Nomination of Members of Government.
Contributions 167–379 of 379. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It is not the prerogative of a mercenary to show mercy. A mercenary is a ruthless type of soldier. Mercenary politicians can be more ruthless still and Deputy Haughey is such a mercenary in our political arena of these times. Not alone has he caused trouble with the farmers but he has brought members of his staff to the position of being public relations officers for this political appointment. It has always been recognised in a democracy—the Fianna Fáil Party are very fond of talking about democracy when they are in power— that a good Civil Service is the most cherished thing one can have, a solid bulwark between the governed and the governing. The Government, in the process of administering policy, of recommending policy, should at all times seek the advice of their senior advisers and officers. They are free, of course, to reject that advice, whether good or bad.
The people always had the right to have in the Civil Service and in the Civil Service personnel that bulwark against a dictatorial, tyrannical Government. The former Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Haughey, last week forced two senior officers of the Department to give some sort of press conference, or to make some press release, defending their position. When he did this, he destroyed that bulwark, or certainly made a very severe inroad into it. For the little time left with this Party in power—I do not care who cuts up whom with knives, tomahawks or anything else—and however long they last, I do not think Deputy Haughey's ingenuity will enable him to destroy the true workings of our Civil Service which was well established and well respected down the years. He is bringing it into disrepute by this kind of conduct.
Deputy Lenihan remains in the Department of Justice. It used to be very fashionable for the Fianna Fáil Party to say harsh things about lawyers. The lawyer was somebody who should not be in Government. Am I right when I think they have elected one as Taoiseach? They have. They are bringing Deputy Haughey, a lawyer, into the Department of Finance. Are there are any more? Yes, of course, Deputy Lenihan is a lawyer. Mr. Ó Moráin, alias Moran, is a lawyer. Deputy Colley, who tried to be leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, is a lawyer. Deputy Flanagan, the Minister for Health, is a lawyer. What is happening at all? They are becoming extremely careless when they are letting those bad boys take over. I am surprised at Deputy de Valera allowing this to happen. I do not intend to say anything about Deputy O'Malley. I do not think I should.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Malley is such a nice fellow. He is a promising young man. He looks well. He photographs well and he dresses well. He promises well, but when Deputy O'Malley comes to promise, he does not stop at anything. He is tremendous; he gives the whole lot. I am not going to follow him down to Shannon, into the dispensaries, out of the dispensaries, into the free choice of doctor, into the technical schools or over the ancient monuments, the rights for day nurses, the rights for night nurses and all this business. We will leave him at that. The Taoiseach has left him in Education. No doubt he will give him a chance to scurry out. He is going to resign next September if he does not get his own way. Deputy O'Malley says all this free education will be given next September.
Comment on this
Do you think we will have them? I think they will be postponed, if things are not right. If the cattle prices are not good and other things are not good by next May, you might have them postponed again.
Comment on this
Whether I am in or whether I am out, I will always be happy to know that the high standards of this House are preserved by Deputy Corry. Probably this might be one of the last times, or nearly the last time, in which a new Government have been offered to us and once again it does not include the name of Deputy Corry.
Comment on this
Deputy Colley continues in Industry and Commerce. Of course, he was removed from Education by reason of the extreme views he held here and there, and possibly other misunderstandings. He does not emerge out of this as the Diogenes of the Fianna Fáil Party, the honest man going to the Fianna Fáil Party looking for another honest man. I wish my countyman, Deputy Flanagan well in Health. He is too short there to say anything about him. This Government, bad as they are—and they will be appointed—should direct themselves towards markets in Europe or anywhere they can. Let them concentrate on the nation's business and not spend their time opening garages, driving into banks, driving out of banks, all those queer places, all those peccadillos —of course they are nice—dancehalls, public houses and all those kind of things which could well be left to the people themselves to run instead of using ministerial time in trying to get prestige for themselves, if indeed prestige it is. That is what is happening. The standards are becoming so bad that prestige is a very relative term.
In conclusion, I should like to say to Deputy Lynch, the newly-elected Taoiseach, a few words on behalf of the west of Ireland. He began his career—not his political career but his career in Government—as a Parliamentary Secretary responsible for the Gaeltacht and the congested districts. I believe that if he had been given any kind of fair chance and given money he might have begun a good job. The same was true indeed of all of us who had any responsibility in that regard. The only things we wanted were time, initiative and the money on our side, and the work could be done. I want the Taoiseach to direct himself again towards that and to see to it that wherever money has to be tightened or expenditure curtailed, it will not be curtailed in the area of the small farmers and small fishermen, or even in the area of the small hotelier or the small shopkeeper in the west of Ireland.
I would ask him to direct his new Minister for Finance to stop this terrible onslaught, looking for estate duties and death duties from the small farm which they never looked for before. This is what kills the small farms. I have often said that a series of deaths, sickness, losses on cattle or an unsuccessful law suit are things which finish a small holding or a small family in those areas. Do away with this business of trying to get death duties and all that kind of thing.
It does not matter how many fact finding committees you set up. It does not matter how many development teams you form because there are things happening now, which I see in the local papers, and the people who are seeking to promote the good of the people in those parts are merely saying what Deputies for those areas, both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, have been saying and urging down the years. That is the situation as I see it, and all of this will lead to no good. A multiplicity of committees, officials on top of officials, secretaries to secretaries, all of this will lead nowhere unless the Government are able to inspire the people. Some newspaper made mention in relation to the new Taoiseach, about his referring one time to those areas and classifying it as a problem of the spirit. To a very great extent, he was right, and if he can get that sort of situation going again, he will do a service.
I wish Deputy Lynch well in his office as Taoiseach. He certainly possesses the integrity; he certainly possesses the capacity to secure everyone's goodwill. There is only one area where I would fear for him, that is, that his gentle nature, which I hope is not as gentle as we think it is, will easily submit to pressures. And all along that side from his left right over here and into the next one, there is a gathering of gentlemen whose capacity for intrigue and pressure is unmatched. They have been described as the youngest Cabinet in Europe; they have been described as the ablest Cabinet in Europe. I would hate to use the descriptions I think logically apply to them and for that reason and through no objection to the Taoiseach himself, we are opposing this Government because they are, as Deputy Cosgrave said, the mixture as before and you do not achieve things by reshuffling. You do not cure a damp spot on a wall by pushing a chair over to hide it. You do not take a chair with a spring gone and put it where the light shines on it. It does not matter whether you put them backwards or forwards, or upwards or downwards, and downwards would be the easiest way to put these fellows, they are arrogant. I was going to say more. I shall not say anything more, but I think they are the subject matter clearly of such uncivil gossip all round this country that the people cannot be confident in them, and, regrettably, can hardly be confident in the Taoiseach who selects them.
Comment on this
I have listened for the past couple of hours, and particularly in the past half hour, and I must say I have been highly amused. I have indeed been waiting to hear policies of any description or kind from either Fine Gael or Labour but the usual clichés have been dragged out, with the usual abuse of the Fianna Fáil Government and personalities. It is a pity in a responsible Parliament, as I would like to think we are, and as I am sure we are, that we should have these exaggerations as a political expediency indulged in from time to time in this House, and that we do not get down to some serious business. It has been suggested indeed that the Taoiseach who was appointed today should call for the dissolution of Government and go to the country. It has been said that we have not a majority in this House, and that we have not got the confidence of the country. Let us look at the facts. Even the vote today in this House for the Taoiseach was 71 to 64. Where were the other seven?
Comment on this
It was said that we did not want them but we won by 71 to 64, with the Ceann Comhairle automatically elected.
Comment on this
You lost 100,000 votes. Why did you not contest the local elections last June? You lost 100,000 votes.
Comment on this
Tell us about the elections in Sligo-Leitrim. You hoped to get 10,000 in Sligo-Leitrim but you did not get them.
Comment on this
We have had Deputy O'Higgins talking about the long knives being drawn over the past three weeks and I could not help thinking how glad he would be if the knives were not drawn. The Fianna Fáil Party met in a democratic fashion and elected the person they wanted to be Taoiseach and they came into this House talking and smiling right down the line. The Taoiseach has come back and recommended his Cabinet to this House and has asked the House to vote on it. I have no doubt as to what the decision will be. All the speeches from the Opposition side will not in any way detract from that vote, nor will they gain any glory there. I am as sure as I am standing here that the Taoiseach chosen by this Party is not alone the Taoiseach of the Fianna Fáil Party but also——
Comment on this
It has been said that the country is gone to pot. There was a time when the country had gone to pot, but when the Coalition Parties had a majority in the House, the country was gone to pot.
Comment on this
I remember the years 1954, 1955 and 1956, and you were given your answer in the spring of 1957, and if you want to see what progress has been made, go out and you will see it all round you. I have heard criticism here this evening of capital investment in this city, in the matter of office blocks.
Comment on this
If Deputy Reynolds cannot restrain himself, I shall have to ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
I am sorry. If you want an indication of confidence, it is when you get investment of capital in the country. This has followed as a consequence——
Comment on this
This followed the election of a Fianna Fáil Government in 1957 and the restoration of confidence and it has of course been maintained right up to this moment. Who can say that the nation has not made progress? Who can say there is not confidence when there is still an inflow of foreign capital as well as the enterprise of Irish people in developing this country? Why do you think there is a shortage of money? I remember when Ireland was not doing anything and you could walk into a bank and get money. You could nearly take it away.
Comment on this
At the moment there is a shortage of money because the demand for capital is so great. Not alone do England and all other developing European countries find themselves short of capital, but even the United States finds itself short of capital. Then you are surprised to find that we are not in line with them, not keeping in step. There is a simple answer. As you want to develop and as you need to develop, you will certainly find that there is a greater demand for capital. That demand is there for capital but Deputies opposite say it is a shortage of money. Why cannot they realise that it is a vote of confidence in the country that people today want to borrow and to invest? There are more people today buying their own homes and glad to borrow the money to buy them.
When the Taoiseach presented his Cabinet and asked for the approval of the House, Deputies opposite should have given their wholehearted approval. They should have given their vote of confidence. Of course, that would be too much to expect from the Opposition. It would be too much to expect them to put the nation before political expediency.
Comment on this
Every single thing the Government do is all wrong. There is not an institution of government that is not all wrong. They are the judges over there. They will not recognise that progress has been made. They will not recognise the confidence this Government have got from the people down through the years. They continue, as a Party and a conglomeration of Parties, to seek to hold up progress for the sake of their own progress and for their own accession to office, if that day should ever come.
I was pleased on the Vote for the Taoiseach that the Labour Party said: "We will be a Party in future. We will build up until we govern this country. We will stand on our own feet." Then Fine Gael take the same attitude. I wondered when I heard the excuse given after the 1965 general election: "I would have put them out but Deputy Corish said they would not join us in a Coalition." There is something to be said for political honesty and I hope Deputy Tully will hold fast, and if, at any time, the combined numbers on the opposite side gained a majority of one or two I hope the promise that was made and the stand that was taken here today will not again be put aside so that they might have a short time in power.
Comment on this
I thought the Taoiseach told you that himself. He is more qualified to tell you. He has served the country for 50 years and we should respect his wish to retire.
Comment on this
I want to thank Seán Lemass for the job he did for this country and hope to see him for a long time in the back benches.
We have a new Taoiseach, and I am confident that he will give this Party the leadership we believe he will give, and this country the Taoiseach it is used to having from Fianna Fáil. I am confident that he will carry on the same high traditions as past leaders. The Cabinet have been nominated and those who try to see weaknesses in this Party and Cabinet find themselves disillusioned. They would have liked the new Taoiseach to make major changes in the Cabinet. They think this would show a difference of opinion in Fianna Fáil. It is a measure of the confidence the nation has in Fianna Fáil, and the backbenchers here have, that the same Cabinet is presented, with one or two changes in portfolio. I wish the Taoiseach well; I wish the new Cabinet well. When he comes to look for a vote of public confidence, sooner rather than later——
Comment on this
——our friends on the opposite side will have the opportunity of putting their policies before the people in South Kerry and Waterford.
Comment on this
I promise them judgment will be passed on their policies and our policies and Fianna Fáil will win both seats.
Comment on this
It is most unfortunate for the new Taoiseach that one of his first defenders in this House should be the Deputy who has just spoken and who is now leaving the House in rather a hurry. I did my best to listen to him and you will have observed, a Cheann Comhairle, that I did not interrupt him because I tried to get the message he appeared to be endeavouring to get across to us, and I did not succeed. I will freely admit that there are Deputies such as the Deputy who has just spoken who are much more conversant with manipulation and the ways and means of extracting money from banks by fair or foul means that I could not comprehend or do not wish to comprehend, but I do not think the House should be subjected to a lecture from an expert in this type of manipulation, who says brazenly in Parliament that in one year, during the regime of the inter-Party Government, there was a time when one could just walk into a bank and take whatever one liked out of it. As far as I know, that is exactly what Deputy Gallagher said.
Comment on this
——I intended my first message to be a congratulatory one to the Taoiseach, but I sympathise with him in his having to sit here and listen to the last performance to which the House was treated and to the team of crackpots who interrupted.
As the first Corkman to speak in this debate, I should like seriously and sincerely to extend on my own behalf, and I think I can say on behalf of everybody in Cork city and county, heartiest congratulations to the new Taoiseach. It would be wrong to present any picture other than that the people of Cork generally, irrespective of politics, irrespective of sport, of class or of creed, all rejoice in the selection and election of Deputy Jack Lynch as Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Cork people quite genuinely—I can assure the House of this—rejoice in the selection of Deputy Jack Lynch as Taoiseach and we wish him and his good wife well in the years that lie ahead of them.
Having said that, I must confess I am disappointed by his first act as Taoiseach. We admire the man himself as a man. There is no doubt about his integrity, his dedication to duty, and no doubt about the service he has given to his native city and to the country since he was a schoolboy in many spheres. There is absolutely no doubt about all that. But we had hoped he would regard the scene he had inherited in the way in which any reasonable, intelligent person would regard it and that he would tell himself he was inheriting an old-fashioned conservative policy with a Front Bench composed largely of elderly sages, on the one hand, and on the other, a couple of juvenile delinquents, and that he would have said to himself that he must get rid of these old men and the irresponsible juvenile delinquents. Apparently he did not see fit to do that. Perhaps it is too soon to expect it. Perhaps it was too much to expect of the new Taoiseach. Perhaps it was too much to expect him between 11 a.m. and 3 p.m. today to bring into the House some of the hatchets and tomahawks used against himself in the days leading up to his selection by the Party in order to chop down some of the people to whom I have referred.
Whatever the reason, and it is not for us on this side of the House to inquire into it, we are presented by the new Taoiseach, who, we are told, is starting a new era, a young man representing a new generation, with the same old hobbyhorses going round and round and round again. There is no indication that there will be any change in any Department under his leadership. All we can do then is to examine that situation and examine its implications. Here is a young Taoiseach embarking on a new career, with the country looking to him for new leadership and a break with some of the policies we have been following for the past 40 years, or so.
There is not much consolation for us or for the country in the set-up. When I refer to Ministers who are about to accept portfolios, let me say that I make my references in no personal sense whatsoever but simply to illustrate the points of view on the policy they have adopted in the past and are most likely to continue to adopt in the future under the leadership of the new Taoiseach.
We have the Department of Transport and Power and the Department of Posts and Telegraphs under the leadership of Erskine Childers, Esquire. I should not like anybody to think I have a personal spleen against Deputy Childers, but we all know that he was absolutely unfitted and unequipped to do the job he was given to do in the Department of Transport and Power. He has given nothing but dissatisfaction in this House and outside it. He has given dissatisfaction even to the members of his own Party. Those sitting behind him will admit, if they are honest, that there have been occasions on which Fianna Fáil Deputies have had to attend their local councils up and down the country and there join in expressions of dissatisfaction in regard to the manner in which the Minister for Transport and Power functioned. One could never get a reply from him in this House, particularly with regard to the affairs of Córas Iompair Éireann. The simplest question brought forth the answer that he had no function in the day-to-day administration of CIE, the ESB, or any of the other State or semi-State bodies under his control.
To make the situation more frustrating still, on the night following such a reply, he attended chamber of commerce dinners up and down the country and there he knew all about CIE and was able to produce statistics about mileage, man hours, wages, and so on. But he could never answer in the House. In other words, he ignored the elected representatives of the people. It is not without significance — I mentioned this recently —that all the major industrial unrest over the past few years can be traced to and is attributable to the State and semi-State industries over which our friend, Deputy Childers, had a deadening influence. Wherever his dead hand rested, there was trouble.
Instead of getting rid of a man who, I am sure, meant well but who proved himself to be incompetent in the tasks allotted to him, we find that the Taoiseach has retained him in the job to which he was obviously unsuited and has put him in charge of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs as well. All I can say to those engaged in one capacity or another in the Department of Posts and Telegraphs is: "May the Lord break your cross," because as surely as night will follow day, he will go out of his way to create confusion and bad public relations within that Department as he has done within CIE.
You will find that in a very short time the morale of the employees of all grades in the Department of Posts and Telegraphs will be as low as the morale of employees in CIE and that is as low as I can imagine. Of course, he will get a few brainwaves, that is for sure. We will have all sorts of alleged reconstruction and reconstitution within the staff structure of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs. He is bound to have that because he leans that way. I can forecast that and I can forecast the questions I will have to put down. He will dig up new men with new ideas. It does not matter what they are. It might be the manager of a chewing gum factory as there was in the past in CIE. Some other manager of a chewing gum factory will be put into the Department of Posts and Telegraphs.
While I congratulate the Taoiseach and wish him well, I want to express some disappointment at the manner in which he is starting his new regime. I thought that we might have had some news about what many of us, particularly those of us in Cork, Dublin and Limerick regard as the most serious problem of all, housing. This was referred to previously and I do not want to delay the House by dwelling on it, but if a non-political vote was taken among all Deputies, particularly those who are also members of local authorities, it would be shown that the housing situation is the one problem which we regard as the most pressing and most urgent. However, we had no indication that anything new will be done. It has been clearly indicated in recent years to people interested in the rehousing of those living in slums, hovels and garrets that the Government do not intend to do anything about the situation or to step up their present programme which, in many cases, is almost static at the moment. Each year we look at the number of houses being built and we find that it is decreasing rather than increasing. Members of all Parties in the local authorities are seriously perturbed about this and, of course, more perturbed are the unfortunate families who are expected to be content in the squalid surroundings in which they are living. Many of them if they can assess the situation at all must say: "I have not got a hope in the world of getting a new house for at least ten years." That is not good enough. I thought the Taoiseach, even in the short time available to him, would have selected a Minister with a broad, liberal outlook to go into the Department of Local Government.
Today Deputy Corish referred to the actions of the late Minister for Local Government, Mr. T.J. Murphy, and outlined to the House what he had done and what can be done. He showed how red tape can be cut and how civil servants can be ordered to do things rather than be a man who just draws his salary and lets the Civil Service run or refuse to run the job for him. I hoped that the Taoiseach would have tackled this with that spirit in mind, that he would have said: "I regard this as the major problem facing the country and the man I am putting in is going to tackle it". I appeal to him to have another look at his Cabinet appointments and I hope he will not be satisfied to let things drift as they have been drifting. I hope he will tackle them with a vigorous mind, which he has, and with courage, which he has, and hope he will decide to employ that vigour and courage and a new approach which this country so badly needs.
Nowadays when one comments on any aspect of Government policy, or alleged policy, and if one is critical— and I have heard this both inside and outside the House—it is fashionable to say that the person who is doing so is in some way unpatriotic and is rocking the boat. If you say "this Minister cannot do his job" or "the Government are leading the country into bankruptcy" or utter some such comment, you are told that you are not a true Irishman, that you are rocking the boat and that we should all row together. We should all row together, of course, when the Fianna Fáil Party are at the helm. Deputy Gallagher said that he had listened to all the speeches here today and that he had not heard any kind of constructive policy enunciated by the Labour Party. The Labour Party speakers included Deputy Corish, Deputy Dunne, Deputy James Tully and Deputy Cluskey, and Deputy Gallagher is hard of hearing or his mental capacity is such that he cannot assimilate doctrine or policy when he hears it, or he is a knave who pretends he does not understand. Labour Party speakers made it quite clear what our broad policy is on all matters, and if anybody wants to know the details of Labour Party policy on education, health or local Government, we shall be glad to supply him with that information. We shall avail of the various opportunities of debate in this House to expand the details of Labour Party policy on these various matters.
Under Fianna Fáil Government for a long number of years, either with sinister motives, deliberately or accidentally, the Government have lost the ideal of the men whose Rising we celebrated this year. We think it is our duty to bring the Government back to earth, to reiterate again and again, even to the point of boring people, the words enshrined in the Proclamation of 1916 and get them to apply these ideals to present day needs. In other words, we are not satisfied — the Government apparently are—by saying to Mrs. Murphy and her husband and three children living in a garret in Shandon Street in Cork: "We can do nothing for you for the next ten years." We are not satisfied, and we think the Government should wake up to this, with saying to young Tommy Murphy because he happens to be the son of a docker, no matter what his ability is, at the age of 14: "There is no more free education for you. You must go out and work; take a messenger boy's job and, for your further education, we will insist on sending you to school for one day per week." That is not good enough nor is it in accordance with the principles outlined in the 1916 Proclamation.
Further, we say it is not good enough to say to a man or woman of 75 or 80 years of age living alone: "We are doling you out these few shillings each week by way of old age pension but if you fall sick we have no place to put you, no hospital for you, no homes for the aged, even no local authority nurses who might call daily to look after you." We just leave them there until they rot. How often do we see it happen, lone elderly people dying of the cold and starvation in this Christian community of ours in 1966? These are the basic things on which the Labour Party builds its policy. Deputy Gallagher was in too much of a hurry to listen but if he wants any further information regarding Labour Party policy I shall be glad to give it to him.
I conclude by again wishing the new Taoiseach well and I hope some message will reach him from what I have said in regard to the changes that I and Cork people generally expect him to implement.
Comment on this
As one who has been more closely associated with the new Taoiseach than most Members of this House, I should like to join in the congratulations proffered to him by Deputy Casey, my fellow Deputy from Cork. I knew the Taoiseach as a fellow student. I worked with him and against him as a member of the Cork circuit of the Bar. I entered politics as a man consistently opposed to him, both on the hustings and the local elections. I, like Deputy Casey, formed the same opinion of him as most people in Cork have, that he is a man of decency and integrity, two qualities which can be quite an incapacity in dealing with some of the Front Bench he has presented to the House this afternoon to ratify as Members of the Government.
I wish him well and I assure the new Cabinet that in using disparaging terms, I do not throw a blanket over the entire Front Bench, but there are elements in it which are wildly hopeful and optimistic about the claims they make in regard to what they will be able to do in their Departments. One thing on which the Taoiseach should insist is that when a Minister makes a promise whether in this House, the Parliament of the people, or at a dinner of the NUJ in Dún Laoghaire or on Telefís Éireann, it should be fulfilled. The people expect the integrity of the House to be respected and the integrity of the Government should be respected. When a Minister makes a promise, he should be sure that he has a reasonable chance of honouring it. I do not believe that can be said about some of the promises made by Ministers who were re-selected here today by the Taoiseach to fulfil their promises. As far as that is concerned, I regret that the Taoiseach had not the foresight to change these Ministers.
It is difficult to know why, at this stage, the House has been asked to elect a new Taoiseach and thereby elect a new Front Bench. When it is agreed — and this is something that pleases all of us—that the former Taoiseach did not resign for reasons of ill-health, those of us who have seen him working in full possession of all his very fine faculties must ask ourselves why, at this stage, did he have to vacate the seat which was today filled by Deputy Lynch, particularly when Deputy Lemass, being a skilled politician, knew that was going to cause disunity in the Party from which the Party will suffer for many years to come. Inevitably we ask ourselves why did he have to take this extreme step? We couple that with the knowledge that he himself has admitted that the Second Programme for Economic Expansion must now be reshaped. Must it be reshaped so drastically that its architect had to leave the position of Taoiseach so that he would not impede the reshaping of this Programme?
If it was necessary for him to disappear for that reason, as a manoeuvre, it will be a failure, but if the Second Programme must be changed, I rejoice in one respect particularly, one already referred to by nearly every Deputy on this side of the House who has had any occasion to survey the miserable failure of successive Fianna Fáil Governments to deal with the most urgent social programme we have. Having described it in these terms, I need scarcely mention that I am speaking of housing. The fact that the figures for houses built by local authorities decreased year after year once the Fianna Fáil Government came back into power after 1957 is no mere accident. I here challenge the new Taoiseach and all those associated with him on the Front Bench of the new Government to deny that was the deliberate policy of the First Programme for Economic Expansion. It was stated plainly in the document that matters such as housing and hospitalisation had been adequately catered for in most centres in the country and that in future capital funds should be deliberately diverted to matters which they described as productive.
That was not an accident: it was a deliberate portion of Fianna Fáil policy in the First Programme for Economic Expansion. Any Fianna Fáil Deputy may look at the document and he will find it enshrined there. The Second Programme followed and again there was the same depressing outlook enshrined there, with the result that every Deputy who stood up to speak felt conscientiously impelled to remind the new Taoiseach of his responsibilities to the tens of thousands of families, not just tens of thousands of people, but tens of thousands of families who, as a result of Fianna Fáil policy, are deliberately being left to rot and fester in the slums of Dublin, Cork, Limerick and other centres.
I appeal to the new Taoiseach with a particular sense of confidence because he, as a member of Cork Corporation with myself and Deputy Casey, who has just spoken, had reason to see at first-hand the dreadful conditions under which men and women were expected to bring up their families in his native city of Cork. I can tell him that those who welcome him in Cork on Saturday night as the first Cork Taoiseach will expect that he will advert to the first necessity in his own constituency and that he will advert also to the necessities of the city of Dublin and various other cities who are plagued with this dreadful social ill, deliberately—and again I say "deliberately"—inflicted on the people by the pragmatic gentleman who preceded the present Taoiseach as Leader of the Government.
I confidently look to the new Taoiseach to change that policy. I confidently expect that when the Second Programme for Economic Expansion is re-appraised, one of the things that will be expunged from it is the fallacy that, generally speaking, the housing needs of the people have been met. They have not been met, and if the Taoiseach is advised they have been met, he has been ill-advised, and I would ask him to look at his own constituency, to look at the constituency that sent him to Dáil Éireann so that he could achieve the highest position in the gift of the Irish people, and, observing it, to resolve that that situation should be righted as rapidly as possible and, that situation being righted, that it should be righted elsewhere as well.
There is on the records of this House within the past few months another crying injustice which I hope the new Taoiseach will rectify. I asked a question here in this regard and later made reference to the fact that old age pensioners and widows who received increased allowances from the British Government had these allowances, in effect, deliberately taken from them by the Department of Finance which the Taoiseach has just left. The facts are that old age pensioners, widows and various others who are in receipt of pensions from the British Government had their pensions increased by a certain percentage which the British Government thought appropriate. When they arrived here, they were siphoned off into the Department to the extent of £564,000, so that what happened, in effect, was that £564,000 sent into this country by the British Government for the individual benefit of a specified number of recipients was diverted at source by the Government, which was immoral, which was unjust. I confidently look to the new Taoiseach to see this injustice is also righted.
The former Taoiseach, on 12th October last, made reference to his view as to how Telefís Éireann and Radio Éireann should be used as a medium of communication of political thought. It caused me and most thinking men in this House and outside it the gravest concern. It amounted to this, that the Government are the arbiters of what is or what is not to appear in the news section or any propaganda section of Telefís Éireann.
On the debate for the Department of Posts and Telegraphs, the then Minister for Posts and Telegraphs was faced with it, and when it was pointed out to him that under section 31 of the Broadcasting Act he had certain powers but that under section 18 of the same Act, the Broadcasting Authority had certain duties, the then Minister for Posts and Telegraphs impudently said that he was the final arbiter and that no matter what the law enacted by this Parliament said, he was going to say eventually what would appear on Telefís Éireann or Radio Éireann by way of comment on current affairs.
I hope the new Taoiseach, when replying to this debate, will in some way modify the views expressed by Deputy Seán Lemass as Taoiseach here on 12th October and will admit that the Government have no right whatsoever to interfere with the statutory duty of Telefís Éireann under section 18 of the Broadcasting Act to present news and comments on current matters in a fair and objective fashion.
I am sorry to say that the Taoiseach's choice as the new Minister for Posts and Telegraphs has increased rather than abated the agitation which I felt when Deputy Joe Brennan, the then Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, told me in reply to a question that he would be the boss as far as the presentation of news on Telefís Éireann was concerned. The new Minister for Posts and Telegraphs is even more autocratic. Still more disturbing is the fact that we have a Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and Transport and Power but most of the duties of Posts and Telegraphs are to be carried out by a Parliamentary Secretary, as yet unnamed. It is unfair to throw a burden of this nature upon the new Parliamentary Secretary, whoever he may be. A Department as important as Posts and Telegraphs should have been given more thought by the Taoiseach, and he should realise that having regard to the immense impact which presentations from Telefís Éireann and Radio Éireann have on the public mind, the Department of Posts and Telegraphs should not be relegated to the status of being looked after by a Parliamentary Secretary alone.
I do not intend to keep the House much longer. I again want to say I hope the Taoiseach is aware that he has had cast upon him an immense burden, a burden which many of us feel the former Taoiseach felt he could no longer bear. The former Taoiseach has left the Front Bench as a confession of the failure of his Second Programme for Economic Expansion. When the Taoiseach was gathering around him what should be the best brains and the highest standard of integrity in this country to deal with the many problems with which he will have to deal, there were quite a number of omissions he could usefully have made from the Front Bench which he now asks us to ratify as the Cabinet.
I am sorry some of the old Ministers have again been included. I am sorry some Ministers who have behaved in a most irrational fashion, who have made promises they know they cannot justify, are allowed to remain with the same portfolio. I refer particularly to the most unreasonable claim of the Minister for Education that by next September every child who leaves the primary school will be given post-primary education. Anybody who knows anything about the set-up in post-primary education knows, just as the Minister knows if he has been advised by his officials, that that is absolutely impossible. It is unfair that the mothers and fathers of children who will be looking for post-primary education next September should be treated in this fashion by the Minister. The Taoiseach might well have shown his bona fides to the Irish people by tactfully dropping the Minister for Education from the portfolio he holds now, just as tactfully as he dropped the Minister for Agriculture into the Department of Finance. As to whether that is a wise move or not, people will have their own views, but it is a good thing to see that the former Minister for Agriculture no longer has that portfolio. If I had my way, he would not hold a portfolio at all and I think the country would rejoice in that.
The Taoiseach, I am quite certain, has the goodwill of the Irish people. If he can control his Cabinet, if he can get his Cabinet to work as a team, he has some hope of making his term of office as Taoiseach a successful one. I believe that he will not be able to control the Cabinet in that fashion. He had the opportunity today of giving to the Irish people a Cabinet which was more fully pruned. Had he done so, we might have welcomed more his advent as Taoiseach in this House.
Comment on this
I want to add my congratulations to the new Taoiseach, a man of dignity, a man of vigour and courage. It has been indicated by the Opposition speakers that he has these characteristics—dignity, vigour and courage. We on this side of the House are proud that we have elected such a man, a man who will inspire public confidence and, no doubt, one who will carry with him the good wishes of all responsible Members of this House, irrespective of the side of the House to which they belong.
We have witnessed here today the dignified manner in which he presented his Ministers to the House and asked for their adoption. We have listened tonight to five or six speakers. To give the last speaker his due, he did the best he could to make a reasonable speech while trying to extract all the political advantage that he could, unlike many of the speakers who went before him.
For the last half hour or so the trend of the discussion was towards knives and hatchets, bullseyes and chewing gum. That is what we have been treated to by members of the Opposition, the political hardware merchants of the Dáil. These able, efficient and honourable men——
Comment on this
——have been attacked by the character assassins of the Opposition. This is, I suppose, something that we have come to expect when a man of dignity, vigour and courage presents in a dignified manner to the House able and efficient men. The present position is unlike the situation that existed when Ministers were presented on a previous occasion after auctions that took place for the spoils for many weeks prior to their presentation. These are men who will work as a team, men who did not seek the offices in the manner in which the people of another Government of another day sought them by these political auctions that took place in 1948 and at a later stage.
Comment on this
We can look back with pride and can look forward with confidence. We can look forward with confidence to the new Taoiseach. We look back with pride on the great work done by the outgoing Taoiseach, Seán Lemass, a man who brought to this country industrial expansion, a man under whose guidance the social services and social benefits were increased.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I should like to thank Deputy Byrne for the conscientious manner in which he sought to have other Members of the Dáil brought in to hear my speech.
Comment on this
As I have said, the dignified manner in which the Ministers were presented here today is something that should be taken to heart by the Opposition. There were no auctions prior to their presentation to the Dáil such as there were in 1948 and again some years later.
Comment on this
We are aware of the manner in which attempts were made today at character assassination, when every single member of the Cabinet was singled out by one or other of the Opposition speakers. One would think there was not an honourable man in the Dáil, according to the Opposition. We are happy in the knowledge that we have able, efficient and honourable men. Down through the years it has been the case that every honourable man that this country produced has been attacked in one way or another. I suppose it is history repeating itself here today when honourable men are attacked in the way in which the outgoing Taoiseach and the Ministers were attacked. Indeed, there was some criticism of our now Leader and Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch, who, on the other hand, was described as a man of dignity, vigour and courage by the Opposition.
Much has been said about the Ministers whom we have here and who have served for the last 18 months or so, who have worked as a team and always worked as a team, a team that never fell asunder under stress and strain, like previous inter-Party Governments did.
Comment on this
They seem to have consolidated themselves more in recent times and when the occasion arises, if it ever does, they will be only too happy to come back once again in an effort to sabotage this nation as they did on previous occasions. We have listened today to talk about policies. I should like to know what policies these people are talking about. The political paupers of the Opposition have talked about policies. What policies?
Comment on this
Those who were in office on two occasions spoke tonight about the old age pensions. What did they do? They took 1/- off them on one occasion and in six years gave them 10d a year. That is what the Opposition thought of the old age pensioners—that they were worth only 10d a year. When the old age pensioner gets an increase of 5/- or 10/- nowadays, we are told it is not enough. That may be so, and we do not consider that it is enough, and as time and money permit and as the country prospers, we will ensure that we will give to the old age pensioners and to the other groups who are in need of assistance the finance that is available.
Comment on this
You stick to the bullseyes. There is a difference between 10/- a week and 10d a year. In every year we have given an increase to the weaker sections of the community, and I am confident we will continue to do so in the future. As finance becomes available, more money will be provided for the social side of our programme. We can look ahead with confidence to the further expansion of our industrial arm, which was initiated and developed by Deputy Seán Lemass and his team of Ministers. That team of Ministers never fell asunder under the threat of political corruption. We are confident that our new team will not fall asunder either but will work as a team under the leadership of Deputy Jack Lynch, a man of dignity, vigour and courage. I am sure he will bring with him the confidence displayed by other Taoiseachs in the past who have led our Party. It is the most democratic Party this country has ever known.
Comment on this
I am proud to be a member of it. I say as a trade unionist, and on behalf of the many fellow-trade unionists I represent here, that we congratulate Deputy Jack Lynch on his appointment today and we will congratulate the Ministers when they are appointed tomorrow. This will be done, notwithstanding what will take place in the Division Lobby and the effort to gain time in order to publish untruths in the papers. We have heard many of them tonight. I am sure they will be published in tomorrow's papers, especially the local papers. Many Deputies seem to be playing to the gallery in the hope of gaining some advantage in areas where the people are not aware of the truth.
Comment on this
Have you not got your tuning fork with you that you could strike? Never mind; he is doing splendidly.
Comment on this
I should like to answer Deputy Dunne and the other variety artistes we have opposite. Many of the variety artistes in the city are out of a job. Give them a chance to earn a few bob. We have many people here who would do well in the variety halls. When they lose their seats, they will have another occupation to which they can turn. There may be a revival of the variety halls after the next election.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne should cease interrupting and allow Deputy Dowling continue his speech.
Comment on this
We heard a lot about the establishment of industry here tonight. We look back with pride on the establishment of Irish Shipping, the air services, the shipyards, the industrial estate at Shannon and the various other industries established throughout the country. We know how many of these industries were treated by the Opposition when they were in power. We know the destruction of our industrial arm that took place. We know the sabotage carried out for the sake of a few paltry pounds, when men were cast on the scrapheap and sent packing to far distant shores. In fact, friends of my own were sent packing by the Labour Party and Fine Gael to far distant shores throughout the world. Some time ago Deputy Coogan gave an undertaking here that if they were returned to power, they would sack 80 per cent of the personnel in Telefís Éireann.
Comment on this
So we have it that Fine Gael are prepared to purge Telefís Éireann and other industries, just as they did in the case of Aer Lingus and the chassis factory at Inchicore?
Comment on this
Deputy Coogan is deliberately trying to damage the chances of the Potez factory and the people of Galway know it. He should be ashamed of himself.
Comment on this
The last speaker referred to the records of the House. They have been referred to frequently today. They make sorry reading in relation to the period of office of the inter-Party Government or the Coalition Government, or however you care to describe them. Certainly, they did not act with dignity and courage when they ran away from their responsibilities.
Comment on this
Give us the figures of the houses we built and the houses you built, and we will compare them.
Comment on this
And the rents. We will deal with them one at a time. As regards the rents, some time ago rents were increased in this city, but rents were also reduced for the weaker sections of the community who could not afford to pay the rents imposed on them previously. This relief, which came about by a revision of the rental system, was opposed by the Labour Party. Last night we heard members of the Labour Party and Fine Gael say that the solution was that these people could get social assistance to offset a rent increase. If that is the social thinking of the Labour Party and Fine Gael, they are welcome to it. Make paupers out of the people in unfortunate circumstances. We will deal with the rent situation when it comes before us. I am confident we will deal with it just as we dealt with the development of the air services, the shipyards, the industrial estates, and all the industries and housing projects we see throughout the country.
Comment on this
We see in Dublin city the great housing estates of Crumlin, Kimmage, Ballyfermot, Cabra, Coolock, Ballymun——
Comment on this
All these housing estates are monuments to the initiative, energy and forward thinking of Fianna Fáil in housing the people as they should be housed. I am confident that as money becomes available more houses will be built.
Comment on this
There is an increased demand for houses, due to the fact that there is an increase in population in our city. It will be a sorry day for the city when it has no housing problem, because then Dublin will be a dead city with no one to live in it. On a previous occasion, Deputy Dillon boasted that we had 1,500 empty houses in Dublin. That is true. At one period we had. However, the corporation always had a waiting list which never went below 5,000. Due to the increase in population and the increase in prosperity, more people have come home, people who were driven from this country during the term of office of the inter-Party Government or the Coalition Government—I am sorry if I am confusing you.
Whatever conglomeration we may call it, we see the saboteurs of this nation who sent so many people packing that there were 1,500 vacant corporation houses in this city. What happens today if the breadwinner is forced by necessity to leave this country? He leaves behind his wife and family. However, on that other occasion when the Coalition Government were in office, 1,500 families were sent packing and the Opposition can take credit for those 1,500 vacant houses that occurred only because the father and the mother, the sons and the daughters all had to emigrate. However, these people are back now and are in the queue looking for additional housing accommodation.
Comment on this
They have come back because of the increased prosperity, because of the development of our industrial arm, because of the opportunities which are being made available each day. I am quite sure, as I said earlier on, that there are many trade unionists who support Fine Gael and Labour. Incidentally, as a trade unionist, I should like to congratulate the new Taoiseach. However, these trade unionists are very happy that we are in office because they know there will be opportunities and development, irrespective of the other factors which may bring them to give support to Fine Gael and to Labour. So few workers support these two Parties that it is indicated by their numbers here. Their numbers here matter very little. The combined forces of Fine Gael and Labour in this House are unable at any time to defeat the Fianna Fáil group who have the confidence and the support of the workers of this nation, and rightly so.
Comment on this
We heard a lot about front bench and back bench members. I can assure the Opposition Parties that this Party is, to a man, behind the Government, the members of which were presented here today in so dignified a manner. They were chosen and presented without the type of connivance and intrigue that had been so evident on previous occasions when Coalition Governments were endeavouring to dispute the spoils of office by various means and then, when the time came to pay the piper, the Irish worker had to pay. Consider the plight of men employed at Aer Lingus and at Shannon. Do we forget that the Lockheed development at Shannon had to go to Paris? The Irish worker had to pay for this type of political manoeuvring which certainly did not do any credit to this country or to anybody who accepted office under such a dispensation. In conclusion——
Comment on this
I might say a few more words now and bring back to memory maybe a few more of the terrible deeds and terrible tortures we had to endure during the Coalition period. It will take some time, of course, before I get this Coalition period perfect but even if I have to wait another ten, 15 or 20 minutes, I shall perfect it before I leave. There is one thing that cannot be said about a Fianna Fáil Government, whether this Government or any Fianna Fáil Government in the past. It can never be said that we ran away from our responsibilities, never on any occasion——
Comment on this
We have a Government here today of whom it will be said, I am quite sure, in the future, when we are looking back, that we were certainly a group that did equal credit to those great Fianna Fáil Governments in the past. We know the circumstances in which other Governments terminated. The Government who came into power in 1948 came asunder as a result of a dispute among themselves. It was composed of a number of men of different Parties who could not agree. After they had sold the nation and sent the workers packing, they could not agree amongst themselves because they had not enough money to get rid of the distrust and disruption within that particular group.
As I say, we have now a sound Government and the people can be sure that it will never happen again that we will have a group of men such as we had in the Coalition Governments who were so dishonest that they would sell out the workers and close down their valuable sources of employment. The Labour Party were a Party to this position. It is a terrible thing to think, as a trade unionist, that a Labour Party—of course, it is only a tag—would deprive Irish workers of employment. In my constituency, or adjacent to it, we had a shop which would now be giving employment to 3,000 personnel in the heavy engineering industry.
Comment on this
This particular shell in Inchicore is commonly known as the "Chassis Job" and it would now be giving to skilled and unskilled personnel valuable employment in the engineering industry. The cheap jibes about Potez are an effort to divert attention from the real problem which I am trying to outline. They are an effort to prevent me from pointing out that under this Government, we will never have a situation whereby a deliberate attempt will be made to reduce the content of employment and to disrupt the existing employment of so many people. The Irish people are quite certain of that and will be quite happy that this will never happen under a situation such as this Party has presented.
Comment on this
He would need to have the prompters because he had not an original thought since he was born. Look at the three of them over there!
Comment on this
I am glad Deputy Dowling appreciates the agony we are going through having to sit here and listen to him.
Comment on this
Deputy Cluskey has made his contribution and will he now please allow his colleague, Deputy Dowling, to make his contribution?
Comment on this
One of the groans or moans I heard from the Opposition —probably from Deputy Coogan—was about Potez. There is no doubt that Deputy Coogan would like to see, as would other members of the Opposition, the Potez factory fail.
Comment on this
That is why there is so much bull from him now. He knows nothing about the history of Potez in Galway.
Comment on this
As Deputy Molloy said, the Deputy was at a corporation meeting when he spoke about some old site in Galway. Even if it were an original idea of his, which I doubt, as has been confirmed here to a large degree, we will give him credit for it, if there is doubt in his mind. But we have no doubt in our minds as to who brought these factories into production and who will see them in full production in time to come. There was a valley period in the Potez factory but I am quite certain that under our Minister for Industry and Commerce and under the Ministers of this Government, who will act with collective responsibility as they have always acted, we will see in time to come full employment in the factory.
Comment on this
The Deputy is doing something which is against all the rules. He should make his own speech and not be getting Popo the Puppet to do it for him.
Comment on this
We are all familiar with the artists from the Opposition group who from time to time throw in this slick talk.
Comment on this
It is a pity you would not give the unfortunate men who are trying to earn their living an opportunity to do so; certainly their jokes are being spun out here daily.
Comment on this
I have a heavy cold at the moment and for that reason I am sorry I will not be able to continue. But I am quite sure we will have an opportunity at a later stage to develop on the lines I have already taken.
Comment on this
When the post comes, I will have a look at the Official Report and read Deputy Dunne's contribution.
Comment on this
I will read it again and again in order to get an insight into the mind of that great man.
Comment on this
Once again I want to express my confidence in the Taoiseach and his Ministers. I am quite sure they will not let the nation down——
Comment on this
This Party in the past have produced teams such as we have here today who never let the nation down, who never sabotaged the nation, who never ran away from their responsibilities and, as time goes on, we will look back with pride on the men who have been proposed here today, men of dignity, vigour and courage. These people, these honourable men who have been proposed have been subjected to this campaign of character assassination for so long.
Comment on this
Once again I am quite sure we will look back on progress and I am quite sure there will be considerable progress to the credit of these men. In conclusion, I would say with regard to Deputy Seán Lemass, the man who has led this Party for so long, so vigorously and brought to this nation so many industries, that it would be fitting for the Labour Party to sit up and refresh their consciences in relation to the industrial development, the social increases and advances which have taken place under a Fianna Fáil Government. They should bear in mind that we are not satisfied to give the old age pensioners 10/- a week, if we could afford it, and we are always giving some increase to the weaker section of the community. We do not subscribe to the mentality of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties that people in poor circumstances should have to depend on public assistance in order to supplement their incomes and as was stated here last night, that people should be forced to make paupers of themselves to obtain some relief made available by honourable means.
On the question of rents, mentioned here before, we will then arrive at a situation which will be one which will do justice to all, and maybe it will surprise many of the people who have spoken so long and so loudly of the march through this city the other night trying to terrorise the people of this city, trying to impose a view which the Minister was supposed to have expressed, which in actual fact he did not express. As I said last night, when this question of the rents revision comes up for discussion in the many proposals I will make for a scheme to do justice to all I trust the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party will give me the necessary support so that we will arrive at a situation which will do justice to all.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling is running out again on the excuse of going for his tea. However, we have some of his puppet masters and we will deal with them as we go along.
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy a soother in a minute and that will stop him talking when his elders are talking; he should have manners.
I am glad that today has brought to Dáil Éireann, to Leinster House, a not inconsiderable gallery and I am glad that the Gallery has been fairly well populated over the last hour or two——
Comment on this
——because it is not often that we see so representative a body of the public contemplating the proceedings of this House. I am particularly pleased that those of them who have had an opportunity of being here during the speech to which we have just listened—it cannot be dignified by the description "speech": the rambling semi-hysteria we have listened to—will have seen, I am sure, the kind of mental calibre of which the so-called great Fianna Fáil Party are composed. Punch-drunk boxers would express their views with more clarity than the speaker to whom we have just listened. Mind you, it takes me back in memory to the time when that kind of trash swayed votes. Some of my contemporaries will remember that that kind of bunk and boloney used to influence people——
Comment on this
——and, indeed, swept to government certain individuals who have now passed into history. Of course, those who make use of such a stream of abuse as that to which we have just listened, in this modern age plainly show the fact that they are unqualified to be in public life, because they do not appreciate that we are now dealing with, and have been dealing with, a very sophisticated electorate. The kind of tubthumping nonsense we have listened to might have been very effective, and was very effective, in the days before there was widespread literacy, and in the days when large masses of the population could be deemed to have been remote from the organs of informed public opinion.
I do not believe and I cannot believe that Deputy Dowling if he is a trade unionist, as he says he is, attends trade union meetings because no body of responsible trade unionists such as exist today in this State would tolerate his claptrap for five seconds. He is probably fortunate in that what he says will never be exposed to those who are misled into voting for him. If his oratorical technique were shown to those who live in his constituency, they would give him short shrift.
I notice that he mentioned in the course of his remarks that the people who marched through the city the other night were intimidating the population, that 30,000 citizens of Dublin who live in corporation housing estates and from whom, mark you, he got a lot of votes on the last occasion when he stood before them, were intimidating the population, and that their purpose was to intimidate the population of this city.
The other night in Dublin we had a most orderly and well-stewarded demonstration. I have seen some big processions go through Dublin, but I have never seen in my lifetime one of the dimensions of the tenants' demonstration the other night. There must have been, and according to the Garda there were, in excess of 25,000 people walking. All those people were corporation tenants. Deputy Dowling seeks to convey that these people were terrorists and intimidators, trying to push, he infers, an unworthy cause by unworthy methods. Of course last night we had a division on this matter.
Deputy Dowling said he likes to refer to the records of the House. I never found it an engaging or an entrancing occupation and it is not one in which I would indulge for light reading. It is a pretty laborious exercise at best. I have often noticed that those who bury themselves in these heavy volumes are more concerned with the exercise of a little bit of McCarthyism, if one likes to describe it as such, than to inform themselves on the history of the debates of the House.
I am inclined to the view that Deputy Dowling's anxiety in his search through the lines, through the endless miles of verbiage to be found in the records, is to see whether he can pick out, probably out of its context, some statement or other of the kind which he tried to use here tonight which may have been made ten or 20 years ago, or even longer, in defence of his own utterly hopeless position. If I am not mistaken, he went back to 1929. I do not think he was born in 1929. At any rate, he was not very old then, and there are certain people here who were not born in that year.
This progressive Party who are concerned with projecting an image for the future have as their apostle and prophet, Deputy Dowling, who apparently considers that the best way to put across what he describes as the policy of this great Party is to go back 30 or 35 years. There was a time when that kind of activity paid, as I say, in the days before there was even the limited degree of education we now have. We still see in this House some fossilised relics of those days who, when we listen to them, display the all too obvious incapacity which resides in them for membership of this august assembly. I do not want to name names and I will leave the deduction to themselves. The brilliant Shavian wit to which we have to listen at times here from some of the more elderly of our Members is a sufficient indication of what I am talking about.
I will leave that subject for the nonce because it does not merit any consideration. It is of no consequence, of no significance. I am certain that with the passage of time Deputy Dowling will join the vast army which I have seen in my time who become Members of this House and depart therefrom. It seems to be a vast army and it must run into hundreds. I have seen people who follow the line Deputy Dowling sought to pursue here tonight and invariably they were just single termers. The electorate got wise to them quickly enough and at the first available opportunity, got rid of them, just as they did last year when the House had a springcleaning at the time of the General Election.
Let us get on to the main topic, which is that of the election of the new Taoiseach and the proposal before us for the constitution of his Cabinet. It is pleasant, indeed, to see Proinsias Mac Aogáin, because it is seldom we see him. He does not seem to change very much: he is not ageing. It is hard to say of course because we do not see him, but he is not ageing too perceptibly and unlike the former Taoiseach, Deputy S. Lemass, Frankie Ferocious considers himself to be fitting in there with the youngest of them and, indeed, it may well be that he is more mentally agile than many of his juniors. I do not know: it remains to be seen. I studied his visage during the course of the day and I remembered when I was a chap running around in short trousers, I used to see his pictures in the papers. I am afraid Proinsias Mac Aogáin, like poverty, seems fated always to be with us. One does not mind that. I suppose it is nice to have souvenirs around the place.
Comment on this
However, one must call in question the masquerade in which he indulges in the name of this historic nation in the United Nations Building in New York and at other UN gatherings wherever they might be in any part of the known universe. If there is need, Frankie will go there——
Comment on this
——infused, no doubt, with the genuine spirit of self-sacrifice, prepared to leave the shores of the Emerald Isle at any time in the knowledge that, after all, other men have made greater sacrifices. What are we doing at all, might I ask, when the old aged people are being neglected shamefully, people whom we expect to live on the crumbs, whose pensions we are cutting—what are we doing junketing in New York, settling the nuclear problems, if you do not mind, of the world? A sense of proportion is called for surely. We are talking about nuclear groups and indulging in things called, I believe, détentes. We live in a world of aides mémoire, if you do not mind. We are suffering from delusions of grandeur, I am afraid.
Comment on this
If the Minister for Health is not out of the way in the neighbourhood of noon tomorrow, I shall be about to reach my apogee.
Comment on this
As I was saying when the Minister interrupted me, it is a pity Frankie is not here with us. I should like to hear some of his succinct comments on his various missions to while away this tiresome day. Just what was he doing over there, apart from conspiring and, God knows, giving the worst possible advice to young politicians——
Comment on this
Nothing as low as that. The Deputy is thinking of some place down around the Bowery. This is Fifth Avenue stuff.
Comment on this
It does not matter in the least that the old age pensioner is paying for this, or the farm labourer with his princely £9 a week, or the small farmer who is struggling to get a living from the worst possible land, or the tenant who has to march the length and breadth of Dublin to try to influence the views of a tyrannous Minister for Local Government—to try to induce him to see some reason and not to increase the cost of living, not to cause inflation, not to cause further strikes by increasing the cost of living. These things did not percolate through the elevator shaft to the 23rd floor of the New York Hilton.
Comment on this
I have come to the conclusion that the gentleman I am talking about does not understand words at all. Pardon me; I forgot that the very eminent occupant of the Chair is far better qualified than I to understand matters of this kind in many more languages than I am capable of assimilating. I was referring to the Minister for Local Government now, I believe, on his way up the steps, uninhibited I hope, at least for the time being, though he had an inquiry the other day as to whether the equipment was going cheap, because some other people might be willing to move into what was quickly becoming an unestablished Civil Service position. The Minister for Local Government, as I was saying——
Comment on this
The Deputy has only one minute left for the passion. Try the old age pensioners again. It is about time.
Comment on this
No; I shall be fixing the old age pensioners and the widows, the expectant mothers——
Comment on this
I shall also come to the general question of health and if it is passion the Minister is interested in, we can supply that and, indeed, a lot more things which might not be very pleasant to deal with. However, I was speaking about the New York Hilton Hotel and its remoteness from the people of this country, and I was regretting the absence of Proinsias Mac Aogáin, one of the surviving generals of old unhappy far-off things and battles long ago.