We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Tuarascáil agus an Chéim Dheiridh. Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Report and Final Stages.

Contributions 1–207 of 610. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 6 of 1968 ›

Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

Tairgim leasú 1:

I move amendment No. 1:

I leathanach 7, líne 38, "ag comhaltaíbh a cinntear amhlaidh a bheith i bhfreasabhra" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "dligheadh";

I leathanach 11, líne 7, "by members so determined" a chur isteach i ndiaidh "law".

This amendment arises out of amendments moved on Committee Stage by Deputy Fitzpatrick, which sought to secure that the three Opposition members of the Constituency Commission would be appointed by the Opposition Deputies from among their members instead of being appointed by the Dáil on nomination provided for by law. The Deputy stated that, while he accepted that the intention was that the Opposition should have the right to select three representatives on the Commission, he felt it necessary that the provision in the Bill should be amended to provide a constitutional safeguard for the Opposition of the day from the Government of the day who might, by their majority in the Dáil, secure the nomination of representatives unacceptable to the Opposition. While I could not accept the amendment which would provide for appointment of the Opposition members by the Opposition, for reasons which I have already explained, I suggested the Deputy's case might be met by inserting the words "by such members" between "nomination" and "provided" in the relevant subsection and promised to consider an amendment on those lines on the Report Stage.

I am advised the matter can most appropriately be dealt with by adding the words "by members so determined" in subsection 2. The official amendment, which provides accordingly, will require that three Opposition nominations will be made from the members to be determined by law to be in opposition and "by members so determined". I trust this meets the Deputy's point.

Comment on this

Do we understand that this proposed Commission, which, I am sure, will never come about, is to be set up and is to consist of seven members, three from the Government, three Opposition nominees and one independent? Am I right in that?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I should like, first of all, to mention that the debate on this Bill has served some useful purpose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not debating the Bill. We are debating a simple amendment.

Comment on this

We are debating the setting up of a Commission and the making available to the people of information. You, a Cheann Comhairle, will remember that on the last occasion on which we discussed these amendments, I mentioned the Minister's endeavour to stifle discussion when he refused——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on this amendment.

Comment on this

——to allow Telefís Éireann to have a discussion on this and the Telefís Éireann programme was changed to "Prices and Incomes."

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Murphy allow me to read the amendment to him, in view of the fact that he does not appear to have himself read the amendment?

Comment on this

We are speaking about the Commission.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Murphy persists in his attitude, I shall have to ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

No, Sir, I am in order.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not in order and he knows he is not in order.

Comment on this

How does the Minister propose to set up this Commission? Surely the establishment of the Commission can cover a very wide field in the debate——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise on the amendment.

Comment on this

——and the people should know what is happening.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is not a Second Reading debate.

Comment on this

We have Fianna Fáil changing their minds now.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must not continue along those lines. I must ask him to resume his seat. He is not relating his remarks to the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With great respect, he has not been long on his feet.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

He has been out of order since he rose.

Comment on this

Opposition Parties appreciate that, possibly at the instance of the Government, there is a move afoot to curtail discussion as much as possible on this measure, and I was just referring to their move in regard to Telefís Éireann and to the fact that they have changed their minds since we discussed the matter last week. I think it is no harm to put that on the record.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is completely out of order.

Comment on this

I do not know anything about Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

The Minister looks in only when the clergy are on television.

Comment on this

No: I never see them either.

Comment on this

I am reasonably well conversant with the procedure of the House, but we seldom or never had on Committee Stages of Bills passed so much interruption from the Chair——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy may not criticise the Chair.

Comment on this

This is a very wide measure.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not a wide measure. We are discussing an amendment which permits the Opposition to select their own nominee on the Commission. That is the only question before us.

Comment on this

I was just mentioning that it is a wide measure; it is a measure to change the whole system of election.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputy mention the amendment, just for the record?

Comment on this

Now, Sir, the Government will nominate three members of this proposed Commission, which, I believe, will never come into existence because, a Cheann Comhairle, I think it is reasonably well known that this effort on the part of the Government is futile.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy must not begin to ramble again. Would he keep to the amendment before the House? It is a simple amendment.

Comment on this

We know from previous experience that, so far as the Fianna Fáil Party are concerned, whenever an opportunity arises of constituency changes, they use it to the fullest extent possible.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise on the amendment. I clearly pointed out to the Deputy what the amendment means.

Comment on this

It is proposed to have three Government nominees and three Opposition nominees. Who is the chairman to be then? Will this Commission determine by majority vote? I understand, that if there is a failure on the part of the Commission to submit a report, the Chairman's report will be final and binding, so, to my mind, this Commission makes little difference because the Government of the day will have a majority vote on the Commission, and if we have three Opposition members and if they put forward suggestions, they can easily be outvoted. Seeing that you are rather impatient, Sir, I do not propose to hold you up on this——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is not impatient at all.

Comment on this

——at this time much longer other than to say that this proposal to my mind means little or nothing. Fianna Fáil are going to rig the constituencies.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This has nothing to do with the constituencies.

Comment on this

I have the greatest respect for the Chair. I know you know that very well yourself.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On the Committee Stage of this Bill, I referred to Article 32 which it is proposed to insert. I pointed out that the Bill as it stands is, as Deputy Murphy has pointed out, a very far-reaching measure which seeks to change the whole electoral system here from a multi-seat transferable vote system to a single-seat non-transferable vote system and that the Government, in introducing such a measure, appreciated that the electorate would regard it with great suspicion and would approach it with great care. In order therefore to satisfy the electorate that they had not as much to fear as might appear on the surface of the Bill, the Government included in the Bill this article with which we are now dealing to provide a Commission to arrange the new constituencies and indeed to arrange constituencies at 12 yearly periods thereafter.

The composition of this Commission is very important and it is laid down in the subsection that it shall consist of a Judge of the High Court or the Supreme Court, of three Members of this House to be nominated by the Taoiseach—I am not sure whether it is Members of this House or Members of the Oireachtas——

Comment on this

A High Court Judge is nominated by the Taoiseach as well. That does not get you anywhere.

Comment on this

He is not. Can the Deputy not read? He is not nominated by the Government.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Seven Members anyway. I am not too sure what “Member” means. I take it it is a Member of this House. The subsection provides that it shall consist of a Judge of the High Court or Supreme Court, three members nominated by the Taoiseach—we take it that they will be three Government members—and three other members who the subsection intends should be members of the Opposition and appointed by the Opposition.

I was not satisfied that the subsection as drafted ensured that the three Opposition members would, in fact, be members of the Opposition and, more important still, would be appointed by the Opposition. I put down three amendments, one dealing with the appointment of the Chairman, one dealing with the appointment of the Government nominees—and with these two amendments I was not really so concerned—but I put down a third amendment to ensure that the three Opposition members would be members of the Opposition and would be appointed by the Opposition. The Minister saw, I think, the force of the point I was making and he decided to consider it and he did introduce at this stage an amendment with which we are now dealing. When I first read this amendment, I came to the conclusion that the three Opposition members would be appointed by the Opposition but I am not satisfied that that is the case, having regard to what the Minister says. The relevant part of the subsection reads:

...and three shall be appointed, from such Members of Dáil Éireann as are determined in accordance with law to be in opposition, on nomination provided for by law.

I thought that "by members so determined" might refer to the appointment and indeed, I think it is open to that interpretation, but the Minister obviously has put the other interpretation on it, that they shall be appointed by Dáil Éireann. One would need to read the whole section. It says:

A Constituency Commission shall consist of seven members appointed by Dáil Éireann...

Yes. I think it is clear now when you go back to that part of it that the three Opposition nominees are also to be appointed by the entire Assembly here. I still think that this is not adequate to ensure that the three members representing the Opposition will in fact be members acceptable to the Opposition. I concede that the four words added by the Minister in response to the point raised by me and in response to the amendment put down by me appear to improve the position considerably. If I am satisfied that these three members can only be appointed by the Dáil on the nomination of the Opposition and that the Opposition will have the right to the nomination as determined by law, will have the right to nominate three members and submit them to the House and that the House will not have the right to appoint anybody to represent the Opposition other than these three members, then I think that the amendment goes a long way to meet my point.

As I say, I am satisfied that the subsection as it stands still means that the seven members, including the Chairman and the three members representing the Government and the three Opposition members, will be appointed by the entire House. I hope that the subsection means, and I confess I think it does, that the judge to be appointed by the House to act as Chairman must be a judge nominated by the Chief Justice and that the three members, who, I take it, are intended to represent the Government side of the House must be three members who are nominated by the Taoiseach and that, in the unlikely event of this measure becoming law, it would be necessary to introduce a Bill to provide machinery to decide what Members of the House would be regarded as the Opposition and that having introduced that machinery and decided what Members of the House would be regarded as the Opposition, those Members would, when the occasion arose, meet and select presumably—it would be their own fault if they did not—three Members from among themselves and submit that those three would then be submitted to the House as the nominees of the Opposition to serve on this Commission and that the House could not appoint anybody else. If that is the correct interpretation of this subsection, and I think it is, then I say it is satisfactory enough.

Deputy M.P. Murphy rose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I must point out to Deputy Murphy that this is the Report Stage. Deputies may speak only once.

Comment on this

Sorry: I was about to say that I listened to Deputy Fitzpatrick——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have an opportunity on the Fifth Stage.

Comment on this

Excuse me: I overlooked the fact that we were not in Committee.

Comment on this

Sé an rud atá ag déanamh tinnis domhsa maidir le leasú mar seo ná cé hé an Freasúra sa Tí seo agus conas a socrófar na difríochtaí atá eatorthu nuair a thiocfaidh an tráth chun na daoine d'ainmniú ar an gCoimisiún seo. Tá mé ag éisteacht leo le cúpla mí anuas agus deallraíonn sé domhsa gur dream do-shásta iad. Ní bhaineann sé linne pé rud a dheineann siad le chéile. Is léir go mbeidh drochfhuil eatorthu agus go mbeidh sé ina chogadh eatorthu.

Comment on this

A leithéid de ráiméis níor chuala mé riamh.

Comment on this

Ní thuigeann tú é.

Comment on this

Go deimhin, tuigim.

Comment on this

Is trua liom, a Cheann Comhairle——

Comment on this

Nach fíor é go bhfuil na difríochtaí seo eadraibh?

Comment on this

An bhfuil tú cinnte?

Comment on this

Tá, agus idir lucht na bPáirtí féin.

Comment on this

Is trua liom go léiríonn an Teachta O'Connell an cineál béasa atá aige nuair a chuireann sé isteach ar dhuine nár chuir isteach air riamh.

Comment on this

Níor chuala mé riamh thú ag caint.

Comment on this

Tá an rud seo ar siúl aige ón lá a tháinig sé isteach sa Tí. Ba chóir ciall a bheith aige. Ba chóir dó a mhíniú, in ionad bheith ag cur isteach orm, na difríochtaí atá idir an dá aicme. Ba mhaith liom tagairt phearsanta a dhéanamh don rud a adubhairt an Teachta——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is this a personal statement?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tá an Teachta Ó Ceallaigh in ordú.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is this relevant on this amendment? I submit it is not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Tá mé ag rialú go bhfuil an Teachta in ordú ar an leasú.

Comment on this

Tá sé ag tagairt don Fhreasúra agus conas a ainmneófar na daoine atá san bhFreasúra.

Comment on this

Is annamh a chuirim spéis i——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This has nothing to do with the amendment, good, bad or indifferent.

Comment on this

Tá mé lán-tsásta le leasuithe an Aire. Is dual dó, ó thosach, bheith macánta.

Comment on this

Tá cúpla pointe go mba cheart dom tagairt a dhéanamh dóibh. Maidir leis an bhFreasúra, mar adubhairt mé, caithfear na daoine atá san bhFreasúra a léiriú i mBille speisialta a tabharfar os cóir na Dála. Tá a fhios agam go bhfuil na difríochtaí so eatorthu ach sin fadhb nach foláir dóibh féin a réiteach.

I do not know whether Deputy Fitzpatrick, in fact, is accepting or is agreeing with this amendment or not but the only purpose in bringing it in is to meet the point that Deputy Fitzpatrick raised in so far as it can reasonably be met. Deputy Fitzpatrick says that this does not mean that people will be appointed by the Opposition and, of course, that is so; they will not be formally appointed by the Opposition but I pointed out on Committee Stage that it is essential that the whole Commission should be appointed together, that is, should be appointed at the same time but, in fact the Dáil will not have any discretion in regard to the members to be appointed. It is clearly laid down that the Chairman shall be appointed from the judges of the Supreme Court and the High Court on the nomination of the Chief Justice, that three shall be appointed from the Members of Dáil Éireann on the nomination of the Taoiseach and now that three shall be appointed from such Members of Dáil Éireann as are determined in accordance with law by members so determined to be in opposition. In other words, it is quite obvious from the subsection that these three members that we are dealing with now must be nominated by members who are determined by law to be in opposition and that the Dáil merely performs the formal act of appointing the seven members nominated in the manner laid down in this subsection.

Comment on this

And who is going to nominate the three Opposition members?

Comment on this

I have explained that two or three times already.

Comment on this

Explain it again, please.

Comment on this

I have apparently failed to explain it to Deputy Murphy. I plead incompetence to explain it to Deputy Murphy. I do not think it is possible.

Comment on this

Do we take it that any Member of the House who is not a member of the Government Party is, in fact, a member of the Opposition?

Comment on this

A Bill will have to be introduced here to provide a method of determining who is in Opposition and who is not and also to provide a manner in which those members so determined to be in Opposition will decide on the nomination of three people to this Commission.

As I say, the only reason for proposing this amendment is to meet Deputy Fitzpatrick's point. I do not know whether it suits him or not. It is immaterial as far as I am concerned because the intention is, at any rate, to provide by law that this will be done and it is merely to meet Deputy Fitzpatrick's point that it is now being inserted in the Constitution. I do not see any real need for it, since the law will provide for it at any rate, but it is there. If it suits Deputy Fitzpatrick, that is all right, and if it does not, I do not mind. Deputy Fitzpatrick is right that when the referendum is passed, the Bill will be——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That will be the day that will never come, a Bill you will never see.

Comment on this

Early in the next session.

Cuireadh agus d'aontaíodh an leasú.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Murphy's remarks will be relevant on the following Stage.

Comment on this

I resent that reminder from the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There can be no discussion on this Stage.

Comment on this

I have been a Member of this House since 1951 and am reasonably conversant with the procedure, and I have never yet heard the Chair advise a Deputy on rising to speak as to how he should address his remarks.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I want to point out to Deputy Murphy that what he is going to say will be relevant on the next Stage.

Comment on this

I resent your advice.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should welcome it.

Comment on this

The Chair has no function in this matter to advise me as to what remarks I should make.

Cuireadh agus d'aontaíodh an cheist.

Comment on this

On this question, there is procedure laid down here for every Member of the House and I am most surprised at the remarks of the Chair and repeat that I resent such remarks. Earlier on, when Deputy Fitzpatrick was commenting on the advantages of the Minister's amendment, I was rather surprised that Deputy Fitzpatrick should be such a simple man. I would be the last person in the House to regard him as such a simple man as to accept there is anything in this section as far as the Commission is concerned. This Commission was not included in previous measures. Everyone knows it was included in this measure to give a nice coating to it. The Commission means nothing. It will give Fianna Fáil an opportunity during the election campaign to tell the people: "If the straight vote is adopted, we have enshrined in the Bill that an independent Commission, consisting of three members nominated by the Government and three nominated by the Opposition, with an independent chairman, will arrange the constituencies." That may go down well with people who do not understand what is behind the Fianna Fáil mind. There are seven members on this commission. It is clearly set out in the Bill that, if there is disagreement, the chairman will have the right to submit within four months a report as to how he thinks the constituency should be divided, and that report is binding. I do not want to reflect on anyone, but I am quite satisfied that, irrespective of how this Commission is established, it will be completely under the control of the Government because they are bound to have at least four supporters on it.

Let us hope that what is in the Bill and what is not in the Bill will not matter. I will repeat that what is in this Bill is an endeavour to keep Fianna Fáil longer in office than the people want them. Fianna Fáil are not satisfied with the present electoral system. They feel they are on the way out and that, if they can get the people to change the electoral system, they may be able to hold office a little longer. I have no doubt the people will be wise enough when it comes to voting on this referendum. This proposal will not be defeated by 33,000 odd votes as was the referendum in 1959. I venture to prophesy it will be defeated by 133,000 votes. Then the capital expenditure of £100,000 plus hundreds of thousands in incidental expenses will have gone down the drain and we will be back to where we started, with a loss of valuable time by this House, by State officials and by all concerned.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Broadly speaking, the Bill we are now asked to pass contains two proposals. One is a proposal to establish single member constituencies. The second is to abolish the peculiarly Irish system of proportional representation, which has served this country efficiently, effectively and fairly since the foundation of the State, and to replace it by a system known as the straight vote or more technically and properly described as the spot vote. This Party are entirely against these two proposals. In my opinion, neither the Minister nor the Government have any mandate from the people to put the country to the expense of a referendum which is estimated to cost between £100,000 and £150,000 to decide the issue.

Comment on this

What about the incidental expenses? That is just the expenditure by the State.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Exactly. This Government have no mandate to do that. This Government were elected in 1965 having obtained approximately 47 per cent of the votes cast and 50 per cent of the seats. It was elected then as a minority Government. During the campaign conducted on behalf of the Fianna Fáil Party before the last election there was not one solitary word spoken about the proposal which has wasted the time of this House for several months past, which is going to throw the country into political uncertainty for the next six months and which is going to cost, as I said, £150,000. There was not one syllable of that spoken in the Fianna Fáil election campaign. Furthermore, if the Government had attempted to introduce this Bill as one of their first measures after their election in April, 1965, they would have been decisively defeated in this House.

Comment on this

What about the by-elections?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is my next point. They would have been decisively defeated, the people would have been spared the cost of £150,000 and the time of this House would have been better occupied in dealing with matters of national importance the people required attended to. As Deputy Cunningham has remarked, what about the by-elections? What has happened in this country since 1965 to give Fianna Fáil a mandate to introduce this measure about which they never spoke a word in the last general election? I want to tell Deputy Cunningham what has happened.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

On this stage I wish to draw the Deputy's attention to the fact that what we are debating is just what is in the Bill and irrelevancies cannot be introduced.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): With respect, Sir, I accept that principle. I am saying I am disagreeing with what is in the Bill and I am putting it forward as an argument that the Government have no mandate to introduce it. With the greatest respect, I say I am within the confines of order on this Stage.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Except in so far as by-elections are not concerned at this stage.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): My next few sentences are calculated to establish that the Government know they have not got a mandate and that the by-elections did not give them a mandate and did not alter the position since the last election. I do not intend to deal with it in detail. Deputy Cunningham posed the question: “What about the by-elections?” I pose the question——

Comment on this

I take it I can deal with the by-elections, Sir?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have already said by-elections are not in order.

Comment on this

I love dealing with those by-elections.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not want to quarrel with the Chair's ruling, but if I can establish to the House that this Government have no mandate from the people to put them to the expense of £150,000 by introducing what is contained in this Bill, I submit, with the greatest respect, I am in order. All I want to say is this. Through accidents of fate, by-elections occurred in certain constituencies which favour the Government. Notwithstanding that they occurred in these constituencies, the Government won them on a declining vote, demonstrating to the Government that the people were turning against them and prompting the Government and the Fianna Fáil Party to change the electoral law to cope with that fall in favour which the Government admits——

Comment on this

I can deal with the Deputy's assertion that the by-elections occurred in constituencies favourable to the Government, if the Deputy wishes.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have already pointed out that discussion on by-elections is not in order and that what is before the House is just what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I claim the right to reply to what the Deputy has been saying about the by-elections.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall leave the by-elections by saying that the Government vote went down all over the place and, taking the by-elections as half a dozen plus one, while they won six of them, their prestige was walloped in every one of them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy realises that what is before the House at this stage is the question of the straight vote.

Comment on this

Is that a definitive definition?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

And the single-member constituencies—what is in the Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I have said all I wanted to say about by-elections. It is clear that the Government had no mandate after the last general election. They always talk about putting policies before the people at a general election. Where did they put this policy before the people at the last general election? I am against the straight vote because it is undemocratic and can work to put into office a Government who have not the support of the electors. In order to demonstrate that, I propose to take a constituency with an electorate of 10,500 because that is a number that has already been taken by the Minister. If one candidate gets 4,000, another 3,500 and another 3,000 votes, the candidate with 4,000 votes gets the seat, although he has got 1,000 votes less than half the votes cast, 1,500 less than half the votes cast, and although it is almost manifestly——

Comment on this

That is not right either.

Comment on this

The Deputy has his figures a little tangled.

Comment on this

I think you can get the message anyway.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Have I got the message across to Deputy Booth?

Comment on this

I think I know what it means but it does not make sense even then.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to show that the candidate with 4,000 votes has nothing like half the votes. Yet he gets the seat just as the Fianna Fáil candidate would have got the seat in Wicklow, although that candidate did not secure a majority of the votes or anything like it.

Comment on this

It would be much fairer than that the fellow with 3,500 votes should get the seat.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It would be much fairer if all votes became effective. The Minister has been arguing that if the votes of candidate C with 3,000 has his second preferences counted, there is no reason why the second preferences of candidate A with 4,000 should not be counted. The Minister knows that is absurd. What PR means is that a person's vote should become effective, that it should be used on until he either backs the winning candidate or is fighting the winning candidate face to face. That is what PR does. It operates to make the vote effective and in that respect it is fair.

Comment on this

That is what I proposed and the Deputy would not support me.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): One thing strikes me about Deputy Norton. I sympathise with him that he had a little mishap through no fault of his own last week when his amendment was taken at a time when, apparently, he did not expect it and was not here to move it. What amazes me is that I opened my post yesterday morning and again this morning expecting to see that Deputy Norton in his enthusiasm would have made good the trick the Minister played on him last week by putting down his amendment on Report Stage today, as he was perfectly entitled to do. Then he could have moved it and spoken on it for two hours. But I cannot understand the Deputy's attitude, his enthusiasm for this amendment and his apparent anxiety to force it on all and sundry and his accidental absence when it was taken on Committee Stage and his failure to make good that omission by putting down the amendment on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I shall explain that in a few minutes.

Comment on this

We shall await the explanation with great interest.

Comment on this

I expect you await all my speeches with great interest.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): They will become fewer.

Comment on this

That is merely wishful thinking.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): When the Deputy is endeavouring to project himself as a national figure——

Comment on this

I never used those words. The Deputy may get that impression.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——and when he has a platform, he should use it.

Comment on this

I never said that. I am sorry if I gave that impression.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I intend to conclude this speech——

Comment on this

Before the Deputy does so, would he tell us did he support his Leader in the vote in the Party? Was he with or against his Leader?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy is trying to project himself as a national figure but he is, in fact, running about in political nappies without a clue as to what is going on. He missed the boat last week and had not the—I do not know what word to use; I do not want to be offensive—to put it right.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage could we have the Deputy on the Bill, please?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the little boy over here behaves himself, I shall get on with the work. I have said that the Fianna Fáil Party know, as a result of the presidential election, the local elections and the by-elections that their popularity is falling and for that reason they propose to introduce this so-called straight vote system because they hope that in the next general election they can obtain an unfair advantage, as has been demonstrated by political commentators and by the staff of Telefís Éireann.

Comment on this

That is a joke.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the Minister and his Party get their way, they hope, after the next general election, with less than 40 per cent of the votes, to get 95 seats. That is what they have in mind and I am satisfied that the Irish people do not want that and that it would not be good for the country to give the Fianna Fáil Party or any Party 95 seats out of 144 in this House. That is what the Government Party hope they will be able to do, but I am satisfied that the people in their wisdom will not fall for it. At a time when Fianna Fáil in one way or another have got control of many institutions of State and when they are encouraging such doubtful organisations as Taca to thrive, it would not be good for the country——

Comment on this

The latest is a big grant for a hotel to Taca.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):——that it would be dangerous to give this Fianna Fáil Party at the next election 65 per cent of the seats in this House. It would lead to a lack of interest—if that word is strong enough— in public life, a lack of interest in politics. It would do what Fianna Fáil hope they will be able to do, that is, establish here a one-Party dictatorship. That is what they have in mind, but the people appreciate that. If there is any necessity, in order to establish stable government, to do what Fianna Fáil are asking to do, then there might be something to be said for it, but we know from experience that it is not necessary and that a case cannot be made for this straight vote system on those grounds.

I could understand the arguments being put by the Minister if we were embarking on the present system for the first time. That is not the case. We have had ample experience of this system; it has worked and worked well. No case has been made on the failure of the present system to justify the straight vote, single-member constituency proposals contained in this Bill. We are told that this spot vote system will lead to stability. The opposite is the danger. In Canada, where the straight vote system operates, they are now in their fourth election is six years. Is that stability?

Comment on this

Is it one-party dictatorship?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is that an argument in favour of the system which the Minister asks us to accept?

Comment on this

What about Italy, France and Belgium?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Did Deputy Crowley contribute to this debate? The people who contributed to this debate are really remarkable, but the people who did not contribute are more remarkable still, because I do not think that any of the Fianna Fáil nominees on the Committee have contributed to this.

Comment on this

At least two. The Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley, and Deputy Andrews did anyway.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It must be a long, long time ago.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been holding it up for a long time now.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I think Deputy Andrews contributed more at Party meetings than he contributed in the House, and perhaps Deputy Crowley, too. However, I deny that this proposal will lead to stability. It is well known that under the system which the Minister proposes an increase of one per cent in the votes of a Party can mean an increase of six or seven per cent of the seats for that Party; that is not stability. On the other side, as small a drop as one per cent can mean a drop of six or seven per cent of the seats of that Party. I am against this proposal, too, because it introduces what the Committee on the Constitution calls the wasted vote phenomenon.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I should like to draw the Deputy's attention to the fact that what is before the House is what is in the Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I bow to your ruling, but, with respect, I suggest I am entitled to point out the shortcomings of what is in the Bill, because otherwise it would be impossible to have a discussion on it. I am pointing out that the straight vote—or what I prefer to call the crooked vote or the spot vote—leads to what the Committee on the Constitution described as the wasted vote phenomenon. That reference can be found at page 24, paragraph k, of the Report and I should like the Minister, in replying, to deal with what the Committee called the wasted vote phenomenon. The Committee thought that a vote should be effective, that it should pass on until it got into battle and either won or lost. Here, if the Minister has his way, the vote will get lost perhaps early on without having gone into battle, without having played any part in electing a candidate, and I say that is unsound.

One of the biggest arguments against this straight vote proposal is that it can lead to the formation of a Government who do not enjoy the confidence of the majority of the people. For that proposition I can rely on the Committee on the Constitution Report, pages 24 and 25, paragraph q. I think it is highly relevant to read a short extract from that Report, because it does demonstrate the weakness and the danger of the proposal which the Minister is putting before us, the straight vote in the single-member constituency. This was an argument put forward in support of a change of the electoral system. It reads:

One of the most serious objections raised in the past against the first-past-the-post system as an alternative to PR was that it could give rise to a government which does not have the support of the majority of the electorate. This arises out of the fact that a member is elected simply because he has been given more votes than any other candidate, even though he may not have secured more than 50 per cent of the total poll.

That proposition, I submit, was accepted by the six Fianna Fáil representatives on that Committee. It is clear from that that it is a dangerous proposal that is contained in this measure and that we are asked to pass and recommend to the people.

Now, as well as those fundamental objections to this measure and to this proposal, there are other objections which, although they may not be fundamental, are very important. In the single-seat constituency which is proposed in this measure, supporters of the defeated candidate are left without representation. In a multi-member constituency, that is extremely unlikely to happen. In a single-member constituency, it is certain to happen. These supporters of the defeated candidate, if they have a genuine grievance, perhaps against the Government of the day, which they want to ventilate in this House, have no representative in their constituency and in this House to ventilate it.

They must do one of three things: drop their grievance, go out of their constituency to another to raise it, or employ legal means to bring it to light. The Minister may argue that it is open to the people who do not support the Government candidate to go to the Government TD in their constituency to ventilate their grievance. Supposing a person wants to ventilate a Government scandal, what sort of reception will he get from the Government TD in his constituency? That is not the position at present. He has, or it is most likely that he has, an Opposition TD to represent him.

I have another objection to the single-seat constituencies. This lends itself to the safe seat. It lends itself to the big Party plant. The Government or the strong Party arrange a constituency or a number of constituencies with strong Government support, and it is not the Party candidate the people want whom they will get. They will get the candidate whom the political bosses want to send down. This cannot happen in a multi-seat constituency because the electorate will differentiate between the candidates of a particular Party in the way they think they should differentiate, and they will vote for the candidate or candidates they think best suited to represent that constituency.

In this age when the Party opposite, the Fianna Fáil Party, have become so drunk with power, we should not provide conveniences of this sort for them which, in effect, are traps. If I had ever any doubt about the necessity for curbing the Fianna Fáil Party, if I had ever any doubt in my mind about the inadvisability of providing an electoral system here which would give the Fianna Fáil Party the opportunity of entrenching themselves in power with a dangerously strong majority, that doubt vanished when I saw in the by-elections—and in this way, Sir, I think the by-elections are relevant in a general way—the amount of money that was spent in seeking power, when I saw the people who were brought in literally in their hundreds, in expensive attire, in fabulously expensive motor cars, from hundreds of miles away——

Comment on this

If this is relevant, I take it I can discuss the people Fine Gael brought in for the purpose of disrupting not only the by-elections but the whole campaign, the people who were imported from other parts of the country. I take it this is relevant and I can discuss it also?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has pointed out on a number of occasions that while references may be made, it is not in order to enlarge the scope of the debate on this stage of the Bill.

Comment on this

I propose to deal with the personnel employed by Fine Gael and the manner in which they were employed.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I noticed on a few occasions since the by-elections that if there is anything that gets under the Minister's skin, it is a mention——

Comment on this

I am all in favour of discussing the by-elections.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must point out that by-elections are irrelevant to this discussion.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to say that, in my opinion, this measure which provides for single-member constituencies and the nontransferable vote lends itself to corruption, to the buying of power by money and patronage. The size of your constituency is reduced. The number of the electorate is reduced. In my opinion, this proposal in regard to small constituencies, manageable by men like the Minister, lends itself to the purchase of power. I am against that, and I have seen examples of it. It lends itself to the creation of a situation in which in a few years time, after a few elections, democracy will have been driven underground and Taca and Taca tactics will reign supreme.

Finally, there is no necessity to pass this Bill to ask the Irish people what they think about PR or the single-seat constituency because we asked them in 1959 at very considerable expense, and they then gave a very decided answer. I am convinced, again from my canvass at the by-elections amongst other things, that the people on this occasion will give an equally decided but much more decisive answer to the question which the Fianna Fáil majority in this House, which they did not enjoy as a result of the last elections but which they won by fate since then, has forced them to put to the people.

Comment on this

I should like to take this opportunity to refer to the incident last week when the amendment which I had on the Order Paper was taken at a time when I was not here. As reported in the Official Reports of 19th June at column 1252, on the Order of Business, the Taoiseach said:

It is proposed to take Nos. 7, 8 and 9. If not already reached, it is proposed to interrupt business at 6 o'clock to take No. 9 and to resume the Order of Business at 7.30.

When the business was interrupted at 6 o'clock, I naturally assumed that the Order of Business would be as stated by the Taoiseach and would not be resumed before 7.30 p.m. When I came back at 7.20 p.m. I found that the business had commenced again at 6.45 p.m. I feel that this was not only discourteous but a mean and shabby attempt by the House to abuse the privileges of a single Independent Deputy. I am not altogether surprised at some people who for the past few months have been shouting about democracy and the rights of small sections of the community and protecting minority interests but last week nobody seemed to speak up on behalf of the interests of the people I represent. I should also like to say that the Chair should have adjourned the House——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not think this is the Bill.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick referred to it.

Comment on this

The Deputy asked for an explanation and if he does not like it——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I commented on it.

Comment on this

Surely what is relevant for Deputy Fitzpatrick is relevant for other Deputies?

Comment on this

I feel I have been done a grave disservice by the House when the House did not adjourn. The Chair should have protected my rights as well as those of others and should have adjourned until 7.30 p.m. The least the Chair owes me on this occasion is an apology. It is not often that the Chair is in the wrong but 7.30 p.m. was quite clearly stated as the time to resume business, and when I came in business had commenced and nobody had communicated with me. Since my amendment was before the House, I was done a great disservice. Whether I get any satisfaction or not is of no importance, but I want to have this on the records of the House, that the minority group I represent has been abused. Whether or not Deputy Fitzpatrick scoffs in the rude, churlish manner he has adopted in this debate does not interest me in the least. I assume from the silence of the Chair that the Chair does not altogether disagree with me.

The main purpose of this Fourth Amendment Bill is to replace the present inefficient and unsatisfactory multi-seat constituency with the more compact and manageable single-seat constituency. The second purpose was to replace the present transferable vote, with its element of chance, by the straight vote. The motive behind these changes is to forestall the impending political stalemate which will befall us in the immediate future, most probably after the next general election. If, as seems almost certain, we emerge from the next general election with no Party with an overall majority able to form a government on their own, I believe our future will be pretty bleak. Deputy Corish, speaking recently on behalf of the Labour Party, stated clearly that they will not take part in a Coalition unless they are the majority Party in such a Coalition. It is difficult to blame the Labour Party for reaching their decision. It is true that in politics the minority Party in a Coalition Government tend to be absorbed by their larger partners. On the two previous occasions when the Labour Party were in a Coalition, they were reduced in numbers in the following general election.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not wish to interrupt the Deputy but I would ask him to come back to the Bill.

Comment on this

The Chair was lenient with the last speaker and I think he could allow me to develop my point because whether or not we have a Coalition after the next general election is surely a very vital part of this Bill, as the whole purpose of the Bill is to avoid political stalemate. I was saying that the Labour Party on the two previous occasions when they were in a Coalition Government came out on both occasions greatly reduced in numbers. If they were to take part in such a Coalition again, it is inevitable that this should happen to them again and the question naturally arises why should they, unless of course they see themselves merely as vote-fodder for the Fine Gael Party or unless some Labour Deputies put personal advancement before party and no genuine socialist could think of doing so.

On the other hand, the Fine Gael Party have degenerated into political harlots and they are prepared to offer anything to anybody, provided the price is right, and the price is coalition. However, there are no takers. Therefore we are faced with the problem of a minority Government with no real authority, a Government who must in the increasingly difficult days ahead plan for economic advancement, social progress and entry into the EEC and face all the complex problems to which this will give rise; a Government who must not only have confidence in itself but a reasonable opportunity to carry out its programme and command the respect and authority of the people. It must be obvious to any fair-minded person that unless we change our system of election, we are not going to get this type of Government in the future. I am not interested in keeping Fianna Fáil in office in perpetuity. It is one of the maxims of commerce that competition is the life of trade and I believe it should be so also in politics.

The straight vote and the single-seat constituency would in a very short time lead to a two-Party system which would offer the people a real choice of Government and Opposition. While the tide flows with the Government, we would have strong government and the present disgruntled incoherent Opposition would be welded into a strong coherent Opposition. As for myself, I have made my position clear. I believe in the single-seat constituency and in the straight vote. The reason I tabled my amendment was two-fold. First, I felt it was something which should be discussed in this House and it was obvious that none of the political Parties intended to give this House an opportunity to discuss it or give the people outside an opportunity to consider it. I was also afraid that people might not, at this time, be prepared to accept both measures and I thought it wiser to make haste slowly. I was confident that my amendment was a winner and that the people would have been glad to accept it. I was prepared to urge on the Government and the Opposition Parties the desirability of adopting my amendment so that we would not lose an opportunity to reform. I still think that would have been the path of wisdom. However, the die is now cast and those interested in reform and the future progress of our country must be prepared to work to bring this about. For myself, in my own limited way I intend to do whatever lies in my power whenever I can to see that the referendum is carried out and that the people get an opportunity to move forward.

I am sorry that this has developed into a battle of Fianna Fáil versus the rest. I had hoped that the members of the Fine Gael Party might have listened to the sound advice of their Leader and adopted his opinion on this. However, it is one of those situations with which Irish politics seem to be so bedevilled, a victory for the small minds and the selfish interests.

A silly point has been raised time and again by the Opposition and it was raised once more today by Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy M.P. Murphy. It is the point about the cost of the referendum. The cost will work out at approximately 2/- per head. All through our history, we have had patriots prepared to give their lives and proud to shed their blood in the cause of an Irish Constitution. Yet, this petty point is raised by Opposition Deputies: they do not think it is worth 2/- per head to consult the people about the Constitution for which so many were proud to pay with their blood. This argument about cost is one of which they should be ashamed. Perhaps, when they think it over, they will cease to advance this silly argument.

Deputy Fitzpatrick, although invited to do so, refrained from telling us whether he voted with or against his Leader on this issue of the straight vote. If he voted with his Leader, quite obviously he is in favour of this Bill. If he is against the Bill, then, equally obviously, he is one of the people who has no use for his Leader's point of view. It is a pity he was not a little more forthcoming, as forthcoming as some of the Fine Gael representatives have been on television recently.

I was asked why I did not seek to put my amendment down again on the Order Paper and have it discussed again. The reason is a simple one. I felt it had already had a sufficient airing and been sufficiently discussed. It is obvious that, whatever individual Deputies may think, they were not prepared to accept it in deference to their Party rules. It served its purpose. I do not choose to give myself more unnecessary publicity. Neither do I wish to hold up the business of the House. If I were, as Deputy Fitzpatrick suggested, trying to build myself into a national figure, I would have tabled my amendment again. I am not responsible for the publicity my amendment got. There is no Press behind an Independent Deputy and no one can accuse me of having a capitalist Press behind me.

I hope that those who favour the straight vote, even those Opposition Deputies who have remained discreetly silent in the House on the issue, will use whatever influence they have to ensure that the people are not deprived of this reform. We would not, of course, want them to clash with their Party leaders, but we hope they will use whatever influence they have to see that the people get what they want, namely, the straight vote and the single-seat constituency. I hope they will explain to the people that this is their opportunity to vote either for reform or chaos. Bearing in mind the position in France, I hope they will vote for reform.

Comment on this

Whether or not the people want this—and Deputy Norton seems to think they do—they are going to have this referendum thrust upon them. I may be minister-preting Deputy Norton's remarks, but I understood that part of the case he made for his own amendment was based on a warning which he uttered, as I understood it, to the Government that they had not a snowball's chance in hell of forcing the straight vote through the people at a referendum.

Comment on this

I never used that expression.

Comment on this

The Deputy may not have expressed himself quite so colourfully, but he did make the case, I think, that the reason he was putting forward his amendment was as a compromise and, if the Government went on with their so-called straight vote proposals, they would be defeated by the people.

Comment on this

I said that three minutes ago.

Comment on this

If that is Deputy Norton's view, then I thoroughly agree with him. It will be defeated by the people. It was defeated by the people a comparatively short time ago. As a politician, I am naturally interested in these proposals from a Party point of view and, when I spoke here on the Second Reading of this Bill, I endeavoured not to argue the case from a Party point of view, because I believe it goes a great deal deeper than that. Certainly the political future of individual Deputies is not a matter of any great importance. No matter how much any of us may think that we are indispensable either to our Party or in this House, the fact is that that is not what is important in considering the proposals in this Bill.

Many of the arguments advanced in favour of these proposals were advanced mainly on the grounds of the convenience of individual Deputies: it was difficult for a Deputy to manage a large constituency; he had to travel many hundreds of miles in the course of carrying out his duties as a Deputy; he had to withstand not only competition from within but competition from without and everything in the garden would be lovely if we could only get rid of multiple-seat constituencies and put Deputies in small constituencies, easily-managed, and with no opposition.

I do not think this House should regard a proposal as fundamental as this on the basis of the convenience of Deputies. This goes a lot deeper than that. What is important, both to the House and to the country, is that we should endeavour to preserve true democracy in our election system and we should not sacrifice on the altar of convenience or political expediency either fairness in our election system or fairness of representation in this House and, as far as I am concerned, arguments in favour of these proposals based on the convenience of Deputies should not carry any weight either in the House or outside it. I feel quite confident that they will not carry any weight in any event outside the House.

What are the proposals? They have been described as the straight vote. I will not attempt a definition at this stage but I certainly do not accept the description of the straight vote as being fairly applicable to these proposals. What we are being asked to do by the Government is to adopt an election system under which a Party may get a substantial majority of seats in this House, although with a substantial minority of the votes in the country, and no argument, to satisfy me in any event, that that is not so has been made by the sponsors of these referendum proposals. Various figures have been suggested as examples of what can happen under the existing system or under the alternative proposed in this Bill. I want to give this example of what may happen under the Minister's proposals. Admittedly, it is an extreme example and I am taking it deliberately as an extreme example to show what can happen and to show how vast numbers of people in this country may be completely unrepresented in this House, may have no opportunity of having their views expressed in this House if these proposals go through.

I understood from the Taoiseach's speech when he introduced these measures that what was contemplated was an electorate of something in the region of 12,000. The calculation I have made is on the basis of 12,000 people actually voting in an election. If you take a case where there are four candidates contesting a single-seat constituency as envisaged by this legislation, we may have a situation where one candidate gets 3,002 votes, where the second candidate gets 3,001 votes, where the third candidate gets 2,999 votes and where the fourth candidate gets 2,998 votes. There you have a situation where the seat will go to the candidate who gets 3,002 votes although 8,998 voters in that constituency have voted for other candidates. How could such a candidate, if elected under this proposed system, fairly claim that he properly represents the views of the majority of voters in that constituency or that he is there by a consensus of opinion in the constituency that he should represent them? No such thing.

He is there with 3,002 votes cast for him and nearly 9,000 votes cast against him. With a little more than one-third of the valid votes in that constituency, he can become the sole Deputy, the sole spokesman for every voter in that constituency. That is certainly, as I conceded, an extreme example. You will get different variations of those figures all of which will be true but they all point to the basic flaw in the system the Minister is asking the House to recommend to the people. The fact is that you may have in this House, if this system is adopted, a Party with a minority of votes getting a substantial majority of the seats.

One of the arguments advanced in favour of the change this Bill proposes is the old argument about the necessity for stable government. I think that those who talk about stable government in that sense believe what they say but that they are talking not merely of stable government but of their concept of strong government. I am the first to admit that under the system proposed in this Bill, you may get strong government. I do not think you will get strong government in the sense that that Government will be effective to carry out the wishes of the people who elected it. Under the new system, if it comes into existence, I think you will get powerful government. I think you will get government that will be able to push through this House any legislation they like merely by counting heads as the Fianna Fáil Party are doing now, steam-rolling legislation of this type through the House. They will be able to do that certainly if the so-called straight vote comes into being. They will get powerful government in that sense but it will not be representative government; it will not be a Government representing fairly the views and the wishes of the majority of the people.

Deputy Norton, I think, saw the position clearly enough when he foresaw that if the system the Government want to foist on the people is adopted, it will lead to a two-Party system and will crush out of existence any minority representation in this House, whether it is a minority represented by the Labour Party or a minority represented by a breakaway Labour Deputy such as Deputy Norton. Deputy Norton sees the position clearly enough, that you are going to crush out minority representation and you will do it and that is one of the features I object to.

Comment on this

I do not want to interrupt the Deputy——

Comment on this

All right; if the Deputy does not want to interrupt me, just keep quiet.

Comment on this

Do not be rude.

Comment on this

That is exactly what is likely to happen if this system is adopted. Another of the fundamental flaws in this system is the very fact that it does not permit of minority representation. I am not talking about religious miniorities; I am talking about political minorities. If you have a single-seat constituency, you can only have one voice speaking in Parliament from that constituency. You cannot have any other views or any other voice represented here in this House. Of course you will not have minority representation. Deputy Norton is quite right if he believes that.

Comment on this

Do not misrepresent what I said. Speak for yourself and do not be so silly just because you have been in trouble with the Party recently.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Cry baby.

Comment on this

I do not mind Deputies telling the truth, but when they have to get down to telling lies to provide themselves with political arguments, I think it is contemptible.

Comment on this

If I am misrepresenting Deputy Norton——

Comment on this

The Deputy is.

Comment on this

——correct me. I give him permission to do so.

Comment on this

You are not in a position to give me permission; that is the function of the Chair. Continue.

Comment on this

Deputy Norton made the case and I believe he was right that if this is forced through——

Comment on this

Deputy Norton said quite clearly that he did not accept and did not believe and did not want the Labour Party to be extinguished. Perhaps you were not here. You are often not here. It is a pity you do not follow in the Official Report what is said when you are not here and then you would not be misrepresenting me.

Comment on this

Will you "hould your whisht" for a minute. I understood Deputy Norton agreed with me——

Comment on this

You misunderstood.

Comment on this

——when I said that he foresaw that this could lead to a two-Party system.

Comment on this

In any event this will not be your problem. You will not have a constituency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, I appeal to the Chair to allow Deputy O'Higgins to continue.

Comment on this

Surely I cannot be expected to sit here and hear myself being misrepresented? Deputy O'Higgins is in a minority group in a minority Party.

Comment on this

I said before and I will say it again that Deputy Norton believes it will have the same effect.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage perhaps interruptions would cease and Deputy O'Higgins be allowed to continue.

Comment on this

I quite agree.

Comment on this

If Deputy Norton cannot possess his soul in patience while I am speaking, he is at liberty to leave the House, but so long as he remains in the House, I suggest he stops acting the ignoble part of the flea on the dog, doing little good and no harm. I agree with the view which I understand to have been expressed by Deputy Norton that this system proposed in this Bill if it is adopted is likely to lead to a two-Party system, and that means that minority representation, whether it comes in the form of the Labour Party or a breakaway Labour Deputy such as Deputy Norton, is going to disappear from this House. I do not think it should be the policy of any Deputy or of any Party in this House to partake of that kind of operation with their eyes open.

I could understand people saying: "Well, this will only be an accidental result of it," but to my mind, Deputy Norton was quite right to bring that aspect of the matter before the House, that it is going to lead to a situation where you will have a two-Party system and no more. As I say, one of the fundamental weaknesses in this proposed system is that in each individual constituency you can have only one voice speaking in the Dáil. You cannot have minority representation in a single-seat constituency.

I do not know whether Deputies opposite have fully considered the implications of that. Have they fully considered the implications of a situation which may arise where one of their number is elected to this House with 3,000 or a little more votes and over 8,000 votes cast against him? Have they considered whether or not such a Deputy can really represent the views of his constituency in the House? Can he talk with any confidence about the people he represents?

I heard Deputy Norton talking a few minutes ago about the minority he represents. I am at my wit's ends to discover what that is. As I understand the position, he was elected as a Labour Deputy and I doubt very much if the Labour supporters in his constituency regard him as representing their interests.

Comment on this

They still write to me. I will be there next time, when you are gone from Wicklow.

Comment on this

Where is he going to?

Comment on this

And I will do my best to get the Deputy a seat when Deputy Sweetman retires, if he carries out his threat.

Comment on this

There are a few things I should like to say. I have heard that kind of taunt from the Government benches before and, judging from the remarks of some of the Deputies as recorded in the Dáil Debates, they look forward to my early political demise.

Comment on this

It is inevitable.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that that is a prospect that would fill many of them with glee and the reason for that is that Fianna Fáil are not at all happy about, not at all enamoured of, my record in the constituency of Wicklow but it is one which I am proud and will be proud to put before the people of Wicklow at any time because in that record is the fact that when I first went there in 1961, I found two Fianna Fáil Deputies in possession and after the 1961 election, there was one Fianna Fáil Deputy less.

Comment on this

Surely this is irrelevant on the Bill?

Comment on this

Another point of that record is the fact that now, instead of two Fianna Fáil Deputies, there are two Fine Gael Deputies in the constituency.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would Deputy O'Higgins come back to the question of the single seat and the straight vote?

Comment on this

If the system being proposed by the Government were to be adopted, that situation could not arise. We could not have two Fine Gael seats out of three in the county of Wicklow for the simple reason that there would be only one Deputy for each constituency.

I do not blame the Members opposite for taunting me with regard to Wicklow. I am proud of my record there. I am proud of the fact that because we have a multi-seat constituency in the county of Wicklow, we have reduced the Fianna Fáil representation and we brought the Fine Gael representation from nought to two. I am proud of the fact that in that constituency also in a straight fight such as is proposed in this Bill, the Fine Gael candidate was able to trounce the Fianna Fáil candidate during the Presidential election. However, as the Leas-Cheann Comhairle points out, that is not entirely relevant to the Bill except in so far as it illustrates the difference between single-seat constituencies which are proposed and the multi-seat constituencies which we have at the moment.

I do not think this argument about strong government is a good argument. I do not think the argument about stable government, which I think is intended to mean the same thing, is a good argument and the reason is that I do not believe that you can have really effective government without fair representation in Parliament, and if you have a situation where you have the big battalions coming in here with a minority of votes, while you will have strong government numerically, you will have power concentrated in the hands of a single Party; you will have a powerful number of seats concentrated in the hands of a single Party but I do not believe that that will be strong government because it will not be effective government and it will not be representative government.

Another flaw in these proposals is the danger that you will have the emergence of what I regard as an evil in any democracy, the evil of safe seats, that you will have a situation arising where everyone knows that one political Party is so strong in one of these pocket-size constituencies that there is not much point in challenging the candidate of that Party and that eventually you will have the situation arising where a person will be able to go through his entire life in a constituency from babyhood to adulthood, to old age, to the grave, without ever casting a single vote because it will be regarded as a safe seat; it will be uncontested and the people in that constituency who are against the holder of the safe seat will not ever have an opportunity of voicing their views in the ballot box.

There is coupled with that another flaw. We have heard of wasted votes. Surely, under the system which the Government are proposing, every vote cast unless it goes to the candidate who wins is a wasted vote? It is completely wasted. It plays no part in Parliament; it plays no part in the formation of a Government for the country. At least, under our present system no one can deny the fact that every vote counts in an election.

Comment on this

Some count twice.

Comment on this

It would be possible, again, under the system the Minister is proposing, for a person to vote in every single election without that vote ever being of the slightest use so far as the formation of a Government was concerned and so far as giving expression to the views of that individual in Parliament is concerned. These are some of the defects, as I see it, in the system which the Minister is proposing.

I want to refer very briefly, in conclusion, to views that were expressed by individuals who, I think, would certainly be regarded as having less of a political mind on this topic than I have when it was brought before the people less than a decade ago. I do not know whether Deputy Norton was of voting age or not at that time. I do not know whether he was taking the same interest in constitutional matters then as he is now. But if he was of an age nine years ago to take an interest in politics and in the voting system, he will probably remember that this matter was the subject of examination and scrutiny by six university Senators who examined the proposal being put before the people at the time and gave their views with regard to it. They certainly would be regarded as being less politically-minded than a person such as myself.

Comment on this

The Deputy should at least be serious.

Comment on this

I want to remind the House of the views they expressed. I do not get the Minister's point.

Comment on this

Do not treat the matter in such a jocose fashion.

Comment on this

Does the Minister regard these views as a joke?

Comment on this

I regard the suggestion that they are not political as a ridiculous joke.

Comment on this

I do not know whether the Minister was following what I was saying very closely or not.

Comment on this