Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 4: Wholesale Tax (Resumed).
Contributions 378–574 of 762. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.
——for the personal character of anyone on this side of the House who you may blacken, regardless of what you may do or how untrue these allegations may be.
Comment on this
Deputy, I have waited and waited for you to have the guts to back up your big mouth and to go outside and give to the Gardaí the statement they asked you for when they came here after you made your false allegations.
Comment on this
I agree entirely, but the Deputy started this a while ago. Deputy Lindsay, unfortunately, has brought this discussion to the narrow debate that it is today. It is a direct jab at me, an allegation by innuendo which would indicate that my friends and associates are people who take bribes to get favours for their friends and acquaintances and that they sell favours which they get by their friendship with me. This is what Deputy L'Estrange charged me with by innuendo here a couple of months ago.
Comment on this
On a point of order, would it not be in accordance with the higher standards of Parliamentary decency if we went back to discuss what is before us, the Supplementary Budget? Let us remain on the Supplementary Budget and let us, as the Taoiseach is so fond of doing, wipe the slate clean.
Comment on this
The Chair is trying to keep the debate on the Resolution and it would appreciate the assistance of the Deputies in the matter.
Comment on this
I have been trying to get the record straightened somewhat because with people who are not straight it is——
Comment on this
Of course, Deputy, if it is the wish of the Chair and the wish of Fine Gael that I should be blackguarded——
Comment on this
——as I was by Deputy L'Estrange — and that blackguarding has been carried through into this debate by Deputy Lindsay and I am entitled to refute in so far as it is possible for me to do so, these base, false and groundless allegations—then by all means use pressure if you like to stop me.
Comment on this
It is on the records and no later than yesterday it was there again when we had the sludge pump Deputy from North Mayo, Deputy Lindsay, giving not only a rehash of what Deputy L'Estrange had alleged a couple of months ago but making many other groundless allegations against various members of this Party. I am only dealing at this moment with the charge that has been made by Deputy L'Estrange and reiterated by Deputy Lindsay. I want to say to Deputy L'Estrange that this is false and without foundation, that he has made this charge by innuendo in this House. As soon as it was made the Garda were informed and they came to this House and sought out the Deputy. In fact, that was the night that you had a fairly critical Fine Gael meeting when there nearly was a burst-up. Maybe that is what is bothering you. However, the fact of the matter was that the Deputy was asked to give to the Garda the information that he had spoken about in this House when he made, under privilege, these unsupported charges against me.
Comment on this
The Deputy would not give to the Garda any statement whatsoever except, as he said himself——
Comment on this
——that the Garda should read the Dáil Debates. It is one thing, Deputy, to be dishonest but it is another thing to be too cute. In referring the Garda to the Dáil Debates the Deputy was probably well advised by his legal friends about how he could get out of the obligation to say outside, by way of statement to the Gardaí investigating his allegation in this House, what he knew, if he knew anything that could stand up. I should like to say to the Deputy that, even now, I do not know and I never did know the man who was said to have got the money to get a planning permission during my time in the Department of Local Government. I do not even know him yet despite the innuendo that because a Donegal man was given——
Comment on this
The Minister for Justice admitted that he said he would use his influence. I do not know with whom he was using it.
Comment on this
You apparently know far more about the money and the man and the case than I do. I want to ask you and the members of you Party, the legal members particularly, is it a fact that you got whatever information you have from a member of your own Party, a legal member of your own Party, who got it through a colleague in the legal profession who was employed by one of the two parties to this dispute, and that he should be reported to his own Bar Association and knocked off the register for impropriety of conduct?
Comment on this
I will name him if you want me to. If there is anybody on any of those benches, or inside or outside this House, who can support any allegation of the nature made by Deputy L'Estrange and repeated by Deputy Lindsay, then I challenge him here and now to come out and put it on record and then we will find out which man has been treading the straight path and which man has been treading the crooked path. I have never——
Comment on this
I think the Minister will agree that the Chair has allowed the Minister to make his explanation.
Comment on this
My character is relevant to this debate and, if charges are made against me, I am entitled to reply.
Comment on this
All the Chair can do is point out to the Minister that this is irrelevant to the debate.
Comment on this
I agree it is irrelevant, but it was even more irrelevant when these false, baseless charges were made against me here and were, apparently, allowed to go on the record of the House, as they were allowed to go on the record of the House when Deputy L'Estrange was allowed to make them on an earlier occasion. Surely I have not indulged in breaking the rules as to relevancy when, in fact, it has been my character that has been taken away by two blackguards of Deputies who bloody well will not repeat the charges outside. These are the people who make the charges.
I shall finish as quickly as I can. Perhaps, on another occasion, I will be allowed to deal at greater length with these charges. In deference to the Chair, I will finish. I want to ask Deputy L'Estrange and Deputy Lindsay — if Deputy L'Estrange will listen to me for one moment — to back up their talk with some action outside this House, and we can then proceed——
Comment on this
Shut up, you dirty little gurrier. Will the gurrier shut up? Shut up you gurrier. If you want to start throwing muck then I can throw some, too, that will really stick to the Deputy. I do not indulge in this kind of thing. I give it to the Deputy politically but I do not like personalities. I do not like using or abusing a man's personality, even when I have the goods on me.
Comment on this
My name never was mentioned, but the accusation was made and there was a repetition of the accusation only yesterday by Deputy Lindsay. There was a direct assertion that a Donegal teacher demanded and got money for his services in unduly using influence on the then Minister for Local Government, also a Donegal man. The accusation was that this teacher got money and that planning permission was granted through his influence, the inference being that it was his undue influence, as a Donegal man, with me — because I was then in the Department of Local Government — that resulted in permission being granted, this undue influence being paid for and bought by a bribe. Do not try to sidestep it now. Take the challenge for what it is worth. I have never taken money from anybody for any of the jobs I did and I did as many as anybody else. This is one of the things in which I sincerely believe and, God knows, there were times when I could have done with money when I first came into this House. Never at any stage in the past, at the present moment, or in the future will anyone get Blaney taking money from anybody.
Comment on this
In the speeches from those benches! I did not expect they would go back on the implied innuendo. The charges were made here. Deputy Lindsay made them yesterday. There is no doubt about that. If Deputies now want to withdraw what was implied in what they said, it would be a good thing if they would withdraw unreservedly, because I resent it to a degree that could be dangerous.
Comment on this
There was no charge made against the Minister. As far as the Minister is concerned, I am quite prepared to say that we never made any accusation against him. We made the accusation against Kelly, that Kelly said he could, for a sum of money, get the permission. We do not know whether he got it, but we want to find out the truth. The accusation was never made personally against the Minister. It is only fair to say that.
Comment on this
The names of people outside the House must not be brought into debate in the House because they have no opportunity of defending themselves.
Comment on this
I will present to the House the record of what the Deputy said and the record of what Deputy Lindsay said yesterday, crossing the t's and dotting the i's. I will bring the two documents to the House. If the Deputies who have indulged in this innuendo and insinuation read what they said, they will see that there can be no mistake as to the direction in which the charges were levelled or for whom they were intended. I hope they will have the guts to get up and withdraw unreservedly the allegations they have made and recorded twice in this House. I will leave it at that. I will bring to the House on another occasion the two records. I hope the Chair will allow me to let the Deputies concerned hear the charges, made by innuendo, and give them an opportunity to withdraw them unreservedly.
Comment on this
We meant it for Kelly and we believe the matter should be followed up to the very last.
Comment on this
There is no point in pursuing this further. The Deputies made the allegation. They should not now try to waffle their way out or try to say they did not make the allegation. If they did not mean it, then let them tell us that they had no proof involving me in any degree in improper practices. If they have proof, then let them present it outside the House where it can be fully investigated.
Comment on this
Could we finish with this matter now and get back to the Financial Resolution and the Budget Debate?
Comment on this
We will get this thing straightened out. Straightened out it has got to be, and not for any purpose of getting people on the wrong foot, as far as I am concerned. All I am concerned about is my own character, and I am sure I will have the facilities of the House in order to straighten this thing out. I will be vindicated of this, or any other charge of a like nature, at any time during my entire career—indeed, during my entire life.
To get back to the Financial Resolution, the justification for this Budget is precise and clear. Wages, salaries, wheat, milk and sundry other items all benefit. That is the reason for this increased taxation. Deputy O'Higgins took the line that we did not budget correctly last April, even though we knew at that time that we needed the money. On the other hand, Deputy Corish argued that we do not really need the money and that we are anticipating next year's Budget in order to influence voters at the next general election. The two arguments are diametrically opposed. There is no validity in Deputy O'Higgins's argument and neither is there any validity in Deputy Corish's argument. We need £9 million to meet increases in salaries and wages in the public service. We need £4 million for milk. We need £1½ million for wheat. That makes a total of £14 million. All we will get between now and next March as a result of this increased taxation is £4.2 million. With a sum of £14½ million already earmarked for various things and revenue of £4.2 million, it is difficult to understand how there could be anything left over to give away at the next Budget in April of next year, prior to the general election. This must be the greatest miracle since the loaves and fishes. The total sum required is £14½ million. The revenue will amount to £4.2 million. Out of that it is argued there will be enough left to spread around the country to all the social welfare classes, to the farmers and others, and perhaps to reduce income tax.
That is Deputy Corish's summing up of the situation. He thinks that £14½ million can be taken out of £4.2 million leaving, probably, £50 million still behind. That is Deputy Corish's philosophy. We must have missed it. Fine Gael have got one of the wonders of the earth and here is someone not far behind. To be fair, Deputy O'Higgins, with his great knowledge and foresight, dealt only with agriculture. I was giving him credit that he would go on to speak about industry and finance and the general economy. Maybe I was wrong. Maybe there has been a visitation from outer space that has left its mark on Deputy Corish and on Deputy O'Higgins also. Maybe these two great things are arriving together. In the financial sense Deputy Corish thinks we can take £14½ million out of £4.2 million and still have £50 million left to give away in gifts to the people to buy votes. That is what Fine Gael and Labour say we want to do at the general election some months beyond next April.
Maybe there is a new order of things, but why did it pass us by? Perhaps it was thought that we had a fairly good grasp of how to run the country without getting this supernatural and superhuman inbuilt mechanism. Maybe it was ordained that we already have enough ability and that the pair over there needed some input to be given to them. Being an ordinary mortal I do not believe that Deputy O'Higgins knows something before it happens, as he indicated he knew something last April before it happened. Neither do I believe that Deputy Corish can perform miracles. I do not believe either of them. We cannot be codded that far. I am not easily codded. I do not believe that these things are on for Deputy Corish or Deputy O'Higgins. I do not think it is possible.
I believe we should have a little honesty from those benches. When we get to the point, which we seem to have passed now, at which the sky is the limit for the Opposition so far as lies and allegations without foundation are concerned, we are really on the downgrade as a nation and as a democracy. Our people must be aware of the scandalous lack of consideration given to the truth by the Opposition in this House when they want to press a case to the detriment of the Government. I hope that the people will take note of this and that they will build up a great kick on the behind for those boys at the next election which will not be too long——
Comment on this
Only some of them will return to those benches where they will just sit around as they are now, perhaps making big talk for the sake of keeping up their spirits for the election after the next one. We have had the experience of two coalitions in my time. Never again. We know they would form a coalition again if they got the chance on the morning after an election. Let us not allow that to happen. Let us have the truth. Let us get the record out, as I have been trying to get it out tonight, despite all the interruptions, and let the people decide on that record. If they do that, there is no danger of a coalition.
Comment on this
Our Government were supported as, indeed, this Government are supported. There are Independents supporting this Government. We did not buy support and we had no midnight sessions, as the Opposition Parties had, before forming a coalition. The Deputy should not draw me because I know far too much about the wheeling and dealing that went on.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that the Minister is the very man who on the night the turnover tax was passed stood the champagne?
Comment on this
It was not a point of order. It was used by Deputy Flanagan merely to get on the record something he was not entitled to say. I presume he has spoken?
Comment on this
It is far from bottles of champagne that Deputy Flanagan and I were reared. I am a non-drinker and so is the Deputy. Why should I not have bought a bottle of champagne on the night something went through the House?
Comment on this
What harm? I do not drink myself. Why should I not have the pleasure of giving a drink to someone else? Is there anything wrong with that?
Comment on this
No. Does the Chair agree that champagne should be bought after the imposition of severe taxes?
Comment on this
These little pop-ins are intended to put me off what I was saying. This time the Deputy has succeeded. I will probably come across something which annoys me even more like the turnover tax and the suggestion by Deputy Luke Belton that we coalesced before. I have said that we have had, as, indeed, we still now have, even though we do not need them numerically, the support of Independents in this Dáil. We had the support of Independents in previous Dáils. We have had the support of the Labour Party, Deputy Coughlan, even if you were too young then.
Comment on this
I was asking Deputy Coughlan whether on behalf of the Labour Party he contributes or subscribes to the view that we in Fianna Fáil coalesced wheeling and dealing bargains with his Party in 1932 to get their support or that we bought them to do it?
Comment on this
It would seem that the Chair must exercise his control in regard to the matter before the House. Questions and answers are not in order in the House. Unless the Chair is allowed to control the debate he will have no option but to take other steps.
Comment on this
The more they talk to me the better they like me. It is amazing but true. However, I will not embarrass Deputy Coughlan by pursuing the question. We will debate that at a more appropriate time.
Comment on this
I gave Deputy Corish a bit of advice last week. It will be a great day's work and suit both of you if you run Lipper in Wexford. I was being kind to you. You will not find me repudiating my leaders. That is more than can be said for many of your boys over there. Do not draw me on this.
Comment on this
We are talking about the danger that the country faces if there were sufficient people deluded long enough by the allegations made by the Fine Gael and Labour Front Benches in regard to these taxes and how they were imposed, why they were imposed and all the motives attributed to the last Budget and now to this Budget. They are conflicting but designed to complement each other and confuse the people and keep them in confusion until you get them to the ballot boxes at the general election. Then they might give the two Parties the opportunity to get together and wheel and deal in broad daylight or in the middle of the night and coalesce as they undoubtedly will have to if they get the chance, regardless of what sort of undertaking they give before the election that they will not go together. God help the country if that happens.
Comment on this
If you say beforehand that you are not going to go together and then if you get the opportunity and say that you will go together it is a crime. That is a crime against the people of this country.
Comment on this
In the last inter-Party Government the finest and most loyal members of the Government working as a team were the Labour Ministers.
Comment on this
Did you ever split it that way and tell your colleague you have a different opinion?
Comment on this
The Labour Party courtship is on. Many of your people think little of the Labour Party. On with the courtship.
Comment on this
You must arrange it before taking it to the people to get their votes. That is not asking too much.
Comment on this
I hope that this coalition will not come about. We cannot afford it at this stage in our progress. We cannot afford to have our progress not only stopped but reversed. We cannot afford to go back under the dead hand of a Coalition Government.
Comment on this
The Chair will not have any more interruptions. Deputy Flanagan will have an opportunity of speaking.
Comment on this
Some of the finest Minister this country ever had were Labour Members. They were men you would be proud to work with.
Comment on this
We cannot afford a Coalition Government in the future. I say that without any reflection on those who took part in the last Coalition Government. It has a bad record and we cannot afford a repetition. We are trying to get the Opposition to be honest enough not to try codding the people by telling them before an election that they will not coalesce and subsequently after the election wheeling and dealing to form a Government. If you do not pull something like that out of the hat there is no danger. The people will make up their own minds.
Before I conclude, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, there is something on which I want to take Deputy Lindsay to task. He did a totally unfair thing. When slandering people here last night he had a "go" at the ushers of this House. In reference to his attack on the members of Taca this is what he said: "They do not have to bother about coming to the gates or about the ushers. We meet them regularly in the corridors of the new building. We see them going into Ministers' offices without being ushered in by ushers or private secretaries. They have open sesame to the House and all its corridors."
I want to take Deputy Lindsay up on that. I hope he will be a gentleman and admit his grave error in slandering the ushers and the staff of this House by saying that they, in some manner best known only to him, have been carrying out their jobs improperly and that people of Taca or others have been allowed to come in the gates and around the corridors without an usher taking any notice of them or that the ushers are under instruction not to stop these fellows. I think this is a base charge made by Deputy Lindsay in a vicious and slanderous way. In throwing muck he is capable of slandering the ushers. I would ask Deputy Lindsay, if nothing else, to at least have the common decency to come in and withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon should not mind me, Taca or the ushers. He should just keep in mind his old friends, the Molly Maguires and the shoneens of the past of which there are still many. He should look to those for the last few years of his days.
Comment on this
The Minister should leave decent people alone. He is beginning to talk like the Hibernians.
Comment on this
Deputy Dillon is in reasonably good humour this evening, but he is typical of every member of his Party. He is as touchy as everyone of the members of Fine Gael. I am saying to Deputy Lindsay, through the Chair, and I hope it is conveyed to him by Deputy Dillon——
Comment on this
——that if he has any decency in him, which I doubt, he will come into this House and clear the ushers of the charges that he has made against them. We have known the ushers for a long number of years and they are a decent bunch of fellows, doing a job that is not always easy. They should be cleared by the Deputy who made that false, baseless charge. He should come in here and withdraw the remark that he made in this House within the last 24 hours.
Comment on this
The only thing that this House has been infested with and has suffered from during the years is people like the Deputy. He is like dry-rot in the roof. He came in away back 36 years ago on Fianna Fáil preferences, codded the people but, by God, he did not come back in Government——
Comment on this
——until in 1948 he came up on my bye-election and as every one of his Cabinet tried to do, tried to keep Blaney out of the House. What happened to the Deputy? The rats at that time were so well fed with the oats for which he promised the price that never materialised that they stood to attention as he went by and shouted "Up Dillon". When he got to Carndonagh he was beaten out of the square with oats.
Comment on this
Even the rats knew of the Deputy's promise to pay much higher prices for oats. They never had a winter like it before or since. To get back to this issue — I am sure the Leas-Cheann Comhairle, for his own reasons, will not be sorry——
Comment on this
——might I say that we will have a debate here on agriculture during the next ten days and if there is anybody in Fine Gael, including Deputy Dillon, who really can take it, I would ask them to be here for all of that debate, because this will be the debate above all other agricultural debates. We will show that, under Fianna Fáil and, since Blaney went to Agriculture, the past two years have been the two best years in the agricultural history of this country.
Comment on this
I wish to bring some sense into this debate. I have been listening to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries for exactly two hours and 13 minutes. Any man with a sprig of intelligence would have condensed what he said into a quarter of an hour. It was repetition after repetition. He almost brought us back to Brian Boru at Clontarf in 1014.
Then, having brought us back to things that happened 30 or 40 years ago, he jumped from 1954 to the future and started to tell us what will happen when Fianna Fáil are defeated. From what he said there is no doubt that he has resigned himself to the fact that Fianna Fáil are beaten. Their only aim now is to try to create an atmosphere of deception, to try, as the Minister himself mentioned, to cod the people.
Trying to cod the people is one thing. It has been fairly well accomplished by the Minister during the past few years. But now, having codded the people, they are setting about codding God. That is one thing they cannot do, but they are trying. The Minister sees himself as the great Cassandra, the great prophet and the great historian out of the past, but he has overlooked one fundamental — the plain, common people of Ireland. He, and many members of his Cabinet, have failed to realise that there are in this country plain, common people, people who can think for themselves. Indeed, the folly of the exercise carried out on the 16th of October can leave no doubt about this in the Government's mind. They got their answer when more than a quarter of a million people said "No" and it is not so long since more than one hundred thousand people changed their minds in the Presidential Election. However, having got these cautions and warnings, the Government still pursued this road to perdition.
Now they have introduced this Budget which is crippling, to say the least of it, but they tell us it is a mini-Budget. I should like to know what form a maxi-Budget would have taken if this was only a mini one. The people most affected were the people for whom Fianna Fáil have no time, the people on whom Fianna Fáil depended in the past and whom they fooled along the road for years— the plain, common, working people of Ireland. These are the people who are hit hardest in this Budget. The social club of the worker can be visited maybe only one night or two nights a week. When I speak of the social club of the worker I mean the ordinary public house into which the worker can go at night to discuss his problems, to have his social contacts renewed and to seek relief from the toil of a hard day. He has hit these people most through the imposition of taxes on beer, spirits and cigarettes. He has not hit the mini-millionaires whom we have in this country. He did not hit them because he could not. He is indebted to them through this consortium of theirs which they call Taca. He dare not touch those. He hit hardest the section of the people who deserve most and, if he did, what concession did he give to those who are hit hardest — the widow, the old age pensioner and all those living on social welfare benefits? He has not distributed a farthing amongst them or given them one second's thought or consideration.
Comment on this
Did he not do so in the last Budget and in every Budget since 1957? The old age pension was 22s 6d in 1957. What is it now?
Comment on this
On 16th October of this year, 300,000 people told Fianna Fáil to waken up and to take some "pep" tablets — be they illegal or whatever way you procure them; let it be LSD or purple hearts, or whatever it may be — to try to put a bit of life into the Fianna Fáil Party. Three hundred thousand people told Fianna Fáil in no uncertain manner that they do not want Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Is it not a fact that 100,000 changed from your support at the previous Presidential Election? I do not know how many hundred thousand changed from Fianna Fáil at the local elections——
Comment on this
The promise of this Government is: "Live horse and you will get grass." Here are these signs and warnings by the people who live and work in this country, the fellow who draws his weekly wage, the fellow who foolishly and stupidly in the past was codded by Fianna Fáil. I use the word "cod" because it was repeated so often here by the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.
Comment on this
Who made the jobs worth while for the ordinary working people of the country but Fianna Fáil?
Comment on this
Deputy Fanning will not be here much longer. Listen, I want to be charitable. Therefore, do not interrupt me.
Comment on this
Deputy Coughlan need not be charitable if he likes. I have nothing to run away from, anyway.
Comment on this
I shall not tell it to the Deputy. I want him to leave this House in peace because there will be no return.
Comment on this
These were the people who were hardest hit. He could not touch the mini-millionaires. On top of that, has he not closed the social club of the worker because he cannot frequent his "local" at night in future as often as he did in the past? Furthermore, the publican who supplied the comforts of the premises is hit harder than anybody else. With one exception, every item inside a public house door is taxed to the hilt —and more taxes to follow. If you want to know the exception, I shall tell it to you. The 2d box of matches is the only thing that is not taxed in a public house. Here we have men who came along and purchased these premises, who put a burden of debt on their shoulders, and, in every Budget that comes along, without exception I would imagine, the worker and the publican are hit hardest. Here is the deception and here is where the unseen dig comes in. While providing for these increases, there is added— which we have not heard of yet from the Fianna Fáil side of the House — the increase in turnover tax.
A man's turnover may increase or it may not increase because of these impositions but he has to pay the turnover tax on top of these increases, on top of the wholesale tax. This is something we have heard nothing about yet with regard to the imposition of these ruthless taxes. We now find that there are more increases being applied. The tea importers are looking for an increase. The soft drinks manufacturers are looking for an increase. The publicans are looking for an increase because of these taxes. On top of that, we shall have the worker and the wage-earner who has committed himself to agreements for one year or two years into the future: all these agreements are now gone by the board. Another round of increases is on the way. Some of them will be settled satisfactorily: more of them will not. In any event, we shall have closures and strikes and lockouts. This is what this Budget has done; let there be no doubt in anybody's mind about that. The trade union movement and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions came out in no uncertain manner during the referendum campaign, as they did in the previous one in 1959, and made their stand, made their statement, worked on it and won and defeated the Government on both occasions. This is the backlash which is typical of Fianna Fáil: "If you do not come with us, we shall destroy you: we shall wipe you out." That has been their approach.
A younger generation is coming up, and this is what the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Blaney, and the Minister for Local Government, Deputy Boland, refuse to see. This younger generation came out openly on the 16th October and told these buckos over there: "Come down off your high horse and live with us and work with us. Find out what we are thinking and how we are living." More than a quarter of a million of them said that.
The quicker Fianna Fáil face up to the situation which exists throughout the land the better. I know this is asking for a miracle. I know it cannot happen. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries talked about senile decay, but if there is a plague of senility in this land it is rampant in the Fianna Fáil ranks. They are living behind closed doors. They are living in Tír na nÓg. They are also living on borrowed time, because the people will give them their answer in the near future. Let the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries speak anyway he likes; he knows they will never come back with a majority. He is trying to confuse the issue now talking about coalitions and the curse of this and the curse of that. The greatest curse since Cromwell——
Comment on this
——and that is a long time ago, are the two Bs that occupy those benches over there, Boland and Blaney.
Comment on this
The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has promised to bring in something that will stun the world. We shall all be here to hear him when he brings in his Estimate next week. I will ask the Minister to fill the public gallery with the NFA, the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers, Macra na Feirme, Muintir na Tíre, the Irish Countrywomen's Association and all the other Agricultural associations. Will he take them off the channels of mud and out of the weather in which he left them——
Comment on this
Talk to the people concerned. The late John Feely worked hard for the farmers; you put him into an early grave. Talk to the people who represent the farmers.
Comment on this
If Deputy Fanning continues to interrupt I shall have to ask him to leave. We cannot have the debate carried on in this fashion.
Comment on this
I am proud to be a bookmaker. It is an honourable profession. I know they are ruffled. That is why there is nobody here except the poor Parliamentary Secretary. He just could not take it. The unfortunate creature they put in to hold the fort had to run away with his tail between his legs.
Comment on this
They cannot listen to the truth, but the people of Ireland have said it; the man in the factory has said it, and the small farmer has said it: "Get out and let somebody in who will be honest and do a good day's work for the country."
Comment on this
It must be worrying you. There was a time you would not mention it. You were too complacent sitting back in your armchairs in your slippers and with your cigars and the old bottle beside you.
Comment on this
I am not like some of the people with whom you are associated — the fellows that have not only the Mercedes but a little car for the wife to hop into for the messages and another one for the boys to go to school in. These are the people you cater for, and these are the people who are not included in this Budget because they have given you too much already. You have taken the 30 pieces of silver from them.
We do not mind raising money if money has to be raised. We must be practical. We cannot live on air. However, we disagree, first of all, on the method of finding this money. We also disagree with the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries on his statement in regard to the over production of milk. That surplus was there two years ago, and we tried to tell him. The butter was in the cold stores for two years and it is still there; so is the cheese. The surplus milk was let flow down the rivers, and every day of the week I saw it flowing down the Shannon into the Atlantic. We told him the surplus was there but he ignored it. No one can do anything except Fianna Fáil.
The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries comes along in the heel of the evening quoting figures, giving £6 million for this, and £14 million for that. However, he did not give us the breakdown of the millions of pounds, and he did not tell us this could have been saved two years ago if he had taken our advice, and I was one of those who gave it to him. If he had directed the agricultural industry along different lines instead of into the production of milk we would not be in the mess we are in today.
He gave the farmers a bounty on heifers and calves, but who got the benefit of this? It was the 400 to 500acre farmer, Lord This and Earl That. The man on the side of the road rearing seven or eight cows and doing a bit of work on the side as well got no benefit, because he had only six or seven calves every year if he was lucky. He could not buy 200 or 300 heifers and have them in-calf and get the bounty on the milk.
That is what happened. When I pointed out here two years ago that he was handling the agricultural policy from the wrong end, and when I tried to point out to him the necessity for improvement in the bacon industry, particularly, and in the beef industry, what did he do? He stuck his head in the sand, his whole carcase in the sand, and saw nothing. Accordingly, we find ourselves in this mess because of the blindness of that man and his predecessor. I must say I am sorry his predecessor is indisposed. All sides of the House regret it. Though we are no Casandras as the Minister has set himself up to be, or Old Moore's Almanac, as he has set himself up to be, we can see the barometer and the way the pendulum swings.
Comment on this
We live among the people and we know what they think. If the Parliamentary Secretary went back to Loughrea——