We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Debate on Adjournment (Christmas Recess) (Resumed).

Contributions 169–371 of 556. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Thank you very much.

Comment on this

But there is no hope of Ministers of the calibre of the Minister for Health and the Minister for Justice and of the Minister for Finance going easily. The night of the long knives——

Comment on this

The Deputy left out the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

I am deeply grateful to Deputy Harte for including perhaps the best of them all, depending on how you look on the word "best". However, the position is that the night of the long knives is not so long away. and when we are talking about Waterford and Kerry, let us remember the night when during a Division, we saw what I considered the most undignified performance I have ever witnessed anywhere: the Minister for Education, then Minister for Health, openly canvassing every Fianna Fáil Deputy, as he came in through the door, for Deputy Haughey. Where are we going in this sovereign parliament? Is this thing to be decided on the basis of canvassing by a few men? What about this undignified bullrush home from America? Afterwards the Minister for Industry and Commerce told us that his trip cost £572. I thought then of the signs we saw during the war: "Is your journey really necessary?"

Comment on this

I missed that.

Comment on this

Yes, that is what it cost. The undignified attitude of the Government and the place-seeking, the scramble for power and the ratrace——

Comment on this

You never lose hope.

Comment on this

For the benefit of the Parliamentary Secretary, the definition of a rat-race is very simple. A rat when racing will run across the dead bodies of his own to escape. That is the definition.

Comment on this

Where are the dead bodies in this?

Comment on this

There are a few around.

Comment on this

There are two dead bodies in Waterford and two in Kerry.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley, is one. I can never make up my mind whether Deputy Blaney, the Minister for Agriculture, was just a front runner or not, but there are a few dead bodies if you want them. I want to suggest now that they are going to split wide open.

Comment on this

You are not in Killarney Town Hall now.

Comment on this

Order.

Comment on this

The point I am making is that these ambitious men will not stay as they always did. I always think that Deputy Dr. Hillery as Minister for Industry and Commerce was guilty of one of the greatest gaffes a Minister for Industry and Commerce was ever guilty of when, in face of increases in wages of £1 a week, he gave increases to all the brewers and purveyors of liquor—like myself, because I am a purveyor of liquor at home—and excluded one, with the result that he had to step down in the most undignified way and everything was patched up in a month. The Minister for Agriculture has given 10/- extra for wheat but the price of foreign wheat has gone up by £3 a ton. I am going to say something that politically is not "with it" which will not win me any votes. It is indisputable that the end result will be an increase in the price of flour. The amount of wheat that is stored by the mills is generally taken to be two months' supply. In other words, if there was a wet harvest, they had last year's wheat to carry them on, dried and in proper condition. Now, all that wheat is gone and at present the Minister for Industry and Commerce is telling people, whether rich or poor does not matter, in the case of some firms to take a £1,000 note every day, drop it in the Liffey and watch it float out to the Kish.

How are we to get industrial expansion and some sort of useful relationship between the Minister and Department of Industry and Commerce and business, if that sort of thing goes on? They have been asking for an interview for six solid weeks. The remainder of last year's wheat at the low price is gone and they now have to use this year's wheat at a high price. I am not flogging their case: I am just setting out the situation.

Everybody knows that for the past six months almost every article they buy, with the exception of universal items such as a box of matches or something that can be identified by one brand or one maker and which is similar all over the country and that can be pinned down, has increased in price. Take the purveyors of liquor. All drink prices have gone up more than was allowed. Take articles of drapery, clothing and shoes, children's shoes. They have all gone up and there has not been any prosecution. Now, the Minister for Industry and Commerce decides on this stupid action. It is as clear as crystal to me that this day three months the prices of flour and bread will be up and this is nothing but a political gimmick to suggest that Fianna Fáil kept them down.

I think I have talked long enough and I am sure others agree with me on that. I have been very free in what I said and I believe every word of it.

Comment on this

The Labour Party are very angry with you.

Comment on this

I had hoped that, having expended all their wind in the past few weeks in Kerry and Waterford, Deputies opposite would find something better to do today than come here to tell us about the speeches they should have made but did not make in Kerry and Waterford. We had the final exposition from Deputy Donegan of how he would have won the election. He was down there, I believe——

Comment on this

I was not too far from yourself.

Comment on this

I can tell the Deputy that we selected the right Taoiseach and we got the result in the two by-elections. Deputy Donegan was selected as shadow Minister for Agriculture by Deputy Dillon when Deputy Dillon was a shadow Taoiseach. He lost that job. He is not shadow Minister for Agriculture now. He was moved out of that job for his activities, the assistance he gave the Irish people in selling Irish exports. We do a big trade in the export of milk and milk products and Deputy Donegan's contribution to their sale was to say that 75 per cent of the farmers' milk going to the creameries was unfit for processing because it was too dirty. That was his contribution to the export of our milk and butter products.

Comment on this

That is not exactly what he said.

Comment on this

Exactly, word for word. The Deputy should stop interrupting and mind his three heads of cabbage and puck goat up in Donegal and stick to them.

Comment on this

I do not know where the Deputy gets the three heads of cabbage.

Comment on this

If the Deputy cannot conduct himself, put some whiskey in that jar and give it to him. I am dealing in facts and that was Deputy Donegan's contribution to the export of our milk products.

Comment on this

He never said that!

Comment on this

His contribution was to say that 75 per cent of the milk that goes into the creameries from the farmers was too dirty for processing.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

What did he say?

Comment on this

Deputy Donegan now comes along and—God help Deputy Cluskey when he starts—will be in charge of trade unions. I suppose he will be the new shadow Minister for Labour if he succeeds in joining them together.

Comment on this

The Deputy is as wrong in that as he was in his previous remarks.

Comment on this

He went a long way in this because he went on to deal with proportional representation and the wiping out of the Labour Party if proportional representation was not there.

Comment on this

He made some exceptions.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry is in possession.

Comment on this

That was his statement here tonight—that the Labour Party would be wiped out——

Comment on this

But is Deputy Corry not elected on proportional representation?

Comment on this

——in single seat constituencies. I am in favour of single seat constituencies because, in my opinion, you get a much better Deputy from such a constituency than from a constituency of five or six where two or three can dodge and do nothing, leaving all the work to the others.

Comment on this

There is something in what you say.

Comment on this

In my constituency, the Labour Deputy is Deputy McAuliffe. I believe that if it were a single seat constituency, he would always be returned because he has worked. I would say the same thing for West Cork about my colleague, Deputy Mrs. Desmond. In any constituency in Cork county, the Deputies would be re-elected if they were single seat constituencies because they are workers and have worked for their people. They are not like the pack of drones over there, God between me and harm. I am judging on what I know and what I have seen built up. I saw the late Deputy Desmond build up that constituency and build a Labour seat in it, and I was proud and glad to see him do it.

Then we had Deputy Barrett telling us about unemployment as Deputy Donegan did. I am only dealing with their contributions. I wonder when Deputy Barrett went to Kerry did he inform them that he had advocated here the closing of an industry and the disemployment or throwing on the roadside of 800 workers from his constituency?

Comment on this

That again is not true.

Comment on this

That is the constituency in which your pal said in his election address he was going to close down Verolme Dockyard and all other extravagances of that kind.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Four Cork Deputies apologised for its existence.

Comment on this

The people who like to come in here to talk about the number of unemployed under the Fianna Fáil Government are the people who stood up in this House deliberately and endeavoured to sabotage that industry which is giving employment to over 1,000 young men.

Comment on this

There is not a word of truth in that.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Dillon talking about housing. Why are houses needed in this country today? They are needed because Deputy Seán Lemass initiated the policy of industrialising this country. When I came here first, the total employment then being given by the Cumann na nGaedheal Government in Cobh was three weeks' work each year to six men to go over to Haulbowline and lift there a certain amount of machinery for the scrap heap to be sold by public auction. That was the total employment in the town of Cobh when I came in here. If anybody goes to the bother of looking up the records of this House for November, 1928, he will find that the then Cumann na nGaedheal Deputy for the constituency, Deputy Hennessy, moved in this House that a 25 per cent subsidy be given to every worker in Rushbrooke Dockyard to keep them in employment there. It was turned down, of course, by his brothers in arms and the dockyard closed. It remained closed for many a long year. I saw every scrap of machinery that was there being taken out and sold by public auction. That is the site where today there are 1,000 young men going to work, and those people over there endeavour to sabotage that industry. Let me go back now to 1932 when the Fianna Fáil Government first took over here. At that time the total employment in the town of Midleton was 20 men working three days a week in the flour mills.

Comment on this

What did the Deputy tell the farmers to do with their livestock? I have read his speeches.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy going to do with his puck goat?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Harte does not cease interrupting, I shall have to ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

I am merely asking Deputy Corry——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order.

Comment on this

I am giving the position of my constituency as I find it, combined with the efforts of some gentlemen to prevent employment being given there.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why do you not build a few houses in Cobh?

Comment on this

There have been 180 houses built by Cork County Council around the borough area of Cobh and there have been 110 more houses built by Cobh Urban Council. The reason there are over 300 houses required in that town today is that there are young men there who are in employment and who previously had no outlet but the emigrant ship.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Young men living in appalling conditions.

Comment on this

The young men you tried to hunt out of Rushbrooke.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): In appalling conditions.

Comment on this

Appalling conditions, at £25 a week. These houses had to be built because those young men, instead of having to face the emigrant ship, found there was employment now for them at home and that they could get married and settle down under a Fianna Fáil Government, in the knowledge that that employment was going to continue.

Comment on this

What happened Potez?

Comment on this

The Deputy ought to mind the three heads of cabbage and the puck goat. If it eats the three heads of cabbage, he will have to sell it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is getting my constituency mixed up with that of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle. He is misinformed.

Comment on this

That was the position in connection with housing and that is the reason we want houses in the country today.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When are you going to build them?

Comment on this

That is first in the order of priorities. Those young men, having now, thanks to Deputy Seán Lemass and the Fianna Fáil Government, secured constant employment, are now entitled to a decent home in which to live. They are going to get that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When?

Comment on this

Not by the policy you adopted when you formed a mixum-gatherum Government twice and ran out. I heard Deputy Donegan talking this evening about the contracts that were put back. You did not put them back, but you did not pay. You ran out and left the bills after you. You had 11 of a majority in this House the last time, but you did not last the full three years even of the five. By jove, there was not even a Jewman to give you twopence.

Comment on this

That was the biggest mistake that ever happened.

Comment on this

We remained here. Your colleague, Deputy O'Higgins, had a straight fight in the whole Republic and he was beaten.

Comment on this

That was not politics.

Comment on this

I thought, from all the shouting we heard here about threats to move writs, we would see somebody coming in over there. Labour know you too well. They had experience of you before. The last time they had experience of the mixum-gatherum team over there, they said the old man was right when he declared: "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me." When the Labour Party were fooled a second time, they were not going to have any more of it.

I had hoped for better things from Labour in the by-election. I hoped Labour would at least come second. In fact, I was nearly prepared to concede them the seat in the two by-elections in the hope that they would go over across there and form some kind of opposition, for I am tired of being in Opposition myself. I have to do it when the official Opposition in this House will not do it.

Comment on this

No doubt, you are an all-round man.

Comment on this

We heard a lot of talk from Deputy Cluskey. It would have been a good job for the Labour Party if they had kept Deputy Cluskey at home in the recent by-elections. That is honest and above board. I do not think he would appeal to any countryman. I know what is wrong with him. The poor man is shivering and shaking, morning, noon and night, for fear he will lose his job. If he cannot keep up the row between employer and worker, he fears he will no longer be needed as a trade union official.

Comment on this

That is typical of the thinking of a Fianna Fáil Deputy.

Comment on this

That is what is wrong with him. I have a kind of sympathy for him, although it is no good having sympathy for him now. Deputy Cluskey went down to Kerry and the trade union hours were so imprinted on his mind that he stopped canvassing at 5 o'clock every evening and worked only a five-day week while all the other boys were working 8½ hours.

Comment on this

The other fellows were slaves.

Comment on this

That is what happened Labour in the by-election. You cannot bring in trade union hours and have them so imprinted on your mind that you will not work after them.

The gap between the agricultural worker and the industrial worker is widening every day. That is unfortunate. If the agricultural worker, be he small farmer or labourer, were to impose a five-day week—as he would be perfectly entitled to do, seeing that nobody else is going to work any longer hours—and you have to pay overtime for the milking and feeding of the cows on Saturdays and Sundays, I wonder what would the price of milk be. I was not surprised when I saw Deputy Donegan's friends—the boys with the dirty milk, as he called them, the ICMSA—walking up and down outside here. They are ordinary working farmers. I am drawing a very wide distinction. I met them out there. Some of them were comrades of mine who fought with me during the Tan War. They were up there with their medals on their coats, having to walk up and down for their rights.

Comment on this

And you put them in jail.

Comment on this

If there are to be trade union hours in this country, if there is to be the 40-hour week and no work on Sunday unless they are paid overtime for it, then let that apply to the rural community as well as the cities and towns. Let us have a levelling up in prices.

When I was so rudely interrupted by those chatterboxes over there, I was comparing the position in which I found my constituency when I first took it over 39 years ago with its position today. In the town of Cobh, there are 600 working in Irish Steel and about 1,000 working in the industry that Deputy Fitzpatrick was going to close in his election address. That is 1,600 men working where only six were working under the Cumann na nGaedheal regime.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): How many thousands did you put out of work in Ford's in 1932? Eight thousand.

Comment on this

We brought Ford's there, lad. In your election address, you guaranteed your constituents that you would close Rushbrooke Dockyard. You closed Rushbrooke Dockyard. I will tell you that it shook the toenails out of your brothers in arms who were candidates in the constituency. I have Deputy Fitzpatrick's election address in which he declared that the policy of his Party was to close Verolme Dockyard. He did not care what harm he was doing to his brothers down in the constituency when he was publishing that above in Cavan but these are the things that count. It was just the same as when Deputy Barrett was seen below in Kerry during the by-election: you could hear a whisper going around among the boys: "Is that the fellow that was closing Verolme Dockyard and going to throw 800 out on the road?" These are the kinds of things that count in the election and these are the things that got you out. But you cannot be up here preaching and telling us the speeches you were going to make below but were afraid to make.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You had a football match there, not an election campaign.

Comment on this

The next place I will come to is the town of Midleton. In the town of Midleton today, there are at least 1,500 people employed between the wireless factory, the distillery and our little job above in the processing factory. I will tell you one thing honestly, that is, that none of the farmers there could spare a day to sit on the steps. The farmers there are working farmers. Three years ago, we started a little processing industry there. Our total the first year was 270 acres of vegetables processed; last year we had 750 acres. I have just finished putting in proposals to An Foras Tionscal under which we will be processing 1,400 acres next year and, to prove that my farmers are prepared to do it, I have applications at present lying in the factory offices for 2,400 acres of vegetables. That will prove to you that, as far as the farmer is concerned, if you give him a market, he will produce.

Comment on this

Quite right.

Comment on this

If you have not these industries going in other constituencies, well, if you had single-seat constituencies, you would have them because you would get rid of most of the drones after two elections. But that is what is wrong.

Last year, we employed roughly 80 in that factory. We paid £47,000 in wages and we paid £75,000 to the farmers for producing crops. That is a good turnover in one year. Next year, please God, we shall have 200 working in the factory and we will be paying the farmers about £150,000. That is employment; that is building up a country. That is building it up without bringing in the foreigner to import the raw material and sell out. This raw material is growing on our own land. It is produced by our working farmers. When I say that I signed cheques for some of those farmers for as high as £220 an acre for carrots and somewhere around £200 an acre for French beans, it will give you an idea of what can be done even with the small farmer if he has somebody who will not lie down on him but will help him out and find a market for his produce and give him a job. These are facts.

I was absent here for a couple of hours today because I had to go over to Foras Tionscal to lodge an application for a further grant. Within the next two years, we shall have the full 2,400 acres under vegetables there and our farmers in that little patch of this country will be drawing an income of roughly £500,000 a year. These are facts and they are so strong that they cannot be contradicted. The proof is there. If any Deputy doubts me, he can come down and I will take great pleasure in showing him over. I will even do what I did with Deputy Fitzpatrick: I will give him a glass of grog at the end of it, the same as he got in Rushbrooke from Verolme. That is the way to build up a country. That is the reason why, when you went down to the small farmers and the workers of Kerry, you had a Fianna Fáil representative coming back here.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Without a quota.

Comment on this

Where was your quota? I thought, with all the clacking made by you and when you got the few farmers to sit on the steps on the day of the election, and for two days before it, you were going to pull something out of the bag, but even that would not help you. These are facts. That is why you remain over there in fewer numbers every year until perhaps Labour will take over from you and you will be smaller still. That is the reason. I saw poor Deputy Donegan there and he nearly went out of his wits complaining because Labour did not give their No. 2 vote to Fine Gael.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): To anybody.

Comment on this

What reason would they have to give Fine Gael their No. 2 vote? Can anybody over there give me a sound reason why any worker in the Verolme Dockyard would give a No. 2 vote to Deputy Fitzpatrick who was going to deprive them of employment or to Deputy Donegan who endeavoured to sabotage our exports of milk products?

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Why should they do it? They saw, before Fianna Fáil came in here, before Deputy Seán Lemass started his industrial policy here, the outlook that was before them. You had the farmer who looked at his son when he came to 14 years of age and said: "Mike, you will have to go next year to England or some place where you will get a day's work".

Comment on this

Now they are going at the age of 12. Whole families are going.

Comment on this

The leopard never changes his spots and that is true as far as you are concerned. I saw that tried out. That was the condition of affairs that obtained then. Now, if a man is rearing a family, he can look around at his children and say: "Thank God, they will get a job in Rushbrooke and Verolme in spite of Deputy Fitzpatrick. They will get a job in Irish Steel, in spite of the activities of the inter-Party Government who had reduced employment there to fewer than 400 men when Deputy Seán Lemass took over again." They will get employment in those places and, if they do not have enough of employment there for them, I will have new industries ready to put them into.

Comment on this

Good. The wrong man is leading that Party. Deputy Corry should have been selected as Taoiseach.

Comment on this

If the Deputy will come down, I will show him where I put his three heads of cabbage.

Comment on this

The tomahawk is out again.

Comment on this

I suppose what happened to you was that if you took the puck goat to Kerry he might be taken down.

Comment on this

Or Killorglin.

Comment on this

I am sure he has a bigger whisker on him than the fellow you have there. That is where you made a mistake. If I had a puck goat like that, I would take him down and would not be making a noise about the price of livestock. I would shut my mouth. They have kept me here and I cannot go home tonight, and I might as well amuse myself here with them as anywhere else. I had honestly hoped that, having got the results of the two by-elections, they would have folded their tents and gone home in peace for Christmas. Instead, Deputy Donegan came in here to tell us how he would win the by-election. He would take these labour trade unionists and he would make them vote No. 2 for the Fine Gael candidate. He told us so tonight. He would be trotting two Fine Gael men down here and you could be looking at them and shaking the boys' hands. Frankly, I was disappointed that Labour did not get their rightful place in the by-elections. Their rightful place was second.

Comment on this

You are putting Fine Gael first?

Comment on this

No. You could not put your puck goat anywhere else. I heard you were down around Dingle with him.

Comment on this

No; I was in Valentia with the Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this

Do not come moaning here about the price of livestock when all of you have to sell is a puck goat.

Comment on this

Do not talk about livestock. I read the speeches made by Deputy Corry in 1932 on the subject of livestock. Deputy Belton and I spent a couple of hours reading them.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I wonder could Deputy Harte cease talking for a few moments and allow Deputy Corry to make his speech?

Comment on this

To continue his intelligent contribution to the proceedings of the House.

Comment on this

I am far more intelligent than the Deputy.

Comment on this

I am sure you are, but display it.

Comment on this

That is why I am here so long. I am afraid I will lose the Deputy next time. I would not like to. When they talk here about the rumpus in the Fianna Fáil ranks in regard to the election of the Taoiseach, may I ask Fine Gael why did they drive Deputy Dillon out? Why was Deputy Dillon condemned by the Fine Gael Party and ordered out of that Party in the height of a crisis in the country? Why was he ordered out?

Comment on this

Just for the record, that is not so and Deputy Corry knows it is not so. Deputy Corry knows that he is saying something that is not accurate.

Comment on this

Why——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Corry cease for a moment? Deputy O'Higgins may not make a remark along those lines. He will have to withdraw the remark that Deputy Corry is speaking an untruth and that he knows it.

Comment on this

I did not say that he was speaking an untruth. I said he was inaccurate.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And that he knew it.

Comment on this

He knows it because I told it to him.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy did not say it, there is no need to withdraw.

Comment on this

I said it was inaccurate and the Deputy knows it is inaccurate.

Comment on this

I am prepared to produce for the information of Deputy O'Higgins the records of this House to prove what I am saying——

Comment on this

Please do so.

Comment on this

——that Deputy Dillon left the Fine Gael Party.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

You said a minute ago that he was put out.

Comment on this

If these fellows said to me in the morning that I would have to get out, I suppose I would nearly have to go.

Comment on this

That would be our good luck.

Comment on this

He was afterwards taken back into the fold. He was tried out as Minister for Agriculture for a bit and as a result of his activities in that period, we had an illusion, which bears out my contention in regard to the agricultural community. Deputy Donegan told us about the £3 rise in the price of wheat. We had the same condition of affairs here when Deputy Dillon became Minister for Agriculture. Two years after we had made an agreement with the Irish Sugar Company that the price of beet would be paid on the cost of production plus a profit, after the coming in of the inter-Party Government, I went down to my colleagues to get that honoured for one year and I was met below with a letter signed by the then Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Agriculture, that the previous Government were far too generous to the farming community and on no account whatever would there be any increase in the price for beet in that year. That was followed up. There was a reduction of some 20,000 acres of beet that year. We had to import 75,000 tons of foreign sugar to meet that. That foreign sugar was imported at £12 a ton higher than the price of the best white sugar leaving our own factory. When I saw the imports and the price, I went to the then General Manager of the Sugar Company, General Costello, and I said: "We never fought in this country to have a foreign nigger getting £12 a ton more for his sugar than an Irish farmer".

Comment on this

What is a "nigger"?

Comment on this

He agreed with me.

Comment on this

What is a nigger?

Comment on this

In a woodpile.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I want to know how is this rubbish Deputy Corry is talking relevant to the motion we are discussing here?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Corry is now discussing facets of agriculture.

Comment on this

I do not think he should be allowed to describe people who are not of the same colour as people in this country as "niggers."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

"Niggers" is not a disorderly word.

Comment on this

It may not be, within the traditions of the House, but I think it is an objectionable word.

Comment on this

You would not like to be called a nigger.

Comment on this

I am giving a description of the manner in which those things were brought about and the result. As a result, the negotiating committee of the Beetgrowers Association met General Costello the following Monday morning. Although the contracts were signed in November we got from him an increase of 7/6 per ton in the price of beet for that year, to bring us in line with the price of the foreign sugar that was being imported.

We have Deputy Donegan complaining and wanting to know the position with regard to the price of wheat. They are now asking why we should import wheat when the price of foreign wheat has gone up by £3 per ton but it is the same with everything else that we are producing from the soil of Ireland. They condemn it. It is not good enough for the Irish people to eat. I heard the Minister for Agriculture they had say that he once had the pleasure of eating bread made from Irish wheat. He said that you took it in your hands and kneaded it and squeezed the water out of it and that then you decided whether it was boot polish or bread. If it was boots polish, you applied it to your boots and if it was bread, you ate it and tried to digest it. That is Deputy Dillon's description of bread made from Irish wheat and that is why they now come along and charge us with letting in foreign wheat because the Irish people are too civilised to eat the bread their fathers eat.

These are hard facts but they are there. The only time I saw these people anxious for wheat growing was during the war years. I saw them buying Irish wheat from 1914-1918. I ate bread in Crumlin Road jail in 1918 and the black culls of the oats were cocking up out of it. That is what we had to eat.

Comment on this

It did not do you any harm.

Comment on this

It did not do me any more harm than the hunger strike I had to do in Newbridge for my friends opposite. I am now 77 years of age and I am going to retire from this House in 1985.

Comment on this

Have we to put up with you for that length of time?

Comment on this

You can take a bet on it, and you will win. I firmly believe that before that time comes, I will see Deputy Coughlan as Finance Minister in this House.

Comment on this

I will make you Minister for Agriculture and you will do a job on it.

Comment on this

That is where they lost. If I were Minister for Agriculture, I would have the whole country as I have my own little constituency, plenty of employment and my farmers working and satisfied and not sitting on the steps. I do not understand why Deputies should take up the time of the Parliament set up by the people in shouting, wailing and moaning because they cannot accept the decision of the people. In the two by-elections the people told them they did not want them. Can they not take that for a month or two and perhaps some people will forget their defeat after Christmas? Until that time, I suggest that they go home quietly and peacefully. I would also say to my colleagues that those opposite are the people who want to keep them up all night. Let them keep the House if they want to. There is no occasion for us to keep it.

Comment on this

As the previous Deputy went back into the past, it is only right that we should go into the future and make submissions to the Taoiseach that he should go seriously to work and produce a positive programme that will prepare us for our entry into the Common Market. Deputy Corry has admitted that eventually the Labour Party will become the Government but surely the time is upon us now when we should prepare ourselves for entry to the Common Market. The time has come for us to give serious consideration to matters in the realm of local government and we will have to attempt to produce the goods in a far better fashion than has been done in the past couple of years.

In Dublin, the housing situation is still chronic. The emergency which was created three years ago as a result of houses falling is still in existence and some thousands of people are left in the position that no one can tell them when they are going to be accommodated. Recently Dublin Corporation found it necessary to conduct the exercise of setting about ascertaining from the people on their waiting list whether they were still interested in houses.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present.

Comment on this

It was not I who asked for a House and it is my understanding that it would not have been called for, were it not for the fact that Deputy Corry invited his colleagues to walk out. We are all conscious of the fact that this is the House of Parliament and the ruling Party are responsible for keeping a House.

Before the quorum was called for, I was adverting to the useful exercise undertaken recently by Dublin Corporation in trying to ascertain if those on the waiting list are still interested in houses. The result of that exercise has shown that the situation is as bad now as it ever was and there is very little hope of solving the problem for families of five and no hope of solving the problem for families of four. That is just not good enough and that situation must not be allowed to continue. I do not make this issue a political football, but public representatives in Dublin must now be fed up giving the stereotyped answer to those seeking housing accommodation. We still have families living in overcrowded conditions, whether it be in tenements or in corporation houses which they share with other members of the family. We still have people obliged to walk the streets because there is no housing accommodation for them. I entreat the Taoiseach to urge the responsible Minister to give this matter his serious consideration.

There has been a good deal of disappointment in relation to the much-vaunted Ballymun scheme. It was stated that these houses would be ready by a certain time but, so far, that certain time has failed to arrive. I appreciate that weather has had an adverse effect on building operations there. Nevertheless, the position today shows clearly that those charged with responsibility for the development of this estate were not right in their initial estimates. We had the assurance, too, that all services and amenities would be provided simultaneously with the erection of the houses. We have retreated a little from that ambition. These things must be tackled and tackled promptly.

As I said at the outset, we should be looking to the future. We are not concerned with who went with whom in 1922 and the years following. Our concern is to face the reality of today in relation to our commitments to the community. Bearing in mind our possible eventual entry into the European Economic Community, it is time something was done in relation to our social welfare benefits. I do not think it is wrong to advocate a graded system of benefits and a graded system of contributions. There is need for improvement in pensions. We know that such improvement will cost money, but, if we are to take our place in the European Economic Community and be as good as the other countries in that Community, we shall have to gear up our social welfare benefits. They are crying out for attention. Up to now there has been no positive plan from the Department of Social Welfare to show how this real problem should be tackled. I am satisfied there is a genuine desire, among workingclass people in particular, among all shades of political thought, for an improvement in benefits. They realise that, in order to obtain that improvement, money will have to be found.

While it is laudable to project improved health schemes, it is much more laudable to do something positive from the point of view of providing an adequate health scheme. Again, in this connection, we will have to be as good as the Member countries of the European Economic Community. At the moment we lag very far behind. Again, this will have to be paid for. The scheme announced by the former Minister shows some improvement. It has in it things this Party have been advocating repeatedly, as can be proved by our published programme. The question arises as to where the money will come from and we have not yet been told by the former Minister, by the present Minister, by the Minister for Finance or, indeed, by the Taoiseach, where the money will come from. We should be told and we should be in a position to examine the situation and see to what extent we can combine our interests.

With regard to education, I am aware that arrangements will be made to give every child attending a national school an opportunity of further education. No Party would have the impudence to fall out with that suggestion. We have not yet heard any statement of policy or been given any indication as to the extent to which the curriculum will be changed in the national schools. There is room for improvement in the curriculum. That is something which will have to be tackled if we are to equate our efforts in education with those of the other Member countries of the European Economic Community. It is pertinent, too, to inquire what the cost will be and in what way the Minister for Finance proposes to obtain the money to pay for this improvement. We are entitled to know to what extent the people will be levied in order to pay for this improved education. It is an important matter.

There is another matter the tackling of which is long overdue. I am thinking of the effects on some of our industries, if and when we go into the Common Market. It is wrong to say that our industries will not be affected; some of our industries will be affected and perhaps some will go to the wall. Up to the present we have had lip service paid to the idea of redundancy compensation. We have got to do something rapidly about this, otherwise we will find our labour force emigrating instead of remaining here for retraining and being compensated while being retrained. Repeatedly we hear that we will be in the Common Market by 1970 and surely it is about time that something positive was done about redundancy compensation.

This is an opportune time for the Taoiseach to consult with the Minister for Industry and Commerce and the Minister for Transport and Power in regard to the type of work our people are likely to be engaging in if we go into the Common Market. While some of our industries will go to the wall, some will undoubtedly improve. One industry which will improve, a very valuable industry, is the tourist industry. Bearing in mind that the tourist industry is a highly competitive one and that almost every nation has realised its value, it is imperative that we have a close look at the system of training staff for this industry. People formerly engaged in industries which go to the wall will have to be channelled into other types of employment and the tourist industry will provide an outlet for some of them. This will necessitate training and it is imperative that the Minister for Transport and Power, who has responsibility for tourism, should consult with the Minister for Education, and in turn, they should consult with the Minister for Finance, in regard to who is going to accept responsibility for the cost of training staff in order to ensure that this great asset will be secured, bearing in mind that it is highly competitive.

There are other matters about which one could speak in this debate, but as I said, I am not one for asking what others did over the years. The time has come to face realities and the difficulties which exist. The time has come for positive thinking and action. The time has gone when people can be asking: "Where were you or what did you do in the past?" The time has come for catching up in the fight for an existence and we must gear ourselves for the change to which we are committed. Whether that change is for good or ill, I will not say. Now is the time for producing a proper health scheme and for saying where the money is to come from. The same applies to social welfare, education and a scheme for redundancy. If we do this, we will have less recriminations and more positive action.

Comment on this

I wonder if it is right or wrong for me to claim a victory for the Fine Gael Party in the two by-elections? I should like to give my view of how the by-elections were won and lost and what the results mean. If the Government had postponed the elections until after Christmas, the wave of enthusiasm that had been so apparent for the first time in the past three or four years in the Fianna Fáil camp would have disappeared. That wave of enthusiasm was there for one reason and one reason only, that is, that the Party had a new Leader.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What was wrong with the new Leader?

Comment on this

I am not saying anything about the new Leader. This wave of enthusiasm within the Fianna Fáil ranks lasted from the day Deputy Lynch announced that he would accept the leadership until just past the date of the by-election.

Comment on this

We were split before that?

Comment on this

In every week that went by after Deputy Jack Lynch had accepted the leadership of the Party, the enthusiasm was getting less and less, so much so that the results of the Waterford by-election proves beyond all doubt that had the elections been fought another fortnight or three weeks later——

Comment on this

What about Kerry? A nail in the coffin.

Comment on this

If the Deputy from East Limerick will wait, I will deal with it.

Comment on this

The cheer leader for Fianna Fáil has arrived, the man who appears most in the Official Debates as the chief interrupter. The young boy——

Comment on this

The Deputy is misquoting what I said.

Comment on this

The Deputy who backed the wrong horse. He could have been driving around Kerry in a Mercedes.

Comment on this

Be very careful; Deputy Flanagan made his speech from the back benches the other night. You will be up there soon.

Comment on this

I could be better placed there. I want to give the Deputy some advice. If the Deputy had stood back, he would have been driving a Mercedes——

Comment on this

This is a very illuminating speech.

Comment on this

I am corrected by a colleague. The Deputy would not have had to drive himself; he would have had a driver, or perhaps two drivers.

Comment on this

If I were tired, I might drive myself.

Comment on this

I was saying that the result of the Waterford by-election indicates to me the growing support for the Fine Gael Party, and if the election had been postponed for a fortnight at least, the Fianna Fáil Party would have been defeated.

Comment on this

You are not in Killarney Town Hall now. Sit back and listen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Harte is entitled to make his speech without interruption.

Comment on this

He should address the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is part of my problem. Deputies should allow him speak. If they want to make statements themselves, there is still time for them to do so.

Comment on this

I was pointing out in regard to the result of the Kerry by-election the importance the Fianna Fáil Party placed on winning it when they had no fewer than 11 Ministers there for a fortnight. They considered it more important to canvass votes than to run their Departments. The Minister for Agriculture was talking about building a bridge at Valentia while farmers were sitting at his door step.

Comment on this

They are so fond of sitting down that it is a pity to put them off it.

Comment on this

We know the difficulties Deputy Molloy had in Dingle.

Comment on this

Do you want to hear about that? Stink bombs and the lot— you threw the lot.

Comment on this

It would have been more pleasant for the Deputy if he had backed the right man for Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The result of the by-election can be discussed in too much detail for the liking of the Chair. There are many other matters that may, more relevantly, be discussed.

Comment on this

Before the Ceann Comhairle came in, I was making a brief reference to them.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

And I shall assume the Deputy has concluded his reference to them.

Comment on this

I have, I should have concluded earlier except for the interruptions.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputies should allow Deputy Harte to proceed in his own way.

Comment on this

We thought he would be ashamed to mention the by-elections.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should show that in some other way.

Comment on this

There was no Fine Gael Deputy in Killarney when the election was won.

Comment on this

Before leaving the by-elections, let me say that about three years ago the Fianna Fáil Party won two by-elections and within six months, they lost a by-election. If they had the opportunity of selecting any constituencies in Ireland, they could not have picked two better ones for their purpose. They succeeded in getting two Deputies elected without reaching a quota. That is sufficient for the by-elections.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask Deputy Clohessy to restrain himself.

Comment on this

I apologise.

Comment on this

I should like to put it on record that I do not mind being interrupted by Deputy Clohessy——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy has now put it on the record.

Comment on this

——because Deputy Clohessy's name never appears on the records of this House——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That has nothing whatever to do with the motion.

Comment on this

He is not a bad example.

Comment on this

When the Minister for Transport and Power spoke this evening, he said that some of the difficulties of the Government in going into these two by-elections were beyond the Government's control. He instanced inflation and said one of the reasons for inflation was that it was the wish of the Irish people. May I suggest that one of the functions of the Government is to control inflation and that despite all attempts by the Fianna Fáil Government and the interParty Government or any government in a democratic society, inflation will take place? That is a natural development since we got away from the barter system. The problem of a Government is to control it and if it is controlled, natural inflation is not wrong, but when a Government openly admit and encourage it, that Government are failing in their duty.

Not so long ago I heard the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, make statements here. I read speeches he made at Fianna Fáil meetings in this city and throughout the country advocating inflation. He told us here that the Irish people should have a honeymoon—that was the term he used— and spend their money, that the proof of our prosperity was in the shops. We heard the Minister for Finance who was then Minister for Justice introducing a Bill increasing salaries from £4,500 to £6,000 per year. The reason he gave was that those people should share in the cake of prosperity. That was the green light for inflation. When the workers put forward their claims for increased wages, they were justified in doing so and were encouraged to do so by the Government. The present Minister for Finance gave them the green light early in 1963. That caused such a spiral of inflation and such an increase in the cost of living that we almost priced ourselves out of the foreign market.

Comment on this

Is this Fine Gael policy you are telling us about? You are only talking about history.

Comment on this

The Deputy has made mistakes.

Comment on this

Please God I shall make more. How can I learn otherwise?

Comment on this

If the Deputy had not made the vital mistake, he could have been down in the Front Benches.

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must insist that Deputy Harte be allowed to make his statement.

Comment on this

But he is looking for trouble.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The first interruption was made by Deputy Molloy.

Comment on this

Indeed, one reason why we were in such a serious financial position in the past few months is basically that the Government encouraged inflation. Then they bought themselves out of two by-elections by the ninth round increase. They purchased the votes. Within a few months, the workers who voted for them because they got more money in their pay packets discovered that they were able to buy less goods from the merchants. As one person in Donegal put it, he said he remembered the time when he sent the messenger to the shop with the bag for the groceries and the money in his pocket, whereas now he sends for the groceries with the money in the bag and the messenger can bring the groceries in his pocket. The rich were becoming richer and the poor poorer. People were begining to live in castles while others had no homes.

Deputy Lenihan does not agree with me but he will be the first to agree that there are more posh offices in this city and more money spent on office blocks, centrally heated and with fitted carpets than has been spent on local authority housing in the Twenty-Six Counties. I openly admit I was disappointed that the people of Waterford and Kerry did not reject this situation when they had the opportunity. The only reason I can put forward for it is that when the Minister for Agriculture was finished making his promises, they put him into the Department of Finance so that he could start making promises again; and, when the Minister for Local Government was finished with his blarney, they put him into the Department of Agriculture so that he could start promising again. He even went down to Valentia and promised a bridge that should have been built seven years ago. This is all psychology and that is what won the election.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy deal with some other aspect of the motion? He told me before that he was leaving that part of his statement.

Comment on this

I just remarked briefly on it. I feel it is wrong that a Government should spend so much money in this direction and encourage the spending of so much money in this direction when people in our society have to live in houses completely unfit for human habitation. Passing by an election platform in the past few weeks, I heard the Taoiseach make a statement that the Fianna Fáil Party drew their support from the poorer sections of our community.

Comment on this

We never reduced the old age pension.

Comment on this

No, but you promised and did not pay, which was worse.

Comment on this

You never gave them anything.

Comment on this

You promised and did not pay, inside the past 12 months.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said a great deal of their support was drawn from the poorer sections of the community. I saw industrialists from Dublin in their Mercedes cars, people who subscribe £1,000 or £5,000 a year to the Fianna Fáil Party, drawing the people out to support Fianna Fáil. The people were told the story: "Unless you vote for Fianna Fáil, you will lose your benefits." I wonder was the Taoiseach really sincere or am I misinterpreting what he said when I suggest he said: "We draw our support from the poorer sections of the community." They even send down Mercedes cars to bring them out.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is a method of dealing with interruptions, and the Chair will put it into operation, if Deputies insist on misconducting themselves.

Comment on this

There are four of them there now.

Comment on this

And three of them could be better placed somewhere else.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would the Deputy speak to the motion?

Comment on this

I as a young Deputy have seen a new Leader in the Fianna Fáil Party and I wonder, when the next general election takes place, whether in six months time or in 1969-70, as the former Taoiseach said, the new Leader will take the same attitude as the former Taoiseach did when he used the catchcries: "Let Lemass Lead On". "Do not change horses in mid-stream". "Do not put back the clock"—all these catch-phrases which were used to capture the imagination of the people. This is the psychology that the Fianna Fáil Party have mastered in an election campaign. I wonder will the present Taoiseach use these tactics or will he say, as Deputy John A. Costello said in 1957: "We have difficulties——

Comment on this

You ran out of Government.

Comment on this