We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an Tríú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Coiste (atógáil). Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Committee Stage (resumed).

Contributions 170–337 of 337. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 5 of 1968 ›

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Why not put into both Bills?

Comment on this

You do not, when legislating, put precisely the same provision into two Bills.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Of course you do. Will the Commission in the Fourth Amendment Bill operate for the business in hand for the Third Amendment Bill?

Comment on this

Of course it will.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You know that if the Fourth Amendment Bill is defeated, you have no commission.

Comment on this

They are both going through anyway.

Comment on this

You do not introduce something you think will be defeated.

Comment on this

You are doing it and you know it will be defeated.

Comment on this

We are not as stupid as Deputies opposite think.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Yesterday Deputy Booth thought there was a commission.

Comment on this

When I see the nature of opposition, I am damn sure we are going to get it through. Fine Gael have not been able to produce anything except two or three Deputies. The remainder of the Party are probably equally divided between those who are slightly against the proposal and those who are 100 per cent in favour of it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Tell us about the last Fianna Fáil Party meeting.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave's views will prevail——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I heard that the resignation of the Minister for Local Government was called for.

Comment on this

That is a bit drastic.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Could we hear Deputy Booth on the Schedule, as amended?

Comment on this

It would be drastic for the Minister.

Comment on this

The so-called Minister.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick said that the provisions of the commission should be in the Third Amendment Bill. I am quite happy to leave it where it is in the Fourth Amendment Bill, but if the Deputy thinks it should be in the Third Amendment Bill, he is perfectly free to put down an amendment——

Comment on this

Will the Deputy vote for it?

Comment on this

Was that a helpful or a stupid interjection?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I made the proposal several times and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick now has Deputy Booth's permission. It is very nice and kind of him to give it.

Comment on this

The procedure is that if the Deputy wishes to make an amendment he puts it in writing and there has been no amendment dealing with this commission put down in the Deputy's name, so far as I am aware. If the Deputy were really in earnest about this, I doubt if he would have hesitated for a moment to put down an amendment. Either it did not occur to him or he does not believe in it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not approve of the two Bills and I am pointing out the absence of a commission to demonstrate the dishonesty of the present Bill.

Comment on this

We all know that the Deputy disapproves of the Bills and consequently he has put down certain amendments. He has omitted making any amendment about the commission in this Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Will the Deputy vote for an amendment if it is put down?

Comment on this

I do not see any objection to it myself. I am absolutely certain that we should have a commission and that we are going to have it. I hope the Deputies will keep in mind that mathematical accuracy is a physical impossibility, always has been and always will be, except, as I have stated, under one particular system of the block party vote, which is an intolerable suggestion and which even the Opposition would not suggest for a moment. Therefore we have got to live with a certain amount of mathematical inequality. We have always lived with it, and no member of the electorate to whom I have ever spoken has felt in the slightest degree prejudiced or unfairly treated by the way this has happened, even though at the moment the variation from the 16 per cent up or down is 45 per cent up in Dublin county; it is 30.55 per cent above the national average in my own constituency, and nobody is worried about it. Here we are tidying up the whole thing, bringing it down to a compulsory 16 per cent.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy would not know. He never meets his constituents.

Comment on this

The sheer stupidity of a person like Deputy Fitzpatrick making such a remark passes belief. I know he is just trying to be rude. There are ways and ways of being rude, and a display of ignorance is not the best way.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): A slimy, oily way is more appropriate, according to the Deputy's approach.

Comment on this

I do not know whether Deputy Fitzpatrick ever meets his constituents, but I am not going to accuse him of it, because I do not know. I challenge the Opposition to produce any alternative in order to meet Deputy Costello's point that there has to be absolute mathematical accuracy and equality. Nobody on that side of the House has produced any idea for the very good reason that it is not physically possible. We have done the best we can, a workmanlike job, and I challenge anybody to do better.

Comment on this

I should like to stress the importance of having this amendment passed here in the House and carried by the country at large. I feel confident that the two Amendments will be carried by the people. We are dealing with the tolerance question here and I believe it will be carried because we in Fianna Fáil are united on this question.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Does that mean you are not united on the other?

Comment on this

We are united on both questions, but it is the question of tolerance that is in this amendment. We know that the Opposition are divided on this question 50-50 and therefore there will not be a united effort. The Deputies who have spoken over there are those who are opposed to this amendment. The Opposition Members who are willing to accept the amendment have not spoken here so far, and we should like to have their views on this matter. This question of tolerance is very important. It is important from the point of view of giving stability to the various constituencies throughout the country. It is also important from the point of view of ensuring that we shall have here an adequate rural representation.

Reference has been made to the principle of one man, one vote. Under the present system we have not got that. In my own constituency, there is a glaring example of this. The area of West Waterford that was taken into South Tipperary on the occasion of the last division of constituencies contains a population of roughly 11,000, in or about the population of the town of Clonmel. The area of West Waterford has a voting strength of roughly 7,000 and the town of Clonmel, with roughly the same population, has a voting strength of roughly 5,000. This is a glaring example, showing that the vote in Clonmel carries much greater weight than that in the rural area of West Waterford.

The stability of constituencies is essential, and I am very conscious of this, coming from a constituency which suffered under the last division. I know how the people of Waterford resented being taken out of their county and attached to the constituency of South Tipperary; and how they resented the fact that Waterford was reduced from a four-seat constituency to a three-seat constituency. If this tolerance proposal is not carried, they will be facing a further change. We do not know what that change will be, but yesterday evening the Minister gave us some idea of what may happen. He told us that under the Constitution the constituency of North Tipperary has not sufficient population at present to maintain three Deputies. This could mean a further division between South Tipperary and North Tipperary, and there is the possibility that on this occasion South Tipperary would be reduced to a three-seat constituency in North Tipperary and that Waterford could become a four-seat constituency with portion of South Tipperary added on. If that happens, I know the people of South Tipperary will not take kindly to it, and rightly so. I would not like to see it happen. I am sure Deputy Hogan across the way would not like it to happen; and I am sure my colleague, Deputy Treacy, would not like to see, for instance, the town of Clonmel going into County Waterford for election purposes.

This would be altogether undesirable and it is in order to avoid something like that happening that we are asking the House, and will in turn be asking the people, to accept the tolerance proposal we are putting before them in this amendment. A revision having taken place, it could happen that after the next census further revision would be necessary and we would have the ridiculous situation that the Deputies elected would not know where their future constituencies would be and that the electorate would not know who their future representative would be or in what constituency they would be for the coming general election. It is such a situation we want to avoid by having this proposal accepted.

I am personally aware of the difficulties of dealing with two county councils, and I am a firm believer in the retaining of administrative areas and county boundaries. I know how difficult it is dealing with two sets of county managers, county engineers, county medical officers and officials, down to the very bottom of the list. This situation can make the work of a Deputy much harder. The rural vote is an important one and I cannot see how the rural Deputies in particular are going to go back to their various constituencies and oppose this amendment. The people in the rural areas will not take kindly to it. They believe they are entitled to adequate representation here. The city Deputies may think they are courting favour with their constituents by opposing this but a lot of the people in the cities are first or second generation country people who have loyalties to their own particular areas and they would not like to see them denied the representation they are entitled to. I believe we will get both amendments because we are united on this and because the Opposition are divided.

Comment on this

Why not get it to the people then instead of talking it out?

Comment on this

It is you who are talking it out.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No, we only put up one speaker today.

Comment on this

We know what the people's answer will be. We have every confidence in them on this occasion. We want to ensure this stability in the constituencies and to ensure that there will be adequate representation here.

Comment on this

In view of what has been stated by some of the Opposition speakers, I want to express my appreciation of the effort the Minister has made in placing before the Dáil the full facts regarding this Third Amendment. On many occasions we have heard Opposition speakers stating that the Dáil is the place in which important matters should be discussed and that the Government should put their views before the people through the Dáil. We had the Minister yesterday going to great lengths to explain the very intricate problems in order to show up all the implications of this Bill. What did we get in return? Nothing but criticism from the Opposition benches for having done this. The pity is that public interest in the affairs of this House is not great and it is to be regretted that his speech will not be read by many people throughout the country. If every citizen who will have a vote in the referendum took the time to sit down and read through his speech, there would be no doubt about the outcome of the referendum.

Despite the lack of interest among the public in this, we believe, and I say this in all sincerity, that there will not be any great difficulty in getting this referendum through. We are the people who are putting it forward and it is up to us to explain it to the people. We have had nothing but negative criticism from the Opposition Parties. If they want to present a negative case to this amendment, by all means let them do so. We have a responsibility to the people and we are putting forward a proposal which we believe to be in the best interests of the people. We want the people to decide on this issue, and that is why the Third Amendment, and the Fourth Amendment, have been brought forward. I was very glad to hear Deputy Norton, on television last night, stating exactly the same thing. He is giving an independent view. As he is not now tied by the Labour Party, he can do so.

Comment on this

As the Deputy is by the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

He stated that it was his own personal view that the straight vote was the best system and the only system that could be adopted here. We believe that a tremendous amount of study and hard work will have to be done by us. The Opposition do not want the people to know what this is about. They want to finish the debate so that the people will not know what it is about and will be left in the dark. As they know from our performance in the past, we will not allow that to happen. We are interested in the future not only of the Party but of the country and of the people, whether they vote for us or not. It is only too plain that the only interest Fine Gael and the Labour Party Members have is in their own individual seats and positions and the future of their Parties. There has been an effort made on the part of some Fine Gael Members to oppose these two proposals purely for selfish reasons. That is quite clear and it is well known throughout the country. They could not deny now, if I put it to them, that the decision they made was defeated by one vote——

Comment on this

That is not right.

Comment on this

It is. I was informed by one of your members——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Tell us about the last Fianna Fáil meeting when there was a call for the resignation of a Minister?

Comment on this

That is absurd.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not entitled to perpetrate falsehoods.

Comment on this

It is my intention to place on the record of the House——

Comment on this

Falsehoods.

Comment on this

——that I have been informed by a well-known member of the Fine Gael Party that there was only one vote between them——

Comment on this

Name him.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You little rat, name him or shut up.

Comment on this

Name him.

Comment on this

I will ask him——

Comment on this

Coward.

Comment on this

I will ask his permission to name him.

Comment on this

Do not break a confidence.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy does not know the meaning of the word integrity.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy does not know the meaning of the word integrity.

Comment on this

I have heard Fine Gael spokesmen coming in here and referring in speeches to what they have been told in the corridors by members of the Fianna Fáil Party. I think that is all right but they never mentioned their names. It might be——

Comment on this

They invented it.

Comment on this

It might be breaking confidence.

Comment on this

Was it a casting vote?

Comment on this

No, it was no such thing.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy if I could use his name and he said: "Do not drag me into it."

Comment on this

Just a moment ago the Deputy said that he would ask the Deputy's permission to name him.

Comment on this

I will ask him again.

Comment on this

This is a contemptible performance.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not intimidate me.

Comment on this

There is no question of intimidation. We want the truth.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy fell into the bad books of the Minister for Local Government over the Party leadership and now he is trying to get back into his good books by licking up to him.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Molloy. Deputy Lindsay had better cease interrupting.

Comment on this

I will make my own speech.

Comment on this

Make it without falsehoods.

Comment on this

I am sorely tempted to mention the Deputy's name.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I defy you to.

Comment on this

I will not because he did not give me permission.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy knows that that is not true.

Comment on this

I have a personal letter here and I will read part of it. This is written by a parish priest——

Comment on this

Is the Deputy proposing to give the source of the quotation?

Comment on this

——the backbenchers did not want to risk the straight vote——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, Deputy Molloy has quoted from a written document and I submit that under Standing Orders it is his duty to give the reference.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is not an official document; it is a private document. He is entitled to quote from it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He is quoting from a document.

Comment on this

He said it was a parish priest in County Galway.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Perhaps he was writing to the Minister.

Comment on this

We know the Fine Gael Party are confused. Some of their backbenchers did not want the straight vote because they were afraid they would lose their seats.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I should like to remind the Deputy——

Comment on this

I am on the Third Amendment. They know in their hearts and souls they should be voting for the Third Amendment. We are putting proposals before the people which we know it will be difficult to get across to the people. We know how difficult it is to explain things to the people. We know there are still people who come into the polling station and want to give their votes to Mr. de Valera. That is why we are trying to raise the general standard of education throughout the country and that is why we have a very great responsibility in putting the case to the people through the Dáil. There are other ways in which we can do it and we will do it. We know Deputy Lindsay has given up hope of retaining his seat down in the West. He is fiddling around in Dublin and he may go forward for Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Molloy on the Schedule, as amended.

Comment on this

It comes very badly from absentee TDs to be running down the provision of tolerance for the people in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

To whom is the Deputy referring? Deputy Aiken? The Deputy had an absentee leader for 40 years in Clare.

Comment on this

Do I have to be interrupted by this absentee Deputy from North Mayo?

Comment on this

The Deputy is an offensive boy himself.

Comment on this

I would like to compliment the Minister on the time he took yesterday to put the full facts before us. If it is true that the west of Ireland is to lose three TDs, if this goes through, that might not concern very many people, but, if there are three TDs fewer in one place, there will be three added in another place. I know the progression. One can end up with a completely Dublin or Leinster-orientated East of Ireland Parliament and the rest of Ireland will be forgotten. Are we to arrive at a position when Ireland ends at Chapelizod? So long as I am alive, that day will never come. I will fight to the end to ensure that the people in the West, in the South and in Donegal are given proper representation here in our Irish Parliament.

Comment on this

I just want to say a few short words since the last speaker, supported by the Minister, has brought into the discussion the question of the Fine Gael attitude. I want to make it quite clear that the statement issued by the Fine Gael Party, after they considered this matter and took their decision on it, conveyed that decision accurately and there were considerably fewer members of the Fine Gael Party who had reservations with regard to that attitude than there were amongst the Deputies of the Fianna Fáil Party who voted for Deputy Colley as Taoiseach as against Deputy Lynch. I should like to make that quite clear for the digestion, in particular, of the Minister for Local Government and Deputy Molloy. So far as the Fine Gael Party are concerned with the particular measure before the House at the moment and with the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution, which we will be considering later, there is no doubt in the mind of anyone in this Party, and there need be no doubts in the mind of anyone in the country, that we are going to fight this tooth and nail and we are going to defeat it.

Comment on this

As I have said already today, I thought I had dealt fairly comprehensively with this proposal, but a number of Opposition Deputies have asked me to deal with other aspects of it, in particular Deputy Fitzpatrick, who has demanded that I go in some more detail into the position in the Dublin area. Deputy Fitzpatrick may not remember that I dealt with the situation in Dublin city and county as a whole and that I said it must be obvious, even to Deputy Fitzpatrick, who has taken no interest in the matter, that the ways in which the situation arising in that area could be dealt with were so numerous that there did not seem to be much point in my trying to go through all the different arrangements that might happen in that area.

I did, however, place on the records of the House the fundamental facts with regard to the Dublin area. I gave the House the total population in accordance with the 1966 census. I gave the total number of voters in the area in accordance with the 1967-68 register of electors. I showed Deputy Fitzpatrick and any other Deputy who wanted to know, and who was prepared to take the trouble of reading yesterday's debate, that, on the basis of total population, the minimum number of seats for Dublin would be 38, an increase of four, whereas, on the basis of voters, the increase required would be only two. I compared that with the situation in the west of Ireland in an area stretching from Donegal to Clare, including the province of Connacht, where, on the basis of population — which is the basis the Fine Gael and Labour Parties are determined to retain — there must be a reduction in the total representation of the area from 33 to 30, a loss of three seats, although, on the basis of voters per Deputy, the reduction should be only from 33 to 32.

The whole operation, therefore, of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties in opposing this amendment to the Constitution, which we are putting forward — largely, as I showed in response to the unanimous demands of the Opposition Parties in 1961—is intended to deprive the people in the western part of the country of two seats to which they are fully entitled, even on the most rigid interpretation of this famous principle of one man one vote. It is intended to do that for the purpose of giving to the urban area of Dublin an extra representation of two Deputies to which that area is not entitled in accordance with this principle. I surmised that part of the reason for this campaign was that Fine Gael Deputies from rural areas had lately shown a tendency of wanting to transfer themselves from their rural constituencies to the city of Dublin. Deputy M.J. O'Higgins is, we are led to believe, one of the four who have been mentioned in this regard. Deputy Lindsay, is, admittedly, another. There are also Deputy T.F. O'Higgins and, apparently, Deputy P. O'Donnell.

Having shown that, I really thought that I had dealt sufficiently with the Dublin area. There did not seem to be any point in going into the individual constituencies as they exist in Dublin at present because it must be obvious that those constituencies will have no further relevance if there is to be a revision of constituencies carried out now on the basis of the last census and on the basis of the Constitution as it is at present, that is on the assumption that this amendment will not be made because, obviously, the only thing that could be done in regard to the Dublin area would be to start afresh, to start right from scratch and deal with it in the new. There would be no question of a Dublin county constituency, Dún Laoghaire or Rathdown, Dublin North-East, Dublin North-Central, Dublin South-East, Dublin South-Central and Dublin South-West. These constituencies just will not exist any more. We will just have to start afresh and draw up a completely new system of constituencies for the Dublin area. As I say, there are numerous ways in which that could be done.

It appears to me that the first thing we would have to decide in regard to the Dublin area would be how that area will be affected by all the problems that will arise in the counties bordering on it. I gave some indication yesterday of what these problems are and indicated that the solution of those problems might very well involve some adjustments with the county of Dublin. That might be found to be — I shall not say the most satisfactory way of dealing with the problem — but the least unsatisfactory way, because, as everybody here knows, both Opposition Deputies and Deputies on this side of the House — only the Opposition Deputies will not admit it — the constituencies cannot be revised in a satisfactory way under the present system. Even Deputy Costello admitted that there was a "constitutional infirmity", as he described it here today. I am not going back on history. Deputy Hogan seems to be surprised that Deputy Costello said that but he did say it today, just a short time ago. It was admitted by everybody, he said, that this "constitutional infirmity" was there and that it was not a reasonable thing that the Constitution should require these injustices to be perpetrated on a comparatively large section of the community throughout the country as a whole.

I admit that this was rather surprising, particularly when we are told by other members of the Fine Gael Party that they are quite united on this matter and in view of the fact that Deputy Fitzpatrick has been for days here, both on the Second Stage and on the Committee Stage of this Bill, making it apparent that in so far as he was concerned — and he is supposed to be the spokesman of the Fine Gael Party — the present constitutional requirement is ideal, that it is democratic and that there is no need to amend it.

However, as I said, obviously, in dealing with the situation in the Dublin area, the first thing that would have to be decided would be, for instance, whether the situation that arises in County Meath could be best dealt with by an adjustment with the county of Dublin or in some other way and, of course, the situation that will arise in County Meath is something that cannot be postulated definitely at present because what happens in Meath is dependent on what happens in Louth and what happens in Louth is dependent on what happens in Monaghan and what happens in Monaghan is dependent on what happens in Cavan.

As I showed yesterday, nothing at all need happen in County Cavan, unless Deputy Fitzpatrick has his way and this amendment is not effected, because there is no reason whatever for any change in County Cavan as the number of voters in the county fully entitles it to its present three seats. However, the unnecessary situation that Deputy Fitzpatrick wants to create in his own constituency of Cavan, the disruption that he wants to create there, the butchering of the county boundaries that he wants to cause in Cavan, will affect all these other counties and will be a factor that must be taken into consideration in deciding on the revision of the scheme of constituencies in the Dublin area.

County Meath, as I said, may be affected either by having to receive a considerable portion of the population of County Louth or by giving a considerable portion of its population to County Louth. Again, it may be affected by receiving back from the Kildare constituency portion of the population of County Meath that was transferred to that constituency in 1961. Another way in which County Meath might be affected would be in adjusting the situation of Longford-Westmeath.

Nobody can say at this stage which of these situations will arise in the County Meath because it all depends on the way in which other constituencies are dealt with. One thing is certain, that there will be a problem to be dealt with there and one of the possible solutions of it would involve an adjustment of one kind or another with County Dublin, either by transferring part of County Dublin to a Meath constituency or by transferring part of Meath to a Dublin County constituency.

Dublin is also bordered by the County Kildare and the same thing may happen with regard to Kildare because, although the present constituency of Kildare is, as I showed yesterday, within the constitutional requirements, just as Meath is at present, and there is no requirement in accordance with the present Constitution to revise either a Kildare or a Meath constituency, still, because of what Deputy Fitzpatrick wants to insist on happening in Cavan, the constituency of Kildare may well be affected also by this unnecessary chopping and changing.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I thought the Minister rose to deal with Dublin.

Comment on this

That is what I am dealing with.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister is making a very good job of avoiding it.

Comment on this

I have to work into it, just as I had to work to Kildare from Cavan.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): An excellent job of avoiding. The Minister may have his own reasons.

Comment on this

The constituency of Kildare may well be affected by this and, in order to deal with the problem that is unnecessarily caused in Kildare, some adjustment between County Kildare and the county of Dublin may be unavoidable. So the manner in which the problem in Meath and Kildare will be dealt with will obviously affect the rearranging of the constituencies in the Dublin area.

The other county which borders Dublin is County Wicklow. As far as I can see, that is one of the counties that is likely — but not certain — to escape change on this occasion but, of course, not on future occasions.

Therefore, in dealing with the Dublin situation, you would, first of all, have to base our approach on some assumptions in regard to County Meath and County Kildare. Accordingly, no really definite indication can be given at this stage as to what would happen in the Dublin area, but the position there is that the population of the whole county of Dublin, including the county borough, is 795,047 people. That of course is the figure on which in present circumstances representation must be based. That figure includes new-born children as well as voters. It includes all children in the different maternity hospitals, on census night, whether or not they ever see Dublin again for the rest of their lives. It includes pupils in colleges and visitors in hotels. It includes aliens who have not got a vote here at all. All these people must be taken into account in determining constituencies at present.

That is what the Deputies opposite are insisting on. That is what we will let their constituents know they are insisting on before this referendum is held. That is the figure. In accordance with that figure, the Dublin area must get at least 38 seats. The number of voters there on the 1967-68 register is 446,781. On the assumption that the same percentage divergence from the national average of voters would be permissible as in the case of population, this would require a minimum of 36 seats, not 38. Deputy Fitzpatrick, who represents the constituency of Cavan, Deputy Collins, who represents West Cork, Deputy Hogan, who represents South Tipperary — all these people for some reason or other want to ensure that this area will be given two seats more than even the most rigid interpretation of this principle they have so frequently quoted requires.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We want to avoid gerrymandering.

Comment on this

For some reason or other they want to deprive the rural part of this country of at least two seats to which that part of the country is fully entitled, no matter how rigidly you interpret this idea of one vote equalling another vote in different parts of the country.

I think I know the people of Dublin as well as anybody else. I was born and reared in the city of Dublin. I am elected for a Dublin constituency. I have no hesitation in going to any part of Dublin city or county and saying to the people there that there is no reason why a Dublin vote should be more valuable than a rural vote. I know the Dublin people and I think they are prepared to accept that. The Opposition Parties have got accustomed to the idea of treating the electorate, whether a rural electorate or an urban electorate, as being people incapable of appreciating such things. We have not. We believe that they can appreciate this and that is why we continue to retain the support of the people. I do not believe the people of Dublin want to deprive the people of rural Ireland of a right to which they are fully entitled. I can well understand that Deputies like Deputy Lindsay who are in the process of leaving a rural constituency——

Comment on this

Will you be certain now?

Comment on this

——and coming to Dublin seeing an advantage in taking from the province of Connacht two seats to which it is fully entitled and bringing those two seats to Dublin.

Comment on this

The Minister's only worry is that Fianna Fáil will lose them.

Comment on this

If there are two extra seats in Dublin and two less in the west of Ireland, from which Deputy Lindsay is emigrating——

Comment on this

Migrating.

Comment on this

——then Deputy Lindsay's prospects of securing election in the new field in which he has chosen to serve are greatly increased. I want to point out that the figures show that this is an undemocratic thing that the Fine Gael Party and Labour Party are trying to do. I am quite confident both the people of Dublin and of rural Ireland will accept that.

If this proposal we are making that the maximum permissible divergence from the national average of one-sixth over or below is passed and if it were utilised to the maximum possible extent in the urban areas, the absolute minimum representation that the Dublin area could receive would be 35, which would be an increase of one. As I said, it is quite obvious it will not be possible to use this maximum divergence of one-sixth throughout the country as a whole, even if anybody wanted to. It would not be possible to do it because for one thing you have not got the population with that great accuracy. You have it only for certain areas.

Comment on this

It is not one-sixth. It is one-sixth above or below. That is one-third.

Comment on this

That is what I said. Even if anybody wanted to use the minimum population per Deputy in every part of rural Ireland and the maximum population per Deputy in every more urbanised area, it would not be physically possible to do it. Therefore, the likelihood is, at the very minimum, if this proposal we have is passed by the people, the Dublin area will have 36 seats, which is exactly the number required, based on the national average of voters per Deputy. Therefore this proposal will do no injustice to the Dublin area, for which the Deputies opposite in the Labour Party and Fine Gael Party express such concern. They say they are concerned that justice shall be done in the Dublin area. That is what they pretend. In fact, what they are trying to do is to ensure that there will be a differential in the voting power as between urban and rural areas. I have already demonstrated that. I know the Deputies opposite will try to conceal that but we intend to see they will not succeed.

I showed here that the percentage of voters in the population of Dublin North-West is 50.96 per cent of the population comprising the electorate there. If constituencies are to be as the Opposition want, if they are to be decided on the basis of strict equality of population per Deputy, this will mean that the number of voters per Deputy in the Dublin North-West area will be 10,206. I pointed out that in Donegal South-West the percentage of the population comprised by the electorate is 67.74. What the Opposition are trying to do is to arrange that there will be an electorate per Deputy in Donegal South-West of 13,567 as against 10,206 in the Dublin North-West area.

Deputies may try to do what they like here. I can assure them we will let the people know exactly what they are trying to do. In the county of Donegal as a whole, for instance, the percentage of the population which the electorate comprises is 65.1. What the Opposition are insisting on is that it will take 13,038 voters to elect a Deputy in that county as against 10,206 in the constituency at present described as Dublin North-West. The amazing thing is that Deputies opposite are trying to maintain this position, and they have the effrontery to say that they are doing this in the interests of ensuring that votes will be equal in all parts of the country.

The fact that Fine Gael Deputies are deciding to contest city constituencies instead of the constituencies that have elected them is one indication that officially, as a Party, they have decided to abandon the rural areas. It did not need Deputy Cosgrave's speech in which he indicated that it is now the policy of the Fine Gael Party to reduce the number of farmers in the country to one in every 60——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It was the Minister's policy that made this Bill necessary.

Comment on this

It is obvious that even if Fine Gael do succeed in eliminating all these family farms they intend to eliminate, those who will survive and eventually wind up owning farms with a minimum of 400 cows per farm will not be even a small percentage of the existing farmers, because few farmers will be able to acquire the capital necessary to equip and stock farms of that size. It is creating a new class of person altogether. However, I do not think that arises on the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister is having difficulty in finding words to distort adequately.

Comment on this

It is an indication of the whole attitude of the Fine Gael Party that in order to implement this policy, they have decided to try to retain the position which makes an urban vote of greater value in electing a Deputy than a rural vote.

I assume that when Deputy Fitzpatrick asks me to deal with the Dublin area he wants me to go through the Dublin constituencies as they exist at present and show what the position is. As I have said, the figures have all been put on the records of the House already. I know that the Fine Gael Party have been complaining about their lack of facilities for research. It may be that it was with that in mind that Deputy Collins was so kind as to arrange to have the figures put on the records of the House. They are there and available — they were given in reply to a question — to Deputies who want to know what the position is.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Minister is determined not to deal with Dublin.

Comment on this

No, the Minister will deal with that. I am pointing out that it is completely unnecessary and completely irrevelant because the existing constituencies in the Dublin area — you have a coalition now and surely you have not started fighting?

Comment on this

I am pointing out that the Minister will go on until 6.30 tonight and we will not be discussing this Bill tomorrow. The Minister is scared to death. He is scared after Limerick.

Comment on this

I would not like to see their lovely newly formed coalition breaking up.

Comment on this

The Minister is looking for an excuse. Tell the truth.

Comment on this

The constituencies in Dublin have no further relevance because it is obvious that the change of population in that whole area will require a completely new approach after we have decided how the area is to be affected by the situation arising in Meath and Kildare. However, since Deputy Fitzpatrick is incapable of reading the figures for himself and wants me to read them out specially for him, I will start off with the constituency of Dublin County.

In the constituency of Dublin County, the population, in accordance with the 1966 census, is 145,903, and the number of voters on the register is 74,600. In accordance with the High Court decision, such a constituency, if it were to continue, would have to have a minimum of seven seats allocated to it. If the constituency could be considered in isolation, which it cannot of course, the matter could be dealt with by increasing the representation of that constituency by two, by making it to a seven-seat constituency. That might be the simplest way to deal with it if it could be considered in isolation, which it cannot be because it is affected by all the other Dublin constituencies and by the situation in Meath and Kildare.

No one can say at this stage exactly what will happen in the constituency of Dublin County but I have given the figures to Deputy Fitzpatrick which he is incapable of reading from the Official Report himself. I have indicated to him that the proper representation of that constituency would be seven Deputies in accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution. If it could be considered by itself, it could be dealt with by taking those two seats which Deputy Lindsay unjustifiably wants to take from the Province of Connacht and giving them to the constituency of Dublin County as it exists at present, and no doubt we would have Deputy Lindsay contesting the constituency of Dublin County, and we would then have the benefit of two Mayomen contesting it.

Comment on this

The Minister could not stand that.

Comment on this

Somehow or other, I think we would have only one Mayo Deputy representing Dublin County as the result of such an election. That is the possibility, however.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What the Minister is afraid of is not two seats from Connacht but two Fianna Fáil seats. That is the trouble.

Comment on this

I know that in his search for a seat in the Dublin area up to now, Deputy Lindsay has not considered the constituency of Dublin County. I have indicated the position there and the possibility of an increase of two seats in that area, and it may be that he will now extend the scope of his investigation to the constituency of Dublin County. No doubt Deputy Clinton and Senator Rooney will welcome him as a colleague on the Fine Gael panel.

Comment on this

As warmly as the Minister welcomed Deputy Burke.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The people of Connacht do not want any more Fianna Fáil TDs.

Comment on this

The position in the constituency of Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown is that the population in accordance with the 1966 census is 104,582, and the number of voters on the 1967-68 register is 61,322. Obviously that constituency in accordance with the present requirements of the Constitution, if it could be considered alone, if it would not be affected by other adjustments in other constituencies, would be entitled to five Deputies.

In accordance with the 1966 census, the constituency of Dublin North-East has a population of 139,163 and the number of voters is 78,192. This is, as Deputies may know — particularly those Deputies who have investigated the possibility of transferring themselves to the Dublin area — a five-seat constituency at present. On the basis of the present population, like the constituency of Dublin County, it would be entitled to seven seats. This is another area to which Deputy Lindsay, the two Deputies O'Higgins and Deputy O'Donnell might direct their attention if this is not passed.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

What about George and Charlie?

Comment on this

I now come to another constituency which will not have the same attraction for Deputy Lindsay, the constituency of Dublin North-Central where the population in accordance with the 1966 census is 66,842 and the number of voters is 38,557. It is a four-seat constituency but in accordance with the High Court decision, the minimum population required for a four-seat constituency is 76,112. This is one of the constituencies that have more representation than is justified by the present requirements of the Constitution. It will have to be adjusted in some way. It cannot be adjusted by a mere reduction in the number of seats because there would be too many there then, for three seats in accordance with the High Court interpretation of the Constitution. Therefore, it must be adjusted with some neighbouring constituency. Obviously, this means, as I said already, that there is no point really in considering the constituencies in Dublin as they exist at present — the constituencies of Dublin County, Dublin North-East and so on — because they will be affected by a situation such as this.

The constituency of Dublin North-West as it exists at present has a population of 81,841 and has 41,715 voters. That constituency is a three-seat constituency at present. In accordance with the present constitutional provisions, it requires additional representation. It would be entitled to four seats as against the three there at present. If rumour is correct, I think that is one of the constituencies in which the Fine Gael migrants or potential migrants are showing an interest.

Comment on this

There is a Fianna Fáil migrant there, too, do not forget — Dublin North-West.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

Very much so.

Comment on this

Deputy Gogan?

Comment on this

There is somebody on his heels — and a Mayoman.

Comment on this

This constituency of Dublin North-West is entitled to four seats in accordance with the present Constitution. This will be based on a voting strength per Deputy in the area of 10,206 as against 13,567 in Donegal South-West — and this is the democratic principle that Deputy Dunne, Deputy Fitzpatrick of Cavan and the rest of them are trying to establish, namely, that it should take over 13,500 votes to elect a Deputy in a scattered and mountainous rural area and a bare 10,000 votes in a built-up area.

Comment on this

Constitutionally, the voting strength is not relevant.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the Fine Gael Party apparently agree with Deputy Ryan's contention that the trials and tribulations of a Deputy in covering his constituency from Rathmines to Kimmage are much more difficult and impose much more hardship on that Deputy than would be imposed on Deputy Harte in covering Donegal from the top of Inishowen down to Bundoran, or down through part of County Leitrim, which may be the position if this amendment is not effected. It may be for that reason that the Deputies opposite want to have a smaller electorate per Deputy in the Dublin area than in those much more easily worked areas of Donegal and Kerry, the idea apparently being that to travel in and out of the Kerry peninsulas and around the McGillicuddy Reeks and the Sliabh Mis Mountains is a much easier operation than this fearsome journey Deputy Ryan described to us that he has to perform in visiting his constituents and travelling from Rathmines to Kimmage.

The constituency of Dublin SouthEast, as it exists at present, has a population of 65.608 and the number of voters there is 41,013. That is a three-seat area. Marginally, it would be in excess of the permitted number of population per Deputy at present. Therefore, this would be one of the constituencies that require adjustment in accordance with the present constitutional requirements. The population, however, is not such as to call for another Deputy. Accordingly, it could be dealt with either by being added to a part of some other constituency or by part of that other constituency being incorporated in it.

The population in Dublin South-Central is 90,687 and the number of voters there is 53,295. That is a five-seat area. There would be surprise if this is one of the areas Deputy Lindsay has been investigating, because the minimum population required at present for five seats is 95,140. Therefore, this constituency would obviously have to be altered, either by losing a seat and having portion of the area transferred to some other Dublin constituency or by having portion of some other constituency added to it and retaining its present representation.

As I pointed out, the only realistic way to deal with the whole problem in the Dublin area would be to start afresh and to ignore the existence of any constituency whatever in the area and to start on the basis of the total population of 795,047 and draw up a completely new scheme of constituencies.

Dublin South-West has a population of 100,221 and the number of voters there is 58,097. This is a five-seat area. It is one of the few constituencies that are within the present provisions of the Constitution. Fourteen out of the 38 constituencies comply with the present constitutional requirements and this is one of them. It is not a constituency that can avoid dismemberment because of that because the constitutional requirements in the rest of the Dublin area will inevitably also affect Dublin South-West. The possible result may conceivably be that the journeys Deputy Ryan will have to perform in order to get from one part of his constituency to the other may be even more hazardous and make more demands on his stamina than his present stupendous task of travelling occasionally from Rathmines to Kimmage.

That gives Deputy Fitzpatrick the information he requires to visualise the position in the Dublin area, and the problems there will be in deciding on the new scheme of constituencies if this amendment is not passed. His idea of what may happen is as good as mine but, as I pointed out, he would, first of all, want to decide on how the situation in Meath and Kildare would be dealt with and work on from there. The fundamental thing about it, at any rate, is that this area as a whole has at present 34 seats. The western area of Donegal to Clare, including the Province of Connacht, has 33 seats. If the amendment we propose is not made, this area must have an increase of four seats and the western area must have a decrease of three seats.

However, if a revision were based on the number of voters, the increase in seats in this Dublin area would be two — not four — and the decrease of seats in the western area would be one — not three. The spurious claim of the Opposition Parties that their opposition to this proposal is on the basis of their desire to ensure that in every part of the country a vote will be of equal effect in electing a Deputy is shown to be a spurious claim by this fact, that what they insist on is that there will be two more seats than are required by that principle in the Dublin area and two fewer seats than are required by that principle in the rural area. It exposes this as an attempt by the Fine Gael and Labour Parties to deprive rural areas of the country, and the rural parts of Dublin also, of their due representation. This is a deliberate attempt by the Fine Gael and Labour Parties to perpetuate the injustice that resulted from the Fine Gael manoeuvre in the courts in 1961, to perpetuate that situation and to ensure for evermore that an urban vote will be of greater effect in electing a Deputy than a rural vote. It is part of a vendetta——

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it right that the Minister should refer to the results of a judgment of the court as perpetuating an injustice?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister has made no reflection on the judge. This matter has already been raised and the Chair has ruled that the Minister made no reflection on the judge and that he is in order in referring to that judgment.

Comment on this

He has now used the phrase "the injustice resulting from a Fine Gael manoeuvre in our courts".

Comment on this

That is right. There is no reflection on the judge. The reflection is on Fine Gael.

Comment on this

The reflection is obviously on the judge who became the subject of a Fine Gael manoeuvre and failed to administer the law as he swore to administer it.

Comment on this

Nobody suggested that.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister is suggesting it.

Comment on this

I did not suggest for a moment that the judge gave a wrong decision.

Comment on this

If injustice resulted, it was a wrong decision.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that prior to that Fine Gael manoeuvre in the court, this Article in the Constitution had been interpreted by the people who drafted the Constitution, by the Oireachtas, and prior to that interpretation which was extracted from the courts by this Fine Gael manoeuvre, it had been assumed that the phrase "so far as it is practicable" entitled Dáil Éireann to take such practical considerations as we have included in this Bill into account in deciding on the delineation of constituencies.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And the Supreme Court so held in 1961.

Comment on this

The judgment of the High Court was to the effect that the Article of the Constitution did not permit this to be done and as a result of that, as I have shown by quotations from many Opposition speakers in 1961, it was the view at that time of all sides of this House that this requirement of the Constitution which had now been interpreted by the authority which is laid down as being the competent authority to interpret, constituted an injustice on the people of the country. Deputy Costello here today admitted that. There was what he described as a "constitutional infirmity". He implied that there was some other way in which that could be rectified but he studiously refrained from indicating any way in which this injustice which the Constitution requires to be perpetrated on the people, can be rectified other than by giving the Oireachtas reasonable scope to avoid this injustice; in other words, by giving them reasonable scope in regard to the proportion of population per Deputy in different areas——

Comment on this

We now have the extraordinary situation that the much-vaunted Constitution of the Fianna Fáil Party is perpetrating an injustice.

Comment on this

That is correct, but not intentionally. That became obvious when it was interpreted by the High Court at the instigation of Fine Gael in 1961 and, as I pointed out yesterday——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, Deputy Costello is on record here today, and it was for the purpose of pointing out this clearly and without ambiguity that he rose, as saying that Senator John O'Donovan brought the case in 1959 or 1960 on his own and that the Fine Gael Party had no hand, act or part in it, either financially or otherwise.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I would not expect the Minister to have the decency to accept that.

Comment on this

No; I would not expect anybody in the country to accept it either. Anybody who thinks that a Senator of the Fine Gael Party with his solicitor, a Deputy of the Fine Gael Party, were acting as private individuals in this case is a simpler person than I would expect.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Honester.

Comment on this

I am afraid the Minister is inclined to judge people by his own standards.

Comment on this

I think it is natural to assume that since this manoeuvre was carried out by a Senator and a Deputy of the Fine Gael Party this was, in fact, as everybody said, a Fine Gael effort to establish this interpretation of the Constitution as the correct one. When the Constitution has been interpreted by the courts, that must be accepted as the correct legal interpretation of the words in the Constitution, although the Oireachtas had agreed down through the years——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deal with the case in the Supreme Court in 1961.

Comment on this

——that this phrase should be interpreted, as it had been interpreted up to then. Apparently, the Opposition are not satisfied with the system of election that will give some arbitrarily selected people as many as five, ten, 15, or 20 votes but in addition, they want to ensure for some reason that an urban vote will be more effective than a rural vote.

Comment on this

How can you make that out? It is ridiculous.

Comment on this

That is exactly what the Deputy is trying to do. He is trying to insist that it will take 10,000 votes to elect a Deputy in Dublin North-West and 13,500 votes to elect a Deputy in South-West Donegal.

Comment on this

(South Tipperary): Why not base your amendment on votes rather than population?

Comment on this

Deputy Norton raised that earlier and I shall be coming to it. This is a deliberate attempt to increase the differential in voting at present being made available to one section of the community. It is a purely sectional approach. It is a cold-blooded effort by the Fine Gael and Labour Parties to divide the country on the basis of the urban population versus the rural population. It is completely unnecessary, and we are quite prepared to justify this proposal of ours in the urban areas of Dublin, Cork, or anywhere else as well as in the rural areas because we know that the people of Dublin do not want to get specially-favoured treatment as compared with people in rural areas——

Comment on this

They want to be second-class citizens, is that it?

Comment on this

We know that the most they want is that a vote in every part of the country will be of reasonably equal value and that is exactly what this proposal will ensure, no more and no less. Nobody knows it better than Deputy Dunne and Deputy Fitzpatrick but, for base ulterior motives of their own, they want to deprive rural Ireland of the representation to which it is entitled on the basis of equality in the effectiveness of a vote in electing a Deputy. This is a deliberate attempt to perpetuate that situation.

Tugadh tuairisc ar a ndearnadh; an Coiste do shuí arís.

Comment on this