We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Local Elections Bill, 1966: Second Stage.

Contributions 178–362 of 362. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Local Elections Bill, 1966
Enacted

No. 13 of 1966 ›

I do not need any breathing space.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

The Deputy needs oxygen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

As far as the GPO is concerned——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The GPO does not come into this Bill.

Comment on this

—— I did not express any opinions there that I have not expressed in this House, in Dublin Corporation and elsewhere, and I shall continue to express them, irrespective of the way in which the Minister for Local Government cracks the whip. I do not have to jump through a particular hoop as Deputy Dowling has to jump and I am afraid Deputy Dowling and his colleagues are very conscious of the fact that there is more than a chance of their being caught halfway through, if the people are allowed to exercise their democratic right and give their view now on what they think of the present Administration.

Comment on this

The main proposal in this Bill is to postpone the elections for a further year beyond the point of time at which they should have been held and to deprive the people of their democratic right to pass judgment on the performance of the Government, and particularly of the Minister for Local Government, represents to me a further abuse of Government power. As other speakers have said, abuses of Government power are becoming more numerous in recent years. Certain reasons are given for the postponement and of course they are not the real reasons. We all know why the elections were postponed last year but there was some justification for a postponement then because many members of this

House are also members of local authorities, and it would hardly be fair to expect that they should stand the burden and strain of two elections in the same year. I would say there was some justification for postponing local elections in the year of a general election but it was deplorable that these elections should have been further postponed in the present year. They were postponed at a time when a considerable saving could have been effected if they had been held in conjunction with the Presidential election.

We all know how scarce money is at present, how difficult it is to get money for essential services of one sort or another, but the Government have decided to abuse their power simply because the country is going through a serious economic crisis, a crisis brought about by their mismanagement. They are afraid to face the electorate and they are postponing the day in the hope that there will be turn for the better. They are postponing it because of the hopeless position in relation to housing, because rates are at an all-time high and the capacity of the people to pay rates is less as time passes because of the increased cost of living and the hopeless prices for cattle and sheep at present.

We are being asked to agree to this Bill for some reasons which are certainly not spelled out and in anticipation of legislation to be brought forward. It seems strange to me that this Bill should be brought in at present. If we can legalise what has happened since last June by this retrospective legislation, I fail to see why we could not wait that bit longer and again legalise by retrospective legislation what has happened in the meantime, in order to give the Minister an opportunity to bring in this new legislation in relation to local authority work to which he referred in his opening speech. He said that important changes in the law governing local elections are in course of preparation. It is quite unfair to give that as a reason for postponing the elections and not to spell out the changes.

One matter referred to was the extension of the postal vote. It is well known that we on this side brought in a Bill for this purpose and it was rejected by the Government Party without good reason. We brought it in to extend the facility of the postal vote to a large section of people who are precluded from voting under the present system. Now it is proposed to introduce something of that sort but we are not told to what extent it is proposed to do it. At the same time, we are being pressed to accept this Bill. There have been two postponements and I should like to ask the Minister if the Government next year feel like it in the circumstances prevailing, will there be a further postponement and a further abuse of the power they have in law, by denying the people the right to pass judgment on them?

Comment on this

If the price of cattle does not increase, it is quite likely they will postpone them again.

Comment on this

It is deplorable that the Government are using this measure to avoid their responsibilities and denying the people the opportunity to pass judgment on the administration.

Comment on this

I want to bring a personal point of view to bear on this measure. I am often provoked into thinking that proposals of this kind concerning local elections are really something of a farce. This Bill seeks to set, not in any specific way, but in a general way, a date for the next local elections. It does not give a date but mentions next June. I want to suggest that in fact this charade about local elections is unreal and it would be far more honest if the Government —and all political Parties—were to forget about local elections altogether, because the representatives on local authorities are no more than "fall guys" for the managers and the Minister. What power have they? What significance has this Bill?

Comment on this

Deputies opposite must see something in it; they are very anxious to have the elections.

Comment on this

My colleagues who are members of local authorities have their reasons for advancing their views.

I am not a member of a local authority—pro tem—although, mark you, it is quite possible I may never be, because unlike one of the previous speakers, I have no confidence when going before the electorate. My experience indicates to me that even the most assured may find themselves deflated by the will of the people.

Comment on this
A Deputy

It happened before.

Comment on this

It did, and it happened this year on a much higher level.

Comment on this

He beat the lot of you this time.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is nothing about this in the Bill.

Comment on this

If I were as long in the business as he was and did as badly as that, I would pack it in voluntarily.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not be around as long——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Bill before the House.

Comment on this

Let me not pursue that inviting line of discussion. Just to provoke a thought in the minds of the Members, I want to talk about the need, or the lack of need, for this election next year. Are we not putting over on the people a large-scale national imposture in holding local elections at all and in fixing elections for next year? Is it not true that when the members of local authorities are in reality merely ciphers, and when the policy of the Government, as laid down by the Minister in relation to the rents of Dublin Corporation which he proposes to increase—over our dead bodies, may I say——

Comment on this

May I say, Sir, that there are no proposals from the Minister to increase anybody's rent? I just want that correction made.

Comment on this

There are.

Comment on this

Let us be accurate.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have prevented Deputies——

Comment on this

The Minister cannot sidestep that one.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps the Deputy will allow me to speak? I have prevented Deputies from introducing matters which are extraneous to this Bill. Deputy Dunne is travelling on that road. I want to hear what he has to say to convince me that he is discussing some matter not extraneous to the Bill.

Comment on this

This Bill, with respect, a Cheann Comhairle, proposes to have local elections held next year. I am suggesting that any proposal of this kind to have local elections is a delusion——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not pertinent to the measure before the House. It is really saying, in effect, that the local councils should be abolished.

Comment on this

In effect, what I am saying is that the local councils are as good as abolished.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not provided for in the measure and, therefore, is outside its scope.

Comment on this

I bow to your ruling, of course, as I am always anxious to abide by the Standing Orders of the House. At the same time, it appears to me that the discussion has been very restricted. Surely, if the Bill proposes to hold elections, and I wish to point out the actual position which local authority representatives hold as a whole, it should be considered relevant? However, if you say it is not relevant, so be it.

To return to the actual narrow point which the Bill makes in regard to the date of the elections, it has been stated here that it is seven years since the last occasion when the electorate had an opportunity of deciding who would populate the local authorities throughout the country. Many of us have regard for democracy. I do not for a moment suggest that all the Members of this House have very much regard for democracy. In fact, I suggest that most members of the Fianna Fáil Party at least, have nothing but contempt for democracy. They feel that if they cannot fashion it to their will, then democracy is nought. Those of us who cherish the ideal of a free choice by the people of our representatives know that those people are no more than ciphers in the local authorities by reason of the hold which the managers and the Minister have over them.

Those of us who feel that we must maintain the thin grasp we have on the remnants of democracy, relevant to the election of local authorities, regard it as a scandalous shame that seven years have elapsed since there was an opportunity for the people either to return those who are now members or to replace them with others. It is verifiable that on inquiry from most local authorities, it will be found that from one-third to one-half of the membership has been changed in that seven years by reason of members dying or resigning and being replaced by co-option. It would be interesting to know how many co-opted members there are in Dublin Corporation. I certainly know there has been a number in Dublin county and I suppose there also has been a number of co-options throughout the country.

This is the very opposite of what is meant by the exercise of the franchise in democratic elections. A great deal of the abuses arising in local authorities are the result of co-option in a large measure and these co-options have become necessary because we have not had local elections for so long. It was understandable, I suppose, that local elections were not held at the time of the last general election, although I remember local elections being held in conjunction with a general election and it was not found to be all that hard on the candidates.

I remember a previous occasion when there was a Presidential election on the same day. This was a device which, of course, worked to produce substantial Fianna Fáil representation on many county councils and other local authorities throughout the country because the machine, the home-made Tammany, which we have all come to know, was at its peak at that time. Whatever arguments may have been adduced in favour of postponing the elections to some other year, other than the year in which a general election takes place, there was certainly no valid argument whatsoever brought forward for not holding the local elections in the present year.

Comment on this

Everybody knows the reason they were postponed last year.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Dunne should be allowed to continue his argument.

Comment on this

The President would leave the Park if they were held then.

Comment on this

The other argument is that they were taken together before.

Comment on this

That is a long time ago. It was in 1945, when the predecessor of the present holder took office. The Deputy was probably far too young, politically, to remember it but I was old enough at that time to contest.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This conversation cannot be allowed to continue.

Comment on this

They are merely interesting reminiscences.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

This is not the place for them.

Comment on this

In any event, as Deputy Barry reminded me, the reason the elections were not held this year was the fact that the energies of the nation might have been dissipated by local candidates for county councils seeking support for themselves rather than doing their national duty. This was obviously what happened but it might have worked the other way. At the same time, the fact that this step was taken is, as I have said, one more piece of evidence that the Party now temporarily occupying the Government benches are in the condition of senility in which they are.

Comment on this

The Deputy may think that. Local elections were held with the Presidential election on a former occasion.

Comment on this

You barely got over it. Next year, you are coming to Ballyhack and I do not think you will manage to clear that obstacle with all the éclat which you have shown in other elections. It is obvious to me, whether or not you will, that the date fixed in this Bill for the elections is far too distant to be accepted by the House as a bona fide effort on the part of the Government to remedy this denial of democratic rights to the electorate which has gone on for a number of years.

Why should this Bill not specify that instead of next June we will have the elections in the early spring? I was about to say January or February but I have bitter experience of electioneering in times gone by.

Comment on this

It would be a strain on you.

Comment on this

It would be an overall strain in that kind of weather. Why is it being put back until June?

Comment on this

In hope.

Comment on this

Am I right in suggesting to the House that it is hoped that by that time the cyclone, which is now gathering on the horizon and which will come into full force, as it were, in the course of a month or two when the new broom in the City Hall allied with the Government representatives on the corporation seek to inflict an average increase in rents upon the people of Dublin, will be forgotten? Is this not the reason for the postponement until June?

Comment on this

I wish interrupters would enunciate more clearly so that a reply could be given to the points made. It is obvious to me, and obvious to the people, that this is the answer. Indeed, I would not put it past the powers that be for the time being, the powers that temporarily be, to drop in here next year a month or so before the proposed elections—in April or May—with another Bill to postpone the elections still further on some pretext or other if the tide is not running right and if the storm has not by then abated. Let me say the storm will not have abated. The Night of the Big Wind will be nothing to the big wind that will sweep through the corridors of the council chambers in this country.

Comment on this

It is the case of the long night at the moment.

Comment on this

That reference has so many connotations that I hesitate to pursue it.

Comment on this

No better man.

Comment on this

Most of them will be with their backs to the wall.

Comment on this

We do not appreciate the electioneering at the moment.

Comment on this

You are innocent.

Comment on this

It is a pity that such promising young men of the holding Party on the opposite benches will suffer the awful experience of having what was thought to be prolonged careers cut off in mid-flight, as it were.

To turn to the Bill, we have no assurance in it, and we should like the Minister to give us an assurance. I challenge him to give us an assurance that this is the last postponement there will, in fact, be on the local elections. It is a matter of considerable concern to the 800 odd councillors up and down the country, if for no other reason than the relationship it has to the Upper Chamber, apart altogether from the fact that members of the local authorities, and the members to be, the various rúnaithe of the cumainn, have their eyes open for unseating the present leaders with all possible expedition. It is characteristic of the Tammany party. It is only fair that they should have assurance from the Minister for Local Government that this is the occasion when they can make their effort. Many of them have been engaged in long-distance efforts. The Bill provides in a vague way for the possibility of local elections in June.

Comment on this

They have been put back twice already.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would Deputy Barry cease interrupting? The Deputy will be afforded an opportunity to make a contribution. Deputy S. Dunne, on the Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Barry might make a contribution somewhere else on this Bill. It shows up great as the Corkonian attitude.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

The Labour Party are delaying.

Comment on this

Again, the rules of order, and indeed more than the rules of order, the canons of order and the laws in relation to profanity forbid me to answer in the kind of language Deputy Dowling so deserves. As I was saying, people, even in the Minister's Party, are entitled to know whether there will definitely be local elections in June next. People who are about to enter public life have a right to be told that in six months' time D-day will be upon them. The same can be said for some who are about to make their exit from public life, who will have to put their political affairs in order and retrieve from the wreckage whatever they may need in the years that lie ahead.

I have no intention of delaying the House unduly on this matter. I merely want to express my view, which I feel strongly, that it would not be right that we should have any discussion regarding local authorities in this House without there being some advertence to the importance of these authorities. I know this matter is not covered in the Bill but we are not offered any opportunity of making reference to the situation wherein, as I have said, members of local authorities are made a whipping-boy by the public for every piece of misfeasance which can be laid at their door by the managers of the Department of Local Government. I hope that I will have another opportunity of raising that in a much broader way. In the meantime, I think that the Bill is long overdue and we should, in fact, have the local elections much earlier than the date set out.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister, to conclude.

Comment on this

This is——

Comment on this

This Bill is——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Minister gives way, the Deputy may speak but he should have offered before I called on the Minister.

Comment on this

I will give way certainly.

Comment on this

The Deputy was asleep.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy de Valera.

Comment on this

This Bill is simple in its terms but it shows the desirability of having local elections. For my own part I wonder what useful purpose would be served by having local elections. As the situation is at present, elected representatives of the local authorities tend more and more to be of political groups. The difficulty for the ordinary citizen who elects them is that it becomes a competition very largely for popular support with a view to parliamentary elections.

In the present situation a person who is not a member of a local authority might wonder what can our local authorities do. The clamour from local authorities, as far as I can see, is, under political pressure, for more and more money from the central authority and after that there is little enough heard of them. The point I am making is whether local elections in themselves are, under present circumstances, as important as some people try to make out. They certainly should be separate from the Parliamentary elections.

I should like to develop the point about Parliamentary elections but I shall leave it at that because I can see that I could very easily get out of order and I do not want to do that.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is confessing he is out of order.

Comment on this

No; I just want to make this point——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If it is disorderly, the Deputy should not make it.

Comment on this

It is this. In 1965, there was the general election. It was desirable that the Parliamentary and local government elections should not be held together. This year there was another election and whether one regarded it from the point of view of the Opposition in 1945 or from the point of view of the present Opposition there is very good reason for not having confusion. Therefore, the only thing that could be done was introduce this Bill and for that reason I think it should be passed. It does not call for very much comment.

Comment on this

I am at a loss to know what exactly one can say in relation to whether or not there should be local elections having regard to the rulings on this matter. The last speaker raised a very pertinent point when he asked: "What can local authorities do?" I think this comes within the ambit of this Bill because the Bill, from my reading of it, says that the local elections should be held in June of next year. That being so, one should be allowed to make a case as to whether or not there should be local elections next year and for what purpose. I submit that local elections are regarded by a number of people as miniature general elections. They are an opportunity for the people to indicate how they feel about local affairs which are very much related to national affairs.

It is a well-known fact that local authorities are stepping-stones to either this House or the Seanad. That being so, local election time is an occasion when people are afforded an opportunity to account for their stewardship and the electorate in turn are afforded an opportunity of saying whether or not they are satisfied.

I can say, as a member of Dublin Corporation, that the local elections are long overdue. They are overdue because of the fact that what the people in relation to local affairs desired in the city of Dublin certainly did not come about. There are many events taking place and there are many things which should be done not being done because of the way the local authority operates.

In the second paragraph of his speech in connection with this Bill, the Minister says:

Important changes in the law governing local elections are in course of preparation. A Bill is being drafted to repeal certain disqualifications for membership of local authorities and to set up new legal machinery for questioning local elections by petition.

In the last paragraph he says:

The Bill also includes certain minor consequential provisions concerning appointments of school attendance committees and meetings of vocational education committees.

Why go so far and then go no further? Why can we not have an indication from the Minister when he makes this point that he intends or does not intend to take steps to alter the way in which local affairs are administered?

One of my colleagues referred to, and, indeed, I think Deputy de Valera adverted to it in a certain way, the question of whether or not any useful purpose is served by having local authorities, particularly in regard to managerial functions. This is something which is related to this Bill because we should decide whether or not it is necessary to have local elections.

I agree with previous speakers that those elections have been held off and I think anybody, no matter what his political affiliations, will agree they have been held off deliberately because the time was not opportune so far as the Government were concerned to hold the elections. That does not answer the problem. As Deputy Cluskey said, we are living in a democracy, at least we are supposed to be, and surely the people should be afforded an opportunity of saying whether or not they are satisfied with the administration of local affairs.

There are many facets of local affairs which are crying out for attention. If the Minister is now saying that the local elections should take place in June of next year, as Deputy Seán Dunne said, can we have any assurance that they will, in fact, take place? Can we have an assurance that things that are not desired by the people will not be perpetrated against them in the meantime? Can we have an assurance that the people will be afforded an opportunity of saying how they feel about the manner in which their local affairs are being administered? Will the people be given an opportunity, if and when county managers carry out Ministerial instructions in connection with rents, of deciding, through the ballot box, whether or not they agree with it?

I submit that there is little point in having this Bill if we are not afforded an opportunity of making a case for and against whether or not it should be today or tomorrow. We submit it should be instantly, because people need the opportunity, and deserve the opportunity to make known how they feel about local affairs. There is no denying the fact that there is a situation in existence in Dublin which requires attention for a number of years. There has been a housing emergency in Dublin for three years now and surely that alone constitutes a need for local elections? We read in the papers every day expressions of fear on the part of tenants of local authorities who are seeking to have something to say, were they but given the opportunity. I would expect the Minister at least to make a case as to why the local elections should be further postponed. What is wrong in having the local elections next month, for example? We have our own views and, indeed, the reasons given from these benches can well be substantiated as to why the elections have already been postponed.

Bearing in mind these valid reasons and the dissatisfaction that exists, surely an opportunity should be given to the people to determine how they feel about the members of local authorities, how they feel about lending themselves to a situation not looked upon with favour by them? Having regard to the fact that the Minister did say he was looking into this position, that he was preparing a new measure, might I ask him, also having regard to what he has said in his statement, if it is his intention to give members of local authorities more power? This is a very pertinent point because there are quite a number of people, apart from members of local authorities, who have become very much aware of the inability of members of local authorities to do something positive with regard to local affairs.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this Bill.

Comment on this

I want to intervene briefly to say that, in my honest view, there is no justification whatever for postponing the local elections still further to June 1967. I want to make a point which I believe has not been made already here in regard to local elections, that is, that too many people here in this House have little or no regard for rural Ireland at all. The Minister for Local Government and most Deputies here will agree with me when I say that, when the last local elections were held in the month of June 1960, the poll in rural areas was an all-time low. That was so because the month of June in the country, especially for the farming community, is one of those months when people are extra busy and if one gets a fine day in the 30 days of June, one is busy saving hay and so forth. I am wondering now if it is the attitude of the Minister for Local Government and the Government to forget completely that rural Ireland exists at all and if there is any consideration for the people in the country when it comes to fixing the time and dates for local or national elections.

What I want to suggest now more than anything else is that, while I disagree completely with the postponement of the local elections for the past two years, I do not think there is any reason whatever the Minister can put forward to justify postponing them further than March of 1967. Let us look at it this way—January and February are regarded as months when the weather is rather hazardous and there might be a danger that people could not get out one way or the other but the month of March would suit most people, whether it be in Dublin or the country. I am suggesting now in all seriousness to the Minister that he have a second look at this Bill and, rather than suggest June 1967, should suggest March 1967. That would be giving the people two advantages. It would give them the chance, denied them for two years, to change their local representatives, and would also give them a chance of voicing their opinion with regard to the national parliament one way or the other. At this stage the Minister should decide to have these local elections in March 1967, rather than June 1967 and at least show the people in the country they are not forgotten completely and that their views or decisions are not altogether forgotten either.

Comment on this

Great play is being made with the reasons for postponing these local elections until 1967 and all sorts of motives are being attributed to Fianna Fáil, to the Government and to the Minister for Local Government in relation to this postponement. But what really puzzles me is that, when a year or so ago we were postponing them until some time, any time, within 1966, the reasons then enunciated as to the advisability of postponing them were agreed to as being good reasons by the Fine Gael speakers. In regard to that, I should say that at column 800, Volume 217, No. 5 of the Official Report, we had Deputy Clinton— who was the chief spokesman last year for the Fine Gael Opposition on local government matters—at that time opening his remarks by saying:

We on this side of the House are in general agreement with the proposals in the Bill.

He goes on again and says:

Nevertheless, I think it is quite a sensible thing to postpone the elections for another year even if many people are anxious to have an opportunity to express their dissatisfaction with the way local government matters have gone during the past few years.

He continued in the same column:

Members of the House who are also members of local authorities have had their fill of elections for one year.

and further down in the same column he says:

I disagree with this view in the circumstances in which we find ourselves

——that is the view that these people are dissatisfied and want to have a go at whoever was in the councils for some years past.

Deputy James Tully, in the same debate—which incidentally was a very short one—opened his remarks, at column 802, by saying:

I have no objection to the postponement of the elections.

If those two spokesmen—I take it they were acting as spokesmen for their two Parties—had those views to express about a year ago in regard to a postponement, for which there was no different reason from that which exists in relation to the proposed postponement, how come there is such play being made and so many motives being dragged out of nowhere to be attributed to Fianna Fáil for presenting this Bill to the House?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The understanding then was that the local elections would be held on the same day as the Presidential election this year; that was the understanding.

Comment on this

There is no doubt about it—whether it is some little advantage the Deputy has that none of the rest of us have—but he does seem to have the queerest ideas about what was understood, that nobody else saw or understood and that nobody else stated from his Party benches was understood. Where he gets these understandings, I do not know. I am not disputing that his point of view, at this particular juncture, may appear very reasonable to him but he will pardon the rest of us if we cannot go right along with him and agree that this understanding was there.

There were only three speakers on this Bill to which I have referred: one from Fine Gael, one from Labour, and myself. Lest it might be said that there was a slip of the tongue on Deputy Tully's part, or that I quoted his first words only, at column 803 of the same volume he said:

As I said at the outset —and I have quoted the outset—— we have no objection —he said "I" the first time—— to the postponement.

Further down in the same column he said:

I expect that this will not be a very contentious Bill and that it will not hold up the House...

It is a pity that the same sentiment could not have been expressed and maintained in regard to this Bill.

Comment on this

Another year has gone by.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Many things have happened since then.

Comment on this

The things that have happened since then are not really relevant except in the mind of Fine Gael because the Fine Gael attitude a year ago, to be fair to them, was consistent with the attitude of their predecessors, their Party predecessors, Cumann na nGaedheal. Between 1922 and 1931, they postponed the local elections four times.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The country was in a state of armed siege.

Comment on this

I do not want to bore the House, but if I am pressed I can give the reasons advanced by the Ministers who introduced those four adjourning Bills and not one of them gave it as a reason that the country was in a state of "chassis". They gave all sorts of other reasons which were probably quite valid. I am not disputing that. They postponed them four times between 1922 and 1931.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You postponed them during the last World War.

Comment on this

That was in a period of nine years. I am being put in the dock now this year—although I was not last year—and it is suggested that I am being unreasonable, and that the Government are unreasonable, because in my nine years in local government, I am postponing them for the second time, although the Cumann na nGaedheal Government postponed them four times.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is no comparison and the Minister knows it. As I said, the country was in a state of armed siege.

Comment on this

I agree there is no comparison. Fine Gael are trying to be consistent with their past. We know they changed their name but I think they did not change their spots. I would hate to see them becoming inconsistent to the degree to which Deputy Fitzpatrick walked them this morning. Not only are they now inconsistent with their predecessors and founders but they are absolutely inconsistent with what was said by the Fine Gael spokesman who spoke on the postponing Bill a year ago. All one can say is: what happened to Fine Gael in the meantime? What happened to bring about this departure from the sentiments they expressed in similar circumstances last year which were consistent with what was done by Cumann na nGaedheal 40 years ago?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the Minister asked the leader of his Party, he could probably tell him why it was impossible to hold those elections.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not keep asking for it. He will get it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am well able to take it.

Comment on this

I admit he is a great man to take it. He needs to be because he leaves himself open. There is the inconsistency that no one has attempted to explain away. A person with an open mind and objective mind, who did not know the Fine Gael views last year or those of Cumann na nGaedheal many years ago, would take it from the contributions made here today that not only do Fine Gael hold that view this year but undoubtedly by their sincerity in expressing it here today they always held it and never departed from it——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): These elections were never postponed in normal times.

Comment on this

——that it was something they were almost born with.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The 20s were not normal times and the 40s were not normal times, and the Minister knows that.

Comment on this

The record is there. Only one speaker thought it worthwhile to speak on behalf of Fine Gael last year and I have quoted him in a way that leaves no doubt that a year ago in similar circumstances Fine Gael were approving of the postponement.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): To be held on the same day as the Presidential election, to save money.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick should cease interrupting.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The country will not accept that.

Comment on this

I know the Deputy will not accept it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The country will not accept it.

Comment on this

For the benefit of those who may come to read it in the papers or in the Official Report, I have put on record what the actual position is, and the inconsistency that has been displayed by Fine Gael in regard to this matter. I will go further and say that had the elections been held in June, 1965—as incidentally I should like them to have been held—there would be very few Fine Gael people on our councils today or during the next three or four years.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why not give them a chance?

Comment on this

The Deputy should not have any illusions about this because his Party had no illusions a year ago when they agreed that the elections should be postponed.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Nonsense.

Comment on this

Do not be hypocritical. There is no point in the Deputy washing his hands.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister can talk——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick has no licence to interrupt.

Comment on this

The whole attitude of Fine Gael is so patently false that the public will see through it. I should like to go back again to try to get Fine Gael not to lose any contacts they have and any consistency they may wish to display in their outlook, because when the two elections were proposed to be held in 1945—the local elections and the Presidential election —together and on the same day, which is what Deputy Fitzpatrick says he wanted this year, who were the people who were against it? Who were the people who on every possible occasion spoke vehemently against the idea that the Presidential and local candidates should be voted for on the same day on two separate ballot papers in the same polling stations? I need scarcely tell the House that it was the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this

It was not.

Comment on this

Fine Gael vehemently and vocally opposed it, and in great volume, and in many places are on record as having opposed it. Unless Fine Gael want to disown their leader of that day, they cannot get away from the fact they opposed it in principle— and very high-sounding those principles were.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You supported it.

Comment on this

Unless they want to disown their leader of those days, which incidentally is not something Fine Gael find hard to do——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Does the Minister disown his leader, because that is what he appears to be doing?

Comment on this

The fact is that the leader of Fine Gael in 1945 with the most high-sounding and apparently well-held beliefs took every possible opportunity up and down the country inside and outside the House of denouncing the Act and the iniquity that was being perpetrated on the people.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Do you disown your leader?

Comment on this

If Fine Gael were wrong, Fianna Fáil must be wrong. You cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

The point the Deputy seems to miss is that Fianna Fáil do occasionally learn something, but Fine Gael do not. Instead, they seem to forget what they already knew. I do not want to be pressed into going over the well-documented quotations and the flowery language in which these were delivered by the then leader of Fine Gael. Nor do I think there is any need for it because I am sure even the least of them will be able to recall to the extent that they will agree with me that his view was that in no circumstances should the Presidential and local government elections be held on the same day.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And the views of Fianna Fáil were that they should.

Comment on this

The point is that those were your views then. We did not go along with you. We held the two elections on the same day then and we won the two elections in 1945. Despite the fact that we did win them and that from the political point of view, holding them on the same day would seem to have been good tactics, the fact is that we have since changed to the extent that we did not intend, and did not agree, to hold them on the same day this year.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Referendum taught you a lesson. You lost the Referendum and you nearly lost “Dev”, in the words of the Minister for Justice.

Comment on this

As was very quietly stated here today, our revered President beat the lot of you and there is no point in trying to get away from that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You got the shock of your lives.

Comment on this

He did it in spite of all your gimmicks and tea parties and the aping of the scene in another far-away country and despite all the confusion you tried to create by bringing every sort of political gimmick into the election. He beat the lot of you.

Comment on this

Using taxpayers' money through Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

And by rattling the bones of men 50 years dead.

Comment on this

Never forget that he beat the lot of you.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You just scraped home.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should conduct themselves and allow the Minister to speak.

Comment on this

Thanks be to the Lord, the President is back, and no thanks to Fine Gael or any of the touts and tails that hang on to them.

Comment on this

He is only barely there.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy beware: this mocking might be catching. You people tried to do it during the election and it did not work.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He is there by 10,000 votes and numerically he is there just by a straw.

Comment on this

The fact is that he beat the lot of you with all the dirty tactics you used and all the gimmicks of all kinds from every direction.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Hold the local elections and see.

Comment on this

The Deputy says that the Bill denies the people the right to pass judgment on Ministers' policies. I suppose that could be said of Cumann na nGaedheal in 1923, 1924, 1927 and 1931. If it applies to me now, it must apply to them then. Just to show the inaccuracy of which Deputy Fitzpatrick is capable—and this surprises me—he spoke of the right in the Constitution to have general elections every five years——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): General elections are held by law.

Comment on this

The fact is that they are held by law not less than once every five years but the Constitution, which the Deputy was trying to imply came into play here, says that they must be held not less than once every seven years. It was the Constitution the Deputy was supposed to be quoting.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Does the Minister propose to change the law?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies should conduct themselves and allow the Minister to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

The Deputy should keep in mind that in using these tactics or inaccurate statements purporting to come from documents such as the Constitution, the making of even one of these blunders here in a debate is sufficient to wipe out the accuracy of anything else he may say.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister knows I was speaking about general elections every five years.

Comment on this

The Deputy was quoting his version of the Constitution, that there must be general elections not less than once every five years and he should be sufficiently upright to admit that he did not know what he was talking about. Even Deputy Tully was correcting him as he was speaking.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister knows that was not what I was talking about.

Comment on this

There is no point in talking to a man who when he has seen he has made a blunder will not admit it. Deputy Clinton claims that his Bill of last year would have extended postal voting—as he claims, to quote his own words—"to a large section of the people". The large section of the people according to the figures we can get would be approximately 4,000 and the electorate generally is 1,700,000. If 4,000 in relation to 1,700,000 is "a large proportion" of that figure and if this is the measure of the accuracy of Deputy Clinton in this debate, then I think we can ignore almost anything else he says.

In fairness, I may say that the postal vote, without any of this clap-trap we hear about "a large section of the people"—4,000 out of 1,700,000— has already been extended without any flourish of trumpets to 6,000 or 7,000 people by the present Minister and Government and we are not going around trying to tell the people that this is something that only we could give. According to Deputy Clinton, the 4,000 is "a large section" of 1,700,000. Then Deputy Fitzpatrick described the Bill as an instrument to destroy local democracy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I said national democracy as we know it.

Comment on this

I begin to wonder if the Deputy knows anything about democracy, national or local, judging from the way in which during the past couple of days he has kept interjecting and interrupting, despite the best efforts of the Chair to keep order. If that is his view of national or local democracy, it is not my view of how democracy should work in this House. This Bill, as we know, is a simple, straightforward measure the like of which Members of the House have not had experience of in the past, the recent past or the distant past, and its description in the terms used by Deputy Fitzpatrick can only be understood when one begins to appreciate the sort of Deputy the Deputy is.

Deputy James Tully spoke about fair representation. He said there are local areas, counties, local councils, where the number of electors related to the number of elected members shows wide disparity and that this is unfair representation. The funny thing about it is that we cannot expect to have agreement in Fine Gael on this matter. That being so, how could we expect to get agreement between Fine Gael and Labour? It was particularly interesting to note that Deputy M. Dockrell has quite a different view about this. He would have us change back to what we had years ago, back to giving more votes to ratepayers in some way related to their total valuation. According to him, it should no longer be as it is now, one man, one vote. He would have us revert to the old system of not having the heads counted but the money counted so that those with the most money and the most property would have votes corresponding to that wealth and property.

Therefore, I can never see Deputy Tully and the Fine Gael spokesman achieving unity of views on what fair representation should be. It is even more strange to find not only Deputy Tully's Party members in some of our cities but the Fine Gael members in our city councils here and there throughout the country howling when I made, or indicated that I was about to make, changes in these cities to give fairer representation related to the number of heads versus the number of seats by setting up the ward system and designating the seats nearly equally in relation to the population. Where, I ask, can I turn then except to my own Party?

Comment on this

What about Deputy Corry?

Comment on this

Neither of the Parties has shown consistency even in the past six months. If I could not rely on them for guidance during that period, how possibly can I be expected to ask them for or to get worthwhile guidance from them in the years to come? In these circumstances, one would be better occupied looking anywhere than over there. There is no help from over there. I should like to see fair representation, as Deputy Tully says.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why did the Minister change his mind since 1945?

Comment on this

The one trouble is that the Minister has changed his mind even since 1945. That causes trouble to the Deputy. This is the usual sort of legal quibble. If I make a statement, another meaning is attributed to it. I am quite simple.

Comment on this

A simple man.

Comment on this

Very often when I change my mind, even in the period since 1945, I do not claim I am right. I am making that statement for what it is worth, not for the interpretation Deputy Fitzpatrick and his colleagues will put on it in their own legal way.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It could mean anything.

Comment on this

That is true, when the Deputy and his colleagues get to it. Do not attribute to me the meaning you take from it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister was in favour of holding the two elections in 1945.

Comment on this

We did not do it in 1965.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They did it in 1959.

Comment on this

The Deputy's people in Fine Gael agreed that we should not do it in 1965. Therefore, they should not ask why we did it in 1945 and not in 1965 or 1966.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You sprang an election to jump the gun in 1965.

Comment on this

It is quite simple. There was an assertion that we are filching from the local authorities and the people their legal rights or their constitutional rights, or both. There was an assertion that the local elections were being held every three years. If we check back a bit, we shall find that when the three years were supposed to be the term between local elections, during a period of 30 years, there were exactly six elections held, which gives an average spread of about five years. Instead of having the election every three years as designated by law, the average gap between the elections was not three years but five years. If we are to become mathematical about it and relate three to five, how are we to relate five to seven? I know Deputy Fitzpatrick will work this out and be forced down on the side of the Minister for Local Government who is speaking here at the moment.

We had contributions from a few other Deputies and the one I appreciated most was Deputy O'Hara from Mayo, this morning bright and early. I am delighted he is now back in the House. He complained—I am delighted he did—because I did not speak long enough when introducing this Bill. After the past two days—I finished at 10.30 last night—I was amazed and gratified to hear Deputy O'Hara, who listened to a lot of my speech during the past couple of days and who contributed a lot to my speech by way of interruptions, complain because I did not speak sufficiently long this morning.

Comment on this

The Minister is making up for it now.

Comment on this

I said at the beginning of that two-day marathon that I intended to finish in 1½ hours if I were allowed——

Comment on this

It always takes him longer to get himself out of trouble than into it.

Comment on this

If that is so, it is unlikely I will give trouble very often if I keep on talking.

Comment on this

It depends on the recent count.

Comment on this

Perhaps.

Comment on this

I know it does.

Comment on this

It has not been published yet.

Comment on this

Though the reasons are valid for my decision that there should be a postponement — as valid as they were when they agreed with them here — they are now sorry and angry and disappointed that they are not allowed to do as they habitually have done— try to make use of national difficulties for their own petty political advantage even in local elections. According to their own professions, Fine Gael and their predecessors, Cumann na nGaedheal, never believed in and in fact, condemned roundly year in and year out, the use of Party politics in local elections. It is amazing that, in spite of those professions, Fine Gael would now avail themselves of the local elections in order to gain political advantage by distortion of our national difficulties. It is only the sort of mind displayed by Fine Gael over years that would be capable of doing that, and I am sure that if they are still around in 1970 and in 1980, we shall experience this duplicity again. However, many elections over the years, including local elections, have shown that the electorate as a whole have not been taken in by the duplicity of Fine Gael, or certainly have not been taken in consistently. Even we in Fianna Fáil really believed at one time that Fine Gael meant what they said about deploring Party politics in local affairs until we found to our cost this was not so.

As Deputy Tully said earlier today, no matter how a person goes before the electorate, no matter what way he may be described, when the life of the council to which he has been elected has run its course, whether it is the fixed course or an extended course, we always find that these people join up into Party political groups. Because of this I am firmly convinced, as is Deputy Tully in the Labour Party, that there is nothing whatever wrong with Party politics in any election, that there is every reason why Parties should declare themselves for what they are rather than go around in various cloaks before an election not belonging to the "bunch over there" sort of thing but, as soon as they get in, almost invariably having no difficulty whatsoever in finding where they belong, for the very good reason that they knew where they belonged before they started out.

This Fine Gael practice of cloaking the real purpose of some of the candidates has worked for them in the past, but it will work in fewer places in the future. This may be a fair tactic but it is not one for which I have a very great liking. I prefer to go out and fight the election on the basis of the candidates' declaring their affiliations.

Comment on this

The elections are not taking place until next June.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned, I do not worry a great deal when any election takes place, and that is more than the great majority over there could say. It would not matter if these elections took place tomorrow. However, I would hate that they should take place tomorrow because the Deputies opposite would be so disillusioned and would not be able to enjoy these few months between now and the time of the elections when their false hopes will be shattered.

Comment on this

Do you think Senators Sheldon and Cole will stand for you?

Comment on this

This is a great political speech.

Comment on this

In the Presidential election, it was Arkle by only a short head.

Comment on this

Despite all the tricks you could play and despite the fact that you had a start of six months in the race, you were still beaten.

Comment on this

Your majority was reduced to 10,000. The most illustrious man in Ireland barely scraped home.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy allow the Minister to conclude?

Comment on this

As the Deputy well knows, when a good stable is running a good horse with the right jockey, it wins only by the amount that is required to win the race.

Comment on this

He was never a front runner.

Comment on this

He has proved to be a stayer.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He had the welterweight of the Minister's Party around his neck.

Comment on this

We must give Fine Gael credit for the fact that they made an early start. There was not a gimmick they did not try, and good luck to them. They got away with some of the gimmicks, but the gimmicks that worked for them before will not work half as well the next time.

Comment on this

The Minister knows nothing about electioneering tactics himself.

Comment on this

You are beaten, and you will continue to be beaten until you get to the stage where at least from one year to the next, your Party show some consistency, something which they have not shown here today by their attitude on this little Bill as against their attitude last year on a similar Bill, for similar reasons, and which is completely contrary to the edicts issued by your leader in 1945 about this whole matter. Beaten you are and beaten you will be.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputies allow me to put the question?

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 53
·
Níl 36
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?