Adjournment (Summer Recess).
Contributions 1–177 of 359. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
When speaking last night on this vote of censure, I was referring to the housing situation. I promised today for the record to turn to a matter which I think it is particularly desirable to ventilate in this House, particularly for the benefit of younger Deputies who are frequently misled by the kind of propaganda on which they are reared by Fianna Fáil. Before undertaking that assignment, I want to direct the attention of the House to two very disturbing facts that have come to light in the past 24 hours.
One is the receipt this morning of the record of the Live Register of unemployed. On 27th June, 1964, there were in receipt of unemployment benefit, which excludes people in receipt of unemployment assistance, 22,470 persons. On 2nd July, 1965, there were 22,664 and on 1st July, 1966, 26,694. Unemployment is rising compared with last year. There are 4,000 more persons in receipt of unemployment benefit, that is, people drawing money on foot of the stamps they have affixed to their social welfare cards. It is not untypical of Fianna Fáil that the general figures for unemployment as we used to use them in this House are no longer available to us because they have changed the whole basis of reckoning the total number of unemployed. For years, the practice was to put them on the boat and ship them to Great Britain or anywhere else they could get rid of them. At present there are approximately, I understand, one million people of Irish birth working in Great Britain. Fianna Fáil made an abundant contribution to that great diaspora of our people.
However, not content with shipping them out of the country, according to the footnote on the returns made by the Central Statistics Office, as from 7th January, 1966, the Live Register excludes persons who are in beneficial occupation of agricultural land and a number of other categories who are here set out. Thus the figures sound less remarkable than they would if they were calculated on the basis with which we were all familiar over the past ten years, but it is gravely significant that we have 4,000 more people drawing unemployment benefit as a result of being out of work today than we had this day 12 months or this day two years ago.
The second remarkable fact that has come to light in the past 24 hours is the fact mentioned by Deputy Mrs. Desmond when speaking last night. There are some Deputies who are a bit liberal in their interpretation of current statistics but that is not the reputation Deputy Mrs. Desmond has. She was talking about the circumstances of a family living in the environs of Cork and sending their children to school, and the head of which had secured the £1 a week increase agreed with the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. In her reckoning, which I do not believe to be extravagant, she pointed out that one item of domestic expenditure alone, the transport of those children going to school in Cork city from their home outside the city, on five days a week, had absorbed practically the entire £1 a week. Practically the entire £1 had been absorbed by increased transport costs in getting the children to school and all the other elements of increases in the cost of living of that family have to be met out of the wages they got before they received the £1 under the general agreement which is in course of being put into effect at the suggestion of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions.
I want to say this: I hear a lot of people talking about the reckless irresponsibility of the trade union movement. I have said in this House before, and I am saying it again, that all my life. I have been dealing with trade unions. I never found them irresponsible or reckless. I found them tough; I found them very often unbending in the course of negotiation, but I recognise that that was their job, and they may have found me on many occasions tough and unbending too, and we had our collisions. However, if we expect the trade union movement to maintain their record of responsibility and prudence, we have got to recognise that all the obligations are not on one side. We have got to do two things. One is to ensure that we will not let the cost of living run away and sweep out of the wage-earner's hand any benefit he may have secured as a result of legitimate negotiations. We have also got to try to bear in mind that if we want trade unionists to exercise reasonable restraint in their demands for increased wages for the benefit of the community as a whole, if we want industry which employs them to play its part in efficiency and economy and prudent administration, then exhortations from the Government Front Bench are not enough. Example is a very desirable additional contribution to the solution of this problem. Whether or not it is good example to increase the number of Ministers to the maximum the Constitution will allow, when it is notorious that more than one Minister in the present administration has nothing to do, is open to doubt.
I want now to refer to the matter which I promised to refer to yesterday. I have heard it frequently stated, and I believe that several honest young Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party believe it to be true, that when this country borrowed £40 million sterling in dollars from the Government of the United States of America in 1949, under the Marshall Aid plan, and accepted the corresponding grant at that time, in fact what happened was that the Government borrowed £40 million and spent it improvidently and that it was gone. I want to try to explain to them a complex series of facts. I want to try to explain this extremely complex transaction and in a sense I apologise to the House for dealing with history, but it is important that it should be understood in order to differentiate from the situation with which we are now confronted.
In 1948, there was no scarcity of capital. The House should understand that. We had just finished the European war during which we were importing virtually nothing but exporting everything that we would permit to be exported. All during the war we were controlling exports, for if we did not control them, everything we had to sell would have been swept out of the country to a hungry people who were beleaguered in Great Britain and savagely rationed, with the result that at the end of the war, one thing that was not scarce was capital. The great problem was to find, in addition to the social investment we considered essential, productive investment which would absorb the capital available if we could get productive enterprises under way. We were looking everywhere to get people to set up industries which would export. What we ought to remember is that at that time the problem was that the whole of Europe was devastated and they were all trying to rebuild their own countries.
We were almost unique in Europe in that we had a surplus of capital. Every other country in Europe—Great Britain, France, Germany, Holland and Belgium—were all on the flat of their backs, with their countries devastated and with an acute shortage of capital. However, we shared with Europe one serious problem and that was that we had no dollars. Now, no country in Europe had anything to sell to us. They wanted it all for themselves. France wanted it to buy building materials she had not got; Belgium wanted it to buy building materials she had not got; and Germany wanted it to buy building materials she had not got. They all wanted those building materials to rebuild their shattered countries. We wanted it to build houses. The sterling we had in abundance was negotiable only in countries that had nothing to sell us. The same was true in England; the same was true in France, Belgium and Germany. I well remember speaking to a prominent miller in this country in 1947. He said to me: "The Americans' problem very shortly will be that they will have an abundance to sell and they will have no one to buy it". I remember saying to him: "What do you think they will do?" He said: "They are going to have the greatest economic catastrophe the world has even seen. They will have to close down their agricultural industry." I said: "They have a major problem." He said: "What will they do?" I said: "They will give it away. They cannot do anything else."
I still remember that man's horror at the idea that any country would give its produce away. Of course, in 1948, when President Truman took office and the Secretary of State, General Marshall, realised the magnitude of that dilemma, they launched the Marshall Plan. The whole purpose of that plan was to put launched the Marshall Plan. The whole purpose of that plan was to put into the hands of the European countries dollars with which to buy all the USA could produce in abundance, building materials, machinery, food. Remember, all Europe was starving.
When I took office as Minister for Agriculture, all we had in this country was rationing. Even in this country the ration was only two ounces of butter a week and half an ounce of tea. On the Continent of Europe and in Great Britain, it was much worse. I remember going into one of the most fashionable clubs in London and asking for my lunch and being told the only thing available was fish sausage. The reason that it was made into sausage was that the appearance of the only fish available was so revolting nobody would eat it if it was not converted into sausage.
The Marshall Plan was launched in that situation. We did not want capital: we wanted dollars, hard currency. The British wanted dollars, too, and accordingly the Marshall Plan was launched. Remember, we had been neutral during the war and a very grave question was: "Would the USA include us in the Marshall Plan at all?" Largely through the superb skill of Deputy Seán MacBride, who was then Minister for External Affairs, and Deputy J.A. Costello, who was then Taoiseach, we succeeded in getting in on the Marshall Plan. We got our allocation of dollars. Despite the Fianna Fáil Leader trying to persuade his younger, inexperienced supporters, that we went out on a spending spree, and that 40 million dollars was dissipated, I am producing here the American Counterpart Fund Account for the years 1963-64, 1962-63, 1961-62, 1960-61, 1959-60, 1958-59, 1957-58, 1956-57, 1955-56, 1954-55, 1953-54, 1952-53, 1951-52, 1950-51, 1949-50 and 1948-49. I ask you: how can you keep an account, and present it annually to Dáil Éireann, of a fund that does not exist? If that 40 million dollars were spent by the inter-Party Government in 1948, 1949 and 1950, why are we still keeping an account of it in 1964-65? Those are not private documents. I borrowed them from the Library. They are there for all to read but they tell an extraordinary story.
What happened? The Irish Government borrowed the dollars and we deposited them in the Central Bank. A building contractor undertook to build 1,000 houses for the working people of this country. He came to us and he said: "I cannot get steel in England, Germany or Belgium. The only place I can get steel is in Philadelphia in Pennsylvania. I can get abundant steel there but they will not take payment in sterling. They want it in dollars". "Very Well", we said, "that is why we borrowed the dollars from America. We have dollars in the Central Bank. How much do you want?" He said: "I need dollars for £100,000." We said to him: "Give us your cheque for £100,000 and we will give you the dollars". We took his cheque for £100,000 and we gave him 300,000 dollars. He went off with those dollars in his pocket to Pennsylvania. He bought the steel there and he built the houses. We had the dollars and we were able to build the houses. We were, by our foresight, able to do that.
Comment on this
May I not relate that to what the situation is now? Remember the position the country is in now. The Government are trying to blame us for the present situation. They refer back to what took place then and I am trying to explain the exact position.
Comment on this
I will come to that in due course. You are going to hear something that will astonish you.
Comment on this
We had the dollars which we swapped for sterling and accumulated it gradually in the Central Bank. We had sterling and we borrowed the dollars. I well remember Paddy McGilligan was then Minister for Finance. His plan was that he issued a National Loan every year to meet the immense cost we had to meet to build hospitals and sanatoria. Remember, when we took office in 1948, if you wanted to get a TB child into hospital, it took 16 to 18 months. We built sanatoria then and a great many of the Fianna Fáil Party, who are now sitting there, said we were mad. We had to do all this building and we proceeded to do it as an emergency. As I said, Paddy McGilligan, as Minister for Finance, issued a National Loan and so far as that failed to meet the total amount of money we needed, we borrowed from the funds on deposit in the Central Bank that were there to pay back the Marshall Loan as it fell due.
Some of the younger men might ask: "If you got the £40 million in the Central Bank in exchange for the dollars, why did you not pay off the loan?" We did not pay it because the Americans would not take sterling. Sterling would be no good to pay a dollar loan in those days. We could only pay a dollar loan with dollars but we got the loan at 2½ per cent and we got it for five years interest-free, certainly with no obligation to pay the capital, and at the end of five years, we agreed to pay so much per annum of the capital and the interest at 2½ per cent, and now we are paying the Bank of Nova Scotia seven per cent and undertaking to pay it back in ten years. The Marshall Aid loan was to be paid in 40 years at 2½ per cent. So every year the Irish Government would borrow from the Counterpart Loan Fund in the Central Bank so much for ways and means advances to meet our capital requirements. We went out of office in 1951 and I want to read out to you what the account of that year showed.
The year we went out of office the account of the Minister for Finance with the Central Bank shows that there was a balance of £23,503,632 14s 10d lying on the desk of Deputy Seán MacEntee the day he went into office as Minister for Finance. Let us not forget that—£23,503,632 14s 10d. Now, I want to turn your attention to the account of the following year.
Comment on this
Listen, at the end of the following year, what was left? It was £267,000. What had become of the rest of it?
Comment on this
Every penny of it had been taken by Deputy Seán MacEntee not to build hospitals, not to build houses, not to construct roads, not to carry out any civic or urban amenity but to balance his Budget. What was the result? We had a raging, tearing inflation and the following year, we had Deputy MacEntee's famous Budget. Now, a great many of the younger Deputies will not remember that Budget, but it sacrificed and crucified our people to such an extent that they rose up in revolution and chased him out of the country in 1954 and ever since he has been like a sore thumb in the Fianna Fáil Party, until, eventually, they squeezed him out and when Deputy Jack Lynch, as Minister for Finance, found himself in difficulties this year, the dagger came stealing down Deputy MacEntee's sleeve and he wrote: "If he is in trouble, I know why: Because he let these necromancers and soothsayers dictate his policy".
That is the type of history I think the young fellows of this House ought to know. When you think, or when you are persuaded, or when you have people thinking that in 1948, Bill Norton, God be good to him, Tim Murphy and Michael Keyes—Brendan Corish was only a lad then and I do not think he was in the Government—prostituted their trust and when you are told they squandered the public money in collaboration with their Fine Gael colleagues and their Clann na Talmhan colleagues and their Clann na Poblachta colleagues in the Government, go down and take these accounts, which are still being kept because the fund is still there, and read the history of one of the greatest services ever done to this country.
First, there were thousands of families housed that would have been broken up and driven out of this country by emigration but for that fund and the masterly use made of it by the Government of which we were members. There are living monuments in every town and village to the extent to which they were financed by that fund. There are fathers of families today healthy and strong all over Ireland who would have been mouldering in their graves as a result of tuberculosis, but for the way we spent the money from that fund, and the glory of it is that as we look around the country today, one half the santatoria we built are empty. That is why we built them, so that 20 years afterwards, they would be like white elephants, empty. We want them empty, but we desperately wanted them in 1948 and they were all full the day they were built.
Was that extravagance? Was that folly? Go and ask the mothers who did not lose their children, go and ask the wives whose husbands survived to rear their families, go and ask the children would they have sooner never known their fathers than that we should have spent the money we spent to see that they survived. That is a story I wanted to tell and the documentation of it is no secret. There are public documents in the library of Dáil Éireann and any Deputy can go down and read and study them. There was never a read penny of net debt due to the United States of America in respect of the Marshall loan fund. It was purely a currency transaction, to secure the materials we bought to build houses, sanatoria and hospitals.
Do not forget that the day I took office as Minister for Agriculture, there were fewer cattle, fewer sheep and fewer pigs on the land of Ireland than at any time since the famine of 1847. That is the situation I was confronted with the day I came into the Department of Agriculture. I had to produce the pigs, the sheep and the cattle but there was no use producing them if I could not feed them. Do not forget that in 1948 Ymer feeding barely was unknown in this country. Do not forget this crop was unknown in Ireland. The only barley grown in Ireland in 1948 was malting barley, the average yield of which was 19 cwt. per statute acre. Ymer barley which yielded 40 cwt. per statute acre made it possible to feed our pigs from our own land, but the day I started, there was no grain crop available in this country that would economically feed pigs. The only place I could get grain to feed them was the United States of America and if I had not dollars to pay for it, the farmers of this country would have had to slaughter their pigs. I shall not talk about calves. That arose in the days gone by. I bought maize, hundreds of thousands of tons of maize, so that the farmers would have the wherewithal to feed their livestock.
I remember during that period we had no fertilisers in this country. The French would not sell us phosphate and they controlled it in Algiers. I remember a Dutch firm coming into the Department of Agriculture—I thought they were bluffing—and saying to me: "Minister, would you take 100,000 tons of super at £8 a ton?" I asked: "Are you offering it?" They said: "Yes, we are.""Well," I said "you have sold it", and I remember picking up the telephone and ringing Deputy McGilligan in the Department of Finance and saying to him: "Paddy, I have spent a million". He said to me: "In the name of God, what on?" I said: "On super for the farmers," and he said: "All right; I will find the money for any raw materials for the farmers". In one split second, because we had to, we brought into this country 100,000 tons of super, where there had not been a pound put out for the previous ten years.
So I would say to any young Fianna Fáil Deputy, if anyone talks to him about the £40 million again, let him go down to the Library and read those papers; let him go down to the sanatoria, empty now, and say to himself: "I myself might be in the grave and there might be Deputies here amongst us who would be dead and gone but for the sanatoria built by Dr. Noel Browne." But then there are none of the houses or livestock of this country which could not have been brought back to the levels at which they stood when we left the office if that currency had not been borrowed. Bear in mind, there was never a penny of net debt. We took in the dollars but no man got a dollar to spend who did not put down a pound in exchange for it. No, not one cent of that money was spent if it was not to buy raw materials for our agricultural industry, or the means of housing our people or to save those who must otherwise have died.
This is a vote of no confidence in the Government and you were apprehensive a moment ago, Sir, that I would be primarily concerned to deal with the vindication of things past. I do not want to talk about things past at all, except in so far as it is appropriate to set the present in its right perspective. This is a vote of censure on the Government and it is a demand upon them to get out and make way for other men. The ground upon which we make that motion is that we charge this Government with having deliberately, recklessly and improvidently led our people down the alluring road to an inflation and we are now faced with the moment of truth. Let us fact the truth for what it is. This country is bust.
Now, I know those are harsh words but let us make up our minds to this —do not let any Deputy imagine that the world of international finance will estimate our economic circumstances by what we say or do not say in Dáil Éireann. They knew all that we knew six months ago. They sit in Zurich; they sit in Wall Street; they sit in Threadneedle Street; they sit in Sweeden. Their business is to know and they are not one bit impressed by Ministers for Finance here, or Taoisigh, or anybody else, who get up and say: "Everything in the garden is lovely". They put the statistics through the computers; they look at the picture that comes out and they mutter under their breath: "Not bloody likely". And, when we go to borrow 10 million in Eurodollars, or USA dollars, or any other dollars, we cannot find the man we want to meet; he is at a tea party. The next day we go to call, he has gone to the country; the following week he has received an urgent call to leave for California and, in the heel of the hunt, we come home without the Eurodollars.
Then we go to Bonn and we say to them: "We are the only country in the world on which you never declared war; is it not time we did something about it?" And they say: "Well, I suppose it is"—£7 million, and we borrow £7 million, but, when it comes to the practical question about terms of repayment, they are seven per cent for 15 years, and we come home with the £7 million rejoicing, only to discover that we have spent it before we got it. We have spent it, not to build hospitals, not to build houses, not to invest in industries but to balance last year's Budget, £50 million of which were to pay the previous years' debts.
Then we go to negotiate a loan in London and the Minister for Finance gets very angry with me, shocked, dismayed, distressed and, mind you, he is a nice, decent kind of fellow— Deputy Jack Lynch—and he says— I quote him from columns 1615 and 1616, volume 223, of the Official Report of 29th June, 1966:
According to Deputy Dillon, the country, and I want to quote him, "had its back to the wall and never stood in greater economic peril than it is in today". These assertions, I think, went beyond legitimate criticism of the Government, both as being untrue and harmful to the country's credit and reputation. He made other assertions which I think I can establish as being unfounded as well. I hesitate to repeat these lest I give them further currency but I can only describe them as not only hysterical but malicious—the assertions that this Government were unable to raise £5 million in sterling and that the general reserves of the Central Bank were, again to use his own particular term, "gone and spent".
Indeed, the announcement on the day following the Deputy's remarks, 15th June, of the negotiation of a loan of £5 million on good market conditions and good market terms with the Bank of Nova Scotia gave the lie to these assertions.
Now, my assertion was that we went to negotiate a loan in London and we failed to get a loan in London. We then went to the Bank of Nova Scotia, which we had admitted to this country not so long ago, and we said to the Bank of Nova Scotia: The Joint Stock Banks of this country have been on strike for the last two months; now you have raked in a lot of deposits here; what are you going to do with them? I suggest you did not come in here for a month, or 12 months; you came in here to stay. We expect you to cough up and, if you do not cough up, we will not burn down the houses around you, but we will remember it and we can get very awkward out here. And the Bank of Nova Scotia said: "Now do you want anything?"; to which we replied: "Yes, £5 million." The Bank of Nova Scotia said: "That is all right, but what about paying it back?" What were the terms for paying it back? —seven per cent and ten years. I want to ask the House this question. Has any other sovereign Government in Europe, Asia, Africa, America, or Australia ever borrowed £5 million at seven per cent with an undertaking to pay it back in ten years?
I want to put this analogy. The Minister for Finance is a kindly and a friendly man. If I met him one morning and said: "Look, Jack, I left my wallet at home. There is something I want to pay. Will you give me £10?", he would take out his wallet and give me £10. But if I sidled up to him and said: "Would you ever lend me half a crown?" he would say: "What in the name of God has happened to Dillon? Is he drinking secretly?" I do not think he would say it maliciously. He would go to the other Ministers and say: "Do you know what happened to me this morning? Dillon came sidling up to me and asked for a loan of half a crown. He must be bust. Is there anything wrong with him?"
Is that a fair analogy? I think it is, and that is what causes me alarm. You may ask yourself why is it that we are driven to this extremity. I am obliged to say that in my considered judgment, we are driven to this extremity because we have borrowed every penny the Joint Stock Banks in this country are in a position to lend. We owe the Joint Stock Banks on the short-term a debt of £60 million sterling. I want to tell the House that to the best of my information the Joint Stock Banks told the Government, when they went to them before the strike to ask for a further loan, that they had not got it and could not lend it. To the best of my knowledge and belief, they got from the Government the reply: "If you have not got it, go and get it from your customers."
I now assert that until the banks closed, there was pressure being brought to bear on businessmen in this country, small and large, to reduce their overdrafts at a pace and to a level which put many of them in very serious peril of survival. It is very difficult to explain to people who are not in business how vital an element to an ordinary small business in this country bank overdraft accommodation is. I remember saying to the Government when they brought in the turnover tax that one of the progeny of that tax would be the arrival of Garfield—Weston Tesco and all the big international combines, with a corresponding burden thrown on small family businesses who would have to compete with those great combines.
I remember saying to the Government: "Do not be under any illusion. These big combines are prepared to spend £½ million, £1 million or £2 million to do what they call making the market." What does making the market mean? It means closing up 20 or 30 shops in the neighbourhood which are competing with them. While these people, our own neighbours, our own people, are fighting for their lives to meet that kind of competition, our own people, are fighting for their lives to meet that kind of competition, our own Government come up behind them with a stiletto and sink it in their backs by saying to the banks: "Go to John Byrne or Pat Tynan and tell him, battling as he is with the big combines who are trying to take his business away from him: ‘You must reduce your overdraft by £1,000 by this day three months or get out.'" Between Tesco on the one side and the banks on the other, he is out.
I beg Deputies to listen to this story I am telling now. They will never hear from the victims who are about to die because if you are a small businessman and the word goes around that you are under pressure from the bank, you might as well go out and cut your throat on the market square. The minute the word goes out that a small businessman has been sent for by the bank manager, or if he is seen looking worried going along the street to the bank, all the commercial travellers in the whole province leap into their cars and fly like the wind to line up in a queue outside his door.
They greet him: "Good morning, Mr. Fleming. You are looking well. I am glad to see you. I have a little business with you." Then they produce the bill. If Pat Fleming is lucky enough to have the money to pay the bill, he is all right, but if he says he will post it on, the traveller is off like a scalded cat to the nearest hotel to tell the other travellers: "I gave Pat Fleming a bill for £17 3s 4d and he told me he would post it." They are all down on him and Pat Fleming's credit is gone. I am not naming any individual. It could be John Smith. I am talking of my own neighbours in Monaghan, Clones, Castleblayney, Ballaghaderreen or Elphin.
When I say the country has gone bust, what I mean is that our own Government are reduced to straits which constrain them to join in the crucifixion of our own people. I do not think I am guilty of any exaggeration, I do not think I am guilty of any reckless language, if in those circumstances I say the country is bust. A country does not sink under the sea if it is bankrupt and bust. What happens is that the people suffer. I now allege that the kind of people I came from, the kind of people I belong to, are suffering. I now allege that old-established businesses, which are run on what I suppose might be described as old-fashioned lines, where the employees are friends and have been with the business for ten, 20, 30 or 40 years, are being wiped out and not only the owners but the workers are being put on the road. I say a country whose Government are constrained to act in that fashion is bust.
That alone would not, in my opinion, adequately describe the syndrome of being "bust." You must add to that the fact that in the capital city of Ireland any family of fewer than five people living in one room will not even be considered for a house, while at the same time we see London public companies coming into the country, buying up property and building skyscrapers to be let at 25/-or £1 per square foot.
Am I justified in saying the country is bust? Am I justified in saying we have got our priorities madly wrong? We have allowed people to come in and build skyscrapers and let them at £1 or 25/- per square foot while we cannot find a place for a family of five persons—father, mother and three children—living in one room, bearing in mind that since 1963 no residential unit in this city has been condemned as unfit for human habitation by Dublin Corporation. There are two branches of the corporation dealing with habitations: one is the architectural department which exists to find out what buildings are in danger of falling down and injuring people; the other is the sanitary section which determines whether a room or house or cottage is fit for human habitation. I now allege that there has not been a single condemnation of a building or a room in this city since 1963 on the ground that it was unfit for human habitation and I know of houses, I know of rooms, which are rat-infested, damp, unhealthy and dangerous to health and in some of them a father, mother and three children are living, cooking, eating and sleeping while we are building skyscrapers to set at 20/- or 25/- per square foot.
It is not people who have no place to work in, not people who could not do their work if these skyscrapers were not there who are being put into them. It is people who have been working in offices better than I ever had, people who have been working in Georgian and Victorian Buildings, some of them erected at the end of the last century but much better than any office I have ever worked in in my life. They have now moved in, largely Government employees, into two floors at a time because we took a lease of two floors of a new building for I do not know how many years and undertook to spend £80,000 decorating it before ever we went in. I think we are stark, starting mad.
I am not talking about ulterior motives. All I am asking is did I say too much, did I speak too harshly when I said a country in that situation is bust? We have sold ourselves; we have sold the things that matter for money. My God, if the British Government had attempted to do that by fire and sword 100 years ago, is there a man or woman in this House who would not have gone out and manned the barricades to stop them? If the British Government by force had said: "We will put the bloody Irish out; we will put them to live five in a room so that the servants of the State and of the plutocracy will have wall to wall carpeting, central heating and airconditioning", what would we have said? We would have said: "Not bloody likely, so long as we are here to fight".
What staggers me, what terrifies me is that the British and the Germans and the Americans have discovered they can conquer us with a cheque book, we who are the children and the grandchildren of men and women who fought with their bare hands in their bare feet. I remember my father told me he saw them walking to meet Parnell in the town of Ennis to fight the Vandeleur evictions in their bare feet and with nothing but their bare hands. Why? Because Vandeleur wanted to put them in the workhouse and they fought for their homes because they would not submit. If Vandeleur had known, the right way was for Vandeleur to come around with his cheque book and say: "How much?"
It makes me quite ill. I do not know if anybody else feels that way. Have we all changed? Are we all corrupt? We have just moved ourselves into a great air-conditioned five-storey building, carpeted from wall to wall. I do not complain about that: I think it is reasonable that the premises in which we work should be efficient, but as we are sitting here, do we think of the families of five in one room? What appals me is that sometimes I do not think we are thinking of them. We think of them sometimes in a vague, general kind of way. Are we thinking now of a mother, living with her husband and three children in one room? She has sent the father out to work, perhaps sent one or two of the children to school and put the baby in a corner with a bottle.
There she is now washing potatoes for the father's dinner. The children will probably come home and she will have to feed them. She will have to give the baby a bottle. She has to try to keep the room clean; she has to make the beds. She must say to herself: "If he goes out to the pub tonight, can I blame him? If he is not going to the pub but to a place where there is mixed bathing, can I blame him?" In conscience, she could not blame him. He has come home to one room, three children and a wife worn out trying to make ends meet.
Would any of us like it? The husband comes home to a worn-out woman. He has his wages and he can say: "I have the money to pay for a house but I was down at the corporation today and they told me they will not put me on the list." All would be well if he could say to her that he had been put on the list, that she would have to hang on perhaps for 12 months but he had been promised a house. If he had been put on the list, he would have been told by the corporation of the houses they were building and the claims for those houses. All he can tell her is that he had not even been put on the list.
I never was poor. Sometimes that is a disadvantage. I do not know what it means to have been hungry. Maybe I would be all the better for it if I had. Maybe it is because I have never been poor, never hungry, that I feel such compassion and personal distress at the thought of the misery of my neighbours. I cannot dissociate myself from them. I cannot think of them as other people: I was born among them and I lived among them in George's Street in this city in the early years of my life. The rest of the time I have spent in the country. They are my neighbours and I know no difference between them and me. I know how they face their problems.
I love this parliamentary system of Government because I know it to be the true symbol of freedom, but how long can people be patient and accept it, if it proves so callous and indifferent to their intolerable woes? The problem in rural Ireland is not as unbearable as in the city. Even in rural Ireland it is not a good thing for a young couple to have to go and live with a father and mother but it is not as intolerable as it is in the city. In rural Ireland there is the farmyard: there is the road; there is the crossroads. The young man can take the father down to the crossroads and if he wants to take his wife to the pictures occasionally, the mother will look after the baby.
However, it is a great evil that the authorities in this country cannot build the houses so urgently needed in rural Ireland. It is even a greater evil that we are urging the young people to get married when the first thing any sensible girl would ask a chap who wanted to marry her is: "Have we a house?" If he says: "We have. We have my father's house," she goes out and she sees the house without water, and other facilities, a house which maybe 150 years ago was comfortable, and she says: "How am I going to keep the place clean?" and he says: "You can go to the well for water." She replies: "Maybe I am in love with you but I am not all that much in love with you."
That fellow goes to the local authority; he has the money to put down a deposit and he has the income to pay the interest on the loan. He says he wants a Small Dwellings Acquisition loan to build himself a house. In County Monaghan if he makes application now, he will be told his application will not be considered for at least 12 months. Some of my colleagues may think perhaps I am unduly conscious of my age, but there are some of them young enough to realise that if you are in love and you want to get married, there is nothing standing between you and the altar but a house. You have the bird but you have no cage to put it in, and there is a danger that somebody else might provide the cage or find a more attractive cage than the one you have. You go to the bank manager and he says: "I would not lend you 6d." You inquire if there is anywhere else you can get the money, and the answer is "No, you will have to go without it for the present." This may be considered a problem for the young, but it is not their problem only. It is the problem of us all. We who are in middle age ought to understand the problems of the young. It is really their problem, but they have not the means nor the wisdom to resolve it.
I say the Government that cannot give that help to our own people are "bust". Am I wrong in saying that? I do not think so. I represent Monaghan, and I live in Mayo. Those are two congested areas at the present moment. The rural improvements schemes, the special employments schemes, and the bog roads schemes are all being closed down in these counties. That does not only mean that a variety of amenities are going to be withheld from people. It means the ganger, the supervisor, the other people who got temporary work to help out with their income are being refused employment, and it means they are going to England because they have no other means of subsistence. Am I wrong in saying a Government which finds itself in these circumstances is "bust"?
Does anybody maintain that Deputy Gibbons is doing it out of malice? I think he is doing it because he has not got the money. We find poor Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Local Government, being lambasted because he will not provide houses and finance sewerage and all the other things local authorities want to do. I often feel compassion for him. I think he wants to do it, that he would like to do it, but the answer is he has not the money. That is the one alibi he cannot advance here because as a member of the Government, he has to accept responsibility with the rest of them.
These are the facts as I see them. Some Deputies may think I have spoken too strongly if I say a country which is reduced to these circumstances is "bust". I do not, and I claim I have the right to say that now, because I warned them of it years ago. At great political cost I went out to the country and I warned the people, not yesterday or a month ago or a year ago, but two years ago. Fifteen times at public meetings during the general election and the by-election campaigns I warned people of the dangers that lay ahead. Fianna Fáil beat us in Cork and Kildare, the two dearest by-elections that ever were bought in the history of this nation.
Comment on this
But we beat them in North-East Dublin, in Roscommon and in Galway, and Labour defeated them in Cork. Then we had the election with the slogan "Let Lemass Lead On." We were told: "If you let Lemass lead on, there will be nothing but milk and honey for all our people, and all the prophets of doom are saboteurs." Now I am entitled to stand up and ask: "Who spoke the truth? Who kept faith with our people, and who betrayed them?"
I want to deal with another matter about which the Minister for Finance, in his usual decent kind of way, expressed great distress. At column 1616, volumn 223 of the Official Report of 29th June, 1966, he said:
The validity of the other assertions can be judged from the fact, and I want to stress this particularly for the benefit of Deputy Dillon, that the assets of the general fund of the Central Bank stand at over £100 million, of which £75 million is in gold and in foreign securities. These assets, I would like to remind the Deputy, are distinct from those of the Legal Tender Note Fund which amount to about £110 million. However much astray Deputy Dillon may be led by his horrible imaginings and reckless utterances, this country's financial position is sound.
Mr. Dillon: I hope you are right.
He was referring to my statement reported in the same column where he said:
... the assertions that this Government were unable to raise £6 million in sterling and that the general reserves of the Central Bank were, again to use his own particular term, "gone and spent".
I know these are very important statements to make. I know that my word carries some authority in the country and I must not make statements which are not provable up to the hilt, especially about matters relating to finance or to the Central Bank of the country. Therefore, I felt it my duty to bring here for inspection by every Deputy the reports of the Central Bank. I refer to the annual report of the Central Bank 1963-64 which says:
Of the assets in the Legal Tender Note Fund at 31st March 1964 totalling £100,123,967 the value of currency and securities of the Federal Government of the United States of America was £11,056,428 11s 5d. On the same date total advances to the Minister for Finance under subsection (7) of Section 3 of the Bretton Woods Agreements Act, 1957 amounted to £5,877,365 1s 1d, the sum advanced under this head during the year having been £1,064,525 4s 2d. The amount of the Balance in the General Fund on 31st March 1964 was £22,448,535 10s.
I now allege that the Government borrowed that from the Central Bank last year on foot of the funding operations they carried out to redeem the Treasury Bills that they were not in a position to renew and they issued a £20 million loan to the Joint Stock Banks on the understanding that, if the Joint Stock Banks would take it up, the Central Bank would take it off their hands and use that fund to do it.
Now we wonder how he could have the daring to deny that. I want to tell you how. He knows, or at least his advisers know, that these are very complex matters and very intricate matters and, as you observe, the prospect of educating the Fianna Fáil Party, of which not one single member is now present in the House, except the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, is extremely laborious. I do not blame them. The truth is harsh and one must not complain if they cannot listen to it. I refer the House to the Report of the Central Bank for 1964/65, page 16. Listen:
To provide greater flexibility in rediscount operations, to extend the capacity of the Central Bank to act as lender of last resort and generally to develop operations through the General Fund, a transfer of assets from the Legal Tender Note Fund was made under the authority of an order made by the Minister for Finance, at the request of the Central Bank, on 29 August, 1961, entitled Legal Tender Note Fund (Additional Form of Asset) Order, 1961. This order empowered the Central Bank to include among the assets of the Legal Tender Note Fund a Balance in the General Fund. At the same time the Minister made consequential regulations entitled "Central Bank of Ireland (Form of Statement of Accounts) Regulations, 1961" to provide for the new item in the accounts of the two Funds. In exercise of the new power a transfer from the Legal Tender Note Fund to the General Fund of British Government securities and cash amounting in total to £20 million was made on 30 November 1961. On 6 February 1963 the Board of the Central Bank decided to allow the balance in the General Fund to be held in the Legal Tender Note Fund to fluctuate between £20 million and £22 million. On 11 November 1963 the upper limit was increased to £25 million.
That is the last reference we have and I draw the attention of the House to this significant fact: the Report of the Central Bank for 1965-66 has not been published. This is the first year in my memory that the Report of the Central Bank was not available before 1st July. It is true that last year they published quarterly reports but the annual general report has not been published. It may be due to the printing strike or to a variety of factors. I have not got the annual report for this year but I challenge the Minister for Finance to deny that he got from the joint stock banks of this country last year £20 million of a funding loan to repay Treasury Bills that he was not in a position to renew, on the understanding that that would be taken over from the joint stock banks by the Central Bank out of its General Fund.
Perhaps I have delayed the House somewhat long but these are matters that I want to put on record because it is very important that they should be put on record. The House will notice with satisfaction that, without reference to my notes, I have managed to dispose of a great many of them.
I want to sound a note of warning to Deputy Moore, who has kindly come in to join us, to Deputy Geoghegan from Carna, who is here vigilantly watching the interests of the Gaeltacht and to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs whose body may be in Dublin but whose heart and whose spirit, no doubt, are in West Donegal. I want to warn the House of a very serious development in the agricultural industry. I think Deputy Paddy Smith had the best intentions in the world when he brought in the heifer scheme. I had grave misgivings about it, but, I must be honest, when it came to formulating those misgivings I found it very hard to crystallise them in my own mind but I had an instinctive feeling that this represented so radical an interference with the ordinary flow of a thing like the livestock industry that there were grave dangers inherent in it and I was apprehensive on behalf of the small farmer. The worst of my apprehensions have come to pass.
I want to warn the House that as of today strong cattle in forward condition are doing fairly well; strong cattle in thin condition are selling badly but the kind of cattle that are kept by the people I represent in this House and the people amongst whom I live in Mayo, the cattle from 12 months to 18 or 20 months, are unsaleable. Cattle for which I could have got £50 this day 12 months, I would not get £30 for today and most people are not asked where they are going when they drive them to a fair. I warn that that is creating an acute problem in the congested areas of Ireland.
We are now joined by Deputy O'Connor from Kerry. They come in in ones and go out in ones. I think Deputy O'Connor will confirm what I say.
Comment on this
At 12 months and 18 months. Advanced cattle are at the highest price they ever reached.
Comment on this
Do not let us quarrel. Deputy O'Connor will tell us what he knows; we will tell what we know. My experience is that the beast for which I could get £50 this day 12 months, I cannot get £30 for now. I can get £30 if I can find a buyer.
Comment on this
The cattle I had were well done. I had not run out of grass or silage until the grass began to grow. I agree that there is a lot of poor cattle and that is one of the by-products of a scheme I think Deputy Smith initiated with the best of intentions but he had the misfortune in the year when the increase in the young cattle came — this year — that we had the worst winter I remember and the latest spring. I think Deputy O'Connor will sympathise with me. I am warning the House that there is a condition of acute crisis amongst small farmers I know. I am a small farmer and a shopkeeper serving small farmers. Ask any small farmer or any shopkeeper serving them and they will tell you that it is not the bank strike that prevents the small farmer from buying a hat for the wife or a lb of tea or boots for the children. They have the money in the jug if they have it at all. The trouble is, they cannot sell their stock.
I do not know what business I have to warn the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs but he is all I have to warn. He is there cocked in front of me. I suppose he will tell his colleagues. I am bound to tell you. I need not tell you that egg production is dead. That is not the fault of our Government. That is due to the fact that the British are now producing a surplus and are themselves egg exporters and the British market for eggs is gone and we are sharing that misfortune with the Danes. But pigkeeping is becoming uneconomic for the smallholder. There is a combination of reasons for that. One is that the grading has become too complicated and, secondly, the people in the factory kind of production of 500, 1,000 and 2,000 pigs, have adopted entirely new techniques and they can take a profit of about 10/- a pig, turning them out in hundreds and thousands, which the small farmer cannot live on. It is the same kind of thing as the broiler fowl have done to the fowl industry that you knew in the old days in West Cork and parts of Kerry where it was very profitable. It has been wiped out by the broiler industry.
Sheepkeeping on the small farm is becoming a very grave problem. I know some of my colleagues feel the fall in the price of sheep and lambs at the moment is a great menace. I think that dramatic fall at present is possibly a passing phase but there is this problem that keeping sheep on small holdings gives rise to problems of infestation of the land with worms and the old traditional problem of fluke is making sheepkeeping on smallholdings more and more complex. I agree that so far as mountain sheepkeeping is concerned — and Deputy O'Connor probably knows a good deal more about that than I do coming, as he does, from Kerry — it may not be so badly affected but I mean small farmers in Monaghan, Cavan, Mayo and these areas.
I am just warning the House. There is one remedy and one remedy only. I am coming to the end of what I have to say. I implore the country to face this. There is only one hope of stopping the haemorrhage of people from the land because no young man is going back to try to farm under the conditions I have described. He will not stay on a holding of 30 or 40 acres which, in my boyhood, was wealth. He is just leaving it and going into industrial employment in England in preference to it. There is only one hope of saving the situation — if we are not too late — and that is the immediate and urgent implementation of the parish plan. The maddening thing to me is that the Minister for Agriculture is starting pilot areas and this plan and that plan and the real fact is that he is moving over to the parish plan and is ashamed to say so. Nothing but a crash programme can save the small farm and for the first time in my life, I am obliged to say in public with full sense of responsibility that I am not certain any longer that it is possible to save it.
I think this is largely as a result of our own failure to put the parish plan into operation in time and reorganise the whole life of the small farmer in rural Ireland on an effective co-operative basis. We could have done that at one time. I remember when we started the land project and when we had the Young Farmers Association starting. We had the enthusiastic young men then who would have been able to do it. I doubt if they would be so enthusiastic now.
I have a great regard for Deputy Dowling. He reminded me yesterday of an old French grenadier coming back from the siege of Moscow, staggering along with his bayonet bent and his shoes flapping as he tramped through the Fianna Fáil snow but with his last shot he was trying to fight it out to the bitter end. I like a man who can fight to the end. But he has a hard task. Every time he goes to his constituency in Dublin South-West his life must be agony. He is as brave as a lion. He had his papers there and he was diverted from them but he returned to them. He dropped the papers and picked them up again and carried on but eventually he threw his hat at it and went out. As he went, I said to myself: "That is a loyal old grenadier. He does not let down his own." I like that. I am not sure that all the grenadiers are as loyal. I see some heads poking out through the portholes looking for the hawser.
I do not believe it is a healthy thing to have Dáil Éireann full of rumours of which the country does not know. The rumour floating around this House for the last couple of months is that the Taoiseach is going to retire.
Comment on this
You must say one thing for the Taoiseach: he is as hardworking a public servant as this country ever saw. Nobody will deny him that. If he did not work half as hard, he might not have done half as much harm. Nobody will deny he worked hard: his worst enemy could not do that, but it is a common rumour that he is going to resign. To tell the truth, I think he would be very well advised to do it. There comes a time in the life of every man when he has done his part and it is no harm for him to move on to fresh woods and pastures new. That is one rumour. A second rumour is that the Minister for Finance is going to succeed him after all the bloody bodies in the battle for succession have been laid in parallel rows, having slaughtered one another. I think poor Deputy Lynch will be the ultimate victim and will be the next Taoiseach to control the warriors. He will not be troubled with that burden very long if my judgment of politics is worth anything.
I want to mention this aspiration of his. I wish people would read the speech he made in the Seanad last week when he said that everything was lovely, that the sun was coming up over the horizon and that we could all throw off our coats and bask in it. Capri would be nothing to Ireland. I wish he would go and tell that to the hotel keepers in Rosslare. However, I think he will get the job. It is right that the people of the country should know what is going on but if he is going to take up that position, I hope he will learn a little more economics than he now appears to know. I cannot undertake the task of educating him. I have been at it too long but he should get some other mentor because whoever is instructing him now is off the beam. He may have degrees a mile long but what he badly wants is a year's residence in proximity to our own people. When all the theses are written and when all the soothsayers have finished saying "sooth" and when all the necromancers have concluded their magic and their tricks, it is ordinary people like myself and Deputy Moore and the Deputy from Kerry who live among and understand our people who are the best advisers on policy for Ireland. It was not right for Deputy MacEntee to say what he said when he said it but there was a hell of a lot of truth in what he said.
Here is the last word I have to say. Mr. Roosa delivered a lecture in Washington recently and explained how an expanding economy, an investment in expansion, depends on a stable cost of living. I beg Deputies to read it. I shall not read it to the House now but I shall show it to Deputies: here it is. It is available to anybody who writes and asks for it to the Per Jacobson Foundation, Washington, D.C. If anyone wants it, I shall give him the address. He has only to ask for it and he will get it.
It was Mr. Frere, speaking under the same patronage in the context of a rising cost of living and a decline in the value of money, who said:
In the presence of unstable money, the country's economy is, in any case, destined to stagnate until such time as the Government collapse and make way for new men.
That time has come in Ireland. When my friend, Deputy Dowling, from South Dublin says, in effect, "You did not make any constructive suggestion in the course of this long debate", I shall make to him, in conclusion, the same suggestion as I made when I began. There is only one constructive proposal that Fine Gael or any responsible Opposition could make in our present circumstances, "bust" as we are: go away and make room for new men.
Comment on this
I regret I was obliged to miss most of the entertainment which was undoubtedly provided by Deputy Dillon, as usual. However, it was a pleasure to know, even in the short portion of his speech I heard, that he has not lost any of his touch. I think I can honestly say, probably in company with all the members of this House, that there is no Deputy to whom it is a greater pleasure to listen than Deputy Dillon. One can always be sure of excellent entertainment. Mark you, whether one can be equally sure of enlightenment is a different matter.
Comment on this
The purpose of this debate is, of course, to review the economy of the State and the performance of the Government in relation to the economy and in relation to all aspects of Government policy. It does appear to me, from what has been said on the Fine Gael benches, in particular, earlier in the debate, and even from the short amount I have heard from Deputy Dillon, that certain things have gone to their heads. It perpetually amazes me how the Fine Gael Party can, with monotonous regularity, go into an election saying— and I think believing — that they will win and, having lost, come back and tell us and the country that they have won. I suppose it is a defence mechanism which has been built in, over the years, in a Party who have not now, who have not had for many years and who never will in the future have any prospect whatsoever of forming a Government as a Party on their own.
Comment on this
I know they cannot read the signs. For their own peace of mind, perhaps it is just as well that they cannot, but, for the rest of us, it is necessary, perhaps, now and again to draw attention to the facts. We know that the recent Presidential election has been regarded apparently by the Fine Gael Party as an indication that they are going to sweep the country.
Comment on this
It might be worth while spending a little time dwelling on just what can be read into the Presidential election. In the first place, it is quite clear that the Fine Gael Party went into the election and conducted the campaign on the basis that they were asking people to vote against the Government. It is equally clear that we went into the election telling the people that this was not the issue before the people, that the issue was the election of the best man for President.
Comment on this
I am merely repeating what was said during the election. At this stage, the election is over.
Comment on this
The last speaker was able to make his speech without interruptions. I cannot see why the interruptions should now begin.
Comment on this
It is always a pleasure to me to be interrupted by the Fine Gael Deputies because then I know I am getting amongst them. The Fine Gael Party contested this election on the basis of a vote of no confidence in the Government and they contested it in circumstances which could hardly have been more favourable to them, and they know that, because, of course, we were going through a very difficult economic situation.
Comment on this
Our attitude was that we were not fighting a political campaign and this presented us with great difficulties because there we were, being attacked on our policies and unable to defend ourselves. We fought with one hand tied behind our backs.
Comment on this
If one accepts that it was a test of the unpopularity of the Government, do not forget that we won.
Comment on this
This, of course, was not a test of the Government, as far as I am concerned. If it were, the Fine Gael Party would know that they had been in a political election.
Comment on this
Let us keep this in perspective. This talk of sweeping the country and Deputy Dillon telling the Government to get out: let us get it in perspective. If, on your own terms, there was a test before the people, you lost the test.
Comment on this
In the usual Fine Gael fashion, an effort was made to cash in on difficulties but even those difficulties were not enough to help them. However, we are getting over the difficulties now. Fine Gael, of course, conveniently forget that people cannot refrain from comparing the way these difficulties were handled with the way they were handled when a similar situation arose ten years ago when Fine Gael formed the main part of the Government.
Comment on this
——but the symptoms were somewhat similar. The principal difficulty was the balance of payments problem, but it was accompanied by other difficulties, too. It has not escaped the notice of many people that, in dealing with the situation now, we had this advantage: since 1959, the country was making unprecedented strides, averaging an annual growth rate of four per cent and that, of course, helped the economy very much to take the strain. Perhaps more important was the fact that, unlike our predecessors in 1956, we did not panic, but every effort was made on the other side of this House to cause us to panic. We did not panic. We took the measures necessary, and no more measures than were necessary, and in quite a short time, signs are already showing that these measures are paying off and, by the end of the year, we shall certainly be back on an even keel again.
Comment on this
I do not wish to waste the time of the House by giving a lecture to Deputy Coogan on borrowed money.
Comment on this
It would appear that even members of the Fine Gael Front Bench have not yet grasped the fact that the economy of today is somewhat different from the economy that existed when money did not exist but, perhaps, they will eventually catch up with what is happening.
Comment on this
There was, of course, an international capital shortage, balance of payments difficulties in other countries, particularly in Britain, inflation. All these things, apart from any difficulties within our own economy, contributed to the difficulty. But there is one thing of which we can all be certain, that is, that had this difficulty been tackled in the only way known apparently to the Coalition Government, the position today would be very much worse and our prospects of recovery would be much more remote.
I should like to comment on some of the references made in this debate. I understand Deputy Lindsay made a reference to some previous speeches by a colleague of mine: all I want to say about that is that I think the frog-loving, birch-wielding, Tory Fíor-Gheal from Mayo, Deputy Lindsay, would do well, before he talks in terms like that, to examine his own past speeches.
Comment on this
Ní thuigfeadh an Teachta mé. Tá a fhios agam go raibh air leathscéal a ghabháil leis an muintir ina Dháil-cheantar féin toisc nach raibh Gaeilge aige. Ní chuirim aon mhilleón air faoi sin ach ná bíodh sé ag iarraidh dallamullóg a chur orainn anso faoin Ghaeilge.
Comment on this
Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Lindsay tried to suggest that changes in the Government were, in effect, designed to effect changes of policy.
Comment on this
I can understand in a way that Deputy Lindsay and Deputy Cosgrave might make this mistake because they have no real experience of Government. Their only experience was in a Coalition Government in which the idea of collective responsibility did not exist.
Comment on this
But they are now dealing with a real Government in which collective responsibility does exist and in which policies are the policies of the Government and not of individual Ministers. If they have any doubt about that, they will find out quick enough.
Comment on this
Furthermore, I noticed that recently in the debate on the nomination of Deputy Seán Flanagan as Minister for Health — I think it was on that occasion — Deputy Cosgrave referred to what he called my expressed views in favour of the replacement of the English language by Irish. I noticed also that in a document issued recently by the Fine Gael Party a number of references in similar vein. Now it is true that there is a group of cranks in existence who have been making this allegation for some time.
Comment on this
They are people who claim to be devoted to freedom— language freedom. They have some peculiar ideas of freedom, which appear to include agitation, quite forceful agitation, against the decision of His Grace, Most Rev. Dr. McQuaid, Archbishop of Dublin, to provide one Mass in Irish out of six, or more.
Comment on this
Their idea of freedom is not my idea of freedom and I doubt if it is that of many other people. However, from a group such as that I suppose one could not expect anything better, but I think one is entitled to expect something better from Deputy Cosgrave and Fine Gael, the main Opposition Party. One might reasonably expect, I think, that Deputy Cosgrave and his Party, before making such references would take the trouble to find out exactly what I did say.
Comment on this
I shall make my own speech. The speech to which reference was made was made by me in Cork to Cumann na Mean Mhuinteoirí. It was made in Irish and was inaccurately reported in English in some of the papers and only portion of the relevant section of my address was used.
Comment on this
I am not blaming the Press; I am blaming Fine Gael because they have tried to base an alleged policy on what I am supposed to have said.
Comment on this
We will now check what I did say. There are some people, I suppose, who would be uncharitable enough to say they did check but do not mind misrepresenting the position. I prefer to take the more charitable view that the misrepresentation was due to the usual Fine Gael lazy amateurism, their failure to do their homework, a failure to which the Taoiseach has referred on numerous occasions.
Comment on this
I propose now to give the exact words I used. I want to make it clear that I did not say on that occasion that I wanted this country to be a country of one language and that that language should be English.
Comment on this
If Deputy L'Estrange would pay a little attention, instead of spewing out silly remarks, remarks which are not based on fact, he might learn something and, as a result, he might make less of a fool of himself. I am trying to save the Fine Gael Party from themselves. The actual words I used were in Irish and the translation into English — I should say I was referring to the policy which had been adopted at the foundation of the State in relation to the teaching of Irish in the schools — for those who apparently did not understand what I said in Irish was:
It is unnecessary in any case to go beyond the scientific principle of osmosis which ordains that it is the stronger solution which absorbs the weaker and not the reverse.
Unilingualism was the aim and Irish was to be the language. That aim was based, of course, on the incontrovertible principle that there is no such thing as a bilingual community or a bilingual culture. Nothing such exists anywhere. There are communities which have two languages, or even more— Belgium, Holland, Switzerland, for example. But in each such case the communities existing within the greater community are basically unilingual: that is they have one language as a mould and thesaurus for creative literature and a second (or even a third) language as a means of communication with the world outside.... That is a linguistic fact which cannot be gain-said.
Therefore the philosophy which ordained that Irish should be restored through the schools was fundamentally sound. But the mistake which was made was to believe that that could be done suddenly. It was not understood that there would be more than one stage in the process: that as a first step a basic knowledge of the language would have to be imparted to the great majority of the people of the country; that there would then be a period—however long or short— when all the people would know both Irish and English, but that Irish during that period would be more a means of communication than a vehicle of culture; and finally, as Irish gained strength, that it would eventually take the place of English as the vehicle of culture so that English would be (finally) the second language, the language of converse with the world outside.
Comment on this
Give it to us now in the Irish language so we can have it on the records of the House. That is only a translation of what you said.
Comment on this
Will the Minister answer this? Why have young men in the Gaeltacht who have passed the examination in Irish with top marks been turned down for the Garda because they have not sufficient English? I have several cases of that. There is no sincerity in all this.
Comment on this
I propose to refer further to another statement I made, of which I think the Fine Gael Party are aware but to which they carefully make no reference when talking about this matter. I said that at no stage had I ever advocated the abandonment of English in this country and that, in fact, if by any chance we found ourselves without English, we would have to start in the morning to learn English, because it is obvious that we must have at least one world language and preferably more than one. It would be crazy for us to think otherwise. Those are the facts. As I say, I am trying to save the Fine Gael Party from themselves in basing any of their alleged policies on misconceptions.
Comment on this
How can the Deputy say that? Has he not heard what I have said? He has listened to what Fine Gael said I said. Would he listen to what I did say? This is what I am trying to save the Fine Gael Party from. You can take the facts if you want to or you can be dishonest and not take the facts.
Comment on this
The Minister is entitled to make his contribution to this debate without interruption. If Deputy Coogan feels he has something to contribute, he can wait for the opportunity but he cannot say it by way of interruption. I will not allow interruptions.
Comment on this
The Minister is making a speech, if the Deputy does not mind, and this is not Question Time.
Comment on this
If we could get away from what is really, I suppose, a storm in a teacup, we might get on to the subject this debate should really be about. I want to suggest to the members of the Labour Party that really it is time they stopped trying to appropriate James Connolly to themselves. It is clear there are a number of members of the Labour Party and, if James Connolly were alive, Lord have mercy on him, he would have very little to do with them or their ideas.
Comment on this
That is a statement the Minister should not make. He should at least try to make this a serious debate.
Comment on this
I do not believe the Minister should make sneering remarks like that which he cannot substantiate.
Comment on this
The Deputy will not wait for me to substantiate it. We have had to put up time after time with this kind of talk from the Labour Party. We are answering back. We told you during the Presidential election campaign that we were being attacked not only by Fine Gael but by the Labour Party and we could not answer back. We are doing it now and the Deputy will take his medicine.
Comment on this
The Minister will take his medicine from me later on.
Comment on this
I must insist that the Minister get an opportunity of making his statement. He is making a statement within the rules of order and relevancy and must not be interrupted.
Comment on this
I feel that what James Connolly and his colleagues of 1916 died for was not just political independence — I think we are all agreed on what I am about to say now — but for intellectual freedom, for the freedom to improve our society, the freedom to adjust our society to the requirements of our people in changing circumstances in the world.
Comment on this
Exactly; that is one of them. If the Deputy cast his mind back to the position when his Party had full power in Government and the situation they left behind them, he would not talk about this.
Comment on this
If Deputies insist on interrupting, I shall have to name the Deputy who is interrupting. They know the meaning of that.
Comment on this
Our society is changing and changing rapidly. Already we are in an era of free trade with Britain and close to an era of free trade with Europe. It is clear that the requirements of our people are such that we must modernise as far as we can all our institutions. We must ensure as far as we can that we increase production. We must ensure that we can export. This country is more dependent than any other country in the world on exports. If we do not export not alone will we fail to provide full employment but we will lose the employment we have, our standard of living will go down and efforts to create a just social order will be futile.
It is clear that in these circumstances it is very necessary that measures should be taken in relation to workers who are going to be affected adversely by the changes that will take place. How can we do this unless our economy is progressing, unless we are making enough money to provide for this? Therefore, my complaint, largely, against the Labour Party in this matter is that they have been guilty of the gravest conservatism in their approach to free trade in their approach to the modernisation of the trade union structure. They stand up and they preach about the doctrines which evolved at the beginning of this century, and earlier, in Britain and they hold these up as the Sermon on the Mount. They know surely as well as we do that it is not in the interests of the trade unions or of their members, or in the interests of the community, but they are afraid to get up and say that changes are needed, that changes must take place.
They know as well as I do that when any change takes place, there is always an element in the community who are basically conservative and against any change. They know there will be resistance and that they will be attacked by such people, but they have been unable to summon up the moral courage to say, as some trade union leaders have said, that this has to be done. What do we get here from the Labour Party? We get allegations that we are trying to ruin the trade union movement, trying to take away the rights of the trade unions. They know that if there is any Party in this country with a record it can be proud of in regard to its relations with workers, it is the Fianna Fáil Party. We are very proud of that record and the electorate have shown that they believe this, too.
I want to put on record my view that the Labour Party have been guilty of the grossest conservatism and they are holding back, to the extent that they can, the progress of the country. There is an urgent necessity for progress in the circumstances in which we find ourselves. We cannot afford this kind of delay; we cannot afford this kind of obstruction.
Comment on this
The structure of our society is changing and changing rapidly. The relationships between town and country, between church and people, between Government and governed, between employees and workers, are all changing and changing rapidly. The educational plans under way at present will accelerate that process of change. The proportion of young people to old is changing and with the lowering average marriage rate, that change is going to accelerate also.
All of this means that we now have an opportunity to shape a new pattern of society, retaining what is best in our past to ensure that the society we get has the kind of moral fibre we all want to see but with a more just social order than we have had. In other words, we have an opportunity, and a great opportunity, to achieve the aims of the 1916 Proclamation. But these aims will not be achieved by faint-heartedness, by conservatism, by playing on grouses, or by denigrating things Irish and national. This will merely sap our own self-confidence and make us waste our energies in futile dispute. What is required is a mobilising of all that is best in our people, a mobilising of their enthusiasm and their well-demonstrated willingness to sacrifice for the benefit of the nation. But they must know what the nation is. They must not have doubts cast in their minds as to whether we have a nation at all. If we are to make progress, and if we are to harness all that is best in our people, they must be helped to realise we are a nation and must work as a nation and that, if we fail to do so, we will fail completely. This nation has this opportunity, a great opportunity. There is a place in that work for every Party in this House. I hope every Party will play their part but, whether they do or not, we in Fianna Fáil will do so.
Comment on this
We in the Labour Party have submitted a motion to the effect that this House has no confidence in the Government and we set out the reasons we felt it necessary to do this. The main reason for our putting down that motion was that there is no doubt that it is a clear reflection of the people's thoughts. This Dáil has been in existence for a little over 12 months. During the 1965 election campaign, the Taoiseach and his Ministers went around telling the people how prosperous we were and how good things were under a Fianna Fáil Administration. They told the people that the only way in which they could not only maintain our prosperity but improve the lot of the people was to return a Fianna Fáil Government. There is no doubt that that was the utmost in political dishonesty, because whatever about the sheep, the Government must have known how serious was the situation into which we were drifting.
I said in this House before, and I repeat, that "Lemass leading on" was not too sure that he would be leading on and he wanted to have an each way bet. The whole trick was to tell the people how good things were and that they would continue to be good if Fianna Fáil were returned to power. If that worked, it would be grand, and if it did not, they knew that all this trouble was coming up and they could blame the other fellows who came in. We now find that there is no money available for health, education, housing or anything else that is required by the ordinary people. We know that as far as the housing situation is concerned, there are no prospects in this city of Dublin of houses being provided for people with four, five or six in family in some cases. There is no prospect in the immediate future of very many of those people with that size family being housed. They are condemned to live in one room and they have no prospect of being offered alternative accommodation. They are not only living in one room but they are living in a room that has been declared unfit for human habitation. That is as a result of: "Let Lemass Lead On". We have heard the Minister — I am not sure whether he is for Education or Industry and Commerce——
Comment on this
——trying to educate the Labour Party but I would like to say this to the Minister. We in the Labour Party welcomed his remarks this morning because it has suddenly dawned on him and his colleagues in the Government that the danger to Fianna Fáil lies here. That is why the Minister was so concerned about making such an attack on the Labour Party. He is right: we are the danger. I want to tell the Minister what the workers of this country have received from the Fianna Fáil Government. It is a great pity that a few of the Dublin Deputies are not here, who were such staunch Fianna Fáil men and, according to themselves, such staunch trade unionists, although to me it is a contradiction.
Comment on this
The Fianna Fáil Party have handed out a standstill order to the workers, a turnover tax which can only be described as vicious, which puts taxation on clothes, food, medicines and every conceivable thing necessary for an ordinary workingman to buy in order to live. We had the Taoiseach and his Ministers telling the workers of this country a very short while ago that all they could possibly get was three per cent but the workers knew where their interest lay then. It lay in their trade unions and it lay in this Party here.
Comment on this
They got more than the three per cent the Minister and his colleagues told them was all they could have. The Minister made certain remarks about freedom and he went on to define what freedom was in his own confused way. Does he regard it as a progressive step in 1966 that the recognised right in any free society of a worker to go on strike was withdrawn by a Bill introduced by the Minister's Party——
Comment on this
——in this Dáil some few weeks ago? We had a spectacle then of the staunch trade union Fianna Fáil hacks trooping into the lobby to take away the democratic rights of their fellow workers.
Comment on this
Is this the Party the Minister would invite the workers to support? As the Minister indicated very clearly by his attack this morning on the Labour Party, it has even dawned on Fianna Fáil that the jig is up. Yesterday evening Deputy Corry from Cork said that the Presidential election was a vote of confidence by the people. I do not want to dwell on the Presidential election. We will leave that between the two contestants but I would like to comment and say this in all sincerity. I find it hard to make such a comment on a man who is so much older than myself but I think it has to be made. I find it hard to believe that a Deputy, probably one of the staunchest workers of this House, could make a statement to the effect that because Dublin exercised its democratic right and rejected the Fianna Fáil candidate for the presidency — this, mind you, is a Deputy of this House talking about the capital city of this country — the only mistake the Germans made when they bombed this city during the war was that they did not wipe it out.
I happen to know one family at least who lost both mother and father as a result of that bombing. I did not mind Deputy Corry so much because, quite frankly, his remarks could only be inspired by his ignorance, but what I took grave exception to was those staunch Fianna Fáil Deputies, and Deputy Dowling in particular, sitting listening — I do not know where the Minister was: it was his constituency which was bombed — in silence. Because of Deputy Dowling's silence, one can only conclude he agreed with Deputy Corry, or there might be another explanation. Obviously, it has been handed down to the lower rank: any slanderous remark you can think up about the Labour Party or members of the Labour Party, use it because they are the danger. We had Deputy Dowling who was so preoccupied in thinking up a slanderous remark — or possibly he aspires to take over from the archmudslinger, Deputy MacEntee — that he had not time to dissociate himself from such a despicable comment by one who is reputed to be a responsible Deputy in this House. What Dublin city did in the Presidential election is only a warning of things to come for Fianna Fáil in this city, and there is no doubt, and I repeat this, Sir, that the Fianna Fáil Party, particularly those at the top — it might not have filtered through to the others yet — realise that Labour is definitely arriving. They are worried because they also know that when they were rejected so overwhelmingly in this city in the Presidential election what Dublin does today Ireland does tomorrow. The Government the Minister invites the workers of this country to support — and, let us face it and be honest, the workers have been misguided enough in the past to give them a considerable amount of support — this benevolent Government who are so concerned about the interests of the workers, and who have warned them against the conservatism of the Labour Party, are responsible for the conditions in this country today.
They are responsible for employment, for housing, for health and for education, and in none of these fields is there money available. I know, and I am sure the Minister for Education must know, as he is a Deputy elected for Dublin——
Comment on this
——that unfortunate people trying to start life, young people who got married just before the balloon burst and had saved up money for a house, who had all the qualifications, who applied to the local authority for a loan under the SDA were told: "Something has gone wrong; you let Lemass lead on, but this is where he has led you". They were told "You have all the qualifications and we did tell you that if you met these requirements the money would be available to you but there is no money". The local authority will tell you there is no money. The Minister for Local Government will tell you anything except that there is no money. He will tell you, when he is asked about the housing scheme in Ballymun that was supposed to cure all our ills, that it actually rains in Ballymun. What a revelation! It rains in Ballymun. It apparently does not rain in Edenmore or Coolock. They are building houses there. I envy the Minister a constituency with such a wonderful climate.
The people made a mistake in 1965 when they elected a Fianna Fáil Government. They are entitled to make a mistake: that is their democratic right. But it is also their democratic right to change their minds and wake up, and they have done that. The only honest thing the people can expect from the Government is to be allowed an opportunity of giving their effective opinion on the mismanagement of the Fianna Fáil Government and also, we are quite confident, of giving the Minister for Education his answer as to where they think the workers' interests lie. We have no doubt in the world. We have no fears of an election. Have Fianna Fáil any fears?
Comment on this
(Cavan): We are drawing to the end of one of the most eventful parliamentary years since the foundation of this State, a year in which there has been unprecedented industrial unrest, an unprecedented shortage of capital for worthwhile projects, a year in which on two occasions it has been found necessary by the Government to operate the Offences against the State Act against, first of all, workers who were demanding what they considered to be their rights and, in the second place, against the farming community who found it necessary to parade outside Leinster House to focus the attention of the Government and the public on the fact that they were being neglected, and disgracefully neglected. This is a year in which the Government found it necessary to introduce emergency legislation at short notice to compel workers to work, to make it illegal for workers to strike and to prescribe penalties which would mean the imprisonment of workers, and a year in which we have had a Budget introduced in the early days of March, two months earlier than ever before, and yet followed by another Budget nine weeks later, both of which imposed blistering taxation without prescribing any incentives of any description to encourage production, to encourage employment or to improve the lot of the people. It is a year, as I said, in which we have had unprecedented industrial unrest.
The best known name in this country in the year 1966 must surely be the name of Mr. Dermot McDermott, the Chief Conciliation Officer of the Labour Court whose name we have heard on every news bulletin and whose name we have read in the newspapers every day intervening in strikes, trying to get people back to work. In this year of 1966 as the parliamentary year draws to an end, we have had the banks of this country on strike for, I think, nearly three months now. The extraordinary thing about the bankers' strike is that nobody seems to be in the slightest concerned about it; it seems to be a relief to many people because, for months past and indeed for years past, the principal occupation or exercise of the banks in this country had been to try to get in money due to them. They had ceased, over 12 months ago, to be a source of credit to the farming community, the industrial community or the business community.
It is not, therefore, any surprise that this parliamentary year should end with a debate on two motions of no confidence in the present Government. The object of the introduction of the votes of no confidence is to defeat the Government Party in the Dáil, to force a general election and bring about a change of Government. Unfortunately we know that, due to the present constitution of this House and the fact that the majority of the Members were elected under false pretences and the fact that certain Independent Deputies in this House will take no part in this debate or in the vote which follows, the Government Party will not be defeated. But even in those circumstances, it is the duty of the Opposition Parties to challenge the Government on occasions like this at the end of a parliamentary year. However, these votes of no confidence should not be necessary because the people of this country, particularly the people of Dublin and Greater Dublin, the people of Cork city and county and the people of Ireland in general, have already indicated to this Government that they have no confidence in them and want a change of Government.
I believe the Labour Party honestly put down their vote of no confidence in the hope of bringing about a general election and a change of Government. However, I am afraid the Labour Party, while being honest, have, nevertheless, been guilty of tactics which were less effective than tactics they might have employed in bringing about a change of Government. Already, on 1st June, thousands and thousands of Labour supporters in this country, without any definite lead from the Parliamentary Labour Party, and indeed against the advice of some of the members of that Party, registered an emphatic protest against the present Government and demanded in no uncertain terms that there be a general election and a change of Government.
However, I feel — and I say this in no critical spirit but only in the sense that I believe it is a pity the Labour Party did not use the most effective means at their disposal to put out this Government — I believe that the Labour Party should have, through one means of communication or another, in the month of May, indicated to the people of this country that they believed this Government were as bad, as rotten and as unsound as the House says they are; they should have communicated to the people of the country, to their supporters that they should have registered a protest on 1st June — that is all I say: should have registered a protest against the present Government and present Government policy — by voting against the Fianna Fáil nominee in the Presidential election.
I honestly believe that, had they done that, they would have done a good service to this country. The candidate who opposed Government policy in that election would not have been defeated by a paltry 10,000 votes. He would have won and we would not now be debating in the Eighteenth Dáil. We would have been here, re-assembled, in the Nineteenth Dáil with a different Government, a different policy and a different outlook. However, all we can do now is remind the Government that they have been rejected by the people, that notice to quit has been served upon them and that they should take heed of that fact and accede to the wishes of the people.
Now I know, as the House knows, that this debate, coupled with two votes of no confidence in the Government, is an important occasion, an occasion when one would expect the Government Party to come in, first of all, to defend their record and, secondly, to put before the people their plans for the future. From the Government side of the House, since this debate began at 10.30 yesterday morning, we have heard the Taoiseach in a speech which lasted half an hour, although there was no time limit on him. I think I am correct in saying he was supported during yesterday by Deputy Corry from Cork, who, as I said here last week, is part of the price a country must pay for democracy. The Taoiseach was supported by Deputy Dowling and then it did appear that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs would intervene in this debate. He offered to speak but he gave away to Deputy Dillon and, as this debate proceeded, it became apparent that the Government considered that the ex-Minister for Education, now the Minister for Industry and Commerce, should speak instead.
That appeared to me to be an indication that we were to hear the record of the Government defended, and to hear the Government's plans for the future from a man who is regarded as one of the top brass of the Fianna Fáil Party, a member of the economic cabinet, a man for whom I have the greatest respect, both as an individual and as a Minister. I must say that nothing made it clearer to me during this debate, or during this parliamentary year, that the Government had no defence for their record and no plans for the future, than the speech of the Minister for Industry and Commerce a short time ago.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Deputy Colley, then, betwixt and between the Ministries of Education and Industry and Commerce. I believe that if there were a case to be made, if there were a defence to be put forward for the state of the country at present, if the Government had any plans for the future, they could instruct no better man, to use a modernism, to put it forward than Deputy Colley, Minister for Education at the moment, and shortly to be Minister for Industry and Commerce.
He made a short speech. He resurrected the patriot dead and accused the Labour Party of appropriating the patriot dead. To me that sounds extraordinary coming from the Party who, since the foundation of the State, have more than any other Party claimed an exclusive right in the men who died in 1916, who never endorsed any of the Fianna Fáil Party's programmes because that Party was not founded until 1926. He went on to say there were wonderful opportunities for this country and that, whether or not other Parties did so, the Fianna Fáil Party would exploit these opportunities to the full. One thing Deputy Colley did not tell us was what these opportunities were. Three things he did not tell us: how this country got into the present mess; what the opportunities for the future are; and how the Government propose to exploit them.
The Fianna Fáil Party have treated this debate and these votes of no confidence in the casual manner in which they have been treating the Irish people for a great many years. I admit they have got away with it for a good many years, but I think they will not get away with it any longer. That was clearly indicated on 1st June when, despite their cunning, despite their political ingenuity, despite their political experience, in putting forward what they considered to be the best and only candidate at their disposal, they escaped from the people by a mere whisker.
I want to conclude my remarks on this aspect of the matter by saying that I do not think it is good enough for the Government who have got the country into the state it is now in, to come in here to an important debate like this and offer the Taoiseach for half an hour, followed by Deputy Corry with a display of buffoonery for I do not know how long, followed by a well-meaning but junior back bencher, Deputy Dowling, followed by the disappointing performance of the Minister for Education.
Comment on this
That is the Deputy's point of view and I want to dissociate myself from it. I thought it was very good basic philosophy.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am sure Deputy Andrews has many points of view. He is one of the young dynamos of the Fianna Fáil Party. I am sorry they did not put Deputy Andrews in instead of Deputy Corry.
Comment on this
(Cavan): In this debate. I do not wish to be offensive to Deputy Dowling but I think Deputy Andrews is better qualified to put forward a case, if there is a case, than Deputy Dowling.
The Taoiseach in opening this debate glibly dismissed these votes of no confidence as being of no importance. He said the important point was that the Government should continue to have confidence in themselves and in their policies. I think I am quoting him correctly. I want to say there is abundant evidence up and down the country that the Government have confidence neither in themselves nor in their policies. Their policies are changing from day to day. I think I can prove that conclusively by discussing for a short time the happenings in this House during 1966. The Taoiseach says the Government have confidence in themselves and in their policies, but in the early days of March of this year, they introduced a Budget in which they said there was no necessity to provide additional supports for the farming community and, during the course of that debate, the claims of the farmers were resisted, although everyone knew that the door of the Department of Agriculture was being hammered upon, and that appeals were being made to the Taoiseach by the NFA and the ICMSA demanding that the farmers should get fair play, demanding that the farmers should get a fair share of the national income.
Yet, in the early days of March of this year, this Government who have confidence in themselves and their policies introduced a Budget in which they did not provide one brass farthing for additional agriculture supports, but, before the debate on that Budget had terminated, additional supports were given to the farming community for milk, for lambs, etc., which had not been provided for in the Budget and which were resisted and resisted strongly. Are they a Government confident in themselves and in their policies, as the Taoiseach said — a Government who cannot budget for nine weeks ahead, a Government who cannot make up their minds in the month of March what the requirements of the farmers will be in the month of May?
This Government who, as the Taoiseach says, are confident in themselves and confident in their policies, resisted at the last general election, the necessity for a Ministry of Labour, though it was advocated by the Fine Gael Party. Now they come in here with legislation implementing the Fine Gael policy on the necessity for a Ministry of Labour. The same Government who say they are confident in themselves and in their policies spoke through their Taoiseach in March, 1965, and said they believed an incomes policy was so much nonesense — that an incomes policy worked only in Communist countries, that they would not operate it in Government and would resist it in Opposition.
That same Taoiseach comes in here during the present parliamentary year and advocates an incomes policy and says it is necessary if the economy of the country is to progress. We have further evidence that this Government are neither confident in themselves nor in their policies in the recent change of Ministers. This Government have been in office only since April, 1965, and we then had appointed Deputy O'Malley as Minister for Health and Deputy Colley as Minister for Education. There can be no doubt whatever about it that those two Departments were controversial Departments in the last general election campaign. The health policy of the Government was attacked right, left and centre. The educational policy was attacked from all angles.
We had appointed to these two Departments two young, energetic Ministers. During the year the Minister for Health produced a White Paper in which he promised to implement the Fine Gael policy on health. Admittedly, he stated that he could not implement it until next year, but surely if that is the continued health policy of the Government, one would have thought the Minister for Health should be allowed to remain in the Custom House and introduce the legislation he promised to introduce in November of this year. That was his promise during the debate on the White Paper. He said that in November, 1966, he would lay before the House legislation to implement a great portion of his White Paper.
Are we to be told now that Deputy Seán Flanagan, the new Minister for Health, could not be expected in a few months to become sufficiently familiar with his Department to introduce the necessary Bills to implement the White Paper? It seems to me to be an indication that there is a change in the Government's policy on health. Usually a change of Ministers means that. If the Government were confident in themselves and in their policies, why did they not leave the Minister for Health in the Custom House to introduce the necessary Bills to implement the White Paper or to explain to the country why he did not introduce them?
We had the Minister for Education, an able man, a likeable man, an approachable man, a man of considerable ability, removed from the Department of Education and transplanted to the filleted Department of Industry and Commerce which is not now responsible for semi-State bodies, not responsible for labour troubles — indeed it is difficult to see what he will have to do there. Is his transfer an indication that the Government are accepting the Fine Gael policy on education? Is it an indication from the Government that they are about to have second thoughts on educational policy?
Comment on this
(Cavan): It does not seem to me to be the action of a Taoiseach who is confident in his Government, confident in their policies, a Taoiseach who believes he has the best Cabinet in Europe and probably the best placed Ministers in Europe. The Minister for Industry and Commerce tried to extricate himself from the statement that has been attributed to him that he would convert this country not into a bilingual society but into an Irish-speaking country. He now denies that and, like so many of his illustrious predecessors, states that he has been wrongly reported or wrongly translated.
The Taoiseach in his short speech had something to promise, something that would solve all our difficulties. On this occasion it was his old friend the European Economic Community. When I entered the Seanad for the first time, it was a foregone conclusion that we would be in the Common Market by 1st January, 1964. The Taoiseach and his Ministers were then confident that the turnover tax and everything else would be forgotten, would be submerged in the state of affairs that would exist following our admission into the Common Market.
We did not get into the Common Market; neither did England, and I am not blaming the Taoiseach for that. I am sure he was very disappointed. However, he told us yesterday that we may be invited into the EEC at very short notice — that we may not even have time to change our clothes before accepting the invitation. I charge the Government, particularly the Taoiseach, with creating a situation here which equips us badly to enter into competition with the other countries of the Common Market.
According to the Taoiseach, as I interpret his speech, the only solution he has for our present ills is entry into the Common Market. If we go into the Common Market, there may be advantages to be reaped but there will also be keen competition to be met. It is not going to be a question of take all and give nothing. We shall have to prove ourselves. Our farmers and industrialists will have to be able to compete with the best, and it is the duty of the Government, particularly a Government who have for years past been advocating our entry into the Common Market, so to regulate our economy, so to regulate industry and agriculture, that our industrialists and farmers will not go in under a severe handicap.
Let us think for a moment about what Government policy has done to equip us for entry into the Common Market. We have a state of industrial unrest here the like of which this country never experienced, except perhaps in the fateful year 1913, before I was born. I blame the Government for the industrial unrest there is today. The Government have been in power since 1957 without a break, and they cannot pass this baby on to anybody else. I blame them for the present industrial unrest and accuse them of bringing it about by the removal of the food subsidies in 1957——
Comment on this
(Cavan):——by their taxation of food and the necessaries of life through the turnover tax in 1963, by the dishonest by-election round of wage increases in 1964.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Coupled with, as Deputy L'Estrange says, the status increase, the child of Deputy Haughey, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. I believe that he and the former Deputy Lenehan begot the status increase. In 1962 in the Seanad they were saying the national cake had grown to such proportions that it would be unfair or unjust to debar any section of the community, whether they had enough money or not, from sharing the fruits of the buoyant and flourishing national economy. I blame them for bringing the present situation about. In 1964, the Taoiseach said the economy could afford an increase of only seven per cent, at the most, in the national wage packet. Yet, for dishonest political motives, in order to avoid a national wage discussion at the same time as two vital by-elections, he said: “Let it rip; give them the 12 per cent and things will work out.”
Comment on this
(Cavan): We said, and we say now, that the only increase which should have been given was an increase the economy could afford. These increases were given, followed by an increase in the cost of living which devoured them, rendered them useless in a matter of months.
The country is entering into the Common Market, we are told by the Taoiseach, at a time when there is no capital for agriculture, when there is no capital for industry, when there is no money available for anything. This Government have a heavy sin to answer for if we are accepted into the Common Market under a severe handicap. I should like the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to tell us, if he speaks, and if not, whoever is concluding on this debate, whether the Government believe we are as well equipped to enter into and compete in the EEC as the other members.
There has been a long discussion here about housing and who built how many houses, about whether Dublin Corporation discharged their obligations, whether there are enough houses in Dublin or whether Dublin Corporation and the Department of Local Government fell down on housing in Dublin. I should like to question whether the housing programme in the country in general has met the requirements of the people. I do not propose to spend any time arguing as to whether or not there are enough houses for the workers of Dublin: it is evident there are not. It is evident that the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Finance have fallen down and fallen down miserably in the provision of houses for the people of Dublin. We do not have to do any reading or any great research to establish that fact.
I was utterly amazed, as a country Deputy, to hear the Minister for Local Government say that unless a man and his wife and three children, constituting a family of five, are occupying one room in the city of Dublin, Dublin Corporation are not interested in them and are not prepared to do anything about them. That is what I understood the Minister for Local Government to say in reply to a Parliamentary Question, and I understood that there are 700 such families. If that is so, it is a national disgrace; if it is not so, it should be contradicted. I should have thought it would be a disgrace to have an elderly man and woman, sleeping, washing, cooking and living in one room, but when I hear that there are married people with one child, two, three and four children, living in one room, and that Dublin Corporation are not prepared even to take their names at the present time, I think that is scandalous.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Through the Chair, may I ask Deputy Moore, who is a member of Dublin Corporation, am I right in saying that only families of five residing in one room are entitled to be considered for housing by Dublin Corporation in the foreseeable future?
Comment on this
(Cavan): As I understand the position — and if I am wrong, I am sure I will be contradicted — only a family of five residing in one room in the city of Dublin will be considered for housing in the foreseeable future.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am saying that only families of five will be housed in the foreseeable future.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am saying that only families of five will be housed in the foreseeable future and that Dublin Corporation are not interested at the moment in families of four, three, two or one.
Comment on this
Any corporation that would not be interested in housing the people should not be there. The Deputy's argument is far too facile.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I regret that Deputy Dowling, who is a member of the corporation, instead of indulging in mudslinging, did not make the case Deputy Moore and Deputy Andrews are making now. He did not make it and it has not been made. One does not have to go to Dublin to find people badly housed. I know a man working with a county council who is married and has seven children. There are nine persons living in two rooms — not two bedrooms — a room and a kitchen. The children's ages range from 19 years to two years. Is that not a disgrace? He is told by the local authority that they are not acquiring sites any more but that, if he can get a site, they will see what they can do about it.
Comment on this
I have worse cases than Deputy Fitzpatrick has mentioned. We are not unaware of these cases.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Do Deputies over there agree that it is a sad reflection on the Government in power that they admit that this state of affairs exists after seven unbroken years of their government?
Comment on this
There are 80,000 fewer employed than in 1951. The population is the lowest we ever had.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It is even worse if the Deputies are callously aware of it and doing nothing about it.