We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Finance Bill, 1967: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–137 of 270. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 8 of 1967 ›

Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 1 in the name of Deputy Noel Lemass not moved?

Comment on this

Is it open to me to move it, Sir, in the absence of Deputy Lemass?

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Unless the Deputy has the permission of Deputy Lemass to move it, he may not.

Comment on this

I have not got it.

Comment on this

Deputy Lemass was only codacting. Everybody knows that. I am sorry he did not move it. I would have liked to have made him swallow his words by not voting.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3, in the name of Deputy T.F. O'Higgins:

In page 3, lines 36 and 37, to delete "full-time".

Comment on this

Have you his permission?

Comment on this

I have, but what I have not got is my note. The Minister was not the only person to arrive without his papers today.

Comment on this

Perhaps in the interval I might explain what my view of the section is? As most Deputies know, the housekeeper allowance is at present granted to a widower or a widow or a husband whose wife has deserted him. The purpose of the section is to extend that housekeeper allowance to a married woman not living with her husband who has presumably, deserted her. We want to put the deserted wife in the same position as the deserted husband at the moment.

The reason we specified "full-time" is that, if we did not, it would leave it wide open to all sorts of people to avail of this who would not really be entitled to it, strictly speaking. Unless we use some words like "full-time" the most nominal type of employment would entitle a woman to secure this concession. The idea is that it is given to a woman who, because of the full-time nature of the occupation she undertakes, has to be absent from her home and therefore has to employ somebody to look after her children.

Comment on this

The Minister's argument may be all very well to avoid what I shall call the fake claim, but he must accept also that many young widows with young families cannot take a completely full-time job. They have to give some time and attention to their families and take a job that may be a half-time job or even a three-quarter-time job. Therefore, they have to have somebody to look after the young family while they are out. Surely that case deserves much more consideration than is being given to it by the Minister?

I can see the Minister's point of view that a person could get around the section by working for five minutes in the day. I am quite prepared to meet the Minister on that, but full-time employment takes the matter too far the other way. Some phraseology to the effect that she is engaged in some trade or profession which occupies at least half working time would, I think, be a fair compromise. I am with the Minister in so drafting the Act that there will not be the avoidance of the type he suggests. Equally, I think the present wording of it is far too rigid and it ought to be possible to arrive at a halfway house that would be feasible and fair both ways.

Comment on this

I would be inclined to support Deputy O'Higgins's amendment but it does appear that, perhaps, the wording is a little too loose. The Minister must take into account a person who is working for a period and whose major income is what he gets for that period. If the phraseology used could be related to that, it would meet the bill. I would ask the Minister to consider dealing with this matter at a later stage or in the Seanad.

There is one other thing. The fact that there might be fraud is hardly worth considering. The amount of money involved is very small. There is the substitution of £135 for £120. The amount involved would be £15 at 5/3. I do not think anybody would be inclined to bother trying to obtain that fraudulently, or even the whole £35 at 5/3. For that reason, the Minister, if he wants to help, should phrase it in such a way that it would refer to persons who are getting their major income from this sum.

Comment on this

It would not necessarily apply only to persons who would be practising fraud. Unless we put in words to that effect, everybody would be legitimately entitled to it who worked five minutes a day. They would not necessarily have to be practising fraud. I want to repeat this assurance to the House, that this provision will be administered in a very liberal and sensible way and I also want to say that I will interpret and the Revenue Commissioners also will interpret "full-time" as covering the case of a woman who could show that she is working what might be regarded as the normal hours for the occupation in which she is engaged. We would certainly consider her as working full-time.

Comment on this

Supposing she is working as a typist, half-day?

Comment on this

I cannot attempt to deal with everything here. The sort of thing I am thinking of is this: supposing you had a receptionist whose normal work hours were three or four hours in the morning. Provided that she is working the full amount of hours which would normally be understood to be the appropriate amount for the occupation, then we would regard her as working full-time. I would also envisage "full-time" being interpreted to cover a case where the employment involved lengthy absences from home and where the earnings involved substantially represented the means of subsistence of the taxpayer and the children. In other words, if, by virtue of the employment, she were away from home for considerable periods of time and the amount she earned was reasonably equivalent to full maintenance for herself and her family, this also would qualify as full-time.

Comment on this

The Minister's approach is extremely stingy. The Minister may say that this will be dealt with liberally but did anyone ever see the income tax people dealing liberally with anybody? Do we not all know they try to screw the very last penny when it comes to assessing tax and is it not true that unless it is written into the Bill and is in fact laid down so that it cannot be twisted in any way, there will be no remission at all except for those working full-time? The Minister might as well face up to it. Either change it and include "full-time" or delete "full-time".

Comment on this

I do not accept Deputy Tully's view of the administration of the Act.

Comment on this

You do not have to.

Comment on this

No, I do not. But I do think that Deputy Tully is right, for this reason: the Revenue Commissioners have got to interpret the Act and administer the Act that is before them and the Bill that is before us does not allow of liberal interpretation. It is as specific and as restrictive as it could possibly be and there is no use in the Minister saying that it will be interpreted in a liberal way when the wording of the section which the Revenue Commissioners under their warrant of appointment have to carry out does not allow of any liberal interpretation. It could be covered, if you like, by phraseology such as I suggested already or by such phraseology as "throughout the year is in reasonably full-time employment". If it is specifically, as it is there, "in full-time employment", there is no use in abusing the Revenue Commissioners and the inspectors of taxes for carrying that out. The person to be abused is the Minister for Finance who brings in the Bill and who has so phrased the Bill that it is restrictive and cannot be interpreted in any other way.

Comment on this

Deputy Tully says that the Minister is being extremely stingy. I do not think this is the case. The Minister is doing something that has not been done before—let us be fair to him there—broadening the scope of relief not previously available. It is true to say that in this section we are treating of deserted wives. Is that not so?

Comment on this

Of whom there are quite a number in this country.

Comment on this

They must be very few and far between and I wish we could prevail on the Minister to go the whole hog and to have regard to the reality of the situation, that there is plenty of part-time work of a clerical nature available in this city today. I know nothing about the rest of the country. I mentioned typists This is the sort of work which a deserted wife with three or four or five young children is likely to take to, working for half a day.

Comment on this

She would hardly be paying tax on part-time employment if she has a young family.

Comment on this

I grant you that. The Minister will concede that the housekeeping allowance dealt with in this section is only £100—a very modest allowance—and to be fair to himself, to do justice to himself, the Minister should go the whole hog and accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I am in difficulty here. The idea behind this, of course, and the idea behind the use of the phrase "full-time", is that a woman's employment or business must entail a substantial absence from her home, must, bona fide, necessitate the employment by her of a housekeeper. I think we are all agreed on that. If a woman is necessarily absent from home sufficiently long to have to employ a housekeeper, then we would all like her to qualify.

I want to put the opposite point of view. I want to say that by using "full-time" here we are, in fact, making it flexible. What is "full-time"? For a Senator, for instance, "full-time" employment as a Senator does not by any means equate with full-time employment for a Deputy. "Full-time" in this regard may be used flexibly as related to the type of employment a woman would take. If the employment necessitates being absent for only half a day, that is full-time employment, whereas, if we go the other way at it and try to spell out the circumstances in which she will be entitled to this allowance, then we will probably bring unnecessary rigidity into it, which I know Deputies would be anxious to avoid.

I am giving the House a solemn assurance that the term "full-time" will be sensibly interpreted. I do not quite agree with Deputy Sweetman that that assurance by me in this House is of no value because, admittedly, the revenue officers have to interpret the law and apply it without fear or favour or distinction. But, here what we are dealing with is the actual interpretation of this phrase and this single phrase, not the section as a whole, just this phrase. I think they will be quite within their jurisdiction in interpreting "full-time" in the way in which I am describing it.

Comment on this

I am sure that if the Minister checks through the various Government Departments he will find there is an interpretation of "full-time" which does not equate with what he has just been saying; in fact, if the person is full-time, it will be taken that he or she is employed for a set number of hours per day.

Comment on this

Not necessarily.

Comment on this

If the Minister checks, he will find that the interpretation, even in his own Department, of "full-time" cannot be taken as two or three hours. I should like to see included in the Bill something which would protect the interest of a woman who is living in Ballyfermot—if Deputy Dunne were here, he would tell me there are no deserted wives in Ballyfermot—or in some other part of the city, and has to travel across town to a job which she may be doing for only two hours in the morning and two in the evening. Because she has this job, she has to get somebody to look after one or two small children at home. My reading of this provision would be that that type of woman will not qualify. I am quite sure the Revenue Commissioners will be the very first to say that the law does not allow them to include her because she is not employed full-time. I do not wish to delay the House by pressing this, but surely it should not be beyond the competence of the Minister, between now and the introduction of this Bill in the Seanad, to have the matter investigated and try to find out something which would meet the wishes of the House? It is not a big matter. Deputy Byrne says there are not many of them; I think there are too many, but the amount involved is very small and it is not going to make or break the Minister's next Budget, if he has a next Budget.

Comment on this

It could be very large if we do not have some restriction on it. Deputies do not have to force me very hard to do things for deserted wives, and I should like to remind them that was the approach right from the Succession Act to the various other pieces of legislation which I introduced, and it is in that context I introduced this provision into the Bill. However, I have a difficulty, and it seems to me at any rate that this is the best and most flexible way of tackling the problem. I do not mind undertaking to look at it again.

Comment on this

Why not substitute "bona fide” for “full-time”.

Comment on this

I am not sure "bona fide” would help in that content.

Comment on this

I think it would.

Comment on this

I want to say in reply to Deputy Tully that it is not the hours that a person works the Revenue Commissioners will look at; it is the period of absence from home. If between travelling to her place of employment and the hours she works, a long absence from home is entailed, and if the amount she earns is reasonably equivalent to what is necessary to maintain a wife and family, that will certainly qualify as full-time.

Comment on this

Surely a person earning a taxable income must automatically be taken as full-time?

Comment on this

Regular employment.

Comment on this

If a salary is taxable over a year, surely the employment must be full-time?

Comment on this

Would Deputies agree to let it go for a year and see how it works out? I should point out that this is the exact phraseology used in the British Act and it has not caused any problem there.

Comment on this

What I am saying is that if a person earns sufficient to be taxable, say, £300 or £400, that alone proves it is full-time employment. Anybody who earns enough to come under the tax law——

Comment on this

It might be only £50 and there might be £500 private income or investment income.

Comment on this

Why not work it the other way around: let the amended provision run for a year and see if there is any bad avoidance?

Comment on this

I should like to try it as it is for a year, and if any Deputies come up with cases of hardship during the year, we can fix it next year.

Comment on this

I should like it done the other way, and if the Minister was able to come up with cases of avoidance——

Comment on this

There is nothing to be lost by undertaking to look at it between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

Would the Minister just remind me what is section 335?

Comment on this

In what connection?

Comment on this

It is related to friendly societies.

Comment on this

What is the point of section 7?

Comment on this

This is to increase from £300 to £1,000 the amount by which a registered friendly society can insure a member and still maintain exemption from income tax under Schedules A, C and D. This is in line with the change made in the Credit Union Act.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say why section 335 is being amended and section 336 is not being so amended? Why is the sum there not raised from £600 to £1,000 and the yearly annuity from £350 to £500? Surely it should follow?

Comment on this

If there is a case for one, there would seem to be a case for the other.

Comment on this

Section 336 is covered by trade union legislation.

Comment on this

Yes. Has the Minister anything against trade unions?

Comment on this

No, not at all. This, as I say, is simply to bring this provision into line with the change in the credit union legislation.

Comment on this

The reason for introducing that legislation was the change in money values, and, therefore, the Minister is entitled to change it here. Surely section 336 would also require amendment because there is a change of money values there?

Comment on this

It would require a change in the trade union legislation first.

Comment on this

It would not. The Minister can change this without changing trade union legislation at all.

Comment on this

It would not make any sense.

Comment on this

Of course it would make sense.

Comment on this

Unless the trade unions are empowered to do it, there would be no sense in that. It would not exempt them from income tax.

Comment on this

If the Minister introduces the amendment to section 336, it can follow. There is no reason why we should not do it.

Comment on this

It is putting the cart before the horse.

Comment on this

A start must be made somewhere, and there would be no point in changing the trade union end of it without the provision being made in the Bill to allow it to happen. If money value has dropped in the other case, surely the case is just as strong for a change here? Would the Minister have a look at it to see if there is validity in the argument I am making?

Comment on this

Surely the trade union provision was altered in 1963?

Comment on this

Not in the same way. That was the first time since 1918.

Comment on this

As I say, it is a question of putting the cart before the horse. It seems to me that what we do here is follow practice. If the benevolent societies, the credit unions or anybody else want to raise these figures, then we make sure that our income tax provisions keep in line. As I understand it, the trade unions do not provide £1,000 or anything like that for their members and section 336 was agreed with the trade unions as adequate to cover what they are doing.

Comment on this

If I assure the Minister that it is as a result of a request from a substantial number of trade unions that I make this plea that they should be permitted to do this will be reconsider the matter?

Comment on this

The Deputy means there are trade unions which would, if permitted, give greater benefits?

Comment on this

If permitted, yes.

Comment on this

I certainly will consider that.

Comment on this

This deals with section 344 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, into which was carried the exact wording that had been in earlier sections. I find considerable difficulty not in dealing with this administratively but in understanding the actual wording of subsection (1) of section 344. I am surprised that I should find that difficulty. The present position factually is that if a person has deposit interest which is less than £50 per annum, that deposit interest is exempt from income tax assessment. On the other hand, if a person has £55 deposit interest, the first £50 is exempt and the assessment is made on the excess over £50. The effect of this amendment is to change the £50 to £70. I have no difficulty whatever in understanding the wording of section 334 in relation to a sum by way of deposit interest received by an individual up to £70 per annum but, if a person has £75 worth of deposit interest per annum, after this section is passed, I take it the intention of the Minister is that the first £70 will be clear of assessment and the remaining £5 will be assessed. Am I correct in that?

Comment on this

No. I think the Deputy is overlooking the words "or in so far as".

Comment on this

Is it the intention that, if a person has £71 deposit interest in a year, he will get no exemption at all?

Comment on this

No. He gets the £1.

Comment on this

No. He gets £70.

Comment on this

That is the intention. It is either going to be the first £70 of deposit interest, or less than £70, if it is less. In section 344 subsection (1), it is stated "said sums shall be disregarded for the purposes of this Act if or in so far as the said sums do not exceed £50". I cannot see where in that there is authorisation that only the excess on £50—£70 now—is to be taxed. I should have thought a more reasonable approach to the drafting of section 344, except that it had to be taken from the previous Act, would be that the basis would be that, if the interest were under £50——

Comment on this

May I interrupt? It seems to me that the words "in so far as" cover the position.

Comment on this

In so far as the sums do not exceed £50.

Comment on this

First of all, it says a sum of money; if it does not exceed £50, it is out.

Comment on this

Agreed.

Comment on this

In so far as it does not exceed £50, it is out.

Comment on this

But if it does exceed £50, what then?

Comment on this

Suppose it is £54, then the £50 is excluded. That is the old figure.

Comment on this

I am aware of the administrative way of dealing with it but I do not think that is the right interpretation from the point of view of language. It is interpreted the other way. The right answer comes but the phraseology is wrong.

Comment on this

Suppose a person has an income of £700 a year from investments, or something, is he taxed then on £630?

Comment on this

I still do not think the phrasing is right. However, the result is right.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 4 and 5 may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

Before section 10 to insert a new section as follows:—

"Section 186 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, is hereby amended by the deletion of subsection (2)".

The purpose of these amendments is to ensure that it will not be possible in future for the income tax authorities to go back ad infinitum. Let me say at once that we all accept that, if there is a case of fraud, then there should be no time limit on that fraud. Everybody accepts that without question. However, the effect of subsection (2) of section 186 of the Income Tax Act is that the Revenue Commissioners can go back for 45 years. I am not quite certain if they can go back even before the inception of the State. Certainly they can go back 45 years. Very often it is extremely difficult for a taxpayer to have the kind of records to deal with what is required and the Revenue Commissioners are in a most unfair position vis-à-vis that taxpayer. This case has been made to the Minister on many occasions. It was made very forcibly this year in a joint memorandum submitted by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland and the Incorporated Law Society. They made it clear that they thought the time had come for a review of the time limits in the making of assessments, time limits which extend back over 44 years. Incidentally, are they entitled to go back beyond 1922?

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that the 46th year at least is out. To go back to 1922 seems to me to be quite absurd in present circumstances. That was not the law originally. Up to 1936 there was a six-year time limit. The law was then changed to enable assessments to be made from 1922-1923 onwards. That meant the Revenue Commissioners were then entitled to go back 15 years. Now they are entitled to go back 45 years. I urge the Minister very strongly that is unreasonably long. It is, in fact, quite indefensible. On the other side of the water, assessments can be made only for six years, unless fraud is established. They have found there that the power of going back for six years is quite adequate and I do not understand why, if it is adequate there, it is not adequate here. The penalty provisions are such that if there is fraud, adequate compensation can be obtained by the State. Where no fraud has been established, it is unreasonable to have a state of uncertainty continuing for such a long time, for 40 years or more.

The merit of the amendment does not depend only on the submissions made by the two bodies. It is also dealt with in the Seventh Report of the Commission on Income Taxation, pages 91 and 92, paragraphs 301 to 305. It has been suggested that the time limit was extended to enable tax to be recovered because of delay in unearthing evasion. If there was evasion of that sort, there must have been fraud and the ministerial statement of 1936 was not a case at all for this provision. The Seventh Report comes down flatly in paragraph 305 and recommends that claims for recovery of tax should not be made later than ten years after the year in which the tax is chargeable. That is four years longer than in Britain and four years longer than was the case here in the period from 1922 to 1936. Bearing in mind that in most cases penalties can be raised which would greatly exceed the tax evaded, there does not seem to me to be any case in relation to the power to go back 45 years. I would ask the Minister to accept the recommendation made in the Seventh Report of the Commission set up by a most enlightened Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

I would also like to speak on this amendment. It seems to me that here is a matter of principle which can be understood by most people. We have often said that the income tax code, as a code of taxation, is not one that has enjoyed general popularity but I am sure that can be said in relation to any system or method of taxation. But when one finds, as one finds in this respect, that a system of taxation has features which appear, prima facie, to be unfair to the taxpayer, then we should entertain a suggestion for its amendment. The ordinary taxpayer who, for one reason or another, ignorance, confusion or mistake, has been overcharged in relation to taxation and has overpaid for a number of years is restricted by our present law in making a claim for overpayment to a period of six years. When that period of six years became part of our income tax code, the Revenue Commissioners were equally restricted on their side to a back date of six years. When the change was made which means that the State can go back effectively almost to the beginning of time, certainly to 1922-23, which covers the span of most people's earning life, the taxpayer was still restricted to a claim for six years. I do not think that is fair and I would be interested to hear what case can be made for providing an inequality of treatment of that kind as between the State and the taxpayer.

If the individual can go back only six years, why should it be that the taxation authority should have no such restriction? Why should it be that the individual taxpayer can never feel that he has settled his accounts with the State? The taxpayer must always be under the fear and the danger that an assessment can be mounted against him going back into years where, effectively, the taxpayer cannot deal with the matter. The six year limit which applies in relation to most claims for debt has been found on experience to be very fair and it is felt that if a six year is exceeded, a liability should not remain hanging over a person.

That is approaching the matter from the point of view of ordinary people looking at a code which, if it is to be maintained, should be as equitable as possible. In addition to that, there is the strong recommendation from the Commission on Income Taxation referred to by Deputy Sweetman which asks that the almost unlimited right to make a back assessment should be limited to ten years. Why the Commission recommended that period of ten years is another matter and personally I do not see why they did so. It seems an unduly long period and to my mind, the difference they make between the rights of the taxpayer and the rights of the Revenue Commissioners does not seem justifiable. What is accepted as fair for the individual should be accepted as fair for the State.

Comment on this

It appears as if the Deputy's amendment has a lot of merit. He says that in this case the State is trying to have it both ways. If the period over which taxation can be recovered by the citizen is six years, then surely there should be a limit on the period the State can recover tax which is considered due? Another angle which might have a bigger effect on the matter than anything else is that, over the years, the approach by the State to the matter may have altered. By going back 12 or 15 years, it could happen that a person would not be in a position to prove something which was easily capable of proof at the time and which justified the person in the amount of tax paid or the amount of tax he or she refused to pay. Such evidence might not be available after a period of years and is a very strong argument in favour of Deputy O'Higgins's amendment.

Comment on this

Nobody in this House holds any brief for the evasion of income tax. In so far as the continuance of the powers which we seek to repeal might be necessary in order to curb evasion, our case for repeal would be so much weaker. In this context, however, I think it is essential to have a look at the entire picture, to look at the developments, based on the recommendations of the Commission, which have transpired in the past few years in regard to strengthening the powers of the Revenue Commissioners to deal with income tax evasion.

The part of the Seventh Report to which Deputy Sweetman referred dealt with that aspect of the matter. Their report, advocating restriction on the right of the Revenue Commissioners to re-open cases to ten years, as urged by us, was a corollary of their major recommendation which was that the hand of the Revenue Commissioners should be strengthened. That has been done. The need for the continued existence of these undesirable and unjust powers is no longer there.

It is essential to have a look at the position in 1936 when the then Minister for Finance, Deputy MacEntee, repealed the six-year limit of British law. He was concerned about unearthing evasion in the troublesome 15 or 16 years prior to 1936 in this country. I do not think it was in the mind of the Minister for Finance or of the Revenue Commissioners in 1936 that this power should continue indefinitely. I am convinced it was not—and I read Deputy MacEntee's speech pretty carefully.

Our amendment is based on the report of the Commission on Income Taxation and is backed by the submission referred to by Deputy Sweetman, the submission made to the Minister by the Institute of Chartered Accountants and the Incorporated Law Society. I referred to this matter here a fortnight ago on Second Stage. I gave the Minister advance word of these amendments. The Minister then said it had been indicated to the Institute of Chartered Accountants that the practice was, except in cases of fraud, not to go back beyond the six-year period and that this practice has the formal sanction of the Minister for Finance.

As far as I am aware, there is no part of the income tax law which provides machinery for the Minister for Finance to indicate formal sanction of what is or is not good and practice, no matter how good, is not legislation. This House must look to its rights. This is a House of Parliament. It is our job to legislate. It is not for a Minister to come along and say what is good practice. If it were done by statutory order, duly submitted to the processes of the House, it might be quite another matter but there is no such machinery in existence.

We do not want Government legislation by practice, by promise of Ministers, by undertakings or by formal sanctions. That is not good parliamentary practice. It is not good legislation. It is unsound in principle. I cannot, for the life of me, understand why the Minister should resist the amendment——

Comment on this

He has not said he is resisting it.

Comment on this

Perhaps I am jumping to conclusions. Hope springs eternal. As I said here a fortnight ago, I am conscious of the fact that Deputy Haughey is the first chartered accountant to become Minister for Finance. I expect much from him in the way of tax reform. He understands these matters as none of his predecessors did.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this

I was referring to his Fianna Fáil predecessors. I am quite deflated and I do not think I can say very much more on the issue except to repeat that if the Minister was genuinely sincere in what he said on the Second Stage, then he must accept the amendment. Our proposed amendment, No. 5, comes from the British Income Tax Act of 1952. I have strong views about copying British legislation in this country but if it has got to be done, then let us go the whole hog and copy it properly and comprehensively. I urge the Minister to accept this very desirable amendment.

Comment on this

I should, just briefly, like to support this amendment. As Deputy Byrne has said, Deputy Haughey is the first Minister for Finance who is a chartered accountant and we all have high hopes that he will have a more broadminded approach to these problems. I do not know whether or not the Minister has as yet indicated his intentions in this matter. I would hope that his training as an accountant, plus his ordinary sense of fair play, will encourage him to accept the amendment rather than resist it. It seems very unreasonable that the Revenue Commissioners should have the die loaded very much in their favour while it is very much loaded against the ordinary private citizen. Ordinary justice demands that both sides of the balance get equal play. If a limit of six years is good enough for the ordinary citizen to claim back from the Revenue Commissioners, then they, in their turn, ought to be satisfied with claiming from the individual in respect of a back period of six years. If, as the Minister indicated, it is the practice not to go back farther than six years, then, as Deputy Byrne says, we ought to get away from the practice and make it formal by accepting this amendment so that everybody will know where he stands and will have the same degree of security in the situation which is what we have not now got.

Comment on this

I should like to support this amendment. Apparently, we increasingly live in an age of bureaucracy in which the State has one right on its side and the ordinary individual is denied rights in return. As I see the position, first of all, no estate under this could conclusively be wound up forever. There is nothing to stop somebody in the Revenue Commissioners or in the Department of Finance from deciding, for instance in the case of a person who died a great many years ago, that inappropriate tax was paid on his estate so that the whole position of the estate would be brought to life again. This imposes tremendous expense on those who succeed the deceased or even on the individual who is still living.

Comment on this

Section 211 covers that.

Comment on this

It covers the living taxpayer.

Comment on this

That is a small consolation. However, it is something. In any case, I do not see why the State should have any particular privilege over a private individual. Further than that, if the State owes me money, if I discover I have paid too much income tax—which I feel I most certainly have done over the years— after seven or eight years, I have no rights at all. I cannot get the money from the State because I am statutorily barred after six years. Here we are asked to legislate to make it right for the Revenue Commissioners to chase a person after six years and take the money from him. It is unjust and inequitable, and I am very strongly in favour of this amendment. We should resist the other proposal as much as we can.

It has to be accepted that the ordinary individual has not got a file or a shoal of clerks, officials, or typists to help him. Anybody who is brought into court or brought back into the arena of having to pay tax in regard to some years ago, is placed at a tremendous disadvantage. The Minister should consider these things. It is absolutely unreasonable to take a person back over a period of years and say to him: "You did not pay sufficient tax in 1947 and we are now going to bring it up again and bring you into court". It may be suggested that you committed fraud. If you are taken into court to argue the matter and you have to seek legal advice—and I may say that legal advice is not always cheaply obtained—you have to go to all these expenses. Are we to know that the State will pay the expenses if they fail to prove their case, or are we to find ourselves in the position that the State is free from any charges imposed on the private individual? The Minister could very easily accept this amendment. If he does, another deathblow will be struck at bureaucracy which is growing day by day to the detriment of each one of us.

Comment on this

I would appeal to Deputies to try, if possible, to see this from my side. Deputy O'Higgins does not approach this with the right attitude. This is not a game which is played between the Revenue Commissioners and the taxpayers. It is not a question of playing a game according to the rules and everybody being under the same restrictions. After all, there is a fundamental difference between the Revenue and the taxpayers in this regard. The taxpayer knows his own circumstances, knows his own resources, income, capital, assets and so on, but the Revenue do not. The Revenue can only find out and endeavour to assess and collect income tax on the basis of certain limited powers which we confer upon them.

Therefore, to begin with, the two parties are not at all equal. It is not, as I say, a question of playing a game; it is a question of trying to enable the Revenue to do their job, to give them the power to collect the taxes which we need to run the State. It is not a question of being able to outwit the Revenue Commissioners for six years and then you have got away with it. It is a simple matter that anybody who is liable to pay income tax, surtax or any other tax, should pay it, and that is that. Therefore, I do not think there is an analogy at all between the situation of the taxpayer claiming back overpayments from the State and the ability of the Revenue to re-open cases where there has been either fraud or wilful neglect. That is all we are talking about, cases where there has been fraud or wilful neglect, because it is the unvarying practice of the Revenue Commissioners not to go back further than six years except where they are satisfied that there has been fraud or neglect.

To refer to what Deputy Sweetman said, as he and other Deputies know, the Revenue Commissioners received a deputation from the Institute of Incorporated Accountants in regard to this matter and the whole business was discussed very fully and frankly. My understanding is that the Revenue Commissioners made it absolutely clear to the chartered accountants that in no case did they go back beyond six years unless there was fraud or wilful neglect.

Comment on this

That is what the amendment is seeking.

Comment on this

We are giving you ten years in the amendment.

Comment on this

I do not want ten years; I want six years.

Comment on this

Does that mean that they do not go back beyond six years?

Comment on this

Unless there has been fraud or wilful neglect.

Comment on this

When the Minister says that the Revenue do not go back except where there is fraud, does it not only become fraud when it has been proved to be fraud? Surely there are borderline cases where people do not know——

Comment on this

Fraud in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners.

Comment on this

Perhaps this may arise after ten or 12 years when you may not have your receipts. Personally, I have not even got receipts after three years.

Comment on this

The Revenue Commissioners have to establish that there was fraud.

Comment on this

Then you have to defend yourself in a case which may be ten to 15 years years old.

Comment on this

You have to do that in any aspect of administration and——

Comment on this

But then you only do it——

Comment on this

If you committed murder 20 years ago, you do not get away with it because you say you cannot remember.

However, I want to put another few aspects of this to the House. Deputies are quoting the situation in Britain but the situation in Britain is not qute as straightforward or as simple as some Deputies have indicated. The British authorities evidently found it necessary to bring in a number of amendments to protect themselves. In particular, they brought in, by section 51 of the 1960 Finance Act, an amendment which extended the time limit for making assessments in cases of neglect —neglect now, not wilful neglect— neglect simpliciter which did not amount to fraud or wilful neglect. We confine ourselves to fraud and wilful neglect. In 1960 they brought in this provision and they extended the time limit beyond six years where there is simple neglect. They define “neglect” in that context as meaning negligence or failure to give any notice, make any return, statement or declaration, or to produce or furnish any list, document or other information required by or under the Income Tax Acts. That is a very wide and sweeping definition.

Comment on this

Does that mean where there is no return?

Comment on this

In any of these cases they say neglect covers negligence or failure to give any notice, make any return, statement or declaration or to produce or furnish any list, document or other information required by or under the Income Tax Acts. When they brought that in, they said that if an assessment had been raised within the normal six year period, they could go back a further six years dating from the year of assessment. I mention this to show that it is not true to say that in Britain they do not go back beyond six years simpliciter.

To go back again to the chartered accountants. They were received by the Revenue Commissioners at my request, and they had long and fruitful discussions about the matter, and my understanding is that they indicated that they would be satisfied if they could have from the Revenue Commissioners a letter confirming that the practice was that cases were not re-opened, other than cases of fraud or wilful neglect, beyond a limit of six years. That letter has been issued to the chartered accountants stating that in practice cases are not re-opened beyond a six-year limit. I have no evidence, and nothing to suggest, that the Institute are not satisfied with that assurance.

Another assurance I want to give Deputies is that there is no question ever of an inspector of taxes making, outside the six-year limit, an additional assessment on the same set of facts simply because he has changed his mind in regard to the facts. Deputies are inclined to look at this from one point of view very largely. I want to suggest that there is another point of view about the procedure that is there at present. It is a simple, flexible and well-established procedure, and it enables Revenue to go back and open up appropriate cases. We think they should be entitled to, where there is a deliberate attempt to deceive. If we spell out in a statute that they cannot go back beyond six years, we put the onus on them of establishing fraud and that is a very difficult thing to do. As I say, they do not in practice go back beyond six years.

Comment on this

Can the Minister say what happens about costs if fraud is not proven?

Comment on this

They follow the event.

Comment on this

I want to take up one phrase the Minister used. The Minister says: "Look, the Revenue Commissioners do not go back beyond six years unless it is a case of fraud or wilful neglect." I accept that that is the practice and experience judged from the point of view of the Revenue Commissioners, but we are legislating here and we are dealing with what the law of the land is. The law of the land provides that the Revenue Commissioners can go back in effect to any point. They can go back to 1922 or 1923. Applying the law to what the Minister says is the experience of the Revenue Commissioners, the fact is that when the Revenue Commissioners decide that this is a case of fraud or wilful neglect, they bring in a back assessment. That is a decision against which there is no appeal because the power is there to make a back assessment. It may be wrong, unfair, or contrary to the facts, but so long as we permit our taxation code to operate in effect under unwritten laws, the taxpayer has no rights and no remedy.

The situation is worse because he is then branded as a person who has committed a fraud on Revenue, a person who is guilty of gross and wilful negligence. He has no way of ventilating his case because the machine goes on, and there is a back assessment, and there is nothing he can do about it. In my view, that pinpoints how unfair this is. If the law said: "If there is a case of fraud or a case of wilful neglect, then there will be no time limit", that would mean that before some court or some independent person the Revenue Commissioners would have to say: "All right; here is our evidence that this is fraud or wilful neglect", and the taxpayer, in accordance with ordinary justice, would be entitled to say: "That is wrong because of A, B, C or D", and someone would decide the issue one way or the other. I do not see what is wrong with that. It is in accordance with what the Minister says is the policy of the Revenue Commissioners.

I am sorry to have to say this, but this is obviously the point of view of bureaucracy—and Deputy Esmonde is perfectly correct—as expressed by the Minister. I think that, on reflection, he will agree because he said that if we changed the law, we would be putting the onus on the Revenue Commissioners to prove fraud. Why should that onus not be there? If we all agree that it is fair and just that there should be a time limit of six years except in a case of fraud—and there is no disagreement about that—why should the onus not be on the Revenue Commissioners to prove fraud? Why should we allow a situation in which someone who is nameless in a back room decides for some reason, never stated, that this is a case of fraud, and the taxpayer can never answer that anonymous person who makes that allegation for reasons which are never disclosed? Surely that is unfair?

I agree entirely that there is an obligation and a clear responsibility on the taxpayer to settle his accounts with the State fully and honourably. I agree that it is a responsibility of the State and the Revenue Commissioners, within the framework of the law, to see that everyone discharges his just and due liability for tax. There is no disagreement about that. I would have no sympathy for people who feel it is a game, and who pit their wits and by blowing hot and cold, conceal these things. I am not making any case for people of that kind. I am talking about the majority of taxpayers, the person who endeavours to discharge his obligations, the person who does not wilfully conceal things, the person who is not in any way guilty of that kind of taxation fraud, but who, for some reason he is not told, finds, as has happened, make no mistake about it, that there has been a back assessment over that number of years, years he is not able to grapple with. Added to that back assessment, he is told in effect that the reason is that he has been guilty of fraud. He is convicted and tried in his absence. That is what I object to.

Comment on this

I want to join issue with the Deputy on that. It is not a question of trying a person for fraud at all.

Comment on this

I may have been exaggerating but I am stating it in that sense.

Comment on this

I want to put it as I see it. Here we say we have an inviolable practice that we do not go back beyond six years. We will go back beyond six years only if we are satisfied that there is fraud. All that fraud does is to operate to set the practice aside. The Revenue Commissioners are then free to abandon the practice and go back over previous assessments. The taxpayer is still perfectly entitled to defend himself on the facts before the Special Commissioners, the Circuit Court and even up to the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

On the facts of his liability, but not in relation to fraud.

Comment on this

If the Revenue Commissioners want to do anything about fraud, any person can defend himself again before the courts. It is not correct to say that somebody in a back room suggests there was fraud in this case and therefore the person is condemned. All that happens is that the decision of the Revenue Commissioners that this man is guilty of fraud simply enables them to set aside their standard practice of not going back and bringing the whole law into operation.

Comment on this

Is that not the same thing? I shall give an example. I am a taxpayer and have been having discussions perhaps over my tax liability. I find an assessment is made on me going back 20 years. I have to find out whether that assessment is right or wrong. The onus is on me to prove it is incorrect and I endeavour to do it one way or another. The only issue that arises from the assessment is my liability to the tax involved in the assessment and nothing else. But in fact the assessment has gone back 20 years because somebody decided I was guilty of fraud. That charge I cannot deal with. I have already been convicted of that.

Comment on this

If they charge you with fraud——

Comment on this

I am not talking about the penalties in relation to fraud. Somebody has decided I have been guilty of fraud and that is why they have gone back over the matter. In that sense, I say I have been tried and convicted.

Comment on this

Only to start the process.

Comment on this

There it is. All that is involved is whether the assessment is right and to what extent. In fact the assessment may be perfectly right. I make the Minister a present of that. But the reason I did not pay my tax was a genuine bona fide mistake, something that was not fraud, but I have to pay up. If in fact the boot were on the other foot and genuinely, through some mistake, I neglected to claim an allowance that I properly should have claimed and I find that for the past 20 years I should be getting such an allowance, there is no question of whether or to what extent my mistake was due to my fault or not. There is no discretion. There is an absolute barrier against going back beyond six years. There it is. I do not mean any disrespect to the Minister, but I have to go.

Comment on this

I should have liked to continue the argument with the Deputy, but no doubt he is leaving an able substitute. Deputies opposite lay a lot of stress on the situation in Britain. In fact, as we stand at present, we are more lenient than the British are. The British found themselves having to have a statutory dependence on fraud. That is what the Deputies opposite would like, too— that there would have to be a statutory barrier against going beyond six years unless there was fraud. The British found themselves in that position. They had a statutory dependence on fraud being established. They appear to have found it unworkable and brought in a provision so that in fact in Britain now you can go back indefinitely, providing there is "neglect", which is a much wider term altogether than we are using. We are confining it to fraud and wilful neglect. They can go back as far as they like in Britain, once they find simple neglect. Deputies cannot quote the British situation to me in favour of what they are arguing. I have a lot of sympathy with the point of view of the Deputies opposite, but I feel that, unless they can establish that the Revenue are not adhering to this practice and are in fact going back beyond six years in cases where there is not fraud or wilful neglect, they should not press the amendment.

Comment on this

In what other way could there be a mistake like that except through fraud or neglect?

Comment on this

There are two things. There is wilful neglect; in other words, a wilful omission to do something that the taxpayer should do. A taxpayer is compelled by law to fill in a return every year. If he wilfully does not do that, conceals his existence or his identity, that is wilful neglect on his part. Only in that case or in some such case could they go back beyond the six years and make additional assessments. In Britain they can go back six years by statute and back beyond six years if there is neglect. Neglect is a far wider term. It is defined as:

Negligence or failure to give any notice, make any return, statement or declaration or to produce or furnish any list, document or other information required by law under the Income Tax Acts.

So that a simple omission to supply some form or statement might mean that they are statutorily entitled to go back as far as they like.

Comment on this

Do the Revenue Commissioners collect much money on the basis of going back? Is there much money involved?

Comment on this