National Loan 1987-1992. - Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–239 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1967 ›
Under subsection (3), the Minister may make regulations—this is something I had intended adverting to earlier but overlooked it—and I should like to ask the Minister if it is his intention that these regulations should be laid before the House? In the case of regulations under most legislation they are laid before the Houses. In this case quite a number of regulations will be made under various sections and is it the Minister's intent to lay them before the House for the information of Members?
Comment on this
We can do that. I did intend to have any changes in the amount of contribution come through the House. This is just for information and I have no objection to doing it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 13, line 44, before "an employee" to insert "such".
This is a drafting amendment. It is necessary to qualify the term "employee" on line 44 to ensure that the term applies only to an employee who is entitled to redundancy payments under this Bill. As worded at present, it would seem from reading the section that a worker who terminates his employment in accordance with section 12 (2) would automatically become entitled to redundancy payments under the section, irrespective of whether or not he qualified. The insertion of the word "such" covers this situation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 14, lines 17 and 24, after "employment" to insert "on terms which are generally not less favourable than those of his contract with the previous owner."
It is very desirable that this should be done. It is not much use offering a person who has been employed at, say, £18 or £20 a week, other employment at £8 or £10 a week. The terms of employment which he is offered must be comparable with the kind of employment he had prior to this notice; otherwise it would be unreasonable to expect a person who did have this type of employment to accept another type which will either lower his status or put him, perhaps, to grave inconvenience financially if he were to take it. In order to protect the workers, we should have such words as these inserted into the section.
Comment on this
I think this will be covered by the employee's rights to refuse the employment and if he loses redundancy payments as a result, he can go to the appeal court. It would appear that there is no objection in writing to this but it would be possible, in circumstances which we may not conceive, that a worker would be willing to take employment which was less remunerative than what he had been used to and if we put in this amendment, we would stop him from getting that employment. It would be better to leave it as it is.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 16, line 15, to delete "an appeals officer" and insert "the Tribunal".
Comment on this
Yes. We discussed this change of name last week. As far as I was concerned at the time, it did not matter whether the word "Board" or "Tribunal" was used. The House accepted "Board" because it did not seem to matter and particularly since Deputy Treacy conjured up a vivid picture of workers being arraigned before a tribunal which would put the worker in a bad position. As it did not seem to matter, I said I would accept the word "Board". But, over the weekend, I learned that the trade unions, who will be one side of those engaged in the operation of the appeals tribunal, wanted the word "Tribunal". I wondered if Deputy Jones, in the knowledge of that, would like to go back to "Tribunal"?
Comment on this
If we were going to change, I would have to ask the House for permission to change the word in each of the consequential amendments.
Comment on this
Am I to take it that there has been an expression of opinion from some of the trade union movement. If so, can the Minister say to what extent? Is it Congress or is it perhaps particular unions?
Comment on this
It is difficult to deal with members of trade unions who do not consult with their own unions. I cannot spell out publicly every communication I receive. I do not think it would be desirable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 16, line 17, after "is" to insert "employed".
It is necessary to bring in this to clarify the situation of a worker who might be outside the State in the ordinary way for some reason, even in the course of his employment here. The section ought to cover the worker at any stage, unless he happens to be employed outside the State. Can the Minister say if a person working outside the State for a subsidiary, for instance, is covered?
Comment on this
A person ordinarily working in the State is entitled to redundancy payment and would not be affected because he was outside the State on the date of his dismissal. For that reason, the amendment is not necessary. If it were accepted, a person who was outside the State on the date of his dismissal for some reason other than one connected with his work—for instance, if he were on sick leave with his employer's permission—his position might not be clear. As it stands, the man who ordinarily works in the State but is outside it at the time of his dismissal is covered. Therefore, it might be better not to have the extra words.
Comment on this
Take the case of a person employed by a petrol company in Ireland but transferred to England?
Comment on this
He is all right for 12 months, but after 12 months he is regarded as ordinarily working outside the State and there would be a break in his service.
Comment on this
What would be the position of a person employed by Aer Lingus, sent to work on their behalf in London, Manchester or Birmingham and who was normally working there although employed by Aer Lingus? Would that man forfeit his claim?
Comment on this
If he is ordinarily working in the other State, he would be covered by the Redundancy Act there.
Comment on this
Only 12 months is not sufficient. A person is often sent over to England for two years to gain experience or a knowledge of management or of a certain product. Under this Bill, if he is outside the State for 12 months, he is no longer eligible.
Comment on this
I told the Deputy that if he is out for 12 months and comes back here again, his service is regarded as continuous.
Comment on this
Suppose one of the petrol companies send him to England for two years and he is dismissed after 14 months? Even though he is working to gain experience and comes back here what position is he in?
Comment on this
After 12 months, he is not regarded as ordinarily working here. His employers could bring him back if they thought he was going to be redundant. You have to assume that employers such as you mention, seeing that he would be caught by the law, would bring him back if there was a question of redundancy.
Comment on this
The Minister has so far more faith in the employers than many people have. When a person employed by an Irish concern is sent outside the State for some considerable time on the business of that concern, surely he should be covered?
Comment on this
I thought 12 months was sufficient with a branch of his firm, especially those firms just mentioned.
Comment on this
I know a person employed by an oil company here sent to England for two years. They may retain him there or he may come back. It would appear there could be redundancy and under this, he could be dismissed without getting anything.
Comment on this
In the unlikely event of redundancy within the first 12 months, his service here counts. After 12 months, he is establishing service with a new firm.
Comment on this
It is regarded as a new firm in this country. He may have established his right to redundancy payments in that other country. I do not know how long a period would give reasonable cover to such a person. Could the Deputies say what the period should be? I cannot think what it should be.
Comment on this
Aer Lingus was mentioned. The Minister must be aware there are Irish people working for Aer Lingus in New York and other places. They would not qualify under the Minister's present suggestion.
Comment on this
If they are sent out for experience for an Irish company for two or three years and the Irish company is still employing them, they should be eligible.
Comment on this
I will look into it for Report Stage. What you want covered is the man sent out for some years, but still employed by the head office. If he is brought back within 12 months there is no break in his continuity but I will look into it again. At the moment I cannot think how it could be done.
Comment on this
If a man becomes redundant, say, after 12 months or two years, the query is whether he qualifies under the Redundancy Compensation Bill; that should relate only to the question of a limited period of time.
Comment on this
If redundancy came quickly, it would be a very short period of time. However, we must consider the case that where a man is gone 12 months, two years or four years, he will have spent that time not contributing to the fund here. What the House is asking is that for a period during which he did not contribute and his employer did not contribute to the fund here, he would draw benefit. I shall have a look at it between now and Report Stage to see if any better cover can be given to this type of person.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 16, line 44, to delete ", under the control and management of the Minister,".
Comment on this
Yes. The House will be aware that when funds such as the proposed Redundancy Fund are established which comprise a current account and an investment account, it is normal procedure to provide that the current account will be managed by the appropriate Minister who is dealing with the legislation and the investment account will be managed by the Minister for Finance. Examples of such funds are the Social Insurance Fund under the Social Welfare Act, 1952, and the Occupational Injuries Fund established under the Social Welfare (Occupational Injuries) Act, 1966. These three amendments are designed to provide that these arrangements will apply to the accounts of the Redundancy Fund.
Comment on this
On the next section I have a comprehensive amendment in regard to this Fund, and I do not know whether I should deal at this stage with what the Minister is proposing now or deal with it on the next amendment.
Comment on this
If we accept this as the usual procedure in regard to such funds, we can discuss the Deputy's amendment afterwards.
Comment on this
While the two funds which the Minister has mentioned have an element of State contribution in them, there is no element of State contribution in the fund which is now being created. Therefore I have reservations in this regard. If the Minister's proposal goes through, what effect will it have on the section which follows it if the House should accept the amendment which I propose to move in relation to this Fund? Here is a fund to which only the employer and worker contribute; the State has no responsibility in regard to it, but the Minister for Labour who is directly concerned with the administration of the Act will not have the administration of the Fund at all. Its administration will pass over to the Minister for Finance. This again involves the dual type of responsibility in relation to which I was glad to see the Minister accept the principle that he should keep it within his own Department. The Minister knows from his own experience in the Department of Education that many funds which fell to be administered within the Department of Education were administered, invested and managed by the Department of Education. This is an argument on which I should like to elaborate on the succeeding amendment. If this amendment is passed, I do not want to be told afterwards: "The previous section nullifies the effect of what is now being proposed." If the control of the Fund passes over to the Minister for Finance, there is no reason why there should be an advisory board set up at all to deal with the matter. Therefore I am in some difficulty in this regard and I should like to have some advice on it.
Comment on this
If Deputy Jones's amendment is accepted, the decision on these three amendments can be raised on Report.
Comment on this
We are not discussing Deputy Jones's amendment; we are discussing amendments Nos. 24, 25 and 26.
Comment on this
The point he is making is that if we pass these now, they will influence our decision on his amendment.
Comment on this
I have a certain amount of sympathy for the point of view expressed by Deputy Jones in relation to control of funds having regard to the fact that funds such as superannuation funds, which arise as the result of the contributions of workers and employers, are usually dealt with on a trustee basis. However, there is another aspect of the matter on which we have not disguised our dissatisfaction, that is, that the Minister up to this stage has insisted that contributions towards this Fund shall come only from workers and employers. We have consistently held that because to some extent redundancy may come about as a result of State activities, as a result of State exhortations to employers, etc., the Government should not stand aside and refuse to contribute. This is the reason I feel reluctant to support Deputy Jones's amendment, because we would be indicating quite clearly that we would be departing from the stand we have taken and will continue to take on this question of redundancy compensation, that the State should not wash its hands of the responsibility of contributing.
Comment on this
I agree with the Minister's amendments for this reason: I realise that somebody must control the Fund and I certainly would not agree it should be left to employers to control, because we know what some employers would do and what other employers would not do. I regard this arrangement as a progressive step, and I take into consideration the predicament the worker finds himself or herself in in connection with social welfare cards. They are in the custody of the employer, and if they are lost or stolen, the poor worker will not be paid. We know whom to look to in connection with this Fund, and I am sure it will be accounted for regularly. If it were left to each individual employer, we would be in a sorry mess. I know we are not dealing with Deputy Jones's amendment, but I am not for this idea of setting up too many bodies to administer this Fund, particularly when it is advocated that people should be paid out of it other than people who contribute to it.
Comment on this
One of the points which fall to be considered at a later stage in regard to this Fund, and even under these amendments, is the fact that the Minister's control is being weakened. Subsection (6) of section 26 says:
...shall be invested by the Minister in accordance with such directions as may be given by the Minister for Finance...
One thing that emerges in the following sections is that while the Minister for Finance on behalf of the State will not contribute anything to this Fund, at the same time, he will have power to see that his expenses and other expenses will be paid from this Fund. It is very important that the Minister for Labour, under whose auspices this Fund is being created and to which the Minister for Finance makes no contribution, will not be able to deal with this Fund directly himself but its control and management will pass to the Minister for Finance. The extraordinary thing is that in later sections of the Bill the Minister for Finance is taking power so to arrange that he can require that payments shall be made out of this Fund in regard to any measure required under this Bill. Equally, should we have to advance moneys under this Bill to enable it to get off the ground, he can recover these sums from this Fund. I hold this is something that should not happen in regard to legislation like this.
The point made by Deputy Mullen and by Deputy Larkin previously is that they do not concede that there should not be a contribution from the State. They feel that the State could very well have an obligation in regard to redundancy payments for workers who lose their employment. At the same time, it is hard to imagine why, in these amendments as proposed, control of the Fund is passing to the Department of Finance and from the Department of Labour. Why should the Department of Labour not be able to manage these funds as other Departments manage theirs, invest them and give an account of their management as is done by every other Department, to the Comptroller and Auditor General?
Previously, I objected to the fact that control was taken away from the Minister under another section. That has now been rectified but, particularly when the State is not contributing, I see no good reason why the Minister and his Department should not be able to manage this Fund. If the State were contributing to the Fund, one might see that the Department of Finance, as custodian of State finances, would have a vested interest in the Fund to ensure that it was properly managed. I shall be later suggesting that this Fund could very well be properly managed by the Department of Labour with the advice of the Department of Finance. I am sure the Minister has some views on this and I should like to hear them.
Comment on this
As I have already said, the ordinary management of the Fund will be the function of the Minister for Labour, the collection of subscriptions, payment of redundancy lump sums and so on. Any management of a current type will be done by the Department of Labour but from time to time I hope and expect there will be money available that is not being drawn and the Minister would have to invest it as best he could. In any case he would seek advice from the Minister for Finance on how best to invest the money and for administrative purposes it is better to give the Minister for Finance the money and say to him: "Invest that for me". That is exactly what the amendments are doing. The management of the Fund so far as it affects the scheme and any activity related to the scheme will be done by the Department of Labour and any moneys which come to be invested will be given to the Minister for Finance who would invest it for the Fund. If the amendments are not accepted and there is a duty on the Minister for Labour to invest it himself he would still, because of the structure of Government, have to seek the advice of the Minister for Finance on investment. Therefore, for administrative reasons I think what is suggested here is best. The principle is already established in other legislation.
Comment on this
Having the Minister for Finance involved in this is, I think, a guarantee for the future. From the point of view of the workers affected, it is well to have the Minister for Finance concerned because, as we know, this is purely a trial piece of legislation. It may have to be amended when we find out how it functions. Therefore I think we should leave it as it stands in the meantime, with the Minister for Finance having a deep interest in the whole matter.
Deputy Mullen spoke about stamping cards. Will we have any guarantee that cards will all be stamped under this Bill? At present we very often have cases, particularly with small employers, where cards are not stamped and even though the offender is prosecuted, it does not do the worker much good even if the offender is sent to prison or fined. That does not restore payments. I should like to know what improvement we could have on the present system to ensure that redundancy payment cards are properly stamped and the workers given full credit for them.
Comment on this
I want to ask the Minister to keep an open mind on the question of financing the Redundancy Fund and if he would consider leaving scope in the measure so that a subvention might be made to the Fund by the Minister for Finance who will now control it to a very large extent in the event of a serious run being made on the Fund.
Comment on this
I am pleased to hear that because the financing of the Fund marks a complete departure from traditional methods of financing social welfare here which up to now has been on a tripartite basis, with contributions from the employee, the employer and the State. In this case contributions come only from the worker and the employer and there is no provision for State contribution. That is regrettable, and while the Minister is very confident in his belief that there will not be serious redundancy in the future and does not envisage a run on the Redundancy Fund, we have to face the fact that the Committee on Industrial Organisation which examined certain industries indicated very clearly that as freer trade came about, we would face serious unemployment and redundancy problems, that we could have upwards of 11,000 people unemployed in freer trading circumstances and if certain adaptation measures were not adopted, we could have a further 23,000 unemployed.
In such circumstances, it would be unfair to expect the financing of the Fund to fall only on workers and employers. The Minister should have latitude in this measure to allow the State to come to the rescue of the Fund in the event of its being in jeopardy. I am pleased to have an assurance from the Minister—and I want it to go on the records of the House—that in the case of such an event occurring, there is provision in this Bill whereby the Minister for Finance can make a subvention to the Fund in order to deal with a special emergency situation.
Comment on this
If the amendment is adopted and the investment money is under the control of the Minister for Finance, do we take it as a matter of course that the investment income from that will revert to the credit of the Fund?
Comment on this
Any time money is wanted for the Fund it is covered in the Bill that it will be taken back. Deputy Moore raised the point about an employer who does not stamp an employee's card. In this Bill the worker is covered by his service, whether his card is stamped or not, so that if he has an adequate period of service he has a claim on that employer for a redundancy lump sum and a claim on weekly payments according to his service. So that, if an employer does not stamp his card, the worker does not suffer.
As to the question of a subvention, what is provided for in case of a run on the Fund, which I do not expect, is that the Minister for Finance will give a repayable loan to the Fund, but this comes under a later section.
Comment on this
Having regard to what the Minister has just said, is there any way whereby an employee will know that the regulations are being carried out by his employer in respect of this Fund? The employee may continue to contribute. Is there any regulation in existence whereby the employer will be obliged to give a weekly account or acknowledgment of the deduction of this money for the Redundancy Fund?
Comment on this
I have been trying to find a way. At the changeover of cards is the time that the employment exchange would be able to see the position.
Comment on this
There will be regulations all right but how to catch such an employer is what the Deputy is anxious about.
Comment on this
The Minister knows how loose it has been in this part of the world having regard to our experience under the social welfare code. This Bill should afford us an opportunity to tighten up matters. I am just inquiring now what effort will be made.
Comment on this
There will be regulations and the worker will be entitled to demand to see that his cards are stamped. We have been trying to cover every loophole. No matter what happens, the worker will not suffer loss of benefit.
Comment on this
There is one other point I want to put to the Minister. It concerns one of his amendments in connection with subsection (6) of section 26. As this Bill is drafted, it is provided in subsection (6) that moneys standing to the credit of the investment account of the Redundancy Fund shall be invested by the Minister in accordance with such directions as may be given by the Minister for Finance. For some reason, that is now being amended and it will be provided that the money shall be invested by the Minister for Finance. Could the Minister justify that amendment at this stage or is this a matter of the Department of Finance sticking its nose in?
Comment on this
It is to bring it into line with social welfare legislation. As I explained, it is easier administration. It is easier to let the Minister for Finance have the money in order to invest it rather than that he should tell the Minister for Labour how to do it. It is easier administration.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware, from his experience as Minister for Education, that there are various funds under the control of the Minister for Education and that the Minister for Education directs the investment of these funds. Again, he seeks the advice of the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
This amendment is to bring it into line with social welfare legislation. There is not a big principle in it, only easier administration. It will have the same effect in the long run. Either the Minister for Labour invests it on the advice of the Minister for Finance or he will give it to the Minister for Finance to invest. The second course is the easier administrative way. There is no big principle involved. There are much more difficult things in the Bill than that.
Comment on this
I still think there is the principle that a Minister in his own Department should be able to manage the funds of his own Department.
Comment on this
As the Deputy said some time ago, they are not my funds at all. I have it in such a way that the Minister for Labour in anything to do with the day to day running of the fund, collection of contributions, payment of benefit, payment of the part of the lump sum or all the lump sum if the employer defaults, will be managed by the Minister for Labour. If he wants money he gets it from the Minister for Finance, wherever he has it invested, and if he has money to spare, instead of asking the Minister for Finance, "Where will I invest it?" he gives it to him and says "Invest that." I do not see a big principle involved. It brings it into line with social welfare legislation. It is better administration, easier to handle. However, management and every dealing with that Fund in anything to do with redundancy are done by the Minister for Labour. The investment of money for the Minister for Labour and where it is best invested is left to the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
Having regard to the contemplated wise investment the Minister for Finance is going to indulge in, we can assume that the Fund will grow, particularly if we take into consideration what the Minister for Labour has already said, that he has great hopes for the future. This means the Fund will grow and there will not be the draw upon it that, perhaps, there would have been if it had been in operation now. Am I to take it that as the Fund will grow as a result of investment and because people are not withdrawing money, that will enable the Minister to have another look at the benefits? Is there any provision made at the moment or about to be made for the yearly, biennial or triennial revision of the Fund, with a view to seeing if the Fund can afford greater benefits?
Comment on this
This is true. Any scheme of this kind is experimental and what you do first is based on your best calculations and the experience in other countries. Our calculations are based on an estimate of about £1 million coming in in contributions and the benefits payable are based on what the Fund with that income and the likely draws on it could carry. I would hope that the Deputy is right. If any change is necessary in the benefits payable I would have to come to the House again, but it can be done by motion rather than new legislation. This comes later.
Comment on this
I should have added, bearing in mind the number we have excluded and who will be contributing, which will also help to build up the Fund.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 16, lines 49 and 50, to delete subsection (2) and substitute the following new subsection:
"(2) The Redundancy Fund shall comprise a current account, to be managed and controlled by the Minister, and an investment account, to be managed by and controlled by the Minister for Finance."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 17, lines 16 and 17, to delete "by the Minister in accordance with such directions as may be given".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 27:
Before section 27 to insert a new section as follows:
"(1) The Minister shall appoint an advisory Council to be known as `the Redundancy Fund Advisory Council' (in this Act referred to as the Advisory Council) consisting of a chairman and members three of whom shall be appointed from a body or bodies representative of employers and three from a body or bodies representative of employees.
(2) The Advisory Council shall advise the Minister on the management of the Fund, the level of weekly contributions necessary to be maintained from time to time and on any other matter referred to them under this Act by the Minister.
(3) The members of the Advisory Council, not being employees of the State, shall be paid such remuneration, and in the case of all members, such allowances as the Minister may determine."
I have previously adverted to the fact that I am concerned about the position that here there is a Fund which is being created by the contributions of workers and employers and the manner as to how the Fund is to be built up, what the level of contributions will be, are matters being determined by an authority outside the persons who are contributing to the Fund. We suggest that an advisory body be set up which would be helpful, first and foremost, to the Minister in his administration of the Fund. The setting up of that body would be an indication again of what is most necessary in regard to the future of both workers and employers, that is, the goodwill which is necessary even for the successful working of a Redundancy Payments Bill.
When the Minister comes to think of it, he will find that in setting up a body such as this to assist him he would not be imposing, by way of regulations or otherwise, on either side in regard to the contributions that will have to be made, and he would not be imposing in regard to the state the Fund would be in at such time. Everyone knows that it is necessary to keep an eye on a fund created for a purpose such as this, or for any other purpose, where contributions are paid out at a later stage. That is an actuarial job which requires expert advice. Where there are contributions from two sections, without any third body contributing, surely the two contributing elements should be entitled to express their opinion as to how the Fund should be financed and administered? That does not take from the Minister's discretion at all. This is an effort to improve the situation. It is a negation to deny the people who are contributing any say in the administration of the Fund or the level of the payments to be made into it.
One of the things that may well fall to be considered at a later stage is that the contributions may have to be increased. If we may envisage such a fortuitous occurrence, it is easily possible that the amount being contributed may not be needed. The Fund will be growing and will be passed over to the Investment Fund of the Minister for Finance. The fact of having an advisory body such as that recommended in this amendment to deal with this Redundancy Fund would do a lot of good from the point of view of creating an interest on the part of the people contributing to it and creating their goodwill, and it would also be helpful from the management point of view. It would be helpful either way. Beyond that, it would give the people directly concerned a say in the administration of the Fund which they themselves were helping to create.
In the third subsection of the amendment, we propose that the people engaged on such an advisory body should be remunerated. That is no worse than the situation will be if the Minister for Finance is handling it, as is proposed at present, because the Minister for Finance has the right, as set out in this legislation, to recoup any expenditure incurred by him out of the Fund. I cannot see any violation of that principle. I cannot see that the situation will be any different from what will happen if the Fund is completely under the control of the Minister for Finance. For that reason, I am moving this amendment and I hope the Minister will see fit to accept it.
Comment on this
I imagine that, in actual practice, the decisions which will come to be made about the Fund will be in relation to changes in the rate of benefit or changes in the contributions required, as our experience may suggest. As I said before, any redundancy fund must be experimental because we do not know what the demand will be. As I said, £1 million might be paid in but the amount necessary will depend on the age of the workers, the level of incomes, the years of service and many other imponderables. That is why we say it is experimental. It is a tentative estimate of the payments and contributions that will be required. An advisory committee, to my mind, could deal only with actual figures such as, should the contributions be higher or the benefits be better. That is in relation to the day to day running of the Fund. I believe that any change in the rates should be a function of both Houses of the Oireachtas. We have provided that any proposal to change the rates should be subject to an affirmative resolution of the Houses of the Oireachtas. I am satisfied that the Oireachtas is the appropriate place to discuss what in actual fact would be discussed by an advisory committee.
There is a man-power advisory committee which has worked all the way with me and with the Department on this legislation and the training legislation. While they are there to advise and to alert the Minister to what needs to be looked at, the Oireachtas is still the place for making decisions and giving advice about the rates of contribution and the rates of benefit. I do not think I could accept an advisory committee. It would not be required and would be taking the place of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I am at a loss to understand the need for an advisory committee. As I understand the situation, this Fund will be under the control of and administered by the Department of Labour. I am wondering can the Minister describe the set-up which will come into existence when this Bill becomes law. Am I right in assuming that in actual fact a section of the Department of Labour will be responsible for the administration of this Bill, and that it will remain for any aggrieved person to make a complaint through the channels which are there?
Earlier on, we were talking about the composition of an appeals tribunal to which matters in dispute would be referred. Furthermore, am I right in saying that since this scheme is in its infancy, it will be open to the employers' side and the workers' side, as time goes on, to make representations, if they see fit, in connection with any improvement of this Bill, and that in the final analysis, if any improvements are to be made in regard to the contributions or the benefits, such matters will be brought to this House? I should like the Minister to tell us how he envisages this Bill will operate?
I have already said that I presume a section of the Department of Labour will be doing this job. I am sure the people in such section will be charged with the responsibility for gathering in funds and making sure that contributions are paid. As was said earlier, arrangements will be made to advise those who come within the scope of this measure as to what they should do in order to obtain benefit from it. I do not support the idea of the formation of more committees for this and committees for that. One can get cluttered up with committees. Very often committees are set up to keep people quiet. I know a great number of voluntary committees working in industrial circles in which no payment is made to the members of the committees, in which the members of the committees do not expect payment for their services.
I have in mind the various joint industrial councils and other committees in existence, representative of both employers and employees. These people are not paid: they give their labour voluntarily in the interests of the particular industry. If it is necessary to set up a committee, I am sure it could be done without making this kind of provision for it. The Minister has his contacts with organised employers and with the trade unions; he would have no difficulty in calling them together at any time for consultation. I do not think this advisory council is necessary. If Deputy Jones insists on this, then I should like him to elaborate further on the particular purpose he thinks it will serve.
Comment on this
I have already mentioned the purpose. Under the social welfare code, employers and employees make a joint contribution towards the payment of a representative of management and labour to look after welfare funds; they meet from time to time and discuss how this money is to be apportioned. Now this is something in the nature of welfare, in the sense that it is designed to make provision for people who become redundant so that they can be helped financially until such time as they get other jobs. There will be two sides contributing and those who contribute will naturally have the greatest interest in the operation of the Fund. While admitting the validity of Deputy Mullen's argument in relation to people who give voluntary service, subsection (3) of this amendment is not mandatory in any sense. I am sure management and workers could set up an advisory body, the members of which would not require compensation for their time. This is just the ordinary provision to ensure that such a body could be set up, if it were thought desirable.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that, when this Bill becomes law, those who administer it will have no option but to stick strictly to what is in the Act? If there were an advisory committee such as the Deputy suggests and that committee recommended the stretching of a point or the barring of something else, that could not be done under the Act. There would be no authority to do anything except talk.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 28:
In page 17, line 32, after "shall be" to insert "paid into the Fund".
This is a drafting amendment to improve the wording of the subsection and make its meaning clearer.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 29:
In page 17, to delete lines 38 and 39 and substitute the following:
"(b) advances as provided for in subsection (2)".
This, again, is a drafting amendment. There is an inconsistency as between the provisions of subsection (1) (b) and subsection (5) of the section. Subsection (1) (b) provides for advances to the Redundancy Fund out of moneys voted by the Oireachtas whereas subsection (5) makes it clear such advances should be made from the Central Fund. The amendment, as I say, clears up the inconsistency.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 31:
In page 18, lines 52 to 54, and in page 19, lines 1 to 4, to delete subsection (7) and to substitute the following new subsection:
"(7) A contribution under this section shall be payable in respect of each contribution week during the whole or any part of which the employee concerned was employed and in respect of which an employment contribution was payable for that employee under the Act of 1952."
Subsection (7) of this section lays down the circumstances under which redundancy contributions are payable. The basic intention with regard to these contributions is that they should be payable on behalf of eligible employees in precisely the same circumstances as employment contributions are payable under the Social Welfare Act, 1952. This intention is not fully expressed in the subsection as at present worded. Instead of repeating the lengthy sections of the social welfare legislation involved, I consider it makes the requirement more readily understood if it is simply stated that a redundancy payment on behalf of an eligible employee is payable when an employment contribution is paid under the Social Welfare Act. The amendment accordingly has been drafted with this simplification in mind.
Comment on this
What is the position in the case of a worker who becomes ill? Under the social welfare legislation at the moment, a worker who becomes ill can be credited with contributions. Will there be a credit given in this particular case? Will the worker who falls ill be given credits for contributions to this redundancy fund?
Comment on this
If he is off work with pay, his contributions are payable. He is covered any way if his service is not broken.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy is on to another question now, that of the length of illness which breaks continuity. This is not like social welfare. His service is what counts.
Comment on this
If we are making the point that this is not like social welfare, and indeed that it is better than social welfare, surely we now have the opportunity to recognise that where a worker is absent from work through no fault of his own, it should not be held against him? One can envisage a person who has been paying into this Fund for a number of years and through no fault of his own meets with an accident or becomes very ill and has to go into hospital for a period of time. Is this person to be denied benefit? Surely that should not be held against him?
Comment on this
Paragraph 5 of Schedule 3 relates to continuity of employment rather than what we are dealing with at the moment. It says:
...continuity of employment shall not be broken (even though notice of termination of a contract of employment has been given) where an employee's period of service has been interrupted for a period of not more than 26 weeks by reason of lay-off, sickness, holidays, service by the employee in the Defence Forces of the State or any other reason (other than the voluntary leaving of his employment by the employee) authorised by the employer.
Therefore it would take 26 weeks to break the continuity of employment, but what the Deputies envisage is sickness and dismissal.
Comment on this
It is not the principle of payment; it is the principle of service and continuity of service that counts for redundancy.
Comment on this
No. An employer could have neglected to pay contributions, but because of having his service, the employee is covered. It is on service.
Comment on this
In the case of a person with, say, tuberculosis, where a minimum period away from work is six months, is it not unreasonable to have a person who is afflicted by such a disease cut off from the Redundancy Fund? We can discuss it later if the Minister wishes, but one would have thought that where a person has pulmonary tuberculosis and is laid up for a considerable period of time—six months is the minimum period and very often a person is advised not to return to work for a further three months —he should not be cut off. I think this is something the Minister should look into. It is unreasonable that such a person should be deprived of the benefit of a fund to which he has been contributing and that his benefit at that stage is lost. I feel this is something the Minister will have to consider seriously.
Comment on this
This is a very complicated Bill and the Deputies have jumped right on to the Third Schedule. We are discussing a section and it would be far easier to discuss it as it stands.
Comment on this
The Deputy went on to things like breaking continuity of service and this makes it very difficult. It is very complicated to handle as it is.
Comment on this
The Minister moved his amendment to subsection (7) of section 28. That amendment reads:
A contribution under this section shall be payable in respect of each contribution week during the whole or any part of which the employee concerned was employed and in respect of which an employment contribution was payable for that employee under the Act of 1952.
The Act of 1952 being the Social Welfare Act.
Comment on this
What I am concerned with is an employee under the Social Welfare Act of 1952 may not make a contribution if he is not in employment on that occasion but he is credited.
Comment on this
I explained to the House that this has nothing to do with credits. This Bill relates to service and there is no question of credits. If the employer neglects to pay the contributions, the man still gets his redundancy payment on the service he has given the employer.
Comment on this
When I say credit, I mean that a person may, if he is not working, go to the Garda barracks and say he is able and willing for work and he gets what is called credit.
Comment on this
A person who is sick could not go to the Garda barracks and a person who is available for employment could not be put on credit. It is a total misconception.
Comment on this
The Deputy is saying that a man is going for employment to the Guards and he wants that to be put on credit to the employment he is in, but he is not in employment if he is unemployed.
Comment on this
I do not know how further to explain it. The point is that it is not related to the number of contributions and has nothing to do with the contributions. It is related to the number of years service he has and it does not matter whether he is permitted to pay up contributions; that has no influence on it. What would influence it is if he were to break his period of service.
Comment on this
If the Act of 1952 is to govern this subsection, take a docker who has worked today for one stevedore; then the boat is finished and he is let go. Next week he works for a different stevedore and gets another contribution marked up against him. If that went on for four years, would he qualify for redundancy payment even though he did not work for the same employer for four years?
Comment on this
We dealt with that last week. The claim is made by a worker who has worked for four years with one employer and by having worked four years, he has established a right in that position by contributing during his work in that employment. The question was raised here last week of workers who do not stay with the one employer — dockers and catering workers were mentioned—and it was argued that something should be done for those people. I propose for this type of work that we will have a special scheme and under this scheme they would be contribution. If they frequently change their employment, they would never work up enough service with a single employer to get benefit. The amendment is for a separate type of scheme.
Comment on this
If a worker works one day in the week, he is eligible to pay contributions to this Fund; is that not so?
Comment on this
Yes. I would like to get across to the Deputies that payment of the contribution is not related to the man's requirement to claim benefit.
Comment on this
I understand that. Am I right in thinking that he is expected to make contribution to this Fund in the same way as he presently makes contribution to the social welfare fund? The man may work one day in the week with one employer. The first person he works with is the person who stamps his card. The man has got to pay the contribution, once he is employed in any part of the week.
Comment on this
I thought I explained that last week. There will be people paying contributions who will not benefit under this Bill. We hope to have a special scheme for them. There was a proposal before I brought this Bill to the House to have such people excluded but I felt it was better to put pressure on those concerned to have a special scheme.
Comment on this
I just want to comment briefly on the section. Subsection (7) states:
A contribution under this section shall be payable in respect of each contribution week during the whole or any part of which the employee concerned was employed but where no remuneration has been received for, or no services have been rendered by the employee during, any contribution week, the employer shall not be liable to pay any contribution either on his own behalf or on behalf of the employee concerned for that week.
That is easy enough but I want to query the Minister as to whether the same principle stands in every week where the employee may be rendered unemployed because of a laying-off, sickness, holidays and the like, that is, for every week he receives no wages, no redundancy stamp will be applied? It is very unfair if this is true because it means that if a man is out because of sickness he obviously gets no wages and no stamp is credited to him for redundancy purposes.
Comment on this
What purpose do the stamps serve at all excepts to indicate that he is eligible for redundancy payment?
Comment on this
The unfairness Deputies have been preaching about is that there is not any money coming into the Fund when a man is sick but by being sick, it does not take away in any way from the payment he will get if he is declared redundant.
Comment on this
It is not related to his contributions and if he does not pay a contribution when he is sick. If he is declared redundant afterwards, he does not lose any benefit because of being sick.
Comment on this
Bearing in mind that we are dealing with contributions, and as I understand it, the worker is still employed when he is on holidays, just to be right about this so that we know what we are talking about elsewhere, am I to understand that when a person is going on holidays, the contribution is deducted?
Comment on this
I understand from the Official Assignee that as at present worded, subsection (3) of this section may be defective. I am having the matter looked into and if necessary, I will have an appropriate amendment tabled on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 32:
In page 22, lines 26 and 27, to delete "this section" and insert "subsection (2) (b) or (2) (c)".
This amendment proposes a slight change in the wording of subsection (3) of this section so as to limit the offences under the section to (a) the failure of an employer to comply with regulations made relating to the production of documents and (b) to the furnishing by any person of false information under regulation made requiring information to be furnished. The Deputies will appreciate that subsection (3) as at present drafted is too wide having regard to the type of matters mentioned at subparagraphs (a), (d) and (e) of subsection (2). Contravention of regulations made in relation to these matters could not, of course, be regarded as an offence warranting prosecution and hence the desirability of this amendment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister inform me what rank will the deciding officers mentioned in this section be? Would the Minister also inform me when decisions are being communicated under this section, will it be made clear that those decisions are the decisions of the deciding officer?
Comment on this
The officers would generally be of the grade of staff officer. I expect that the officers appointed to act as deciding officers will be of such rank.
Comment on this
That there be a clear indication that the decision given is the decision of a deciding officer?
Comment on this
The Minister will be aware that sometimes you are told that under a decision under section so-and-so you are debarred without its being confirmed or intimated that this is a decision of a deciding officer.
Comment on this
The Minister will be aware that under social welfare legislation at present decisions are sometimes given and then a person may have to come back to the Department and find, eventually, on appeal that it is decided by a deciding officer, and that is final and conclusive in the ordinary way. But if a person knew at the beginning that it was a decision of a deciding officer, there would be no need to pursue it further.
Comment on this
When a deciding officer makes a decision, if it is found that it is against the person concerned, he is told, and surely they would also be told that they had a right of appeal? This is the position in Social Welfare. A person is told he is disqualified and will not get benefit. Presumably this will be the same.
Comment on this
I am not quite clear on why Deputy Jones mentions a deciding officer. What benefit would this give?
Comment on this
If a deciding officer makes a decision against the person seeking benefit, will the deciding officer, in making known his decision to the person concerned, also inform him of his entitlement to appeal?
Comment on this
I asked the Minister a point in respect of deciding officers and I want again to reiterate the questions raised by Deputy Jones in respect of the status of these officers. Could the Minister say at this stage how these people will be recruited; whether, in fact, they will be recruited from his own Department of Labour or whether, in the main, they may well be recruited from the Department of Social Welfare? Is the Minister in a position to give the House information at this stage as to the calibre of the people who will be recruited?
Comment on this
They are all Departments of State and they are drafted from the same pool of officers. While the Department of Labour is being established, we have arrangements with other Departments about staffing. When fully established, recruitment will be in the ordinary way. Officers will be recruited from the Civil Service. It may, perhaps, be possible to get these people in the Department of Labour in the first instance.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 33:
Before section 39 to insert the following new section:
39. (1) There shall be a tribunal (which shall be known as the Redundancy Appeals Tribunal and is in this section hereinafter referred to as the Tribunal) to determine the appeals provided for in this section.
(2) The Tribunal shall consist of the following members—
(a) a chairman who shall be a practising barrister or solicitor of seven years' standing at least,
(b) not more than three vicechairmen, and
(c) not more than eight ordinary members.
(3) The members of the Tribunal shall be appointed by the Minister and shall be eligible for re-appointment.
(4) The appointments pursuant to subsection (3) of the ordinary members of the Tribunal shall be made—
(a) as to one-half of these members, from among persons nominated for that purpose by a body or bodies representative of employees, and
(b) as to the other half of those members, from among persons nominated for that purpose by a body or bodies representative of employers.
(5) The term of officer of a member of the Tribunal shall be such period as is specified by the Minister when appointing such member.
(6) (a) A member of the Tribunal may, by letter addressed to the Minister, resign his membership,
(b) A member of the Tribunal may be removed from office by the Minister.
(7) (a) Whenever a vacancy occurs in the membership of the Tribunal and is caused by the resignation, removal from office or death of an ordinary member mentioned in subsection (4) (a), the vacancy shall be filled by the Minister by appointment in the manner specified in that subsection.
(b) Whenever a vacancy occurs in the membership of the Tribunal and is caused by the resignation, removal from office or death of an ordinary member mentioned in subsection (4) (b), the vacancy shall be filled by the Minister by appointment in the manner specified in that subsection.
(8) In the case of a member of the Tribunal filling a vacancy caused by the resignation, removal from office or death of a member before the completion of the term of office of the last-mentioned member, the member filling that vacancy shall hold office for the remainder of the term of office of the person who so resigned, died or was so removed from office.
(9) A vice-chairman of the Tribunal shall act as chairman thereof when so required by the chairman or the Minister and when so acting shall have all the powers of the chairman.
(10) A member of the Tribunal shall be paid such remuneration (if any) and allowances as may be determined by the Minister with the consent of the Minister for Finance.
(11) Whenever the chairman of the Tribunal is of opinion that, for the speedy dispatch of the business of the Tribunal, it is expedient that the Tribunal should act by divisions, he may direct accordingly and, until he revokes his direction, the Tribunal shall be grouped as so directed.
(12) Each division of the Tribunal shall consist of either the chairman or a vice-chairman of the Tribunal, an ordinary member of the Tribunal mentioned in subsection (4) (a) and an ordinary member of the Tribunal mentioned in subsection (4) (b).
(13) The Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for Finance, appoint such officers and servants of the Tribunal as he considers necessary to assist the Tribunal in the performance of its functions, and such officers and servants shall hold office on such terms and receive such remuneration as the Minister for Finance determines.
(14) The decision of the Tribunal on any question referred to it under this section shall be final and conclusive, save that any person dissatisfied with the decision may appeal therefrom to the High Court on a question of law.
(15) Any employer who is dissatisfied with a decision given by the Minister in relation to a rebate or with any decision given by a deciding officer in relation to any question specified in section 38 (1) (d), 38 (1) (e) or 38 (1) (f), or any employee who is dissatisfied with a decision given by a deciding officer under section 38 or with any decision of an employer under this Act may, on giving notice of appeal to the Minister in the prescribed manner, have the question referred to the Tribunal for a decision thereon; provided however, that the Tribunal shall not be competent to decide whether or not an employee is or was at the material time in employment which is or was insurable for all benefits under the Social Welfare Acts, 1952 to 1966.
(16) A deciding officer may if he so thinks proper, instead of deciding it himself, refer in the prescribed manner to the Tribunal for a decision thereon any question which falls to be decided by him under section 38.
(17) (a) The Tribunal shall, on the hearing of any matter referred to it under this section, have power to take evidence on oath and for that purpose may cause to be administered oaths to persons attending as witnesses at such hearing.
(b) Any person who, upon examination on oath authorised under this subsection, wilfully and corruptly gives false evidence or wilfully and corruptly swears anything which is false, being convicted thereof, shall be liable to the penalties for wilful and corrupt perjury.
(c) The Tribunal may, by giving notice in that behalf in writing to any person, require such person to attend at such time and place as is specified in the notice to give evidence in relation to any matter referred to the Tribunal under this section or to produce any documents in his possession, custody or control which relate to any such matter.
(d) A notice under paragraph (c) may be given either by delivering it to the person to whom it relates or by sending it by post in a prepaid registered letter addressed to such person at the address at which he ordinarily resides.
(e) A person to whom a notice under paragraph (c) has been given and who refuses or wilfully neglects to attend in accordance with the notice or who, having so attended, refuses to give evidence or refuses or wilfully fails to produce any document to which the notice relates shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to a fine not exceeding twenty pounds.
(18) The Minister may make regulations giving effect to this section and such regulation may, in particular but without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, provide for all or any of the following matters—
(a) the procedure to be followed regarding the submission of appeals to the Tribunal,
(b) the times and places of hearings by the Tribunal,
(c) the representation of parties attending hearings by the Tribunal,
(d) procedure regarding the hearing of appeals by the Tribunal,
(e) publication and notification of decisions of the Tribunal,
(f) notices relating to appeals or hearings by the Tribunal.
(g) the award by the Tribunal of costs and expenses and the payment of such awards,
(h) an official seal of the Tribunal,
(i) for treating the Minister as a party to any proceedings before the Tribunal where he would not otherwise be a party to them and entitling him to appear and be heard accordingly."
This amendment proposes the establishment of an appeals tribunal, on which we had the discussion last week.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 39:
In page 24, lines 10 and 11, to delete "an appeals officers" and insert "the Tribunal".
This is consequential on amendment No. 33.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 40:
In page 24, lines 12 and 13, to delete "Chief Appeals Officer" and insert "Tribunal".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 41:
In page 24, line 15, to delete "an appeals officer" and insert "the Tribunal".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 44:
In page 24, lines 48 and 49, to delete "or an appeals officer".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 45:
In page 25, line 6, to delete "or appeals officer (as the case may be)".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 46:
In page 25, lines 12 and 13, to delete "or appeals officer (as the case may be)".
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 48 and 49 will be taken together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 48:
In page 25, line 28, to delete "four months" and substitute "twelve months".
The purpose of this amendment is to increase from four to 12 months the period of arrears of contributions to the Redundancy Fund which will be regarded as preferential payments in the distribution of the assets of the company which is being wound up or of the assets of an employer who has been adjudicated bankrupt.
This is the period that applies in the case of Social Insurance Fund contributions, and it is desirable that there should be uniformity as between the periods for preferential payment in regard to the contributions due to both Funds.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 49:
In page 25, line 41, to delete "four months" and substitute "twelve months".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 50:
In page 25, line 51, after "to" to insert "the Official Assignee in Bankruptcy or".
This is a drafting amendment to clarify the position regarding the position of the Official Assignee in relation to weekly payments being made out of the Redundancy Fund to a redundant worker who is also a bankrupt. The amendment makes it clear that the Official Assignee will be debarred from seeking to have the weekly payments being paid to a bankrupt worker regarded as assets for distribution among his creditors. This will mean that, for the purposes of the laws of bankruptcy, redundancy weekly payments will be treated in the same way as ordinary weekly wages.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51:
In page 25, line 52, after subsection (4) to insert the following new section:
"(5) Nothing in section 53 of the Bankruptcy (Ireland) Amendment Act, 1872, or in section 286 of the Companies Act, 1963, shall apply to any redundancy payments made by an employer."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 51a:
In page 26 to delete line 7 and substitute "offences under this Act or under regulations thereunder as it applies".
There was a typographical error, which repeated one line and caused another line to be dropped. This amendment corrects that error.
Comment on this
Will the Minister, when he is making copies of these regulations available, put into the regulations the relevant subsections of the Social Welfare Acts which will affect people in this regard, so that they will not have to deal with the Acts as a whole to find out what the regulations deal with, when regulations are being made in regard to redundancy? In this section there is reference to the Act of 1952. Would the Minister consider putting that in when he is making regulations—to spell it out for people so that they can look at this without having to go back to previous Acts?
Comment on this
In that connection, will the Minister keep in mind what we have advocated before in connection with this matter—we must publish the regulations and in this case they would need to be published, and compulsorily published, in all places of employment where they can be seen. Furthermore, it is imperative that a synopsis of the regulations be made out and published alongside for the workers' scrutiny, because it is very difficult for an ordinary working man to apply his mind to a set of regulations drawn up in Civil Service language. I agree with the point made by Deputy Jones of a worker having to refer to section this, that or the other of a previous Act. The clearer these regulations can be made, even to the people contributing to the Fund, the better.
Comment on this
What we should do is to have this type of clear publicity material prepared. I intend that there should be clear publicity about it; we shall arrange for that.
Comment on this
Might I ask the Minister if he would have something in the nature of a little handbook available for workers?
Comment on this
In regard to section 49, might I ask the Minister a question? Are there many such schemes, arrangements—to the knowledge of the Minister—in regard to firms where these schemes exist? Has the Minister any knowledge of them; does he know how many there are?
Comment on this
I have not the number; I know there are some schemes which are controlled by Government Departments but I have not any figure here with me.
Comment on this
I have a Parliamentary Question about that for tomorrow and I shall try to have some information then.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 52:
In page 27, line 37, to delete "employer's".
The section provides that the benefit of the Probation of Offenders Act may not be applied in the case of an employer charged with an offence relating to employer's redundancy contributions until the court ascertains that all contributions have been paid. As drafted, the section would relate to offences relating to employers' contributions only, but it is possible that an employer would commit an offence in relation to an employee's contribution. Accordingly, if we delete the word "employer's", we will cover offences in relation to both contributions, and that will relate the section to what I intended.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 53:
In page 28, lines 32 and 33, to delete "or an appeals officer".
This is consequential on the Tribunal in section 23 and we discussed it last week.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 54:
In page 28, before section 55, to insert the following new section:
(1) If in any respect any difficulty arises in bringing into operation this Act or any amendment or repeal effected by this Act, the Minister may by order do anything which appears to be necessary or expedient for bringing this Act into operation, and any such order may modify a provision of this Act so far as may appear necessary or expedient for carrying the order into effect.
(2) Every order made by the Minister under this section shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after it is made, and if a resolution is passed by either House of the Oireachtas within the next twenty-one days on which that House has sat after the order is laid before it annulling such order, the order shall be annulled accordingly, but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under the order.
(3) No order may be made under this section after the expiration of one year after the commencement of this Act.
I think Deputies will realise by now that this Bill is a very complex piece of legislation. To a large extent, it is breaking new ground in social legislation. In these circumstances, it is quite conceivable—although I think it unlikely—that when the Act is brought into operation, some unforeseen difficulty or circumstances could arise which would impede or hold up the implementation or the operation of the redundancy payments scheme. I would then be in the position of having to come to the House, to the Oireachtas, with amending legislation. I think the House will agree it would be unfortunate if, after the commencement date of the Act, some technicality for which we had not provided could hold up the benefits for the section of the community for which the Bill is intended.
Accordingly, to ensure the smooth and uninterrupted operation of the Act, I would seek in this section power to remove any difficulty which is likely to stand in the way of the full implementation of the Act when it is in force. The section would not give me power to make substantial changes, or any change, in the Act; it would merely give power to the Minister to overcome any difficulty in the operation of what has been enacted by the Oireachtas. There are ample safeguards for the Oireachtas against misuse of any powers vested in the Minister by way of this section.
Comment on this
Yes, and the House could annul such an order by resolution. It is also a transitory provision; it is not one which will last after a year.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 55:
In page 28, line 45, after "Minister" to insert "which relates to the scheme of redundancy payments established by this Act".
This amendment is to correct an omission in the drafting of subsection (2) of section 55. The subsection refers to the part of the Minister's expenses without indicating which part is in question. The amendment makes it clear that the subsection relates to the scheme of redundancy payments to be established under the Act.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 56:
In paragraph 4, page 29, line 36, to delete "four weeks" and substitute "one week".
We think this is a reasonable amendment, particularly when one considers that the type of people we are dealing with are in the main provident people. They are people who, according to this Bill, will have less than £1,200 per year income. If we bear that in mind, I submit it is unreasonable to ask them to wait four weeks before the first weekly payment is made to them. The people I speak about have not been in a position, and will not be, to save up for the type of eventuality posed by redundancy. The main reason we welcome the Bill is that it affords such people an opportunity of getting something in the event of redundancy.
We ask the Minister to accept the amendment because, one way or another, these people will get paid and we consider it to be imposing a hardship on them to have them waiting longer than a week before they get their first weekly payment. Workers now declared redundant are covered by the social welfare code and can go to the employment exchange to obtain their benefit without having to wait a period of four weeks. We ask the Minister to go along with the idea of giving the benefit a week after the termination of employment. It should be an easy thing to bring about, particularly because the Department of Labour will have a special section dealing with it.
In this Bill we get a more enlightened approach to extending benefits than has been the case under the Social Welfare Acts. We are more than anxious to avoid delay in giving redundant workers their weekly payments. As I have said, all the people who will come within the ambit of the Bill will not be able to afford to wait for the money to come. They have daily commitments, never mind weekly commitments, and will need to be paid a week after termination of employment.
Comment on this
In parts of this Bill we decided on periods which we thought most suitable in the light of circumstances which exist. In determining the lump sum provision, we had to decide what an industry could carry, what would be an incentive to an employer. In relation to this period of four weeks, I have tried to come to a decision on whether a man should get redundancy weekly payments at once or whether there should first be a waiting period so as to provide an incentive to him to seek out new employment. I should point out that the waiting period does not reduce the number of weeks for which he will get benefit.
Comment on this
It takes nothing from him—he will get the full benefit, starting four weeks after he becomes unemployed. I have been thinking it over: I have had strong representations from my own Party to reduce this period and I am prepared to take a lesser period than four weeks. I think one week is too short. The smallest lump sum would equal two weeks pay and I would be willing to take two weeks as the waiting period.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minister's approach but may I direct his attention to the fact that this amendment deals with weekly payments, not lump sums, and I understand that the purpose of the Bill is to help people to tide themselves over until they get employment, to keep them going? The income of those who will be affected by the Bill is so low at present that it is not sufficient to enable them to put money by for this rainy or evil day. The State is in a better position, the Department are in a better position, to meet the payments immediately —there is the Redundancy Fund itself. The Department are in a better position to do the waiting, if waiting is required. This deals with a man who, through no fault of his own or, perhaps, of his employer, loses his employment and finds himself subsisting on a weekly redundancy payment, to be regarded as something in the way of a substitute for the weekly wage he had. He will have lost that wage to which he was accustomed and will have to fall back on this, but instead of being able to fall back on it immediately, he will have to wait four weeks. I am conscious of the fact that he will not lose anything but the payment should be made, shall we say as a continuity of the wages he had.
The Minister has said he has had representations from his own Party. I can assure him we shall be satisfied if he makes up his mind between now and Report Stage on this matter. I am sure a number of Deputies in his Party who are in touch with working people will bear out what I have said, that it is highly desirable that this payment be made on a weekly basis without a gap before the first payment.
Comment on this
I am not now concerned with the lump sum. It is all very well if the employee gets a lump sum but a lump sum should not be regarded as being a workman's first weekly payment from the Redundancy Fund. That is not its purpose and let us not confuse it.
Comment on this
We are now on weekly payments. I do not care if a man keeps his lump sum payment and never adverts to it. I am concerned with the system of weekly payments. None of the workers affected by this Bill is paid by the month—they are all in receipt of weekly wages.
Comment on this
The lump sum is related to weekly wages. The smallest possible lump sum is two weeks' wages. Most people will have, in the lump sum, money to carry them over the period and that will give them a longer period for their weekly contributions.
Comment on this
When the Minister mentions "lump sum", one would think that it would amount to something.
Comment on this
At the worst, he will have two weeks' wages to cover a gap of two weeks. Most redundant people will have more and will not be left without money for the gap. It is a sort of horse-trading, if you like, but I think we should have a gap.
Comment on this
The weekly payment will undoubtedly be considerably removed from his weekly wage and it will last only a certain period. The lump sum will last as long as he sees fit to keep it. In the majority of cases, the lump sum will be utilised to supplement the weekly payment for as long as the weekly payment last so as to bring it as near as possible to his weekly wage. Most men endeavour to ensure that the wife has a fixed amount per week to run the home. If the lump sum is spread out over the period of weekly payments then the amount will not be anything related to his weekly wage. Perhaps we would never be satisfied with the amount of money that is paid. Many people will pay into this Fund who will never get anything from it. Let us not attach too much importance to this lump sum payment. When a working man thinks in terms of the expression "lump sum payment", he thinks of a few hundred pounds or £60 or £70—not of two weeks.
Comment on this
It is very pleasant to hear that the Minister is amenable to cutting down the time-lag in this connection. Much play has been made of the payment of a lump sum as something which would tide a man over this difficult period. Have we any guarantee that that lump sum will quickly be paid, that it is immediately payable when a man becomes redundant? Is it not conceivable that there would be a considerable time-lag before the lump sum is paid?
Comment on this
That is all very fine. We want to be completely satisfied that the lump sum will be paid quickly, immediately, on a man's being dismissed and qualifying for redundancy pay. If the time-lag is too great before coming to the rescue of a redundant worker by way of weekly payments, there is a grave likelihood that we may lose quite substantial numbers of skilled workers. In these times of high cost of living, the responsible worker and especially the skilled worker is not prepared to wait around for two, three or four weeks until such time as the State gives his extra benefit or until a job turns up.
Our experience at the present time, especially in industry, is that unless a man sees a prospect of employment— especially a man with family responsibilities who has been used to a relatively high standard of life—he invariably goes to Britain. Such people cannot afford to wait four weeks. They must come to a decision. Unfortunately, all too many of them decide to go to Britain. We simply cannot afford to lose this important pool of highly-skilled labour which may well be affected by redundancy.
Comment on this
We must not be niggardly or dilatory about it. I think, in all the circumstances, the Minister is being relatively fair in coming down from four weeks to two weeks. I want to sound this note of warning that, during this crucial period of waiting, a man and his family must make a serious adjustment in their standards of life and unless the assistance is readily forthcoming we may lose these people to our society and to our economy. The day has gone when men could simply stick around hoping, like Micawber, that something would turn up. If this Bill is to be effective, there must be the speediest application of redundancy payment.
Comment on this
The amendment is withdrawn, on the understanding that the Minister will meet us half way.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 57:
In page 30, after line 27, to insert the following new paragraph:
"13. Notwithstanding anything in paragraph 5, 8 or 9, a person who is undergoing a course of training arranged or approved by An Chomhairle Oiliúna shall not be disentitled to receive a weekly payment for the period of such training on the ground only that he is ineligible to receive unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance for that period."
This is designed to ensure that a redundant worker who is undergoing a course of training approved by An Chomhairle Oiliúna will be entitled to draw the weekly payments under the redundancy scheme as if he were not undergoing training at all. The Social Welfare Acts lay down that a person undergoing a course of training is deemed to be not available for work and consequently would not be entitled to receive unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance. Under Paragraph 5 of Schedule 1 of this Bill, a redundant worker is not entitled to a weekly payment if he is disqualified or ineligible in any way to receive unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance. As it stands this would mean that a person who is redundant but who accepts a course of training for employment would not be entitled to receive redundancy payments. The amendment is designed to preserve such a man's entitlement to weekly payments.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 58:
In page 33, line 50, before "section 10 (4)" to insert "section 10 (3) and".
This is a drafting amendment. If it is to be explained, we should have to study the complex provisions of section 10 (3) and Paragraph 18 of Schedule 2 to grasp the need for the amendment. If the House wants me to explain, I will endeavour to do so.
Paragraph 18 of Schedule I deals with the position of an employee (a) who is under notice of dismissal by his employer, (b) who has given notice to terminate his employment on a date earlier than in his employer's notice and (c) having done that, dies before the expiry date of his own notice and before his employer has a chance to give him notice requiring the employee to withdraw his notice. This is very complicated but circumstances do arise where an employer gives notice to the worker and the worker sees an opportunity of getting employment before the period of notice is up. In such a case, if he wishes to get redundancy payment, he has to give notice to the employer of his desire to terminate at an earlier date. If an employer for good reasons does not want to let him go, he has to give a further notice to the employee to withdraw his notice of earlier termination. If the employee should die at the stage where he had given notice to terminate earlier and before the employer has had a chance to ask the employee to withdraw his notice, this difficulty arises.
The intention is that in the circumstances I have outlined, it would be assumed that the employer had given the employee notice requiring him to withdraw his notice of termination of employment and the employee had not complied with that notice. If an employee dies in the circumstances I have mentioned, the rights of the employer to dispute a redundancy payment claim will not be taken away by the death of the employee. If the claim were disputed, it would be for the Tribunal to decide whether or not redundancy payment should be made. Just to go over that again: provision is made for a man who is under notice and who wants to leave his employment at a date before the expiry of that notice while preserving his entitlement to redundancy payment, to give notice that he wants to terminate at that earlier date. If the employer has good reasons for requiring the employee to finish out the notice given by him, then he must give the employee notice asking him to withdraw his intention to terminate earlier and if the employee unreasonably refuses to comply with that, then he would not be entitled to redundancy payment.
Comment on this
That is a matter that will be determined by the appeals tribunal. This section deals with the case where an employer had not time to give an employee notice to withdraw the employee's notice because the employee dies. This would mean the employer could not say that he gave him notice to withdraw the employee's notice.
Comment on this
May we take it that the clause is similar in every way to the wording contained in the British Act?
Comment on this
I think if we could get it drafted in such a way that a man under notice, whether his own or anybody else's, to terminate employment because of redundancy should get redundancy benefit, it would be better. I do not know if it can be so drafted. I will see if it can be improved.
Comment on this
This is to prevent disputes. There are some sections of the Bill which are really legalistic snakes and ladders. I have to accept that they should be there to cover isolated cases that may arise. It might be possible to make it simpler, but I might be told by the draftsman that it would not be possible.