Adjournment (Summer Recess).
Contributions 178–359 of 359. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
(Cavan): I want to know what the Government are doing and what they were doing about housing during their long term of office.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There is a record kept now in Griffith Barracks where people are being registered in and out as if they were in an institution. I can appreciate the Deputies opposite being annoyed. It is not a matter one would expect them to be glad about or to boast about. This is a motion of no confidence in the Government and I am entitled to make the case I am making.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I had not intended to deal with this matter for more than two minutes because I thought the reply of the Minister for Local Government yesterday was a confession of abject failure on his part and on the part of the Government. Apparently, the Deputies opposite wish to wriggle their way out of it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I should like to ask the Minister for Local Government one question which I should like the Taoiseach to answer when he is concluding the debate. There is a housing scheme in Ballymun. I have not seen it. I gather that there are a number of houses completed but that, for some reason or another which appears to be somewhat of a mystery, they are not being handed over. I do not know whether they are defective, whether they are dangerous or what the reason is.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The people cannot be blamed for that. The Minister for Local Government should enlist the good offices of the Minister for Transport and Power in getting that little matter attended to. There are these houses there and the people are not getting them. I understand that there is a long delay in the completion of the Ballymun scheme and that the weather has been blamed. I should like the Minister for Local Government to tell us what proportion of the delay is attributable to bad weather. That is a fair question to which we should get an answer.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I will depart from the question of housing because even Deputy Andrews and the lot of them agree that it is a disgrace and there is no use in my flogging a dead horse.
The Taoiseach, in opening the debate, stated that he had confidence in the Government and confidence in his policy. The Department of Education is behaving in a most extraordinary manner. They are advocating more extensive education and the introduction of comprehensive schools and a common intermediate certificate and at the same time they are reducing the amount of money available to vocational education committees. Other Deputies have dealt with their failure to implement their promises about secondary schools. I shall deal only with vocational education because I happen to be a member of a committee and know what I am talking about in that connection.
The grant payable to Cavan Vocational Education Committee is being reduced in the year 1966-67 as compared with 1965-66 by £4,587 and at the same time, we are expected to provide better facilities for education and to extend the common intermediate certificate course to various schools. I ask myself have the Government taken leave of their senses or do they think the people are dumb or do not know what is going on. Deputy Colley, Minister for Education, seemed to say to me yesterday that more education could be provided in 1966 than in 1965 for less money. That was his argument as I understood it. That is their policy on education.
During the past few days we had a long discussion in this House on housing. In regard to Dublin city, they are not really concerned about entrances to houses. Deputy Dillon spoke this morning about young people getting married and young men inviting girls to join them in matrimony and live in the ancestral home. The rural improvements scheme was a scheme which enabled country lanes, some one mile long leading to houses, to be repaired. That scheme, for all practical purposes, has been dropped.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Yes it is, for all practical purposes. Am I exaggerating when I say that when you apply for a form to have a lane repaired now you will be told that the number of applications on hands is more than can be dealt with in view of the amount of money available and that no further applications are being accepted for the time being?
Comment on this
(Cavan): For all practical purposes, it has been dropped. The minor employment scheme has gone also, the scheme under which, if there were sufficient unemployment in the area, you could get the work done for nothing.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I could point out plenty of places where it would serve a very useful purpose.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It is merged into the rural improvements scheme. I am telling Deputy O'Connor, because he interrupted me, that my information is that only half the amount of money will be spent on these schemes this year compared with last year — that is reliable information — notwithstanding that the cost of doing these schemes has increased considerably. That is something the Government must take responsibility for, something that will drive people out of rural Ireland. Teenagers, and people of 20 years of age or so, do not want to walk out through these lanes up to their ankles in water and muck. A comparatively small sum of money — it could be dealt with in thousands and certainly would not go into the million — would do much of this work. It is a sorry state of affairs when the country has gone so far that the hatchet must be used on rural improvements schemes.
Last year we had a Bill introduced with a great fanfare of trumpets. That was the Land Bill which was supposed to provide land for everybody when it became an Act. We were accused of obstructing it because we insisted on some objectionable sections being deleted and we fought tooth and nail, through Deputy Hogan and other Deputies, about the section which would prevent the sale of land to foreigners. The Bill became law and we were told the effect would be that congestion would be relieved and there would be more land for forestry and all the rest of it.
Yesterday, I was told by the Minister for Lands that in County Cavan in 1963-64 his Department acquired 737 acres for forestry; in 1964-65, they acquired 730 acres and in 1965-66, after the coming into operation of this Land Act, they acquired 172 acres. For the relief of congestion in the same county in 1963-65, they acquired 827 acres; in 1964-65, 543 acres; and in 1965-66, 341 acres. That is what the Land Act has brought about. Cavan is a county in which there is plenty of land suitable for forestry and where there are hordes of people seeking to be transferred to larger farms in richer counties and many people are prepared to surrender their small farms for more suitable farms elsewhere, which operation would effect the relief of congestion in County Cavan. But the Government's approach to it is to cut down the acreage acquired from 827 in 1963-64 to 341 in 1965-66. That is something of which the Government should be ashamed.
Apart from the economic state of the country, I should like to deal in a general way with some other points. I think the Government discriminate unfairly against their opponents. They could not even organise the 1916 Commemoration ceremonies on a fair and decent basis. They excluded, either deliberately or through incompetence, many leaders, many public men from a place of honour on the platform at the GPO on Easter Sunday. The Taoiseach said it happened through a mistake. It is a mistake that should not happen. If there had been Members of the Opposition on the Committee, it could not have happened. Invitations for the Easter Week Ceremonies were sent out by the Government on Wednesday of Holy Week, Good Friday and Holy Saturday being bank holidays. We were told that the other invitations were accidentally excluded, a page of names. Surely it is not reasonable to send somebody important, a busy person, an invitation on Wednesday of Holy Week to attend ceremonies during Easter Week? I accuse the Government at best of bungling and, at worst, of absolutely dishonest and unfair discrimination.
I shall deal briefly with the disgraceful presentation by Telefís Éireann of the Presidential election campaign. I say there was discrimination in the worst possible form and it is no answer for the Minister or the Chairman of Telefís Éireann to tell the people of the country that it was the practice never to cover the Presidential election. Did they not know perfectly well that while they were blacking out one candidate completely, they were building up the other candidate day after day and night after night on Telefís Éireann? That is something I charge the Government with, something of which they should be ashamed. If those who were operating Telefís Éireann honestly believe they were impartial, they are not fit to be in charge of Telefís Éireann or of any service paid for at public expense.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Mention has been made here on several occasions — I am dealing with Telefís Éireann — of the appointment of the new Chairman of Telefís Éireann, Dr. Andrews. I want to deal with this as fairly as I can. I personally am not blaming the Government for giving Dr. Andrews a gratuity on his retirement because apparently the terms of his appointment provided for that; I am not blaming the Government for giving Dr. Andrews a pension on his retirement because apparently his terms of appointment provided for that. I am blaming the Government for giving a man who has been adequately provided for, by both a large gratuity and a generous pension, another job at £1,000 a year, in a field for which his years do not suit him.
It may be going back very far but I am old enough to remember the time when the Minister's Party were saying that nobody was worth more than £1,000 a year. I know the value of money has changed since then; of course I do. I do not expect that £1,000 in 1930 is the same as £1,000 now but I do believe that when a man has served in the Civil Service or in any other sphere and has retired with a generous gratuity and on a more than adequate pension, he should not, over the heads of younger men, be put into another job at £1,000 a year.
In his remarks today, Deputy Dillon stated that the only salvation for rural Ireland is the implementation of the parish plan. He stated that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries believed that but was not man enough to say it. I was present at a function in County Cavan organised by the Killeshandra Co-Operative Society, one of the biggest societies in the country, a function to present prizes for a farm prize scheme, a scheme to encourage young farmers to keep their farm buildings better, to engage in better farming methods, to keep better stock and, generally, to organise their farms so that they will have better incomes and better lives. The Minister was present at that function, as, indeed, were the heads of many bodies interested in agriculture. That very worthwhile scheme was started in Killeshandra by the parish agent appointed by Deputy Dillon when he was Minister for Agriculture. How right he was. The great pity is that many more such parish agents were not appointed — indeed, one in every parish in the country. If that had been done, and if they had not been ridiculed, we should be much better equipped today from an agricultural point of view to enter into the Common Market.
These votes of no confidence will not be carried because, as I said in the beginning, the 72 Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party sitting opposite me were elected in the last general election on false pretences. They were elected on the speeches of the Taoiseach that conditions were never so good, that the people never had it so good and that all that was necessary to continue that state of affairs was to return them to office. Deputy Gilbride laughs; I shall ask him if I am wrong. I hope I shall be able to explain to him, in a very brief way, that what I am saying is correct. Take the three slogans "Stay with Prosperity", "Do not put back the Clock" and "Let Lemass Lead On"——
Comment on this
(Cavan): Am I incorrect in saying that these slogans were meant to convey, and did convey, that the economy of the country was sound?
Comment on this
(Cavan): Am I incorrect in saying that they were intended to convey that there was plenty of money for everybody, that there was plenty of prosperity, that there were no problems to be faced and that all that was necessary to continue that happy state of affairs was to re-elect the present Government? The people did re-elect the present Government. Was Deputy Gilbride in the House in the month of July, 1965, when the Taoiseach came in here and, without a blush, without an explanation and without an apology, told Dáil Éireann that the country was in a bad way, that everybody would have to tighten his belt and pull his weight, wear a hairshirt and put up with sacrifices in order to get the country right again? Did that happen between March, 1965, and July, 1965?
Comment on this
(Cavan): Did this transformation from super-abundance into abject poverty take place between the month of March, 1965, and the month of July, 1965? Of course, it did not. That state of affairs was there in March, 1965, but the Taoiseach and Deputy Gilbride suppressed it from the people——
Comment on this
(Cavan):——and made them vote in blinkers, deceived them and got their votes on false pretences. That is why I say that these votes of no confidence will not be carried. The Government have 72 Deputies and certain other Deputies in the House may not vote.
Comment on this
(Cavan): However, as far as the Government's majority is concerned, the Government are living in a world of unreality. The Government are operating in this House with a majority they know they are not entitled to. I venture to suggest to Deputy Gilbride and to the other Deputies opposite that there are many Deputies who will walk into the Division Lobby today behind the Taoiseach, expressing confidence in him, who, if they now submitted themselves to the same people who elected them in April, 1965, would be rejected and sent into the wilderness.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am glad Deputy Gilbride mentioned the Presidential election. He is one of the few members of the Fianna Fáil Party who would have the neck to claim they won the Presidential election.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Did Deputy Gilbride hear Deputy Donegan read out from these benches the leading article in the Irish Press on the day following the general election in which it was admitted that you were beaten and beaten badly? Why did the Minister for External Affairs not stand as a candidate in that election? Why did he not make a speech in that election? The fact is that Fianna Fáil were annihilated in Dublin and Greater Dublin, in Cork city and county. In practically every constituency in the country, the Fianna Fáil majority went down.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Fianna Fáil 120,000 majority dropped to 10,000 with the only candidate they could stand behind. I invite Fianna Fáil, if they think they won the Presidential election, to repeal the Local Elections Act, 1965, and submit themselves to the people at local authority level and see what will happen to them.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Fianna Fáil know they will be wiped out. I accuse this Government of avoiding the people. They held a general election in 1965, before it was due, and despite the promises of the Taoiseach to ex-Deputy Sherwin and company that he would not hold an election until the Government had run their course in accordance with the Constitution. He made the same promise the other day. He went even further.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It was fraudulently held in order to conceal from the people and the country the real state of affairs. All I want Deputy Gilbride to do is to hold the local elections when they are due. That is all I am talking about and that is all I am asking. Fianna Fáil have postponed them twice.
Comment on this
The Deputy complains one moment that they were held too soon and, in the next moment, that they are being held too late. He cannot have it both ways.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The fact is that, although the Government may survive this censure motion, this motion of no confidence, they have lost the confidence of the people and of the country. That was demonstrated clearly in the Presidential election. The only thing the Government can do now is resign and hold a general election. If they are not prepared to do that, let them hold the local elections and we will see what will happen.
Comment on this
I have listened to a good many of the speeches here and, when one has been in this House for a number of years, it becomes very difficult to talk on an adjournment motion. In my 15 odd years I have listened to quite a few adjournment speeches. They have not changed one bit. There is one thing that really disgusts me, and I say this in all sincerity: every time we come back, we are not three months back until the Opposition are shouting for another election. Go to the country: face the people. Yet, when we do go to the country, the result shows that the Opposition are not fit to be returned to office. We have gone to the country time and time again. We will hold elections when we think we should.
Comment on this
I did not interrupt any Deputy but there are a few Deputies in this House who do nothing else.
Comment on this
The Minister's time is limited. At 2.45 p.m. the Chair will call on the Fine Gael spokesman to conclude on behalf of his Party. The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.
Comment on this
I have listened patiently to all this piffle: hold an election; go to the country; face the people; the Government have lost the confidence of the people. The fact is the Opposition got quite a few opportunities. As I pointed out to Deputy Dillon last night, when he was interrupting, the Opposition formed two coalition Governments at a time when they had no mandate to do so. Labour and Fine Gael went before the country with separate policies. On the first occasion they formed a Government; they stuck it for a while. The going was rough.
Comment on this
I have been listening to the speeches from Opposition Deputies about the state of the country. Sometimes one is saddened by the wishful thinking behind those speeches; every speaker is praying that the condition of the country will become worse than it is. There are thousands of people coming into this country and investing in the country right now. They are taking no notice whatsoever of all these speeches, just as the electorate takes no notice when an election takes place. Here is the Official Report carrying a Budget Statement by Deputy Sweetman. I listened to it sitting on those benches over there. I almost cried as Deputy Sweetman painted a picture of the state of the country. Deputy Sweetman had a sad story to tell. It is not the story we have to tell today.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach was able to give some very encouraging and solid facts. He told us the balance of trade had improved by £20 million in the first five months of this year. Is that wrong? Our external assets had increased by £21 million. Is that wrong?
Comment on this
If the Deputy had a shred of decency, he would not mention building, good bad or indifferent. It was the Deputy's Coalition Government who drove the skilled operatives out of this country in 1956 and 1957. Every builder in the city knows that. There was not a single skilled tradesman left and the Deputies opposite should be ashamed of it. When we returned to office, there were vacant houses all over the city of Dublin. It amuses me to hear all the talk about Dublin city and about the poor people.
Comment on this
What was the position when Deputy Sweetman presented the Budget to which I have referred? The balance of payments was in a serious state; it would decline more and more over the years.
Comment on this
Savings were depleted to a serious extent; bank deposits were down; exports were at an all-time low; unemployment was the highest ever; and emigration had reached alarming proportions.
Comment on this
The figures are there. It was at that time Deputy Sweetman proceeded to tax every commodity that could bear a tax.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange must cease interrupting. The Minister has only a few minutes in which to make his speech.
Comment on this
Deputy L'Estrange has no licence to interrupt everyone who speaks and the Chair is pointing that out to the Deputy.
Comment on this
The Chair is not concerned with anything except order and Deputy L'Estrange has no licence to interrupt speakers.
Comment on this
Unemployment had increased to quite serious proportions. That was the picture in the Budget Statement of 1956. In 1957, before the Budget was introduced, the Coalition Government abdicated and we were returned to clean up the mess. There can be no question about that. It happened a very short time ago, relatively speaking. Mark you, although the position then was, on the admission of the Opposition speakers here now, much more serious than the position of financial stringency in which we found ourselves recently, the fact is that we restored confidence and redressed the position then, and we did it very quickly, and the position today will be redressed just as quickly.
Comment on this
This is not the last time this country will have to face a similar situation. These things have a habit of recurring and no economist so far has been able to come up with the answer as to how they can be prevented. There is, however, one thing we can do; we can strengthen the economy to enable us to ride the storm when the chill wind blows. That is the difference between this occasion and the earlier occasion. The country will pass through on this occasion unscathed. As the figures show, it is already emerging. We will be able to move on rapidly in a short time.
Writing recently, one of the best known economists in the country said:
No person could yet find an answer for an expanding economy when incomes increased that would prevent extra imports. The increase in imports must always automatically follow on improved purchasing power in any country where the economy is expanding.
No person has attempted to give the answer to that. I do not think anybody really has the answer. In an integrated community like Europe or even larger than Europe, it might be possible to have a centralised monetary fund which would enable that sort of thing to be avoided. But, as society is organised in the world today, it seems to be quite unavoidable. It is our ability to overcome that situation which is more important than anything else. I think this one has been overcome very successfully.
Does anybody think the day will ever come in this House when somebody will not be able to get up and say there is a poor man living somewhere in the country? I do not think any Party will ever be in that position, but that is the sort of thing we have to listen to. We had Deputy Dillon taking out of context a statement regarding somebody. We had Deputy Mrs. Desmond talking about people who had to travel on a bus and whose increase was absorbed by this. We will never reach a stage where you cannot pick out some unfortunate member of the community. But, by and large, the people are enjoying a better standard of living than ever before. Nobody is hungry. Deputy Reynolds made a silly statement that farmers are dying of hunger. That sort of thing does not get one anywhere.
Comment on this
Let us be realistic and face the situation as it is. We find it very nice to use every adjective we can when condemning and criticising other people, but the electorate outside are looking on. They can interpret things their own way and they have been doing so very successfully. The local elections will come in their own time and we will win every one of them. You know that. On the figures in the Presidential election, we would have won every rural council in Ireland.
Comment on this
While you are trying to satisfy yourselves by making exaggerated statements and criticism which does not impress anybody or does not do the country any good, you must always remember that outside there is an intelligent electorate carefully interpreting the whole situation. They have done it in every year in which there was an election and they will do so again.
We have this talk about there being no confidence in the Government, but the fact remains there is confidence everywhere in the country today. People are prepared to come and invest in business enterprises of every type here, in spite of the fact that you people are trying to denigrate our efforts and undermine the economy in all your statements over the past six months. This should prove to you how ineffective your efforts are. If you ever did achieve Government, it would be better for yourselves when in Opposition to be realistic, face up to the situation and give credit where credit is due. But making exaggerated statements only serves to undermine the confidence of anybody who ever had confidence in the Opposition. The whole thing is stupid. I have been listening to the same type of debate on every Adjournment since I came into the House. We have had the same type of argument, people telling us to go to the country. We did go to the country.
Comment on this
We were in Opposition for a time and I enjoyed every moment of it. When listening to Deputy Dillon's speech I thought I was at the opening of the new Abbey. One speaker saw fit to make a reference to television and challenged me to stand over the appointment of Dr. Andrews. We appointed Dr. Andrews as Chairman of the Authority for one reason, and one reason only, that he was the most suitable man for the job. I think he will prove to be a most suitable Chairman. The reference to the television coverage during the Presidential election was puerile.
Comment on this
That coverage was a disgrace to any Party. One man was on all the time while the other man was never mentioned.
Comment on this
Items which had no news value whatever, entirely out of proportion to their importance as news items. I hope the day will never be reached in this country when the President, no matter who he is, will go out on a State function and not be covered by all the information media in the country.
Comment on this
He has done quite a few since. According to you people, he was so old he was not fit to go out.
Comment on this
Last night Deputy Dillon did not speak on the no confidence motion — perhaps he does not agree with it — but he gave us a history of the time he was Minister. It is on the record and should prove amusing reading. He took a new line, but otherwise his speech was entirely the one we have heard a thousand times. As the Minister for Education has said, Deputy Dillon with his histrionics and demagogy is always worth hearing. But, as I say, he gave his speech a new twist in that he claimed the Coalition ran the country into debt in an effort to build houses. He went on to try to prove that the Marshall Aid was used to get dollars for people who were importing steel to build houses. He said last night that he would build no skyscrapers and I do not know where one uses steel to build houses. He said last night that he would build no skyscrapers and I do not know where one uses steel to build residential houses. He said these people applied for money because they wanted steel to erect houses and the Coalition were glad to give it to them.
Let us take a look at what the Marshall Aid money was spent on. That alone will give an insight into the amount of truth, if any, there was in the entire speech, which lasted for two hours and was completely irrelevant.
Comment on this
It was an effort at defending what the Coalition Government did. However, he was entitled to do that even if it did not relate to this debate. As I said, it is a speech we heard a thousand times with a little new bit thrown in to the effect that they ran this country into debt in their attempt to build houses. When we came into office, it was to find houses lying vacant. It took us a long time to get back to the level of advancement again because the people were not there. The position has improved very much now, or disimproved if you like, in so far as the number looking for houses are concerned, because the population of this city is growing every year. It continues to expand but that is something that is happening all over the world; people are fleeing from the land to the cities.
Housebuilding is an activity with a fairly worthwhile labour content. Very often when housebuilding is growing apace, it is creating problems for itself because you are building houses for people employed building houses. This is the type of vicious circle you have to face. The prosperity of this city is considerably enhanced by the building trade. As I say, you will actually reach the stage where you are building houses for people who build them——
Comment on this
There are thousands of people in Dublin looking for houses at present. In 1957, there were houses vacant in Ballyfermot because there was nobody to occupy them, but today people there are living in overcrowded conditions, living in sub-tenancies which are not really legitimate. Much time has been devoted to this question of housing because the Coalition Government in their time failed to do the job. Now they want to harp on a situation which they feel will win them some sympathy, and to stress and overstress a situation we are tackling and will overcome. When that stage is reached, they will have to turn their attention to criticising something else, which we will most surely deal with successfully as we have often dealt with them before. You need not have nay worries. The harder the tasks the better we like them.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon dealt with the question of priorities in housing and social services. These are priorities certainly of a type and must always remain priorities, but if the economy is not advancing, there is not much good talking about social services or about extra money for education, extra money for social welfare, or extra money for anything. There is no use talking about these things unless the economy is sound and moving and made to move as rapidly as possible. These other things are consequential and must necessarily follow so long as the Government have the will, as this Government always have had.
The economy as a whole is most important and while Deputy Dillon would have us forget about the Second Programme for Economic Expansion, there is not much good building houses if you have not got the people who can live in comfort in them and pay the rent and be able to support themselves and their families. This is something which has been done and something which should automatically follow as the economy expands. Any Government who think that they can continue their expansion of the economy, without having the problems which must necessarily follow, are living in a fool's paradise. We are aware that the expansion which has taken place in the economy over the past five years, particularly the improved standard of living which has been brought about, must necessarily bring with it its own problems and its own difficulties. That always happens. I think our action in showing our cognisance of these things is in itself a sufficient guarantee that we will deal with them accordingly. I do not think there is much time left——
Comment on this
Thank you. The Taoiseach's speech, which was factual, realistic and unemotional gave a true picture of the exact position today. It is not a bad picture — it could be better, and we would like it to be much better — but we are confident that it will be better. We are also confident in the knowledge that the vast majority of the people have confidence in us.
Comment on this
I should like first to correct two misstatements of fact which the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs seems to have made. First of all, he referred to the Marshall Aid loan after the last war and he queried the things upon which portion of that money was spent. For the record, let it be said that in so far as the inter-Party Government of that period were concerned, the Marshall Aid funds were devoted towards the essential raw materials for building up this country. I do not think anyone will controvert that.
It is a pity the Minister in referring to these funds, and in referring to what he regards as attacks on the economic position of the country, did not recall that very shortly after 1948, when Ireland received Marshall Aid assistance, the hoardings and billboards of this city were decorated with the pawnbroker's sign. I wonder who did that? That was an effort made in a contemptible fashion by the then Opposition to suggest that the sharing of this country in the Marshall Aid scheme for the building up of Europe was in some way putting this country into bond and endangering its future.
The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs also seems to forget that during the period of the then inter-Party Government, £16 million of the Marshall Aid fund was devoted to productive purposes and when they left office, they left £24 million of that fund behind. How it was spent, what was done with it, is a matter of record but any Minister of a Fianna Fáil Government who is curious about it had better ask the Fianna Fáil Government as to the object to which it was devoted.
Secondly, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs referred to housing. I do not intend to go in detail over the debates we have had on housing but it is fair to say that, when the present Fianna Fáil administration came into office in 1957, housing of all kinds, for the ensuing five years, decreased and declined, so much so that by 1962 the amount of local authority housing being carried out was at a dangerously low level. Indeed, it was the strong reaction of the Opposition Parties at that time which eventually convinced the Government that they had to do something about housing. Whatever progress has been made since — and it is very small — has been due to the determined role which the Opposition played in and around the years after 1957.
I would like, having said that, to come back to this debate. The debate, as was expected, has ranged around the economic and social policies, or perhaps lack of policies, of the Government. I do not think it unreasonable, or an exaggeration, for me to say that today there exists considerable uneasiness amongst many people as to where we are going. Not only is there uneasiness but there is also cynicism amongst far too many people with regard to politicians, political Parties and political promises. They have heard it all before. Most young people today disregard the promises and undertakings given on behalf of the Government. That is due to the known contrast between the promises made not so long ago and the performances which the people can actually see. There is uneasiness and cynicism in Ireland in 1966, among people who only three years ago were told that by this year, 1966, there would be 35,000 new jobs for young men and women in this country — 35,000 extra Irish men and women were promised they would have, this year, gainful, lucrative employment in their own country.
That was the promise. The actual performance shows that in this year there are 6,000 fewer jobs and, compared with the promises, we have gone backwards to the extent of 41,000 jobs. There have been promises repeated ad nauseam by the Taoiseach, and members of this Government over the years. There have been promises of an expansion in health services and there have been promises of what would be done for education. Indeed, it is worth recalling that in one of the major taxation debates and controversies in this House, only three years ago, concerning the turnover tax, the Fianna Fáil Government and the Fianna Fáil Party at that time were so concerned with the public doubt and apprehension with regard to the turnover tax that they issued a public advertisement in the daily papers indicating to the people the benefits that were to flow from the imposition of that tax.
What were those benefits? They were an expansion in health services, an expansion in education, an expansion in housing, an expansion in employment and a definite move towards full employment. We are now at a point almost four years after that advertisement was issued and those pledges given but, so far as the ordinary people are concerned, nothing has been done. Our health services are still the same. They are creaking with age, antiquated, embodying the poor-house, Victorian philosophy of the last century. They are still good enough to allow any expansion being postponed until next year or the year after.
The same applies to education. Something is about to be done but nevertheless, now in 1966, in an era of the greatest possible competition and strife amongst the people of the world, we are allowing our children every year to leave our schools, many of whom are forced to emigrate, without the educational qualifications to compete with the people in other countries. Yesterday, we had more of this from the Taoiseach. We had another of those long speeches promising things to come. He was at it again yesterday. We are to have full employment some day, somehow. We are to have better health services, some day somehow. Now he has realised that a scientific explosion has hit the world. Mothers and fathers have been talking about this for a number of years. A scientific explosion has hit the world and we are to have an expansion in education some day somehow.
I wonder how long the Taoiseach expects the people to accept from him the admonition: "Live horse and you will get grass"? The plain fact is the people are not living now: they are leaving. They are leaving every week and every month. Even yesterday the Taoiseach conceded that the rate of emigration is a disappointment. Of course it is. That has been known to many people for many years. We had blueprints about prosperity. We had programmes that were to build up our country. The plain fact is we seem to be going backwards. There is less employment; more of our people are emigrating; taxation is increasing and social services are not attended to.
I wonder what the Taoiseach expects from the people? He cannot say that the people have not been patient. He leads a Government now who are possibly the oldest Government in western Europe. They are there for almost ten years. The Taoiseach has been given every opportunity to fulfil his promises and his policies and I do not think he can complain that he has had a disruptive Opposition to contend with. Certainly there have been no pawnbroking signs. There have been no posters of that kind indicating that this country was being put in pawn. The plain fact is that the progress which should have been made has not been made.
Now, I believe that we will get out of the economic difficulties we have experienced. I believe we could have got out of them sooner and earlier, were it not for the budgetary policies adopted this year, the fact that the two Budgets introduced prolonged the period of difficulty in the country. I hope things will improve, and that we will see some solid advance being made by the Government in providing for the people the things they need now rather than at some indefinite date in the future.
It was inevitable that in the course of this debate reference should be made to the Presidential election campaign and to its result. I am not going to make any comment on the significance of the result. Everyone is entitled to his own opinion with regard to that, but I think certain things should be said about that election, about how it was conducted and about the features which appear to have engaged public attention and imagination, and I am glad to have the opportunity here in the closing debate of this session of the Dáil to say a few things on my own behalf.
As one of the two candidates, I was subjected at times to virulent abuse from certain members of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
It is interesting to note that those who were most vocal in the election campaign have been conspicuous by their absence in this debate and have had very little to contribute in a constructive way to the discussion here on the real economic and political problems that face the country. I believe that in that election the people were prepared to reject any claim by any political Party that that Party alone were entitled to speak for this country. I believe the people resented as arrogance, and without foundation, the claims made on behalf of Fianna Fáil that they alone were able to express Irish national ideals in modern times. I believe the people generally felt that most political Parties and most people who engage in the public life of this country are endeavouring in their own way to contribute to the advancement of this country and I believe people desire more tolerance and less political character assassination. I am certain that is one of the lessons that can be learned by those who are willing to learn from that election.
Some things were said, and I am glad the Taoiseach is here at this moment. The Taoiseach at the commencement of the campaign proceeded to state what our national ideals were.
Comment on this
As reported in the Irish Press of 11th May this year, the Taoiseach said that the national aims today are an Ireland not free merely but Gaelic as well, not Gaelic merely but free as well, not only free and Gaelic, but united as well. That is a cliché, a catchphrase borrowed from the past. It is something that many of us learned to say many years ago and it represented the idealism of a young nation struggling for freedom in the years before the Treaty, but it was used by the leader of a modern Government in 1966 in a Presidential election campaign. For what purpose? Was it to suggest that he, and the candidate he supported, alone can express Irish nationalism? Was it to impute in a snide kind of way a reflection on anyone who dared to oppose him? He has an obligation now to express what he meant, to express in terms of Ireland in 1966 what he means by saying we are aiming today for a Gaelic Ireland and at the same time, a united Ireland.
He has an obligation not to throw these phrases into the arena and leave them there to confuse and mystify young people, to confuse and mystify people who are still believing and hoping that some day all the people who live on this island will again accept responsibility for the country. What does he mean by a Gaelic Ireland and a united Ireland? Obviously, that speech was made in reply to, or certainly taking notice of, a speech I had made earlier in which I referred to the fact that 25 per cent of our people, people who live on this island, do not share the Celtic and Gaelic background of the majority but are nonetheless Irishmen, and merely because of that accident of history, are not to be banished and regarded as second-class citizens.
I said that, in my view, their position had to be recognised and their right to pursue and hold dear their own background and their own culture must be protected. I should like the Taoiseach now to tell us his views. Are we going to wipe out 25 per cent of our people the majority of whom live in the north-east portion of our country? If we are not going to wipe them out why do we say we are aiming still to establish a Gaelic and United Ireland? Is it any wonder when things like this are said, and not thought out, that young people are bewildered? They do not know where we are going and what national ideals we are to pursue.
I would have thought that no responsible political leader today would aim at uniting our country, except with the support and the goodwill and the consent of all Irishmen concerned. Then, in a later speech, the Taoiseach went on to say that if there were not overwhelming support for the candidate he supported that would be taken as a signal and a sign of a national retreat. I want to ask him now does he think this country as a nation is in retreat? Does he think that the people who voted in that election were any the less Irishmen because they exercised a democratic right and a democratic choice?
Then, he went on in another speech to say that if the candidate he supported did not receive a substantial majority our position would be misunderstood outside. Again, I want to ask was there any reality in that, or was it merely an effort to suggest that the candidate whom he was not supporting was in some way nationally unsound and was not entitled to speak to Irishmen as an Irishman concerned, with them, for the future of the country?
I do not mind what the Minister for Lands may have said; I disregard what the Minister for Social Welfare did say; I do not mind what Deputy MacEntee said. It helped considerably, but I do resent the snide suggestion by the Taoiseach in that election campaign that, merely because I had not the support of the Fianna Fáil Party, I was in some way to be regarded as an object of scorn.
Comment on this
However, in my view, the election has taught many people a lesson. I believe it has indicated, whatever the political significance may be, that our people are beginning to think again. They are beginning to realise that, in a highly competitive world, new solutions and new thinking must be applied to the problems which face our country. We all recognise here — and I believe more people in the North in the long run will recognise — how essential it is to the benefit of our country that we achieve re-union. If we do not achieve the unity of Ireland in the years ahead, we will find ourselves — all the people who live in this island — at a considerable disadvantage in the economic difficulties we may have to face. I believe people will expect from the Government and from the Taoiseach some worthwhile thinking on these lines, not borrowing phrases from 50 years ago and throwing them around as if they represented considered thought in 1966.
I believe young people in particular are fed up with clichés, with catchphrases, with the bromides which are doled out to them so often. I believe young people today, just the same as young people in every age, in every year, in every generation, have an idealism, an idealism which is there to serve the country. They are thirsting for some worthwhile national aim, thirsting for some target which can be attained, some aim which can be realised and it is because they are not getting that that so many of them are cynical and not very concerned with the future of the country.
We in Fine Gael, as the main Opposition, are, I believe, playing a constructive role in the political life of the country. If we are not succeeding, at least we are trying to do it; we are endeavouring to promote new thinking on many of the endemic problems, problems which always seem to be there. We believe our policy, if implemented, will bring about a just society. Our views on health, on employment and housing, on taxation and on planning — are all designed to provide more justice for the ordinary people of this country. We have not the opportunity at the moment of implementing the things we advocate but we do rejoice to see that so many of the things we have said, so many of the proposals we have put forward, are gradually being accepted by the Government.
Our proposals on health were regarded as unnecessary by the Minister for Health prior to the last election and the Taoiseach himself indicated that he approved of that view. This is for us a sign that our point of view is commanding more and more support, that some kind of promise has now been given by the Government of a new health policy. In education, there is need for the application of more justice, of more tolerance. The Taoiseach said, in announcing the change of Ministers the other day, that that did not indicate any change of policy. We will wait and see with interest because I believe that in the field of education, there is a growing demand for more tolerance of the difficulties of young people and a growing demand to bring our educational standards up to that of other countries.
I can say now, at the end of this session of the Dáil, that we have had many general debates, many economic debates and all of us have said as much as we possibly could say. I know the Taoiseach has had to listen to a surfeit of speeches in recent months and for that I extend to him my deep sympathy. But we have come to the end of this session and I believe we can go away to our constituencies, to our other work, feeling that in this Dáil, all of us, according to our likes, according to our talents and according to our views, are endeavouring to work for the betterment of the country. I believe that if we accept that — and the people outside expect us to accept it — if we have more tolerance for one another, the country will be advanced and the future will be served. As far as my Party are concerned, we will continue to play a constructive role until such time as we have an opportunity to undertake the obligations and the duty of implementing in full our policies.
Comment on this
When this debate started yesterday, the Taoiseach used an expression, and I quote from the Irish Times of today, Friday 8th July, 1966: He said he proposed:
to take advantage of the occasion to give a survey of the more important matters affecting the economic, national and international situation. The debate would cover two confidence motions which had appeared on the Order Paper by reason of the rather childish jockeying for political advantage in precedence in Dáil debates between the two Opposition Parties.
I should like to point out that maybe by virtue of the fact that the Taoiseach owns the course upon which the race is being run, he is the jockey who has won the first position because there was no need for Fianna Fáil to put down the motion for the Adjournment. The House would have adjourned in the ordinary way but he put down a motion to adjourn so that he would get in first and get in last. So, if he wants to talk about people being childish, he has succeeded in winning the child's game.
He said he would give us a survey of the matters affecting the economic, national and international situation. If that is what he did when he was opening the debate, he must have been using words and expressions which nobody in the House except himself understood; there must have been some kind of a code he used because if anybody were to accuse him of giving any kind of a survey, he would be entirely wrong. He got up and started — as some commentators said — in first gear and stayed in first gear right through the whole time. In the half-hour or so he was speaking, he said very little. What he did say was not very important and, maybe, he is waiting until the conclusion to fire his big guns. But if he really took the debate seriously, and if his Party took this debate seriously, what has happened during this debate would not have happened.
Yesterday no one moved in the Fianna Fáil benches until last night when — whether he got permission to do so, or whether in his usual way, he decided to do so himself — Deputy Corry came in to explain the Fianna Fáil attitude on everything happening in the country. He ranged from all the industries he said he had started in his own constituency to the fact that he regretted that the German bombers had not finished off Dublin, and to the fact that Dublin city and county having defeated the Government resoundingly in the Presidential election would not have it forgotten to them by the Fianna Fáil Party. These are the kind of things which I am sure the Taoiseach would have been delighted to have sat here listening to when Deputy Corry trotted them out.
I suppose he was a better policitian than many people gave him credit for, because he mentioned what he thought were the national priorities. The former Taoiseach, now the President, and the present Taoiseach have repeated on more than one occasion, when they thought it suitable, that the two most important matters before the Irish nation were the restoration of the Irish language and the uniting of the country. I want the Taoiseach when he is replying to say honestly if he thinks they are the two most important things before the Irish nation.
Deputy Corry did not agree, and I do not think that 90 per cent of the people would agree, with the Taoiseach if he said they are the two most important things. Deputy Corry placed full employment, housing — believe it or not — education, and better health services for the people as being the most important things. If the Taoiseach would come out of what the late Deputy Norton so often referred to as cloud-cuckooland and realise that in this day and age we must face up to the fact that we have far too many people unemployed, far too many people emigrating, far too few facilities for education, far too few facilities for health services, then he would be justifying his existence as Taoiseach. I propose to give some figures in support of what I am saying, but I am afraid these things have not dawned on the Taoiseach or the Government.
Late yesterday evening, efforts were made by some members of Fianna Fáil to explain their attitude on this debate. I respect Deputy Dowling because of the fact that he, like myself, served in the Defence Forces during the emergency. He had to work pretty hard to get into this House. When Deputy Dowling on those benches accused the Labour Party of going Red or being associated with Reds, he was talking through his hat. I wonder is he to be the mudslinger with whom Fianna Fáil always seem to be well armed.
Comment on this
As long as I can remember during my period in this House, they have always had a mudslinger who seldom got very far in the Party hierarchy but was always well armed with mud.
Comment on this
If Deputy Dowling is going to descend to that level, he will have to be dealt with. He bragged about his trade union card but we know what he thought of his trade union card three weeks ago when the vote in relation to the ESB strike took place. If Deputy Dowling wants to engage in those tactics, he will have to take the criticisms which will be directed towards him in this House.
This morning the new Minister for Industry and Commerce decided to say a little bit of his new piece. Whether he was shooting a line, as someone suggested, to show that he would make a better prospective Taoiseach than the Minister for Finance, or whether he was trying to impress everyone with the fact that he was a tough guy, I do not know. I do know that as Minister for Education we had great respect for him because we felt that he was at least trying to do something. That he was not allowed to do anything was not his fault. He has moved into Industry and Commerce and started off by doing something to which we did not think even Fianna Fáil would stoop.
During the Easter commemorations and during all the pageants that took place, one figure stood out miles above everyone else, the figure of James Connolly, despite efforts made over the years by certain people to denigrate him. Because of the fact that James Connolly stood head and shoulders above everyone else, he is now to be adopted by Fianna Fáil and Deputy Colley claimed this morning that if James Connolly were alive today, he would be a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, or words to that effect. If James Connolly were alive today and heard Deputy Colley say that, I would not like to be in Deputy Colley's shoes.
Then we had the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I will say this much for him. He did not hurt anything because he did not say anything. He spoke for a certain length of time and I hope he understood what he was saying because I and others certainly did not know what it was all about.
I had better refer to the new Minister for Industry and Commerce as Deputy Colley because otherwise he might be confused with someone else. Deputy Colley tried to prove, and seemed to prove to himself, that the Labour Party were really a conservative party. He wanted us to go out on a limb to the left to prove that we were socialists of the first water. I do not think we need lessons from Deputy Colley or anyone else to show that we represent the workingclass of this country, first and foremost. So far as we are concerned, we have proved that here in the past few weeks when many of their so-called friends seemed to desert them in their need.
Recently there has been a lot of talk about changing the trade union laws. A question was raised here yesterday which proved the sort of thing of which the Government are capable. Some months ago the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and the Department of Industry and Commerce had discussions on legislation which was to result in changing the trade union law so that the effects of what has become known as the Fitzpatrick judgment would be dealt with and, as a result, the draft of a Bill called the Trade Union Bill, 1963, was introduced. Congress were informed that this was what the Government proposed to do and, in addition, that that Bill would be introduced together with two other Bills dealing with trade union law and labour relations.
The two other Bills were introduced last week and this one was not. It took a lot of checking to find out why. The reason was that one section of the Bills which were introduced cuts completely across and is directly contrary to the section of the Bill which is dealing with the Fitzpatrick judgment. So much for guarantees given by the Government and by the Department of Industry and Commerce that they would look after the trade union legislation and deal in a fair way with the workers of the country. This indeed is evidence, if we need evidence — and we do not need it, I may say — that the Government believe that they are here to represent the monied classes having been put here unfortunately on the votes of the trade unions, but backed by the monied people of the country. They feel they will look after that section no matter what happens, even if it means breaking their word and slipping into legislation sections that would tie down the trade unionists to the small concessions they have at the present time.
We have had before the House two Budgets this year but we have no guarantee that there is not another coming. The Minister for Finance was prepared to say on the Finance (No. 2) Bill that he did not intend to introduce any more penal legislation later, but he was not so sure, and he seemed to indicate that if certain things did not go right, it might be necessary to come back. Can anybody understand how a Government act when in a country as small as this they cannot at the beginning of a financial year decide how much it will take to keep the country going? They introduced one Budget and then tried to impress the country until the Presidential election was over. Then they came back with a second one and that they could even dream of a third Budget is past all understanding. It is nearly certain they are because a statement made by a member of the Government suggested it was not proposed to borrow any more money. They found it hard enough to borrow what they got, but if there is not to be more external borrowing, they are bound to attempt to get the money in some other way and apparently the only way this Government know to get money is to add more taxation to an already overtaxed community.
The Minister for Finance said recently that it was proposed or intended to ease the financial situation in September. Why September? Is it because a Bill which will come before the House after the recess will fix the date for the local elections for June of next year? Are the Government already prepared to agree that it is necessary to get money flowing so that if we are to have local elections, Fianna Fáil will have a chance of winning? We know, and everybody in the country knows, that the reason the local elections were not held this year was that the Government realised that if they were held, the Government Party would have been badly beaten in practically every local authority. I can assue them that even if they come along next year, unless something wonderful happens in the meantime, that same beating is awaiting them.
The Government may decide they will start money flowing, no matter where it comes from, so that in May or June of next year they can say to the country that there is an improvement in the financial position. One of the things that will not be accepted here is the antics of a Government who repeat, as the Minister for Local Government has, that there is plenty of money for necessaries. The Minister for Local Government has been saying right up to the present day that money is available for housing, that there is plenty of money and that all anybody has to do is ask for it.
In County Meath we have a few small towns where we had hoped to build houses and where we have been building houses whenever we get the necessary money. This year Trim got no money for housebuilding; Navan got £3,000, which the Minister for Local Government subsequently raised to £6,000; Kells got nothing. Perhaps it will be said there is not any money needed for housing in these towns. It is true that Navan requires £100,000 for housing: not alone do they require it but they had in fact plans prepared and the plans have been with the Department since December last. In Trim, they required approximately £30,000 to carry out a scheme for which they had prepared plans which are before the Department. In Kells, £70,000 is needed and they got nothing.
In the rural areas of the county, the position is much worse. Meath County Council got a grant of £23,000 for rural housing. A deputation went to the Department and the Minister agreed to add £10,000, making a total of £33,000. What are the county council supposed to do with that? All they could do was start four cottages in Oldcastle, eight in Athboy and 16 rural cottages, the plans for which have been before the Department. Of course, the Minister's idea is that we should make a start, giving the impression that something is being done. I tell him here that we have 431 applicants for houses, 206 of whom, with families, live in unfit houses, 147 in overcrowded conditions and 78 in more or less normal conditions. In answer to that problem, we get £33,000 from the Department to pay SDA loans.
We promised the money. Many people began to build houses and since then, many small contractors have gone out of business and many small and not so small contractors have gone bankrupt. The people they supplied with materials were not able to pay for them and the Department eventually produced money, but when they produced it, it was found that all that could be done was pay up to 1st April last which left us, coming into April, with a balance of £65,000 which we owed and could not pay. Then the Department decided they would give us £13,000 for the year 1966-67 to meet all our requirements for last year and this year, and when we went to the Minister to ask how he expected us to continue our housing programme, he made the wonderful suggestion that there is no reason why we should not promise people looking for houses that they would get loans and let them go ahead and build their houses, and next year we would get the following year's share and the people who were building the houses could pay then.
Is it any wonder the country is in the state it is? If that is the kind of book-keeping the Government are capable of, I do not wonder we are not able to pay as we go along. Parenthetically, I may add that I omitted to mention that the Minister suggested, with regard to hundreds of people looking for rural cottages, that we should buy land from the farmers and promise to pay them by instalments. He also told us that we should advertise for contractors and when we got the contracts, to send them to the Department. When that happened, he would not sanction the money because it would interfere with the Government's public capital expenditure programme. He said it will be all right, so, because there will be some money next year. This is the Minister who, during the past six months has said everything is all right, that there is plenty of money available, that all we have to do is plan and we will get housing for our people. Is it any wonder people are getting fed up with the stories they are being given by Government Departments? Is it any wonder people are disappointed?
Employment and unemployment have been mentioned. It is awfully difficult at times to understand, when people start quoting statistics, where the statistics come from. They seem just to suit the occasion. I shall now give some figures from the Research Department of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions in their Economic Review for June, 1966. It is easy enough to check. This shows that the number at work this year is 7,000 fewer than in 1964. It also shows that for the first time since 1961 the number of people in employment has fallen over the last 12 months. There was an increase of 4,000 in industry, and 3,000 in services, but this has been offset by a drop in employment in agriculture of 14,000 people. Fourteen thousand people have left the land in the past 12 months. The total number at work in April of this year was 1,050,000, of whom 330,000 were in agriculture, 291,000 in industry, and 421,000 in services. I should like the Taoiseach to consider these figures, because we hear so much talk about the expansion of industry and the fact that the vast-majority of our people are now being employed in industry, that those figures show whether or not that is true.
Unemployment and emigration give a very clear picture of what is happening. At 17th June of this year, the number registered as unemployed was 42,462. It is impossible to get comparable figures because the Department of Social Welfare tricked around with the statistics, I believe, for no other reason than to make comparisons impossible.
Comment on this
There does not seem to be any other reason why it should be done. Up to then we could compare year with year but this new idea prevents that being done. However, this is a significant thing. The numbers getting unemployment benefit or with unemployment benefit claims current on 17th June at 27,701 was 5,306, or one-fourth higher than a year ago. If the Taoiseach does not get the significance of that, let me point out to him that the people on unemployment benefit can only draw for six months and those people, therefore, who are drawing unemployment benefit are extra people who have come within the past six months. Therefore the number of people in insurable employment must be dropping even more at the present time. Of course, the unemployment rate in respect of insured persons at mid-April was 6.6 per cent, and the figure last year was 6.3 per cent, so even there the evidence is that the figure for unemployed is going up.
As Deputy Corish said yesterday, the hardest hit by this wave of unemployment are those in the building industry. It is very annoying to hear Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party, mainly by interruption, attempting to prove that the position now is better than it was in 1956, because even though there was a considerable number of people unemployed in 1956, there were very many thousands more people in employment in 1956 than there are at the present time.
Comment on this
I am not sure of the exact figure.
Comment on this
Yes, there were 79,000 more in employment in 1956 than at the present time. The Deputies who make comments of that sort should remember that position. In addition to that, they should remember that right through 1954, 1955 and 1956, which were supposed to be the black years, the number of houses being erected — right into 1957, when Fianna Fáil got control and when the slide started going down the other way — were many thousands more than are being built at the present time. I do not know whether it is, as somebody else said here today, a matter of not knowing the facts or whether it is a deliberate attempt to distort them that causes Deputies to make such comments but those are the facts and they might as well know them. At mid-May, the number out of work in general building was 4,620, and this was 1,349 higher than last year. There was also increased unemployment in the distributive trades, food industries, dock work, woollen industry and tailoring.
In regard to emigration, I remember that a few years ago the Government were bragging that emigration was finished and that we were not going to have any more worries about it. Again they told us all about the years when the last inter-Party Government were in office and about all the people who were leaving the country. It is only fair to put on record that the net outward passenger movement by sea and air — which is the only way in which these figures can be checked in the 12 months ended February last was 30,000, compared with 27,400 in the previous 12 months. That does not look as if the country is on the up and up. That does not look as if the Government are doing the wonderful job which we are informed by the Taoiseach and the Government they are doing.
As far as gross national product is concerned, in real terms there was an increase last year of 2½ per cent compared with an increase of 4 per cent in 1963 and 1964. Production in manufacturing industries increased by 3½ per cent in the year 1965, but in the fourth quarter of the year the increase was only two per cent. I am quite prepared to agree that this being an increase on the existing position, it is a difficult thing to maintain, that for every increase that is gained each year, it requires a greater effort to get even the same increase the following year. However, how can we have an increase in the gross national product when the number of people in employment is dropping year by year and when the number of people emigrating is increasing year by year? Surely, if we are going to do anything about increasing production, we must first find employment for our people at home?
The biggest snag of the whole lot is that our social welfare benefits are pretty low. If we had full employment, it would follow naturally that we would have very much more money available for those who were receiving social welfare benefits. It also follows that the more people who are drawing unemployment benefit, the smaller the amount of money available in the pool. There is one thing I can never understand, and in all the years the Fianna Fáil Government have been in office, they have never, apparently, got around even to considering it. It is this problem that a man who is earning £8 or £10 per week doing productive work can be laid off by a semi-State body or by a local authority and goes to the labour exchange, to which he does not want to go if he can get employment, where he gets almost as much for doing nothing, on condition he does nothing for six months. I can never see why some Department of State could not be set up to try to ensure the money which is available in this country is used in the proper way and end this complete waste of money and manpower in forcing people to stay unemployed rather than give them productive employment.
A typical example of this is what has happened this year in the Forestry Division of the Department of Lands. They have reduced the acreage from 25,000 to 20,000 and have reduced the number of people employed in forestry by hundreds. Men who have been employed in the forests for a number of years have simply been laid off without any explanation except that there has been a reduction in the programme. Surely it should not be beyond the ability of the Minister for Lands and of his Department and the Department of Social Welfare to regulate matters in such a way that the money which those people are reluctantly forced to draw from the employment exchange will be channelled into keeping them in full employment.
There has been a great deal of comment here over the past few weeks about labour relations. Everybody is blamed, except the Government. The Government do not believe that they have any responsibility here. Their principal whipping boy is the trade unions. The trade unions are responsible, according to them, for this, that and the other thing. Somebody suggested that there should be compulsory arbitration. Others suggested that trade union leaders are not doing their stuff. Everybody has his own solution, Like the thinkers problem, it is a case of everybody having a solution except the people concerned.
This is a democracy and we have a free country as far as workers are concerned. If workers vote to go on strike, let me make it very clear, neither the trade union officials nor the executive of the union have the right to tell them not to go on strike. After 20 years' experience as a trade union official my experience is that in 99 cases out of 100 the workers who go on strike have a damn good reason for doing so. Otherwise, they would not do it.
Be that as it may, we are told that the problem of strikes is causing a great loss to the national economy. I wonder if anybody has gone to the trouble of calculating the loss to the national economy represented by the people who cannot get work? Would the Taoiseach consider that that would be an interesting exercise? Who causes strikes? We are all blamed but we have an example in the State. The State is a very big employer. The State employs people in various Departments. The State employs people in the Civil Service at reasonably good salaries, regulated in a certain way. There is an appeals tribunal. There is a salary or wages tribunal that sets up the wages and salaries in a certain way and ensures that they are decent wages and salaries.
What about manual workers, people outside, most of whom work at ordinary labouring work? Does the State consider that it is an example to employers in that field. Is it not true the £1 a week which we were told the Government had adopted as the guide-line, and was all right, therefore, must apply to these workers? Is it not true that, so far, not one word has been heard from the State as to whether that £1 will be paid? Not alone that, but when something happens which causes trouble in State employment, such as the rotten system adopted by the Department of Lands, whereby they start men's holidays on a Friday night because Saturday is a non-working day, and count that non-working day, the whole of the following week, and the final Saturday, and deduct two days from the annual holidays, is there an appeal against that? Of course not. There is nobody at all to deal with that type of thing. Then we are told that there should be good labour relations, that trade unions should see to it that they carry out negotiations to the full before attempting to take any action.
Dealing with a State Department is going to court with the devil and holding the court in hell because the only appeal is back to the man who made the original offer and he is not the Minister for the particular Department but some official, junior or otherwise, who says what he is allowed to do and that he cannot go any further.
The State has a responsibility which it is not prepared to face up to. It is quite obvious to anybody who wants to see that under half a dozen different headings the State has failed, the Government have failed and the motion which the Labour Party have put down is perfectly justified. We honestly believe — if we did not we would not have put down the motion of no confidence — that the time has come for the Government to test the country. Let us see what the people feel about the Government! Do not mind what happened in the Presidential election.
We did not take part in the Presidential election. I am quite satisfied that a very great number of our people voted for Deputy O'Higgins in the Presidential election, not because they were told to do so but because they were voting against the Government. It is a peculiar situation when somebody who made the Fianna Fáil Party, who brought it to its hour of greatness, who brought it into this House, must have felt very ashamed that that same Fianna Fáil Party nearly put him out of his seat in the Phoenix Park at the end of his days.
The Government, in fairness to themselves and knowing what the situation is, as they must, should put this matter to the test. They could have, if they wanted to, earlier this year and can even do it now if they want to see whether or not what has been said from these benches is true. They could have a test through the local elections and see what the results will be. It does not take too long to arrange local elections. The people would soon prove that what we are saying is true, that the complete confidence of the people has been taken from the Government.
Do not let anyone try, as was tried here today, to prove that confidence in the people and confidence in the Government are the one thing. I had the pleasure the other night of being present when a mining company which was introduced here during the period of office of the last inter-Party Government, announced that they had succeeded in financing their second mine in this country and hoped over the years to come to be selling so much of their product abroad that it will represent an income one-half as great as the entire cattle industry of the country, and hoped to develop, as I hope they will, further mines in this country. These people were able, not because of the Government but because of the fact that there was confidence in the people and confidence that mines could be found here, to produce the necessary money from abroad not only to back up the mining and refining but the exportation and sale of the ore after it had been taken out of the ground. That was confidence in Ireland as a country and there is a great deal of difference between that and confidence in a Government who have lost the complete confidence of their own people which is, I suggest, the position of the present Government.
I do not know whether the members of the Fianna Fáil Party who are Members of this House and of the other House go around the country as we do. I am sure quite a number of them are very hard workers and go in and out of the houses of the ordinary people and hear what they have to say, just as we do. One of the most extraordinary things that I have found, over the past six months particularly, is the number of former rabid Fianna Fáil supporters who were prepared to come to me and to say that they were dissatisfied with the Government, that they thought they had been let down. When that movement starts, the Government have a right to look out for themselves.
The Taoiseach who, before the last general election, felt that the country was on the crest of a wave of prosperity and kept saying so — he was perfectly entitled if that was the way he felt to continue to say that the country was doing well — would now have to be honest about it and say that that is not so. The accusation was made here yesterday evening by Deputy Corry — I do not think Deputy Corry meant any slur but I would like to put the record straight because Fine Gael also made the same assertion — that, the Taoiseach finding a situation before the ninth round of wage increases in which the employers had arrived at eight per cent and the workers were looking for 14 per cent, had said: "O.K. Take 12 per cent", and we decided it on that. Of course, the Taoiseach knows as well as I do that that is entirely untrue. What the Taoiseach did, and I give him credit for it, was to call both sides together. He called the employers first; he called the workers. He told them what he thought and succeeded in getting them together again, after which an agreement was made.
I want to repeat for the benefit of Deputy Corry and the Fine Gael Party and anybody else who wants to hear it, that the ninth round wage increase was negotiated directly between the trade unions and the employers and the Taoiseach did not make an order by which the increase was given, any more than he made an order that the three per cent he was talking about a couple of weeks ago would be the wage increase for the country, because it would not be taken from him or anybody else. The three per cent was what he suggested could be paid. The trade unions made a very reasonable arrangement that they would take £1. That £1 is being put into operation by practically everybody except the State. I suggest the State should do so now and do so from a date, not as they are apparently doing in the case of the higher paid officers, from 1st June, but date it back to a reasonable date as is being done in the case of other employees throughout the country.
Finally, whether we like it or not, the people have lost confidence in the present Government. In those benches we feel there is only one way to test that confidence. If the Taoiseach is able to go to the country and come back with a live majority, then he is entitled to do the things he has been doing. If he is unable to get a majority sufficient to rule the House, what we have said here will have been proved. The country is sick and fed up with Fianna Fáil talk and no action.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish, who opened this debate on behalf of the Labour Party and Deputy Cosgrave who was the first speaker of Fine Gael, gave me the impression of making speeches because they had to make speeches.
Comment on this
I am going to say it again. I presume I have the same right to speak here as any other Deputy. I listened through a long tirade from Deputy Tully and from Deputy O'Higgins and they were not interrupted. I am not objecting to interruptions but do not start too soon. Deputy L'Estrange said that I was asleep when Deputy O'Higgins was speaking; I have not the slightest objection if he goes to sleep while I am speaking.
Comment on this
Listening to those speeches here — and anybody who likes to do so can check in the Official Report — it was quite clear that these speakers had no new ideas to contribute. Their ideas were not directed to any particular purpose nor inspired by any sense of conviction. They were just routine, in almost ritual conformity with the unimaginative and uninspiring roles of their Parties.
Deputy Corish began by explaining that this no confidence motion which appears on the Order Paper in his name, was put there because of his Party's concern with certain political aspect of our affairs. He realised during the course of the Presidential Election that people tended to forget his Party existed. Almost everybody did except the Irish Times and he felt that it was necessary to do something to bring the Party back into public notice. I have not the slightest objection. I note they are publishing a new paper for non-delinquent juveniles and if they will take my advice, if the next issue is going to be like the first, they should suppress it quickly. The image of the Party will not stand up to it.
Neither I nor other members of the Government pretend to be disinterested in political affairs but we are doing the work of the nation at this time without looking over our shoulders to see how it is affecting our Party support. The next election is a long way ahead, four years ahead. One does not have to be a prophet to predict that there will be many new happenings, many changes——
Comment on this
When the next election does occur, I am certain people will be concerned mainly with evidence that the country is being well managed, not with the outcome of minor tactical engagements that the Opposition Parties appear to delight in. I believe the people are much more intelligent than Deputy Corish assumes, much more informed and much more reasonable in their approach to crucial political decisions. Deputy Corish gave us a very pessimistic and gloomy forecast of our prospects in 1966. But pessimism is the stock in trade of the Labour Party. They have changed their party hymn from the Red Flag, as Deputy Tully assures us, to the "De Profundis".
I do not think there is the slightest reason for pessimism. Anybody who can leave party politics aside will see there is a possibility of a very considerable upsurge of economic activity in this country this year. Events may not enable all these possibilities to be fully realised but it can be said that provided we can assume there will be no further serious disruptions of production for any cause, external or internal, including strikes, there is scope for very considerable expansion this year and the prospects for next year are quite good. This expansion of production must be realised if employment is to expand and if our national development policies for education and health and so on are to be carried out, and particularly if the higher wages now being paid or negotiated in a number of trades, can be sustained without serious consequences on employment and prices.
I wonder what would be the attitude of the Opposition Parties to the proposition that the aim of increasing employment should, in this period in Irish history, have priority over the aim of improving living standards. I suspect their reaction would be to run for cover straightaway. I am well aware that this would, in many circumstances, be a council of perfection, that those who are in employment and who do not fear for the security of their employment, are not likely to be persuaded to forgo any personal advantage that might be open to them for the benefit of other workers in other areas who are seeking employment. In a totalitarian state this would be ordered and they could do nothing about it but in a democracy we have to secure acceptance of these concepts by persuasion.
I wonder would the Parties opposite join us in this work of persuasion because I think it is true to say that this nation has now, and in this respect, a choice to make. We are not strong enough at this time to take up all the options and if we elect to enjoy the benefit of higher national output in the form of rising incomes for those already employed we know we are weakening our capacity to organise at the same time the expansion of employment on a scale that would eventually equate to full employment. This applies not merely in respect of the national economy as a whole but applies in respect of many major economic activities carried on in the country. It applies particularly to construction activity, house building, water supplies, and road construction to which both Deputy Corish and Deputy Cosgrave, in common with other speakers, devoted a large part of their remarks. The amount being spent this year on these public constructural activities is higher than in any previous year. If output and employment are not rising in the same degree it is because the output which can be achieved within any fixed level of expenditure is contracting as costs go up and this is affecting employment also.
The financial problem of expanding output at a time when construction costs are continuously rising is very considerable. I know Opposition Deputies can put it aside or dispose of it with a meaningless phrase but the Government have to relate their construction programme in a very precise way to the resources that are available to pay for it. In this year, the output of State-aided and local authority houses will, we expect, be equal to and probably slightly higher than the output last year which was an all-time record. It is quite obvious that Deputies who have been addressing themselves to these matters either do not want to or are unable to understand the problem.
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants the precise amounts, I shall give them. The amount provided for housing in the State capital programme in 1964-65 was £15.37 million.
Comment on this
In 1965-66, the amount spent was £20.07 million. This year, the amount is £21.84 million. Never before in the history of the State was a sum of that dimension been provided for housing.
Comment on this
At the end of the year, the accuracy of this estimate that the number of new houses completed in this year will be equal to and perhaps more than what was completed last year, and that was the highest ever can be checked.
Comment on this
The problem is that a very large part of these capital resources made available for the housing programme in this year is committed to projects which were begun last year.
Comment on this
Not merely is this commitment in respect of schemes already in progress very considerable but it is larger than was assumed on the basis of information supplied by local authorities when the capital programme was being prepared. The real question, and the question the Government are now considering, is the extent to which new starts can be authorised in this year in the certainty that, next year, when payments are due, these payments can be made.
Comment on this
Deputy Corish asked about prices. Sooner or later, Deputy Corish and his colleagues will have to face up to the facts of life. If an increase in wages of £1 a week is being paid to workers in industry and other employments then, in many instances, that increase will cause an increase in prices and no system of price control could possibly avoid this in all cases. If the Government were to maintain a system of price control and were to say that in no circumstances may prices be increased because of increases in wages, then, in many cases the increased wages could not be paid or, if they were paid, they would have to be withdrawn. Deputies opposite are quite unmoved by solid arguments of that kind and have an extraordinary capacity to ignore facts but it is one of the facts of life which the Government have to deal with.
Comment on this
Of course, everything comes out of profits: if it does not come out of profits, it will fall from Heaven like manna. Deputy Cosgrave spoke about the Presidential election. I am not prepared, and Deputy O'Higgins is inclined to agree with me, to accept the voting in the Presidential election as a reliable political barometer: I wish we could. If we could accept the voting in the Presidential election as a reliable political barometer we could count upon a higher percentage of the total vote than we actually achieved in the general election.
Comment on this
We shall not allow ourselves to be tripped into complacency by Fine Gael's misrepresentation of the result.
Comment on this
Fine Gael should not mislead themselves either. In the Presidential election, we were fighting with our hands tied, and that made it rather easy for Fine Gael.
Comment on this
I listened to Deputy Cosgrave's speech with increasing curiosity. Almost every statement he made was contradicted by the following one. I was particularly intrigued by his suggestion that the Government could raise more money to maintain an increasing output of houses and other forms of local construction activity and similar purposes and then he argued that, if it is true that it is possible to envisage the release of greater resources for productive purposes then the Government must not attempt to secure them for these purposes, then the Government must not them to become available to private enterprise for the expansion of their activities. Make up your minds about what you want. That is something the Government must do. I hope Deputy Cosgrave and his colleagues will appreciate my difficulty in dealing intelligently with that kind of comment. We cannot win because no matter what course we decide upon they will always be able to say that we should have taken the opposite course.
There is one matter of some seriousness to which I want to refer in order to avoid misunderstanding. Deputy Cosgrave asked how our application for membership of the EEC now stands. It is in a state of suspended animation but capable of being revived very quickly when this course is warranted. Deputy Cosgrave asked if we were thinking in terms of a joint application to the EEC in conjunction with other countries seeking membership. We do not contemplate——
Comment on this
If Deputy Tully will listen, he will understand. The Deputy will hear better if he keeps his mouth shut and his ears open.
Comment on this
The brains of Fine Gael are calling. I think every Deputy understands very well that the political problem — and it is a political problem — for the EEC relates only to the British application. Until that political problem is solved, it is unlikely that the EEC will wish to reactivate their consideration of any of the other applications. This would be true even if we decided it was in our interest to "go it alone". When the way is cleared by reason of a settlement between Britain and EEC then we shall want to pursue our application without reference to any other application except Britain's because, in that case, our new Trade Agreement will be involved. The effect of the new Trade Agreement with Britain has a two-way application. I do not think that is likely to be a problem for Britain and ourselves. It was made on the understanding of our position as an applicant country seeking and desiring membership of the EEC.
I was slightly perturbed by the manner in which certain newspapers reported my statements yesterday regarding the intention to send a Ministerial delegation to Brussels during the Recess. I should not like the importance of that delegation to be exaggerated in any way. Its work will be completely exploratory and no active negotiations are likely to be involved. What they said regarding the composition of the delegation and the time of its departure was speculation. No decisions have yet been made in that regard and these decisions will depend to some degree upon developments in the interim.
I note that some Irish newspaper correspondents recently went to Brussels and met there representatives of the Commission of the EEC and have since been writing in their newspapers about the impressions they formed there. It seems to me that they behaved very much like innocents abroad and did not even make any attempt to check the motives of their informants. I should like them and every Deputy to keep in mind that when negotiations on our application for membership are taking place they will take place with the six Member countries of the EEC, and I say straightaway that we have from these six Member countries all the assurances we could desire at this stage in relation to their attitudes to our application. That does not mean that we shall not be in for a great deal of hard bargaining when the time comes, particularly as we will try to carry over into the European Community provisions somewhat similar to those we succeeded in negotiating with the British Government.
I gather from Deputy Tully that someone accused the Labour Party of going "Red", which hurt his feelings very much. May I straightaway dissociate myself from any such suggestion? The Labour Party are, and always have been, the most conservative element in our community. Far from the Labour Party going "Red", they are not going anywhere.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach did not make any improvements since he became Taoiseach, did he? We won seats in the last two elections. Are the Irish people going conservative?
Comment on this
The Labour Party are a nice, respectable, docile, harmless body of men — as harmless a body as ever graced any parliament.
Comment on this
I hope the Taoiseach will have the same opinion after the next election.
Comment on this
I do not intend to cover all the points made in speeches by Opposition Deputies. A large number of these speeches raised doubts in my mind as to the desirability of sending out to them all the documentary information we do with regard to the state of the economy and various reports and statistical returns. It is quite clear now that a large number never read them and those who do read them for the purpose of distorting their contents. In any case it is quite clear that no Deputy opposite had anything new to say. Their speeches were the usual stereotyped catalogue of complaints, unrelieved by any constructive idea, the catalogue we heard again and again throughout the session.
New ideas, or a new way of presenting ideas, is the mainspring of political activity and it is quite clear now in respect of both the Opposition Parties that their mainsprings are running down. The world is changing and the pace of change is always accelerating. Ireland is changing and the pace of change in Ireland is accelerating also. Both Fine Gael and Labour should try to find out what is happening in the country and overcome this innate revulsion of theirs to face new ideas. Deputies are not reading the information we are giving to them correctly.
Comment on this
I hope that during the ten weeks, or so, of the Recess, Deputies will do their best to try——
Comment on this
——to profit from experience, generate some ideas and give us some prospect of a new approach to things when the Dáil reassembles. They can go into Recess in the comfortable knowledge that the economy of the country is in good hands and, if any problem should arise between now and 27th September, it will be dealt with competently. They need have no anxiety of any sort on that score. We have been able to carry on the government of the country now for a few years without any help from them and I am sure we will be able to do it for a couple of months more.