We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um An Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–188 of 547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

During the past few weeks, I heard many statements about PR. I was very hurt by the uncharitable statements made here about individuals who were not present. We should view this attitude adopted by Members of the Oireachtas as lowering the prestige of this Parliament. If anyone has anything to say about anyone else who is not present, he should say it outside the House, and if he does not say it outside, he should not say it at all. In my short time in the Dáil, I have found that people claimed the privilege of this House to abuse others.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if I am not mistaken Deputy Burke is getting confused. He is confusing the Planning Appeals Bill with the referendum.

Comment on this

I thought we were speaking about the referendum. The only real mortal sin these people have committed politically is that they were not members of some of the Opposition Parties. They were alleged to be members of Fianna Fáil. Great things have happened in our time and if a few of our citizens, as a result of the good management of Fianna Fáil Governments, and as a result of the way the country has been administered, have become reasonably wealthy, thanks be to God that is so.

Comment on this

We did not have to collect sixpences in tin cans.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt the Deputy when he was speaking.

Comment on this

I have not spoken yet.

Comment on this

If it is a crime for any man to become reasonably comfortable under very good government —and let me repeat that great things have happened in our time——

Comment on this

Queer things.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy——

Comment on this

Bear with me, Sir. I do not say anything personal about anyone. I have enough to do to look after myself without saying anything uncharitable about anyone. I condemn this action here. I do not feel it is worthy of our Deputies. People can throw stones in this House against anyone they like because they know they are protected. I am not dealing with individuals. Quite a number of Deputies engaged in this.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was talking about the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

It was Deputy Colley who spoke about low standards in high places.

Comment on this

Do not tempt me. It was alleged that if PR were abolished, Fianna Fáil would be in power for all time. The people of Ireland have this opportunity to make their decision. The people of Ireland have defeated Fianna Fáil before, and they have defeated Fine Gael and Labour. I am very sorry for the Opposition because they adopted the pessimistic attitude that if we had the one-seat constituencies, Fianna Fáil would be in power for all time. I want to congratulate the Opposition on the wonderful opinion they have of us. It is a wonderful tribute to us that they think we will be in power for all time with one-seat constituencies.

Comment on this

It is a terrible prospect.

Comment on this

There must be some good in some of us when their verdict is that we will be here for all time if PR is abolished.

Is there any Deputy who would not be better off when elected in a one-seat constituency than in a multi-seat constituency? There are five Deputies in my constituency which runs from the Scalp in Wicklow down almost to Drogheda, across to Blessington, and over to Lucan and Leixlip. The five Members representing that area would sometimes need to be at four meetings at the same time. You would need to be a Jekyll and Hyde. If you go north one night, you must go south, east or west the following night.

Comment on this

You may go west. That is the trouble.

Comment on this

I feel that when the matter is put properly to the voters, they will say to themselves that they can elect one Deputy in a constituency of approximately 20,000 people. However, that particular Deputy can give that area more help because he will be able to concentrate all his energies there. He is bound to be able to look after it better than would be the case in a multi-seat constituency such as my constituency is at the moment.

Nobody knows who will win the seat in any constituency and, within reason, I feel there is no point in saying: "Fianna Fáil will win the seat", "Fine Gael will win the seat" or "Labour will win the seat". It is a lot of presumption to say that any Party will have an overall majority. We do not know what will happen.

If I live until 31st May next, I shall be 24 years a Member of this House. I have found that, in a multi-seat constituency, the competition is not from the Opposition at all but from one's own people—and from the Opposition people, too.

Comment on this

Now, now.

Comment on this

No matter who they are——

Comment on this

Speak for yourself.

Comment on this

This is what they are afraid of. They are afraid of the potential candidates in the constituency.

Comment on this

In every Party, if you have two or three running mates with you in a multi-seat constituency, each one wants to get in himself; that is human nature. If it were not that way, they would be no use as candidates. The result is enmity and ill-feeling which is not good for one side of the House or for any Party. Consider it from that aspect and then consider it from the logical aspect of one Deputy representing 20,000 people and being responsible for them and trying to help them as best he can.

It has been alleged that if, for instance, a Fianna Fáil Deputy is elected to represent the single-seat constituency then all the people who support Fine Gael and the Labour Party will not go for assistance to the Fianna Fáil Deputy for the area. I never ask anybody whether or not he or she voted for me. Directly one is elected to a constituency, one is there to serve all the people as best one can, irrespective of whether or not they voted for one. I never stoop to that level at all. A man has often said to me: "I voted for you at the last election." My reply is: "I did not ask you whether or not you voted for me. If I can do the job for you, I shall do it if it can possibly be done and I do not mind about anything else."

I do a job in this House. I do not intend to say anything personal about anybody but I appeal to the House to approach this question in a very sane way. I consider that the outlook in relation to election to a seat, under the proposed system, should be: "My chances are as good as the other fellow's." The fact is that nobody knows what Party will be returned if the single-seat constituency system is adopted.

Furthermore, for local elections, the single-seat method would be easier to operate. As a member of Dublin Corporation, I represent, with three others, an area comprising approximately 40,000 voters. The whole thing is ridiculous.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy propose a change in the electoral system for local authorities as well?

Comment on this

I am dealing with the one question now.

Comment on this

Does Deputy Burke want to make it easier for Deputies and more difficult for members of corporations and county councils who are not being paid?

Comment on this

That is a debatable point. If one is elected to represent a small area under the local authority system, then the people there would receive better service. I am putting up this case the same as I am putting up the case for the Deputies. We are not Jekylls and Hydes. We cannot be in two places at the one time.

Comment on this

He never managed that, either.

Comment on this

That is true. Nobody can manage these things. However, if the House and the country considered this proposition very seriously, we should be doing something worth while for posterity. Another thing it will ensure, as far as the country is concerned, is that we shall always have a stable Government that can rule. If it is the Labour Party or the Fine Gael Party are in government, or if Fianna Fáil are in government, they should be in a position to carry out their programme and their programme should be carried out.

The Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party say we are trying to disfranchise a section of the people. God forbid that we should do that. There is not a man in this House who would not die to uphold the right of every man in this country to a vote. That is what men have died for. That is democracy in action. It is not true to say that this is a Fianna Fáil ramp. I feel that the Opposition have dealt with this whole question from a very narrow viewpoint and that the arguments they put forward were made in an effort to misrepresent the Government. It may well be that if I stand for election in a single-seat constituency, I shall be defeated and may never return to this House. However, while I am a Member of this House, I desire to make some contribution towards the national wellbeing because the nation must come first. I am convinced that what the Government propose is in the best interests of the nation and is the right thing for them to do.

I am aware that adverse comments are being made about this Bill. A number of people have said that Fianna Fáil want to remain in office. I am aware that we were given a completely wrong slant on television. If we adopt the single-seat constituency method of election to Dáil Éireann, then the person who goes forward for election from the Fianna Fáil Party, the Fine Gael Party or the Labour Party will be fighting on his own and his only opposition will be the candidates of the other Parties. We are all colleagues in this House. Good luck to the man who is elected, no matter what his Party may be. His job will be to serve every person in the area he represents. In my estimation, we shall then have a better Ireland. We shall bring about a feeling of general goodwill and, if I might say so, charity and goodwill towards public representatives and Members of this House as a whole. All of that will be for the betterment of our country.

Anybody who looks upon the matter from the point of view I have just mentioned must surely feel it is worth giving the proposed electoral system a trial. If, as a result of our experience, we find that the single-seat constituency system does not suit the temperament of the Irish people, well, things have been changed here before. People often make up their minds and then change their minds on greater enlightenment. Lawyers and judges and other people will do it. Anybody who feels he knows everything the first day and who condemns everything because he feels he knows all and has an answer for everything will not solve our problems at all.

I ask the House and the country to consider the viewpoints I have put forward because I feel it is in the interests of our nation. I have no doubt that my friend, Deputy Cluskey, will be returned in his area: more power to him.

Comment on this

Thanks very much indeed.

Comment on this

Is Mother's Day past?

Comment on this

Beware the Greeks bearing gifts.

Comment on this

I shall bring another Labour Deputy in with me, too.

Comment on this

Good luck to him.

Comment on this

Deputy Treacy shows the benefits of a classical education.

Comment on this

Do not worry; I get in on merit.

Comment on this

It is a great tribute to Fianna Fáil that the Opposition are afraid of us under the single-seat electoral system. They have no reason at all to be afraid. We are all human beings and we all struggle to get into this House. I want to thank the Opposition speakers for the wonderful tribute they have paid to us in saying that they are afraid of us in one-seat constituencies. They have no reason to be afraid because they are all good fellows and have looked after their affairs and I am sure they will manage to get a big number of seats in the single-seat constituencies. At least they should give the proposal a trial. I shall not delay the House further.

Comment on this

Could you not increase the number of seats and settle it all before you sit down?

Comment on this

Thank you very much, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, for your indulgence I am sure Deputy Corish has already spoken, but if not, I hope that my appeal will not fall on rocky ground but on arable land.

Comment on this

Quite a while ago we in the Labour Party came to the conclusion that it was a tremendous pity that Fianna Fáil imposed the necessity for this debate on the country. We do not see that any useful purpose is being served by occupying the time of the House and the Government in debating an issue that was decided by the people only eight or nine years ago. At this stage of the debate it is very difficult for any Deputy to speak. Anything that could be said has already been said but we think that, although we consider it an unnecessary exercise, the debate has been imposed on us and on the nation, and we feel it is our duty to spell out as clearly as possible what motivated the Fianna Fáil Party in this action.

We do not believe for a moment that many of the backbench Fianna Fáil members who have spoken in this debate want to see a change in the present system or that they anticipate a change. That is why they have been able to come here, admittedly under the whip of Fianna Fáil, irrespective of their own thoughts or beliefs on this subject. It is well known that these backbenchers do not contribute in any way to the formulation of policy; they just do as they are told. In this instance they have been fortunate in that they could have what they believe to be the best of both worlds: they could come in here and make pleasant sounds so far as some Government members were concerned and still be assured that the people have already indicated quite clearly what they intend to do regarding the proposed change in the electoral system.

The Labour Party have no difficulty in its attitude towards proportional representation. It is a fact that we are the smallest Party in the House and Fianna Fáil have had the audacity to try to put over on the people the idea that their main concern was to ensure the growth and effectiveness of the Labour Party. How even Fianna Fáil could imagine that the people would be so lacking in intelligence as to believe that that Party would take an action such as this—and this does put their prestige very much in issue—in order to further the interests of another Party which they have done everything in their power to annihilate over the years, escapes me. I do not believe that their desperate action—I am speaking about the Cabinet because as I said backbenchers do not count: they are not considered or told—was a unanimous decision within the Cabinet. I firmly believe that those who ganged up together within the Cabinet, Deputies Boland, Haughey, Lenihan and Blaney, will find when the result of this action and its inherent consequences to Fianna Fáil are known when this proposal goes before the people, that there will be an even greater division in the Party than there was over the election of the Taoiseach.

How any Government or any individual who at any time aspired to enter public life and went before the people offering their services and offering to represent people in Parliament and form a Government for the people of the country could take such an irresponsible action is beyond me, especially when we are faced in this country with unemployment to the extent of even the official figure given here today by the Minister for Labour which was something in the region of 66,000. This is not an accurate figure: the real figure is far in excess of that. In a country that is recognised as having one of the most deplorable and unchristian social service systems in Europe, a country with housing problems that can only be described as staggering and whose health services are anything but enviable, how a Government or any collection of men could brush all these things aside and proceed to spend a considerable amount of the taxpayers' money on an exercise designed for purely one purpose, to perpetuate Fianna Fáil rule perhaps not for all time but for all time that matters as far as the individuals who decided this issue within the Fianna Fáil Cabinet are concerned, is beyond me.

Comment on this

30 years.

Comment on this

As a fairly young Cabinet, they probably tried to look ahead 30 years, and they milked the country to suit their own advantage. They could not care less.

Comment on this

We will have it both ways; under PR and the straight vote. This is the point the Deputy is making. Talk your way out of that.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to talk, I will be sitting down fairly soon, but I doubt if he will follow me.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

One would wonder, if, as Deputy Carter mentions, PR has been so good to Fianna Fáil, why they want to change it. It is not a very difficult question to answer. In the last general election, particularly in the urban areas, the Labour Party showed very significant gains. Prior to the 1965 general election, there was one Labour Deputy representing the city of Dublin, and in the 1965 general election, the Labour Party returned to this House six Deputies, a very significant increase. Prior to the last local elections, the Labour Party were represented by five councillors on Dublin Corporation. They are now represented by 13 aldermen and councillors, also a very significant increase.

I believe that the Fianna Fáil Party —and let us not underestimate their intelligence or their political cuteness; that would be a drastic mistake— recognise clearly the writing on the wall and that as far as PR is concerned and as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, the jig is up. If they cannot win the game under the present rules, they have no hesitation in changing the rules. This attempt by Fianna Fáil was inspired by one thing and one thing alone, by fear, fear of losing power, fear of not being able to deliver to the Taca merchants what was promised to them in return for their very generous subscriptions to the Party funds. I believe that the people who make up the membership of that organisation known as Taca are of the type who can never be satisfied, who can never get enough or demand enough. Fianna Fáil find that under the present system they are not able to deliver enough, and these are the hungry, power-mad young men to whom Fianna Fáil find themselves so closely related and so deeply indebted.

We have also seen, particularly prior to the last general election when selection conferences were being held around the country, very definite and desperate efforts being made by the all-powerful Fianna Fáil organisation to try to dislodge some of their old, less disciplined members such as Deputy Corry, who, in his own misguided way, has given a lifetime of service to the Fianna Fáil Party in Cork. However, the need has now arisen to push aside these old weary warriors and make room for the young executive type that make up the Taca organisation. I have the menu here of their second annual dinner if anyone would care to read it.

The trouble was that Deputy Corry and a few more like him were not disposed to listen to the youngest Cabinet in Europe when it came to telling them that they could not go forward in their constituencies. The same exercise was tried with the last speaker, Deputy Burke, because he was becoming a serious embarrassment to the sponsor of the abolition of PR, the Minister for Local Government, and when they found that they could not dislodge him, they decided: "Right: we will recruit a new boy who has the GAA wrapped around him, and he might dislodge him."

Comment on this

If you cannot lick them join them.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have been able to pursue that policy: if you cannot lick them join them. We are at a slight disadvantage. We have principles and integrity, and we are not prepared to sacrifice our principles or our integrity in order to get on the gravy train or on the bandwagon like some of your MacGreevy merchants in Taca. Fear makes men do foolish things at times, and goodness knows, this is a very foolish thing that the Fianna Fáil Party allowed the hatchetmen in the Front Bench to talk them into, to go again to the Irish people after slightly over eight years, to tell them: "We recognise the fact that you rejected this a very short while ago in a referendum, but we also recognise that you are a very gullible lot. We have been able to fool you on other issues for a long period of time."

Comment on this

The Labour Party keeps on expanding all the time. Deputy Coogan has joined them now.

Comment on this

In letters of gold.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Cluskey.

Comment on this

This is a very cosy conversation.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has nothing to do with the matter before the House.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have been able, over the years, to fool the people. They have called themselves the Republican Party and that lasted for quite a while and it secured sufficient support for them to hold government for some time. Then in recent years we have heard some of the university socialists, such as the new Minister for Education, with the help of some runaway trade unionists like Deputy Dowling and Deputy Moore, trying to convert this into the Workers' Party, the friend of the workers. That lasted for a somewhat shorter period but it proved to be successful even if it was short-lived. Now we have switched and we are going to recognise the Fianna Fáil Party as the Party of the progressive, young, ambitious executive. While I never agreed with the first two descriptions, the Republican Party or the Workers' Party, I have no argument with Fianna Fáil when they describe themselves as the Party of the young, ambitious, greedy, ruthless, unscrupulous type of mohair-suited executive.

Comment on this

I have no recollection of any Fianna Fáil man so describing himself.

Comment on this

Well, if the Parliamentary Secretary would like me to read from the second annual dinner, Gresham Hotel, Dublin, Thursday, 29th February, 1968——

Comment on this

On a point of order, how can you read from a dinner?

Comment on this

Are you worried? I will read out the names of the committee of the organisation known as Taca. The patron is Charles J. Haughey.

Comment on this

Well described as patron.

Comment on this

For such a crowd, what better patron could you have?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I should like the Deputy to return to the Bill now. I should like him to relate his remarks to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary challenged my description of the mohair-suited, ambitious young men. I describe them as Desmond MacGreevy, Dillon Digby, Noel Griffin, Gerard Jones, Eoin Kennedy, K.P. O'Reilly Hyland, Denis McCarthy, John Reihill and Sam Stephenson—I heard that name before. The rest are not important; they are only small fry. However, the Fianna Fáil Party——

Comment on this

We are a wonderful outfit, are we not?

Comment on this

Who?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Efficient?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Dillinger, Mussolini and Hitler were efficient. No one ever doubted their efficiency.

Comment on this

All those fellows came to a sticky end.

Comment on this

Do not worry.

Comment on this

I do not say that you fellows will not come to a sticky end either.

Comment on this

Is there any other bit of praise left?

Comment on this

If your sense of values is so distorted that you regard that as praise, you have my sympathy.

Comment on this

These are all IRA pensioners, fellows who fought and nearly died for Ireland—that gang.

Comment on this

A combination of fear of losing power, commitment to these people who have filled their coffers, the results of which we have seen in the by-elections, the posters every ten yards, the paid hatchetmen from all counties——

Comment on this

And Deputy Coughlan's double-decker buses. What do they do with the buses?

Comment on this

They send them to Kilkenny on exhibition, as you have never seen them in Kilkenny.

Comment on this

Do not forget you are in the Confraternity.

Comment on this

I would rather be in hell than in Taca, or anyone belonging to me.

Comment on this

That is not a very nice way for a prefect to speak.

Comment on this

I am a commandant.

Comment on this

A combination of the commitment to the type of people I have described, the fear of losing power and the very real and serious difficulty that has arisen between Fianna Fáil Deputies in their constituencies——

Comment on this

You will never have that problem.

Comment on this

We will. We will have the potential for it but not the problem, I agree. If you look at who inspired this, you will see that, first of all, it was the Minister for Local Government. He has been in serious trouble in his constituency because of the effectiveness at funeral attendances of Deputy Burke. Another one responsible for it and backing it all the way, and not only from the personal point of view because he has had considerable backing within the Cabinet because of the potential danger to the whole Party which exists in the feud between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce——

Comment on this

This is the Sunday racing which we were looking for a short while ago.

Comment on this

We have seen it in the open when the rivalry for the leadership of the Fianna Fáil Party was in progress and this matter burst into the headlines and everyone realised at last the greed, the lust for power and the ruthlessness——

Comment on this

And arrogance——

Comment on this

You can say that again.

Comment on this

I did not like to mention the word "arrogance"; I did not think it was necessary. It is well known, not perhaps to the public in general but certainly to those who have any close connection at all with politics, what the situation is in this constituency; it is a serious situation to have two Ministers, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, representing the one constituency and contending one against the other. When that situation is multiplied, though not to quite the same high degree, in the other constituencies around the country in which the same kind of rivalry exists—a rivalry which was acknowledged by the Taoiseach in his opening statement—one can readily understand the reason Fianna Fáil seek to make this change and are so desperate and so foolish as to think they can put it across on the Irish people.

Fear makes people do foolish things. God knows, Fianna Fáil have done a very foolish thing this time. I do not think they should take any consolation from the fact that they have been able —I am not too sure by what means— to persuade a now Independent Deputy in this House to throw out what some appear to consider a liferaft to save Fianna Fáil in their horrible dilemma. I do not think they should take too much consolation from that because I am firmly convinced that the Irish people are not prepared to buy this. Fianna Fáil seek to change that which is enshrined in the Constitution for the purpose of ensuring the continuance of democracy in this country. It is my sincere hope that this referendum will be put to the people as soon as possible and, in order to allow that to be done, I will sit down without further delay.

Comment on this

Most of what could be said for proportional representation has already been said and there is little I can add at this stage which might enlighten Deputy Dowling, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Finance, or any other Fianna Fáil Deputy. However, one never knows. Not so long ago, in 1959, this same proposal was put before the people. It was a package deal—the election of the President and the abolition of proportional representation. The President was elected and the referendum on proportional representation was defeated. I am confident that when this referendum is put to the people, it too will be defeated, not by 30,000 votes but by a much greater majority than that.

The referendum in 1959 was actually carried in County Donegal, but I am quite satisfied that, if this proposed referendum were confined only to County Donegal, it would be defeated there on this occasion. Many members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the county council—some closely associated with one of the Ministers whom Deputy Cluskey accused of being primarily responsible for having this manoeuvred through the Cabinet—share my view in this, as do a few members of the Fianna Fáil Party in the Upper House. Some of them live in hope that, if constituencies are realigned in Donegal and if we have the straight vote, they may be promoted to this House. I shall not stand in the way of anyone who aspires to be a member of this House but, if the conduct of the Fianna Fáil Party is to be judged by the manner in which they conducted themselves in a recent county council meeting at which a ratepayer was being appointed, then God save the people in Donegal. Deputy Dowling smiles. He wonders what I am hinting at. If he goes down to the Library and takes out last week's papers, he will see to what I am referring. I will leave it at that. I wish to strike a note of warning. The Parliamentary Secretary was exercised about some descriptions applied to the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Arrogance, ruthlessness, bloodthirsty, lust for power— a big long litany.

Comment on this

I am afraid I will be out of order if I speak any more. I never like to be out of order.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair appreciates that.

Comment on this

I want to examine now how this proposal will affect the people in Donegal and the political situation there. We have approximately 108,000 people and we have two constituencies which return three Deputies each to this House. Prior to the last carving up of constituencies, there was a four-seat constituency and a three-seat constituency. The former Minister for Local Government, when he revised the constituencies, either got his geography mixed up or his compass went mad because he ended up by calling one constituency North-East and the other South-West and some parts of the South-West were so much east that they could almost be said to belong to Tyrone. The people in my parish, which is east, are described as being in the South-West constituency. I have no doubt that if Fianna Fáil have their way in any future realignment of constituencies, they will not be concerned about the good of the people. What they will be concerned with will be who will use the hatchet when it comes to electing a Taoiseach, a Government and dishing out the jobs.

We have at the present time two constituencies, each sending three Deputies to the House, and if common-sense is to be observed and if the Constitution is to be honoured, it should be one constituency sending back five Deputies. This will be conceded by anybody with limited intelligence who devotes any time to the political scene in Donegal. In that five-seat constituency, with the Ceann Comhairle being returned unopposed, four seats would be contested and it would be physically impossible for Fianna Fáil to get three seats out of the four. Fianna Fáil would lose one seat and that must be so obvious that it scarcely needs mention by me.

However, it is to Fianna Fáil's advantage to change the rules while the game is on. I am prepared to debate it with any Fianna Fáil Deputy, and any Deputy of my Party is prepared to debate it with any Deputy of the opposite Party sent here from the same constituency. Having listened to the debate, any Deputy will have learned that it is to the advantage of Fianna Fáil to change the rules while the game is on.

We can take South Leitrim or Roscommon and put up a similar argument. We can take the constituencies in Cork-the one in which two by-elections have been fought might be an exception—or for that matter, we can take any constituency in Ireland which at present returns four Deputies. Needless to remark, the fourth seat is usually held by Fianna Fáil and if that is not an abuse of PR, I do not know the meaning of that word. We have had arguments from Fianna Fáil Deputies on the desirability of having stable government but is there any member of the Fianna Fáil Party, any member of the Government, who can reasonably put forward the argument that in a four-seat constituency, they can have a majority? There could be a landslide for one side or the other.

In South Leitrim, a traditional Fine Gael stronghold, Fianna Fáil have so designed the constituency that the fourth seat goes to Fianna Fáil, thereby diminishing the Fine Gael majority. In South Leitrim, Roscommon and one of the Dublin constituencies—I do not forecast the result of the East Limerick by-election—it would be very difficult for Fianna Fáil to get two seats out of three. If county boundaries are to be adhered to, the two constituencies in Limerick will each return three Deputies and the Parliamentary Secretary cannot by the longest stretch of his imagination, foresee the same number of Fianna Fáil Deputies——

Comment on this

The Deputy is making a very good case for the straight vote.

Comment on this

I am not. I am pointing out that the present system, given a fair chance, is a good system. It has sent the Parliamentary Secretary here If it were not for it, he would not be here.

Comment on this

I would be.

Comment on this

Look at the figures. I do not wish to be personal. I remind the Parliamentary Secretary that the humblest Deputy has the same power, the same right as a member of the Cabinet: he might be the most vocal or the most silent, but when he walks through the barrier, he carries the same power as the Taoiseach or any other member of the Government. I do not know why the Government suggest that the present system is a bad one. No matter which system we have, it will have its faults and its merits, and I cannot see why the Government wish to change our present system of voting and presume to have the wisdom to foresee that stable Governments will be returned under the straight vote system. Can Deputy Gibbons or any Fianna Fáil Deputy guarantee to me that, not after the first election on the straight vote system but after the second or third, there will not be 73 Fianna Fáil Deputies, 47 Fine Gael and 22 Labour Deputies—the same numerical strength as we have?

Comment on this

The Deputy is arguing from a childish viewpoint.

Comment on this

It is a viewpoint. We have argued this during the past six weeks and I have yet to see Deputy Carter offering.

Comment on this

I will.

Comment on this

The only time his name has appeared in the debate reports has been by way of interruption, and pretty ignorant interruptions at that.

Comment on this

A childish point of view.

Comment on this

It is a point of view, and Deputy Carter cannot by any calculation guarantee me or any other person that under the straight vote the strength of the Parties will not remain numerically the same. If there are to be 144 Deputies returned, no matter which system you use, you cannot guarantee what the people of Ireland will think in five, six or seven years.

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this

Then, why change the rules? It is quite reasonable to conclude that Fianna Fáil have used every aspect of PR to abuse the system so much that by now they have exhausted their energies. The system is beyond abuse as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned.

Comment on this

We will teach you a lesson.

Comment on this

Far off fields look green and I do not wish to debate PR as it appears to Deputies in Mid-Cork, South Kerry, North Kerry or Waterford. I represent the people of North-East Donegal. I know the people there and I know how they look at it and it is my duty to put their views before the House. I am prepared to debate these views with the Minister for Agriculture, who has not spoken, with the Minister for Social Welfare, who has not spoken, or with Deputy Cunningham, who has not spoken.

Comment on this

Or even with Deputy Cosgrave?

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave has spoken. I am prepared to discuss with all three the merits of PR as it appears to me and to them in Donegal. They have not spoken. The people of Donegal know that I am talking broad commonsense. They understand why I am talking and it is for that reason that I oppose any method the Government may use either to change the present system or the system proposed by an Independent Deputy. I do this not to protect my own political future in the House but because I have consulted the members of my Party. We have had meetings in different parts of the constituency. We had them many months ago, before I expressed a personal opinion, and I can say without fear of contradiction that not one person in the Fine Gael Organisation in North-East Donegal expressed anything but objection to any effort by the Government to change the electoral system.

I have the same story to tell the Parliamentary Secretary in relation to what the Fianna Fáil Party describe as tolerance. Not alone have I elicited the opinion of the Fine Gael organisation in Donegal but I have also consulted other people whose opinions I would be guided by and they see no reason why £100,000 should be spent in trying to have the electoral system changed, thereby giving the House a new lease of life.

Comment on this

It will cost more than £100,000. That was the figure in 1959. Surely it will cost more now?

Comment on this

Do not change it now. It is on the record too many times.

Comment on this

If it will cost more, I will not dispute it. Whatever the figure is, whatever the Parliamentary Secretary may mean by slick remarks across the House, let me say that I do not believe that even he is fully in support of the Government move.

Comment on this

Do you not now?

Comment on this

I welcome Deputy Cunningham to the House. It is a pity he was not here earlier. I hope that when I sit down, Deputy Cunningham will give us his views on proportional representation. Come to think of it, Deputy Cunningham is about the only Deputy in the Fianna Fáil Party who should be spearheading the abolition of PR because he knows that under the provision of the Constitution which says that 20,000 people will return a Deputy to this House, he might not be here after the next general election.

Comment on this

I understand you are having some trouble yourself.

Comment on this

As I see it, the Fianna Fáil Party have failed and failed miserably to provide a decent living for people in Donegal and emigration has taken a number of my supporters, a number of Deputy P. O'Donnell's supporters and a number of Deputy Cunningham's supporters. Deputy Cunningham knows that the Fianna Fáil Party have failed to provide houses for the people to live in. We will not go into that one too deeply because we might take a few votes from Deputy Cunningham and make it more difficult for him to get here. He knows that social services are so inadequate that people are leaving County Donegal and going to live with their sons and daughters who have been given decent houses to live in in Derry and Tyrone.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Of course it is true. I know dozens of them.

Comment on this

They do not qualify for the first seven years.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this

What you are talking about?

Comment on this

Deputy Harte walked into it.

Comment on this

Deputy Cunningham must know that people have come to him asking him to make representations to see that their rights are given to them.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte was talking about people going into the Six Counties and getting social welfare services.

Comment on this

Yes, of course.

Comment on this

They cannot get them.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cunningham so dense——

Comment on this

There is no harm in trying, Paddy.

Comment on this

——as not to see the point I am making that if a man who has worked a long time in County Tyrone or County Derry——

Comment on this

Oh!

Comment on this

——and has lived all that time and reared a family in County Donegal——

Comment on this

You are mending your hand.

Comment on this

At least do not be ignorant about it.

Comment on this

Do not be cross about it.

Comment on this
Patrick O'Donnell Mr. P. O'Donnell Fine Gael

I think Deputy Harte should be allowed to make his own speech.

Comment on this

I am only giving him my assistance.

Comment on this

If Deputy Cunningham wishes to take me to task on this——

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this

——let me get down to brass tacks. Deputy Cunningham knows a certain gentleman——

Comment on this

Who shall be nameless.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wishes I will name him. I am talking about a gentleman in the district of Muff whose name hit the headlines of the local newspapers in the last month or two. That man has lived or worked in Derry City for the last ten or 12 years. If that man should retire when he reaches the age of 60 and go back to live in Northern Ireland, does Deputy Cunningham tell me now that he loses all benefits for seven years?

Comment on this

No, I did not say that.

Comment on this

Make up your mind. Do you wish me to name that person?

Comment on this

You said people were going in to get benefit in Northern Ireland.

Comment on this

How many people have sons and daughters working in Derry? How many people have husbands working in Tyrone whose families are being reared in Donegal?

Comment on this

What has this to do with legislation?

Comment on this

It has this: as a result of the bad social services, bad housing, bad administration, the population has reduced so much in County Donegal that there will only be five Deputies returned here and Deputy Cunningham is the one who will be left out. I do not wish to be personal with Deputy Cunningham. I am merely expressing what is common knowledge in County Donegal. Deputy Cunningham is boxed in by Lough Foyle on the one side and Lough Swilly on the other.

Comment on this

It is a nice little box so.

Comment on this

It is a very nice box but we got three seats out of six in the local elections.

Comment on this

The Deputy said before the last election that he would lead me by a mile.

Comment on this

No, I am never boastful. I am one of the most humble and most modest Deputies that ever came into this House.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte is very modest.

Comment on this

In spite of the interruptions of Deputy Cunningham, of the Parliamentary Secretary and indeed of Deputy Carter, I will make my own speech.

Comment on this

Good.

Comment on this

It is about time.

Comment on this

Deputy Carter should keep out of it. When Deputy L'Estrange was making his speech here Deputy Carter should have been here to debate the straight vote and PR in Longford-Westmeath.

Comment on this

I am here now.

Comment on this

There is no use in being here now. I am not interested in Longford-Westmeath. I am interested in Donegal.

Comment on this

So we have noticed.

Comment on this

I am prepared to debate the merits or otherwise of PR as I see it in Donegal with Deputy Cunningham, with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, with the Minister for Social Welfare or indeed with any other Deputy who cares to debate it with me in this House or at any other venue.

Comment on this

Let them all come.

Comment on this

I am quite certain that the people who have sent me here and the people who have sent Deputy Cunningham here will come to accept and agree that the only reason Fianna Fáil propose to amend the Constitution is not in the interests of the Irish people but to protect individual Fianna Fáil Deputies as indeed the case is in County Donegal.

What Fianna Fáil referred to as the tolerance proposal is more intolerance. While the people of Donegal might like to have as many Deputies or more than the people of Dublin, I can quite categorically state here and now that the people of Donegal will reject the proposal of the Government to abolish PR and they will also reject the Third Amendment, the tolerance that Deputy Cunningham boasts about, not because they do not want to have extra TDs in Donegal but because they do not want to protect the Fianna Fáil TD. There is enough deadwood in the country without having too many silent backbench members of the Fianna Fáil Party.

When Fianna Fáil Deputies were making their case in this House, they continually referred to the fact that they wanted a strong Opposition. What great gift have the Fianna Fáil Party to judge the merits or see the qualities of a good Opposition? Do they want the type of Opposition they provided in 1922? Is that how they judge an Opposition? Do they want an Opposition like the Fianna Fáil Party provided in 1948 when they voted against the national loan? Is this the type of irresponsible Opposition they want? Is this the quality they want in Opposition Deputies? Do they want an Opposition like the Opposition, the backbenchers of which led certain protesters in Dublin to strike in 1951? Is this the type of Opposition Fianna Fáil are talking about? Is it to provide this type of Opposition that the bloodthirsty back-benchers and front benchers of Fianna Fáil are anxious to change the rules of the game?

Comment on this

Thirsty.

Comment on this

Bloodthirsty.

Comment on this

Is this the type of Deputy the Fianna Fáil Party want on this side of the House?

Comment on this

No. We want an Opposition composed of Deputies like Deputy Harte. If we had an Opposition like that, the country would certainly do well.

Comment on this

We would be away in a hack.

Comment on this

Deputy Molloy would do best to remain silent. I wonder what the Fianna Fáil Party really want? Do they want a good Opposition or do they want a strong Government? If those are the arguments put forward for the changing of the Constitution they should make up their minds. I have stated here by way of interruption, but I will put it on the record of the House, that if the Fianna Fáil Party want good Opposition I ask them to hold the next general election under the system of PR without changing the constituencies and they will have the opportunity of providing an Opposition in this House. Let us be frank in this House. I do not know whether this will influence members of the Fine Gael Party or whether it will influence members of the Labour Party but I believe that if a certain speech had not been made during the 1965 general election campaign, the result might have been different.

Comment on this

The speech made in Tullamore.

Comment on this

It was made in Tullamore by Deputy Corish. There is a widely held opinion that if Deputy Corish had not made that speech the Fianna Fáil Party might not have been returned to this House as a major Party. If they were returned they might have been returned as a minority government and if they were a minority Government they would not have dared to bring in those measures into this House. The only reason they brought in those proposals is that they were lucky enough to win by-elections where they had strong support and where the Opposition were not lucky enough to win except in one.

I am opposed to Fianna Fáil and no doubt Deputy Corish is opposed to Fianna Fáil. I am prepared to go along the lines advocated by Deputy Hogan of South Tipperary, when he spoke in this House, that this country cannot afford another term of Fianna Fáil maladministration and corruption. This country cannot afford another term of the Fianna Fáil Party handing over powers and rights to men who hide behind the scenes, as read out by Deputy Cluskey, the previous speaker, to men who belong to Taca. This country must, in my opinion, get rid of this force which has crept into politics unnoticed. This is a fact. I do not have to repeat it every time I come into this House. No Labour Deputy has to repeat it every time he comes into this House. I would be failing in my duty——

Comment on this

If you did not repeat it every time it would be all right.

Comment on this

Not outside.

Comment on this

Deputy Cunningham's calculations misfired in Donegal on Monday week last. Keep quiet. Bí id thost. I would be failing in my duty if I did not say to the people of Ireland that I am prepared to join hands with anyone who can put Fianna Fáil out of office. I am prepared in the interests of the people——

Comment on this

Any dog or devil who offers.

Comment on this

It has been done before. No doubt what the Fianna Fáil Party are most interested in doing is keeping the Opposition Party and, indeed, the Opposition members of different Parties separated so that they can——

Comment on this

So that there will be a Coalition.

Comment on this

Your Party is split up the middle and divided. Is your Party united on this?

Comment on this

Is Deputy Cunningham's Party not split? I am not denying it. We have the Fianna Fáil Party parading in here and telling us that they agree unanimously with what is being proposed. This is a cod. Does Deputy Molloy, or any other Deputy over there, seriously believe that anybody in his right mind would accept that 74 or 75 men could agree unanimously on anything?

Comment on this

It is true. I was there. How do you know what went on?

Comment on this

Did Deputy Cunningham ask me a question? Did he ask me was our Party united? Does the Deputy want an answer?

Comment on this

You know the answer.

Comment on this

I can inform Deputy Molloy, if he has manners to listen, that if one reads through the Dáil debates and looks through them repeatedly one will come across Deputy Molloy as the chief interpreter of the Fianna Fáil Party. He is not that long here. The ballot papers are still wet.

Comment on this

You are not much longer here.

Comment on this

I am slightly longer. Does Deputy Molloy really want to convince me or anybody else that his Party are unanimous on this? Members of the Fianna Fáil Party in private conversation with me told me that it would be senseless to do away with PR. Do you wish me to name them?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would the Deputy come back to the Bill?

Comment on this

I will not name them.

Comment on this

We knew you would not.

Comment on this

If Deputy Cunningham tempts me, I might name them.

Comment on this