Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967: Report and Final Stages.
Contributions 1–129 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1967 ›
Amendment No. 1, in the name of Deputy M. O'Leary, with which perhaps we could take amendment 7a, which is consequential.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 4, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:
"‘business' includes a trade, industry, profession or undertaking or any activity carried on by a person or body of persons whether corporate or unincorporate or by a public or local authority or a Department of State and the performance of its functions by a public or local authority or a Department of State".
Added to the amendments we have already suggested, we move this amendment to further strengthen the Bill and give it more comprehensive coverage. On this point of strengthening the Bill, perhaps I should say at this stage that my Party wish in some respects to compliment the Minister on the constructive attitude he has taken during the passage of the Bill in respect of matters we have brought up which we thought might help to improve the Bill. We feel that with this spirit we can further improve the Bill.
Comment on this
I will accept the Labour Party amendment. However, its acceptance would involve the deletion of the definition of "business" and I have tabled amendment 7a which would be consequential on accepting amendment No. 1.
Comment on this
Co-operation officially and unofficially.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 5, between lines 9 and 10, to insert the following:
"‘lay-off' has the meaning assigned to it by section 11 (1);".
This is to meet a point made by Deputy Jones that, where a term is defined in a section of the Bill but is used in an earlier section, it should be included in the definition section again. Amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 4 are all designed to meet the situation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 5, between lines 16 and 17, to insert the following:
"‘short-time' has the meaning assigned to it by section 11 (2);".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 5, between lines 18 and 19, to insert the following:
"‘the Tribunal' has the meaning assigned to it by section 39 (1);".
Comment on this
Amendment No. 5, in the name of Deputy O'Leary and other members of the Labour Party, has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
We are contesting this because I read in the press last week a suggestion that one particular undertaking would come under the terms of this Bill. The Minister knows that during the past year when we were pressing for the passage of this Bill, we suggested some retrospective provision should be part of it. I read in the press last week that at least one undertaking, Rawsons of Dundalk, was expected to come within the terms of the Bill.
Comment on this
There will be no retrospection in this Bill. Anything which would be done in the particular case would be done separately.
Comment on this
If Rawsons are to be covered in that connection, I would have thought that Brittains and Lincoln and Nolans, two factories in which workers have been laid off, would also be covered.
Comment on this
The Deputy is doing a disservice to that cause. I think we had better leave it. There will be no retrospection in this Bill.
Comment on this
We cannot have a discussion on amendment No. 5 since it has been ruled out of order.
Comment on this
It would be very difficult to do it, but as far as this Bill is concerned, I could not agree to retrospection.
Comment on this
I do not want to cut across amendment No. 5 since it has been ruled out of order, but may I be permitted to make one short comment? There is another aspect of this which is entirely overlooked, that is, that if there is no retrospective date fixed, smart employers will be allowed to re-employ workers for a period longer than 26 weeks, putting them outside the scope of the Bill. I am talking about what we referred to as long-term seasonal workers, and perhaps the Minister would have a look at that aspect.
Comment on this
I undertook that if I got evidence of evasion, I would take legislative measures to deal with it.
Comment on this
Unfortunately after the evidence is given, there will be no point in talking about it because the Bill will be law.
Comment on this
I am not talking about undertakings closing down.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 5, to delete lines 45 to 49, and in page 6, to delete line 1, and substitute the following:
"(2) This Act shall not apply to persons who work, or are normally expected to work, with the same employer for less than 21 hours in a week."
Comment on this
This is accepting the Labour Party amendment.
Comment on this
It was an amendment by the Labour Party.
Comment on this
I did say that in relation to young workers I would be willing to accept something which I had, at an earlier stage, refused. The context in which I said it was that I would be more willing to accept the case of the 16 to 20-year-old than something else which had been advocated by the Labour Party, and I think I had better put on record all we have done in the amendments. The first proposal is to bring within the scope of the Bill all part-time workers who normally work for 21 or more hours per week for the same employers. That was the reduction that was not previously mentioned by the Labour Party. The next thing was to reduce the lower age limit to 16 years of age, and I undertook to consider raising the upper age limit to 70, and the amendments give effect to this. This widens the scope of the Bill to apply it to all workers who are insured for all the benefits under the Social Welfare Acts, except part-time employees who work for less than 21 hours per week. It brings the scope of the Bill into line with the social welfare code.
Comment on this
Except that we think 21 should be 17.
Comment on this
I am talking about 16 to 70. When I agreed to take 16 as a starting age, I explained to the House that I started off by taking an age of 18 because of the belief that with a four-year qualifying requirement starting at 16, 20 would be too young for a person to be given a redundancy payment. I felt that at least he should be 22. I still have doubts about giving the redundancy payment to people at 20 years of age. However, at some later stage when I had been pressed to accept something which I found contrary to the principle of the Bill, I said I would prefer to accept the proposal to allow a person of 20 to get a redundancy payment. Having said that and having reflected on it, I decided to accept the inclusion of persons at 16 years of age without insisting on the 22 years of age minimum for benefit. Another consideration is that by specifying 22 we were making a qualifying period of six years for some persons as against four years for others. That is the explanation. The rest has been agreed by the House and the House sought what I am now proposing.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 6, line 4, after "household" to insert "(including an employee who is employed at agricultural, maintenance or other work connected with the household)".
I think this is consequential.
Comment on this
I am advised it is not necessary, since we have accepted No. 1 which broadens the definition of "business".
Comment on this
I do not see in what sense the Minister thinks it is not necessary. Our idea is to provide for the actual operatives involved.
Comment on this
Having accepted No. 1, we are covering what the Deputies wish to cover by this amendment. The people drafting the Bill advise me it is not necessary.
Comment on this
That is not correct and the people drafting it would need to have another look at it. It is quite obvious that it is necessary.
Comment on this
Will the existing provision suffice, having regard to what the Minister says, that they are covered?
Comment on this
Is this good enough and does it mean there will be no question of going to the tribunal or the board to discuss this matter?
Comment on this
We feel it strengthens No. 1, and that is why we put it down. Does it harm the Bill?
Comment on this
My advice is that what Deputy Mullen says is true, that by accepting the first amendment, we are covering the people whom it is sought to cover in this amendment.
Comment on this
I do not think that would be enough. If the Deputies like, I shall take further advice on it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 7, line 49, to delete "18 years" and substitute "16 years".
This is consequential.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 8, between lines 53 and 54, to insert the following:
"(3) (a) An employee shall not be taken for the purposes of this Part as having been dismissed by his employer if—
(i) he is re-engaged by another employer (hereinafter referred to as the new employer) immediately on the termination of his previous employment,
(ii) the re-engagement takes place with the agreement of the employee, the previous employer and the new employer,
(iii) before the commencement of the period of employment with the new employer the employee receives a statement in writing on behalf of the previous employer and the new employer which—
(A) sets out the terms and conditions of the employee's contract of employment with the new employer,
(B) specifies that the employee's period of service with the previous employer will, for the purposes of this Act, be regarded by the new employer as service with the new employer,
(C) contains particulars of the service mentioned in clause (B), and
(D) the employee notifies in writing the new employer that the employee accepts the statement required by this subparagraph.
(b) Where in accordance with this subsection an employee is re-engaged by the new employer, the service of that employee mentioned in paragraph (a) (ii) shall for the purposes of this Act be deemed to be service with the new employer."
This is a complicated matter which was raised by Deputy Mullen and Deputy Booth on Committee Stage. Both asked me to widen the definition of "associated companies" in the Bill so as to include companies that are associated by one having a holding of 25 per cent or more in the other. I explained on Committee Stage the difficulties involved in moving away from the already accepted definition of "associated companies". That definition, as I explained to the House at the time, was a definition based on one company being a subsidiary of another and this is defined in the Companies Act, 1963. I was satisfied, and still am satisfied, that we should not go outside that definition of "associated company".
However, I was at the time in sympathy with the intention expressed by Deputy Mullen and I accept that when a worker transfers from one employer to another, it might in certain circumstances be desirable that he should be able to carry with him the service he had with his first employer and to preserve the continuity of his employment even though he goes from one employer to another. I think this could be of benefit to both the employee and the employers concerned irrespective of whether they were associated companies or not. This is not exactly what Deputy Mullen and Deputy Booth asked for but it meets the general point of what they sought.
The important thing in an amendment of this kind is that the employee's interest should be fully protected and, as I explained to Deputy Mullen at the time, whatever we do should not diminish the workers' right to redundancy payment. If the Deputy remembers, it seemed to appear at the time that if you made the arrangement that he could be sent to another company he would have to lose his rights to redundancy payment by the company letting him go. I had the question examined to see if the spirit of what Deputy Booth and Deputy Mullen asked for could be met and this amendment is tabled to bring in the result of this deliberation.
The effect of the amendment is that where a worker voluntarily transfers from one employer to another and where both employers concerned agree that his service with the first employer will be regarded as service with the second employer, that is, the new employer, the continuity of his service for the purposes of this Bill will not be broken by the transfer. In the interests of the worker it is being provided that before the transfer the employee must be furnished with a written statement on behalf of both employers which (a) will set out the terms and conditions of the new employment; (b) contains the agreement of the new employer that the worker's service with the first employer will be regarded as service with the new employer and (c) that the notice contains particulars of the worker's service with the first employer. As an additional safeguard for the employee, it is also being provided that the terms and conditions set out in the statement must be accepted in writing by the worker concerned.
The worker need not accept, of course, and when it comes to the time when he would be leaving the first employer, if he so desires he can claim whatever redundancy payment he would be entitled to. If he does that, he can take employment with the next employer and start anew from that point. But, if he opts to go from one employment to another and carry his service with him and both employers agree then he cannot get redundancy payment but the decision is made by the worker himself.
The essential difference between the proposal and the provisions relating to associated companies is, as I have said, that the employee in this case has the option of refusing to accept re-engagement and to retain his right to whatever redundancy payment might be due to him from the first employer, while under section 16, as the House knows, if he refused an offer of re-employment he would lose redundancy payment.
Comment on this
I think the Minister has tried to go a long way to meet the points raised in this House in relation to this matter but I do not know how it would cover the particular problem of those engaged in the construction industry because one of the problems there would be the question of being able to get agreement between the preceding and the succeeding employers. The Minister's amendment provides that the employee would have to get documentary evidence of the problems in this industry is the lack of continuity of work.
Comment on this
This is a separate matter. This is something raised by Deputy Mullen and Deputy Booth about associated companies. The background to this is that an employee who is coming to face redundancy in a company may be offered employment in an associated company and the definition of associated company may not be broad enough to cover the situation. Deputy Mullen and Deputy Booth say that situations exist where, if we extended the definition of associated company further, there would be more opportunities for employees to get employment in other companies. I felt that what they wanted was to make sure that a man would get an offer of employment as quickly as possible, but to do it in the way I was asked would move us away from the definition of associated companies. What I have produced is a method by which two employers and an employee can so agree that the employee can say, "I do not want redundancy payment if I get employment from another employer and my service is continuous". But, the three, the employee and the two employers concerned must agree to the arrangement.
What Deputy Larkin is referring to now is the question of special schemes but this amendment is not to deal with special types of employment. It is to deal with arrangements where an employee says, "I will give up my right to redundancy payment from the first employer if he gets me a job with the second employer with continuity of service". It is a different situation.
Comment on this
I am quite aware that that is the situation but I am commenting on the fact that in relation to the type of worker that I have referred to and also referred to in the course of the earlier discussions there is the problem that service cannot be built up because the employment is not continuous with a particular employer or, in many cases, even with clearly associated employers. The hope of their coming within the scope of this Bill, having regard to the qualification, is very slight.
Comment on this
This matter was raised on the section dealing with associated companies on the last occasion. What I am suggesting now is to meet something the Deputies wanted. It does not touch on that aspect mentioned by Deputy Larkin.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 9, between lines 15 and 16, to insert the following:
"(6) In determining for the purposes of this Act whether at a particular time before the commencement of this Act an employee was dismissed by his employer, the appropriate provisions of this section shall apply as if the matter to be decided occurred after such commencement."
On Committee Stage, I said I would look at amendment No. 66 put down by the Labour Party. At the time I did not know whether it was necessary or not to achieve the intention in it. This amendment of mine arises out of that consideration. Do I need to explain it further?
Comment on this
Personally, I should like to know what exactly it means. I cannot make head or tail of it.
Comment on this
The Labour Party, on the last occasion, sought to provide that continuity of service would not be broken where an employee of a company was taken into the employment of an associated company and also that the period of service with the first company would count as service with the associated company. I think what was in Deputy Cluskey's mind was that before and after the Act there would be different circumstances.
The situation envisaged in the Labour Party amendment is covered by sections 9 and 16 of this Bill. Section 9, subsection (2) provides that an employee shall not be taken to be dismissed by his employer—in other words, continuity is not broken—(a) if the employee's contract of employment is renewed or if he is re-engaged by the same employer under a new contract which does not differ from the previous contract and the renewal or re-engagement takes effect immediately on the ending of his employment under the previous contract, or (b) in any other case the renewal or re-engagement is the result of an offer made in writing by the employer before the ending of his employment under the previous contract, and takes effect either immediately on the ending of that employment or after an interval of not more than four weeks thereafter.
Now section 16, subsection (1) provides:
Where the employer is a company, any reference in this Part to re-engagement by the employer shall be construed as a reference to re-engagement by that company or by an associated company, and any reference in this Part to an offer made by the employer shall be construed as including a reference to an offer made by an associated company.
The effect of these two provisions when taken together is that continuity of service is preserved, when an employee is re-engaged by an associated company as the result of an offer made before the termination of his employment with the first company, provided that the re-employment takes place within four weeks of that termination. The only doubt which arises relates to the question of whether the provisions of section 9 will apply to the renewal or re-engagement that takes place before the Act comes into operation. My amendment resolves any doubts in that connection.
Comment on this
I am afraid I cannot follow the Minister at all. The amendment is:
In page 9, between lines 15 and 16, to insert the following:
"(6) In determining for the purposes of this Act whether at a particular time before the commencement of this Act an employee was dismissed by his employer, the appropriate provisions of this section shall apply as if the matter to be decided occurred after such commencement."
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would let me finish? This whole question deals with the matter of re-employment in the same job.
Comment on this
I told the House during Committee that the section would come into operation when the Act is in force. The Labour Party asked would it work in the same way if it happened before the Act came into force. They had an amendment down to make sure of this. We are covering that now.
Comment on this
The amendment submitted by the Labour Party to which the Minister is referring was amendment No. 66. He is now indicating that this amendment was put in to meet what was advocated in amendment No. 66. That is not so because amendment No. 66 related to his amendment No. 65 on Committee Stage. We accepted the Minister's amendment No. 65 and did not pursue our amendment No. 66. The Minister is now relating this amendment to amendment No. 66. That is causing confusion. As my colleague, Deputy Tully, points out, it refers to a different matter. Perhaps the Minister could give us a more concise explanation of what he is doing in this amendment?
Comment on this
This is Report Stage. The point is that a Deputy may speak only once on Report Stage, unlike Committee Stage of a Bill. I am just explaining this so that there will not be any confusion.
Comment on this
We have been attempting by skating closely around Standing Orders to have something decided quickly rather than having everyone getting up in turn. I ask the indulgence of the Chair to allow this to continue. Otherwise, we will be here all night and for many nights.
Comment on this
I have the Labour Party amendment here. I may have confused the House by my explanation of the sections involved. The essential problem was recognised quickly on the last occasion, that is, whether the provision of the section would apply to events that happened before the commencement of the Act. What I am doing in this amendment is what the Labour Party asked me to do. The last night I felt it would not be necessary but I undertook to examine it to see if it would be necessary. The reason for the lengthy evaluation was that the amendment will change the wording of a section other than section 16 and produce the same result as the Labour Party amendment.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if the special circumstances which I outlined to him on the last occasion are covered by his amendment, in respect of a number of workers who took unofficial action and whose employer insisted that unless they resumed work by a certain date, they would, to all intents and purposes, have to re-apply for their jobs, re-enlist in the firm, that their services would be reckoned as and from that date, and that their previous service with the same firm would be set aside altogether?
Comment on this
I got the Deputy's letter yesterday but I did not have time to deal with it by today. It will be possible to deal with it in the Seanad.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that the amendment he has brought forward at this stage does not cover them?
Comment on this
The evidence which the Deputy mentioned came to me yesterday and I am having the legal implications examined. I did not have time to have it with me today.
Comment on this
I called amendment No. 12 but I am informed that it is out of order.
Comment on this
That is right. I want to make the point that we feel it is a pity this could not be included in the Act because we feel it would strengthen the Act. All the Labour Party amendments have been designed to strengthen the Act and make it a better piece of legislation. We regret that the Chair has ruled that these people cannot qualify in a two-year period. That is regettable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 20, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following:
"provided, however, that where an employer is insolvent, the Minister shall be entitled to claim in the bankruptcy, arrangement, administration of the insolvent estate or winding up (as the case may be) in respect of, and only in respect of, a sum (if any) equal to the amount of the payment made by the Minister under this section less the amount of the rebate that would have been payable to the employer from the Redundancy Fund under section 29 if the employer had paid the lump sum to the employee."
When we were considering section 32 in Committee, I told the House that I understood from the Official Assignee that subsection (3) of the section might be defective and that I was having the matter examined further. The subsection provides that, where a lump sum payment is made to a worker out of the Redundancy Fund because of the failure of his employer to make the payment, the Minister will have the right to take any necessary action to recover from that employer the appropriate amount.
With relation to bankrupt employers, the intention is that in claiming against the estate of a bankrupt employer the claim will be limited to the net amount due from the employer instead of the full lump sum payment—that is, the amount of the lump sum payment, less the amount of rebate he might receive if he had made the payment. I have been advised that, in order to proceed in this way, the intention would need to be made clear in the subsection and the amendment is designed to achieve this.
Comment on this
This is a welcome move, but does it not highlight the necessity for taking steps, if not in this measure, then in some other measure, to ensure that in the case of bankruptcy, the worker will be protected? Provision will have to be made to ensure that his payment in lieu of notice plus any other moneys which may be due to him will have first call in any proceedings.
Comment on this
I merely make the point. Will the Minister bear in mind the necessity for protecting the workers in the case of bankruptcy? Even if that is not within his competence in this measure, it is nevertheless something to which he should attend.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Deputy's point. As far as this Bill is concerned, the worker is protected. The point raised by the Deputy would be for separate consideration. I shall bear it in mind.
Comment on this
Other points have been raised in this debate which will be proper for other legislation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 14:
In page 23, to delete lines 20 to 22 and substitute:
"(a) as to one half of those members, on the nomination of the Irish Congress of Trade Unions".
We suggested on Committee Stage that the nominating bodies on the employees' side should be the Irish Congress of Trade Unions. The Minister explained that that was the usual procedure. However, we are anxious that it should be made quite clear and we believe that this amendment would strengthen the Bill.
Comment on this
In the previous discussion I told the House it would be my intention to seek nominations from the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, but I do not think I should like to introduce it in quite this way into the Bill. I will be prepared to say: "As to one half of those members, being persons nominated for that purpose by an organisation representative of trade unions of workers." That would bring it into line with the Industrial Training Act.
Comment on this
We appreciate the Minister's good intentions. We know, however, that there is a tendency for some groups to describe themselves as trade union organisations. It is not very difficult to get a licence and it is not very difficult for house unions to come into existence. It could happen that a number of house unions would get together and describe themselves as an organisation representing trade unions. Apart from the Minister's goodwill, it is imperative to ensure that the nominations will be from reputable representatives of the workers, and that is the Irish Congress of Trade Unions.
Comment on this
The implication is not mine at all because I am mindful of the fact that some of the Minister's colleagues favour the formation of house unions.
Comment on this
My practice has been, and will continue to be, to accept nominations from the Congress of Trade Unions. The wording I have here—the House will have to agree to it now as an amendment—is "an organisation representative of trade unions of workers."
Comment on this
An organisation, not organisations.
Comment on this
"As to one half of those members, being persons nominated for that purpose by an organisation representative of trade union workers."
Comment on this
So long as it is not a French organisation, or a German organisation, or anything like that.
Comment on this
I do not think any organisation would suddenly spring up like that. By leave of the House, I will change the wording if the Labour Party withdraw their amendment.
Comment on this
I move the altered amendment:
as to one half of those members being persons nominated for that purpose by an organisation representative of trade unions of workers.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 30, to delete lines 1 to 9, and substitute the following:
"(2) There shall be paid to the Minister for Finance out of the Redundancy Fund, at such times and in such manner as the Minister for Finance may direct, such sums as the Minister may estimate, on such basis as may be agreed upon between him and the Minister for Finance, to be part of the said expenses of the Minister or any other Minister in carrying into effect section 39, and any sums so paid shall be appropriated in aid of moneys provided by the Oireachtas for carrying this Act into effect."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 30, line 17, after "for the" to insert "keeping of records and the".
Here, we ask that, as well as furnishing information, the employers will also keep permanent records. If that is done, we should be able to build up a body of information on the working of the Bill and make available statistical information that might be valuable in the future.
Comment on this
Section 17, unless it specifically states that records must be kept, will be of very little use and we are therefore asking that employers should be required to keep records.
Comment on this
I have not decided what the final form of the regulations to be made under section 57 will be. I would be prepared to accept this amendment on the understanding that it does not commit me to anything specific in relation to the regulations I may make under section 57. It may be felt desirable to include provisions regarding the keeping of records by employers but a final decision on what regulations will be made has not yet been taken. When regulations have been prepared, I would accept the amendment on condition that it does not commit me at this stage regarding what precisely should go with the regulations.
Comment on this
The problem here is that the section provides that the employer may be required to furnish information. We feel in relation to the records of workers for the purpose of this Bill that it is completely unrealistic to say that the employer is required to furnish information if the employers do not know in advance that they will be required under the Bill to keep records so as to have the information available, as and when required.
Comment on this
I will accept it. The wording ahead of it in the Bill "The Minister may..." gives me enough freedom. I will accept it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 30, to delete lines 49 to 51 and substitute the following:
"4. A weekly payment shall not be paid to a person entitled thereto until the expiration of the period of two weeks beginning on the date of the termination of his employment and shall not be paid in respect of that two-week period."
We agreed on this on Committee Stage. An amendment was proposed by the Labour Party to reduce from four weeks to one week the waiting period for the commencement of the weekly payments. I said at the time that I was unable to come down to a week but I accepted a two-week period and I think the House agreed. This amendment has met the undertaking I gave at that time. I have added to the paragraph certain words which I think are desirable to make clear what the intention is.
Comment on this
We recognise that on Committee Stage the Minister met quite a number of points raised by Labour Deputies. The Labour Party had an amendment before the House on Committee Stage seeking payment after one week. The Minister indicated that he would go some way to meet the amendment and the suggestion that he was prepared to bring in an amendment for payment after two weeks was accepted by the representatives of the Labour Party. Consequently we accept the Minister's amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 31, line 7, after "continuous employment", to insert "after he has attained the age of sixteen years".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 31, lines 22 and 28, to delete "four-week period" and substitute "two-week period".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20.
In page 35, line 10, to delete "not".
We are getting very confused in this. The original amendments I had on Committee Stage were to meet a situation which might arise but which I would expect to arise very rarely. In explaining the particular paragraphs I thought they were confusing and undertook to try to have an amendment to simplify them. To explain it properly, I will have to give the background to the sections involved. Section 10 of the Bill deals with the position of an employee who is under notice of dismissal and for some reason wants to anticipate the date of expiry of the dismissal notice. If an employee knew he was becoming redundant and wished to get other employment which was offering earlier and wanted to leave the employment before the notice of the employer expired, then he would tell the employer that he himself was giving notice of an earlier expiry time and in that way he would preserve his right to a redundancy payment, unless the employer gave a counter-notice telling him that he required his services to the last day of the notice the employer had given. If, in spite of that counter-notice, the employee did not fulfil the full term of notice given to him by his employer, his right to a redundancy payment would be in question, that is, if the employer were acting reasonably.
That is all here. What was not here was the position which would arise if an employee died before the employer had given the counter-notice or if the employer had given the counter-notice but the employee died before the date of expiry of his own notice. In those circumstances, it would be doubtful if the next-of-kin could claim redundancy payment. Deputies, as far as they could see the situation arising, felt that this might be unfair in relation to an employee's estate. The amendments I now propose will have the effect of stating the position positively in favour of the employee or his next-of-kin by treating the employee as if he had complied with the requirements to get his redundancy payments; in other words had complied with the employer's counter-notice.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 35, line 16, to delete "but did not comply" and substitute "and had complied".
Amendment agree to.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 36, line 11, to delete "one half of".
We are sorry to have a difference on this point. The Minister will recall that we considered the lump sum to be inadequate. We proposed in our amendments to increase the amount of the lump sum to people as they went on in life and we tried to bring the lump sum payment to a more realistic figure for Irish conditions. I suggested that people disemployed in Ireland might be longer looking for alternative work than in other countries and that the amount of the lump sum would need to be geared to this situation. We suggested that the amount of the lump sum should be equivalent to the aggregate: we suggested deleting "one half of". The Minister said that it should be only a half week's pay; we suggested one week's pay and our second amendment suggested that it should be increased to one and a half after he had attained the age of 41 years. Both of these suggestions we thought went a long way to strengthen and improve this Bill.
We think our amendments would make this Bill a more effective piece of legislation which should be the aim of every political Party in this House. The aim of the Labour Party is to strengthen and improve this Bill and it is in that spirit that we suggest these matters on the financial side of the Bill. We do not think that the financial figures laid down here are excessive. We suggest that the minor improvements we suggest would make all the difference in giving the worker some financial protection at a period when he is out of work.
We have been accused on this suggestion and on others of confusing this Bill with a social security measure and we have said repeatedly that in this country a redundancy payments Bill, in some respects, because of the inadequacy of our social security system, must take on some aspect of what might come under social security in another country. We do not suggest that the figures here are in any way excessive but we suggest in our country they are very necessary and we ask the Minister to consider this matter very closely. This amendment proposed by us is another effort to improve this particular Bill. We feel it is necessary and we hope the Minister can see his way to accepting the amendment.
Comment on this
I could not accept these amendments. These amendments would make for very substantial increases in the lump sums payable under the Bill. As I tried to explain before, the principal difference between the scheme we have in this Bill and that in Britain is that in Britain there are no weekly payments. We have a scheme with lump sums and weekly payments. I consider this is a better scheme than if the total amount of benefit were paid in a lump sum. I believe if we try to make the lump sums as big as elsewhere and at the same time give weekly payments we are putting too great a burden on industry, because the contribution would certainly have to be higher.
I have already told the House that we have made estimates of what we are likely to get from the contributions. They will be about £1 million a year. We have also made estimates of what the likely outgoings will be and this is the basis of the figures we have arrived at. I have already made concessions in relation to the age and in relation to certain classes of workers who work for 21 hours a week. I said I would make a change—I have an amendment down to this effect—to allow the maximum lump sum to be the equivalent of 20 weeks pay rather than 16 weeks pay. All those concessions will cause additional outgoings and may mean that I will have to come back to ask for higher contributions. Any such increase would have to be approved by the Dáil. I have been so concerned about the possible effects on the Redundancy Fund that in an earlier amendment, which we did not discuss, I have provided that the expenses of the administration of this Act will be carried by the Exchequer. My intention here is to try and avoid having to increase the contributions. The Exchequer will now carry the expenses of administration except those relating to the appeals machinery which I think should be carried by the Fund. I do not think I can go beyond that.
Comment on this
I want to put this to the Minister, as I stressed on Committee Stage, that if the economy of this country were being managed properly the need for this Redundancy Bill might not be there at all, but because it has not been managed properly, the Minister has been faced with the late necessity of bringing this Bill into the House. The people who would be affected by this, and in respect of whom we are concerned, would be people in many cases where adaptation procedures have been introduced and where considerable amounts of public money will have gone to aid the employer to improve or instal new equipment. The very fact of operating this means that workers in such establishments may well find themselves redundant.
We said on Committee Stage that we could give many instances of cases in which, where new techniques and new equipment have been installed, redundancy has occurred in such industries and employment. We indicated that this measure of a lump sum compensation for workers so made redundant or made redundant because of inefficient management and the failure of management over the years to develop their organisations should be such as to compensate them fully for what they have lost. We indicated that in relation to this lump sum compensation, the basis of half a week for each year of service up to 41 years service and a single week for service of 41 years was, in our view, inadequate. This is not just our view because we believe we are expressing here the feelings of workers who would be affected.
Take the situation of a worker of 55 years of age with 20 years service who may be affected. What would that man have? The most he would have would be compensation for about 15 years. The Minister went a bit further in relation to the maximum period and in many other sections of the Bill, we can see that he has been quite reasonable with regard to the points of view expressed by the House. This is one of the vital issues, the issue of what is going to happen to the worker who becomes redundant and who will need the compensation, aside from the weekly payments, and consequently we press on the Minister to accept our two amendments, Nos. 22 and 24.
Comment on this
I want to join with my colleague, Deputy Larkin, in advocating that the Minister should change his mind in regard to this particular matter. The point that has to be borne in mind in particular is that people regard a lump sum payment as something very substantial. The Minister has already used the word "substantial". I submit that in circumstances of this kind, where the maximum lump payment is bound to be 20 weeks half pay, it cannot be regarded as a handsome sum and is not a very great compensation for the person concerned after all his years of service.
There is another very good reason why the Minister can afford to meet this proposition of ours and it has regard to what he himself has said. He has said that there will be quite a considerable number of people excluded from this Bill. He has admitted that there will be a number of people paying in accordance with the provisions of this Bill who will never get anything out of it. If we are to have regard in a serious way to the Minister's anticipation of the future and the expectations in regard to redundancy, the amount of money so paid out will not be so big because the Minister is fairly confident of the future in regard to industry. That being so, I think this highlights the absence of a rush on the Fund, if what the Minister says is correct.
Furthermore, it is unreasonable of the Minister to make comparison with the situation which exists in Great Britain. Once we think in terms of lump sum payments, we also have to have regard to the reliefs that are afforded to the people concerned. They do not exist here and there is no indication of their coming into existence for the people of this country. I would entreat the Minister to have another look at this matter. If he were to accept what we are advocating in our amendment, it would not have a serious effect on the Fund. As I have already said, there will be a considerable number of people contributing to this Fund who cannot benefit from it because they will be excluded from its provisions. We realise that this Bill will be regarded by a great many workers as locking the stable door when the horse has gone, because a number of workers who should be included will not be included, even those who have been declared redundant in the past few weeks. This Bill is leaving us in the position of saying that this is the end of it, that there will not be a dearth of industry. Let us be realistic and face the facts.
Comment on this
I have given my reasons and I think the House must appreciate that we can only work on the best calculations possible which are available to us now. If experience shows that we can afford better payments I will ask the House for its agreement to improvements at the appropriate time.
Comment on this
The figure we are looking for is not excessive. We have pointed out that the lump sum for the people involved, who are out of work, cannot exceed a certain figure and we do not consider it excessive. You have made calculations and are you suggesting that on your budget you cannot give it?
Comment on this
We do not know with certainty now how much redundancy will occur. We do not know the age groups of those who will become redundant. If they belong to a particular age group, there will be greater amounts involved than if the workers concerned were younger people. The age, experience and so on of people made redundant will determine the level of redundancy payments. The provisions of the Bill related to the income of the Fund and no matter how well-wishing you are, you have to relate what you do to what you can afford to do. This is not a case of Santa Claus handing out.
Comment on this
No politicians would hesitate to give out gifts. We want a scheme than can be carried by Irish industry, to protect Irish workers. If experience shows that the calculations are wrong I will come back to the House. I have to start the scheme with the best calculation I can make in advance.
Comment on this
There are a number of imponderables. Let us have the Bill on the best calculations we can make now, and if we find we can do better, we can discuss it again.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept in good faith that the Labour Party have done their calculations, and we feel this is necessary? We ask you in all earnestness to accept our amendment. Will the Minister accept it?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?