We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 1–209 of 419. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I am glad the Minister for Local Government is present because not long ago at Question Time we had questions regarding the training that should be given to our athletes competing in the Olympic Games. Surely we have here the long distance, all-time record-holder in the person of the Minister for Local Government who spoke for between five and six hours trying to gull the unfortunate people of the country and waste the time of the House and the taxpayers' money in the futile exercise of the referendum. I think the Minister has qualified for a Nobel Prize. If the Taoiseach introduced such a thing I would be the first to put my hand in my pocket and subscribe generously for a proper decoration for the Minister for Local Government, not only on account of his long distance performance but also for the arrogance and ruthlessness with which he behaved here last week when only the hand of God saved him from a paralytic stroke as a result of the anger and bitterness which exuded from every pore of his body.

Thank God the people of Ireland, and the plain, honest rank and file of Fianna Fáil gave their decision in no uncertain fashion. I suppose it would be tantamount to a miracle but I hope the Minister will learn the lesson if that is possible and realise that his arrogance and ruthlessness and the off-handed manner in which he thinks he can treat the people of Ireland have been defeated forever. Let us not be diverted in any way from the lesson that must be learned along the road we travelled for seven or eight months up to 16th October. Along the way and right up to the polling booths on the 16th October the Minister—God help us that Ireland should be inflicted with such a plague—took upon himself to dictate to the hierarchy and clergy of Ireland and accuse them of wrong-doing, of falsification and misrepresentation as if he were a prophet come among us. This is the Minister who will descend to sewer level and make personal attacks on any Member of the House but there would be no God in heaven if this did not boomerang as it did when 250,000 people, the majority of them being members of his own Party, said: "No, definitely, no. To hell with you and your take-over bid by the Tacateers."

Let me remind the Minister that in the early days of this century a brave and noble Irishman said: "They have bought one half of us and they have coerced the other—the fools, the fools!" What has happened in 1968? The buying has gone on. Who were the purchasers? Who paid for this take-over? The Minister's gang and his pal, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries who is patron, have sold themselves or thought they were selling themselves out. They tried to sell themselves out, but the honest rank and file of Fianna Fáil, spearheaded from these benches of the Labour Party and the workers throughout the country came out to give the Minister and his colleagues the answer they surely deserved.

We are proud of that and why should we not be? We have our chests out and why should we not be trumpeting? We did not make the mistake the Minister made. We did not underestimate the intelligence of the ordinary workers. We knew what they were thinking because we mix with them and know all about them and how they live. I hope the Minister will take this lesson of the 16th October, 1968, to the grave with him and that it will harass him and terrify him and haunt him for the rest of his life. That is my prayer for him this morning. He deserves no more because no man in his position as Minister would descend to sewer level in personal attacks such as he has been making in the past 12 months in this House on anybody who disagrees with his views.

I suppose it is hard to blame him—it is dú cha. It is handed down and I suppose we must make excuses. Like the wooden leg in the family it is handed down.

This Budget, which has been composed by the civil servants, is nothing short of a vicious attack on the ordinary worker who came out, organised by the trade unions and different bodies associated with the workers and the trade union movement, and rejected the Government's proposals. This Budget is the chastisement of such a worker. The only comfort and relaxation he has after his hard day's work is the pint of stout, together with a cigarette. What has happened? This is the whip and the scourge that Fianna Fáil have given to the worker because of his action on 16th October.

Together with that they have imposed a severe penalty on the unfortunate mother who tries to make the chores of the house as easy as possible, by practically stopping for all time the introduction of a washing machine into the home. Will any man or woman, father or mother of a family, tell me that a washing machine is not a necessity in any home today? Restrictions have also been imposed, of course, on the purchasing of radios and televisions; but the unfortunate woman who tries to pay for a washing machine, whether it be on hire purchase terms, through the ESB or in any other way, is now being victimised. What has the Minister done? He has put the ability to purchase commodities out of the reach of the working man. He has not put any impediment in the way of his own gang—the people who can have, not one motor car, but maybe two or three in every family. There is no impediment in their way. They came out and voted "yes". They must be compensated. They must be thanked in some way, the attitude being that, if one group must be thanked, another must be victimised. The worker has been hit hard. However, I have news for the Minister. The sooner he goes to the polls the better. I know he will not go. I suppose it is hard to blame him. I will go into the reasons for that when I come to it.

I defy the Minister to go down the country and talk to the people—to come out of his nest egg, the Post Office in Ballyfermot, for once in his life. I have come here to tell the Minister some home truths and I will do it without considering his personal feelings as I would do with other Ministers but not in this case.

I will turn now to the smuggling of pigs and the decline in the bacon industry. I must say that it is a good thing this smuggling is going on. We closed a bacon factory in Limerick 12 months ago because we did not have a sufficient number of pigs to kill. Were it not for the smuggling that is going on at present I can assure the Minister and his colleagues in Agriculture—they are both fettered together like two old goats on the side of a road running blindly before every vehicle that comes along—that we would have more closure in the bacon industry. We must, therefore, turn the blind eye to the smugglers and even congratulate them. It is an unusual thing to condone any breach of the law but in this case we must be factual and truthful. That is the position with regard to the bacon industry and the smuggling going on from Northern Ireland. I hope they keep it up and even increase it, thereby doing what the Minister for Agriculture has declined and failed to do—keep men working in the industry.

That is another reason why we call for an immediate general election—to bring those two heroes out into the open fields and let the people give them their answer, as they did on 16th October. We all know what happened within the Party. It is common knowledge to anyone who has his ear close to the political ground. We know what happened when the postmortems and inquests were held. We all know that certain members of the Party were told to be prepared for the high jump.

Comment on this

To go into the dog house.

Comment on this

Yes, they will go into the dog house.

Comment on this

It happened yesterday.

Comment on this

And the night before. We know also that it was not Labour and Fine Gael who, together, got the quarter of a million votes in our favour. They came from the rank and file members of the Fianna Fáil Party, including some of their Deputies. We know, too, what happened at the cumann meetings held in the old kitchens or elsewhere. The boys said: "Look, lads, we are all right as we are. Do not kill yourselves; things are going grand." That is what happened and if Mr. Local Government over there——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

I have addressed him as "Mr. "—well, Minister, then. If the Minister for Local Government thinks that he has got the full backing of his Party all he need do is to go back and look at the figures in every constituency, particularly at the figures in his own constituency. He will find out what is thought of him in his own constituency, despite the fact that he spent all day from 9 a.m. until closing time at one polling booth in Ballyfermot and his wife spent the entire day at another one.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must remind the Deputy that people who are not in this House should not be referred to in this manner.

Comment on this

The Minister has no respect for anybody.

Comment on this

We shall have to teach the Deputy manners.

Comment on this

I will give the Minister manners in the same way as he gave them to us last week. The position has come about whereby the Minister, in his desperation and in his last hours of agony, has come along to scrape the barrel. Think of the expense involved in scraping the barrel to get men in every constituency who were attached or alleged to be attached to the trade union movement to put their names to an advertisement prepared in Dublin and signed by people who had no allegiance to or connection with the trade union movement and who never subscribed——

Comment on this

That is not so and the Deputy knows that it is wrong.

Comment on this

I will name one. A councillor of your own, Liam Hickey, who is an ESB employee, living in Murroe, County Limerick, put his name to it and I accused him of it and he admitted it. He is a member of no trade union. He signed it and he is only one. I am sure that if I went scrupulously into the rest of the names I should find others. Because I saw "LCC" after his name, I inquired. Will you challenge me on that inside or outside the House? I have named him. He will be a candidate at the next election, or he hopes to be.

Comment on this

You are gone, so.

Comment on this

That is what you would like.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

That is what you would like. That will be the day. I want to bring to the attention of the Minister the difficulties which we are experiencing in Limerick with regard to the unemployment situation and the lack of industrial progress. Not one new industry has been established in Limerick over the last ten years. We have made application. On many occasions we have come on deputations in order to see if something could be done. To give the late Minister for Education his due, he did come up with a scheme which, of course, was harebrained. He gave us some encouragement for a while that he would bring a chipboard factory to Limerick that would absorb about 1,500 male workers.

Comment on this

Be merciful. Your own day will come, too.

Comment on this

You need not preach charity to me. Do not try to play that game with me. To give the late Minister his due, he did try. He realised the situation that existed in Limerick. He did his best. It all went up in smoke. Nothing happened. I want the Minister for Industry and Commerce to pay attention to the remarks of the President of the Chamber of Commerce in Limerick which received notice in the national and local press on last Monday night and on Tuesday. He warned the Government that if something was not done with regard to the provision of industries in Limerick, drastic action would be taken. There was a challenge from the Chamber of Commerce in Limerick whose views must be respected. We have already applied for and the Minister for Industry and Commerce is prepared to issue a licence for a smelting plant in the county. As a body united on a regional basis we have made the case for the Limerick region as the site for this smelting plant——

Comment on this

That is going to Galway.

Comment on this

——because of its proximity to the mines in the locality. I hope the Minister will give sympathetic consideration to our claim for a smelting plant within the region of the estuary of the Shannon. That would relieve in some way the tragic situation of the unemployed in Limerick city.

Three or four years ago we went to the Minister for Transport and Power representing that there should be one estuarial authority for the whole Shannon. That would be a combination of the three smaller ports down the Lower Shannon. If the Minister had been in any way co-operative he could have done that by a stroke of the pen. No. He said that we should go back and settle our differences in Limerick with the ports and harbours concerned and return to him with some solution. That matter has been hanging fire for almost four years. No progress has been made. Let it be clearly understood that Limerick is the most accessible deepwater port in the whole of the Western Continent of Europe. The people on the Fianna Fáil benches are not bothering their head about development so far as Limerick is concerned.

It is about time that the persons responsible take action. Instead of sticking their heads in the sands, they should face realities. If they applied themselves to industrial development and the creation of employment, rather than to attacking the trade unions and the clergy, they would be better compensated and better appreciated by the people whom they are supposed to serve.

Arrogance has taken over. The cheque-book gang have taken over. The unfortunate Taoiseach is, as I said last night, like a cork in a high tide, being buffeted and pilloried on all sides. A split exists in Fianna Fáil. We all know it. We know the gangs that are there, both at top level and at local level. There was an example of it last week in a case of co-option to Limerick Corporation. They were divided down the centre. Their own nominee was thrown to the wolves and discarded by some of their own honest members on Limerick City Council. There is the division. There is the split. We have it in the Cabinet and everybody knows it. Is this not one of the reasons why the Taoiseach will not go to the country? I suppose it is hard to blame him. One does not race a lame horse. It is only a fool who would do that. You get your horse ready before you produce him on a racecourse.

I suppose the Taoiseach is playing a similar game. He is waiting, hoping that some day there will be unification of the different gangs that exist in Fianna Fáil, that he will gather them around him some fine day and they will go as one regiment before the people. Until that happens he cannot face the people. That is the reason for accepting the long stall approach. It would not surprise me if this Taoiseach were to go down in history as one who went the full distance. I cannot see any chance of the split forces in Fianna Fáil being united. It would be like trying to make a Protestant out of the Pope or a seagull out of a crow. It cannot be done.

The Fianna Fáil gang now in office are living on borrowed time, they are in the condemned cell and they know it. They have been condemned out of hand by the people. It is about time the tide turned. It had to turn. But we know they will hang on like a drowning man hangs to a straw, thinking that time will erase from the memories of the people the debacle of 16th October; 1968. While there is blood in our veins we will see that no such thing happens. We will see that honesty comes before fraud. We will expose them and we will tell the people how public money was wasted on the referendum. I want to repeat what I said last night that, if right was right, the Minister for Local Government should be put on trial for the illegal conversion of the taxpayers' money for the holding of the referendum.

While that money was being spent and while all the curbs were being put on the trade unionists, nothing at all has been said about the unfortunate old age pensioner or the widow and her meagre couple of bob a week. No provision has been made for them because they went out and voted "No". The big industrialist did not come under the whip; he is well fortified and he can carry on and perhaps improve his subscription to the Taca brigade in the coming year, having listened, I am sure, so attentively to the talk given by the Taoiseach recently at a symposium in Cork. Where are we going? However, there is one hope on the horizon.

While the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries have trod their primrose path to the everlasting political bonfire, we can look to the people and say that there are still honest people left. One quarter of a million of them diverted from you and told you where you were going. I am looking forward to your next Ard Fheis, whenever that may be, to hear the voices of the ordinary rank and file of Fianna Fáil repeat the charges I am making against you. There are men in Fianna Fáil who are prepared to do it.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy made an application?

Comment on this

The only thing I ever got from Fianna Fáil was coercion and imprisonment, being hauled into the barracks and questioned about my movements. That has been my experience. I am lucky to be here at all and that I did not die of hunger. No matter how long the Government last, no matter what means they devise to deceive the people, there is one governing factor and that is that no longer can they ask "Where were you in the Civil War?" That is over, thanks be to God.

Comment on this

Where were you in 1968?

Comment on this

In the front line and not being paid for it, not like the Deputy, and some of his relations for that matter.

Comment on this

Of course, we will not discuss your record.

Comment on this

My book is open for everybody to see and it has been well analysed. If there was a comma wrong in it, it would be thrown at me. That is why I can stand up boldly here and speak as I do speak.

Comment on this

The Deputy was making accusations about splits in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

Yes, everybody knows about that.

Comment on this

Nobody knows more——

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know much about Limerick.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Andrews cease interrupting and allow Deputy Coughlan to make his speech?

Comment on this

With respect, Sir, I am being provoked.

Comment on this

I cannot help it if the Deputy is not prepared to hear the truth.

Comment on this

Poor Michael Lipper.

Comment on this

Poor Deputy Coughlan.

Comment on this

We are all poor over here but we are honest. We cannot say that about you people.

Comment on this

You cycled up from Limerick?

Comment on this

Thank God I was able to and thank God I was not in a Mercedes.

Comment on this

The Deputy is one person who should not be talking about a Mercedes. The State provided a Mercedes for the Deputy's family——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should stop introducing personalities.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy mouthing about now? Say what you have to say.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle instructed me to remain silent and I am remaining silent.

Comment on this

We have put down this motion of no confidence in the Government because of the lack of responsibility shown by different Ministries, particularly in regard to the problem of unemployment. No serious approach has been made to find a solution, despite all the programmes and the White Papers. The Fairy Tales of Ireland would only be trotting after the programmes put up in the past with regard to a solution for unemployment. As far as Limerick is concerned we have an all-time record. Not one industry was established in Limerick in the last ten years.

Comment on this

We heard that before.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

It obviously made no impact and I hope that, by repeating it, the Government will one day wake up to the fact that something must be done. The housing problem has been handed over to the Taca consortium, the National Building Agency, and its adherents, who are all members of the gang. These are the people who, when they saw the writing on the wall or, as the Taoiseach said, the clouds on the horizon, wanted the takeover bid and the gamble the Minister for Local Government took on 16th October. That was one of the reasons.

We also have a situation in which we are presented with a White Paper on the Health Services telling us what we are to prepare ourselves for as members of a local authority.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's 45 minutes have now concluded.

Comment on this
Kevin Boland Minister for Local Government (Mr. Boland) Fianna Fáil

I am sorry I have not had the privilege of hearing a great deal of this debate.

Comment on this

I am sorry I have not had the privilege——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputies cease interrupting, please?

Comment on this

——of listening to the debate, but I was engaged in the very complicated task of ensuring that representation in this House will be rigidly related to such relevant democratic considerations as the number of temporary residents in hotels and guesthouses and the number of sailors on board ship in harbour on the night of 17th April, 1966. As a result of my preoccupation with this essential aspect of democracy I did not hear my colleague, Deputy Dunne's, contribution and his gracious references to myself or his outrageous attack on the freedom of the press in the form of that estimable journal, the Irish Independent. It is really amazing that, with all his experience, Deputy Dunne has not yet come to appreciate the divine pontifical authority that attaches to the journalistic profession at every level but particularly at the editorial level. However, even if I missed my colleague's contribution, I have been amply compensated by hearing the enlightening contribution from the pure-souled, socialist Deputy, who has just concluded. It was very interesting, indeed, to hear the comments of a true revolutionary on the iniquitous capitalists who, unlike the dispensers of largesse who follow his own noble profession, expect a day's work for a day's pay. It is indeed an interesting development of the socialist creed that brands such as criminals and outcasts who provide productive employment, even though they may be motivated by the ignoble profit motive, which is, of course, so completely foreign to the altruistic principles of those who follow the socialist Deputy for Limerick's profession. They, as true socialists, operate their own private social welfare offices so that the downtrodden employees of the iniquitous capitalists can double or treble their miserable pittances on their way home from work in accordance with the fundamental socialistic principle, “if you do not speculate, you will not accumulate”. It is a far cry from the days when drink and gambling were described as the twin curses of the workers to the present stage of socialist development when it is the operators of the starting price office who are the public benefactors, while those who invest in industrial development in the country are pilloried as criminal malefactors.

This debate has, as far as I can gather from press reports, which, apart from Deputy Coughlan's contribution, is all that I have had available on which to form a judgment, followed a predictable course, a course just as predictable as the Fine Gael Party's reaction to the defeat of the Government's recent proposals in the referendum. The reaction has been, as was to be expected, a revitalisation of the slander factory that operates in the Fine Gael Party and a revitalisation of those members of the Fine Gael Party who have volunteered to constitute themselves a committee for the manufacturing of scandalous falsehoods designed to assassinate the characters of individual Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Party and of members of that Party who are not Members of this House and also for the dissemination of the falsehoods which they manufacture. In so far as I personally am concerned, I am proud to be the recipient of this attention from the Fine Gael Party. I am proud of the fact that Deputy Clinton, for instance, has not even got sufficient regard for his own supporters; he goes so far as to blacken them in addition to me because of the enmity he personally has against me as a representative of the Fianna Fáil Party in his own constituency.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mind being more specific?

Comment on this

I should like to assure Deputy Clinton that, contrary to the slander that he fabricated and spread throughout his own area, I have no connection whatever with the proprietor of the Green Isle Hotel and as far as I know his connections are with Deputy Clinton's Party and not with mine. I have no connection whatever with the gentleman concerned and, if there is anything wrong with the development of that particular project, it has certainly nothing whatsoever to do with me or, as far as I know, with any member of the Fianna Fáil Party. When Deputy Clinton gathers his scandalmongers and slanderers around him and distributes this product of the Fine Gael slander factory to them for circulation in the locality he knows that this is utterly untrue, but it is, of course, an indication of the depths to which the Fine Gael Party are prepared to go in order to try to blacken the name of individuals in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this

They have not even got respect for their own supporters.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Clinton, on a point of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order. When the Minister makes slanderous statements of this kind in the House is he obliged to produce any proof whatever?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has no function in the matter.

Comment on this

I want to say categorically that I know absolutely nothing about what the Minister said and I emphatically contradict him. I have not the faintest notion what he is talking about and I want him to produce any facts he has and any proofs he has, because I just do not know what he is talking about.

Comment on this

This has been a predictable Fine Gael reaction.

Comment on this

Let the Minister produce anything he has.

Comment on this

The tactics we have seen them adopt in this House are a reversal to the procedure of trying to deny their opponents the opportunity of speaking——

Comment on this

Produce the facts.

Comment on this

——an organisation of the tattered battalions of their blue-shirt stormtroopers on the adjournment to take up their 20 minutes and then seek by the promotion of planned disorder to deny the Minister the right to reply.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle called on the Minister to withdraw and he refused.

Comment on this

Apart from this, the debate itself has followed a predictable course. Apart from references to the referendum campaign and result, and a slight change of emphasis in regard to the individual Ministers selected for personal attacks, this appears to be merely a rehash of many previous debates. The result will be to place on record again the fact that the Opposition Parties have no confidence in the Government. That is something that is well known, something that has been said many times. Its re-assertion this week does not in any way alter the position, and does not in any way add to the public knowledge. It is known that Deputies on the opposite side of the House desire a change of Government, but there is no reason to believe that the people of the country desire a change of Government. In fact, the only available indications are to the contrary.

Comment on this

There is a good way of finding out.

Comment on this

It will be found out in good time.

Comment on this

The Minister is having trouble trying to gerrymander the constituencies to suit his backbenchers.

Comment on this

The requirements of the Constitution must be complied with first.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is in possession.

Comment on this

We will give the Minister free transport to Stormont.

Comment on this

Fine Gael transferred enough of the territory of this country to Stormont in their day. They transferred six of the counties of this country to Stormont and it is not our fault if the Constitution does not at present factually extend to these Six Counties. It is no wonder that the Premier of the Six Counties——

Comment on this

The Minister's Party executed republicans from 1936 to 1939.

Comment on this

——like his predecessors was able to quote the authority given to him by the people on the opposite side of the House who signed away six of our counties.

Comment on this

What did Fianna Fáil do about it since?

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Harte should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

What could we do when the treachery had been effectively perpetrated by the people now in the Opposition?

Comment on this

What did Fianna Fáil do?

Comment on this

They did nothing about it.

Comment on this

We were defeated by their treachery, but the Irish people have made sure ever since that Fine Gael were never in a position to do it again.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We will have to send the Minister to London to have a talk with Mr. Wilson.

Comment on this

Since the last general election the people have voted in four different ways. We had the presidential election, the local government elections, seven by-elections, and the referendum in regard to the proposed Constitution amendments. Of those four different votings by the people, only the seven by-elections were concerned with Government performance or policies. In those seven by-elections, approximately 17.5 per cent of the people have at four different periods had the opportunity to express either confidence in or disapproval of the Government.

Comment on this

If the Minister moves the writ in Wexford he will get his answer.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Allen should cease interrupting.

Comment on this

He does not want the by-election.

Comment on this

The matter of the continuance of the Government was not at stake in the by-elections. The possibility of a Coalition Government was not apparent, so the people might reasonably have felt it was safe to express any disapproval or disagreement they might have felt about minor aspects of Government policy. Despite that and despite the tendency that exists in all known democracies for by-elections to go marginally at least against the Government in office, particularly when an adverse decision in a by-election will not affect the stability of the Government, and particularly when the vacancy is not caused by a member of the Government Party, in six out of seven of those by-elections the people gave a clear vote of confidence in the Government.

That result was never approached in this country before. The only period during which there was anything approaching this kind of result in by-elections was in the period 1957 to 1961 when the Fianna Fáil Government of the time won five out of eight by-elections which took place. As the results of the by-elections indicated, we were, of course, returned to office again at the next general election. In the next period from 1961 to 1965 there were six by-elections and the Government won only two. Despite what might conceivably be interpreted as an indication of a change of opinion among the electorate, we were again returned to office at the next general election. On this occasion we have had seven by-elections and the Government have been successful in six. There could be no clearer indication of the continuing confidence of the people in the Government than that fact.

Comment on this

Try them and see.

Comment on this

This can be compared with the record of the two Coalition Governments we have had. During the period of the first Coalition Government—it lasted such a short time that there were three by-elections only—the Government succeeded in winning two out of three. During the second Coalition period there were seven by-elections.

Comment on this

Which coalition is the Minister talking about? Is it the Sherwin-Lenehan coalition?

Comment on this

The most they could do was to win two out of seven. So, as far as the people of the country are concerned, there is a clear indication available to the Government that they retain their confidence. In only three out of the six by-elections which we won was it a Fianna Fáil seat that was in question? In those three by-elections the people decided to replace the Fianna Fáil Deputy who had died by another Fianna Fáil Deputy, thereby maintaining the status quo which was established in the general election of 1965.

In the other three cases of the by-elections which we won, the people decided to increase the Fianna Fáil representation. In one case, in Cork city, the people made the very remarkable decision of giving Fianna Fáil four out of five seats. In a situation in which we already had three out of the four surviving seats, the people decided to fill the fifth seat by giving us a fourth representative. It is hard to imagine a more definite vote of confidence in the Government than that.

In another of these by-elections, in Waterford, the result was a reversal of the position that existed after the general election of 1965. There, despite the tendency of by-elections to go against the Government, the result was to change the situation in which we got only one seat out of three in the general election to a victory in the by-election. This Fianna Fáil victory in a by-election in a three-seat constituency is equivalent to a two out of three result in a general election. Even in the solitary case where the Opposition candidate was "deemed to be elected" there was a clear indication of a "no change" attitude on the part of the electorate. These seven elections took place at four different times: 7th December, 1966, 9th November, 1967, 14th March of this year and 26th May of this year, so that we have quite recent expression of opinion in regard to the question of whether or not this Government retains the confidence of the people from some of these constituencies.

The first two by-elections took place at a time when we were in the throes of an adverse economic situation and when the man who as Minister for Finance had the responsibility of introducing the measures which were deemed necessary by the Government had just taken over as Taoiseach. They were held in two mainly agricultural constituencies at a time when the major farmers' organisation was in direct dispute with the Government and when circumstances were particularly favourable to the Opposition's attempt to exploit sectional differences for their own advantage. Only one of the two seats to be filled at that time was a Fianna Fáil seat. In one of the constituencies we had only obtained a minority of the seats at the general election. Despite all these factors and the fact that this was a period in which the economy was going through adverse and difficult times the people of Waterford and South Kerry clearly indicated confidence in the Government and their desire that the affairs of the country should continue to remain in responsible hands.

The next two by-elections were held when the measures taken were just beginning to have their effect and the next two when the economy was once more moving satisfactorily. Although the last by-election was held at a time when Coalition solidarity had been restored by the decision of the two Parties opposite to oppose the Constitutional amendment proposals and although this was made the principal point in the campaign by the Opposition, the people left no doubt as to their decision to retain the present Government.

With regard to the Presidential election, while this was not in any way a political matter it was contested on a very intensive scale by the Opposition. Whereas the outgoing President, because of his position was, in effect, a non-participant in the campaign, and even despite this the Fianna Fáil organisation succeeded in getting an overall majority which is something only achieved once in the history of this country in a political election. If there is any political indication in that particular result it is clearly of continued and increased support for Fianna Fáil.

With regard to the local elections, these are concerned with different matters to Dáil elections—the issues are local ones and the location of a candidate is often more important than anything else. The constituencies are smaller and quotas go down as low as 400. There is room for every type of fringe candidate. Despite this Fianna Fáil increased its representation on local authorities, obtaining 589 seats out of a total of 1,538.

The difference between the local elections and the Dáil elections is indicated by the fact that candidates outside the main political Parties who are described under the collective title of "others" obtained almost one-half as much as the major political Party and considerably in excess of 50 per cent of the number obtained by the second political Party. While this election was not either a political matter in the same sense as Dáil elections any indication that can be drawn from it is surely of continued support for the Government.

The two recent referenda, the results of which have inspired the Opposition Parties to put down these motions of no confidence, were concerned with two specific proposals for Constitutional amendments. The people have decided not to make these two changes and they have decided nothing else. They decided not to change the present system of multi-seat constituencies and the transferable vote and they decided constituencies must be revised on the basis of equality of population within very narrow limits, as assessed in the census, per deputy. We accept that. This is what the people want. They want more than one Deputy to represent them. They do not accept that the dangers which we see in the present system are there.

Comment on this

They did not trust you.

Comment on this

The result will be that Deputies will continue to fulfil the functions they must perform at present as exemplified by this letter which somebody was kind enough to send to me. It is a letter in an envelope which is stamped "Oireachtas" and is further stamped "Íoctha go hOifigiúil". It is sent to a lady in Rathmines and reads:

Dear Mrs. (Lady's name),

I understand my constituents find it very inconvenient travelling to Inchicore to consult me as the Labour TD for the area. Accordingly from now on if you or your neighbours wish to see me about any problem would you simply drop me a note and I will be glad to call on you.

Yours sincerely,

J.F. O'Connell

Underneath that we have typed "Dr. John O'Connell, T.D.". It is on Dáil notepaper and it is headed 64 Inchicore Road, Dublin 8.

Comment on this

Is there something wrong with that?

Comment on this

This is the function of the Deputy.

Comment on this

Is that bad form?

Comment on this

That is a matter of opinion.

Comment on this

The Minister would never do that. He has no experience of it.

Comment on this

I have had to tolerate that for seven years past by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in Donegal.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Minister be allowed to continue his speech?

Comment on this

The social mind——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Harte allow the Minister to continue? If Deputy Harte refuses to obey I will ask him to leave the House and that also goes for Deputy Andrews.

Comment on this

The result of the other decision is that constituencies must be revised on a very strict basis of near-equality of population per Deputy irrespective of other considerations. Although the constituencies were last revised in 1961, I and my Department have now to engage in the complicated task of squeezing four more Deputies into Dublin and re-arranging the other areas on the basis of four fewer seats. It is not permissible to take into consideration even such known facts as the fact that the Ballymun housing scheme, which was only in its initial stages in April, 1966, will soon be complete and that large scale housing developments will have taken place soon in Tallaght and other places in my own constituency and that these will significantly affect the census in 1971.

Since these things cannot be taken into account it seems inevitable that another revision must take place in a few years' time. However, that is the position. We are not complaining, but there has not been any other decision made by the people and we have every reason to believe that the people, at the next general election, will decide to renew their mandate to the present Government.

When the Taoiseach concluded his statement announcing the Government's proposals for the proper management of the country's finances, to go as close as possible to matching increased expenditure with increased income and to counteract a somewhat unfavourable trend, Opposition Deputies remarked on the fact that there was no applause from the Government benches. That was true. There was no welcome here, either in the Government or among the members of the Party, for increased taxation in itself. But there is a realisation that the surest and most reliable test of good government is the manner in which it deals with the country's finances and the promptness with which it recognises and deals with ominous trends.

We have always believed that the public can appreciate the necessity for this type of action. We have always believed that they appreciate that the increased expenditure on the pay of State employees, on social services and on agricultural subsidies must, if the economy is to survive, be met from increased tax revenue and, if the revenue itself is not sufficiently buoyant to match increased expenditure, that extra taxes are then required. We have always believed that the people can appreciate this. Our experience has been that we were right and we have never hesitated to do this, when circumstances called for it—and the public have continued to express their confidence in us as a Government.

Nevertheless, as politicians, we appreciate that life would be a lot easier for everyone if taxes never had to be increased. We know that increased taxation in itself can never be popular. The Opposition are quite correct. It was on their side of the House that these proposals for taxation were greeted jubilantly and with smiles. The welcome for the proposals was on the side of the House that voted against them—but it was the other side, the Government side, that did their duty and this will be recognised by the people, as it has been before.

Deputy O.J. Flanagan's remark that he thinks we are "stone mad" is typical of the Opposition attitude. It is a clear indication of what the country can expect in the unlikely event of a change of government after the next general election. The Opposition cannot understand the mentality of a government that does an unpopular thing because it is the right thing to do. With them, that is described as "stone madness". We feel confident that we can demonstrate to the people that, so far from this being "stone madness", it is an example of the wise and courageous government which has resulted in a period of practically continuous economic growth such as this country has never experienced before. It is because of the responsible and meticulous handling of the nation's finances that we have been able to make continuous progress in every aspect of social welfare. There is no need for me to go into detail about that. I know how painful it is for Opposition Deputies to hear even the most general cataloguing of the achievements in every aspect of social welfare of this Government, particularly because of the contrast that it provides with their own almost completely barren record in this regard.

Take the question of the income maintenance services themselves. In every year since this Government came to office in 1957—and despite the disastrous state of the economy which we took over in 1957—this Government has been able to increase the social welfare services and, not alone that, but, in almost every one of those years, each of the income maintenance services was increased. This contrasts very sharply with the record—or lack of record—of the Opposition Parties when they had the opportunity to do something about these services in respect of which they are so vocal when they are on the Opposition benches.

Most of the social welfare services have never been touched by any hands other than those of Fianna Fáil. Certainly, there is no social welfare service that has been introduced by any government in this country other than Fianna Fáil. Every single one of them —with the exception of the non-contributory old age pension scheme which was introduced during the British time and a rudimentary form of unemployment benefit—was introduced by Fianna Fáil and practically all the increases in rates have been introduced by Fianna Fáil. I do not say that this is because the Opposition would not like to improve these social welfare services. It is because they were not able to do so. This was because they have not the courage nor the sense of responsibility to handle the country's finances in a responsible way and so they have not been able to do it. Each one of our Budgets since 1957 has been an exercise in the redistribution of the increased national income resulting from our economic policy— and the people have continued to demonstrate their confidence in the Government because they know that our policy can be expressed simply as "To generate increased national prosperity so as to enable the Government to make real progress in all aspects of social welfare." They can see from experience and from the demonstration they get every year that we have never confused the means with the end; that economic policy, so far as Fianna Fáil are concerned, is the means and improved social welfare, in all its aspects, is the end and that our object in fostering economic growth is to have available an increasing source from which to draw resources for the improvement of living conditions for the people as a whole. My own Department of Local Government is an outstanding example of the methods by which the success of the economic Departments is utilised for the common good.

So far as I myself am concerned, and I think so far as the majority of us are concerned, the most important aspect of my Department is probably the provision of adequate housing for our people. The number of houses built each year has been rising now, with the exception of one year, when there was a slight deterioration, for a longer period than ever before in the history of this State. Between 1963-64 and 1967-68 it has, in fact, risen by about 50 per cent. This rise is continuing. In the first six months of the present financial year, about 8,300 houses were started or had grants allocated for them compared with 7,606 houses in the first six months of last year. In the current financial year, it is expected that about 13,000 houses will be completed compared with 12,017 houses last year. This rise is reflected in total spending on the construction of private and local authority housing and on substantial reconstruction work. In the current financial year, the total amount spent in this way is expected to reach £54 million compared with about £46 million in the last financial year and, of course, this also was a record.

In fact, in the last six years, including the estimated figures for the present financial year, capital expenditure on housing construction, at about £233 million, is almost equal to the total capital expenditure in the 15 years preceding 31st March, 1963, when the total was £240 million. The rise in capital expenditure on housing is continuing. The figures for loan advances or for loan applications on hand by the principal building societies, local authorities and assurance companies for house purchase showed that in the first six months of 1968-69 they had paid out £10.2 million compared with the figure of £8.5 million in the first six months of 1967-68. The value of loans for which applications were in the hands of the principal lending agencies has risen from £5.6 million at 30th September, 1967 to £7.7 million at 30th September, 1968.

Of course, this massive increase in the numbers of houses built and in expenditure on housing construction has naturally been accompanied by an increase in subsidy payments. Since 1963-64 these have risen from £8.2 million to an estimated £11.8 million in the current financial year, and this figure excludes £7.8 million in subsidies for local authority housing.

The Government have taken a number of steps to encourage greater efficiency in building which will in turn result in reduced housing costs. These include a scheme of technical assistance grants for builders to encourage them to engage consultants and to streamline their procedures and to attend courses and seminars where the latest building and control techniques are described; work on dimensional co-ordination, with the object of achieving economies through greater efficiency in the production and use of components in building; and standardisation, throughout the country, of requirements for structural standards etc. in building regulations, which are at present being drafted by An Foras Forbartha.

In regard to the local authority housing programme specifically, 4,045 dwellings, including 1,255 at Ballymun, were completed in 1967-1968.

Work in progress has increased very rapidly and at 30th September a total of not less than 7,277 dwellings were in progress including 1,749 in special projects of the National Building Agency in Dublin, at Ballymun and in Cork and Limerick. Houses in progress, excluding the National Building Agency projects, have increased from 3,031 at 31st March, 1967, to 5,528 at 30th September, 1968. 4,251 men were employed on ordinary local authority housing and 1,016 on National Building Agency projects. A total of 4,684 new dwellings, excluding the National Building Agency projects, were started in 1967-1968 as compared with 2,411 dwellings in 1966-1967, and 2,611 in 1965-1966. Nearly £11 million worth of tenders were approved by the local authority housing, leaving out the National Building Agency projects, in 1967-1968. This compares with £6.06 million in 1966-1967, £5.86 million in 1965-1966, and £7.4 million in 1964-1965.

This is only one aspect of my own Department's administration that I can touch on in this debate, but similar progress has been made in every other aspect. It is because this Government looks after the country's finances, that this Government has sufficient courage and sufficient wisdom to take the necessary remedial measures in time, that it does not have to wait until a critical situation develops, that we ensure that the economy progresses on an even keel throughout our period of office. That is why we have been able to remain in office continuously since 1957. That is why we have been able to maintain such continuous and outstanding progress in every aspect of social welfare; and why the people, realising this will decide, at the next general election when it comes about, to continue to place responsibility for the conduct of the country's affairs in the same hands that have produced such an outstanding contrast to the miserable performance of the two Coalition Parties opposite when, through an indecisive election result, they got the opportunity of wreaking the havoc they did wreak on the country's economy.

Comment on this

Since the people gave their decisive verdict in the referendum and since the start of this debate, many Fianna Fáil speakers have said openly that they accept completely the verdict of the people. I wonder could I ask the Minister for Local Government to remain for a couple of moments because I want to challenge him to something——

Comment on this

The Deputy can challenge me anywhere.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government is now running away from his own accusations.

Comment on this

I left an able Deputy there and I challenge Deputy Clinton anywhere he likes.

Comment on this

Outside the House.

Comment on this

With his stone throwers or without them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not in order for remarks to be made outside the House.

Comment on this

As I said, I heard many Fianna Fáil Deputies stating openly they accepted fully the verdict of the people. This is obviously not so with the Minister for Local Government. He is still whining and complaining that the people are wrong. The only person who is wrong in this country now is the Minister for Local Government. Even his own Taoiseach is wrong. The Taoiseach accepts the verdict of the people; the Minister for Local Government refuses to do so.

The Minister for Local Government proceeds from there to defend the Irish Independent against the attacks of Deputy Dunne. Surely this is novel and particularly good coming from the Minister for Local Government who has himself, in the course of the campaign, been attacking the Irish Independent and doing everything possible to intimidate them. Of course, he would see to it that those advertisements were withdrawn from the Irish Independent if he were not afraid to do it as was done in the case of the Farmers' Journal. It is certainly novel to see the Minister defending the Irish Independent against Deputy Seán Dunne. Deputy Dunne is well known for his appreciation of the high standards observed by the press in this country and of the service they render to the people. The Minister's attitude is typical of his arrogance.

He goes on then to make a personal attack on me and when he is challenged he runs out of the House. He makes a scandalous personal attack on my character but cannot produce a shred of evidence to support what he says. He talks about what I said in regard to some development or other in the Green Isle Hotel in Clondalkin and what I said he did or did not do about this development. He refused to give particulars. I could not possibly follow it up but I challenge him here and now to meet me, with the directors of this hotel, and to tell them and me what he has in mind; because anything I have in mind about the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or the Minister for Local Government or any other Minister, I will say it to him both here and outside the House. I will not be afraid to say it because I am not a person who takes pride in annihilating people's characters as some of those opposite do. I want that challenge to be on record and I want to see the Minister outside the House because I insist I will defend my character no matter who attacks it. I want him to produce the evidence. He is completely free to do so.

He made an attack on Deputy O'Connell about the letters the Deputy writes to his constituents. I had a question on the Order Paper today to ask the Minister if it was the practice in his Department, when he accepted tenders, first to notify certain Deputies in his own constituency before notifying the county council concerned, and I was told the answer was in the negative. I was told the answer was in the negative while I hold in my possession a letter to Deputy Foley: "Dear Des, I am very pleased to be able to tell you I have today accepted the tender for such a house." This was given to Deputy Foley on the 14th and was given to the county council on the 16th.

This is his method of keeping himself in office and for keeping a Deputy in office who is well known to have done no work since he came into the House, either in the constituency or in the House. This is the way for getting a pretext for deceiving the people into believing that they have been in some way responsible for getting a house built for an unfortunate woman. This is the type of practice the Minister for Local Government indulges in when he should be doing his own work. This is the job he has his civil servants engaged in with public money. It is a disgrace and it should be exposed. Of course, there is another Fianna Fáil Deputy in the county but he is not in such favour as Deputy Foley. He may get a letter a few days after the county council have got it and "Dear Paddy" will then be late with the story. This is the form, this is what I want to expose. The Irish Independent, to which the Minister for Local Government referred, had this to say in a leading article on 5th November:

Distasteful, even humiliating, steps are required of the Government to expunge the undemocratic arrogance of which, until last month, it could be rightly accused.

If the Irish Independent wants further evidence of arrogance, it certainly got it today from the Minister for Local Government. The leading article continued:

An easier policy is required of the Opposition: to expose and relentlessly hunt down that arrogance should it show itself again.

I say that, in fact, it has shown itself on a number of occasions inside the last week and I have been thinking about this problem just as the Irish Independent has been. The arrogant people, the people who refuse to talk to people in the country, who refuse to consult the various vocational groups and who ignore the express wishes of the people, are well known in Fianna Fáil. The Minister for Local Government is well known, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, sitting opposite, is well known. He refuses to get down to talk to the people for whose welfare primarily he is responsible. The Minister for Education refuses to talk to the people concerned with education in this country.

I do not know what the Taoiseach will do about them but he has a responsibility to do something. Frankly, I think the only solution is that he should introduce them to Deputy MacEntee, because Deputy MacEntee has friends in Greece, and I think they would be suitably employed there imposing martial law. Either that or, perhaps, Backbencher's NGKA might come out from its anonymity like Taca and make Deputy Boland Taoiseach of that organisation, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Tánaiste, and, perhaps, even find a job for Deputy Lenihan also. That deals with our friend Deputy Boland particularly. When the Taoiseach spoke here earlier he tried to make the point that there was an element of political opportunism in Fine Gael tabling this motion of no confidence at the present time, and that this, of course, applied also to the motion in the name of Labour.

However, the Taoiseach saw no such element in his, on the same day, bringing in a staggering Budget that will leave the people of this country incapable of thinking of anything except the backbreaking load of added taxation that has been piled on their backs and which they are being asked to accept. The Taoiseach so far has got away successfully with his pose on the pious altar of rectitude, but the people are now finding him out and they have realised fully that he is well able to play Party politics with the best.

Since we put down this motion, and following this crushing defeat at the referendum, many people have come to me and said: "You had not to wait for the defeat to put this motion down. This motion is long overdue. There is overwhelming evidence available already to prove that they have failed completely to solve the many pressing problems from which the country is suffering and they appear to have no worthwhile ideas or plans for the future". After 30 years of Fianna Fáil in office we have a situation where unemployment is increasing rather than decreasing. We have emigration proceeding apace. We have health and social welfare services lagging behind the rest of Europe and we have a deplorable backlog of housing needs.

At the same time, we have scandalous speculation in building land. In the course of the past week, I have come across sites for sale, individual sites for houses, for £5,000 each, plus 5 per cent. I know another case where the speculator bought a nine-acre field for £47,000. He got planning permission for 75 housing sites on it. These housing sites are now being sold at £1,675 each, plus 5 per cent, plus—this is an important plus—£22 ground rent, so that when these houses are built on this site, this speculator will have an annual income of not less than £1,600 from the ground rents alone. This is the type of speculation that the Government have facilitated and encouraged. It is what brought Taca into being. They are the people who want to see Fianna Fáil continue in office. They are the people who have grown fat during Fianna Fáil's reign in office. Fianna Fáil have refused absolutely to accept our proposals for the setting up of an impartial body to deal with planning appeals. They know that these favours can be handed out, that they can make or break any such person and that money has been put into the pockets of people of this kind.

It is all right for the Minister for Local Government to come in here and tell us all the present Government have done in relation to the housing problem. What I want to know is what is the present position. It is deplorable. There is a backlog of housing needs and I do not know when it will be caught up with and I do not think that any evidence is needed to prove that many thousands of our people have been living in deplorable housing conditions for many years. This city is ringed with caravans. Every approach road to the city is locked up with caravans on the side of the road and every open space has caravans. These caravans are occupied by decent people who cannot find the wherewithal to buy a housing site and build houses. Those people cannot get a local authority house and do not qualify in many cases for a local authority house.

In many of these caravans you have children of nine, ten and 11 years of age who do not know what it is to run from one room to another and who possibly will never know the joy of running from one room to another. How children can be expected to grow up with a healthy mind and wholesome aspirations from these surroundings beats me, and how any Minister for Local Government can come in here, with his own Government in office for so long, and flap his wings about what has been done about the housing situation in this country beats me.

I think the people have sized up the situation. They have realised that this Government is more concerned about the wealthy people in this country and about making the rich people richer than they are about unfortunate people who are confronted with circumstances such as I describe. We do not find the Minister for Local Government going to Ballyfermot on a Sunday morning to see the position there and listen to the plight of many people: but he can come in and attack people in this House who are trying to do what they can to assist people of that kind.

I said earlier that, instead of improving, the unemployment situation is worsening. Unfortunately the facts are there and this fact does not require any proof from me or from anybody else. The main reason why we have this situation is that many people are fleeing from conditions in rural Ireland. We are not able to find jobs for them outside rural Ireland and we have no plans to hold them in rural Ireland or to try and find worthwhile occupation for them there. So, therefore, we have no plans in rural Ireland and we have no plans when they leave it. Were it not for the safety valve of emigration this Government would be out of office long ago.

The people of rural Ireland are the most important sector in this country. On their production depends our ability to buy the raw materials for all other industries. We know that, if they do not produce agricultural goods at a price at which we can sell them in the export market, the whole of the economy is doomed. It has long since been well established that the welfare of the economy as a whole in the last analysis depends on how agriculture is doing and how much it is producing for export. The more we succeed in producing in rural Ireland the more dependent we become on export markets.

What is the situation in agriculture to-day? I said earlier on that we have a situation where the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is not talking to the people in the industry. This war is in existence now for over two years. I personally have pleaded with the Minister and with the farmers concerned to try and build a bridge between them but the Minister is not prepared to come and meet them. He is not prepared to accept that he is there to serve the people and not to bully them and not to drive them. The day is gone and should be buried forever when farmers can be kicked around and dictated to by their own Minister.

An essential starting point in any agricultural policy programme is the full involvement and participation of the farmers on whom the future of the industry depends. If we have not this type of democracy in agriculture, we have no hope. We talk about industrial democracy but I think it is far more essential to have democracy in agriculture.

This week what have we been given? What has agriculture been given? It has been blamed for the heavy taxation that has been imposed on the people's back in the second enormous Budget we have had this year. But, what are they likely to get out of it? The subsidy on calves will give them nothing this year. That is accepted. It does not operate until the 1st April next and the one penny a gallon for those who produce milk up to 7,000 gallons cannot bring in more, cannot cost the Government more than £250,000 in what is left of this year. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries knows, and nobody has to tell him, that the end of the lactation period has arrived and that cows will be dry over the winter in the dairying areas and the amount of milk involved in this will certainly not call for expenditure up to the amount described in this second Budget. It is ridiculous to say it will. It is ridiculous to suggest that this taxation has been found necessary because of the fact that there are £6 million for the farmers. This is the type of deplorable attitude that exists towards the Irish farmers and Irish agriculture. That has been in evidence here for a long time.

If farmers get anything in a budget it should operate from April or May, that is the summer. The other sectors of the people who have to pay for this enormous load of taxation are said to carry the farmers on their back, when in fact the reverse is the case. Today we hear that this limited number of small farmers are getting this one penny when their cows are dry. On the same day as we are told that there will be £8 for a calf on a farm where no milk will be supplied to a creamery or no milk will be supplied to a city or a town, we hear the news that the B and I are charging 25s more per beast for bringing cattle from Dublin to Liverpool and that they are going to confine their operations in future to one route. This means that cattle being exported from Cork and from all over the country will first have to be conveyed to Dublin. I would like the Minister to calculate the cost of bringing those cattle to Dublin and then 25s more to convey them to England from Dublin and only on the one route. I hold that the loss involved in this to the producers of cattle is in fact going to be much greater than what the Minister is providing so that the sooner the sing-song about what the farmers of this country are getting is given up the better. They are getting a pittance.

What the Minister is doing is encouraging people to stay below 7,000 gallons. He knows as well as I know that this is not an economic unit of production. We have had programmes on television indicating that if you want an economic unit, a viable unit, you must have 30 cows on a 40-45 acre farm of good land. Here we have the situation where the Minister comes in offering a penny a gallon to those who produce under 7,000 gallons. This does not make sense to me and it does not make sense to anybody. We have the Second Programme for Economic Expansion laying down certain targets. We have not nearly reached those targets in cow numbers, in cattle numbers or in milk production but the farmers are told: "You are producing too much milk. We must stop you producing milk." They are told at the same time: "You are producing too much wheat. We must stop this. Look at what this is involving the country in." We have a situation where we are not able to supply our quota of bacon to the British market. This arises purely and solely because Fianna Fáil have no agricultural policy and never had an agricultural policy and because their policy is being decided from day to day and from month to month.

I said earlier on that it was the job of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to serve the people and to serve the farmers of this country. I want to say more about that. It is also the job of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to take some of the uncertainty out of farming in the future. He must look a reasonable distance ahead and he must plan a reasonable distance ahead. He should be able to say to the farmers: "I want you to produce so much of this, that and the other and, if you do, I will guarantee that you will get a rock bottom price of so much." Put a floor on it and say: "You will get this price when you produce so much and I will guarantee an outlet." No such statement has been made and consequently there is no confidence in the future of Irish farming. No farmer is in the position today that he can plan ahead and that he can make worthwhile investment knowing in advance that, if he does this, he will have an outlet and a reasonable price for his produce. This should be engaging the attention of the Minister and it certainly has not been engaging the attention of the Minister. We have had slumps and booms and every time that we produce more pigs, more grain, more milk, more cattle, we have a slump simply and solely because forecasting and marketing as it should be done in a modern society is just not being done. It is being neglected.

We have a situation at the present time where the Minister says that there must be a shift away from milk and, at one and the same time, his advisers are going around the country, especially in the intensive development areas, telling the farmers: "Your only hope is to get into milk. This is the best way to increase your income. This is the best advice we can give you!" Surely that is a contradiction in terms and surely a stop must be put to this once and for all. The farmers must be told where they are going.

We have a chaotic position in the pig industry. Smuggling has been referred to earlier on today. We have a situation whereby we are not able to supply our quota on the British market. We have failed to do that and we are only supplying it because of the enormous amount of pigs being smuggled in across the Border from the Six Counties. My view is that no serious attempt has been made to stop this smuggling and that this is because of our embarrassment at not being able to supply our quota. This smuggling is costing the taxpayers of the country on average £12,000 per week. These smugglers are well known and the number of pigs they are smuggling is well known but, as Deputy Coughlan has said, were it not for these smugglers the bacon industry in this country would be sitting down. This is a deplorable situation. We have skim milk to the point where we cannot dispose of it and there has been no organised effort to get the pig industry into a situation where it could absorb an immense amount of this skim. We have failed because we refused to accept that you will not get pigs produced in this country unless you get a balance between the price of pigs and the price of feeding stuffs and unless you keep this relationship always the same or reasonably the same. Farmers will get into pigs and get out of pigs.

We have had the chairman of the Pigs and Bacon Commission—where I think a good job is being done having regard to the circumstances—coming into the open and saying that the situation that took place here in 1965 would justify a public inquiry in any other country in the world except here and that obviously the advice he had given and the recommendations he had made to the Department were ignored. It is a deplorable situation that this can be said and not contradicted and that farmers were put into the situation, long before they had reached the target of pig production set by Fianna Fáil in the Second Programme, where they practically had to give pigs away. It is no wonder the situation is as it is but I think it is something to be thoroughly ashamed of.

It is obvious that the market is there. It is obvious that the Irish farmer is in a position to supply that market. It is obvious, too, that there are difficulties in the disposal of milk products and that the Minister has a duty to attract people into other lines of production. We cannot afford to say in the case of milk production, the economy as a whole cannot afford to say: "You cannot produce any more milk," when we have regard to the fact that two-thirds of our beef cattle are supplied from the dairy herds of this country. We are treading on very dangerous ground now and we offer £8 for calves in this very limited category. At one and the same time, as I understand it, we are taking away the calved heifer subsidy scheme. If that is so, the result will be a minus benefit to the farmers of this country. There will be no benefit in it and I think the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries knows this well and it is time he did something about it.

I spoke about increased charges for transport and so on. I believe the Minister has been forewarned on many occasions that this situation would arise. He had been warned about the situation in England with which the people in the cattle trade were confronted when the B and I allowed their waggon stock to run down and when farmers and traders were required to convey their cattle by road at very much increased costs. Obviously nothing was done about this or, if so, nobody knows that any effort was made; but we do know that no success was achieved in regard to overcoming these difficulties. Now there is a war between B and I and British Railways, a war that the Irish farmers and those in the cattle trade must endure. The Minister should do whatever he can, with his colleague the Minister for Transport and Power, to resolve these difficulties and ensure that our farmers get the service they deserve. He should try to reduce the costs involved.

I am dealing with agricultural matters and we shall probably be dealing with them in a week or so again because we have now reached the situation when one Estimate is catching up with the next simply because we have had so much unwanted and undesirable legislation introduced, eating into the time of the House and causing unnecessary expense to the country. We had the referendum thrown in for good measure. We scarcely know what Estimate we are discussing. The country is alarmed at the situation in regard to sheep. Sheep numbers are down by about 500,000 or something approaching that. The reply to a question I had down the other day indicates that the subsidy on sheep is only about half what it is on other products. Here we have an imbalance that apparently had not been looked at or no great effort was made to level it up. It is a serious situation when we want to attract farmers into lines of production that are easy to sell to find that we are making little or no effort to bring that about.

What is our grain policy? Since last January we imported about £1.5 million of low-class and low-quality pollard. Why? Why did we refuse last year to give our farmers a few extra shillings per barrel or per ton for barley? Why did we not encourage the growing of greater quantities of barley by increasing the price? We all made a case for an increased price for barley or for an acreage subsidy for barley as they do in Northern Ireland. We are boasting about the £8 for a very small number of calves but I was in Northern Ireland last week buying cows and I inquired from a farmer what they were getting by way of subsidy in Northern Ireland and he informed me that they were getting 10 guineas for bull calves and 9 guineas for heifer calves of all breeds and sorts. We are now boasting about taking away the heifer subsidy scheme and giving a small subsidy for a limited number of calves.

I am glad horticulture is making some progress, even though last year we imported £2 million worth of apples. I believe strawberries are paying, but no effort is being made to find a market on a contractual basis for a reasonable period ahead such as would induce people to make an investment knowing they would not be throwing away their money.

I have not much time left but I want to say a word to the Minister about the Cook-Sprague Report. Why is this Report left lying about? We first had the Knapp Report. We still have this chaos in the milk industry. Recommendations were made in the Knapp Report but we were not wholly satisfied with that and we brought in two more experts to check on the previous ones and they reported a considerable time ago. The Cook-Sprague Report, when it comes out, is not the Cook-Sprague Report but an edited version of it. I want the Minister to say why was he afraid to print what was in the Cook-Sprague Report and why it has been altered and what right he has to alter a Report produced by two experts and paid for out of public money?

There is also the store cattle report. That is lying in the Minister's Department since last April and not yet printed. I am sure it contains some very important material that would benefit the country, but it is kept in the background like whatever the Minister has to say about all his visits to the British Minister for Agriculture. That has also been kept secret. The House has been told nothing about what happened in the course of the Minister's visits to his British counterpart. What matters were discussed? There are many matters of urgent importance to this country. The Minister promised the House before we went into Recess that he would come back and tell us what it was all about and asked us not to embarrass him about it in advance. We refrained but, after all this time, it cannot be a cause of embarrassment for the Minister now to stand up and tell the House what he has been discussing with the British Minister because there have been no obvious results. No great beneficial results have followed these visits.

I do not want to continue to speak but I believe the time has come when the people will speak. A general election is obviously in the offing and I think the people are looking forward to that day when, I believe, their verdict will be for a change of government. That is the relief the country is looking for. The present Government stand discredited before the people for their failure in so many departments. I think it was Deputy Coughlan who said earlier that there was no fear of the Government going to the country. I agree with him because I think if they went to the country they would be slaughtered.

Comment on this

Annihilated is the word.

Comment on this

They are hoping that the memory of the people will be short and that if they can drag out the present Government sufficiently long the people will have forgotten the Government's ignominious defeat in the referendum. The people know where they stand now. They know the arrogance they have to put up with. They know the dishonesty and they are craving at the present time for honest Government and for fairplay for the Irish people. Because of the arrogance of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and of his refusal to meet deputations from Macra na Feirme——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this

On a point of order, Sir, we had this last night when the Ceann Comhairle called on a Minister to speak instead of a Labour speaker. The Minister said he would check with his Whip. He did check and found that one speaker at a time, in rotation, would speak from each Party. I do not expect that the agreement has been changed since last night and I suggest that Deputy Tierney is entitled to his place.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has found that the Chair was not informed and in these circumstances the Chair could not depart from the usual practice of not calling two speakers from the same Party in rotation.

Comment on this

Would the Chair not agree, despite what occurred last night, when the Minister stated that he was checking with his Whip that the Chair should have been informed. The Fianna Fáil Whip is in the House and could be brought here for confirmation of what I am saying.

Comment on this

This was a vote of no confidence in the Government. The Labour Party also put down a vote of no confidence. We looked for time and we came to certain agreements. The speakers were to rotate up to 2.45 p.m. this evening. If the Labour speaker is coming in afterwards that is no reason why this ruling should be given.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Are you afraid to give the Minister a chance to answer what has been said?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy seeking a vacancy?

Comment on this

Furthermore, despite the fact that we were allowed three clear days, the Taoiseach came in here yesterday with a mini-Budget which took 2½ hours out of that time. There is no use in making agreements in this House if they are not to be kept. If this agreement is broken we shall make no further agreements with the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In these circumstances, the Chair can only proceed on the basis on what has been officially communicated to the Chair. I must, therefore, call on the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this

Did not the Ceann Comhairle get information from the Fianna Fáil Parliamentary Secretary, the Chief Whip, last evening and is this information not in your notes?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no such information.

Comment on this

On a point of order surely it cannot be ruled that a rural Deputy from the South of Ireland will not be allowed to speak in this House.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is not denying the right of any Deputy to speak but the practice of not calling two Deputies from the same Party in rotation must be adhered to.

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

This would not have happened were it not for the fact that Deputy L'Estrange was afraid that the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries might get in to deny some of the lies that have been heard in this House.

Comment on this

We do not care who gets in.

Comment on this

The Deputy went across to Deputy Tully and asked him to get one of his other speakers to speak and he asked Deputy Tierney. If you do not like that, you can bottle it up. We are not asleep over here. The obvious tactics of the Opposition are to prevent me from speaking here.

Comment on this

No such thing. We made a Whips' agreement and it should be kept.

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has put his foot down on rural Ireland during the last three years. He is not going to come in here now and deprive me of my time.

Comment on this

Of course not, I would not dream of it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have called the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this

I am claiming injury time.

Comment on this

There was an agreement made.

Comment on this

This was not the Whips' agreement.

Comment on this

On a point of order, the Ceann Comhairle is here now and I wish to ask him if he were informed by the Fianna Fáil Whip yesterday evening that an agreement was made whereby, the speakers were to be called one, one, one in rotation.

Comment on this

There was no such agreement.

Comment on this

An agreement was made. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach confirmed it with Deputy Tully and informed the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this

I have been called now. There is no point in trying to talk me out of it.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this

The Deputy should sit down.

Comment on this

I will, when the Ceann Comhairle tells me, on a point of order, what I have asked—but there was a Whips' agreement. I am asking the Ceann Comhairle a question.

Comment on this

Are you afraid of me?

Comment on this

Not of the Minister.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy would sit down I would reply. The Deputy has referred to the agreement of one, one, one and if he wants that carried out, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle was correct in calling a Member of the Fianna Fáil Party to speak in view of the fact that Labour will follow.

Comment on this
Mr. Tully

It is a supposition.

Comment on this

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle has already called me, Sir.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Leas-Cheann Comhairle has called the Minister.

Comment on this

I want to make my point quite clear. I understood that I would be getting in at approximately 2.20 p.m. I object strongly to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries who has shot down the plain people of this country during the last three years——

Comment on this

I wish to point out that the Minister for Local Government has had 15 minutes——

Comment on this

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this

Obviously, they are under the impression that I am in charge of that as well.

Comment on this

The farmers know what the Minister is in charge of.

Comment on this

Obviously, they do not want to know what I am in charge of. That is why they have spent the past ten or 15 minutes in this way. In so far as this motion is concerned, that this House has confidence in the Government, as distinct from the negative sort of motion put down by Fine Gael, that there is no confidence in the Government, I want to give with regard to agriculture, to which I will confine myself now because of the time-wasting tactics indulged in, a few figures which, perhaps, the Opposition Deputies will take home and add up. Agriculture is our most important industry and always has been in the mind of Fianna Fáil. In the years since Fianna Fáil last came into office, that is 1956, gross agricultural output has risen from £175 million in that last glorious year, as they would like to believe, of coalition, to £293 million estimated for 1968. These are two good figures— £175 million in 1956; £293 million in 1968—for gross agricultural output as between those two years over that period.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Everything has gone up in the meantime, including the Minister's salary.

Comment on this

If the Deputy does not like his increase in salary he can give it back. He was told that already. Aggregate farm income—I am sure you must be absolutely bubbling over with enthusiasm to hear these figures about agriculture—£95 million was the aggregate farm income in 1956. It will be, or is, this year £161 million. Agricultural exports, about which we are all so concerned——

Comment on this

Do you remember when you told us the British market was gone forever, thank God?

Comment on this

In 1956, output and export was £66 million worth of agricultural goods. Last year, it was £144 million worth of agricultural goods. Surely, you must be delighted?

Comment on this

Thanks to James Dillon and the 1949 cattle agreement.

Comment on this

One shilling a gallon for milk and the rocks of Connemara to be moved into the sea. Cattle numbers: in 1956, 4,537,000 head of cattle. Under Fianna Fáil, since then, the figure has gone up from that figure of 4,537,000 to 5,546,000 in the year 1968. Milch cows, about which we have heard so much in the past few days, have gone up since 1956 from 1,187,000 to 1,603,000 in the year 1968. Exports of cattle and beef have gone up from 830,000. In 1956, 830,000 cattle or their equivalent went out from this country. In 1967, 1,404,000 cattle went out by way of export and earned very good and substantial money for the farmers of this country.

Comment on this

Thanks be to God.

Comment on this

Again, creamery milk, in which you like to wallow in this House and you cry crocodile tears about the dairy farmers, here in brief form is the record. In 1956, creamery milk delivered to creameries was 263,000,000 gallons. In 1968, now drawing to a close, the figure will be in or about 520,000,000 gallons from these same dairy farmers—surely, even in Fine Gael's estimation, a significant increase in milk production and deliveries to our creameries?

Comment on this

That was done in spite of you.

Comment on this

Listen to this. The value of that milk, which was £20 million in 1956, is now, in this year, reaching £56 million for the milk supplied by the dairy farmers of this country and then we hear Fine Gael crying about them and they would have us revert to James Dillon and his agricultural policy and his bob a gallon.

Comment on this

He put the farmers on their feet.

Comment on this

If we reverted to that we would not only not need the supplementary Budget just introduced but, in fact, we would save so much that we would have a surplus to distribute at this time or six months from now, next April, because one bob a gallon at this stage would save us £25 million by reducing our support to milk and bringing it back to the level it was at when you people in Fine Gael were in government in 1956, and well the Deputies know that.

Comment on this

One shilling then is equal to 4s 2d now.

Comment on this

Never mind what it is equal to. That is what you would have them get. Are you now backing down on Deputy Dillon's offer of a shilling a gallon? Are you also backing down on the statement I made that our output at the present time in milk is 520,000,000 gallons as against 263,000,000 gallons, when the land, apparently, in 1956, was flowing with milk and honey brought about by the good government of you lot over there? Is this what you are trying to tell us? Is that what we want to go back to and how are we to guard ourselves against the threat to the future that your colleague talked about a few minutes ago? Are we to take him to heart? Are we to listen to him and take some notice when he talks about what we are to do for the farmers in the future? How are we to secure their future?

Comment on this

Get Fianna Fáil out of office.

Comment on this

One way in which we can do that is to ensure that Fine Gael stays in Opposition and does not get over here. This is the best security, the best assurance, for the future that the farmers can get, and well Fine Gael knows it and well the farmers know it and well the people know it. When you go to the country, as you will have to do in the not too distant future, the people will tell you that they want their future secured, that they want to see agriculture progress in future as it has been doing under Fianna Fáil and the only way to ensure it will be to keep you people where you are, in the Opposition, forever and always. This is the only rôle that you can fill, and very badly, if I may say so, do you fill it and have been filling it over these recent months.

Let us look at just another aspect, lest the increased production that the farmers have been giving us and the increased out-turn they have been earning for this country is attributed to them and them alone and lest it should be said that the Government had no hand or part in it, that it was in spite of the Government that it was done. Here is your record: in 1956-57, in terms of money, your government's total contribution to the agricultural community and the advancement of agriculture was a scanty £17 million. What will it be this year?

Comment on this

They were better off then than they are now.

Comment on this

In 1968-69, that £17 million will have risen to a figure approximating to £80 million. Start sorting that one out and ask yourselves whether we as a Government have not only done our part as a Government in supporting and aiding agriculture, have not only kept in step with the increased production, but have gone far ahead of it as against your record as a Government during that term of Coalition during that last year in office, and your figure of £17 million odd. That is what you gave. That is what you thought the farmers were worth. That is what you thought agriculture was worth. Whereas, we in Fianna Fáil, this year, are putting into agriculture, taking it on the same basis as that £17 million, a figure of £80 million. Sneeze that one off.

Comment on this

That is cod.

Comment on this

Talk about it as cod or anything you like. These are the facts and the people over there should learn them off and stop making fools of themselves both in this House and outside when making these criticisms merely to hear the sound of their own voices.

Comment on this

Why are they picketing your office? Why are your friends in the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association picketing your office if they are so well off?

Comment on this

What about the wee farmers of Rossnakill? There must be someone else left in Rossnakill.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy behave himself?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants personalities he can have them outside, not in here.

Comment on this

I was elected to this House——

Comment on this

Not to talk about personalities.

Comment on this

I am not talking about personalities.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputy please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

Can I ask the Chair to see that the amplification is turned down a little bit?

Comment on this

I quite agree. There should be no amplification except for the man who is speaking. That is how it should be and if that was so there would be no need for it to be turned up. If there is to be any arrangement it should be that the amplification should be dead in respect of the man over there.

Comment on this

It is dead.

Comment on this

I know it is because the whole damn lot of you are dead.

Comment on this

There was resuscitation in the Fianna Fáil benches in the last fortnight.

Comment on this

We will have a really good day on this next week. I will really tell you something next week. I want now to turn to the referendum and the Leader of the Fine Gael Party, that is, if you can recognise him. We recognised Deputy Cosgrave as the Leader of your Party and he came in here on this debate and talked about the referendum and about how many hundreds of thousands of people said "No" to the proposals and he said this was a reflection on the Government who made the proposals. Has it occurred to him, as it must have occurred to everybody in this House, that if it is a reflection on us by a couple of hundred of thousands of votes then it is a reflection on Deputy Cosgrave who agreed with the proposals but with which his Party would not agree?

Comment on this

Do not be claiming companionship with Deputy Cosgrave; you are not in the same class.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputies please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

It is true beyond doubt that the situation of your Leader is pitiful, to say the least.

Comment on this

Not as pitiful as your own.

Comment on this

If the referendum had been won he would have been blamed for losing your case and now it is being said that you won in spite of him. That is all I have to say about that. What else could he expect from associating with a group that allegedly has him as Leader and then will not take his leadership or accept his advice on this or any other matter? Is that not typical of the split Party you always have been, of the split personality you have always been? This is the Party that we know to be a Party of reactionaries, the group who down through the years, even though they changed their name, sold part of the country and would sell it again if they got the chance and you know——

Comment on this

What about the Kelly case? Tell us about the Kelly case.

Comment on this

You will never get away from the fact that you are the people responsible for the sale of this country, for the partition of this country and for the difficulties up there today.

Comment on this

What about 1939? Who executed the people in 1936 and in 1939?

Comment on this

You use these troubles for your own advantage. You came trotting down here and said "Look at Derry. We will have to send Deputy Harte and Deputy O'Donnell to see at first hand what is going on there." The only thing I would say from a political standpoint is that it is a pity they did not stay there.

Comment on this

On a point of order, does the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries disagree with Deputy O'Donnell and myself——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order. The Minister to conclude. The Minister has one minute left.

Comment on this

What I disagree with is the hypocrisy, the sheer hypocrisy of sending this pair of "boyos" to Derry to see what was going on and which was brought about by Partition which was caused by this Party. Go back now and tell them in Derry who you really belong to, that today you are the descendants of the Old Cumann na nGaedheal Party which sold the Six Counties.

Comment on this

Was the Minister in Hyde Park?

Comment on this

Hypocrisy of the highest order or of the lowest order, whichever way you like to take it. That is the position of Fine Gael. They said the straight vote caused the difficulty in Derry and they knew it was Partition that caused it and that they were responsible for Partition.

Comment on this
Deputies

Sit down.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Tully to conclude on behalf of the Labour Party.

Comment on this

To be continued next week.

Comment on this

Since there is a Fianna Fáil and a Fine Gael speaker to follow me, perhaps the Deputies would let me say what I have to say? I do not want to get involved in the Derry question but when the Labour Party voted against the constituency commission the people now shouting over there did not come in to vote.

Comment on this