We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Debate on Adjournment (Christmas Recess) (Resumed).

Contributions 372–556 of 556. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

"We have difficulties; we are going to the country." If he does that, he will have my word that the Leader of the Fine Gael Party will not, like the former Leader of Fianna Fáil, promise to create 100,000 new jobs. That kind of psychology is how Fianna Fáil won the elections.

Comment on this

You will be very lucky if you are elected at the next election.

Comment on this

That remains to be seen.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

You were not serious in the by-elections.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If Deputy Fanning insists on interrupting, I shall have to ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

I believe that had the present Government gone to the country, a completely different result would have been forthcoming. In regard to housebuilding, in the 17th Dáil we had a Minister for Local Government whose duty it was to build houses and he did not build them. In the 18th Dáil, the Taoiseach saw fit to appoint a Parliamentary Secretary to help him not to build them. I wonder what all the Parliamentary Secretaries are for? I have come to the conclusion that they are chief organisers when it comes to by-elections.

Like many Deputies, and indeed like many other people in the country, I feel obliged to refer to the system of election, namely, proportional representation, and I do not cast any reflection on Members of the Labour Party in this regard. In 1959, this subject was discussed and, by referendum the people decided to retain the system of proportional representation. I believe that the majority of the people who marked No. 1 on the ballot paper in the by-election and left it at that were people who supported proportional representation in the referendum. This is our system of election, and irrespective of whether it was their desire to vote for the Government candidate or the Fine Gael candidate, my advice to them is that it is their democratic right to use the transferable vote and they should have used it.

Comment on this

It is their democratic right also not to use it.

Comment on this

They were all Fianna Fáil anyway.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

That is what you thought—three to one. Grow up, you little——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow that remark.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

I will withdraw it, Sir.

Comment on this

I will not dispute with Deputy Corish that these people had the right to use their second preference votes or to abstain from doing so. But, when we have the system of proportional representation here, they should use their second preference votes.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy a question? Does he know how many "plumpers" there were in the papers of the Fine Gael candidates and the Fianna Fáil candidates?

Comment on this

I would answer that question by this. I said to the Fine Gael voters in Kerry for the brief time I was there——

Comment on this

The brief time.

Comment on this

A smart young boy like Deputy Molloy, with all the glory in his past——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please get to the point?

Comment on this

Deputy Corish asked how many "plumpers" there were in the Fine Gael votes. I did not see the count. I gave the same advice to the people voting for the Fine Gael candidate, that they should use their second preferences. I made no apology to anyone in Kerry for advising the Fine Gael voters to transfer their votes to the Labour candidate.

Comment on this

It was your only hope.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil can stay in office and feather their nests at the expense of the poor by making the poor people believe that, if any other Party are returned to power, the poor will lose all their social welfare benefits. As long as Fianna Fáil can maintain that position, the vested interests in Dublin who dictate the law to Fianna Fáil, the men with the income of £50,000, are all right. They have more say in the Fianna Fáil Party than Deputy Molloy. You are only a small cog in the wheel, Deputy Molloy.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not address a Deputy across the House.

Comment on this

As long as that is the position, Fianna Fáil will be safe for another period.

Comment on this

Is that what you think of the Kerry people?

Comment on this

This is my personal opinion. Fianna Fáil have created the myth that there is only one system of government in this country—the one-Party system. They came to power with the help of Labour. Some of the strongest economies in Europe have had a Coalition Government. I cannot see why it should not work here.

Comment on this

But it did not work.

Comment on this

I cannot see why it should not work.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, I would like to point out that Deputy Harte has been subjected to persistent interruption.

Comment on this

I am surprised that Deputy Fanning should use this opportunity to interrupt me. I have never interrupted him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Harte should not be addressing Deputies across the House. I am cautioning both sides, Deputy Harte and the interrupters on the other side. There is power vested in the Chair to deal with interruptions in a drastic fashion. If the Deputies wish the Chair to do that, the Chair will do it very freely. The Chair is cautioning both sides of the House now.

Comment on this

Countries in Western Europe have had coalition Governments which have been more successful than a Fianna Fáil Government. If the Labour Party are to be in opposition, they should be in Opposition to the Government, whether it is a Fianna Fáil or a Fine Gael Government. If Fianna Fáil are the Government, the Opposition Parties must be opposed to them. If Deputy Corish, as Leader of the Labour Party, had said to his supporters before the elections: "Transfer your second preference votes to the Fine Gael candidate," and if Deputy Cosgrave had said publicly to his supporters: "Transfer your second preference votes to the Labour candidates," two different Deputies would have been elected to this House. I would go further and say if tomorrow morning both Leaders were to say: "We both oppose Fianna Fáil and we are going to set up a Government if the country wills it," Fianna Fáil would not be in office. That is my personal opinion. I give it in the knowledge that some of my backbenchers will probably tell me I should not have said it. I do not say it simply because I think what Deputy Corish says or what Deputy Cosgrave says will influence the Irish people in the election of a Government.

I say it because I feel the Irish people are sick, sore and tired of Fianna Fáil government. I say it because of Fianna Fáil's dismal record of house building, so dismal that certain Fianna Fáil Deputies in marginal seats would lose their seats in a general election. I say it because I know that the people Fianna Fáil have deprived of social benefit by increased taxation would reject them in a general election. I say it because people with no political commitments, who vote on a personal basis, would probably vote cross-Party. This was very apparent in the Killarney district in the by-election. Both the Labour and Fianna Fáil candidates came from that locality. Certain people voted on a personal basis and transferred votes to the opposite Party. If a lesser percentage had done so, Deputy O'Leary would not have been elected to this House. If I were a member of the back bench of Fianna Fáil, I would not be sticking out my chest and crowing that the Taoiseach has received a vote of confidence from the people of Waterford and South Kerry.

Comment on this

He has.

Comment on this

This reminds me of a football team that does all the pressing but the other team scores the goals.

Comment on this

The footballer in Galway——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Would Deputy Fanning please restrain himself or else leave the House?

Comment on this

I am sorry.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You are short of hurlers at the moment, so cheer up.

Comment on this

I am sure Deputy Harte's personal opinions are of no importance——

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

Stand up when you are addressing the Chair.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Briscoe must not interrupt but must wait until Deputy Harte has finished, if he wants to make a contribution to the debate.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He made one.

Comment on this

Quite recently, when the Fianna Fáil Party decided to change leadership, the imagination of the entire country was held for a few weeks in anticipation of who would succeed. We had names mentioned in the Fianna Fáil ranks as to who would be the successful candidate. I feel that when the Taoiseach, Deputy J. Lynch, decided to contest these two by-elections it was the first decision and the only decision he could make as Taoiseach because, had he postponed that decision until early in the New Year, the results would have been quite different.

Comment on this

Deputy Donegan suggested that.

Comment on this

He told us we were afraid to go.

Comment on this

But during this period of the election of Taoiseach, some names were mentioned and certain remarks were made. Pressure groups existed. Certain Deputies in the Fianna Fáil Party were known to be canvassing for two people, and possibly three.

Comment on this

What happened to poor Deputy Dillon?

Comment on this

We are not surprised at that because even that very Deputy wanted to join the Fine Gael Party at one stage.

Comment on this

"It is time for a change."

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

It is a good job this debate will not continue much longer, in view of the behaviour of some Deputies.

Comment on this

It is nearly impossible to make a speech with Deputy Clohessy interrupting.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I asked Deputy Clohessy before to stop interrupting.

Comment on this

I am sorry; he is looking for it.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy's sorrow does not seem to be in any way permanent.

Comment on this

I shall conclude by saying that I hope the present Taoiseach will make a better job of the post than his predecessor. I hope that when the decision is his, whether it is best for the country or best for the Fianna Fáil Party, he will decide in favour of what is best for the country.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is synonymous.

Comment on this

I dispute that.

Comment on this

There is a declaration now.

Comment on this

I sincerely hope that if it is the lot of the Taoiseach to decide about going to the country at a time when it is inopportune for Fianna Fáil to do so, he will not postpone that decision for reasons of political expediency.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

He just told you he will.

Comment on this

His predecessors made those decisions and openly admitted that the only thing they were concerned with was the future of the Fianna Fáil Party. Might I, in conclusion, say that the Fianna Fáil Party are not the 73 members who are elected to this House to represent the Party but that some of the financial and vested interests in this city dictate the terms more forcefully than the backbenchers of the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

As a backbencher on the Fianna Fáil benches, I am proud to be here behind our present Taoiseach, Deputy Jack Lynch. The previous speaker asked why we did not go to the country at a certain time, why this and why that. It was not an opportune time for us to go to the country recently and yet we won the two seats. We had the NFA dispute and we had the credit squeeze. However, we went with a man as our leader whom we are proud to follow, Deputy Jack Lynch. Apart from that, Fianna Fáil have a record in this country. We represent every class and creed in the country, the labourer, the farmer, the businessman and everybody else. If we had not gone to the country, we would have been asked a different set of questions. Deputy Harte asked if we could not give them time enough to consider going to the country. I thought it would be the other way about because everything was pointing in their favour if the people had thought them good enough to vote for, but they did not.

There was something in the Sunday Independent about putting a hurler in your tank. Some two or three years ago, Fine Gael put a footballer in their tank in Galway. They brought the cup and the gansey around to every little village so as to get John Donnellan elected.

Comment on this

You would not do anything like that.

Comment on this

I have no objection to hurling or football. In a small way, I played these games myself. You did it more so than the present Taoiseach did it, but, apart altogether from his six all-Ireland gold medals, our Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, is a statesman. He has held three very good positions in Government.

Comment on this

Good luck to him, then.

Comment on this

I think he is entitled to be where he is today. We did not go down and say to the people: "You must vote for Jack Lynch or out you go". The people voted in conscience for what they thought was the best Government and they will do it again tomorrow, if needs be. I shall not criticise Labour. They put their record before the people as best they could in regard to social welfare, and so on. Fianna Fáil have a record in social welfare. I do not think Fine Gael mentioned social welfare at all. If they went back far enough, the people would tell them to forget about it because Fine Gael never knew anything about social welfare. Down through the years, Fianna Fáil increased the social welfare allowances.

There was the NFA dispute. We heard the Fine Gael fellows going around the country saying, in effect: "Look at what Fianna Fáil have done to the farmers who are sitting on the steps of the Department of Agriculture". The best remark I heard came from a Fianna Fáil fellow who said: "Why would some of those chaps on the steps not go down on their knees and thank God for all they have got under Fianna Fáil?" I think they should have done so. They have gone around talking about the small farmer. The expression "small farmer" is used far too often by some people, as far as I can see. If there are a few acres of ground for sale in my constituency, the big fellow will buy the land for himself and for his own good and that shows the love they have for the small farmer.

I come from North Tipperary where we have the NFA at the present time. I am sorry for the farmers of North Tipperary, and for the poor country, that they are following such a man. A man who could not be good for himself could not be good for anybody else, and that is my idea. I was wondering why the Opposition should continue this debate for so long. I thought they would not even attempt to have an adjournment debate because they had lacerated all the Ministers and the Taoiseach in a previous debate. It was suggested that the Taoiseach is a shy and bashful man and did not want the job, but I think he will prove to the Opposition that he is fit for the job and will do his job well. We of Tipperary are associated with Cork in the GAA. They beat us and we beat them. I am glad that we have a decent man as Taoiseach in Jack Lynch.

Comment on this

I suppose that in a way you are jealous that he is not a Tipperary man.

Comment on this

When Deputy Donnellan was being carried shoulder-high it was OK as far as he was concerned. I am sorry that we have been forced into this debate. I thought we would have had no debate tonight.

Comment on this

The Deputy is taking part in it.

Comment on this

We had a debate a few weeks ago when Ministers could not take part. They were debarred from taking part in the debate, because if they had done so, they would have been speaking on their own behalf. They are entitled in this debate to say what their policy is. We have discussed what they have done for social welfare and everything else. I do not think the people are so foolish as to believe the propaganda that has been put out. I say that the Opposition are foolish to be here tonight. They have faced the people in the past few weeks in Kerry and South Waterford, and they know the result.

Comment on this

But for the free hand-out in Kerry you would not have won the by-election.

Comment on this

Were there no medical cards in Deputy Donnellan's election, prescribed by a medical doctor?

Comment on this

I am sure there were.

Comment on this

I am sure there were, on your behalf.

Comment on this

On my behalf? On a Fianna Fáil county council?

Comment on this

When you were looking for election to this House.

Comment on this

I certainly did not give any medical cards.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Harte talking about the transfer of votes to elect a Deputy. You cannot go into a polling booth and hold a man's hand and say to him to vote No. 1 and No. 2. Electors will vote as they wish. I headed the poll in North Tipperary and was proud to be elected. A certain number of people will say in respect of a candidate that he is OK, that he does not want transferred votes. Fianna Fáil are proud to have won these two by-elections. We are proud to be here. Some of the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil are very glad that we are here—I mean the backbenchers in the Opposition.

Comment on this

You said "Fianna Fáil". Do not go away from it.

Comment on this

I am sure you are delighted.

Comment on this

I would say that there are many Deputies in the backbenches of Fine Gael who are very glad that we won the two seats. They were wondering what would happen if we were defeated.

I am sorry to have delayed the House. I am sure that the Deputies Opposite will go back to their own people and say that they will have to pull up their socks, that Fianna Fáil are on the crest of the wave and going up. I know what will happen in the next election. Fianna Fáil will come back with a greater majority than they had before.

Comment on this

I will be very brief. This 18th Dáil has a wonderful opportunity. This is the most testing time in our 40 odd years of freedom. Remember, in these 40 odd years Fianna Fáil have been in power from 1932 to 1966. For only six years, they were in Opposition. The difference between 1932 and 1966 must be obvious to everybody. This is the most testing time and it is a time when we should be fitting ourselves for the tasks in front of us in the Seventies. There is very important work before us, very important legislation to be dealt with, industrial relations legislation, trade union legislation, legislation concerning education and health. As the Taoiseach said in his opening statement, there will be legislation covering social adjustments, commercial adjustments, fiscal adjustments, to prepare us for the Common Market.

Comment on this

You are always about to achieve something.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will allow Deputy Lenihan to proceed.

Comment on this

If the Deputy had even a glimmer of what I am talking about, he would not interrupt. There will be social, fiscal, commercial adjustments to fit us for the Common Market. All in this House—this is the point I am getting at—are reasonably agreed on the main objective before the country. There are no ideological differences between us in this House. We are a rather homogeneous society. We are reasonably agreed in our objective, which is so to improve our efficiency, our productivity, so that we will have a better standard of living for our people, better social welfare, an increase in material wealth. All these things are objectives common to every one of us.

Comment on this

They are all provided in Great Britain.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Deputy is talking about, to be quite honest. There has to be adjustment to fit us to enter the Common Market in the Seventies. Why, in ainm Dé, do we not all get in on this job? Why is there this arid bickering when we are agreed on the common objectives and there is no ideological difference between us? Why has there been this arid, Sahara-like, bitter talking from 1922 to God knows when? Will it ever stop?

I should like to see the 18th Dáil arriving at something like a consensus. A consensus is not very well thought of at the moment. What does "consensus" mean. It means people with one mind and a common objective. We can have a consensus in this Dáil, a getting together of minds.

A great deal has been said about the by-elections but they were a form of mini-general election. I spent a long time in one constituency, a farming constituency in Kerry. The other was a city constituency. It is all right to say that if people had given their second votes to this or that candidate, the result would have been different. That is codology. It has nothing to do with it. The people have given their decision. In God's name, accept it. Let this Dáil get together and have that consensus. History will give the answer. The people of Kerry and Waterford realised the difficulties as well as any Deputy. They knew the price of cattle and of milk. They accepted these difficulties. Despite their realisation, they put the Fianna Fáil candidates in. That is the point I am getting at. They have given their verdict in two far-flung constituencies of different types. The Kerry people are not fools. I hope to have published in The Kerryman Deputy Harte's remark about the people of Kerry.

We on this side, to be quite honest, need the help of Fine Gael and Labour to get through all this legislation. It is important social legislation. It must have the greatest area and measures of agreement possible. We need their help. This 18th Dáil could go down in history as a Dáil in which, when the country was entering the greatest crisis in its career as a young nation, we all got together and decided to provide the best legislation possible for the job.

If we continue this negative, arid discussion, on the basis of "anything you can do, I can do better", "me, too-ism", when the people are waiting and looking for leadership, they will say: "We asked for bread and you gave us a stone." That is what they will say about this 18th Dáil. Mark my words: you will have something to answer for. Unless you try in the next session to put through legislation, broadly based, with the greatest consensus of opinion, you will be held to answer for your failure when we come to the Seventies. I strike this note of warning. I am simply asking all of us on every side of the House to work together for this objective. If we do this, we will go down as a Dáil that agreed to differ but that did its job.

Comment on this

Ní gá dhom caint anois mar gheall ar na fó-thoghcháin. Táid thart agus thug an pobal a mbreith ar na Páirtithe éagsúla. Toghadh Fianna Fáil ins an dá Dháilcheantar ina raibh na folúntaisí— Ciarraí Theas agus Port Láirge. Ní gá do Fhine Gael nó do Dhream an Lucht Oibre leithscéal ar bith a dhéanamh mar nach bhfuil leithscéal dá laghad acu. Chlis orthu an dalladhmhullog a chur ar an bpobal. Thug an dá fhó-thoghchán rialtas seasmhach don tír agus beidh rialtas cinnte cóir ann go ceann trí no ceithre bliana eile, buíochas le Dia. Sé an rud is tábhachtaí anois muintir na hÉireann a bheith lán-chinnte de go leanfar ar aghaidh leis an dul chun cinn a rinneadh sa tír seo le linn Seán Lemass a bheith ina Thaoiseach orainn fé Rialtas Fhianna Fáil. Beidh an dul chun cinn céanna ann faoi Fhianna Fáil arís ach leis an dTaoiseach nua, an Teachta Seán Ó Loingsigh i mbun na hoibre.

Cén iarracht atá á dhéanamh againn chun an Ghaeilge a chur ar aghaidh? Cén iarracht atá á dhéanamh ag na Teachtaí a chuireann iad féin ós cóir an phobail chun an Ghaeilge a chur chun cinn? Níor chuala mise mórán Gaeilge sa Tí seo ó toghadh mé mar Theachta agus ní dóigh liom go bhfuil leithscéal ar bith ag níos mó ná leath de na Teachtaí atá anso.

Níl agam féin ach Gaeilge shimplí ach táim ag iarraidh feabhas a chur uirthi ó sheachtain go seachtain. Ní cainteoir ó dhúchas mé. D'fhoghlamaíos mo chuid Gaeilge ar scoil a bhuíochas sin do Pháirtí Fianna Fáil.

Táimid ag iarraidh ceangal eacnamaíochta a dhéanamh le Mór-Roinn na hEorpa ach cad a bhéas againn le teaspáint gur Éireannaigh sinn agus go bhfuilimid bródúil as an dtír ina rugadh sinn? Feictear domsa nach mbeidh againn ach an teanga agus tá dualgas mór orainn iarracht níos fearr a dhéanamh chun teanga na hÉireann a chur chun cinn agus í a úsáid i bhfad níos mó inár ngnáth-shaol. Ní féidir le héinne againn a rá go bhfuil sé sásta leis féin maidir le labhairt na Gaeilge. Nílim féin sásta leis an méid atá á dhéanamh agam chun teanga na hÉireann a chur chun cinn mar ghnáth-theanga imeasc muintir na hÉireann agus tá mé cinnte nach bhfuil éinne sa Tí seo sásta ach an oiread.

Tá sé an-dheacair nuair is Teachta de Pháirtí thú atá ag déanamh a seacht ndícheall chun an teanga a chur ar aghaidh nuair a feictear duit go bhfuil dhá Pháirtí eile san Oireachtas nach bhfuil ag déanamh a gcion. Níl faic á dhéanamh acu dáiríre chun teanga na hÉireann a chur chun cinn. Is mór an trua é. Amach anso nuair a bhéifear ag scríobhadh stair an tréimhse seo, cuirfear an locht ar Fhine Gael agus ar Dhream an Lucht Oibre toisc nach ndearnadh dul chun cinn níos mó maidir leis an dteanga a thabhairt thar n-ais mar ghnáth-theanga mhuintir na hÉireann.

Comment on this

This debate has taken some remarkable turns. We have had, of course, the two by-elections all over again and, towards the close of the debate, we have had two Fianna Fáil Deputies apparently realising—I expect it was their trip to the country which has made them realise it—that this is not a land flowing with milk and honey, the land of milk and honey in which they told the people in the by-election areas they were living. There are, in fact, a number of people who need a great deal more than they are getting.

Deputy Lenihan was perfectly correct when he said we are not doing enough for the people, and Deputy Molloy supported him in that theme. I agree with both. The only mistake they made was in not stating that the people who are not doing enough are the Government. The ball is at their feet. Let it be a hurling ball or a football, they can hit it or kick it any way they like. Deputy Lenihan referred to the people asking for bread and being given a stone. The people who have the responsibility at the present time to hand out the bread are the people elected as the Government of the country; if they hand out a stone instead, surely Deputy Lenihan cannot blame the Opposition for that? I am not quite sure whether or not Deputy Lenihan was appealing for a national Government or for a coalition of Fine Gael and themselves, but he certainly felt something should be done. If he means there should be some change and if he realises—I am sure others in the Fianna Fáil Party also realise it—that something has to be done, then I am all with him.

Deputy Molloy's sermon was in the Irish language. He used the Irish language under the impression, perhaps, that nobody in the House would understand it and he could therefore hold forth at length on some of his pet theories. He sometimes uses the language, but not always. His lecture to the House—I claim it was a lecture —was a little out of place because, though he mentioned the by-elections, he did not refer to something that was very evident during those elections. During the by-election campaigns—I am sure Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael realise this just as well as we do—the Irish language was not made an issue by any of the three Parties, and for that we should all be truly thankful.

Now, the arguments have been that we have, of course, to find more money for the people who have not enough, but will the Parties opposite vote the money? Will the Government tell us first how they will raise the money? Will the Government say: "We require this money for social services. This is where we will place the tax." I solemnly guarantee to the Taoiseach and his Party that, if they do that, the Labour Party will be prepared to vote or it as they have on previous occasions voted in this Dáil for taxes specifically designed to supply certain needs in social welfare. This business of saying that this will be taxed and that will be taxed, and something will be given out of that taxation to social welfare, is just not good enough when we find subsequently that the taxes, allegedly designed for assistance to social services, turn up in some rich man's pocket. We will not support that: we have no intention of doing so.

I believe a great disservice has been done to the nation in having a debate here today dealing almost entirely with the by-elections. God knows, during the election campaign, all of us debated the issues affecting the areas in which the by-elections were fought, and we made the best we could of it. The fact that the Government got the majority of the No. 1 preferences and subsequently got enough transfers to give them the seats is neither here nor there. We know, and the Government know, that in Waterford the Government have got only the loan of a seat. These things have happened before; they will happen again. We believe the same situation has arisen in Kerry and, when the next general election is held, nobody will worry and nobody will talk about what happened at the by-elections. These things just happen. Personally, I believe there should be some other way of settling these issues because I do not believe by-elections ever settle very much.

We have heard talk about the plumpers. I contested a by-election myself. So did a number of people in this House, and outside it, contest by-elections. I believe that, when a person goes to the polling booth to vote, he votes No. 1 and, having done that, he is entitled to do anything he blooming well likes with his second and third preferences. If he decides he will not vote 2 and 3 for anybody, that is his business. That is equally true for Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil as it is for the Labour Party. That is the privilege of the voter and I should not like to see a situation arise in which the person who is going to plump would give his name and address to the presiding officer before the actual voting took place. That is the situation in which it is claimed the plumpers are because one or other Party has lost a seat. That has happened in every by-election I remember. It happened in the by-election in which I was a candidate. I have no quarrel with those who feel strongly about a particular Party, so strongly that, having voted No. 1 for the Party of their choice, they then decide they will not give their No. 2 to anybody else. Let us be grown up. Let us be sensible about this. We will have this so long as elections are elections. There is no point in debating the matter any further.

I want to make our position very clear, however, and this is the only reference I shall make to the by-elections. We have no apology to make to Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil, or anybody else, because some of our people reserve the right to vote No. 1 Labour, and stop there. The position is quite clear to everybody concerned. We have no quarrel with that and we have no quarrel with the Parties who contested the election. We contested it, and lost. It is true we hoped to do much better. It is true we did not do as well as we hoped we would, but we have no quarrel with the electors. They exercised their right and, when the next general election comes, we do not believe the way the people voted in the by-elections will make one damn bit of difference because, when the time comes, the people will make up their minds and vote whatever way they feel at the time the election is held. In both areas, when the next general election comes, we hope we will have two safe seats. So much for the by-election.

Usually this debate is referred to as the "State of the Nation Account". I would not blame the Taoiseach at all if his particular reference to the state of the nation today was not as detailed as many of us perhaps hoped it would be. The Taoiseach has not been very long in office. As we have said before—I think nobody will deny it—as far as we are concerned, the Taoiseach is a decent man, but he cannot get away from the fact that he is now the Leader of the Government and is now the Leader of a Party which is creaking at the joints. Deputy Lenihan was quite correct. He did not put it in those words, but I agree with him someone will have to go around with an oilcan and deal with these joints. I believe the electorate and the country will eventually apply the oil to the right places.

We have heard all sorts of promises over the years and all manner of statements about things being better just around the corner. The former Taoiseach was a great man for promising improvements around the corner. It was Dublin Opinion, I think, which suggested a few years ago that the corner to which the Taoiseach was referring was a corner just beside the mailboat at Dún Laoghaire, because that is where the change usually takes place. The trouble with the former Taoiseach was that his incurable optimism about something turning up around the corner led him into all sorts of difficulties. From the way the present Taoiseach is talking, I assume he has no great fear for the future of the country and that he feels we are going to make out all right.

I am going to ask him a straight question. Does he really think that everything in the country is as rosy as his Party seem to think? Does the Taoiseach realise that at present there are on the unemployment register 50,000 people and because of a bit of hookery—there is no other word to describe it—by the people who make up the statistics, there are an additional 16,000 not included on the list? That makes a grand total of 66,000 unemployed as of last Saturday. Surely we cannot tell the country that everything is grand while coming up to Christmas we have those people without a week's wages coming in? I do not know if there are many people here who have had the experience of having to depend on what is known by the workingman as a week's wages, but everyone who has had that experience, of depending for his livelihood on what he is able to earn with his hands or brain and then finds at the end of the week that there is no job for him and no week's wages coming in, knows what a sorry plight it is. We can do what we like about trying to improve wages and conditions but if a man gets eight months work in the year and spends four months on the labour exchange, his average wage over the year will be pretty small. Yet we are told that there is nothing to worry about.

I understand that a Government Senator referred to the fact that he could not get men to do his threshing. He had one day's threshing and he was disappointed and annoyed that the working men who normally attended for threshing were not waiting outside the gate to go in when the engine whistled. Rural Deputies, whatever about city Deputies, should be aware that threshing as it was known and as apparently this Senator still carries on, is completely outmoded. With the introduction of the combine harvester, very little threshing as such is done. The days when men went around behind a threshing mill and received fairly good wages are gone.

Comment on this

They travelled over half the country.

Comment on this

Yes. But this man, who has more money than he knows what to do with, was disappointed because the men were not standing outside his gates waiting to work for the measly £1 or 30/- he would give them, and then he says the country is in excellent condition and there is no unemployment. This is the sort of thinking which has led Fianna Fáil into the mess they are in, and they are in a mess. The whole question of employment has been debated here again and again. Today I had a question down asking the Minister for Local Government if he was aware that in Monaghan, a county bordering my constituency, a large number of road workers had been laid off without any prospect of re-employment. I pointed out that it gave me no pleasure to be raising this but there is one Minister and one Deputy on the Government side from that constituency, and they were not present to give words of advice to the Parliamentary Secretary who was answering, nor apparently were they able to do anything about having the men re-employed. These men were employed as road workers for many years and found themselves out of a job. Why? Government grants were given to each county council but what was ignored by the Department of Local Government, and by the Department of Finance, was that when the wage increase which was granted to practically all workers was applied to the road workers, the amount of money available for employment was greatly reduced.

Some of these men had big families and because of the fact that there was no money to employ them, they went to the labour exchange where, because of their big families, they got as much social welfare benefits as if they had been working. Many of them, however, were people with grown-up families, or single men, or men with brothers and sisters or parents depending on them. Despite that, these men found themselves out of employment. When Monaghan County Council found the money running short, they suggested that the new bridge grant for Emyvale village should be transferred to some other job so that the former employees would have some work over Christmas. That proposal was before the Department for a considerable time and the Parliamentary Secretary today was happy, according to himself, to tell me that the grant had been sanctioned a few days ago.

I do not know if he has had the experience of trying to make up the number of days a man must work before he qualifies for Christmas holidays. Even if these people are re-employed, and it is apparent from the answer that they have been re-employed in the past day or two, they still will not qualify for the couple of days holidays at Christmas. Perhaps that is one way of saving money. At least, it appears that way to me. I mentioned Monaghan because I know it well and my trade union caters for the Monaghan road workers. I am aware that this same thing is likely to occur all over the country. What are the Government doing about it? Nothing, just sitting back and saying that everything is grand. There should be no complaints in the country because Senator Dr. Ryan could not get men to do this threshing.

I give credit to Deputy Dillon for using an expression which I have used on more than one occasion since he used it because I think it is an apt description. He said that it appeared that we were going to have Government by gimmick. That appears to be what the former Taoiseach believed in and what the present Taoiseach seems to have taken over. Take the gimmick of the wage increase which was agreed on some time ago; take the increase in the old age pensions which was mentioned in the Budget and which was headlined in the newspapers. I do not know whether I am unique in this respect—I do not believe I am—but every morning my mail contains at least ten letters from people who say: "I am an old age pensioner"—or a widow pensioner—"and I have no means. I did not get the 5/- we were promised. What has happened?"

Many of these people made inquiries and I myself have made inquiries on their behalf. My inquiries have always been answered by the Department of Social Welfare, a Department for which I have the highest regard. What I got from them was a little bit of paper gummed together which said they had received my letter. Obviously they were getting so many that they had not got around to answering those sent in several weeks before. A few did get replies and I have seen some of them. The reply has been changed for reasons which I think I can explain later. The first replies said they could not get the 5/- increase because their income was assessed at £2 12s per year. Where did that figure arise? That was the amount which the Department of Social Welfare officials decided was the value of their lodging, just of the beds, of those old people who were being accommodated by their sons and daughters at very great inconvenience.

I know very many of these people living with sons and daughters who have little for themselves and who could not be considered able to maintain their parents. Although the old people buy food and fire and do all they can to help to keep themselves, it has been found that they are not buying their beds. Therefore, they must be deprived of the 5/- per week because the Department say that 1/- a week is the value of the bed. Would the Taoiseach say if they are prepared to pay the 1/- to the son or daughter? In many cases they must pay much more than that to help to buy the fire and pay for light? Will that be taken as proof that they are not getting a bed free and will they get this mean 5/- that has been distributed in this way?

I said the reply has changed. It now simply says "You are not entitled to the increase as your income exceeds the statutory limit". No figure is mentioned. I am sure the Department officials who first decided to state the amount had their knuckles rapped. This was mentioned in the Dáil, that the figure was 1/- a week. This is the sort of mean, petty thing the Government are capable of doing. Lest anybody think it applies to only a few people, it has been admitted that there are over 111,483 non-contributory old age pensioners, I think, and 10,070 received the 5/-, so that well over 100,000 of what nobody can describe as other than poor, old people do not get it. Some of them are assessed as having 1/- a week income and are refused the mean amount represented by the 5/- increase.

I do not know if the Taoiseach realises that there is a new means test involved which says that £2 12s per year prevents them from getting the maximum non-contributory pension. Before this, we had quite a row because the figure was £26 per year. This was a new means test, we said, and it was awfully mean. We are away down now.

I shall give an instance of what I think has happened. When the old age pension was introduced in 1909 by the British Government, it was 5/- a week and a man who was 70 got 5/- and, if his wife was living, she got 5/-. That was 10/-. If the old man worked with a farmer at the time, his wages would be about 9/- of 10/- so that in fact the non-contributory old age pension of a man and his wife equalled a farm worker's wages. What have we now? A non-contributory old age pension represents less than a quarter of the amount given to a farm worker, badly as they are paid in this country. This is not anything of which the Government can be proud.

We had a comment by the former Minister for Social Welfare. They move so quickly now that one has to be very careful not to miss them on the merry-go-round. I suppose that when in the Department of Social Welfare, he did as well as the Government would allow him, but he said he was warning the House that any further increases in social welfare would have to be borne by the employers and employees. I assume this is the way in which the State propose, if they give more in social welfare, to finance it. The Government are opting out. When the contributory old age pension was introduced—I certainly give credit to the Government for introducing it: it was planned by the late Deputy Norton who was Minister in the inter-Party Government but for some reason it was not put into operation until the Fianna Fáil Government put it into effect—it did have the effect that, by those pensioners paying for their pensions and those who were not pensioners paying for those who were pensioners, through their stamps, quite a number of people were removed from the non-contributory old age pension register. Despite that, and despite the fact that there should then be quite a substantial sum in the pool for distribution, we still have the lowest level of old age pensions in Europe, if not in the world.

The whole matter of social welfare is a national scandal. There is no point in Deputies getting up on the Government benches and saying that the Opposition when in Government gave only so much. The cost of living has increased very substantially since the last pension increase was given and this mythical 5/- apparently disappeared over the horizon for at least 100,000 old people, and I am sure for as big a proportion of widow pensioners. Despite this, the State do not appear to be prepared to do their share to alleviate the sufferings of those old people at present.

I wonder if Government Deputies would go to the trouble of checking with the really poor people in their constituencies as I do in mine. They would find that one of the biggest complaints at this time of year is the price of coal, 14/8d a bag. It is a poor fire that one bag of coal would keep going for a week. Take that sum from the non-contributory old age pension and the poor people have very little with which to buy food.

The price of bread, we are told, may go up; the price of electricity is going up. The Minister for Industry and Commerce was a little coy yesterday when we tried to find out if there was danger of a double increase in the price of bread. He said he did not want to anticipate the findings of the tribunal but he knows damn well that when the tribunal is finished, if the recommendation is favourable, there will be an increase of not 2d on the loaf but of 4d. What can old age pensioners and widows with small families live on on a non-contributory pension? They live on the well-known bread and spread and cups of watery tea and this in the year of Our Lord 1966 in a State which, according to the people who run it, is a land flowing with milk and honey.

We had a great deal of discussion in this House and a number of promises about the EEC. The Taoiseach has not been so rash as to say we are going it alone—yet anyway. His predecessor said that on one occasion; he backed out of it very quickly and I think he was a wise man to do so. The bald facts are that if Britain goes into EEC, we have to go in, and we know that the only thing that is keeping Britain out is France's veto. If France agrees to modify the Treaty of Rome, whether we like it or not, Britain goes in and, as some of the Common Market people said to us when we were in Brussels, if Britain goes in, we go in, not on negotiation or anything else but piggy-back on Britain.

What preparation is being made for entry to the EEC? What lead have the Government given to have preparation made? We have the NIEC Report and also a lot of talk about it. However, if anybody wants to find out whether or not the talks led to anything, let him visit any factory in this country and he will find that with very few exceptions, they are carrying on the very same old system as they were carrying on 20, 30 and 40 years ago. Nobody has encouraged them and nobody has tried to force them. If we have reached the stage where it is a question of survival, this Government must use force to try to make these people gear themselves to meet competition or get out of business altogether. The stupid idea some industrialists still seem to have that they can sit behind tariff walls which are gradually crumbling around them is so outdated that even they should realise it.

We had a discussion here yesterday on proposals to retrain workers, and we asked the Minister for Labour—the poor man, I am sure he is doing his best—retrain for what? Did anybody ever see such a helpless effort as this Government are carrying out in regard to the retraining of workers? What are they to be retrained for? The Minister got a little mixed up. He said we could not expect industrialists to come in here unless we had a panel of trained workers. We asked what kind of industrialists, and he was not quite sure. Which comes first, the hen or the egg? Are they going to train workers and hope that some fellow in Germany, France or somewhere else will come in here with an industry, or go to him and say: "We have workers. We want them trained. Will you send somebody along to help us to do it and guarantee that you are coming in?", because one Potez is quite enough for this country for a generation.

We had the Free Trade Agreement last year. People may say we are overdoing this, but I am mentioning it particularly because we were rushed back from our Christmas holidays to a meeting of the Dáil last January in order to hear the wonderful news about the Free Trade Agreement. The meeting was a few days before Christmas and I described the former Taoiseach and his Minister coming back from Britain like Santa Clauses. The only thing was that the bags were empty although they thought they were full; at least they said they were full. We had the then Taoiseach waxing eloquent in this House about the wonderful job which he and his Ministers had done. He pounded the desk in front of him to emphasise that they had in fact done a wonderful job. He mentioned them by name and, as the old poets long ago used to do, he sang the praises of their wonderful deeds.

Now almost 12 months later we know what we got. We know what was in the bag. We were told—and this cannot be denied, and I will give credit to the Fianna Fáil Party, most of them have not sought to deny it—there was to be an increase of £10 million for Irish agriculture in the first year. This was going to be the first benefit, and they promised that there would be an increase of from £5 to £7 in the price of cattle. They promised this, that and the other thing. We here in these benches pointed out, item by item, where those promises were going to fall down. We did not claim to be prophets. We had not even the crystal ball which Deputy MacEntee described the Taoiseach as having when he was drawing up the Second Programme for Economic Expansion. However, we did see into the future because it was very obvious to everybody that the promises being made were not going to be carried out.

We had the situation that we went over to Britain to sign an agreement and came back with nothing in return. What did we give away? We gave away progressively to Britain the right to import into this country her industrial goods. Has it been having any effect? Go into any shop in Dublin and see whether or not the first three or four articles offered will bear the British trade mark. Is this something we can be proud of in 1966?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

A ten per cent reduction in the tariff?

Comment on this

Yes. The Taoiseach must not be doing his shopping in Dublin, because if he were, he would realise that reduction of ten per cent has resulted in an influx of British goods the like of which very few people dreamed they would see. I know what will happen as the years go by—ten per cent after ten per cent and, if something is not done to stem the tide, we will finish up in a very short time with nothing but British goods to sell in Ireland.

The Taoiseach may say: "We had to give something to get something". I pointed out we got absolutely nothing. We are still only able to export to Britain with certainty our manpower, because the emigration figure is still growing, and we still have 30,000 people a year leaving this country. While we were told a few years ago all about the number that were unemployed when the inter-Party Government were in power, since the Fianna Fáil Government resumed office, the position is that year after year between 20,000 and 30,000 emigrate, moving from 20,000 to 22,000, 25,000, 27,000, 28,000, and now 30,000 a year are going across to Britain.

One of the big jokes that was tried on this country and that actually worked was that we were told the British Government had guaranteed to take 638,000 of our cattle stores each year. It turned out the British Government did not guarantee any such thing but that they would allow the Irish Government to sell that number if they required 638,000. It makes a very big difference. So far this year we have not sent over 50 per cent of what we were sending in previous years. Will the former Taoiseach be able to go to Harold Wilson and say: "This was the agreement. You are supposed to take that number and you must take them". He knows the Agreement did not say any such thing, but it sounded well coming from the front benches of the Government immediately after Christmas in the full flush of their defeat because it could not be called a victory. This is the sort of announcement we have been hearing from Fianna Fáil year after year.

I am not being critical of them just because they are Fianna Fáil. I am being critical of them because as a Government Party who have been in power for so long they do not yet appear to have mastered the art of government. If they did, they would never have made as many mistakes as they have made over the years. I am quite sure the Taoiseach will say he is entitled to his first bite the same as any other. But I feel the Taoiseach who went out got so many free bites that the present Taoiseach should be entitled to go ahead and stop making mistakes. The mistakes were made before that. But it appears from the Taoiseach's opening speech as if he is determined to carry on in the same old merry way. After all, the ship has not foundered yet. Who knows what is around the corner? Keep going and everything will be all right.

I wonder if Deputy Lenihan was correct in what he stated here? He honestly and truthfully said—I do not know what the Party Whip will have to say to him—that we were not giving the people what they were looking for. He said something would have to be done or the 18th Dáil would go down as having given a stone to the people looking for bread: he obviously meant the Government. He knows that neither Fine Gael nor ourselves are in a position to give the people what they want. Therefore, he was telling the Taoiseach that he, as a backbencher, was not satisfied with what the Government were doing. Deputy Molloy, who spoke in Gaelic, followed on almost the same theme. He gave a particular twist to it at the end to ensure, I suppose, that he would not be branded as a complete rebel. He gave the impression he also felt something should be done. The Taoiseach, realising that this is so and being an intelligent man who has recently assumed high office, must take cognisance, if not of what we are saying, at least of what his backbenchers are saying. With 1967 coming, he should make an effort to try to improve the position.

We have heard from time to time in the House about the number of factories being opened and about their employment potential. It is one thing I am particularly sore about. Whenever I attempted to find out what the actual number of employees was, I was told these were matters appertaining to a private company and therefore should not be discussed publicly in the Dáil. The country knows it has become the general practice for somebody wishing to start an industry here to declare the employment potential as high as 500 or 5,000 and, obviously on the strength of that, to obtain very substantial grants. Apparently, they are not asked by the Government either to allow a Government director on the board to watch the substantial sum of money granted, or for a date on which they would put into operation the employment which is potential when looking for the money. The result is that, year after year, we have had a repetition of these failures. I am not saying that every effort is a failure. I am saying there are far too many of them coming to the notice of the Dáil and of the ordinary people, failures which are costing, not the Government, but the taxpayers a substantial sum of money.

I suggest to the Taoiseach that he could possibly do one thing. There are in this country hundreds of small industries which need extra capital. If they got it, they would be prepared to improve their employment position. The Taoiseach should instruct his Ministers to see if it would be possible to have something done to assist these people.

If what the Minister for Labour said yesterday is correct, the Taoiseach must of necessity look around the country and see where industries can be established by the State. Industries run by the State must be run properly and be a success. If the Taoiseach does that, he will be making an effort to meet the requirements of the country. If not, we will just have another year of Fianna Fáil failure, as we have had so many in the past.

Comment on this

Sitting in this House listening to the debate, I felt at times a deep sense of depression at the manner in which the major Party now regard Dáil Éireann. I can only assume that, since this is the last debate before the Christmas Recess, the Taoiseach, as a kind of Christmas gift to some of the more irresponsible members of his Party, permitted them to shout their heads off here in this debate.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

You insisted on the debate.

Comment on this

Certainly, the standards of debate and the contributions made by at least two Fianna Fáil Deputies, in my opinion, represent a very serious black mark against what we are endeavouring to do in this Dáil for the country. We should be discussing at this stage in this debate how this country now stands. We are now almost half way through the effective life of the present Dáil. The last general election was held in April, 1965. Almost two years have now elapsed. I think it is true to say these two years have represented a period of drift and stagnation in this country.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I want to assert clearly what my view is in this regard. I would like to remind Deputies, and the Taoiseach in particular, that prior to the last general election, when the Second Programme for Economic Expansion was announced by the Government, the people were led to believe that we were going to see an orderly, planned development of our economic resources. They were led to believe that the Government had set before it targets which were possible of achievement, and that the Government had the determination and the intention to achieve these targets. They were led to believe that each year during the Programme unemployment would begin to disappear, emigration would gradually waste away and more Irish people would find remunerative employment here at home. At the same time, the people were told that, not only was more and more employment to become available and less and less emigration to drain the country, but that we would see a stepping up of our level of social services, an improvement in education, an improvement in health, an improvement in the manner in which we would provide for and look after the needy and less well-off in our community.

These were the targets set before the people by the Fianna Fáil Party immediately prior to the last general election. These are the things by which they must be tested. These are the targets we must inquire into now some three years later.

I think it is fair to say that since the announcement of the Second Programme, when it was blazoned across our newspapers and media of communication, Government Ministers sat back, twiddled their thumbs and waited for things to happen. I want to charge now, when the Second Programme is halfway through, that the dismal fact is plain to be seen that this Government, comprised of Fianna Fáil Deputies, have in fact made no conscious effort to achieve the targets set out in the Second Programme.

It will be remembered that, in the last general election, the former Taoiseach drew a distinction and attached importance to the distinction between what he called "economic programming" and "economic planning". He proceeded to criticise the policy of the Fine Gael Party because it was not in accordance with his views of economic programming. We said at the time that what he announced and appeared to stand for could not achieve success because it merely represented the setting of targets by a Government without evolving the detailed administrative and technical service required to achieve these targets. I should like to ask now, two years later, who has been right. I think it is fair to say that the result of Fianna Fáil programming over the past two years has been failure all along the line. In no respect, not in any single respect, in the past two years, has any target set out in the Second Programme been achieved. The only target that has been exceeded, as I am reminded, has been the level of taxation set out in the Programme.

Comment on this

And borrowings.

Comment on this

Our people were told that unemployment would begin to disappear. It has been increasing steadily. Today, ten years after this Government went into office, it tries one's patience to listen to some back bench Fianna Fáil Deputies talking about the days of the inter-Party Government. There are today 165,000 fewer Irish people at work here at home than there were ten years ago, and unemployment is growing again.

We thought we were beginning to see the end of emigration not because of any conscious or efficient effort by Fianna Fáil but because we had almost scraped the bottom of the barrel. We thought there were not enough people left to emigrate but apparently we were wrong. Today, emigration is running again at something over 30,000 a year. I want to know from the Taoiseach if he can give any indication now of what his Government proposes to do to achieve the target set out in the Second Programme. Vague promises will not suffice and clichés will not supply any answer. To state that the Government are advancing, and all the rest of it, will not provide a job for any man in this country. These are some of the domestic questions we have to face. We are either still supposed to be implementing the Programme for Economic Expansion or we are doing nothing. The Second Programme was understood by most people in the country to mean orderly progress towards the achievement of possible targets. It was supposed to mean that we would see the end of the stop-go kind of economic policies that have so adversely affected this country and Britain over the past couple of decades. But, of course, we have not had that. We have had, instead, the application of the same methods that, time and time again, have prevented economic expansion.

We had the slush wanton inflation of 1964 when, in a disorderly and inefficient manner, Fianna Fáil Ministers dissipated the available credit in the country and, in effect, almost printed dud £ notes. We had that slush inflation of 1964 when our people were fed with a phony prosperity so that, in the midst of this situation of complete falseness, a cheap election victory might be secured before the bills had to be paid. Then, after the general election of 1965, the corrective measures had to be applied by a Government who had got back into office. Ever since April, 1965, we have had a Government-designed deflation designed deliberately to restrict credit, to reduce business, to prevent expenditure and, generally, to bring about a recession and inevitably to cause unemployment. These have been the measures that have been applied successfully by the present Fianna Fáil administration over the past 12 months. Where is the Second Programme? Where is the orderly advance towards achievable targets? Where is the kind of dynamic approach the people are entitled to expect from the Government they elect?

I am sorry to say that I believe the reason for this appalling failure by the present administration is not lack of good faith; I believe they all desire these things. However, I believe the answer is that they are inefficient and that, individually and collectively, the present Ministers just do not know their jobs and are not able to give to the people the kind of service they should be getting.

We now have the impending approach of European membership. I should like if some neutral observer, some unprejudiced person outside our political arena, could pass unbiassed judgment on the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to Europe. I do not believe they have ever, as a Party, started to consider what Europe could mean, will mean and should mean to this country. Our application for accession to the Treaty of Rome was an afterthought made by the last Taoiseach in the dying days of July, 1961. It was sent in by letter—by letter. It was discovered, only at the last minute, that that was such a grave act of discourtesy that the letter of application had to be taken from the pillar box and delivered by our Minister in Belgium and, having sent in our application for membership, the Fianna Fáil Party in Government proceeded to leave it there. Then we had, in a moment of euphoria, the former Taoiseach, having met a visiting dignitary here, saying in effect: "We will go into Europe. If necessary, we will go it alone."

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

When the absurdity of that proposition dawned on him and his Party, followed by the failure of the British negotiations, nothing was done about Europe whatsoever, until eventually, as a result of insistence from these benches, Fianna Fáil and the Government began to realise that even though the British negotiations had apparently failed, we still had a duty to ourselves and to our country to continue to investigate our possibilities in Europe. The strange fact has been that up to a few months ago our Minister for External Affairs, who has concerned himself with every problem from Japan to Siam, never once mentioned the question of the European Economic Community or the Treaty of Rome, and never went to Brussels until he was forced to go as a result of insistence from these benches here.

What is the result? Europe has now become more probable, as we were saying all the time. It is now becoming nearer and nearer. But look at the wasted years, the years in which Fianna Fáil Ministers dithered and did nothing. Look at what has happened to Irish agriculture, to the primary industry of this country, the industry that should benefit enormously by getting access to the markets of Europe. Instead of there being, as there should have been, in operation over the past few years a long term development plan for agriculture providing large-scale investment, there have been doles and subsidies and gimmicks of one kind and another designed to palliate some particular problem in a particular section of the agricultural industry. No thought has been given to planning our agricultural industry in such a way that it can be geared to take full advantage in 1970 of the European market.

The same thing has happened in our factories and in our manufacturing industries. As Deputy Tully has mentioned, there have been the usual clichés in ministerial speeches, the usual bromides thrown out to industrialists, but the plain requirement of re-tooling our industries, of re-tooling our factories and our sources of manufacture to equip our industry for the challenge of Europe has not been met. At the end of 1966 and the beginning of 1967, these facts pose serious difficulties for our people in the future.

We said all along that accession to the Treaty of Rome, entry into Europe, meant for this country either a wonderful opportunity or a very real and grave danger—one or the other. At least four years have been wasted by inefficient Ministers of an inefficient Administration. There may be a couple of years still left. I hope we will see evidence now, as a matter of urgency, that this Government at last realise that they are not sent into office merely to draw their salaries, to drive around in their cars, to make speeches at dinners and lunches and to do nothing else. Europe can be a great opportunity or a great danger. The opportunity can be known to all. It is an opportunity for us to sell what we can produce in a vast, almost unlimited, market, but the danger is that, if we do not avail of this opportunity and if we are not prepared for it, our people will be sucked from the land of Ireland into the big centres of population, sucked away, and our money and our wealth will disappear and the Irish people will become like the wandering Jews of Exodus—that is the real danger, with our land owned and populated as the playground of Europe. That is the problem that faces this country and that is why we expect to see—and I want to make it quite clear that we will insist on seeing—evidence that this Government for the remainder of their term in office get down to the job of preparing and equipping this country for membership of the European Community.

There are other things. In the last general election, just two years ago, the Fine Gael Party announced a programme, a policy, aimed at achieving a just society. We provided views and principles based on economic planning to achieve the targets in the Second Programme or in any other programme, but we also put before the people the absolute necessity to achieve for our people as a matter of urgency a standard in health services and in social welfare services which were at least comparable with those in other countries in Western Europe. We did that, not only because it is the just thing to do, but because it is the wise and essential thing to do. If we do not step up our social services, the manner in which we provide for those in need and in ill health, if we do not do that step up our social services, the manner in which we provide for those in need and in ill health, if we do not do that as a matter of urgency, by the time Europe comes about, we will limp into that association as the poor relation, tattered and unable to wear the kind of clothes that everybody else wears.

Our policy, Towards A Just Society, eventually evoked from the Fianna Fáil Party in the dying days of the last election, some evidence that our message was going home and eventually an assurance was given by the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lemass, almost on the eve of poll. He said: “All right; vote for Fianna Fáil and we will implement the Fine Gael policy in relation to health services and social welfare.” I want to know what has happened since. I want to remind the Taoiseach and this House that here we are in the last month of 1966 in precisely the same situation as we were ten years ago, carrying on with a creaking, antiquated system of health services. We have had a plethora of promises. We have had a galaxy of commissions. We have had a complete canopy of White Papers. The end result has been nothing.

What has happened to the promises made here in the early part of this year by the former Minister for Health, now the Minister for Education? He solemnly undertook in a debate in this House that by the month of November, the Fianna Fáil limited proposal to review our health services would be brought as a legislative measure before the Dáil. Why has it not been done? Has it just been forgotten? Does the Taoiseach feel that our people are no longer interested in improving the health services of the country? Does he feel that, once the election was over, we would forget the reason we are here and the policies and the programmes we have talked about? I want to know why the limited improvement in our health services as promised has not been introduced in this session of the Dáil.

We now see some more promises by the present Minister for Education, a most promising Minister, with regard to improvements in our educational system. That is some little benefit. It does not go as far as we would like it to go but at least it is some little consolation to us to know that insistence and emphasis here can have an effect. We have stressed for many years that in relation to Europe, in relation to the competition we are bound to face, if our people cannot find work at home, if they emigrate, we must ensure that they will be equipped for the highest, not the lowest, jobs. If there is to be any improvement in our educational services, let us hope they will come into operation as quickly as possible. I trust the Minister knows what he is doing in this regard and that he will be in a position next September to ensure that the scheme for extended educational facilities goes into operation smoothly.

There are a lot of other things about which I could speak but I do not want to cover too wide a field. There has been a discussion here about the recent by-elections and other elections this year. After an election, everybody is entitled to give his own opinion of the result, how it came about and so on. I was interested to hear Fianna Fáil Deputies talking about a vote of confidence in the Government in Kerry and in Waterford. It is amazing how mad one can get and what frenzy may possess one when one talks about political matters. They talk about a vote of confidence with 16,000 votes cast against the Government and 12,000 for them demonstrating a drop in their own vote. In Kerry, 15,000 people voted against them and they were in a minority of 3,000.

These elections were purely on the political issue as to whether you support or oppose Fianna Fáil and they resulted in the most decisive condemnation in the two constituencies in which, in the last election, Fianna Fáil secured almost 50 per cent of the vote. Still they talk about a vote of confidence. Whatever view one may take of that, one of the most significant features of the current political situation has been the growth this year of the strength of Fine Gael. I say that to all other Parties in this House. I say that in this country we do not like living in a political vacuum and I would like to state my belief that the Irish people do not desire to wind up in one-Party Government conditions here. I believe the people desire and will have an alternative Government to Fianna Fáil.

References have been made here to the inter-Party Government. I do not want to go back over old issues but I make no apology for the fact that I was a Minister in an inter-Party Government. I am proud to have served in it with one of the greatest Irishmen of his day, the late Mr. William Norton, proud to sit around a council table and see that man in action as one of the Ministers of an Irish Government. I make no apology for it. I have no doubt that in the immediate future the will of the people of this country will be demonstrated in action, demonstrated in the sense and in the way that an alternative Government to Fianna Fáil will be found. I serve notice on the Taoiseach that the present indication and the present trend is that in the near future a Fine Gael Government with sufficient support in this House to carry on will be elected.

In these two by-elections, if they are to be taken as a test, every Party lost votes except Fine Gael. The Fine Gael share of the total votes in both constituencies rose from 29 per cent in the last general election to 36 per cent. That shows that the people, first of all, voted by such a large majority against the Government and, secondly, that they are going to get behind and back and support the one Party in this House who are prepared to take on the responsibility of government. It is a matter for others to interpret what I am saying but I assert that it is inevitable that in a change of Government Fine Gael will be elected to take over. If other Parties do not play their part in that, the responsibility will be on Fine Gael to provide the alternative Government. I believe that that will come about very rapidly.

We have all been very kind to the Taoiseach. We have all said what a nice man he is. I welcomed personally his election to this office. I heard some of his speeches in the recent by-election and I think he lowered the tone of political dialogue and discussion in this country very much. He went out appealing, not to the intelligence of the people, but trying to inflame old sores and old bitternesses. He told the people that he did not want the job. That is a matter entirely for him.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I challenge the Deputy to state one inflammatory statement I made.

Comment on this

I am not going to make the Taoiseach's speeches for him, but I want to say this——

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Do you hear the cackling hens?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Just give me one inflammatory sentence.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has been elected with a great degree of personal popularity, and from this side of the House, too. He has been dubbed the reluctant Taoiseach and the reluctant leader. I will ask him now to get rid of his relucance and to realise that, in times like these, and in present circumstances, Ireland needs a leader with fire in his belly and with the determination to do the job. We cannot afford to have a nice man going around the country and being coy. We need a leader who will give dynamic leadership, a sense of direction and a sense of national purpose to our people.

Comment on this

Today the Taoiseach, in an intervention, said that what is best for Fianna Fáil is best for the country.

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

What is best for Fianna Fáil is best for the country. If that is the kind of leadership our people are to get for the next year or for as long as this Dáil lasts, then I say "God help Ireland". If we are to have a situation, as was unfortunately the position under the previous Taoiseach, in which the requirements of the country are judged first of all by what suits the Fianna Fáil Party, then we are in for trouble. It was because of that attitude that we got the inflation of 1964; it suited Fianna Fáil at the beginning of 1964 to bring about the 12 per cent wage increase. That was good for Fianna Fáil. Was it good for Ireland? Are we to have a continuation now under the new Taoiseach of this same philosophy—what is best for Fianna Fáil is best for the country?

Comment on this

Correct.

Comment on this

Certainly the Taoiseach's sentiments appear to have the unanimous support of his Party. I wonder what the people will think of that in due course? Deputy MacEntee is back.

Comment on this

Ask them in Kerry.

Comment on this

Deputy MacEntee is back. The soothsayer! He had enough to say the last time the Fianna Fáil Government decided what was best for the country. "What went wrong?" he asked. They consulted the soothsayers and the astrologers and, having consulted both the astrologers and the soothsayers, they got the wrong answer.

Comment on this

And Garret FitzGerald.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil would not mind having him, would they?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

You are welcome to him.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

In the course of this debate, the Minister for Labour said something I judged to be critical about Deputy Cosgrave having had the temerity to go to Brussels to inquire into the problems affecting this country. Impliedly he seemed to suggest that Deputy Cosgrave had better not do that again. I should like to remind the Minister for Labour and the Fianna Fáil Party that Deputy Cosgrave will, in accordance with his responsibility, do whatever is right for this country, either inside it or outside it.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

He will not do what a former leader of Fianna Fáil did at a time of critical domestic problems — go elsewhere to fan up flames that should long since have been allowed to die down. I am glad to see Deputy MacEntee here tonight. He now recognises, because he is a repentant sinner, that so far as Partition is concerned many mistakes were made. Let us hope the Taoiseach will at least understand——

Comment on this

What about 1949 and the Republic of Ireland Act?

Comment on this

Why did you not repeal it if you did not want it? You are still there. You can repeal it tomorrow.

Comment on this

You tried to join the British Army.

Comment on this

Repeat that outside.

Comment on this

If it were not the truth, it would not worry you so much.

Comment on this

Put that old man to bed.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I just want to conclude by saying, with Deputy MacEntee's permission, that the Taoiseach and his Government can take some consolation in the fact that, so long as we are the Opposition in this House and in the country, we will respect the laws and the institutions of the State. We will respect the economic principles of the State. We will never denigrate our country. We will at all times act responsibly for we know that Fianna Fáil at the moment have only a loan of the responsibility for the future of Ireland and very shortly they will have to give it back to us.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Until about an hour and a half ago, I thought the spirit had completely left both the Fine Gael and Labour Parties because I never heard in all my time in this House such inept offerings as I heard from those benches during today. However, they drummed up a little enthusiasm by getting Deputy James Tully and Deputy O'Higgins to come in here, talk loudly, trot out the old clichés, the old recriminations and complaints that have bedevilled this kind of debate for the past year or so, which were uttered right through the length and breadth of the constituencies of Waterford and South Kerry not so long since and which were thrown back in their faces when the people went to the polling booths.

Comment on this

A monority vote.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If one comes in here and shouts loud enough, he is regarded as a strong character with fire in his belly. If a man seldom raises his voice in the House, he is accused of being coy. I am accused of making inflammatory statements in Waterford and South Kerry, despite the allegation of coyness on my part. I challenge Deputy O'Higgins to produce one inflammatory sentence I uttered during the course of the campaign. I challenge him now or tomorrow in the press to quote, by letter or otherwise, any inflammatory statement I made during the by-election campaigns. If he succeeds, I will acknowledge it immediately.

I have never before heard such excuses trotted out here for lack of success in two by-elections. In 1964 we had two by-elections, one in Cork and one in Kildare. These were typical constituencies in that one was a city constituency and the other a rural constituency. We brought off a double then. We were accused of having gone to the people with promises. It was alleged that we threatened the 12 per cent wage increase would be withdrawn unless the Fianna Fáil candidates were supported and that was why we won the two by-elections.

On this occasion we went to the hustings at a time that could not have been more propitious for the two Opposition Parties. Again we brought off a double. I went to South Kerry and Waterford. I made no promises. I told the people candidly what the position was. I told them there were difficulties that we as a Government had to face; I told them there were economic difficulties, some of which were caused by external influences and some of which were of our own making. I did not exclude the Government from responsibility for some of these. We came at a time when these economic difficulties were still with us, when the Government's measures to overcome these economic difficulties, unpalatable and politically unpopular as they were, were still in the minds of the people. We came when there was active agitation by a big section of the community, a section representative of the constituencies in which these by-elections were fought, and nevertheless we beat the combined Opposition to a frazzle.

Comment on this

You what?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Apparently Deputy O'Higgins——

Comment on this

You are in a minority.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

According to Deputy O'Higgins, there were 16,000 votes against Fianna Fáil and, if we were to go on that basis, Fine Gael were beaten in those two elections by almost two to one. Where is the moral victory there?

Comment on this

It was nothing like that.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

However, I will refer to this topic again because I will have plenty of time to deal with it. I want to deal now with a few points which were made during the debate. The main one as far as I could judge was criticism of the preparations by the Fianna Fáil Government for membership of the European Economic Community. Fine Gael have been making allegations against this Government for the manner in which they have handled not only our application for membership but the manner in which we have encouraged our people and facilitated our people to prepare for membership of the European Economic Community. Before I finished my opening statement this morning, I put it to Deputy Cosgrave to give us an indication of what exactly he and his colleague who went to Brussels last week had said to the members of the Commission whom they met, and whether there was anything in the oft-repeated suggestion that we have had here, and also in the Seanad, that there was some other means whereby we could have got advantages of membership of the Community while retaining the advantages we have by our Trade Agreement with the United Kingdom. In no case did I get any indication that there was something in what Fine Gael had been saying all along the line that could have advanced our position one single degree.

Fine Gael have been suggesting, for example, that we could have negotiated with the Common Market the same type of agreements as Denmark and Austria have negotiated. I hope now that they have visited Brussels that they know that neither Denmark nor Austria has negotiated any agreement with——

Comment on this

But Denmark is getting in 16,000 cattle and we are not even getting in 2,000.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Denmark and Austria were held up as having the type of agreement which we could have negotiated with the European Economic Community, if we had gone about it in the right way.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I will give Deputy Donegan the status of Denmark's agreement. He knows it as well as I do. Denmark and Germany have had, over a number of years, a trade agreement which provides for the admission from Denmark into Germany of some 200,000 or more cattle a year, and some 16,000 cattle in particular in the off-the-grass period. That agreement carried over beyond the period when the Common Market agricultural policy was negotiated and by a concession recommended by the Commission of the European Economic Community, the agreement was permitted to be carried into the period beyond that Common Market agricultural policy commencement date. We sought a similar concession and got it.

Comment on this

You did not get it. You are not getting 2,000 cattle in.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Indeed, we are.

Comment on this

When?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

At this moment there is an agent in Germany negotiating about these 2,000 cattle.

Comment on this

Take your medicine.

Comment on this

We will believe it——

Comment on this

Má tá Gaeilge agat labhair í.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Is beag Gaeilge atá ag an Teachta.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will Deputies abide by the rules of the House? Deputy Donegan has been interrupting since the Taoiseach started.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to say that the full extent of this alleged agreement that Fine Gael would have us believe Denmark has with the European Economic Community is only a concession and it is on similar lines to the one we have won for ourselves. Austria has no agreement, and the only reason that Austria is being considered at all for a special relationship with the European Economic Community is her political agreement with the USSR. Surely Fine Gael could not suggest that the same strategic reasons apply to us vis-á-vis the USSR and the European Economic Community as apply to Austria.

We were told that we should have negotiated the same type of agreement but the fact remains that there is no such agreement yet and there is not likely to be for some considerable time.

We were accused of not making sufficient preparation for the European Economic Community, in particular by the last speaker, Deputy T.F. O'Higgins. He seems to have forgotten that at the time of our application, and even before our application was made, we had established the Committee on Industrial Organisation to make an examination in depth of the whole range of Irish industry, such an examination as was never carried out in the history of any country. Not only did we have regard to the reports of the Committee on Industrial Organisation but we implemented every one of their recommendations.

When the British application for membership was suspended, we saw that there might be some slackening off in interest in the possibility of freer trading by our industrialists and, in 1964, we introduced a voluntary reduction in our industrial tariffs in order to ensure that the pace of industrial efficiency would be maintained. The only reason we suspended the rhythm of tariff reductions was the imposition of the British surcharge on imports of industrial goods to that country. Immediately, however, we found that the prospect of early entry to the European Economic Community was not good, we negotiated the Free Trade Area Agreement with Britain whereby we would continue this rhythm of industrial tariff reductions and whereby our industrialists would equip themselves with the necessary techniques and skill and the necessary adaptations in order to make them fit for meeting freer trading, freer trading such as we are certain to meet when we enter the European Economic Community. Not only that—and the suggestion has been made that it was not sufficient to adopt the recommendations of the Committee on Industrial Organisation—we went further by making adaptation grants and loans at low interest rates available for the re-equipping and re-tooling which Deputy O'Higgins said was not taking place, but for which £5 millions and over has been contributed by way of these adaptation grants to industry. Not only did we do that, but I set up, when I was Minister for Industry and Commerce, a special branch called the Industrial Re-Organisation Branch and we gave to that branch some of the best officers in the Department of Industry and Commerce, and individually they went around to firms and made recommendations to them about re-adaptation and explained what they thought could be done in order to make these firms more efficient.

This work is proceeding apace. I am glad to say that many Irish firms have applied for re-adaptation grants and many of them are now increasing their competitiveness to the extent that even in these adverse conditions in the British market our industrial exports are showing an increase over the past few months. It is true that some industrialists have been lethargic in their approach to this matter. They have not availed to the full extent—and in a few cases not at all—of the facilities made available by the Government to ensure their greater efficiency. But not only are our industrialists dilatory in this way but some workers are also dilatory.

When we come in here, it depends on which side of the House you are: if you are a Labour man, you blame the industrialists: if you are a member of the other Party, you blame both sides of industry; but it is true that there is blame attaching to both sides of industry in this respect. No Labour Party member will deny that there are dilatory workers as there are dilatory employers, but I believe that with the impact of the Free Trade Area Agreement now and the impact of the renewed British initiative in relation to the Common Market, our people generally will be more alert to the requirements of entry into the EEC.

A few specific points were raised in the course of the debate and there is one to which I should like to refer in particular in so far as an attack was made by Deputy Lindsay on a group of individuals who had been asked to form the consortium to advise on the organisation and building of the new regional technical colleges. First of all, a steering committee has been set up, selected only because of their particular knowledge of the requirements of technical colleges where higher training is to be given. I shall not go through the list of persons so appointed but, so far as I know, not one of them has any attachment whatever to the Fianna Fáil Party. These are men who are senior management specialists, professors of chemical engineering, and managers of successful companies in different parts of the country.

There has also been established this consortium to which Deputy Lindsay referred as high-up members of the Fianna Fáil Party, unsuccessful candidates to the Seanad elections and a neutral element here and there to take the bare look off them. But people who have been appointed to this consortium are members of firms, some of which are famous in their own fields, not only in this country but in the world. Again, I do not want to parade their names before the Dáil but the purpose of appointing this consortium was to ensure that the best and cheapest possible method of providing the necessary skill to build these colleges would be employed. Otherwise, there would have been a greater—I shall not say waste of public money—expenditure of public moneys on these colleges than there will be under the system now proposed.

Deputy James Tully spoke about social benefits and asked what taxes did the Government propose in order to increase social benefits and, if we said what taxes we would propose, the Labour Party would guarantee to vote for them. The level of social welfare benefits does not depend on taxation alone. As Fianna Fáil have consistently pointed out, this depends on the level of economic activity that we can generate in order to support the highest possible level of social welfare benefits.

Deputy O'Higgins, in his contribution a while ago, claimed that it was Fine Gael who pushed Fianna Fáil into making some recompense to the recipients of social welfare benefits in the last or, particularly, the second last Budget. This kind of boast comes ill from Deputy O'Higgins whose Party have a dismal record in the field of social services. Not only that, but they actually sabotaged whatever efforts were being made by the late Deputy William Norton, whom he so justly eulogised a few minutes ago, to provide a comprehensive system of social welfare.

The fact is that over their last three-year period in office, they succeeded in giving an overall increase of 2/6 to old age pensioners. In one year when we came back we gave a 10/-increase. At those rates it would have taken the Coalition Government 12 years to catch up with us. Then they tell us that we are not doing enough for the social welfare recipients. The fact is that we intend to continue increasing the level of benefits for social welfare recipients but we know we cannot do it by increasing taxation that the economy cannot bear. Our progress in that direction depends on the ability of our people to earn sufficient money to provide the taxation that will enable us to make better provision for social welfare recipients.

I should like to return for a short time to the by-elections. I have here a publication called The Citizen, with the sub-title “For the People”. I must confess it is the first time I was given this publication. I understand it is the official publication of the Fine Gael Party. This is the December, 1966, issue. They tell us, in what would appear to be the leading article, under the heading “The Choice”:

The issue of the by-elections in Waterford and South Kerry is simply: Is Fianna Fáil's mandate to continue in office which it won in the 1965 General Election to be endorsed by the dictate of these two constituencies; or is a verdict of approval and confidence in Fine Gael to be given now...

We know the answer to that. It goes on to say why the verdict should be in favour of Fine Gael. Unfortunately, either this document did not reach sufficient voters in the constituencies concerned or the arguments did not convince them.

Comment on this

Of course, we did not have the Press.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The amusing part of this debate was that, having lost the by-elections, Fine Gael began blaming Labour and Labour supporters because they did not vote for Fine Gael. They gave Labour supporters a lecture on how in future they should distribute their second preference votes. Labour should watch out: there seems to be some infiltration of the ranks of their first preferences by the Fine Gael Party. The wooing of second preferences is only the usual back door method employed by Fine Gael to achieve their purposes. I advise Deputy Corish and his colleagues to watch out for this wooing of second preferences in the future.

Comment on this

Now the Taoiseach is advising us: you are all very concerned about us.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is advice that you are free to accept or reject. Whether you accept it or not, it will not imperil our position.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I should hate to have the bright smile of Deputy Dunne absent from the House and that might well be——

Comment on this

You would not hate it as much as Deputy Dunne.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We always claim that the Fianna Fáil Party get on the figures—and the results show this— as many as, and, perhaps, more—in fact, I am certain they get more— votes from the trade unionists and workers, as they are called, than Labour do, so that, even if Labour lose their second preferences to Fine Gael, we have no intention of losing our first preference labour votes to Labour or anybody else.

Comment on this

You lost them in the last two elections.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is only one of the excuses.

Comment on this

I am not making any excuses.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am talking about Fine Gael excuses—that the Labour Party did not give them their second preferences, or else as, I think, Deputy Cosgrave said today, the journalists brought about their defeat because in one constituency they predicted that the Labour Party man would beat the Fine Gael Party man. I have often heard journalists criticised for being unfair to individuals but I never heard of them being criticised for causing the defeat of a by-election Fine Gael candidate, and particularly journalists from the Irish Independent and the Irish Times. That was not all. I read in one of today's papers that the Fine Gael candidate in South Kerry was blaming the county manager. It is a report of yesterday's county council meeting. The county manager handed out too many medical cards during the weeks before the election.

Comment on this

It is not usual to criticise people who are not Members of the House.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is not usual to criticise public servants who cannot speak for themselves. However, there is only one person left and, like the bad team, blame the referee. I am sure the returning officer will be the next target.

Comment on this

He was not able to announce the count in Kerry with the mob interrupting him.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I have not finished with this document yet. There is another article in page 3. Again I quote The Citizen: For the People, December, 1966. The article is entitled “Fianna Fáil Dilemma” and it is written by a person who styles himself Jim Ryan. I do not know who Jim Ryan is.

Comment on this

Dr. Ryan, I suppose.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The name is good but the stuff is not all that good.

Comment on this

It might even be Richie's brother.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

In the course of this article, Mr. Jim Ryan discusses the "vicious struggle" that was taking place in Fianna Fáil before the selection of the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Deputy Colley is looking at you.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy Blaney was a front runner or not.

Comment on this

He was there.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I quote from the article:

... it is the first time that a faction within an Irish political Party, openly declared its dissent from the rest of the party.

As far as I know, it is not the first time there was an election in an Irish political Party to choose the next leader. There was an election, in our memory, when Deputy Dillon pipped Deputy Cosgrave by one vote. But nobody heard about it; nobody saw it in any papers. We in our usual democratic way published our full results. However, soon after the Just Society was swallowed by Deputy Dillon, the Just Society was kicked out the back door by the electorate.

Comment on this

And swallowed by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Lower down they discuss me. They describe me as being weak, indecisive and mediocre, but I am sorry that some Fine Gael man across the way had not the guts to get up and say this to my face in the House. I gather that, since this appeared in their official organ, it is the official view of the Fine Gael Party. I know there is a propensity in people who have certain drawbacks and limitations to ascribe those very drawbacks and limitations to their adversaries. Of course "Weak, indecisive and mediocre" would be a very apt description of the Fine Gael Party. They have been weak right down through the years. It is because of their weakness that they have spent four-fifths of the past 25 years on the other side of the House. It is because they have been indecisive that they are in Opposition, and because they have been mediocre, they will be in Opposition for a hell of a long time more.

Comment on this

We won the by-elections.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

If that is weakness, indecision and mediocrity, I am happy to have these qualities.

Comment on this

It is beginner's luck.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I did not parade the all-Ireland Cup around the constituency as Fine Gael did. That is not the end of this personal attack on me. The article goes on to say:

He was elected because .... he is not a sufficiently strong character to provoke antagonism.

I promise that before I get out of this Seat the people in the Fine Gael Party will get as much antagonism from me as will make them blue in their faces. That antagonism is not going to come by means of shouting here but from the success this Government are going to produce for the economy of this country.

Comment on this

Más maith é is mithid.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am not denying we have had difficulties for the past year-and-a-half. I did not deny it in Waterford. It is because I did not deny it, because I explained how these came about and what action we had to take, it is because I explained to the people of South Kerry and Waterford that they would have to work hard with the Government to overcome our difficulties, it was because I said that to them and did not make any rosy promises that they came with us. They were prepared to believe me and to believe that Fianna Fáil were the only Party who could overcome those difficulties, and lead the country forward successfully again.

I made an appeal in the course of my opening remarks for co-operation between people engaged in both sides of industry. Our country does not belong to any single group. It does not belong to industrialists or to workers. It does not belong to the self-employed or to political Parties or to the Government. This country belongs to all the people and to a lot of generations yet unborn. I believe that whether we are in Opposition or in Government, what we do in the next couple of years, how we fashion our economy, how we prepare for these crucial years ahead, will determine what place we in this country will have in the future. In the next few years, we shall feel the full blast of free industrial and agricultural trade and, unless we by that time have geared our economy to withstand that blast, I do not think we will get the chance to catch up again. However, I believe that now that we have been given the mandate to press forward with our policies, we shall overcome those difficulties. The people will understand what our goal is. We shall bring them along with us and achieve the same rate of progress as we achieved in the period from 1958-1964 which was spectacular by any standards, especially any standards ever achieved in this country before. I believe this is possible and I believe this Government will do it.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 67
·
Níl 56
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?