We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 4: Wholesale Tax (Resumed).

Contributions 1–186 of 762. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Last night, I was endeavouring to show that the Government have no forward-looking policy. Their policy appears to consist in imposing taxation and hoping for the best. It is obvious now that the Anglo-Irish Free Trade Agreement, about which there was so much talk in the rank and file of Fianna Fáil, is not likely to yield very much more in the agricultural sphere. It has allowed for an industrial expansion, but a limited industrial expansion. I suggested last night that the Government should take another look at the beef export potential. The prosperity at the moment is due entirely to the fact that so much stock was lost in the United Kingdom through foot and mouth disease, with a resultant heavy restocking; that will continue possibly until the end of this year. I was challenged last night by Fianna Fáil Deputies who said that stocks are higher today than they ever were before. It may be that young stock is higher, but replacements simply do not exist as they might have existed had the Government exercised some foresight in their policy.

I asked the Taoiseach a question today and I suggested that the Government might avail themselves of the opportunity that now appears to be presented to them in the latest agreement, and it is an agreement, the first sign of a communal agreement between the Six, to explore a wider trading area than we have had over the last two or three years. There is an opportunity now for an expansion of trade. There is an opportunity of making a trade agreement not alone with one of the Six but with every single member of the EEC. It seems strange, therefore, that we apparently have to wait before we take any action. It is for that I criticise this Government. They never move in time. They can never do the obvious thing. Every other country has ambassadors and parliamentary representatives out looking for trade agreements. We never do anything like that.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

I do not like to interrupt the Deputy, but I thought I answered the Deputy today in reply to a parliamentary question on this matter. Apparently the Deputy does not believe me. The Council at its meeting referred to the proposals to the Committee of Permanent Representatives for consideration. The Dutch Foreign Minister, Mr. Luns, said after that meeting that they were in no way committed to the French trading arrangement and nothing of substance had been decided at the meeting. That was stated in reply to the journalist's question. I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy, but he is now trying to put the Government on the wrong foot in defiance of an answer he got today.

Comment on this

I am not criticising the Taoiseach, but here is something that will obviously come to something. Ministers of the Six do not take a definite policy decision without something coming out of it.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

They have been referring things to the Committee of Permanent Representatives for years and they never came out of it.

Comment on this

That is what I am criticising the Government for: it is an entirely negative attitude.

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

It is not negative. We are watching it.

Comment on this

The Government will never get trade agreements without commencing to negotiate. Supposing agreement does come out of this, does the Taoiseach mean to tell me that other countries have not already stepped in and started to negotiate?

Comment on this
John Lynch The Taoiseach Fianna Fáil

We will be in on the ground floor.

Comment on this

Our ambassadors should be instructed straightaway to approach the EEC. They should be in on the ground floor and they should be making inquiries as to the potential for trade agreements. This is the same as entry to the Common Market; one asks questions and one gets the same reply—negotiations will take place. The only chance a small country like this has is to get in on the ground floor before anybody else. It is easier for a small country to make a trade agreement because the other participant does not have to give as big a quota as that which would be required in the case of larger countries. That is why I indict the Government for its slowness and its lack of policy. All that is done is to impose more taxation. The Taoiseach says that, because of the buoyancy of revenue, taxation is less than it should be. That would have happened had there not been the buoyancy? We would have had a maxi-Budget. Indeed, it was very nearly that.

One must look to the future. It is no use merely progressing from Budget to Budget, from one six months to the next. The policy of the Government is one of living from hand to mouth. They will not be there indefinitely but, so long as they are there. I hope they will keep improving the situation so that it will not be too bad when we take over. I suggest to the Taoiseach that there must be an overall increase in trading. The Anglo-Irish Free Trade Area Agreement is not the be-all and end-all of trade. It has produced results in industrial exports. The results in agricultural exports are largely fortuitous because of external circumstances—disastrous circumstances from the point of view of the British because they had to buy so much from us in order to replace their stock. We have now practically reached saturation point in the British market. Every time one reads the papers one notes that there are plans and schemes on foot to increase agricultural production in Britain. The traditional policy of Britain was to buy food from abroad and to export to the countries from which they bought food, industrial goods and products. We were in on the ground floor. We were an agricultural country living in close proximity to the United Kingdom and our trade with that country kept our economy alive over the years. I want to stress that this is changing now. Our ambassadors abroad should be instructed to take action.

The Taoiseach knows as well as I do—he has travelled as much as I have—that a great deal of trade is arranged at social functions such as dinner and luncheon parties. These matters can be discussed in amicable surroundings and very often trade follows on those discussions. We have useful ambassadors in different parts of the world, and they should be instructed to look for all the trade possible, and pass back any information they have to the Government. The thinking here today is on one track in Government circles. We have had 50 years of self-government and although we have had our trials and tribulations we have had comparative peace. All the emerging nations which have come into existence as one unit are out looking for trade every day of the week literally. Perhaps the Government are a little bit sensitive on the question of the British market. The Taoiseach is responsible for the destiny of this country. There was a time when it was suggested that we should not trade with Britain. Now there is a complete swing around and the Government have a one-track mind. So long as they have a one-track mind, and so long as we confine ourselves to the existing trade potential, the Government will continue to impose extra taxation.

There is another angle with which I should like to deal briefly before I conclude. I am sure many other Deputies are waiting to make their contributions. There has been very little mention of economy. The idea in thinking circles seems to be that we should raise all the money we can, that anyone who is earning or producing should have the life taxed out of him to supply funds for Government purposes, and that there should be an increase in the bureaucratic control of the country as a whole.

We established the Department of Labour about two years ago. It is costing the Exchequer £1,100,000. I do not know what is the function of that Department. When it came into existence it was said that it would have a special function with regard to establishing better relations between workers and employers and correlating production and wage increases. I fail to see that the Department of Labour has achieved anything.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid the Deputy is getting away from the Budget.

Comment on this

I am suggesting a saving of £1 million which I am entitled to do on the Budget.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not entitled to do that.

Comment on this

I am referring en passant to a Department on which we could save £1 million and to justify that I am telling the House——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would open up a very wide discussion indeed.

Comment on this

I am simply saying that, to my mind, spending £1 million on a Department that has absolutely no function whatever——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That matter would be relevant to the Estimate. It is certainly not relevant on the Budget which deals with taxation, expenditure and the financial policy of the Government.

Comment on this

I am not talking about administration at all. I am talking about the Department of Labour.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

And I am pointing out to the Deputy that it does not arise.

Comment on this

We could save £1 million by getting rid of that Department. If that goes on record I am quite happy. I want to refer now to the Land Commission.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid I cannot allow the Deputy to continue along those lines. This is a discussion on the Budget and the financial policy of the Government.

Comment on this

And the money that goes to the Land Commission and the Forestry Branch.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That would be a matter for an Estimate.

Comment on this

If I am not to be allowed — if I am to be muzzled——

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is not being muzzled.

Comment on this

I will come in here later and hear other Deputies talking for hours on these subjects, but I am being muzzled because I am saying something that is definitely true and embarrassing to the Government. I will sit down in protest.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It may be true but it is not relevant.

Comment on this

I am ruled out of order unjustly.

Comment on this

It is rather interesting to note that some speakers from the Opposition benches seem to have a cure for all ills, believe it or not. Many Deputies who spoke will remember the years 1949 to 1951 and 1954 to 1957. The Ceann Comhairle is a man of great character and I do not like always to be reminding him of these things, but I am forced into the position of asking the Opposition why during their period of office they did not do all the wonderful things they are now criticising us for not having done. In 1957 this country was at the lowest economic and political ebb possible. As a matter of fact, we were nearly the same as Newfoundland, a country which asked another country to take over their administration or assist them out of their difficulties.

One would imagine that out of the conglomeration of intelligentsia made up of Fine Gael, Labour, Clann na Poblachta, Clann na Talmhan and Independents, someone would have produced some economic policy to save the nation. I remember in my own constituency at that time about 1,800 families left their homes, and over 100,000 were unemployed in the country. In my constituency 1,800 families left their homes and went to America, England, Scotland and various other places. I saw this happening. There was one honest man amongst them.

I asked the Minister for Education a question about a school in Brittas. I told him we had the land and that everything else was settled, and I asked him when he would build it. The honourable gentleman said: "You cannot take the trousers off a Highlander.""Congratulations," I said, "you are one honest person." At that time the Minister for Local Government was telling us there was money for everything. The Opposition talk nowadays about the building of houses, about what we did in relation to building enough houses, and what we should have done. I was a member of Dublin County Council and Dublin Corporation during the period of office of the Coalition Government, and I remember that the building machinery of the local authorities was disbanded because there was no money to go ahead. Houses were built but there were no grants or loans for them. There was not the price of a bag of cement left when they left office. That is what we found in the city and county of Dublin, certain parts of which I have the honour to represent from time to time.

We are trying to keep our economy alive. We are only doing what any other intelligent Government would do. I often stood up here, a Cheann Comhairle, to defend tough Budgets but today I am proud to say that the Taoiseach, as Acting Minister for Finance, is keeping the economy of this nation as it should be kept. I do not want to see our nation back to where we were in 1956-57. I remember in 1948, when we were defeated, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy Seán F. Lemass, said to the Taoiseach, the very honourable gentleman, Deputy John A. Costello, that we had given over the country in a sound financial position and asked him to give it back to us in the same way. The whole approach to our economy by these people at that time was hopeless. They could not run a hotel never mind a country. They scuttled everyless thing and did not stand up to their responsibilities. We are standing up to our responsibilities and so long as we can keep reasonable employment in the country we are going to do that.

I mentioned before that this country has to depend on its own resources. When I was a member of a delegation to Jerusalem in 1964 the Prime Minister of Israel spoke to me of what the Jews all over the world had done for their own country. He, the then Prime Minister, in the course of a personal conversation while entertaining me in his home said that he could not find any country in the world which should be as good as Ireland because there are so many Irish all over the world. The Jews would not have been able to carry on except for the Jews all over the world helping them. In this country we have to depend on the resources of our own people. Large numbers of relatives of Deputies and their friends contributed by sending home money from time to time to their own people.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Burke suggested the tin can collection in 1966.

Comment on this

You are quoting me out of context. I congratulate you on taking my speech out of context. I said nothing of the kind. I was misquoted and misrepresented. That is politics. I hold nothing against the man who did that on me. Some sections of the press as well as Opposition speakers misquoted me.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): And the Editor of Debates.

Comment on this

I never mentioned a tin can in my life. I made the point I made then and I will stand over it. This country has to get along on its own resources. Lloyd George is alleged to have stated behind the backs of the plenipotentiaries when they signed the Treaty: "We have given them back the agricultural south and they will never be able to carry on." That was the feeling then It is a great pleasure to see that the agricultural south is able to balance its Budget. The balance of payments was never better than last year. That is a great tribute to the Fianna Fáil Government and to what we have succeeded in doing to the Irish people.

Comment on this

You balanced the Budget?

Comment on this

The balance of payments was never better than last year.

Comment on this

I beg your pardon.

Comment on this

We are concerned with every section of our people. We are anxious to see that so far as possible the economy of this country should progress to such a degree that we will be able to employ all our people. We have tried to do that. It has been an uphill task. No Government have any money except what they get from the people.

During my visit to Israel the Prime Minister explained what the Jews had succeeded in doing for Israel and I saw what they had done. Even if I was surcharged for my visit it was worth it. We had to fall back on our own resources in this country. When the First Programme for Economic Expansion was introduced in 1958 the economic life of this country was at a very low ebb. It took about four years' hard work to build up the economy and for this country to get going ahead again. Notwithstanding that, my friends on all sides of the Opposition will ask us: "What are you doing about unemployment? What are you doing about drainage? What are you doing about schools? What are you doing about secondary and university education?" They were not able to build national schools. During their term of office there was a Minister in the Government who is not in the House now, and who was not concerned with unemployment at all. Unemployment was a matter for the people themselves. We have done much for the farming community and have given £80 million towards helping the farmers. We are trying to do everything we can for them. Look at what we have done for education.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What is wrong with the farmers? Why are they protesting?

Comment on this

If you give me that question in writing I might be able to answer it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is like the reference to the tin can. You would rather stop.

Comment on this

That is a cheap jibe of the Deputy. For an old family solicitor and a gentleman it is an unworthy cheap jibe.

Comment on this

What is un-worthy about it?

Comment on this

Since the commencement of the Government's Programmes for Economic Expansion the volume of output of manufacturing industries in Ireland has grown at an annual average rate of 6½ per cent. The employment given by the industries increased from 142,000 in 1958 to 177,000 in 1967, which is not a bad effort. In the same period industrial exports rose from a maximum of £33 million in 1958 to an estimated £147 million by 1967. How was that done? That was not done by the crows or the birds. It was done by the initiative of the Government who looked after the interests of the nation and tried to bring about the balance of payments.

The capital investment in industrial enterprise in the State in the nine years from 1959 to 1967 is estimated at £98 million of which State grants represented one quarter. These industries have an employment potential of 44,000 people. They have already absorbed about 30,000 of our people in good employment. Most of these enterprises are producing for export. In dealing with this problem alone it is possible to see the great advances we have made; great things have happened in our time. Notwithstanding the adverse criticism of the Opposition speakers, we have succeeded in doing great things and we will continue to do great things.

The Industrial Credit Corporation was closed down in 1957. There was not a bob stirring during that period. Since 1959, however, the Industrial Credit Corporation have advanced capital totalling £28 million to industry, the bulk of that being loan capital. More than 4,000 people are employed in the enterprises at Shannon.

I do not wish to delay the House, as there are other Deputies who wish to speak. I do not trangress the laws of courtesy in this House and, therefore, I do not speak for too long at any time. However, before concluding, I should like to refer to education. There has been an increase from 59,300 children attending secondary schools in 1957 to the present figure of 118,800, a considerable increase. The number of full-time teachers has increased in the same period from 2,850 to 5,080. In the vocational schools the trend has been the same. The number of pupils attending wholetime day courses has grown from 22,000 to 42,000 since 1957 while the number of teachers in these schools has increased from 1,500 to 2,800. In the universities, student numbers have increased from 7,700 to 16,000. These advances could not have been made without very substantial capital.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Not wishing to interrupt the Deputy, but on a point of order may we have details of the document from which he is quoting these figures so that we may be enabled to make further references and inquiries in regard to these statistics? Further, may I inquire if he is quoting from this document when he makes reference to the fact that the Agricultural Credit Corporation was at one stage closed down? It has never been closed in my memory.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it did not have a bob which is the same thing.

Comment on this

The Deputy made no reference at all to it.

Comment on this

I went to a great deal of trouble to prepare my speech.

Comment on this

God forgive you.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy does not expect me to tell him where I got these figures from?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

It would be a surprise if the Deputy did.

Comment on this

They are available to every Deputy in this House.

Comment on this

There are lies, damn lies and statistics. I take it that the Deputy's speech falls into the category of statistics.

Comment on this
Frank Carter Acting Chairman (Mr. Carter) Fianna Fáil

Deputy P.J. Burke.

Comment on this

I am delighted that Deputy O.J. Flanagan corrected me. If I implied in my statement that the Industrial Credit Corporation closed down, I did not mean it that way. There was not a bob to be loaned by the Industrial Credit Corporation in 1957; they might as well have been closed down. It was just the same as the pub with no beer. They had a licence but no beer. Does the Deputy understand what I mean? Of course, the Agricultural Credit Corporation was the same.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What about the Agricultural Credit Corporation in 1966?

Comment on this

We are talking about the present time.

Comment on this

During the past ten years we have had many increases in social welfare, the highlights being 10/- in 1965 and 7s 6d this year. These increases exceeded by far the general rises in prices. Therefore, they have improved significantly the position of social welfare beneficiaries, the unemployed, the disabled, the old, the blind and the widows.

Comment on this

Especially those who live in Balbriggan.

Comment on this

Since 1957 we have increased the non-contributory old age pension——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Everyone will acknowledge the right of a Deputy to fortify himself with a copious note but perhaps, the Chair will make a distinction between reading a speech and referring to a copious note. If we are to hear long wads of manuscript prepared by minor Deputies, however popular, of Fianna Fáil, the proceedings in this House will suffer.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy is entitled to quote from a script. He is not entitled to read a speech but he is making a speech and he need not necessarily give any further details.

Comment on this

May I thank Deputy Dillon for helping me to make my speech? It is very kind of him.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order——

Comment on this

What harm is there in telling of the good things we have done? Since 1957 we have increased the non-contributory old age pensions and widows pensions from 24s to 65s a week and we have increased unemployment assistance from 19s——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order. Deputy Burke stated that he quoted from some document. He has stated specifically that it is a quote. I submit to the ruling of the Chair so long as Deputy Burke is now obliged under the Rules of the House, to give the source of his quotations.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

As I said before, the Deputy is entitled to quote from a script. Deputy Fitzpatrick is making a frivolous point.

Comment on this

Surely a Deputy who is making a speech and who has a script from which he wishes to quote a lot of figures is entitled to refer to this script for figures?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): On a point of order, if Deputy Burke says that he is quoting from some figures of his own, he is quite in order but he started off by saying that he was quoting. According to that it would appear that he is quoting figures other than his own. It is obvious that he is reading from something.

Comment on this

I do not know anything in Standing Orders that stops a Deputy from——

Comment on this

——quoting himself.

Comment on this

I am quoting myself here.

Comment on this

However, it is nice of Deputy Fitzpatrick to help me out.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is annoying Deputy Fitzpatrick.

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

No. I should not like to do that.

Comment on this

When he quotes himself he is a noble figure but when he quotes Upper Mount Street——

Comment on this

I shall leave the——

Comment on this

——manuscript.

Comment on this

Here we are at the moment. We have never in the history of this House spent more money——

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

——on sewerage schemes, on housing and on roads as well as derating 77.9 per cent of our agricultural land. I have to keep away from the quoting now and, if I am wrong, Deputy Fitzpatrick will correct me.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is quite right.

Comment on this

Seventy-nine per cent of our farmers have to pay no rates. Up to £900 is given to a farmer——

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is not quoting from his script. The figure is £910.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Cunningham is including £10 for expenses: the public utility society fee.

Comment on this

It is £10.

Comment on this

It is well to reflect on what our farming community have been given under that great old Fianna Fáil Government and Party who are so concerned about the welfare of all our people, irrespective of class or creed. I am sure Deputy Fitzpatrick and Deputy Flanagan will realise that, too.

Comment on this

Deputy Burke is now going back to the script.

Comment on this

I do not want to embarrass the Opposition further by reminding them of all the beneficial things Fianna Fáil has done. I have the script here. I am sorry I was interrupted because I had some wonderful stuff in my old script but I do not want to embarrass the Leas-Cheann Comhairle——

Comment on this

The Cathaoirleach.

Comment on this

Yes. Deputy Carter is the Acting Chairman. I am really sorry if I embarrassed Deputy Fitzpatrick. I wonder if Deputy Fitzpatrick would tell this House what he would do if he ever succeeded in achieving office under——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I would pass a tin can over to Deputy Burke for suggestions.

Comment on this

That is a cheap jibe. I did not say that. I was talking about the investment of money in bonds, as the Jews have done for their own people. It was a cheap jibe, then, to convert what I said by saying that I was standing with a tin can——

Comment on this

And, if Deputy Burke did so, he would get more than Deputy Fitzpatrick would.

Comment on this

I often milked a cow into a tin can. That was the most I ever did: That was some years ago. I am always anxious to listen to constructive criticism because I am at school as far as this Assembly is concerned. There is not a day that passes when I come in here and possibly learn something. I always like to listen to constructive criticism but not to cheap jibes of the kind one might hear around a public house at closing time. The unintelligent type of criticism that we have heard from Deputy Fitzpatrick across the floor of the House is unworthy——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I shall quote the Deputy in full before very long.

Comment on this

——and is not what one would expect from a wellknown family solicitor and, as far as I know of him—a gentleman. I have nothing to say against him personally. I may have a lot of enemies but I have none worse than myself. I do not want to delay the House any longer. Believe it or not, I would have finished long ago were it not for the help I got from Deputy O.J. Flanagan, Deputy Dillon and Deputy T.J. Fitzpatrick of Cavan. It is now 4.45 p.m. and that means that I have made an unusually long speech, for me. On the whole, we have been doing our best for our country. We have faced up to our responsibilities here. On anything we have done, let it be unpopular or otherwise, we stand four-square behind our Taoiseach who is at present also our Minister for Finance. I am very proud of him. I must say he has done and is doing a very good job for our country. Long may he be spared to us. I am thankful to the gentlemen of the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy is more than welcome.

Comment on this

This interim Budget, or moiety of the Budget, or whatever we might call it—we certainly cannot call it a "mini-Budget"—seems to me to be the proof, if proof were needed, of the sensible attitude taken by the Irish people only a few weeks ago when they refused, in no uncertain terms, to give this Government the mandate they sought to continue in office for an indefinite period of perhaps 20 or 25 years. Coming at this particular time of the year, this Budget proves beyond all doubt, if proof were needed, that the Fianna Fáil Government is incapable of leading this nation other than up the never-ending cul-de-sac to which we have become accustomed down the years. We seem to be in an economic and social rut out of which this Government do not seem capable of leading us. As evidence of that statement, one could go back over a long number of years but I do not propose to do that now. For instance, we could cast our thoughts back to 1965 and the occasion of the last general election, the one in which I became a Member of this House. I remember that, just before that election, we seemed to be going ahead very well as a country. Indeed, according to the words of the then Fianna Fáil Government, we were entering upon a long period of prosperity. No sooner was the general election over than all the economic ills, in precisely the same forms as now, reared their heads. The new Fianna Fáil Government took precisely the same steps as are now being taken to curb those economic ills. This seems to be an ever-recurring facet of life here down through the years.

From that period in 1965, practically to the present day, we have had stagnation. Those of us in public life had repeatedly to make the standard excuse to people who sought local authority services and, in fact, who sought services of any kind that financial measures were taken to correct the ills that were apparent in the economy with the result that no money was available for such schemes. The tragedy is that the corrective measures taken down through the years have tended to aggravate our basic ill which appears to me to be a lack of employment and a high rate of unemployment. Until the provision of more and more jobs becomes a priority over every other consideration, our social and economic ills will never be solved. We have, I believe, a small proportion of our people in productive employment—that is, in proportion to the numbers in our community—on whom the aged and the young depend. Until we increase that proportion, our economic ills will certainly never heal for any length of time and our social ills will not be cured at all. We have a relatively small work force with a wide disparity in the ranges of remuneration paid to that work force.

We have an unjust taxation system in so far as the emphasis is on indirect taxation and in so far as direct taxation weighs most heavily on the section of the community least able to bear it. Some of the items taxed may be considered luxury goods but the fact remains that they are goods which are essential to some members of our community. While 4d on the packet of cigarettes may be an insignificant increase to a highly paid worker, to a man on £8 or £10 a week it represents a very large slice of his income on this one commodity alone.

About three years ago we talked about a minimum living wage. Surely with this never-ending spiral of taxation, taxation which, as I say, weighs most heavily on the poorer section of the community, the time has definitely come to introduce a minimum living wage? However, I believe that all these ills to which I have referred, and many others to which in the course of the next few minutes I shall also refer, cannot be eradicated until we increase the number of people in productive employment and the number of people who will be able to contribute to the revenue of the country.

The wholesale tax has been represented as not weighing on essential goods such as food and clothing. However, it will have the effect of slowing down our economy, of slowing down housebuilding and very many other activities. The increase in postal charges will have a similar effect. The result of all this will be further stagnation and a further retraction in the number of our people in employment.

Hardships have been imposed and hardships continue to be imposed, but they are not solving anything. The basic problems remain, and this Budget, in spite of what Deputy Burke says, far from solving them, will only aggravate them. Deputy Burke stated we have spent more money on water supply and sewerage schemes and other such local authority services in the past two or three years than we have ever done before. That is a wild statement. My recollection of the last few years is that we never had a longer list of schemes waiting for sanction, waiting for money and waiting for the go-ahead from the Department of Local Government. The people's needs are not being met in regard to housing, water supplies and sewerage schemes. Arrears are being built up year after year and it would appear to me that the present policy of the Government will not solve them within the foreseeable future.

We have basic problems in regard to agriculture and in regard to land drainage. People are facing a situation where more and more acres of their arable land are becoming incapable of being cultivated and are being lost to the economy. Large sums of money are required and I cannot see this Government being able to provide the necessary finance. Therefore, I can see this problem being aggravated to the point where it will be a very major one indeed. Large tracts of arable land are being lost to us, a tremendous source of wealth which is not being explored and does not look like being explored in the foreseeable future. Similarly large sums of money are required to arrest coastal erosion which is a very serious problem, because such land could be lost to us forever.

Then there is the big problem of agriculture itself. I do not intend to go into it in detail on this motion. Suffice it to say that we should be gearing this industry to the future; otherwise we shall find ourselves facing serious problems which could well have been avoided if the appropriate measures were taken in time.

Going back to 1965 I remember we had the good news of a White Paper on health. It was not all that this Party would wish for, but it promised to go a long way towards eliminating some of the basic ills in the health services at the moment. We were told this scheme would be in operation in a very short time, in a matter of months. Years have passed. We have had various negotiations and various reasons have been put forward as to why this health scheme is not being put into operation. Of course, the simple reason is that there is no money available to implement it.

Deputy Burke also spoke about education, and, perhaps, tomorrow we shall have an opportunity of going into some of the difficulties that remain in the field of education. On this motion I shall confine myself to the remark I made in regard to the provision of jobs. Education is a worthy goal in itself, but we must bear in mind that, having educated our people, we must find jobs for them. This Government have fallen down badly over the years in this regard.

We have intermittent Budgets and intermittent efforts to collect money for various purposes one of which is to improve the social welfare services. I suppose they have been improved in some small way, but not alone as a result of direct Budget reaction but as a result of lack of price control, these improvements have been vitiated. Whatever the Government may say, if you ask any Irish housewife about price control she will tell you there is no such thing.

Because of the spiral of price increases and because of the big disparity year after year in the incomes of the various sections, our social welfare classes are no better off, relatively, than they were a few years ago. The same applies to our lower paid workers. They are the people to whom we must give particular attention in the future. They have been sadly neglected and they have been paying more than their fair share of the burden of all taxation. In spite of that, there does not seem to be any long-term solution to their problem.

I come back to the basic problem with which we should be able to get to grips—that of providing more wealth by way of putting more people into productive, taxable employment. Unfortunately, we are as far away from a solution as ever. Another basic problem is our unjust taxation system. Our taxation system has been unvaried over the years. Under it, people with £6 5s or £6 10s a week must pay income tax. All of us on these benches have agitated for the upgrading or the increasing of the personal allowance but we have been told of the big figure it would involve by way of loss of revenue. This is another basic injustice which the Government do not appear capable of ever solving.

I do not wish to detain the House longer on this subject. We have many ills in our economy, industrial and social ills. Occasionally we appear to recover from them temporarily, but always only temporarily. The rut is still there and it calls for a lot of new thinking, for a fresh approach. First of all, we have got to make employment a first priority. The Government have to see that our economy develops to the point where there will be more and more jobs and they must take positive steps to intervene to ensure there will be more jobs. Whatever the effects of such a policy will be, if we are to get out of this rut we have got to take action. It requires a fresh approach and it is clear now that this is not the Government to consider such an approach.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The year 1968 will go down in the political history of this country as the year in which the Fianna Fáil Government played party politics with the finances and the economy of this country, the year in which the Fianna Fáil Government wasted the time of this House and of the country in trying to alter the electoral system so as to consolidate themselves in power indefinitely. But it is the year in which the Irish people made their power and voices felt by refusing to be fooled and stampeded into handing over absolute power to Fianna Fáil, and how right the people were.

The Budget which we are discussing is proof positive of the dishonesty of the present Government. I want to put it to the House that in introducing this Budget the Taoiseach did so with a guilty conscience. He realised that what I have just said is correct, and in introducing this Budget he immediately went on the defensive by trying to establish and to put across the bona fides of the Government.

In his opening remarks the Taoiseach stated, as reported in column 2051 of the Official Dáil Debates for 5th November, 1968:

The Financial Motions on the Order Paper for today are clear expressions of the Government's sense of responsibility for the good management of the economy.

I think the Financial Motions on the Order Paper of this House for 5th November, 1968, portray the present Government as political adventurers who are more interested in keeping themselves in power than in the good management of the economy of this country.

It is not without significance that we had a Budget introduced earlier this year by the Minister for Finance which should have been a Budget dealing with the finances of the country for 12 months, a Budget which would raise by taxation or otherwise the finances to run the country for 12 months. But, in fact, it was no such thing. It was a Budget introduced in advance of a referendum, in advance of a national political contest to try to present the Government in as favourable a light as possible, so that they would be able to put over their electoral reform proposals to the country.

I think it is a disgrace that an Irish Government in a referendum year, in a year of a national electoral contest, should introduce a Budget in the spring and then come along in the autumn of this year, immediately after the referendum had been disposed of by the people, with this second Budget, which was hailed in advance by some newspapers as a "mini-Budget", but on the morning of 5th November was branded by Radio Éireann as the "late autumn Budget". The fact is that the Government hoped by the comparatively favourable Budget which they introduced in the spring of this year to get their electoral proposals across, and, if they had done that, I shudder to think what sort of Budget they would now have presented in the House. I think the people are entitled to ask that. It has been said that in the referendum the people won. They certainly did. These kind of tactics are not new. They have been tried out before.

The present Government are discredited. They have received a defeat at the hands of the people such as no political Party received in this country in the last 50 years. They are a Government that seem to be divided. The Cabinet, as far as we can see, are completely divided. We had the Taoiseach making a speech one day, a senior Minister making a totally different speech the next day and again that speech being contradicted by the Taoiseach on the following day and a speech from a senior Minister on the next day. But, in so far as this Government claim the confidence of the people in any shape or form, they do so on the basis that the Taoiseach is an honest man. I am afraid the Taoiseach's record in the matter of budgeting, especially in election years, does not entitle him to the description of an honest Minister for Finance or the honest Head of a Government.

In 1965 the present Taoiseach introduced his first Budget. At any rate, he introduced a Budget which I think was his first. In the following year, 1966, which was the Presidential Election year, the present Taoiseach, as Minister for Finance, introduced a Budget on the 9th March. In the very early part of his statement he posed the question "What went wrong with my Budget introduced in May last?" One would have thought that a Minister for Finance, who was forced on the 9th March, 1966, when introducing a Budget to pose the question "What went wrong with my Budget introduced in May last?" would have gone to great pains and taken great care to ensure that the Budget which he was then introducing was an honest and adequate Budget and one that would meet the requirements of the country for the ensuing 12 months.

That profound statement was made by the present Taoiseach on 9th March, 1966, and he introduced his Budget and put it through the House. As we know, there was a Presidential Election held here on 1st June, 1966. As things turned out, we know that was an election in which the Fianna Fáil Party and their candidate required any vote they could get and only won by a whistle. That contest was held on 1st June, 1966, and, on 14th June, 1966, two weeks after, we had the present Taoiseach, the then Minister for Finance, back into this House with another Budget—three months approximately after his Budget on 9th March, 1966.

That was an extraordinary performance. It was a performance which required a lot of explanation, but the Taoiseach got away with it, and the Fianna Fáil Party got away with it. That was in 1966 and, as I have told the House, in 1968, in the year of the greatest electoral contest of all time, the contest in which the Fianna Fáil party gambled its future, we have a repeat performance. We have a spring Budget before the referendum. There was a generous increase of 7s 6d for the social welfare classes, and very little taxes at a time when the Fianna Fáil Party anticipated that the referendum would be held within months. At that time it was fairly clear that we would have a referendum in June. The referendum was held but the people did not fall for the "Yes" vote and back we have the Taoiseach. Perhaps it is ironical that fate should decree that the Taoiseach's nose would be rubbed in the mud, that the man who introduced two Budgets in 1966, in the Presidential year, should be directed by fate back into this House to introduce the second Budget of 1968.

I do not think that by any stretch of the imagination the Budget with which we are now dealing could be described as a mini-Budget. It is a maxi-Budget. Not only is it not a mini-Budget but it is not a mini-Budget as compared with the spring Budget of this year, that was introduced on the 23rd April. Let us have a look at the taxes imposed by the April Budget of this year and the taxes imposed by the Budget which we are now discussing. The April Budget of 1968 imposed a tax of 2d on 20 cigarettes; the present Budget imposes a tax of 4d, double the amount.

Comment on this

It is 3d.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is 3d plus 1d. It is all in the statement.

Comment on this

It is 3d tax and a penny increase.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Is that the best argument Deputy Cunningham can put forward?

Comment on this

It is not an argument; it is a statement.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is 3d tax and, as a result, there will be 4d more on 20 cigarettes. If Deputy Cunningham wants to break that down or dissociate the Taoiseach from onethird of it, I will not argue. Beer was increased by one penny per pint in the April Budget. It has been increased by 2d a pint in this Budget. It is true that wine was increased at the rate of 1/a bottle in the April Budget and it is equally true that wine has escaped the Taoiseach's axe in this Budget— for what that will mean to the ordinary man in the street. In the April Budget imported spirits other than spirits imported from Great Britain were taxed at the rate of 6d a glass but, as we know, spirits other than spirits imported from Great Britain again only concern the more wealthy classes. In this Budget all spirits, including Irish spirits, are taxed at the rate of 2d a glass.

When we deal with the taxation of spirits to the tune of 2d a glass in this Budget it is necessary to recall something the Minister for Finance, Deputy Haughey, had to say on the 23rd April when he was introducing his prereferendum Budget. I quote the Minister for Finance at column 66 of the Dáil Debates of 23rd April, 1968. He said:

Revenue receipts from Irish-made spirits in the year just ended were lower than in the previous year and I have decided that the home products could not be asked to bear additional taxation this year.

The taxation of spirits had ceased to be profitable and he had decided that in the present year spirits could not bear any further taxation. Well, I should like to remind the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance that notwithstanding the fact that a referendum intervened between April and November we are still in the year 1968 and I would like to ask what change has come about in the spirits trade which justifies the change of attitude.

That is why it is impossible to describe this as a mini or a minor Budget and that is important for two reasons because if it was an honest Budget one could understand some miscalculation but surely one would expect that the subsequent or second Budget in a year would impose less taxation if it was an honest mistake? The people are entitled to conclude that this was not a case of miscalculation or making a mistake, that it was a deliberate attempt to fool the people, a deliberate attempt to introduce an easy Budget in April, 1968, so that the referendum would go down and now the real Budget is being introduced.

As well as the charges I have mentioned up goes wholesale tax by 5 per cent from 1st January next. That increase is as severe as the wholesale tax imposed in the first instance. Post Office charges have gone up all over the place. That is why I say, Sir, that this is not an honest Budget and that is why I say that the Fianna Fáil Party are not entitled to shelter under the umbrella of the Taoiseach's honesty because this Budget does not present him or the Government of which he is head as an honest Government or as an honest Taoiseach. He is an experienced man in finance. He served his time in Finance. Surely he vetted this Budget when it was being introduced in April last? If he was honest, if he was sincere about it, why did he not tell his Minister for Finance that he did not want any political playacting, that he did not want any electioneering tactics and that he should go back and introduce a full and adequate Budget? People are entitled to know that and the people, mind you, as has been proved in this year of 1968, are not so easily fooled. I for one am satisfied that no matter what sort of Budget is introduced by this Government if they are still in office next spring the people will not accept it. How could they accept any Budget introduced by the Fianna Fáil Party in an election year as an honest Budget in view of their experience in the election years of 1966 and 1968?

So much, Sir, for the sincerity of this Budget. So much for the motives which prompted an easy Budget in April, 1968, and this harsh Budget now. The people have already caught out the Government in the referendum and they have certainly caught out the Government now. I do not want to deal at length with Deputy Burke's speech but I seem to remember that the theme of Deputy Burke when speaking on the April Budget was: "You do not want to pay for the social welfare benefits. Do you object to the old age pensioner getting an increase? Do you object to the widows and orphans getting an increase?" A funny thing about this Budget is that although its taxes are far more severe than those of the spring Budget there is not a penny in it for the social welfare class. I shall deal with that when I come to it.

Let us just discuss for a moment the objects of a Budget. A Budget should reasonably be expected to raise the necessary revenue for 12 months; it should provide incentives for industry and agriculture and it should make a fair distribution of the national income by protecting the social welfare classes or those unable to protect themselves. Those would be my ideas about it. The Minister for Finance in introducing the April Budget gave us some of his objectives: "To improve social welfare benefits so as to offset recent and foreseeable cost of living increases and to assure the recipients of a share in the advance in community living standards." He also went on to say that there should be provision made to grant a moderate increase in public service pensions. Those two objects are certainly worthy—to improve the lot of the social welfare classes, to cushion them against the increase in the cost of living and to give them a share in increased living standards and also to grant a moderate increase in public service pensions. In so far as the Budget of April last honestly set out to achieve that it deserves credit but let us see what has happened.

The increases for the non-contributory old age pensioners and social welfare people, the non-contributory classes, only came into force in August last and the increases granted in the April Budget to the contributory section will not come into force until next January. Yet, within a couple of months of the non-contributory people reaping their small benefits and a couple of months in advance of the contributory sections receiving their benefits we have this late autumn Budget, as it is called, introduced with the effect of taking away substantially from the non-contributory social welfare classes the benefits which they received in August and of ensuring that the benefits promised to the contributory social welfare classes as from January next will mean nothing to them. Was that fair? Is that an honest deal? If this was an honest mistake in budgeting, why did the Minister for Finance or the Taoiseach not give some further benefit to the social welfare classes and the State pensioners to bring them up to date and ensure that this Budget would not further reduce their standard of living?

I want to make a brief reference to the health services mentioned by Deputy Mrs. Desmond. I remember sitting in this House for a week and spending a long week at home before that trying to understand the White Paper on Health. That was early in 1966 and we were solemnly assured then that the necessary legislation to implement that White Paper would be introduced here before the end of 1966 and that the sections promised in that White Paper would be a reality before the end of 1967. We are now at the end of 1968 and not a section of an Act of Parliament has been introduced to give effect to the White Paper. That is a disgrace. The fact that the Government were too busy all this year trying to steamroll their electoral reform measures through the House and distracting the attention of the country and trying to get people to accept these measures and the fact that we are now going to have further elaborate electoral reforms before the House present no excuse for the Government in regard to the provision of fundamental health services.

The Government know perfectly well that if they introduce worthwhile health services, even on the lines of the White Paper and even if they do not go as far as some of us would wish they would be practically accepted as an agreed measure. There is some satisfaction in the fact that the delay in the case of the health services is possibly due to the fact that the Government are now going to accept in toto the Fine Gael health proposals because I understand, from either the Taoiseach or one of his Ministers recently, that they are now considering a health scheme based on insurance.

This Budget will further retard housing because it will increase the cost of houses which has already been increased several times in the last few years by turnover tax, wholesale tax, devaluation and now an increase in wholesale tax and all at a time when the standard State grant has not been increased since 1948. I speak of the standard State housing grant. The honesty of the Taoiseach and the Government is at stake here. That is the case and it is all they appear to have on which to hang their hat—the honesty not of the Members but of the head of the Government. When the Taoiseach recently and not so recently —in months past—asked that workers should be careful in demanding increases in salaries and warned that if wages were further increased the economy of the country would get out of control. I make no apology to the Taoiseach or any Member of the House for asking: did the Taoiseach appreciate that position when he as head of the Government sanctioned increases in ministerial salaries and in Deputies' and in judges' salaries?

I am entitled to ask that question when the honesty of the Taoiseach is at stake and the integrity of the Government. It is no answer for the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to throw across the House at me: "If you do not want your increase, give it back." That is not the issue. The issue is whether the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Cabinet, when sanctioning these increases, appreciated the necessity for the call for restraint which has since come from the Taoiseach and his Ministers. It is no answer to say that I did not then stand up in the House and refuse or oppose the increases. The Government are the experts and they are in charge of the country. They have an expert Civil Service to advise them. Either the Taoiseach did not know of the need for restraint, which he and his Ministers have been preaching, when he sanctioned these increases and he was not minding his business or, worse still, he did know and concealed it from the House and the country. I should like the Taoiseach to deal with that point when replying.

I want to conclude by saying that the Government have no mandate whatever to impose these taxes in this Budget. It is a responsible function of a Government to introduce one Budget in the year but in my opinion a Government needs considerable authority before introducing a second Budget. It is an unusual step, something that is rare, although, admittedly, less rare than formerly. Therefore, I say that a Government should be backed not only by the confidence of the House but of the country in introducing a second Budget in the same year.

There is no doubt that the Government have lost the confidence of the people. They went to the country on 16th October and asked the people to accept their electoral reform proposals, having campaigned up and down the country at enormous expense for months before that. There is no doubt that Fianna Fáil put the Referendum to the country as a political issue.

Comment on this

Not true.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is no doubt that the Fianna Fáil Party did that. It is true that they were not united within the Party as we know now.

Comment on this

Flagrantly dishonest.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Now, Deputy Andrews——

Comment on this

It is no more dishonest than the rest of his speech.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is also true that the Government put the referendum to the people with the full support of every member of the Government and with the strong recommendation, both written and verbal, of every member of the Government from the Taoiseach down. There is no doubt about it that practically every householder in the country received a letter from the Taoiseach strongly recommending as his firm conviction that his electoral reforms were in the interests of the country and that, if they were not accepted, he foresaw grave difficulties for the country in the future. He urged the people to accept his advice and to accept those proposals. If that is not making it a political issue, if that is not staking the reputation of the Government on the outcome of the referendum, I do not know what it is. The fact of the matter is the people, by a majority of practically 250,000 votes, refused to accept the Taoiseach's recommendation or the Government's recommendation.

I say, therefore, that this Government have not got the confidence of the country and it is very doubtful if the Taoiseach, who introduced this Budget and who is acting Minister for Finance, has the confidence of his own Cabinet. It is impossible to find out who is the Leader of the Government, who we are to accept as the man in authority. I am glad the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is here because I would prefer to say anything I have to say in his presence rather than behind his back. One day we have the Taoiseach making a nice, polite hands-across-the-border, friendly speech to Captain O'Neill and the following day or a couple of days later we have the Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like to ask what this has to do with the Financial Resolution?

Comment on this

Because the Government are breaking up.

Comment on this

I should like to have the Chair's ruling.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The discussion is on the Financial Resolution before the House, Resolution No. 4 and——

Comment on this

It involves Government policy.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It involves Government policy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The point I am making is that the Government have no mandate from the people to introduce this. I have referred to the Taoiseach's hands-across-the-border speech and the next day we had the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries coming out and disembowelling Captain O'Neill and, by implication, disembowelling the Taoiseach.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

At this stage might I point out to the Deputy that, in bringing in these matters, he is widening the scope of the debate on the Financial Resolution?

Comment on this

A debate on the Budget Resolution has always embraced Government policy and the concern of Deputy Fitzpatrick is to find out what is Government policy now and who states it.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

And who is in charge.

Comment on this

What has Partition got to do with the Financial Resolution?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What has housing or health——

Comment on this

I am asking the Leas-Cheann Comhairle to hand down a ruling.

Comment on this

It is perfectly clear that Deputy Andrews is sensitive on this subject and I can appreciate why.

Comment on this

I do not want your ruling, I want the ruling of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to make one further point which is highly relevant.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair's ruling is that the matter of Partition is not a subject for debate on a Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

But who the Leader of the Government is, is a subject for debate.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We have it on the authority of one member of the Government, to wit the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, that certain members of the Government are not pulling their weight. We had the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries stating the other day that he is doing his best to serve under the Taoiseach and that he is doing a lot better than most. I want to pose the question if in “most” he includes the Minister for Finance, because the Minister for Finance is responsible for this Budget? If the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries means to convey to the House that the Minister for Finance, who cannot budget for more than six months ahead, is incompetent, is not pulling his weight and not doing his stuff, I for one agree with him. We have it from within the Cabinet. Sometimes we have to look for external evidence and sometimes look for evidence to corroborate statements we make. I have been trying to establish that this Government is both incompetent and dishonest. I can prove out of the mouth of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries that it certainly is incompetent because he has stated that he put the Taoiseach where he is, that he played a big part in putting in the Taoiseach. We know is was a big job and we give him credit for the part he played, but he went on to say that he has done his best to serve under the Taoiseach and we know what the best from the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries amounts to; we know the Minister's best has ended up in chaos, absolute chaos in the agricultural industry. Yet this is the man who says that he has done his best to serve well under the Taoiseach and that he has done much better than most. I cannot conclude my contribution on a stronger note, and with some humility may I say on a more eloquent note, than quoting the words of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.

Comment on this
Neil T.C. Blaney Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries (Mr. Blaney) Fianna Fáil

Whatever about the eloquence of the Deputy's finishing remarks there was certainly very little eloquence about what he was saying in the few minutes that I have been present in the House. He has been far removed from the matter before the House and he has taken time off to have a swipe at matters which are of little concern to him, if any, and which of course were untrue in most respects. The present Leader of the Government——

Comment on this

The present Leader?

Comment on this

——is the elected Leader of our Government. He is there by agreement of our Party and there is nobody in our Party who does not agree with that leadership. That leadership is going to continue, not only of the Party but of the Government. This contrasts very much with Deputy O'Higgins, who is in the driver's seat over there today and who has been doing his best, with others helping him, to unseat Deputy Cosgrave in recent years. As I have said, Deputy Cosgrave is really to be pitied rather than laughed at in the position he has found himself, particularly in relation to this matter of the referendum where, as the view of the Fine Gael Party, taken for their own political motives——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): What do you call the bird that makes a noise away from its nest in order to distract attention?

Comment on this

There is another bird known as the "whang" bird and it would describe the Deputy well. In so far as their line on the referendum was concerned, it is true, as we said before the campaign began, that the only real reason there was a narrow majority of the Fine Gael Party against the proposals and against their own Leader's view was——

Comment on this

On a point of order. Is this relevant?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I suggest that the Minister come to the Financial Resolution. Other matters are, at the moment, irrelevant to the debate.

Comment on this

I shall certainly do that, but the unfortunate thing is that this matter has been raised. In fact, little else has been talked about since I came into the House. Certain assertions have been made which I feel I am entitled to rebut on behalf of the Government and on behalf of my Party. Statements have been made. As Deputy Andrews said, it is unfortunate that these matters should have been introduced but, since they were introduced, I would crave the indulgence of the Chair to the extent at least of allowing me to refute the statements and to put the facts briefly. The tactics of the Party opposite were well displayed and equally well detected by members on this side of the House long before the referendum, when we said publicly that the reason for Fine Gael's attitude to the referendum was based on their hope that, by joining with any sort of queer bedfellow, they might be able to resurrect themselves as a political Party and, if the referendum were lost, they would claim the victory as a political victory for themselves. That is the extent of Fine Gael's outlook on anything today, on the importance of the country as a whole, on the importance of its Constitution even.

Comment on this

On a point of order. The Minister's queer bedfellows may be something he may wish to speak about, but they have nothing to do with this debate. I know the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has queer bedfellows now, but that is his concern; it is not relevant to this debate.

Comment on this

If Fine Gael are so elated about winning a great victory, as they would like people to believe, how is it that they are all so touchy? They still get up here and talk about all sorts of things and they keep sniping across the floor of the House and, when their sniping is ignored, they begin to howl. I cannot understand it.

Comment on this

The Minister cannot understand a great many things, including the farmers of Ireland.

Comment on this

When the Deputy has the same understanding of them as I have, he will be a lot wiser and a good deal older.

Comment on this

Then I am instantly wiser and older.

Comment on this

I think the latter is quite true, regardless of the Deputy's years.

Comment on this

Certainly. Experentia docit.

Comment on this

Too old for anything useful in this House or outside it.

Comment on this

That is a matter for the people to decide.

Comment on this

To get on with the discussion, I should like to pinpoint the fact that the touchiness of Fine Gael is somewhat surprising. It is a contradiction of the elation that they outwardly display because of their alleged great victory, a great victory in which they claim they relegated Labour to nothingness.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

On a point of order. Since the Chair ruled a few moments ago against Deputy Fitzpatrick and described his statements as irrelevant, under all the circumstances, does he now deem the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to be in order? Deputies are entitled to know that. In my opinion—I have the greatest respect for the Leas-Cheann Comhairle—the Minister is not in order; he is not speaking to the Motion before the House.

Comment on this

We assume anyway that it is a valedictory address.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair last night and again today referred to the fact that the debate on this occasion is limited to the Financial Motion before the House and to the Budget. The debate on a previous confidence Motion took in such matters as the referendum and the debate on this occasion should now be kept to the Financial Motion before the House.

Comment on this

I would be the last to question any ruling of the Chair, particularly with you, Sir, in it, but, for the sake of clarification, I should like to ask whether in fact discussion has been allowed on matters not relevant to the debate and, if that is so, surely a fair opportunity must be given to refute the statements made, irrelevant though they may be and even though such refutation may be a perpetuation to some extent of the irrelevancies. I appeal to the Chair's sense of fair play.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That is why the Chair has allowed the Minister to make his point of personal explanation. I hope the Minister will now move to the subject-matter of the Budget.

Comment on this

As I was saying, Deputies on the opposite benches are extremely touchy. I cannot understand why they should be. They give the lie to their own alleged feelings of elation and their anxiety for an early general election. I believe that, if there were an early general election, there would be a great many casualties over there; they would be frightened to go before the electorate. I am sure Deputy O'Higgins is not really interested in going to the country at the moment any more than he has been on any other occasion.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The man behind the Minister is more afraid than either Deputy O'Higgins or the Minister himself.

Comment on this

I took on the best Fianna Fáil could produce and there was only a "nose" in it.

Comment on this

As I said on another occasion, there was an SOS—save Oliver, in order to keep O'Higgins in the Dáil.

Comment on this

I will take on Fianna Fáil at any time, collectively or individually, and beat it.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I wonder could we come now to the Financial Motion.

Comment on this

Leaving Deputy O'Higgins——

Comment on this

Will you go to the country now?

Comment on this

——to his fantasy as to his worth in the political arena, either against Deputy Oliver Flanagan or anybody else——

Comment on this

He may as well enjoy his fantasy while he can. It will not be for long.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

What about the general election the Minister was speaking about; that is what we want. None of us is afraid of it.

Comment on this

If there is anyone over there feeling like backing his talk with a little money—I have not got a lot of it——

Comment on this

This may be finance, but it is not relevant to the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

It is very much on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I will hold the stakes. I have a licence.

Comment on this

The Minister is wasting time.

Comment on this

If Deputy Costello is so sick and tired for the little while he appears in the House, I would suggest——

Comment on this

I would suggest to the Minister that he should not insult Deputy J.A. Costello, who is worth ten times what the Minister is worth.

Comment on this

It is of little consequence to me.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Is it in order for the Minister to make offensive remarks about a former Taoiseach? I think it is disgraceful.

Comment on this

Let the Deputy not be codding himself. I was merely suggesting a remedy.

Comment on this

The Minister insults everyone.

Comment on this

Do not be so touchy.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister now, on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

One would think Deputies opposite were here for the first time.

Comment on this

Let the Minister come to it quickly and finish quickly.

Comment on this

Come to what quickly?

Comment on this

The Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

I did not know Fine Gael had been discussing it. Sorry if I have been misled. On the Financial Resolution, we had Deputy T.F. O'Higgins, the principal spokesman on the financial end. I listened to Deputy O'Higgins. He made great play about this supplementary Budget. He made this play on the basis that it was improper because the Budget of last April was conceived at a time when it was known that there would be a referendum some time later, and it was devised solely and entirely with that in view. He, or some of the other people over there, said it was dishonestly conceived, that it was conceived purely and simply with a view to codding the public, and not providing the proper amount of money requisite and known to be needed at that time for the running of the country in the ensuing 12 months. He or some of his spokesmen—I am not quite sure —said this mistake was of the order of £18¾ million.

The Deputy told us that we did not know we needed extra money for milk, £4 million extra, that he knew last April what we would need by the end of this milking season, and that we would need more than we had provided for. He told us also that he knew last April that we would need £1½ million for the undoubtedly bumper return of wheat which our farmers have produced this year. I want to ask why as a good citizen—and as a wouldbe first citizen, for the last time I am sure—he did not pass on that very much-needed information, since he had the foresight which he now tells us about?

Why did he not correct the erring Government and the erring Minister for Finance at that time, and tell him where he was going wrong by providing £4 million too little for milk? Why did he not tell us that there would be an increase of over 50 million gallons of milk during the present milking season? How he knew this is another matter, but since he alleges that he did know it, and blames our Minister for Finance and our Government for not knowing it, and accuses us of bad faith in not providing for it, I am entitled to ask why, as the good citizen which he makes himself out to be, he did not correct the Government at that time and tell us we would be £4 million short in the provision for milk support?

Comment on this

Did not the Minister know that everyone was going into milk in the spring of this year?

Comment on this

Did the Deputy know?

Comment on this

The trouble is that he did not talk to the farmers. That is why he did not know.

Comment on this