An Bille um an gCeathrú Leasú ar an mBunreacht, 1968: An Tuarascáil agus an Chéim Dheiridh. Fourth Amendment of the Constitution Bill, 1968: Report and Final Stages.
Contributions 416–610 of 610. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.
No. 6 of 1968 ›
I am thankful for that, Sir. We still have the same old arguments about stability, that we cannot achieve stability under PR. There are two ways of looking at stability. Do the Government mean, by that, stability from the point of view of maintaining a Government in this House? If they do, the history of this House since 1945 gives an absolute answer. Far from having unstable government from the point of view of the length of life of Governments in this House, we have had a remarkably stable atmosphere here since the general election of 1944. The Government elected in 1944 lasted three years and seven months; the Government elected in 1948 lasted three years and three months; the Government elected in 1951 lasted two years and ten months; the Government elected in 1945 lasted two years and eight months; the Government elected in 1957 lasted four years and six months.
Deputy Norton is again commencing his interruptions. They say that when a rook either deserts or is deserted by a rookery, it flies by itself, making strange sounds which may be mistaken for caws because it is nervous and feels alone, and this possibly is the psychological background to the mutterings we have been hearing from this part of the House ever since discussion commenced on this Bill. I hope that the psychological reasons will be removed or that the sufferer will remove himself if he cannot behave like a gentleman. I do not like being cawed at by lone, rejected rooks. I was about to say, when Deputy Norton commenced to interrupt, that the 1961 Government lasted three years and five months, and since April, 1966, this present Dáil is in session. Can any Deputy from the Fianna Fáil Government side suggest that that does not represent stable government?
If, on the other hand, the Fianna Fáil Party mean that PR does not bring about stable government, I should like to point out that if you examine the history of the British House of Commons over the past 120 years under the straight vote, which Fianna Fáil now press for, you will see that at least half of that period has seen coalition governments in the British House of Commons. I am not unique in making the suggestion in this House that PR can achieve stability. I quote from volume 67/68, column 1343, of the Official Report of 1st June, 1937, in which the then Leader of the Fianna Fáil Party, Deputy de Valera, talking about the PR system, used these words:
...we have to be very grateful that we have had the system of proportional representation here. It gives a certain amount of stability.
None of us this side of the House who are pressing on the Irish people the necessity to retain PR has suggested that 100 per cent stability is possible. We make only the same claim as was made from that side of the House by the then Leader of that Party when he said PR gives a certain amount of stability.
Another reason adduced here during these debates by the Government Party —a reason which is quite familiar, because the same reason was being adduced in 1959—for the rejection of PR is that it is difficult for the people to follow, that the Irish people cannot express their preference through the involved process of PR. That might have been, and probably was, a valid argument in 1922 and around then when the PR system was first introduced, but it is not now, and the official statistics show it is not now. The official statistics show how accustomed the Irish people have become to using PR now compared to 1922. In testing the Irish voters' ability properly to use PR, the only normal standard one can apply is the percentage of spoiled votes in general elections. In 1922 one might have been dismayed by the fact that 3.08 per cent of the electorate spoiled their votes and that in 1923 3.66 per cent of the electorate spoiled their votes. Let us progress down the years, without going through each general election, to more modern times. In the 1961 general election, only .96 per cent of the electorate spoiled their votes, and that .96 per cent was by no means people who did not know how to vote. As anybody who ever attends a count knows, there are certain thoughtful souls who simply write rude messages to show they think nothing of any political institutions. In 1965 the percentage of spoiled votes was a mere .91 per cent.
Where in those figures can the Government find any single prop for their argument that PR should be done away with because the Irish people do not know how to use it? I venture to suggest that the percentage of spoiled votes here is no greater than in any other country where the straight vote is operated. Again we heard the old familiar argument that people do not approach the polls because of the PR system. That is not true either. The history of our general elections throughout the years shows that more people now are attending the polls than in 1922, when there was perhaps more reason why people should attend at the polls, and there were certainly more stirring events to be decided.
In 1922 only 62 per cent of the electorate exercised the franchise; in 1923 only 61 per cent of the electorate exercised the franchise. Far from interest in political affairs waning because of the baleful influence of PR, we are glad and rejoice in the fact that the Irish people are now more than ever politically conscious, and conscious of the importance of their rights as voters, and as cogs in the electoral machine. In 1961, 70.6 per cent of the electorate voted and in 1965 75.1 per cent of the electorate voted. So we can dispose of the main argument adduced by the Government to try to see that this Bill goes through the House. We are asking the people to say that this is abhorrent and obnoxious.
I do not want to repeat the statistics that have already been used in the course of the debate today. I should like to say that the system which the Fianna Fáil Party are now advocating will produce results which are the very negation of democracy. Deputy Harte and Deputy Fitzpatrick gave the figures, but I should like to repeat one historical example of the injustice which the single-seat system can wreak on the electorate which occurred in the British general election in 1924 in the Southern Counties which were predominantly Conservative.
There were 82 seats available in the Southern Counties and 1,500,000 people approximately voted Conservative and 1 million approximately voted Labour. That means that 50 per cent more voted Conservative than voted Labour, to decide who would fill the 82 seats. The result was that 81 of the 82 seats went to the 1½ million voters and only one seat went to the 1 million voters. I do not want to see that happening here. The Fine Gael Party do not want to see that happening here. Any ordinary sane and sensible Irish man or woman does not want to see that happening here. Whatever the Minister might do, and whatever those behind him might do, I am perfectly satisfied that when this Bill is submitted by way of referendum to the Irish people it will be rejected with the contumely it deserves.
I am satisfied that even the inadequate reasons which have been adduced by Government speakers are not the real reasons why they are bringing this measure before the House again. The reasons are to be found in the fright the Fianna Fáil Party got in the last presidential election and the rebuff they experienced in the local elections. The writing has been on the wall twice already. Before they can progress into general election level, the Fianna Fáil Party are now trying to stifle the voice of the electorate in a constitutional way. It is only in moments of petulance that the Fianna Fáil Party are inclined to give us the truth. In such a moment their former Leader spoke here.
When Deputy Dillon told the House in the course of a debate on a similar Bill in 1959 that the only reason the Government were introducing that measure was that Fianna Fáil were defeated in 1948 and 1954, the then Leader of the House, Deputy de Valera, nodded his head and said, "Precisely". There was another reference in this House by Deputy Blaney, now Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, who, when PR was being discussed on the last occasion, said that when PR was gone, not only was PR gone but the Labour Party, Clann na Talmhan, Clann na Poblachta were gone, and Fine Gael would be on the way out too.
These are the fundamental arguments behind this measure. On this occasion no one on the Fianna Fáil side has lost his temper sufficiently or become petulant enough to tell the Irish people the real reasons behind this measure which were those given to the House in a fit of temper by Deputy de Valera, as he then was, and by Deputy Blaney. Those are unworthy reasons for taking up the time of this House. Those are unworthy reasons for putting the Irish people to the test at the polls. Those are unworthy reasons for the expenditure of between £100,000 and £150,000. Those are unworthy reasons for taking up the time of the House while important legislation awaits it.
I am not surprised that in this debate so far today, although we were told last week that the Fianna Fáil Party are arm in arm behind their leaders, and that there was unanimity to the last man, not one back bencher has spoken in favour of this nefarious measure. I would not mind taking a bet that if we are here until 10.30 tonight or until Tibb's Eve, we will not hear the unanimity which apparently emanated from the Fianna Fáil Party rooms on the occasion of the Party meeting last week emanating from the back benchers in public here.
Comment on this
To put Deputy Barrett at his ease, I should like to speak on behalf of the Fianna Fáil back benchers and say on their behalf that we are entirely behind the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
I hope Deputy Barrett will accept my assurance. Having listened for some time to lectures on the truth according to Fine Gael, and having listened to lectures on what Mr. de Valera said in such-and-such a year, or what so-and-so said in such-and-such a year, I think it comes very shallow from the Party which despised Uachtarán na hÉireann for years and did everything to villify this man's great name, using his name or abusing it. This is what I find abhorrent. This debate is bedevilled by cant and humbug. The last speaker used the honoured name of Uachtarán na hÉireann although his Party made every effort to ensure that he would not be a Deputy never mind Taoiseach or President of our country. It comes shallow to hear them use this honoured name.
We also hear the Constitution being used in support of their arguments. The Fine Gael Party tried to ensure that the Constitution would not be passed and now they are abusing it——
Comment on this
——and using it to substantiate their arguments. This was the Constitution they went out to defeat. They are also using the informal committee on the Constitution. Deputy Fitzpatrick alleged that I did not speak in this debate. I have spoken a number of times and expressed a point of view on behalf of the constituents I represent. I can assure Deputy Fitzpatrick that I do not intend abusing the informal committee on the Constitution by stating who said what on any given issue. I do not intend breaking confidences. The report speaks for itself. Members of the various political Parties contributed their views and alternatives, and, as you yourself know, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, there were pros and cons and arguments in favour of the various subjects placed on record in the report. It was not a Committee of this House; it was an informal all-Party Committee and as such, the views of the members were not binding. In relation to the proposal before us, I can assure Deputy Fitzpatrick that no member of my Party expressed a point of view on that subject, nor indeed did any member of his Party, and I think it is true to say——
Comment on this
——that Deputy T.F. O'Higgins will support me on that. It might reply to the serious allegations which appeared in various newspapers last week that I was afraid, as the Deputy so snidely put it, to come in and reply to them. That is the reply to his question. I do not intend breaking confidences. He can use any report he likes or abuse it by speculation and fabrication and by untruths as he has done. This is typical of the cornered rodent attitude which is prevalent in his Party at present.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There is not one argument in the report in favour of the proposal before us.
Comment on this
I put my reply to Deputy Fitzpatrick on the record. For all the quotations given by the Fine Gael Party on this matter, abusing Mr. de Valera for instance, I could well give quotations made by members of their Party in support of the abolition of proportional representation. I could quote Deputy Dillon, or Deputy Flanagan, or Deputy Cosgrave, and quote with a certain amount of assurance the brother of Deputy Maurice Dockrell, Deputy H.P. Dockrell.
Comment on this
I am not going to filibuster. We have been accused of filibustering but it is an extraordinary thing that in the past few hours quite a number of Opposition Deputies have spoken. If they are anxious to get these proposals to the country, why do they not let the Minister get in?
Comment on this
The question of the cost of the referendum was brought up and Deputy Norton put it on record that it is only going to cost 2/- per voter to find out his opinion. This is not very much in terms of cash, to ask the opinion of the electorate. Despite what the Fine Gael Party say, the Fianna Fáil Party are not going to decide this issue; the Fine Gael Party are not going to decide this issue nor are the Labour Party going to decide it. The people of this country are going to decide it.
Comment on this
This, of course, is more of it, deciding the matter without letting it go to the people. The will of the people will prevail on this issue. No matter what abuse the Opposition throw at us about dictatorship, we have no objection because we are prepared to go to the country. We would be glad to go and we would be glad to accept the will of the people on this issue. In my opinion, this is what democracy is all about. I have made the point that, as Deputy Norton said, the cost of this will be 2/- per voter. This is very reasonable.
Comment on this
Deputy Kyne, a responsible member of the Labour Party and their spokesman on health, called for a general strike on the day of the referendum, mark you. This is a very interesting thought in terms of cost. What would a general strike cost the country?
Comment on this
Deputy Ryan says that a countrywide strike would cost the country £150,000. This is typical——
Comment on this
I hope the newspapers take note of the fact that Deputy Ryan made the point that a general strike would only cost the country——
Comment on this
I did not use the word "only". The Deputy asked a question and I posed a figure for his consideration.
Comment on this
I hope the newspapers make it clear that Deputy Kyne has called for a general strike on the day these proposals are to be put before the people.
Comment on this
I wanted to make these points on the winding up of this debate. I have not been given the speak on behalf of the Fianna Fáil backbenchers who are totally behind the Taoiseach for the single-seat straight vote proposals and all behind the Minister for Local Government. Despite all the abuse he has been getting over the past few months, he has done an excellent job in removing the hysteria generated by the Fine Gael Party in particular from the people's minds. Their tactics have been the tactics of those facing defeat, if not on this issue, then in the next general election. They are the tactics of a tired Party, nothing new, all old hat. Their politics, as I have often said before, are the politics of right wing conservatives, which I think is a bad thing for the country. They are not really an Opposition.
Comment on this
I believe in giving every man, woman and child a free education and that is one of the reasons I am in this Party. We are the best political vehicle to achieve this. I believe we will achieve this ideal——
Comment on this
I congratulate the Minister on what he has been doing. He has been going through a difficult enough time, without the Opposition acting histrionically and spreading speaking histrionically and spreading this prophecy of doom all over the country. People like Miss Enid Lakeman of the Proportional Representation Society are well matched with the Fine Gael Party. Maybe the Fine Gael Party will ask Miss Lakeman to come over and uphold them on this particular issue. They would be doing a great service for the Government on this issue. Again I reiterate my challenge to Deputy Cosgrave and Deputy H.P. Dockrell to appear with Deputy Booth and myself on television to discuss this matter in relation to our constituency. We are in an unusual position in Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown in that we have two Fianna Fáil Deputies in favour of the Government's proposals and—listen to this—we also got two Fine Gael members in that constituency who are in favour of these proposals.
Comment on this
We have Deputy Dockrell in favour of the Government's proposal. That is the extraordinary position. I believe we will do well because I believe the people recognise the fallacy in proportional representation.
Comment on this
The Andrews family have been interested in the social problems of this city and county over the past 30 years.
Comment on this
These interruptions are inviting further comment. Deputy Harte will cease interrupting.
Comment on this
This is more of the humbug. I do not intend to reply. I am grateful for having had an opportunity to clear the minds of Deputy Fitzpatrick and others who think Fianna Fáil are afraid of this proposition.
Comment on this
I speak lest anyone should think I have suffered any conversion to the so-called straight vote during the course of this debate. I was against it at the outset: I am still against it.
Comment on this
There will be a counting of heads now in Fine Gael. Everyone in favour has to come in and speak.
Comment on this
I should not like to accuse Deputy Andrews of telling an untruth, but it is news to me that my brother, Deputy H.P. Dockrell, is in favour of the straight vote. He is not in favour of the straight vote.
Comment on this
I did not hear his point of view, so I assumed, from his silence, that he was in favour of his leader and constituency colleague.
Comment on this
Would the Minister tell us how he issued a bulletin from a meeting about something that had not been discussed at the meeting?
Comment on this
The Minister is not the Taoiseach, but could he tell me how a bulletin was issued about a matter that was not on the agenda?
Comment on this
These interruptions must cease. Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Fitzpatrick must cease interrupting.
Comment on this
It is a strange thing that this debate should arouse such heat in the ranks of the Fianna Fáil Party. Deputy Andrews is a quiet man, but this debate seems somehow to have got his ire. He made great play with the quotations used by this side of the House. I do not propose to go back over these quotations because a great deal has been said on this Bill already and on the parallel measure. I would say, however, to Deputies on the Government benches and to the people generally that the reason we mentioned these quotations was to show that the Fianna Fáil Party did not always think against proportional representation as they think now. The quotations were necessary to show how they once thought and to demonstrate that now they have changed their minds. But they have put forward here no valid reasons for changing their minds except political greed. That is the truth, as I see it, and as many people in the country see it. It is because of that that we introduced these quotations. Sometimes they may have seemed rather harsh, but, in a matter like this, which touches the fundamental roots of our being, it is only natural that names should be mentioned and that quotations from people prominent in this House in the past should be brought out to show that there is no real valid argument put forward for these proposals.
I have listened to and I have read a great deal of what the Minister said about the Fourth Amendment of the Constitution. The Constitution is accepted by all our people as a good Constitution, in many ways a very good Constitution. I am not aware of any vital defects in it. It has served the country well since its enactment. Why should a Party now wish to change this Constitution, a Constitution introduced by themselves, without giving the country very valid reasons for that change? No valid reasons of any kind have been advanced here, singly or collectively.
The word "stability" has been used a great deal in connection with this Bill. It has been argued that stability would come through the so-called straight vote. Again and again we have shown that Governments have, in fact, lasted a long time here, in many cases a much longer period than comparable governments elected in other parts of these islands on the straight vote system. In other words, in Britain, with the straight vote and a sometimes overwhelming majority, there has not been the stability that the parties gaining such majorities would have liked. Stability is, in fact, engendered by good government, by wise and prudent acts and by a proper handling of affairs. Stability is not engendered by the method of election. It is a red herring to argue or, even by inference, to hint, that we are about to have a position of instability because of our method of election. That is simply not the fact and no valid arguments in support of that contention have been put forward.
There has been a great deal of declamation. Conclusions have been drawn from facts which do not warrant the conclusions drawn. Things have been given to us from the Government benches as facts when they are not facts: they are opinions. It has already been said that the Irish people did not use PR properly. I consider, and many people like me consider, that the Irish people understand PR thoroughly and use it extremely skilfully. The case was cited of how, during the presidential election, the present honoured occupant of that honoured position got in and, at the same time, the referendum was decisively beaten. That shows that our people do know how to use PR.
Comment on this
He was not very honoured during the last election campaign by the Fine Gael election tactics. Remember your slander campaign a couple of years ago?
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister should say that. I have paid a sincere tribute to the occupant of that honoured position.
Comment on this
Is it? The Minister pretends to read my mind better than I do myself. I will just say this to the Minister: I am a member of the Council of State, which is the highest body in this country, and chosen as such by the President of Ireland, and I think it comes very ill from the Minister to accuse me of hypocrisy in a matter which touches that office.
Comment on this
I am dealing with the Bill but I have unfortunately had to deal with the Minister's uncalled for and unwarranted interruption—not that I mind an interruption in the least, but I do not like an interruption of a nature which would reflect on my honour.
To continue on the Bill—I looked at figures in the paper today, my eye just falling on them. They show that under the single-seat non-transferable vote, you can have a minority government. I saw where a member of the House of Commons was elected at the last election by getting 18,300 votes. I totted up the votes given to his two opponents and they came to something like 18,900. There was, in that particular constituency in England, a minority electing a man and that can and is duplicated in many constituencies which have the single transferable vote.
I come now to a matter concerning minorities. I should like to say, as a member of a religious minority, that I pay tribute to the successive Irish Governments. I think it is the pride of Ireland that it has treated its minorities in the way it has. During my time in this House, which goes back over 25 years, and during my father's period which would bring it back to 1932, and indeed you can go back to 1922, I have never known of a single issue which came before this House which had the slightest taint of being unfair to minorities in any way. I pay a sincere tribute in that regard, and so I say that the minorities' guarantee of fair play is not based on a need for PR but is based on the fact that the Irish people abhor anything in the nature of deciding issues on the basis of religious differences or anything like that. That has never been the way in this country. However, what I do want to say is that when PR came in, it was brought in as a political and religious protection for minorities, and it was gladly and generously embraced by the Sinn Féin leaders of the day. They in their generosity of mind which somehow echoed the generosity of mind of a person like Wolfe Tone—he had that great wish to unite all the people of Ireland by good government and by acts of generosity—warmly embraced it because they knew that the Irish people were overwhelmingly in favour of self-government and that the minorities could be protected in this manner and that the Irish ideal of self-government would not be harmed.
We here, of all Parties, would like to see Ireland north and south united. I firmly believe that this doing away with PR does not help that ultimate union. I will not go as far as to say that this would wreck something like that, no, but it would be very much a further earnest of the intention of the southern Irish people to protect safeguards which, if and when the North comes in with the South, would be a protection and a bulwark for them. Therefore, I think that apart from all the political reasons which can be advanced against the abolition of PR this looking into the future, looking perhaps far ahead, and showing that the South deliberately rejected the idea of going for the single transferable vote goes far to make this portion of Ireland more attractive for our brethren in the north.
For all those reasons, and I am only touching on them briefly, I feel that this proposal to do away with PR is something the House should reject. It should never have been brought forward. We, as a people, understand PR thoroughly. The Government have shown no real reason for abolishing it, except the fact that it would temporarily enhance their position and for some reason they are not taking the long-term view of what would be best for this country in the future. They are prepared to go for an immediate advantage or what they think would be an immediate advantage, and perhaps wreck very many well-meaning visions of what is best for the country in the future. Therefore, I ask this House to vote against the abolition of PR and, when it comes before the people, I am sure that they will decisively reject it as they rejected it on the last occasion.
Comment on this
May I start where the last speaker finished? I have been here for the last 3½ hours, with the exception of ten minutes, listening to Opposition speakers. If they cannot step up their performances for the people, there will be no doubt about the way this vote will be carried. One Member over there said that he had heard nothing new from this side of the House. It certainly amazes me that so many Members across the Chamber should have such little regard for their blood-pressure as to behave as they have been behaving here for the last three hours.
The people on the other side of the House want to know what demand have the people made for a referendum. Surely, in a democracy, a Government have to think of what will be best for the people in changing world conditions. Whatever one may quote from the person who is now President of the State or from Deputy Dillon or any other Deputy ten, 15, or 20 years ago, does not bear much weight now because the world is changing and nothing stands still. It is said that the devil can quote scripture for his own purpose. We seem to be doing that to great advantage, or seeming advantage, here.
I heard Deputy Dillon this afternoon say again that if the straight vote, single-seat method of election came in, circumstances would arise, or might arise where the people would have to go to the barricades because they could not express their will and because they could not have some say in the government of the country. Does it occur to Deputy Dillon that the very reason why the proportional representation system is working successfully at the present time in France is the violence and the fact that the people had to go to the barricades? Any thinking person must agree that that is the principal reason why one Party is on the way to getting an overall majority. Are we going to suffer that risk in the future? It is all very well to say, and we would all subscribe to the idea, that proportional representation has worked well here over the years, but we must think of the future.
I have been listening to both Parties in Opposition assuring us that Fianna Fáil cannot possibly get an overall majority in the next election. The Opposition have stated that categorically. They seem to have no doubt about it. At the same time, they say that they are not going to form any coalition. What is going to happen? Are we going to have minority government? Is that what we desire? Is that what the people desire? Is that what they wish for us?
I have no intention at this stage of going into the pros and cons of proportional representation versus the straight vote. We have been listening to the arguments here for months. I would much prefer to tell the people whom I will be asking to vote what I think is right than to be speaking to people here whose minds cannot be changed by anything I say.
We have heard that this method of the straight vote will mean safe seats and comparison is made with the North of Ireland and with the South of England, which was so conservative. We know that there is no comparison whatever between this part of Ireland and the North of Ireland where the people of one religion and one political thought live in one section of the area and the others live in another section and the boundary can be very easily defined. It is the same way in Britain. There is a tradition in some places where the Conservative Party have very heavy majorities and can get away with it. It only brings home what I have often felt, that most members of the Opposition Parties do not give the people of Ireland credit for any intelligence. In my experience, you could not designate any section of the community as being pro-Fine Gael, pro-Fianna Fáil, pro-Labour or pro-anything. You could not do it. They are scattered and mixed-up. Whatever happens, everybody in the constituency and in the area in which the election will take place will be represented.
I also firmly believe that the people will not be satisfied with the candidate sent down from headquarters, as was feared by some Opposition speakers. If the candidate is not able to work for the constituency and the constituents, it will not be a safe seat for him. There will be many contenders from his own and other Parties for the seat and he will not get it in a small, contained area where the people know exactly what is happening.
We could keep talking on this subject. It has been thrown at us that the Fianna Fáil Party members have not contained area where the people know they should. That was said very early on when some members of the Opposition spoke for nearly four hours and for 2½ hours at a time. We remained silent because we had nothing to say, because we agreed with what was happening. When it was suggested that our silence could be taken to mean that we did not agree with the policy, we came in and then we were accused of filibustering. Today, when Opposition speakers went on continuously and only one or two of us spoke, it was suggested that we were not speaking because we did not believe in what the Party proposes. I gave my word here last week, and I say it again, that in my presence I have never heard a member of the Fianna Fáil Party at a Party meeting saying that he did not believe that the straight vote, single-seat, was the best possible method for the country. I have never heard that. I have never known a decision to be taken 50-50 or even 95-5. It was a unanimous decision. Of course, I know how difficult it is and am old enough to know, because I could produce a Sunday newspaper with banner headlines something like naming the men who were daggers drawn to succeed the present President when he left office—all conjectures—and how the Party was split from top to bottom and how it was breaking up. Today we have much the same thing—a Deputy on the other side of the House telling us that Fianna Fáil were doing this for their own survival when it must be patently obvious that, under the present system, Fianna Fáil will do at least as well as any other Party in the House and will certainly survive when others are forgotten.
That seems to me to be a fair reflection of what the people would think. Therefore, as I see it, Fianna Fáil are not forcing the people to adopt this measure. All they are doing is putting the two systems before the people and saying: "You choose. We think it is better for the future. You know what the other system has done in the past. We show you the dangers that we feel may exist." I agree with Deputy Dockrell that it is only a supposition as to what may happen. We know what happened in 1959 when the proposal was defeated in the referendum. We were told that Fianna Fáil could not survive as a Party but it is here stronger than ever before.
One cannot say definitely what will happen but you can say to the people that there is a danger of what happened in Italy, what is happening in Belgium, France and various places, happening here. We can also say that the system used in Britain fairly successfully for 150 years is one in which we could put our trust, not because the British use it, but because it is a tried system. Maybe it does not give everybody the same voting power as our system does but I do not think that is a bad thing. Our first duty is to elect a Government, not a House of Representatives representing every Tom, Dick and Harry and every crackpot in the country. Our first duty is to show the people how to elect a Government and, in doing that, also show them the easiest way to get rid of that Government if they do not like it, the very easiest way. We are doing that and that is the essence of democracy.
As I said in my last contribution, I only wish that Members of this House would behave like adults and put this issue to the people objectively. Let the Opposition speakers keep their powder dry until they go to the people and tell the people what exactly is right or wrong with the system we suggest and which they may adopt now and what is right with proportional representation. I certainly am not sorry I sat here. I really believe anybody reading the Dáil Debates must agree that there is not anything but supposition coming from the other Parties. Fianna Fáil are supposed to be split. The Taoiseach is not supposed to be completely in favour of the straight vote. Various things are supposed to happen —all completely without foundation. Naturally, as a member of the Party, I am glad to be able to say that. But I can realise how the other Parties must be disillusioned that after all these years Fianna Fáil are as united and as strong as they ever were in the past. It is with the greatest confidence I would go to the people and ask them to adopt the straight vote and the single seat. I feel I could retire peacefully from public life and know the country was well prepared to elect a Government that would be able to govern and that would be answerable to the people every five years.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I must thank Deputy Healy for describing this proposed system correctly as the British system. He was the first speaker today to describe it as such and advert to the fact it was 150 years old—“a tried and trusted system,” as he described it. Other speakers, with their tongues in their cheeks, have been inclined to describe it as the straight vote. It is the British system and the system in Northern Ireland and there is no use maintaining it is anything else.
However, I take issue with Deputy Healy when he says there would be no danger of safe seats in our community here. His argument was that there were no specific pockets of voting power one way or another in this country. That may be so. He mentioned, for example, that in Britain you had regional areas of Conservatism—and, I presume, as a natural corollary, regional areas of Labour—and that in Northern Ireland you had people divided on the basis of religion, Orangeism and Nationalism, and tending to live in areas, too. You have the same strict voting system here, not perhaps as he says in regions, but it exists just the same. You have traditionalism here. It is diffuse traditionalism, but it is there. I believe it will be sufficient to give us safe seats in the same proportion as exists in Northern Ireland and probably a higher proportion than in Great Britain.
The Minister is producing this electoral change for a specific purpose. He says he wants to abolish small Parties. He wants to develop a two-Party system. When he speaks of abolishing small Parties, I can only assume that the purpose is to abolish the only small Party here at present—the Labour Party—or else it is a prophylactic measure to prevent the emergence of small Parties in the future. If it is to lead to the two-Party system, that will not be the immediate result. The immediate result of such a change, if adopted, will be the obliteration of Labour and the development of a largely one-Party system, because Fine Gael will lose considerably under the new system. We are promised pie in the sky, that in ten, 15 or 20 years time there would evolve a two-Party system more or less balanced. That would be a desirable thing if one felt it could be provided within a reasonable period. As far as I can judge the situation, that will not obtain; nor do I think Fianna Fáil are serious in that. They are speaking with their tongues in their cheeks. They are speaking about providing a two-Party system when what they really mean is that they want to perpetuate themselves in office and provide simply a one-Party system.
I do not know what particular animus the Minister and his Party bear towards small Parties. He mentioned the previous inter-Party Government as being something to be avoided in the future. That is a matter of opinion. Fianna Fáil are entitled to express their opinion as regards inter-Party government and the people on this side of the House who participate in inter-Party government are entitled to express their opinions, which of course would be diametrically opposite.
When speaking here on March 27th I advocated a united Opposition. The Minister's strictures about the failure of this side of the House to provide a proper Opposition may have some basis. Certainly it is true that down through the years the people have not given any Party on this side of the House sufficient support to form an alternative Government. Fine Gael have not won an election for 40 years and Labour have never won an election. By that I mean won sufficient seats to form a Government. We therefore seem to have reached a stalemate. We seem to be at a crossroads.
During all that period various small Parties came in and out of this House. During that period the attitude of these small Parties was not consistent. They seemed to have changed their opinions and attitudes on different occasions. Most of these small Parties were founded on an ideological basis or on a vocational basis. You had, for instance, the Clann na Poblachta Party, an ideological Party which professed to be more extreme Republican than any other Party in the country. You had two farmers' Parties since the State was founded. They professed to be vocational Parties interested in the farmers' interests. Then you had the Labour Party—at one time there were two Labour Parties—who professed to be also a vocational body largely interested in protecting the interests of the working classes.
I think that every one of those Parties also maintained that their ultimate objective was to form a Government. I other words, while they were ideological and narrow and sectarian in their immediate presentation, their ultimate objective—none of them retreated from this—was to form an alternative Government. If any small Party is sincere in that respect, if they come in here they are entitled to represent vocational and sectarian interests. It might be argued that it is unnecessary nowadays to have a farmers' Party in Dáil Éireann in so far as you have the NFA.
Comment on this
I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from the Bill before the House. This is the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution. The question of the formation of Governments does not relevantly arise.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): This Bill is calculated, according to the Minister himself, to develop a two-Party system. It is calculated to prevent the evolution in the future of the inter-Party type of Government. It is calculated to prevent the development and election of small Parties. I am dealing with the position of small Parties in the House. It is relevant to the particular amendment going through now.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): The single non-transferable vote, or the the British system. He was the first and will result in the obliteration of small Parties. It will tend to prevent the formation of other Parties in future as every new Party must start as a small Party. I think I may express my ideas on how it will affect us in future in that respect. There has been different behaviour by different political Parties through the years which has possibly led us into the position where the Minister sees fit to introduce this type of measure. At different times different Parties have adopted different attitudes. In my view, if we are to enjoy a two-Party system, it would seem in the present circumstances, particularly with the measures the Minister is now trying to introduce to try to prevent this, desirable to have such a system. The two-Party system can function perhaps not so smoothly, but it can function, with multiple Parties. Therefore, the Minister is not justified in introducing this measure calculated to obliterate small Parties.
All Parties coming into the House, not elected as Fianna Fáil members, must realise that the majority of votes cast in their favour are not Fianna Fáil votes and are probably anti-Fianna Fáil, and that therefore they have a mandate to oppose the Government. That does not consist in being an Opposition Party in the administrative sense only. That mandate must be carried out to the full. Fine Gael are the only Party who are offering full-blooded opposition and constantly endeavouring to remove the present Government and take over office. Any Party who come in merely as an administrative Opposition and not offering full-blooded political opposition should make their position clear beforehand. Parties down through the years have not done that.
I believe the present opposition Parties under present circumstances and in view of the evidence of public opinion in the recent by-elections should realise the mandate they have and that it is not alone to provide administrative opposition but to provide the country with an opposition Taoiseach and a shadow cabinet. They should not stop there. They should participate in Government positively and actively. They should seek responsibility and take credit or blame. I do not think it right that any Party should stand aside and be the tail that wags the dog. They should not believe that they are entitled to criticise without taking responsibility or that they can act as a pressure group.
On one occasion Clann na Talmhan did not vote when the Taoiseach was being elected. I believe they were wrong. They were elected largely on anti-Fianna Fáil votes and should have voted against the Government's nomination on that occasion. Subsequently they behaved differently and participated in Government. All through the years small Parties have behaved rather inconsistently.
Comment on this
I do not see how we can discuss the policies of Parties coming into the House. That does not arise on the Bill. As I have pointed out, the Bill relates to the single-member constituency and the single non-transferable vote. The Deputy may not discuss the policies of Parties that may come into the House.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): So far as the Minister's legislation is calculated to prevent such Parties coming into the House, I think it is relevant to the amendment before us.
Comment on this
I do not think so. The Deputy is discussing what Parties should do when they come into the House. That has nothing to do with the Bill.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): I am discussing what they should do before and after they come in. Does the Minister maintain that it is impossible to provide a two-Party system with more than two political Parties? Other countries have successfully done so but the Minister seems to think that only two Parties can provide a two-Party system. Of course his real objective is to provide a one-Party system and perpetuate his own Party in office and he will try to sell the notion to the people that because small Parties behave differently at different times they should be wiped out of existence.
Whatever the Minister may think about these small Parties, if the Irish people want them, they have a fundamental right to vote for them and send here whatever groups they want. They have the right to do wrong if they so choose.
Comment on this
The Deputy is cutting across an article of faith in saying the people have the right to do wrong.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): Deputy Healy told us that we should not revert to these things of the past and that all past quotations are irrelevant. Having particular respect for Deputy Healy, I listened to him carefully and I have been trying to observe his admonitions. Possibly he has a point; there is not much use in going back on these quotations of the past. We know them and they have been repeated here ad infinitum.
This British system of election, if carried, will culminate in an authoritarian type of government. Possibly in years to come that will be reversed but I believe that for many years we shall have a repressive, if not a corrupt, society with one Party entrenched in office and very little possibility of removing them by constitutional means. That is the chief danger inherent in this system. I do not say that we shall have dictatorship on the lines of some of the European models, or that we shall have concentration camps——
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): We did have some sort of place, I believe, in the Curragh. I thought we had dispensed with that.
Comment on this
(South Tipperary): The difficulty about a repressive society here is that we would have little help from world opinion. After all, they have repressive societies in some of the communist countries and the free nations of the world bring continuous propaganda to bear on these countries. The repressive society would pass unnoticed and perhaps with very little comment. It would receive little more attention than some of the repressive conditions attending in Northern Ireland. That is the real danger because if there were serious repression action could be taken. One Party would remain in office, but conditions would not be extreme enough to cause violent reaction.
For this reason, I would urge the people of this country not to lose the degree of liberty they now have. Proportional representation affords a degree of flexibility. The multiple-seat constituency ensures the electorate a choice of candidates. The single seat in a small constituency would lead to monopoly conditions. It would be hard to remove any Deputy once elected. After the next election I assume that under this system Fianna Fáil would come back with 95 or 100 seats. Put any Deputy in a small constituency; leave him there with a complete monopoly for a period of five years, and not alone would it be difficult to displace him but it would be well-nigh impossible in many areas to get either a Fine Gael or a Labour candidate to stand. There would be many uncontested seats, and that would be extremely bad. The Minister is perfectly well aware of that, and his answer would be that after a while the position would rectify itself. He has not got the gift of prophecy; he is not able to tell us when that will happen or to give us an assurance that it will happen.
We are dealing here with an unusual type of people, traditional voters, and the more you go into the rural parts the more traditional they become. Whatever chance there is of change in places like Dublin or Cork there is none in some of the rural parts. The pattern of voting remains unchanged from grandfather to grandson, down along the line. Over a period of 40 years there has been no change of thinking on the part of the majority of the people. I would blame the present stalemate primarily upon the Irish people because of their traditional cast-iron thinking. Possibly some blame could be allotted to Fine Gael and to Labour. No Party is perfect, but, by and large, the present stalemate derives from the traditional nature of our people.
Down through the years, Fine Gael have given reasonably good service here. They have participated in debates. They have worked hard in the constituencies and in the various subcommittees. The fact that over a period of 40 years, they have not been given a mandate from the Irish people to form a Government is something to be deplored. I think they deserve better than that from the Irish people. However, there is little we can do about it in so far as it stems from the traditional outlook of the Irish people. However, this pattern may also be due to other factors. It can also arise from the fact that all non-Fianna Fáil Parties or individuals have failed to give full commitment to putting out Fianna Fáil and providing a Taoiseach and a Government from the Opposition. Indeed the failure to do just that consistently has provided the present Minister with the excuse to steamroll this objectionable measure through the House.
Comment on this
I take it we are discussing the question of the single seat with the non-transferable vote. It is difficult to know what we are discussing. I should just like to remind the House that away back in 1918, before we had the opportunity of hearing about the dreams of that constitutional virgin, Miss Enid Lakeman, we won an election with the single seat and the non-transferable vote.
Talking about stability in government, let us take the period from 1932 on when, with the help of the Labour Party and despite the strong Blueshirt Fascist opposition, we did succeed in forming a Government. I am speaking about stability and I am reminded of the Coalition Governments of 1948 to 1951 and 1954 to 1956. It is not possible to get stability when one Party has not a majority in the Dáil. It is difficult to get that in a multi-seat constituency but not so difficult in a single-seat constituency. There has been a great deal of talk about gerrymandering. The Minister cannot gerrymander a single-seat constituency.
Comment on this
I am speaking about the single seat and the non-transferable vote. The non-transferable vote allows the people to express their minds unequivocally and properly. Furthermore, there is no question of gerrymandering. This single-seat system will enable Deputy Dunne to continue to represent Ballyfermot. The single seat will enable Deputy Corish to trot home in Wexford. Backbencher had a certain amount of sympathy for Deputy Norton's amendment but, as far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, no vote was taken and there was no banging of the table; the decision was that we go for the non-transferable vote. I agree with it and I bang the table this time.
Deputy Tully is far too wise a parliamentarian and far too good a parliamentarian to throw the Northern Ireland method of voting on to us. We inherited this awful PR system from people who wanted to keep us down. The north of Ireland is divided on religion and basic thinking; we are not in this part of the country. We heard talk about pressure groups. There are all sorts of pressure groups. If there are two policies to be put before the people, they should be put and let the best horse win. That is what the people want. I have canvassed this all round the country and I know this is what they want.
As I said before, most people could find their way into Fianna Fáil. The Opposition speak as if we were devils and they were angels. In Fianna Fáil we have Deputy Booth and in Fine Gael they have Deputy Dockrell who are both members of a minority. I am sure the Labour Party have their fellow-travellers. So far as the nation is concerned this system would make for quick decision. I did not come in on anyone else's surplus. I came in on eliminations and transfers. I am not a hindtit man—I came in on Fianna Fáil votes.
Comment on this
I am an intelligent man, I hope, and I can be convinced by arguments. I absolutely and fully recommend this to the House.
Comment on this
It was not my intention to intervene at this stage but, as there is a resurrection of interest in this vital matter, it is probably right that a member of our Party which has taken its stand on this matter from the beginning with no division and no question of doubt on principle should intervene. Normally I do not like to talk about principles because when one does it is said: "There is something queer about that fellow; he is talking about principles." In this instance I should like to point out that, contrary to what has been said here and outside the House in the news media and on television, an alteration in the system of voting does not represent the threat to the Labour Party which has been suggested. There are members of this Party—I am not speaking about myself—who would win seats, in my view, no matter what was done to the electoral system——
Comment on this
——or what way it was twisted. The Labour Party, the Labour movement and the trade union movement are such an inherent part of the nation—and I know this is a bitter pill for many people in this House to have to swallow—that they will not be eradicated by any kind of political manoeuvre. Having said that, let me say that this underlines and emphasises that we have taken our stand in this matter on the question of what is the best and most democratic system, and the fairest system. We heard talk about the election of 1918. Let me compliment the Deputy who was speaking about 1918 on the fact that he manages to conceal any evidence that he was in the world at all so many years ago. I was not around then, or I was not taking much interest at any rate.
Comment on this
That explains a great deal of the Deputy's aberration. The year 1918 and the 1918 election have no relevance to what we are talking about, or to the world about which we are talking. The very thoughtful contribution made by Deputy Hogan when he was discussing the traditional voting pattern of our people will, I suggest, have little relevance in the years that lie ahead, because what has been forgotten by many is that we in this country will not escape the revolutionary change in attitude and political thinking which has overtaken western Europe and the greater part of the civilised world, which has come about by reason of the advance of enlightenment and—I hate to use the word because it does not describe what I have in mind—education. This is very vividly shown on the television screen particularly. Television, more than any other single method of communication, has brought the world into the family household and familiarised us with things which ten or 15 years ago represented far away places and distant ideas and matters which could not possibly concern us at all. The advance of knowledge is bringing a change in the whole thought pattern of our people, even those of settled ways. I would suggest that they will not be tied by traditions in this matter as they have been in the past.
We all know that in the past families voted for certain Parties and continued to vote for them: father, son, grandson, and so on. They continued to vote that way, going back to the days of the formation of the State. Attitudes were taken up 50 years ago and remained in existence, and influenced the formation of Governments up to the present day one might say. These are being eroded and I suggest that one example of erosion was to be found recently in Limerick city where the Labour candidate, Lipper, succeeded in getting a vote which was not in any way influenced by these traditional voting patterns which were referred to. It was influenced entirely by bread and butter politics.
This system proposed by the Minister is retrogressive. I do not know when exactly it was first brought into operation in Britain, but I know that the single seat with the non-transferable vote came into existence at a time when democracy as we know it, in the limited sense, if you like, as we know it now, was completely unknown in Britain, and that it has remained in that form unchanged to the present day. I suppose it was pre-Victorian —certainly Victorian but perhaps before it. This system of voting was fashioned and designed by a ruling clique, a ruling caste, to perpetuate themselves in office, to protect their privileged position, and it succeeded in doing this.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that was a wonderful thing. He made a bargain though, which is still a matter of dispute between the acedemics as to whether what he did was entirely right or wrong. However, let us not fall out about so great a figure as Dan O'Connell. In his day he did the best he could, just as Deputy Lenihan is trying to do in his day and as we are all trying to do. The situation, of course, was probably that Dan O'Connell was in sympathy with the idea of rule by a propertied minority at that time and he acted according to his lights and, in doing so, he did bring some benefits to the people. That cannot be denied.
I am not condemning this system because it is British. I am not going to join this vacuous shout which says that everything that comes from Britain is bad, because Magna Carta and many other things came out of England. The idea they have of individual liberty has much to commend itself to us, so let it not be thought that I condemn it simply because it is British. I would condemn it, and this is a personal point of view, because it was a method invented by a privileged wealthy class to keep themselves in situ, to keep themselves in control and to ensure that, while presenting an outward face of democratic procedure, the masses of England would never achieve power. We know that that plan and that plot was overthrown by history. The industrial revolution took the masses from the countryside and moulded them into large concentrations in the cities and towns. This in turn produced poverty, degradation and hardship and eventually combinations and organisations, trade unionism and political representation. Eventually the masses of the English people were able, barely able, to bring themselves to power.
Comment on this
Not entirely to win, because even in power the illusion is still there, in Britain as here, that all power resides in the people who are in the Cabinet. I do not agree with that. Very often it is an illusion of power because very often power resides elsewhere, perhaps in the higher echelons of the Civil Service, certainly in the directorates of the banks and wherever there are large aggregates of wealth. That is where the power is and, no matter what Government sits here, until we take our courage in our hands to control these elements, there will be no power.
Now we are being asked to accept this system but it seems to me that, while proportional representaton is not the perfect electoral system, it is superior to the system which is proposed. Surely if democracy has any meaning, and sometimes I am inclined to the view that it is merely a platitude that is bounced around not alone by politicians but by those who earn their living talking about politicians as well, but if it has any real meaning, it must mean that the right of citizens to combine and form political Parties, no matter how small they may be, and to secure representation in a national Parliament, is a fundamental right. If you take that right away, surely you are tampering with a fundamental liberty. Or are we being asked to accept that the people are not sufficiently developed to operate this sophisticated voting system called PR? Is that what is being said, that it is too complicated for them, that, God help them, they do not know what they are doing when they vote for minority groups? I would reject that entirely.
I do not think there are many nations in the world so politically-conscious as the Irish are by reason of their history and their temperament. We are infinitely more politically-conscious than the English who could be said to be more or less a docile people who tend to go in crowds or large masses. The Irish have not been noted for that characteristic. They are said to be individualistic and for that reason it may well be that the system we have produces at times a multiplicity of Parties. What is so wrong with that? It is wrong of course to the authoritarian mind, to the mind which says the first essential is strong government, that we must have strong government first of all. But who says that? Who says the first essential is strong government? The vested interest says it first, the person who is a bit fearful that the social system may so change as to alter his status in society. He is the first to look for strong government. The character who has a great deal of money or property of any kind and who is anxious to protect that property at all costs will shout for strong government above all other things.
I suggest to the House that these people are not the entire nation. I would accept that they have powerful voices and that their voices are heard invariably in the corridors, as they say, of power. But they are not the Irish nation. The bulk of the Irish people are the people of little or no property. We hope, as time goes on, that it will be possible so to alter our society as to ensure that that situation will be changed and that property will be distributed with the greatest possible equity. We hope that will be achieved. We work towards that end. In the meantime, the people who are shouting for strong government and this so-called great evolution of the two-Party system, in which I can see no merit whatsoever, are not concerned really with democracy, not concerned with the representation of the people.
I have not the slightest doubt that the Minister in putting this Bill before the House is driven by one intention, that is, to see that Fianna Fail remain in power as long as he can possibly arrange it. I do not say that is an unnatural intention, but I do say that we, and that "we" is not just those of us on this side of the House, but the entire nation, would be utter fools to let him get away with it because unquestionably, as Deputy Hogan has said, the trend would probably be towards single-Party government and single-Party government ends up, as we know, inevitably badly for all concerned.
The first function of an electoral system is to secure not necessarily the return of a Party as government but representation in Parliament for the people who vote. That is the first function—representation for the people who vote to enable them to have a voice in the councils of Parliament. What happens after Parliament meets is not even provided for in the Constitution. The Constitution does not provide for Parties. It does not mention political Parties. It lays down nothing about Parties—single-Party, two-Party, multi-Party, or what-you-will. There is no mention of these things in the Constitution. The Constitution merely provides that people will be represented in Parliament and that they will be represented by the method with which we are familiar.
We have all gone over this ground before and the citizens of the State, as well as the Members of this House, are fairly familiar with all the arguments pro and con. To me the sick joke of this whole debate has been the statement by the Minister, I think, initially and echoed by some of his satraps subsequently around the country that what he really is at is endeavouring to provide another Government instead of Fianna Fáil. This is the proposition he is putting up.
Comment on this
The Minister used words to that effect—that he wanted to make it possible for an Opposition to take over.
Comment on this
One would have to have a few hours to spare, right enough, to read the long rambling discourses the Minister has bestowed upon us in this matter. The Minister in my recollection most certainly put forward the proposition that the real benefit of his proposal was to make possible the replacement of Fianna Fail by another Government. To my mind, there is nothing sicker than that because no sane person believes for one single, solitary second——
Comment on this
I am sure the fact that we have the right to raise matters on the Adjournment must be a source of great annoyance. It annoyed Deputy MacEntee yesterday and it seems to be annoying the Minister now. I would not mention it too often if the Minister wants to get home early tonight as he might tempt me.
Comment on this
The Minister tempts me very much. He does not go home early. Mark you, the Minister could because this place will be here after he has gone home. Do not let anybody fall victim to the illusion that we are indespensable because, when all of us are gone, this place will still be here, and probably doing far better.
The Minister interrupted, intentionally no doubt, my trend of thought. I was talking about this question of the provision of an alternative Government. The Irish people will look after this question of alternative Governments. They are to be trusted with the job of electing those they feel are best fitted to represent their interests. Regardless of what Deputy P.J. Lenihan says, and he must move in a very fanatical Fianna Fáil circle if he has heard nothing but assurances that this thing is going like a bomb, the reverse is the case, believe me. I am pretty catholic in my political acquaintanceship and I have yet to hear anybody, bar those who are injected with the serum at birth—they are few in number and becoming fewer every day—say that this proposal has any chance of success. I doubt even that the Minister has any notion that it will succeed. I certainly believe that the Parliamentary Secretary, if the truth were told, is not blessing the day when this ball was first bounced on the floor of Dáil Éireann. It has in it not alone defeat for this Government but the seeds of self-destruction for the Government Party.
Comment on this
I am not particularly worried about the Government Party's destruction at all. I am just trying to parse and analyse, so far as one can reasonably do so——
Comment on this
Is it that their palate for power has become so jaded they want to cast aside all further power?
Comment on this
It is an extraordinary situation. It may very well be that the Minister has forced his will upon the Cabinet. It may be, and this may be the key to it, that the Taoiseach and some others are anxious to opt out of the race and this is one way of doing it, this is one possible way of doing it.
Comment on this
It is not my intention to keep going and boring the House as has been done so adequately by the Minister on other occasions, but I thought it desirable that we should make our position clear at this last moment in consideration of this Bill. The Labour Party, as I have said— the Parliamentary Secretary was not here but I will repeat it for him——
Comment on this
The Labour Party is not, contrary to what has been stated by certain people, in danger of annihilation. It will never be annihilated. In so far as some of us are concerned it would not make any difference what you did with the constituencies—turn them upside down, on their heads; put them sideways, any way you like—we would have representation because we have the support of the people. Labour men are stronger in this sense than probably any other individuals in the House because, whereas others have to depend on political Party tags to gain entry here, most of the Labour men —not all of them—gain entry here by virtue of their own hard, solid work and you will not beat that, no matter how you twist the electoral system.
It is on the matter of fairness to the citizens and on the matter of principle that we most strenuously object to the passage of this Bill. We know it will go through. We know it will go before the people. We are told it will be brought before the electorate somewhere about October. Whenever it is, beyond question it will be hammered into the earth and when that happens, all we can hope is that the harm of the year may go with it.
Comment on this
This evening a challenge was issued to the backbenchers of our Party to stand up and be counted and indicate what our views are on this amendment.
I favour the single-seat constituency because I have no doubt that it is the easiest constituency to work. I live in the most northerly parish of County Roscommon. The most southerly parish is 70 to 80 miles away from me and it takes an infinite amount of work and trouble to get from one end to the other. My colleague, the Minister for Education, also lives at one end of the constituency. He has to travel those 70 or 80 miles and to go further into our constituency, to Leitrim, he has to travel 40 or 50 miles. My colleague of the Fine Gael Party, Deputy Reynolds, finds himself in much the same position as the Minister for Education. I have no doubt that our constituency would be better if we were all confined to our own particular areas. Deputy Mrs. Burke lives in the centre of Roscommon but, to get into Leitrim, she has a considerable distance to travel. Perhaps ours is an exaggerated constituency from this point of view.
I have listened to previous speakers talking of traditional votes. I am beginning to think that the constituency I represent must be one of the most progressive because it certainly has not this tradition. In the 1930s it gave Fianna Fáil a majority. In the 1940s and the early 1950s Clann na Talmhan had the majority. In the late 1950s and now in the early 1960s Fine Gael have this majority and I hope that as we move into the 1970s Fianna Fáil will come back and we will have the majority then. This, to my mind, is an answer to this argument of the traditional vote. A change must come around and we seem to have had it more than any of the other constituencies.
There is one point I should like to deal specifically with here. It is the question of small Parties. Play has been made of the fact that the small Party will cease to exist in a single-seat constituency. This is a view I cannot accept at all. Again, getting down to local conditions, I feel that particularly in a rural area such as North Roscommon, if a man decides under the present system to go forward as an Independent, he does so by virtue of the fact that he is known locally through business contacts, or athletic contacts mostly. He proposes to seek a seat in a big constituency in competition with many others. He is well known for a number of miles—perhaps ten to 12 miles—around but, when he moves out of that area, in most cases he is unknown. If he proposes to organise the constituency as we have it now, he must cover a distance of at least 140 miles from one end of it to the other, perhaps 40 to 50 miles east and west. He must try to sell himself to about 40,000 voters. No matter how he sells himself to those voters, in the end he will find himself in competition at local level with his political opponent who is going to get twos and threes from people at the other end of the constituency.
If that man were confined to a smaller area catering for, say, 15,000 to 16,000, he would have a number of advantages. The first advantage is that he would be known much better in this area. No doubt most of his relatives would be in this area, unless he was a blow-in. If he proposes to spend money on his election, he will spend one-fourth of what he would have to spend in a four-seater constituency. If he proposes to canvass the area, he has but one-fourth of the area to canvass. He is in direct competition with big Parties who are putting up but one representative. As it is now and as has been the case in the past, an Independent is in competition with the big Parties who have three in most cases and in some cases four people throughout the constituency and they are canvassing their own areas. If he proposes to print literature, he has to print but one-fourth of the literature that would be necessary for the bigger constituency. By and large, the small constituency must give the Independent Deputy an equal chance with his political opponents of even the big Parties.
Anybody seeking a seat in any assembly must get most of his votes in a local area. If he is a man of standing in whom the people have confidence and a man the people think should represent them in Parliament, in the local area he will beat his opponents. By and large, perhaps not at the next election, but after this, particularly in Roscommon where the people change, they will go for the best man in the area and the best man will beat his local opponent in the area and he will have the label from the local people saying: "You are the best man of this lot and the man that we think should go to Parliament." Supposing they transfer, what happens? He beats his man in the local area but a transfer comes to his Party opponent from a man maybe 40 or 50 miles away from him and, as a result, this man who has the confidence of the people is beaten.
This is one of the big arguments against the big constituency with the transferable vote. Everything I have now said about the Independent seeking a seat is true about any man representing a small Party except that the man representing the small Party has some extra advantage. From what I have said here now, those listening to me must agree that it is the local area that will breed the best man, the man with the confidence of the people.
It has been said that political Parties put up various people to represent them, people who have not the confidence of the voters, that the voters vote for them because these candidates are put up by the Party. As I see it, the big Parties will be compelled at local level to pick not alone the Party man but the man who will have the confidence of the people who are not sworn Party supporters and this will be a good thing. Perhaps some of us may be brushed under the carpet in the process but we have to accept that.
Other points have been made here. There is this question of dictatorship. My reading of the rise of dictatorships throughout Europe and in other countries is that most of the communities that have given dictators authority to run their countries are people who seem to have been frustrated by the system of voting and the return of Parties as a result of elections. Whether this arose under PR or under the straight vote, I am not fully informed to state in the House but it is a fair interpretation to say that in all those countries there was a multiplicity of Parties. They assembled in Parliament. Parliament was rather chaotic. Nothing much was done. The people were becoming frustrated and at a certain stage, through emotion or through deep thinking and one thing and another, they finally appealed to what they considered the strongest man of those Parties and gave him support which by force enabled him to form a Government. Sometimes this was got by power; other times it was got by revolutionary force, and it was only when this man became installed that you really had the dictatorship established then by the interference with the vote. At this stage a system of election was brought in by which this dictator decided that he was going to keep his party in power. I cannot think offhand of any country in Western Europe where the system of election that obtained automatically gave that country a dictatorship. The dictatorship arose, as I have said, out of the frustrating circumstances that arose from the election.
This brings me to what is a truism, that there is absolutely no satisfactory system of election. All the systems have their faults. The advantages of PR have been paraded in the House at length and it has been almost impossible to say anything new about it. We are told that under the three-seater or five-seater constituencies it is an admirable system but, to my mind, if the proponents of PR laud it so much to the sky or believe in it to this extent, then why not make the whole country into four constituencies and thereby, under PR, give every minority in the community the opportunity to be represented? If it is right for the five-seater constituency, it is right for the seven-, for the nine- and the eleven-seater. The bigger the constituency becomes, if there is truth in this argument, the easier it is to have those minorities represented. I do not think anybody would seriously propose this in the House. They do not believe in PR as a system of election to this extent; they realise that it must be limited. I always learned that it was limited at the three- and five-seater to get rid of the disadvantages it would have for the bigger constituency.
Earlier in the evening, Deputy Maurice Dockrell made reference to the Six Counties and the effect that the abolition of PR would have on the Six Counties. I feel that his interpretation is not correct. I suppose I should say that I do not agree with it. First, they have accepted this system which is in a gerrymandered situation. If we were in the happy position that we could abolish the Border, the single seat would be an attraction to that community to join us because they would feel that in those parts of the Six Counties where they have their majorities, they would continue to have their majority under the new system. Constituencies are gerrymandered up there. This could be abolished and Nationalists there would get, perhaps, a higher share of the seats but I feel that the straight vote in the small constituency would be much more attractive to those people; they would be much more anxious to come in here when they would have a bigger bloc representing them in this House.
Much has been made of the fact that somebody decided at some stage that if this system of voting was changed and we had the single seat, Fianna Fáil would sweep the country. Somebody said 90 seats; somebody said 100 seats—estimating on the figures in the recent local election. This must be unreasonable thinking because, surely, the Party who get the most votes must get the most seats. We have the Fine Gael Party pointing all along to their increasing strength in the various elections—the local elections and the Presidential elections. If they believe their strength is increasing—it was said in the House that there was but six per cent between Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael in the last election—a change of three per cent in the vote in the next general election would give Fine Gael the majority. Surely if Fine Gael get 47 per cent or 48 per cent of the votes, then they must get the largest number of seats?
The same applies to the Labour Party. Listening to Deputy Dunne a short while ago, I think it is true to say he was the first Deputy of the Labour Party I have heard who came out and stated that, no matter what the system is, they will get the votes. He followed that by saying that if they got the votes they would get the seats. For anybody who thinks about this that is the conclusion that must be drawn.
Much emotion has arisen around this problem and much unreasoned thinking, mainly because this problem is not considered as the problem which it is—the straight vote versus the transferable vote, the single constituency versus the multiple constituency. It is considered as what is good for Fianna Fáil and what is bad for Fianna Fáil. It is considered as what is good for Fine Gael and what is bad for them, what is good for Labour and what is bad for them. Again, Deputy Dunne closed this argument. He said this House would be here after us irrespective of what we do. We have a duty to do what we think is the right thing. The right thing is to consider this problem on its own merits.
Deputy Andrews stated the obvious —that this is not being decided here in the House. I do not think we look on this as a political problem. As the Minister pointed out on numerous occasions, it arose in the circumstances that constituencies had to be revised. Deputy Andrews pointed out that the people who were going to decide it are the people who are voting. Surely there is nothing wrong in giving them this opportunity to think again on the matter? Some believe they are going to decide against us. We believe they are not.
It has been said that this matter was dealt with in 1959 and, because it was dealt with then, the people have decided forever against it and that it should not be considered now. But nobody seriously believes that this is an argument against holding a referendum now. If this were an argument against holding a referendum now, surely it would be an argument that would give us on this side of the House, with an overall majority, the right to say that the people decided on several occasions they did not want a Fine Gael Government and we should never give them the opportunity of deciding again whether they want such or not? This is the answer to the argument that this matter was decided in 1959.
It was not my intention to speak on this. I spoke because a challenge was issued and now I am included in the count.
Comment on this
I do not propose to speak at length because the attitude of the Labour Party to these proposals has been adequately expressed. But it is difficult to sit here and listen to the confused thinking of Fianna Fáil spokesmen and the confused reasons they allege compelled them to bring these Bills before the House and to pose the public the problem of deciding for a second time in a short number of years whether they wish to stand by the fairest system of voting in all these islands, in the Continent of Europe and indeed practically throughout the world.
Having regard to this aspect of the matter, we might well ask if by some miracle Fianna Fáil manage to become the Government again under the system of proportional representation, will they in another ten years or so again come to the House with a proposal to amend the electoral system? Having been beaten for a second time, will they try it out for a third time in desperation?
The contradictions that have come from Fianna Fáil spokesmen from the Minister down are somewhat extraordinary, to say the least. At one stage we are told that the purpose of an election is not to elect a Parliament but to elect a Government. Then we get a contribution from Deputy Gibbons, who starts off by telling us that it is quite likely a situation will arise in his constituency of Roscommon under the proposals here in which there will be four Independent Deputies. In other words, four people will be elected who were known locally in various parts of the constituency and who will sit as Independent Deputies. If you take that argument to its logical conclusion, you could well have half this House composed of Independent Deputies. Where then would your strong Government be? Where would any Government be? You would have a situation where the majority of Deputies would, like the Fianna Fáil Government at present, be committed to one thing only—the retention of their seats in this House. There appears to be a lot of concern among the ranks of Fianna Fáil at all levels as to their future. No matter what their protestations are about the single-member constituency with the so-called direct vote providing an opportunity for a change of Government, it is becoming increasingly clear that they are concerned about the question of self-preservation.
Have the Government and the Fianna Fáil spokesmen, including some of the backbenchers who have been dragged out of their holes to make some kind of show, any consideration for the Irish people in this matter? It is all right to say that the people will make the decision. We know they will make a decision against the Fianna Fáil proposals. It is all right for Deputy Gibbons and other Fianna Fáil Deputies to say they have a right to go to the people to look for a change in the Constitution. But the extraordinary thing is that there are discussions about many other Articles of the Constitution. In the course of those discussions, the view was expressed that other Articles might well be examined and be the subject of a referendum. But the Government did not think it worth while to consult the people on any of the other matters referred to in the report as being worthy of being included in a referendum, and to ask what their view was in connection with these other matters. The only issue that was to be put to the people was: will you change the system of election?
We are continually being told that the single-member constituency and so-called direct vote gives a representative result. It could result in a Government elected with the support of a minority on the basis of "winner-takes-all" in any constituency. It has been demonstrated again and again in many places that this type of voting system which is proposed can readily result in a Party that receives 47 or 48 per cent of the votes getting, not 50 per cent, but 60 or 70 per cent of the seats.
Government spokesmen repeatedly say that they are concerned not only with the question of the election of a Government—this is what they keep on talking about—but also the election of representatives able to speak on behalf of the people they represent. I do not know even now if the political Parties here are fully recognised except for the recognition that Fianna Fáil wish to give, so far as they are concerned, but any Deputy nominated by a political Party to represent it in his constituency, if elected, cannot truly at the same time represent the views and policies and thoughts of people in his constituency who disagree fundamentally with the policies and views of his Party. It may and does happen under the present system of PR, and it would happen under any system, that elected representatives feel an obligation to serve their constituents as regards personal and other matters. Is it suggested in an area where there may well be 40 per cent of the electorate supporting not just a Fianna Fáil candidate but whatever policy Fianna Fáil put forward at a particular time, and 30 per cent supporting Fine Gael policies and the remaining 30 per cent supporting Labour Party policies which differ fundamentally from the other two, that under a system which would return only one Deputy for that area— in this case it would be a Fianna Fáil Deputy—he could represent and speak in this House on behalf of people who disagree fundamentally with the policies his Party represent?
If the circumstances were reversed and the Labour Party Deputies were returned with 40 per cent of the vote as against 60 per cent for the other Parties I do not think a conscientious Labour Deputy could say that he was going to change his policies or get his Party to change them on fundamental matters because the majority of people in his constituency did not agree with them.
Comment on this
I would not resign in the circumstances. He would deal with the lesser issues, the problems of people looking for things, but certainly he would be politically dishonest if he were to suggest that he could be a good representative for a Fianna Fáil point of view in that constituency. Of course he could not, because he would be representing a Labour policy, Labour principles and thought. I would hope that, even though Fianna Fáil do not appear to have any policy, whatever vestige of policy they may have would actually be represented by a Fianna Fáil Deputy and that the Fine Gael Deputy would represent something other than the fact that he had a Fine Gael badge in his buttonhole.
These sharp differences and distinctions in policies will grow rather than dwindle in the future. We are getting away from the situation in which Fianna Fáil spokesmen could calmly assume, as they have done, that they represent everybody's views. Over the years we know they have represented the views of those with power, of what might be termed the financial and industrial establishment. What we are concerned with in the Labour Party in regard to this matter is that political developments should take place in an ordered democratic system that would afford any significant section of the community not only the right but the opportunity to have spokesmen elected to Dáil Éireann to express their views, whether we would like these views or not. We are, and have been, at all times conscious of the need here to ensure that minority opinion has full expression and full rights. Minority opinion has no rights under this proposal for the single-member constituencies and so-called direct voting because the majority in any single-seat constituency operates on the basis of "winner-takes-all".
One is not surprised to hear different Fianna Fáil spokesmen, whether at ministerial or other level, putting three or four different points of view at the same time. One spokesman from Fianna Fáil has said the main purpose of the Bills is to secure strong Government, with all that it entails. Another spokesman was saying that from his point of view as a backbencher what Fianna Fáil were trying to do was to make a change which in a constituency like Roscommon might not be repeated in other parts of the country. It could very easily result not in a strong government but in the election of a number of local men, Independents, attached to no Party whatsoever. In other words, they are saying: "Reduce the constituency a bit more and turn the election into a ward-heeling operation."
Deputy Gibbons talked about a lack of choice. Under the present system not only have people a choice of whatever Party they wish to support but they also have the choice as to the candidates from that Party they wish to support. They have exercised that choice in recent times by indicating a preference for people who were not the leading candidates in the Party in a particular area. That would not apply under these proposals. If these proposals were accepted there would be no choice of candidate; there would be only one candidate from each party.
In my own constituency, Dublin North-East, Fianna Fáil had four candidates from which people could choose in the last election; they returned two, the Minister for Finance, Deputy Haughey, and the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Colley. However, if the Fianna Fáil supporters in Dublin North-East had decided they did not want those two Deputies, they could have chosen the other two. In the case of the Labour Party, there were three Labour candidates to choose from. Fine Gael had four candidates in that constituency. The people could show their preference not only for Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or Labour but also for various candidates in those Parties.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil have had their troubles. The Minister is the only member of the Fianna Fáil Front Bench who was not running for Taoiseach six months ago, the only reason being that nobody would vote for him.
Comment on this
The present system gives the people a choice. Fianna Fáil want to remove that choice from the people. They want to bring about a situation where in any constituency the Party will decide on one candidate. If they were honest, they would admit that what they are really saying to the people is: "You are not voting for a candidate; you are voting for a Party." They could have adverted to the situation in regard to PR in West Germany where the people do not vote for an individual candidate but for the Party. The Party candidate is elected on the basis of the number of first preference votes for the Party. However, we are not discussing that. The purpose of this Government is to remove from the people this choice not only of Party but even of candidates of another Party.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy thinking of moving over to them now?
Comment on this
The Deputy will be aware that there is an increasing number of Labour candidates being put up at each election, and this will continue. The Labour Party, of course, have not been in the position of having the unending purse of Fianna Fáil with Taca behind them.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil have unlimited coffers to dip into on the promise of political patronage.
Comment on this
Deputies will have ample opportunity of discussing the role of Fianna Fáil as against that of the Labour Party in the future. What they are concerned with is that the Fianna Fáil Party, who have been putting forward arguments indicating that they have some concern for the people, have twice in a matter of ten years attempted to remove from the people a very fair system of voting. That is not a bad effort.
Comment on this
I raised a question in opening my remarks, as to whether, when this proposal is defeated by the people, if on a future occasion by some miracle a Fianna Fáil Government are again in office, they will make another attempt to save themselves? Will they again want to introduce the same Bill and have a third go at it?
Comment on this
Robert Bruce is only trotting after them.
Comment on this
The position of the Labour Party has been made quite clear. For a considerable period, we have avoided unnecessary talk on the Bill because, once the Government say they will force it through, we know it will go through. It is necessary to reiterate at this stage that the Government have one selfish self-centred notion. They are introducing this in the hope that by some miracle it will be accepted and Fianna Fáil will continue in office for a longer period. They will not be there for very long with the present trend.
Comment on this
There are young Fianna Fáil Deputies who came into this House after the last election. If they get back again, they will have long grey beards before they will sit on the Front Bench of any Government.
Comment on this
The Chair points out that of the last four speakers, two were Fianna Fáil and two were Labour.
Comment on this
If the Minister is making a charge against the Chair, there is a procedure which he can adopt but he cannot bully the Chair.
Comment on this
The purpose of this Bill is to decide whether or not the next general election will be held on the PR system. Therefore, the result of this election is a very relevant factor. It is a very important factor, apart from the manner of voting. Studies have been carried out for Fine Gael by Senator Garret FitzGerald and Senator Dooge separately and individually. I know studies have been carried out by Fianna Fáil and I know studies have been carried out by Labour. Each Party is entitled to proceed with these studies.
If everyone voted as they did in the county council elections, what would be the result in the next general election? Doctors differ and patients die. Punters, including myself, back horses and horses lose. There is such a thing as the form book and that is what is being studied by Fianna Fáil and particularly by the most politically clinical person, the Minister for Local Government, whose idea of humour is cryptic, to say the least of it. I want to develop this in the morning because it will take some time, on the basis not of the constituencies and not of the counties but on the very restricted basis of the electoral areas, of which there are five in my constituency. This point must be made and I shall develop it in the morning. If everyone voted as they did in the county council elections, the result would be 65 for Fianna Fáil, 55 for Fine Gael, 25 for Labour in a Dáil with one seat added. That is why we are having a referendum. Forget about the straight vote; forget about Deputy Norton's amendment; forget about the lot.
Comment on this
I see people looking at me who study the form book. Some are in the Lobby and some are in the House. The form book says quite clearly that Fianna Fáil will not have an overall majority after the next general election.
Comment on this
The exercise is quite simple and quite clear, to throw democracy aside and to proceed step by step to the referendum. Throw in Deputy Norton's amendment and see what happens with it. Juggle with it. The Taoiseach, perhaps, has said too many things too many times. The Minister for Local Government has burned the boats, and no better man to do it. Fianna Fáil decided that despite the fact that the pundits said they were beaten, that they were down the field, it would be better to go on and be defeated than to withdraw at this stage. Perhaps they are drunk with power. The great boast of Fianna Fáil at present is that they have won six out of seven by-elections.
Comment on this
With respect, I suggest that the results of the by-elections have a great bearing on the referendum. We got 1,000 more votes in the Limerick by-election than we ever got in that constituency before.