Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–168 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1967 ›
Before Deputy Cosgrave proceeds, in the unlikely event of the Dáil finishing before 2.30, is it proposed to take Questions then?
Comment on this
The Tánaiste would not understand: he has not been here often enough.
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling will not be here for the next 18 years.
Comment on this
Deputy Tully has asked if we are to have Questions at 2.30. That question has not been answered.
Comment on this
For goodness sake, you are ignorance personified.
Comment on this
Under the shadow of the guillotine, we refuse to discuss the remaining amendments or sections or the remaining Stages of the Livestock Marts Bill which seeks to give absolute control by means of legislation over a trade which has been traditionally free from such control and which has grown to its present satisfactory position in the agricultural community without any such control or direction. The fact that it has achieved this has conferred very considerable benefits on the agricultural community. In the shadow of the guillotine, which was introduced here last night, we are not a position to continue to discuss in a rational and democratic way the remaining Stages of this Bill but we propose with remorseless exactitude to oppose every remaining section and amendment.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 3a:
In page 2, line 16, to add "but does not include the sale otherwise than by auction of livestock the property of the proprietor of such a place".
Comment on this
I said quite definitely that the amendment may be discussed. The amendment was formally moved.
Comment on this
The amendment before the House — I want to know if the Minister wants to speak to it — is 3(a) on the Order Paper.
Comment on this
That is what I thought. It is rather difficult to know what is going on. So far as this amendment is concerned, it would appear that the Opposition, while they have said nothing, are in favour of their own amendment and I just want to point out the folly of their ways in wishing to have such an amendment inserted in this Bill.
Comment on this
May I point out that the amendment has been moved by me and has been supported by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
There can be no discussion on the motion: "That the question be now put." I am not accepting that motion.
Comment on this
At any rate, as I was saying when I was interrupted, the addition of these words would, in fact, be unnecessary to begin with and, secondly, would take from the intention and meaning of the section as it stands. The section would then read:
In this Act—
"business of a livestock mart" means the business of selling livestock by auction or providing, for the holding of sales of livestock by auction or otherwise, a place adapted for the sale of livestock by auction but does not include the sale otherwise than by auction of livestock the property of the proprietor of such a place.
Now, I know it makes no sense, but I am very concerned to know what sense Fine Gael thought there was in it.
Comment on this
That is what I suspect, but I would rather have heard from Fine Gael themselves, and I rather wonder at the fact that they are not discussing this amendment and are merely opposing it for opposition's sake — I forget the term used by the Leader of the Opposition — and whether it is that they now realise that this amendment is of a kind and kindred to those that have gone before and, indeed, will come after, that they never should have been put down, that they were never intended to be taken seriously or, if they were, their only purpose could be to nullify, or stultify, or make obscure, or confuse the definition section in the Bill.
Now I should like to suggest to the Opposition and to the House that this amendment does bring to notice two, three, or four and, maybe five, six, or seven interpretations, all of which, if added to the section as it stands, would make a very poor job. The words I am complaining about are those completely contained in the particular amendment and, if they were added, one interpretation I would put to the people who sponsored this amendment is that it would be impossible, if this were done, that the Bill could, in fact, be operated. This again, of course, is presented in a most humble fashion to the legal luminaries on the Opposition benches as my interpretation, as I see it. But, if the words were added, one interpretation I can see is that it would be impossible to operate the Bill as any livestock — any livestock — could become nominally the property of a proprietor of an unlicensed mart while they are in the mart for sale.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
One of the several interpretations that I feel are pretty obvious in regard to this amendment is that, if added, it would have the effect of nullifying the Bill, which may have been the intention, and, if it was not the intention, it would not do anything for the Bill other than to confuse and provide an escape for those who wish to run unlicensed marts as against those who are running licensed marts, who are doing the job properly today and will do it properly tomorrow. Fine Gael would be lending themselves, as their various confusing amendments have indicated, to encouragement of and provision for those who would evade the law to the detriment of those who observe it.
Do Fine Gael realise that this is one of the very definite side effects that some of these confusing amendments would have? They totally oppose the Bill — we can understand that. They are now totally something else and something else in regard to all parts of it today, including their own amendments, because they are not moving them or talking for or against them.
Comment on this
How will they oppose these things, if they will not oppose them? Why will they not do the decent thing and withdraw them, as this amendment should be withdrawn, or do they want to make further upheaval in the House, in the order of the place, and try to nullify the whole institution here by their methods now being adopted. This morning, they appear like spoiled children from whom the candy was taken last night, despite the fact that they knew the debate on this measure will end at 5 o'clock this afternoon. I asked them, the day before yesterday, to get on with the Bill and to discuss it and to give us the benefit of whatever they have to say which is worth hearing, but they are running away from it. Today, they are running away not only from the Bill but from the amendments. I am not surprised. That interpretation which I have given is one thing. There is an unlimited number of devices that, if these amendments were carried, could be used by those who wish to have unlicensed marts in the future, to evade licensing.
The very serious point about this is not so much that these people without licences would get away with running a mart improperly or a badly-constructed mart, or poorly serving the people or charging exorbitant fees or battening on the farming community but, in addition, they could discriminate against whom they wish at any time whether it be the large farmer, the middle-sized farmer, the small farmer, the dealer, the tangler, the shipper, the exporter or the people from the dead meat trade either here or from abroad. These things could all be done and any one of them could be done.
Are Fine Gael serious in their refusal to withdraw this amendment at this time? Are they really seriously allowing this to stand in their name that will have the effect, if carried, of giving to those who wish to break the law not only the facility to do it but the important thing is to compete unfairly against those who will abide by the law, who are, in fact, today, in their operations in their marts, without practical exception throughout the country conforming to what is required in this Bill? Are they to be thrown to the wolves by Fine Gael? Are they to be put in the position that unfair competition will be allowed to flourish by their side with the protection of a definition section rendered so abortive by this amendment?
Comment on this
On a point of order, I ask for a house. I think the Minister should not be allowed to speak to empty Fine Gael and Labour benches.
Comment on this
Is it not a rule of this House that the Government should keep a house?
Comment on this
Is it not the responsibility of the Parliamentary Secretary to ensure that a quorum is present?
Comment on this
An amendment from the Opposition benches is being discussed. We have to do that as well.
Comment on this
As I was pointing out, the very serious feature about this is not the facility with which the unlicensed mart would be enabled to evade the law and avoid licensing and any requirements that would be necessary for the good of the farming community and the benefit of the cattle trade and sales of cattle but those who are now conforming, those who have been talked about here, and rightly so, as to the input of capital and the efforts they have made over the years to establish marts, as we know them at the moment, these people who have striven in every way possible to build up structurally useful marts in all aspects, who have made the provisions that enable the veterinary regulations to be carried out, who adhere, by their structure, to the health regulations that apply through the local public health authority, would have their efforts nullified because of the fact that some bright spark down the road — maybe he would be Fine Gael: probably he would: probably this amendment was intended to let in these boyos on the cheap — would be enabled to trade unfairly. I should not mind letting them in without licences if that came to the point. Even if they broke the law, it would not be very serious from the point of view——
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
I was trying to point out that the seriousness of carrying an amendment such as this does not lie only in the facility with which the law might be broken by friends of those who put down the amendment, if needs be. It is not that to which I should really seriously object but to the manner in which the efforts of those who have striven and put capital into building up marts, and taken quite a number of years to do it, would be frustrated and probably they would be put in jeopardy in so far as their into carry on against unfair discrimination is concerned. That is very serious.
The breaking of the law, to anybody, must be serious, particularly to any of us here in the House, but it is only one point. The second point is the unfair trading and discrimination and the advantage that it would give to those who would throw up any old structure anywhere and get in and carry on without a licence. They could discriminate against those selling and against those buying; they could victimise people and not list them in the order in which they should be taken. They might not like the fellow who is in first and put him at the end of the day, at 8 o'clock or 9 o'clock in the evening, when whatever buyers were there had gone, when his particular type of animal, for various marketing reasons, would no longer be attractive from a sales point of view. He would have missed the boat as well as missing the market. In practice, this is what could happen, and undoubtedly would happen, if this sort of person who would be induced by this sort of looseness were allowed to get into the business. We do not want these people and the marts already established, as well as any that may come into being, whether private or co-operative, obviously do not want any part of this sort of trick of the trade in which that type of character would engage.
We have the further difficulty that without there being a requirement on these people who could evade a licence, they could evade all the requirements that may be necessary and that are already provided by the other marts. They could ignore these and from the point of view of veterinary operations, we as a Department could be in great difficulty and as a result our trade in cattle could be put in jeopardy, not at home but abroad. We have this matter of blue cards to be dealt with, and we have brucellosis coming along, and this has to be tied in in some system. We have had in operation the warble fly regulations and the certification of animals that were regarded as being clear. These matters could not be seen to properly by the officers of my Department where they would need to be seen to most, in an unlicensed establishment, where, no doubt, any sort of mixing of cattle would be allowed, the mixing of bulls and heifers, to the detriment of the trade. We would have no say in this sort of thing and we would just have to stand by and allow it.
Those friends of Fine Gael who helped to get this amendment before the House could do as they wished, not just for their own pleasure and good but for their undue benefit, for undue discrimination, victimisation and intimidation together with the aborting of the veterinary regulations which are required to be put into operation by my Department and by a number of importing countries. These requirements will be more onerous in the future and therefore will require to be better seen to and better regulated in the future. Existing marts and those which will be licensed will facilitate us in doing these things and carrying out new regulations now emerging from European countries, and particularly the Common Market. We could not allow this thing, even if we were inclined to——
Comment on this
This is not what Fine Gael are saying in this amendment. What they are saying is: "Let us go ahead and have the Marts Bill; let us destroy it in every detail we can, but still let us have it. Let us have as many loopholes as possible for the trick-of-the-loops." We do not want the trick-of-the loops. I am pointing out to Deputy L'Estrange that this amendment would facilitate and ensure the entry into the marts business of trick-of-the-loops who would not have to conform to any regulations whatsoever because this sort of amendment would take them right out of the terms and duties imposed on them by regulations under the Bill.
I should like to ask Fine Gael would they not think again, liverish and all though they may be this morning, and not blindly follow the course of action announced already that they are going to oppose everything all day today again. They are not going to discuss things but just oppose them. What is the purpose of this? Whom does it benefit? I do not think it benefits Fine Gael, but that is their business. I hate to see them really writing themselves off as an incompetent Opposition as well as a useless one, but it is not good for the standing of the House that an Opposition should behave, as they are behaving, like spoiled children from whom the candy has been taken.
Their amendments are not going to be discussed and there is no discussion on the sections of the Bill or what is in the Bill, and this is confirming what I suspected, that Fine Gael do not want to have the terms of the Bill ventilated. They are afraid to ventilate their own amendments, and if possible, they do not want to have any discussion so that the terms of the Bill and the ministerial amendments will not be brought to light and will not be seen to contain the benefits they undoubtedly do contain. I challenged Fine Gael last night, and I begged them at least to use today to discuss the Bill but they have fallen down completely. They have confirmed my worst fears that they do not want the public to know what is in the Bill.
Comment on this
No, this is the point. The public have been given to understand that the Bill contains many things which Fine Gael allege it contains but which it does not. This amendment, as other amendments, is held as being something useful and worthwhile, in an endeavour to show to the public a false picture in regard to what this section is intended to do.
Comment on this
Will you get a market for the farmers' cattle, sheep and wool? They are being annihilated.
Comment on this
What I should like to say is, that when things are not going your way in debate, or otherwise, do not start dragging in things which have nothing to do with the debate. This upsets the debate and makes for a longer discussion than is really necessary. I would appeal to the Deputy not to do that in the future. It is not good for him, for me, for the House or for the country. It certainly is no help to this Bill. It tends to put me off what I was about to say in regard to the amendment.
The devices I was talking about that could be used by the bright boys who would come into this are too numerous to mention, and probably not even all are known to me. It will take time to find them all out. One way we could find out would be to put this amendment through, or half a dozen of the Fine Gael amendments, and let the bright boys find their way through them, as they would. They would find so many holes that it would be like a sieve. Possibly this is now emerging as Fine Gael's real intention. If these words were added, it would read "would not include the sale otherwise than by auction of livestock the property of the proprietor of such a place." It is confusing. Its interpretation has the three disadvantages I have mentioned, the main one being the unfair competition that Fine Gael would bring about for the legitimate marts that will be licensed when this Bill goes through, the marts that have been doing such a good job, have invested so much capital and have been carrying out improvements over the years, as I am sure they will continue to do as time goes on.
I consider that the scandalous feature of this amendment. The Party regarded as the main Opposition Party have so little regard for the well-being of the marts, about which they have been shedding crocodile tears all these weeks, that they would deliberately— one might almost say, with malice aforethought — bring in an amendment that would put into competition with the legitimate marts that will be licensed in the future unlicensed trick-of-the-loops, who would not spend anything, not conform to anything, who would have advantages above and beyond the legitimate people doing their business properly, who would leave the Department and its regulations standing, who would ignore the local authorities in regard to hygiene and other regulations.
It concerns all these things and many more that only the minds of these trick-of-the-loops seek to provide for here and to take advantage of, to the real detriment and loss of the legitimate marts operating to-day. I believe they will continue to flourish, particularly with the help and assistance of this Bill, which will keep out of the business these people whom I am inclined to think of — perhaps I am being uncharitable at this hour of the morning — as the friends of the Fine Gael Party who cannot find a legitimate or useful way of life under present circumstances and who want to have a particular loop-hole through which they could work to their own advantage, and to hell with the country, the cattle and the farmers.
Comment on this
On amendment No. 3a, we have the situation where Fine Gael want to have it both ways. They do not want to move the amendment but they want to vote on it.
Comment on this
We had to move it for them. I do not know what is going to happen if other amendments are not moved. Can Fine Gael indulge in the luxury of having a vote on them?
Comment on this
On a point of order, I should like to direct attention to the fact that I understood Deputy Cunningham to say the amendment was not moved by the Opposition.
Comment on this
All this is an interruption of the vote that took place. We voted for the amendment and then the Chair decided to allow the Minister to speak.
Comment on this
This is before the House. Is it a reflection on the Chair if we are allowed to speak?
Comment on this
I do not mind reflecting on the Chair in this instance. What I am saying is perfectly correct. The Chair had put the amendment and we had voted on it.
Comment on this
I am sure the Chair does not resent it at all. I think the Chair will agree that what I said is 100 per cent correct.
Comment on this
What is 100 per cent correct is that the bloodhounds are around the grounds, scratching at every hotel door to try to bring them in.
Comment on this
It is quite clear, in view of the Fine Gael decision not to have any further discussions on this Bill, having spent all this week and last week on a few amendments to section 1, that they do not want the press and the public to hear what is really in the Bill. They have not got very far with the first section. They have not even discussed it at all, apart from the amendments. They do not want the Fianna Fáil Party to have a discussion on the full Bill, as set out and as amended by the Minister in certain respects. They do not want to have a discussion on the Minister's amendments at all.
Comment on this
They refused to discuss amendment No. 3a. We are compelling them now to listen to what we think amendment No. 3a is about Last night the Minister discussed the Incorporated Law Society and said that these amendments were not as innocent as they looked.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 3a may look innocent, but it is not innocent at all. It proposes that the owner of a livestock mart should be exempt if he proposes to sell his own cattle in that mart. Think of the loopholes that amendment could provide. First, a livestock mart may be a co-operative society with 3,000 or 4,000 members.
Comment on this
Would the Deputy be interested to know that the Minister for Lands and the Minister for Transport and Power have arrived?
Comment on this
No, but I would be very interested to know where the Labour Party are and where they have been all the week.
Comment on this
Will the proposer of the amendment say if a mart established by 3,000 large or small farmers is owned by these farmers? If they should decide to sell their own cattle, are they exempt? Do they have to have a licence? I think that this amendment and other amendments proposed by Fine Gael have been drawn up very cleverly. They have an innocent appearance but they are very clever indeed because if either or any or all of them were adopted, the Bill would become useless because in other amendments we have seen the loopholes which they proposed to insert in the Bill. Although at first glance this amendment looks very reasonable, when you get underneath the skin and see all the avenues it opens up——
Comment on this
——one can visualise a number of marts being held in buildings — we are not now arguing about fields — and no licences would be required at all if the Minister and the House agreed to accept amendment No. 3a. It is for this reason that we have moved this amendment for them.
Comment on this
It was moved by the Parliamentary Secretary, Deputy Carty, when Fine Gael refused to move and discuss the amendment. All they wanted was to have a vote on it. They are not going to get this or any other of their amendments that easily and we will discuss it.
Comment on this
We will discuss it sensibly because I think I have demonstrated clearly that what Fine Gael are seeking by this amendment is to have marts in improperly constructed marts and not to have them licensed.
Comment on this
Will Deputies sit down until I put my submission to the Chair? Has the Parliamentary Secretary no manners at all?
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that I have every respect for him. I am drawing the attention of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to the fact that I had offered and that I wish to contribute on this. Tóg bog é.
Comment on this
I wish to move that the question be now put and I do so because of the determination of the Government Party to avoid voting on our 40 amendments to this Bill.
Comment on this
I move that the question be now put and I do so because if a protracted discussion is allowed, there will not be time to put the amendments remaining on the Order Paper to a vote and we want them put to a vote.
Comment on this
There can be no discussion on the motion that the question be now put. To accept a motion requesting that the question be now put within an hour of the Dáil sitting would certainly be unreasonable and I do not accept it.
Comment on this
On a point of order, between now and 5 p.m. there should be 40 divisions and it is quite clear that if this motion is not accepted, these divisions will not take place.
Comment on this
In other words, you are backing up again the decision to guillotine this debate and prevent democracy functioning in this House.
Comment on this
It is not within the Rules of Order to reflect on my decision. It is highly irregular to charge the Chair with giving a partisan decision. The Deputy has a motion on the Order Paper criticising the action of the Chair. He can put his name again to it as to my action. It was perfectly fair.
Comment on this
It is not on the closure motion. It is a point of order arising from a remark made by a Deputy, a remark made by Deputy L'Estrange that this was a partisan decision on the part of the Chair. Is this proper?