Committee on Finance. - An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (Atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 366–549 of 549. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
I would not have referred to it were it not for Deputy L'Estrange. I agree it is out of order.
Comment on this
——so do I, though it is a discussion I should very much like to enter. However, I agree it is thoroughly out of order. The county of Limerick, as we all know, is divided into two constituencies, West Limerick and East Limerick, and the constituency of West Limerick, according to the 1966 census, has a population of 54,335, which is too small to meet the requirements of the Constitution for three seats. East Limerick has, as some of us know, a population of 83,022. If we do not know the population we certainly know that the number of voters there is 46,493. East Limerick comes within the present Constitutional requirements and need not be touched if it could be considered in isolation. However, because of the present position of the Constitution, it cannot be considered in isolation. Therefore, East Limerick must be adjusted if this proposal is not passed, because it is affected not only by the position in West Limerick but possibly also by the position in County Kerry.
If East Limerick is involved in an adjustment of its boundary with West Limerick, the possible result will still be just barely within the Constitutional requirements and the revised boundary is unlikely to last longer than the next census, particularly if the situation in Kerry is dealt with by an adjustment with County Limerick which, from one point of view, would appear to be the more desirable thing to do because the barrier between the two counties is hardly as prominent as it is between Counties Kerry and Cork.
However, other consideration might make it more desirable to adjust Kerry with Cork. If, in addition to East Limerick and West Limerick being adjusted, there is also an adjustment between West Limerick and Kerry, obviously the situation in each of the four constituencies that would be involved would be so barely in compliance with the Constitution that that situation would be unlikely to last longer than the next census.
However, it is a fact that the situation in the two Limerick constituencies could conceivably be dealt with within the boundaries of the county itself because the population of the whole county, including the county borough, is 137,357 and the minimum population required for seven seats is 133,196. As we know, there are seven seats in that area—four in East Limerick and three in West Limerick —so that County Limerick could be dealt with in that way if it could be treated alone. However, as I have said, Limerick is quite likely to be affected by the position in County Kerry.
The population in the South Kerry constituency is 56,628 which is too low for its present three seats. In North Kerry, the population of 56,157, is also marginally too low from the point of view of the population required for three seats. The county as a whole has a population of 112,785 so that the county would need an addition of population from somewhere in order to retain its present six seats.
It would be possible to deal with Limerick and Kerry as a unit because the total population of the two counties is 250,142 which would be sufficient on the basis of the High Court's interpretation of the Constitution for the retention of the present 13 seats but in order that this could be done not alone would there have to be adjustments between the two constituencies in Kerry and the two constituencies in Limerick but there would also have to be a transference of population from County Limerick to North Kerry. Here again I do not think that there is any democratic principle that requires this "butchery" of Limerick and Kerry to take place. I am just using the words that were used by the Opposition speakers on the last occasion. I do not think there is, and I hope that during the progress of the Referendum campaign the Opposition Deputies for Limerick—I think there are still some of them left—will explain why they insist that some part of County Limerick must be transferred to County Kerry.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Would the Minister like to have a bet on the result of the Referendum in Limerick? Would he like to have a good stiff even money bet with me?
Comment on this
This is one of the ways in which the situation could be dealt with. The total number of Deputies in the whole area would still be the same but we would have near mathematical accuracy in the number of population per Deputy in the whole area. I find it hard to believe that the people of County Limerick who would have to vote for a Kerry Deputy instead of a Limerick Deputy would feel that their democratic rights had been vindicated by this unnecessary operation. I do not think that they would feel in any way underprivileged because of the fact that if they were left in their own county it would take a marginally greater number of votes to elect a Deputy in Limerick than it would in Kerry. I think they would prefer to stay where they are. However, this would be still a very close situation that would just barely comply with the Constitutional requirements and it would be so obviously one that would be purely temporary that it might be more appropriate to leave Limerick County intact within its own borders and deal with the situation in Kerry by adjustment with another county rather than County Limerick.
Of course the only other county that it would be in any way feasible to adjust with County Kerry would be the County of Cork. From the point of view of the figures this would be a feasible thing to do. The population could be taken from County Cork as a whole without depriving Cork of any representatives and of course it is only figures that are relevant in accordance with the present position of the Constitution. People do not count. The fact that the people from County Cork would be required by this adjustment to vote for Deputies in the County of Kerry, the fact that they would be separated from this constituency by the physical barrier of a mountain range which is traversed in one part only by the Healy Pass and the fact that they would also be separated from the County of Kerry by the traditional rivalry between the two counties is something which is irrelevant in present circumstances, which we are not allowed to take into consideration, but it is something which I think all practical politicians would think very relevant indeed.
I feel that we can confidently ask the people of the country to get rid of this requirement, this completely unjustified requirement, that compels the Government or compels the commission to ignore the interests of the people concerned, to ignore the convenience of the public representatives and to ignore the convenience and interests of the voluntary workers in all political Parties. They will be asked to get rid of this requirement which necessitates continuous chopping and changing of constituencies, continuous transferring of people from one county to another with the result that in the chaos that ensues the people do not know from election to election who is their public representative or to what constituency they belong. We are asking for a very very small amount of scope indeed to avoid that type of thing. I do not think we are going as far as we were requested to go by Opposition speakers on the last occasion. As I said the only criticism that we could possibly have expected of this proposal, particularly when the Opposition asked to have this separated from the other proposal, was that this did not give anything like sufficient scope to avoid this kind of thing and that it did not give anything like the scope that is available in every other democratic country in the world. The only amendment that we might have expected would be either to remove the definite percentage which is embodied in the Bill as a maximum percentage of deviation or to increase it to a more realistic level. If the Opposition made the criticism that this scope which we were looking for was too low I would certainly be compelled to agree with them just as I find myself compelled to agree with the views that were expressed by Labour and Fine Gael Deputies when the review of constituencies made in 1961 to comply with the decision of the High Court was being discussed here in this House.
The next county I would like to deal with is the County of Waterford or the constituency of Waterford. I do not know whether to start with the County or the constituency. The constituency of Waterford has a population, according to the 1966 census, of 62,331 and this is within the present requirements of the Constitution. The County of Waterford has a population of 73,080. As Deputies can see to comply with the requirements of the Constitution as interpreted by the High Court this required the transfer of a substantial number of the people of Waterford to another county and another constituency or else the transfer of a substantial portion of the population of some other county to County Waterford. I admit that this could have been done in a number of different ways on the last occasion. I think it was an undesirable thing that Waterford had to be dealt with in the way in which it was dealt with. I can quite understand the feelings of the people there which were very well described by Deputy Kyne and the late Deputy Desmond and the late Deputy Lynch. I am quite sure that they did not in any way exaggerate the feeling of the people in that area. We are asking, as I said, for a minimum amount of scope to avoid doing this kind of thing in the future.
The situation in Waterford combined with the situation in Tipperary was dealt with on the last occasion by transferring some of the population from Waterford to South Tipperary. The situation which exists in the two Tipperary constituencies now is that the population of North Tipperary, according to the 1966 Census, is 56,440. The minimum population required for three seats in accordance with the High Court decision is 57,084. The boundary between North Tipperary and South Tipperary which originally was a boundary between the two separate administrative areas of North Tipperary and South Tipperary must now be further adjusted at least. That is, the least that must now happen is that those boundaries must be further adjusted by a transference to North Tipperary from South Tipperary in order that they may retain the present three seats to comply with this decision.
In the constituency of South Tipperary the population in accordance with the 1966 Census is 77,121. Now this constituency is another one of the 14 existing constituencies which are within the limits prescribed by the High Court decision, as we interpret it. As I said, North Tipperary is not and this means that the boundary between the two constituencies must be altered. The situation could just be dealt with within the present bounds of those two constituencies but the resulting situation would approximate so closely to the minimum number of population per Deputy that it would obviously be only a very temporary solution so that the adjustment made would only be temporary and those constituencies would have to look forward to a further adjustment in the near future.
In Cork County and city again the situation there is that it could be dealt with in a number of different ways. It is not quite as involved a situation as in the county and city of Dublin but it is, I think, something which would not be very practical to go into in any great detail here.
Comment on this
We will go into the cities in any kind of detail which Deputy Fitzpatrick likes. If Deputy Fitzpatrick would cast his mind back to the earlier part of my contribution he would remember that I dealt with the Dublin area as a whole and I demonstrated——
Comment on this
I dealt with it as a whole but not on an individual basis. I demonstrated that if the present constitutional requirements are complied with that area must receive a minimum increase of four seats. I also dealt with that area must receive a mini-number of voters in the area and showed that the number of voters required an increase of only two seats, rather than four seats. I contrasted that with the situation in the West of Ireland where, taking the West of Ireland as an area from Donegal to Clare, including the province of Connacht, the present requirements were for a reduction of three seats and whereas based on voters rather than on population there was only need for a reduction of one seat.
I pointed out that situation to the Deputies on the Fine Gael and Labour benches and showed that what they were insisting on was that there should be this uncalled for reduction in the representation of that area from Donegal to Clare of two Deputies and that there should be this unjustified increase to 38 seats in Dublin whereas only 36 are required even on the most rigid interpretation of the so-called democratic principle which Deputies opposite have been talking about but that for some reason the Fine Gael and Labour Parties had decided it was desirable to unnecessarily reduce the representation of rural Ireland and that it was desirable to unjustifiably increase the representation of the urban areas.
I pointed out that they were for reasons that are known only to themselves embarking on a deliberate campaign of dividing this country on the basis of urban population versus rural population but that in fact there is no need for this. In fact, the proposal we are making is a proposal which we can put forward with confidence in all parts of the country, both urban and rural areas because it is based on justice. I do not want to speculate as to why it is that the Fine Gael Party have decided that it is desirable that the rural areas of the country generally should have less representation than the number of voters in the area would entitle them to. You might get some clue to it from Deputy J.A. Costello's contribution to the Second Reading of the two Bills when he contemptuously referred to the rural vote as the cow vote——
Comment on this
——particularly if we relate Deputy Costello's, the former Taoiseach's remarks of the rural vote being the cow vote to the recent announcement of the Fine Gael policy to reduce the number of farms——
Comment on this
—to a number that will be able to maintain a cow population of a minimum of 400 per farm. I think possibly we may get a clue as to why it is the Fine Gael Party, whose spokesman here is Deputy Fitzpatrick, from the rural constituency of Cavan, have decided to make this all-out effort to ensure that the present position which deprives the rural population in general of their due representation in the Dáil continues rather than that this slight adjustment in the Constitution we are asking for should be made which would have no more effect than to equate the value of a vote in rural areas generally with the value of a vote in urban areas generally. It would certainly do no more than that if it would even succeed in doing it.
As I said, the only criticism that could reasonably have been expected of this proposition would be that it was far too restrictive and that it would not succeed in ensuring justice for the people. The position even after this amendment is passed would still be that these injustices will have to be perpetrated on large sections of the population in different parts of the country, but the Fine Gael and Labour Parties are determined that this situation will continue, and I hope that they will be able to explain that to their constituents. We intend to ensure that the constituents will be aware of what they are doing and I think they will require to justify their actions.
I do not think the present position is required by the principles of democracy. I am inclined to agree with the views expressed by the Opposition Parties in 1961, that this, in fact, is the opposite to democracy. I do not think it is necessary and I cannot understand why the Opposition want to hang on to this position since it obtains in this country and in this country only, why we must be different from everyone else and why we must be compelled to change people from constituency to constituency, to change people around like shuttlecocks from constituency to constituency, in order to "vindicate their democratic rights". I do not feel this is a vindication of their democratic rights, but for some reason or another the Opposition want it to continue.
I find it hard to understand why, if they consider the matter from the point of view of one of their own constituents, who at the time of the general election, let us say, in the County Cavan, voted for the panel of candidates including Deputy Fitzpatrick and who finds himself, as a result of the application of this principle, in the situation after the next census, which may be in a year or two, that he is located in a constituency of Meath. I suppose Deputy Fitzpatrick, being the type of Deputy he is, would continue to devote the same attention to the part of Cavan that had been moved from the rest of the county as if it had been a part that was left there. I think all Deputies are not the same and there might be a Deputy who, finding that part of the constituency he was elected to represent was now transferred to another constituency and that some part of another constituency was added on, might decide: "I am not interested in the part gone from me and I will concentrate now on the new area which I will be contesting in the next election." The people who voted for a Deputy in the original constituency will be bewildered by the change of events. They would find themselves not knowing who their representatives were, whether it was Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick (Cavan) whom they voted for or whether it was Deputy Farrelly whom they would have to vote for the next time.
I do not think this is necessary. I do not think it is demanded by any democratic principle. I do not think it desirable to say what Deputy Harte wants to say to some of Deputy P. O'Donnell's constituents in Donegal: "We cannot leave you to continue voting in Donegal because if we did, your vote would only be 94 per cent as effective as the average vote in the country as a whole, so, in order to vindicate your democratic rights, we will transfer you to county Leitrim and there you will be in a constituency where your vote will be 95 per cent as effective as the average vote in the country as a whole, rather than 94 per cent as effective, and by doing that, we will ensure that you have the same democratic rights as everybody else." The 3,500 odd voters at least of the southern part of Donegal, who, if Deputy Harte has his way, will have to be transferred, may possibly think——
Comment on this
——that this is a vindication of their democratic rights. I do not think that they will. Even if it will involve their votes being only 94 per cent as effective as the average vote, they would prefer to vote in Donegal and have the opportunity of continuing to vote for Deputy P. O'Donnell, rather than for Deputy McLaughlin or Deputy Gilhawley or Deputy Reynolds, because the three of them, if this amendment is not passed, would obviously find themselves contesting the same three-seat constituency. They would have the task of competing among themselves for the votes not only of people in County Sligo and County Leitrim but of persons in County Donegal who are displaced purely and simply because of this ridiculous requirement, that the proportion of population per Deputy must be the same in each constituency throughout the country as a whole, regardless of the fact, as I have shown, that in the county of Donegal, the number of voters per Deputy is sufficient fully to entitle that county to retain its present six seats without any mutilation of its boundaries, and without the addition of part of Leitrim or Sligo, or by transferring part of the county to the constituency of Sligo-Leitrim.
I cannot see how that type of thing adds anything to democracy in this country and I do not think the people will see it either. I hope Deputy Harte will be able to explain to the people of Donegal why he wants this to happen and that Deputy P. O'Donnell will explain during the next referendum campaign why he wants to export part of the people who vote for him to another constituency where admittedly they will have the choice of choosing between three Fine Gael Deputies rather than the one they have already. He will have to explain to them whether the reason for this is that he intends to join the trek to Dublin that has been started by three Deputies—the two Deputies O'Higgins and Deputy Lindsay.
This is a ridiculous requirement and the guidelines we have laid down in the Bill will ensure that this maximum deviation of one-sixth of the national average will not operate generally over the whole country. It can only be used in the circumstances laid down in the Bill, to avoid the breaching of county boundaries or take account of the extent and accessibility of constituencies. If a revision of constituencies is made and a deviation of one-sixth utilised, and if it is not possible to show that it was for these reasons it was done, then such a revision can be challenged in the High Court. Then, obviously, it would not be possible, even if anybody desired to do it, to arrange that every rural constituency would be formed on the basis of one-sixth less than the national average population per Deputy and that every urban constituency would be formed on the basis of one-sixth more than the national average population per Deputy.
If you take the Dublin area as a whole, that is, the Dublin county area plus the Dublin city area, and the other major city of Cork, you will find that in those two areas combined the electors comprise 52 per cent of the total population and if you take the rest of the country as a whole the position is that electors comprise 61 per cent of the total population. So that the present position is that if you revised constituencies on the basis of strict mathematical accuracy of population per Deputy, a vote in the Dublin area and in the Cork city area would, on average, be nine per cent more effective in electing a Deputy than a vote in the rest of Ireland as a whole. Therefore, it must be quite obvious that the ultimate position resulting from the amendment we are proposing will do no more than redress this imbalance in regard to the effectiveness of a vote in a reasonable way.
Comment on this
(Cavan): At the risk of prolonging the Minister's speech, may I ask a question? Do I understand the Minister to say that the one-sixth tolerance could only be operated with a view to avoiding overlapping of county boundaries, et cetera?
Comment on this
They are in the Bill. These are the words that Deputy Fitzpatrick proposes to delete. Perhaps Deputy Fitzpatrick has deleted them already?
Comment on this
(Cavan): We are now on the Schedule and if I read it correctly, the first part of the Schedule says that there can be a tolerance of one-sixth either way and then it says that, subject to that, regard may be had to accessibility, et cetera; but you have one-sixth tolerance either way if you never had any accessibility.
Comment on this
No. The one-sixth tolerance, obviously, can only be operated in accordance with these requirements.
Comment on this
If the maximum of one-sixth is utilised and it is not possible to show that it is done in order to comply with these requirements, then such revision of constituencies could be successfully challenged.
Comment on this
I think it does. That is what it is intended to say and I think that is what it does say. This proposition that we are making is one that is completely justifiable. It has been justified in advance by the Opposition Parties. It is one that will do no more than justice to the people of the country, that will do no injustice to anybody but will help in a small way to avoid the necessity of perpetrating on people in different parts of the country an injustice that nobody wants to perpetrate on them—certainly, nobody on this side of the House. The only possible interpretation to place on the attitude of the Opposition is that they now want the situation that resulted in 1961 to be repeated on a much wider scale on this occasion because, as I have shown, it is inevitable that that will happen now before the next general election and that every part of the country will be affected. It is also quite likely that whatever results from this redrawing of constituencies on this occasion will be only of a very temporary nature and will require further revision probably after the next census. So that the effect of this proposal, so far from breaching any democratic principle, will result in the value of individual votes throughout the country as a whole becoming more nearly equal and its purpose is so clearly to avoid injustice and to safeguard people's democratic rights as to expose the Opposition Parties as being completely insincere in their attitude to the proposal. The Opposition's real views were those that were expressed in 1961 and it is only because they allowed themselves to be panicked into opposing it because it is proposed by Fianna Fáil that they now find themselves in the position of opposing this very desirable proposal.
Comment on this
We have had some filibusters in this House and I think it can be said that the Minister's filibuster tonight will rank amongst the most outrageous of them. I am surprised that this important business dealing with electoral reform was ordered for this evening. The Government must have lost sight of the fact that there is a party in Dublin Castle to which Deputies have been invited.
Comment on this
That being the case, I cannot understand why some other business was not ordered for this evening which could be dealt with in the usual way.
Comment on this
——wantonly encroaching on the time of the House and of its Members. This is outrageous. It is something that I protest against. My opinion of the Minister has not been very high and his present performance does nothing to vary it. Everyone knows that the Minister's statement is insincere.
Comment on this
Everyone knows that the Minister—to use a term which is easily understandable—is just bluffing. With his almost four-hour statement in the Dáil, that is just what he is doing. We all know that this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill was drawn up for one purpose only— with a view to coating—"icing", possibly, would be a better term—the Fourth Amendment which is to be dealt with later.
Comment on this
The Minister and the Government got the idea that they would tell the people now that they were going to give them more representation in the sparsely populated parts and would embody this amendment with the Fourth Amendment which the Government had in mind at the outset and that they would say to the people, "If you want more representation in the west of Ireland you must do what you did not do in 1959 —do away with the single-seat constituencies." Is that not what the Government had in mind? The Minister is not worried about all these constituencies along the western seaboard, details of which he has outlined here tonight, or the living standards of the people in them.
Comment on this
His confessed aim is the advancement of the Fianna Fáil Party and the advancement of the Taca group. Everyone knows that is the main aim behind this Bill—to bring about a change in the view so clearly expressed by the people in the last referendum. It is scandalous that less than nine years after that decisive decision, we should be discussing this position again. I have no doubt that the Third Amendment would never have been brought in but for this endeavour to try to deceive the people into accepting the Fourth Amendment Bill. That is the amendment the Minister is interested in.
Comment on this
The two were like Siamese twins, but in view of public opinion, an operation was performed and they had to be separated. This package deal did not come off. Now they are putting forward the Third Amendment and telling the people: "Look, you are not sufficiently well represented. We are very mindful of you. We would like to give you more representation but this dreadful Opposition are not agreeable." The Minister told us the last day that he was worried about Deputy Dunne being overworked. I am sure the Minister gives a damn about it.
Comment on this
The Minister has cause to be worried about Deputy Dunne.
Comment on this
I know Deputy Dunne is one of the most capable and effective Members of this House. Those of us who know him personally know he is overworked, but I am damn sure the Minister is not worried about the extra duties Deputy Dunne has to perform in looking after the interests of his constituents in County Dublin. The reason I mention this relatively small matter is that it was the main reason put forward by the Minister in reply to a question of mine as to who asked for this reform.
Comment on this
We had this Vote for over £100,000 to ensure that the single-seat constituency will operate. That is the main purpose. His lordship decided this matter in 1960. The usual outcome in much smaller cases than this, particularly in cases where private individuals have to bear the cost, is that if a judge's decision, in the opinion of a particular Party, particularly a Party who have the funds to proceed further, is open to question, then they take it to the Supreme Court. That is one question I put to the Minister which he failed to answer this evening. Why did the Government not take to the Supreme Court the judge's decision which indicated he was not in agreement with the draftsmen who drew up the electoral reform in 1959?
Comment on this
I assume this electoral revision in 1959 was approved by the Attorney General of the time. He must have agreed that this 1959 revision was in accordance with the Constitution. That was challenged by a private individual and it was determined by a single judge sitting in the High Court that changes should be made. The natural thing for the Government to do, if they believe in their own Attorney General and the advice submitted to them the previous year, would be to take the matter to the Supreme Court where they would have a much larger body to determine the particular issue. But that was not done because at that time it possibly suited Fianna Fáil to leave things as they were. They had a second go at revising the constituencies.
I may say at this stage that it is not the intention of this Party to delay the House for an extended period on this measure because it has been discussed over and over. We are much more in favour of leaving it go to the people who will ultimately decide it, the citizens of this country.
Comment on this
The Minister spent three and a half hours filibustering here, which indicates he is not in any great hurry to get this through the House and over to the people.
Comment on this
How much public money has been wasted bringing up the statements of Deputies who have long since left this House, statements taken entirely out of their context, extracts from speeches made by Deputies who have departed from this life for many years—the late Deputy Lynch, the late Deputy Desmond, the late Deputy Norton——
Comment on this
——and some other Deputies? Statements taken out of their context were quoted by the Minister in support of this case he is trying to put before the people for the Third Amendment Bill but actually with the Fourth Amendment Bill in mind.
If I may recall some of his statements, he mentioned the "butchery" of Waterford. Who butchered Waterford, and why? It was butchered because, having regard to the returns of the elections prior to 1961, it was evident to Fianna Fáil, or so they thought, that if Waterford were reduced from a four-seat to a three-seat constituency, Fianna Fáil would still hold the two seats they held and that by doing so, they would take a seat from the Opposition and give that advantage to their own Party. So they butchered Waterford, to use the Minister's phrase, but unfortunately things did not go their way. They had hoped to remove my colleague on this bench, Deputy Kyne, from this House when they reduced the representation from four to three seats in the revision of 1960, but what happened? The people of Waterford sent Deputy Kyne back here with the largest vote he ever got in any election. That was the answer given.
Comment on this
The Minister's Party were sure they could hold the two seats in Waterford, that two out of three would be much better than two out of four.
Comment on this
The Parliamentary Secretary may be in jocose mood. This is a serious matter and I would like him to treat it as such.
Comment on this
The Minister told us about statements by the late Deputy Norton and what happened in Kildare. Big chunks of Westmeath and Meath were thrown into Kildare to do something that proved to be sound so far as the Minister's Party are concerned. That something, of course, was to get two out of four seats. Fianna Fáil could not do better than one out of three when Kildare was a constituency on its own. I will give the Minister the credit that his view was correct. So far as Kildare was concerned he said: "Look here, if we get extra chunks of Meath and Westmeath and make Kildare a four-seat constituency we will get two out of the four." Was that not one of the main reasons why Kildare was transformed from a three-seat constituency to a four-seat constituency?
I am a believer in tolerance but I am not a believer in the Minister. I have not the slightest doubt that he is completely insincere and that his main aim in this provision—if I have the permission of the Parliamentary Secretary to repeat myself—is to sugar-coat this Fourth Amendment Bill in which he is so vitally interested.
Comment on this
The Fourth Amendment Bill is the one the Minister has at the back of his head, and judging from what happened in Limerick, it is going to stay there. If I may digress for a moment, I was down at some of the meetings on the Sunday before the election at Murroe and outside church gates and the Parliamentary Secretary was saying: "If you do not give O'Malley No. 1 and if you give your No. 1 to one of the other candidates, give our fellow No. 2 and even No. 3."
Comment on this
I am surprised that the Minister acknowledges Deputy O'Malley's election. He has stated that he is not a believer in PR.
Comment on this
I did not state it on the Committee Stage of the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill.
Comment on this
If the Minister's proposed reform does not go through, perhaps he will resign in disgust and we will no longer have him in the House. If that happens, some of us will not shed any tears.
To bolster up a bad case, the Minister talked about the county boundaries and said they might be crossed. Even under the present Constitution you cannot keep within the county limits. No matter what system we have, single, double, treble or whatever number of seats, it is not unlikely that in rare cases county boundaries may have to be crossed. I do not like that to happen, but Fianna Fáil have done it before to suit themselves. I remember when they put Youghal into Waterford in order to defeat a former chairman of the Cork County Council. He resided in Youghal, and, by transferring Youghal town to the constituency of Waterford, they thought they would knock him out, but the people thought differently. If Deputy O'Connor looks up the records, he will find there are umpteen cases of that kind.
Comment on this
——and we had an election in 1961. The Government were in power and they did not say anything about his lordship's decision from 1961 to 1965. If they were genuine, they would have asked for the co-operation of all Parties in setting up a Committee of the House. That would be quite a reasonable thing to do.
Comment on this
It could make a recommendation which would be acceptable to all Parties and could then be put before the people. That was not done because the Minister and his Party were not interested in doing it at the time. The Attorney General advised the Government that a general election on the present basis would be contrary to the Constitution. How do we know that the decision of the Attorney General is correct? A decision by the Attorney General in 1959 was revoked by a High Court judge. Is the Minister asserting that the Attorney General is infallible? He did not set down whether the variation or the tolerance should be 1,000 or 2,000. The Minister is misinterpreting his lordship's remarks for the purpose of deceiving the general public. If the viewpoint of the Attorney General is correct, I want to pose a question to the Minister: is the composition of the present Dáil unconstitutional? We were elected in 1965 and some were elected from constituencies which were below the normal tolerance allowed, according to the Minister's interpretation of the judge's remarks.
As I said earlier, I do not want to hold up the House for too long but I do not believe that the Minister's case is in any way sincere. If I thought for a moment that there was any sincerity attaching to the Minister's statement, I would be the first to agree to join in any Committee or group of Members of the House to ensure that the rural areas were properly and adequately represented, but I have not the slightest doubt that the Minister is not interested in rural representation. The Minister is interested in improving the position of his own political Party and keeping himself and his friends in office for longer than the people want them. That is his sole aim. The Government have been in office for too long. Possibly the same could apply to other Governments. The Government are stale and arrogant. The Minister for Local Government is most arrogant. They feel they are declining, and naturally the results in Wicklow and the results in Limerick East bear out that feeling. Limerick was their strongest, or their second strongest, constituency in the country. Everything favoured them. I do not want to go into details but they got in by less than they expected.
Comment on this
If the 464 people who voted O'Higgins No. 1 and O'Malley No. 2 instead of giving their No. 2 to O'Malley had given it to Lipper, we would have had Lipper in the winners' enclosure, shall I say, and the Parliamentary Secretary would have been spared a task earlier today.
Comment on this
I could start off by saying the Labour Party got an increase of more than 80 per cent in their vote there. I shall not use this House for that purpose. I could also say that the Fine Gael vote declined by 2,500. I do not want to inflict that on the House at 9.30 this evening. The Minister is supposed to be the computer of the Fianna Fáil Party that gets in the figures. He said he had taken into account the probable outcome of all the constituencies. The Minister has proposals before him so that in the likely event of his single-seat reform proposal turning out as we expect it to turn out, he will ask himself: "How will we move now? Will we make this place four or five?" The Minister mentioned that here this evening.
I have said that the Labour Party are mindful of the interests of the people, both rural and urban. We should be the first to join in any committee that we thought would genuinely be established with a view to ensuring fair representation for urban and rural people. We oppose this amendment because—I do not wish to repeat what I have already said—we think the sole aim of the Minister in proposing it is to bolster up the declining fortunes of the Fianna Fáil Party and the Taca men associated with it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): As Deputy Murphy said, we listened here this evening for over four hours to the Minister for Local Government who recited a litany of alleged figures and alleged facts which he said were already on the records of this House. It struck me that it was a terrible waste of time. It also occurred to me to ask myself how many highly-paid Civil Service man-hours went into the making-up of these figures for the Minister.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I asked myself how many Civil Service man-hours were devoted to the compilation of these alleged facts and alleged figures for the Minister. It also occurred to me to ask myself if this time of the civil servants would not better be spent in providing houses for St. Joseph's Place in Limerick or other places where they are badly needed or in devising ways and means of providing means of access into homes of people throughout the length and breadth of Ireland and not in that way.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If the Minister were intent on keeping the people in those places, there would not then be occasion for him to say that there are not enough votes for so many seats here and so many seats there. The Minister spoke for over four hours. When I spoke here earlier this evening I charged him with the fact that his sole purpose in introducing this Bill was to gerrymander and to keep himself in power by dishonest means.
Comment on this
(Cavan): As evidence of that, I pointed out that, notwithstanding what Deputy Booth thinks, there is no provision in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill for a commission to arrange the constituencies although there is provision for a commission in the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill. I challenge the Minister to tell the House and the country why he did not put the commission provisions into the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill—the provisions whereby constituencies with a tolerance of six per cent would be arranged by a tribunal consisting of three members of the Opposition and three members of the Government, presided over by a judge. I challenge the Minister to tell the House and the people why he did not do that if he was an honest man and if his proposals were the honest proposals he led the House to believe they were. During the four hours the Minister occupied the time of this House, he never for one moment——
Comment on this
Why did the Deputy not ask me the question? Now, I shall have to get up again to answer it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Deputy Booth does not know the provisions of this Bill and neither does the Minister. In his innocence, the Minister thinks that this one-sixth per cent tolerance——
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister is getting petty and sore and small. He does that with the clergy, with the returning officers, with television, and so on. In any event, the Minister seems to think that the one-sixth tolerance is regulated by things such as accessiblity, rivers, mountains, and so on. If the Minister reads the Bill or consults his advisers, he will find that that just is not so. If there never were a county boundary, the Minister can provide that 16,667 people will be represented by one Teachta Dála in one constituency but in another constituency, one Teachta Dála will represent 23,333 people if there never were a river and never were a mountain.
I want to get back to the commission. I challenge the Minister to agree to put into this measure the commission provisions of the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill—to make them applicable to the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill. There is no difficulty about doing it. It can be done. The only reason the Minister is not doing it is that he wants to retain to himself and to his majority in this House the right to draw up the constituencies, the right to rig the constituencies, the right to gerrymander the constituencies and to arrange them to his best political advantage. If that is not his intention I ask, and I repeat, why will he not include the commission provisions of the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill in the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill and why they were left out of it in the first instance.
The Minister seems to think that county boundaries are sacred and that the counties and constituencies should coincide identically. I do not think there is anything sacred about county boundaries. For example, for years back, we have had county managers managing two counties. We have had joint county managers in a number of counties. Practically every police district in this State consists of two counties joined together. Almost invariably, two counties have been joined together in this country over the years for mental health purposes. We have had a number of joint constituencies. I think I am safe in saying that there are some counties in this State which, from its foundation, have never been a single constituency but have always been joined with another. It we are to accept as genuine the thinking of the Government at present, they are thinking away from counties and thinking in terms of regions. We have a commission sitting at present —their report is overdue—advising on regional hospitals. The day of the old county hospital is done. A hospital now caters for three or four counties. Therefore, there is nothing sacred about county boundaries—there never has been—but if I understand the case the Minister is making correctly, he seems to be saying that constituencies should coincide with county boundaries and that each county should be a constituency. But did it occur to the Minister to consider for a moment what he is doing in the Fourth Amendment Bill? To use his own familiar words, he is butchering up every single county——
Comment on this
(Cavan):——into two and three constituencies. You will then have Deputies representing, say, the eastern part of a county in the Dáil: on the county council they may be representing another area of the county. They will be pulling against their county council interests and their interests will be divided. I should like the Minister to explain how, if he thinks counties are so sacred, he can justify butchering or dividing up—if he thinks it is a better word—each county into two or three constituencies because that is what he is doing. You will then have the people of East Cavan, Mid-Cavan and West Cavan all with different interests. Deputies representing West Cavan will not have the same interests as those representing East Cavan and Deputies representing Mid-Cavan will not have an interest either in East Cavan or West Cavan. Is that not the position?
Comment on this
Perhaps we should have left both measures together; then the Deputy would be relevant.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am making the case that the Minister does not believe in county boundaries. He is making a case for the Schedule of the Bill which we are now discussing on the basis that county boundaries are sacred and that county boundaries and constituencies should coincide. I am drawing the attention of the House to the fact that the Bill which I hope we shall be discussing tomorrow morning——
Comment on this
(Cavan): Another little smart remark. Under the other measure which we shall be discussing tomorrow the Minister shows a total disregard for county boundaries. At present, I represent the constituency of Cavan and I am interested in it from Dowra to Mullagh. The Minister spoke about Virginia to Arva——
Comment on this
I was not talking about the Deputy's present constituency which he wants to get out of.
Comment on this
(Cavan): At present I represent the constituency from Mullagh to Dowra and Blacklion and I am interested in it from one end to the other but if the Minister gets his way—and let him know that I shall be elected even if he gets his way, which he will not—I shall have an interest in only one-third of the constituency and two other TDs will be elected who will each have an interest in one-third of the area. At present there are three Deputies representing the county and I hope they have the interest of the whole county at heart. If County Monaghan is joined with Cavan and there are five Deputies, they will have joint responsibility and joint interest in the whole constituency.
This argument about county boundaries does not hold water. It is neither genuine nor sincere. It is simply put up as a sort of catch-cry in the hope that people would not throw their minds forward to the very next measure to see that it is completely and utterly disregarded. The Minister in his long harangue did not deal with Dublin which he skipped over——
Comment on this
(Cavan): I want to close on this note that I believe that the Minister has got the message. I believe his speech for four hours here tonight was an attempt to drag out this debate into the financial business when he will have an excuse for putting the Third Amendment and the Fourth Amendment Bills at the bottom of the Order Paper. He will then have an opportunity of avoiding the referendum until the end of this year or perhaps next year. So far as I and my Party are concerned, we will just not co-operate with him. If he wants to talk on and on for hours he can do so, but it will be to a quorum of his own Deputies. We want this measure and the next measure, the Fourth Amendment, to go to the people at once and we want to get any uncertainty there may be about electoral change out of the way and let Parliament get on with the business for which it was elected, to pass laws for the people and not to be considering ways and means of keeping itself or portion of it in office. That is what is being done. I repeat that I am not going to co-operate, nor is this Party, in any of the Minister's delaying tactics to drag out this debate. The referendum must be held, I think, within 30 days of the passing of this measure by Seanad Éireann.
Comment on this
I want to draw the attention of the House to the fact that we are getting away from the Schedule.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister will have plenty of time to put his views before the people either at chapel gates, if they will listen to him, or on Telefís Éireann if he allows it to operate and allows all Parties to air their views over it. I challenge him to do that. He will have plenty of time to get his views across to the people and the people will have ample opportunity to consider them. I challenge him now to get on with it, stop talking and put the matter before the people with the minimum delay.
Comment on this
Opposition speakers are accusing the Minister of delaying tactics and have said that he has spoken for four hours. I heard only some of the things he said but there is one point that I think is worth elaborating. It struck me very forcibly. Taking the 20,000 people per Deputy as the base then, according to the Minister's statement that in rural areas the voters consist of 61 per cent of the population and in urban areas the electors make up 52 per cent of the population —if you work it out it means that in, say, Donegal it will take 12,200 electors to return a Deputy whereas in Dublin it will require only 10,400 electors to return a TD. Is this the kind of tolerance that Fine Gael and Labour want? Is this what they want to impose on the rural population of this country? Is this what they want to see happen in the rural constituencies from Donegal to Cork and from Galway to the boundaries of Dublin? I do not think that this is justice. I do not think Fine Gael or Labour should advocate that on this Bill—I presume when it comes to the referendum, they will advocate the same policy—because frankly, any Deputy, and especially rural Deputies like Deputy Murphy from Cork and Deputy Fitzpatrick, does not want this although this is what they are fighting for in this House and will be fighting for on the occasion of the referendum. They want to uphold the system which in the case of Donegal, in the case of Cavan and in the case of West Cork, will require the large number of 12,200 people as the number who will elect a TD, whereas in the city they want to see, and will see, a TD elected by 10,400 people. This is what will happen if the percentage which the Minister has given is correct, and I am sure these are the official figures.
Comment on this
If they are not correct, I am sure Deputy Fitzpatrick and his researchers in Fine Gael will correct them for us.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If I were Deputy Cunningham, I would not talk at all because of the way they are treating him up there.
Comment on this
There again is another point I hope the Minister will highlight, because I think it is a very important one for the people, especially the people of rural Ireland whose interests all Parties seem to have at heart, although it is difficult to understand how any Party can have the interests of rural Ireland at heart when it is trying to preserve the present position. Deputy Fitzpatrick also complained that the Minister read out a litany of constituencies and spoke of what might happen if the referendum were defeated. Only one of two things can happen, either the referendum will succeed or it will be defeated. It is only right to put across to this House and through this House to the people the situation that will obtain in either event. Why tell them what will happen if the referendum succeeds and not tell them what will happen if it does not succeed? Eventually it is the people who will decide, and if they decide against, then what the Minister has been telling the House and the country this evening is what will happen, or something along those lines—the breaching of boundaries, the crossing from one county to another. Deputy Fitzpatrick has said that if the single-seat constituency is adopted, he could represent only one-third of Cavan. I think he would be better able to represent one-third than the whole county; in other words, the area he would represent would be better represented because he would be able to devote more time to it.
Comment on this
There will be plenty of candidates from whom to choose. I presume each Party will have a candidate, and there will be quite a number of candidates. I do hope that the point made by the Minister will be noted by the electorate when they come to decide this matter.
Comment on this
I am fairly familiar with this breaching of constituencies. Before 1945, part of my own county—indeed, part of my present constituency—was attached to County Clare.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted, and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
When I was so rudely interrupted by Deputy Fitzpatrick, I was referring to the breaching of county boundaries and to the fact that some years ago part of my present constituency was attached to County Clare from quite near my own town to Woodford, which is practically on the Clare boundary, and over again to Gort and into Oranmore, which is very near Galway city. It was impossible in those days to get people interested in voting at general or by-elections, because the people in the county of Galway had to vote for candidates of all Parties who were naturally chosen from County Clare. This was mainly due to the fact that at local level, in the county council, they were represented by councillors from Galway and in national affairs they were represented by Dáil Deputies from County Clare. The boundaries were not coterminous with county boundaries for Dáil representation and consequently people in Galway showed very little inclination to vote in Dáil elections, despite the fact that there was always a good turn out at local elections. For Deputy Fitzpatrick to say that breaching the boundaries does not mean a thing is nonsense. We could not get 25 per cent of the people to vote at Dáil elections.
Comment on this
You did, and you will be seeing more of them shortly. You will get a Limerick-like wallop there.
Comment on this
You will be very welcome. However, that is the point I wish to make, that Deputy Fitzpatrick is away off his mark if he speaks, as he does, about the insignificance of county boundaries.
Comment on this
I am correcting the Deputy on matters of fact. Deputy Ryan made the point that TDs should not have to meet their constituents and that constituents should get their rights or their imagined rights without having to have recourse to their Deputy or county councillor. In the next breath, he said that it was as easy in rural Ireland to contact a Deputy as it was in the city of Dublin. Fine Gael speak with many voices but apparently they are not heard and these voices are becoming muted in parts of the country. If he knew the extent of a five-seat constituency, which my constituency is, in rural Ireland, as compared with a three or four seat constituency in the City of Dublin, he would not make a statement like that. My constituency extends from the Mayo border to the Clare border, from north to south, a distance of about 70 miles, and from Tipperary and Offaly a distance of about 40 or 45 miles. Surely nobody could say that a sixpenny bus ticket, which I am sure is all it would cost to visit Deputy Ryan, although from what he says I believe he does not encourage visitors——
Comment on this
——would represent a far greater task than to travel 40 or 50 miles to visit Deputy Donnellan in the north or Deputy Molloy who lives in the West, or Deputy Mrs. Hogan O'Higgins who lives in the south-east? A statement of that kind will certainly not be believed in rural Ireland. I know the Leas-Cheann Comhairle's constituency and I had occasion to be there some time ago and I know what distances are involved there. If we are to believe Deputy Ryan that it is easier to travel from Abbeyfeale, where Deputy Jones, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle lives, than to travel in Dublin South-West——
Comment on this
To travel from Rathmines to Kimmage. You would want to set out early in the morning to do that. It is a long journey.
Comment on this
I can assure the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that to cross from North Galway to South Galway is a far more difficult journey and certainly TDs in many parts of rural Ireland try to make themselves as accessible as possible to their constituents, no matter to what Party they belong.
Comment on this
Deputy Fitzpatrick accused the Minister of spending four hours on the rural constituencies but I am now asking the Minister to spend four hours on the urban constituencies, to tell us and our constituents what exactly these changes will mean, what the issues are. Despite what Deputy Fitzpatrick said, the whole country should know, rural and urban, what the effects of these amendments would mean to them. I urge the Minister to discuss urban constituencies as he has done so thoroughly with the rural areas.
Deputy Fitzpatrick also mentioned the question of television and challenged a discussion on television about proportional representation and its proposed abolition. I would indeed be happy to take up this challenge and I invite Deputy Fitzpatrick to measure up the Leader of the Opposition and Deputy Dockrell with myself and Deputy Booth on television. I can appreciate that it would be a little difficult for the respected Leader of the Opposition to take up this challenge because it is a well-known fact that he is against the retention of PR. I do not know quite what Deputy Dockrell is against but I am sure we will find out all his views in the course of this debate. Until we do hear what his views are, I am assuming that he is ad idem with his leader. So much for the television challenge.
In regard to my own constituency, Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, it is a vast constituency and one which I respectfully submit requires five Deputies. At present it is impossible to look after the whole area. From the point of view of most urban Deputies or rural Deputies, the splitting up of the various constituencies into manageable areas is the important thing. As I said already, when I got up to speak it was to speak about this television challenge. To date Fianna Fáil have not given their views on this matter. We have heard the whole argument from Fine Gael and the Labour Party and we must wait to go to the people in the autumn but if Deputy Fitzpatrick would influence Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy Dockrell I am sure that I can speak on behalf of Deputy Booth——
Comment on this
I believe that given the opportunity of going on television, perhaps we will improve the figure this time.
Comment on this
Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown did not then know that Deputy Cosgrave wanted to do away with proportional representation, but he is now leading the Fine Gael Party on an issue in which he himself does not believe. I have great sympathy for the Leader—the respected Leader —of the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
Tell us about all the people in the Minister's Party who want to retain proportional representation.
Comment on this
I do not want to interrupt the Deputy, but I would remind him that this amendment to the Schedule deals with the tolerance.
Comment on this
I thought I had dealt reasonably comprehensively with this Schedule, but I have been reminded by both Deputy Murphy and Deputy Fitzpatrick that there are some matters which I have as yet not covered.
Comment on this
We will deal with the matters in the order in which they arose. Deputy Murphy spoke before Deputy Fitzpatrick and I should, perhaps, deal with some of the points he raised first. If I omit dealing with any of them, I hope he will remind me.
First of all, there was the question of whether or not a revision of constituencies was due now. Deputy Murphy informed me that the Attorney General had told me that a revision was necessary now.
Comment on this
I do not know where Deputy Murphy got that information; it is something of which I have no knowledge. I have no knowledge of the Attorney General informing me of this. But Deputy Murphy implies that, if he did so inform me, he informed me wrongly. I admit I did not deal with this on Committee Stage because I had already dealt with the matter on Second Reading. That was at a time when we, in order to sort out the confusion of the Opposition, had put the Bills together again, having first separated them in order to avoid confusing the Opposition. Now, in that debate on Second Reading, I instanced a number of occasions on which Deputies put down Parliamentary Questions to me asking when I intended to comply with the constitutional requirement to revise constituencies and, as I said on that occasion, the ink on the census return was hardly dry when my colleague Deputy Dunne apparently being aware of the fact that the constituency of County Dublin was no longer conforming to constitutional requirements, had a question down asking when I was going to revise the constituencies to bring them within the requirements of the Constitution. On Second Reading, I instanced two more occasions on which Deputy Dunne had a similar question down and on at least one of these occasions, he pursued the matter by way of supplementary questions.
Comment on this
Is the Minister now trying to assert that it was as a result of Deputy Dunne's representations this debate is taking place here now?
Comment on this
I know that Deputy Murphy is not really interested in the facts of the matter but, since this whole matter is based on the Constitution, I think I should read the relevant sub-Article of the Constitution:
The ratio between the number of members to be elected at any time for each constituency and the population of each constituency, as ascertained at the last preceding census, shall, so far as it is practicable, be the same throughout the country.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Read the Supreme Court decision on the meaning of the phrase “as far as is practicable” because there was a Supreme Court decision on it in 1961.
Comment on this
And the Supreme Court ruled that the revision of constituencies made to conform with that High Court decision was within the terms of the Constitution, but Deputy Dunne was quick to notice that at the present time the ratio between the number of members to be elected for his constituency, and my constituency, and Deputy Burke's constituency, is not the same as for every other constituency "as ascertained at the last preceding census" and, therefore, the present scheme of constituencies does not, in fact, comply with the Constitution. Now, whether or not that makes it necessary for the Government to revise the constituencies is, of course, something I do not know, but I do know that it is an incontrovertible fact that there are only 14 out of the present 38 constituencies which are within the constitutional provisions, as I have interpreted them, as laid down by the High Court, and I think I have interpreted them correctly. I cannot see any other way in which they could be interpreted.
I have here a copy of Irish Reports, 1961, and at the bottom of page 143 in re O'Donovan v. the Attorney General, there is the following statement:
Another suggestion was to divide Galway into two constituencies, West Galway with three seats, and East Galway with five seats. It was submitted that this could be done fairly simply by transferring the nine electoral divisions of Carmore, Claregalway, Annaghdown, Ballinduff, Donaghpatrick, Headford, Kilcoone, Killeany and Kilursa, with a joint population of 5,166 to West Galway and consolidating the remainder of the other two existing constituencies. For clarity I set out the result:—
Suggested constituency, West Galway, three seats, population 60,269, ratio of population 1 to 20,089; East Galway, five seats, population 95,284, ratio of population 1 to 19,057;
That is, I think, 1,070 below the national average at the particular time. The learned judge went on to say:
Both suggestions would constitute constituencies with a ratio of members to population reasonably close to the national average. These illustrations show what is practicable in these instances and may be compared with what in fact has been done.
Any reasonable person would, I think, interpret that as indicating that a deviation of approximately 1,000 above or below the national average, which was in the region of 20,000, was permissible, and that is five per cent.
Comment on this
The figure of 1,000 is not set down in any statement by the judge and it does not appear in any enactment. The figure the Minister mentions of 1,000 is not set down anywhere. It was the Minister himself who thought up that figure.