Livestock Marts Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 169–337 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 13 of 1967 ›
On a point of order, it has been suggested in the course of this discussion that this amendment was moved by the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Clarification is required, I understand, by your own staff in this connection, Sir. I ask the Chair if the position is that I moved the amendment and that when a vote was about to be taken, the Minister offered to intervene, and at that stage Deputy Carty said he would move it. May I say this, as a point of personal explanation? I said a few minutes ago I did not mind reflecting on the Chair in this connection. That was not intended as a personal reflection but merely to indicate that I felt quite firmly that my recollection of what took place was correct.
Comment on this
I accept the Deputy's statement in respect of moving the amendment. He is perfectly right; he did move it. I said to the House that the amendment was before the House, but in the confusion, it was impossible to hear what a Deputy said or what I said. Therefore, I repeated my statement. I do not know whether the official reporter heard it or not, but that is exactly the position. I repeated my statement that the amendment was before the House and might be discussed.
Comment on this
I must thank the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach for his indication of support for this amendment, which I trust will recommend itself to the Minister.
Comment on this
My speaking did not indicate what Deputy O'Higgins, in his optimism, thought was support for the amendment.
Comment on this
If the words "but does not include the sale otherwise than by auction of livestock the property of the proprietor of such a place" were added, it would be impossible to operate the Bill in regard to any livestock, because all livestock could nominally become the property of the proprietor. This may seem to be a gross exaggeration, but even though we assume that the majority of the people are basically honest, there are a certain percentage who make it incumbent on us and make it incumbent, indeed, on all Governments, to provide protection against those who are willing to take advantage by sleight-of-hand, or by play with words. We see this operated in numerous cases, particularly where livestock itself is concerned. We have licensed hauliers; we have people without licences who are also hauliers and who would be entitled to bring their own livestock to a mart or fair. However, if they do so for hire or reward and if they are stopped by the gardaí, they first claim the cattle are theirs. Until such time as it goes to court and they are put under oath, they will remain adamant in this contention.
A similar situation would undoubtedly arise in the livestock business if this amendment were added. It would leave itself wide open to abuse, abuse that would be to the detriment of the entire Bill, might well undermine its effect, and certainly would make the operation of it nigh impossible.
Comment on this
I wish to move, Sir, that the question be now put. The position is that there are approximately 50 divisions to be taken today. In view of the fact that the Government have guillotined this discussion and that the Opposition require to get a decision from the House on their amendments, I think it reasonable that the discussion should not be protracted, particularly when the Government are quite clearly——
Comment on this
We cannot have a discussion on this motion. The House is not in session.
An Ceann Comhairle took the Chair.
Comment on this
I move under Standing Order 53 that the question be now put. I do so because there are approximately 50 divisions to be taken between now and 5 o'clock, with a break for Questions. There is a number of amendments moved by members of the Fine Gael Party on which we require and, I think, are entitled to get a decision from the House. In view of the fact that a guillotine motion was moved and closure of the guillotine accepted by the Chair last night after a discussion of approximately 1½ hours, I suggest it is only reasonable that the minority in the House be given an opportunity of getting decisions from the House on these amendments. I suggest it is quite clear that in moving this motion there is no question that it is an infringement of the rights of the minority in the House because it is the Government majority that are endeavouring to prevent a decision being taken on these amendments.
Comment on this
It is less than ten minutes since I refused a similar motion in respect of the question now put. Nothing has arisen since to alter the position in this regard and I think it a gross abuse of the procedure of the House to move a motion within ten minutes of the previous one being rejected.
Comment on this
It has always been accepted that the decisions of the Chair should not be referred to as partisan and to do so is grossly disorderly and irregular. There is a procedure by which the actions of the Chair can be questioned and brought before the House. If the Deputy wishes to do that, he will be facilitated in every way but to describe the actions of the Ceann Comhairle in the Chair as partisan is disorderly and irregular. There can be no discussion on the remarks of the Chair in reference to this matter.
Comment on this
There can be no discussion on the remarks of the Chair in reference to this matter. The Deputy will resume his seat.
Comment on this
I am not referring to the decision of the Chair but arising out of the remarks of the Chair about a motion being necessary to censure the Chair, is there any truth in the rumour that Deputy Patrick Hogan of Clare has resigned from the Labour Party and joined the Fianna Fáil Party?
Comment on this
I was pointing out to the House the dangers involved if this amendment were included. I said that we have had experience of people with lorries who are not licensed who would be permitted to transport cattle of their own to livestock marts.
Comment on this
I am merely pointing out the dangers that would arise. If the words "but does not include the sale otherwise than by auction of livestock the property of the proprietor of such a place" were inserted, it would be more than simple for the proprietor of an unlicensed mart to claim that the animals were his and, indeed, while an inspector or any member of the public or any person might be well satisfied that these cattle were not in fact the property of the proprietor, it could be difficult to prove this. Therefore it would leave the entire business of licensed marts open to abuse unprecedented in this country.
Comment on this
The Deputy might extend to me the same courtesy as I extended to him during the past few days. I did not interrupt him. The Deputy might show a little restraint.
Comment on this
I am referring to notes, as I am entitled to do. Surely, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, you are the person to rule on whether someone is reading or referring to notes and surely it is not the prerogative of any Deputy on the Opposition Benches to instruct you on your functions in this House? We have seen how unworkable this amendment would make the entire Bill. Indeed its principal purpose would be to make the Bill completely worthless. If this amendment were accepted, the Bill might as well be rejected by the House immediately.
I do not think any responsible person wants this Bill rejected, because everyone appreciates that the new regulations especially emanating from the EEC make it incumbent on us to build up a very high regard in all spheres of our livestock, as we have built up in our freedom from foot and mouth disease, as well as the value of a certificate from the Department of Agriculture in this respect.
These are things we must guard jealously in this House and to ensure that any amendment, no matter how well intentioned—and I assume they were well intentioned—would not frustrate the overriding aim to bring about a proper and regularised method of sale. We want to ensure that it will remain constant as the Northern Star by bringing in this Bill.
Comment on this
I can assure you that there are people who have made mistakes in the Fianna Fáil cumainn. I would not say they are all infallible. There is only one man who claims to be infallible, but I do say that there are people in our Party who seldom, if ever, made a mistake.
Comment on this
After talking about the conditions of the cattle industry in the EEC countries and so on—you never heard of foot and mouth disease?
Comment on this
There would be no limit to the number of devices which might be adopted to frustrate this Bill and its purpose if this amendment were included and, indeed, Deputies from rural Ireland know full well that the majority of the farming community and the majority of the people involved in the livestock industry one way or another are honest men, but unfortunately as in every walk of life, there is the small percentage who would queer the pitch for their own personal gain, on a short term basis only, with no reference to and no thought whatever for the overall position from the national point of view, or indeed, from the point of view of their neighbours or anyone else connected with the livestock trade.
I feel strongly about this amendment. We have proved to this House that its inclusion in the Bill would be a complete and utter waste of time because it would waste the time the House has spent on the Bill to date and will spend before the Bill is passed. If it completely frustrated the provisions of the section——
Comment on this
Surely the Deputy does not say that an amendment put down by the Fine Gael Party is not worthy of full discussion?
Comment on this
Any Deputy is entitled to put that motion to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, who has now sent for the Ceann Comhairle.
Comment on this
It looks as if it is not necessary to do so, if the Minister is agreeable that the question be put.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, in regard to amendment No. 4, it is possible that amendments Nos. 4, 5 and 6, although spread over different sections, could be regarded as related. I am only suggesting that to the House. They do seem to have a certain relationship which might make for single discussion.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 2, line 17, to delete "licence" wherever it appears and substitute "certificate of qualification".
Comment on this
From my reading of it, amendment No. 4 is probably consequential on amendment No. 6. Is that right?
Comment on this
If we were discussing them, I would have agreed to discuss them together but we will take the decision on amendment No. 4 and then we will consider the relationship between amendments Nos. 5 and 6. I think amendment No. 7 stands on its own.
Comment on this
The amendment that the Deputy has moved is, as I see it, consequential on Deputy O'Higgins's amendment to section 3 which seeks to provide that the authorisation to carry on the business of livestock marts should be given to the district courts. Am I right in that?
Comment on this
If the Minister is prepared to take a decision on this, we can deal with the other later but if the Minister proposes discussing them all together I am not agreeable.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it in order to read the daily paper during the debate? Some of the Opposition Deputies are reading the daily paper during this debate.
Comment on this
Learn sense, boy. You should get instruction before you poke your nose into things you do not understand.
Comment on this
They are merely reading to find out what they said yesterday because they do not know themselves.
Comment on this
I do not mind which way they fall. I thought it was the reverse but it is quite all right with me this way. Amendment No. 4 has been moved by Deputy M.J. O'Higgins and the peculiar thing about it is that apparently he is not going to advocate it. Being consequential on amendment No. 6, I feel it is necessary to refer to amendment No. 6 because without knowing what is in amendment No. 6, amendment No. 4 has no meaning.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Minister but I do not want to be unfair to the Chair. It is our desire to get a decision on these amendments and if the Government Party, having introduced a guillotine motion, endeavour to prevent the House from giving a decision on these amendments we will feel it legitimate to use every device available under Standing Orders to get a decision. I want to give notice of that because I do not want to be unfair either to the Chair or to anyone else. It seems to me to be reasonable in these circumstances, when discussion is being guillotined, that at least we should be able to get a decision.
Comment on this
Surely the logic of the situation should dictate to Fine Gael that if they do not want discussion on their own amendments——
Comment on this
You had weeks and deliberately did not avail of it. If you do not want to discuss them yourselves I think there is an onus on the Government Party to expose them unless you want to withdraw them. If you do withdraw them, this is the clear simple way out. Withdraw them and there will be no need to discuss them.
Comment on this
If the Opposition have lost courage, hope or faith in the amendments on the Order Paper they should withdraw them. If they are not going to withdraw them, they are surely not entitled to say that we on this side of the House should not expose them for what they are lest the people in the country would interpret the various amendments as expounded by the speakers over there ad nauseam in the last fortnight on all Stages of the Bill and which did not have any relevance.
Comment on this
It is not the first time Buckshot Forster has made that challenge. We do not debate under the guillotine; we divide.
Comment on this
It is, in fact, and has been for a number of weeks, thanks to the Opposition, but we will go ahead with this as Fine Gael want it. We will take amendment No. 4 which is consequential on amendment No. 6 which they refused to have taken with it to make any sense out of it. However, since the two together do not make any great appeal, I am sure it does not matter whether they are taken separately or not. The amendment is consequential on amendment No. 6 and could only be sensible if amendment No. 6 were carried. What amendments No. 6 and No. 4 together would apparently seek to do is to provide——
Comment on this
Oh, you do. Well now, is that not wonderful because that is what we have been trying to get you to do, to divide on something——
Comment on this
We must, in fairness to the people, indicate that what Fine Gael has been saying is not a true picture of what is in the Bill or what they propose to put in it themselves. Amendments Nos. 4 and 6 tie up together and amendment No. 4 will make no sense unless amendment No. 6 is carried. However, since they do not make any sense together anyway let us take them separately.
Comment on this
Deputy, behave yourself, please. We just want to say this about it. What these two together would provide if they were both carried is that authorisation to carry on the business of livestock marts would be given to the district courts. What I say to Deputy Dillon is this. Why did he not give in his time under his Fertilisers, Feeding Stuffs and Mineral Mixtures Act of 1955 these things to the district court if he was so fond of them? Why did he not think it was right then if it is so right now unless Deputy Dillon does not at all agree with the legal people in his Party who put down these amendments to refer these things, unnecessarily in my estimation and in Deputy Dillon's estimation, when he was Minister for Agriculture in 1955, to the district court? Why should that go through now, particularly if Deputy Dillon is still against that as he obviously displayed at that time? We do not agree with that. We do not agree with taking amendments which are consequential on amendments not yet reached and we are naturally opposing this. In order to get on to some amendments that might at least even read sensibly, though they do not contain any sense, I do not propose to say any more.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand".
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That section 1 stand part of the Bill".
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That section 2 stand part of the Bill".
Do you agree with this result?
I understand that, under Standing Orders, it is permissible to move the adjournment of the House for some short period to enable Members to have their luncheon, and I so move, since it does not seem possible that anybody will have luncheon——
Comment on this
Sir, can this be done now under Standing Orders? It was not mentioned on the Order of Business this morning.
Comment on this
This is quite unfair, in view of the guillotine. If the time of the adjournment is extended beyond five o'clock, we can consider it.
Comment on this
It is not usual for the Chair to have to justify his actions under Standing Orders, but I——
Comment on this
We are entitled to discuss it. The Parliamentary Secretary wants to use the guillotine on us all the time.
Comment on this
It is a reasonable proposal and I am accepting it. The motion is: "That the sitting he suspended——"
Comment on this
The motion is that the House adjourn until 2 p.m. today. I am putting the question——
Comment on this
Will you ever re-open House if you adjourn? It does not look like it. There is no such thing as democracy here.
Comment on this
Tellers: Tá, Deputies Carty and Geoghegan; Níl, Deputies L'Estrange and James Tully.
Comment on this
The Committee divided: Tá,
Do you agree with this result?
I want on behalf of the Members of the House to apologise abjectly to you, Sir, for the disregard and utter contempt shown to you, the Chair, and to the Orders of this House by the deliberately slow voting on the part of a few Fine Gael Party members. I exonerate those decent people in Fine Gael who did not participate in it, and the Labour Party as a whole. I would ask that the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach report this matter to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges.
Comment on this
Get along with you: be your age. Three guillotine motions with the support and blessing of the Chair.
Comment on this
Tairgim leasú a 7:
To delete subsections (1), (2), (3) and (5) and substitute the following:
"(1) Applications of or on behalf of a person who proposes to carry on the business of a livestock mart at a specified place, shall be made to a District Justice having jurisdiction in the District Court area wherein it is proposed to carry on such business.
(2) Such District Justice shall, at the time of the granting of the licence, attach to such licence such conditions as he shall think proper and shall specify same in the licence.
(3) The District Justice may, if he so thinks fit, amend or revoke a condition attached to a licence."
Comment on this
The amendment is to delete subsections (1), (2), (3) and (5) and substitute words as set out. In order to save subsequent amendments, the question is: "That the words proposed to be deleted down to and including `persons' in line 27, stand." That distinction is made now to save subsequent amendments.
Comment on this
"The words proposed to be deleted down to and including persons." That arrangement is made so as to save subsequent amendments.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted down to and including ‘persons' in line 27, stand."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 8:
In subsection (1), line 27, after "person" to insert "or an unincorporated body of persons".
Comment on this
In regard to this amendment, section 11 (c) of the Interpretation Act, 1937 defines "person" as including an unincorporated body of persons and also as to amendment No. 16, which refers to the same thing, and to which I would suggest the same answer applies, the amendments are unnecessary.
Comment on this
As I understand it, the definition referred to by the Minister includes a corporate body but not an unincorporated body of persons.
Comment on this
Section 11 (c) of the 1937 Interpretation Act says:
Person. The word "person" shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate (whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole) and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual.
Comment on this
In regard to this amendment, the phrase is a normal one in quite a number of Acts, and I do not see that its deletion would improve or do anything that is not already being done by the section as it stands. I do want to note the anxiety of Deputy Clinton, speaking for Fine Gael, to get on with this matter, where amendments that are similar and related are not being taken together. It is worth noting that this is the attitude.
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?