Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 4: Wholesale Tax (Resumed).
Contributions 187–377 of 762. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
Yes, good farmers, and the majority of them have supported Fianna Fáil traditionally down the years, as the Deputy knows, and knew when he was supporting Fianna Fáil himself—as far back as that. To get back to Deputy O'Higgins's speech and interjections, he was so close to the farmers that he knew last April what no one over here knew—and I will go a little further and say that very few over there apart from himself knew —that the cows were going to produce upwards of 50 million gallons of milk more in 1968 than the same cows produced in 1967.
Comment on this
If the Deputy read it before last April why did he not tell us, or pass us on a copy?
Comment on this
This will be added to the other wonders of the world. There is a man in this House who is so close to the farmers that he knows what the cows are going to do six months before they do it. He would be a valuable acquisition to the country if we could use him properly.
Comment on this
Anyone would know there would be more milk when the farmers were being asked to go more into milk production.
Comment on this
Taking into account the additional number of cows that went into milk production and taking the average production per cow—I have not got the foresight or the hindsight the Deputy has——
Comment on this
I do not claim it but I probably have more than the Deputy. We have very clear and concrete evidence of the extraordinary increase in our milk production, and if we take from it the amount of milk produced by the additional number of cows that went into our herds and supplied milk to our creameries during 1968, we find that 37,000,000 gallons approximately were produced by the same number of cows as we had last year. That cannot be accounted for by saying we knew more people were going into milk production. If we take the 50 million gallons produced with approximately 26,000 extra cows, an average national production of 500 gallons per cow, we will find that 37 million or 38 million gallons more were produced by the same number of cows, 99 per cent of which will be the same cows as were there the year before. They produced 37 million gallons more and Deputy O'Higgins knew last April that they would.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins with his foresight and his knowledge of the farmers and their cows knew all this, but unfortunately he kept to himself the information that 37 million gallons more would be produced in the 1968 milking season than the same cows produced in 1967. The Deputy did not tell us about it so that we could have provided an extra £4 million.
Comment on this
On a point of order, is it not true that even the birds hopping in the streets knew that milk production was increasing in the spring of this year?
Comment on this
There is a record of the debate on the Budget last April, and I would ask the Deputy to have a look at that record and show us, for our clarification, where he in any part of his contribution to that debate indicated this knowledge which he now displays that the cows were going to give us 37 million gallons of milk more in 1968 than the same cows gave us in 1967.
Comment on this
Two or three. This is what I want to know. Where in that debate did the Deputy give us even a hint of this knowledge which he says he had? I admit we did not know it. Apparently, we do not know the cows as the Deputy knows them, or the farmers either. I should like the Deputy to put on record now that in Volume so-and-so, and on such and such a date, he gave us a hint that he knew what the cows were going to do in the five or six months which have now passed. This would be useful. It would establish the Deputy as a new type of expert, the man who can see into the future the milk the cows are going to give, and no doubt calculate the weather we are going to have, the manner in which the grass is going to grow and how much sunshine we are likely to have.
All these things would have to come into the calculation which Deputy O'Higgins made before the Budget last year which gave him the knowledge to say: "Provide another £4 million for the extra 37 million gallons these same cows are going to give over and above what they gave in 1967." This is a question the Deputy can answer by showing to us in his contribution then that he had the knowledge. Perhaps, if he has not indicated it and if he has it, he will tell us the exact scientific approach he used to come to this conclusion which none of my advisers, technical or otherwise, were capable of projecting to that degree.
Comment on this
I have been asked a series of questions. I am entitled to remind the Minister that I indicated at the time of the last Budget that the provision in the Budget for agriculture was inadequate. I queried why the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, who had not partaken in the debate—it was my recollection that he intervened in a hurry at the end—had not made better provision. I indicated the subsidy provisions in the Budget were inadequate in relation to the agricultural situation.
Comment on this
There is no doubt about it that there are not many people with a mind like that or with such a way of discovering something new. It is almost a human computer with a built-in crystal ball.
Comment on this
We have now discovered that last April some colossal conversion had taken place. Here is a man who did not think that our provision for agriculture in the present Book of Estimates was nearly enough for the farmers without specifying we are short £4 million for milk. That has not been covered, despite the good answer given. We will excuse that. Last April the Deputy was concerned that we did not provide sufficient in subsidies for the farming community, despite the fact that our provision was then four times greater than the total amount that he and his Government provided in 1956-7. This is really a conversion which is nearly as big as the conversion of Fine Gael to the point where they declared a Republic in 1948. It is tantamount to that and deserves to be noted and recorded. It was as big a change as was that great decision taken at that time and announced outside the country. I think it was announced in Canada.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins, I have never had the habit of turning my back on the Chair or on anything else.
Comment on this
The reply I have quoted is pretty well known. The Deputy craves the protection of the Chair when it suits him and only when it suits him. The testiness of the Deputies is very noticeable. You are as sore as boils at the moment, whatever is wrong with you. You are supposed to be celebrating a victory but you are like a crowd who had a wake yesterday and are expecting another tomorrow. I do not blame you.
Comment on this
Come the day of the next general election, if some of you with a little money lay the odds beside where your talk is, I will take them as to who is going to win.
Comment on this
I am asking Deputies who are making noise over there to put their money beside their talk and to lay the odds themselves.
Comment on this
I have not the habit of slipping up behind anybody's back. If that is the practice in your constituency I do not know anything about it.
Comment on this
It suits Deputy O.J. Flanagan. We have SOS—Save Oliver's Surplus and preserve Deputy O'Higgins.
Comment on this
However, to get back to the wonders of today, we have already found the wonder of the knowledge of Deputy O'Higgins in regard to milk and cows and things pertaining to farming in this country.
Comment on this
I am coming to that. Here is, if anything, an even greater wonder. If what the Deputy alleged here the other day is true even greater tribute is due to his insight and foresight and knowledge of agriculture and all it means. Here we have a man who says that last April he knew that we needed £1½ million or thereabouts over and above what was provided in the Budget in order to pay for the extra wheat our farmers would produce over and above our needs for milling purposes. The winter wheat was well on its way in April but the spring wheat was only just getting its nose up. The Deputy was able by some computer mechanism he has installed to compute at that time when the little ears were coming up that they would provide a bumper crop of wheat. He knew that there was going to be a new record yield per acre, a yield never before known to even the most ambitious farmers in the country. Deputy O'Higgins knew it well. He knew it so well he could charge my colleague, the Minister for Finance, with being dishonest in his preparation of the Budget by not providing an additional £1½ million to cover this excess of wheat over and above our needs for flour and bread purposes. However, Deputy O'Higgins did not tell us that he knew this record was going to be created. Probably the greatest thing of all Deputy O'Higgins was able to know was that, out of that yield of nearly 36 cwt. of wheat per acre, 98 per cent would be of millable quality.
This is astounding. It is absolutely phenomenal. It is the greatest thing of all time. If we can have these projections now, even six months ahead; if he can tell us that we are going to plant so many acres of wheat this year, that this will produce so many hundredweights per acre next year, it could be of great value not only to the Government but also to the farming community because they would then know to the exact penny how much they would make on their wheat. They would know what profit would ensue from their activities in this regard. I do not suppose there is any fault in the Deputy's computer that would not allow it to be used for telling us about barley and how many ears per stalk will grow inside. This is a colossal thing. It is one of the greatest finds of our time. We in this country and in this Parliament should put this man to work and get him a job in this great field.
This is the dream of the planners of economies everywhere. We could, in fact, not only make a great job of our own country with this knowledge and insight but we could make a fortune by selling the services of Deputy O'Higgins to other countries where the planners are only groping about with such calculations. This is the biggest thing that has ever come about. Everything pales into insignificance compared with the Deputy's new-found attributes that give him this sort of knowledge which could be turned to such great effect.
It would be a shame, a loss to the community and to the farmers, whom Deputy O'Higgins knows so well, if he did not make this knowledge available to them and make it available right away. It would be unfair, not only to this generation, but to the generations to come if this knowledge were not used in a proper way.
Comment on this
Has the Minister finished his lament for the fact that he does have means of talking to the farmers? Will he move on to the public service? I am surprised that Deputy Gibbons did not tell the Minister that wheat was increased and that milk was increased.
Comment on this
I know a good deal more about these matters than the Deputy does. I do not profess to foresee wheat yields although I know a good deal more about this than the Deputy.
Comment on this
This is a valedictory address by the outgoing Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. Deputy Lalor is grinning behind him and so is Deputy J. Gibbons. Which of these Deputies will get the job?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins should not take it on himself to direct any of us on this side of the House as to what we should or should not do, particularly those of us who are called upon and are entitled to have the floor of the House to make our contributions in our own way.
Comment on this
Without interruption, Deputy, I and others are entitled to talk but with or without interruptions, talk we will about the matters that the Deputy does not want to hear. There is no point in Deputy O'Higgins hiding his light under a bushel and running away from the claim that he undoubtedly can prove, that he has this knowledge and this insight, this ability to predict the future, to predict the amount of milk that a cow will give and the grains of corn that the wheat or barley will produce. He might as well bring the oats into it also and let us have a computerisation of the entire grain policy. There is no point in his being modest. He should stand up and give the benefit of this attribute to the community. We shall all be thankful for this sort of knowledge.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not try to water it down and say that everybody knew there would be more wheat and more milk. What everybody knows is one thing but what the Deputy knows in an exact way is quite another thing. He should not depart from the claim that he has already made—that he knew last April that which nobody else on this side of the House and nobody on the other side of the House knew. Not even Deputy Donegan who was sitting beside Deputy O'Higgins on the day he made that contribution knew and he is a man who has been in the grain business for a long time. He buys, sells, stores and dries grain. He also makes calls on the farmers in his area in connection with the sale of fertilisers. Even he did not know this.
I suppose Deputy O'Higgins is not only adept at forecasting and, indeed with certainty, telling us what the produce of the cows would be but he also took the Minister for Finance and the Government to task for not providing in the Budget of last April the amount of money that would be required this year to meet the wage claims and the salary adjustments that had not even then been commenced to be decided or negotiated. He claims to have known how much we would need over and above to meet salary and wage claims and adjustments that had not even then been served, let alone decided, and, indeed, some of which are not even yet finally determined. He knew then but he did not tell us. This was very naughty of Deputy O'Higgins. It was not fair at all. He was not playing the game of the good citizen that he really is. Perhaps, he forgot. He might be excused for forgetting to give us the information. Of course, he does not like the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries. I am quite happy about that; in fact, I should be very worried if it were otherwise. Had he given us this information last April we might have known a little more about what we were going to produce, but this might not have been a good thing. But, apparently, it might have shown that I had more knowledge about farming than I have, that I had an insight into it that is superhuman. This would not do. This might put Blaney up a step. Also, if he was told about the wheat, this might in some way be used to Blaney's advantage and that would be bad.
But, when it comes to the provision of money for the public service of this country, the civil servants, the members of State boards and all others who draw sustenance from the State Exchequer one way or another, the Deputy surely had not this excuse to make for not imparting this knowledge. Why did he not tell us then that £9 million more than we were providing for would be needed before the year was out?
I do not think he can be forgiven for this unless he has an explanation that none of us can really think about. I do not think there is any excuse for not imparting this very important knowledge, for not correcting the Government and the Minister for Finance at that time and keeping them on the right financial track: I do not think there is any excuse for not making them put up the taxes higher last April than the Government and the Minister for Finance announced in that Budget. The Deputy should have told us.
If we required to put another 2d, 3d or 4d on the fags last April, Deputy O'Higgins should have said so. If we required liquor to go up, he should have told us. Now, what I do not like at all, he comes along and says we are to blame, that we should have known, that he knew. I think this is wrong. I think it is unfair of Deputy O'Higgins to gibe at this Government for not making provision for these unknown things to ordinary mortals like ourselves over here. He said he could see in the crystal ball what we did not know about, namely, that £9 million more would be needed. It was terribly unfair of him not to say all that last April.
It is now being said that we did know, whereas, in fact, we did not know and could not know because we have not this inbuilt computer that Deputy O'Higgins has recently developed. However, an extra £9 million clear is needed between now and the end of next March; an extra £4 million is needed in order to pay for the additional great yields from our farmers and an extra £1½ million is needed for the wheat from a phenomenally good crop that has the highest millable percentage of all time; a yield that is a record for this country; a yield beyond that which we were seeking or even hoping to get. All that amounts to £14½ million. There are three items that Deputy O'Higgins could have told us about. Now he blames us for not including them at that time.
We publicly confess we could not have known at that time that these things would happen and that they would cost that additional money but Deputy O'Higgins knew it and he knew it at that time. He now says that we were really trying to cod the people. It was not that he was afraid to say it to us lest he might hurt our feelings when we were doing an honest job according to our lights and that he did not want to disturb us. No. He says we also knew and concealed this from the April Budget in order to present a false Budget in the hope that this would in some way affect the referendum which some of his colleagues said was expected last June. Deputy O'Higgins is not being honest: that is to say the very least about it. He is being far from honest when he makes these assertions and these charges. Unless he can — by a display of this inbuilt computer that he has now got, this new mystical insight and foresight that he is now saying he has got — show us clear evidence that he has this quality that we never suspected before, then we can only say that it is not we who have been dishonest but Deputy O'Higgins who has been blatantly dishonest in all of his harangue about this supplementary Budget.
Deputy O'Higgins can and will have his opportunity. As I say, I shall await him with open arms to disprove my belief that his assertions on this Budget are the dishonest participation in this debate and not the action of the Minister for Finance last April. By coming along and offering his services; by projecting next year's wheat acreage, the yield, millable quantity percentage and the price the people will get; by telling me, in Agriculture, how many cows will give how many gallons and the profit; how the grass will grow; what day will be fine and what day will be wet; whether it will be a good or a bad grass season; whether it will be a good or a bad hay season: all of these things the Deputy can tell me if he has been honest with this House. If he cannot, or if he will not, tell me those things then he is not standing by the farmers of this country whom he claims to know so well and for whom he alleges he has such great regard because this is a service to them, not to me. This knowledge is vital to them. I have not got it. I am human and mortal. I am without this inbuilt knowledge or insight or crystal ball that the Deputy seems to have. He can give the information if he has it. If he does not, he is losing faith and face with the people of this country.
If Deputy O'Higgins chooses to give the information then it will authenticate the claims that this Budget of last April was conceived in dishonesty and presented with an ulterior motive last April by the Minister for Finance, Deputy Haughey. If, on the other hand, he cannot produce the evidence and show his good faith by putting that knowledge at my disposal and at the disposal of the farmers of this country then Deputy O'Higgins stands condemned as the man who has been dishonest in his contribution and in his assertions on these Financial Resolutions and on this Budget when it was introduced a week ago. That is fair.
Deputy O'Higgins has his course open to him. I am sure, before the week is out, we shall hear from the Deputy. If, by next week, we have not heard from Deputy O'Higgins then we can only take it — as, indeed, I unfortunately suspect — that the Deputy, in fact, will be shown to be a man who has been misleading; a man who has been making assertions that are not honest; a man who has been blackguarding the Minister, who is now absent, unfortunately, through illness, and all that went with him in the preparation of that Budget, honestly done and undertaken and presented to this House at that time.
Let us go on from there and see how we have fared during this past year and what the likelihood and chances are of faring well in the future. When we are considering what our prospects are in the future, we must have regard to how the engine worked in the past — in the recent past and farther back. Indeed, if there is this talk — as the Deputies over there like to talk amongst themselves, particularly in and around this House and more so here than anywhere else — that there should be a change, then we must also, in fairness to ourselves and to the people outside, have a look at what the alternative to the Fianna Fáil Government would be. Thereby, we get very enlightening figures.
The last opportunity we have to compare this Party and this Government would be with the Coalition Government of 1954-1957. These indicators can, I think, be taken in any economy as fair indicators and a fair barometer on how fares the Government and what is the welfare of the country at any given time. How fares the country? Growth rate is important to our wellbeing. Under that alternative government, the Coalition Government, the only alternative then and the only alternative now, we find that Government saw, during 1954-57, the results of its great efforts and its great promise in a growth rate of a miserable ½ per cent. That was the Coalition's growth rate during those three years 1954 to 1957 — one half per cent. I cannot but be somewhat annoyed with that retarding of our progress, with that miserable ½ per cent that the Coalition recorded after all their efforts from 1954 to 1957. One miserable ½ per cent per year — that was the record of all their sweat.
Comment on this
——but the Deputy may depart. This ½ per cent average growth rate in the three years of the Coalition Government is to be compared with an average growth rate of 3¾ per cent during the ten years of Fianna Fáil Government from 1957 to 1967. Maybe Deputy O'Higgins has another sort of computer that will show that a ½ per cent is greater than 3¾ per cent; that may satisfy Fine Gael but it will not satisfy anybody else.
Exports are a very important element in the economy of any country but particularly of our country which depends so much on its exports. During the years 1954 to 1956 exports went down by £2 million per year. That was the record of the Coalition Government during those three years, and that Government is the only alternative to Fianna Fáil. From 1957 to 1967 the increase in our exports was an average of £16 million per year. Therefore, exports go up under Fianna Fáil up to last year, the latest available figures, as against an average downward trend of £2 million per year in the three years of the last Coalition Government.
Some people say: "Why accumulate external assets? Let us blow them." Maybe they are right, but at the same time we must remember that these assets do not belong to one, two or three of us; they are the assets of the nation. It has been held by all the economists we have ever heard speak — that is, bar the scatty ones; there are always a few of those in every profession—that it is necessary for a trading country to have a reasonable amount of money available to them quickly in external assets. When the last Coalition Government came in in 1954 our external assets stood at roughly £241 million. Of course, it will be said the value of money fell since then. Fair enough; it fell somewhat, but if it fell during those following three years, in order to have an equivalent value in our external assets it is obvious that, under a wise Government, that £241 million would have increased, to take account of the decline in money value. But what happened? Instead of the assets increasing to take account of devaluation, they went down. Just the same as the exports went down the external assets went down. This is something that I hope the people here, over there and outside will take note of, that our external assets were allowed to go down from £241 million in 1954 to £183 million at the end of 1956, whereas our assets now stand, not at £183 million as we found them in 1957 when we came back into office, but at approximately £295 million.
This is noteworthy, because when we came back in 1957 things were in a bad way. Nobody knows that better than the people over there. There were all sorts of bills lying about that had to be paid and there was no money to pay them. As a new Government we had to find ways and means of paying the debts of the Coalition Government. We had to find a few million pounds to make up the deficit in the Budget that was left as a legacy to us by the very people who are blasting us now about dishonesty in Budgets. I have not the actual figures here; I will get them before I finish, but relative to the total Budget of that time, the error in the Budget of 1956-57 was far greater than the alleged error made by Fianna Fáil in relation to the present Budget. And there are reasons this year in regard to milk, wheat and wages and salaries that did not arise in 1956-57.
Therefore, if Deputy O'Higgins wants to go home with arguments, let us give him the arguments. Let him make his charges. Let him compare his own performance as a partner in the Coalition of that time, using the same yardstick but without any of the causes of the increases which have arisen this year. Let him compare the Coalition Government's performance with ours. On that basis, if the Budget of last April was dishonest, the dishonesty of the 1956-57 Budget beggars description. I will get the actual figures but, broadly speaking, there is no doubt the error displayed in the deficit in the Budget we inherited in 1957 was, relatively and percentagewise, far greater than the error alleged by Deputy O'Higgins to have been made in the Budget of last April.
All the economists tell us is that savings as a percentage of gross national product are a fair indicator at any given time as to the state of the nation. So we have the records showing that savings during 1956, expressed as a percentage of GNP, stood at 7 per cent. In 1967, under Fianna Fáil Government as distinct from Coalition Government, that 7 had been converted to 12 per cent—a healthy 12 per cent savings expressed as a percentage of GNP. Again, on comparisons, they are beaten by many points. Another thing which is worthy of note is the matter of capital inflow and outflow to a country, denoting in its various ways the healthy state or otherwise of an economy.
What do we find about 1954-57, a period when we should have expected that all the friends the Coalition allegedly had, who had gone away during the period of Fianna Fáil Government and who would come back to reap the benefits of Coalition Government? Not only were the people still going out of the country in numbers approaching something we have never seen before but, in fact, the capital outflow was running at an average of £1 million annually.
So, instead of attracting money in to develop our country during those three years, in addition to all their other failures there was a net outflow of capital of £1 million annually during those three years. When we look at that and stop to think, we begin to realise just what sort of a Government would be in prospect if we had to have an alternative to Fianna Fáil tomorrow, next month or next year. There is nothing in prospect but a return to Coalition and Coalition Governments have a record on all the worthwhile points I have indicated. They have a record there on the economic barometer which shows them up in a very poor light as to performance for the benefit of the economy.
That is the serious thing about all the squawking and the talking about how much Fine Gael want an election and about how they will come back as a Fine Gael Government. Maybe they can cod themselves that far, but the Lord save us, let them not for a moment think they will cod the people of the country sufficiently to allow that to happen. It will not. The gentlemen have not a chance so let them not waste their time thinking they have. There is the danger that at the same time as they make these big claims they will annoy the people who provide the only possibility of getting them into a Government—the aid and assistance of the Labour Party. If a situation should arise when Fianna Fáil could not get an overall majority—I do not for one moment believe it could—Fine Gael's chances of participating in a Government lie with the boys over there. They know as well as I that they have not a hope of making it on their own. That is one bet that Deputy Coughlan would not chalk the board on.
Comment on this
We all do but that is beyond even the Deputy's capacity. I left out a figure which I should have given in fairness to the Coalition. I mentioned capital inflow and outflow and said there was a net outflow of £1 million for each of the three years of Coalition Government. I should have given that figure of £1 million a year as compared with the ten-year average inflow during the ten years of Fianna Fáil Government since 1957. In those years, up to 1967, the average capital inflow was £20 million per year. That is the end of the tables for the moment. They provide a good all-round barometer—they all point the finger in the same way—that Coalition performance cannot match the performance of Fianna Fáil Government. On each of the six heads of the economic barometer to which I have referred, which are taken as a guide, an indicator, in every economy in the world, the Coalition Government come out very badly, on the wrong side of each.
This economic barometer, applied to the years of Coalition administration, indicates definitely that we shall not have progress if we should by any chance, mischance or otherwise, get around to the point of electing another Coalition Government. We are realising to a large degree that if Fianna Fáil do not get an overall majority — I do not for a moment believe they will fail to do so——
Comment on this
We have good reason, when all the smoke has cleared away, to expect that the people will see that their hopes stand on having Fianna Fáil Government because our record, compared with the only alternative, a Coalition, is so far ahead that it just is not a race. That is the picture. It is why, in a logical sort of way, I say to Deputy Coughlan: "Put down the old money, give us a bit of the odds——"
Comment on this
The Minister will get into a lot of trouble. The Revenue people can fine him £500 for operating without a licence.
Comment on this
You cannot accept it in here or outside. You will have to join the profession. You have not got a licence.
Comment on this
Even if we did it with buttons — two or three to one — we would have a bit of sport. As I have said, the indicators in every respect point in the one direction, to vote Fianna Fáil for your own sake, for the sake of the country, because the alternative can only be a Coalition. In that respect I advise Fine Gael not to be making all the big talk because all they are doing is annoying Labour. If, by any mischance, we should not have an overall majority in Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael's only hope would be to join with Labour, so they should not annoy Labour to such an extent that they would not join with them. As I have said, and regardless of all the pious statements by Fine Gael and Labour that it will not come to pass, if Fianna Fáil should not get an overall majority, these two Parties would combine their strength and, if by so doing they could beat Fianna Fáil for Government, they would coalesce. They may say in good faith: "Not on your life. We will not touch them with a 40-foot pole." I say that if such a situation arose at a general election, regardless of all the pious promises, there will be a coalescing of the same two Parties to replace Fianna Fáil as a Government.
Comment on this
With all due respect, the Minister has been looking into the future with regard to Fine Gael and ourselves. Why did he not look into the future with regard to the farmers last April when he was told what was happening?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Higgins, with all his knowledge, kept it to himself. He did not like me enough to give me this information, and I am sorry. Maybe he is sorry too. I have asked him to give me the information for next year and maybe we will have a supplementary Budget to raise the taxes for these very worthy causes: £4 million for milk; £1½ million for wheat; £9 million for the workers and those in the public service, the civil servants, the Gardaí, and all the other paraphernalia to which this money is to go.
Comment on this
As I was saying to Deputy Coughlan in a particular way, and indeed to the other Deputies in the two Opposition Parties, even though you make these pronouncements in the best of good faith from now until the eve of the next general election that there will be no more coalition, if by any chance you should get enough to beat Fianna Fáil for the Government I say — and not in any sense by way of reflection — that you will coalesce. This is what you will do and there is no point in trying to make people believe you will do otherwise. You will go together if you get an opportunity, no matter a damn what you said before. This would be a misfortune. It would give us a coalition with the sort of results I have pointed out here tonight.
There have been a number of other statements about the Government and their lack of ability to do this, that or the other, and that Fine Gael could do better. We have heard the sneering of Deputy O'Higgins about our lack of knowledge in finance in preparing last year's Budget. That I have dealt with to some degree already. We also had Deputy O'Higgins telling us that we have done no planning during our period of office or that no planning was evident during the past year and the present year. I wonder what Deputy O'Higgins had in mind? Why does he say we have not been planning for the future? Why does he say that since the evidence is there, even though the plans may not have worked out according to plan. He cannot accuse this Government or the Fianna Fáil Governments for the last nine to ten years of not having a plan; they even published their plans. We have been publishing plans since away back in the 1950s and Deputy O'Higgins says there is no planning under Fianna Fáil. Maybe Deputy O'Higgins, bright in some spots, will forecast milk production and the wages a man may get after bargaining a year or maybe he has a blind spot and has not seen any of the programmes for economic expansion that have been produced and discussed in this House — and even criticised by Deputies as to whether they were correct or not. Deputy O'Higgins cannot be serious unless it is that corresponding to the bright spot he has displayed, there is a complete blank on the other side and there are certain things he does not see at all.
There has been a little play on "who is your leader?" I am asking Fine Gael — who is your leader? It is not evident. One cannot have them saying things about us which are not true and not have them saying these things about themselves. Do you all agree with your Leader? How long will you keep him? Have you real belief in him?
Comment on this
Fine Gael is united behind Deputy Cosgrave. Perhaps the Minister would tell us something about the farmers' situation for which he is responsible.
Comment on this
I thought Deputy T. O'Donnell was placid but apparently he has the same touchiness——
Comment on this
——which his colleagues both young and old have been displaying here tonight. There will be coming before you in this House the Estimate for the Department of Agriculture for the year 1968-69 and, coupled with that — it has been agreed that they be taken together — a Supplementary Estimate for £8-9 million additional aid for farmers. Then I am told I do not seem to be in touch with and have no care for those on whose behalf I, as Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, will be bringing into this House an Estimate and Supplementary Estimate, totalling for the current year almost £80 million. If the Deputy wants to discuss agriculture and my care for the farmers in detail on this discussion, I will oblige him, but I know the Chair may not wish this to be discussed in that way and it would be a duplication of the much more detailed discussion Deputy T. O'Donnell and I and others will have within, I hope, a week. I am waiting to get this through, to slam it into Fine Gael that the farmers of this country are getting this year almost £80 million against the miserable £17.5 million which you in your hey-day as coalition could provide for them in 1956-57. That is a full play on its own, all the second and third acts of it and it would be a pity to spoil it by making it a trailer now.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister would tell us about the penny a gallon on the first 7,000 gallons.
Comment on this
I have no sympathy with 400-cow farmers. I never had and I never will and hence the penny on the first 7,000 gallons has typified my attitude as between the small farmers who need assistance from the Exchequer and the large farmers who not only do not need it but in fact are getting more out of it than they need or deserve.
Comment on this
Indeed — and the men I referred to now will not resent it — Fianna Fáil have seen that that day is past in the farming community and the lads who had not a backside in their trousers are now driving about in their cars and machinery and more power to them. It was under Fianna Fáil that was done.
Comment on this
And one shilling a gallon for the milk. We would not need a Supplementary Budget if we were to take the advice of Deputy James Dillon. He is a decent man but not as Minister for Agriculture. I still enjoy the man when I hear him. If we stuck to the one shilling a gallon, which was the offer Deputy James Dillon as Minister for Agriculture made to the farmers, instead of our needing £4 million additional for milk support at the moment we would be saving £24 million and we would have——
Comment on this
A minimum, and it is even 2/4d in money value today and the farmers are getting less than 2/-d.
Comment on this
I was really going to finish there but I was reminded of Deputy Dillon again. All I am saying is that instead of this £4 million more which has contributed to the need for these additional taxes that the Supplementary Budget has to impose in order to keep our economy fairly well level and its Budgetary provisions near the mark, if we were only giving that promised bob a gallon to the milk producers of this country as offered to them and advocated for them by the then Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Dillon, we would by that very exercise today——
Comment on this
Wait until you hear the end of the figures. By that very exercise we would be saving a bob a gallon and this measure would mean at least a saving of £24 million. Deputy L'Estrange accused Deputy Allen of trying to have it both ways.
Comment on this
I went out for my tea and got in again. The Deputies over there, particularly Deputy L'Estrange, is the last man who should talk about wanting to have it both ways because this is exactly what Deputy L'Estrange seeks to have. He would like to boast about the success of Deputy James Dillon as Minister for Agriculture in the Coalition Government but he wants to forget the folly of their Minister for Agriculture, he likes to forget promises such as the bob a gallon. You cannot have it both ways. If you like to let it be known that Deputy Dillon is a great orator this is OK. This is fine.
Comment on this
This is fine, I agree, but if you want to let it be known that he was a great Minister for Agriculture with this I cannot agree.
Comment on this
If you want to say that he did the job well I cannot agree with you and I certainly cannot let you away with the outward belief that Deputy James Dillon never did really mean a bob a gallon when he said a bob a gallon.
Comment on this
I am sorry, a Cheann Comhairle. When I say that Deputy Dillon said a bob a gallon then Deputy L'Estrange says I am misrepresenting him. Would I be misrepresenting him if I went back to 1948 when he said that he would bury the British in bacon and drown them in eggs? That was the bacon and eggs policy of Deputy Dillon, Minister for Agriculture. Would I be wrong if I quoted that as something he said and really meant because it was given great publicity at the time?
Comment on this
Deputy, we imported butter that we described as yellow because it was yellow during his years in office. Do you remember that? Do you remember that we had to import butter which, though it might be good quality, was not to our taste and we did not like it.
Comment on this
On a point of order. May I ask if it is in order to go back over past history in this debate because if that be the case surely we are at liberty to speak about the British market being gone and gone forever, the economic war, the slaughtering of the calves and all the havoc that Fianna Fáil wrought on Irish agriculture?
Comment on this
They are only provoking me. If you could only control them for a few minutes, Deputy, I would not be going back so far.
Comment on this
There is nothing to straighten out between the Taoiseach and myself or any member of Fianna Fáil or any supporter of our organisation. There just is no difference between our outlooks on the Border. We in Fianna Fáil were founded to get rid of the Border and you know it as we know it. There is no divergence of opinion; there never has been and there never will be as long as there is a Fianna Fáil. That is what you resent.
Comment on this
Do not be codding yourself with that red herring because if you do I will probably say something that will really annoy you.
Comment on this
What is bothering the Opposition is that the Taoiseach should not have been annoyed, that he did not get annoyed. That is all that is bothering you. I am sorry for your trouble but we could have told you that.
Comment on this
The fact that Deputies in Fine Gael, particularly in the Front Bench, think like this is indicative of the dilemma they face in their own minds because, as I asked before Deputy L'Estrange came in, who, in fact, is your Leader?
Comment on this
I will not go any further, Deputy, with that conservation. We will leave it at that.
Comment on this
No, sufficient for you and the House to know that I know what you think about your Leader and I am not going to say any more.
Comment on this
What has the leadership of Fine Gael got to do with the supplementary Budget? Surely the Chair can give a ruling on that?
Comment on this
The Chair has already said on a number of occasions that the Financial Resolution and the Budget are before the House. Other matters are irrelevant in this debate.
Comment on this
They got the 1d and the subsidy as well. The poor ones got it in full but more about that next week.
Comment on this
It will be a long play with many acts but they are all good ones. It is the best year farming ever had. Even the Deputies over there, try as they may, cannot conceal that fact and I am sure they will not attempt to in fairness to their own sort of front of honesty that they have been trying so hard to put up of late. They will not attempt to make out it is anything but the best year they have ever had.
Comment on this
We cannot have that too long for the reason that this supplementary amount of money, this supplementary Estimate, that I have coming up and you have so kindly agreed to take with the main Estimate I must have through by a certain date. Otherwise this extra money that I will be providing cannot be paid and they will blame Fine Gael and, hell, that would not be fair.
Comment on this
Will the Minister be looking for the farmers organisations in the gallery next week?
Comment on this
The honesty of last year's Budget is the big matter that is being questioned by Deputy O'Higgins, Fine Gael's Front Bench spokesman on Finance. I have been pointing out to him that these allegations of dishonesty against the Minister who prepared and presented that Budget last April are completely and absolutely unfounded and that any extraordinary foresight that Deputy O'Higgins could have, and that no human being in this or any other House could possibly have, was not in our possession here. Neither we as a Government, nor our Minister for Finance, can be blamed because this superhuman knowledge that Deputy O'Higgins had of cows and wheat, wages and salaries that had not even begun to be negotiated, we could not have in advance. That being so, if you take that factor away and say that only Deputy O'Higgins could possibly have that sort of knowledge, you must admit that the Budget, as presented and passed last April, was honest and fair and a good attempt at providing for our financial needs in the current financial year. It would just about have balanced had it not been for the good fortune of the farmers in getting 50 million extra gallons of milk during an extraordinarily good season, the like of which I have never seen before and very few others have seen. We got wheat to beat the band, quality beyond anything we have ever had before and quantity and yield per acre beyond the dreams of the most optimistic farmer. Also, through the collective bargaining of the trade unions with the employers of certain of their members and through the associations of civil servants and public servants during the time since April these people freely negotiated wage and salary increases and adjustments which, up to the end of next March, will mean an extra £9 million for those who benefited from the negotiations. These increases are in line with the millions that the other hundreds of thousands of workers throughout the land have negotiated in these same months.
That is something we could not possibly have known and provided for last April. Deputy O'Higgins could do it with no bother. He did no, tell us. I do not know why. Perhaps, he will give us the news for next year so that we can plan ahead but, whether he does or not, it is wrong of Deputy O'Higgins to make allegations of dishonesty and miscalculations against the Minister for Finance in preparing a proper Budget last year. The Minister, no more than any of us— except Deputy O'Higgins, who has for the first time disclosed his ability—has not a built-in computer system. This wonder-man of the ages can do a lot of good for the country in future if he puts to work the valuable asset he has now discovered in himself. Not only will it make millions for us but if we can have him at the disposal of the nation — and I am sure that having offered himself in such a capacity in the past he would gladly do so again for this great work of planning our future, predicting the growth rate of our wheat, the yield and out-turn——
Comment on this
As regards votes leave me to look after my own. The Deputy has enough to do in looking after his own votes.
Comment on this
When each one of us has finished garnering his votes in his own area he has had enough to do without trying to tell other people what they should do.
Comment on this
That weight of votes would be killing. What would I do with a half a million votes? That would frighten the Deputy out of his wits.
Comment on this
When the Minister cannot be selected for Taoiseach he cannot expect to be selected for President.
Comment on this
It is a pity that brother O'Higgins did not have the correct range as otherwise the Deputy would have got that prompt——
Comment on this
I should normally be finished in an hour as I am quite a fast speaker. Indeed, I could, perhaps, say it all in half an hour if I had been let alone and if the Opposition had not been trying to upset me by twisting things so that they would not make good sense but now, thanks to the interruptions, I have been slowed down in my rate of delivery and have had to go into more detail to show that what I am saying does make good sense.
As I was saying, we need this great asset, this wonder-man, if he can show that he has got what he claims to have, the ability to predict how much milk the cows would produce, how much wheat will be grown, how much barley and what will be the incomes of the farmers. Not only will this be an immense benefit to us in planning exactly our farming programme and, indeed, our economic programme as I am sure he can be switched over from agricultural to industrial forecasting. We shall be able to make a fortune on him, as I said earlier by hiring him out to all the other countries in Europe or, indeed, in the world. It seems to me that if we can get this business organised none of us will have to work again because he will be such a valuable national asset.
The Budget, in our humble opinion as ordinary human people, was designed in honesty and honestly presented on the basis of our needs and if there had been none of these changes I mentioned during the year, changes we could not have anticipated, the Budget would have been just about right and we could be saying to the Minister for Finance, who will no doubt be back hale and hearty before the end of the financial year: "You were dead on the button", instead of having this unfair criticism that the Minister conceived this Budget and presented it dishonestly with an ulterior motive so as to cod the public. Fianna Fáil have been here sufficiently long for the Opposition to realise that that is something we do not indulge in. The Opposition should learn from us that it is because we do not try to cod the people that we have been the Government, in spite of all that the Opposition could do to prevent it, for 30 out of 36 years. There is a lesson there for Fine Gael.
One might expect that even in this debate they would "get wise" to themselves. If they want to attack us they should keep their criticism within the credibility limit of normal people. They should also keep it as near as possible, if not bang on the button, within the limit of the matters that should be discussed. I do not mean that it should be tied into any particular sphere but the debate should be conducted in the realm of general politics. If they want to have "a go" at us, that is fair enough but instead they get down to the blackguarding and rumour-mongering that has been the hallmark of Fine Gael's efforts at frequent intervals over the years since they were Cumann na nGaedheal. I was quite small then but I never forgot you. You were blackguarding the people in Fianna Fáil at that time and telling the most outlandish stories about them. You did it approaching the 1948 election and you were back at it again around the 1954-55 period and I suppose, going in cycles in some queer way, it is motivating you again.
Comment on this
You are one man here who is going to be very worried one day if you open your trap outside and repeat the allegations you made in here. You will have no farm left. You will not be selling it to the Egyptian Jew or anybody else, it will be taken off you. You started a slander about me a few months ago and I want to nail you for what you are—a scandalmonger of the first order who has no regard to the truth, has no regard——