We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–191 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

This amendment proposes to delete the provision which we were proposing to put into the Constitution—that regard will be had to the extent and accessibility of constituencies and the need for securing convenient areas of representation. I have not much more to say about it.

The contention by the Fine Gael Party apparently is that this is not required and that there is no likelihood of there being a constituency in which the question of extent and accessibility would impose any difficulty on a Deputy in adequately representing the people of that constituency. I am not for a moment suggesting that there are any possible constituencies in which there would be large extents of tractless wastelands to be covered. At the same time, I think that if anybody here would take the trouble to examine what must happen if the changes we propose are not made, he will see that there are bound to be certain constituencies which will be unwieldy in extent and which will impose considerable difficulty on the elected Deputies for the constituencies in adequately covering them.

Deputy Harte is on record as saying that in so far as he is concerned it is quite clear that the county of Donegal should be one constituency only and that there would be no difficulty whatever, again in so far as he is concerned, in adequately representing the whole of the county of Donegal. That is one viewpoint. I am suggesting that there would be difficulty in one Deputy adequately representing the whole of the county of Donegal.

I suggest that the size, the shape and the other physical features of a constituency such as that would make it impossible for any one individual adequately to represent the whole of that county. Of course, under the system of representation we have here, each Deputy is elected to represent the whole of the constituency. Perhaps other Opposition Deputies would like to give us their opinion about the adequate representation of the new areas with which they will be involved and which they will have to represent, if this amendment is not passed, because I am quite sure that, with all the information available to them, Deputies have considered this matter— that they have not just decided to oppose this proposition that we are making because it has been introduced by Fianna Fáil, but that they have examined what must happen if some such scope as we are asking for in this proposed amendment of the Constitution is not given in the delineation of constituencies.

We have on record from one of the Deputies from Donegal the suggestion that the ideal thing for that part of the country is that there should be one five-seat constituency of the whole county of Donegal. It might have been interesting to hear also, let us say, from Deputies from County Kerry as to whether the size, shape and accessibility of the county of Kerry would make it difficult for them adequately to represent that whole county, because if what we are proposing is not accepted, it is quite on the cards that, like Donegal, County Kerry may have to become one single constituency and I should like to hear the Opposition Deputies for that constituency giving us their opinion as to the feasibility of adequately representing that likely constituency.

It would be interesting to hear from these Deputies whether the physical features of the area would interfere with them, would make it difficult for the people to have the type of representation that they have come to expect; whether the existence of mountain ranges and peninsulas in that area would affect the adequate representation of the people and also whether the possible addition of portion of the present constituency of West Cork, separated from County Kerry by a mountain range and accessible in so far as some parts of it are concerned only by means of the Healy Pass, would be a type of solution to the problems that exist—whether it would be preferable to what we are proposing here, that is, that it should be permissible to take these things into consideration in deciding on constituencies.

Again, as Deputy Fitzpatrick knows, the likelihood is that if what we are proposing is not accepted, if we are not given some scope in avoiding anomalies, one of the things that is likely to happen is that the counties of Cavan and Monaghan will be combined to form one constituency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That would suit me down to the ground.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick, the chief Opposition spokesman, knows from figures and so on, that this is probably the most likely thing to happen in that part of the country. I should like him to go on record as saying whether he thinks that the same services can be given to the people by a Deputy who has to cover the whole of those two counties from Castleblayney to Arva and from Virginia to Emyvale. There is, I think, no point in considering this question except in the context of the type of situation that must arise if this amendment we are proposing to the Constitution is not carried. I think it is necessary to have these guidelines that we put down here so that it will be definetely permissible to take those very relevant practical matters into consideration in revising constituencies in future.

Comment on this

Of the many disservices which the Fianna Fáil Party have rendered to the people of Ireland, one of the greatest is the conviction which they have spread abroad and which they wish to continue to create that a right, a service, an opportunity, is not available unless the application for it is processed through a TD. It is because of that disservice, because of that idea which they have implanted in the minds of the Irish people, that they now wish to base representation in this Parliament upon acreage and not upon the minds of independent, sturdy, disciplined, self-respecting people. The Fianna Fáil Party do not wish the Irish people to be self-respecting and independent. They wish the people of Ireland to be beholden to some political person. They wish the people to feel that anything in this world will be denied to them unless they go hat-in-hand to some politician, preferably of the Fianna Fáil Party, to get what is theirs as a right.

It is because that situation has been built up over the years by the Fianna Fáil Party who want the people to be subservient to them that we are now asked to base our whole parliamentary representation upon the paths that are to be worn by public representatives going to see their constituents or the paths that are to be worn by constituents going to see their public representatives. This is contemptible. This is folly. This is an effort to crystallise one of the most destructive forces in this land, the force which is destroying the self-respecting dignity of our people.

In an effort to justify this, which is to facilitate the operation of this demoralising practice, the Minister has suggested that some constituencies, as we know them, would be abolished and that some counties would be amalgamated with other counties in order to create convenient constituencies, or in order to create constituencies which the law now requires should exist because the law now says that there should be equality in the ratio between population and Deputy. What is interesting to recall, Sir, is that the then Minister for Local Government of the Fianna Fáil Party gave evidence on oath in the High Court seven years ago that it would be necessary to amalgamate some 16 constituencies or some 16 counties, some 16 administrative areas, if the court interpreted the Constitution in the way in which it was argued by the plaintiff it should be interpreted.

Comment on this

And that was right.

Comment on this

The truth, of course, is that in the event it was not necessary to amalgamate 16 counties.

Comment on this

That was because the court permitted the 5 per cent divergence.

Comment on this

The court allowed no such thing, and typical of the utterly false propaganda being advanced in support of this despicable proposal is the one that the courts have allowed a 5 per cent divergence. The courts have allowed no divergence from equality in so far as equality is practicable. The courts have said, because our Constitution says and because the people of Ireland said, equality should operate in the ratio between population and Deputy as far as it was practicable. In relation to the 1961 revision equality as far as it was practicable was operated. The courts have not said that a 5 per cent divergence is permissible. That is not what the courts said. That is not what the Constitution says. That is not what the law at the moment says and that is why I queried last week the ruling out of order of an amendment when the reason for ruling it out of order was supposed to be that the law at the moment allowed a 5 per cent divergence. The law allows no divergence whatsoever. It says it shall be equal as far as practicable.

It is open to this House and to the Seanad now under our existing law to make a re-arrangement of constituencies but there is an obligation on this House and on the other House to make the ratio between the population and Deputies equal as far as practicable. This House and the Seanad have no right to assume, and nobody has any right to assume, that the courts would allow a 5 per cent differential in the year 1968, because if it were possible to arrange the constituencies with equality without any differential, that is the obligation which would lie on us to achieve and it is that equality which the Minister and the Government are now seeking to depart from. They are now saying that no longer will there be an obligation to achieve that equality. We are to allow a divergence which is going to disfranchise almost one-third of the people living in the urban areas compared with their politically more powerful cousins down the country.

Comment on this

Can we deal with the question of the proposed amount of deviation on this amendment, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle?

Comment on this

Do I understand that the Minister wants me to deal with the proposed amount of deviation?

Comment on this

I want to know whether we can deal with it on this amendment or wait until we come to the Schedule.

Comment on this

I understood from what the Minister said that we were dealing with it.

Comment on this

I did not mention it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would point out to the Deputy that a reference to that might be appropriate to the Schedule as amended but at this stage it would not be appropriate.

Comment on this

The section we are dealing with, I understand, is on page 6, the sixth amendment. I think, Sir, with all respects, and I am going to accept the restrictions you are imposing on me, that you cannot consider it in a vacuum and that you must bear in mind the departure from the fundamental principle which at present applies, that is, the principle of one man, one vote and to every man an equal vote, an equal say and an equal interest in the destiny of the nation. I think that is a worthy and desirable objective. We in the Fine Gael Party do not believe that we are justified in destroying that principle by all kinds of fatuous excuses about extent and accessibility of constituencies.

What is to be the test of accessibility? Will it depend on rainfall, on frequency of air transport, on location of airports? Is it fair, in determining accessibility of constituencies, to say that there are regions in Dublin where during many hours of the day, because of traffic jams and such, it takes the better part of an hour to travel three miles? Is any allowance to be made for the inaccessibility of some areas in Dublin?

Comment on this

That could not be the same as down the country where you have to travel to some parts of the constituency 40 and 50 miles away.

Comment on this

The Minister's colleague, the former Minister for Lands, said that civil servants should not complain if they had to go to Castlebar or Athlone because they could get to their place of work quicker than from the homes they had in Dublin. The Parliamentary Secretary, if he is condemning me, and I would be pleased to think he was, because if he and I were to agree it would be a very sorry situation, with regard to what I am saying in relation to traffic jams in Dublin, is condemning his own Minister and his own Government who put forward as a justification for putting people down the country that they would be able to travel 20 miles in Connemara or the Midlands faster than they could travel three miles through the centre of Dublin.

I am not saying that is a wrong test. I say it is a fair one, but if that is to be the test, then 60 miles in rural Ireland should be equivalent to nine miles in urban areas of Dublin. I know that Dublin Deputies on the opposite side listening to me could not entirely disagree with what I am saying. There are difficulties in travelling through one's constituency in Dublin during the normal working day which I am sure are greater than travelling miles and miles of open land in rural constituencies.

Comment on this

You could use your own two feet.

Comment on this

Or a fourpenny bus.

Comment on this

We have a typical anti-urban attitude. The Parliamentary Secretary has just said that a fourpenny bus ride will get you anywhere in Dublin.

Comment on this

In your constituency.

Comment on this

A fourpenny bus ride could not get us through any of our constituencies in Dublin.

Comment on this

Or a sixpenny one.

Comment on this

There are many families in Dublin where they are obliged to pay 1/- to get into town and 1/- to get out of town, that is 2/- for a return journey, and because of the way in which the Dublin bus services operate, many people are obliged to go from their homes into town on one bus and get another in the centre of the city to take them to their destination.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy in favour of the amendment or against it?

Comment on this

It is not at all unusual for people in the Dublin area to have to pay as much as 4/- a day to travel to their relatives or friends. I am against this amendment because——

Comment on this

You are not in favour of it then?

Comment on this

I am in favour of our amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They are annoyed because they were dragged in here to listen to this.

Comment on this

We are making an amendment to your amendment. It is difficult and one can easily get confused. I do not pretend to be——

Comment on this

Omnipotent.

Comment on this

——free from confusion. The truth of the matter is—the Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister by their own remarks confirm me in my awareness of this—that you people over there have no understanding of the difficulty of traversing an urban area and do not consider the problems of getting through Dublin, where the problems of accessibility are such that it would take many people in Dublin much longer to reach their TD than it would take others in rural constituencies who might have to travel 40, 50 or 60 miles.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

It is true that people in Dublin who want to consult their TDs can spend much longer trying to get to them than many others in rural areas who have to travel much longer distances. Those unfortunate people in Dublin who have to pay bus fares of up to 4/- find it very hard to get in touch with their TDs. The Minister knows darn well that this is true.

Comment on this

You said it is only Fianna Fáil people who go to their TDs.

Comment on this

I am aware that there is a serious burden placed on the people in Dublin, the many thousands of people who have to pay high bus fares and spend a long time getting from one area to another. I am also aware that the problem of accessibility to TDs was not what was in the mind of the Government when they wrote the word "accessibility" into their abnoxious proposal. The extent of a constituency can be due to many factors, such as inland lakes, mountain ranges, large agricultural pastures and so forth. It is apparent that those will now be the determining factors in the representation of the people of Ireland.

I think we have reached a sorry state of affairs when we are going to determine the structure of this House by the bricks, stones and acres of this country. There is no parallel like it in the world. It is because we in the Fine Gael Party believe that these are unworthy things to have in mind when setting up constituencies that we have proposed our amendment to the Government amendment.

Finally, I would like to make this remark. Some 70 per cent of the Members of this House who can be members of local authorities are in fact members of local authorities. In other countries it is a rare event for members of Parliament to be members of local authorities. If the Government genuinely feel that there are insufficient public representatives for the people of this country, there is a very easy way of increasing the pool of public representatives available to our people, that is, by prohibiting Members of either House of the Oireachtas from being members of local authorities. You would, in so doing, make available to the Irish people, without any additional numbers whatsoever, some 100 or more additional public representatives because you would have county councillors, urban councillors, town councillors who would not be Members of the Dáil or the Seanad. Those people would be scattered across the trackless wastes, to which reference has been made by Government speakers. They would be there seven days a week and we would get away from the present system where some 70 per cent of us are members of local authorities and, on account of being Members of the Dáil or Seanad, are not accessible to the people for three or four days of a week during the parts of the year we are in this House. These are the kinds of thing which could give better representation to the people of this country without any additional problem. These are the kinds of things which could be brought into operation, which would avoid doing violence to the Constitution, which would avoid interfering with the fundamentals which one would have thought sacred and accepted principles—one man, one vote and to every man an equal vote, an equal say in the destinies of the nation.

Comment on this

At the start of his remarks, Deputy Ryan criticised Fianna Fáil as being responsible for the present feeling amongst Irish people that they must always contact their local TD in order to get anything. I contradict that absolutely, but I am very much in favour of taking every possible action to keep constituents very closely in touch with their TD at all times. For that reason the Government have put in this provision in the Schedule to the Bill which has my complete support.

Deputy Ryan says that to take into account in determining constituencies the extent and accessibility of these constituencies would need that we secure convenient areas of representation. I would not agree with this for a moment and I think it is only someone who has failed to read the papers or look at television in the past couple of weeks who would put forward the suggestion that we do not need as close as possible contact between the ordinary representative and the public. What Frenchmen call a revolution which is taking place in France at the moment is simply because the French people do not want to be ruled by faceless men.

Comment on this

Speak for yourself.

Comment on this

I cannot speak as a Frenchman. Deputies believe that troubles of the moment are due to a lack of representation between Governments and the ordinary man in the street. We are sometimes criticised as being over-represented, having too high a rate of representation. I do not agree. I think we must do everything we can to ensure that every man in the street knows who his TD is, knows where to get him, and is constantly in touch with him. It is not a question of arguing about old age pensions, drainage, roads, resurfacing of boreens, or whatever it may be. It involves a steady line of communication between Government and people so that the people will know what the Government are doing, when a measure is significant when it comes before the House, and so on.

It is because in other countries this line of communication is broken that people who do not know who are governing them have no confidence in the people in the National Assembly. We must make certain that we will not become faceless men, cut off from the community. We must keep ourselves closely in touch with our constituents at all times.

A country constituency has particular difficulties in that there are physical features, which Deputy Ryan mentions, like mountains, rivers, road systems, which make it difficult for a parliamentary representative adequately to represent his area. To my mind, the main difference between the rural and urban areas is that in the urban areas you have frequent meetings of groups of people together where a TD can meet 50 or 200 people at a time. In an ordinary rural area, it is hard enough to get groups of 15 or 20 together and the average country TD has to do most of his work by personal calls, by receiving people at his own house, or his clinic, or whatever it may be. I think present events make this provision in the Bill more relevant and more necessary than ever and to a dispassionate observer, it will be clear how vital it is to proper development of parliamentary democracy.

If we have large country constituencies where a large majority of the people rarely, if ever, see their TD and even more rarely have a chance of talking to him about legislation and what is going on, we are in danger of the disruption of society which is already taking place in so many European countries. We must learn from them, and even if it does mean a slightly increased representation here in one constituency over another, what difference. We have Deputy Ryan talking about one man, one vote, and so on. He has only to look at the situation of this day to see where the situation is wildly in excess of what we are providing, how the constituencies will be revised, what loading will be given to extent and accessibility. He quite forgets of course that these constituencies will be determined by a commission representative of the Government and the Opposition in equal numbers and presided over by a High Court judge. In his more rational moments, Deputy Ryan approves of High Court judges.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Surely the Deputy knows there is no such provision in the Third Amendment.

Comment on this

It covers the whole of the constituency boundaries and Deputy Fitzpatrick knows that well.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not know any such thing.

Comment on this

It is the commission who will read the meaning into these amendments. They are perfectly clear themselves and the people who will interpret them will be three Government Members, three Opposition Members, with the help of the casting vote of a High Court judge.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Nonsense.

Comment on this

Nothing could be fairer than that. There is nothing here to say that these provisions shall be applicable to rural areas only. If there is any validity in Deputy Ryan's comments about city traffic jams, and so on, there is nothing to prevent the commission taking action on that and making allowances accordingly. Therefore, a properly dispassionate and properly balanced commission will do that. If they feel there is no real value in what Deputy Ryan contends, they will not take action along these lines. Where are we to give priority? Deputy Ryan says that this refers only to rural constituencies. I hope the Opposition will think again about this amendment. It is a useful exercise in determining what sort of parliamentary democracy we need. I am the last one to suggest we should encourage constituents to come to their TDs to investigate their statutory rights. I am positive we must keep our parliamentary representatives closely in touch with their constituents, much more closely than they are at the moment. If we do not do this, we will face a disaster similar to that which has happened in France and other countries.

There is no question of anything arbitrary. If we ignore mountains, lakes, and so on, we are just fooling ourselves. We have to take into account how easy it is to get from one place to another, and also the density of population and whether a TD will have to meet his constituents singly or will have an opportunity of meeting them in groups of ten, 15, 20 or more. These are matters which have to be taken into consideration and which should be taken into consideration.

When this Bill becomes law and we get smaller, more manageable, constituencies, that will enable every TD to do a far better job of public relations between the Houses of the Oireachtas and the ordinary voter. That is the essential feature of parliamentary democracy, as I see it. If we tamper with that or make it more difficult to have that close link at all times, we are taking a very dangerous course.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): In his concluding remarks, the Minister asked several times whether the members of the Opposition were prepared to deal with various constituencies and asked us to say whether, for example, I would be prepared to take on the representation of a constituency of Cavan-Monaghan. My answer is that I would, with the greatest pleasure. The Minister has asked a number of questions—whether various Members of the Dáil have studied the implications behind these two Bills. One thing is clear to me, that is that the Irish people have given a very considerable amount of thought and consideration to the contents of these two Bills and fully appreciate what is in them and what is behind them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I would suggest that the Deputy keep to the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With the greatest respect, I will, but I must deal with the point made by the Minister.

Comment on this

I was dealing only with the size of constituencies and accessibility and with the words which the Deputy is proposing to delete.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister has invited me to deal with individual constituencies. I want to make the case to the Minister and to the House that that is not necessary because the people of the country know exactly what is behind this “tolerance”, and what is behind the proposal to take into consideration, in drawing up constituencies, such natural features as mountains and rivers and accessibility, and all the rest of it. The people know, and have said in Limerick and in Wicklow that they know and fully appreciate that this is a manoeuvre of the Fianna Fáil Party to juggle with the Constitution, to rig the electoral system, to do away with a system that has proved fair and effective and to substitute for it a rigging device that will keep Fianna Fáil in power.

Comment on this

By how much would we have won but for that?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The fact is that the people have spoken clearly and distinctly in those two constituencies.

Comment on this

That is what we thought, too.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am sorry that the defender of the voters in the mountains is leaving the House because I wanted to say a few things before he left.

Comment on this

I shall be back.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to say that the sooner these Bills are submitted to the people, the better. I am satisfied as to what the result will be. The Minister in making the case against the amendment seemed to be making the case that it is necessary that TDs should be very easily accessible to their constituents so that they can serve them at county council level.

Comment on this

I never mentioned the word.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I know the Minister did not mention the word but I cannot see what else he could mean. On the other hand, the Taoiseach, in introducing the Fourth Amendment providing for single member constituencies, seemed clearly to make the case that it was highly undesirable that Members of this House should be messengers——

Comment on this

It certainly is.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——that Members of this House should be called upon to get health cards, to get hospital bills reduced, and that sort of thing. The Taoiseach made that case for the Fourth Amendment. The Minister now seems to me to be making the opposite case, that it is necessary that people should be running with hat in hand to TDs for everything, that they should be led to believe that unless they do that, they will not get what they are clearly entitled to get.

In an effort to justify this measure, Deputy Booth spoke of the situation in France. It is very far-fetched to compare the situation or circumstances in France with the position here. There is no comparison, geographically, demographically or in any other way. Deputy Booth spoke about TDs becoming faceless men. In my experience of rural Ireland, every constituent of every constituency knows who his TD is and knows where to get him and how to get him. Under the present system of multi-seat constituencies, every TD keeps in close touch with his constituents if he wants to remain in Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

There are many of them who do not know me.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy is a national joke but he is not such a joke at all. The only place where TDs, with the notable exception of Deputy Burke, may become faceless is the city of Dublin. On numerous occasions I have spoken to citizens of this city, some of whom I knew and some of whom I did not know but met casually, who could not tell who their TD is or in what constituency he resided.

Comment on this

There is one area where that does not apply.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): County Dublin, I would say.

Comment on this

We need hardly name it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We need hardly name it. Apart from that area, there are very many citizens of this city who could not identify their own constituency or their public representative.

Comment on this

They are not as demanding as others. They do not make such demands upon their representatives.

Comment on this

Will you look at Deputy Burke?

Comment on this

That man is a martyr—I know that.

Comment on this

Thank you very much.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The provision in the Bill the discussion of which we are now engaged in is to allot thousands and thousands more constituents to Dublin Deputies. As I have said, in rural Ireland, under the present system, the people know their constituency, know their Deputies and how to get at them and where to get them. The Deputies make very sure to keep in close touch with their constituents. Maybe the Minister thinks that this will not be necessary if he succeeds in introducing single-seat constituencies with, perhaps, huge majorities in some, which in turn will lend itself to lazy, inactive TDs sitting on large majorities as happens in Northern Ireland and England. If that is what the Minister has in mind, he need not worry his head about it because we are not going to have single-member constituencies.

Deputy Booth, in his effort to justify this dangerous provision of this Bill, told the House solemnly that we need not have any fears because the constituencies would be arranged by a tribunal consisting of six Members of this House, presided over by an independent member of the judiciary. I want to tell Deputy Booth that in the Third Amendment of the Constitution, there is not one thing about a commission.

Comment on this

No, the commission is there still.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Where? I want to tell Deputy Booth that if the Third Amendment is accepted by the people and if the Fourth Amendment is kicked out, there is not one iota——

Comment on this

When you had them together, you would not take them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——about a commission. When a Deputy trained in the law like Deputy Booth puts up that sort of argument in favour of this provision in the Third Amendment and against our amendment, one can only believe he is not sincere or that he has not read the Third Amendment Bill or that he is only trying to waste the time of the House.

Comment on this

No, I do not follow the Fine Gael example.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Booth told us at considerable length—I tried to put him right but he persisted in going on—that we need not have any fear, that a judge would eventually delineate these constituencies. I want to put it on record that that just is not so, that the Government in drafting the Third Amendment Bill made very sure that they would not put anything about a commission or a judge in it, that they would reserve unto themselves and their majority in this House the right to draw up the constituencies.

Comment on this

You will be wanting it taken out of the Bill next.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They did that deliberately because they know perfectly well that there is no hope whatever of the Fourth Amendment being accepted and there is no hope of this being accepted.

Comment on this

What are you worrying about then?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is my business to deal with measures as they are here and I am going to do it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister stated it was not possible to put the commission into the two Bills. I say that is just not so. There is nothing to prevent him putting it into them. There is nothing to prevent him writing it into the two Bills on the basis that, should the other not be accepted by the people, the provisions of the commission then stand. But he does not want the commission. He prefers, with this tolerance and with being allowed to take into consideration extraneous matters like those being taken into consideration here and which we are attempting to disregard, to retain to himself the right to rig the constituencies, the right to gerrymander, if and when the people kick out the other Bill.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy any evidence of that or is he just sticking his neck out?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When I see the commission in one Bill and do not see it in the other, when I see Deputy Booth thinking it is in both of them and when I hear him telling the people that the commission provisions of the Third Amendment Bill will safeguard them and that they need not worry, I know Deputy Booth is very anxious to get this thing through notwithstanding the fact that he has not read it.

Comment on this

It is because I read it I want to get it through.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When I sit down, I will welcome Deputy Booth standing up to explain to the House how, if the Fourth Amendment is rejected and the Third Amendment accepted, the people are going to have the benefit of a commission presided over by a judge in arranging the constituencies. I ask him to do it now.

Comment on this

Normally no reasonable person could object to the provision that somebody as impartial as it is possible to obtain should preside and decide on the extent and accessibility of constituencies, the need for securing convenient arrangements, representation and so on. It is a very reasonable sounding proposal. It would indeed be reasonable if it were not simply the sugar on the pill. It is the sugar on a very poisonous pill. The poison is the so-called tolerance, this proposal to disfranchise the Dublin city, and indeed to some extent, the Dublin county, voter.

Comment on this

Can we deal with this on the amendment, Sir?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

When we dispose of the amendment.

Comment on this

This proposal of the Minister in regard to extent and accessibility is only put in in order to try to give a decent face to a very indecent and obnoxious political manoeuvre. I suppose there is no constituency more awkwardly placed in regard to the diversity of interests, and indeed, it could be said, to some extent of distance, as the constituency represented by my distinguished colleague here, who is overladen with letters, and by the Minister and myself. We have mountains, plains, villages, hamlets——

Comment on this

And long distances.

Comment on this

And long distances. The most highly populated working-class area in Ireland as well.

Comment on this

And a peninsula.

Comment on this

And an island.

Comment on this

Of course, the Minister would not know about the island. We have chapel gates. Near every chapel gate there is a cemetery, as my distinguished colleague very well knows. It would wear any man out trying to cover them all: the daily perusal of the evening papers to glean the sad news of burials——

Comment on this

A decade of the Rosary.

Comment on this

The demands made on the great charity of my distinguished colleague in this matter is a subject of marvel to all who know him. Long may he continue to exercise this great Christian virtue which is completely divorced, as we know, from the gathering of votes.

Comment on this

Does "one man, one vote" apply in the constituency at the moment, or is it not a fact that you are 45 per cent above the national average?

Comment on this

Quite true, and I am glad the Deputy mentioned that point. It is essential that there should be redistribution. We approach that on the basis of principle rather than expediency.

There is a good deal of argument in this House on the whole question being discussed here on this Bill which is determined by the interests of the individual Deputy, and not by the interests of the whole country, or the national good as it is often referred to, or by what is good policy for the country as a whole. It would suit several Deputies to have single-member constituencies, but that is not the point. The point is that they must address themselves to what is good for the whole country.

I feel that this provision is written into the Bill for a purpose, the purpose being, as I say, to shroud the main activities to which I have referred and to which apparently I am not permitted by the Chair to refer at any length. The provision implies a departure from the principle of one man, one vote, and that where it is convenient for representation, the commission may by this enactment be empowered to disregard the question of population. That is wrong. That is fundamentally wrong. If we are to have a democratic country, we must relate representation to people. If we depart from that principle, we depart from democracy.

Comment on this

Hear, hear: that is the point.

Comment on this

It must be related to people and not to the configuration of the country and the convenience of Deputies.

Comment on this

Nor to mathematical equality which is impossible as the Deputy well knows. I am entirely with the Deputy there. Contact between individual people and individual parliamentary representatives.

Comment on this

The Deputy went on to what was obviously to me a head-line-hunting ploy and talked about France, what was happening in France and the possibility of its happening here. It could not happen here. It could not happen here for the simple reason that Deputies of Dáil Éireann, to my knowledge over the period I have been a Member of the House, have been accessible to everyone who wished to see them. They are not faceless men in the sense that they might be in a country with a population of many millions. So the comparison is not only odious but it is ridiculous and impossible—the comparison of saying that a Deputy of Dáil Éireann could get so out of touch with his constituents as to be compared with, say, a Deputy of the French National Assembly.

There is a corrective for that. Particularly in the times in which we live, unlike days gone by when a Party tag was sufficient to usher a person in here, any Deputy who does not do his work properly, or make a fairly good stab at it, is for the road. There are many others on his heels to take up the task if he is not willing to do it. Indeed, there is a competitiveness about polities which, as we know, does not always produce the most desirable results, but it is there.

This provision is a danger I feel, and represents a possible infringement of the democratic principle which is vital in so far as the Labour Party are concerned, and one on which we intend to stand. We agree that before the next election there must be a redistribution of seats to correspond with the location of population and other changes that have occurred since the last redistribution. That must take place, but it must be determined on the basis of the number of people who will be casting votes, and not upon the number of cattle or sheep, or the shape of the country. The voter must be considered not inanimate objects or animals.

It is on that score only that I would quarrel with this provision. It contains the danger of tampering with the idea of popular representation as we know it. Certain proposals by the Minister which apparently he bulldozed through the Cabinet and which, in a moment of political somnolence, Fianna Fáil accepted in conclave, will be completely and utterly rejected by the people, and any honest man knows that. I have not heard one person sincerely advocating the abolition of PR. This applies to many people who I know are supporters of the Government in normal circumstances, but they will not vote for the abolition of PR.

Comment on this

In Limerick, 2,000 would not even use it. They voted against PR for a start.

Comment on this

In Limerick, 1,900 and 1,600 Fine Gael voters put Deputy O'Malley in here. He is here by dint of the benefit of 3,500 Fine Gael votes.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

Yes at all, and I am sure that is what annoyed the Minister.

Comment on this

If there were a proper system, he would have had a majority of 6,000.

Comment on this

If there were a proper system?

Comment on this

A rational system.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If Taca meant anything, he would have got 25,000. Taca suffered a death blow in Limerick.

Comment on this

Like the small farmers.

Comment on this

We suffered a victory in Limerick.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If Taca and arrogance and money meant anything, he would have got 25,000.

Comment on this

We all won. Is that not a grand way to be?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not say we won. If Taca meant anything or stood for anything, he would have got 25,000.

Comment on this

We all won, but we got the seat.

Comment on this

I do not want to say anything about any Member of the House and particularly about someone who is related to the man who is dead and who was a friend of all of us.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Time will tell its own tale in regard to that man. As it was brought up, I just mentioned the fact that it was 3,500 of the conservative hard core——

Comment on this

There would have been more of yours if they were investigated.

Comment on this

I do not get that.

Comment on this

There would have been more non-transferable Labour Party votes.

Comment on this

The Minister sought an argument with the Attorney General and was grossly hurtful to his feelings. When he saw the way the ball was hopping, he lost his temper. I have nothing further to add at this stage. We will have other opportunities of giving our views.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is Deputy Booth going to tell us about the commission?

Comment on this

I do not think I want to say anything more.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I thought the Deputy would explain how the commission will operate in the Third Amendment Bill, if the Fourth Amendment Bill goes down.

Cuireadh an cheist: "Go bhfanfaidh na focail a tarraigeadh a scriosadh", agus faisnéiseadh go rabhthas tar éis glacadh léi.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The object of the Schedule as it stands is to allow this one-sixth tolerance and to permit of the taking into consideration of matters of accessibility of constituencies and the need for securing convenient areas of representation, and subject to those considerations the main purpose of the Schedule is to give this very substantial tolerance of one-sixth. I want to say that the one-sixth tolerance is anti-democratic. It is designed to give some citizens in some parts of the country 40 per cent more Dáil representations than others who live in other districts.

Comment on this

How does the Deputy work out 40 per cent?

Comment on this

In the same way as they worked out that they won in Limerick.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If Deputy Booth wants to take part in this discussion, he should have read the Bill and considered its implications. Obviously, he has not done so. If he will keep quiet, I shall tell him.

Comment on this

That is what I was hoping for.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Under the Bill, 16,667 people in one area will be entitled to the Teachta Dála while, in another area, 23,333 persons may be required in order to have the Teachta Dála. A population of 116,667 persons could be represented by five Teachtaí Dála in one area.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy repeat that figure? It seemed to get jumbled up.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): A population of 116,667 could be represented by five Teachtaí Dála in one area and by seven in another, giving the citizens in the second area 40 per cent greater representation and influence in legislation and in other matters than the citizens in the first area. I say that that is anti-democratic.

Comment on this

It is also crazy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This undemocratic procedure is designed to increase still further Fianna Fáil control of the Dáil so that, in conjunction with the first-past-the-post voting system which they are trying to bring into operation, they will be able to secure a Dáil majority with a good deal less than 40 per cent of the popular vote.

Comment on this

It might be the Deputy's own Party. He is paying us a wonderful compliment.

Comment on this

It never occurred to him.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Booth has not studied the Bill and therefore he should keep quiet and try to listen to the arguments on it. In a number of counties in the west of Ireland, Fianna Fáil have barely half the number of seats. In a number of counties, they have 21 seats out of 29. Under the first-past-the-post system, they calculate they will secure three-fourths of these seats in defiance of the wishes of the electorate.

Comment on this

Who calculated it?

Comment on this

The Fine Gael professors who told them they won in Limerick.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Therefore, they want in conjunction with the first-past-the-post system——

Comment on this

We have a majority of two in Dublin.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——to give this 40 per cent more seats to those areas in proportion to the population. I say that that is not fair. In this way, they want to increase and inflate artificially their Dáil majority still further so that, with a good deal less than 40 per cent of the popular vote, they can control the Dáil. That is what they want to do. That is the object of this Bill.

Comment on this

What percentage have Fine Gael to get?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is why the people are so violently against it.

Comment on this

Will Fine Gael get stuck on 20 per cent indefinitely?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall not listen to Deputy Booth or deal with the remarks of a man who thinks there is a commission in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. Until he satisfies himself about that and reads the Bill and sees that there is no provision for a commission in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill——

Comment on this

I never said there was.

Comment on this

He is too busy to read Bills.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The people know perfectly well what is behind this. That is why they have expressed their views against it so violently on the two occasions they got the opportunity to do so.

Comment on this

Three, was it not? What about Clare?

Comment on this

A long shadow was cast in Clare.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Did the Taoiseach, in opening the Limerick campaign, not ask the people to make it an issue? He must have been told off by one of the many Taoiseachs when he came back.

Comment on this

Did we lose Limerick?

Comment on this

You certainly should have. You lost thousands of votes there.

Comment on this

You lost the by-election, all the same. I read it in the papers.

Comment on this

Deputy Booth was in Canada. He should not believe all he reads in the papers. He is very young and innocent.

Comment on this

Who was it who came in here today?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The figures I have given are correct and accurate. They are figures that cannot be justified by the Government in introducing this measure. The two Bills together are undemocratic. This Bill does violence, and very great violence, to the system of one-man, one-vote. On those grounds I am violently against the Schedule to this Bill. It really discloses the real intention of the Fianna Fáil Party. They started off by having a package deal. They were driven away from that. They come in, then, and separate the two proposals——

Comment on this

The Deputy wants us to put them back again, as far as I can see.

Comment on this

Fine Gael never can make up their mind.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): In the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, as a bit of encouragement, the Minister gives the commission, presided over by a High Court judge. Notwithstanding what Deputy Booth thinks, there is no provision for any commission in this Bill and the Government retain the right to fix the constituencies as they elect, with their majority in the present Dáil.

Comment on this

That will be an interesting operation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That has to be done before the next election. Surely the Minister agrees he could write the commission into both Bills?

Comment on this

It would be a funny-looking Constitution that we would end up with.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It can be stated that it could operate only in the event of the other's not being passed.

Comment on this

Why does the Deputy not produce an amendment if he feels so badly about it?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It will be produced in due course.

Comment on this

The Deputy forgot about it until now.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have made this point all along. That is, as I say, what discloses the Government's real intention. I think that is one of the reasons prompting public opinion to distrust the Government's proposals. It has driven the national newspapers — the free ones — to denounce this proposal which the Minister is now seeking to implement——

Comment on this

They denounce everything Fianna Fáil proposes.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The State-sponsored television service also pointed out——

Comment on this

What sort of television service did the Deputy call it?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——the dangers of this system until it was blacked out, until it came under the Minister's hatchet. So far as the people have got an opportunity they also have said what they thought about it. The sooner this matter gets to the people the better and the sooner the time of the Dáil is made available for other more vital matters, the better.

Comment on this

I want to comment on some of the statements made by Councillor Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this

Where does the Deputy think he is now?

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick —my apologies to the Deputy. He has claimed that we are certain to win in one-seat constituencies. I thank him for the great confidence he has in our Party——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You are capable of rigging the constituency under this measure.

Comment on this

We won six out of seven of them.

Comment on this

At a cost of £250,000.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick should not be so pessimistic about his own Party's chances.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am afraid of you rigging the constituencies and that is what I am against.

Comment on this

If we cannot count the votes better than you counted them in Limerick——

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest the Limerick figures were wrong?

Comment on this

No, but the Fine Gael checkers put them ahead of Labour.

Comment on this

I am sorry for interrupting Deputy Burke.

Comment on this

Looking at it from a practical point of view, a Deputy in a single-seat constituency, fighting an election, would have a smaller constituency to deal with than a man in a multi-seat constituency such as that with which I and my colleagues, and others concerned who were not successful had to cope. You have to cross through the city and go from the Scalp to Glencullen, away up the mountains and when you get to the top you must come down again to the flat lands and go into Kilduff. The following day you start off for the mountains in a different direction up to Brittas.

Comment on this

There are parts of the Deputy's area where he was never seen.

Comment on this