We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Confidence in Government: Motion (Resumed).

Contributions 210–419 of 419. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

At least you are not along with that gang.

Comment on this

They were outside the House and did not come in.

Comment on this

The Labour Party did not belong to that outfit then.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The only thing I cannot understand — I am not quite sure where Fianna Fáil were at that time——

Comment on this

When men were needed they were there and that is a lot more than can be said for any of them near you.

Comment on this

During the Emergency when men were wanted very few of the men sitting behind you were there.

Comment on this
A Deputy

That is a lie.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

You did not belong to that crowd. Keep away from them if you have any sense.

Comment on this

The Minister for Aggravation.

Comment on this

If things are so good in agriculture why have we got a picket outside Government Buildings? Why would the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries and his predecessor not talk with the farmers?

Comment on this

Why do you not ask them?

Comment on this

I am asking the Minister.

Comment on this

Do not start talking now. The Deputy will have enough to say during the by-election. I was born and reared on a farm and I was not born with a silver spoon in my mouth like the Deputy. The Deputy has to earn his first bob yet but I had to earn my living from the start. Do not tell me anything about——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, order.

Comment on this

If I had a farm I would run it. The Deputy has a farm and he has to come in here——

Comment on this

I will give the Deputy——

Comment on this

I do not want anything from you. Just keep out of this.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Tully.

Comment on this

What I cannot understand is why——

Comment on this

You are always trying to shout down young Members.

Comment on this

There was an attempt made to shout down Deputy Tully who did not interrupt when the Minister was speaking.

Comment on this

His points of order were good. I only got 15 minutes.

Comment on this

The position is that an arrangement was made with the Whips for this debate and the arrangement was quite clear. Speakers were to be called one/one/one from each of the Parties and each speaker was to get three-quarters of an hour, if he could use it. When the debate started an attempt was made to use up time by introducing the maxi-Budget and, along with it, a national loan and, as well as that, the debate was to finish at 5 O'clock this evening. That did not work and when it did not work, some other tactics had to be devised.

Comment on this

On a point of order. So far as I am concerned, the only agreement I was aware of——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

The understanding and agreement, as I know it, was 45 minutes per speaker and there was no question of one/one/one or one/two/ three.

Comment on this

The Minister for Aggravation has spoken.

Comment on this

The difference between us is that I was present at the Whips' meeting and the Minister was not. The Fianna Fáil Whip, who is a decent man and who will stand by his word, would, if he were here, say that I am telling the truth, but he is not here.

Comment on this

The Deputy took ten minutes off my time and it was not fair.

Comment on this

The Minister was not entitled to any ten minutes at all. This is further evidence of the tactics of the Fianna Fáil Party, the Party that does not want anybody but themselves to be heard and, as well as that, they want only their own particular version. The Government, particularly the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, tell us about the wonderful situation agriculture is in and, simultaneously, the farmers are picketing and the Minister will not speak to them. When the referendum was on the stocks he suddenly got the idea that it might be a good thing to say he would meet them under certain terms but, the farmers having had their fingers burned on at least two occasions by the Minister and his predecessor, the invitation was turned down.

Comment on this

Would Deputy Molloy keep quiet? He was not allowed to talk. Would he keep quiet now, for goodness' sake? There will be two Fianna Fáil and a Fine Gael speaker after me so would Fianna Fáil Deputies now please let me say what I have got to say? I do not want any help from either Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Cut out the personal attacks then.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

Why did the Deputy not make a speech? He was not competent to make it, but he likes to interrupt somebody else. Deputy Martin Corry and Deputy Des Foley were considered suitable speakers, but Deputy Molloy was not.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Andrews please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

We have heard a great deal about this extra penny on the milk. Would Fianna Fáil realise that the penny per gallon offered to the farmers works out at shillings per week? It is the very same as the derating of land under £20 valuation. That also works out at shillings per week. The small farmer does not want doles or pennies handed to him, as if he were a child. He wants a decent living and, if he does not get it with Fianna Fáil in office, he will get it with Fianna Fáil out of office.

I promised Deputy Foley I would comment on one particular point because he obviously does not know the facts. He spoke for three-quarters of an hour. He made some fairly good points, but one point was entirely off beam and, because it was, it requires a little explanation from me. I refer to this matter of the political fund. He talked about trade unions giving money to the Labour Party, having got that money by slitting the workers' wage packets as they came home from work. That statement, for the benefit of Deputy Foley and those like him who do not know anything about trade unions, is absolutely wrong. The position is that any trade union can, if their members agree, set up a political fund. By law, they can have a certain subscription paid towards a political fund. Any member who wants to opt out of the fund can do so. All he need do is sign a declaration that he does not want to contribute.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order. Will Deputy Molloy cease interrupting?

Comment on this

All trade union members have the right to opt out and if they sign an option out their money is not used. During the recent referendum campaign the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, following a discussion at their annual conference, decided they would campaign against the change and the money they used for that campaign was money subscribed by unions which had political funds and which subscribed some of those funds to help finance the campaign. Those who were not subscribing to the funds had no right to say how the money should be used.

The trade union of which I am general secretary had no political fund and we did not, therefore, contribute; but certain people signed a document to the effect that they were opting out and disagreed with what we did. One fellow had not paid a penny to us for six years, or to anybody else, but his name was down as disagreeing with the way we spent his money. I do not know what money he was talking about. If one goes to the trouble of checking the published lists one finds that some did not know the name of the union and some did not belong to any union, as was proved subsequently. In the case of members of families, the address got changed around a bit, but it was the same family. To suggest that money was illegally used for this campaign, or any other campaign, or that the Labour Party is getting money which is taken off Fianna Fáil supporters for the purpose of campaigning, is a lot of damn nonsense and anyone who does not know that must be very thick.

We had a great deal of talk from the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Boland, about all the by-elections Fianna Fáil won. I do not want to go back on the ones they won. I am more interested in the ones to come. There are two by-elections, unfortunately. I would like to see the Government moving the writ for one or the other. That would show their confidence in the people and the result would show the confidence the people have in them. We will take the test on one or the other and the sooner the better. Are they afraid to go to the country? Let there be no doubt about it, Fianna Fáil are afraid to face the electorate. If President de Valera or Deputy Seán Lemass were Taoiseach, either of them would have been up in the Park the moment the result of the referendum was known. Do not forget what happened when Mrs. Eileen Desmond won the seat in Cork a few years ago. Deputy Seán Lemass was up to the Park asking for the dissolution of the Dáil before the information was published in the evening papers that Mrs. Desmond had won the seat.

We have people here who, knowing they have done wrong and knowing they have no chance of getting what they got in the last general election, an overall majority, are sitting around in the hope that another miracle will occur which, by some peculiar set of circumstances, they may be able to twist around and recover the face they have lost. Why did they lose the referendum? They lost it for two good reasons. First, the presentation of it to this House proved that the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Boland, in particular, did not give two damns about anybody. During the debate here he talked, and talked, and talked for hours on end. When anybody made a point he talked for another hour on that. But he objected to one of our members in the Seanad speaking for 20 minutes. He himself spoke for six hours and twenty-five minutes. Does anybody think the people were going to tolerate his antics when they saw that, if he represented Government thinking, it would be only a matter of time until all the members of the Government would be walking on the necks of the people even more than they are now, if they had all that authority, and the people decided to give them a good kick in the pants and they did?

Comment on this

We did not stab them in the back.

Comment on this

The Deputy's Party used to shoot them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There are two budding Parliamentary secretaries over there.

Comment on this

I have been a lot longer in politics than Deputy Molloy and I will give him a little advice. People in glasshouses should not throw stones. I will not read out a list of people who in sheer disgust resigned from the Fianna Fáil Party, and gave their reasons, over the past few weeks. I will not mention in this House the name of anyone who is not a Member of the House. I would suggest that the Deputy should do the same. I am sure that in years to come he will agree that that is right, and that we should leave people outside the House outside it.

Comment on this

They were not thrown out.

Comment on this

They did not wait to be thrown out. They walked out and gave their reasons. They said they did not agree with the cant and hypocrisy carried on by the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

Would the socialist from Meath tell us about Dr. Browne?

Comment on this

Dr. Browne is not a Member of this House. He was a member of Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's social philosophy?

Comment on this

I do not know if I am supposed to engage in a discussion with Deputy Andrews—a Deputy with his connections speaking about a social philosophy.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy's social philosophy? Am I embarrassing the Deputy?

Comment on this

A golden handshake of £8,000.

Comment on this

No one belonging to me ever got a handful of money for nothing.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Andrews please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

We heard a lot from the Minister for Local Government about the improvements which he said had been made in housing and in health. He and the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries who followed him talked about the improvements in conditions from 1956 to the present. That seems fair enough except that both of them seemed to have a blind spot. They seemed to forget the year 1932. If things were bad in 1956 after the Coalition went out of office, surely the Fianna Fáil Government who held office continuously except for one break of three years in the late 1940s, must carry the major share of the responsibility. We could go back to the time after they took over when no houses were built. No houses were built in 1957 when Fianna Fáil were in power, and when pressed they said that the housing problem had been solved.

Comment on this

They had all left.

Comment on this

I would not blame them for leaving in 1957 and 1958.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy will have to do a lot of interrupting before he is made a Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be a long time over there.

Comment on this

My time is running out and I want to go back to the question of newspaper publicity. Statements were made by various Members of the House as to what was said in the newspapers. This morning the Editor of the Irish Independent seems to think that Deputy Seán Dunne has a thin skin. I can only say that I think the Editor of the Irish Independent is a little thin-skinned himself. If it is fair game, and I believe it is, for any political correspondent to attack and criticise any Member of this House, no matter to which Party he belongs, and if his editor feels he is entitled to write a leading article on whether or not the political Parties are behaving in the right way, surely the Deputy is also entitled to give his version of what he thinks is right or wrong in that newspaper.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said: "Hear, hear" but I am sure the heart of the Editor of the Irish Independent would jump if he were here today and heard Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, defending him. He certainly made a spirited defence. There may be some people who are members of the Press Gallery who have got the idea that they know everything there is to know about politics. I remember an old man who did not belong to my Party saying that when you go into politics you are in a trade union and you are an apprentice until you leave. You are learning all the time. If someone who looks down on us from an exalted height presumes to be an expert without going through the mill he had better think again.

We all had the reasons trotted out as to why Fianna Fáil lost the referendum. I gave as the first reason the presentation of the referendum to this House by Deputy Boland. The second and main reason was that the proposals were outrageous and no one could hope to get away with them. I am amazed that the Government did, in fact, agree to adopt Deputy Boland's suggestion. When the matter went before the people of Ireland the people decided. The voters of Ireland decided.

Again, I should like to cross swords with the newspaper correspondents who said politicians had nothing to do with it and that the politicians of Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and the Labour Party all got their knuckles rapped. That line of reasoning is a bit hard to follow. There was a decision to be made. Fianna Fáil were in favour of it and Fine Gael and Labour were against it. We campaigned against a change and we won. How someone can blame us for that is a bit devious to follow. I am unable to untangle it. In the fight against the proposed change not only were the two Opposition Parties and various bodies outside the House against it, but quite strong support came from prominent Fianna Fáil supporters. If some Deputies who are members of the Fianna Fáil Party did not get up on a platform and say they did not want a change, they certainly did not get up and say they did want a change. When the election was over it was extraordinary—or, perhaps, it was not so extraordinary—to see the number of people who formerly supported Fianna Fáil who were prepared to say: "We won." Having considered the matter over the past few weeks, I am quite satisfied that a substantial number of those people will never again put a stroke in front of the name of a Fianna Fáil candidate. If Fianna Fáil want proof of that they can easily get it. All they have to do is ask the Taoiseach to dissolve the Dáil, and if he does we will have a decision pretty quickly.

It was suggested that originally this whole thing started at the committee on the Constitution. I want to repeat something which many people would like to deny but cannot deny. During the discussions by the committee when we came to the section dealing with election to Dáil Éireann which said that Members of Dáil Éireann would be elected by the system of proportional representation for multi-member constituencies Deputy Seán Lemass who had set up that committee when he was Taoiseach said: "There is no point in wasting our time discussing this, boys. It was decided by the people of Ireland less than nine years ago and no Government would be fool enough to put it before the people again." Yet here we had Fianna Fáil, his own Party, being fool enough to put it before the people again. I was very suspicious about the fact that this decision was taken to put it before the people again nine years after it had been rejected. There was a difference of 200,000 in the number of voters who rejected it this time. Deputy Boland today was not too happy about the position.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

The Minister for Local Government. I will give him his full title.

Comment on this

Do not give him his full title.

Comment on this

I will give him what he is called in this House. He was very shaky about the whole thing and was suggesting, if there was any excuse at all, another attempt might be made later. In the meantime he talked, as indeed Deputy Foley did, as if he knew a lot more than anybody else in the House, about the way the constituencies were going to be broken up. Nobody will forget the attempt at blackmail made by the Minister for Local Government when he threatened a number of Deputies, including me personally, about what would happen to my constituency and to their constituencies if they did not agree with his policy of changing the system. He told us we would never sit in the House again. He even got the secretary of the Fianna Fáil Party to write to the local papers making stupid suggestions that we were trying to get out of our constituencies and that the Minister was going to fix us up with "cushiony" constituencies. We are accusing him of being arrogant and making arrogant replies to Questions put in the House. After the referenda results they became sullen and kept their heads down and had not a word to throw to a cat. Today and yesterday they have their voices back again. We had the Minister for Local Government in the House again not content with shouting here but going outside the rail to shout back to Deputy Clinton and tell him what he would propose to do with certain things. These are the people who tell us they are a fair and reasonable Government and they would not do anything out of the way.

I would suggest if the Minister has any sense he will look at the answer he gave me on the slight changes which might have to be made to some constituencies in order to comply with the law. He will make those changes and leave the rest alone because when he goes before the electorate, whenever he is forced to do so, he will get an answer he will not forget. Somebody said he was going to leave politics if he did not win the referendum.

Comment on this

He was advised to emigrate.

Comment on this

He can leave politics no matter what way he gerrymanders the constituencies. He said he was going to put part of Meath, which is my constituency, with his constituency of County Dublin. If he does that he will remember it for a long time.

We had a lot of talk about coalitions. What about coalitions? We had talk about what would happen after the next election. They gave the impression that they had nothing to do with coalitions. The Labour Party put Fianna Fáil into power the first time, for their sins. For a number of years Fianna Fáil stayed in power with the assistance of what Deputy Dillon referred to as the "busted flush". They are now in power and they will be mainly depending on one pair until the next election. They have one pair they can depend on.

Comment on this

What about the diamonds and the bleeding hearts? There is not one of them left.

Comment on this

I think the papers were right when they said Deputies were nearly struck dumb when they heard the amount of money required for this Budget. Then, after saying that the country was in a terrible state, the Taoiseach came in a few days later, said it was a great country and told us to look at how well off we are.

It is only fair to put this on the record that, when the Minister for Finance introduced his Budget last Spring, those of us who spoke on it from this side of the House pointed out that without doubt the Budget was intended to put the country over the referendum after which another Budget would be introduced. There were hands raised in horror by the Fianna Fáil people. They would not do anything like that. The Budget was the housekeeping for the year. The Minister for Finance said unless it was extremely urgent there would be no further Budget. I suggest that what happened was that the Government decided to bring in a reasonably easy Budget and that then, when the referendum was finished, to have a further Budget. I would say to the Taoiseach—and it is something which will come up again—the amount of money he is attempting to get now on the increased taxes is not required and they are deliberately building up for a surplus next April or May to give another easy Budget before a general election.

This seems to be the system which Fianna Fáil have. This is their financial system and this is how they are going to run the country. In between all those Budgets we have Supplementary Estimates. It is fair to say until a few years ago every Government of this country budgeted for 12 months. Whether the amount of money required was produced or not produced, the next Budget corrected whatever happened. We then had a change where a second Budget was introduced. Now we have a system which has become common with Fianna Fáil of introducing Supplementary Budgets all over the place and the result is the Budget in the Spring gives no indication of what the situation will be at the end of the year.

I am a trade union official. It is my job to try to negotiate wages for my members. How can I or anybody else know what is going to happen if we negotiate wages on the taxes announced in the Spring and on the cost of living and find out in November everything we got for them is being taken back again? Does it not tempt them to say to me and to the other people like me "We are back where we started. We must get more money"? Are they not finishing up with their last position worst than their first? While this means we will have to go for more money almost immediately what about the minor employees of the State who got nothing at all, despite promises made by the Minister for Finance and his officials and by the Taoiseach in this House? Are they going to say "Keep it all until we negotiate a reasonable amount," or are they to be handed an increase which everybody else got last April? The State should be ashamed of itself for the way it is treating minor employees like labourers—the men who work shovels and machines and do the menial and hard work for the State. They get nothing.

It is bad enough for those able to negotiate for an increase. What about unfortunate people on social welfare benefits or on fixed incomes? They do not know, from year to year or from month to month, whether or not the money they have budgeted to carry on their housekeeping is going to be sufficient.

Comment on this

Lord Keynes will tell them what to do. That is all the advice they will get from the Government. He will tell them all about it.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach, acting as Minister for Finance, should have introduced along with the supplementary Budget a supplementary allowance for social welfare beneficiaries. I am sure he realises that the unfortunate people who are depending on the State for their existence and livelihood would require something. They were not considered. There was not a word about them. Some of them are getting a few shillings increase in January and they will have to wait until May to see what God will send them. I think the Government over the past number of years have been getting worse. We have heard talk during the referendum campaign and in this House about Taca and Tacateers. Is it not true that the ordinary rank and file Fianna Fáil supporter throughout the country is now realising that what he says no longer matters, if it ever did, and that the only people that matter are the people who are able to put money in large doses into the pockets of the Fianna Fáil exchequer so that they can run the expensive campaigns which have been run, particularly in the past couple of months. Mind you, if the Taoiseach is not aware of this, the members of his Party who are in touch with the grassroots of his organisation will remind him of it very shortly.

I would say that this system of the church-gate collection, whereby they give the impression that some poor devil, who is giving 2/6d to Fianna Fáil, which he cannot afford, is running the Party, is becoming known for what it is. A lot of them now realise that that is only a blind for the purpose of trying to keep them in association with the Party. The Taoiseach will find that there will be a lot fewer 2/6d. pieces and, what is more important to Fianna Fáil, a lot fewer votes the next time he faces the general public.

The whole question of the Vote of Confidence or the Vote of No Confidence in the Government should have been debated here for the past few days. I felt, when the Taoiseach started, that in the course of the debate we would hear a clear elucidation of Government policy by Ministers who knew the situation and who were trying to explain where they stood. What had we? We had Deputy Martin Corry coming in to tell us about agriculture. We had Deputy Desmond Foley coming in to tell us about what I do not know. I am not sure he even knew himself. We had Deputy Lionel Booth coming in to tell the Taoiseach that, whatever he did he should not be too hard on the motor industry. In the finish up, we had the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries protesting that we were taking away his time, that we did not allow him to take overtime which rightfully belonged to Deputy Patrick Tierney of the Labour Party. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries came in and succeeded in getting that time. He forgot that, earlier on, the Deputies I mentioned would have been only too delighted to step down and let the Minister make the speech in their place and tell the Dáil and the country about the actions of the Government and what the Government propose to do.

The whole situation here has been, I would suggest, bedevilled by the failure of the Fianna Fáil Party to keep in touch with the ordinary people of the country. I think Fianna Fáil themselves realise that they are out of touch. But, as I said earlier, they hope, by hanging on, that something will turn up which will succeed in getting them back into favour again. Personally, I cannot see it. They have only until the Spring of 1970. If they hold on until the last minute, they have to go at that time. If they had succeeded in winning the referenda, it is quite possible that they would have got away with something big, but they did not.

Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, is now trying to "have a go" at the constituencies. He said today, and he is bemoaning the fact, that he has to tear the constituencies as under: to do all the terrible things he has to do.

Comment on this

It will be no trouble to him.

Comment on this

It will be a lot of trouble to him before he finishes. He has requested that we pass his Bill before Christmas. He should go and have his head examined. The very idea is ridiculous that the people of this House, who take an interest in the passing of legislation, will let him bulldoze through here a Bill such as he suggests, in a couple of months, and allow him to "have a go" at the country and to attempt, with gerrymandered constituencies, to win back government of this country. He will very soon find that he is wrong.

I am sure the Taoiseach knows that I have the very highest respect for him as a person. However, I think it was rather ridiculous to hear the report of his complaint to Mr. Wilson, the British Premier, about gerrymandering in the North when his own Minister here was attempting to carry out almost the same gerrymandering, right under his nose, and he did not appear to know it. We cannot possibly ever hope to get anybody within this country to believe that the Government are serious about anything if we continue to do what Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, said he was going to do. If, for the simple purpose of trying to win one extra seat for Fianna Fáil, we try to take portions of counties and put them with other counties with which they have no connection at all and to say that this is the way it should be done then the Taoiseach is a lesser man than I had thought him to be

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Constitution requires it.

Comment on this

No. From the reply of the Minister for Local Government it is quite evident that it does not require it. He did not say he was doing it because it was required. He said he was doing it and would "get" at people—as if he had the right, as a member of the Government of this country, to "get" at anybody. He barely scraped into this House himself and now he has the audacity to talk in that fashion.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I suggest that the Taoiseach should ask the Minister for Local Government to read the judgment of the Chief Justice in relation to the Electoral Bill, 1961.

Comment on this

A letter was read out in this House by the Minister for Local Government which was written by Deputy O'Connell, a member of the Labour Party, to one of his constituents. It suggested that, as Rathmines was a considerable distance from the lady to whom the letter was written and as a number of people in the area found it inconvenient to travel to his residence, he was prepared to go along to meet them in the Town Hall. I wonder if the Taoiseach or any Member of this House considers there was anything irregular in a Deputy of the House sending that letter to his constituents on Dáil paper in an "Official Paid" envelope? The Minister for Local Government thought it was wrong.

Comment on this

He did not say. He said, in effect: "This is the sort of thing they are doing and want to do." Does that not bring us back to the suggestion made when the referendum was first being introduced, that it was not the job of a Deputy to look after the day-to-day matters affecting constituencies?

Comment on this

Some Ministers call cumann meetings in their own offices.

Comment on this

The same Minister who made this comment must be aware that Deputies, including Deputies of his own Party—I am not objecting to it—have advertisements in local papers all over the country saying that they will be at a certain place at a certain time on a certain day to meet constituents.

Comment on this

More power to them.

Comment on this

I send notices to people all over the country saying that I will meet them at a certain time in a certain place and inviting them to come along: I do not apologise for so doing. Just because, a few nights ago, Deputy O'Connell stated, when speaking here, that he did not hear the Minister for Local Government withdraw an unparliamentary remark which he made and because Deputy Boland, the Minister for Local Government, threatened to strike Deputy O'Connell over it, the Minister has carried it on into this House today and has tried to discredit Deputy O'Connell by producing this stupid letter——

Comment on this

He is a bad-tempered fellow, let us face it.

Comment on this

It was a very sensible letter but it was stupid of the Minister to produce it.

Comment on this

It was stupid as far as the Minister for Local Government is concerned.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

There was absolutely no reason at all why it should be produced except that, in his warped mind, Deputy Boland felt he was "getting at" Deputy O'Connell. My time, today, is nearly up but, before I conclude, I want to put two questions to the Taoiseach to which I hope he will reply when he is closing the debate. When the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement was made some years ago, this Party objected to it for a number of reasons. I do not propose to go into them now. The then Taoiseach, the then Minister for Finance and the then Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries guaranteed to this House, as did the Government, that, in its first year of operation, the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement would give an extra £10 million to our agricultural industry. Now, when the Taoiseach is concluding this debate, would he say if that £10 million has been made or, if it has not been made, how far short of it have we fallen? Finally, would the Taoiseach, when he is concluding this debate, tell the House and the country when he proposes to move the writ for the Wexford by-election so that we can test whether the people of Wexford —a cross-section of the people of this country—have as much confidence in himself and his Party as he would seem to have in asking this House to give him this evening a vote of confidence.

Comment on this

At the outset of the recent referendum campaign we indicated that, at the conclusion of the vote, if the people rejected what we regarded as the audacious proposal of the Government, we would table a motion of no confidence in the Government here in this House. Accordingly, on 17th October the Fine Gael motion of no confidence was tabled; on 30th October the Labour Party tabled their motion; and on 1st November the Government motion was tabled. In other words, for a fortnight this Government, in disarray, was trying to puzzle out how best to face up to the Dáil in the aftermath of one of the most crushing defeats that any Government has ever received in a Parliamentary democracy.

This debate takes place at the end of the fourth year of this Dáil. It takes place at a time when an election is almost on the cards. It is worth recalling to Deputies how this House was elected in the last general election. Deputies will remember that election held in March, 1965, an election which the present Fianna Fáil Party fought on certain specific lines of propaganda.

First of all, they said to the people that they were the only political Party capable of forming a government in this country, and their propaganda was along these lines: "Well, you might not like us. You might have things against us, but we are indispensable." That line of propaganda, no doubt, carried some weight with people who were led to believe that the attainment of an overall majority in this House gave added wisdom to Government Ministers and sense to a policy that otherwise might lack it.

Their second line of propaganda was that they could guarantee that their re-election to office would mean for the ordinary people a continuance of success and prosperity. If Deputies have forgotten, I should like to remind them of the Fianna Fáil posters in the general election of four years ago: "Stay with success": "Back prosperity". These posters were designed to get people to believe that success and material advancement for the worker, for the farmer, for the businessman, was in some way associated with the re-election to office of a Fianna Fáil Government.

Their third line of propaganda—let us not forget it; Fianna Fáil Deputies may wish to forget it—was that their Leader, Deputy Seán Lemass, was essential to the future prosperity of the country, to its better Government, and to its survival as a nation. And need I remind Deputies of the poster: "Let Lemass lead on?"

This was the way in which the last general election was fought: a political party, a lot of puny little men gathering themselves around a man whom they had described in heroic terms, a man who, they suggested, had gifts of leadership, a wealth of imagination and a dynamic approach which was going to guarantee a flow of prosperity and money and the welfare of the ordinary people. The result was that they got into office. They did not get an overall majority but they got enough to get them back into Government, and so this Dáil came into being. What happened? Lest it be forgotten, let it be stated now in the dying weeks of this Dáil that the people who voted for Fianna Fáil in the last election, who sent them back over there, and who waited patiently for a continuance of the success and of the prosperity they were promised, found very quickly that there was no prosperity, that there was no success, that, in fact, the election had been held in circumstances of heady, frothy inflation, that the prosperity was phoney, that the success was synthetic.

They found very quickly that a confidence trick had been played upon them and that this heroic leader, this man who asserted to himself an indispensability to the welfare of this country, had called that election when he saw the black clouds of the economic difficulties beginning to gather. He got the people to vote while the sun was shining, knowing well that very shortly the black clouds were going to wipe out the sun, and that the position was that he had been leading this country on a drunken binge and sooner or later, not he, but the ordinary poor people of the country would have to pay the bill.

The prosperity disappeared. The success was not there, and the bills of the inflation had to be paid. The Taoiseach was then Minister for Finance and he had to come in here, as was his duty as Minister for Finance, with a large bill, the costs of this dissipation of the previous two years, a bill which had to be paid by the ordinary working people. It was paid for in growing unemployment. It was paid for in long queues at the labour exchanges. It was paid for by every young boy and girl who had to swell the groups getting on the boats and the ships to emigrate and to work elsewhere. It was paid for by every shopkeeper and businessman who found his little shop or his little business dampened down by the new financial strictures introduced by the Government. It was paid for by thousands and thousands of small people, by pensioners and people of limited incomes who were told they must bear the burden of a new period of deflation.

Following that, this Government, that had scrambled into office by this huge confidence trick, was trying to clear up the economic mess they had created. They turned their backs on the great social problems of our time, on the need in our community for a reform in our social services, for a new approach to our health problems. They turned their backs on these and on the great need for housing and on many of the endemic social problems affecting our people. These had to be abandoned and at the end of it all, the heroic figure, the man who asserted he was indispensable to the future of the country, the man whose dynamism was to solve all the problems of our time, the man who had the effrontery to ask the Irish people to let him lead on, left and instead of a hero there was a mouse. In his place what happened?

The present Leader of Fianna Fáil came into office and he said himself, when he was elected, that he was a via media, that is, the chairman of a meeting where your only duty is to keep the house. That is the via media, and during the past two years the country has been led by Deputy Lynch, as Taoiseach, in place of Deputy Seán Lemass. Where are we two years later?

He is controlling a team that have the bits in their teeth and he is desperately trying to hold the reins of runaway horses. He has a number of men on that team who should shame any decent leader of any decent government. What is he doing about them? The people told him quite definitely and clearly to get rid of Deputy Blaney and Deputy Boland. Is he doing it, or are we to have a continuance of this kind of Government with little pocket dictators running around as if in some way they were masters of the Irish people? In this vote by the Irish people on the 16th October, a clear demand was made that if this Government are to seek to continue in office they should be altered drastically from top to bottom—that new men should be introduced if Fianna Fáil are to remain in office for the expiration of their term.

Is the Taoiseach strong enough to do it? Certainly if he is not the people will get another Taoiseach and another Government as quickly as possible. During two wasted, miserable years the people have had to worry through 1966 and the best part of 1967 paying for the bills of the incompetence of Deputy Lemass's regime, paying for the profligate spending, the dissipation of the resources of this country, in 1964 and the early part of 1965. They had to pay for it in unemployment, in want and in hardship, and it was only this year that people felt we were at last beginning to get back to some kind of reasonable circumstances in which employment, one might hope, might expand, in which housing, one might hope, would get attention, in which emigration might begin to curtail itself and in which the country might advance again.

But what happened? In April of this year the Minister for Finance on behalf of the Government introduced his Budget—a Budget which it now transpires was a phoney exercise in political playacting.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Government that permitted that to be done, that paraded under false pretences in April merely because they were having a test on the referendum and merely because they were hoping to gain an election victory from that vote confronted the country with a Budget containing no provisions for an increase in the remuneration of the public service that was already taking place at the time. It contained no provision for payment in respect of the wheat harvest though everyone knew more and more wheat was being sown in this particular year and everyone knew we were likely to have a considerable harvest of wheat.

It contained no provision in relation to the considerable expansion in milk production that was taking place and which everybody knew was taking place. The result was that the Budget this year—the Minister for Finance must have known it and every Member of the Government must have known it—was a Budget that was deliberately designed to raise at least £15 million less than the required amount.

So we now have had this autumn Budget. One can understand that at any stage in the best regulated governments a completely unexpected contingency may arise which could not have been foreseen but there was not one Member of this Government who could not have foreseen the extra cost in the public service, the need for a wheat subsidy and the added subsidy requirements in relation to milk.

This autumn Budget is not some slight modification or some slight adjustment in the country's finances. It is a Budget that imposes taxation— Deputies should remember this—which is between three and four times the amount of the taxation imposed in the Budget of April. Did anyone ever see such a bizarre situation?

Comment on this

Common fraud.

Comment on this

This mini-Budget, this autumn Budget, imposes taxation three or four times that exacted in the Budget of April. It is not unreasonable to suggest that one can suspect the April Budget was designed to achieve a political advantage for the Government. It was introduced by a government that are supposed to be responsible, with their tongues in their cheeks. It was introduced in the knowledge that it was telling a false story, introduced in the hope that it would snatch a false victory. I do not believe that kind of exercise in political expediency will achieve any advantage in the long run. I want to go further and here and now give voice to another suspicion. I want to assert that this Budget is designed to raise in taxation more money than is required in relation to known and contemplated commitments in the next 12 months.

Comment on this

A general election in April.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said that existing commitments in the Budget are likely to be about £27 million. He is raising now in these taxes, carried over 12 months, an extra £15½ million. Buoyancy in existing taxation is certainly running at the rate of £20 million and a simple addition of £20 million and £15½ gives £35½ million to pay debts that do not exceed £27 million. If it transpires that this is another bit of political action, another exercise in political expediency, merely to provide circumstances for an apparently good Budget next year— which, in fact, would be another phoney Budget—then I have no doubt the people will react in a very significant way.

The fact is that by reason of what has been done after two years of Lynch leadership, we are back where we were in 1965. We are back at the beginning of another cycle of stop-go economics.

After the deflation of 1965 and the consequences of it, when the economy is beginning to move forward again, there is the sign "stop". This time it is "stop" with an imposition of taxation which is very severe indeed, taxation which can only have the effect of substantially increasing living costs and industrial costs, which can only have the effect of damping down economic and business activity, leading to a very grave and widespread recession in trade. Why has it been done? I do not believe the fiscal situation should have required it. If it did, it could have been met some months ago without the consequences now entailed. I do not believe the balance of payments situation requires the doing of what has been done.

The Taoiseach said on Tuesday that there was a need to absorb excess purchasing power. That may be so. You do not do it by regressive taxation because regressive taxation leads inevitably to a damping down of industrial, business and economic activity. It leads to a spiral of living costs and it leads inevitably to a costing of our exports out of markets.

Why did the Taoiseach, if that is the problem, not endeavour to use a monetary policy? Why did he not exercise some restraint in credit? It could be done temporarily. It could be done easily and it could be done without harming the lives and the fortunes of small people. He has not done that. He has decided not to do it. Instead, he has decided to proceed with a volume of taxation which, in my view, will turn out to be excessive and wrong.

What is the cause of the economic difficulties I have mentioned? Number one, because we have an incompetent government in office, a government that has failed to control even their own expenditure. Are Deputies aware that current government expenditure in the first six months of this financial year is 18 per cent higher than the year before and that the Government themselves are spending now three-and-a-half times the growth in real national output. That is one cause for the present economic difficulties.

The second one is that this Government have failed consistently to do anything whatsoever about the achievement of an incomes policy. An incomes policy is part of the Fine Gael Policy Towards a Just Society. It was raised and has been the subject of debate in this House 12 or 18 months ago. There is not one who does not recognise the difficulties towards its attainment. It can be a very difficult and uphill task and one that calls for a great measure of understanding among all sections in our community, not merely those who work and are employed and earning wages but among management and everybody associated with every facet of industry and economic activity.

Though an incomes policy is the only means by which a small country like ours can continue to be a viable unit in a highly competitive world, if we do not keep our costings real and significant, if we cannot plan our industrial activity and our drive in the export markets without getting into a situation that planning when it reaches its production stage is destroyed by rising costs, then we cannot survive. An incomes policy is essential towards that end. It is difficult and it is a formidable undertaking. This Government have done nothing whatsoever in the last few years to achieve such a policy, nothing at all. They have allowed a situation to develop in which bodies which are, or should be, under their control in fact are the very first to rock the boat and cause economic difficulties.

I think the third reason for our present difficulties has been again the dereliction by Government Ministers of their responsibilities in the last 12 months in relation to the use of credit. I would have thought that anyone who had to live through the inflationary outburst of 1964 and early 1965, when people were able to go into their bank manager and, wishing to speculate on the stock exchange, were able to get an advance for the purpose of speculation, a situation in which the available national credit of this country was dissipated widespread on purposes and on objectives which certainly were not going to help the country, should have understood.

Everyone should have been aware of that and the Taoiseach in particular should have been so aware because he was a member of the Government, and certainly as Minister for Finance he should have tried to rectify the situation which developed. Here we are now 12 months or two years later and precisely the same situation has been allowed to recur. Domestic credit in the past 12 months has expanded by 21 per cent, and again this credit is being used and devoted to purposes which are speculative in nature and which are not productive in their objectives. That means that we have now a Government in office that apparently lacks, collectively or individually, ability. That is a human failing but a government which has failed to learn by experience and a government which as a result has allowed a similar situation to repeat itself is incompetent.

This is not only incompetence but it is highly dangerous to the future welfare of this country. I have little doubt that there would be a sigh of relief from Cork to Donegal, from the east across to the western coast of this country, if the Taoiseach stood up and said: "I am going to resign." The people would be delighted, not in a vengeful way, because our people are not vengeful or spiteful, but because they see today that we have a government that are just not fit for the job, and the time has come to change that government and to get into office a team that can measure up to what is required.

May I repeat—not fit for the job.

During the referendum campaign—and I want Fianna Fáil Deputies to listen to this—the Minister for Finance in advocating a Fianna Fáil proposal said that there would have to be a change, that this Dáil was no more than a debating society, that the Deputies in it were not fit for the purpose of legislating and that the time had come to get better Deputies. Well, I know the Deputies he knew best, and they certainly are not on this side of the House. He went on to say that in this Dáil it was impossible under our system of proportional representation to introduce the great schemes of social reform which are so urgently necessary. I would like to ask the Taoiseach: is that the explanation we are going to be offered for the failure of this Government to do anything worthwhile in relation to the solution of the social problems of our people. If they cannot do it in this Dáil, elected as it is, if that is their feeling, let them make way for those who will do it and do it very quickly.

Now we have, as a result of the madness of the Government, come to the end of a wasted year. Here, in the eleventh month of 1968, we in this House end a year which began with a barren, fruitless controversy with regard to our voting system and for the last ten months members of this Government instead of doing their jobs, instead of doing the things that the people expected them to do, instead of devoting their time and energy towards solving some of the problems of our people, spent all their time conniving and manoeuvring among their own backbenchers and elsewhere, collecting money and spending it in order to rig the electoral system and to abolish proportional representation.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Social welfare schemes? Not at all. Housing did not matter. Balance of payments could go and take a run for itself. Nothing mattered as long as they could achieve their purpose, and that was to abolish proportional representation. It has been a wasted year. It has demonstrated, however, that with the vast expenditure of money Fianna Fáil indulged in —I do not know what it is going to cost them, I am told something of the order of £100,000, a vast expenditure of money in any event, in all forms of propaganda and all the rest of it——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

£100,000 is the official estimate of the cost of the holding of the referendum. It was nothing like that.

Comment on this

What it has demonstrated is that the men and the Party responsible for it were mad, and there was not a child of six going the streets of Dublin who would not have told them that they were mad.

Comment on this

Stone mad.

Comment on this

Stone, stark, raving mad. Everybody knew that those proposals would not be accepted, except Fianna Fáil and the Fianna Fáil Ministers. They were so smug, so far removed from the people, so much above even their own backroom Deputies, so possessed of instant knowledge and immediate wisdom on everything, they knew all the answers. People now know the score. A government that could be so utterly irresponsible in relation to their own political affairs, how can we long continue to trust them as being responsible for the affairs of all of us?

I appreciate that that has been the result of a breakdown in communications between Ministers and those who put them there, but it is symptomatic of what is happening in this country today. There is a breakdown of communications between authority and the people. It happens in every walk of life, in every facet of activity. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is not in communication with the farmers, with the agricultural industry. That can be repeated in relation to every Minister's office. It is the result of Ministers being in office too long. Deputy Dillon would perhaps sympathise with this point of view.

I have served as a Minister and I know what takes place from half-past nine or ten o'clock in the morning until five o'clock in the evening. I know how many sycophants come in and say: "Oh, Minister you are so right; Oh, Minister, what you say is so wise; Oh, Minister, you put this in such an original way." You might not believe it for the first week or the first month but, after six months or 12 months, you begin to think that perhaps you are something special and significant and unique; and if you are there, not for 12 months or two years or three years or five years or seven years but for 11 years well, of course, is it any wonder that they are all stark, raving mad, thinking that they know everything and not bothering about listening to anybody else?

We, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, on this side of the House, the Deputies sitting on your right, now have to face up to our responsibilities. I want to say with humility and sincerity that I believe much more is now required of us than ever before. We have a responsibility clearly thrust upon us now to develop our policies, to seek for solutions, to project attention towards public service, to give to this country as quickly as possible the kind of alternative Government that it demands and wishes—a government that will be a government of integrity; a government that will apply consistently high standards in high places.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

A government that will never have its honour be-smirched by rumours, by suggestions, by implications; a government that will be steadfast in its aims, that will apply, irrespective of whether it has an overall majority in this House or not, a policy which it regards as proper and right; a government that will proceed ahead in the discharge of the great responsibility we all have of providing decent Government for the ordinary people in this country.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The debate inevitably ranged over a fairly wide number of topics, including the recent Budget. In fact, I was hoping that it would be possible to have both debates together but, in deference to the request of the Opposition, they have been separated. Nevertheless, both the confidence motion and the Budget debate seem to have been part and parcel of this debate since last Tuesday afternoon.

The case put forward by Deputy Cosgrave, Deputy Corish and their colleagues who have spoken in this debate rests entirely on the proposition that the results of the referendum show that the Government have lost the confidence of the people. They have not attempted in any way to challenge the policies of the Government on any serious ground because they know they cannot, because they know that they have not been able themselves to put a single line of policy in any field as an alternative to the policy of the Government. Much of Deputy Cosgrave's contribution in the opening part of his speech was most uncharacteristic of him and of the reasonably serious kind of approach he normally brings to bear on the debates in this national Parliament. I think the people of the country generally and the Dáil are entitled to expect more from the Leader of the Opposition than the kind of ridicule to which he resorted here last Tuesday. The technique that Deputy Cosgrave employed was mainly an attempt to ridicule the Minister for External Affairs. The Minister for External Affairs needs no defence from me or from anybody else. His record as a soldier and as a statesman can proudly stand on its own. Nobody in Fine Gael or anywhere else can take the credit from him which is rightly his and which he has won for his outstanding work in the field of foreign affairs and particularly for his work in the United Nations. Even though that has been scorned by Fine Gael and the Labour Party it has been publically acclaimed and recognised all over the world. If it is Deputy Cosgrave's opinion that the signing of the Non-Proliferation Treaty, in the formulation of which Deputy Frank Aiken played a very outstanding part, was a trivial and wasteful exercise he will find, I think, that this opinion is not shared by any statesman of any standing in any part of the world.

Before I leave this field I want to refer to statements which were made here and outside about my visit to London last week. I want to ask, some Members of the Labour Party particularly—they are not here now; Deputy O'Leary and Deputy Corish— if they believe or advocate that in the context of what I had to say in London last week I should not have mentioned Partition? If I had not mentioned Partition and had come back here answering Parliamentary questions and said I had not done so, I should like to know what would be the attitude of those who now criticise me for having done so.

Comment on this

Nobody from the Labour Party criticised the Taoiseach on that ground.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Michael O'Leary did.

Comment on this

Not for mentioning Partition.

Comment on this

In the line of not doing something about it. That would be more appropriate.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I shall not dwell on it but I want to say that in the contacts that my predecessor and I had with Captain O'Neill in the last three or four years there was never any suggestion or understanding that we, on our part, would abandon in any way our aim of a united Ireland. It has been the aim of this Government, and of its predecessors, to promote the re-unification of our country by promoting and fostering a spirit of brotherhood, mutal understanding and goodwill among all sections of the Irish people. I have not discussed, nor should I have done so, the details of the conversations I had with Mr. Wilson but I do not think he would regard it as any breach of confidence if I say that I expressed to him my conviction that Captain O'Neill was a reasonable and fairminded man. I know Mr. Wilson will not object because I know Mr. Wilson agrees with me. In fact, I said many months ago and again at the press interview in London last Monday, after meeting Mr. Wilson, that I thought Captain O'Neill was a fair and reasonable man. That being so, I am convinced that he is anxious to ensure that all people within his jurisdiction will get a fair deal. Therefore, I believe the spirit of brotherhood to which I have referred can eventually prevail not only in the northern part of the country but throughout the whole country and that this could lead to a new approach to the solution of the main political problem.

Mr. McAteer in the course of his speech yesterday—and I believe in a radio interview today he expanded on it even though I did not hear him— referred to the possibility of this new approach and particularly to the possibility of separate Parliaments, North and South, in a united Ireland. This is an aim to which I think we would very gladly subscribe but, nevertheless, it is not a completely new proposition. As most Deputies know, it was mentioned in the course of the Treaty negotiations or rather, it was put forward on behalf of Dáil-Éireann prior to the Treaty negotiations of 1921 and repeated on many occasions since. It was in these terms: that, subject to safeguards, the confirmation of the position of the Northern Ireland Legislature with its existing powers in an All-Ireland constitution for as long as the people of the north eastern counties might desire it, was something that we, in this part of the country, would accept.

I introduce this only because I want to indicate that much loose talk and loose expressions have been used about what I said or did in London last week. Before I go to the main part of the debate I should like to refer to some aspects of the debate that, I suggest, were more appropriate to the debate we shall have next week on the Budget but, lest the absence of reference by me might be taken as acquiescence in the points of view put forward, it is only right that I should refer to them.

Deputy Cosgrave said here last Tuesday that the Government while attempting to control prices was itself raising prices through new taxes and post office charges and that there was no control of the Government's costs. Deputy O'Higgins repeated that charge here today. I am sure both Deputies must know why the cost of Government is rising. They must know that it is due to improvements in social welfare and education, improvements in the subsidies required to raise farmers' incomes and to the effect on the Government as an employer and because of the pay increases that have been generally secured this year. The Deputies opposite did not consider it politic to say that these improvements in social welfare or education should not have taken place or that farmers' incomes should not have been supported, as has been done, or that wage and salary increases generally should be controlled and limited to a lower percentage increase. Perhaps that is sufficient to say about this line of argument.

Deputy Corish went on to refer to our external reserves. I referred to the matter briefly in my reply to the first part of the Budget debate. The Deputy referred to these external reserves and generally he appeared to think that all these reserves were invested in Britain. That is not the case.

Comment on this

I said in Britain and other places.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The fact is that about 50 per cent are invested in non-sterling reserves. The Deputy said that these reserves should be invested so as to employ Irish workers at home. Let us examine that proposition and what its ultimate effects might be. He asked the Government to decide whether it wants to maintain employment or not. As between maintaining employment and maintaining these reserves the difference is not as sharp as he seems to suggest. There is no intention on the Government's part deliberately to create unemployment. On the contrary, the aims of the present policy are to preserve a national growth rate of over four per cent per annum, as is happening now, and, in this way, to continue and insure and safeguard the rise in industrial employment. Any serious loss of external reserves would react drastically on investment, on production and on employment.

As I have said, I thought the Deputy might be genuinely in doubt about what level of external reserves it is desirable and necessary to maintain. However, I do not think he should be in any doubt about the absolute necessity to maintain a substantial amount of reserves. We should have enough foreign money to draw on to meet large and unforeseen deficits in external payments and these can arise sometimes through circumstances outside our control and, of course, sometimes within our control.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach be able to say what is "substantial"?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

"Substantial" is about the level we now have—something between £275 and £300 million.

Comment on this

How is that figure arrived at?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It represents roughly about eight or nine months purchasing of supplies.

Comment on this

Goods and raw materials?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Yes, that is so.

Comment on this

That is the first time we were told that in this House.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

These reserves are also required to meet unforeseen deficits of our own country. I do not think the Deputy can be in any doubt that if we were to run down our external reserves to boost employment the stimulus that this would give would be very temporary indeed. If our reserves were seen to be dropping by £20 million or £30 million a year and the Government took no action, not only Irish investors but foreign investors would soon cease to invest in our country or cease to create the extra stimulus to employment that this kind of investment gives. If a crisis in these circumstances occurred the question would be asked as to why the Government had not taken action at the right time. Certainly, that would not solve the kind of problem which arises here now.

Comment on this

It would create the kind of crisis to which I have referred.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I cannot continue this reply on the basis of question and answer. However, because of the lack of confidence that such a policy would create, not only would our capital inflow dry up, and that is important, but I think it has been indicated in past years that there would be a steady decline in the kind of money that we would require to maintain employment and production in the future. During the years we have had reductions in our external reserves and I need only mention the years and the amounts to give an indication of the trend: 1951, £61.6 million; 1955, £35.5 million; 1964, £31.4 million; 1965, £41.8 million.

I am sure the Deputy will remember the trouble in his own time as a Minister when these reserves began to be run down and when the balance of payments were going awry and the consequences that followed. As I said, our situation would become all the worse because the capital inflow which now protects these reserves would dry up and what I am saying, in effect, is that the reserves would not only have an important financial impact on our economy but a psychological impact as well.

By maintaining these at a reasonably high level we are encouraging confidence in our country and this, in itself, encourages the flow of funds from home and abroad and investment in Ireland will, therefore, create higher employment, a higher standard of living and an improvement in the economy generally. These reserves also provide us with a fund to be drawn on when unforeseen crisis arise in our external trade.

Deputy Corish's arguments have appeared in one form or another in newspaper comments and in leading articles, some by economists. We are being accused of putting the brake on too severely when we should have accelerated. I think, that spending one's way out of a depression is certainly an acceptable type of remedy but no one can regard the kind of advice to spend one's way out of inflation as being a responsible type of advice. It is easy for those who are not in positions of responsibility to adopt courageous attitudes and to suggest that we should throw caution to the wind but the very same economists or, at least, the vocal groups who adopt such attitudes, would be happy in their criticism of the Government if a continuation of the present trend resulted in a crisis in 1969. They would lacerate the Government for not recognising the signs when they first appeared and for not taking moderate action to prevent a calamity. The Government would be accused of doing too much too late. We have heard all these arguments before.

As to whether we are doing too much now it is our belief that we are not. We do not anticipate that the measures will cause any economic setback or depression. We expect growth in the economy to be at least four per cent in 1969. I think that is a reasonably good average and I believe we are far from the kind of disastrous stagnation to which Deputy T.F. O'Higgins has referred when one compares it, in particular, with the kind of stagnation that his government permitted in this country ten or 11 years ago.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Can the Taoiseach say whether the same will apply to employment?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I expect it will. A few minutes ago Deputy T.F. O'Higgins said that we were trying to create a surplus Budget situation. I am surprised that he should make the unwise comment that we provided for certain increases in expenditure by way of this new taxation so as to avoid taxation in any coming Budget and he used figures, which I only used by way of illustration, to bolster up his case. He said that the amount I foresaw in extra expenditure in 1969 was about £27 million and that this would be covered by the increases we are getting with the new taxation. The fact is, that the £27 million I referred to was only used by way of illustration. In fact, the increased expenditure which we are likely to face this year is much greater than the £27 million he referred to.

He also said—and I think this is again something that he had heard other people saying—that we should have anticipated these increases and, therefore, should have provided for them in the Budget of last Spring. I might say in reference to that that the principal internal development which has necessitated corrective action is, in fact, the size of the 11th round wage increase. The suggestion is that we should have anticipated this. The 11th round wage increase had not started, or, at least, had not started to give an indication of what size it would be, when the Budget was introduced.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I said it had not started to the extent as to give an indication of the size and I want to say that it is usually the case that outside employment leads. While the Government make their own arrangements with their employees, whether the Civil Service, the Post Office or the Garda, they do not usually precede the rates won in free negotiation in outside employment, and if we had provided for a particular round sum in anticipation of its becoming due and of agreements having been reached, it would have been regarded as quite irresponsible to make budgetary provisions for increases on the scale eventually conceded.

Comment on this

The Louth County Council did it for their road workers and you could not do it for the Budget. We included the amount of the increases.

Comment on this

You are a bigger dope than you look.

Comment on this

The Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach could not do it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Taoiseach, without interruption.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Of course, since Deputy Donegan became Chairman of Louth County Council the sky has lifted up there, things are moving so fast.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We have been blamed for not providing money in April to cover the cost of the milk subsidy and the cost of disposing of our surplus wheat production. Almost every Deputy in the Front Bench of Fine Gael who spoke suggested that we should have been virtual weathercocks, that as far back as April we should have known exactly what kind of summer and autumn we were going to have this year. If the Minister for Finance had come in here last Spring and had said on Budget day that he had imposed additional taxation that would be required because we were going to have a wonderful Summer and a wonderful Autumn that would boost milk production and wheat yields, I can imagine the kind of comment and criticism that would have come from the Deputies opposite. They would have asked how the Minister could know in April what kind of Summer and what kind of Autumn we were going to have; how would he know in what way this would boost milk and wheat production. This, in itself, is dishonest criticism and the Deputies who have made it know it is dishonest. Having said that—I will be dealing more and perhaps at greater length with these economic considerations next week—perhaps, now, I will come to the motion of confidence and the kind of arguments that we have heard, arguments that were bolstered up in order to try to establish that the referendum result meant that the Government should leave office.

In the first place, Deputy Tully has threatened that the kind of legislation that is necessary before a general election can take place will not be given readily to the Minister for Local Government. It is the bounden duty of the Minister for Local Government now, under the Constitution as it stands, after the rejection of the referendum proposal for a commission in amendment No. 4, to bring into the House these proposals for a change in the constituencies.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We will deal with that in due time. Give us the legislation and then the way will be clear for a general election.

Comment on this

It is not necessary under the law. You do not need to do it until 1973 and you know that.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We can argue that in due time.

Comment on this

The Supreme Court have already said so.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

To come back to the arguments, it is very odd that Deputy Cosgrave should find some consolation in, and claim as a victory, the rejection of the proposals for the constitutional reforms that he himself advocated and supported. Deputy Cosgrave is a good racing man and knows the value of an each-way bet. On this occasion he had an each-way bet.

Comment on this

And I backed the winner.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Depending on which way you look at it. He was on an each-way winner and an each-way loser. In the first instance, he was on an each-way loser, I suggest, because the kind of reform that he had advocated has been rejected and his Party has been seen now amongst those who talk about leadership to have refuted the kind of leadership that he tried to show them when the debates on these referendum proposals were going on in his own councils.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies on either side of the House will allow the Taoiseach to make his speech.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am suggesting that the each-way bet was on a loser as far as Deputy Cosgrave himself is concerned.

Comment on this
Seán Collins Mr. S. Collins Fine Gael

You were on a landslide in the referendum.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Cosgrave knows well that the case he has been making and that Deputy Corish and others have been making in support of this no confidence motion could not be made on the basis of the referendum result. Deputy Cosgrave then, having abandoned that, quickly resorted to the old, hoary Fine Gael charges of intolerance, arrogance——

Comment on this

And corruption.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——And corruption. Deputy Cosgrave said here last Tuesday that there should be a standard of integrity recognised and accepted by all, irrespective of whether they are members of the Government or Opposition. This is a suggestion that all reasonable Deputies on both sides of the House will accept. But, then he went on to say that there were certain rumours of corruption, there were certain rumours of things not being right but he was not in a position accurately to assess the accuracy of these rumours because he had no proof of them.

Comment on this

One of your own Ministers said it.

Comment on this

Excuse me, Taoiseach. I substantiated my charges against the Coalition. I substantiated them. You did not.

Comment on this

That is rubbish.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

By deliberately peddling these rumours in this House, by mentioning these rumours and suspicions in the House, Deputy Cosgrave deliberately went out of his way to again start this kind of smear campaign that we have seen, that we have met and weathered, on the eve of almost every general election in the past 20 years.

Comment on this

Tell us about Taca and the Ryans.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It was inevitable, of course, that these rumours, which as Deputy Cosgrave said, in Christian charity he could not very well support, should be taken up by no less a person than Deputy Oliver Flanagan. Deputy Oliver Flanagan said on television or in the press some time ago that when he goes around his constituency he calls into the nuns and asks them or the children to say a prayer for him. I had thought and hoped—in fact most of us on this side of the House had thought and hoped—that the nuns' prayers were being answered, because Deputy Flanagan has not been seen here very much in recent years and, when he has been, he has not resorted to these charges of corruption. However, he came out in full blast on last Tuesday night and alleged not only corruption and dishonesty against some members of our Party but against every one of us who were all tarred with the same brush. I am glad to be tarred with the same kind of brush or covered with the same kind of aroma as members of the Government and our Backbenchers because it is only on the basis of the integrity of this Party, on the basis of being honest with the people and only on that basis, that we have been able to resist these charges of corruption down through the years and we shall do it again.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I said during several of the by-elections that we won, when Deputies opposite raised these charges of corruption, that we were sick and tired of hearing them and I told them to either put up or shut up and I repeat if they have evidence let them produce it here.

Comment on this

What about the Kelly case?

Comment on this

The evidence was produced.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange had the opportunity of producing that evidence in the only legal way it could be produced and he ran away from it.

Comment on this

I certainly did not. It is on the files of the court and the Government refused to do their duty. They are guilty of corruption in that regard.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies please cease interrupting?

Comment on this

The evidence is there and you failed to follow it up.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

What the Deputy calls "evidence" is in the form of a pleading in defence to a statement of claim. That is not evidence. Deputy L'Estrange was asked to supply it to an officer of the Garda Síochána and he funked it.

Comment on this

I told him to read the Dáil Debates, that it was all there in black and white. The Government funked their duty. It is there in black and white.

Comment on this
Deputies

Chair.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

That is what I mean by putting up or shutting up. Now let me deal with the argument——

Comment on this

There is no justice or law and order in the country.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to repudiate emphatically that the referendum results——

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I take it that this is the kind of injury time to which I referred earlier. I would like somebody to time Deputy L'Estrange's interruptions.

Comment on this

And time Deputy Allen's too.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I challenged the Deputy, let him take it up if he wants to. I want to repudiate emphatically this charge that the Government have lost the confidence of the people. I am quite confident about this. The referendum proposals were put forward in the most democratic way possible. The referendum is the most democratic of democratic processes and we asked the people to consider our proposals in relation to Constitutional reforms affecting the method of election. Being a Constitutional matter, we said it was a national issue and the Parties opposite——

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

——regarded it as such. Indeed, leading members of the Labour Party inside and outside the House said that this was not a plebiscite for or against Fianna Fáil. We asked the people in this democratic way whether they wanted to say "yes" or "no".

Comment on this

What did you spend the £100,000 on?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Deputy comes in to interrupt but he was not here when I took that matter up with Deputy O'Higgins. That was the official estimate of the costs of the referendum. It has nothing to do with what Fianna Fáil spent.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies on either side allow the Taoiseach to make his contribution so that the debate may proceed?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

As I said throughout the campaign we asked the people to consider this as a Constitutional matter and at least in this regard the people took our advice. Many thousands of people voted outside the traditional Party lines and Deputies opposite have acknowledged that. That has been shown by the pattern of voting both in rural and urban areas. I am not making any secret of my disappointment at the results but I will say that I was glad the people on this occasion acted objectively on the issues and in a mature way; I was glad that they came out in such a high percentage poll which certainly gave an indication that they took the matter seriously, considered it objectively and decided for good or ill to retain the present system. I have nothing but praise for the action of the people in this respect and the manner in which the electorate generally approached these issues. I think it was a healthy and wholesome approach and now that the dust of battle and acrimony has settled it is well to make that comment.

Comment on this

It is not finished yet.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Whatever conclusions the Parties opposite may draw from the result of the referendum, whatever morsel of consolation it gives either or both of them, they are welcome to it but there is one conclusion that both of them cannot draw from this referendum and that is that either of them or both of them together can have an easy ride into office as a result. If they think that, they can think again. Before the referendum I expressed the view, and I still hold it, that in the future it will be increasingly difficult for any single Party to get an overall majority under the present system of voting. People either did not share that view with me or, if they did, they decided to take a chance on the continuation of the present system in the hope that it would, taking one election with another, produce a viable and effective Government.

I have no doubt that the people will approach the next general election with that same kind of maturity and the same objectivity with which they approached the referendum and they will be asking themselves certain questions. They will be examining very closely the merits or the demerits of the policies put forward by the respective Parties. They will examine the Fine Gael policy "Towards a Just Society" which I said before and which I say again is nothing but a conglomeration of economic and social desiderata. Any young boy in the sixth class could write out that kind of programme saying what is desirable and what we would like to obtain in the social, education and employment fields—less taxation and more housing, without any regard to where the capital would come from and, as we saw and had evidence of in one of the by-elections, increased expenditure on education amounting to about £7 million without an resort to taxation. These are the kind of things the people will be asking about and on which they will judge the respective policies. They will ask the Labour Party their policy. They have not declared it fully. Some members have: the vice-chairman has rolled out this rip-roaring socialist policy——

Comment on this

Who is the vice-chairman?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

A former Member of the House.

Comment on this

No, he is not.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The people, when the election comes round, will be asking the Labour Party if that is the policy they are going to pursue. I am not going to criticise the Labour Party for it, they are entitled to have it but I would like to ask especially since Deputy O'Higgins said today that now more than ever must they face up to their responsibility as a Party and I will ask them to do just that.

Comment on this

We will.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Deputy Michael O'Higgins has made overtures to Deputy Corish about a coalition and, as far as I can understand Deputy Corish, he has repudiated him. This marriage is not on. Whether he will do it again or not I do not know. Whether it is to be a coalition or a minority Fine Gael Government supported by Labour, the people will want to know what part of the Labour Party's programme, the ultra socialist programme, will be implemented, what part they will abandon or, to use a famous phrase, "put into abeyance" and what part of the socialist Labour programme will the Fine Gael Party adopt? These are the questions the people are asking.

Comment on this

What is the Taoiseach worrying about? Did he not say he was going to get a majority in the next election?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I am putting this to the Parties opposite because they said only a few minutes ago through a Fine Gael spokesman that they will have to face their responsibilities now much more seriously than they have done up to this.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

These are the things the people opposite will have to tell the electorate before, I suggest, and not after the election. They will either have to tell the electorate what kind of conglomerate policy they are going to ask the people to support or impose on the people after the election.

Comment on this

What is the Taoiseach worrying about?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

There is a little election exercise that I would ask the Parties opposite to consider.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

In the interests of decorum in the House, I must indicate that Deputies on both sides of the House should allow the Taoiseach to make his statement without interruption.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I want to put this question. It is, I think, worth considering. As Deputy Corish said, we are confident we will get a majority the next time, but we can never be prophets. If we do not get a majority we know that we will be by far the largest single Party and, if by any chance, a combination of both Parties opposite could outvote us in the election for Taoiseach, then what would the pattern be? We would put up a candidate and he would be beaten. Fine Gael would put up their candidate: at that stage would Labour vote for the Fine Gael candidate?

Comment on this

I told the Taoiseach on television that we will neither vote for Fine Gael nor Fianna Fáil. Will Fianna Fáil vote for Labour?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

The Fianna Fáil candidate will be beaten. The Fine Gael candidate will be beaten. The Labour candidate will be beaten. What will Labour do then?

Comment on this

What is the Taoiseach going to do? It is over to you now.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Sir, I want to finish as quickly as I can. I have not much time.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has a few minutes at least.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I have six minutes. The usual charges are being made, apart from charges of corruption, that we are arrogant, and arrogant in particular towards the farming community. I want to repudiate these charges. What possible advantage could it be to any government in a democracy to set out deliberately on a collision course with any sizeable section of the community, unless there was a principle involved, and the principle involved here is that, so long as we have authority from the people, we are entitled to, and are expected by the people, to exercise that authority and no group can wrest that authority from us? Certainly, so long as I am Taoiseach, no group will. I will endeavour to ensure that that authority will not be usurped in any way. On the other hand, this Government has been and still is anxious to go a long way towards promoting harmony in all spheres of relationships between government and organisations within the community. We are prepared to go a long way in order to establish permanently harmonious and fruitful relations with all organised farming groups. As everybody knows, it takes two sides to make a quarrel. It also takes two sides to make peace. I say here and now, on behalf of the Government, that I am prepared to wipe the slate clean, if that will bring about a return to harmonious and fruitful relationships between Government and farmers, the relationships which should, I think, exist between Government and interests of this kind and which, in the interests of both sides, it is desirable to have.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We regard ourselves in Government as the servants and not the masters of the people. The power which the Government has is the power which the people, and only the people, give it. It is for the people to decide in their wisdom at the appropriate time whether or not they will continue to give that power to Fianna Fáil and whether or not they will renew the mandate they gave Fianna Fáil to govern. We confidently expect they will do so when the opportunity offers.

Comment on this

Would the Taoiseach deal with the problem of the West of Ireland? His predecessor said it was No. 1 priority.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

This is a vote of confidence and, in a vote of confidence, one takes one side or the other. As far as the record of Fianna Fáil is concerned, particularly the record since we assumed office again 11 years ago, it is a record which I am proud to defend. Fine Gael must think the people's memories are very short when they pretend now that the two Coalitions in which they participated gave us a land flowing with milk and honey. What was the Coalition record? What are the facts? I gave them at the opening of this debate. I do not propose to repeat them. Deputy Corish asked us the other day to forget his term of office in the Coalition Government.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should not misquote me. I said I will take responsibility for anything I said, or any decision I participated in, in those Governments.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Very well. That is the only basis on which we and the people can judge the effectiveness of the Parties opposite as against Fianna Fáil. On that judgment I would be very happy to rest, knowing the sound sense of the people. The Coalition record speaks for itself. It is there for all to see. By any test it is a miserable story of incompetence which brought this country to the verge of ruin. Fianna Fáil lifted the country out of the slough of despond and despair. Through its programmes of economic expansion, programmes much decried here by the Opposition, Fianna Fáil raised again the spirit and the courage and the confidence of the people and achieved a high measure of economic prosperity. We do not begrudge the Opposition Parties whatever morsel of consolation they can draw from the results of the referendum.

Comment on this

Some morsel.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It took sacrifice and time and toil and effort to rescue the country from the effects and consequences of the disastrous Coalition years and to restore the confidence of the people and achieve the kind of progress that has been achieved over the past decade.

Comment on this
Deputies

Rubbish.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I know the country will not take the chance again of permitting the fruits of our efforts to go down the Coalition drain once more.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I can never understand the Deputy. If he writes it down I will try to reply. Deputy O'Higgins referred to these last two wasted years. I wonder what does he regard as wasted years when the rate of progress in each of those years was eight and nine times as high as in the years when he himself was a member of a Government?

Incidentally, I want to say in relation to references which have been made about my responsibilities as Head of the Government that it would have been an easy thing for me to lay about me after the referendum, and try to deny my responsibility for the referendum results by rolling a few heads around the Cabinet table. If and when there are to be changes in the Government they will be of my own choosing. I will not be stampeded into this either by Opposition jibes here or by writers outside.

So also will be the timing of the next election. The timing of the next election will also be of my choosing and I will, as any worthwhile politician would, choose the best time for it. When I do I am confident that the people will continue to maintain their confidence in the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

I asked the Taoiseach if he would say when he proposes to move the writ for the Wexford by-election.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

Not before Christmas.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 69
·
Níl 62
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The motion is carried. The other two motions fall.

The Dáil adjourned at 5.20 p.m. until 3 p.m. on Tuesday, 12th November, 1968.

Comment on this