An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (resumed).
Contributions 1–169 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 5 of 1968 ›
I was dealing with some further points that had been raised by members of the Opposition although I suspect they were not raised really for the purpose of having the points elucidated but rather in pursuance of the efforts of the Opposition Parties to delay the passage of the Bill.
Comment on this
The only other point I should deal with again in view of Deputy Fitzpatrick's insistence on it, although it has been dealt with several times already, is the reason why provision for the Constituency Commission is not in this Bill. If the Deputy remembers, it was originally the intention of the Government to put these proposals, which are designed to give a more rational system of election, in the form of one proposition to the people. At that stage there was a howl from the two Opposition Parties that this was far too complicated a matter for them to consider on the basis of one single proposition and in order to try to make it a little clearer for them we agreed to divide them into two separate proposals.
This meant, of course, that since we will be asking the people to adopt these two proposals, there had to be a decision to put this question of the requirement of the Constitution to establish a commission into one Bill or the other. It was deemed more appropriate to put it into the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill rather than into the Third Amendment Bill. It would be silly to put it into both. I think that if there is any particular importance attached to having the constituencies delineated by a commission rather than by the Government, the importance would be greater if a radical change were being made from the present system of multi-member constituencies to the proposed system of single-seat constituencies. For that reason it was decided to put the provision for a commission into the Fourth Amendment Bill rather than into this one.
The only other point to which I want to refer is that Deputy Cunningham, in speaking on this Bill, appeared to a certain extent to have misunderstood what I have said. I pointed out that in the area of Dublin and the area of Cork Borough taken together, the electorate formed 56 per cent of the total population, whereas in the remainder of the country the proportion of the electorate to the total population is 61 per cent and that that meant that a vote in the rural areas generally, if constituencies were divided strictly on a basis of mathematical accuracy of population per Deputy, would be nine per cent less effective in electing a Deputy than in the area of Dublin and Cork taken as a whole. I pointed out that that was the position which Deputy Fitzpatrick and his colleagues in his own benches and in the Labour benches are trying to maintain for some reason. I think Deputy Cunningham took this to mean that the difference was that the figures should have been 52 per cent in the Dublin-Cork area and 61 per cent in the remainder of the country but in fact it is 56 per cent as against 61 per cent.
This would mean that, in general, the system which the Opposition are trying to maintain would result in the average electorate per Deputy in urban areas being 11,200, that is, in the Dublin and Cork areas—as against 12,200 in the rural areas. I hope that when this campaign is in operation, Opposition Deputies will be prepared to explain to their constituents why it is that they want to maintain a position in which it would take more people in rural Ireland to elect a Deputy than in the urban areas. Needless to say, in individual constituencies the disparity will be much greater if the Opposition campaign succeeds.
For instance, in the present constituency of Dublin North-West the electorate, that is, the voters, comprise 50.96 of the total population, whereas in Donegal South-West they comprise 67.74 per cent of the electorate, so that if the present position, which requires constituencies to be delineated on the basis of the same number of the population per Deputy in each constituency, is maintained as a result of this campaign of Deputy Fitzpatrick, Deputy Harte, Deputy P. O'Donnell and other Opposition Deputies, then we will have the situation that in the constituency of Dublin North-West the electorate per Deputy will be 10,206, whereas in Donegal South-West it will take 13,567 voters to elect one Deputy. In Donegal North-East where the electorate is 62.5 per cent of the total population it will take 12,518 people to elect a Deputy as against the 10,206 in Dublin North-West. In the county of Donegal as a whole, with an electorate of 65.1 per cent of the total population, the number of voters per Deputy will be 13,038 as against 10,206.
I am just giving these figures for Donegal but they will be made available to the people for other constituencies also and I hope that both Deputy Harte and Deputy P. O'Donnell will be able to explain to the people of Donegal why it is that they want to have this differential in voting effectiveness given to the constituency of Dublin North-West as compared with the county of Donegal, and I hope that Deputy Fitzpatrick will be able to explain to the people of Cavan why it is that he wants to multilate the boundaries of County Cavan, although on the basis of the number of voters per Deputy, there is no reason whatever why that should be done because on the basis of the national average of voters per Deputy, County Cavan could retain its integrity as a three-seat constituency.
As I say, I have the suspicion that the other points raised were raised merely for the purpose of delaying the progress of this Bill through the House. Anything that was raised has been covered already, and since the answers to these things are already on the record, I do not want to delay the House unnecessarily by repeating them.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I certainly do not want to delay the House or to hold up the passage of these measures; I want to get them through the House and get them to the people. The Minister spent four hours yesterday evening dealing with the Schedule to the Third Amendment Bill, going laboriously through constituency after constituency, pouring out figures prepared under his jurisdiction by the Civil Service in an effort to confuse, not to clarify. When it came as far as the city of Dublin, which comprises the vast proportion of the population of this country, he dismissed it with a brush of his hand and said it was too complicated to deal with. I simply made the remark when replying to him that I thought he had dealt rather casually with the city of Dublin. In the course of his further remarks yesterday evening before he reported progress, he promised, or indeed, might I say, he threatened, to deal with Dublin as he had dealt with the other constituencies. He stood up today to continue his reply, and he got back to Donegal——
Comment on this
(Cavan):——and did not mention Dublin. Yesterday evening I charged the Minister with introducing the Third Amendment for the purpose of gerrymandering, for the purpose of rigging our electoral laws and, with his majority in the House, of arranging constituencies to suit himself and to suit his pockets of supporters here and there in the country. I made that specific charge against him, and I based the argument in support of that charge on the fact that the Schedule to the Third Amendment, with which we are dealing now, contains no provision for a commission to arrange the constituencies. I challenged the Minister to explain to this House and to the country why he included in the Fourth Amendment a commission, with its shortcomings, to arrange the constituencies if proportional representation is abolished, and why in this Third Amendment he made no provision for such commission in the event of the Fourth Amendment being rejected by the people and the Third Amendment being carried. I accused him, and I accuse him again now, of doing it because he knows that with a tolerance of one-sixth, he will have enough elbow room to gerrymander the constituencies in a way that will give his vote much more strength than it deserves. The Minister tries to say that this Third Amendment is not an important one, that the change being made is slight.
Comment on this
(Cavan): If this Third Amendment is accepted by the people, it will mean that in one area 16,667 people will be entitled to have a TD representing them in this House, and in another area it will take 23,333 people to elect a TD. I say that is undemocratic and unfair. I asked the Minister to explain to this House why he would not entrust the arrangement of constituencies to a commission consisting of three Government Deputies, three Opposition Deputies, and an impartial, independent chairman.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am asking the Minister why he excluded that from the Third Amendment, and when I reminded him about it last night he said: “Why did you not ask me a question and I would have explained?” Today when he stands up his explanation is that the change proposed in the Fourth Amendment is more radical than that in the Third Amendment, and that is why they put the commission into the Fourth Amendment and did not put it into the Third.
The Minister knows perfectly well— and that is why he is delaying this Bill through the House—that the Fourth Amendment has no hope whatever of being accepted by the people, but he has some sort of vague hope that he might get the Third Amendment through and he wants to retain for himself with his majority in the House the right to gerrymander, the right to carve up the constituencies in such a way as to give himself and his Party far more representation in this House than they are entitled to. He wants by that measure not to stimulate interest in public life, not to stimulate political thought, but to kill it by this unfair gerrymandering of constituencies. He wants to ensure that after the next general election he will have such a majority attained in this unfair, undemocratic, and grossly dishonest way that he will drive people out of political parties and create here a one-party dictatorship. There is no fear of that if the electoral system is preserved as it is at the present time. There is no fear of it if the constituencies are fairly delineated.
I intend to hammer at this obvious attempt by the Minister and the Government to hold on to what I refer to as the Minister's safety value in the Third Amendment. He wants to retain to himself, with his majority, the right to arrange the constituencies, having given himself this one-sixth tolerance, which is entirely unnecessary and extremely dangerous, especially when in the hands of a political Party presided over by a ruthless, dishonest political boss in the person of the Minister for Local Government. I intend to hammer at this particular aspect of this Third Amendment because it is by far the most significant provision in it. If the commission had not been thought of, if it had not been mentioned, it would not have been so obvious——
Comment on this
(Cavan): I want the commission, shortcomings though it may have, to advise on the constituencies as they are to be arranged under the Third Amendment, with the Fourth Amendment defeated, as if they were to be arranged under the Fourth Amendment. I have got no satisfactory explanation from the Minister, nor has the House or country and I do not know whether the Minister intends to go on giving irrelevant figures——
Comment on this
(Cavan): I demanded that if you are dealing with Donegal, you should also deal with Dublin city.
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am commenting on the fact that the Minister dealt with the constituencies he wanted to deal with, the ones he thinks meet his case, but he has failed to deal with Dublin city. Instead of the Minister behaving as he is behaving and trying to put off the evil day, hoping that something will turn up to avoid the referendum, he should acknowledge the fact that public opinion has already rejected these measures and he should withdraw.
Comment on this
I wish to make just two or three observations on the Minister's very lengthy speech. In the course of that speech, I could only extract one sentence with which I am in complete agreement. He said that it was no part of the Government's or of Fianna Fáil's purpose in sponsoring the measure before the House to advance the political fortunes of Fine Gael. I am in complete agreement with that. Nobody but a fool would imagine that there was any purpose in bringing in this Bill in present circumstances other than to advance the political fortunes of Fianna Fáil. Before I make my other observations, I want to clear up one matter in order that it be put on the records of the House.
In the course of his observations, to which I took exception by way of interruption, the Minister stated that the judgment in the High Court, in regard to the further redistribution of constituencies before the next general election, came at the behest of Fine Gael. He had, I am glad to say, the grace to withdraw the word "behest", but at the same time he did suggest that because Mr. O'Donovan, the plaintiff in the action, and his solicitor, Deputy Ryan, were members of Fine Gael it was on behalf of the Fine Gael Party. I want to place it on record that that action was brought on behalf of Mr. John O'Donovan because of his own intellectual conviction that the Bill was unconstitutional, in which he was upheld by Mr. Justice Budd. He took the action at his own personal risk and if he had lost it, as a lot of people thought he was likely to, he would have had to pay the very heavy costs out of his own pocket. There was no question of Party funds being involved. He brought that action as an individual believing that he was right, and subsequently he was proved to be right, but he took it at his own personal risk and on his own personal conviction. Fine Gael had no hand, act or part in supporting him in that action by way of monetary contribution or otherwise. I hope I have laid that ghost for all time.
I listened to the Minister reading extract after extract from various speeches made by Deputies from the several Opposition Parties here, pointing out the infirmities of the Constitution which led to the difficult situation which then existed as a result of Mr. Justice Budd's decision. The Minister said that in introducing this Bill he was complying with the wishes of the Opposition Parties. No statement which he made in the whole course of his long statement had less grounds for validity than that. Everybody knows he is not bringing it in for that purpose, but, as I said, in order to further the political fortunes of the Fianna Fáil Party. I gather that he stated that he was complying with the wishes of the Opposition Parties in bringing in the Bill and his object in reading extracts from speeches made by Deputy Norton and others pointing out the infirmities which existed in the Constitution and pointing out that something had to be done by way of amendment to the Constitution, was to suggest that this Bill was in conformity with the wishes of those who objected to the provisions of the Bill and the problem facing them as a result of the judgment of the High Court.
As I understand the Bill, the very objectionable principle embodied in it is that certain sections of the community will, if the Bill gets the benediction of the people, have greater representation in the national parliament than other sections of the community. That is the fundamental principle: that is the objectionable principle. I challenge the Minister, with all his ingenuity, with all the resources he has and all the resources for misrepresentation at his disposal, to justify in any way the suggestion he made in the course of his speech that Deputy Norton, or any other Deputy who spoke in the way he quoted last night, in any way sponsored or suggested, or in any way gave their benediction to that objectionable principle. They pointed out that there was an infirmity in the Constitution as a result of Mr. Justice Budd's judgment, that there was a problem facing any Government in regard to the redistribution of seats. They never said that the problem was to be met in the way it is to be met in this Bill, giving certain citizens greater representation.
Comment on this
This is flouting the principle of one man, one vote. There is nothing in any of the speeches justifying the suggestion the Minister made. It was because of this that I rose to speak, to put this on the records of the House. I would agree that there was a problem but the problem was such that it was a national problem requiring national consideration and a national solution, by agreement, if possible. What the Minister should have done was to consult the various sections of the House and obtain their suggestions as to how the problem could be solved.
Comment on this
I would have thought that if the Minister were really in earnest in his suggestion and not merely making the hypocritical statement that he was complying with the wishes of the Opposition Parties, he would have consulted them beforehand and that the people in all Parties could have availed of their intellect and experience in obtaining an agreed solution of that undoubted problem. We are faced now with this Bill which embodies that objectionable principle and it is wrong to suggest that the Opposition Parties were in agreement with that principle or that it was to comply with those wishes that this objectionable principle was embodied in the Bill. I would have thought that consultation between the Parties was more desirable than ever in a Bill of this kind. There was undoubtedly a constitutional infirmity to be solved and what the Government should have been doing was finding out the best way of solving the problem and not adopting the procedure which they have adopted of bringing in this measure, intending to put the Bill through by their majority, without consultation with any of the Parties because their political interests might be affected by the embodiment of this objectionable principle.
Deputy Fitzpatrick in the course of his observations, to which I listened last night, made charges—undoubtedly they were well-founded—that the purpose of the Bill was to advance the political fortunes of Fianna Fáil and that the really objectionable feature of the Bill, apart from the fundamental objection to its principle was that, if the Government were fortunate enough, —we would say, unfortunate enough, from the national point of view—to get this measure enacted, then they would be in a position to rig the constituencies in their own favour and they would undoubtedly do so. While I agree with what Deputy Fitzpatrick said, I should like to put the matter on a more general and a sounder basis; I would say that no parliament should put into the hands of any government the powers that are enshrined in this Bill because no government should be put in the position of being tempted to rig constituencies. I am not enough of a hypocrite to say that, if Fine Gael were in office, we would not attempt to rig the constituencies; we should be less than human if we did not. Undoubtedly any government, faced with such a temptation, would naturally and inevitably endeavour to rig constituencies, within the law, of course, in their own favour.
Those are powers that ought not to be given to any government as a matter of high principle, high principle with which this Government in office at the moment is in no way concerned. That is what I object to; the powers in this Bill should not be given—first of all, to give people greater representation in the national parliament, abolish the principle of one man, one vote, and also facilitate, in order to achieve political advantage over political opponents, the power, the undoubtedly unjust and irrational power, of rigging constituencies in their own favour.
These are the main objections I have to this Bill. I mentioned them in the course of the speech I made on Second Reading. I referred to what is known in America as the "cow vote" and to the fact that what is endeavoured to be done here failed to be achieved in the United States of America.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Fianna Fáil introduced the cows but they did not provide a market for their milk. That is where they slipped up.
Comment on this
I should like briefly to reject the attempt made by Deputy Costello to interpret my late father's speeches.
Comment on this
I do not think any of us can say now what opinions my father, if he were alive, would hold today. We can only project what we think he might think. I certainly know that my father regarded this action by Senator O'Donovan as a mistake and he thought it would give rise to more problems that it would solve. Actually that seems to be the position now and I should like to put that on record. As a Deputy who represented a rural constituency and who had the interests of rural constituents at heart, he would not like the problems of rural constituents swamped in this House by the problems of urban-oriented Deputies; that is the position in which my father was, and I am sure that he would look with favour on a Bill which gives tolerance to rural areas and anyone who thinks otherwise is less than fair. We should speak for ourselves and not indulge in interpretations of speeches made by people who are no longer here.
Now, much as I dislike interpreting Deputy Costello, or anyone else, I cannot sit here and listen to people trying to lend the cloak of respectability to their arguments. If Deputy Costello wants to quote, then he should have his facts right. I was not here during the whole of yesterday. Perhaps the Minister explained why he chose to base seats on the basis of population rather than on the basis of the electorate, but, looking at the answer to a reply given to a question put down by Deputy Collins, it would appear that, had this been fixed on the basis of the electorate, only 19 constituencies would have been affected by the 5 per cent tolerance, which was acceptable to Mr. Justice Budd, but, on the basis of population, 24 constituencies would be affected and it would obviously be much better if the basis had been fixed on the electorate. Would the Minister like to explain the reason for choosing population rather than the electorate?
Comment on this
When the Bill of 1961 was going through this House, Deputy Corish mentioned my constituency and instanced the fears he had at that time of the results of carving up portions of three counties. I can assure the Deputy his fears at that time have been fully justified. Remembering the shifting of population that has taken place since then, that change in the population means that every constituency requires revision. I know from my own experience that the people in Westmeath and Meath feel out of it to a certain extent. Most people would prefer to have this fixed on a county basis or on an administrative area basis. My opposite number in Fine Gael seems to have given up the ghost and handed over to Deputy L'Estrange.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There is some talk of the Deputy moving into Meath. Is there any truth in that?
Comment on this
I know that Labour actually published a notice that the Senator in that area was to look after Westmeath. The question is: should this situation be allowed to occur in every constituency? My advice is that we should have some consideration for the people and give them the proper tolerance. It is not a very big one, but it is a fair margin and it would obtain in a number of constituencies. It is a tolerance which would give the people the chance of keeping within recognised units. The single-member constituencies would be the ideal. I know that from experience because I live in the exact centre of the constituency I represent, Meath, Westmeath and portion of Kildare. I am quite close to everybody. In the multi-seat constituency, a representative could be living miles away and he could never be truly representative of his whole constituency and portions of his constituency would inevitably be neglected. A typical example was the question in the last election of who would be the candidate for Longford-Westmeath. When I was going around the constituency meeting delegates, I found that it was very difficult to get them to talk about their own candidature; they were more concerned about the Longford-Westmeath position.
I would implore the Opposition to think twice about what they are doing in opposing tolerance and the single-member constituency. I would ask them to give the people a chance to have administrative areas, such as county council areas. Otherwise, these areas will be neglected. There is sitting beside me here a colleague who is in much the same boat as I. I imagine the position in Waterford would be the same as in my constituency. If my colleague had not been elected there, that area would be completely neglected and the people there would have nobody to look after them. The people have been used to administrative areas such as county council areas and like to have their TDs and county councillors all in one area. It seems strange that in a local election a person would vote Meath or Westmeath while in a Dáil election he would vote Kildare.
Consider what would happen. We have seen from the reply to the question put down by Deputy Collins the number of constituencies that would be carved up. Kildare is but one example. There are others—Sligo-Leitrim, South Tipperary——
Comment on this
Why should that be? They are two separate counties.
Comment on this
The fact that it has been recognised——
Comment on this
We did not. Fianna Fáil have been in power for 20 years.
Comment on this
He is not the only one who has a colleague who is anxious to get rid of him, as you know—two colleagues.
Comment on this
With the tolerance, even some of those areas that have been traditionally dual county constituencies would be able to have their own representatives. Having had the experience of dealing with three counties in my constituency, I know how difficult it is and I also know the feelings of the people in these cut-away areas. They would dearly love to have county boundaries retained as far as possible. That is why I ask the Opposition to think twice about tolerance and the single-seat constituency and to give a chance to the people to elect their representatives on a county basis. If the single-seat proposal were carried, it would be possible to fit it into the respective counties but you would need tolerance in order that it would have a chance of working. Otherwise, there will be tremendous carving up. Mr. Justice Budd gave no great tolerance. In order to get 20,000 votes — the national average is 20,028 — there would have to be a great carving up and the people would not know how to get to their representative. The people should have the say and they should be accommodated. It is with that in mind that we are bringing in the two Amendments of the Constitution, providing for constituencies on a county basis and also that TDs will be accessible to the people they represent. In the case of most Members of this Dáil, the people do not travel that far in order to see them. A Deputy has to go out to meet his constituents at the far end of his constituency and must have a centre or office in these places in order to give his constituents an opportunity of meeting him. We are giving the people a chance to have a representative who is within easy reach of their homes.
Comment on this
The choice which the Minister is offering the country is whether we are going to change from having a democratic Constitution to a geographic Constitution. That is the simple situation. This is done and all these arguments are produced, as Deputy John A. Costello said and as everybody knows, without any of us here saying it, in order to buttress the failing popularity of the Government Party, to try to effect a rescue operation, not upon Fine Gael, but upon themselves.
From observation of the voting trends even in the by-elections which have been boasted of by the Taoiseach, by-elections which were due to the fact that, unfortunately, we lost so many colleagues in the last couple of years, it would seem obvious that the natural progress of events is reducing the strength of the Government Party and is making for greater strength in so far as the Opposition Parties are concerned. I shall not go into the reasons for that. It is, probably, to some extent true that there is a pendulum effect in operation in every democracy and a pendulum effect in operation in so far as every Deputy is concerned. I should like to bring to the notice of Deputies who have been talking in this House as if in applying their minds to this problem they were thinking about their own little corner, that membership of this House is very transient, that we live by the most insecure and casual of employments. There is no guarantee whatsoever of the three "Fs" for the TD.
Comment on this
This House is founded upon the principle of free speech and orderly speech and it is not for Deputy Booth, with his authoritarian mind, which may operate very effectively outside this House, to try to impose it on the Members here. Let him go and exercise that somewhere else. We will not have it here.
Comment on this
May I suggest that it is not in order to make a Second Reading speech on Committee Stage? We are now dealing with the Schedule.
Comment on this
I was saying that the mistake is being made that Deputies— not all of them but too many of them —are looking at this whole Bill and have looked at it entirely as it relates to their own personal positions. This is not as it should be. We are here tampering with the fundamental instrument of our liberties, the Constitution, which will affect not alone us for our short time in this House, and indeed upon this earth, but will affect the Irish nation for as long as it continues its existence, be that long or short. The struggle for the nation to continue becomes more difficult with each year this Government exist. Looking at it from the point of view of the general welfare and good, it seems to me there is inherent in the Schedule a departure from the principle of democratic representation, that is to say, all sections of the community having the right to equal representation in the Dáil based on their numbers, and with no section having advantage over another except in so far as they are numerically superior, that there are more of them in the country than there are of some other section.
That is the basis and fundamental of freedom, and when we depart from it, we are proceeding along a road which may well wind up with the absolute domination of our whole nation's future by a small power clique. That is the trend and it is something which should not be tolerated by Dáil Éireann. Tolerance, they call it. Tolerance, how are you! Tolerance for what? We are asked to vote tolerance for dictatorship, for single-Party rule. That is what is being sought here, not tolerance as between the west and the east of Ireland. We are being asked to tolerate something which is insufferable.
The Minister wasted the time of the House last evening reciting, if one is to judge by what one reads in the papers, what was said by former Members of this House. I have listened to Deputy Norton's attack upon Deputy J.A. Costello——
Comment on this
I was saying, when I was so petulantly interrupted by those in politics who are not able to take it but who are prepared to dish it out, that Deputy Costello, I would suggest to the House, is one of the outstanding statesmen this country has seen.
Comment on this
I always praise a good man and I always will. When you are as long a Member of this House as I am, maybe you too can afford to speak your mind.
Comment on this
I am glad I have excited some response from you and from those about you. If I can return to the subject matter——
Comment on this
You are trying to deflect my thoughts now. It seems to me that the whole exercise of this Bill and of this Schedule, to which I am addressing myself, is simply a stunt to try to save the political lives of many members of the Fianna Fáil Party who otherwise face a bleak prospect. It is an unworthy one. A comment was made about Deputies trying to get rid of their colleagues. I would not like to think that the Minister is trying to get rid of Deputy Burke or Deputy Foley. I think it would not become me to make an allegation such as that but there is a kind of appearance on it that he wants to get out of the same area as Deputy Burke.
Comment on this
I would draw the attention of the Minister to the fact that Deputy Burke and I have pursued a policy of co-existence for over 20 years, long before he became a Member of this House, and when he on two separate occasions sought to intrude upon our privacy, he was repulsed in two successive elections. Therefore, it cannot be said that I harbour any feelings of rejection as far as Deputy Burke is concerned. On the other hand, I would suspect that the Minister might have secret longings to see him relegated to some other area so that the Minister might gain a greater assurance of being returned here.
I see by the reports of the Minister's speech that he spoke about distribution and securing representation. It would appear to me that the principle is to secure representation for depopulated areas at the expense of the urban and built-up areas. In simple terms, that is nothing more than a robbing of Dublin city and county in the main and other cities and towns in order to create artificial TDs for areas where people do not exist. This may be supported by those Deputies who think that the Dáil is made for their convenience, and that the Dáil should be a kind of reflection of the physical configuration of the country, but that is not so. In these times—and let us endeavour to drag the reactionaries who are pursuing this line into the Sixties and Seventies—it is people who count, individuals. More and more and more they are counting. They used not to count of course when Government machines could deploy them at will to secure their own ends and marshal them in voting groups and blocks to secure the return of countless faceless men throughout the country. That day has gone. With the advance of enlightenment and knowledge, people are thinking more. It is the people who must have a say in the election of members of Parliament and every individual, whether he be a farmer, a farm labourer, a road worker——
Comment on this
—— a railway worker, a corporation worker, a worker in the motor car assembly industry, a building trade worker or a worker with his hands or brains, has an equal right to say what kind of Government we will have. This so-called tolerance seeks to rob him of that and create a special privileged clique, for no other purpose than to prop up in office a Government who are imposing themselves upon the people. Let me say this. No one enjoys a general election less than I do. I do not regard a general election as something to look forward to. I have had enough of them in my time to know that they can be an agonising experience, but my personal feelings do not come into it. A duty is imposed upon us here when we become Members of the Dáil. If we had a general election now or at any other time within the next 12 months, I have no doubt whatever that Fianna Fáil would not come back as the majority Party.
Comment on this
There was never a clearer indication that we would: six out of seven. We could not ask for better.
Comment on this
We know what Deputy Dowling heard in Garryowen and we are glad to see that he returned safely from there, because we look upon his misguided efforts with some degree of charity. It imposes a strain upon our charity, but from long association with my colleague in Dublin, I have charity to give away.
Comment on this
Yes, if you need some. Look at the last returns for the local elections. They tell their own tale. One is not usually generous with things like votes when the drum sounds for battle. That is natural enough. These disorderly interruptions have thrown me off the point I was making.
Comment on this
(Cavan): It is like a Fianna Fáil Party meeting at the moment. I hear they have been very stormy recently.
Comment on this
You do not see us staggering out looking haggard at night. We never have a vote of confidence in the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister has been sent in to hold this up until the row in his Party about the referendum is settled.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Minister promised that yesterday, and he is sidestepping it again today.
Comment on this
I am guilty of as much sin as any human being, not alone in the country but in Dáil Éireann, but I have never attended a meeting of the Fianna Fáil Party. At least that is a score on which I do not have to ask for Divine forgiveness.
I want to impress upon the Minister that he is not getting away with this pretence in which he has been indulging over the past several hours that this tolerance is for the good of the country. It is not. This tolerance, in inverted commas, which he talks about it simply tolerance of Fianna Fáil who, to my mind, do not really care about the people or where they live, so long as they themselves are in office, and the camp followers who will never be on the Front Bench, fondly though some of them cherish thoughts of such loftiness, know of course that their existence in this House similarly is predicated upon membership of the Fianna Fáil Party. It is a diminishing return because we are living in different times. Limerick was an indication of that. It is obvious that there is no support for this idea among the people. Unfortunately by even contributing to this debate, I am aiding and unwittingly abetting the Minister in his objective, which is to postpone the evil day. Therefore I will sit down and let the business go ahead.
Comment on this
I have been very disappointed with the contributions from the Opposition benches; yet I am not unduly surprised. Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy Costello are not people who indulge in abuse just for the sake of it. When they do indulge in abuse of the Minister, it is perfectly clear to me that their only reason is: when you cannot attack the argument, attack the character of the man or attack his motives. A clearer indication of a bankruptcy of ideas could not be given. The Minister has been criticised for his very long and detailed speech, but he has been most criticised by those who did not bother to listen to what he was saying, or who did not bother to try to find out for themselves why he was saying it.
Comment on this
(Cavan): We knew. He was passing the time until the Fianna Fáil Party made up their minds on the referendum.
Comment on this
I am making sure that the Deputy knows. He attributes filthy motives because he has a filthy mind. If he would confine himself to facts, he would be much better employed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): This Bill was circulated months ago and Deputy Booth had not read it up to yesterday.
Comment on this
If Deputy Fitzpatrick would kindly keep his mouth shut and listen, he might be better employed.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Does the Deputy assure me he has read the Bill? He had not read it up to yesterday.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Deputy has been given assurances time and again on numerous points and still has not accepted those assurances, I will not add to them.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The Deputy thought yesterday that there was a commission in it. There is not.
Comment on this
The trouble with Deputy Fitzpatrick is that he is either dishonest or stupid. I think he is stupid.
Comment on this
Deputy Dunne sickens me with his talk about faceless men. He is a typical example of a faceless man.
Comment on this
I know Deputy Dunne's technique. He accused me of trying to hit the headlines with something I said yesterday. At least, if I said it, it was in order. I do not try to hit the headlines by getting myself ejected from the House.
On the question of tolerance, I know this question of mathematical accuracy which Deputy Costello was trying to deal with. Let us get down to hard facts. How are we to get this absolute mathematical equality? Nobody has produced any answer there. It is a physical impossibility. It is also accepted in the Constitution that constituency boundaries must be revised on the basis of the population as ascertained at the last preceding census. By the time the results of the census have been ascertained and published, they are already out of date. Thousands of people have died. Maybe hundreds of people have left the country. Thousands of babies have been born. You will not get mathematical accuracy in 1968 based on the 1966 census because a lot of people have been born or died in the intervening period.
There is only one way to get mathematical accuracy, that is, by working on the electorate only, treating the country as one constituency and voting on a purely Party ticket and not for individual candidates. This is the system which has been practised in Europe and in many countries and which has consistently led to disaster.
Therefore, instead of dealing with high-falutin' theory, we are trying to deal with the hard facts of life, one of which is that there is a tremendous variation throughout the country in the proportion of those of the population who are electors. In certain constituencies, a high proportion of the total population are electors. In others, it is a comparatively low proportion. That is a thing which can throw out mathematical accuracy altogether unless you say that constituencies should be redrawn purely on the basis of the electoral list. I can imagine the howl that would come from the Opposition if we were to suggest any such thing. We should be told we were rigging the electoral lists, that we were bribing those employed to make up the electoral register.
It is far more fair to base the constituencies on the population and not just on the electors because those constituencies should stand for more than four or five years and, consequently, you are basing them not only on the actual electors at the time but on the potential electors, those who will be electors during the ensuing eight or ten years.
Comment on this
Suppose they go for employment to London or Birmingham or somewhere else in Britain and remain there for some time?
Comment on this
These muttered comments by Deputy Dunne are so typical of his deliberate ignorance of the whole problem that——
Comment on this
We are dealing, therefore, with the only fair basis of work on the delineation of the constituency boundaries, that is, the basis of the number of the population in the area. However, it cannot ever be, and never has been, mathematically accurate.
It has been said that the people have no wish for this Bill and, particularly, for the provisions of the Bill as set out in the Schedule. The whole issue is far too complicated for the average man-in-the-street to have any opinion on it, good, bad or indifferent. The average man-in-the-street certainly is not losing any night's sleep at the moment by reason of the extraordinary discrepancies between voting strengths in various areas at the present day.
I have not heard anybody in my constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown complain that he has not got enough Teachtaí Dála in his area even though, in that area, the electorate per Deputy exceeds the national average by 28.83. I have never met anyone in my area who feels himself in the slightest degree prejudiced by that.
Comment on this
Deputy Lindsay does not know the Party line. He does not know the Fine Gael Party line.
Comment on this
I should apologise to Deputy Lindsay. I should not blame him for not knowing the Fine Gael Party line as there are so many Party lines in Fine Gael.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Deputy Booth is thinking of the dog-fighting that goes on in the Fianna Fáil Party.
Comment on this
Deputy Lindsay has said the electorate do not feel in the slightest degree prejudiced if the number of people in their area exceeds the national average per Deputy.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Deputy Booth should sit down and let Deputy Norton get on with his amendment.
Comment on this
There are incredible discrepancies at the moment and nobody is worried about them outside this House.
Comment on this
I can assure the Minister there will not be another Mayo-man on his back in County Dublin.
Comment on this
The fact remains that nobody outside this House is at all disturbed by the fact that there are wide discrepancies in voting strength throughout the country at the present day because nobody feels himself adversely affected in any way. The only reason we on this side of the House are concerned about it is because we know that, in itself, it would be a breach of the Constitution if we were to allow it to go to another general election. We could not run another general election on that basis. It has to be altered whether or not we like it.
Comment on this
He agrees with us, then, that nobody feels himself in any way concerned about it but we are concerned about it on the constitutional issue. We must do it in some way. We must amend the whole procedure in some way so that it becomes workable simply because mathematical accuracy for any period is a physical impossibility. We have, therefore, suggested a tolerance of one-sixth up or down to deal with the changes which will undoubtedly occur from time to time.
Every sort of obscene motive is being attributed to us for doing this simply because there is no rational argument. Anybody who thinks it over quietly will find it obvious that you must have a certain amount of give and take to compensate for the different proportions in different constituencies of populations and electorates. You must make provision for migration from the rural to the urban areas and for changes in population, births, deaths and so on. We want a system which will give some stability in constituencies so that they will not be changed every five years. It is far better, if possible, that constituency boundaries should be retained for, I would say, up to ten years or more— the longer the better, because the longer the period, the more chance there is of getting a community spirit in the area and a proper relationship between the electorate and the elected representatives.
This is a matter that should be dealt with on its merits and not simply by ascribing dirty motives to the Government. It is an entirely destructive attitude on the part of those who say this Schedule is completely wrong and malicious and so on. If the Minister has challenged them before, I challenge them again now: can you think of any other way in which to consider a realistic basis of forming constituencies which will not be of a very temporary nature only? Can you think of any other basis which will take account of variations between electorate and total population? I certainly cannot, and I think the Minister was perfectly justified yesterday in showing what would happen in the main country constituencies if his proposal were defeated.
The urban constituencies are not as difficult in many ways unless you take them street by street or ward by ward. I do not think it will really worry city constituencies very much if there are slight alterations in their boundaries, nothing like the alterations in a country area, where a county boundary may be affected, because there is not the same close community spirit in any city as there is in the rural areas.
If the Minister is challenged to do it, I am sure he can do it, but I do not think there is much point in going through the various Dublin city and county constituencies, Dún Laoghaire and Rathdown, and coming up with a lot of absolute facts. That will not get us any great distance, but if the Opposition want it, I am sure the Minister would be only too glad to explain——
Comment on this
He says he will be very glad if you will tell us what would happen in the Dublin constituencies.
Comment on this
Here we have something which, to my mind, exposes again the incredible inconsistency of the Opposition. We hear them saying: "Let us get this matter to the country quickly; let the Minister stop talking." Now they are saying he should keep telling us what may happen, start going into suppositions. How does that affect the issue? The issue now before the House is whether or not we are to have a system whereby the proportion of electorate per Deputy shall be maintained with a certain latitude for tolerance of one-sixth up or down, over or under the national average. That is the only point at issue. Whether a bit of Rathmines goes into Rathgar or a bit of Rathgar slides into Terenure will not alter the situation in the slightest degree. It may be an interesting mathematical exercise, but if people are anxious to get down to the hard facts of what is before us, this sort of exercise is not very helpful.
I am satisfied that this is the only workable scheme which has so far been put forward. No workable alternative scheme under the Constitution has even been suggested in the vaguest outline and if the Opposition Parties are going to say: "This is damnable, devilish and malicious" and so on, let them, in the national interest, come up with some better scheme. Even Deputy Lindsay had to agree that the old constituency system at present required revision.
Comment on this
(Cavan): Does the Deputy approve of the absence of the commission from the Third Amendment Bill?
Comment on this
If we put it into the Third Amendment Bill and not into the Fourth Amendment, the Opposition would say it was done absolutely maliciously simply because we thought we were going to get the Third Amendment through. Regardless of what we do on this side, we are doing it maliciously, ignorantly and everything else. We shall not bother trying to talk sense into the Opposition.