We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967: Report and Final Stages.

Contributions 130–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Redundancy Payments Bill, 1967
Enacted

No. 10 of 1967 ›

Acting Chairman

Amendment No. 24 has been discussed with amendment No. 22.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 36, lines 23 and 24, to delete "sixteen weeks' " and substitute "twenty weeks' ".

I mentioned this when speaking on the other amendment. I propose to raise the maximum amount of a lump sum payable from equal to 16 weeks pay to 20 weeks pay.

Comment on this

I am thankful to the Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy is welcome.

Comment on this

Deputy Dowling never thought of it until we suggested it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 26:

In page 37, to delete lines 1 to 8, and substitute the following:

"5. Where an employee's period of service had been interrupted by any one of the following—

(a) a period of not more than 52 consecutive weeks by reason of sickness,

(b) a period of not more than 26 consecutive weeks by reason of—

(i) lay-off,

(ii) holidays,

(iii) service by the employee in the Defence Forces of the State,

(iv) any cause (other than the voluntary leaving of his employment by the employee) not mentioned in clause (i) to (iii) but authorised by the employer,

continuity of employment shall not be broken by such interruption even though notice of termination of the contract of employment has been given.".

Deputy Jones raised the matter of the length of time a man might be sick without breaking continuity of service, where he had been dismissed but had been taken back into his employment. The Deputy thought six months, which was the time mentioned, too short. I have arranged that the period of 26 weeks shall be altered to 52 consecutive weeks in the case of illness. The periods in relation to lay-off, holidays, service by the employee in the Defence Forces of the State or any other cause not mentioned in clauses (i) and (ii) of the paragraph in question but authorised by the employer, will not break continuity of employment, which, even though notice of termination of the contract of employment has been given, will remain at 26 weeks. I should like to explain that even if a man had been sick for three years, and his employer wishes to overlook that, it will not break his continuity of employment. However, if a man is sick for over 12 months then, under this new amendment, the employer could terminate the employment and continuity would be broken.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Minister.

Comment on this

I want to put it to the Minister that the 26 consecutive weeks by reason of lay-off is still very inadequate and that there is a very compelling case to be made that it should be at least 52 weeks. The Minister will surely have taken into account that there is quite a lot of seasonal employment in this country and that it is not unusual for workers to be laid off for some months of the year. We know of instances where the period has amounted to some six months, or even more, so that the Minister is placing in a very precarious position those thousands of casual workers in industry, on the bogs, on the roads, in the building industry and the like, by confining them to a 26-week period for reckonable service. In all the circumstances, I would ask the Minister to have a second look at that stipulation in respect of lay-offs. I feel that 26 weeks is dangerously low in respect of the very many categories of workers whom we know to have no security of tenure in respect of employment and who are used to being laid off from time to time.

There is, too, a real danger that, where the employment is checkered, haphazard or casual, the employers may avail of this clause to set their workers outside the Redundancy Payments Bill, when enacted—disfranchise them, disqualify them, so to speak, of set and deliberate purpose by laying them off for more than 26 weeks. This is a real possibility in certain industries, in certain spheres of employment: I do not wish to name them here. It is wide open to an employer to exonerate himself from the obligations contained in this measure merely by keeping them out of work for more than six months, thereby disqualifying them from benefit and exonerating himself in respect of any payments under the scheme.

Comment on this

I think the Minister, in introducing the amendment, has improved the section considerably because, as previously drafted, it provided for a maximum of only 26 weeks. I wonder if the Minister has gone far enough. He refers to 52 weeks illness. This section is dealing with continuous employment for the purpose of the Bill, not reckonable service. Take a person who may have to spend a period in hospital. We know that TB is pretty well in hand at the present moment. Its incidence is not nearly as high as it was. Nevertheless, it occurs. It is to be found in the middle-age group at this stage much more than it is to be found in the young. It is quite a common fact that people have to receive hospital treatment—perhaps nine months, 12 months or 15 months in hospital—and may then have to attend clinics before they are fit to resume work. A person may have been working for ten years or so and contracts TB or is a victim to any long period of illness. Such person will lose, for the purpose of the Bill, continuity of employment. I do not think the Minister would intend to deprive people who are unfortunate enough to be struck down with a serious illness from getting the benefit, on return to work, of previous service for the purpose of this measure. The same thing may come under another heading. Lay-off has been dealt with by Deputy Treacy, and quite properly so. There are a number of employments with what might be termed temporary workers who, over a number of years, work for four or five months in the year for the same employer and automatically go back to work with the same employer. Yet, under this, they would never qualify for any recognition and would never qualify over the years for any protection under this Bill.

While agreeing that the Minister's amendment does improve the Bill, I would ask him whether he would not look at this question again from the point of view of long-term sickness. I do not think there is a Member of this House, least of all the Minister, who would, on reflection, suggest that a person who is in employment for ten or 15 years and contracts TB or is seriously ill, or for any other such cause, and is out of work for a period of 52 weeks, should on return to work, lose all the benefits of his or her employment from the point of view of redundancy payments.

This section is not dealing with reckonable service, I understand. It is dealing with the question of continuity. I would ask the Minister to look at the question of sickness from the point of view of continuity of employment for reckonable service. Many good employers are prepared to accept it but, of course, there are a lot of bad ones. Many good employers are prepared to accept that if a person is out 12 months, 18 months or two years with a serious disease such as I have mentioned and is restored to his or her ordinary employment——

Comment on this

There is nothing in this Bill to stop them.

Comment on this

But, if they are out over 12 months, they will lose, for the purposes of the Bill——

Comment on this

It is very difficult to explain this but I shall try to do so. If a man is sick for three weeks now and three weeks again and the employer dismisses him, he is gone anyway. The purpose of paragraph 5 in Schedule 3 is that if a man is sick, or has other reasons for being away from his place of business, an employer cannot dismiss him and later re-employ him and call that a break in continuity. To protect the worker from this being done, that is, the breaking of his continuity of service by his employer, he will have to be absent for at least 12 months before this device can be used by an employer. An employer could have a worker out for three years and take him back and that would count as service as long as the employer does not dismiss him. I think we dealt with Deputy Treacy's point about seasonal workers under section 8. We have made conditions which would discount the annual average period in which he would not be working anyway. I will have a look at that to see how it affects the protection of the workers in regard to the payment of the redundancy lump sum and, if necessary, I will make changes, but I think we have dealt with it.

Comment on this

We welcome this period of 52 weeks but could the Minister explain to me how this would operate, having regard to a situation I will describe? If a person goes on holidays and just at the end of the holidays, becomes ill and his illness lasts for 52 weeks, is the holiday period taken into consideration in reckoning the 52 weeks?

Comment on this

It does happen in certain employments with which I am familiar that a person, a teacher, say, who was ill at the beginning of a long holiday has the whole period treated as a period of illness. I do not think it would be so treated here. The period of illness would not be calculated in the period of holidays. The holidays would be separate and would not come within the 26 weeks period of authorised absence mentioned in the paragraph.

Comment on this

As we are dealing with continuity of employment, am I to take it that if a man goes on holidays and becomes sick at the end of the holidays, he starts to punch in his 52 weeks from the time he goes sick?

Comment on this

That would be my interpretation.

Comment on this

I do not know how many workers would have 26 weeks holidays. I should like the Minister——

Comment on this

Is it confined to holidays with pay?

Comment on this

No, any authorised absence. Subparagraph (4) says "any cause (other than the voluntary leaving of an employment by the employee) not mentioned in clause (iii)." Clauses (i) to (iii) cover lay-off, holidays and service by the employee in the Defence Forces.

Comment on this

You go on then and refer to any cause other than the voluntary leaving of his employment not mentioned in the other clauses.

Comment on this

Any cause authorised by the employer.

Comment on this

An employer could send a worker away on a course and could fall out with the employee towards the end of the course. The worker could be obliged to go on a course for 12 months and then in regard to his continuity of employment——

Comment on this

I do not think I could visualise a case where a worker is sent by his employer on a course and then being regarded by the employer as absenting himself from employment.

Comment on this

We want to be very clear about this because we have to look after the workers.

Comment on this

He is in the employment of the employer. What is visualised is a situation wherein the services of the employee are not available to the employer by the worker being on service with the Defence Forces or through illness or lay-off. If an employer has an employee on a training course which is designed to improve his usefulness, he is still in that employment.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain what are the circumstances that would apply to the latter portion of this change. Would he give us a case in point?

Comment on this

There are circumstances in which an employee might be away with Defence Forces or might be sick. If he is away for a period in such circumstances, the employer is deprived of his services for that period and he might use this as an excuse to dismiss the worker and re-employ him when he was again available. Having done that, having dismissed him and re-employed him, the date of the re-employment would start a new period in which that man would build up again rights to redundancy payment. To protect the employee from this, we are introducing these limitations on the employer so that he cannot use sickness, except for a period of 12 months or anything over 12 months, to dismiss a man and re-employ him and so break continuity. The employer can dismiss a worker at any time for inefficiency, for illness or a bad health record, but where an employer dismisses and re-employs we are protecting workers so that they will be at least 12 months sick before such dismissal and re-employment would break continuity. We have tried to cover all eventualities by having a final clause in case something is overlooked. It is just a way of protecting the worker against this device of being dismissed and re-employed to break continuity during a period when his services are not available to his employer. I think all possible uses of that device are covered by the provision as amended.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of the final provision?

Comment on this

The reason is that, first of all, I named the things that came to mind. I mentioned all the things that could possibly happen and then I said if I had left anything out, I would cover it by a general clause. Some circumstances might turn up and then the last clause will cover those. Say a person was in the United Nations for a time——

Comment on this

He might be lent to the United Nations.

Comment on this
James Tully Acting Chairman Labour Party

Deputy Moore. Deputies should remember that this is Report Stage.

Comment on this

We are very disorderly.

Comment on this

This is a very important Bill because it is a new charter for workers. Many of us know that an unscrupulous employer would often sack a man if he was out sick for a month, but in this Bill he is given a year.

Comment on this

He is not.

Comment on this

Yes, that is the limit.

Comment on this

For sickness.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain this Bill to one of his Deputies?

Comment on this

This particular section is very difficult to grasp because it is trying to meet a situation where——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Moore must be allowed to speak.

Comment on this

Would anyone listen to poor Deputy Moore?

Comment on this

I welcome the amendment because it removes something about which we were not quite sure before. Workers will welcome this very much as being some guarantee against being treated as they have been in the past.

Comment on this

I have had to make this comment in this House more than once: Who are these voracious, bloodthirsty, unscrupulous, persecuting employers?

Comment on this

Man's inhumanity to man.

Comment on this

I have been 40 years an employer. I have had a good deal to do with trade unionists and employers. There may be a few monsters circulating——

Comment on this

A lot of them.

Comment on this

Where? There has been a lot of general talk of this kind. I have been a Deputy for 35 years and in all that time I have never been approached by any of these monsters.

Comment on this

Some of them are members of this House.

Comment on this

There is a provision here that, if such a monster exists, he cannot unjustly treat his employees absent from work because of sickness in a period of not more than 52 consecutive weeks or for other specified causes in a period of not more than 26 consecutive weeks. That seems to me to make provision against the existence of these monsters, if they exist. I beg seriously to doubt that any substantial number of persons of this character do exist. It is a pity, for the sake of human relations between us all, that we should have this kind of perennial implication that there are ravening wolves moving around in any number amongst us who are capable of treating their men in this way.

Comment on this

If there were not, we would not need this amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister has put something into this Bill to provide against this contingency. I would like to be clear on this. A man falls sick and has a chronic illness of the kind Deputy Larkin referred to, such as tuberculosis or leukaemia. It may take a long time to restore his health. Am I correct in believing that man preserves his service for the purpose of redundancy compensation for so long a period as he is entitled to receive sickness benefit under what we used to call the national health insurance system?

Comment on this

If he is absent for 12 months, he loses all.

Comment on this

He does not lose anything at the end of 52 weeks except a guarantee that the employer will not walk into his room and say: "You are sacked."

Comment on this

I have known them to send their cards to the hospital.

Comment on this

That may be.

Comment on this

It is difficult to explain it. The drafting was difficult but I am assured by the draftsman that it now meets the intention. An employer could come into the hospital to anybody and say after three weeks "You are sacked". He might wait six months or two years. Most employers would probably not do that at all. What this draft is calculated to catch is the use of the sacking and re-employment device. It cannot be used in these circumstances except after 12 months have elapsed in the case of illness and six months in the other cases. But at any time an employer can dismiss a person. What is being covered here is the case where an employer dismisses a worker, takes him back and then says: "You have broken your continuity." Redundancy payments are related to continuity of service and not weekly contributions.

Comment on this

I think I follow that. What I am anxious to clarify is that we are ensuring that an employee will not lose his redundancy rights under this legislation, unless his employment has been legitimately interrupted by valid dismissal, and that we are seeking to attach to the word "valid" a moral as well as a legal form, that an employer will not have a right for the first 52 weeks to terminate his employment and disrupt his redundancy rights.

Comment on this

It is not even that. It is the right to terminate his employment, re-employ him and call it a break in service.

Comment on this

Why should any employer want to do that?

Comment on this

The amount of the lump sum is related to the service.

Comment on this

I am bound to say, with reluctance, that I think this provision in draft here is as comprehensive as the Minister can make it. If there are these rapacious cut-throats that Deputy Moore and members of the Labour Party speak of, I think the form we have here is as effective as it is possible to provide. I should like to find fault with the Minister — it is my business as a member of the Opposition — but it lends more verisimilitude to our debate if, when he tries to do his best to meet a legitimate point, we say that on the whole he has done as well as any man can reasonably be expected to do, particularly in view of the fact that if this Schedule proves in practice not to be adequate to achieve our purpose, I am quite prepared to come back if cases emerge that men have been unjustly treated. I am often astonished that more people here do not inveigh against the fact that when a man is sick for a certain period, he ceases to become eligible for sickness benefit. I admit that is another day's work.

Comment on this

We are forbidden to talk on that.

Comment on this

I am just gingering you up.

Comment on this

That there are such employers here was proved by the 1936 Act and the granting of holidays. Within a few months hundreds of employers took advantage of that Act to deprive people of their holidays on technicalities and the Act had to be amended. In this case those employers who wish to deprive people who have been ill a long time and save themselves the contributions and lump sum payments can after 12 months technically dismiss somebody, bring him back and then say he does not qualify for the lump sum. Subsequent amendment of the Act will be of little use. The Minister said he was opposed to retrospection.

Comment on this

What would the Deputy suggest? He criticised what I did the last time and I doubled the period.

Comment on this

It should be longer than 12 months.

Comment on this

The Deputy leaves me completely in the dark.

Comment on this

Make it two years.

Comment on this

If I could find an average. I will have a look at it.

Comment on this

We are not quarrelling with the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 37, to delete lines 51 to 54.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 27 and 28 may be taken together.

Comment on this

The section says:

Absence from work by reason of a strike in the business or industry in which the employee concerned is employed and which occurred after the commencement of this Act shall not be allowable as reckonable service.

On Committee Stage, we suggested that this section be dropped. One of the difficulties in this matter is that of determining legally what a strike is and of deciding who will keep the records of unofficial stoppages, which may last for a day or three days, or of a strike which may last a week. What kind of legal battles will there be in a case like this, where the employer declares that the people have been on strike and, on the other hand, it is arguable that it is a lock-out? On Committee Stage, we indicated that the interruption of work by strikes was very small in the overwhelming majority of cases compared with the loss of man-days through illness and other causes, compared to the man-days lost through lay-offs, dislocation of industry and other occurrences outside the control of the people in industry. As I have said, a stoppage may involve only a half day, two days or a week. While we are particularly concerned, and expressed our concern under another section, that employers should keep proper records, we consider that the attempt to keep records under this heading for the purpose of depriving the workers of reckonable service will only create confusion. Therefore, we would ask the Minister to look at this again and to accept our amendment.

Comment on this

I want to support this amendment. As I indicated on Committee Stage, if the Minister does not accept this amendment and persists in doing what he has set out to do, he will take the good out of this whole Bill, because it will be regarded as a penalty to be imposed on people who go on strike. Strikes occur for a host of reasons. Strikes are not always created by the workers' side, and it is wrong to have this provision when one takes into consideration that in the preceding paragraph, the Minister, for the purpose of determining reckonable service, is disposed towards not regarding strikes which have occurred before this Bill becomes law as being an interruption of service. Surely he can follow through with this idea, particularly in view of the fact that we have not got a history of strikes of long duration?

I wonder at the purpose of putting this in. It savours of the big stick, and it belies the attitude the Minister has been adopting all along the line in relation to this Bill. I have said before that I do not think this idea was thought up by the Minister himself, and I would urge him to reconsider the matter. If it is to be laid down that anybody who indulges in a strike or finds himself involved in a strike will have that set against him for the purpose of reckoning his service, it will have a wrong effect on such a person. It does not amount to much by way of punishment, because the period of a strike can be very short. In most cases, fortunately, in our history of strikes, they have been reasonably short. However, it can be regarded as the wielding of the big stick against people who have to take strike action, and there is no need for this section.

During Committee Stage, the Minister, in defence of this provision, said he came to the conclusion, as a result of consultations he had with both sides on this matter, that they wanted it. I submitted then that I thought this did not emanate from the workers' representatives. I have since checked and I have been assured that it did not and would not. I am also satisfied that well-meaning and organised employers would not advocate this. We know from our experience that when a strike is over, a settlement having been made, both sides hope to go back and work together in a proper atmosphere. Let us go along with that, and when both sides to a dispute have come to an agreement, let there not be hanging over the workers' heads this section in the Redundancy Payments Bill, where it is said that despite the fact that a dispute has been settled, this is going to be set against the worker when it comes to reckoning his service.

This does not happen in other cases where people, having been on strike, seek to obtain benefits from their employers. A worker who goes on strike now and who is in receipt of service pay, does not have his service pay interfered with because he has been on strike. I suggest that if this sort of thing is pressed, it will encourage the bringing about of that situation. Furthermore, if a strike lasts a long time, employers do not generally use this period in assessing holiday entitlement. Of course, the law in relation to holidays indicates clearly and distinctly that unless the period of absence from work is of an unreasonable duration, such absence will not be held against a worker in the event of claiming holiday pay. As I have said before, this provision interferes with people's liberty.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to reconsider the stand he has taken on this matter. Apart from any question of principle, this might lead to a considerable amount of dispute in future. The question of whether a strike is a strike or a lock-out is very often a question of which particular side you happen to be on, and there have been innumerable disputes where one side has claimed that it was a strike and the other side has claimed it was a lock-out.

Also, we mentioned in connection with the previous section the fact that there are good employers and bad employers, and the Minister saw fit to introduce certain regulations that would ensure that the least decent employer would, at least, meet certain standards in relation to implementing the Bill. Surely the Minister must realise that the number of days lost through either strike or lock-out over a period of twenty or thirty years will be very little? The good employer would normally tend to disregard the small amount of time that would be accumulated due to strike or lock-out, but you will find that the bad employer may come to a man and say that fifteen years ago he was out on strike for three days, that ten years ago there was a stoppage which lasted for a day, and this type of argument will develop in future if the Minister persists in leaving this in.

The Minister should bear in mind that during negotiations for the settlement of a strike and after a strike one of the major considerations as far as trade unions are concerned is that there should be no victimisation of those who have been on strike and are returning to work. I would suggest that if the Minister thought of this for a moment he would agree that this in fact is a type of victimisation that would have the power of law. The Minister should reconsider his attitude on this matter.

Comment on this

Deputy Jones speaks for the Fine Gael Party and has forgotten more about these problems than I know and has given very close study to the Bill. I should, however, like to comment on this. I see the force of the argument advanced by Deputy Cluskey and Deputy Mullen but I see a great difference between a strike sponsored by a responsible trade union and an unofficial strike.

Comment on this

I agree there.

Comment on this

I would be much more comfortable about this proviso if it were possible for the draftsman to distinguish between a strike sponsored by a responsible trade union and an unofficial strike. I think there is a good deal of force in what the Labour Deputies have said that the Legislature should follow the practice we have always followed down through the years, and that is, that where there is a genuine labour dispute, with a responsible trade union informing the Labour Court that they have reached deadlock with a responsible employer and have done as much as they can to resolve their difficulties, the men are going to exercise their constitutional right as free men to strike.

I should like to avoid if I could injecting into that position the argument on the side of the employer, "Remember boys, if your trade union leaders bring you out on strike it is going to reduce your benefits under the Redundancy Payments Act". I would not be at all sure that there would be objection to the proposal, where you get some irresponsible chap who is kicking up ructions and trying to make himself shop steward or trying to advance himself in the union and is a scourge to responsible trade union officials who are trying to defend their members' interests and at the same time exercise the immense power of a trade union responsibly and resolutely if the trade union officials were in a position to say, "For God's sake go back boys because this kind of wild cat operation will interfere with your rights under the Bill, as well as all the other evils. We will negotiate. Go back to work. We will take up your grievances and we may have to call you out on strike but if we do call you out on strike you may forget about the provisions of the Redundancy Payments Act. They will not operate because this is an official, sponsored strike for which the union will answer and which the union certificate is sufficient to exempt from the consequences that would accrue if it were unofficial."

The time has come, both here and in Great Britain, where it will need passionate devotion to the right of men to belong to their trade unions and the right to use the power to strike through the machinery of the trade union but the time has come when legislatures in every free country are beginning to ask themselves is there no means whereby we can differentiate between that fundamental right of free men to organise in trade unions and to strike as their last sanction in a trade dispute and the kind of goings on which I will not particularise but which is generally described as an unofficial strike which many of us know and which is frequently precipitated for reasons far different from those alleged by the people who promote the strikes, often to the detriment of the trade union rather than the employer.

So, I should like to say to the House that I have not given this matter the very careful consideration that Deputy Jones has but, personally, I would have great sympathy with the view expressed by Deputy Cluskey and Deputy Mullen but if we were going to accept their point of view we ought to try to distinguish between a strike sponsored by a responsible trade union or, indeed, by any recognised trade union and a strike sponsored by nobody, commonly known as an unofficial strike.

Comment on this

I hope I never have to try to persuade my members to go back off a strike because of the fact that if they did not they would lose their claim to redundancy payment because in that case the best advice to give them would be to look for another job. If redundancy payment came into it the job would not be worth staying in.

The arguments made from the benches here that this is something which is rather irksome, which may be used in order to cause trouble in the employment at a later stage has not so very very much in it. The Minister is breaking a nut with a very big mallet because in this case he is saying, in effect, that if people are on strike then those people will lose their right to redundancy pay.

Comment on this

For the period.

Comment on this

For the period during which they are on strike. If the Minister pauses to think for a moment he will realise that very few employers are prepared to consider at all the question that they are going to close down and that is where redundancy pay comes in or a lay off will occur. There is no big principle involved on which the Minister has to stand. Because of the fact that Deputies on these benches said here earlier that this is simply an irksome thing, something which might possibly cause trouble at a later stage of the job, I would ask the Minister to accept the amendment suggested by the Labour Party.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy object on principle to differentiating between a strike and an unofficial strike?

Comment on this

I do not think you should discuss that now.

Comment on this

We are not discussing that but I say there are "unofficial strikes" and "unofficial strikes". I may be different from the general run of trade union officials but when I find an employer dismissing summarily an employee or employees for no reason at all there is only one answer to him and that is the unofficial strike.

Comment on this

The arguments of Deputy Larkin and his colleagues in the Labour benches recalled to my mind certain circumstances in connection with some strikes with which I had rather close connection in my time, and convince me that I should advocate that the Minister should accept the Labour Party amendment. I recall the bank strikes with which I had close connections, on two occasions, I think. I also recall a strike with which I have very little connection, the teachers' strike. I recall another strike with which I had no connection. The issue was raised with the bank clerks, the teachers and the Post Office officials, that if they went on strike, they interfered with their superannuation. That was never allowed in the end to prevent a settlement. It was never allowed in the end as something which had to be taken into account in penalising those who went on strike. It seems to me that the analogy between the teachers, the bank officials and the Post Office workers is clear in this case. I am convinced that the Minister should accept this amendment. It seems to me that this will cause nothing but disruption and trouble between the workers and employers and will effect no useful purpose.

There is one last remark I should like to make. There is a provision in the Bill that absence from work by reason of a lock-out shall be allowable as reckonable service. You cannot reckon service for a strike or a lock-out. Who is to say what is a lock-out and what is a strike? In every strike, the workers say they are locked out and the employers say it is a strike and not a lock-out at all. Who will decide that as an issue of fact? It will be impossible, and this will cause nothing but trouble. The Minister should consider the amendment favourably.

Comment on this

What is in the minds of Deputies is a principle but it is not a principle which applies to the Redundancy Bill. Deputy Tully argued rightly and concluded wrongly. If there were any question of penalising people for striking, the British Labour Government would not have brought this into their legislation.

Comment on this

They are not infallible either.

Comment on this

The basic principle of redundancy legislation is that a man is establishing certain rights in his firm, or industry, or job, because he is being employed in that job and contributing to the welfare of the firm. We do not say that the period of a strike would break continuity of service. There is the principle that if a man is not working for his employer then the period he is away from his employment, if it is not the employer's fault——

Comment on this

Who is to differentiate between that and the superannuation schemes?

Comment on this

The period when the employer is not getting the benefit of the employee's presence and labour, while it does not break his service, should not be reckoned as a period in which the employee is building up that firm. The whole basis of redundancy legislation is the contribution of the employee to the firm. Deputy Tully is right that the periods involved would hardly amount to anything. The 26 week period for benefit is weighted in favour of the employee.

The principle I see in this is that a man is establishing rights in a firm. If he is locked out that is not his fault. Therefore we will penalise the employer and make him pay to the man who was willing to contribute, by his services, but if the employee is away from work and not contributing, then that period should not fall to be reckoned in the aggregate period of service for the calculation of redundancy payment.

I know that the question of whether a strike is a strike or a lock-out can be raised. I imagine that in actual practice the question will not often arise. We have provision for an appeals tribunal machinery if such a question should arise. I feel that at the end of the period of dispute, it would be a problem for the trade unions firmly to establish whether it was a lock-out or a strike. The appeals tribunal would be available to determine such questions.

Comment on this

Does the Minister see any point in an effort to distinguish between an official strike and an unofficial strike?

Comment on this

I would, in other legislation, but that would be introducing a purpose into a Bill which I do not intend to introduce into this Bill, that is, penalising people by withdrawing some benefit.

Comment on this

Does the Minister agree there are such things as justifiable strikes?

Comment on this

I agree.

Comment on this

But the worker will be penalised.

Comment on this

He will not. If he is on strike, he has withdrawn his labour. Redundancy payments are paid in relation to labour.

Comment on this

He might have no other recourse.

Comment on this

He might be goaded into a strike.

Comment on this

If the Minister agrees there are justifiable strikes——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy agree there are justifiable lock-outs?

Comment on this

I have never seen one: it is possible.

Comment on this

If the House accepts the principle that a man is entitled to redundancy payments because of his contribution to that firm, and that while a strike period should not break continuity of service, he cannot be regarded as contributing to the firm during the period of the strike, that is fair I think.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered my point about the analogy between superannuation and this kind of contributory service. It is the same.

Comment on this

What has the Deputy in mind in this analogy? In relation to superannuation, the continuity of service would be broken.

Comment on this

Continuity of service was allowed by the banks.

Comment on this

In this Bill continuity of service will not be broken by a strike.

Comment on this

Of course it will.

Comment on this

Continuity of service will not be broken but the period for which he is on strike shall not be reckonable.

Comment on this

It is a distinction without a difference.

Comment on this

I think Deputy Costello is completely misinformed. He is misconceiving what a superannuation scheme is. In general——

Comment on this

We can take to the hills now.

Comment on this

——it is based on the assumption that a person is not paid everything he earns at periodic intervals but that a proportion is set aside in order to provide him with a pension. So far as I understand it, there is no question of providing any person with a pension in the Redundancy Bill. Therefore, the analogy which Deputy Costello tried to establish as between a superannuation scheme and redundancy payments does not exist.

Comment on this

That, of course, is all very clear.

Deputy Larkin rose.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Larkin, concluding on the amendment now.

Comment on this

Concluding again!

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Concluding on the amendment.

Comment on this

The last speaker has confused the issue. He has deliberately confused it in order to create a certain situation. As Deputy Costello said, there are many schemes of compensation and retirement benefit operating in which interruptions in employment have occurred because of disputes, lock-outs, or strikes, and they have been settled on the basis that there would be no interference with the full rights of the employees concerned. In the case of the bank clerks, they were paid in respect of the period during which they were on strike. Now, we are not asking for that, but we are putting it to the Minister that, if there is a dispute next February, a month after this Bill comes into operation, and a dozen people stop work and 988 other employees find themselves out of work for three days, according to this legislation, a record will have to be kept for maybe ten, 15 or 20 years in order to show what interruptions have occurred during the ordinary working life of the employees, what the cause has been, whether it has been a lock-out or a strike, and these statistics will be compiled and kept for the sole purpose of depriving some workers of a very small amount of money. I think the Minister should explain this further. There are eminent legal people here who would find it difficult after a lapse of 20 years to pinpoint the actual cause of a stoppage of work and decide whether it was a strike or a lock-out.

This provision will create uncertainty. Might I remind the Minister—he may not be aware of it—that this type of situation kept the port of Dublin closed for a long time? After a week in which there was a dispute, and during which the workers did not even picket the port, the Labour Court intervened. A settlement had almost been reached when the question was raised as to whether the rights of the workers with regard to superannuation would be affected. The manager at the time was doubtful and because of his doubt, the port was almost closed for an indefinite period. Does the Minister visualise a situation arising in which part of the settlement of a dispute will turn on the question as to whether or not the redundancy compensation rights of workers will be affected five, ten, 15 or 20 years hence?

In relation to the question raised by Deputy Dillon, it is our view that a strike, whether it be official or unofficial, should be treated in the same way as a lock-out. No contribution towards peace in industry will be made by thinking in terms of legislating unofficial disputes out of the picture. However, this is not the time to deal with that particular matter. I put it to the Minister: how will anyone keep the type of records which will be required for the possible purpose of depriving someone of half a week's pay, or even a day's pay? This type of section creates nothing but problems. There is no principle involved other than that the Minister wants—I am sure it is unintentional on his part—to use this particular piece of legislation as a prelude to further legislation. The Minister is well attuned now to the views of Deputies. He has improved the Bill, following on consultation with certain people. I put it to him that it would be of great benefit both to employers and workers if he were to accept this amendment.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 42
·
Níl 17
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I said earlier on that I hoped to bring in the redundancy payments scheme based on this legislation on 1st January of next year and I told the House that in order to do this I would go ahead with certain administrative arrangements over the summer holiday period and later in anticipation of the Bill so that when the Bill would become law the scheme could be brought into operation without delay. I made the administrative arrangements anticipating legislation and I am satisfied that with the progress we have made it will be possible to introduce the scheme on 1st January, 1968.

A stage has now been reached where I consider that I should inform the House of certain measures which are necessary to facilitate the introduction of the scheme. These measures involve the making of announcements inviting the co-operation of people who will be affected by the scheme. I feel that before these arrangements are made I should tell the House of my proposals.

One matter on which immediate publicity is necessary relates to arrangements for the issue of redundancy contribution cards. I would like to tell the House what is involved in this. The redundancy cards for men will be issued through the employment exchanges and offices and the local agents of the Department of Social Welfare in conjunction with the exchange of the current social insurance cards. Employers will accordingly on the surrender of this year's social insurance cards for male workers receive in exchange two cards for each male worker, the social welfare insurance card for 1968 and the new redundancy contribution card. In the case of women, the social insurance cards are not due to be exchanged until the middle of the year and it will be necessary therefore to make special arrangements for the first issue of women's redundancy cards. What is proposed is that the issuing offices, employment exchanges and so on, will issue redundancy cards for women workers on the basis of lists supplied by the employers on request. These lists will give the names and the social insurance numbers of female employees who are to be covered by the scheme. This procedure will require the co-operation of employers and I propose to request employers through various public announcements to send, as soon as possible, to their nearest employment exchange, employment office or Local Agent of the Department of Social Welfare a list of the names and social insurance numbers of all their female employees who come within the terms of the redundancy scheme.

I know that Deputies will be in general agreement with this proposal which involves taking necessary publicity measures before the Bill is law, because it is designed to make sure that we can bring in the redundancy scheme on 1st January next. I would like to give some details of my proposals in relation to publicity material. I am very concerned that workers should be fully advised of their entitlements under the proposed redundancy payments scheme when it comes into operation and I intend to take all the necessary steps to ensure that this is done. On Committee Stage, I undertook to have a booklet about the scheme available for general information. This booklet will be available free of charge in the employment exchanges and local offices or direct from the Department of Labour on request before the 1st January next.

In addition, I intend that a special leaflet for the guidance of employers on how to make their arrangements will be available free of charge, too. I feel that those publicity measures to make workers and employers aware of their rights and obligations under the scheme are well worth having and I am sure the House will agree to this type of publicity being undertaken in anticipation of the enactment of the Bill by both Houses of the Oireachtas.

Comment on this

I am glad that the Minister has taken those steps to publicise this Bill as fully as possible and that there will be available to both employers and employees the kind of information which is very necessary for the proper working of the measure so that people will be aware of their rights in this matter. This is a very good thing. This matter of redundancy has been mentioned from time to time and I hope there will not be any great necessity in regard to payments under this redundancy measure. I hope the figures will not be large.

Redundancy may occur once during a person's life time or it may occur twice but the important thing is that the person who becomes redundant should be taken care of as soon as possible and as fully as possible. Another important matter is that elderly people who become redundant take more time to settle down than younger people. One thing which struck me in relation to an amendment tabled by the Labour Party was the question of strikes. I would very earnestly ask the Minister to look at this matter between now and the time he takes the Bill to the Seanad.

Superannuation schemes were mentioned in this context. Hardship could be imposed on individuals in regard to superannuation schemes because of loss of service, even a number of days. That is true particularly in regard to the teaching profession, about which I know most. Where teachers may be absent five or six days, this could mean a loss of years as regards pension. The Minister, as Minister for Labour, occupies a position midway between employers and employees. His job is to ensure good industrial relations. Anything he can do to keep both sides together and remove resentment of any kind as between employers and employees is something the Minister should bear in mind.

I would earnestly ask the Minister between now and the time he takes this Bill to the Seanad to look again at this matter and see if he could meet the point. I do not think it involves much but from the point of view of goodwill it could mean a great deal that the workers should not feel that this is something which would mitigate even against half a week's payment and in doing that the Minister will not be doing a disservice to anybody but as Minister for Labour, who is guiding the workers' interests at this stage, he would be doing them a great service. I would again earnestly appeal to him to consider this matter.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has given us some of those details and proposals to go ahead with now that we have come to the end of the passage of this Bill through this House. The members of the Labour Party have made a concerted effort in regard to this Bill. We put forward a number of amendments and if we should take away anything from this debate it is the fact that the Bill has been improved by the amendments which have been inserted during the course of this Bill through the House. The Minister has in some cases opposed our amendments but in many other cases he has accepted them. We look on this as a creative role. We consider that the amendments which have been accepted have strengthened this legislation. They have improved the Bill a great deal.

Comment on this

Fine Gael take note.

Comment on this

I hope the members of the press who have been splashing their inaccuracies in some of the papers last weekend will consider and understand the role of the Labour Party in this House.

Comment on this
Patrick Hogan An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should not mention the press.

Comment on this

Having said that, I note that the main Opposition Party was missing for the last vote but evidently they have recovered by the vote on the last amendment. I hope they will be around for some more important votes in the future. We have explained that we are concerned to protect the people we are interested in. We have done so during the passage of this Bill and with a modest sense of pride I should say that we are very happy to contribute to this piece of legislation. We compliment the Minister on his acceptance of some of the amendments put forward by this Party.

Comment on this

Of course, Deputy O'Leary had to mark the 50 years of his friends by that speech.

Comment on this

I have just seen where the President sent a telegram to the President of Russia. If there was another President there, I am sure he would do the same.

Comment on this