An Bille um An Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Dara Céim (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 189–380 of 547. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
Before the Bill was introduced, a member of the Fianna Fáil Government, whom I consider a friend, indicated to me that he was not prepared to go along with the abolition of PR but that it would be foolish not to accept it because it would get rid of the Labour Party.
Comment on this
This is the type of thing which prompted Fianna Fáil Ministers to introduce PR. Deputy Cunningham knows that the former Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party advised his Party that unless Fine Gael accepted the straight vote it was not to be introduced.
Comment on this
Deputy Booth and I exchanged a few words by way of interjection a fortnight ago. The Deputy spoke about Germany and said that it was under PR that Hitler came to power in Germany and that the same type of election that sends Deputies to this House also sent the Nazis into the Reichstag under the leadership of Herr Hitler. Many reasons are given for Hitler's success, if it can be described as such, in the late Twenties or early Thirties. In Germany nobody in his wildest imagination can seriously suggest that Herr Adolf Hitler was elected and kept in office for democratic purposes.
Comment on this
He was elected by democratic methods but once he got into office, he asked for the same powers as the Fianna Fáil Party are asking for. Once he got there, they could not get him out of it.
Comment on this
I have read it and it shows the similarity between the Fianna Fáil Party and the Nazi Party in Germany. I quote from page 101 of Nazi Germany Explained by Vernon Barlett:
The one bond of union between the millions of men who look to him as their leader has been the desire to overthrow a system of government which, to their mind, was unsuitable for their country.
Comment on this
What you are suggesting to the Irish people—that the system of election is not suitable for sending people to this Parliament. I quote from page 102:
There are, as far as one can see, three main tendencies that are making themselves felt. It is difficult to know how much Hitler depends upon the people around him, and how much they depend upon him— difficult to know, in other words, whether he is just an animated and earnest figurehead or whether he has his own ideas of government and seeks people who feel the same way as he does ....
There are, in the first place, the people on the Right, the industrialists who have helped him in the past so that they might use him for their own ends.
That is the Hitlerism of Taca, the Taca of Nazi Germany speaking. These are the type of people who got Deputy Booth into power by democratic means.
Comment on this
I am quite certain that Deputy Booth made certain remarks as to how Nazism came to be in Germany. It is difficult to say to Deputy Booth that he is wrong because what he said is true, but it is only partly true. I quite agree with Deputy Booth that Hitler came into power in Germany in 1931.
Comment on this
It is quite true that he came to power by democratic means. This is a recognised fact but there are other things involved. The economic structure of the country was chaotic. The terms of the Treaty of Versailles were so severe that it made people grasp at the last straw——
Comment on this
——and represented Hitler as the one hope for the German people. These were the things that brought Hitler to power. It was not what brought him to power that made him what he was. What really was his fault in Germany in those times was that Hitler was supported by wealthy people who could not get into politics under a democratic system but who were prepared to back the myth of Hitler and having sent him so far along his way, they could not stop him. I do not wish——
Comment on this
Deputy Booth and I disputed about what brought Hitler to Germany. I do not profess to be an authority on the recent history of Nazi Germany.
Comment on this
I have read my history. Deputy Booth should ask the back-benchers to have some manners.
Comment on this
One of the principles enshrined in the Constitution of the Nazi Party was that of Nazifying Germany.
Comment on this
It does; it is very relevant. I quote again from page 109:
"Nazifying" the State has been a little more difficult. Thousands upon thousands of officials have been retired on pension and Nazis have taken their places.
Is this what Deputy Booth is trying to get? Is he trying to get an elected dictatorship into this House?
Comment on this
Do not start throwing those accusations at this Party. Members of your Party founded the Blue-shirts who were going to do for Ireland what the Brown shirts were doing for Germany and what the Blackshirts were going to do for Italy. You are on dangerous ground.
Comment on this
I do not want to argue with Deputy Briscoe. He and I are on friendly terms outside this House. My Party have some respect for democracy. The leader of the Party you claim to be a believer in, went in his tall hat to the German Embassy to sympathise with the Germans on the death of Hitler. What did Deputy Booth say then? Thank God, I have not blood on my hands. I was young enough not to know what was going on in Nazi Germany. What was the stand Deputy Booth took then? He cannot blow hot and cold.
Comment on this
It was a pity you did not stay in the Army. You should have stayed in it. There is another thing——
Comment on this
I should like to quote from Encyclopedia Britannica, Volume 2, 1966 edition. I do not wish to quote at length but this is really relevant:
Once in power Hitler proceeded to establish an absolute dictatorship.
Comment on this
If the Deputy had been listening, he would have heard. The stenographer heard and the Chair heard. I continue the quotation:
He secured the President's assent for new elections on the grounds that a majority in the Reichstag could not be obtained after all.
Is this not very relevant? Is it not relevant to the argument that it is reasonable to expect that under the present system the Fianna Fáil Party cannot hope to have a majority in this House?
Comment on this
At the next general election. I will not be so bold as to forecast what will happen at any future election. This is common property. All the national newspapers, all political commentators, maintain that under the present system Fianna Fáil would be reduced to an approximate strength of 66 to 67 Deputies. That, I might add, is under the present structure, the present constituencies, the present frame of mind of the electorate. Is this not exactly what the Taoiseach is asking, that we have a new system of democratic election? Is this not what Hitler asked in 1931, when elected— a new system to give him a majority in the Reichstag so that he would have dictatorial powers and, having got dictatorial powers from a very highly educated people, he proceeded to cut them to pieces? Does Deputy Booth not agree with me on that score?
Comment on this
I did not expect you to. I am only quoting from Encyclopedia Britannica. What are we to expect if the Fianna Fáil Party get elected as a dictatorship in this country?
Comment on this
I have every confidence in and respect for the Taoiseach, Jack Lynch. He is a man that I cannot say anything about but he will not be there always. He will not always be the man in the saddle. I should hate to think of what certain junior Ministers in his Cabinet would do if they had the same power as he has. Maybe it would be on a miniature scale but, nevertheless, it would be an abuse of democracy. I wonder what the attitude of certain Minister would be if they had the power of Taoiseach.
Comment on this
This is a proposal to change the electoral system and, to me, with respect, it is very relevant. I wonder what the Minister responsible for putting farmers in gaol for claiming democratic rights would have done, to what extreme he would have gone, if he had been Taoiseach. I wonder what would have happened last week if the Minister responsible had had the same arrogance as certain other Ministers, when men were put in gaol for protesting because they were offered as little as twopence an hour increase on a wage of £12 a week.
Comment on this
This is what I will protest about in this House. This is what I will fight against and this is what I will dispute with Deputy Cunningham, if he cares to take up my challenge, at every chapelgate in North East Donegal.
Comment on this
I do not have to consult the record to know that Deputy Cunningham supported it. These are the efforts which make me afraid when certain members, no doubt expressing their Party's view, seek a change in the electoral system so that they can get dictatorial power. At the moment it may seem innocent, even foolish, to protest against it but there is no given guarantee that some person with the same mythical powers as Hitler had——
Comment on this
——could not get into power through a democratic process and then become as arrogant as the most arrogant of the Fianna Fáil Ministers in the Cabinet at the moment.
Comment on this
There was another gentleman in Nazi Germany, Josef Goebbels and his job in the Party was not to build a Germany, not to cure the ills affecting the social services, not to build autobahns or private houses but simply and solely to be Minister for Propaganda and we all know the success he made of that. His maxim was that if you tell a lie big enough and often enough people will believe you. Can we again make a comparison between Nazi Germany and the Fianna Fáil Party?
Comment on this
Do we know not that prior to general elections we had promises like 100,000 new jobs, that people were told to get their sons and daughters out to work, that wives were told to bring their husbands back from England?
Comment on this
As Deputy L'Estrange says, there are 100,000 fewer in employment—and these are figures out of the Taoiseach's office—than in 1957. Does Deputy Booth care to dispute that?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not discuss the whole economic position of the country on an amendment of the Constitution.
Comment on this
In Volume 233 of the Official Report for 21st March, Deputy Booth dealt at great length with the electoral system, as he saw it, in Germany. He then proceeded to France and from there to Italy and eventually came back to Ireland.
Comment on this
Deputy Booth dealt with the electoral system to which he attributed all the faults and the ills under Hitler. I am debating the point with him and expanding my argument inasmuch as no one can prove to me that at some future time, if dictatorial powers are given to the Fianna Fáil Party, some person like Hitler cannot come along and create someone like Josef Goebbels. No one, not even Deputy Booth, can tell me that that will not happen. If Deputy Booth can tell me that it will not, I will not dispute his word.
What will happen if for some reason or other there is a social revolution in this country and somebody comes to the top, as Hitler did in Germany, and wins the imagination of the Irish people and has at his mercy a democratic system such as you now ask for? To what extreme can he go? Is there anyone here who can say that you can stop that man? Under the Constitution he would be doing nothing wrong until it would be too late. This is my argument. This is why I prefaced my remarks by the statement that under the present system every Deputy, no matter how humble or silent, has the same right in this House as the Taoiseach or any member of the Cabinet when he walks into the division lobby. This is a divine right given under an electoral system suited to the Irish people, a system which may not be perfect. No system is perfect, not even the system in use in the United Nations.
Comment on this
You will have a hell of a long look if you are searching for advice on PR. It is worth trying anyway.
Comment on this
Irrespective of whether Deputy Booth disputes the terminology with me or not, he cannot get away from the argument that given an electoral system, in certain circumstances, any man cannot do in the future what Hitler did to Germany. It was Deputy Booth who raised this hare. I am quite prepared to debate it with him. I do not profess to be an authority on the recent history of Germany. In my leisure hours, I have consulted a number of books. One was by the late President John F. Kennedy, whose views disagree violently with the views of Deputy Booth, as reported in the Official Report in volume 233 of Thursday, 21st March. This book, While England Slept, was written by the late President Kennedy when doing his thesis in 1940. It is in the libraries of Ireland for students of history like Deputy Booth to consult. If Deputy Booth is right, then President Kennedy is wrong.
Comment on this
So is Vernon Bartlett, and so is Winston Churchill. I am only quoting what they have said. If they are wrong, I will humbly apologise to Deputy Booth, who indeed has more wisdom than all these gentlemen put together. Deputy Cunningham's mathematics are as disturbed as his history. Deputy Cunningham devalued the £25 million loan to £30 million. It is a pity he is not Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
We will compare our honours course in leaving certificate, and compare marks if you like.
Comment on this
No. If the Deputy wishes to tell the House that he finished his education and I did not, I do not feel ashamed of that. I will tell Deputy Cunningham something he does not know: ability without education has taken more people to the top——
Comment on this
This is entirely irrelevant. Unless Deputy Harte comes back to the Bill, I shall have to ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I am quoting from volume 233 of the Official Report, in which Deputy Booth went to great lengths to explain to whatever Fianna Fáil Deputies were present that the system of election which operated in Germany pre-Hitler was the reason Hitler came to power. Therefore, the Irish people should change the electoral system, because look what Hitler did to Nazi Germany. I have quoted certain remarks from the book Nazi Germany Explained by Vernon Bartlett and I have quoted from the Encyclopedia Britannica. I am saying that I disagree with Deputy Booth, and in so doing, I am exercising my right as a Deputy. I am explaining to the House why I disagree with him. If I am called to order because I have to reply to interruptions by Deputy Cunningham, Deputy Carter and Deputy Molloy—who have not spoken —I beg your indulgence, Sir, but it is not my fault. I am just putting the record right.
If we have to spend £100,000 to ascertain what system of election the Irish people want, why not have the referendum on the same day as the next general election? The cost would be minute compared with the figure admitted by the Minister for Finance, and Deputy Corish said it would be much more than the £100,000 the referendum cost in 1959. What is the rush? Why do certain members of Fianna Fáil want to change the electoral system now? It has been with us since 1918. It has been discussed by public representatives since 1911. Why change it now? Has Deputy Booth any objection to holding it on the same day as the next general election?
Comment on this
The Deputy was here when I spoke and he alleges he read my speech afterwards. I made it very clear.
Comment on this
The reason Fianna Fáil will not have the referendum on the same day as the next general election is that they know it is possible they could lose the general election and then it would be the duty of the new Minister for Local Government to draw the new constituency boundaries. They would lose the initiative. It is not in the interest of the Irish people that they wish to change the rules while the game is on but in the interest of the Fianna Fáil Party.
Deputy Booth claims to be an upright Deputy—and, even though I am debating with him, he is a man for whom I have the utmost respect—but, like every other member of Fianna Fáil, he is trying to confuse the issue. I want to ask him what is the objection to holding the referendum on the same day as the next general election. Rumour has it that there could be a general election at a very early date. That is the privilege of the Government to decide. Whenever it comes, I will just have to accept it and see what I can do about getting re-elected.
Comment on this
Whatever note Deputy Cunningham passed to Deputy Booth to interrupt me, he should have had the courage to get up and say it himself.
Comment on this
Many arguments have been put forward as to why we should get rid of proportional representation. We had Deputy Booth telling us we should get rid of it because it was the reason Hitler came to power in Germany. But then we had Deputy Gilbride from Sligo telling us we should get rid of it because it was imposed on us by Great Britain. It was not imposed on us by Great Britain. This is something we accepted. If Deputy Molloy states that certain members of Fine Gael are not behind this, I will not deny it. At least, they have openly admitted it. That was the decent thing to do. Certain members of your Party have not that decency in them. What did the former President of the country, the late Seán T. O'Kelly, say in the Dáil on 21st March, 1934? He said:
I still stand for proportional representation. I believe in this country it is suited to the needs of the people and I would vote against any Bill that proposed to abolish the system.
Comment on this
What has come over the Fianna Fáil Party since Mr. S. T. O'Kelly said that in 1934 ?
Comment on this
Is it that in 1934 the Fianna Fáil Party were the workman's Party, that they represented the working men, the council workers, the quarry workers, the road workers, the small farmers, the forestry workers——
Comment on this
We now have, as Deputy Cluskey described them, the mohair executives in the city of Dublin, the chaps who come in here to the Fianna Fáil Party Rooms and have more influence than Deputy Cunningham, an elected representative of the people, the guy who comes in to the Parliamentary Secretary and talks to him about the type of work that could be done by the Board of Works in the city of Dublin——
Comment on this
——the type of work which his predecessor was responsible for doing in Templemore. What contract was there for the Garda barracks in Templemore?
Comment on this
We are not going to discuss that on an Amendment of the Constitution Bill. It is not relevant and has no connection whatsoever with the Bills before the House.
Comment on this
Surely I am allowed to expand my argument and say that under PR the people have a right to select one, two or three members of a panel of candidates put forward by any political Party, and that no candidates should be foisted on them as would be the case if the straight vote were introduced? Do we not know that there are people closer to the centre of gravity than Fianna Fáil back benchers? Do we not know that there are people in this infamous association or organisation known as Taca——
Comment on this
Do we not know what the situation is in any safe seat in this country? Instead of giving a contract to these gentlemen, Fianna Fáil can give them a safe seat and their more loyal supporters will have to vote for them, or lump it. That is the democratic system about which Deputy Cunningham wants to boast. Is he ashamed of the present system? Is he afraid that some person will be selected by the Fianna Fáil Party in North-East Donegal and he will have to run harder to get there? Does he not know—and I know he knows—and accept as a reality that some day some one will challenge his right to represent the Fianna Fáil Party just as someone might challenge my right to represent the Fine Gael Party?
Comment on this
Does Deputy Molloy remember that Mr. Tom Walsh's daughter was selected in Carlow and was rejected by the Fianna Fáil National Executive?
Comment on this
Rude interruptions will get Deputy Molloy nowhere. We know how he climbed on the back of Deputy Bartley to get in here.
Comment on this
Lest Deputy Molloy should think Fine Gael are the only Party to do such things as he alleges we did in Clare, what happened in Wicklow?
Comment on this
Does Deputy Cunningham feel that our system of election is unhealthy? Does he feel it is wrong that any member of the Fianna Fáil Party who believes in that Party has not got a democratic right to seek a nomination in North-East Donegal? He might succeed in replacing either Deputy Cunningham or the Minister for Agriculture. Is that what Deputy Cunningham is protecting? Is it the system of election or his election? That is what I want made clear.
Fianna Fáil know that certain members of their Party must fall by the way in the next general election. I do not know who they will be, but they are going. He knows that certain threemember constituencies will be amalgamated with one or two-member constituencies and that five-seat constituencies will be made up, and he knows very well that one member of the Fianna Fáil Party will go. In Donegal, all the Deputies are geographically placed by their home positions and none really steps on the toes of the other. That is fair play. I am glad Deputy Brennan has come into the House because he might tell Deputy Molloy something he does not know. If Deputy Molloy wants to know what I am hinting at, let him ask the Parliamentary Secretary in the silence of the Party Rooms because he might be embarrassed if it came out here.
Does Deputy Cunningham feel that he should change the system just to protect his re-election to this Parliament or does he feel that would be in the best interests of the people who send Deputies here? That is what is confusing me. If I thought for a second that the straight vote was a healthy system of election, irrespective of the result for me, I would opt for it.
Comment on this
I will sit down in a few minutes and the Deputy can accept my invitation to speak. He would be the first Deputy from Donegal.
Comment on this
I am giving my views. I have extended many invitations to the Deputy before on different matters.
Comment on this
I challenge Deputy Cunningham to debate this with me in this House or in any town or village. He can invite the Royal Showband or whatever band was in the hotel in Bray the night before the election. They celebrated victory before they got it.
Comment on this
If Deputy Cunningham wishes to debate the merits or demerits of PR with me, I extend that invitation to him. I will debate it with him. We should not annoy people like Deputy Cluskey who is not interested in Donegal to the same degree as we are, or Deputy O'Connell who has no interest in what is happening in Donegal. He might have a passing interest in it but that is about all. I extend this challenge to Deputy Cunningham openly. I will debate with him or any member of his Party the merits or demerits of the different systems of election which have sent him and other people here.
Comment on this
I will take you on. I will beat you in Donegal. We will take you up in Donegal and I will beat you on it.
Comment on this
If the present system is to be changed then, as I say, there is no reason why it cannot be changed on the occasion of the next general election. There is no great rush. I cannot see any reason why the present Government cannot stay in office under the same democratic right that sent them here three years ago. They are no less powerful today than they were three years ago. They are no less powerful today than they were ten years ago. Why all the rush?
Under the Constitution, we shall definitely have an election within the next two years and possibly, under a political system which generally sends the Government to the country before the statutory period is up within the next 12 months. Why can we not wait? What is the reason for all the rush? Is there not a very simple reason for it, namely, that, under the present electoral system it is a foregone conclusion that the Fianna Fáil Party will lose their majority in this House which they have at the moment—artificial as it may be? As I have already said, they have won by-elections in constituencies where it would be impossible for any other Party to win them. Deputy Sylvester Barrett from Clare is an example of that. In a constituency such as Clare, it is a foregone conclusion that the Government Party would win a by-election there.
I wonder what the position will be in Clare at the next general election. Indeed, I wonder what the position will then be in the city of Cork where there are at present four Fianna Fáil Teachtai Dála out of five. One, no doubt, must go and, in all probability, on the results of the last by-election, two will go. Therefore, it will be physically impossible for the Fianna Fáil Party to hold four seats out of five according to calculations based on the last by-election results in the city of Cork where the Fianna Fáil vote dropped dramatically. Is this not the reason for all the rush? Is this not the reason the Taoiseach, even, is in favour of this proposal? Is this not the reason certain power-crazy men in the Fianna Fáil Party are claiming the same right as Adolf Hitler claimed in Nazi Germany in 1931?
Is the reason Fianna Fáil must have the referendum before the next general election not so as to have the decks clear and the constituencies rigged and the system designed not in the interests of the Opposition but in the absolute interest of the Fianna Fáil Party? Is this not the reason a Minister of State bluntly said to me privately "Back the straight vote and you will get rid of Labour"? Is this not the reason certain Fianna Fáil Members were canvassing the opinion of the Members of the Opposition Parties in the Lobbies of this House in an effort to find out how they were thinking? Is this not the reason the Fianna Fáil Party are divided as to whether or not it is right to abolish proportional representation now?
Did Deputy Seán Lemass not tell the Fianna Fáil Party to introduce proposals for the abolition of proportional representation if the Fine Gael Party accepted it, but not to touch it if the Fine Gael Party opposed it? Is this not the reason certain people say: "If Fine Gael oppose it, we shall have someone to put forward an amendment"—as an Independent Deputy of this House has put forward an amendment? Is this not the reason we shall have all the arguments of the Fianna Fáil Party to explain why they meant A was not A or B was not B when they want to assert that a single-seat constituency with a single transferable vote is not a system of proportional representation?
Is that not the codology that is going on in this House at the moment at a time when we should be discussing more urgent matters such as the housing crisis in this city and the provision of money to meet the housing problem that is so serious in various parts of our country? Should we not be providing better social services than the services which are an embarrassment to public representatives who, out of force of duty, represent a constituency such as I do and who are compared with people in public life in Tyrone and Derry when comparisons are made between the social services in Northern Ireland and those in Donegal and in the rest of our country? These are embarrassing situations. These are the things I am not proud of.
Comment on this
Will Deputy Harte please listen when the Chair addresses him? I would point out that we are discussing the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. On this Bill, the Deputy may not ramble over every question.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
——for the past six weeks—discussing something that the country has already decided, less than eight years ago, it did not want. We would be better employed discussing measures more pertinent to be discussed in this House. We would be better employed in an examination of the public conscience of the Government. We would be better employed in asking ourselves the question: "Can we not make better provision for the unemployed in this city?"
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that the only point before the House is the Bill, the Third Amendment to the Constitution Bill. All the other issues raised by Deputy Harte are not relevant.
Comment on this
I submit to the ruling of the Chair but I just wish to say that I think it is a sad state of affairs whenever a Government, for no reason other than to perpetuate their own political existence, introduce a measure that will cost this Dáil valuable time and our country an immense amount of money, money that could be used in providing necessary things for our people. As the Ceann Comhairle will not allow me to expand on that, I shall leave it at that and leave it to the imagination of the people who are in need.
Arguments have also been put forward by Deputies such as Deputy Dowling that it is nearer the ideal to have a small constituency. Deputy Dowling represents a city constituency and a twopenny bus ride would take him to his Dublin constituency. In other words, what the Deputy wants is a constituency where he walks down one side of the street and up the other and may then say that he has made an intensive tour of his constituency.
Comment on this
Not only that, but in today's national papers we see that Deputies are to receive almost 100 per cent——
Comment on this
We cannot have a discussion on this matter. I have an idea that the Deputy is talking for the sake of talking, and if he cannot come to the Bill, I shall ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I do not wish to come in conflict with the Chair but I resent very much the inference that I am speaking for the sake of speaking. I have a contribution to make here and if it does not appeal to the Ceann Comhairle, I do not apologise. These are my views and I am going to express them.
Comment on this
The Deputy's views are relevant on the business before the House but not on other matters.
Comment on this
I repeat the statement I made that it is evident from the Deputy's speech that he cannot say anything on the Bill. If he cannot, I shall ask him to resume his seat.
Comment on this
I was dealing with Deputy Dowling's remarks last night here when he said that it was nearer the ideal to have a small constituency and I was about to ask whether he was thinking of himself or of the people who vote for him. Was it nearer the ideal for the Deputy or for the people?
Comment on this
At least Deputy Booth is prepared to compromise. I represent a constituency in which I can travel 55 miles in a straight line without leaving it, in two or three different directions. I can say that any person who has found fault with me is either a crank or a person who does not understand. If Deputy Booth came in contact with as many people in his constituency as I meet in mine, he could truthfully say here that the number who say to him that the constituency is too big and that he should get a smaller one is a very small number indeed. The problems that are discussed and the conversations that take place between a Deputy and a constituent very seldom turn in that direction. I cannot see why the only Deputies who have made a case for the single-member constituency in the Fianna Fáil Party are Deputies representing Dublin city. Take two streets and you have a constituency in the city of Dublin. What sense does it make? What kind of an arrangement would it be? Deputies from rural Ireland who represent a Party and are elected to Parliament make sacrifices to be here. There are Deputies who get into politics for what they can get out of them: most of us try to avoid losing by being in public life.
Comment on this
The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley, Deputy de Valera, Deputy Seán Lemass.
Comment on this
Please leave Deputy Dowling alone. He seems to think that the only Party that is unanimous on this question is the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Booth refused to pledge his word of honour when I asked him was the decision at the Party meeting unanimous. The Deputy is an honourable man and I did not pursue that line of argument. Deputy Dowling tells us it was unanimous but it is not on me he is reflecting but on his colleague, Deputy Booth. I know as well as Deputy Dowling that the Fianna Fáil Party were not unanimous and there is no point in trying to persuade me that they were, any more than the Fine Gael Party were unanimous or that the Labour Party were unanimous.
Comment on this
That is what the Deputy says and I have no reason to doubt it, but you cannot hope to get a number of people together at any level, even a football club, who will agree unanimously on any particular point. You cannot convince us that all the people in Fianna Fáil are out of step except our John—or should I say, our Jack?
Democracy works strangely. In a two-Party or three-Party system everything presented to the Dáil by the Government will no doubt be discussed by the Government Party, and if the Party by a majority decide that it is to be put through the Dáil then, irrespective of what views a front or a backbench Member may have in the Party room, he is committed by a democratic process that exists in this country to toe the Party line. Likewise, if the same proposition is being discussed in the Fine Gael Party room, the members examine it and debate it and decide by majority vote whether they should oppose it or accept it or try to amend it, and any Member of the Party who disagrees with the majority view will have to toe the Party line when the matter comes up in the House. It is the same in the case of the Labour Party; the same process operates. This is pure democracy and I do not despise any member of Fianna Fáil who disagrees with the present Government's proposal to abolish proportional representation but what I do disagree with is their castigation of the Fine Gael Party because certain members of Fine Gael have openly expressed their views. I disagree with their "holier than thou" attitude.
We know that some members of Fianna Fáil do not agree with the present proposal and I openly admit that members of the Fine Gael Party have expressed the view that they are in favour of the single-seat non-transferable vote system. In a democracy that is bound to happen. On many occasions if a free vote were taken in this House when certain Fianna Fáil Deputies are walking behind their Leader into the division lobby against their consciences—the crisis is not anything as great as we have in Vietnam—on any vote whatever that is put before the House, these Deputies have the consolation of knowing that members of the Opposition are voting against the proposal when if they were free to do so they would vote for it. We can all agree that if a free vote system were in operation in nine out of ten or perhaps 99 out of 100 cases we would come up with the same result. But we must have the Party system. Why then do certain Fianna Fáil members play on the fact that members of the Fine Gael Party have said something in public on this issue?
Fianna Fáil have forgotten one thing. They have been led into an attitude of complacency, into a fool's paradise, into believing that the Fine Gael Party were divided on this issue and would break. Let me say, as a member of that Party, that it is a democratic Party and if the result had been the other way, I should have accepted it. That is democracy and that is why I have been speaking for the past hour-and-a-half for the retention of proportional representation. I believe it is a good system and that the Irish people believe it is a good system. I believe the Fianna Fáil Party are having second thoughts about it, that they are in full retreat and looking for a way out. Why is it that some Ministers have become very pally with a certain Member of this House in the recent past? It is very interesting to read in the national papers where a Member of the House——