We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Tuarascáil agus an Chéim Dheiridh. Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Report and Final Stages.

Contributions 208–415 of 610. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968
Rejected

No. 6 of 1968 ›

I was.

Comment on this

I was saying I do not think they would be regarded as being so politically-minded as myself.

Comment on this

That surely was intended as a joke?

Comment on this

Not by me. If the Minister sees a humorous side to it, do not let me begrudge him his moment of enjoyment. As soon as he forces this Bill through the Dáil and forces it through the Seanad, his moment of enjoyment will finish. The six university Senators examined these proposals and gave their views as to what they saw happening if these proposals were adopted. I want to record these views here, particularly for the benefit of new Deputies such as Deputy Norton. Some of the old-timers like Deputy Booth will probably have heard them before. The Minister was probably not even in the House at the time. If he was, it was at least in his green and salad days and he might not have digested these views.

Comment on this

The suspense is killing me. Are you going to get around to saying what is going to happen?

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy O'Higgins would give us the reference? He is quoting from some document.

Comment on this

Certainly, I would not have the Minister disappointed for anything. If the Minister wants to check the reference, let him look up the Dáil Debates of 29th April, 1959, at column 1366.

Comment on this

Would Deputy O'Higgins care to explain whether or not the six university Senators were Members of Dáil Éireann in 1959? How could the views of six Senators be on the records of this House? Is it not obvious that this is some other reference Deputy O'Higgins has given?

Comment on this

You are keeping poor Deputy Booth in suspense. I want to give him the gist of what is here.

Comment on this

I think the Dáil is entitled to the correct reference if Deputy O'Higgins is quoting the views of six university Senators who are not Members of the Dáil.

Comment on this

I am quoting the views of six university Senators——

Comment on this

I contend that these views could not be on the record of the Dáil.

Comment on this

Whether they should be on the record of the Dáil or not, let me assure the Minister that they are on the record of the Dáil and I am quoting from them at column 1366 of 29th April, 1959. This is what the six university Senators had to say.

Comment on this

Six university Senators could not have expressed any views in the Dáil Debates on whatever date Deputy O'Higgins quoted because they were not Members of the House. Only Members of the House can contribute to the Dáil Debates. It is obvious Deputy O'Higgins is not quoting what he is purporting to quote.

Comment on this

They are the views of the six university Senators recorded here in the Dáil Debates. This is a mystery to the Minister. May I explain it to him? Sit down now and I will explain it. The six university Senators examined these proposals when they were put forward by the Fianna Fáil Government at the time. The six university Senators published their findings. Lest the Deputies opposite might at that time have overlooked them, I quoted the views of the six university Senators.

Comment on this

So Deputy O'Higgins is quoting himself? That is what I thought.

Comment on this

Their remarks were quoted by me and are now on the records of this House at column 1366 of the Dáil Debates of 29th April, 1959. Does the Minister now understand?

Comment on this

Deputy O'Higgins is quoting himself. I understand that.

Comment on this

You have put poor Deputy Booth out of the House. I was most anxious he would hear this, but at least Deputy Norton is still here.

Comment on this

I do not mind the constant repetition of my name but I know it is irritating Deputy Fitzpatrick. Just for his sake, I would ask you not to keep mentioning it. He is attacking a Bill he really believes in.

Comment on this

This is what the six university Senators had to say. I hope Deputy Norton is listening:

We are convinced from our many investigations that the proposed change to the miscalled straight vote system would be disastrous on the following grounds:

(1) It would lead to an excessive Government majority with an Opposition almost as powerless as the present Opposition in the Six County Parliament.

(2) This would result in intolerant and dictatorial Government and might ultimately evoke as a reaction an organised extra-parliamentary Opposition.

(3) It would cause division and Party strife rather than a cooperative approach to our economic and national problems in the coming decade.

(4) The single-seat constituency would inevitably narrow the voter's choice at elections and would greatly increase the power of political Parties as such. This would undoubtedly lower the quality of Dáil representatives since unquestioning obedience to the Party leaders would then be the first demand made on any candidate.

(5) The proposed system sets the stage for class warfare between town and country and makes it possible for a majority to command 40 per cent in the urban constituencies and, getting little or no support in the rural areas, due to its deliberate anti-rural policy, to get a majority in Dáil Éireann.

Such a Party might have the support of as little as 25 per cent of the total electorate, and yet the miscalled straight vote system would enable it to impose its doctrines on the remaining 75 per cent of the population.

There are five solid arguments set out against this system after an examination carried out a little over nine years ago by six university Senators.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy tell us what Deputy Cosgrave said about that? Did he read that to him?

Comment on this

As far as the members of this Party are concerned, let Deputy Norton remember this: they will act as a Party. If Deputy Norton had continued to act as a Party man, his voice might find better reception on the benches in this House.

Comment on this

In what way would the university Senators describe that?

Comment on this

Now I intend to deal with this. The Minister may regard the whole thing as a huge joke——

Comment on this

I certainly do not.

Comment on this

——but let me warn him that the joke will be on him when it goes before the people. The university Senators have pointed out a number of reasons why they would regard the system the Minister is proposing as disastrous. One of the points they made referred to a matter that has been mentioned here before and I want to refer to it again. It is the fact that, if the referendum proposal is adopted, it will concentrate power into the hands of the political Party bosses as to who will be the candidate for the Party in any constituency and the Party supporters in the constituency will not have any choice. Whether they like it or not, they will either have to vote against the Party or accept the nominee put forward by the Party. The university Senators have summed that up in the fourth part of their statement on the previous occasion when they said that the single-seat constituency would inevitably narrow the voters' choice at elections and would greatly increase the power of political Parties as such.

The arguments are all against the Minister's and the Government's proposals. I do not want to delay the House any longer: I want to see these proposals go before the people so that they can deal with them. The Minister may feel that he can ooze confidence about the outcome. I doubt if he can. If I were asked to advise the Minister for his own good and that of his political Party, I would tell him now, that even at the eleventh hour, he would be a wiser man to drop these proposals.

Comment on this

I do not propose to delay the House but I think I have a matter of some significance to which attention might, with advantage, be directed in connection with the final stage of the Bill. Deputy O'Higgins has covered wide ground. I had occasion last week to discharge the agreeable function of congratulating a new Deputy on his maiden speech. He is a young man newly entered into our public life, a married man with a young family. We of the older generation are often rebuked for our failure to communicate with the later generations. The Minister for Local Government would do well to reflect on this extract from Deputy O'Malley's speech to which I direct the attention of the House. It is contained in volume 235, at column 1158. In the course of a general contribution on the Finance Bill, Deputy O'Malley had this to say:

People of my generation, particularly, who have never seen political anarchy in this country, who were born after all those troubles were over and who do not realise how disastrous they can be, should be grateful to a Government whose Ministers have over the past ten years or so maintained our economic progress so well in spite of difficulties all round us that we are politically as stable as any country in the world, far more so than our much wealthier, larger and more powerful neighbours whom I have mentioned.

The long-term benefit of that situation, our political stability, will be immense because political stability more than anything else is what foreign industrialists will look for in a country. They now regard it as more important than grants, loans or other facilities. No matter what grants or loans the American or German or any other foreign industrialist will get, he does not want to come into a country where he will run the risk of being faced by a situation like that which exists in France today.

Deputy O'Malley continued to deal with other aspects of that statement and concluded at column 1159 by saying:

There is a lot of cribbing in general in this country, particularly among younger people, about the cost of things and so on, but I would point out to them—and I think it is something worth reflecting on by people of my generation who did not see political trouble— that it is no good living in a country where stout costs 1/- a pint if you are liable to get shot when you go out to drink it.

If those were my words, I think they would have been attributed to the excessive conservatism of advanced middle age. Coming from the source they did, they should be a reminder to the Minister that the impression made on the minds of the youngest recruit of his own Party is that of deep thankfulness for the atmosphere of political stability in which he grew up, married and established his own family. He compared that political stability favourably with the political situation in any other country in the world. I have heard Fianna Fáil boast of the fact that a feature of that stability has been the long term during which they constituted the Government of the country. I find in that no reason to complain; I glory in the right of our people to do wrong and if the people wish to choose Fianna Fáil every time they do, however harsh the consequences for them may be, it is the vindication of the sovereign independence of the Irish people, even though the Minister for Education may feel from time to time in London that its vindication, in retrospect, is a mistake. I rejoice that we have that independence and that we here today constitute a Dáil of three Parties and four Independents rightly described by Deputy O'Malley as one of the most stable political societies in the world.

I believe that to be in no small measure due to the decision taken by our people nine or ten years ago on this very issue. I do not hold that everything that was relevant and true of 1938 is necessarily relevant and true of 1948 or 1958 or 1968. Only a fool in public life feels himself bound to apply in 1968 that which might have seemed expedient 30 years ago. But only a fool would fail to see the evidence of his own eyes that, in a troubled world, we have in Ireland stable political institutions, with no excuse for any person, however ill-intentioned, to mislead the young on to the streets of our cities or towns or roads, there to erect barricades to achieve that which everyone, young and old, knows is abundantly available to all through the instrument of the vote and the ballot box.

Why has all that to be put in peril now? Why has all that precious political stability to be thrown into the cockpit of Party politics in a frantic effort to have it swept away? Do the facts not speak for themselves? Is this not a sordid plot on the part of a power-hungry minority in the Fianna Fáil Party to destroy the Labour Party? Are we not all old enough in politics to know the further we penetrate to rural Ireland the deeper Party loyalties become, but in our urban population Party loyalties tend to weaken? Still there are those who change from Fianna Fáil to Fine Gael from black to white, but the Party managers of Fianna Fáil believe the Labour Party to be the real and present threat to their hope for enduring political domination—and so this foolish, irresponsible action.

I wish the Taoiseach, who I do not believe approves this course of conduct, would show the strength of character which he ought to have to say this farce must stop; there are more important matters to which the Oireachtas should apply its mind than this renewed attempt to assassinate the Labour political movement in this country. I am no supporter of the Labour Party. I do not agree with many things for which the Labour Party stand, but I am certain that the voice of organised labour is entitled to be heard in this House, if it wishes so to be heard. I apprehend that if the attempt is made to take that right from them, those who would wish to send them here will lose faith in the genuineness of the Parliament of Ireland. Other countries have had that deplorable experience, and it has not gone unobserved by the youngest member of the Fianna Fáil Party.

I do not expect to change the mind of the Minister for Local Government, but I think it right, on the occasion of the last discussion on this Bill before this House, to bring these matters not only to the attention of the House but to the attention of the country, and to reiterate on the floor of Dáil Éireann on the last occasion available to me my advice for what it is worth: I advise everyone in this country to vote "No", "No", in the coming referendum.

Comment on this

I am simple enough to believe in the meaning of democracy as it was taught in my time. Democracy, as I understand it, means government by the people, and from "government by the people", I interpret, further, government by the majority of the people. The measure which the Government are now foisting upon the Dáil and will, by virtue of their numbers, successfully foist on the Seanad, is a contradiction of the term "democracy", in so far as it implies that vast tracts of country can be disfranchised, can be without representation in Parliament, which after all is the seat of government by the people.

The people were consulted as late as 1959 on this question as to whether they preferred to retain the system of PR which has been in operation here from the beginning of the State, or whether they would opt for the kind of system that operates in Great Britain and the similar system that keeps out of the Parliament of the Six Counties of Ireland a large number of Nationalist members. In 1959 the people rejected—some say by a small majority, but when one considers the ballyhoo that was associated with that campaign, the majority was significant —the advice of the Fianna Fáil Party and Government when they asked the people to abolish PR. They told the same falsehood then, that they wanted to get rid of it because it was British-imposed. The same falsehood is being repeated now in spite of the fact that the Constitution, upon which they very often tend to rely and from which at other times they tend to shy away, has enshrined in its provisions the system of PR, and that was enshrined under the direction and guidance of someone who gave a strange political maxim to this country when he said the people have no right to do wrong. Obviously this maxim in its application is now being extended again, because it would appear that the Fianna Fáil view today in 1968 is that the people had no right to do wrong in 1959.

If I believed even remotely in the single-member constituency with the non-transferrable vote, I would, in the circumstances in which we find ourselves, reject it because I would not trust any Commission set up by the Fianna Fáil Party to operate any demarcation fairly, that is, without making their own Party advantage their primary consideration. There is and has been for some years back dissatisfaction in this country. There are many rumours of corruption in high places. These rumours are growing in intensity and in some cases they are backed by reality. It is in circumstances such as those that I would ask the people to become more than extremely aware of their rights, and not to barter an atmosphere of comparative freedom under PR for the straight vote system which would ensure Fianna Fáil not only in power but in power absolutely with the tendency then extended by what they would minister-pret as the authority to be more corrupt still.

I do not want to see single-member constituencies represented by Fianna Fáil members of the kind I have experienced in the past, when fathers of families were refused work because they did not vote for Fianna Fáil candidates at parliamentary and local elections. I am opposed to a system that proposes to disfranchise the people who for 30 odd years were strong enough in all the constituencies to vote against Fianna Fáil despite the handouts and corruption that existed. It is true that these handouts and that corruption have assumed a more sophisticated touch in recent times. It is now the dinners with the £100 per plate. Does anyone think that these people have banded themselves together for love of this country, when one sees the various contracts being given, the various consultants being employed and consults the names on the lists and recognises the names of the people who are subscribing to the Party not because they want it to thrive for the good of the country, but because they want it to thrive for their own personal and professional advancement?

That is the kind of country you would have under the system which is being proposed by the Government at present. Who would ever have thought that under the heel of handouts and corruption, there could ever be this great swing and change these people offer as an argument in support of this proposal? In our six north-eastern counties at the moment, people are disfranchised. If they had the multi-seat constituencies system, they would be able to take their place, for the time being at any rate, and make their contributions in the Stormont Parliament in greater numbers, and vast areas would not go unrepresented, giving rise to the frustration and irritation that beset our people in that area.

Why do this Government want to go over to the British system now, the system which keeps the Unionists in power in Northern Ireland for ever and will continue to do so? Is it not because they hope the same system here would keep them in power for their natural lives and, they would hope, their children after them. Even if this system were to be operated fairly, or an attempt were to be made to operate it fairly, I would not trust the Fianna Fáil Party to do it. One cannot trust a Party who say one thing at home and another thing abroad, whose Ministers speak with two voices, depending on their geographical location. At any given time I do not trust a Party who seek to prove they have a monopoly of patriotism, a monopoly of everything good, and who would deny any minority, be it Fine Gael, Labour, or Independents, or even religious minorities, the right to speak out and contradict them. I do not trust people of that calibre. I do not think they can be trusted.

Coupling the straight vote system, or whatever you like to call it, with a Commission is, as Deputy Murphy said, offering the people a bitter pill with sugar-coating, but the sugar is not even very sweet. We are not even told what members of the Opposition would be on the Commission, or how it would be composed. We know selections would be made. A Supreme Court judge or a High Court judge would be the chairman. There would be three members of the Fianna Fáil Party presumably, and, presumably, three Members of this House not of the Fianna Fáil Party. Let us put it at that level at the moment. If the three members not of the Fianna Fáil Party objected strongly to some line of demarcation proposed by one of the three Fianna Fáil members, and objected so strongly that they had to walk out, what would be the position of the chairman? A member of the judiciary would be put in a venal position in relation to the three members of the Government Party, the Party that probably appointed him. There are very few others.

A Commission, bad and all as it would be with Members of the House making up six members, would present an intolerable position for any member of the judiciary, and would put him in a most unenviable position vis-à-vis litigants coming before him, would render him innocuous in the presence of jurors to whom he would be expected to give advice from time to time, would make him the laughingstock of the people when he purported to enunciate a legal maxim or a legal principle that was to govern their lives. If the Fianna Fáil Party have not got that respect for the ordinary voters, by trying to trample on them with this measure so soon again, let them have respect for that other integral part of our democratic life, the judiciary, and not try to make them the pawn of their vile ambition. Maybe that is too much to expect. Maybe that is something that never entered the heads of this corrupt Government, this Government who so violate the wishes of the people without a mandate, without a whisper of it in the last general election, and now seek to thrust something down the throats of our people for which they never sought the power to do. Our people will not give it to them. Fianna Fáil will get it here and in Seanad Éireann by virtue of numbers, by virtue of the numbers this Constitution they are trying to change has given them with their nominated eleven in Seanad Éireann.

This Government and the Party supporting them cannot have it both ways because sooner or later the tide must turn and sooner or later this Government and their members will realise that authority rests finally in the people. Sooner or later this Government will be made to realise by the people that the authority they have got from the ballot box is not a power complacently to be used or flagrantly to be abused but that authority is a service which connotes equality of opportunity and the same privileges for all. It is for those reasons that we in Fine Gael recommend the people to reject these proposals by a firm "no" to both Bills, and particularly to this one. If they do not, they will find themselves beaten down again, beaten down again by the Fianna Fáil Party who are, as I have often said, the second evil in the history of our country, the first being the Famine which banished our people or caused them to die by the roadsides. The Fianna Fáil Party have depopulated our country and banished them again, and now they want to put the heel of totalitarianism down on the very throats of a people whose great desire all down the years was to be free. Leave them free. I exhort them from this House to exercise that freedom by rejecting these proposals.

Comment on this

Over the past few weeks we in the Labour Party have taken very little part in this debate because we felt that the quicker the matter was put before the people for a decision the better it would be for all concerned. However, since it has been made obvious by the Government members, and particularly the Taoiseach, that it is not proposed to put the amendments before the country until the late autumn, and I assume by that he means some time well into October, there does not appear to be any great rush to have them brought through the House and therefore I want to say a few words on the proposal. I do not understand from whom the Government got the idea that the people wanted this change. I do not understand why the Government should try to put through the Dáil and Seanad and to have put before the country some time this year a proposal to change the system of election and, consequently on that, a proposal to change the constituencies. I know that over the past few weeks the Minister for Local Government has been making comments here which could only be described as an attempt at blackmail.

He has been threatening individual Deputies in the Opposition Parties, including myself, that if he did not have his way and if the people rejected the proposals to amend the Constitution, the Government would then divide the country into constituencies to suit themselves. He is holding this out as if it were something he thought about for the first time. We know that the last time an opportunity arose the Government did just that and they made a very bad job of it. Deputy MacEntee, who was then Minister for Local Government, succeeded in manipulating them so that Fianna Fáil succeeded in losing five seats in the ensuing election. The present Minister for Local Government has been telling everybody that if the people do not vote the way he wants them to vote, he will change the constituencies in such a way that it will affect individual Deputies and he has promised me that he would put the portion of County Meath in which I live in with County Louth and when I——

Comment on this

Can we deal with the Third Amendment, Sir?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No, the Third Amendment does not arise— just what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

I will keep within the rules of the House.

Comment on this

As long as I can deal with it also.

Comment on this

The Minister will not browbeat me in the way he browbeat the members of the Fianna Fáil Party last week when they tried to vote against him.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

He is not going to get away with it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is certainly not in the Bill.

Comment on this

I propose to prove that what I am saying is within the ambit of the Fourth Amendment because what the Minister says is that he will change the constituencies and put portion of Meath with Louth, that he will see that that will be done and that I——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That was discussed on the Third Amendment; we are now discussing the Fourth Amendment.

Comment on this

I have been listening for several hours to the debate and it is unfair that the Chair should be asked by the Minister to intervene. I know that this is hurting him but he does not even know what I am leading up to.

Comment on this

On a point of order. I did not ask the Chair to intervene. I merely asked if it was in order to discuss the proposals in the Third Amendment as Deputy Tully was discussing them.

Comment on this

When the Minister stands up, he will talk not alone about the Third Amendment but about various other things which are not before the House this year in order to waste time, as has been done for the past three or four weeks because he was not anxious to get this before the country. It does not matter a damn to me or to the Members of the Labour Party what way he manipulates constituencies because we will still be here when it is all over. I would like nothing better than to be in the same constituency as the Minister and I would show him whether he is as tough as he thinks. There is only one way to deal with a bully, as the Minister has shown himself to be, and that is to beat him at his own game. I do not mind whether he divides up Meath with Dublin or Louth or anywhere else; it would suit me and I hope the Minister will be satisfied when it is finished.

The ridiculous argument the Government have been making is that they are doing this for the purpose of giving the Opposition an opportunity to become the Government. If we had not over the years seen and observed the antics of the Fianna Fáil Government, manipulating everything they possibly could in order that they and their supporters would get the best out of everything until they were shown up, then we could understand the arguments. But, in view of the fact that we realise the Government will move heaven and earth to get what they can for their own, we all know that the suggestion of the single-seat constituency and the system of voting they want to set up is being made with one intent only, that is, so that they can people this Parliament with the lackeys they have latched on to themselves and their Party, particularly through Taca, the people with the money and ambition, but no brains, whom they can send down the country to make the representatives of the people.

The Taoiseach led us up to it. He said: "It is all right. We will not impose on the good people who will be coming in here"—and he looked around at the people who represent Fianna Fáil, and concluded—"We must have a better type of Deputy." Some of us would agree with him on that, but the way he would get a better type of Deputy would be by selecting him. How? From the headquarters of the Fianna Fáil Party. The extraordinary thing is that it was some time before it dawned on the older members, in particular, of the Fianna Fáil Party exactly what the Taoiseach meant when he said he did not think Deputies should be bothered with day-to-day to-daymatters affecting their constituents, that a great many of these things could be dealt with by constituents themselves taking the matter up with the particular Department, as if it were the easiest thing in the world for poor old John Murphy, who has not got his old age pension for five or six weeks, to get on the phone and ring the Department, and achieve the same result as does a Deputy who makes an inquiry of that kind.

The Taoiseach was giving a warning that, when the new constituencies were set up, as he thought they would be, these gentlemen, representing various parts of the country, would have no time for looking after the John Murphys. Their time would be spent here in this House, basking in the reflected glory of what a few on the Front Bench of the Government Party might be doing. He said that no longer would we have the democratic representation we have had and no longer would we have ordinary men and women selected by a constituency conference and elected to Dáil Éireann by the votes of the people. It would be the Northern Ireland system. The Government would pick the candidate, the fellow with the money who could support the Party, and they would put him into a safe seat and, when he was returned, he would not be bothered with the ordinary day-to-day work that Deputies now do. He would not be bothered! He would not know even how to begin because all these people know is how to make money, and make it in a hurry and, having made it, all they want then is power.

Fianna Fáil, realising this, believe they can cement themselves into power by doing what they suggest under these two measures. Most extraordinary of all, the impression has been given by certain people that the Government are doing this in order that the best use may be made of the votes of the people. Again and again the Minister has alleged that, under the present system, some votes have more value than others. The Minister, of course, knows that is all cod. The Minister knows quite well that the present system of election is a fair system. Mark you, it was not a system introduced by the Labour Party. Not alone was it introduced by the Cumann na nGaedhael Government but it was subsequently taken over by the Fianna Fáil Government under the leadership of the present President, who had nothing but good to say for it. Indeed, on more than one occasion he quoted the fact that this was protection for the democratic system in this country and thanked God that we had this democratic way of election. Now the Minister for Local Government comes along and says that is not so at all; the President did not know what he was talking about.

I am quite sure the Minister and some of his colleagues do not approve all that was done over the years by the man who held office for so long as Leader of the Party, but to try to push down the throats of the people in this House, and subsequently the throats of the people all over the country, that the system Fianna Fáil are now trying to introduce is the right system is just something which will not be swallowed. We had earlier the argument advanced that there was no objection by Deputy Seán Lemass, the former Taoiseach, to this matter being put before the House. I am rather interested to notice that Deputy Lemass has not himself come in here and made a statement because he is the one person who could clear the matter up; he is a person for whom I have the greatest respect, although I have been in opposition to him for many years. He made it clear—again this is something denied by members of the Fianna Fáil Party—at a meeting of the Constitution Committee that he did not think it was right that we should try to have this change. He said there was no point in talking about it, or discussing it, or making a recommendation on it, because it was less than nine years since the people gave a decision on it. Yet, we now have the present Government coming along and saying there is a demand for this change and that there is a wish now to have this change made.

It is true that the last time the matter was decided it was decided by a relatively small majority, but the significant feature is that, while that majority was small, the majority in favour of the then leader of the Fianna Fáil Party for the Presidency was obtained on the same vote. We will now have two votes on the referendum and I am quite sure that every effort will be made to make it as confusing as possible for the ordinary voter, to prevent the voter from having a clear idea as to what he is voting for or against. I want to warn the Minister that, when the voting is over and when the decision is taken, he will be the one man in this House who will have reason to be sorry because he is the person who has been bulldozing this through the House, and not only from the Front Bench of the Government; he has made statements outside the House and he has got his stupid lackeys to go down the country to write stupid letters to the local papers, attacking individual Deputies in regard to matters about which these stupid lackeys know nothing. I would respect the Minister very much more if he fought his own battles here and were man enough to stand up and say: "This is what I believe. You are wrong in this and you are wrong in that," but, when he has to go behind backs and use anonymous letters—the person who is unknown in an area is anonymous and, therefore, the letters he writes are anonymous—to bolster up an untenable position, the picture becomes clear because this is the sort of thing which betrays the man behind the proposal to change the Constitution.

The one thing the Minister is trying to dodge here is the fact that though the Commission he proposes will be set up to draw up the lines of demarcation of the new constituencies, this House, by a simple majority, a majority of one, can reject what the Commission recommends. Therefore, it does not matter whether his amendment this afternoon is accepted; the amendment does not matter a snap of the fingers because what the Minister intends to do is to try to get control by hook or by crook, and preferably by crook. We in the Labour Party have no wish at all to prolong the agony here. We do not mind if the vote is taken tomorrow. As far as we are concerned, we have no division on this. We are all of the one mind. Fine Gael have been accused by the Minister and his colleagues of not being at one on this. I can say, and it is something I say with reluctance, that numerous members of the Fianna Fáil Party in this House have expressed the view that they did not think it was a wise thing to go on with. The Whip went on and then it was dangerous for them to disclose this view. They might not be selected the next time. It is true, however, that numerous members of the Fianna Fáil Party have expressed the view that as they were the curates, the second Deputy or the third Deputy to be elected in a particular constituency, it would not do them any good. The strong man who was bringing them in might not be on hand to lend them a helping hand and therefore they might find difficulty in getting back into this House. For that reason they felt that it was best to leave well enough alone.

As far as we are concerned we see in this an attempt by the Government to emulate the Tory Government in Northern Ireland, where, because of the fact that they have what they call the straight vote, 27 constituencies have not been contested for very many years, almost since the set-up of the breakaway State because they could not be contested in the circumstances. There is no representation for minorities there and no representation provided for. The Fianna Fáil Government felt that now or never was the time. If they cannot get away with now, they will never get away with it when the voting day comes and, as I said, the quicker it comes the better we will like it; the Minister will find that this time, not for the first time, he has bitten off more than he can chew.

The Minister, Deputy Harte, Deputy Healy and Deputy P.J. Lenihan rose.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When the Minister speaks, the Minister will be concluding. If any other Deputy wishes to speak——

Comment on this

He has put down one of them.

Comment on this

If Deputy Healy or Deputy P.J. Lenihan wishes to offer——

Comment on this

They both offered.

Comment on this

We will follow the Deputy.

Comment on this

The only one I saw offering was the Deputy behind me. That is why I sat down.

Comment on this

The Minister told him to sit down and he sat down. We all saw it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

I just wish to put on the record of the House that I do not wish to cut in on Deputy Healy or Deputy Lenihan, or to prevent them from intervening in this debate. I feel that the normal procedure of the House should be recognised. Deputy Lindsay spoke for Fine Gael before Deputy Tully.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When the Deputies offer, the Chair will call on them. Deputy Healy did not persist so I did not call on him.

Comment on this

I think the true reason is that the Minister for Local Government has now changed his tactics.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this

He told Deputy Healy to shut up.

Comment on this

I did not.

Comment on this

Yes, and he sat down. We saw it.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy misunderstood.

Comment on this

Let us have the truth from a so-called Minister.

Comment on this

There is no truth in that.

Comment on this

If Deputy Healy says there is no truth in it, I will accept that Deputy Healy did not hear the Minister. I accept that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte please speak on the Bill? We are not discussing the calling of Deputies.

Comment on this

I just wish to put on the record——

Comment on this

The courts are over now.

Comment on this

——that the Minister instructed Deputy Healy to shut up.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte stop this business?

Comment on this

Are they in from the courts?

Comment on this

They are in from the courts long ago and, thanks be to God, we have barristers who get briefs. They are not briefless barristers in any case.

Comment on this

They will need them after the next election.

Comment on this

Some Deputies might have had a brighter future in a different Party.

Comment on this

If Deputy Harte would concentrate on supplying clean meat to his constituents, he would do much better.

Comment on this

The only man who was proven to have sold stinking meat was Doctor Ward who was a member of a Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Crowley please cease interrupting and allow Deputy Harte to speak on the Bill.

Comment on this

I would ask you, a Cheann Comhairle, to ask Deputy Crowley to withdraw that remark. It is a reflection on my business, and incidentally, you were present on the night that allegation was made by the then Minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please leave the Chair out of this?

Comment on this

Did you hear the allegation?

Comment on this

The Deputy has nothing else to say.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see that it is any reflection on Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

The allegation was made by Deputy L'Estrange.

Comment on this

Make your speech.

Comment on this

I will make my speech but I want you, a Cheann Comhairle, to give a ruling on whether it is in order for Deputy Crowley to allege that I have supplied bad or rotten meat.

Comment on this

I never said that.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange said that.

Comment on this

I mentioned the case of Doctor Ward which was proved in court.

Comment on this

That is not what was proved.

Comment on this

Slimy bacon.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Could we have Deputy Harte, on the Bill?

Comment on this

I will continue with the Bill when you ask Deputy Crowley to withdraw that remark.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not see that it is any reflection on Deputy Harte and furthermore Deputy Harte made a reflection on Deputy Crowley.

Comment on this

I never mentioned Deputy Crowley's name.

Comment on this

There is a difference between a political reflection and a personal innuendo.

Comment on this

You mentioned it here last week.

Comment on this

I believe that Deputy Crowley's remark needs an explanation and I demand that you ask him to withdraw it.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not asking Deputy Crowley to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Deputy Harte has nothing else to say. He is just filibustering, waiting for the lawyers to come in.

Comment on this

One has arrived now.

Comment on this

If Deputy Crowley is getting his rotten information from the Minister for Agriculture let me state here and now that the Minister for Agriculture was in a position to inquire into the situation for which he alleged I was responsible. He declined. He is a mouse of a man and we know he is. That is where the Deputy got his information. He was disappointed that the Fine Gael Party did not accept him.

Comment on this

Now who is saying "rotten"? Does he mean meat?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Crowley does not cease interrupting, I will ask him to leave the House.

Comment on this

Sorry.

Comment on this

Now, big boy, that shook you.

Comment on this

The truth is bitter.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Crowley persists, I am asking him to leave the House.

Comment on this

I would ask you to allow him to stay.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is a matter for the Chair and not for Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

I would just make an appeal to you to allow him to stay.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Harte has nothing to say on the Bill, I would ask him to resume his seat.

Comment on this

Who is the new member of the Labour Front Bench?

Comment on this

If this Bill passes through this House and if the Government have their way, they will do everything in their power to avail of this last opportunity to seize absolute power because this is the only thing which the Minister for Local Government as the spokesman and the person most responsible to the Fianna Fáil Party aspires to—absolute power—and absolute power corrupts. This is why the Minister is anxious to push this legislation through the House. This is why he seeks to have the power at some future date, when the political scene is ripe and more advantageous for his Party, to go to the people and say: "This is what we want you to do", so that he can claim power absolutely. Absolute power corrupts.

A schoolchild said to me a few days ago: "When Fianna Fáil talk about the straight vote, what do they mean? Do they mean `straight' or `strait'?" There is a subtle difference. This is the thinking of a schoolchild. It spotlights the thinking of future generations. What does the Minister mean? Is it the straight and narrow he is talking about? Is this the straight vote he refers to or is it straight in the sense of fair play? Is it straight and simple that he means to convey to the House and, if it is, how can he explain that last week the Canadian Government were elected under the straight vote system for the first time in eight years as a majority government? How can the Minister explain that between 1910 and 1951 four Governments in Great Britain were elected on minority votes; four Governments, who received less votes than the total Opposition received, were elected as the majority Party in the House of Commons? Is this democracy?

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong there.

Comment on this

I do not claim to be correct all the time.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not right.

Comment on this

From 1910 to 1951, unless my information is incorrect, four British Governments were elected with a majority in the House of Commons, despite the fact that they received a minority popular vote.

Comment on this

Where does the Deputy get that from? I should like to hear the source of the quotation.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Allen cease interrupting?

Comment on this

Deputy Allen has yet to make his maiden speech. We now know the reason why.

Comment on this

I will give you a wager of ten to one on that. Take me up on that. I made it years ago.

Comment on this

If the Deputy is going to interject, he should do so intelligently.

Comment on this

Get your facts right.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If Deputy Allen persists, I will have to ask him to leave.

Comment on this

Do not, because it is not that often that he comes in. Some of the ushers wonder who the stranger is sitting in the back benches of the Fianna Fáil Party at times. In 1951, the Labour Party lost office in Britain, despite the fact that they increased their popular vote and received more votes than the Conservative Party. This is a recognised fact. If this is the system of democracy which the Minister claims is more pure, simpler and more democratic than the present system we have, then I do not follow his argument. Set against that, we have had Fianna Fáil Governments elected as minority governments, with 70-odd seats, maybe one or two seats less than the overall majority but, as against that, they have received 48 to 51 per cent of the votes. It has always been a fair return per Fianna Fáil Deputy from the system of proportional representation. No Fianna Fáil Deputy can dispute that the fairest system to the Fianna Fáil Party has been proportional representation. The former and founder Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party preached the fairness of the system of proportional representation and he has been repeatedly quoted by members of the Fine Gael Party and of the Labour Party during this long debate and I do not propose to go into these quotations again.

It has been established beyond reasonable doubt that the former Leader, the occupant of Aras an Uachtaráin, is on record as having said that no other system could give a more fair return than proportional representation. This was his line of thinking right up to the time he lost power in 1948. Subsequent to the formation of the first inter-Party Government, he changed horses. He then believed that proportional representation would not be as kind to the Fianna Fáil Party in the future as it had been in the past.

Last week, in the debate on an amendment, I mentioned that one of the tricks of proportional representation is that a government in power and, particularly, a Minister for Local Government who has the complete and absolute authority to draw the boundary lines of constituencies, can decide that a three-seat constituency would suit their Party in an area where that Party has one percentage more of the votes than 50, that they must get two seats out of three.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy——

Comment on this

If Deputy Allen stays there long enough, we may entice him to make his maiden speech. At least, he may have a few points that he could make. This has been the thinking of the Fianna Fáil Party in the past: in an area where they have something more than 50 per cent of the votes, if they make that area a three-seat constituency, they must come out with two out of three seats but if, on balance, the Opposition Parties have something more than 50 per cent of the votes, then by all means, they must make it a four-seat constituency inasmuch as when four Deputies are returned to the House, the voting power of the Opposition can be neutralised. This has been the pattern of Fianna Fáil administration. This has been their thinking in regard to proportional representation. This is the democracy which the Minister boasts of — abuse of the proportional representation system.

If it is contended that instability is wrong, how can any Deputy reasonably argue that you can have anything but instability from results in a four-seat constituency? Unless one Party has over 75 per cent of the votes, you will have a 50 per cent return from each constituency.

Immediately after 1948, when Fianna Fáil could see the writing on the wall, they believed that sooner or later their past would catch up with them and they began to think that proportional representation could be the stick that would beat them eventually. So they started to preach the advantage of the straight vote. As his legacy to that Party, their Leader, prior to the presidential election campaign of 1959, decided that proportional representation would be an issue in a referendum conjointly with the presidential election. As Deputy Tully has pointed out, Mr. de Valera was elected as the President of this country with a majority of 120,000 votes, despite the fact that the proportional representation proposal was defeated by 30,000 votes. These are the figures as far as I can remember them.

The argument has been put forward since then that had the Fianna Fáil Party listened to certain members within that group and, instead of going for the straight vote, had gone for the single-member constituency with the transferable vote, they would have got it through. All this time this cancer has been gnawing at the people who claimed that the straight vote was the only thing that could get through and the only thing that could perpetuate the existence of the Fianna Fáil Party.

These are things we know. Anyone who cares to examine or listen to political discussion within the ranks knows that since 1959 the Fianna Fáil Party have been divided on whether it is right to have the straight vote or to retain PR. We know that in 1959 certain members of the Party expressed the view within the ranks of the Party that if they put to the people the system of the single-member constituency, with the transferable vote, the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party might take it as a compromise, in view of the fact that the Opposition Parties at that time believed that Fianna Fáil were strong enough, having a candidate running for the Presidency on the same day as the referendum was being contested.

These were the things at issue in 1959. Despite that the Fianna Fáil Party stuck to their guns and were defeated in the referendum. Since that time, this movement within Fianna Fáil has been continually whispering that the leaders who took the decision in 1959 were wrong and should have gone for the single-member, single transferable vote system. It has been put on record that the former Leader of the Party, Deputy Seán Lemass—Deputy Andrews who was present can deny or confirm this—attended meetings of the Committee considering revision of the Constitution and is on record as saying that, unless the Fine Gael Party accepted the single transferable vote, the Constitution should be left alone. That is no secret. Everyone knows the way the Fianna Fáil Party have been thinking since 1959. Last week we had Deputy Norton tabling his amendment. We know who inspired that amendment. A certain Minister of the Fianna Fáil Government canvassed my personal opinion in regard to a change. Some members of the Fianna Fáil Party have taken exception to the fact that I have named them. I do not propose to name this Minister because it was in private conversation.

Comment on this

I take exception to the remark that a Fianna Fáil Minister would consider the Deputy's opinion important enough.

Comment on this

That is a matter of your opinion. That does not influence me in the least. A Deputy coming from a sheltered background like Deputy Andrews does not realise the importance of commonsense.

Comment on this

As propounded by the Deputy?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Harte.

Comment on this

A Minister of the Fianna Fáil Government tried to elicit my views on the single-member, single transferable vote. This was not too long ago. This was the feeling of the Fianna Fáil Party. They were sounding. They received a rebuff. If Deputy Norton's amendment were put to the House, Fine Gael would vote against it. A fortnight or three weeks ago, during my absence, the Minister tore the constituency of South-West Donegal apart. He went to great pains to explain to the House what would happen in Donegal if something was not done to change the Constitution. He forgot to say that the reason why——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This does not arise on the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution. We are dealing with the Bill before the House.

Comment on this

Would the Chair explain why it does not arise?

Comment on this

It is on the Third Amendment.

Comment on this

I am asking the Chair a question and it is not in order for the Minister to give his views.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has told the Deputy how he is out of order. It does not arise on the present Bill, the Bill we are now discussing. It would arise on the other Bill.

Comment on this

This only deals with single-member constituencies and the method of voting.

Comment on this

Can the Chair explain why I am out of order?

Comment on this

The matter of divergence arises on the other Bill.

Comment on this

I have addressed my question to the Chair.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The matter mentioned by the Deputy is not contained in this Bill.

Comment on this

Can the Chair say——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not going to cross-examine the Chair.

Comment on this

Excuse me, Sir, I do not wish to appear to do so at all. You say I am not in order?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is right.

Comment on this

Why am I not?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I have already told the Deputy twice.

Comment on this

I do not follow.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is not contained in this Bill before us. It was contained in the Third Amendment.

Comment on this

What is not contained?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What the Deputy mentioned.

Comment on this

What have I mentioned?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy does not know what he has mentioned, I am not going to tell him.

Comment on this

I had not mentioned anything.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I was only leading up to it.

Comment on this

The Deputy was talking about what would happen if the constituencies have to be revised under the present system. That is relevant to the Third Amendment.

Comment on this

The point I was trying to make was that under the present Constitution, six Deputies are elected from County Donegal. Two constituencies each return three Deputies. Under the Fianna Fáil administration, the population of Donegal has fallen drastically from 124,000 to 108,000.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that last week.

Comment on this

I will say it again because it is true.

Comment on this

And the Deputy will lose his seat.

Comment on this

No; Deputy O'Donnell is coming to Dublin.

Comment on this

The Minister insists that if the referendum is not carried——

Comment on this

Yes, the Third Amendment.

Comment on this

It does not matter which amendment. If the referendum is not carried, the Minister says Donegal will be reduced to a five-member constituency.

Comment on this

I quoted the Deputy as saying that should happen.

Comment on this

Look, I know the Minister is ignorant, but there are people in the Public Gallery. Watch it. The Minister maintains that if the referendum is not carried, Donegal will be reduced to a five-member constituency. This would give a surplus of 8,000 votes. Those 8,000 votes would have to be transferred into North Leitrim and this would have the effect of depriving Deputy O'Donnell of his seat. But the Minister forgot that Deputy O'Donnell would not be the weak member in that constituency. I submit that the Minister for Social Welfare might be the weak member, and that, instead of Fianna Fáil returning four out of six, they would be returning two out of five, with the Ceann Comhairle being returned automatically.

Comment on this

I want to point out to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that Deputy Harte is discussing what will happen in the two constituencies of Donegal if the Third Amendment of the Constitution Bill is not passed and that therefore I presume I have the right to deal with that situation also.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair directs the attention of Deputy Harte to the fact that what is before the House in the present Bill is the question of single-member constituencies and the single non-transferable vote. Nothing else is before the House in this Bill.

Comment on this

I appreciate you were not here, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, for the earlier discussion between the Ceann Comhairle, the Minister and myself. I maintain that within the ambit of the amendments to the Constitution I am in order. I feel at this stage I should be allowed to put on record that the Minister for Local Government is not confusing anyone in Donegal and that his threats to the people of South-West Donegal are falling on deaf ears. What they are being asked to do in these amendments is to decide whether the Fianna Fáil administration has fulfilled its promises and has served them reasonably well over the past 30 years by allowing the population of that county to reduce from a stage when it was able——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

What is before the House on this Bill, the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, is the question of the single-member constituency and what is termed the straight vote.

Comment on this

The Minister was arguing a fortnight or three weeks ago that if these proposals were not carried, if the single-member constituencies were not accepted by the people the result would be—am I in order in following through that argument?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister has not spoken in this debate so far. The Deputy is in possession and the Chair is pointing out that what is before the House is the question of the single-member constituency and the single non-transferable vote.

Comment on this

I submit to your ruling.

Comment on this

Having dealt with it.

Comment on this

No. I should like to go into it in more detail but we shall meet at Bundoran or Ballyshannon.

Comment on this

If this amendment is carried, we shall have a situation where not alone will people electing Deputies to represent them not have a choice in selecting the type of candidate who should represent their Party but the hard core of the Party's supporters within the framework of a constituency organisation may be deprived of the selection of that candidate. By way of example, in a constituency such as my own, three Members are elected. I am not concerned with the machinery of the Fianna Fáil Party. They select a number of candidates under the present system to represent them in a general election and Fine Gael, with whom I am more concerned, will select two candidates. At present Fianna Fáil elect two Deputies and Fine Gael elect one. If the Fine Gael supporters in North-East Donegal and the Party organisation there are dissatisfied, they have a democratic right to elect the other candidate contesting the election with me. Fianna Fáil believe this should not be done and that single-member constituencies should be designed to elect one member to represent them.

I can visualise the situation where the general headquarters in Dublin of any Party will direct a local organisation to select a particular candidate and an outstanding candidate living in the constituency where his Party is not in control of the votes may have to move outside the constituency to be elected. It is for this reason that I do not agree with the Minister for Local Government or Fianna Fáil in their attempt to abolish PR and it is for the same reason I think this Bill should be defeated. For this reason also, this generation should look at the political scene and ask what guarantee would any future generation have if the amendments of the Constitution proposed by the Government are carried when the referendum is put to the people, what guarantee would there be that an electoral dictatorship such as the Minister for Local Government would wish to have, would not result? What guarantee would there be that their democratic rights would not be interfered with to a greater extent than is proposed in these moves to amend the Constitution?

There are many things that could be said against these proposals. It is the attitude of Fine Gael that the sooner this Bill is dealt with in the House and the sooner the Minister puts it to the people for decision——

Comment on this

Was the Deputy not told to hold it up?

Comment on this

This is another fallacy. This is the type of conduct we must tolerate from the Minister for Local Government. A fortnight ago he spoke for seven hours about nothing while his Party were being torn asunder deciding whether they should accept Deputy Norton's amendment or not. Immediately afterwards an announcement was made by the Taoiseach that there was an unanimous decision. Someone has said that there is a new definition of "unanimous", that it means equally divided in the Fianna Fáil Party. We know that they were equally divided.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This would seem to be irrelevant.

Comment on this

It is just as irrelevant as the Minister's remarks to which I have been replying. I want to say in conclusion——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Deputy Andrews is a smart Deputy, one of the briefless barristers of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Tell us about the views of Deputy Cosgrave. The people in the Gallery who were mentioned would like to hear them.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave is an honourable Deputy, something I cannot say about Deputy Andrews.

Comment on this

Nobody denied that.

Comment on this

Deputy Cosgrave has put on record his personal views.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

What we are concerned about is what is in the Bill.

Comment on this

Why did he not vote?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He was paired with Deputy Seán Lemass, the man who said this was as dead as the dodo.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Harte, on the Bill.

Comment on this

I was concluding only for Deputy Andrews becoming slightly sarcastic. One of the reasons I oppose this Bill is that it is Deputies with bright ideas like Deputy Andrews who have to walk about ten feet that they want elected, Deputies who have been reared in an atmosphere sheltered from the outside world, who have never known what it is to go hungry or to walk to school. They were driven to school in motorcars. That is the protected life he had as a child. I do not want Deputies like that elected and that is why I am opposing this measure. That is the type of Deputy Fianna Fáil want to get into the House, the mohair executives who control the Fianna Fáil camp. This is what the Minister aspires to.

Comment on this

Look to your left.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Would Deputy Harte come back to the business before the House?

Comment on this

The starving Deputy from Donegal.

Comment on this

This is the type——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions from any side of the House are disorderly.

Comment on this

Sorry; it is very difficult to be silent.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Especially for Deputies who are not prepared to speak on the measure.

Comment on this

Deputy Andrews has not spoken——

Comment on this

I have spoken a number of times on the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy did not tell us about the Committee's report.

Comment on this

I told the Deputy he was speaking falsely.

Comment on this

I want to conclude by saying that my attitude to this measure is that the sooner it is passed through the House and put to the people for decision the better I shall like it. For this reason I am not speaking at any great length and possibly it is for this reason that Deputy Andrews is in agreement with me. Why has not Deputy Andrews——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must draw to the attention of the Deputy the fact that this is irrelevant. He should confine himself to the Bill.

Comment on this

The sooner this Bill goes to the people the better.

Comment on this
Stephen D. Barrett Mr. S.D. Barrett Fine Gael

In this debate Deputy Norton was upbraiding the Fine Gael Party for complaining about the expenditure involved in the passing of this Amendment by way of referendum. Deputy Norton can take it that no Member of the Fine Gael Party would object to the expenditure of this money, if one sound, convincing reason for the passage of this Bill through the Oireachtas were forthcoming in the course of the debates to which we have listened over an extended period. A remarkable aspect of this debate and of the passage of this obnoxious and abhorrent measure through this House has been that never once from either the front or the back benches of the Fianna Fáil Party was there any argument adduced which was not adduced in 1959 when the Irish people were asked to express their views on an exactly similar measure. Taking up that invitation, the Irish people decided they were dead against the 1959 measure.

One would think that a responsible Government Party proffering a similar measure after the end of such a short time would come forward and say to this House: "There are new reasons which have emerged since 1959." No such new reason have been given to this House. No such new reason have been offered by way of argument to the electorate to whom this measure will be submitted by way of referendum later on. The same old spurious reasons are being given to the House.

Comment on this

Like the Deputy's.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions of all kinds will have to cease.

Comment on this
Stephen D. Barrett Mr. S.D. Barrett Fine Gael

Deputy Crowley's interruptions do not affect me.

Comment on this