National Loan 1987-1992. - Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 240–482 of 482. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1967 ›
If an employer gives notice and the employee wants to leave at an earlier date than the one contained in the employer's notice, because he has an opportunity of getting another job, and he gives the employer notice and before the employer has any opportunity to inform the employee that he will not accept the shorter notice, the employee dies, is his widow still entitled to redundancy payment?
Comment on this
Yes. The original drafting was to protect the employer against an employee leaving him when he needed him, even though the employee was under notice. As originally drafted, if an employer said: "I want your services to the last date of my notice," and if the employee unreasonably— and this is something that could be determined by the Tribunal—refused to finish on the employer's expiry date, he would not get redundancy payment. It depended on the employer saying in writing: "I want you to withdraw notice terminating your employment at an earlier date because I want you to the end of the notice."
Comment on this
I suppose he would have to say that he wanted him to remain on for business purposes. He could not do that if the employee dies. It would be difficult for the employer to say that the employee caused him to suffer by his absence for the full term of notice. It is something at which I should like to have another look between now and Report Stage. It is an isolated case, if the House accepts it.
Comment on this
Yes. If a man is under notice because of redundancy and is to terminate his employment on, say, December 1st and the man says: "I can get a job before that," and gives notice that he wants to terminate and get his redundancy repayments in the middle of November, then if the employer says: "I am entitled to your services to the last day I have given you and I require them" he is entitled to them. If the worker unreasonably says: "I am going before the notice is up," he will lose his redundancy payment but he will lose it only if the employer has told him in writing that he wants his services. If he dies——
Comment on this
If he dies before the employer has an opportunity to write to him, is the man's estate still entitled to redundancy payments?
Comment on this
It may. But for this amendment, however, the employer would lose his right to contest the payment because the man said: "I am leaving you before the time."
Comment on this
Will the Minister be re-introducing this amendment or introducing a new amendment to cover this?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 59:
In page 34, line 21, to delete "six months" and substitute "30 weeks".
This is a drafting amendment to remove an inconsistency between this paragraph and section 24. Section 24 provides for a time limit of 30 weeks in which to make claims for lump sum payments. Paragraph 20 is intended to provide for the position where a redundant employee dies before the expiration of the time limit for making a claim for a redundancy payment and, accordingly, to be consistent, it is necessary to change "six months" in paragraph 20 to "30 weeks". If this amendment were not made and the redundant worker died in the period between six months and 30 weeks without making a claim for a lump sum payment, his personal representative would be debarred from making a claim.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 60:
In page 34, line 43, to delete "an appeals officer" and insert "the Tribunal".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 61:
In page 34, lines 49 and 50, to delete "appeals officer" and insert "Tribunal".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 62:
In page 34, line 53, to delete "appeals officer" and insert "Tribunal".
Second Schedule, as amended, agreed to.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 63:
In page 35 to delete paragraph 1 and 2 and substitute the following:
"1. The amount of the lump sum shall be equivalent to the aggregate of the following:
(a) the product of one and one-half times the employee's normal weekly remuneration on the date of his dismissal and the number of years of continuous employment with the employer in whose employment he was on the date of dismissal, after the employee had attained the age of forty-one years, and
(b) the product of the employee's normal weekly remuneration and the number of years of continuous employment with the employer in whose employment he was on the date of dismissal, between the date on which the employee attained the age of twenty-one years and the date on which he attained the age of forty-one years, and
(c) the product of one-half of the employee's normal weekly remuneration and the number of years of continuous employment, with the employer in whose employment he was on the date of dismissal, between the date on which the employee attained the age of eighteen years and the date on which he attained the age of twenty-one years.
2. Where, in reckoning the number of years, of employment in accordance with paragraph 1 of this Schedule, twenty years of employment have been reckoned, no account shall be taken of any year of employment earlier than those twenty years."
Under the Bill as it now stands, a lump sum redundancy payment of a half week's pay for each year of employment between the age of 18 and 41 and one week's pay for each year of employment over the age of 41 is provided for, subject to a maximum of 16 weeks' pay. We propose that the lump sum should be as it is in Northern Ireland, that is, a half week's pay for each year of employment between 18 and 21 years; one week's pay for each year of employment between 22 and 41 years; and one and a half week's pay for each year of employment over 41 years of age. In addition, we propose that the lump sum should be related to the number of complete years in continuous employment up to a maximum of 20 years.
We feel that a man who has given such service in employment is entitlted to far more consideration than is proposed in the Bill. It is only proper that the Minister should accept this amendment as something more reasonable than that proposed in the Bill for a person who has given long and loyal service to a firm and who, through no fault of his own, finds himself faced with unemployment. As I said, the amendment we have tabled conforms with the provision in Northern Ireland. Surely we can have here at least as good a Redundancy Bill as is provided for there? I would urge the Minister to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
Apart from the practice in Northern Ireland, reasonable redundancy compensation has in a number of cases been negotiated with individual employers. Under the provision in the Bill, a person could work almost 20 years with an employer and find, possibly as a result of adaptation procedures or the re-equipment of the industry, himself faced with redundancy. Apart from temporary weekly redundancy compensation, the lump sum would be confined to a half week's pay for each year of service, which would be completely insufficient. For workers with long years of service to suggest, as the Minister has, that a half week's pay up to 41 years and a week over 41 years is leaving the situation most unsatisfactory.
In considering this Bill we must bear in mind we are dealing not only with cases of redundancy arising from a diminution in trade or a loss of orders. We may very well be dealing with redundancy brought about as a result of adaptation procedures or the introduction of new and expensive machinery, for which in many cases the owners may receive adaptation grants or grants from An Foras Tionscal. Yet the effect on that industry might be that the labour force is reduced. Even though production in that industry may increase, there could still be a reduction in the labour force involved. That is not guesswork. It has happened in many cases. Unless orders in such industries increase tremendously, you may have the situation in which fewer workers are producing the same or more goods. Cases can be cited from these benches in which employment in fairly substantial industries has decreased by as much as 30 per cent over a relatively short number of years; yet the production in the same industries has gone up. Therefore, we are not dealing with something that comes about merely by chance. It can happen as the result of the implementation of policy emanating in some cases from the Government benches.
In certain cases where this has occurred, as a result of negotiations by the representatives of the workers concerned, agreement has been reached to protect the workers against the effects of direct redundancy. They are guaranteed either that alternative work will be available for them or, in cases where reasonable pension schemes are in operation, they are urged to opt for a pension at an earlier age. But this Bill would not apply only to these cases. It would apply in any case where a worker is declared redundant. The Labour Party view on this matter is set out clearly in the amendment. In our view, the lump sum compensation under this Bill is inadequate in the circumstances I have described.
We would ask the Minister to look at the position again. Workers are not just cogwheels. They may be considered as such by the employers or even by representatives of the State. But for somebody who has worked ten, 15 or 20 years for an employer, that is his way of life. His domestic circumstances and his social circumstances are geared to that employment. Where redundancy occurs, it means a major operation so far as the worker is concerned, from the family and from the social point of view. He may have to transfer his home, maybe not to another town but certainly to a different part of the city or town in which he lives. I support this amendment and I would ask the Minister to have another look at the level of the lump sum compensation.
Comment on this
I should like to add to what has already been said in relation to the lump sum payment, which is probably the key to the whole Bill. This compensation is intended to cushion the effects of redundancy, which is a depressing and expensive period for a worker. He may have entered into long-term commitments in the belief that he would continue in permanent employment, and then finds himself redundant; he may have purchased a home near his place of employment in order to cut out travelling expenses. I believe the period of 16 weeks is somewhat short. The Minister has been fairly sympathetic right through in meeting the points of view of the various Deputies, and as this is probably the most important section of the Bill, I would ask him to reconsider the size of the lump sum.
Comment on this
I support this amendment and I am glad that Deputy Dowling is also supporting it. What is provided in this Bill could not be described as a reasonable lump sum. In this regard, I should like to emphasise something that has already been said, and indeed acknowledged by the Minister, that there will be a number of workers excluded from payment under this Bill who have paid into the Fund. The Minister has already indicated that he expects there will not be a great deal of redundancy. Those are two indications that this Fund will be reasonably solvent. If we take into consideration the Minister's confidence in regard to the future, we cannot be regarded as unreasonable in putting forward this amendment. Furthermore, as I said here last week, it is highly desirable that when the opportunity presents itself to be as good to our people as the other Government is to our people in the Six Counties, we should seize that opportunity. The opportunity is now there for us to equate our scheme with that of the Six Counties. What we are advocating here is already law in the Six Counties.
In the matter of the lump sum payment, there is not a whole lot dividing us. As Deputy Larkin pointed out, redundancy can come about as a result of improvements in industry and in some cases an employee may be regarded for the time being anyhow as conveniently old because the type of job he has been doing for a number of years has folded up. It could take a considerable time for such a person to adjust himself to other types of employment, and I understand the whole purpose behind these redundancy payments is to assist people to get by, pending the finding of other employment. That being so, it is imperative that we give them a reasonable lump sum payment.
Earlier on when we were advocating from these benches that the weekly payments should be made the first week after an employee's employment has been terminated, instead of after four weeks as provided in the Bill, we were told from the Government benches that there was this lump sum payment provision in existence. If one takes time to add up what this lump sum payment amounts to as it is set out, one finds it is nothing to write home about. We have the support of Deputy Dowling for this amendment, and I am sure there are other Deputies in the Minister's Party who feel the same way. If the Minister does not agree to the amendment, perhaps he would agree to make his decision known on Report Stage. We would naturally hope he would recognise that there is a case for increasing the lump sum payment.
Comment on this
I think there is a misconception here, because we are told we should give this lump sum, that we should make it bigger, omitting any consideration of the fact that this lump sum does not come out of public funds, that it does not come out of the contributions towards the Redundancy Fund but from the employer alone.
Comment on this
It is not a question of voting money from public funds but of putting an obligation on the employer only who is already contributing very heavily to the Redundancy Fund, who may very well find his business running down due to circumstances over which he has no control and that he has to pay this lump sum as well. It is not just a matter of the Minister being generous, of the Minister having another think about it. The Minister has not got to find the money. It is the employer who has to find the money. I agree that a man may very well be placed in a difficult position because of redundancy, but who is going to take the brunt of it in the total sense? As I see it, the chances of redundancy coming about by way of large-scale modernisation of equipment or methods are quite slight. It does happen occasionally but rarely enough. What is much more likely is that redundancy will be caused by a change in trading conditions, withdrawal of protection to an industry or some such factor over which the employer has no control. Where a business is contracting, it certainly cannot afford to pay unlimited lump sums to its employees.
Comment on this
We are not seeking unlimited lump sums. That is distorting it. We have set out what we are looking for.
Comment on this
Vastly increased lump sums. When all this is taken together, we find that the employer is being burdened far more—
Comment on this
It is not meant to be annoying, but very often the truth is disturbing to people who would prefer to pontificate sheer nonsense such as we have heard in this House already.
Comment on this
I would be the first man to say to Deputy Dowling that it is all very well for him to say: "Please, Minister, will you give increased lump sums", but Deputy Dowling has completely forgotten, as the Labour Party Deputies have forgotten, that the Minister will not be paying any lump sums, that the community will not be paying any lump sums.
Comment on this
It is always the employer who has to pay. Also he must not make any profit. That is the last thing he must do. Out of what is he to pay all this benefit?
Comment on this
If Deputy Cluskey did not annoy me, it would surprise me. I should be disappointed if he did not make stupid remarks. He has no conception of business. I do not think he has ever worked——
Comment on this
It disturbs Labour Deputies to hear the facts, but let it be clearly understood in the House and appreciated by the Minister, as I am sure it is, that we are not here to agree to distribute benefits out of somebody else's pocket. It is very easy to say that so-and-so should get more money when neither I nor you have to pay it, but when you are putting an obligation on one sector of the economy which has already been burdened with a considerable amount of additional taxation to subsidise this Redundancy Fund, to place on him an additional load at a time probably when business is least able to bear it, is all nonsense.
Everybody would like everybody else to have more money, but we must see where the money is to come from. The entire amount of weekly payments will be paid out of the Redundancy Fund to which the employer as well as the worker contributes, but the lump sum is entirely the employer's responsibility. I do not object to the lump sum provision as it stands. It is a good provision and an added incentive to employers not to declare people redundant. It is a penalty on an employer for declaring people redundant.
Comment on this
I do not think I was the first to mention "halo". Employers have not unlimited funds and neither Deputy Dowling nor Deputy Mullen nor anybody else should be irresponsible on that point, just to vote people money out of somebody else's pocket. That is completely irresponsible. If you want to increase the benefits, do it out of the insurance fund or out of public funds but do not put this added burden entirely on the employer's shoulders over and above what they are already doing. That would be completely unreasonable.
Comment on this
Very many employers already have pension schemes. Under this Bill they will without any pension scheme have to contribute a larger amount than the employees to the Redundancy Fund. Also the employers must now make provision towards setting aside a certain amount of money to pay this lump sum immediately on the dismissal of any employee for reasons of redundancy. What more can you ask? You may say the amount is small. It is small where the service is very short but it will be a considerable sum in the case of a genuine long term employee. The House must remember that we are not dispensing money out of the air. We are imposing an obligation on an employer, on a company, which probably when this arises will be very hard pushed even to meet its obligations. That is what happens when there is redundancy. It is a question of contraction of business and consequently there is no money there to distribute to anybody. Please look at this in a realistic way and do not begin distributing largesse without realising who has to foot the bill.
Comment on this
The final point made by Deputy Booth was dealt with by Deputy Larkin, that is that redundancy is not necessarily caused by contraction of business. Redundancy can be caused—and we are told by the Minister is likely to be caused—by the adoption of new methods of production which may make a reduction of the labour force inevitable. Contraction of business does not come into that and, in fact, adoption of modern production methods and the introduction of up-to-date machinery may bring about a situation in which far greater production is secured and consequently far greater profit instead of the reverse which is the poor mouth case made by Deputy Booth. Deputy Booth is a halo dispenser.
Comment on this
We do not want to hear any uncanonised saints from the Labour Party talking about it.
Comment on this
He did this but at the same time he did not speak entirely with the tongue of angels on this subject. In fact, he fell to what I might describe as no more than vulgar abuse in addressing Members of the House. It is distressing to see a man of his public image indulging in this behaviour.
Comment on this
Through the Chair, I want to ask Deputy Booth is he saying that the employers in this part of the country are not able to give this facility to their workers as the employers in the Six Counties are? Is he saying that they are not sufficiently well financed?
Comment on this
It is a different scheme. There is no weekly payment in the North. There are weekly payments plus lump sums here.
Comment on this
A very difficult feat and one which I know will take a little time and perhaps another election to accomplish. But the day will come and the Minister should not let his overweening self-confidence run away with him because it is on Deputy Dowling that he depends for sitting where he is and he must take account of Deputy Dowling's views on these matters.
Comment on this
I make a strong appeal for democracy on the Minister's part so that the voice of the backbenchers shall be heard in his Party.
Comment on this
Is the Minister then saying, in effect, that Deputy Dowling is only putting on a show here, that he has already agreed to these provisions? Is that what the Minister is saying? He is not paying attention. Leave West Limerick and Cork alone for a minute.
Comment on this
When the two Ministers have ceased discussing West Limerick and Cork and the arrangements for the weekend, I should like to attract the Minister's attention and to ask him is he saying then, when he says that Deputy Dowling's handiwork is in this Bill, that Deputy Dowling is putting on a false front, that Deputy Dowling is not sincere, because that is a gross insult to Deputy Dowling?
Comment on this
Deputy Dowling has expressed his views in private and has now expressed them in public. Government Deputies are tied down a lot. The Deputy must see that.
Comment on this
Your assistant from the extreme right, Deputy Booth, has disappeared, as he is wont to do, having delivered his conservative and Tory broadsides. However, nobody will take much notice of him.
Comment on this
——the fate of thousands of workers should be thrown aside? Is there nobody who will take the Minister's place?
Comment on this
There are plenty of volunteers who will take the Minister's place. The Minister considers himself indispensable. There is a very well-fed man behind him who will sit in for him. I do not want to take up the Minister's teatime unduly. I should not like to see him develop gastronomic difficulties. At the same time, I must say that I remember the time when such a triviality would not be brought up in defence of the effort to steamroll this Bill through the House, which is what is being done, without due and proper consideration.
Comment on this
I was doing very hard and laborious work, much more difficult than sitting here exchanging pleasantries.
Comment on this
It is obvious that you are not being kept under control. I must appeal to the Chair for protection against this gross interruption that I am subjected to by the Minister. If I may be allowed to come back to the subject of the Bill, I want to say that we feel very strongly that the proposal is acceptable. Surely, we cannot be in earnest in our protestations about our desire for the unity of the country if we perpetuate the inequities existing as between workers in the North and workers in the South? It is very obvious that we have a duty to endeavour to do as well as the Government in the North of Ireland do in respect of the people for whom they have responsibility. Accordingly, we urge this amendment upon the Minister. I certainly think that the Deputies who have tabled the amendment have done very well.
I am sorry that Deputy Booth is not here. I would have a great deal more to say to him if he were here, but as he is not here, I do not propose to say anything further about him. I would say to the Minister that he has got now the opportunity of proving whether Deputy Dowling is just putting on a show or not, whether he is pretending or not. We would like to know just what the Minister's attitude is in this respect.
Comment on this
I want very briefly to refer to one or two points. Strange as it may seem, the answer to this whole controversy may be found in the Labour Party's contributions and in Deputy Booth's, and in the centre there is the Minister who has given tremendous thought to this Bill. I feel with him that the Bill here compares favourably with the legislation in the Six Counties. It is a good start in a redundancy payments scheme. I would accept the Labour Party outlook that automation will lead to less employment but for the fact that this theory is over 100 years old, going back to the time when the Luddites of England opposed the introduction of the spinning jenny in Lancashire. They were defeated and Lancashire became the greatest cotton centre in the whole world until the Japanese, by better methods, made Japan the cotton centre. Automation and modernisation do not necessarily mean less employment. That has been proved in the United States of America where industries have been modernised and automation has been introduced. Eventually you have much greater employment. In the OECD magazine issued monthly or quarterly, the opinion is always stressed that automation does not, in fact, lead to redundancy. I do not think it does.
In fairness to the Labour Party, they do feel like Deputy Dowling and myself. While I know the Minister has given very careful thought to the Bill, it is natural for some of us here to seek more for a man who is going to lose his job. It is not a pension, merely payment to tide him over temporary difficulties until he finds alternative employment. I know what is in the Minister's mind. On previous occasions when we asked the Minister to amend a proposal, he has done so. I do feel that tonight, perhaps, he could extend the period mentioned in the Bill. That would meet the Labour Party's wishes and I am sure, despite what Deputy Booth has said, would meet his wishes. We have to consider the fact that this money will not come from Government funds or members' contributions; it will come from employers. If we approach this matter in the spirit that each person involved has his rights, an extra few weeks would not break any employer while it would mean a great deal to a worker.
I support Deputy Dowling and the Labour Party on this point in asking the Minister to examine the period mentioned in the Bill and, if possible, to extend it. At the same time, I want to pay tribute to the Minister who has done a tremendous job on this Bill. This is the first time that we have had redundancy payments legislation and the Minister has set a headline in its preparation and has promised that he will have special schemes for special types of workers. We can face the future unafraid of automation or that a worker will be left penniless. He certainly will not become affluent as a result of the Bill but, at least, he will not be left penniless. I put it to the Minister that he should review the period here and, if possible, increase it.
Comment on this
I do not wish to enter into a discussion with Deputy Moore in regard to the effects of automation. He said that automation does not bring about redundancy. He should have said: "should not bring about redundancy." We cannot ignore the fact that our unemployment figure has grown and is still growing and we are not in a period of full employment when we can start thinking in other terms in regard to automation. In my capacity as a trade union official, I have had some knowledge of the results of automation. In a number of cases it has brought about redundancy.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about that. Let us not talk about automation as doing great things for the workers.
I want to deal with the section now. Despite the knowing way in which Deputy Booth talked on this occasion —as he tried to do on other occasions —it is obvious that he, who is always eager to point out to people that they are wrong, has not applied his mind to this Bill at all. It strikes me that he has neglected to do his homework. He tried to come to the defence of the employers and he unhesitatingly cried on behalf of the employers, without realising the full extent of the provisions of the Bill. In the explanatory memorandum which was circulated to all Deputies, it is stated on page 2, paragraph 10:
The principal payments which will be made out of the Redundancy Fund are the weekly payments to redundant workers (paragraph 7 above) and rebates to employers who make lump-sum payments in accordance with section 19 of the Bill. The rebates to employers will be the equivalent of one-half of the lump-sum paid but a bonus of 2½ per cent of the lump-sum will be added to a rebate in respect of each extra week of notice given in excess of the minimum period of two weeks provided for in section 17, subject to a maximum rebate of 65 per cent of the actual lump-sum payment (section 29).
It is perfectly obvious that Deputy Booth did not read that. It is unfortunate that he is not here: as usual, as my colleague, Deputy Dunne, said, he runs in and makes a speech and runs out again. He is oblivious of what is happening. In this instance he does not know what he is talking about. There is the proof that rebates are given to the employers. Let us forget about crying and whinging about the employers paying the lump sum. The money to a great extent will come from the Redundancy Payment Fund. Let us stop talking about the employers paying all this. They will get rebates. Where will the rebates come from? They will come from the Fund. Indeed, I am sorry that Deputy Booth did not bother to study this piece of legislation since it affects his business as an employer, and his business as a man responsible for workers. Now and then he purports to have an interest in the workers.
I think a reasonable case has been made for the amendment. Many arguments were put forward in favour of it, including those made by Deputy Moore and Deputy Dowling. I hope the Minister will accept all that has been said. He has been urged from these benches and by his two colleagues to change this section and to make the provision which we are advocating in the Labour Party amendment. Undoubtedly this will not make or break the Fund. If what we envisage comes about, it surely will not break the Fund to give decent lump sum payments. There is no doubt that the lump sum payments and the weekly payments will be utilised by the working men and women to tide them over until such time as they find another job. During that period of tiding over, it is natural that they should aspire to have the same standard of living, if possible, or as near as possible to the same standard of living, as they had before they were declared redundant, while they were working.
The people we are talking about have less than £1,200 a year. They need this type of assistance and they need these lump sum payments. They are not extravagant lump sums. Another good reason why the Minister should accept this is that apart from this Redundancy Payments Bill, day after day the different trade unions find it necessary, unfortunately, to discuss redundancy payments in respect of some of their members, and on those occasions we have to ask the employers to have regard to the years of service given by the employees. In most cases payment has been made far in excess of what is mentioned in the Bill. I am conscious of the fact that the Bill provides for the minimum only. We have some decent employers and I am hoping that they will not regard this as the be-all and the end-all of this matter.
Comment on this
As I said before, these are largely tentative estimates of what the Fund can carry. Experience will show us whether we can improve them. The figures given here are based on the best estimate that could be made by us, but only experience can tell us what can be done in actual fact. The experience in Britain was that after a year or so of operation the contribution had to be doubled. Their estimate erred and they had to double the contribution to support the Fund.
The difference between our scheme and the one in Britain is that we have weekly payments out of the Fund. This Fund will have to carry the weekly payments and the lump sums or part of the lump sums. Deputy Mullen spoke about the rebate which may be given to an individual employer, and the individual employer will provide the rest of the lump sum. Industry generally in Ireland will be carrying these lump sums and weekly payments. If we want to make our lump sums equal to those in Britain and continue with the weekly payments, we will be putting too much of a burden on industry.
I think it is a better scheme to have weekly payments and lump sums rather than lump sums only. It suits us better to have lump sums plus weekly payments. I do not know what our experience will be, but if time proves that the Fund can carry more, the House will be in a position to accept a proposal by me to increase the amount. I have gone into this deeply with representatives of the workers and employers. Deputy Moore spoke about this period of 16 weeks. That is a figure which I would not mind looking at again, and increasing it.
Comment on this
Right. I do not think we can change the basis of calculating the lump sum without some experience.
Comment on this
I have gone into them and I must stay with them until we have experience. These are decisions which were taken. Under our scheme the man with long service, the older man, the man from 55 years on, with a lump sum and weekly payments, would be better off than under the British system.
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that he will consider extending the period to 20 weeks. I should like to raise another question.
Comment on this
We appreciate that the Minister is moving in that direction, but I would like to press the other matter. I am surprised at the ignorance shown by Deputy Moore when he talks about new equipment and new methods not resulting in many cases in fewer workers being employed. Let him look at his own undertaking and he will discover what has happened there.
Comment on this
In the Deputy's own case, new techniques and new equipment have meant a very substantial reduction in the numbers employed.
Comment on this
I can produce a letter I got only yesterday in relation to new methods, new equipment and a new approach: the firm is looking for a reduction of some 40 per cent in the labour force in one particular department. As it happens, they will not be made redundant; they will not be put out the gate. There will be alternative work for them elsewhere. Let us make the position quite clear because there has been a great deal of talk about productivity: productivity means making the same amount of goods with less labour or a greater amount of goods with the same labour.
Comment on this
With all due respect, Sir, I heard you permitting discussion across the floor of this House which had nothing to do with the amendment and, with your permission, I will now demonstrate the relevance of my remarks.
Comment on this
Ministers have called for a greater development of industry and that has resulted in adaptation and new equipment. That may well result in redundancy. Many employers on many occasions have indicated that, in order to make new techniques and new equipment most efficient, it might be as well if the older workers would stand aside, retire earlier, or become redundant. Employers are doubtful that the older workers can be retrained as efficient units in the handling of new equipment. As Deputy Mullen has pointed out, the Minister is very conscious of this particular problem and that is shown in the sections providing for a rebate out of a common fund in relation to redundancy compensation.
We are concerned primarily in our amendment with the effect on the worker who is declared redundant. There are two methods of approach. One is the payment of weekly compensation for a certain period. It is hoped it will be a short period, but it may be longer than is anticipated. The other is compensation by way of a lump sum. I urge the Minister to look again at this level of redundancy compensation. As the Bill stands, if a worker becomes redundant after 20 or 25 years service, he can get half a week's wages for each year of service. Would that happen at any level in management? The Minister knows very well it would not. Management would get compensation of one year, two or three years salary. Management would get adequate notice. Here we are dealing with the worker earning under £1,200 who becomes redundant after 20 or 25 years' faithful service. We hold that ten weeks redundancy compensation, aside from the weekly compensation, is wholly inadequate. In the case of a worker who may have difficulty in getting employment readily elsewhere, it is not only inadequate but utterly miserable. We appeal to the Minister to reconsider this.
Comment on this
Unless the Minister agrees to go some of the way with us in this amendment, this Bill will be an extremely poor measure. The amendment is by no means the best kind of redundancy scheme of which we know. There are many schemes in operation——
Comment on this
I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy, but he will have to adhere to the amendment. We are dealing with the lump sum.
Comment on this
There are many schemes in operation far superior to that contained in this measure. One has only to look at the schemes in operation on the Continent and in Britain. I know schemes under which two weeks wages are paid for each year of service, and sums in excess of that in certain industries. If the Minister insists on pinning down the lump sum payment to half a week's wages, or a week's wages are paid for each year of will stand as a very inferior one. The Minister has agreed to extend the payment period from 16 weeks to 20 weeks.
Comment on this
I have not agreed to extend the rate of payment; I have agreed that for the lump-sum the maximum period will be 20 weeks instead of 16 weeks. I am not talking about weekly payments. It is impossible to discuss the Bill if the Deputy does not know what is going on.
Comment on this
The Minister was out while I was here. In all the circumstances, I would like clarification of the original stipulation in the Bill that the half-week's pay would commence at the age of 18, between 18 and 41. I take it that the Minister has agreed to apply the scheme to people at the age of 16 and that this age limit will now change to 16 years of age. I do not know if the Minister is confirmed in that opinion at the present time, but I thought at an earlier stage that he was favourably disposed towards applying the scheme to people at the age of 16 rather than 18.
Comment on this
That is clear. One of the reasons why we feel that the lump-sum payment should be a pretty generous payment is the fall in the value of money in these times. Workers, when they are declared redundant, are compelled to make a decision, sometimes a quick decision, and this may involve the requirement of their being mobile enough to transfer to another area within the country or perhaps to emigrate.
Where the lump-sum is concerned also, many workers think in terms of branching out on their own and going into some little industry or enterprise and the payments which we envisage in this scheme are ridiculously low from that point of view. Taking a basis of an average wage of £10 a week, the redundancy payment under this scheme as at present constituted would not exceed £160, or £80 for the people who would be only entitled to half a week's pay. If one of the features of this redundancy scheme is to achieve mobility of labour and to entice people to change from one job to another, the Minister will have to increase the lump-sum payments.
In all the circumstances, we feel that a half week's pay between 18 and 21 is something which the Minister has in mind anyway, a week's pay for each year of service between 22 and 40 is contained in the British Act and we are only asking for 1½ week's pay between 41 and, say, 70. There is not an awful lot between us I suppose and I would appeal to the Minister at least to bridge that gap.
Comment on this
Otherwise, the lump sum payments are not very attractive. As was pointed out earlier, the Minister does not envisage a spate of redundancy and the vast majority of the workers who will be contributing to this Fund, fortunately for them, will never benefit by this scheme, so that in respect of the small numbers of people whom we are catering for, I feel that we could afford to be more generous.
Comment on this
There is no question of generosity. Before the Deputy came in, I was saying that we must keep in mind what the industry can carry and if our experience is that the benefits can be increased, we can come back here.
Comment on this
Our scheme provides for a lump sum as well as weekly payments; the British scheme has a lump sum alone. If we were asking our industries to give the equivalent of the British lump sum plus a weekly sum, it would be asking much too much. The workers would have to contribute much more.
Comment on this
I am quoting from the Minister himself last Thursday:
The basic thing behind redundancy is that a man has rights against his employer and he is compensated for those rights when he loses them.
Comment on this
There is no getting away from economic reality, and if you want a bigger payment, you must have a bigger contribution which would be a burden on the workers and on the industry.
Comment on this
According to the Minister's statement, a worker is being compensated for rights which he is losing. The employers pay it.
Comment on this
If there is necessity to increase the contribution after a year, then the Minister can make a case for it, bearing in mind the plans he has laid and that he has said there is not going to be any great redundancy in the future. The Minister is inconsistent.
Comment on this
I am not inconsistent, but it would be irresponsible of me to go away from the calculations we have made. If they prove wrong, I can come back.
Comment on this
The Minister admits that there is a considerable number of workers going to contribute to this Fund who will never get a penny piece out of it.
Comment on this
I will agree to raise the maximum lump sum. As I say, the older worker is doing better under this scheme than in Britain.
Comment on this
There are many other factors relating to older workers in Britain and older workers here.
Comment on this
There are many other factors which would justify their not doing so well, but here redundancy is a very serious problem. In many cases, it may be in small towns where there is little hope of getting employment.
Comment on this
That is why I am willing to make the maximum bigger. I will make the maximum 20 weeks, as requested, but the rest of the figures will have to stay until we have experience.
Comment on this
We will have it out with you on Report Stage. We reserve the right to speak on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 64:
In page 35, after line 33, to insert the following new subparagraph:
"(d) When the total number of years of continuous employment as ascertained in accordance with subparagraphs (a) to (c) falls to be divided for the purposes of paragraphs 1 (a) and 1 (b), any remaining parts of a year in those divisions shall be aggregated and the number of full years represented by this aggregation (when calculated in accordance with subparagraphs (a) to (c) shall be added to the period of employment mentioned in paragraph 1 (a)."
This is an additional sub-paragraph to paragraph 3 of Schedule 3 and it is necessary to provide a basis of calculation when the period of continuous service falls to be broken down between service under 41 years of age and service over 41 years of age because there is a different estimation of amounts for each and it affects the amounts of the lump sum to be paid. We have to lay down rules for the calculation of this because of a complication which arises from a provision which provides for periods of 26 weeks or more being rounded up to one year. In other words if a period of 26 weeks is remaining it is called a year. This is favourable to the worker. The purpose of the new subparagraph is that where this breakdown of service is necessary, any residual service under or over 41 is treated as years under 41. This arrangement preserves the balance between the employers' and the employees' interests. The employee gains by rounding up anything over 26 weeks to a year and to counter that incomplete years would be counted as equal to a year under 41 years of age. It is a fair balance.
Comment on this
It may not be strictly on the amendment but I would appreciate if the Minister would clarify the point in respect of entitlement under this scheme and this whole question of continuity of service.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 65:
In page 35, after line 45, to insert the following new paragraph:
"6. Where a trade or business or an undertaking (whether or not it be an undertaking established by or under an Act of the Oireachtas) was transferred from one person to another, the period of employment of an employee in the trade or business or undertaking at the time of the transfer shall count as a period of employment with the transferee, and the transfer shall not break the continuity of the period of employment."
This amendment is designed to ensure that continuity of employment is preserved for the purposes of redundancy payment, where a worker was employed in a business which changed ownership before the operative date of the Bill. This may be already covered by the Bill but the amendment is for the purpose of making it clear that a period of employment was not broken by a change of ownership in the business before the Bill became operative.
Comment on this
There is one question I want to put to the Minister on this. It is strictly not relevant to it, but since the Minister was speaking about this continuity, I should like to know what is the position of the workers who have been contributing to a pension fund in one business, say, Dunlops, at the present time? If they should become redundant but secure employment with Fords, can they carry over their payment rights to the new firm?
Comment on this
I thought that might be the intention of your amendment. It is the same idea in another context. As far as I see, the Bill covers what you want but I will make sure about it.
Comment on this
Would you indicate whether in fact your amendment covers the content of our amendment?
Comment on this
It is on the same principle. My amendment makes sure that changes of ownership before the operative date of the Bill will have the same effect as changes of ownership afterwards. The Labour Party amendment is intended to deal with transfers before the operative date. I think as the Bill stands such transfers are covered. The amendment has a limited date. I will look at the matter and see what should be done, if it is necessary to do anything, to cover what is intended.
Comment on this
Could I, at this stage, raise a question in respect of the interpretation of this whole question of seniority of service? I want to pose a special question to the Minister. You may have a situation where an employer arbitrarily decides to suspend the services of his workers and to take up an attitude that they are no longer entitled to seniority of service or any other perquisites attached to the firm. This employer adopts the attitude, as the result of a trade dispute, that the workers have ceased their entitlement to any recognition in the firm and that he is purporting to re-open the firm. He purports to re-open the firm, even though the firm is in the same name. Can that employer's arbitrary action have any adverse effect in respect of continuity of service under this redundancy payments scheme?
Comment on this
Once this Bill is an Act it cannot. On the Second Stage, I think it was Deputy Jones who mentioned the fact that people might do it before the Act was in operation. I said I would be prepared to bring proposals before the House to deal with such a situation.
Comment on this
Where we have evidence that it has already happened and where the cessation of the work only lasted a few days but the employer adopted the attitude that he would re-employ those people, break their service and purport to start afresh, would the Minister deal with this?
Comment on this
I would be glad to have details. As the Deputy will understand, you do not make law for rumours. I refer particularly to people doing this to avoid redundancy payments.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 66:
In page 35, between lines 50 and 51, to insert a new paragraph as follows:—
"7. Where an employee of a company is taken into the employment of another company which, at the time when he is taken into its employment, is an associated company of the first-mentioned company, his period of employment at that time shall count as a period of employment with the associated company, and the change of employer shall not break the continuity of the period of employment. This paragraph shall be deemed to have applied from the 1st January, 1966."
Comment on this
Amendment 68 is consequential on amendment 67. Both amendments may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 67:
In page 36 to delete paragraph 11.
The effect of this amendment is that we want a strike as well as a lock-out to count. The Minister makes it clear in the Bill that where a lock-out takes place, this would be deemed as allowable service for the purpose of qualifying for redundancy payment. We feel that "strike" should be inserted. We are asking that this word be inserted before "lock-out" so that this will cover both strike and lock-out. There are many cases where a strike would be very justifiable In the vast majority of cases, strikes are justifiable and people are placed in the position where in order to secure their rights, they have to withdraw labour. We feel that this period of time should be allowable with regard to qualifying for redundancy payments. We would ask the Minister to accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I wish to support this amendment and in doing so, may I direct the Minister's attention to what appears to me to be contradictory? We are objecting to paragraph 11 which reads:
Absence from work by reason of a strike in the business or industry in which the employee concerned is employed and which occurred after the commencement of this Act shall not be allowable as reckonable service.
Paragraph 10 appears to be contradictory. It reads:
Absence from work by reason of a strike in the business or industry in which the employee concerned is employed and which occurred before the commencement of this Act shall be allowable as reckonable service.
Paragraph 11 clearly indicates that workers who go on strike will not get redundancy payments. This is extremely unfair. It interferes with the liberty of people. Very often people have to go on strike. They have no other option. The Minister is very well aware of this in regard to the office he holds now as Minister for Labour. Many strikes have come about in this country after long and tedious negotiations extending as far as the Labour Court. What is being advocated in this paragraph is affecting all these efforts and you get an employer continuously saying no, as has been highlighted by a very eminent man who attempted to intervene in the bacon strike. If we have a situation of that kind occurring and the workers are let go on strike such workers will not be allowed to have that period of time taken into account as continuous service. We have always held that a workman on strike is still in employment, still under contract. Does it break his contract to have a disagreement with his employer? When he goes back, he goes back on whatever terms emanate from the strike.
That is added on to the agreement that is already in existence, but this particular paragraph will create a very serious precedent. It will encourage employers to do something that only a few of them have attempted to do up to the present. To the present time, in the matter of service being extended to people, we have had strikes which have been taken into consideration for continuance of service. This paragraph will inspire employers to say in future that if you go out on strike, the period you spend on strike will be a penalty and you will not get any allowance for that period by way of continuity of employment. If this happens, it will only make the people involved in a strike look for compensation before they return to work.
The taking out of this paragraph will improve the Bill. The continuity inclusion in it will destroy the real meaning of the Bill and will fall into line with the thoughts that have been repeatedly expressed, not only on this occasion but on other occasions, by Deputy Booth. There is no penalty of this kind being imposed on the employer. His failure to give continuous employment to the worker can end up only with the worker getting a meagre lump-sum or weekly payment.
I would entreat the Minister to accept the Labour Party's amendment and delete this paragraph from the Bill, just as he has in paragraph 10 where there is an allowance made for strikes in retrospect. They are taken into account for the purpose of calculating continuous service. Surely the Minister can follow it through and let it continue that way? We will not look to the future and say that there will be a series of strikes. Let this Bill not indicate any semblance of a big strike, of a penalty being imposed on workers because they exercise their constitutional rights, rights which they exercise most times after a lot of discussion and argument in connection with the matters affecting them. Very often it can be proved that the disputes that occur are not always the workers' fault. But this paragraph is saying straight away that because a person went on strike, he will have his continuity of service interfered with for the duration of the period of the strike. I would ask the Minister to change it.
Comment on this
I should like to put to the Minister another aspect of the matter. Section 10 deals with the question of absences from work through industrial illness and so on, and absence from work with the permission of the employers. Every case is dealt with on an individual basis, on the individual's absence from work because of his suffering from industrial disease or injury or being absent from work because of illness through occupational disease or absence from work with the permission of his employer for a period not exceeding 13 weeks. This is all covered on the basis of what happens in the case of the individual, but when you come down to this particular section, what do you find—absence from work by reason of strike or absence in the case of injury to a person concerned with his employment.
This particular case departs completely from an individual on strike, perhaps on a strike on a decision of all the workers in the particular employment. It may arise as a result of a section of the workers who are members of a trade union having a dispute with their particular employer and placing pickets on their employment, and other workers in the employment observing the normal trade union practice of not passing trade union pickets. Therefore, you have people who are affected because of this by reason of a strike, not even a strike they are engaged in, a strike from which they gain nothing but one which has affected some other grades of workers.
As has already been said, if you have progressive legislation going through this House, and with all its faults this Bill represents progressive legislation, it does not do very much good and it does not create any kind of good atmosphere to include a section like this in the Bill. There have been many cases in which employers in some circumstances have had perturbed feelings. Yet, they have recognised service for employment purposes, for seniority purposes, for the purposes of payment of service pay and for payment of other things, and interruption of work due to strike would not affect the claim of the worker. It has been accepted and agreed to very widely by large employer organisations and, in fact, accepted by the trade unions, that if a strike takes place, its having taken place should not deprive the worker of the rights he enjoyed previous to the strike.
This section will, in the eyes of the average worker, be a section which will interfere with the rights he had and which will affect him in relation to his compensation. Aside from these matters of a policy approach, let us say, I would put it to the Minister that if he looks at the record of the average period of people on strike, it is so short that to put such a paragraph in this Bill is only creating a situation where people will start looking back on records. Take five years from now. This is 1967 and it comes in in 1968. In 1970, the employer will start compensatory redundancy payments, start looking back over the records and will find "we had a strike of a week's duration in 1969; all right; that is when we got somebody else," and make all these calculations for the purpose of interfering with and reducing the rights of the workers under this Bill. From the practical point of view, it is not worth inclusion in the Bill and from the policy point of view, might I put it to the Minister that it is a section which does not contain the slightest bit of merit? The Minister has been not unreasonable regarding some of the Labour Party amendments. If he will accept this amendment, then he will be doing a good day's work in relation to this matter.
Comment on this
I fail to understand the full implications of this section. If the worker has a right to strike, a break in continuity of service should not occur with the implementation of this section. If it indicated that it applied only in the case of unofficial strikes or wildcat strikes, then there would be some sense in the section, but, in the case of official strikes, I do not see why there should be any break in continuity of service. If an employer feels he can hold up workers as an example —that they will lose redundancy payments because they participate in a strike—that is very wrong. I would ask the Minister to take another look at this section. I feel it is wrong; the worker has a right to strike and the question of continuity of service should be preserved if it is an official strike.
Comment on this
I merely want to add my voice to the voices of others in an appeal to the Minister to delete this penal clause, which is directed against the trade unionists of this country. Reading through the various sections here, one is amazed to see the inconsistencies from one section to another. Paragraph 10 reads:
Absence from work by reason of a strike in the business or industry in which the employee concerned is employed and which occurred before the commencement of this Act shall be allowable as reckonable service.
That is all right.
Paragraph 11 reads:
Absence from work by reason of a strike in the business or industry in which the employee concerned is employed and which occurred after the commencement of this Act shall not be allowable as reckonable service.
That is all wrong, but paragraph 12 says that absence from work by reason of a lock-out shall be allowable as reckonable service. This challenges the fundamental right of people to join a union and to assert their right to strike, which is enshrined in our Constitution: the right to free association and to withdrawal of labour when the necessity arises is fundamental. It is wrong of the Minister and his Department to seek to intimidate, reprimand, or denigrate in any way this fundamental right by allowing this penal clause to stand —that absence from work as a result of strike action will not be allowable as reckonable service. This is obviously an attempt to punish people for going on strike, even those who go on official strike with the sanction of their unions, and there is no punishment at all contained in this Act in respect of the employer who can continue to lock out hundreds or thousands of men indiscriminately at his own whim. The problem of lock-outs has been serious in these times also. It is gratifying to observe that the period of the lock-out is allowable as reckonable service, but there is obviously no way in which a Minister can get at the employer who may be completely in the wrong in respect of a lock-out.
Therefore, unless this Bill is going to show a very distinct anti-working class and anti-trade union bias, this penal clause must be removed. If it is a puny attempt by the Minister or his Department to intimidate trade unionists in the future—that because of the paltry sums which they will get under this measure, they will for one moment concede or acquiesce in this right to strike—these people are under a very mistaken notion altogether. This will have no effect at all in respect of the principles applying in industry in respect of whether or not there shall be strikes in the future; it will not alter the situation one jot, but it does appear to us to make very bad law that one section of our people should be singled out in this Bill for special treatment if they are not good boys.
It was a pity this section was allowed to stand at all, that it should come before the House, because it does indicate a certain mentality and it may well be a forecast of things in future in respect of this whole question of trade unionists, strikes and industrial relations. If this Bill is to be a new section of a workers' charter in this country, I would ask the Minister to consider omitting this reference to setting aside the period involved in official strikes. It is difficult to rationalise or understand why this should have happened at a time when the period of strike, prior to the commencement of the Bill, is being taken into account. I feel sure the Minister, being a sensible man, will meet our wishes in this matter and will not be influenced by people in his Party or outside it who have a distinct bias against trade unionists and who would seek to shackle them in respect of the rights they enjoy in our democratic society, rights which they will never give up.
Comment on this
A man's right to strike is held sacred in this country and, provided it is an official strike with union sanction, I join with Deputy Dowling in asking the Minister to look at this matter again. A man may be on strike for six months before he is affected and very few strikes last six months. Most of them are of much shorter duration. Deputy Treacy's suggestion that this is anti-trade union legislation is wrong.
Comment on this
Deputy Larkin took me to task for my remarks on redundancy. I refer him to the annual report of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions for 1957.
Comment on this
It was the last time the Deputy read the report. I have to deal with this problem and with the workers affected by it.
Comment on this
I am well aware of the Deputy's trade union history and let us leave it at that. I hope the Minister will see the point in the Labour Party amendment, supported by Deputy Dowling and myself. I must have regard to the Minister's view on this because he has given deep thought to it.
Comment on this
I am afraid we shall have to create a chance to discuss it again. This Bill, as drafted, is the result of many consultations with employers' and workers' representatives. Matters of the nature now before us have been debated at long and difficult discussions and it will be difficult for me to get away from the principle that a man creates a right in his job by working in it; and that when a man is on strike he is not giving anything to that job. Therefore, it is hard to say to an employer that he owes something to a man for not being there.
Comment on this
Reckonable service. I hope the Minister is not suggesting that the unions or the employers asked for this clause. I am satisfied the Congress of Trade Unions did not ask for it and equally, that the employers' representatives did not do so. Who, then, is the villain? Certainly it is not the Minister.
Comment on this
Past strikes are out, so let them be dead. From now on, the question is, should an employer reckon as service a period when he has not had the man in his service?
Comment on this
He will have to reckon the period as service. If an employer locks out his workers, he is penalised by having to count that as service by his workers. That is the penalty.
Comment on this
It is small because I do not think that in actual practice, it will amount to much. Certain employers will add this, that and the other as an aggregate of time out. I have some doubts about this.
Comment on this
Is it not very difficult sometimes to determine whether it was a lock-out or a strike? This very frequently occurs. Who will determine it?
Comment on this
If it comes to a claim in retrospect, there will be an appeal to the tribunal which would have to come to some decision as to whether it was a lock-out or a strike. It could arise only in the case of an individual who had so much aggregated strike time that he loses——
Comment on this
It is so small it is not worth mentioning in the Bill. Yet it is destroying the spirit of the Bill. It involves reckonable service. It is infinitesimal but it is ruining the Bill.
Comment on this
I will see if there is any way of determining how much it would mean in actual practice and mention it on Report Stage. I should like to point out now that it would not be fair to say to an employer that he must cover a man for working while he is not working. It is likely that, in operation and in practice, employers will not do this.
Comment on this
This gives them the opportunity. Good employers will ignore it but there are the fly-by-nights who take advantage of every technical loophole.
Comment on this
The people who drafted this clause dug a hole for themselves because there will be more trouble in the Department about this than the rest of the Bill.
Comment on this
I will look into it between now and Report Stage. The Labour Party can put down the amendment again.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 69:
In page 38, between lines 9 and 10, to insert the following new paragraph:
"22. For the purposes of paragraphs 14 and 15, account shall not be taken of any sums paid to an employee by way of recoupment of expenses necessarily incurred by him in the proper discharge of the duties of his employment."
Comment on this
This is the question I posed to the Minister and he asked me to furnish the information——
Comment on this
Would the Minister say anything now in regard to a person who is ill for longer than 26 weeks?
Comment on this
The basic principle is that employment shall be deemed to be continuous unless terminated by a dismissal or by the employee leaving the employment voluntarily. Notwithstanding that, it says that continuity of employment will not be broken even though notice of termination has been served where the employment is interrupted for a period not exceeding six months in respect of any absence authorised by the employer. The Deputy asked about a man who is sick for a period of less than six months. If a man is ill for longer than six months I think the employer could then dismiss him.
Comment on this
That is the point I wanted clarified. Would it not be possible to cover this contingency if there is a doctor's certificate?
Comment on this
I did realise, when the Deputy was speaking earlier, that there is special provision for some of the diseases which were mentioned. In the case of tuberculosis, I think there is a period of 18 months as against a period of six months for ordinary illness.
Comment on this
I shall have a look at that. I am not altogether satisfied with it. There is some possibility that what the Deputy is saying could be brought into the Bill.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister a question in connection with this Bill. I can understand that, perhaps because of all the confusion, he did not get an opportunity of replying. Is the Minister in a position to say what the salary will be for the chairman and vice-chairman of the tribunal?
Comment on this
It is probable that it will not be fulltime. I do not know yet how much work will be available. We have the comparable employment of chairmen of arbitration councils. They are paid on a fee basis while they are working. I imagine this could be the way the chairman of the appeals tribunal will work, unless there are so many appeals as to warrant fulltime employment.
Comment on this
Some of these people lay down their own charges. Will the Minister lay down the payment in this case?
Comment on this
Yes; it would have to be laid down by the Minister. I do not know if the chairmen of arbitration councils lay down a charge or whether it is mutually agreed. I think it is probably agreed.
Comment on this
The charges vary. I know of one case where £50 was charged for an hour's work. I know of another case where £100 was charged for half a day's work. This is very interesting.