We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Committee on Finance. - Resolution No. 4: Wholesale Tax (Resumed).

Contributions 575–762 of 762. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 4 parts.

Like the Deputy, I hear the confessions.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary's would take a bit of hearing. As I have been saying, this is what has put us in a mess. The Budget introduced by the Taoiseach last week laid bare the fact that we warned about two years ago. We warned him about his folly then. We told him where it would lead him and though we must congratulate ourselves on that, we must also sympathise with the unfortunate people who are now being asked to carry the burden of his folly. It is no use trying to cod God. That is one thing. There is an old Latin phrase the Parliamentary Secretary knows as a schoolmaster: Deus non——

Comment on this

There is the one about those whom the Gods love they first make mad.

Comment on this

That is why you are here. It means that God will not be mocked. We have put the facts clearly before the people. We live with them and we know how they have to exist. That is what happened. It is tragic for any of us to see the impositions of this Budget descending on the working people. I ask Fianna Fáil Deputies to go into any of the social clubs in their constituencies on a Saturday night, the only night of the week people can afford to frequent them, and to listen to the sentiments, listen to a lad talking to his neighbour and ask him or his wife what he or she thinks of the alleged mini-Budget. If they go to the country in the morning — I know they will not, I know they have no more notion of going to the country now than Stalin had of going to the poll — they know what will happen. They are living in fear and trembling and their only resort is to a campaign of deceit and confusion with regard to what will happen after the next election. Let Fianna Fáil resign themselves to the prospect that whatever happens at the next general election they will not be over there afterwards. That is as much a certainty as Sir Ivor. In their dying political moments, I appeal to them to make restitution and to do penance for their political sins of the past. For them, the finger has written on the wall —Mana, Thekel, Phares. It is written on the wall in indelible ink.

Comment on this

The Deputy is very classical tonight.

Comment on this

That is my second nature. Charity is my first.

Comment on this

I was wondering what your first was.

Comment on this

I know what Fianna Fáil would do to me, back and front, with the sharpest knife they could get. However, if you have people who hate you and people who love you, the balance will swing in my favour. I appeal, though, to Fianna Fáil at this late stage to make restitution and to go to the people whom they have deceived and robbed so often within the last two years, and certainly within the last month in no uncertain terms. The people will tell them where to get off and they will go to rock bottom. It is the plain people of this country who suffer most under Fianna Fáil. I am sorry the Taoiseach did not come in earlier to hear my appeal to his Party in the dying moments of their political lives to do penance and to make restitution particularly to the small farmers, the wage earners of this country.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

This Supplementary Budget is another proof, if indeed any proof was needed, that Fianna Fáil are prepared to be less than honest with the people of this country. In his concluding statement when he introduced this mini-Budget, the Taoiseach, as acting Minister for Finance, said that Fianna Fáil never flinched from taking unpopular measures when they were necessary. He certainly flinched from taking unpopular measures when he deemed them to be politically inexpedient and inadvisable.

Last April when the Minister for Finance introduced the Budget, speakers from these benches, and in particular Deputy Sweetman, told them that this Budget was not a Budget that would last the year and was being introduced because of the forthcoming referendum, but they tried to laugh him to scorn. However, since last April the Government have found themselves no longer able to carry on and they want something in the region of another £18 million to try to continue on.

The Taoiseach, when he was Minister for Finance, introduced a second Budget in that year, and he then wanted to know what had gone wrong as he could not believe it was necessary to introduce a second Budget. He did not ask us this year what went wrong with the Budget. We all know what went wrong, because it was a Budget purely and simply designed to condition the people for events which lay ahead. On 25th April the Taoiseach said the Budget was a good one. He described it as a Budget which suited the needs of the present and also suited the hopes for the future.

I wonder, when he was talking of the hopes for the future, were those hopes the hopes of a success in the referendum. He had hoped at that time that his Budget would condition the people to accept the Government's proposals which we all knew were doomed to fail, proposals which assumed the character of being political but which were non-political when it suited the Fianna Fáil Party. We were told they were not political, that this was a national issue and had nothing to do with politics. Yet, at every council meeting throughout the country when it was introduced Fianna Fáil opposed it as being a political matter. However, the people of this country gave their answer in no uncertain terms to the Government in that referendum. Never before have a Government been so defeated, practically annihilated. The Government, because they neglected for nine months of the year to look after the finances of the country, because they were so occupied with this useless and wasteful referendum, could not see how the finances of the country were going. They did not know until now that they were so deeply indebted and once again we have them coming in here taxing the usual items — the pint, the cigarettes and whiskey. Those are things which have been taxed out of existence. Those are the things which Fianna Fáil regard as a luxury. We on this side of the House believe that the pint and the cigarettes are no longer a luxury. They are practically a necessity for the ordinary worker.

In his Budget statement we were told by the Taoiseach that there is £4 million necessary for milk subsidy. I do not profess to know a lot about agriculture but I can tell you that it is no consolation to the people I represent in an urban area to know that there is £4 million being given to subsidise milk prices. I wonder has this surplus milk come as a result of the £15 heifer scheme? If it has, this heifer scheme has proved to be a costly failure.

The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries spoke here this evening and told us about the tremendous success he had achieved in agriculture. Again, I do not profess to be an expert on it, but he told us the farmers were never so well off. Indeed, lately inside and outside this House he has been telling us how well off the farmers are. He shouted through a barrage of interruptions last week, he nearly broke his vocal cords, trying to tell us that the farmers of this country were prosperous in spite of Fine Gael and that they will continue to be prosperous whether Fine Gael like it or not. I am glad that he was able to tell us the farmers are prosperous.

He also told us about the increase in exports. He could have saved his voice and his shouting and could have more usefully told this to the members of his Cabinet. Remember, Fine Gael always believed in farming exports. The Minister for Industry and Commerce told us recently that 70 per cent of our exports are to Great Britain, even still, and the great bulk of our exports to Britain are agricultural produce. The Minister, instead of trying to shout across and tell Fine Gael that these exports would increase in spite of them, could have turned to his colleagues on the Front Bench; he could have turned to the Tánaiste and told him how lucky it was that the people of Ireland did not take the Tánaiste's advice when he wished to have all the ships sunk to the bottom of the sea; I do not think he was considering that exports to Britain should be transported by air. He had other reasons. He could go to another strong supporter, a former member of Fianna Fáil, and tell him that he was thankful that his words were not true when he said that the British market was gone and gone forever, thank God. At that time Fine Gael advocated that it was in the best interests of the country to trade with Britain. Fine Gael have always advocated trade with Britain and we are glad to hear that our trade with Britain is doing so well, even under a Fianna Fáil Government.

The Fianna Fáil Government have talked about encouraging personal savings. How can they expect people to save when there have been no less than 300 increases in prices and services since the 1st January, 1968. How can they expect the wage earner, the ordinary worker, to save under circumstances like this?

I wonder why the Taoiseach did not ask this time what happened in the Budget of the Minister for Finance. It reminds me of a slogan that has appeared on notices all over the city. I do not know where it emanated from. The slogan is "What really happened to my son Henry". I see it has been followed up now by a new slogan—"Watch out for the Fiddler". I do not know whether this has any reference to the Fianna Fáil Party.

We know that recently the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries has thought fit to go to places outside this House and preach about Partition and wave the flags and beat the drums and even contradict the Taoiseach on his own statement.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of Partition does not arise on the Financial Resolution.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney got away with certain things.

Comment on this

The question of Cabinet responsibility surely arises?

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

I do not think there is a question of Cabinet responsibility any longer. The Taoiseach should become firm and make firm decisions before it is too late. He should make changes and exercise his power within the Cabinet because, if the situation continues, changing Ministers from one post to another will not be sufficient. What they want is a complete change of Government. The Government must know that the present situation can last only for a short time. All the signs are against them, and the results of the referendum show in no uncertain manner that the people are tired of Fianna Fáil Government. This trend has been evident for some time. It was evident in the local elections; it was evident in the last Presidential Election. Certainly the Taoiseach, although he claimed it was a record to have won six by-elections, knows that they were all by-elections with reduced majorities.

The Taoiseach knows that in his own constituency the Government had an overall majority before ever he was Taoiseach. Before even he was Taoiseach they won a by-election on the first count. He knows that in the last general election Fianna Fáil had an overall majority in his own constituency and yet in a by-election held there since he became Taoiseach not alone did Fianna Fáil not hold their votes but they dropped 3,000. Surely he cannot say that this is an indication of a mandate from the people to carry on? Surely he must see that even if they won by-elections on reduced majorities they no longer have the confidence of the people? In all sincerity would he not think it is time that he came out and gave the people a chance to show him what they want? He is reluctant to move the writ for the Wexford by-election. If he would only come out and hold that the people would surely give an indication of what their feelings are. The sooner the Fianna Fáil Government decide to hold a general election and let a fit and proper Fine Gael government take over the better for everyone.

Comment on this

I am amazed by the attitude of the two Opposition Parties to this Budget and the Financial Resolutions which were presented to the House. They were opposed by both Parties. It is regrettable to think that the Labour Party would vote against the necessary Financial Resolutions when money was needed to pay the workers of the State concerns, deplorable to think that workers were granted increases and when the Financial Resolutions were presented to this House the Labour Party had the audacity to stand up and oppose them. This is an indication that they were not prepared to meet the bill to pay the workers.

Comment on this

Are the workers going to get £20 million per annum out of this?

Comment on this

That is only one portion of it. The Fine Gael Party on the other hand were concerned about milk prices and other reliefs for the farming community. This was also a factor in the Financial Resolutions which were put to the House and opposed by both Parties. I can only take it that the Party opposite was opposed to the increases for the farming community for which the money was necessary.

I speak as a worker, as one who has worked, on behalf of the workers and as a member of the workers' party. I say that the workers can now look forward with confidence and without the haunting fear of poverty destroying their peace of mind. We can do that because the Fianna Fáil Party over the years have taken the necessary steps at all times to correct situations, to keep Irish workers in employment and to meet their commitments to Irish workers. It is regrettable that when the necessary Financial Resolution was put to the House people who talk labour voted against it and tried to discolour the picture. The bare facts are that the money was required to pay the State servants who are just as entitled to salary increases as other sections of the community. The money was required for reliefs for the farming community and we faced it with the courage and understanding it deserved. Our policy throughout the years has been one of support for the worker and reliefs for every section of the community that needed them where reliefs could be granted in the circumstances.

What is the Fianna Fáil policy? It is to achieve the maximum development in both agriculture and industry. It is to ensure that the benefits of this development are shared equally by all and not by the few only and to give special care to those who are unable to support themselves. This has been the policy of Fianna Fáil over the years. It has been the policy for which we have stood and for which we were prepared to come to this House time after time and look for reliefs.

It has been said by Labour speakers in this debate that there is little difference now between the policy of our Party and that of Fine Gael. Fine Gael speakers have said that there is little difference between our policy and that of the Labour Party. This may be so. There may be a little difference in certain respects because we have convinced those Parties over the years that it is necessary to have industrial development, necessary to have social services, necessary to meet our commitments in relation to the weaker sections of the community. We are not a Party that talks left and acts right. We talk left and we act left in relation to industrial development and in relation to the social services that are required to meet the needs of the needy sections of the community.

Comment on this

That is a bit out of date now, is it not?

Comment on this

Members of the Fine Gael Party have spoken at length about their Party's policy, the Just Society. It is interesting to hear Fine Gael speak of a policy because the political dustbins are full to the brim with discarded and rejected Fine Gael policies including the Just Society. There is little need for me to speak about a Labour Party policy because they have no policy. They are supposed to be compiling a policy. The sham socialists of the Labour Party are now compiling a policy which they are going to present to the people in the future. Their policies, too, have been rejected and are filling the political dustbins.

We are concerned about the worker and about employment for the worker. As we look back over the years we see what has been done for the worker, not alone by the provision of industries which I will deal with in a moment but also by way of the concessions that are necessary and desirable to relieve him from the hardships and the hazards in employment. We brought into operation the Conditions of Employment Act, 1936 and 1944, which wiped out the sweated labour conditions for Irish workers. We brought in the holidays with pay Act, 1939, the holidays with pay Act, 1961, the Industrial Relations Act, 1946, the Occupational Injuries Act, the Redundancy Payments Act and many others. No doubt Deputy Dillon will laugh about what we have achieved for the workers by way of conditions. We have set here a high code and high standards and we will press still further and I, as a worker, will keep pressing to ensure that all the needs and all the desires of the workers are met in full as finances are available and as we progress.

Comment on this

And if they go on strike you will put them in jail.

Comment on this

You did not do much about it the last time.

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this

Lip service is no use to anybody.

Comment on this

The Division Lobby is the place.

Comment on this

Are unfortunate people to be deprived by a small section of the community of essential services, all the drugs and other essential items in hospitals that require an electricity supply? If that is what you are referring to we value human life and we will continue to do so despite the Labour Party who have no interest at all in human life, or so it would seem. At that time a man almost lost his life on the operating table. We were aware of that. Deputy Corish can take it from me that we are concerned about the workers. The indications are there over the years by our action in relation to the services of the workers, in relation to the conditions of the workers. They have been receiving our fullest consideration.

No doubt when we go through this quite comprehensive list of items, giving concessions to the workers time after time, it is easy for Deputy Corish to sit back and pick out one particular point and disregard all the others in regard to the situation that developed here. I have the same concern for the workers, for every worker, as Deputy Corish has. I have more concern for the progress of the nation than Deputy Corish was seen to have when he buckled on to an unfortunate situation when the lives of the people were at stake——

Comment on this

A simple question — do you think they should have been put in jail?

Comment on this

I do not think anybody should have been put in jail.

Comment on this

But the Deputy voted for it.

Comment on this

And I can and will justify my actions before I finish.

All the concessions given and all the comprehensive legislation brought in in relation to conditions of employment, holidays with pay, industrial relations, apprenticeship and all the other legislation for the benefit of workers were brought in by Fianna Fáil and by them alone. It was easy for Deputy Dillon to laugh earlier. I could quote the Deputy in regard to many aspects of industrial life when he was not very concerned about the workers. There was no cause for the workers to laugh when the Deputy finished his mouthings about what should and should not be done. Perhaps I shall bring back his memory to some statements he made and deal with them in some detail. He once declared that he would venture to say that five years from that day the rabbits would start to play leapfrog in Rineanna and that the masts erected for the purpose of radio communication would be converted into knitting needles to knit the wool off the rabbits. Thank God, we have at Shannon Airport now a very extensive industrial estate. We know the vast numbers employed there and the service the estate is giving to the nation, but that was Deputy Dillon's view regarding the industrial development of Shannon Airport. The Airport has proved to be a boon to the nation and the industrial estate has given employment to thousands and will continue to do so despite the wanderings of the Deputy in the past.

Also in regard to tourism, which is a very important industry, Deputy Dillon said on one occasion that he observed with amazement and astonishment a collection of strange people swarming into the hotels of Dublin and elsewhere and that it was time we warned them off in terms that would ensure that none of their brothers would favour us with their company in future.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy be kind enough to give the reference?

Comment on this

No doubt the Deputy has since changed his mind——

Comment on this

Would the Deputy please give the reference?

Comment on this

It was 5th January, 1948, Irish Independent.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Over 20 years ago.

Comment on this

I should like to know the context in which it was spoken.

Comment on this

I shall deal with some of the Deputy's speeches within the 20 years——

Comment on this

On 5th January, 1948— was that the time of the Locke Inquiry?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Maximoe, Chapelle, Eindigger and Dunnico— people I shall never forget.

Comment on this

I thought it might have been a reference to Maximoe.

Comment on this

"Tourists eating us out of house and home..."

Comment on this

I shall look it up.

Comment on this

We shall deal with another aspect of what Deputy Dillon said about peat and turf development. He said that some day he was convinced that peat and turf would go up the spout after beet and wheat and "God speed the day." He had no confidence in anything. We were concerned about the progress of the nation, about tourism and development. I shall quote what he said about the tourist industry——

Comment on this

Eindigger, Dunnico and——

Comment on this

Dillono.

Comment on this

I think Maximoe jumped overboard afterwards.

Comment on this

It was a good job he was not waiting for a job at Shannon Airport when the Deputy was there.

Comment on this

He was up at a tea party with the President if I remember rightly.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Has the Deputy any quotation by a man who said he would break stones? We should love to hear that.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

After that rude interruption——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Perhaps the Deputy could give us a quotation about the British market?

Comment on this

Let us keep on with Maximoe, Eindigger and Mrs. Chapelle.

Comment on this

On the first occasion that Fine Gael and the Labour Party came into office in 1948 there was a statement by Deputy James Larkin. This is what he said about that gang: "We know that Fine Gael used every opportunity that came their way not only in the open light of day but also in the dark of night." The Deputy is one of those who acted in the dark of night. It was during this period that they gave the tenpence a week to the old age pensioners, a never-to-be-for-gotten contribution. There is this miserable sum of tenpence a week, of which the Labour Party and Fine Gael collectively must feel very proud as their contribution for their time in office— a remarkable contribution to social welfare. I do not know to what degree the Labour Party were responsible for this enormous increase, whether we should give them credit for 60 per cent of it or more, but that is all the old age pensioners got under that Government.

I could make quite a number of contributions in regard to the advances of that time, but to get back to the Conditions of Employment Act and the various other Acts we brought in so that the workers would get justice, I am pointing out that it is only from this Party they got justice I should like to know what policies favouring the workers or what aids to workers were enacted in the two periods when both the Labour and Fine Gael Parties enjoyed power. Can they indicate any legislation that gave the workers any reliefs?

Comment on this

Is the Deputy waiting for an answer?

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Local Authorities (Works) Act that your Government did away with.

Comment on this

In 1954-1957 these two Parties came back into power. What did they give the workers and old age pensioners then?

Comment on this

Is that a rhetorical question? Does the Deputy want an answer?

Comment on this

I understand the Deputy was strangled by the other gang.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not want an answer?

Comment on this

Probably the position was that they did strangle the Labour Party because I think the Deputy is a man with a better social conscience than tenpence a week would indicate. But that is all they gave.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy want an answer?

Comment on this

The facts speak for themselves. These Parties were in office on two occasions and if anyone wants to compare legislation affecting the workers and the social legislation enacted by Fianna Fáil with any other legislation let them tell us what was done in that period when the old age pensioners were given tenpence a week. What was done for the widows and orphans, for the children's allowances, for disability allowances, for holidays with pay, for wet time pay, for the contributory old age pensions, for redundancy? We introduced all these Acts and many others. Time would not permit me to enumerate all the Acts we introduced to help the workers. I have mentioned just a few and many more will come into operation as time goes on.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Did you mention the biscuit factory for Ballina or the drainage of the Shannon? That should be on your list.

Comment on this

And the plywood factory in Limerick.

Comment on this
Luke Belton Mr. L. Belton Fine Gael

And the university.

Comment on this

I will deal with the Fine Gael Party first and I will not go back too far. We will go back to the last general election.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Deputy must have some note about the food subsidies.

Comment on this
Cormac Breslin An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Flanagan should allow Deputy Dowling to make his speech. This barrage of interruptions is not in order.

Comment on this

We do not know whether he wants answers to his questions.

Comment on this

We find that the Fine Gael policy was to attack industries which had been set up and we will take just a few of them. We find that in the 1965 election address of Deputy Fitzpatrick and Mr. O'Reilly of the Fine Gael Party, they referred to the establishment of the Verolme Dockyard as financial extravagance and a waste of money. This dockyard has provided substantial employment and now has a very wide range of skilled personnel. As a result of its being established we have trained a substantial number of skilled personnel who are members of trade unions and who have made their contribution to the trade union movement. This industry was frowned upon by the Fine Gael Party as financial extravagance and a waste of money. They also condemned the building of luxury hotels. We were not supposed to build any more hotels or attract visitors who had money to spend. We were supposed to remain in whitewashed houses and ask people to come and stay in them. Fortunately, we have long since passed that stage and it was regrettable that this attitude should have been adopted. They also advocated that we must not have any more fine roadways, continental speedways as they termed them. Is that their policy, that we are to remain a backward nation for all time, that we are not to have good roadways or good hotels? Surely we are entitled to them?

To refer again to the Verolme Dockyard, it has provided valuable employment, brought new skills to the country and increased the earning power of many of our workers, yet it was condemned by the Fine Gael Party as a waste of money and as extravagance. We know that this is their mentality and it was not the only industry that was sabotaged by Fine Gael over the years. I will deal with more of them before I am finished. There was the chassis shop at Inchicore and the transatlantic air service. The Verolme Dockyard which employs 750 people was one of the silly industries about which we heard so much spoken in the past. This may be silly in the eyes of Fine Gael or in the eyes of the Labour Party but we consider that these people are getting valuable employment. This industry will develop and will continue to expand and will bring greater skills and greater opportunities to the workers.

Comment on this

What did we say about Verolme Dockyard?

Comment on this

You are all the one gang over there. You are working very closely together.

Comment on this

That is an ignorant observation.

Comment on this

I could not distinguish one from the other. It would be impossible to distinguish the Fine Gael Party from the Labour Party at times because they are so closely knit on many aspects. I do not want to deal in too great detail with the many pronouncements made from time to time about the functions of a Government. No Minister of this Government has ever said that it was not the duty of the Government to find work for the people. That is the distinction of an ex-member of the Fine Gael Party. Nevertheless, we have people speaking about the closing down of silly industries. Would they stand up now and tell us what they were?

Comment on this

Potez.

Comment on this

We will deal with Potez in a minute. Maybe it was a failure but it was not the only failure. If we take the number of jobs created and the number of failures—and there will always be failures just as there were failures in Fine Gael's time and just as Deputy Dillon was a failure, because he was kicked out of his own Party; you are always going to have failures both in politics and outside and——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Tell us about the plan for the 100,000 new jobs or is that in the political dustbin?

Comment on this

If the Deputy takes the time to drive around the vast industrial estates being developed in Waterford, Shannon, Galway, Ballyfermot, Finglas, Coolock, Walkinstown and elsewhere, he will see the basis on which industries are being built in order to provide work for the people. The population increase demands even greater effort by Fianna Fáil and we will make the effort and make greater efforts than ever in order to ensure that all our people will be employed. We know that when we had the terrible tragedy of 1957 there was not a building worker in the country and, as Deputy P.J. Burke says, not the price of a bag of cement. That is an undeniable fact. There were very few workers in the country and we can judge the fact by the number of vacancies in the corporation housing schemes and the vast number of people who were forced to emigrate by the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party working in close co-operation.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy agree that we had more houses than tenants to go into them?

Comment on this

I will deal with that.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy admits that.

Comment on this

I represent that area and I am aware of the barricades that went up in a vast number of houses and the tears that were shed for not alone one member of a family but the whole family, father, mother and children, who had to emigrate because of the situation which existed when the Coalition were in power. Anyone can create vacancies by forcing people out of their homes and then say that there are houses available. Deputy Dillon talks about the number of houses available and he takes pride in it but they were only available because people had to leave their homes, just as they had to leave the country before in coffin ships and in other ways. There would be plenty of homes available if we drove the people out of the country. It is not our intention to drive people out. We want to ensure that they have employment in industrial estates like Shannon, Ballyfermot, Walkinstown, Coolock, Waterford, Galway and elsewhere. We will not be impeded in our industrial development by crackpots who would try to ruin such development.

The ambition of the inter-Party Government in 1948, when they first came into office, was to drive people out of Aerlínte, sell the aircraft, and deny them the right to work in their own country. The disposal of these aircraft was put into the hands of a very competent auctioneer, Daniel Morrissey; he was a Minister in the inter-Party Government at the time. There is no doubt about it; if they got into power tomorrow they might give the same opportunity to Deputy Oliver Flanagan, who is a very competent auctioneer, and I am quite sure he would be just as capable of disposing of anything put into his hands for sale. He would probably sell this place, if he had his way.

The last general election gave the people an opportunity and they rose to that opportunity in no uncertain fashion. They returned this Government. They were satisfied that this Government, and this Government alone, were the only people who would help the nation to make progress, limited as it might be. As a worker and trade unionist, I hope there will be more progress still. We are prepared to meet our commitments. We are prepared to impose taxation. We are prepared to measure up to our responsibilities in the future as we have done in the past, irrespective of whether or not the steps we take are popular or unpopular. We are not concerned about trying to rule the people. We do what we think is right and we do it when we think the time is right.

We have been criticised here a good deal, particularly in relation to this Budget. But this Budget is designed to increase the income for the farmer and for a very responsible section of the community employed in the Government service. It may be that the Labour Party do not want the workers to get these increases, even though they deserve them. It may be that the Fine Gael Party do not want the workers to get these increases. It may well be that they want discontent among workers. We want to ensure good conditions for the workers. We have passed legislation here designed to achieve that object. We will pass more in the future. We will build more factories, whether the Opposition like it or not. If Providence decrees that the Opposition get into Government and if they try to sabotage the nation, as they sabotaged it before, we will again rectify the position, as we did on the last occasion. Unfortunately, so many had lost their jobs and departed to foreign fields in search of employment it was not possible to rectify the situation in its entirety.

The chassis shop in Inchicore, which would have been a valuable source of employment in the heavy engineering industry, was ruthlessly closed down by the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party. Both Parties had no regard for Irish workers. They stabbed them in the back. They sold the means by which they could be employed. They sold the machinery, some of it still in the packing cases. Some was sold as scrap. That is the picture, and the only picture, one can present to the people of government by the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party when they get together.

Facts speak for themselves. They had no regard for the workers. They cannot point to any legislation passed by them on behalf of the workers. They said the workers should get this, that and the other. When they got in, what did they do? What did they give the worker? They gave the majority a one-way ticket to Australia, Birmingham, London, and elsewhere. Those are the places to which our building workers had to emigrate in search of a livelihood. That was the coalition's contribution to the Irish worker. There have been reckless and untruthful statements made here. Some were made by Deputy Dillon in relation to Verolme. Verolme is now giving employment to 750 workers.

When talking about tourism, Deputy Dillon spoke about observing with amazement and astonishment a collection of strange people swarming into the hotels of Dublin and elsewhere——

Comment on this

Maximoe, Eindigger and Dunnico.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon wants to frighten away tourists from the country. The coalition were not prepared to build hotels or improve roads. The latest figures available for tourism show an income of approximately £84.3 million. Tourism is our second highest earner. Directly and indirectly it employs 160,000 people. That is the industry Deputy Dillon wanted to frighten off in 1948. Fortunately he did not have his way and today 160,000 people are employed in this industry. He was not the only one, of course. Deputy Costello was another who wanted to frighten away tourists. He said it was nonsense.

The Shannon Industrial Estate was developed in spite of the Opposition, in spite of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party. It was developed because we had confidence in the ability of the Irish worker to acquire the skills needed in this industrial estate.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I must interrupt the Deputy at this stage and tell him that this is getting very far away from the Budget statement. Details relevant to specific Estimates are not in order on a Budget debate.

Comment on this

It is impossible to take a Budget in isolation. I am sorry if I have transgressed but there were some rude interruptions which tended to put me off. I am very easily upset, as you know. I think the Shannon Industrial Estate deserves mention here because of the employment content.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

All the Chair seeks to do is to remind the Deputy that there will be an opportunity to raise these details on the relevant Estimates. The Estimate for Transport and Power has still to be debated.

Comment on this

The general situation in relation to industrial development, agriculture, tourism and all other aspects is tied up with the Budget. You cannot take one Budget in isolation. No one else took the Budget in isolation. I do not want to disobey the rules of the Chair but this is very important. The moneys for the Shannon Industrial Estate were made available in various Budgets and, for that reason, I should like very briefly to deal with the Shannon development.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is certainly making an excellent statement in regard to this matter.

Comment on this

This is one of a number of Budgets relating to the economy and industrial development of the country. In relation to the employment of Irish workers that gentleman once said that in five years from that day the rabbits would be playing leapfrog in Rineanna and that the masts erected for the purpose of radio communication would be converted into knitting needles to knit the wool off the rabbits.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that a half an hour ago.

Comment on this

I did not get in the bit about the knitting needles. In the Shannon Estate today there are 3,942 people employed and despite the sabotage of Aerlínte, in all sectors of Shannon Airport we have 6,201 people employed. That represents a considerable amount of employment and we can be proud of it. We never tried to sabotage anything but people who are here today tried to sabotage things when they were in power. They are all part and parcel of it. They were all Ministers in the Cabinet.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

On a point of order, is it correct to allow the Deputy to accuse the Fine Gael Party of sabotaging the industrial estate at Shannon? I have always advocated the development of Shannon.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dowling will have an opportunity of developing that point on another occasion.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell the House about the 3,000 fewer people in employment than were employed 12 months ago?

Comment on this

They tried to sabotage Aerlínte. Today Aer Lingus employs 4,954 people. Despite that sabotage by the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party we brought it back. It took some time. I venture to say, to use Deputy Dillon's words, that if we had remained in power at that time that figure would be greater and many more people would be employed at Shannon and elsewhere. The vast amount of money made available to Aer Lingus is an indication of our confidence in the Irishman, the Irish worker, to carry out a certain type of job in the field of aviation. I will not dwell on that any further. I hope I have got the message across. I was disappointed the other day when I saw that the Labour Party had a Question down about the cost of the jumbo jets.

Comment on this

What was the question?

Comment on this

It is a question of evaluating the situation. The Minister indicated that the cost of the jets will be reckonable against something else. If the Opposition ever got into power again I have no doubt that the jumbo jets would go the same way as the other planes.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

Has the Deputy any little note about Ryan's Hotels?

Comment on this

I will deal with anything I want to while I am on my feet.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

We would love to hear the history of that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must insist that the Deputy keeps to the Budget.

Comment on this

You are upsetting me now.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I hope the Chair is not upsetting the Deputy.

Comment on this

As a member of the Workers' Party, the only Party to show consistent recognition for the workers by way of aids——

Comment on this

And put them in jail.

Comment on this

Previous Budgets had regard for the thousands of workers who would have been thrown out of employment had certain action taken place. Deputy Corish would like to indicate that hundreds of thousands of people should suffer and that no action should be taken, that hospitals should close down, that incubators should be out of use, that operations should cease because of some action within the State.

Comment on this

The Deputy thinks they should be put in jail?

Comment on this

I sympathise with every worker.

Comment on this

The Deputy has not answered the question I posed.

Comment on this

Let us deal with the situation in the ESB in relation to the strike.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must point out that we cannot expand the scope of the debates.

Comment on this

I was rudely interrupted and I want to clarify the situation because the situation of the worker as presented by Deputy Corish has gone on record.

Comment on this

I asked the Deputy a question and he did not answer it.

Comment on this

The answer is that the situation was caused because of the stupidity of the people who formulated the demand for the workers at the time and tried to claim parity between clerical workers and highly-skilled industrial workers. That was like comparing an orange with an elephant. There is no comparison. That is what you tried to do and you slipped up.

Comment on this

Who slipped up?

Comment on this

The people who formulated the claim. The workers had a valid claim on the basis of their technical capacity and, had it been presented in a different way, I am quite sure that no one would have been able to deny them the increase they sought. It was a justifiable increase but you cannot compare highly-skilled technical workers with clerical officers. There is no comparison and no basis for comparison. As I say, it is like comparing an orange with an elephant. It cannot be done.

Comment on this

I cannot compare an orange to an elephant.

Comment on this

Had a proper claim been made there would have been no problem.

Comment on this

They go on strike and they are put in jail.

Comment on this

They have a right to go on strike.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies must address the Chair.

Comment on this

We can look back with pride on the various advances made in social welfare over the years, to the advances made in payments to the disabled, the unemployed and the weaker sections of our community. We have always directed our attention to the weaker section of the community.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Deputy had better not lose his notes. He will want to pass them on to the next man.

Comment on this

The moment of truth is here.

Comment on this

Is that what the Deputy calls himself now?

Comment on this

We are the Republican Party.

Comment on this

The soldiers of destiny.

Comment on this

We have a Republican outlook. We are the soldiers of destiny. We march under one banner.

Comment on this

I wonder.

Comment on this

We are not like some Parties who march under half a dozen. I will deal with that in a moment. The facts speak for themselves in relation to social welfare advances.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy was going to deal with Republicanism.

Comment on this

I was a soldier of the Republic. I served this nation honourably in arms like many others and I will not allow them to be insulted by anyone.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair must insist that Deputies address the Chair.

Comment on this

The facts speak for themselves in relation to social welfare. This Party have always been concerned with the workers and their conditions of employment. If there are defects I have no doubt that the Government will set about rectifying them at the earliest possible moment.

The establishment of the Department of Labour was an expression in the strongest terms of the Government's desire to ensure that Irish workers got the consideration they deserve and the consideration of which they were deprived for far too long. We have at the moment a very responsible Minister, Dr. Hillery, who has devoted time and energy to try and alleviate and solve the problems of the Irish workers. We are behind him and we will continue to be behind him despite the opposition of the Deputies opposite from time to time in relation to our progressive legislation for Irish workers. I know there are defects and I am very conscious of them. I want to make my voice heard until these defects have been rectified. My trade union comrades are anxious to ensure that Irish workers get the treatment they deserve and that they will not be sent to Birmingham or elsewhere, as happened in 1947 when the nation was deserted by the then Government. We will never desert the worker. We will not desert the nation in the future. That goes for many generations of people associated with this Party.

I come back now to the social welfare aspect and to the various schemes brought in like the unemployment assistance, widows' and orphans' pensions, conditions of employment, disablement allowances, children's allowances, holidays with pay, and wet time allowances to obviate workers having to shelter from inclement weather in their own time. I heard a reference to wet time allowances by one speaker earlier who described them as farcical. We have the contributory old age pension which gives people in their old age, after years of toil, a pension by which they can live. I know the pension itself is contributory. The State make contribution charges as they do in other cases. Because of the contributory old age pension the situation of an old age pensioner today is far removed from that in which an old age pensioner found himself in the dark and difficult years when the Coalition were in power. These advances, together with the Redundancy Act, the Occupational Injuries Act and various other Acts, as well as other to come, will confer on the workers many advantages. We will never shirk our responsibility to them and, if we require taxes to give increases to the workers, we will not be afraid to vote for them.

We know from the past that the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party can speak with two mouths. They praise the increases given but vote against financial resolutions. This is equivalent to stabbing a man in the back. They say, in affect: "We are in favour of the increases but we are not going to give you the money to implement them." That is not the type of Party the people want. They appreciate honesty and that is the reason we have had the support of the working people for so long. We will continue to have the support of the workers because they can rely on the honesty and understanding of the Fianna Fáil Party. They know that when it is possible to assist them we will be courageous enough to do so, even at the expense of becoming unpopular. We will seek the necessary taxes and the necessary moneys to make the increases available. We will continue to make increases not in the region of 10d per week——

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil gave them nothing for 16 years. There was no increase in old age pensions from 1932 to 1948.

Comment on this

If they were depending on Fine Gael they would get 10d a week. We have been supported consistently because of our concern for the worker as expressed in the legislation to which I have referred. This is only part of the assistance we have given to the Irish workers to give them that sense of security to which they are entitled. I feel we could go much further in the future. It will not be my fault or that of my colleagues here if we do not. We would like to make it as easy as possible for the aged and the unemployed or those in need of assistance in any way.

There is much one can say about this but I do not want to go back and point out all that has been done and what has not been done by the various other groups here in this House. I would like to say once again that so far as social welfare is concerned we are ever conscious of our responsibility to the aged and the unemployed and other sections of the community and we will continue to assist them whenever it is necessary and possible to do so. We are not afraid to come and ask for the necessary money whether we may be unpopular or not. We will not hide behind the banners that the Opposition hid behind when they were in power.

I want to deal now with one or two other items. I would like to refer to Deputy Lindsay who made some references here last night. He spoke about Old Moore's Almanac. It is quite obvious from his speech here that this has been the guiding line of the Fine Gael Party. There is no doubt about it, judging by the blunders and inaccuracies in the past. This was the particular policy by which the Fine Gael Party were guided — Old Moore, Old Dillon, Old Flanagan and a lot of other old people in their time. Deputy Lindsay referred last night to a number of other factors worthy of mention.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil will have to do something about him.

Comment on this

They always kept one of them. It used to be poor old Deputy Martin Corry. Now they are keeping him.

Comment on this

Deputy Lindsay said "We meet them in the corridors".

Comment on this

He was referring to Taca.

Comment on this

His words were a reflection on the staff of the House here.

Comment on this

No, it was all about Taca.

Comment on this

He said people can get in and out of this House undetected. I believe the security of this House is as good as it could be. I think it is deplorable that a Front Bench Member should try to derogate the very worthy section of the State servants in control here. It is a reflection on the workers of this House. If, as has been alleged, people go in and out freely from the House, something will have to be done about it but I do not believe that this is so.

I do not know to what extent the socalled research workers of Fine Gael come and go, but I do know that the personnel in charge of the security here are responsible people. They do not allow people to roam freely through the House as has been suggested by Deputy Lindsay. I hope that the Leader of the Opposition or some other responsible person will correct the erroneous impression given in the Deputy's speech.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not employ Taca; Taca employ him. That is the trouble.

Comment on this

Deputy Dillon is a man of many words. When he was in power he said that emigration was a safety valve; in Opposition, he said it was a dirty word.

Comment on this

It was the Minister for Transport and Power who said that originally.

Comment on this

I wish to say that, amongst the many problems that have been discussed here during the past few days, housing has been referred to by quite a number of people.

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

No housing, the Deputy means.

Comment on this

I will convince Deputy Flanagan and his colleagues that a considerable amount of progress has been made in this respect and sufficient money has been made available to deal with the housing problem. I am sure Deputies are aware that when we came back into office the building trade was at a complete standstill and the workers were employed in Birmingham. Coventry, Glasgow and elsewhere. This was the situation which prevailed when we came back to power but in a short space of time we had that rectified.

I read in a report in the paper of a demonstration which is being planned by members of the Labour Party in Dublin Corporation in relation to widespread agitation by Labour supporters for the immediate improvement of the housing situation in Dublin. This was revealed in a statement to the press by a man who is vice-president of the Labour Party. The report appears in the Irish Press of Wednesday, November 13th. It comes from a man who knows nothing at all about housing but, nevertheless, he thought it worth his while to protest. This man is vice-chairman of the housing committee. He has no confidence in himself, in the committee or in the Corporation. At the moment Dublin Corporation have 2,430 houses under construction.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

What is the man's name?

Comment on this

O'Rourke.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I should like to remind the Deputy, as the Chair has reminded other Deputies, that people who are outside this House ought not be mentioned here.

Comment on this

He will be here after the next general election in Deputy Dowling's place.

Comment on this

In relation to this demonstration which is to take place I should like to let the situation be known as it exists at present and as it will exist in the future. The housing situation on 1st July, 1967, indicated a need for 17,219 dwellings in Dublin city up to March, 1971. The Corporation propose to provide, in that time, a total of 17,914 dwellings which is in excess of the needs assessed. The Corporation will make both houses and private sites available.

We are, of course, aware that it is necessary and desirable that money be made available for housing programmes. Money has been made available. The Corporation are working at full pressure to provide houses for our people and not, as has been suggested by the publicity mongers of the Labour Party in Dublin Corporation, that the Government are not providing for housing. I might add that in Dublin Corporation Fianna Fáil have a very small representation as compared to the Opposition Parties who have the controlling interest. One would think that no money was provided in any Budget to meet demands for housing, but in actual fact the demands of Dublin Corporation have been met in full by the Minister for Local Government.

Comment on this

How is the Dowling housing bureau going?

Comment on this

Before I was so rudely interrupted, I was saying that the moneys that have been demanded by the local authorities for housing have been met by the Government. I am a member of the local authority here in Dublin and I can therefore speak with some authority on it. I am aware that any moneys that were requested were made available and I am sure they will continue to be made available until the housing programme is completed.

The sites that are available and the package deals that will be entered into in the near future will be more than enough to meet the needs of the people. Due to the expanding economy, I am quite sure there will be more people. With the population increase and other factors, we shall have a bigger demand but this, too, will be met in no small way. While at the moment the housing programme needs to be speeded up to some degree, nevertheless, much has already been achieved. It would have been unthoughtful of me if I did not compliment the progressive thought of the Minister for Local Government and, indeed, other Ministers for Local Government in their efforts to stimulate building in Dublin when the local authority had failed to measure up to the targets. In the development of the Ballymun and other housing schemes, the Minister for Local Government has taken upon himself the——

Comment on this

The Deputy is now holding the note about the rates, I suppose.

Comment on this

I shall deal with that, too.

Comment on this

I am sure you will.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

Have you your little book?

Comment on this

Is he a secret service agent?

Comment on this

You should be thinking of Blaney at the moment.

Comment on this
Gerard Collins Mr. G. Collins

He is able to look after himself.

Comment on this

A man with a career. He will teach you how to knife your superiors. Thoughts on Blaney.

Comment on this

This is Dáil Éireann. It does not look like it at present.

Comment on this

The methodology of Taoiseach assassination.

Comment on this

You are between two henchmen there. Do not talk about knifing.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If, at this stage, Deputies will not cease interrupting——

Comment on this

You boys have given up the green shirts anyhow.

Comment on this

Red tie and red shirt.

Comment on this

If I might continue, without interruption——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will, at the moment, resume his seat.

Deputy Dowling resumed his seat.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has no intention of staying in the Chair if Deputies continue in this fashion. Unless these interruptions cease, the Chair will be vacated by the present occupant.

Comment on this

Thank you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy Dowling please keep to the Financial Resolution and not go into detail on matters which can more relevantly be raised on the Estimates for the different Departments concerned? The Deputy will have an opportunity of dealing with certain matters when the Estimates come before this House for discussion.

Comment on this

I was dealing with the housing situation in a very limited way before I was rudely interrupted. I should just like to make one or two further points in relation to the housing——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already pointed out to the Deputy that he will have an opportunity of dealing with housing when the relevant Estimate for the Department comes before the House for consideration. The Chair is asking the Deputy to keep to the Financial Resolution before the House in this supplementary Budget.

Comment on this

There are many aspects of this Budget which I should like to deal with but which the limitation of time will prevent me from doing so. In addition, I have other duties such as duties to my constituents——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

The Deputy has only an hour and ten minutes.

Comment on this

I shall not take very long but there are just a few other points I should like to make. Quite recently, in the housing schemes around the city, there have been——

Comment on this
Oliver J. Flanagan Mr. O.J. Flanagan Fine Gael

On a point of order. If Deputy Dowling is going to proceed with a discussion of housing in the Dublin Corporation area then I presume that the Chair will have no objection to allowing me to deal fully and in great detail with the subject of housing in Mountmellick?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not intend to allow any Deputy to proceed beyond the Rules of Order. The debate is limited to the Financial Resolutions which come under the supplementary Budget. There will be an opportunity for Deputies on other occasions to deal in detail with matters affecting the Departments of Local Government, Transport and Power and so on.

Comment on this

I am sorry if I am going off the track. I was rudely interrupted here so many times tonight that I can hardly be blamed if I am inclined to get confused in relation to what I may discuss in detail now. However, to get back to the Financial Resolution and to the moneys that are given by the Minister for Finance for housing, health, industry and the money to aid other sectors of the economy, I want to dwell briefly on a number of other sectors of our economy that have not been dealt with. I think this is justiable. It is regrettable and unfortunate that I was not allowed to pursue the discussion in relation to housing. I can well understand the desire of some members of the Opposition to interrupt me and to silence me on that score because they know that the targets that have been set will be met by 1970. I do not know how far I can now deal with the housing position. If the Chair feels that in my observations I am unduly labouring the question of the housing situation or I am in any way infringing on the rights of others or am out of line with the procedure, then I do not mind going to another aspect of Government policy and dealing with it in detail.

As I see it, Budgets, whether supplementary or otherwise, concern the financial set-up of the nation in relation to all aspects of Government policy. I know that in a general situation in relation to housing as a whole, in 1964 when targets were set, the housing programme was formulated and published. At that stage, there were 9,679 houses, taking into consideration all aspects of building. Today, in 1967-68, that figure has risen to 12,000 and it is estimated that it will reach 13,000 in another year. This housing achievement will be second only to a record year in the past when, on one occasion, this figure was surpassed by a Fianna Fáil Government. I do hope that every effort will be made to push forward diligently with the housing of our people and that, as more demands are made on the Minister for Finance for housing and other services in relation to housing — the services I have mentioned — this money will be forthcoming. For my part, I shall do all in my power to ensure that the weaker sections of the community, whether they require social assistance or housing or any other assistance, will be catered for and I shall raise my voice at all times in an endeavour to ensure that the necessary moneys will be forthcoming.

I am very conscious of the many demands that are made on the Exchequer. I cannot but be aware of the demands that are made from day to day by the Opposition Parties in relation to a variety of different schemes whether housing or other types of development and I am forced to note the cowardly attitude adopted by them, which is shown up in the Division Lobbies when they are called upon to face up to their responsibilities, as on this occasion when they were asked to provide money for the take-home packet of the Irish worker. It would seem as if the Government worker is in a very different position from that of the industrial worker or the workers outside.

The people who speak loudest and longest in defence of the workers are the people who flowed into the Division Lobbies on this occasion and voted against the necessary moneys to make the increases available to Government employees. I wonder if Government employees are a different type of people, if they do not require the same type of meals or the same facilities as other workers. It would seem the Labour Party and the Fine Gael Party single them out for special attention. When called upon to meet their responsibilities in order to ensure that the necessary moneys would be available to meet the increases which had been granted as a result of trade union and other pressures, those Parties failed to respond to the call of the Government that they should go into the Division Lobbies and support the Financial Resolutions which would make the money available for this very deserving purpose. As a trade unionist I take pride in saying that my colleagues and I went into the Division Lobbies, and whether it was unpopular or not to vote for further taxation, we were prepared to meet our responsibilities fully in order to ensure that the Government workers got what they deserved, the increases that have been awarded to them. We as a political Party honour our obligations to the workers. When we are called upon to impose additional taxation for the benefit of Government employees, whether they be in the Board of Works or in the Chamber or in any other Government employment, we will meet our responsibilities fully and ensure that the wage packet of the Irish worker is protected.

The effort on this occasion by Labour and Fine Gael to sabotage the situation by voting against the necessary taxation shows their disregard for the workers and shows their complete disregard for everything that is honest and just. We will measure up to our responsibilities, however difficult the task may be. If additional taxation is necessary to meet these requirements I will never hesitate to go into the Division Lobbies to vote for the imposition of the taxation on a section of the community that can afford to pay it. While my colleagues and I are here we will honour our obligations to Government employees and other workers. It was regrettable on this occasion to see members of the Labour Party going into the Division Lobbies to vote against the necessary Financial Resolutions which means, in effect, they are opposing an increase to Irish workers, to workers employed in Government service. It indicates that they feel that Irish workers in Government service have no right to these increases and that these people are to be treated as lepers or something else divorced altogether from the rest of the community when it comes to a general wage increase. We will fully meet our obligations to the Irish workers and to the weaker sections of the community, and if it is necessary at any time to impose additional taxation——

Comment on this

On a point of order. I wish to submit to you, Sir, that it is a shameful prostitution of our procedure that a Deputy should be sent in here by the Taoiseach to repeat nine times in my presence the same sentiments for no other purpose than to waste parliamentary time. I submit to you that that is not consistent with our rules of order and gravely reflects on the dignity, not to speak of the decency, of our procedure.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy speaking about Deputy Harte?

Comment on this

I am speaking about Deputy Dowling.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Repetition is not in order.

Comment on this

This is a disgraceful display by Deputy Dillon, to indicate that the Taoiseach sent me in here to waste the time of the House. It is a deliberate falsehood and is in keeping with many of the falsehoods that have been uttered during this debate by members of the Fine Gael Party. I am not a party to any delaying tactics. I do not tell untruths. Anything I say is factual. The suggestion by Deputy Dillon that I was sent in here deliberately to use up the time of the House is completely false and erroneous. What I have said about various aspects of Government policy, the housing of our people, employment and so on, is a bitter pill for the Opposition to swallow. I know that early on in my statement I did direct some of my remarks to the statements which have been made by Deputy Dillon on many occasions in the past and which have now become a joke. I can well understand that he would become frustrated at this stage and try to create the erroneous impression that I was sent in here by the Taoiseach. I came in here of my own accord to deal with the problems before this House. We had the courage to back up our policies by going into the Division Lobbies in order to ensure that the necessary finances were available to meet the workers' claim for increases, the claims of the farmers and of the other sections of the community.

I will not be intimidated by Deputy Dillon or anyone else in the Opposition. Moneys are being made available in order that the workers in the employment of the State will get their fair reward for work done, and they should not be intimidated as they were intimidated by members of the Fine Gael Party, and particularly by the foul utterances of Deputy Lindsay in relation to a very responsible group of people here in this House, the ushers, and the various people in control of the services in the House. As a Deputy I will not see these people trampled on by Deputy Lindsay, Deputy Dillon or any other Deputy. We will protect the right of the ordinary employees in the Government service. We will see that they get the increases they fully deserve, and even if it means the imposition of taxation we will go into the Division Lobbies and vote for it, whatever the reaction may be. We will not be put off by Deputy Dillon or by the other Deputies who have spoken here from the Fine Gael benches or by the tactics used to try to silence me.

Comment on this