We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Debate on Adjournment (Christmas Recess) (Resumed).

Contributions 1–168 of 556. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Patrick John Hillery Minister for Labour (Dr. Hillery) Fianna Fáil

I was saying that Deputy Briscoe was right in asserting that the record of this and former Fianna Fáil Governments in matters concerning the workers was one of which we could be proud. It is no harm that something should be put on the record to show what has happened since Fianna Fáil Governments realised that the body of legislation inherited from the British was inadequate for the protection of Irish workers. The Fianna Fáil Government, through their brilliant Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Lemass, undertook at that time a programme of legislation to protect the workers from the worst of the conditions from which they were suffering.

Comment on this

The Minister is not in Kenmare now.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy going to make a duet of this? We had the Conditions of Employment Act 1936 to regulate the conditions of employment of industrial workers——

Comment on this

In what year?

Comment on this

1936—before the Deputy's time.

Comment on this

Indeed, it was.

Comment on this

He was in the Curragh at that time.

Comment on this

Do not stick your chin out.

Comment on this

In the Glasshouse.

Comment on this

As I said, we introduced this Act to cover the conditions of industrial workers in regard to matters of the normal working week, shift work, overtime, night work and the like. This was followed by similar legislation in 1938 in relation to shops, the Shops (Conditions of Employment) Act, to give similar protection to workers in shops, restaurants, hotels and such like, and also to oblige employers to provide minimum sanitary and washing facilities, heating and seating accommodation for workers. The Industrial Relations Act of 1946, which was another Seán Lemass Act, set up——

Comment on this

What about the Standstill Orders?

Comment on this

I need no assistance, I assure the House.

Comment on this

The Minister seemed to jump to 1946.

Comment on this

There is a big gap.

Comment on this

Tell us about the Standstill.

Comment on this

When we were not allowed to talk, the Deputy spoke freely enough. The Industrial Relations Act of 1946 set up the Labour Court and other machinery for the settlement of industrial disputes. The comprehensive Factories Act, although it did not reach the Statute Book until the second Coalition Government were in office, was drafted under the direction of Deputy Seán Lemass, as Minister for Industry and Commerce, and went through its Second Stage, but then had to start from scratch again. That was another Lemass production for the protection of the workers.

It provided an elaborate code dealing with the safety, health and welfare of workers, in factories, docks, buildings and engineering construction works. That Act provided for the establishment on a voluntary basis of safety committees in factories. Deputy Cluskey and other Labour Deputies have time and again criticised the lack of progress in setting up these committees and have put the onus on me. You cannot have a mulish attitude to life. The origin and purpose of these committees can be traced to a concept introduced into this Bill by the predecessors of the present Labour Deputies at the time it was introduced and it was for the purpose of conferring an initiative on the workers, not on the factory inspectors or the employers.

If the workers will not accept what I say in this matter—and I have experience that Labour Deputies are not inclined to accept what one says—I should like to quote Mr. Barry Desmond, who is Vice-President and Industrial Officer of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, speaking at the annual general meeting of the National Industrial Safety Organisation at Liberty Hall, Dublin, on 30th November, this year. He said:

When this Act (i.e. the Factories Act) became law in 1955 a special and particular responsibility developed on the trade union movement. During the passage of the Act through the Houses of the Oireachtas very strong representations were made from the trade union movement to have embodied in the Bill provisions which would in some form or other, directly associate the workers in the factories with the actual application and enforcement of the legislative provisions.

As a result, section 73 of that Act provides that persons employed in a factory may select from among themselves a safety committee and may nominate one of their members as a safety delegate.... It is quite clear that the powers and functions of workers' representatives on those safety committees are extensive. Therefore there can be no excuse that because management may be lukewarm, because management may be indifferent or may indeed oppose safety procedures, action on the part of workers may not effectively be introduced.

Speaking on the same occasion, Mr. Desmond also said:

Therefore, the trade unions also have a major responsibility in promoting safe working in industry.... Union members should and indeed, in their own best interest, must co-operate in the observance of safety regulations even where they may seem irksome and unnecessary. However, lip-service and management/ labour safety co-operation and the strict observance of regulations are of little use unless a worker feels a direct and personal responsibility.

One is delighted to get an amendment and here is an amendment brought in or suggested by Labour Deputies to give an initiative to workers and here now are Labour Deputies asking me why I am not doing it.

Comment on this

That is a bit hairy.

Comment on this

The main reason for the delay is that the Minister's inspectors ignore the safety delegate and consult only the management when they go to factories.

Comment on this

You must go back to your predecessors who wanted to see that the workers had the initiative in setting up these committees.

Comment on this

Yes, but what happens when they are set up?

Comment on this

I am making a journey through the various legislative actions of Fianna Fáil to protect the workers.

Comment on this

The Minister is missing several ports.

Comment on this

We had the Office Premises Act in 1958. Last year or the year before under the present Taoiseach, the Mines and Quarries Act was completed. I took the stage after the election last year in the Seanad. This extends the same protection to mine and quarry workers as industrial workers had under the Factories Act. Only a few days ago, I addressed the first meeting of the advisory council appointed under the Act. The Holidays (Employees) Act which gives workers legal entitlement to a minimum of a fortnight's holiday with pay additional to public holidays was passed under Fianna Fáil Government in 1961.

The Apprenticeship Act of 1959 was introduced and passed through the Oireachtas by the present Taoiseach when he was Minister for Industry and Commerce. This has been singularly successful in providing better methods of recruiting and training apprentices over a wide range of industries. The experience gained with that Act has been most useful in framing the Industrial Training Bill which the House dealt with last night. This is an impressive list of legislation and fully proves that Fianna Fáil are the Party concerned with the workers and the result of the elections proves that the workers see that.

Comment on this

Deputy Cluskey should open his eyes.

Comment on this

The establishment of a separate Department of State with staff specially recruited for this work should further facilitate the work of Fianna Fáil Government for workers. It is true that the unions in their activities, together with enlightenment of managements, have tended to make unnecessary some of the provisions of protection of earlier legislation but I intend, in consultation with those concerned, to go over all the legislation and amend it where this is found to be appropriate.

At present the Government are proceeding on the basis that the road to better industrial relations lies to a large extent in allaying the fears of workers and giving them the greatest possible degree of security, and to that end I am strengthening the factory inspectorate so that the health, safety and welfare of workers may be better looked after. I am widening the scope of the employment exchanges so that in reality they will become agencies for placing persons in employment. As the House knows, I am promoting legislation for training and re-training so that workers can change jobs more easily. This legislation has now passed through the Dáil and will go to the Seanad when that body next meets. Drafting is at an advanced stage on a Redundancy Compensation Bill to help to tide redundant workers over a difficult period while getting new jobs. The implementation of Government proposals in all these areas should bring about a greater feeling of security among workers and induce a better climate in industrial relations. I hope it will reduce the incidence of disputes. As the House knows, I am also engaged in detailed discussions through officers of my Department with the trade union movement and the employer organisations to see what improvements in our machinery for processing pay claims can be worked out.

The Taoiseach referred to this this morning. Although the workers now may seem to be less in need of State-provided protection than their predecessors were from the exploitation of bosses and the excesses of the system that came in with the industrial revolution, their need for protection has not in any way disappeared. In some respects the modern worker may be exposed to greater dangers than his underprivileged and unfortunate counterpart of earlier generations; there is much danger to health and limb in the handling of new substances and the management of modern machines. Also, there are more risks that are not easily articulated but I think every worker is now aware of the risks to himself involved in the strike process.

Some workers may still be under the impression that in pressing a demand to the point of strike, they are hurting their employers. In actual fact, I honestly believe that a strike now hurts workers of all kinds, including the workers on strike, much more than anybody else. I have often said that the employer is very often the least effected by a strike. The public may be inconvenienced, customers may go somewhere else, orders may be lost and the worker himself may be impoverished, but the managing director still gets his salary and still drives around in comfort. I think the working out of legislation by me and my officers with the trade union movement and the employer organisations is one of the protections which the modern worker needs because of the fact that the strike weapon now seems to be turning on the worker and away from the employer.

There is another danger which is for the trade union itself to look at, that is, the failure of workers generally to take an interest in trade union activities. If we want any evidence that workers generally are not taking an adequate part in the union activities, I have only to refer to a report I read yesterday of the annual general meeting of an important Irish trade union. The attendance at the meeting was only three per cent of the total membership. From informal inquiries I have made, having read that, I believe this is not by any means a unique experience.

Trade unions rightly pride themselves on being democratic organisations, but how can democracy work, I ask you, if 97 per cent of the people concerned opt out of the affairs of the organisation and leave it to the remaining three per cent to take decisions about who will be the officers, what will be the policy, how we will govern our union? I submit this is a situation fraught with danger for the workers. Despite their assertions and posturings, trade union officials and executives holding office by the vote of three per cent or less of the membership of a trade union can scarcely claim a consensus for the opinions they express and the statements they make. They can hardly be blamed, therefore, if sometimes they take up positions which appear to be at variance with the interests of their members. I would consider it my duty to encourage workers to avail of their rights as members of a trade union, to participate in its affairs, to offer themselves for service in the control of the trade union and, if elected, to help to formulate and carry out the policies of the union.

I reluctantly go back to the by-elections. Deputy Kyne asked me to ascertain if the Taoiseach did in fact say in Dungarvan—and this is Deputy Kyne's statement—that the unions would have done better to build houses with the £1 million they spent on Liberty Hall. Deputy Kyne said he heard the Taoiseach said that. I asked the Taoiseach about it, and the Taoiseach said he never did say that. I am glad to have the opportunity of letting Deputy Kyne know that. Whoever made it up, it was not one of our crowd.

Comment on this

You did say everything else?

Comment on this

Some of his own crowd must have thought that up. To finish on the by-elections, we have been told that we have too many supporters, too many Ministers, too many TD's, too much money, too many cars——

Comment on this

Too many votes.

Comment on this

The only thing they did not say was: "Change generals and we will fight you all over again." Now they know the man they thought could not do it has done it and they are not saying anything about him now.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I hope that the purpose of this debate is rather a review of what the Government are not doing than a re-hash of the by-elections. I am not a bit squeamish about the by-elections. Fianna Fáil have won them. The methods they used to win them are not new to Fianna Fáil: they are part of the skulduggery in which they have grown up. We cannot very well cavil at the continual use by them of those methods. It does not alter the fact that they have won two seats. Neither does it alter the fact that we have to face the review of a bleak situation in the economy of the country. We cannot take the by-elections out of their perspective. In many ways Fianna Fáil got two lucky constituencies and, fair play to them, where they could not talk policy, they talked hurling, and six medals in a row was a great pull, and good luck to him. Apparently there is a fairly good hurling vote in parts of Waterford, too. There is one thing you cannot take from the Taoiseach, and I would not dream of taking it from him: he is one of the best hurlers I ever saw in my life and I saw all of those six matches and lustily urged him on to win them.

However, I am here to come to grips with the difficult economic situation that has arisen and what prospect there is of a resuscitation and of the Government dealing with the problems involved. I am going to deal with the difficulties as they are known to me. From reports from my constituency, there is no doubt that the situation of the small farmer is very difficult and ragged. It is easy for people to talk, as the Minister for Finance, in his new office as controller of the Agricultural Credit Corporation, does airily: "They will get up to £500 to tide them over their difficulties." That is a lie, and he knows it. More than half of them are refused and by the time they have made re-application and by the time they have used every method to get it, their difficulties have become virtually insurmountable. The problem does exist where people are over-stocked and cannot get rid of their cattle. They are not in a position to carry them because they have not the feeding stuffs. This is an actual consequence of the Fianna Fáil outlook on agriculture. They do not give a fiddle-de-dee as to what the situation of the small farmer is going to be.

Their history, despite the arguments put forward by the Minister for Labour in regard to the Lemass plan for industry, does not bear any scrutiny at all in regard to agriculture because it starts with the cutting of the calves' throats and the flogging of hides. We are now in the position that we have more scrub cattle in the country than we ever had before. The market is depressed so that the good type of cattle that should have been disposed of from October to now and should be part of the income of the farmer to tide him and his family over the Christmas festivities, represents a nightmare and a constant worry. It is easy to say: "We won the by-elections in Kerry and in Waterford," but it does not alter the fact that this problem is there and that its solution is of paramount importance to the whole economy.

I stuck my chin out here, as I have often done, in regard to the £15 grant for heifers. I said this scheme was going to make the big farmer richer an inure to the benefit of the person who could buy in large stocks of heifers and could afford to carry them, particularly on extensive uninhabited grazing farms, as is true of many of the very big cattle buyers and cattle graziers in this country. It was the big farmer and the big buyer who reaped the benefit of this scheme and now the position is that where normally there might have been the usual take-up of the type of stock that we reared in West Cork and South Kerry by the big graziers, they are over-stocked themselves. That market is gone and the unfortunate small farmers in areas like West Cork or South Kerry cannot get rid of their stocks even at sacrificial prices. Many of them have literally to give away their stock rather than let them starve to death between this and the time the Minister says prices will improve, at the end of February or the beginning of March.

We had that type of problem before and the position got worse. That is not by-election talk. Those are the facts in regard to what is happening on the land, and I am quite sure the Minister for Labour is aware of quite a lot of it in Clare. I hope the Government will try to get some outlet for this type of stock. No doubt there will have to be very rigid control, quickly introduced, of the widespread breeding we have in the country at present or the tremendous efforts made to improve our stock will be nullified by the creation of doubtful scrub cattle. Indeed, we may have the problem of having to re-investigate much of the work done in respect of the eradication of TB and other cattle diseases, and, I might add, so successfully done under both Governments in the past 15 or 20 years.

There is no good blowing trumpets. The battle is over. It is now a question of trying to tread lightly on the dead in the valley. The dead in the valley in my constituency, and in South Kerry, are likely to be cattle that cannot be fed in the course of the next few months because the reserves are not there. The people have not the capacity to hold on. I know it will be said that the farmers have had ten or 12 good years. You make all sorts of apologies for the present difficulties. But the fact remains that any of us who really understand the difficulties of the small farmer know his reserves are never sufficient to tide him over in this kind of difficulty. The Government must bear considerable responsibility for this difficulty. Not only did they encourage an increase in cattle stocks, but they encouraged holding on to stocks at a time when even then the sacrificial loss would have been more economic than the dire consequences facing many small farmers now.

The tragedy of the situation is that it arises at a time when there is, because of its hazards and difficulty, a tremendous flight from the land. At a time when we should be in a position to improve technical skill in agriculture, we are losing from the land of Ireland the young people who could benefit from that expertise. At the same time, the economic hazards and difficulties are highlighted by the problem of the impracticability of selling stock which must be got rid of. In addition, there is the difficulty constantly arising of the ever-increasing price of feeding stuffs and the cost of distribution. At the same time, there is no stability of any description in the prices the farmers receive for the finished product.

I know that Deputies representing small farmers, if they are not bound by Party, will fully agree with the case I am making. We know the difficulties of the small farmer. We know there is an immense problem to be faced in agriculture that goes further than the present difficulties in relation to cattle prices. We know there is a huge problem to be faced in connection with the resettlement and the improvement of holdings of the people who will stay on the land. There has to be a comprehensive plan to put into rural Ireland something to absorb the people who will become redundant on land resettlement. There must be a huge impetus in forestry and its ancillary industries to enable us to hold population in rural Ireland at all. We are getting away from the reality of having to come to grips with this serious national problem vitally associated with the haemorrhage of emigration.

We have to get down to the problem of getting farmers into the groove of improved production on a practical economic basis and, at the same time, getting them to meet the competition they must meet as markets widen and as Europe becomes more and more an integral unit rather than a series of separate nations. It is not who won South Kerry or who won Waterford that should be agitating our minds today. It is who can bring about that rebirth of confidence in Irish agriculture that will give a stimulus to the increased production we all demand and give guidance and help to make sure that this basic industry can compete elsewhere while remaining the basic economy of the country.

In all our difficulties, whether they be concerned with balance of payments or export versus import, we always fall back on the tough, hard core of Irish agriculture to pull us out of these difficulties. I shall deal later with the industrial side. The major question I want to put to the Government is: what basic plan have they for the development of our agriculture? What are to be the guide-lines for the future development of the samll farmer, so that he will not continuously find himself faced with a difficulty in his own economy which we should have been able to warn him against and, in the main, save him from?

The situation of the small farming community at present is very serious. It is all the more serious because it arises at a time when stability was never more necessary in the industry in order to provide a starting off point for the type of development necessary to face competition in EEC, EFTA or a completely integrated Europe in the course of the next five, ten or 15 years. What are we to do with all our surplus cattle? What are we going to do to eliminate the danger created by the number of scrub cattle in the surplus cattle? I want the Government to do some practical thinking on that problem and to produce a solution. It is their task.

You will tell us you have a new mandate by virtue of by-election wins for that task. My questions here is: "What will you do about it?" You are the Government. What am I to tell Willie McCarthy down at the top of Sheep's Head or the O'Donovan clan at the bottom of Castledonovan, or the small farmer in Beara when I go back there? What is he to do with his stock now on his hands which he cannot get rid of? Where is he to find the stuff to feed it, to carry it until next spring? Is there some magic wand that will suddenly be waved in these areas and deliver various types of gratuitous feeding stuffs for them? That is the problem I want the Government to face—not the catcalls of election stunting.

As I said, I am not squeamish. I do not mind that the Government use their resources of power, money, vested interests and everything else for the purpose of gaining political advantage. My only regret is that we were not strong enough to beat them at their own game. I am not afraid of Fianna Fáil tactics in any circumstances. A little bit of in-fighting is very healthy now and again. But it is not in-fighting that the unfortunate people want who are in this difficulty that I am now telling the Government, in all sincerity, is escalating into a really big problem. They want some substantial help if they are to tide themselves over the difficulty, and that is true of every small farming area in this country. The tragedy of it all is that it is that type of small farmer who up to this, has been the real backbone of our agricultural economy. It was that type of farmer who produced all the stock we once needed for our store trade and for our fat beef trade.

Somebody has to make a very proper re-appraisal of our animal husbandry situation so that we shall not be put in the position that we shall rush farmers into tremendous increases and then do absolutely nothing about finding any market into which they can go at a reasonable profit. In fact, we are in the position now that we have no market at all for them. Even though pretentious and tremendous boasts were made of what the new free zone would do, all we have succeeded in doing for Irish agriculture this year, under the manipulations and gyrations of the former Minister for Agriculture, has been to get ourselves into difficulties even on the home market. For the first time in our history, we read that English, Scottish and Welsh producers, and all the rest of them, have come into open conflict with the Irish salesmasters because of our timing and our wrongly attempted exploitation of the British market. That is a very serious problem. It is one that is away above the thrust and parry of our political present or our political future. I want to keep it on that basis.

There is nobody in this House who does not know that nobody will enjoy by-elections and political contests better than I will. I take to the hustings as a politician should—with his neck well oiled and his heart well steeled. They are the occasions on which we have to show our worth individually in our avocation. But here, in the Dáil on this debate, I feel that we should have a deliberative look at very big problems that are facing what we all agree is our basic industry, agriculture.

People think, and think erroneously, that all is well in the dairying side of our industry. There is no doubt at all that an effort was made to ameliorate a very old and difficult problem in the dairying industry. There has been some adjustment in price that has taken, one might say, the immediate dire urgency out of the problem. However, that does not change the fact that, again, we have to face the reality that there must be rapid diversification of milk outlets and an upward adjustment of price to make the present situation economic.

I do not want to sound like the weeping Willie of agriculture. I am a great believer in the fact that the Irish small farmer, in particular, his sons, daughters and the people who get their living on the land, are a resilient, a great breed. They are our forefathers, thank God. None of us, outside the Dublin Deputies, if we really analyse it, is more than a generation or a generation and a half away from the land of Ireland. We can take pride in our forbears and in the fact that those of ours on the land will always give that little effort and make that sacrifice when the national interest is in need of it. Because of that, I am asking for a dispassionate, objective, realistic look at what is needed to put agriculture back on the kind of sound economic basis it was on only a few years ago.

We may make political capital out of what each Government has done. I can with pride refer to land reclamation and development, the development of small drainage schemes, the Local Authorities (Works) Act, the rumbling of lorries throughout the State carrying the ground limestone to achieve Deputy Dillon's concept of the improvement of our lands. We want to ensure, no matter what Government is here, that these people will get a continuation of these benefits and that what they produce, in many cases in very adverse conditions, will have a full and profitable market.

I have said here on umpteen occasions, when there was no trumpeting of by-elections and no claims of this or that, that we faced the reality of giving to agriculture its fair return for its tremendous contribution to our general economy. Do not let fair advertisements or suddenly produced startling figures fool you. Agriculture is not getting in return the slice of the cake it merits for its contribution to our national effort. I am saying that with all the sincerity at my command. It does not matter whether we are over on the Government benches and the present Government are on the Opposition benches, I believe it is the duty of this House to ensure greater stability and continuous development in agriculture, particularly in advisory services, technical development, improved sales of cattle, sheep and pigs, improvement of quality and a market for the total quantity produced. If that can be done and if we can take a broad, objective, global look at the problem and get it into proper perspective and decide on the size of holding, the type of development, whether in zones or areas, and if we can get the farmers trained into the type of production decided upon, we will not have any difficulty, even after years of a Fianna Fáil Government, in getting the economy right.

We are making a reasonable effort on the industrial side in alerting manufacturers and others to the necessity for improved methods of production and improved quality of goods to meet the type of competition which they will undoubtedly meet. I am satisfied that, despite the temporary difficulties that it created, the imposition of the British levy was a salutary lesson to many people and brought them quickly to grips with the problems of adaptation and improvement of methods.

I am not a Labour Deputy but I have always believed and still believe that there are some of the finest industrial workers in the world available in Ireland. Basically, the worker has the strength of purpose, the capacity and the loyalty to give a worthwhile return to any employer who gives him proper conditions, the right type of incentive and the right spirit of association in their mutual project. When we talk about fostering relations between management, workers and trade unions, we lose sight of the fact that there should be a common understanding that it is a mutual venture and that there should be a reasonable return to all sections engaged in that venture rather than that too great a slice of the cake should go to any one section.

When the Minister for Labour was speaking about industrial relations and the managing director continuing to get his salary and to drive around in his plush limousine while the worker, who was forced into a strike situation, might be creating difficulties and near penury for himself, he lost sight of the fact that it is because there is no real comprehension of the interdependence of the sections in industry that that situation arises. As long as my conscience is the way it is I will continue to express the view that I do not think it is a good thing that there should be any atmosphere of compulsion or "we will make you do it" created. The creation of the spirit that would encourage production is infinitely preferable to the bludgeoning that goes on in the type of society that we, with Christian tradition, abhor.

There are problems in the sphere of industrial relations but I earnestly believe that there is tremendous good in the workers and in the employers, and that there is a good deal of knowledge and experience in the trade unions, and we would be much better employed in applying ourselves to the task of using the goodwill that exists to create sensible industrial relations rather than in issuing threats of legislation where industrial relations are concerned. I am sounding the warning that over-anxiety to interfere with the fundamental rights and privileges of sections of society inevitably leads to the type of society that none of us wants to see imposed on this country.

Let us be realists before we go home for Christmas. It is not the easiest Christmas this country has faced. It is one of the most difficult for many a year. We have had a difficult year. The Dáil is to adjourn for a while now and we may hope to see in the spring some suggestion of effort by the Government.

I want again to face the reality of the situation as we know it. The only suggestion we have had so far as to what the future policy of the Government may be is a startling negative one—the suggestion from the Minister for Finance to the Fianna Fáil Ard Fheis that he is going to deal with his tax problems in the coming Budget on the basis of another belt of turnover tax. I am warning the Government that if they analyse some of the difficulties into which Blue Book No. 2 ran—Document No. 2 in blue—they will find that they go back to the turnover tax and to the difficulties that ensued therefrom. They had better have a very careful look before they create the situation that we will have an unwarranted increase in the cost of living, in a situation in which the Government are trying to get restraint from the workers in connection with just and in many cases overdue demands for wage increases, and hardship imposed on the biggest section of the community in the lower income group as distinct from taxation being levied on the people who may scream or shout but who in general have the broader backs to bear taxation, the wealthier section of the community.

I am warning the Government well in advance that this type of increase in turnover tax is no help to the economy and shows no initiative and leadership in a country which has found itself in tremendous difficulties on the agricultural side in the overproduction of cattle that cannot be sold, and, on the industrial side, in difficulties that could have been avoided but for the fact that there was no real appreciation of the problems created by certain lines of taxation, not only for management and labour but also in the sale of production.

We have to ask this Government to come to grips with reality. Go into any of our towns, to the shopkeepers and hear their reports on the Christmas trade. They are not very cheerful. There is less money moving this Christmas than for a very long time. None of us likes to see an air of depression around Christmas time but it does make us take stock of the fact that there must be something wrong somewhere, that there must be some cancer in the economy that must be put right and that there must be somewhere leadership that will carry us out of this particular slough.

There is no good trying to equate our employment problems with those of Britain. We are trying to create employment here while they have the problem of overemployment. If we had that problem, perhaps we would deal with it in a different way from the way they are doing it in Britain but our own fundamental strength in our economy, whether on the agricultural or industrial side, does not alter the fact that the situation in this country is not good at the moment. We have difficulties in housing and in all aspects of local government. There is no money for this; there is no money for that. All over Ireland there are fewer people at work on the roads and in local government. There are smaller pay packets going into thousands of houses this Christmas at a time when prices have increased and when less money is going to buy far less.

There is difficulty and dissatisfaction generally among social welfare recipients. Disgusting and dishonourable are the only terms in which I can describe the 5/- increase in pensions which so many social welfare recipients have been denied because of Departmental regulations which create increases where no increase exists and which, when theoretically established, are sufficient to debar the unfortunate pensioner from getting his 5/-. It is no credit to this House that these people are not getting this benefit. I have always subscribed to the belief that this is the section of the community that should get the greatest bounty in our power to give them. Most of them have given a lifetime of service to this country, sufficient service to justify them expecting more than penury or a bare subsistence in their final years.

I want to bring the House back to the problems that exist, back to the genuine difficulties of the Irish farmer which are as bad today as they were during the Economic War, back to all the difficulties that arise from Government ineptitude and departmental inefficiency, back to the reality, whether we accept it or not, that our whole economy has run into a great many unnecessary difficulties, many of which an intelligent and efficient Government would have taken steps to foresee and avoid, many of them caused by unreal and impractical thinking by people who should have ensured before they engaged in overproduction that there was a market for that production.

I will nail the Government for all time with the fact that they are from 70 to 80 per cent responsible for our overstocks of cattle. Ministers should not make promises and forecasts that have no basis in reality. It is even a fact that the cattle going to Germany could not be got out in time and, like a former Taoiseach, they have bunions on their toes waiting at the docks to be got out. The Fianna Fáil slogan is now dead. Lemass is no longer leading on. This Government seem to take great pride in the winning of the two by-elections but they still owe a duty to this nation to get the economy back into proper running order.

Comment on this

I would like to speak today as a trade unionist and a worker, as a member of the workers' party, the only Party with the interests of the workers at heart, and the Party who have proved this beyond all doubt by their efforts in the past, their work at the moment and their plans for the future. We can look forward with confidence; we can look back with pride. As the Minister for Labour pointed out, the only aids that came to the workers in the years after 1932 were the aids given them by the then Minister for Industry and Commerce. Deputy Seán Lemass. He was applauded by the trade union officials, by the workers and by the politicians on the opposite benches for his wonderful work. That same work is now critically condemned. It is difficult to understand the criticism, particularly by members of the Labour Party, of the Minister for Labour on his indicating that during the period of industrial expansion, undertaken by the Fianna Fáil Government from 1932 onwards, it was the Fianna Fáil Government who wiped out sweated labour, ensured holidays with pay for workers, ensured better conditions of employment and brought about better industrial relations generally through the medium of various Acts passed by this House. The improvements may not be all that we would desire but the position of the workers today is certainly better than it was before, and that improvement is not due to any activity of the Labour Party or of the trade unions.

Deputy Lemass was a farseeing man. He was conscious of the rights of the workers and of the responsibility of Government. He was conscious of the necessity to improve the position of the worker and he brought about that improvement to the point of perfection at which it is today. There are still problems. There will be new problems in our developing situation. But, in the period from 1932 onwards, the only measure of relief afforded to the workers was that afforded by the legislation passed in this House by a Fianna Fáil Government. If every worker at the moment would give a moment's thought——

Comment on this

To Potez.

Comment on this

——to the person who established the industry in which he is now standing, or improved it, he could come to only one conclusion, namely, that his employment in the industry today is due to Fianna Fáil. That is one of the reasons why the workers consistently support Fianna Fáil. In it there are men of courage, initiative and ability, who are prepared to implement their policy, despite the opposition of trade union organisations, the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party. Remember, the Labour Party here do not represent the trade unions.

As a result of the industrial aids and the creation of improved conditions of employment, we have now arrived at a point at which further industrial expansion is in process of planning. There are the proposed industrial estates in Waterford, Galway and elsewhere. The recent speeches of the Minister for Industry and Commerce clearly indicate the anxiety and the desire to increase the employment content in the industrial sector. As a trade unionist and a worker, I know that the time will come in the not too distant future when the plans now in process will be implemented. We shall then start planning for further ahead.

We have at the moment anti-national groups operating in this city who are opposed to certain developments. They are faceless men and they are operating not for the benefit of the worker, of the Labour Party, or the trade unions, and certainly not in the interests of the nation. They are prepared at every opportunity to distort statements made by Ministers and by Government spokesmen in an effort to prove that the Government are anti-worker. If this Government were anti-worker, I would not be a member of the Fianna Fáil Party, and they would not have had the consistent support they have had since 1932 of the workers. However difficult and however great the problems may be in the years that lie ahead, I believe that we will solve them and that we will provide further employment for those workers who will be waiting to take on new jobs.

Let us contrast the position today with the position when both Fine Gael and Labour had every opportunity to implement their policies. They had two bites of the cherry, one in 1948 and one shortly afterwards. What did they do? The Labour Party accepted ministerial office. Today, there is very little criticism of Ministers but a few weeks ago we heard the most scurrilous speeches by the Opposition in relation to competent, honourable and efficient men. That has ceased now. The 100-watt smile on the face of the Opposition has been reduced to 15 watts since the by-election. As time goes on, it will disappear altogether. They dug into the bottom of the bucket in an effort to find some mud that might stick.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

They found a hole in it.

Comment on this

The Labour Party believe they represent the workers. Perhaps they represent a section of the workers. Perhaps a section of the trade unionists vote for members of the Labour Party because they are nice guys. I know a fellow who said Frank Cluskey was a nice guy. People like him voted for Frank Cluskey and other members of the Labour Party in 1948, but they found, to their sorrow, that the Labour Party were prepared to align themselves with another group who were anxious to sabotage the very industries in which they were working and sell out the actual means of their employment. We know what happened to the planes. We know that had that trail of destruction continued, there would have been no employment left in the country. It took all the energies of Deputy Seán Lemass and other courageous members of the Fianna Fáil Party to re-establish the transatlantic air service and re-establish employment for over 5,000 workers.

The Labour Party in 1948 sold out the Irish worker and sent him packing. How can any member of that Party justify selling the means of employment of one single man? There is no answer. They hang their heads in shame. There is only one Labour Deputy occupying the Labour benches at the moment. I know his tactics: I shall deal with them in a moment.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

I was saying that when the inter-Party Government under John Aloysius Costello were in office and when the Labour Party had sold out for a couple of miserable Parliamentary Secretaryships and ministerial posts, they proceeded to crucify the worker, stab him in the back and sell his means of employment. What man with an ounce of guts could stand behind such a deliberate action, action intended to kill the industries which had been established? Some of the then Labour Party still occupy seats in Dáil Éireann. It amazes me how they are re-elected. Certainly in the coming months the workers will be made aware of the 1948 atrocities, when the unfortunate worker was stabbed in the back. If Deputy Cluskey and his 100-watt smile, the first we have seen since the by-elections, thinks it funny that workers should be dispossessed of their means of employment, he is not the man I thought he was. He speaks on behalf of the lower income groups but he laughs when he hears about unfortunate men, who devoted a lifetime to learning a trade or craft, being dispossessed.

Comment on this

They were sold out in the chassis shop in Inchicore and elsewhere, but one wise thing they did was to put an auctioneer into the Department of Industry and Commerce to make sure he would sell the industries which had been established here by a Fianna Fáil Government. That was wise and intelligent, if you wanted to sell out. It was not the first time the Fine Gael Party sold out or the first time the Labour Party sold out. Now we have the Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Corish, who was a Minister in the second infamous Government of the Opposition, telling us about the requirements and the necessity for producing new jobs. This is a laugh. We are the only Government who produced jobs and we will continue to produce them, irrespective of internal or external sabotage by the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party. We know that if Deputy Cluskey wanted to start a row in Dún Laoghaire, he would go down to Limerick and whisper to somebody there and then it would percolate in the usual way and the row would start in Dún Laoghaire.

We are aware of the irresponsible tactics used by anti-national groups in this country and some members of the Parties here have aligned themselves with these anti-national groups. Some documents have recently issued from these groups who have no interest in the Labour Party, in the workers, or in the nation. The sooner the Labour Party sit down and examine their policy, as they are going to do, and their actions in the past, the better. We will make them aware of the problems which confront the workers now and which confronted them during the period when they had the opportunity of showing the nation that they were a Party really interested in the workers. A number of aids to improve industrial relations will soon be going through this House. I am convinced that some members of the Labour Party will hope that the legislation which is necessary to bring about industrial peace will not be effective, because if it was, they could not stand up and criticise Ministers for being inactive, although they themselves have been inactive since 1946.

I should like the Labour Party spokesman to indicate what the Labour Party have been doing since 1946 to improve industrial relations. What suggestions did they make here or elsewhere in this regard? They adopted a negative critical attitude. It is easy to criticise. Not one suggestion has come from the Labour Party which would bring about industrial peace. We all know the banshee crying that went on in Waterford and Kerry during the by-elections. The same people shed bitter tears here for the worker and the nation. As I said before, no worker would have confidence in a group of men who ruthlessly sabotaged their employment. The aids which the Minister for Labour will bring before the House, in the absence of any suggestions from the people who claim to represent the workers' interests, will bring about a better relationship between management and workers. I am quite sure that workers, who for one reason or another have strayed, and who have accepted the misleading propaganda of the Labour Party's political machine, will realise the position. That Party used every device to gull the workers. The day is not far distant, however, when the members of the Labour Party will get a rude awakening.

I was amused when listening to Deputy Kyne speaking about the terrible situation in Waterford. He spoke also about the old age pensions and it was interesting to hear him, as well as other Labour Party and Fine Gael speakers, refer to these pensions. If I went down the street and robbed a shilling from an old age pensioner, I would be put in jail, but legally the Fine Gael Party were able to rob thousands of shillings from the old age pensioners and go scot free. These are the people who now talk about a 5/- increase for a few old age pensioners. The position was completely distorted during the by-elections by Fine Gael and Labour speakers. A certain amount of money was made available which was sufficient only to cover people without means. Labour and Fine Gael indicated that an unlimited amount was there and that everybody should have got it, but at the same time they voted against the necessary taxation to give any improvement to old age pensioners or others.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not even know what happens in the House. We voted for it——

Comment on this

You voted against the Budget.

Comment on this

—but the people did not get it.

Comment on this

It is amazing that so many did.

Comment on this

We supported any taxation introduced to help social welfare classes.

Comment on this

You did not. A fall of manna from heaven is hardly likely to be repeated.

Comment on this

The Deputy need not be so vocal. He has got his Parliamentary Secretaryship. Deputy Dowling has not.

Comment on this

At least he is a member of the crew of an oceangoing liner and not second mate on a barge.

Comment on this

You voted against the necessary means of providing benefits for the socal welfare recipients. We made available what was there.

We were glad to see, when we visited Waterford, that extensive work has been carried out in the development of the industrial estate there. In the course of time, it will probably equal the very large estate developed at Shannon, despite the opposition of certain people and Parties now in the House. There would be no Shannon had it not been for Fianna Fáil. There would have been another type of industry there, rabbit breeding or something of lesser importance. The rabbits would surely get myxomatosis in the same way as the workers got it when your people were in power.

I trust that the constructive approach by the Minister for Labour in seeking industrial peace and promoting a better relationship between workers and management will succeed, in the interests of the nation as a whole, and that the Labour Party will now take a responsible attitude to this problem. I do not know if that is possible. We do know, however, that a Party endeavouring to attract support by developing hate of groups or individuals or Parties, like any Party conceived in hate, must necessarily fall because the people of the country are intelligent. Deputies opposite underestimated them in Kerry and Waterford and they will certainly get their answer when the time comes.

Comment on this

Next June?

Comment on this

Once again, I say that the workers should ask themselves: "Who gave me my job? Why am I here?" If they did, they would go back to the great political machine which has their interests at heart. That is why I am a member of Fianna Fáil as a trade unionist and as a worker, and that is why the majority of the workers support Fianna Fáil, because they know that the interests of the worker are the interests of every member of the Party and of the Government and that unceasingly they will continue to investigate, develop and analyse new ideas and new methods of promoting industries. Under the very capable Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley, I am sure we shall see that developments in the future will equal, if not surpass, those of the past and that the same qualities of enthusiasm, energy, initiate and commonsense will be available to the nation under this fearless man in the years ahead.

Deputy Cluskey will be speaking in a few moments. I hope he will answer a few questions and that he will be able to tell us what the Labour Party are doing, or have done, regarding industrial relations. What suggestions have they made since 1946, since the Labour Court was established? They criticise the Court or accept it according as it suits them. An effort is now being made by a responsible Minister to improve the situation and there is certain criticism that the worker is about to be scourged. That is laid on the line by Labour Party members. I can understand Labour Party members who are trade union officials being completely out of touch with the ordinary workers. There are some very good union officials and some very good trade unions but the political group in this House is suspect.

One one occasion in the not too distant past, when a certain strike was taking place in the city, one of them was rubbing his hands out in the corridor and he said to me: "The longer this lasts the better it will be because it will bring you fellows to your knees". That is the responsible attitude of a Labour member of the House. That was what he thought of industrial relations, what he thought of the men on strike and their families waiting for a wage packet to come in. He was glad to see it develop and the longer it lasted the better it would be for "the boys". He did not think of the poor fellows out of work.

These people are completely out of touch with union members. I doubt if they have not a vested interest in strikes. If you examine the matter from a political point of view, if it can be seen to be good for you to prolong the strike, it can be prolonged. That is the view of some members but the responsibility of these members is to ensure that the best conditions can be secured in the shortest possible time with the least disruption of employment. There has been unnecessary disruption in some cases by some people who are out of touch.

The ESB dispute was mentioned. It will probably be mentioned again but I am mentioning it first. I was asked what I thought of the ESB dispute. First, I should like to say that the men on strike, highly qualified technicians, working to a few thousand parts or the one-thousand part of an inch, had a valid claim for additional payment. What happened? The claim was made by trade union officials seeking parity with clerical workers, which is just like comparing an orange with an elephant. There is no comparison between technical men and clerical workers. I am sure that if the clerical workers were seeking increases, they would not compare themselves with temporary postmen or technicians. They would feel their own qualifications should be the means of justifying the increases. These unfortunate men were forced out on strike for one reason or another. I think it was a blunder of the trade union officials in formulating the claim to attempt to compare them with another group of workers where no comparison existed.

In the initial stages, I believe these men were entitled to an increase and could have made a case which, standing on its merits, would have been successful if properly made. That is one of the weaknesses in the system. Somebody in the trade union movement thinks he knows everything and that other people know nothing. I hope the next time the claim is made, it will be a realistic claim based on the facts as they are, a high degree of skill obtained over the years together with the increase in knowledge which they developed over the years to meet the technical advances within their workshops or within their calling. I am quite sure no reasonable employer could have stated that men with these qualifications were not entitled to some increase. Unfortunately the people who were handling the case were somewhat responsible for the blunders that were made during that period.

The reason for the legislation has already been made clear by the Minister for Labour and been accepted by the great bulk of the workers and of the people of this nation. Quite recently we heard Deputy O'Leary, the new Leader of the Labour Party—it is "goodbye Brendan Corish" since last Saturday night—speaking on television. In this search for power they will not be using tomahawks: it is: "What size rope do you take?" In any event, it has already been accepted by the people as a whole that the action taken was the proper action. Deputy O'Leary's contribution on television was to ask why the hospital did not have an alternative source of supply. What about the farmers who have milking machines? Should they have a second source of supply?

Comment on this

They were in Merrion Street.

Comment on this

What about the refrigerators that carry all types of drugs and medicines? Should they have a second source of supply? What about factory workers who were being deprived of their livelihood because of a power cut? Should they have a second source of supply?

Comment on this

There was no need for the power cut.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary said they should have a second source of supply. Apparently it was all right, provided the hospital had a second source of supply. The lifeblood of this nation would have been stopped and that is what you people wanted, but it did not come off. There were babies in incubators, nurses running around with hot water bottles; you have heard about the man on the verge of a major operation. You were only concerned to discredit a responsible Minister.

Comment on this

I object to this continued attack upon you, Sir.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should use the third person when addressing the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy should use a bit of intelligence.

Comment on this

That is your trouble, he is using it.

Comment on this

As I said before, the Labour Party are divorced from the situation on the floor, from the ordinary trade union worker. The position here in the Dáil is that they spend quite a lot of time here, a lot of time in local authorities, a lot of time in health authorities and in other bodies, and they could not possibly be up to date on the problems of the workers. I would say as a trade unionist in Dáil Éireann, irrespective of Party, I would be only too happy to help any trade union official or worker who has a problem and who feels I might be able to help him whether it be with a view to legislation here or in relation to problems in a place of employment. There are many problems that come before this House from time to time where the dice are loaded by the Labour Party who come along after consulting certain trade union officials about their problems, and lay them on the line. I am prepared, whether they wish to avail of my services or not, to help them. I am as good a trade unionist as any man in the Labour Party or in the Fine Gael Party—and there are trade unionists in the Fine Gael Party, too. I am prepared to listen to the worker or the trade union official in any trade union because I have an interest in all legislation and all matters affecting workers.

Fianna Fáil are the workers' Party and they are the only Party who have shown themselves in days gone by to have the workers' interest at heart. They have proved this by their efforts in establishing industries, in bringing in the necessary aids, by the Conditions of Employment Act, the Holidays Act and many other measures. The Minister for Labour referred to holidays with pay. I would remind Deputy Cluskey that that was the second Act we brought in. There was another one before that which gave seven days to the workers when they had no holidays at all. He did not mention that. The second Act gave them 14 days. The silent service—no heckling; that is amazing. There was plenty of heckling here when we were discussing the Ministers of the Government. We heard all about their deficiencies.

Comment on this

It is obvious that with the Deputy's limited intelligence he cannot carry on without feeding so I will cut off his source of supply.

Comment on this

I will give him another few in a moment. He will be able to make an excellent speech after this. He will be able to tell us about what happened in various industries.

Comment on this

Aer Lingus.

Comment on this

That is only one. There was the development at Shannon when the Lockheed Group had to go to Paris; there was the closing of the chassis workshops at Inchicore, the selling of the equipment of the shortwave station. I could give the Deputy more but I will not bore the House. The Party of which the Deputy is a member are responsible for this destruction. There is a very different attitude today, as I said. We do not hear anything about tomahawks or hatchets or knives, although there was mention of them down in Waterford from two or three platforms.

Comment on this

Down in Kerry, too.

Comment on this

The people of Waterford and Kerry were using the tomahawks when they returned the Fianna Fáil candidates in the recent by-elections. However, I do not wish to inflict any further wounds on the Parties other than to refer to a point made by Deputy Kyne. He mentioned the Labour support in Waterford. At the count I remember the Labour candidate indicating that he got all his support in Waterford city, in the industrialised section of Waterford. If this be so, then I must congratulate Deputy Kyne on keeping all his supporters away from the polls, because he cannot have it both ways. If the Labour support in the last election was in another area and it is not forthcoming this time and the candidate himself says he got it in Waterford, then I want to convey my sincere congratulations to Deputy Kyne on the wonderful job he did in defeating his own man. He probably did not want him elected anyway.

We also saw down in Waterford, as I said before, the banshees of the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party crying all over the county trying to terrify the poor "oul one" out in the hills, and when they were not successful, they brought down the fellows with the long hair.

Two Sundays ago in the 30 mph zone I saw the Fine Gael policymaker, Senator Garret FitzGerald, exceeding the speed limit by talking at the rate of 40 policies per hour. But it did not impress the people in the industrialised sector of Waterford. "Fad's the Lad" came out on top, and on this occasion there was no 12 per cent inducement, as you said there was on the occasion of the Cork and Kildare by-election. You played up the closing down of the Tramore railway line, the terrible dispute at Dunmore East and Passage and the closing down of the other railway to Cork. There was a farmer's candidate there with plenty of money to fire around. Notwithstanding that we were supposed to be spending all the money, more money was spent by the Opposition candidates than would support 20 of ours at a by-election.

A few days ago I wanted to put down a motion, which unfortunately would not be accepted, that Dáil Éireann had no confidence in the present Opposition and calling on them to resign. There are not so many of them around now and I was just wondering if they had taken my advice. However, I have not seen it stated publicly. But there are so few of them around here nowadays something must have happened somewhere. If they have not already done so, they might give serious consideration to this and over the week-end we might see big headlines in the newspapers. In any event, there will be a new policy. I am quite sure the policymakers will be working overtime, apart from exceeding the speed limit.

Deputy Kyne spoke about how difficult it was for CIE workers to have their grievances rectified. He knows very well that the union group in CIE is so large, and you have to get so many people together in order to move on one small item, there is bound to be irritation caused through workers being unable to get the necessary satisfaction as quickly as they should. You people have it in your own hands to solve that problem. You can do it very quickly if you want to. I could give you a suitable remedy. The workers know there are many remedies. If you speak to a CIE worker today, you find he has a different view now from what he had six or 12 months ago in relation to the way he is being hog-tied by this group. They want to operate in their own way in their own time and have no concern for the small problems of workers. Small problems cause irritation. When the necessary machinery is there, we should try to ensure that the irritation is not great.

Of course, it may be that they want the worker irritated so that they can say it is the fault of the Government or of the Minister. They often say that here. I know there are responsible trade unions and responsible trade union officials. I would appeal to members of the Labour Party who are members of trade unions—I explained how some of you are not responsible —to take a leaf out of the book of responsible trade unions. If they did, they would not have to try to get a few votes by developing hatred of their fellowmen or hatred of a particular Minister of Government. You can say that is your policy, that you are going to assist the worker by pointing the finger at one Minister or another. That is what has you here in such small numbers. I am quite sure that in time commonsense will prevail. I hope the Labour Party at their meeting will consider their sooty past. I hold you responsible for the atrocities of 1948. You allowed a group that had sabotaged the nation before to do so again.

In conclusion, I wish to deal with old age pensions. The people without means got 5/- on this occasion. When the Leader of the Labour Party was Minister for Social Welfare, they did not get 5/—they got 10d a year. It would take six years for the unfortunate person to get sufficient to measure up to this increase. Over the years the only advances that have taken place for the benefit of the weaker section of the community were measures implemented by various Fianna Fáil Ministers for Social Welfare. I should like to know from the Labour Party if they can point to one single measure brought in by them that brought relief to that section of the community. They are the Party who talk about social welfare. Their social thinking was 10d per year—the ten-penny Minister for Social Welfare. You could give a fellow a bob, anyway At least when the others took the bob off, they did not make it tenpence; they made it a round figure. If I took a bob off an old age pensioner, I would go to jail. They took it off thousands, and they went scot free.

As a worker and a trade unionist, I support this Party because it is the workers' Party. It is the only Party that has given the worker employment. When we establish factories and provide employment, the Labour Party surge in like flies and try to capture the workers. They say we are anti-worker, although it is we who are providing the employment. We would not be establishing factories and increasing employment if we were anti-worker. The Government in 1948 and at a later stage was anti-worker. I have told you did you were anti-worker. Not alone did you dispossess men, but you sold their very means of livelihood.

I hope Deputy Cluskey will tell us what plans, if any, the Labour Party have for the future. He will probably not be able to do so because the Party meeting to reconstitute the aims of the Party has not yet been called. Deputy O'Leary told us that the hatchet will have to be used and that certain people must be rooted out. They must have new thinking. That is a clear indication that the thinking in the past was not correct. If they had a proper policy in the past, it would have been acceptable to the workers. Deputy O'Leary is a member of the intellectual wing of the Labour Party. He is not on the side of Deputy Cluskey. Deputy Cluskey may want our support at some time to keep back the flood. If he does, he can give us a shout. Just a week before, Deputy O'Leary was saying that the Labour Party policy was the best for the worker. The workers rejected their policy, and then it was no use. You were codding the workers, but you did not cod the workers of Waterford and Kerry and you certainly will not cod them in Dublin the next time.

Comment on this

That is the sort of rubbish that passes for a political speech in this House, and applauded by the Fianna Fáil Party!

Comment on this

First of all, I should like to refer to the by-elections which have recently taken place. I must say that while I had heard of the Fianna Fáil political machine, I never fully realised how powerful that machine was until I saw it in operation in South Kerry. There is no doubt in the world about it, it is a powerful machine.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

As I was saying, I did not fully realise how powerful the Fianna Fáil electoral machine was until I saw it in operation in both South Kerry and Waterford. I want to be quite honest. Before the by-elections, I did not think, in the circumstances, that Fianna Fáil could win both of them. It is a tribute to this election machine that they did. At a time when, through the policy of the Fianna Fáil Government, we had a crisis in housing, when we had a situation where it was impossible for a local authority to get money to build or to repair houses in need of repair by way of grants, at a time when we had the farmers of the country marching to Dublin as a protest against the policy of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries of the Fianna Fáil Government, at a time when the old age pensioners very recently realised the confidence trick that had been played on them by the Minister for Social Welfare with regard to the 5/- increase and at a time when we had a financial situation that made it impossible for small business people or any kind of business people to get any facilities by way of overdraft in the banks or anywhere else in order to carry on their business, when one considers that all these difficulties were brought about by the Fianna Fáil Government, one must pay tribute to the Fianna Fáil election machine which won the two by-elections. They were not won on policy. They were not won on past records. The same means were adopted to win the by-elections as would be adopted by a commercial concern to sell, for example, a soap powder or any other commodity, namely, by blitzing the area with all the very powerful resources available to the Fianna Fáil Party.

When one considers the amount of patronage they have handed out to their henchmen since 1932 and when the amount of vested interest is taken into account and when one fully realises all that was at stake for a few privileged people who had the money and the resources to put into these constituencies, it is only then that one can understand why Fianna Fáil won the two by-elections. There was too much at stake for these people to win the by-elections because a general election would undoubtedly—and even the Fianna Fáil people know this—have brought about a change with regard to who would govern the country. Fianna Fáil would no longer hold sway. Too many people would lose too many of the "perks" that have been handed out to allow that to happen and that is why Fianna Fáil won the by-elections.

We know that there is this new group of businessmen that has recently been formed to support the Fianna Fáil Party. Some 2,000 businessmen have pledged to subscribe £100 per year to the Fianna Fáil Party funds.

Comment on this

Make it £200 while you are at it.

Comment on this

Let us in on the secret.

Comment on this

I am sure the Taoiseach could give you a list. I do not say that he would give it to you but he could.

Comment on this

Did the Taoiseach give you the list?

Comment on this

The first directors were mentioned in the daily papers. You are the last man to talk about "perks".

Comment on this

These people who are prepared to subscribe £100 a year to the Fianna Fáil Party are doing so because they know where their best interest lies, not the country's. It is a form of insurance. They are subscribing and have put their name to this list, pledging to subscribe, £100 per year, to ensure that all the little favours and all the little "perks" will continue. They are the same people as ensured that Fianna Fáil would win both by-elections.

Deputy Dowling spoke of the Fianna Fáil Party as the workers' Party. He opened his remarks by describing himself as a worker and trade unionist. He went on to make a vicious and unscrupulous attack upon certain individuals who are not even Members of this House. I should like Deputy Dowling or any other member of the Fianna Fáil Party or any person who votes for the Fianna Fáil Party who describes himself as a worker or as a trade unionist to bear in mind the record of the Fianna Fáil Government and their attitude to workers in the past. I would ask workers and trade unionists to keep this record in mind and to judge Fianna Fáil, not by the mumblings and mouthings of their spokesmen, whether at ministerial level or otherwise, as to their concern for the workers, but by their record and how they have behaved towards the workers.

Let us take a look, not as far back as the Minister for Labour had to delve in order to come up with something that might be described as being good for workers, not as far back as 1936, the year the Minister for Labour took here this afternoon as a start when describing the magnificent legislation that had been introduced by Fianna Fáil for the benefit of workers. We will go back just a few years. We noted and brought to the notice of the Minister for Labour that he skipped a period. He skipped the year 1938 and the next year mentioned by the Minister for Labour when he was speaking about legislation that was good for the workers was 1946.

We in the Labour Party remember the legislation that was introduced by Fianna Fáil during the period 1938-1946. We remember the standstill orders that were imposed on the workers by the Fianna Fáil Government. It is not so far back when workers were seeking a 12 per cent increase. We remember the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, and the present Taoiseach, who was then Minister for Finance, telling the workers that the very most they could get was seven or possibly eight per cent. We did not hear the Fianna Fáil Government or Fianna Fáil spokesmen telling employers that they could not have more than seven or eight per cent profit. We did not hear them say that rents, profits, dividends or professional fees should be curtailed. All we heard from the Taoiseach of that time and the Minister for Finance who is now the Taoiseach was that one section of the community would have to be curtailed, namely, the organised workers. This grand Party of workers, Fianna Fáil, were the people who were telling the workers that. When workers secured their 12 per cent, they secured it in the only way in which they have ever secured anything, through their militancy.

We should also examine the attitude of the workers' party and the workers' Government, Fianna Fáil, when it came to the question of taxation. Food was taxed. Clothing was taxed. Medicine was taxed. Every conceivable thing it was necessary for an ordinary working class family to use was affected by the turnover tax introduced by the Fianna Fáil Government. There was no question of ability to pay. That did not enter into it. As far as the Fianna Fáil Government were concerned all they wanted was money and it was to the workers that they went in order to get that money. There was no consideration given to the fact that a man with £10,000 a year could eat only as much bread as a man with £500 a year. There was no consideration given to the fact that whether you earned £10,000 or £500 you could wear only one suit of clothes. There was no consideration given to the fact that the children of a man with an income of £500 a year might require medicine just as the family of a man earning £10,000 a year might require medicine. All these commodities were taxed and the same amount of tax was taken, irrespective of a man's income. This is an example of the attitude of the so-called workers' Party towards the workers.

Let us come down to the last increase secured by workers—the £1. Again we find that Deputy Lemass and Deputy Lynch were telling the workers that the most they could have was three per cent. Nobody heard them on that occasion telling the people who were making profits that the most they could have was three per cent, or that the most by which dividends, rents or professional fees could be increased was three per cent. The workers were the one section of the community who were told that they could have only three per cent. The rest could carry on, plunder what they could. Yet we are told by Deputy Dowling and some of his colleagues who claim to be trade unionists that Fianna Fáil are the workers' Party.

Comment on this

That part seems to worry the Deputy.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not worry. We are getting around to him. Deputy Dowling's heart was bleeding for the democratic rights of workers. Where were the democratic rights of workers and where were Deputy Dowling and his trade union colleagues when the ESB Bill was passed in this House? They were trooping into the lobbies with Fianna Fáil. Deputy Seán Collins's heart is also bleeding for the democratic rights of workers. Deputy Dowling and his Fianna Fáil trade unionists trooped into the lobby to deprive their fellow workers of their basic democratic rights.

Comment on this

Read Deputy O'Leary on it. It is very enlightening.

Comment on this

They trooped into the lobby to deprive the workers, by law, of their right to strike, by making it compulsory, under penalty of imprisonment or fine, to accept the findings of an arbitration board. This is the Party that Deputy Dowling tells us is the workers' party.

We have also heard from the Minister for Labour and other speakers criticisms of the trade union movement. It should be said that the trade union movement is not perfect. We all know that. It is difficult, if not impossible, for a purely democratic organisation to operate without some defects. Possibly the criticisms levelled at the trade union movement by the Minister for Labour might be due to his opinion that the trade union movement is too democratic. It is not too democratic for us. We are going to retain it as a democratic organisation, despite the best efforts of the so-called Fianna Fáil trade unionists, either inside or outside this House.

Deputy Dowling also thought it fit to make a vicious onslaught on trade union officials. I was wondering what inspired Deputy Dowling to make this attack and it suddenly struck me that Deputy Dowling stood two years ago for election for a full-time office in a trade union in this city and was rejected by the workers. Is that why he is so sore and so vicious about trade union officials? Is it because he thought when he stood for election in a democratic organisation that his pull in Fianna Fáil would secure that office for him? He does not know much about the trade union movement and he displayed that ignorance very clearly here today.

One does not expect too much from Deputy Dowling but one is entitled to expect a realistic approach towards the difficulties of industry in this country from the man who is responsible for that side of our affairs, the Minister for Labour. Unfortunately the Minister did not act in a very responsible manner; he was not very realistic. He said that one of the reasons we had strikes here was that trade union officials were serving claims. This statement is from the man charged with the responsibilities of Minister for Labour.

Surely the Minister must know how a trade union works? Surely he must know that it is a general meeting of the workers that decides whether or not a claim should be served? Surely he must realise that if that claim is served and if negotiations take place on it, the result of those negotiations must go back to be accepted or rejected by the main body of workers? Trade union officials do not sit behind their desks churning out claims and turning them in to employers. They do not say that the result of the negotiations does not suit them and that they will go on strike. However stupid Deputy Dowling was in this respect, one is entitled to expect that the Minister for Labour would be acquainted with what actually takes place.

The Minister went on to talk about legislation that would help the conduct of industrial relations. I do not deny that certain things can be introduced which would have a desirable effect. One of the most important of these is to extend the Labour Court which has played a very useful role in our industrial field. It has its defects and it can be improved, but, when the Minister or anyone else suggests to me that there is no conflict between employer and worker, to me he is either a fool or a hypocrite. I am not quite sure which, but he must be one or the other.

There is just so much in our gross national product and it must of necessity lead to conflict when the worker tries to pull out as much as he can and the employer tries to pull out as much as he can. There is undoubtedly a basic conflict of interest between the worker and the employer. The more a worker gets, as the employer sees it, the less profit there is for him. It was ridiculous to suggest otherwise. It is only right and proper that serious consideration should be given to any means that can be introduced to minimise the effects of that conflict but to ignore the conflict or to pretend that it is not there can only lead to further harm.

We listened to Deputy Dowling castigating the Labour Party, the trade union movement, trade unionists, inter-Party Governments, Deputy Corish and the late Deputy Norton. He ended up by saying that the workers support Fianna Fáil and, to a large extent, I agree with him, for, if the workers did not support the Fianna Fáil Party, the Fianna Fáil Party would not and could not have as many seats in this House as they now have.

I believe the day is coming when the workers will at last realise that they can no longer go on supporting conservative Parties and at the same time make progress. I am a trade unionist; I was literally born into the trade union movement. All my family were closely associated with the trade union movement. I worked for a comparatively long time as a trade union official and I assert now, and I appreciate what I am saying, that the trade union movement cannot advance very much further the interests of the workers and the trade union movement. The workers must realise this. Both have reached a stage at which they are running as fast as they possibly can to a complete standstill and any advance to be made by the ordinary working people must in future be made not in the industrial field but in the political field.

I appeal to workers who have in the past supported the Fianna Fáil Party to look at the record of the Fianna Fáil Government, take note of the legislation, of the mis-statements and attitudes of leading spokesmen of the Party towards the workers and realise that there is only one hope now of achieving what they all aspire to, namely, a decent life for both themselves and their families. That will be achieved only through political action and by a Party which, unlike the other two Parties founded on the bitterness and hatred of Civil War, was first formed long years before that Civil War with the object of furthering the interests of the working class people.

Comment on this
Mr. Barrett

I was deeply disappointed with the Taoiseach's speech this morning because the country is entitled to know, when a new Taoiseach speaks on an occasion such as this, if there is to be any new deal for the country. The people are entitled to know if the Taoiseach is going to continue in the way of his precedessor or if there will be some change in policy or some change of approach in the leadership in the Party. Is there going to be any change of Government policy in relation to domestic matters, the internal matters of the Party?

I was bitterly disappointed that the Taoiseach did not give some indication today to a country which feels, perhaps, to use his own expressive phrase, that he is a via media Taoiseach, the weak leader of a Party strongly entrenched in Government. It would be a bad thing for the country if that impression were bruited abroad and it was up to the Taoiseach today to indicate what he purported to indicate on another occasion, namely, that he was to be a strong Taoiseach. There is adequate reason for him to make a statement.

We all wish the Taoiseach well when he goes to Britain shortly to meet the British Prime Minister. Still more will he need the unity of the House and of the country behind him when he subsequently visits the Prime Minister of Northern Ireland in conformity with the policy set for him by Deputy Lemass, his predecessor. When he does go to the North, it is only right that those on the other side of the Border should feel that those on this side are behind him, showing the utmost loyalty and giving him every assistance.

What do we find? We find one of his Ministers, the Minister for Justice, opening his big mouth too wide on the eve virtually of the Taoiseach's efforts to find a new basis of agreement with the Prime Minister of Northern Ireland. When I was Lord Mayor of Cork, it was my pleasure and privilege to invite to Cork the Lord Mayor of Belfast, as representing the people of Belfast; I, representing the people of Cork, welcomed him and I found nothing but the best of good feeling and the greatest anxiety to find any plank, no matter how narrow, on which the people of the South and the people of the North could stand together. It would be a good thing if the Taoiseach dissociated himself now from the sort of loud-mouthed utterances emanating from his own Front Bench at this particular juncture in time.

I suppose that is really a domestic matter for the Taoiseach, but it is something, I think, that has created a very bad climate in the North at a time when the most temperate of climates should be created and at a time when everyone of us should bend all his energies towards helping to create such a climate. I was disappointed that the Taoiseach did not indicate to the House and to the country that he expected to get that loyalty and that assistance in the important tasks that lie before him. Discipline is the essence of good government and, if there is a lack of discipline, the country, as well as the Fianna Fáil Party, will suffer.

There has been a frightening development over the past six or seven months by a vocal minority who claim that nobody has the right to differ from them in relation to the ways and means by which national aspirations in regard to the language are to be achieved. We have had the most shocking manifestations both in Dublin and in Galway and we have had idiot councillors getting up and saying it was a great day for the people when somebody else could not stand up and say what he wanted to say about the manner in which the Irish language should be fostered.

Speaking for a constituency which has still to offer the democratic right to the organisation involved to put their policy before the people, if they wish to do so, I deprecate the views expressed here—they actually horrify me—by the Taoiseach's Parliamentary Secretary on 29th November when he indicated quite plainly that nobody had the right to discuss the Irish language except those who wished to insist on its being taught and fostered in a certain fashion. He said meetings should be proscribed and gatherings of citizens should not be allowed because others disagreed with them and, in disagreeing, had their passions aroused. I would like the Taoiseach to state: "People will have their democratic rights so long as I am Taoiseach. People will have their democratic rights so long as I lead this Cabinet, and these Parliamentary Secretaries, and I regret that my Parliamentary Secretary should have strayed from the democratic path in the fashion in which he did."

The Taoiseach has not done that. He went to the trouble of issuing a statement from his Department on another minor matter in relation to which his Parliamentary Secretary again put his foot in it one Thursday here, but he did not think it worth his while to indicate to the country, as far as this Government are concerned, that this horrible manifestatation of a kind of neo-Nazism would not be tolerated on the part of certain small sections which indicate that not over their dead bodies but over the dead bodies of any section with which they disagree are certain approaches to be made to the fostering of the Irish language.

I deeply regret that the Taoiseach did not make some reference in that respect today. It is important that small, vocal minorities should not get the impression that they have sacred rights which exist neither in law nor in equity, nor in the ordinary democratic processes. I hope that at some stage the Taoiseach will avail of some opportunity to indicate to each man and woman in the nation that they have the right to speak their minds and the right to advocate what they think is right and proper, so long as it is not treason.

I also hoped the Taoiseach would avail of the opportunity to correct an impression, however erroneous it may have been, which was given by his predecessor on 12th October when, broadly speaking, he indicated that as far as Telefís Éireann was concerned, the Government were in the saddle from start to finish and the Government could use Telefís Éireann as they liked for their own ends. That may be their reading of section 31 of the Broadcasting Act, 1960, but it is in direct conflict with another important section, section 18, which starts with the sub-title of "Impartiality" and which indicates that the Authority have a statutory duty, not just a right, on behalf of the people to ensure that discussions on matters of public controversy and current public discussions are impartially presented. I am speaking now purely on domestic matters but they are very important at a time like this when there is a new Government under a new Leader. It is very important that he should come to terms with the people and indicate to the people how their rights are being catered for by the Government.

I hope the Taoiseach will change the trend which has caused the greatest disquiet not alone on this side of the House but in the hearts and minds of many Fianna Fáil backbenchers, and certainly among many of their supporters and many businessmen and, in fact, taxpayers generally who are affected by it. There should be much more frankness with the House and the country about the affairs of companies to which large grants have been given by this House, by the Government in the name of the people. There is a great deal of public money spent in this way. To indicate just how much money is involved, I should point out that since 1952 Foras Tionscal, and this is only a section of the total, has approved grants for £10,471,869, of which £1,764,871 was approved in the last financial year. The approach of the people to such things is that they are glad to encourage companies to come here and give value for money. They are glad to have them here but they do expect that they will be given some details about how their money is being spent.

In 1963, we sat down here for a considerable period and enacted the Companies Act, one of the largest Acts we ever enacted. It takes up an entire volume of the Acts of the Oireachtas for 1963. In it, the most meticulous care was taken to see that a shareholder who voluntarily invests his money in a company and says: "Here is my £100; put it in," will have his rights safeguarded and that the accounts of the firm into which he has put the money will be audited, that he will have access to them and also that he can go along to the annual general meeting and say: "I do not like this and I do not like that". Also, if the directors are not behaving in the fashion in which they should be behaving, they can be removed.

All these safeguards are given by this House and by the people to persons who invest vountarily in companies. What is the approach to people like myself and the unfortunate Deputy Corry and others who invest our money involuntarily in companies because the money is taken from us in taxation and given to some company? The approach is typified by the approach of the former Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Hillery. When I asked him a question about a company in Clare and he refused to answer it, the Chair told me that he was right to refuse and I could of course, go elsewhere and find out the details. This is a company, the affairs of which should not alone have been investigated by the Department of Industry and Commerce but by the Department of Justice, because the company got a large sum of money by way of grant and overnight disappeared like a morning mist and nothing more was heard about it.

It is all very well to say, as Deputy Briscoe said, that it was the policy of the Government to encourage only people who had been a success elsewhere. Whatever the hopes and aspirations of the Government may have been, it cannot be said that they have always been successful. It is incontestible that they gave a grant to a gentleman who came to West Cork with a list of convictions in a British court against him. They gave him a grant and lovely photographs were published in the local papers saying "Here is the skeleton of the magnificent factory in which shortly 200 workers will be employed, thanks be to God and the Fianna Fáil Government". There are about six or seven employed there.

While it may be true that these are not the generality of cases it is important that we should have the right to come in here and ask questions about them, or, through a subcommittee of the House which would report on the activities of these companies, learn what is happening. The people should have the right to investigate where their money has gone and how it has been used. This has not happened under the present dispensation. I had hoped that the Taoiseach would indicate that that trend was being reversed. It is all very well to say that we cannot do that because it will frighten these gentlemen away. If a gentleman feels that his activities are going to be of such a nature that they dare not stand up to public scrutiny, it is better that we should not encourage him to come here at all.

I should like to see the day when anybody who comes looking for a loan or a grant or other assistance or encouragement would know that he is coming subject to public scrutiny of the manner in which he uses our money. It is more important than ever that that should be so because every second day we hear of successful take-over bids. In many cases, these involve companies which got large grants being taken over by companies outside the country and, incidentally, the shareholders of these companies get a very bad return. There should be some form of control over these companies when they receive money from the Government.

I should like now briefly to disillusion Deputy Briscoe in regard to some of the illusions he seems to cherish arising out of recent by-elections. It is true that in some sense it was a victory for the Government inasmuch as they won the two seats, but Deputy Briscoe says that the elections showed that the people have learned to trust Fianna Fáil. If that is so, they are becoming increasingly reluctant every day to express that trust. The by-elections must be taken in conjunction with what happened in the city constituencies in the Presidential election when there was a complete change-over, a swing against the Government, despite the fact that the Government candidate was a man of enormous prestige, both here and abroad.

The figures in the two by-elections did not show that the Government are getting more support in rural areas but that fewer people voted for the Government on this occasion than in the last general election and that 3,324 more people voted for Fine Gael than in the last general election. That is the manifestation of the trust of the Irish people in Fianna Fáil. Surely Deputy Briscoe is intelligent enough to know that it indicates the coming of the day when support in rural Ireland will be withdrawn from Fianna Fáil, just as it was withdrawn from them when Deputy O'Higgins challenged the present President in the Presidential election? I look forward to that day.

There is another very important aspect of national life which should be dealt with. It arises out of the by-elections and also out of the fact that this year, at last, the people are getting an opportunity to express themselves at the local elections. Arising out of what I saw happening in South Kerry, it is very important, not purely in the interests of the Opposition but in the interests of all Parties and of democracy that there should be a clearing up of a matter about which there appears to be some confusion concerning the conduct of the polling booth. I refer to the fact that occasionally it is necessary—and unfortunately was necessary in South Kerry—to appeal to the Garda to maintain public order. That seems an elementary proposition. It is most important that men and women going to the polls know that they will not be molested and that if they are molested by the followers of any Party, they will be protected by the Garda.

When occasion arose to call for Garda protection on this occasion in this town in South Kerry—at the Mercy Convent, to be exact—the position was that nobody knew who was in charge of the Garda. In some circles, the impression is that the presiding officer is king of the poll and can do as he likes, but the presiding officer can lawfully say: "I may be boss here but that is the curtilage out there. That is the playground and I am not in charge of that."

If the presiding officer has to give directions to a garda, there are occasions when the garda says: "The presiding officer cannot give me any directions. These should be given by my superior officers." His superior officer says: "No, it is the returning officer who is the boss." Some indication should be given between now and polling day in the local elections—unless there is a general election in the meantime — to all concerned, returning officers and superior officers of the Garda as to the division of rights and duties in these very important institutions on polling day. Who is to be in control of the booths and the curtilage and the vicinity of the booths so that when a voter goes to express a preference, that voter will know that he or she is safe from molestation of the kind some people experienced in South Kerry? This goes more to the root of democracy than the more prosaic matters dealt with by the Taoiseach today.

Again, let me say, speaking for myself and I am quite sure for my Party, that we hope the Taoiseach will carry with him when he goes to Northern Ireland the best wishes of all. We wish him every success. Our only regret is that he will be festooned with the stupid sort of ill-tempered and ill-timed speech made by the Minister for Justice at a time when anybody should know he ought not make speeches of that type.

Comment on this
Erskine Hamilton Childers Minister for Transport and Power (Mr. Childers) Fianna Fáil

It has been amusing to hear members of the Opposition trying to give some explanation of why they lost the two by-elections.

Comment on this

The Minister was not in the House to hear them.

Comment on this

The latest explanations is that the by-elections must be related to certain events that took place during the Presidential election. If one were to carry on an argument like that, one could say that as Fianna Fáil lost the election in 1954, that fact must be taken into account in connection with any by-election occurring since.

I was interested to hear Deputy Cluskey who engaged in a discourse which, to my mind, showed a complete inferiority complex on the part of the Labour Party. He implied that the people of Kerry and Waterford are capable of being indefinitely bribed and cheated by Fianna Fáil. Apparently, they are people of low character and mentality. They are capable of voting in a particular way at an elecaion because of perpetual patronage alleged to be given by Fianna Fáil or because of the influence of rich businessmen. I know County Kerry rather well, and Waterford to some extent, and that observation in relation to the small farming world of Counties Kerry and Waterford is really childish in the extreme. Deputies in Opposition could spend their time better than in trying to make this sort of excuse.

Deputy Cluskey went on to warn the trade unionist card-holders who he admits continually support Fianna Fáil Government that their action is a desperate one, revealing their spinelessness in regard to the Labour movement and how disastrous was their action in Kerry and Waterford since, according to his admission, they unquestionably assured the re-election of two Fianna Fáil Deputies. He expressed his amazement that Fianna Fáil could ever win any election and that surely the people realised that the turnover tax when imposed was a deliberate attack deliberately designed to take away incomes from the poor people. He did not mention that when the turnover tax was instituted, one-third of it went straight back to increased social welfare benefits and that the Minister for Finance said at the time that he reckoned that only 40 per cent of the entire population would, in view of that, in fact, be paying any degree of tax that could be said to affect their incomes in any way. Apparently, the people of Kerry and Waterford had become aware that the turnover tax was not meant to be a tax which would hit people with low incomes, that the more they spent, the more they paid, and that not only in that year but in successive years, social welfare benefits were raised in order to mitigate any adverse effect of this tax.

Deputy Cluskey spoke of the position of workers in relation to recent economic events. He did not seem to follow the advice given to the Irish people by the National Industrial Economic Council which included nine trade unionists and which persistently warned the people, on an independent basis and not guided by the Government, of what would happen if incomes exceeded a certain limit. The Deputy was apparently speaking in the void, as though his representatives on the NIEC had no merit and that nothing they said should be heeded by the man in the street, although this body was set up independently of the Government and was admittedly free from political Party interests. Then Deputy Cluskey proceeded to make a series of declarations which would suggest that, while there were some deficiencies in the Irish trade union movement, he very much doubted that anything could be done about it, that the trade union movement was a democratic one and because it was a democratic one, it was very difficult to organise properly.

If Deputy Cluskey were to read some of the speeches made recently by trade union leaders, he would find Mr. John Conroy, for example, in his speech at Galway saying that the trade union movement must move gradually towards the formation of industrial unions, one union for each industry, that this might take time, that it would be very difficult but that it was an ideal to reach. Apparently there are some people who do not share the cynical opinions of Deputy Cluskey in regard to the possibilities of reorganisation of the trade union movement.

Then again Deputy Cluskey spoke about the democratic character of the trade union movement. He did not go into any further detail. He did not describe what he meant by democratic action, whether, for example, he would regard it as undemocratic for branches of the trade union movement here to give executive power to their leaders as they do in Sweden and as they do in the Netherlands—in exactly the same way as the Irish people give the Dáil executive power to act on their behalf, as the ratepayers and local authorities give the county councillors executive power to act on their behalf—thus making it possible to engage in negotiations for the solution of industrial disputes with the possibility of a greater chance of success and less possibility of industrial strife. Deputy Cluskey did not mention or talk about any of those problems at all.

He did not refer to the fact that the highly democratic trade union movements of the Netherlands and Sweden not only engage in prolonged negotiations with industries that sometimes take as long as eight months but they also appoint professional economists, both employers and workers, and they go, with exactitude, into the collective and individual profits made by every firm of the industry, its growth of productivity, its competitive success in the export field compared with firms in competing industries abroad. The negotiations take place, leading sometimes to contracts that are entered into and that are enforceable by law for a period of three years at a time, in which there is an assurance of a given growth of productivity within the industry itself based on new machinery, on new techniques and perhaps certain changes made in the method of working on the part of the workers, and which, at the same time, assures the workers of a specific growth in income.

We heard none of this talk from Deputy Cluskey about the democratic trade union movement in Europe. He just spoke about it in a cynical way and suggested that when Deputies on the Fianna Fáil side stated there might be changes in trade union organisation along exactly the same lines as those be spoken by leaders of the trade union movement themselves, the Fianna Fáil Deputies were guilty of attacks upon trade unionists in general and trade unionists in particular.

Comment on this

Of course, that is not true. The proposals are not the same. I have been here.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not in the House when the Deputy made these remarks.

Comment on this

I am dealing with what the Minister said.

Comment on this

I shall take up at any time with Deputy Donegan anything to do with trade union organisation because I know all about it from back to front.

Comment on this

I have been as close to trade union matters as the Minister. I am saying the proposals are not the same. The Government proposals absolutely contravene the trade union proposals.

Comment on this

To what proposals is Deputy Donegan referring!

Comment on this

I shall deal with them when the Minister has finished speaking.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Donegan has personal practical experience.

Comment on this

Whether I have or not, I have the Government proposals here and I have the trade union proposals in my bag.

Comment on this

I was not referring to Government proposals. I was referring to Deputy Cluskey's loose talk about trade union organisation, and Deputy Cluskey himself did not refer to the Trade Union Bill in what he said.

Comment on this

The Minister said the Government proposals were identical to the trade union proposals.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I was speaking about general trade organisations and I was referring to statements made by Irish trade union leaders calling for re-organisation. I was referring to this because Deputy Dowling was attacked by Deputy Cluskey for what he said about solving industrial problems within CIE and other companies. I want to mention the fact that I myself had made proposals, none of which had been contradicted or denied, which would lead to an improvement in industrial relations in the State companies. I made a very specific proposal to which there was not one word of opposition on the part of trade union leaders, and if there could be some arrangement among the trade union organisation, for example, within CIE, over a period of years, they could iron out most of the difficulties that best them and could secure increases in benefits and fringe benefits on a long-term basis which could mean that there would be no need for these disastrous strikes. The main thing was to have a concerted effort at negotiations to solve their difficulties over a long period and in accordance with the capacity of CIE to pay.

Comment on this

If the Minister turns to page 6 of the September issue of Trade Union Viewpoint, he will find the heading: “Minister's proposals on Trade Union Law Rejected”.

Comment on this

I am not talking about those proposals. Deputy Donegan is merely trying to confuse the issue. I know there is a difference of opinion in regard to the trade union proposals and the Government proposals on trade union organisation. I am talking about things that could be done voluntarily by the trade union movement, irrespective of any Government decision. I am referring to matters in which in every case I could quote a trade union leader as saying this problem needs to be studied, and all I am saying is that when Deputy Cluskey accused Deputy Dowling of being anti-trade union he was denying and ignoring the statements made by his own leaders about this very serious problem which is recognised by everybody.

I also noted that we heard from Deputy Barrett again about Foras Tionscal grants. I noted also that during the by-elections the Kerry people and the Waterford people did not respond to the invective by the Opposition on the subject of certain companies that failed to take advantage of Foras Tionscal grants. They were not impressed, although these statements were made in my hearing at the by-elections, the implications being that the Government was guilty of gross negligence or even of corruption in the giving of these grants. The Opposition Deputies did not refer to the fact that since the foundation of Foras Tionscal, allowing for firms that may have had financial difficulties and reopened under other auspices, about 4 per cent of the total money given by Foras Tionscal resulted in failure, and only four per cent.

If Deputies in the Opposition care to look at the list of bankruptcies during the most prosperous era in New York City and relate the bankruptcies to prosperity, they could almost say that Foras Tionscal might be a little bit too cautious, if the results since 1952 show only four per cent of failures. Then of course those Deputies do not know anything about the course of business and about what happens when firms start. They never give any study to the possibilities and the extent of bankruptcies that do take place under the most favourable circumstances. There are very many promoters of industry who would say that a four per cent failure for an investment was not at all bad. A great many investment firms would be very satisfied if over a period going back to 1952 they had only a four per cent failure in the money they invested. All we heard during the election was a suggestion that the money that had been lost on this or that venture could have been directed to some other purpose. It was one of those futile arguments in which you start shifting money from one purpose to another in the hope of bribing and innocent electorate. It did not work in Waterford and Kerry.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Where did the quotas go?

Comment on this

The people of Waterford and Kerry in these two by-elections were far too intelligent to listen to the caterwauling of the Opposition from the platforms. They know very well the fact that real help is being given to farmers, small and big. They know very well that in Kerry, which derives about £4½ million income from tourism alone, the Government have shown a lively interest in tourism and have encouraged Bord Fáilte to spend money wisely and well to bring tourists to Kerry. They provided capital for new hotel accommodation and spent massive sums on promotion. The people of Kerry are very well aware of that fact. They know the Government have brought aid to these countries through industrial grants. They know that, in spite of all the woeful talk of the Opposition, the people of this country are nearly one-third better off in real terms, and allowing for the change in the cost of living, than they were in 1958.

They are also aware that emigration cannot be turned off suddenly like a tap. It would be years before controllable emigration could be ended. They know perfectly well how useless it is to speak off public platforms and wail about emigration, as if it were something immediately controllable by the Government in office. They have plenty of commonsense in regard to that problem.

Of course, above all, the people of Waterford and Kerry showed they were not so innocent as to imagine we could have an extreme and severe crisis taking place in our nearest neighbour, England, and that we could remain completely unaffected, as though we were some kind of island floating in the firmament, independent of all other economic influences. To hear some of the speakers down in the by-elections, one would imagine this country had some peculiar quality of its own, some special privilege, some magic principle whereby we alone of all the countries in the world could remain completely independent of an economic crisis occurring close to us and that, therefore, despite anything that appeared to slow up economic progress—which, of course, was partly our own responsibility as a result of the inflation we ourselves invited here and partly resulting from causes outside us—we could go on normally.

As is usual in the case of a large volume such as the Second Programme we never hear quoted the extremely important paragraphs which define the shape of the whole Programme and which give quite clear indications as to the conditions in which it can proceed. If the Programmes for Economic Expansion, whether the First or the Second, are read, it will be found the Government gave perfectly honest warnings that the Programmes could be mitigated, altered or limited in their effect at any time due to circumstances over which we had no control. It was made perfectly clear in the First and in the Second Economic Programmes that if inflation took place, if incomes advanced excessively at any period in this country, the targets of the Second Programme and the First Programme could not be met.

The Opposition talked in the elections, in so far as they talked intelligently at all about the Programme, as though it were a perfect document, as though it specified no conditions in which the Programme could work and be achieved, as though the Government simply said in 1960 that industry will advance by so much per cent, agriculture by so much per cent and tourism by so much per cent — that they will advance by that percentage regardless of any conditions that may attend the economy during the passage of time. Apparently, the people of Kerry and Waterford were well aware of the fact that when a programme is written by serious men, the conditions in which it can be successful are adumbrated in paragraph after paragraph. They are all in the Economic Programme. The people of Kerry and Waterford did not imagine that Fianna Fáil would be innocent enough or foolish enough to produce a programme without stating the conditions for its working successfully.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Less than half of the people of Kerry and Waterford.

Comment on this

The people of Waterford and Kerry were well aware of the fact that this country, encouraged by the advance in the economy, had undoubtedly started on some kind of spending spree and that the personal savings of the people began to diminish before taxation increased noticeably and that there was simply less money for the Government to borrow for productive purposes. Apparently, in spite of all the talk of the Opposition, they were aware of the fact that our neighbour across the water is in far greater difficulty than we are at the moment. The investment coming from Great Britain has been limited by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. Therefore, the massive investment coming from one country to another was reduced for at least a period.

The people were aware of that. They were also aware of the fact that it is not the immediate responsibility of the Fianna Fáil Government and the Fianna Fáil Ministers that there is a drying up of credit in a great many countries all over the world. For example, American investment taking place here has to be through dollars available in Europe. There is a clear direction to American banks and investment firms to restrain for the time being certain types of investment abroad. Apparently, the people of Kerry and Waterford accepted the difficulties with which we were faced.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I repeat : less than half the people of Kerry and Waterford.

Comment on this

That includes the people you bought.

Comment on this

And they all read the Second Programme for Economic Expansion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

There were people in Kerry and Waterford who wondered what the Opposition would do if they had to face the difficulties we were facing. They noted that the very people who talked about the crushing taxation, who talked about the increase in the cost of living, whenever they had the opportunity and as the national economy advanced, their attitude was that the Government never could spend enough. If the Government increased expenditure by a given percentage in one year, every member of the Opposition decried the efforts of the Government and asked: "Why are you not spending more on A, B and C ?" But they never said where the money was to come from. They also noted that, during the recent difficulty of securing credit of one kind or another, the members of the Opposition, when they decried the Government for simply limiting housing development to schemes that had been authorised and schemes coming along for development, kept on chiding the Government for not finding more money. But they did not say where the money could be got, how it could be furnished or what services of the Government could be reduced in some other direction.

Comment on this

ICI could get £20 million; you could not get £5 million.

Comment on this

A Deputy gave a list of alleged extravagant Government expenditure. When the list was examined, it was found to consist of a whole series of rather long-term projects which it would take about four years to complete. The saving in a particular year would amount to £250,000 or £300,000 and this was the measure of the Government's alleged reckless expenditure and reckless profligacy in spending the money of the people. I think the people realise the facts as we know them to be. They know also that, up to now, we have managed to deal with this inflation which is common to other countries besides our own. It has affected countries with a longer history and more developed economies than our own, countries such as the Netherlands. We have managed to deal with this inflation fairly successfully. There are not 97,000 unemployed now as there were in 1956.

Comment on this

Or 134,000 in 1933. You have the record for unemployment.

Comment on this

And we did not change the method of counting, either: 16,000 was the difference there.

Comment on this

Exports are already beginning to increase and imports have been held. The measures taken by the Government were neither insufficient nor too harsh. When one takes measures to combat inflation, there is a certain element of fortune about it so that, no matter how carefully a Government may act, it is a fact that the best of Governments can make mistakes. So far, we have managed to progress through our difficulties with comparative success.

I want to reinforce what the present Taoiseach said in the course of his speech that, whatever the Government do in the next two or three years, the economic advance will be determined mainly by the decisions of the Irish people themselves and their ambitions for productive effort. We can make marginal changes in economic and social policy. We can tax for a particular purpose. We can provide grants for the adaptation of industry. We can provide facilities in respect of redundancy and for re-training. We can advance educational facilities. We can continue to control inflation and to assist in the provision of credit to a certain degree but not 100 per cent. That also depends on the decisions of the Irish investors and individual Irish spenders.

There is no major change of policy which we could effect at the present time which could materially alter the economic conditions that will be the result of (1) what takes place abroad and (2) the effort we make here. It is the Irish people, working together and making their own decisions about production and about investment, who will play the greatest part in our future. We did not say anything to the contrary during the by-election. We made it clear that the Government was co-operating with the people and would direct the economy to a certain degree. In our present stage and in our present situation when we are taking some 26 per cent of the entire people's income in taxation and rates, which is the figure at the moment and which is still low by Northern European standards, some major decisions in the future will have to be taken by the Irish people themselves. They have responded and did respond splendidly during the period of the economic revival and since 1958. If we can avoid in the next three years certain difficulties we faced in the past three years we shall undoubtedly make progress. It is certain that if, every two years, the incomes of people advance 23 per cent and production per worker advances only 7 per cent, we can make no progress. No country can make progress on that basis. There are Ministers in many countries probably at this moment making the same kind of speech, based on the same view: for example, Ministers of the British Labour Government.

Countries which indulge in that kind of spending will all face the same difficulties and have all faced the same difficulties. At this moment, in other countries whose economies have temporarily been held or have been expanding to a lesser degree for exactly the same reason, incomes have advanced far more rapidly than the productivity of the people. It is a very lucky thing for us that we have not had to apply the appallingly drastic measures applied in Great Britain to correct the situation there which arose from perhaps different causes but reflected the same changes in condition. It is a salutary warning to the people of this country of the sort of thing that can take place in other countries when inflation gets hold of people. The expenses of Government have gone up. Everything the Government do, all the services they provide, become more costly to administer. That means that less can be done for any expenditure of money under the economic programme than could otherwise be done with the same amount of money. There is some actual loss of three per cent in the value of money.

We have been very lucky up to now because inflation here has been matched by almost equal inflation in Great Britain. If our money lost value the British money had also lost value, so relatively a great many of our exports could still reach Great Britain even though some may have become uneconomic. Now, the British economy is held in a vice for which the British Government and the British people are responsible. Inflation has stopped there. We cannot any longer look outwards to Britain and say that it will be all right if production costs increase here as long as the same happens across the water and let us go on with the merry dance. That day is over. It again means that we shall have to take far more care in this question of the costs of production and in the question of maintaining the value of our money because tariffs will be steadily reduced.

In conclusion, I should like to say once more that I was delighted to be down during the course of the by-elections and to hear the speeches on either side. I think myself that we can say we won the election honestly. We certainly faced a lot of difficulties—the temporary low cattle prices; the NFA campaign; recent increases in taxation; recent increases in the cost of living, all of which things have been happening in other countries. In spite of those adverse circumstances, and a halt temporarily in the economic advance of the country, the people chose to respect our opinions and our views. What we said was in our view the correct policy and we triumphed. I think that is typical of the whole history of Fianna Fáil. Very often we succeed best when, like other countries, we are facing adversity of one kind or another. When we face adversity, we find very often the people respond to the Fianna Fáil Government, which has such a long record of improving social conditions, even better than when material prosperity is more rapid.

Comment on this

I was rather amazed that the Minister for Transport and Power used the phrase a few minutes ago "present Taoiseach". We all wonder, with some of the people around him, how long he will be in office. He will not be there very long. Inflation, according to the Minister for Transport and Power, came to us by the wishes of the Irish people. We had his admission that the Government can affect only very slightly the economic affairs of this country, an admission which comes rather strangely from that side of the House. They were always the strong-arm boys. They were always the people who wanted to interfere in the life of the ordinary Irishman. Other Parties here were more inclined to leave the Irishman to look after his own affairs. It seems now, when the ship has gone into stormy waters, that those who steered her course would like to say that she steered herself. That is not so.

The Taoiseach this morning told us that trade figures and balance of payments figures were improving. Of course they are. They are improving because of the restrictive measures imposed by the Government. One has to consider what were the results of these restrictive measures. How many small businesses in country towns closed in the past 24 months? As a percentage of the whole, of course, the number is small, but, if it is small, how many businesses were seriously inconvenienced, how many people knocked off employees, how many people found themselves in the greatest financial difficulties? Very many more than those who closed. How many people with small personal overdrafts, paying for the reconstruction of their houses or the purchase of furniture, with ordinary commercial banks, have been pressed beyond the limit of their capacity to repay? I go among my people in my constituency and I know quite a few. I would suggest that the amount of personal torture, personal inconvenience and personal interference there was with people's lives over the past two years has been quite extraordinary.

If all this has brought a reduction in the purchasing power of the Irish people, has brought about a contracting economy, and if all this is to be mirrored in the figures we will get at Budget time, in a smaller gross national product, that is the price we had to pay for Fianna Fáil, the price we had to pay for the wishes of the Irish people as translated in the ballot box into a Fianna Fáil Government.

If one moves through the sphere of Government spending and considers the number of people who had to sell perhaps a few shares they might have laid aside for a rainy day or who had to sell property or who had to sell cattle that were not fit to be sold and who had to do all these things because local local authorities could not pay them their grants and their loans and they in turn could not pay the builders' providers or contractors, one sees the measure of the cost of the correction of the ills that were brought upon us by Fianna Fáil. Theirs was the hand that was on the tiller since 1957 and, but for a short break, before that for many years. They were the people who, as I said—and it was perhaps to me that the Minister for Transport and Power referred—built all these magnificent buildings, some of which we inhabit ourselves, some of which are inhabited by semi-State companies and some of which are rented at colossal rates. All this was an indication, as I said here before and want to repeat this evening, that the Government's priorities over the years went wrong. The Government did not remember the county council cottages which Deputy Corry and I and the Parliamentary Secretary wanted built. They did not remember the local authority houses. They did not remember essential things. They remember the things they felt could be provided when money was freely available.

It is only a short time ago—1963— that the Government decided that all the deposits in banks here over £1,000 should be recorded and transmitted for investigation to the income tax authorities. They were so arrogant, so certain that a flood of capital would continue to come here that they could discipline those who would send it here. One might say that Switzerland is a rich country. Some people call it an economic funk hole. I do not care where the money comes from. When I see that houses cannot be built in my constituency, I would not object to any kind of money from abroad and would not inquire where it came from, if it did come here to bolster our economy as it needs to be bolstered.

The Minister for Transport and Power referred, for instance, to the question of restricting sanction for houses to those already being planned. What about the situation where the then Minister for Local Government, now moved to Agriculture, actually allowed houses to start on the basis that the contractors could not finish the job before the end of this financial year, so that, politically, he could say that there were 100 houses or 200 houses being built but financially and factually the position was that these houses were being delayed and would not be built until after the financial year?

These are the remedial measures that were taken. I want to refer to some of them again. Their effort was to create an increase in unemployment of, in my opinion, 25,000 people. Where do I get my figure of 25,000? I get it by taking the increase in unemployment of 9,000, plus 16,000, which is the difference in the first week when Fianna Fáil changed the method of counting those on the register of unemployed. There is no method that I or anybody else can contrive to decide what effect that change had in the weeks as they passed along. We can take the difference in one week when the old system was used and the following week when it was not used. The difference is 16,000. Therefore, I suggest that by the old measuring stick there are today 70,000 unemployed. I contest the ability of anybody on the opposite benches to refute that statement.

What other remedial measures were taken? The Minister for Industry and Commerce will be interested to know the figures in relation to the Agricultural Credit Corporation where lendings of £6.7 million were reduced to £3.5 million and where the Minister for Finance, now the Taoiseach, said that this was in fact £0.4 million more of lendings for productive purposes and that only £3.1 million of the £6.7 million was for productive purposes in the previous year.

The definition on which the activities of the Agricultural Credit Corporation were curbed was that if you had a small overdraft in the bank, you could not get a loan. If you wanted a loan and you had an overdraft of £500, the Agricultural Credit Corporation said that the loan was to get rid of the bank overdraft and refused the loan. Therefore, the person concerned did not build a silage unit or did not increase the number of stock on his land because of the small overdraft, which was almost universal. If a man had 50 acres and 20 acres beside him were put up for sale, which he wanted to buy, if he could not get a loan from the commercial bank, the Agricultural Credit Corporation would not give him a loan on the basis that it was not for a productive purpose. He could not get a loan to buy land.

The Parliamentary Secretary knows as well as I and Deputy Corry and anybody from a rural area knows that when you have a unit that is too small, one of the most productive measures you could take is to get it to a proper size for proper farming, proper application of machinery and labour. This definition of productive purposes was nothing but a political catchcry—disgraceful, and almost obscene.

I do not want to go into the figures in relation to the Industrial Credit Company. I could go into them exactly as I have in the case of the Agricultural Credit Corporation. The result is the same—a reduction in investment, a reduction in opportunity, a reduction that has been mirrored in the fact that we have fallen far behind the targets set in the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. It is a reduction that has caused emigration and which will show in 1966, when the figures are produced, a reduction for the first time in the gross national product.

There has been the behaviour of Fianna Fáil in the wasting of industrial grants. The Minister for Transport and Power never ceases to defend this and to say that in times of great prosperity the number of bankruptcies in the city of New York was phenomenal, and all this sort of thing. There is no use in a factory that never opened, that got this grant and drew the grant. There is only one explanation for that. The explanation is that the capital funds they guaranteed to put in were not forthcoming. In the Minister's constituency, there is one that he brought into his town of Clones. He told every other Deputy, including members of his Party, to go away, that he was looking after it. The factory was never opened and the machinery for it is sitting on the floor, unopened, and has to be included in the liquidator's assessment and the Fianna Fáil contractor who built the factory is back with Deputy Dillon to know if he can get his money taken out of the assessment and if he can get 20/- in the £. And, of course, he has no hope of that. The Frenchman who supplied the machinery which is now sitting on the floor of that factory is as much entitled to his shillings in the pound as the Fianna Fáil contractor.

There is no excuse for that. That grant was given on the basis that a capital investment would be forthcoming from the people coming in but you should ask first to see the colour of their money. If any Deputy or any other Irishman went to any financial institution and put up a proposal like that to them, he would first be asked to show the colour of his money. There have been too many of these things and that is one of the reasons why there has been such a wastage of capital which is not now available for meritworthy undertakings. This should have reflected itself in the by-elections. Even the dogs in the streets of Dublin will tell you that it is not "what you know but whom you know" that matters when you go to look for one of these grants.

I want now to refer to the by-elections and to take grave exception to actions by two industrial firms, one in my own constituency which will not gain me any votes, and one in Waterford. I take the greatest possible exception to businessmen on boards bringing a politician on to their boards three or four days before a by-election. That is an indication to the voters that certain members of that board want to swing the scale in the by-elections in a certain way. The ordinary decencies and differences between politics and business in this country should have been observed on this occasion. It was quite wrong that the ex-Taoiseach should have been made a director of the Waterford Glass Company a few days before the election and also a director of GEC, now the Electrical Company of Ireland.

It has been said, and it has not been denied, that in these two by-elections the Government's majority was not a majority over all comers and that it was reduced to a minute size when compared with the figures in the general election and the Presidential election. The Government went back with a very reduced majority. They were, in the first instance, extremely lucky to find themselves with by-elections in constituencies where that majority was possible.

Now, I want to discuss briefly the use of proportional representation in these elections. Proportional representation was fought for by every Party in this House, with the exception of Fianna Fáil. The position then was that, if proportional representation were not retained, Fianna Fáil would have become the Government for perhaps 20 years, Fine Gael would have gone back with a reduced number of Deputies and the Labour Party would have been decimated.

Comment on this

That is an extraordinary confession.

Comment on this

You would have had the fixing of the constituencies. You have already fixed my own constituency so that there cannot be a second Fine Gael man, and if you got your chance without proportional representation, you would make sure that you had three Deputies in Louth. If Fianna Fáil had got rid of PR, they would have installed themselves in power for a considerable number of years and would have decimated the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Everybody is very concerned about the Labour Party. We can look after ourselves.

Comment on this

I am going to deal with your position in this.

Comment on this

Do not tell me that you are falling out.

Comment on this

Not at all. In no constituency at present is a Labour Party Deputy elected with an overall majority of votes, with more than 50 per cent of the votes. If these constituencies were to be divided into smaller areas, the result would be that, with the possible exception of the Leader of the Labour Party or Deputy Seán Dunne, who might get 51 per cent of the votes, there would not be any Labour Deputy elected to the Dáil.

Comment on this

That is cod.

Comment on this

Look up your mathematics.

Comment on this

I am interested in your concern for the Labour Party.

Comment on this

I am very concerned for the Labour Party. It will be a bad thing if they are wiped out. The position as a result of the by-elections in Waterford and South Kerry is that two Fianna Fáil Deputies were returned here by the people who did not use PR.

Comment on this

How many of yours did not use PR?

Comment on this

Far less than yours.

Comment on this

Did you count them?

Comment on this

I did, and I will send for the figures if you want them. They were far less than yours. The Labour Party supporters in these two constituencies who did not use PR elected two Fianna Fáil Deputies. They were told by certain Labour Deputies to do so. I heard the candidate in Waterford say that, if he was in front of the Fine Gael candidate, he was certain to be elected but, if Fine Gael were in front of him, there was no hope of it. Deputy O'Leary, on the night before the poll, made somewhat the same statement in Waterford and Deputies McAuliffe and Coughlan made the same statement.

Comment on this
Mr. O'Leary

There is no difference between you and the gentleman opposite.

Comment on this

This is exactly what I want to hear. I am going to define that difference and I am going to suggest that the non-usage of PR will reduce the number of Labour Deputies in this House.

Comment on this

This is a most unseemly quarrel.

Comment on this

It is a one-sided quarrel.

Comment on this

I want to remark on the position of the Labour supporter in Waterford or Kerry if he had done his homework and decided to whom he should give his second preference vote. I want to quote from the proposals in the amendment of the Industrial Relations Act and the Trade Union Act which have been brought forward by a Fianna Fáil Government. I also want to refer to the September issue of Trade Union Viewpoint, on page 6 of which there is a heading “Minister's Proposals for Trade Unions Rejected”. That quotation refers to sections 41 and 42 of the legislation referred to. Section 41 says that the granting of a negotiating licence will be at the discretion of the Minister and that it will only be granted following consultation with the appropriate representative organisation. Section 42 states that a negotiating licence can be cancelled by the Minister if a request is made by an appropriate representative body or following consultation with such a body. These two provisos are repugnant to the trade unions and repugnant also presumably to the Labour Party.

Point 4 of the Cabinet's proposals: the Chairman and deputies, or deputy —here I am speaking of the members of the Court—will be appointed by the Minister. That proposal is also repugnant to both the Labour Party and the trade unions, if I read my politics aright.

Paragraph 5: the Minister will appoint the persons of his choice to be members of the Court after consultation with the members of the representative bodies. That also is repugnant to the Labour Party and to the trade unions.

I want now to turn to another matter. Would it be a better situation if there were a contract of service, with pension rights and severance payment in the event of disemployment in the industry concerned? This contract of service would be agreed with the Labour Court, the trade unions and the employer. In the event of an industrial dispute, the workers, through their union, would first have recourse to the Court for a period of 70 days and, if they did not, they would break their contract of service.

The tragedy of the two by-elections is that the people were not told that the proposals for new trade union law, adumbrated by Fianna Fáil and soon to be introduced, are repugnant to the Labour Party and to the trade union movement. Had they been told that, the two by-elections would have resulted in a different verdict; we would have had either two Fine Gael Deputies, or one Fine Gael Deputy and one Labour Deputy walking down those steps. It is about time that certain people stopped this idea of throwing a phrase like "Going it alone" to this House when they know that that will not be practicable for 20 years and that the only place one can "go it alone" is to the bottom of the poll.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I have come here tonight to say what I think. The Press Gallery has always been extremely kind to me but there were articles in the Irish Times and the Irish Independent two days before the election suggesting a Labour majority would ensue in both Waterford and Kerry. Nothing could have been further from the truth. Secondly, those articles did enormous damage to the Fine Gael effort in trying to get this Government to go to the people and give them the opportunity of deciding. I do not want to go any further than that.

Comment on this

Shame on the Deputy.

Comment on this

It is significant, and I do not mind who in this House is at my throat, that when I was in a position to produce the Government proposals in relation to proposed trade union law and the Fine Gael proposals, I nearly cleared the House of the Labour Party when, on the day of the election, more than half of them were here instead of in Waterford and Kerry.

Comment on this

The Labour Party let down Fine Gael.

Comment on this

They let themselves down because the Fine Gael proposals were much nearer to what they would desire than anything Fianna Fáil were putting up.

Comment on this

Tell the truth.

Comment on this

When this trade union law is produced, irrevocably Fianna Fáil will move one way and Labour and Fine Gael another.

Comment on this

That will be nothing new.

Comment on this

That will be the day of decision, the decision that should have been made in Waterford and Kerry.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Let me clarify the position. On the ESB Bill, we voted for an amendment proposing that for six months the matter be delayed. The reason was that we did not want to see people die because they had not electricity. In relation to any essential service we are prepared to vote with anybody to ensure that that service is continued while negotiations proceed.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy tell the people that in Waterford and Kerry?

Comment on this

That is Fine Gael industrial policy and Fine Gael are as near to Labour as anybody representing the people of this country could go because we are democratic. We are far nearer to Labour but they do not realise it.

Comment on this

Did the Deputy tell the people that in Waterford and Kerry?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

And they gave the Deputy his answer.

Comment on this

I said it on every platform on which I stood: Vote No. 1, Fine Gael and, No. 2, Labour. I gave my reasons. The Labour Party were going it alone. We were going it alone. I repeat—I said this on every platform in Waterford—"If you vote No. 1 Labour, I respectfully ask you for your No. 2 vote" and, if they had done that, the Government would be on the hustings tonight. Deputies may laugh but they know that what I say is true. That is the kernel of the matter.

Comment on this

And the story of Killarney Town Hall would be quite different.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

People who are elected to this House should say what they think. I think everything I have said tonight. I believe it passionately and therefore I have said it passionately. That is my right, just as it is the right of every other Deputy to disagree with me, if he wishes.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is sitting happy with his overall majority. The people in Waterford and Kerry gave the Government a minority.

Comment on this

We won the elections.

Comment on this

People wrongly instructed failed to use proportional representation.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

My examination and analysis of the situation will be found to be correct in the cold print of the Official Report. The Taoiseach told us this morning that he had had a meeting with the National Farmers Association. He did not say when he will have another one. He did not say that he had refused to have several. I want to define some of the things in this dispute. Before ever the farmers started from Cork to walk to Dublin, the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Haughey, had broken off negotiations with the NFA because of a speech made by Mr. Deasy, a speech which was critical of the Government and the Minister. Now Ministers should be able to take criticism. When the farmers started to walk from Cork, there was every opportunity for the Minister to make his peace, but, long before they arrived in Merrion Street, he had decided he would not see them. He came back from Europe and he suggested, fraudulently, that we were getting 2,000 head of cattle into Germany. That application from Germany to the Common Market headquarters for permission to let them in has not yet been granted.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary knows it backwards because he asked a question with which I shall deal later. With regard to Germany, the position is that it is highly unlikely, 90 per cent unlikely, that we will ever send any cattle there until there is a loosening generally of imports into the Common Market. The reason the Parliamentary Secretary knows that the cattle will get into Italy is that they are a different sort of cattle, young store cattle which are being brought there to be fattened, and therefore this is under a different heading. He knows as well as I do that the Minister for Agriculture came in here and told an untruth, and I will go no further than that because I am not allowed. However, it is an example of the completely double-faced attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party.

This is the man who on the first day he was Minister for Finance walked in for a Supplementary Estimate and when asked what it was for, said it was for the late President Kennedy's visit here. He had not read the first line of his brief. It was for our President's visit to America. Where are we going when a man who can transfer from one major Ministry to another major Ministry is prepared to come here and produce an untruth which is now well known to the Parliamentary Secretary? He rose to the fly like the best fish that ever rose to my bait when he said we will get them into Italy. He knows that the Minister for Finance came in and tried to pull the wool over the eyes of a few farmers for the by-elections.

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

There was a 29.6 per cent drop in wheat, notwithstanding the increase of 10/- per barrel. They could not believe in him and that is why they had to move him.

Comment on this

It was a bad spring.

Comment on this

Because the heifer scheme has been such a gambler's joy, there are 33,000 fewer in-calf heifers in the June census——

Comment on this

There are more cattle than ever.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The gangsters and the gamblers jumped in and now they have jumped out, having collected some £7 million of capital moneys that could have been well used for other purposes. However, we will leave aside any mistakes that were made by the Government or the NFA——

Comment on this

Or the Labour Party.

Comment on this

We will leave aside all these. It is grand to smile today but let Deputy Dunne remember what they are smiling at. They are smiling at who sent the two boys down the steps. We will get back to this question of the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

It is against Standing Orders to smile or laugh. I was put out for doing that.

Comment on this

They do not like this sort of stuff at all. I hope to go to the replay between Dundalk and Drumcondra, so they will be spared some of it. I want to talk about whether or not the people believe in the Minister for Agriculture and to get back to this question of the 2,000 cattle. I want also to raise the question of whether or not the Minister for Agriculture played the slick chick and codded the farmers' association at the time of the rates campaign and whether or not that was the start of the animosity. I suggest that now the NFA, the ICMSA and all the other kindred organisations, ranging from the trade unions to farmers' organisations and businessmen's organisations, may watch out for what has always been shown in time of victory, the arrogance of Fianna Fáil. These associations are now going to have their noses rubbed in the dirt. One of the ways in which Fianna Fáil will put themselves out, because they will put themselves out, will be by being too arrogant. If I were to give them advice, it would be that they should go easy.

Comment on this