British fatstock subsidy scheme. The Minister for Agriculture said that this Agreement gave access to Britain for all agricultural products and I quote him from the Irish Times of January 6th:

Britain had now given up the right to regulate imports from Ireland except only in the context of an international commodity agreement covering all the major suppliers of the product including British producers themselves.

The Minister for Agriculture is noted in political circles for being a "slick chick". Further down the report continues:

The solution arrived at was the letter in which we agreed that in certain circumstances we would be prepared to grant a waiver from our right of duty free access so as to enable the UK to introduce a minimum import price system. The question of the introduction of a minimum import price system could arise only in the context of an international arrangement.

What is the difference between the words "agreement" and "arrangement"? Let us turn to the Minister's letter. I quote:

Having regard to the provisions of those Articles the Government of Ireland undertake that, in the event of the Government of the United Kingdom, after the consultation referred to in paragraph (2) of Article VIII or in paragraph (4) of Article IX, wishing to implement an arrangement of the sort referred to in paragraph (1) of Article VIII or in paragraph (4) of Article IX, which involves the regulation of imports of an agricultural product by means of a minimum import price system enforced by levies, they will be prepared to waive their right under Article I of that Agreement to duty-free access to the United Kingdom for the agricultural product in question, provided that Ireland is accorded no less favourable treatment than that accorded to any other country...

That means that all the talk of the Minister for Agriculture is as straw in the wind. At the stage when Britain is moving closer to Europe, the stage when she will have to implement the GATT reference, as she will, our access is no longer there, and everything we had in the 1948 Agreement is in danger and we will get no better treatment than any other country. Yet we are the people who traditionally supplied that country with her stores, traditionally supplied her with many of her agricultural requirements, and we are the country closest to her in the agricultural trade.

I want to know is the Minister for Agriculture prepared to say, or is the Taoiseach prepared to say on his behalf, there is no difference between the two words "agreement" and "arrangement" and that when he claims he has duty-free access letter No. 1 means nothing? If you read the Irish Times— the Official Report is not, as yet, available but I am sure the Irish Times have recorded the matter correctly—you will see he has given away everything in the 1948 Agreement and all we await now in a movement closer to Europe is the removal of benefits we have long enjoyed.

Deputy Sweetman dealt at length with the question of butter. The situation is that it was unlimited under the 1948 Agreement. We could send as much as we liked. The same applied to bacon. The phrase "or more if available" was included in the phraseology of both Agreements. We are now limited in respect of both butter and bacon. The prognostications of the amount of butter we will have to export suggest that by 1968 we will have too much butter again. We will have to go to world markets to sell it at greater losses. Yet this is the Agreement lauded by the Minister for Agriculture as the greatest thing that ever happened for Irish farming. The figure of 23,000 tons is nothing more or less than the projection of what butter we will have available for Britain in 1968. After that, I know not.

The Minister for Justice has apparently become an agriculturist. I am assured he said here today we had exported carcase beef worth £35 million in the past year. I leave it at that. I do not want to deal with that sort of thing. Let us deal instead with this question of the supply of 638,000 stores and the guarantee to supply beef and lamb.

The heifer scheme exploded in this country in quite an extraordinary way. The Government set out to spend £350,000 in the first year, and found they had to spend £2 million. This meant that a lot of people not in that trade traditionally suddenly turned over and cashed in on the £15 per head. All I hope is that they will not move straight back into dry stock. There is some evidence a lot of them are. The figure of 638,000 is merely the estimate of what would be sent maybe in two or three years' time. Without fresh measures taken, they may not be there or may be just there. In that situation, have we undertaken we will restrict our exports elsewhere and first send our cattle to Britain? I contend we have.

Turning to the cattle agreement, one finds that Article V states:

If, in any calendar year, the number of store cattle imported into the United Kingdom from Ireland falls below 638,000 head, or if, in any United Kingdom fatstock year, the quantity of carcase beef and carcase lamb so imported is less than 25,000 tons and 5,500 tons respectively, the two Governments shall consult with a view to taking such measures as are practicable to meet the situation.

There are no measures practicable if the cattle are not there, except the restriction of our exports to other places.

I want the House to turn their minds to the lamb trade, which I am sure the Minister for Agriculture knows very little about. The week that France comes in for lamb, we who have lambs to sell know that the price of lambs will go up on the Dublin market by as much as £1 per head. Even though France comes in only for three weeks at a time and perhaps does not take any more for six or seven weeks, it is the price of lamb in Paris that makes the price here. Have we given away our right of access to that market to try to make the British pay a higher price?

I have spoken to many cattle exporters since this Agreement was produced. Many of them are extremely worried. At present there is a strong reaction in Britain to high cattle prices from Ireland. If this is so, surely the way we had to make the price was to try to move towards the prices on the Continent? If we do not have 638,000 head of cattle, are we to restrict our exports to other countries? It is largely a gamble. If the heifer scheme has progressed, very well, we will have them. If the system of the £15 payment and no more unless herd numbers are increased is not effective and if they go back to dry stock, we will not have them. In that situation, have we given away something extremely important? The extravagant boasts of the Minister for Agriculture brand him as a bombast and a political fraud. There is no £10 million there. He did not tell us where it is to come from. He just gave it as a figure.

If in agriculture we at least held part of our position, in industry the position is very different. Nobody in this debate mentioned the question of the choice and range of industrial consumer goods. You may have all the Buy Irish campaigns you like but when our wives go into a shoe shop for instance at present for a pair of walking or high-heel shoes they probably get a choice of four or five pairs of shoes to suit them. But, if British footwear come in here, clearly the position will be that they will get a choice of 15 or 20 pairs to suit them. If I know wives, a lot of them will not buy Irish. Maybe that is not a patriotic thing to say, but it is true and we must speak the truth in these matters.

The Taoiseach came back and left us in the dark about this Agreement for three or four days and the Minister for Agriculture went out on his bombastic mission. To give the Minister for Industry and Commerce his due, he did not do that. We believe that in Part II of Annex B there was a section of goods which could be protected by quota until 1975. In this annex we had footwear, laminated springs, sparking plugs, electric filament lamps, brushes, brooms and mops and some varieties of hose. We now find we are dismantling our quotas on footwear by 1968 and on electric bulbs by 1971. Is it not true that, when the Taoiseach and the Minister for Industry and Commerce were negotiating with Douglas Jay in London, they knew that? Yet they came home and flaunted this Agreement in a political way and did not give us copies of it.

Half of the footwear operatives in this country are in my constituency. Therefore, this is a major problem for me. In 1968, when the quotas have been removed, surely the position will be that footwear from Britain will flood the market here? I am using footwear simply as an example. When the choice and range of consumer goods from Britain is put at the disposal of the Irish people, I feel the share of the home market available to us will drop substantially.

Let us consider how much that home market really is. I quote from the NIEC Report of 1965, in which there is a very useful table giving the percentage of gross output of our industries exported. Of our linen and cotton industry, only 14.1 per cent at present is exported; of our jute and canvas industry, only 15.3 per cent; hosiery, only 18.7 per cent; and footwear, only 26.7 per cent. That means that we are fighting, in this situation that I portray in which information was given to us in slices over the days, for 74 per cent of our trade. We are in a position where this 74 per cent can vitally be affected and we have no better access than we had as far as the British market is concerned.

In women's and girls' clothing, only 26.4 per cent is exported. In wood and cork, furniture and textiles, only 18.5 per cent is exported. So, as far as furniture is concerned, we are fighting for 80 per cent of our total output in our home trade.

The question of choice and range is one of the most dangerous things in this Agreement and the safeguards that were secured are not sufficient.

I want now to suggest that, as usual, Fianna Fáil have seen fit to pick a few pets. I am very glad to see the pets picked and I wish them all the best. In a situation where the Minister for Industry and Commerce can talk about the fact that musical instruments have been looked after, and that this will create a good situation, one wonders whether the Minister for Industry and Commerce was more worried about a musical instrument factory at Shannon than about items of far greater importance and far greater employment potential.

I want to suggest, also, that there are factors that could have been looked after that were not looked after. As usual, the Fianna Fáil Government have seen to it that the right things, as far as they are concerned, have been looked after. Article 4 of this Agreement is quite an extraordinary Article because it indicates that fiscal charges against imported goods to this country shall be removed. The new position will be that not only shall no new one be put on but that they shall be removed. As far as I can understand it, this means that, in a few years, there will not be an extra duty on foreign gin, on Scotch whisky, and so on. The Taoiseach may smile, but that is the fact. You are not allowed to put an extra fiscal charge in your Budget on articles that are imported. Whether or not the Taoiseach will be in a position to prove that Scotch whisky is a different product from Irish whiskey, I do not know, but, in his effort to do so, perhaps he will find that the British are the people with the power and he is the person without it.

In the engineering trade of this country, there is a very serious danger of unemployment. The position in Britain is that in all these engineering business one finds that many of the component parts are made in as many as 12, 15 or 20 factories. Here, we have not this wide variety of factories. We find it difficult enough to produce a finished product with the few we have. We find that the trade here is wide open to Britain. We find that the duties are progressively reduced and that the quotas have been removed. In my view, the situation will then be catastrophic.

There is another matter that must be considered before we come to the safeguards, which I believe are inadequate, and that is that, in the wholesale and retail movement of goods in Britain, the normal mark-up is 50 per cent. The normal mark-up here is 25 per cent. The truth of this is that when they have removed four slices of ten per cent from a tariff, we are in for trouble. We are in a position whereby the price of the British article with the tariff paid may well be below the price obtainable here.

This brings up the question of dumping. What constitutes dumping? If you produce 5,000 articles and sell them here at five shillings and the British manufacturer produces 5,000 articles and sells them there at five shillings and sends over 1,000 to this country, and pays the tariff out of his profits and sales at five shillings, is this dumping? As far as I can read it from the Agreement, it is not. Yet, if you have a run of 5,000 articles and you just run another 1,000, the sixth thousand cost probably half of what the other 5,000 did but you have only a little market here that can assimilate the 5,000 and Britain is in the entirely better situation. The safeguard provisions do not give the sort of protection we need. In five years' time, we have a review and we can continue protection on three per cent of our imports. I do not think that is sufficient. I think the range of industries that will vitally be affected will be far more than can be protected by this provision.

We can, if there is gross unemployment in an industry, put on protection for 18 months. Eighteen months in the life of an industry is an extremely short period. I do not think these provisions are sufficient and I honestly believe that better provisions could have been got and should have been sought. Therefore, the balance of the Agreement seems to weigh against us. Assessments have been made of what this is worth in ten years' time to Britain. One assessment has been that it is worth £50 million to Britain in ten years' time. Even the Minister for Agriculture did not set any such figure on the advantages to us. So as far as I can see, this Agreement is unbalanced. Britain is getting the better of the bargain and we are not getting the safeguards a small country would need.

Then the question arises whether we are fit for freer trade and why could we not make a better Agreement. I hold we could not make a better Agreement because the Taoiseach went to London with financial chaos at home, with industrial chaos at home and with a prices situation at home which did not allow him to come back with nothing because the moral effect of that would have placed him in an impossible situation and so he had to take what he got.

What is the situation in which we now find ourselves? We find ourselves in a situation with a balance of payments deficit of from £45 million to £50 million. We find ourselves in a situation where there is a shortage of money at a time when the Government did not accept the discipline they placed on themselves in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion and spent far more than they said they would spend. We find ourselves in a situation in which the Government now have to remove from the private sector of banking far more money than it is safe to remove, thus leaving people who have to adapt their industries in the situation that they have not the money with which to do it. We find ourselves in the situation that the grant such people will get is exactly half what a foreign industrialist would get on coming in here and building a new factory. All that seems to be wrong. The result has been industrial chaos.

The other evening I was looking at the prices of certain articles. A woman said to me: "How would you like to be a workingman today with three children and a wife to feed?"—and that is merely an average family man. Looking at those prices, I said I would not. I do not blame people for looking for extra money here today. I blame the Government because they have allowed this prices situation to develop to the stage at which people cannot live. That is what is wrong with this country. People can no longer live and rear their families in decency here and it is the fault of the Taoiseach and of nobody else because, when two by-elections were pending, he went in and arranged for a 12 per cent increase which he knew could not be given. We know that everybody who got the 12 per cent is now worse off than they were before they got it. This is the fault of the Taoiseach.

The Taoiseach has now created a situation, with shortage of capital and with industrial strife, where we have had a colossal increase in unemployment in the past week. Before I advert to this, I may say I understand the Government are fearful of unemployment in the next quarter with the result that they are changing the manner of giving us the figures. I hope they will be honest enough to give us both sets of figures for at least the next six or 12 months until the new set bears comparison, the one with the other. From the week of 17th December, 1965, to the week of December, 31st, 1965, there were 7,310 more people unemployed. Let us remember that there are 63,714 people unemployed in this country today. This is the highest figure since 1958 and, worse than that, 53,620 of these people are men. That is the state the Government have got us into. They went to England and they had to come back with an Agreement. They came back with one that was not treatment for us as equals. Now there is nothing we can do—it is a fait accompli— except to make comments and hope that, as soon as possible, the Government will be removed from office and we can go back on other terms and put the country back on its feet.

Comment on this

At this hour of the night, I would not attempt to endeavour to correct all the misunderstandings or to contest all the misrepresentations of the Agreement and of the policy of the Government which were expressed during this debate. There will be other opportunities. I suppose, if I were to commit myself to deal with all the misrepresentations, I would be undertaking a life's task.

When I was speaking here a long time ago, proposing the motion which the Dáil has been debating ever since, I urged that any Deputy who intended to argue that the Agreement which we had signed in London should not have been made or should not now be approved by the Dáil had an obligation to answer the question—what alternative course is open to the country, what road could we take in the circumstances now existing and about to develop in Europe, which would help us to promote our economic progress by ensuring the availability of export markets for our rising agricultural and industrial production? Very many Deputies who spoke on this debate ignored that question altogether. Others approached the question but did not seriously attempt to deal with it and yet this is the real issue, indeed the only issue, before the Dáil.

Any Deputy, in relation to an Agreement of the length of that we are now considering and of such infinite complexity, could easily argue that this or that provision should have been different or some clause drafted otherwise. These points are not very relevant. The relevant issue before the Dáil is whether we should in the circumstances now existing make this Agreement, which is the first milestone on a road which will determine the direction of our economic progress in the future and which is related to the situation in which this country will have to earn its living in the future by the development of its exports.

I urged Deputies also to relate this Agreement, and their arguments about this Agreement to the background of the situation in Europe. We cannot ignore that situation. Within 12 months all the countries of western Europe with which we have any trade will be in a free trade system, temporarily divided, I agree, into two trading blocs. There will have been set up in this part of the world a free trade system into which we must get, after adapting ourselves so that we can live in it. Otherwise we go out of business altogether. These are the realities of our situation and there is no sense in ignoring the realities just to make political Party debating points. We have got to organise our national economy and equip ourselves in every way to cope with the free trade situation in Europe. Unless we can earn our living in that situation, we can have no living at all.

Now I know that the leaders of the Fine Gael Party did try to suggest there was an alternative. I have too much respect for their intelligence to think that they really believed what they were saying in that regard. They suggested that we could, by some pleading or haggling, get into the EEC and, at the same time, be able to maintain the preferential system in our trading with Great Britain. That is nonsense and as I said, I have too much respect for the intelligence of those Deputies to think that they regard it otherwise. They have, of course, gone through the motions of criticising this Agreement, but if I interpret properly the speeches made by the more responsible leaders of the Fine Gael Party, they accept that there is no alternative to the road we are now taking. The Labour Party are opposed to the Agreement: we expected that— opposition to change just because it is change is the natural attitude of a conservative party.

Deputy Cosgrave began his speech by talking about the zeal of the convert. I do not know who he was suggesting has been converted to, or from what. So far as I am personally concerned, the process of Irish industrial development is proceeding in accordance with the pattern I envisaged 30 years ago, the pattern which I have been outlining in speeches in this House and throughout the country for the past 30 years. We had to start off with protection, indeed high protection, not merely because 30 years ago the world was in a major economic slump—the great depression of the Thirties—but also because there did not exist in this country at that time any large body of opinion which really believed substantial industrial progress to be possible here. We began that industrial development drive against the hostility of commercial and financial interests and against the embittered hostility of the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

We had to organise the development of Irish industry behind protection in order to demonstrate that it was possible; in order to show that industries could be set up here which were capable of growth and, only when in that way we got the industrial development policy off the ground, did we find a diminution of this original hostility, this acceptance of the policy of industrial development, not merely by Fine Gael but by those commercial and financial interests to whom I have referred.

We always visualised these industries, set up under high protection, developing in skill and efficiency, and gradually venturing into export trade until the time came when the protection which brought them into being could be gradually withdrawn, as this became possible and it was required to facilitate the expansion of their own commercial activities. That is how we always envisaged the development of industry here and it is with some pride that I say to the Dáil now that we are entering the final phase of that process of development we began 30 years ago.

Comment on this

The main trouble with the Party opposite is that they are 30 years behind the time.

Comment on this

Gone and gone for ever, thank God.

Comment on this

The Economic War is as irrelevant to the present situation in this country as the Battle of the Boyne or the curse of Cromwell. We are two-thirds of the way through the twentieth century and heading for the twenty-first. Will the Party opposite not try to wake up to the facts of life?

I must say I am unable to understand the various references which were made here to alleged secrecy surrounding this Agreement. We have been talking here about the imminence of free trade for ten years, first of all, in the context of the European Free Trade Area negotiations and, subsequently, in the context of our application for membership of the EEC. We have been urging our industrialists to prepare for the imminence of free trade. We have been giving them financial help to organise themselves for that purpose. We have been doing that against a zero date of 1970, which may indeed still prove to be the zero date.

We announced in November, 1964, that we were beginning the negotiation of a new Trade Agreement with Great Britain. We announced in July, 1965, as soon as it was possible, that the object of these negotiations was to set up a free trade régime. I cannot understand the colossal stupidity of a Deputy like Deputy Treacy who says we have rushed into this Agreement. There never was an agreement made by this country more deliberately negotiated and which took longer to complete than the Agreement now before the Dáil. After it was possible to announce that the object of the Agreement was a free trade régime, I defended the principles of an Agreement of that kind in various public speeches. It was not possible to give details to the Dáil, or to the public, because the Agreement had not been negotiated. Until 1 a.m. on the morning of 14th December, it was not certain that there was going to be an Agreement at all, and one hour before that I would have laid odds against the possibility of an Agreement.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave asked me to summon a meeting of the Dáil in August. I did not think then, and I do not think now, that he intended that request to be very serious; at least I suspect his main purpose was to get in before Deputy Corish thought about it.

Comment on this

The first time in the July communication when the Dáil was adjourned.

Comment on this

The fact that the Dáil was adjourned was pure coincidence.

Comment on this

As the Deputy knows very well, the date of our meetings in London had been arranged long beforehand. Negotiations of a technical character—and this Agreement is a very technical one—could not possibly be conducted successfully if the parties to it were required to take up attitudes in public which would deprive them of any latitude in subsequent discussions.

Deputy Cosgrave and other Deputies spoke about the possibility of this country being endangered by dumping from Great Britain. This is a problem we have been living with for ten years, since the first time a European Free Trade Area was talked about. We set out, and succeeded in getting, an arrangement that, where dumping is threatened—not actually happening but threatened—we can take action by our own decision and without having to ask anybody's permission or engage in consultation. But, remember, in order to get that freedom of action, we had to concede it to Britain. Do not let Deputies here be under any illusion that we were impeccable in that regard, that there were not occasions in the past, and will not be in the future, when protected Irish manufacturers will be selling goods abroad at lower prices than are being charged at home. It was also necessary to get into that clause the reference to material damage—that is a phrase taken from the GATT—but it takes recognition of the fact that the danger of damage through dumping is greater in the case of a small country than in the case of a large one. It is our proximity to a great industrial exporter which makes this danger a real one for us. However, as the House has been told by the Minister for Industry and Commerce, a Bill to deal with dumping—an anti-dumping Bill—will be before this House in a matter of some months and we can then discuss the adequacy of the arrangements proposed. We did not need a Bill of that kind before. We need it now.

Deputy Cosgrave also spoke about our tax concessions to exporters and urged their extension. May I say, straight away, that provisions for the giving of tax concessions or subsidies, direct or indirect, to encourage exports, are in conflict with Free Trade Area Agreements and, indeed, there is a section of the GATT which deals with them? It would have been quite reasonable for the British to have urged on us that these tax concessions should disappear on 1st July next but, in fact, as the Agreement makes clear, they agreed that these tax concessions, as set out in our law, should continue as provided in the law. If Deputy Cosgrave had in mind the possibility of extending these tax concessions to encourage exports to other countries, it is necessary, I think, to remind ourselves that we have been rather fortunate that we have not yet in any case I know of, induced retaliatory action against us because of them but if we were to extend these concessions, extend our indirect subsidies for export, we would be taking the risk of retaliatory action. In any event, we would be greatly complicating our negotiation of membership of the European Economic Community when that takes place.

In this year tax concessions of any kind are ruled out by Budget considerations. Indeed, it is obvious that tax increases will be unavoidable but further tax incentives at any time or further hidden subsidies to exports would be a hazardous course to take until we knew exactly the consequences they might evoke. The whole apparatus of capital grants and technical aids and all the other methods by which we have been building up new industries in the past ten years will still be operated. There is no question of any limitation of our power to maintain them and extend them if we want to do so. Deputies who said that we have committed ourselves to terminate them in respect of the West or generally have either not understood the Agreement or are anxious to mislead the public about it.

Comment on this

There is no money, is there?

Comment on this

If the Deputy will produce a first-class industrial project, which is most unlikely, we will give him the money for it. There was an effort by some Deputies to see in this Agreement something suggestive of a political withdrawal and many cynical and hypocritical references to the 1916 commemoration which merely revealed their incapacity to understand the ideals of Irish nationalists and republicans, if indeed they ever understood them.

Comment on this

The people of this country fought for their freedom through the years not merely because of patriotic impulses, not merely to give Ireland her proper status among the nations of the earth but so that they could organise themselves to develop their agriculture and industry and improve their standard of living by the application of their own policies. This is what we are trying to do and what we are free to do and the only issue today arising in connection with this Agreement is: does it help us to do it or not?

Deputies are entitled to argue that it is a bad Agreement or that it could be different in some respects but they are not entitled to question our motives for making it. We made it because we believe it will contribute to the economic development of this country, to the advancement and progress of our agriculture and industry. They may question the Agreement but they may not question the sincerity of our conviction that that is what the Agreement will in fact achieve.

Comment on this

The methods by which we develop our industries and open up prospects for expanding our export trade are for ourselves to decide and this is the one issue that the Dáil is now being asked to decide: Is this method we are now trying a good method? Is there an alternative? No Deputy has attempted to suggest that there is an alternative course, much less a better one. We cannot achieve anything in economic development by confining ourselves to the home market. There is nothing that can be done in that respect that has not already been accomplished——

Comment on this

Or tried by you and failed.

Comment on this

If we were now, by rejecting this Agreement, to proclaim that we were withdrawing into a policy of permanent protection, opting out of world markets, it would mean the end of our economic progress and the beginning of the death of our nation. We know there are probably some inefficient industries now producing at high cost. Deputy Corish criticised me because I would not name them. I could not honestly name with certainty a single industry that is not capable of being developed so as to become thoroughly efficient and even if I did think that there was such an industry, it would be unwise in the extreme to designate it at this point of time. But, if there are industries which cannot be reorganised in ten or 15 years, with all the Government aid available to them, so as to be able to meet fair competition in the home market, then they are certain to disappear anyway and it is time we set about replacing them with industries with a brighter future and higher export potential. That is the work we are now going to start on. That is the work that now has to be organised.

I spoke on Monday last to a group of leading industrialists and referred to the project of the National Industrial and Economic Council who were considering the setting up of development councils for each industry, councils which will be representative of managers and workers and whose task it will be to plan the development of these industries and to ensure by their advice that Government policy is so aligned that it will facilitate the execution of their plans.

This is something of personal interest to me because about 20 years ago, I introduced a Bill to set up councils of that character, and got that Bill through the Dáil against the bitter opposition of the Fine Gael Party but with the co-operation of the Labour Party, and then there was a change of Government before the Bill was enacted and, of course, the idea died then.

Comment on this

You never received it.

Comment on this

It was the Coalition Government who killed it.

Comment on this

You never revived it.

Comment on this

I must say, I was thoroughly disappointed at the attitude of the Labour Party at that time in letting it be killed. The idea is coming back to life now. The trouble is, I am always 20 years before my time.

Deputies have been speaking about their concern for the preservation of employment. Our concern is the expansion of employment by the development of new industries. I believe that this Agreement marks the beginning of a new era of industrial expansion in Ireland.

Comment on this

One hundred thousand jobs.

Comment on this

I believe it is true that it is along the road on which we are now starting that we can set up in Ireland industries that will be capable of giving far greater employment than anything we ever previously conceived as possible in the industrial sphere, industries that will be thoroughly efficient, that will be able to put their products into every market in the world and get sale for them on their quality and cost. Those are the kinds of industry we want, the kinds of industry that will survive; those are the kinds of industry we are now going to get. Our aim is to make Ireland as significant a producer and exporter of industrial goods as any of the smaller countries in Europe, countries territorially smaller than ours—Belgium, Holland, Denmark. There is no reason why we should not aim to set up plans to bring about in this country the same degree of industrial activity as they have already accomplished and we are certainly not going to settle for anything less than that.

The task of a Government is to arrange for Trade Agreements which will open up the prospect of markets abroad for the production of these new industries and the expanding production of the older industries. Would anybody in his sane mind invest money in a new enterprise or the expansion of existing enterprises unless he could see as a result of inter-Governmental agreements a market for the commodities he was going to produce? That is what this Agreement is intended to provide. That is what it does provide.

We hoped this assurance of markets for our expanding production, industrial and agricultural, would have been secured through our membership of the European Economic Community. It still may be but I do not think we can afford to stand still until these European Powers have resolved their differences so as to make this possible for us and I do not think, in any event, that we should stop our preparations for that inevitable situation just because some Deputies dislike the prospect of having to face changes. Why should we allow these disputes between other countries to determine our fate? Why should we allow them to stop our progress at this time?

If we sought to achieve a Free Trade Agreement with Great Britain at this time, it is not only because the bulk of our exports go to Great Britain, and always will so far as it is possible to foresee, but because there is no other country or no other group of countries that is willing to make a similar agreement with us at this time. It is true that we could go into the Common Market this year on the basis of signing the Rome Treaty, accepting the obligations of that Treaty, and applying the common external tariff against Great Britain. That is open to us. If we did not take that course, it is because we did not think it would be in our interests to do so. We could have joined the European Free Trade Association at any time but it would have been the height of folly to have done so until we had made an agreement with Britain covering our trade in agricultural goods.

We cannot join the European Economic Community now. We cannot even have useful discussions with that Community now and will not be able to have discussions with them until they have resolved their present difficulties and settled the method and direction of their future development together.

Eventually, we believe that this Agreement we have made with Great Britain will be absorbed in membership of the European Economic Community and when that becomes possible, we will, because of this Agreement, be able to go into the European Economic Community with far greater confidence, in full equality with the other nations in it, equality of status and equality of capacity for achieving the economic progress it will make possible.

If the difficulties which have stopped the progress of the European Economic Community since July of last year persist so as to create doubts as to the future of that Community, that will be a new situation. It is our conviction, however, that the economic unification of Europe is inevitable, that the forces making for this are irresistible and that our duty at this time is to make sure that we are ready for it when it comes. That is why we are now embarking upon this policy; that is why we made this Agreement.

Ireland's independence will always be as real as our economic development makes it. Because this Agreement will promote our economic strength, it will thereby enhance our independence. By submitting our industrial organisation to the test of fair and free competition, we will not only ascertain its real strength and durability but will help to make it grow stronger. It is because we have confidence in the future of Irish industry, in its capacity to achieve a significant export business, in the capacities of our industrial managements, in the ability of our workers to acquire new skills, that we have no hesitation in deciding to accept the test of free trade, to face the effort of moving to a higher level of economic achievement and to win exports by the quality of our production and not by haggling or begging for preferences either in Britain or the European Economic Community or anywhere else.

I have had during my lifetime in Government many experiences of negotiating trade agreements, big and small, with the British Government. This is the first time ever that I did not have to go there to bargain from weakness, to plead for some concession or some preferential treatment, relying solely upon their goodwill in order to get it, but went there to make a fair agreement, an agreement tailored to our requirements as conceived by us in the light of our own estimation of our needs and assumptions as to the future course of world events.

I said earlier this evening that there was only one real issue before the Dáil but there is another issue, that is, whether we have faith in ourselves, faith in our capacity to organise our country effectively, faith in our ability to set up and develop industries as efficient as those of other countries, or whether we are going to content ourselves with a permanent position of inferiority in the world?

I recommend this Agreement to the Dáil as a good agreement. Those who have faith in our future will vote for it. Those who have not do not count.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this

In which amendment?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting a question which covers the two amendments because the two amendments are identical—to delete certain words after "Dáil Éireann".

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has been the procedure of the House all down the years and I am putting the question——

Comment on this

It is not the procedure.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Just a moment. I am putting the question as the question has always been put in similar circumstances all down the years: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this

May I raise a point of order? I was informed by the Ceann Comhairle today that the Fine Gael motion would be put first. The motion would be put as you have put it—"That the words proposed to be deleted stand". I was told that then the motion in the name of the Taoiseach would be put. We are prepared to take the consequences, but we want to vote against the Agreement. We want to have an opportunity of voting against the motion proposed by the Taoiseach. If we can have that agreement——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motion will be put after we have disposed of the amendments. I have said that amendments have been moved to the Taoiseach's motion to delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and to insert other words.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave's amendment now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This covers both amendments.

Comment on this

The motion will be put separately.

Comment on this

The motion must be put separately.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to tell the Leader of the Labour Party that the two amendments are identical——

Comment on this

They are not.

Comment on this

Fine Gael approve of the Agreement but we do not, and the Ceann Comhairle has already given us a ruling that the amendments will be taken separately.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There can be no separate decision on the amendments but Deputies will get an opportunity of voting for or against the main motion.

Comment on this

That is not sufficient. Why is the Ceann Comhairle not present on a vote like this?

Comment on this

How can you mingle both Deputy Cosgrave's amendment and mine? Deputy Cosgrave said they are in favour of the Agreement because it will bring certain results. We say we do not approve of the Agreement because it will have a certain effect. Surely you cannot put these two together?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want his amendment or not?

Comment on this

I want an opportunity to vote on it and I do not want to be associated with an amendment that approves the Agreement.

Comment on this

This arrangement facilitates the Opposition.

Comment on this

On the table in front of you, Sir, there is an advice saying the amendments are to be taken separately. The Ceann Comhairle has given us that ruling.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is no separate decision on the amendments for the reason that both amendments seek to delete the same words from the motion.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

There is no Standing Order in relation to it at all.

Comment on this

The Labour Party may not understand that there will be a second vote on the motion.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle assured me this afternoon that Deputy Cosgrave's amendment would be put first and, on the assumption that the Government Party carried the day, our amendment then would not be put——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is so.

Comment on this

——but we would have an opportunity of voting on the Taoiseach's motion. But our amendment is not going to be mingled with Deputy Cosgrave's. It must be abundantly clear, even to the back benchers of the Fianna Fáil Party, that the Fine Gael Party are not going to vote against the Agreement. We want to vote against the Agreement.

Comment on this

Completely and absolutely.

Comment on this

And the Deputies will get a chance to do that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputies will get an opportunity of voting against the motion.

Comment on this

On the assumption, Sir, that you put Deputy Cosgrave's amendment now

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Cosgrave's amendment falls, then the Deputy's amendment also falls because they are similar——

Comment on this

As long as you make it clear to the House——

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is afraid of winning the vote.

Comment on this

Could the Taoiseach not send him back to Tibet?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies allow me to put the question? I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Comment on this

In the first amendment?

Comment on this

If the House decides that the words stand, then they stand, and there cannot be a second amendment.

Comment on this

This is Deputy Cosgrave's amendment that is being put now. Is that right?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this

What words?

Comment on this
Deputies

All words.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I will explain again to the Deputy. To the Taoiseach's motion, amendments have been moved to delete all words after "Dáil Éireann". I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this

In Deputy Cosgrave's amendment?

An Ceann Comhairle took the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The motion before the House is:

That Dáil Éireann approves the Agreements, Exchanges of Letters and Understandings between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom which were signed in London on the 14th day of December, 1965, and copies of which have been laid before Dáil Éireann.

To this motion, there is an amendment. I am putting the question: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".

Comment on this

Before you put the question, may I ask if this is Deputy Cosgrave's amendment which is being put?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is right.

Comment on this

Only?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is the only one that was technically before the House.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 66
·
Níl 38
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The second amendment may not now be moved, the first having been defeated. I am now putting the Government motion.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That Dáil Éireann approves the Agreements, Exchanges of Letters and Understandings between the Government of Ireland and the Government of the United Kingdom which were signed in London on the 14th day of December, 1965, and copies of which have been laid before Dáil Éireann".

Tá 66
·
Níl 19
Result _

Do you agree with this result?