Committee on Finance. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 192–365 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
Deputy Fitzpatrick said he would not mind representing Cavan and Monaghan. He would have my sympathy—he is a glutton for punishment——
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick is an honourable man and I am sure would be well able to look after Monaghan and Cavan, but if he were ten times better, if he were in a multi-seat constituency he would be doing it in a general way, in the national Parliament, in county councils and other bodies of which he was a member. It is not possible for a man to be present in five places at the same time. Hardly a day passes that we have not four meetings, one perhaps in Brittas, one in Balbriggan——
Comment on this
God help us, some of my friends die also. I believe it would be better for the people, for whom we are concerned, to have the single-seat constituency. Being a member of a national Party concerned with the welfare of all the people, we consider the people first and I think it would be wonderful for them if Deputies had smaller areas. One could know them all by their names.
Comment on this
When you meet them now, you will say: "How are you and how are all at home?" You will not say whether they are married or single and you will let yourself down if you ask the name. You will have had it. You know them in a general way and you know they go to Mass, say, in Bohernabreena or in Brittas—excuse me for laughing.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Deputy's constituents would know him if they saw him now smiling and laughing——
Comment on this
If the Deputy wants to be personal, he may continue to do so. I suppose he, too, goes to some funerals to bury the dead——
Comment on this
I am not jeering at them but I am talking facts and if I have brought humour into it, it is no harm and there is no jeering about it at all. Seriously, I think the multi-seat constituency is wrong for both people and Deputies and I would welcome the change even though it might mean my exit; I might not be returned. It is better for the people and for the Deputies and I believe it would be the right thing for the country.
Comment on this
I wanted to refer to some of the things that were said regarding the Schedule. First of all, I want to state that it appears our attempts to unconfuse the Opposition have not been very successful.
Comment on this
Some people have said that one of the effects of these proposals might be to perform something of a rescue operation on the Fine Gael Party. I admit that there is nothing farther from our intentions in introducing these proposed amendments to the Constitution than that but, at the same time, the fact that they continue to be so confused about this whole issue, although we have leaned over backwards in trying to make matters clear to them, seems to indicate at least that such a rescue operation is pretty urgently required in their case.
This question that has been raised of one-man, one-vote is, I agree, relevant to the proposals we are making. and if the proposals had come before the House in the form we originally intended, that is, as one proposition, then I could understand there being quite an amount of discussion on the principle of one-man, one-vote on the joint proposal. It is not this Bill that deals with that proposition; it is in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution that we are proposing to the people that they should establish for the first time in this country the principle of one-man, one-vote, and that for the first time they should establish a system here in which every voter will be treated in the same way.
Here in this Bill we are dealing with a completely different thing, and the question of one-man, one-vote does not arise. The provision in the Constitution requires that the representation of a constituency will be related to population, not to voters, and the proportion of population to voters is not by any means a constant factor throughout the country as a whole. I demonstrated by the figures here already that the proportion of population to voters in the constituency of Dublin North-West, for instance, is something under 51 per cent, whereas in Donegal South-West the proportion of voters to population is over 67 per cent. Therefore, if we continue with the present requirements of the Constitution, and if the revision of constituencies that Deputy Dunne in particular has been demanding is to be carried out, the result must be that a vote in South-West Donegal will be around 33 per cent less effective in electing a Deputy than in Dublin North-West. It is the maintenance of that position that Opposition Parties are trying to ensure. As I said, it is to the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution that this principle is applicable.
We agreed to separate our proposals with regard to the electoral system into two distinct provisions in response to the demands of the Opposition who claimed that to have to consider this whole complicated matter in one Bill was confusing to them, although, in fact, in the referendum of 1959 there was a provision making it clear that regard should be had to these factors in drawing up a scheme of constituencies, and the only essential difference at that time was that there was not a definite maximum percentage deviation from the national average specified then. The Opposition did not find it confusing at that time, but they apparently found it confusing this time, and so we agreed to bring these two proposals forward separately.
It becomes more and more difficult for me to understand exactly why the Opposition wanted these proposals separately. Apparently they intend to oppose both of them, and that being so, it appears that any confusion that may arise in the minds of their own supporters will be created by themselves. Naturally I took it that when they wanted these things separated, they intended to support this amendment, and I will show from quotations from speeches made by members of the Opposition Parties in the debate on the revision of constituencies in 1961 that that is a very reasonable assumption for anybody to make with regard to both the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party. I certainly could see no other reason for the desire to have separate proposals than the intention of the Opposition Parties to support at least this one.
It is quite clear from the debate on the 1961 revision of constituencies that this proposal, the Third Amendment of the Constitution, is in direct response to the demands of the two Opposition Parties. In dealing with the revision of constituencies that was before the House in 1961 and resulted from the finding of the High Court that the revision of constituencies made in 1959 was in contravention of the Constitution, Deputy Corish, who is now the Leader of the Labour Party—he was not at that time—said at column 213, Volume 188 of the Official Report of 12th April, 1961:
We have a peculiar situation in one county, in Kildare, which under the present proposal embodies three county council areas—and the Minister and Deputies know that as far as Parliamentary members are concerned, not alone do Deputies have to make representations in respect of the work of the Government but to a very large extent the work of local authorities also—and it seems that in these constituencies that have to deal with two or three or four local authorities, the work of the Deputies will be very difficult indeed.
Deputy Corish obviously considered that the difficulty that was placed on Deputies, and presumably also on their constituents, by taking portions of one county and adding them to another county in order to achieve mathematical accuracy in regard to the proportion of population, was a matter of some importance in 1961. Now, as Deputy Dunne says, the situation disclosed by the census obviously indicates that the present scheme of constituencies is not in accordance with the constitutional requirements and, therefore, in order to conform with the Constitution, a further revision must be made. Deputy Corish and every other Deputy has had made available to him all the information which is necessary in order to form a rough opinion, certainly, as to what must happen to each constituency throughout the country if this revision of constituencies is made now in accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution as interpreted by the High Court.
It must be clear to anybody who has had sufficient interest in this matter to investigate what must happen, that this type of thing that happened in County Kildare, to which Deputy Corish took exception in 1961, must be repeated on a much wider scale throughout the length and breadth of the country on this occasion unless the change which we propose is made. Indeed, it will be quite obvious to anybody who makes such an investigation that the change we are proposing will not be sufficient to avoid quite an amount of this, at any rate. However, it will be quite clear to anybody who makes that kind of examination of the position that what happened in this way in 1961 will be as nothing compared with what must happen now.
Deputy Corish in 1961 was followed by Deputy Donnellan, and at column 214, he said:
It is regrettable that this Bill had to be introduced because of a decision of the High Court.
Later on, in the same column, he said:
I do not welcome this Bill; I believe it is the death-knell of rural Ireland.
Further down again he said.
If we are to develop along that line—I believe we are; as Deputy Dillon said and I may repeat it, it is nothing personal to me—representation in the near future will belong to the few cities we have and, quoting the words of a gentleman I heard speaking last Saturday night, "to a dwindling population". If that happens, it will be a bad day for the country and we are actually heading in that direction now.
At column 215 Deputy Donnellan continued:
I suppose the Minister cannot help this situation. I want to be fair to him and I must say I believe that the 1959 Act that was challenged in the High Court was fairer. I supported it. I believed it was the right thing. Some people thought otherwise. The solicitors and the lawyers came into it. The courts reached a decision much to the disadvantage of rural Ireland and its people. Of course, with Fianna Fáil, the Constitution is almighty. According to them, it is the Gospel. They have an opportunity now of seeing what their Constitution is costing the people of rural Ireland. The Taoiseach was not man enough to submit the matter to a referendum so that the people might be given an opportunity of changing the relevant Article in the Constitution and getting a fair crack of the whip. There is no credit due to those who brought the action in the High Court. If the day comes that Dáil Éireann will be influenced by a completely city mentality, it will be a bad day for Ireland and for her people.
I suppose this is the best Bill the Government can bring in in the circumstances. It is as near as possible to representation for every 20,000. What will be the position if this wrong is permitted to continue? What will be the fate of the people living in the rural areas? Will the majority here be Deputies from Dublin city and Cork city and the other cities? I regret the Taoiseach did not put this by way of referendum to the people.
To rectify what was described as a wrong the position now is that we are attempting to rectify that wrong. I do not know how anybody——
Comment on this
Others expressed their views too and I will put them on record for the benefit of members of Fine Gael and the Labour Party. How can it be possible for anybody to try to interpret the minds of the Opposition? When we do what was demanded in 1961, we did not do it immediately after that general election, we did not do it after the next general election, but we propose to do it now because when the census returns for 1966 were published, Deputy Dunne was quick to see that a revision was called for and demanded it——
Comment on this
We acceded to the demand to rectify what was described as this wrong or this injustice to the people. Now we find that the Opposition are actuated by a different principle, by the simple principle of opposition, that the duty of an Opposition is to oppose everything brought forward by a Fianna Fáil Government. The fact that they are already on record as having demanded it is something of no concern. Deputy Donnellan concluded by saying:
My remarks have nothing personal in them. I protest as a public representative. I think this Bill is a step in the wrong direction. It will deprive the people in the rural areas of adequate representation. Remember, it is only a start; day after day and year after year, worse will probably come. The precedent has been established. It will be impossible to undo what is being done here. Another Government tomorrow would probably do the same thing.
Now another Government is faced with a requirement to do something infinitely worse than what had to be done in 1961 and they are proposing, as was demanded by the Opposition, to ask the people to amend the Constitution to give a very small amount of scope to the Government, or the commission, in drawing up constituencies to avoid perpetrating this type of injustice on the people and on their public representatives.
Deputy Norton, who was then Leader of the Labour Party, also spoke in this debate and at column 226 of the same volume he said:
The courts have decided that the last Electoral Bill was ultra vires the Constitution; consequently some other Bill had to be introduced and this is the Bill we got. It is worth the time of the House to dwell for a few moments on the situation in which we have been landed by the Constitution, by the courts and by all the legal people who advised the Government. The courts' decision is that the last Bill which gave a seat in constituencies with fewer than 20,000 of a population per seat was ultra vires the Constitution. That has been the position in many constituencies since the Constitution was passed over 20 years ago.
Deputy Norton might have added also that it also was the position prior to the passing of the Constitution.
At the end of the same column Deputy Norton said:
...our legislation in the past has been based upon the assumption that if we did not get the 20,000 in each constituency, it was good enough to get it in the country as a whole.
That was the assumption on which the legislation was based. At column 230, Deputy Norton said:
I think it is crazy to do what is being done with some constituencies. I represent the constituency of Kildare which is known everywhere as a clearly defined territorial area. In order to box the compass in connection with the results at the next election, Kildare has a chunk of south Meath clamped on to it at one end, and an extreme corner of Westmeath at another end. Now to the constituency which consists of the County of Kildare, a chunk of south Meath and a chunk of Westmeath are being added, and it will be all grouped under the heading of Kildare, although that substantial portion will not in fact be Kildare, but portion of two other counties. The only effect of that is effectively to disfranchise people who live in south Meath and people who live in Long-ford and Westmeath, because of the fact that those areas are not big enough, or not numerically strong enough, to ensure representation for the counties of which they are a natural part. They will be, as it were, just small lungs of Kildare. I think that is a most undesirable way of trying to create constituencies.
This was the then Leader of the Labour Party. Anybody trying to interpret the mind of the Labour Party with regard to this requirement would have been justified in assuming that that opinion—which was not contradicted by any other member of the Labour Party, but was in fact reinforced by other members who spoke—to the effect that this requirement of transferring people from one county to another in order to achieve mathematical accuracy of population per Deputy, but not voters to Deputies, was to the effect that this was disfranchising the people concerned. How could anybody be expected to think that, when a much more widespread operation is required in 1968, the Labour Party would look upon what they held to be disfranchising the people concerned in 1961 as now vindicating the democratic rights of the people in 1968.
I cannot see how anybody could be expected to assume that the minds of Opposition Deputies had changed so much in the meantime—it is quite clear that Deputy Norton in 1961 was speaking with a sense of outrage at the injustice that had, in fact, been perpetrated on these people—and that now the Opposition's approach based purely and simply on the principle that opposition means that one opposes and that, therefore, their task is to oppose everything put forward by the Government.
At the end of column 230, Deputy Norton said:
...It is obviously desirable that we should endeavour to get parliamentary representation to run side by side with local representation. Deputies know that in the course of their duties they have, inevitably, to make representations to local authorities when the business of their constituents requires them to do so. That is not such a difficult job if you have to make representations to the local authority for the area you represent, but if two or three other local authorities are added to the main local authority, a situation will arise which will become unmanageable, and especially unmanageable with regard to the virtues we were told 12 or 18 months ago the small single-member constituency had.
I do not blame the Government for introducing a Bill to deal with this situation. A Bill had to be introduced. That was inevitable after the decision of the High Court, but it is quite clear that the Constitution which imposes upon us the responsibilities now clearly defined by the Court, is a Constitution which should be amended...
That statement by the Leader of the Labour Party at the time could reasonably be taken as being the authoritative opinion of the Labour Party in 1961 in relation to the comparatively small amount of mutilation of county boundaries that had to take place then. Now, when it is quite clear that the amount of mutilation that will have to take place will be much more widespread and much more extensive, we suddenly find that what was disfranchising the people in 1961 is, in 1968, a vindication of their democratic rights. We are not proposing to go nearly as far as was suggested. We are not asking the Dáil or the people to agree to allowing either the Government or a commission to avoid the breaching of administrative boundaries, as is the position in most other democracies of which I know. We are not even asking that. We are suggesting simply that there should be a very small amount of scope given to avoid doing these anomalous and unjust things, where possible. We are asking for a very small amount of scope as compared with what is the position in other democracies.
Further on, at column 231, Deputy Norton said:
...I think the decision of the judge compelling us to butcher these constituencies in this way is not a satisfactory solution to the whole question of the delineation of constituencies.
Someone ought to have a new look at the situation created by the legal decision, created by the necessity of making Parliament work, making the constituencies work and making them sufficiently homogeneous to ensure that the system of Parliamentary representation so reached will continue to give satisfactory results locally to the electorate and satisfactory results from the standpoint of having the constituencies adequately represented in Parliament to ensure that their viewpoint will be put adequately and without impairment on the floor of this House.
The only criticism we could reasonably, I think, have expected of this proposal was that we were not going nearly far enough and that what we were asking the people to write into the Constitution would not be sufficient to safeguard the democratic rights of the people as a whole.
Deputy Norton concluded:
...If we pass this Bill in this most unsatisfactory position we shall leave large portions of the population virtually disfranchised. Some effort should be made to get out the dead timber in the Constitution in that respect and to give us, at least for the subsequent general election, a method of parliamentary general election which will conform to modern conditions of Parliamentary representation and independent thinking.
We were told on that occasion that the result of complying with the decision of the High Court was to leave large portions of the population virtually disfranchised. Now the Opposition want us to continue that position and have this virtual disfranchisement carried out on a much wider scale. Instead of what Deputy Norton described as conforming to modern conditions of Parliamentary representation and independent thinking, this new proposition is put forward by the Opposition that strict mathematical accuracy of the proportion of population per Deputy is the only consideration that matters—population per Deputy, mark you, not voters per Deputy.
Deputy Desmond also spoke at great length in respect of the situation in another part of the country. At column 250 he said:
Where do the people in West Waterford stand now? To whom will they send their inquiries? Is it to a person representing them who may live in Tipperary? Will they expect him to contact the local authority office in Waterford in order to get fair play for them?
Now, when this must happen on a much wider scale, it is considered of no importance.
At column 251 Deputy Desmond said:
It was amazing this evening to listen to some Fianna Fáil members bemoaning the terrible position of rural Ireland because of the decision of the High Court. I had hoped that in view of the decision of the High Court, the Taoiseach would move for an amendment of the Constitution, where necessary, to give protection to rural Ireland. Apparently, neither the Taoiseach nor the Minister was prepared to do that. There is no use in the backbenchers of Fianna Fáil now complaining that the people of rural Ireland are being robbed of their rights when, in actual fact, the only people who could restore those rights to them and improve on them, if they wished, were the Taoiseach, the Minister for Local Government, the Fianna Fáil Government and Party. They refused to do so.
Surely there is a clear demand from the Labour Party for something more than we are asking the people to do here? Surely there is a clear indication of the mind of the Labour Party that what was required by the Constitution, as interpreted by the High Court—I do not dispute the correctness of that interpretation—was an injustice on the people and a clear demand that the people should be given an opportunity of remedying a situation which allows such an injustice to be perpetrated on them? This must happen on a much wider scale now. We did not respond to the appeals to have a referendum to amend the Constitution immediately after the general election of 1961 because the scheme of constituencies had been established; the general election had been held on those constituencies and we were prepared to allow that situation to continue in the belief that it would continue for 12 years.
It did not seem urgent to change it because the situation had been established and presumably would continue for 12 years; and another general election, since then, was fought on the same scheme of constituencies. However, since then we have had published the census returns of 1966 and Deputy Dunne and other Deputies have drawn our attention to the fact that the scheme of constituencies at present does not comply with the requirements of the Constitution and that therefore there is a requirement on the Government to revise the constituencies again.
In face of the fact that what happened in 1961 will be something of no account compared with what must happen now, we have decided to respond to the demands of the Opposition and give the people an opportunity of amending the provision in the Constitution that requires this injustice to be carried on. Deputy T. Lynch also spoke on this matter in April, 1961.
Comment on this
At column 257 he is reported:
I am glad I voted against the Constitution. I never thought it was any good and the High Court has proved that it was no good. It was obvious to the Government what they could have done and they would not do it. They could have attempted to amend the Constitution. They attempted to amend it with their referendum in order to keep themselves in office.
He went on:
In Waterford, we have three members representing this butchered constituency. There is the whole of the Nire valley and that part of the west of Waterford, Ballyduff and down the Blackwater valley to Lismore, Cappoquin and Tallow, traditional Waterford places which have been turned over to County Tipperary. It is a scandalous state of affairs that this enormous slice of a constituency has been taken away.
Deputy Kyne also spoke on the same aspect of the 1961 revision of the constituencies. At column 269 he is reported:
The people of Lismore, Cappoquin, Tallow, Four-Mile-Water, Ballymacarbury, Villierstown, Aglish and Templemichael are as rural as the people in Donegal and they are to be deprived of their right to a Waterford Deputy. They are to be transferred to South Tipperary. Deputy Loughman or any other Deputy from South Tipperary will never be able to represent them. The natural alignment is with their own county.
Further on he said:
What will happen when these people from Tallow to within six miles of my own town, a distance of 30 miles, are transferred into South Tipperary? If a South Tipperary representative, whether he be Labour, Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil, wants to raise some matter in connection with county affairs or the health services, he will have to write to the County Manager in Dungarvan. If he wants to raise matters in connection with, say, the free milk scheme or the assisted footwear scheme, the South Tipperary Deputy will have no right to interfere. All he can do is write a letter. He is not likely to come down from Cashel, Clonmel or wherever he may be in Tipperary to attend a meeting of the county council in Dungarvan in order to help them out. I know the fate of isolated areas like that: they get a visit just prior to the election. But when these people were within the confines of their natural constituency of Waterford, they were taken care of.
Deputy Manley also spoke on that revision of the constituencies. At column 311, he is reported:
There is one particularly regrettable feature in the chopping up of some counties. We cannot complain on that score in Cork, but some counties have been ruthlessly chopped in order to get the necessary proportion. The county is the administrative unit so far as local authority goes. There is invariably a certain rivalry between counties. There is a certain clanishness in counties, to the extent very often that people in one county will not vote for someone from a neighbouring county or another county. That is a grave danger in this Bill. I would much prefer to cut down representation and leave the county as the unit. I would regard that as more practicable in the long run.
I think it can be said that this Bill is going some of the way to meeting the point of view expressed by all those Deputies. Therefore, the only criticism we might reasonably have expected was that we were not going nearly far enough to give reasonable scope to avoid perpetuating this type of injustice.
On that occasion also, Deputy Coburn is reported at column 313:
Coming from County Louth, I should like to assure the Minister that, whilst I sympathise with his position to a certain extent, the people in County Louth area affected, an area which will be put into County Monaghan, are very resentful of the intentions of this Bill.
"Very resentful," mind you, of what the present Opposition describe as vindicating their democratic rights. Deputy Coburn at that time interpreted the feeling of his constituents as a feeling of resentment because the Constitution required something like 3.3 Deputies to represent County Louth and there was not any way of providing 0.3 of a Deputy. County Monaghan was entitled to 2.7 Deputies and the only way it could be achieved was that people should be transferred from Louth to Monaghan. I think Deputy Coburn was accurate when he described the people of that part of Louth as being very resentful of the provisions of the Bill.
He continued:
Various opinions were expressed by both Fianna Fáil supporters and Fine Gael supporters. They all resent being put into a separate county, being detached from their existing native county of Louth and put into Monaghan.
Earlier this evening, Deputy Faulkner pointed out that County Louth was a constituency which had enjoyed all down the years since the foundation of this State its own natural boundaries. Admittedly, there were years ago two constituencies in that small county, North and South Louth, but, as a county, its boundaries were always respected. I think it is a very retrograde step for the Minister at this stage to tamper with our boundaries.
I do not know how there was a gain for democracy in what had to happen in Louth and Monaghan in 1961 because prior to that there were three Deputies elected for Monaghan and three for Louth. All that was achieved by this exercise in theoretical democracy was that the people in that area of Louth had to be taken out of the Louth constituency and had to be compelled to be represented by Deputies who were concerned with County Monaghan rather than—as I believe they desired themselves—to continue to vote for Deputies and be represented by Deputies who were concerned with the County of Louth.
Now, what Deputy Donegan wants is that this position should continue. This requirement in the Constitution will probably require, or may probably result in this area of County Louth being no longer required to top up the constituency of Monaghan or the joint constituency of Cavan-Monaghan as will probably be the ultimate result. They may be returned to Louth and the position will be that from which we started in 1961—that there will be sufficient people in Louth to be represented by more than three Deputies: that now there will be 3.4 Deputies required instead of 3.3 Deputies, and I do not know whether any Deputy opposite can put forward a way in which 0.4 of a Deputy extra can be allocated to Louth.
We cannot discover any way of doing that so that what will be required is that the people who were transferred to County Monaghan in 1961 and who were, as Deputy Coburn and Deputy Faulkner agreed, resentful of that transfer but who have, I suppose, in the meantime become to a certain extent acclimatised to the transfer must now come back. Possibly they will welcome the change back to their own county of Louth but that must be compensated for, and another block of County Louth people must be expelled from the county in order to make up for that. Otherwise they would be deprived of their democratic right. It would take fractionally more people in County Louth to be represented by a Deputy than it would take in some other constituencies, and in order to vindicate those people's democratic right, Deputy Donegan is demanding that these people should be expelled from Louth and transferred to County Meath or some other place.
Comment on this
Which of them is he going to get rid of?
Comment on this
He is demanding that the present situation which requires that the whole of the people of Louth will not vote for candidates going forward to represent the county of Louth must continue.
Comment on this
As soon as the Minister is finished with that particularly stupid brief, I shall deal with that.
Comment on this
The boundaries of County Louth must be breached if this amendment is not carried both by the Dáil and by the people. The constitutional position at present is that the population of County Louth is too many for three seats and too few for four seats.
Admittedly there is at least one other way—possibly there are a number of other ways—in which this could be dealt with, but there is no way in which Louth can be kept as a complete county. It could be dealt with by transferring part of County Meath——
Comment on this
Do that please. It would be a nice cushy one for me.
Comment on this
——to make it a four-seat constituency. One of those two things must happen.
Deputy Coburn went on to say:
I think it is fraught with great danger in so far as there will be much confusion. More serious still is the danger that most people may not vote in future elections to the same extent when they discover that they will not have the chance to vote for a county man. They will be expected to vote for a man who is not one of their own.
These were the opinions that were expressed by Opposition Deputies on the occasion of the revision of constituencies that had to be carried out in 1961 to take cognisance of the fact that the High Court had decided that the revision of constituencies of 1959, which was unanimously accepted by this House, was in contravention of the constitutional requirements. It was only when it became obvious that this must happen on a much wider scale, affecting practically every county and every constituency in the country, when we found that this was imminent that the Government decided to comply with the request of the two Opposition Parties and moved to have the Constitution amended in a very slight way in order to give some scope to avoid this type of anomaly and this type of injustice, to avoid what was described as butchery and as savage dismemberment by members of the Opposition in 1961.
Comment on this
The only possible criticism we could have expected was that our proposals in this regard were far too modest and that they would not be sufficient to avoid this type of injustice.
The question of what is the position in other countries has been raised here. In the United Kingdom, there was a tolerance provided for for a number of years of 25 per cent above or 25 per cent below the national average per member, but this was abandoned as being too restrictive, as not giving sufficient scope for the avoidance of the type of injustice we have been discussing here. I think that, in view of the fact that the Opposition are complaining about this terrible injustice of allowing a maximum deviation of one-sixth in clearly defined circumstances, it is desirable to give some examples of the position in Britain. I propose to compare like with like, not to compare a constituency in the Highlands of Scotland with a constituency in the city of London.
First of all, I should like to give an example of the difference between two London boroughs. In the constituency of Wandsworth-Putney, the electorate is 69,870, whereas in Bermondsey it is 33,811, that is, a difference of 207 per cent between one London borough and another. In other boroughs outside of the city of London, we have Ports-mouth-Langstone with 96,166 and Birmingham-Ladywood with 25,294, a difference of 380 per cent. In regard to English counties the constituency of Billericay (Essex) had an electorate of 102,198, whereas in Leominster (Herefordshire) the figure is 38,880, which is a difference of 263 per cent. With regard to Welsh boroughs, the figure for Newport is 68,131 and the figure for Rhonnda West is 31,189, a difference of 218 per cent. With regard to Welsh counties, in Monmouth, the figure is 64,356 and in Merioneth, the figure is 25,395 which is a difference of 253 per cent. With regard to Scottish burghs, the constituency of Glasgow Cathcart has a figure of 66,266 while Kelvingrove has 24,483, a difference of 271 per cent. In Scottish counties, Dunbartonshire East has 79,031 while the Western Isles have 22,940, a difference of 345 per cent.
In Australia, a tolerance of 20 per cent above or below the number of electors per member is allowed in elections to the House of Representatives, that is, electors, not population as it is here. In Western Germany, the tolerance allowed is 33? per cent of the number of electors. In Canada, a tolerance of 25 per cent above or below their population per member in each province is allowed in determining constituencies for the purpose of elections to the House of Commons. In France, there are deviations from minus 60 per cent to plus 46 per cent of the national average. Compared with all these countries, we are only asking for a maximum deviation of one-sixth, a maximum which can only be exercised in the circumstances specified in the Bill and which would obviously not be possible to apply to the country as a whole, even if the Government desired to do so.
Now, I think it is obvious from the debate that Opposition Deputies have not, in fact, considered the implications of what must happen if this amendment to the Constitution we are proposing is not adopted. I think that is quite obvious. Despite the fact that they had all-night sessions and despite the fact that apparently it caused a considerable amount of wrangling to arrive at the decision, the decision appears to have been quite clearly based on the fact that "Fianna Fáil proposed this; we are the Opposition and we must oppose it."
Comment on this
There were two candidates for Taoiseach. A decision was come to and as a result of that decision we and the Taoiseach accomplished something which has never been accomplished before—we won six by-elections out of seven.
Comment on this
You had to take No. 2 and No. 3 down in Limerick the other day. You had to take this despite the fact that that is what Fianna Fáil want to do away with.
Comment on this
The maximum effort of a Coalition was used in Limerick. Despite the fact that the main Opposition Party said so much about this, almost 20 per cent did not transfer their votes at all and 16 per cent transferred them to Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Yes. As soon as all this has died down, we will get back to the position, as it was in Cork. where at least 40 per cent of the Fine Gael votes are not transferable and I would say a small percentage transferable to us.
Comment on this
I know Deputy Donegan did not want to interrupt me but he did. As I said, it is quite obvious that the Opposition Deputies have not looked into what must happen now if this amendment is not passed. Although it might be justifiable for me to leave them in their ignorance, I think in all the circumstances it is desirable that they should have some idea of what must result if the perverse action of the Opposition to oppose this amendment should by any chance happen to be successful.
Comment on this
Seeing that your statement is so long-winded, will you tell us why you did not appeal to the Supreme Court?
Comment on this
I have no reason whatever to question the decision of the High Court. I have no reason to believe that the learned judge who gave this decision——
Comment on this
I have no reason to believe that the learned judge who at the behest of the Fine Gael Party interpreted——
Comment on this
Surely it is not right for the Minister to say that a judge decided a case at the behest of a political Party? Surely it is not proper to allow the Minister to say that a High Court judge decided a case at the behest of the Fine Gael Party?
Comment on this
It was the learned judge, Mr. Budd, who made that decision. It was the Fine Gael Party who used the subterfuge of Dr. O'Donovan to have this matter decided.
Comment on this
Dr. O'Donovan obtained that decision and that action was taken at the request of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
They objected to the result of it later when the result became apparent. Deputy Murphy wants to know why we did not appeal to the Supreme Court. I would like to point out that the demand of the Opposition Parties at the time, and particularly the Labour Party, was not for an appeal to the Supreme Court but for an appeal to the people. The demand was that the Constitution should be amended and that the Government were lacking in their duty to justice and to the people of the country in not going for an amendment of the Constitution straight away.
Comment on this
Now we are in fact complying with the demand of the two Opposition Parties that was made here in 1961. We are only partially doing so, I agree, because we have proposed this rather severe restriction of maximum deviation of one-sixth. That will not allow us as a Government or will not allow the commission, if it is a commission that will be doing it, to avoid this type of injustice that so enraged members of the Opposition in 1961. I fully agree that those things which had to happen were substantial injustices to the people concerned.
I agree there was an injustice on the people of Louth to transfer them to Monaghan, that there was an injustice on the people of Waterford to transfer them to South Tipperary, that there was an injustice on the people of Meath and Westmeath to transfer them to Kildare, on the people of Wexford to transfer them to Carlow-Kilkenny, on Roscommon to transfer them to Mayo and the dismemberment of County Leitrim was a substantial injustice. It is because this will have to be done all over the country on this occasion that we are now complying with the request of the Opposition in 1961 in giving the people an opportunity to amend the Constitution so as to ensure that this injustice will not have to be done, at least there will be a certain amount of scope in avoiding carrying out injustice such as this in the future.
As I said, I think I should make the Opposition aware of the type of thing that will have to be done if this proposal is not adopted. I do not think there is any better place to start than that part of the country towards which this is alleged to be directed, that is, the west of Ireland. First of all, I think I should deal with the situation in Donegal.
Comment on this
Deputies on the opposite side of the House have not taken the trouble to examine the figures which were given to them here.
Comment on this
There is misrepresentation in this House. The Chair usually replies, to some Members in any case.
Comment on this
They just know they are opposing something that has been proposed by Fianna Fáil and that is the function of the Opposition. I think it is desirable that if Deputy Murphy intends to vote against this, he should have some idea of what he is voting for, rather than that he should come in here as his colleagues did in 1961, and then start moaning about the death verdict of rural Ireland and the injustice being done of part of one county being transferred to another county with which they have no affinity, such as the transfer of a portion of West Cork to the county of Kerry, which is something that would be very likely to happen if this amendment is not enacted by the people.
In the constituency of North-East Donegal, the population, according to the 1966 census which is the relevant figure in so far as the Constitution at present is concerned, is 55,649 and the number of voters on the register is 34,781. We have interpreted Judge Budd's decision as meaning that there can be a deviation of five per cent in the delineation.
Comment on this
You have interpreted this as the important point. That is where your whole case falls down.
Comment on this
A revision based on that has been found to be in accordance with the Constitution by the Supreme Court.
Comment on this
Despite the fact that Deputy Ryan says this is a wrong interpretation, I think the fact that constituencies based on that interpretation have been found to be constitutional makes that a reasonable assessment. On that basis the minimum population that can justify three seats is 57,084 and North-East Donegal has a population, as I said, of 55,649, so that on the basis of the present Constitution that constituency must be revised. The Opposition have been maintaining that their opposition to this proposed amendment to the Constitution is based on their concern to ensure that a vote in every part of the country will have exactly the same effect if it is cast only in electing a Deputy as a vote cast in any other part of the country When we examine the position with regard to North-East Donegal, we find that the national average of voters per Deputy is 11,899 and that on the basis of the same percentage deviation from the national average, a voting strength of 33,912 would justify the retention of the three seats. In this constituency of North-East Donegal, there is more than that number of voters. There are 34,781, so that if the principle is to be that a vote should have the same value in all parts of the country, there is no need to interfere with the constituency of North-East Donegal. It is purely on the basis of equating new-born babies, whether they belong to the particular constituency or not, with adult voters that the requirement of changing that constituency arises.
In regard to South-West Donegal, the population in accordance with the 1966 Census is 52,900, which is substantially below the minimum of 57,084 which is required for three seats, but the number of voters on the register in 1967-68 is 35,837. That is substantially above the minimum number required for three seats which should be 33,912. According to the interpretation of the Constitution established by the High Court, South-West Donegal is 4,184 short of the population for three seats but it is almost 2,000 in excess of the number of voters required for three seats.
If representation is to be based on the theory that, irrespective of considerations such as administrative boundaries and physical features, a vote should have the same effect in electing a Deputy in any part of the country, there is no change required in Donegal. In the county the population is 108,549 and the number of voters on the register is 70,618. The minimum population required for six seats is 114,168. The number of voters required is 67,824 so that obviously based on voters per Deputy the county of Dongal is entitled to six seats. In the present position, County Donegal is 5,619 short of the population required for six seats and is 3,409 in excess of the maximum population for five seats. To comply with the present constitutional requirements, the county of Donegal as a whole must be adjusted by transferring at least 5,619 people from Leitrim and possibly Sligo to County Donegal, and leaving it a six-seat constituency or two three-seat constituencies. Otherwise, 3,409 of the population of Donegal must be transferred out of the county to another constituency which would then be a constituency comprising three counties, Sligo, Leitrim and Donegal and the remainder of Donegal would be left as a single five-seat constituency.
Deputy Harte is apparently one of the Opposition Deputies who did make some kind of superficial study in his area. I quote from the Dáil Debates of 3rd April, 1968, volume 233, column No.1722. He said:
We have at the present time two constituencies, each sending three Deputies to the House, and if common sense is to be observed and if the Constitution is to be honoured, it should be one constituency sending back five Deputies. This will be conceded by anybody with limited intelligence who devotes any time to the political scene in Donegal.
I have shown that on the basis of the number of voters in Donegal the position is that there is an excess of voters in the county over and above what is required to maintain its present representation, and Deputy Harte who has apparently looked into the figures demands that County Donegal should be a single constituency returning five Deputies to the Dáil instead of the present six, although, if he had examined the figures in any way closely, he would have appreciated that even that cannot be done; that it is also necessary, in order that that can be done, to transfer at least 3,409 of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents out of Donegal and into the constituency of Sligo-Leitrim and this, of course, is not required by any democratic principle, either real or imaginary, because the number of voters per Deputy in Donegal as it exists at present is not out of line with the national average of voters per Deputy.
I cannot help wondering why it is that Deputy Harte is so anxious, first of all, to deprive Donegal of one of its representatives and, secondly, to maintain a situation which, as he says, "if common sense is to be observed", requires the transference of a substantial number of his colleague Deputy O'Donnell's constituents out of the constituency and into another constituency. I wonder is it that there are actually more candidates in the Fine Gael Party for transference to Dublin constituencies than those we know of already. It is fairly widely accepted, I think, that Deputy Lindsay has decided to contest a constituency in the Dublin area——
Comment on this
——and also the two Deputies O'Higgins. I wonder if Deputy O'Donnell is also thinking of embarking on this trek to Dublin. However, there is no reason why this change should have to be made. County Donegal, on the basis of voters, is fully entitled to its present representation.
As you can see, this unnecessary mutilation of Donegal, if this amendment is not carried, will affect the position in the constituency of Sligo/ Leitrim and the consequential changes in Sligo/Leitrim will affect other Connacht counties right down to Clare. Obviously, the situation in Clare itself will affect the situation in Galway.
It might be more appropriate for me to go to the other extremity of that area in order to demonstrate exactly what must happen now if the Opposition have their way and if this position is to continue and also to demonstrate that a lot of what must happen is not required even by this theory that, irrespective of such considerations as natural features and administrative boundaries, you must have mathematical accuracy of representation in every constituency.
In County Clare, the position is that the population, according to the 1966 Census, is 73,597. The minimum number of population required for four seats in accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution is 76,112. The number of voters, according to the Register of 1967-68, is 48,182 and the minimum number of voters required for four seats is 45,216. So that, on the basis of voters, the position in Clare is that the proportion of voters per Deputy is actually above the national average but the present Constitution requires that Clare cannot retain its present representation because it is short on the grounds of population.
I must say that I can understand the Fine Gael Party's desire to deprive County Clare of its due representation. I can understand that all right. It is not based on any democratic principle. It is based on the fact that this happens to be an area that gives Fianna Fáil a substantial majority. The result of this is that either there must be a substantial transfer of population from County Clare, probably to Galway, and the county's representation reduced to three or else there must be a substantial transfer of population from County Galway and the representation left at four; but this is not necessitated by the requirement that a vote in that area should have the same power with regard to electing a Deputy as a vote has in other parts of the country because the number of voters per Deputy in Clare is, in fact, over the national average.
These two adjustments that would be required at the northern and southern ends of the Province of Connacht are unjustifiable because of the fact that both Donegal and Clare are fully entitled to their present representation on the basis of the number of voters in these constituencies; but, because of these adjustments that must take place at the southern and northern ends of the Province of Connacht, the situation in the actual Province of Connacht itself will be made even worse than it would otherwise be, and as I have said, unjustifiably so.
Take the present constituency of Sligo-Leitrim. The population, according to the 1966 Census, is 67,892 and the number of voters, according to the 1967-68 Register, is 42,863. That means that that constituency as it stands, in accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution, is 8,220 short of the minimum population required for its present four seats and, as I have shown, if this amendment is not made, Sligo-Leitrim must be involved in an adjustment with Donegal. One possibility is—and it may be a probability—that some of the population of this constituency will have to be transferred to Donegal and the number must be at least 5,619. Even if it was possible to transfer just the exact number that would be required, this would leave Sligo-Leitrim requiring at least 13,839. The population of the part of Leitrim that is at present attached to Roscommon is 13,943, but in fact, it would not be possible to deal with the situation by transferring all of those people from the present constituency of Roscommon to the new constituency of Sligo-Leitrim because Roscommon would still require some Leitrim population in order to retain three seats. Therefore, it seems to me that the more likely thing to happen would be that Sligo-Leitrim would be reduced to three seats and, of course, it would be a completely different constituency from what it is at present because portion of it would probably have gone into Donegal.
The resulting position as far as County Leitrim is concerned is fairly obvious: that the county as a county, as far as Dáil representation is concerned, would completely disappear because now part of it would be with Donegal, part with Sligo and part with Roscommon and possibly there might have to be another part of it tacked on to Cavan. When this happened on a much smaller scale in 1961 the Opposition, as far as I could see, were unanimous in describing it as "butchery." as a "savage dismemberment" and as disfranchising the people concerned and certainly as an injustice to the people and to their public representatives and as an infringement of democracy. It is because we in the Government accept that view that we have decided to give the people the opportunity of allowing a reasonable amount of scope in avoiding that kind of injustice.
The next county is the county of Roscommon which, as I said already, has part of County Leitrim tacked on to it. In addition to that, the ridiculous things that have to be done to comply with the present requirements necessitated in 1961 that part of Roscommon had to be added on to Mayo in order to comply with this requirement. The population of the present constituency of Roscommon is 67,605. It has four seats. At present the minimum population required for four seats is 76,112. Obviously, as I said, this part of the present county of Leitrim tacked on to Roscommon must be returned to the constituency of Sligo-Leitrim, even to retain three seats in that constituency.
There are at present 2,566 Roscommon people attached to Mayo and 3,943 Leitrim people attached to Roscommon. It is obvious if the proposed change is not made, the biggest part of this Leitrim population must be returned to the constituency of Sligo-Leitrim. Roscommon county itself has a population of 56,228 and, as the minimum required for three seats is 57,084, Roscommon county even if it gets back the population at present attached to Mayo will still require some area of County Leitrim to justify three seats.
With regard to the County Mayo, the total population of the county is 115,547. The number of voters on the 1967-68 register is 71,316. It is obvious if this proposed change is not made, Mayo must lose a seat. In fact, I think it is probably likely it will have to lose a seat whether the change is made or not. Because of the situation arising unnecessarily in Donegal, it may well be that the only way of dealing with the Sligo-Leitrim-Roscommon situation will be that some of the population in Mayo will have to be transferred to one of those constituencies. If we were to try to arrange that the whole of the Province of Connacht would retain its maximum entitlement under the present Constitution of 20 seats as against the present 23 seats, it would be necessary to deal in a very detailed way with the division of population per constituency. In fact, Mayo would also very probably have to be adjusted at the other end of the county with County Galway.
I have mentioned that Galway would also be affected by the situation that unnecessarily arises in Clare. The county of Galway as a whole at present has eight seats. If the proposed change in the Constitution is not made, it is short of the minimum population for this number of seats. The total population of County Galway is 148,340 while the minimum population required for eight seats is 152,224. Obviously, if this change is not made, there will have to be this adjustment between Galway and Clare and probably between Galway and Mayo as well.
All this type of thing was found to be very objectionable by the Opposition Parties in 1961. But now, when it must happen on a much wider scale, apparently it is found not to be objectionable at all. It has been alleged that in putting forward this proposed amendment of the Constitution the Government are interested in retaining for the west of Ireland representation to which it is not entitled on the basis of equality of the effect of a vote in different parts of the country. I think it would be appropriate to examine the position in this western area as a whole—Donegal, Clare and the province of Connacht—and to compare it with the situation in the area which it is being alleged is being victimised by this proposal, that is, the Dublin area.
The total population of the province of Connacht is 401,950. As I said the population of Donegal is 108,549 and the population of Clare is 73,597, so that the total population of this area is 584,096. In accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution the maximum representation that could be accorded for this area, which has 33 seats at present, is 30 seats, that is, a reduction of three. But the number of voters in this area is 365,740 and on the basis of the national average of voters per Deputy instead of this artificial and meaningless requirement of the average of population per Deputy, this area would be entitled to 32 seats and not 30. So that the most that even the most rigid application of this alleged principle would require would be a reduction of one seat in that area rather than three seats.
The Opposition campaign against this amendment of the Constitution means in fact that they are insisting on this area losing three seats instead of the maximum of one that is required even on the basis of the most rigid application of this so-called democratic principle which in fact, as the Opposition Deputies pointed out so forcefully in 1961, is the negation of democracy rather than what it is represented to be. As I pointed out, on this fairer basis, Donegal and Clare need not lose a seat at all and there would be a total reduction of one seat in the Province of Connacht. It would not be necessary at least to breach the provincial boundaries at the northern and southern extremity of the province. It must be quite clear that that is probably just exactly what would happen if the amendment we propose were carried. Obviously by adhering to the guidelines laid down in the Bill, it would not be possible to exercise a maximum deviation below the national average in all rural parts of the country and a maximum deviation above the national average in the urban areas as is being alleged. That could be challenged in the courts and such an attempt would be held to be unconstitutional.
So the most that will result from what is proposed in this Bill is that a vote in the western areas will have the same effect in electing a Deputy as it would have in urban areas. What we propose will do no more than enable this amount of justice to be done to the people in the western areas. As I say, that would be much nearer to this alleged principle of one man, one vote. For some reason or another the Opposition have apparently deliberately decided to try to deprive the west of Ireland of representation to which it is entitled even on the basis of the most rigid interpretation of any democratic principle.
It is alleged that for some reason the Government artificially want to maintain the representation of the western areas. Opposition Deputies have been putting forward the allegation that this is because it is there that Fianna Fáil get their majority, and that an attempt is being made to victimise the Dublin areas because we have a minority there. In fact, that is not the position at all. In the province of Connacht, we have a majority of only one, whereas in the Dublin city and county area, we have a majority of two. It is alleged that this proposal will victimise the people of Dublin city and county, so I think the next most appropriate area for us to examine would be the Dublin area and compare it with the western area which must lose three seats if the Opposition succeed in their attempt to retain the present position.
According to the 1966 census, Dublin city and county have a population of 795,047 people. The number of voters is 446,781. On the basis of the present Constitution this area must get at least 38 seats instead of the present 34 seats. As I have shown, the western area must be reduced from 33 seats to 30. This means that if the proposed change is not made there must be an increase of at least four seats in the Dublin area, but on the basis of the national average of voters as distinct from the total population, which includes children, whether at home, in institutions or hospitals or otherwise, the minimum number of seats is 36, not 38. So, the present constitutional provision requires that there should be two more seats than are justified by even the most rigid interpretation of this alleged principle of one man, one vote in this area, and it requires that there be a reduction of two more in the western area than would be required by the same rigid interpretation of this so-called principle.
Even if it were possible to exercise the maximum deviation of one-sixth of the national average of the population over the whole of the Dublin area there would have to be at least 35 seats allocated to the area. Even if this were possible it would be at least nearer to the number of 36 which would be based on the strict application of the principle of equality of the effect of a vote in all parts of the country.
As I have pointed out, because of the lines laid down to guide the exercise of this deviation of one-sixth above or below the national average, obviously it would not be possible to operate that uniformly throughout the country as a whole. It is extremely unlikely that it would be possible to apply that maximum figure over the whole of the Dublin area. With at least eight or nine different constituencies in the Dublin area as a whole it would not be practicable to arrange them in such a way as to have the maximum number per Deputy in each. Even if it were possible to do that——
Comment on this
——it would be necessary to have a minimum population per Deputy in practically every constituency in the rural parts of the country, so that this cannot happen. If this amendment which we propose is passed it will certainly do no more than reduce the increase in the number of Deputies to be elected in the Dublin area to two instead of four. That would be the case and if the amendment is not passed this is exactly what would be required if the representation were to be based on voters rather than on total population. In other words, both as regards the western area which it is alleged we are attempting to favour, and which the Opposition obviously are trying to deprive of its due representation, and as regards the Dublin area which it is being alleged that we are attempting to victimise, it is obvious that this amendment would in fact result at most in doing bare justice to both of those areas.
There is no reason whatever for the deliberate and cold-blooded attempt made by the Opposition Parties—both of them—to divide the people on the basis of the urban population versus the rural population. What we propose will, in fact, result in a much closer approximation to equating the value of votes in various parts of the country than the present position. There must be some reason why the Opposition Parties have departed from the stand they took in 1961 and decided instead to try to maintain a position——
Comment on this
Although this information is available Deputy Belton has not looked at it. Deputy Belton thinks his job here is to oppose everything put forward by Fianna Fáil irrespective of its rights or wrongs. It is because Deputy Belton and his colleagues have refused to investigate the position for themselves that I am making them aware of what the position will be.
Comment on this
You do not want to know the facts, and you do not want the people to know the facts. I want to ensure that the facts will be available in the printed Official Report of the Dáil Debates. Let me say that we also intend to ensure that the people will know the facts. We intend to ensure that the people of Donegal will know that for some reason or other Deputy Harte wants to export at least 3,500 of Deputy O'Donnell's constituents out of Deputy O'Donnell's constituency and reduce the representation of Donegal to five, and that this is completely unnecessary because, on the basis of voters, Donegal is fully entitled to its present number of Deputies.
I know that you would like to have this decided before the people know these things. I can assure you that the people will know these things before they vote. I am making sure now that Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy P. Belton and their colleagues will also have this information available to them so that they cannot plead ignorance. I have also made sure that they will know the opinions their Parties expressed in 1961 about the injustice of the present Constitutional requirements.
Comment on this
We will tell you what he said. We have it here. The Minister is filibustering. He is just trying to put in time.
Comment on this
Is the Minister accepting that the composition of the present Dáil is unconstitutional seeing that it was elected in 1965?
Comment on this
It is the Minister's job, as a Minister of State, to reply to that question—not Deputy Dunne's job.
Comment on this
I do not have to assert it at all. Deputy Dunne has been maintaining that that is the position. He pointed to the fact that the constituency he represents would be entitled, in accordance with the present Constitutional requirements, to seven seats instead of five. He pointed to the provision of the Constitution which requires that the proportion of population per Deputy shall at any time be the same, as far as it is practical, in every constituency. He has pointed to the fact that that is not the position at present and deduced from that that there is now a legal requirement on the Government to revise the constituencies so as to bring them into conformity with the present requirements of the Constitution. I am not a Constitutional lawyer but I cannot dispute the figures Deputy Dunne has produced from the Census of Population. It is a fact that only 14 of the 38 constituencies at present conform to the requirements of the Constitution as interpreted by the High Court.
Comment on this
Is it the position that this Dáil is unconstitutional? Are we to assume from the Minister's statement that Deputy Dunne's statements are infallible when he speaks of constitutional requirements or is the Minister handing over to Deputy Dunne?
Comment on this
I should certainly hesitate to say that Deputy Dunne's statements are infallible. I do not think anybody could ever accuse me of saying that. However, I say that the figures on which you are required by the Constitution to base the scheme of constituencies are the figures produced by the preceding Census of Population and that Deputy Dunne has accurately read the figures for his constituency from the Census of Population. That is all I said.
I have admitted that, in present circumstances, there are only 14 constituencies that do conform to the constitutional requirements, that is, on the basis of the interpretation we put on the decision of the Judge of the High Court which, according to the Opposition, is far too liberal an interpretation. If we take Deputy Ryan's interpretation, there is probably no constituency at all in the whole country that complies with the requirements of the Constitution and a full revision would be required. In fact, as we know, the carrying-out of a revision, involving, as it does, transfers of population from one constituency to another, means that the 14 constituencies, within the most liberal interpretation of the High Court's decision, could not be left undisturbed either.
The next constituency I should like to deal with is that of Cavan. According to the 1966 census, the population of Cavan is 54,022. The minimum population required for three seats, in accordance with the most liberal interpretation of the High Court's decision, is 57,084. According to the 1967-68 Register, the number of voters in Cavan is 34,301. The minimum number of voters, applying the same standard, required for three seats is 33,912. Therefore, in accordance with the High Court's decision, the population of Cavan is too low for three seats and therefore Cavan must be dealt with in a manner similar to the way other constituencies and other counties had to be dealt with in 1961.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister is misquoting the judgment. The judgment said that 17 per cent was too high. It said absolutely nothing between 17 and four per cent.
Comment on this
The judge indicated that a deviation of 1,000 above or below would be acceptable. The revision of constituencies, arising out of that 1961 decision, was based on the interpretation that a deviation of 1,000, which is five per cent, was acceptable and was held to be constitutional. It is on that that I am basing it. If we apply the same standards to voters then the county and constituency of Cavan— which coincide but which will not, if Deputy Fitzpatrick has his way, coincide in future—has sufficient voters for three seats because there are 34,000 odd voters whereas the minimum required is 33,912. I have shown then that this rigid application of their interpretation of the principle of "one-man one-vote"—which is something completely different from what the Opposition pretend—does not require the integrity of Cavan to be breached in any way. It does not require any mutilation of the boundaries of the constituency. It does not require butchering or savage dismemberment. It does not require the disfranchisement or dismemberment of part of the population of Cavan or part of the population of Leitrim or Monaghan in order to do this.
But Deputy Fitzpatrick, because he interprets it to be his duty, as a member of the Opposition, to oppose everything put forward by Fianna Fáil, is insisting on having the constituency of Cavan unnecessarily disrupted purely and simply because Fianna Fáil are proposing that there should be a certain minimum——
Comment on this
——amount of scope available either to the Government or a commission to avoid doing such unnecessary and unjust things as interfering with the County of Cavan. As reported at column 1546 of the Official Report, volume 233, No. 11, he said:
I conclude on the note on which I started and that is that the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is an attack on the fundamental principle of one man, one vote...
Although I have shown that there are sufficient voters in the County of Cavan to justify its present representation of three seats, Deputy Fitzpatrick, for the perverse reason that he wants to oppose Fianna Fáil, wants to insist that Cavan will not retain its present representation but that it would either be combined with County Monaghan to form a five-seat constituency or that it will be topped up by an addition from County Leitrim or County Longford or from some other county or else that Cavan itself will be utilised for this purpose of topping up a constituency here and a constituency there or a constituency somewhere else.
Comment on this
The Deputy wants to insist that this be done. I am pointing out that what we are asking for is an amendment of the Constitution so that it will not be necessary to do that——
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick wants to insist that Cavan will suffer the same type of butchery, the same type of savage dismemberment that we were told that Longford, Westmeath, Meath, Waterford, Wexford, Mayo, Louth, Roscommon and Leitrim suffered in 1961.
Comment on this
Westmeath is a county on its own; I did not say "the constituency of Westmeath"; I said Longford-Westmeath.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am asking the Minister to say when Westmeath was a constituency on its own.
Comment on this
Let the Deputy find that out for himself. I am not interested because I am not saying it was a constituency but I am saying that Westmeath had to be butchered in this way to comply with this ridiculous requirement of the Constitution. We are asking for a certain amount of scope to avoid that sort of thing, to avoid disrupting Cavan unnecessarily and Deputy Fitzpatrick refuses to give it. I have pointed out that the amount of scope we are seeking is much less than is already available in every other democracy that I know of.
In dealing with Cavan I referred to the situation in Monaghan. In the constituency of Monaghan there are at present 53,325 people according to the 1966 census but 7,593 of them are resident in the County of Louth. The minimum population requirement, in accordance with our interpretation of the High Court decision for three seats, is, as I said, 57,084. Obviously, then there must be an adjustment in the County of Monaghan. The population of the county, as distinct from the constituency, is 45,732. It will be immediately apparent to Deputy Fitzpatrick that if the population of Cavan and Monaghan are added together there will be sufficient for a five-seat constituency and therefore there will be no longer any justification for the retention of the 7,593 people from County Louth in a different province.
Comment on this
Perhaps you would: but this is only one possibility. Perhaps you would gain a seat and perhaps that is the only consideration that operates in the Deputy's mind.
Comment on this
That is the only reason operating in Deputy Belton's mind but before this is decided Deputy Fitzpatrick will have to explain to his constituents why he wants this to happen although there are sufficient voters in County Cavan to justify its retaining its integrity as a separate county and electing its own Deputies to the Dáil.
Comment on this
When all the Deputies opposite know exactly what they are doing we shall hold it and when we make sure that the people of the country know what Deputy Fitzpatrick, Deputy Harte and the other Deputies are doing also.
Comment on this
Discussion of the position arising in Monaghan naturally leads us to County Louth which was described by a Fine Gael Deputy as having a large portion of its population disfranchised by the transfer of this portion of the population to Monaghan and which must now be further disturbed. What may possibly happen if Cavan and Monaghan are combined to form a five-seat constituency is that the 7,593 people at present in Monaghan may return to County Louth but then we shall be back where we started in Louth because that would leave the total population of Louth——
Comment on this
On a point of order—in the course of the Minister's statement over the past two hours he has again and again repeated himself and I think that under Standing Orders repetition is not allowed. In this case I think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle should rule on this question which I have put to him.
Comment on this
I think Deputy Donegan is just as much entitled to have this information about what he is doing as Deputy Fitzpatrick is.
Comment on this
For the Deputy's information the Minister is dealing with this constituency by constituency.
Comment on this
Not alone have I not dealt with County Louth at all but I have not dealt with Leinster. I am only starting on Leinster now. I have dealt only with part of the province of Munster——
Comment on this
The Minister is using up time while members of the Government are at a reception in Dublin Castle. He is filibustering.
Comment on this
What annoys Deputy Murphy is that I am going in the wrong direction and that it will take me so long to get to West Cork. He may have to wait some time before he can hear about West Cork, particularly in view of the interruptions——
Comment on this
Members of the Government are attending a reception in Dublin Castle and the Minister for Local Government——
Comment on this
In reply to Parliamentary questions by Deputy Gerard Collins I supplied the figures which would enable Deputies to find these things out for themselves.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Then it is absolutely wasting time since the Minister admits it is already on record.
Comment on this
If Opposition Deputies were not so lazy and so unconcerned with what they do here in the Dáil they would have found all this out for themselves but they have not done so.
Comment on this
Opposition Deputies lead very simple lives. All they have to decide in regard to any measure coming before the House, whether it is a question of putting drunken drivers off the road——
Comment on this
The less said about putting drunken drivers off the road by the Minister the better. He should keep quiet about that. There were half a dozen of them at the count the other day, the principal people there, who were allowed out scott free and they had to come to Limerick and work for Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Opposition Deputies have a very simple existence. Whether the proposal is to try to protect the public from people driving cars while under the influence of alcohol, or whether it is to provide a more rational system of election, all the Opposition have to ask is: "Is it proposed by Fianna Fáil? If so, we oppose it." Therefore, they do not take the trouble to examine the position and find out exactly what they are trying to ensure must happen. If they did they would know that what they protested about vehemently in 1961 will be as nothing compared to the injustice, butchery, savage dismemberment of constituencies and disfranchisement of the people that must occur if this amendment is not passed.
Comment on this
I have confined myself to being purely factual in regard to these constituencies. I have not attempted to forecast what would be the result for the different Parties, but if Deputy Belton insists that I go back over all this and give my ideas as to what would be the result for different Parties, I can do it. I would have County Louth dealt with by now only for Deputy Belton. I do not think that the question as to what would be the result of one system or another for the different political Parties is relevant, but I can appreciate it is the only thing that comes into Deputy Belton's mind. That does not say that I should waste the time of the House by making forecasts as to what would happen——
Comment on this
I admit that a lot of people have been saying that these proposals were the last hope of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
It will take considerably more than this to rescue Fine Gael, or is it Cumann na nGeadheal?
Comment on this
Fine Gael policy is returning to the old discredited Cumann na nGaedheal policy. Are they going to revert to the name as well? Are they going to respond to the urgings of the tigers in the tank or the lions or whatever the inhabitants of the Fine Gael jungle are, to change the name of the Party?
Comment on this
In addition to going back to the discredited Cumann na nGaedheal policy, will they go back to the name? As I pointed out, in 1961 it was discovered that this huge county of Louth had too high a population for three seats and too low a population for four seats. Therefore, in the interests of democracy, according to the Opposition now in 1968, a substantial proportion of the population of County Louth had to be transferred to the constituency of County Monaghan.
Comment on this
With a view to helping towards the election of the Minister for Transport and Power.
Comment on this
He would have been defeated in Longford-Westmeath and you made a safe seat in Monaghan by bringing in parts of Louth.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Deputies opposite even know that there was a revision of constituencies made in 1959, that it was challenged in the High Court and that the decision given was to the effect that the revision of constituencies was in conflict with the terms of the Constitution. The Judge of the High Court made this decision to the effect that the proportion of the population per Deputy must be the same throughout the country. It was this interpretation of the Constitution that required that part of the population of County Louth had to be transferred to the constituency of Monaghan, because the number of people in County Louth, in accordance with the census figures then available, divided by the number of Deputies in County Louth was in excess of the national average of population per Deputy in the country as a whole. This meant, in accordance with this constitutional requirement, that the people of Louth were being deprived of their democratic rights by having only three Deputies; in fact, they were entitled to 3.3 Deputies. As I have said, the Government at the time did not know of any way in which the people of Louth could elect .3 of a Deputy, and therefore it was necessary to shift some of the population out of Louth. Deputies for County Louth at that time complained about it. They said the people were resentful, and I think they interpreted the people's feelings fairly well. As I have pointed out, now there is a probability that the rectifying —if I can use the word, though I do not consider it rectifying—of the situation in Monaghan, in other words, complying with the Constitution in regard to Monaghan, will give rise to a situation in which this addition of population from County Louth will no longer be necessary to maintain the representation of Monaghan. Therefore, it seems obvious that since there is nowhere else that these people can go except to Louth, unless we utilise them to top up West Cork——
Comment on this
——they will go back to County Louth. Then we will have the position that the total population of County Louth will again be back with the county, and that population is 69,519. In accordance with the most liberal interpretation of the judge's decision, the maximum population allowed for three seats would be 63,084 so that if Louth is to continue as a three-seat constituency, there must be a transference of 6,435 people at least out of the county to some other constituency. Now Deputy Donegan may think that this will be welcomed with open arms by the people at the other end of the county who will have to be transferred out of it, but his former colleague Deputy Coburn, described this kind of thing in a different kind of way completely. It would appear that these people would have to be transferred to the County Meath and personally I do not believe that these 6,435 people at least would consider that they had gained in any way in their democratic rights by being transferred from County Louth to County Meath. Maybe they would or maybe they would not be resentful as Deputy Coburn said they were in 1961, but somehow I think they would not be in any way upset if they were left in Louth and left with their three representatives and they would not feel in any way deprived of their democratic rights because it would take marginally more people in Louth to elect a Deputy than in some other constituency.
My own belief is they would prefer that situation rather than that they should be changed into another county in which they may only be in temporary residence as in the case of those who had to be transferred to Monaghan on the last occasion. Another way in which the situation in Louth could be dealt with would be by transferring population to the County Louth and making it a four-seat constituency instead of a three-seat constituency. The minimum population required for four seats would require a transfer of at least 6,593 people to County Louth. These would naturally come from the county of Meath so that unless the amendment we propose is accepted it is obvious that we must have this adjustment carried out between Louth and Meath in exchange for the return of the population who were so unjustly transferred from Louth to Monaghan in 1961. I believe that the people in Louth would prefer to wait with their present representation until such time as the population in the county itself justified an extra seat. The people who were transferred to Monaghan felt they were victimised and now that they have presumably become partly acclimatised to that position they find they must come back but there must be a corresponding adjustment made with Meath.
That brings me to Meath, the constituency of Meath, which is not the County of Meath, because portion of the county is attached to Kildare. The constituency has, according to the 1966 census, a population of 60,830—and the minimum population that is required for three seats is 57,084, in accordance with the present constitutional requirement, so that if it were possible to deal with the constituency in isolation Meath need not be touched. It is one of these 14 constituencies that still comply with the requirements of the Constitutional interpretation by the High Court. But, as I have shown, because of the situation in Louth, which arises because of the situation in Monaghan and which in turn arises partly because of the situation in Cavan, because of this chain of events, the constituency of Meath, which is within the constitutional requirements at present, must be disturbed and I use the mild word "disturbed" rather than the more lurid words used by the Opposition to describe this type of operation. It must be disturbed either by receiving these 6,435 people from Louth or by donating 6,593 people to Louth in order to make Louth a four-seat constituency. I do not know which of these solutions would be adopted but whatever solution is adopted it would leave the County Meath requiring further adjustment either to retain the three seats in one event or to justify four seats in the other event. Of course, the number of ways in which the County Meath could be so adjusted are very numerous. It borders on a number of different counties and the problem could conceivably be involved in some kind of re-arrangement with Cavan, or it could be involved in an adjustment with North County Dublin, or it might be more appropriate to take cognisance of the fact that already a substantial portion of the population of Meath is attached to the constituency of Kildare.
The further you go from the origin of all this unnecessary mutilation of constituencies the more possible solutions to the problem there are. As I say, there are many ways in which the situation in Meath could be dealt with. If Louth is dealt with by transferring 6,435 people to Meath, then Meath would have too high a population for three seats and too low a population for four seats. Even if the population of Meath which is at present attached to Kildare was returned that would still be the position and there would have to be some further adjustment with Dublin, Westmeath or Cavan in order to justify a four-seat constituency. Alternatively there could be a further transfer of population from Meath to leave it a three-seat constituency. On the other hand, if Louth was dealt with by transferring population from Meath and becoming a four-seat constituency then the return of the population in Meath at present attached to Kildare would be sufficient to leave Meath as a three-seat constituency. However, as in the case of all these artificial arrangements which would be required if the proposed change in the Constitution is not made, the solution is likely to require a further change with every census and with resulting frustration both for the population of the county concerned, for the public representatives and the political Party organisations, that is those which have them. I suppose as far as the public representatives are concerned I should qualify it by saying those who do their job. Now, as we have seen the situation that unnecessarily arises in the constituency of Meath is likely to affect the present constituency of Kildare, and the population of the present constituency of Kildare, according to the 1966 Census, is 79,998. Here, again, this is another constituency which is one of the 14 that complies with the present requirements of the Constitution but, because of events elsewhere, it must be disturbed. Of that population, there are 6,493 located in the administrative county of Meath and 7,106 located within the administrative county of Westmeath. Although the constituency of Kildare itself does not require any change, being within the permitted range of population for four seats, it must be changed because of this rigid requirement in the Constitution which the Opposition Parties want to retain.
As I said, there are a number of ways in which this change could be made. First of all, the county of Kildare itself has too high a population for three seats and too low a population for four seats. That is why it had to be dealt with in 1961 by adding these portions of Meath and Westmeath to form a four-seat constituency. The problem could have been dealt with by transferring this artificial excess population from Kildare and leaving it a three-seat constituency. Another way in which it could have been dealt with, as an alternative to this adjustment with Meath and Westmeath, was that it could have been adjusted with, say, County Dublin.
The necessity to change the present constituency arises from two different circumstances: I have dealt with the Cavan-Monaghan situation and shown how that affects Kildare through Louth and Meath. In addition to that, the constituency of Longford-Westmeath is now too low in population for four Deputies. This could be dealt with by the return of some, or all, of the Westmeath population from Kildare so that if, as seems likely, both the Meath and Westmeath additions to County Kildare have to go, one to make Meath a four-seat constituency and the other to justify the retention of four seats in the constituency of Longford-Westmeath, then the position in the county of Kildare would have to be dealt with by transferring the excess population for three seats in Kildare to some constituency in County Dublin or else by transferring the requisite numbers to make up a four-seat constituency in Kildare from some parts of County Dublin.
It could conceivably be dealt with also by joining Kildare with Carlow to form a five-seat constituency. This would be quite feasible because the county of Kilkenny on its own could conceivably become a three-seat constituency. That is another possibility with regard to Kildare. Of course, it could also be dealt with in various different ways by additions from Dublin, Wicklow, Carlow and any other county that happens to touch on it.
As I said, it appears any adjustment will be effective only until the next census and this proposed Third Amendment of the Constitution will, among other things, make this type of chopping and changing after each census unnecessary. It will, too, make it possible for the people who vote, the Party organisations and Deputies to get a reasonable chance to know one another and to know their constituencies as against the chaotic position that obtains at present because of the too frequent changes inevitable under present Constitutional requirements.
All these adjustments in the part of the province of Leinster that I have so far dealt with are completely unnecessary. The total number of Deputies that would be elected in the area would be the same as at present, but there would be marginal differences in the number of voters electing Deputies in the different constituencies and, as I said, I do not think these voters would consider themselves in any way victimised by the fact that it took marginally more votes in, say, County Louth to elect a Deputy than in County Monaghan or in the adjoining counties of Longford-Westmeath. I do not think there is any reason whatsoever to insist on this rigid re-alignment of constituencies after each census, as is required by the present interpretation of the Constitution and I agree with the views expressed by the Opposition Deputies in their discussion of the revision of constituencies in 1961.
I suppose I should really deal with Dublin now, because we have travelled all around it, but the number of permutations and combinations that could be exercised in the Dublin area are so numerous that I would not inflict them on Deputy Fitzpatrick, who has waited here so long and, in doing so, absorbed so much information that he could have collated himself if he had been sufficiently interested to investigate what opposition to this proposal implies. Dublin could be dealt with in so many different ways that it is better to leave it to the imagination. Obviously it could be utilised in remedying the situation that will result in Meath and Kildare, in addition to re-arrangements within the county and city of Dublin itself. I will, therefore, skip over the Dublin area and go on to Carlow-Kilkenny because, as I have pointed out, one of the possible solutions to the unnecessary problem which the present Constitutional requirement creates in Kildare would be that Carlow and Kildare could be combined to form a five-seat constituency. The population would just be sufficient and this might, in fact, prove to be the most feasible thing to do. That could involve Kilkenny in becoming a three-seat constituency and that, in turn, could involve the return of the population of Wexford, which is at present associated with Carlow-Kilkenny, to the county of Wexford; but, if it did, it would again create in Wexford the problem that had to be solved in this way in 1961.
On the other hand, Carlow-Kilkenny, with a population of 98,454, of whom 4,398 live in the administrative county of Wexford, is another one of the 14 out of the 38 constituencies which comply with the present requirements of the Constitution and there is no need whatever to disturb it in any way but for the fact that the unnecessary situation that Deputy Fitzpatrick wants to insist on arises as far up as County Cavan and County Monaghan. This, then, is another constituency that would have to be disturbed; five more Deputies would find themselves contesting a different constituency from the one they contested on the last occasion. This is another area in which Party organisation would have to re-align themselves and another area in which the people would have to adjust themselves to being represented by different Deputies from those to whom they have become accustomed.
I should like now to deal with the constituency of Longford-Westmeath. According to the 1966 census, the population there is 74,788. There are four seats at present in that constituency but in accordance with the judge's decision the minimum population required for the retention of four seats is 76,112. Therefore, that constituency requires an addition of population in order to retain its present representation. As I pointed out, there is at present portion of County Westmeath attached to County Kildare and this problem would most likely and most appropriately be dealt with by returning the 7,106 people in Kildare, but how long it would be possible to leave them there is another matter.
As I have said, the constituency of Wexford is all right as it is. It has a population of 79,039 which is within the Constitutional requirements, but the constituency may be affected by what may have to happen to Kildare which may involve Carlow-Kilkenny and this may require the return of the population of Wexford which is at present in Carlow-Kilkenny, and Wexford, to bring it within the requirements, may have to be then adjusted and this unnecessary disruption may have to take place there.
The most appropriate place to start in the remaining province, Munster, might be the county in which we have all been engaged quite recently— County Limerick.
Comment on this
You lost 3,000 votes there. You went in with a majority of 2,500 and came out with a minority of 4,500.
Comment on this
That constituency recently had the opportunity of demonstrating its confidence in the present Fianna Fáil Government——